TURKEY WANTS TO SEE AAM BACK
Azg/arm
14 Dec 04
The All Armenian Movement held its 14th sitting on December 9 to
support former Armenian president Levon Ter-Petrosian’s reappearance
on thepolitical arena. The same day Hatem Jabbarlu, employee of the
Caucasian Department of Eurasian Military Research Center in Ankara,
posted an article inHaber Analizonline edition urging Turkish
government to boost the return of AAM to the political arena.
In other words, AAM has pinned its hope on Ter-Petrosian and Turkey –
on AAM. So they both supplement each other. But why and how is this
possible? Before answering the question we’ll mention that Jabbarlu’s
article was entitled “Rose in Georgia, Orange in Ukraine. May it be
Snowdrop in Armenia?”. Speaking of the “velvet” and “orange”
revolutions in Georgia and Ukraine, the author calls them
non-traditional ones, notes that only USA today has the power tocarry
out such a revolution and then informs that there are the signs of
“snowdrop” revolution in Armenia.
According to Jabbarlu, the signs of “snowdrop” revolution became
visible in Armenia in March of 2004 when the opposition united around
the Ardarutyun Union and rallied against President Robert Kocharian
demanding his resignation. He thinks that they gave way to Kocharian,
as they “didn’t have one ideology and joint strategy”.
Enumerating the reasons why the opposition failed, Jabbarlu says that
it failed because of wrong evaluation of Georgia’s “velvet”
revolutionas well as opposition’s improvident actions that wanted to
carry out Georgian scenario without considering inner and foreign
developments in Armenia and Kocharian administration’s power.
Apparently the author accuses the US National Democracy Institute and
the so-called Soros Foundation alongside with Armenian opposition of
improvidence. Referring to the head of the Yerevan office of
Democracy Institute, Chet Roger’s support to the opposition and the
critiques addressed to pro-Russian parties and NGOs, Jabbarlu says
that the Institute was not as much of help in Armenia as it was in
Georgia. Besides, neither the Armenian opposition was so strong nor
the authorities were that weak for the anti-government movement backed
by the American organizations to win.
Hatem Jabbarlu speaks of the failure with regret. But he is hopeful
that the “velvet” and “orange” revolutions will inspire Armenian
opposition. “Though the party of Ardarutyun is the initiator of the
upheaval, the All Armenian Movement gets ready for return into the
politics. The first president of Armenia, Levon Ter-Petrosian was not
active in politics since his resignation. But he has all the chances
and abilities to gain people’s support if serious propaganda program
is implemented. But unique political, economic and social approaches,
new strategies as well as cooperation with other oppositional parties
are needed to reach the goal. Otherwise, his past of freedom warrior
will not be enough to take over the reins”.
Thus, we may assume that Jabbarlu is ascribing the mission of not only
AAM but also the opposition as a whole to Ter-Petrosian reminding the
later to turn to the USA for help. Jabbarlu thinks: “Armenian
opposition is attracted by the â=80=98orange’ revolution. Therefore,
the power that will unite the nation by concentrating on socioeconomic
and political issues, will unite the political parties, will take into
consideration the interests of super powers, first of all the US, will
declare of peaceful settlement of the Karabakh issue and will lean on
the US support will be able to carry out the â=80=98snowdropâ=80=99
revolution”.
Along with handing the role of opposition spearhead to Ter-Petrosian,
Jabbarlu says that by heading the “snowdrop” revolution he will fill
his political biography with one more patriotic deed.
What’s the reason of Turkish author’s interest towards Ter-Petrosian?
There may be only one reason: Turkey’s political
calculations. Jabbarlu himself mentions them: “Turkey has to be
attentive as to what is going on in its neighboring countries and
elaborate scenarios on this developments. It mustespecially
concentrate on possible developments in Armenia and meet with Armenian
political parties to direct them and to have the right assessment of
situation and to draw closer to the possible candidate of
presidency”. All these measures are needed to weaken the Armenian
propaganda in the issue of the so-called genocide and to become a
regional super power”.
Jabbarlu’s care for Ter-Petrosian is explicable in the view of the
fact that the 14th sitting of the AAM laid the responsibility for the
Armenian Genocide not on the Ottoman Empire but the Armenian
national-socialist ideology.
The only thing Turkey can do now is to wait for Ter-Petrosian to come
back to the politics, unite all the oppositional parties around AAM
and to lead Armenia to a “snowdrop” revolution in order not to
disappoint Turkey.
By Hakob Chakrian
Category: News
En primer plano sociedades multietnicas y complejidad politica
Expansion (Madrid)
Lunes,13 Diciembre 2004
EN PRIMER PLANO SOCIEDADES MULTIETNICAS Y COMPLEJIDAD POLITICA
El federalismo parece la formula mas razonable para ilustrar y
orientar las soluciones que cada caso merezca de cara a establecer
valores comunes entre intereses opuestos.
El sociologo frances Alain Touraine ha pronosticado que el siglo XXI
estara dominado por “la cuestion nacional”, como el siglo XX lo
estuvo por la cuestion social. “En todas las partes del mundo
-senala- es visible el desgarramiento entre el universalismo
arrogante y unos particularismos agresivos. El principal problema
politico es, y sera, limitar ese conflicto total, establecer unos
valores comunes entre intereses opuestos”.
La realidad le esta dando la razon. Basta echar una mirada a nuestro
alrededor para descubrir que la mayoria de los conflictos politicos y
de las guerras actuales responden a la complejidad multiidentitaria
de las naciones diversas o a los nacionalismos exacerbados en
territorios o en estados cuya integridad esta cuestionada.
Los Balcanes fueron el primer gran estallido y todavia no se ha
resuelto, porque la convivencia en Bosnia, cuando las fuerzas de EEUU
y Europa dejen de ejercer el orden, puede obligarnos a reconocer
otros dos estados, y porque Kosovo sigue siendo un problema
irresoluble: un territorio que pertenece, indudablemente, a Serbia,
con un 80% de poblacion albanesa que odia al 20% serbio y viceversa.
Pero miremos ahora al sur del Caucaso y veremos a los armenios que
odian Turquia por el genocidio de principios del siglo XX.
Georgianos divididos por sus intereses para con Rusia o EEUU.
El conflicto de Nagorno-Karabaj expresa bien esta complejidad.
Territorio de Azerbaian poblado totalmente por armenios. Un enclave
cristiano rodeado por musulmanes. Los ejercitos de ambos paises estan
en una escalada armamentista: los unos para defender su territorio y
los otros para defender a sus ciudadanos.
Mas arriba y al Este esta Chechenia, cuyo conflicto, mejor diremos
guerra, con Rusia no tiene ni facil ni rapida solucion. Incluso en el
actualisimo problema electoral surgido en Ucrania late un gravisimo
problema de convivencia multiidentitaria. Los ucranianos del Norte y
del Este son pro-rusos por origen, afinidad, cultura e intereses y el
resto es pro-occidental y europeo. Un grave cisma de orden politico y
social se cierne sobre ese importantisimo pais en el que ya se han
empezado a escuchar llamamientos separatistas de una comunidad
dividida.
Todo el Este europeo es un polvorin identitario que ha estallado con
la caida del comunismo y el fracaso de las fronteras creadas por
Stalin y los grandes movimientos poblacionales que organizo aquel
regimen politico. Pero ya mucho antes, desde la caida del imperio
austro-hungaro, las minorias etnicas, linguisticas o nacionales en
paises distintos presentan una complejidad no por conocida menos
importante: el enclave ruso de Kaliningrado en Polonia, hungaros en
Rumania, albaneses en Serbia y Montenegro, serbios en Croacia y
Bosnia, turcos en Bulgaria, armenios en Azerbayan, polacos en
Lituania, uzbekos en Tajakistan, etcetera
Tampoco nosotros escapamos a esta complejidad. El nacionalismo
catalan y el vasco, con la deriva violenta de este ultimo,
representan, objetivamente, una dificilisima problematica para la
construccion de la nacion espanola. Pero los franceses tienen
Corcega, y en menor medida la Bretana. Los ingleses, Escocia y Gales;
los italianos, la Padania del Norte, y no digamos los belgas, que no
son dos Estados porque les queda el Rey y el nombre, y la historia de
un solo pais, aunque walones y flamencos parecen dos.
?Que hacer?, que diria Lenin. Hay una falsa solucion: crear nuevos
estados alla donde una comunidad cultural o etnica lo reclama, bajo
el llamado principio de la autodeterminacion. En definitiva, alterar
el statu quo de los limites territoriales y las fronteras y guiarse
del principio nacionalista en la construccion de los estados, que
atribuye esa condicion a las naciones puras, basadas en una lengua,
cultura e historia comunes y en una voluntad ciudadana ampliamente
respaldada (como la escision de la Republica Checa y Eslovaquia, por
ejemplo).
Pero ese principio nos arrastra a una progresiva tribalizacion del
mundo. En plena globalizacion, cuando mas necesario es crear espacios
supranacionales e implementar politicas mundiales en las finanzas, en
la multilateralidad internacional o en el medio ambiente, resulta
paradojico y completamente contradictorio que el mundo se fragmente
en su organizacion politica aplicando el principio de que donde hay
una lengua o una etnia hay una nacion, y donde hay nacion debemos
construir un estado. Conviene recordar que, como nos dice el
historiador britanico E. Hobsbawn, en la actualidad hay no menos de
seiscientas lenguas vivas y mas de cuatro mil grupos etnicos
diferentes. ?Es esta la organizacion del poder politico que
propugnamos para la diversidad y la multietnicidad del mundo?
Tiene que haber otras soluciones. La mia es el federalismo en los
estados complejos por su diversidad identitaria y en los espacios
supranacionales que estamos creando sobre los estados actuales, es
decir, en la Union Europea, en nuestro caso.
El federalismo responde a un triple principio que inspira una triple
exigencia de las comunidades intraestatales. El primero es la
subsidiariedad, que garantiza una organizacion administrativa del
poder politico de abajo a arriba, es decir, de lo local a lo
supranacional con predominio de la gestion local. El segundo es la
identidad, que asegura el respeto y el fomento de los elementos
culturales y politicos distintivos de la comunidad de referencia.
Implica el autogobierno politico de la region-nacion o comunidad.
El tercero es la cohesion que garantiza la unidad y la solidaridad
del Estado y de este como garante de derechos, deberes, igualdad y
seguridad.
El federalismo como cultura politica, como modelo de articulacion del
poder al territorio, con todas sus variables y con todos los
adjetivos que se le quieran anadir, constituye la formula mas
ingeniosa y democratica para resolver las demandas de las
nacionalidades sin estado en el seno de estados plurinacionales.
Es, ademas, la mejor formula para orientar la construccion de los
espacios supranacionales y resolver los mecanismos de subsidiariedad
e identidad de los estados-nacion, con la necesaria cohesion y
coordinacion entre los estados.
El federalismo constituye la formula mas generosa y profunda de
descentralizacion politica, entendiendo por tal no la mera delegacion
o descentralizacion administrativa sino la disposicion de un Poder
Legislativo, Ejecutivo y Judicial, con competencia propia para
decidir, mediante organos elegidos en el ambito de la comunidad y con
reglas democraticas propias, sobre los problemas economico-culturales
y sociales de su interes.
En definitiva, y para establecer esos valores comunes entre intereses
opuestos a los que se referia Touraine, el federalismo parece la
formula mas razonable para ilustrar y orientar las soluciones que
cada caso merezca. Federalismo es union, lealtad y libertad; es
autonomia en cooperacion. Federalismo es soberanias compartidas
sometidas a un orden jerarquico y organizado de decidir en un marco
de cooperacion y no de competencia. Federalismo es hacer compatibles
espacios concentricos de organizacion territorial del poder politico
a traves de un orden constitucional basado en una cultura y unos
principios de respeto mutuo y de colaboracion desde la autonomia.
La mayoria de los conflictos politicos y de las guerras actuales
responden a la complejidad multinidentaria de las naciones
El federalismo es hacer compatibles espacios concentricos de
organizacion territorial del poder politico Portavoz del PSOE en la
Comision Constitucional del Congreso de los Diputados
Ramon Jauregui Atondo
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress
Zurabishvili: We Refuse To Apply Economic Sanctions Against Armenia
SALOME ZURABISHVILI: WE REFUSE TO APPLY ECONOMIC SANCTIONS AGAINST ARMENIA
Azg/arm
14 Dec 04
“Georgia is in good relations with both Armenia and Azerbaijan”,
Freedom radio station quoted foreign minister of Georgia, Salome
Zurabishvili, as saying to France-Presse news agency on the occasion
of a jam-up on the Georgian-Azeri border.
Azerbaijan has reduced the number of goods exported to Georgia
suspecting that they are imported to Armenia via Georgia. Zurabishvili
stated that Tbilisi is willing to prevent arms’ transportation but
added: “We refuse toapply economic sanctions against Armenia”.
The Georgian minister said that if Georgia ever had another standpoint
but being neutral in the conflict “we would adopt the logic of
aggravating the tension which would lead to a disaster not only us but
the region as a whole”.
The Azeri side stopped around 900 goods wagons making their way to
Georgia from Middle East via Azerbaijan saying that half of the goods
are destined for Armenia. Trend news agency quoted first deputy prime
minister of Azerbaijan, Abbas Abbasov, as saying: “We demand the
Georgian authorities to ban goods transportation to Armenia via
Azerbaijan”.
Interestingly, the Armenians and Azeris traded even during the war
years. The market of Sadaghlo (Georgia) remains the only place in the
last 13-14 years where Armenians and Azeris could talk the same
language.
Both today and during the war one could find Azeri tea and sturgeon in
the Armenian market. There were times when the Azeri fuel was imported
to Armenia. Last summer when the cost of bred went up in Armenia, the
frontier villagesof the republic were selling the flour packed in
Azeri town of Gyanja. Azeris in their turn were always greedy for the
potatoes of Sevan Lake basin the white-fish of the Lake, Spitak’s
carrot and cabbage. According to non-official data, the goods
circulation between Armenia and Azerbaijan via the territories of
Georgia and Iran amounts to more than $40 million.
Why did Azerbaijan suddenly decided not to allow the goods from
Azerbaijan to enter Armenia? TheZerkalonewspaper of Baku notes that
Baku’s step is directed on putting pressure on Georgia for two
reasons. It says that the Georgian customs officers confiscated the
tear-gas and bludgeons sent from Azerbaijan to suppress the “velvet”
revolution. President Aliyev perhaps was informed about this and was
not too enthusiastic over Mikheil Saakashvili’s cominginto power.
Thirdly, Baku is willing to punish Tbilisi which voted down
Azerbaijanâ=80=99s initiative at the UN General Assembly (on condition
on the Azerbaijani occupied territories) thus talking a pro-Armenian
stance.
By Tatoul Hakobian
ARKA News Agency – 12/13/2004
ARKA News Agency
Dec 13 2004
68% of Yerevan citizens do not approve general trends of Armenian
development
Two people died, seven wounded in result of traffic accident at
Charentsavan-Yerevan highway
Two convicted for life imprisonment escaped from Goris prison
Street trade in Yerevan to be allowed in connection with New Year’s
celebrations
Independent and impartial judicial power is one of the key tasks of
constitutional reforms in Armenia
Presentation of the book `From Economy of War to Economy of Peace in
South Caucasus’held in Stepanakert
*********************************************************************
68% OF YEREVAN CITIZENS DO NOT APPROVE GENERAL TRENDS OF ARMENIAN
DEVELOPMENT
YEREVAN, December 13. /ARKA/. 68% of Yerevan citizens do not approve
general trends of Armenian development. The data was announced by
Caucasus Research Resources Center in result of analysis conducted in
three South Caucasus republics. 1500 citizens of Yerevan, Tbilisi and
Baku were questioned in the frames of research. The research showed
that 23% of Tbilisi citizens are not satisfied with direction of
development of their country and 47% citizens of Baku.
CRRC is the program of Eurasia Foundation financed by Carnegie
Corporation of New York. L.D. -0–
*********************************************************************
TWO PEOPLE DIED, SEVEN WOUNDED IN RESULT OF TRAFFIC ACCIDENT AT
CHARENTSAVAN-YEREVAN HIGHWAY
YEREVAN, December 13. /ARKA/. Two people died, seven wounded in
result of traffic accident at Charentsavan-Yerevan highway, when
student bus `LAZ’ hit the truck `ZIL’, Emergency Department of RA
Government told ARKA. Among perished are the driver of the truck
Viktor Balasanian, who was repairing his car during the accident and
21-year old passenger of the bus, student Tigran Sargsian. The
details of the case are not announced yet. L.D. –0–
*********************************************************************
TWO CONVICTED FOR LIFE IMPRISONMENT ESCAPED FROM GORIS PRISON
YEREVAN, December 13. /ARKA/. Two convicted for life imprisonment
escaped from Goris prison, RA Police press service told ARKA.
Law-enforcement bodies conduct search of escaped criminals – Mher
Yenokian (born in 1975) and Sohomon Kocharian (born in 1966). All
republican roads are under control, all cars are stopped and
searched. If someone has any information on criminals,
law-enforcement bodies ask citizens to call on: 561-232, 564-821,
553-161, secrecy of information and money reward is guaranteed. L.D.
–0–
*********************************************************************
STREET TRADE IN YEREVAN TO BE ALLOWED IN CONNECTION WITH NEW YEAR’S
CELEBRATIONS
YEREVAN, December 13. /ARKA/. Street trade in Yerevan to be allowed
in connection with New Year’s celebrations, as stated Arman Sahakyan,
the deputy Mayor of Yerevan. According to Sahakyan, the Mayor of
Yerevan had already approved the list of streets where the trade
would be allowed. Sahakyan said that the trade of food would be under
special control. The street trade in Yerevan will be allowed till
January 14, 2005. L.V.-0–
*********************************************************************
INDEPENDENT AND IMPARTIAL JUDICIAL POWER IS ONE OF THE KEY TASKS OF
CONSTITUTIONAL REFORMS IN ARMENIA
YEREVAN, December 13. /ARKA/. Independent and impartial judicial
power is one of the key tasks of constitutional reforms in Armenia.
According to Vardan Poghosyan, the head of Democracy NGO during the
discussions organized by Partnership for Open Society organization,
this is stated in the intermediate assessments of the Venice
Commission concerning the submitted drafts of constitutional reforms
in Armenia. According to him, the Venice Commission welcomes the
constitutional amendment which states that 9 of 12 members of the
Council of Justice of the republic should be elected by the judges
themselves. At that, the rest should be elected by the Parliament,
not the President. Also, in accordance with the intermediate
conclusion of the Commission, the role of the President as the Head
of the Council of Justice should be purely formal. At that, the
Council of Justice should be the end instance in the professional
work of the judges, in particular, concerning the election,
appointment, career growth, training, resignation, etc. in this
connection, the appointment of all Chairmen of courts by the
President without the participation of Council of Justice may cause
certain difficulties. The assessment report also points out the need
for constitutional guarantee for independence of prosecutors from the
executive power. L.V. – 0 –
*********************************************************************
PRESENTATION OF THE BOOK `FROM ECONOMY OF WAR TO ECONOMY OF PEACE IN
SOUTH CAUCASUS’HELD IN STEPANAKERT
STEPANAKERT, December 13. /ARKA/. The presentation of the book `From
Economy of War to Economy of Peace in South Caucasus’ was held in
Stepanakert. According to the own reporter of ARKA agency in
Stepanakert, the book covers the articles of authors from all the
republics of the South Caucasus, both recognized and not judicially
recognized. The Nagorno Karabakh Republic is represented by the
article of Valery Badalyan, the Head of Tradition NGO entitled `The
role of international organizations in development of small and
middle-scale business in the peaceful settlement of Nagorno Karabakh
conflict’. `We will try to shift to practical steps from research
actions and to establish joint business in the region. Unfortunately,
Azerbaijan categorically opposes any cooperation’, he said during the
presentation of the book. He also said that offices will be
functioning in all countries of South Caucasus in the framework of
Business and Conflict program. Their mission will be to assist the
establishment of joint business in the region and support the
peaceful settlement of conflicts.
The book `From Economy of War to Economy of Peace in South Caucasus’
was published in the framework of Business and Conflict program of
International Alert British organization. The objective of the
program is to seek for settlement of prolonged conflicts and their
prevention in crisis regions. L.V.–0–
The conflict in Ukraine must be extinguished as soon as possible
Agency WPS
What the Papers Say. Part A (Russia)
December 13, 2004, Monday
THE CONFLICT IN UKRAINE MUST BE EXTINGUISHED AS SOON AS POSSIBLE
SOURCE: Expert, No. 46 (446), December 12, 2004, p. 36
by Oleg Khrabryi
Question: Over the past few years, the West has seen a great deal of
research and articles about Ukraine and Belarus. What led to this
flood? Might it have been a dress rehearsal for the events we are
witnessing now?
Robert Legvold: It would be a tragedy if people in Russia, or the
friends of Russia in Ukraine, interpreted these events as part of a
large-scale historical strategy by the West with the aim of
undermining Russian influence in the region or turning anyone against
Russia. Many people in Russia are probably already thinking that
someone in Brussels or Washington is organizing all these schemes and
“steering the process.” This is not the case. It s quite obvious that
organizations like George Soros’s Open Society Foundation have played
the key role in supporting the youth movements and other
non-governmental organizations in Georgia, leading to the collapse of
the Shevardnadze regime. With regard to Ukraine – and I can speak
about this with competence – the rallies there have not been a part
of preplanned efforts by any Western country, NATO or the European
Union.
After the “revolution of roses” in Georgia, many people in the West
including some governmental structures decided that it would inspire
other countries to move in a similar direction or at least will
encourage the governments of Central Asian and Caucasian countries
and probably Ukraine, Moldova and Belarus to think about the need for
greater openness and democracy. In reality the effect from the
“revolution of roses” was the opposite. It was taken as a negative
lesson. Askar Akaev, Emomali Rakhmonov and Islam Karimov took the
Georgian revolution as a threat to stability of their regimes and
started defending. Harsh measures against the opposition followed
immediately. Before Ukraine the only country that tried to follow the
example of Georgia was Armenia, where a part of opposition decided to
mobilize the people in the street for struggle against the
authorities in April 2004.
Question: Which conclusions did you make for yourself after the
Ukrainian events about relations between the West and Russia?
Robert Legvold: Interest of the West in Russia and Ukraine has a
deeper nature than the current disputes about legitimacy of victory
of this or that candidate at the elections. Unfortunately,
aggravation of interests occurred in the last few years. These are
interests of Europe and America on the one hand and Russia on the
other. This means that relations between the West and Russia started
having a nature of harsh confrontation and not cooperation. This
resulted in a situation when Moldova, Ukraine and Belarus turned into
the so-called “median lands.” I, as a researcher into these processes
at Ukrainian elections, was most of all astonished not because the
West indicated its candidate and Russia indicate a candidate of its
own but by the reasons why they did this. A real attitude of the
parties to each other was manifested in substantiation of this
choice. Russia backed Yanukovich because it considered Yushchenko a
puppet of the West, the European Union, NATO and America. The US and
Europe, permanently emphasizing their interest in openness of the
process and purity of elections, chose Yushchenko because Yanukovich
was not only considered a protege of Kuchma’s regime but was also
exposed to a strong influence of Moscow. Now everything stood on its
own place in relations between the West and Russia and this is a very
disheartening piece of news.
Along with this, destabilization of this region is not in the
interests of the West or Russia. Judging by my numerous conversations
with officials in Brussels, Kiev and Washington I can say that all my
interlocutors prefer taking into account the interests of Russia in
Moldova, Belarus and Ukraine. It is only necessary to create a
balance. What is happening now? Ukraine is rapidly moving to one side
and a dramatic conflict of interests has appeared. The theoretical
statements that are now extracted from Brzezinski’s books only
aggravate this dissent.
Question: What do you think Russia will lose in reality if the
revolution wins and Yushchenko becomes the president?
Robert Legvold: Many people in the West think that Yushchenko as the
president of Ukraine is not a bad guarantor for observance of
Russia’s interests in Ukraine. Being the prime minister he was
actively working on strengthening of economic ties with Russia. Yes,
he will not be very enthusiastic about the common economic space. It
is also true that he will start establishing closer relations with
the European Union and NATO but this is such a long process that it
does not pose an immediate threat to Russia’s interests. Moreover,
Ukraine will remain in technological dependence on Russia for a long
time.
Putin and his people make a big mistake believing that Yushchenko
will be too bad as a partner. After all, this false opinion made
Moscow interfere into the course of the election campaign. I talked
not only to Ukrainians but also to some Russian specialists. They
think that it was direct interference of Putin and his political
advisors that persuaded the people who had been neutral or skeptical
about both candidates that they had to vote for Yushchenko. Russia’s
role in this campaign was taken very negatively.
If the problem of legitimacy of Yushchenko is solved, I think that
his behavior will be similar to the behavior of Kuchma after he won
his first presidential elections in 1994, defeating Kravchuk.
Everyone was saying then that the new president would turn to the
West. But what was his first step? In October, right after the
elections, he went to Moscow and started establishing bilateral
relations. I believe that Yushchenko will do the same.
Question: Which consequences can this collision of interests in
Ukraine have for bilateral relations between Moscow and Washington?
Robert Legvold: Rivalry between the US and Russia in Eurasia arose in
the early 1990s during the presidency of Bill Clinton, when the
routes of pipelines from the Caspian region were only being
discussed. The rivalry grew worse during the presidency of Bush when
Ukraine started participating in the Partnership for Peace program.
This rivalry was permanently felt with regard to the Baltic republics
until they were not accepted to the European Union and NATO. After
September 11, Putin approved the American military operation in
Central Asia, accepted it, even despite the phobias dominating in the
Russian military establishment and also accepted deployment of
American special forces in Georgia. Russia is one of the few
countries that consider the struggle against terrorism a war. Europe
does not think so, Japan does not think so and many people do not
think so. In this sense Putin is probably one of the most reliable
partners.
He started projecting Russia’s influence primarily by economic tools
hinting to all regimes in the former CIS countries that Russia was a
better partner for them than America. In the US many members of the
Administration, at least at the level of experts, think that Central
Asia should be a place where we will cooperate with Russia. That is
why it is very important to extinguish the conflict in Ukraine as
soon as possible. This conflict could determine the future of our
relations in the most diverse regions. If Europe and US are drawn
into in harsher rivalry with Russia over Ukraine, we will feel a
negative impact from this everywhere, and primarily in Central Asia.
Translated by Pavel Pushkin
Gazprom to take part in Iran-Armenia pipeline construction tender
ITAR-TASS News Agency
TASS
December 13, 2004 Monday 5:29 AM Eastern Time
Gazprom to take part in Iran-Armenia pipeline construction tender
By Tigran Liloyan
YEREVAN
The Russian Gazprom company will take part in a tender for the
construction of a gas pipeline from Iran to Armenia, which the gas
giant expects to win, the executive director of the ArmRosgazprom
joint venture told Itar-Tass.
The executive director of the Russian-Armenian joint venture, Karen
Karapetyan, said the date of the tender will be announced shortly.
The Armenian government and Gazprom have 45 percent of ArmRosgazprom
shares each, while the remaining ten percent belong to the ITERA
company.
Karapetyan dismissed allegations that the gas pipeline from Iran to
Armenia is intended for the transit of Iranian gas to Europe. The
pipeline of a bigger diameter is needed for the transit, and that
would involve bigger investments, he said. Besides, a free sales
market in third countries is necessary for the transit of gas, and
there is no such market, he stressed.
Iran extends a credit of 30 million dollars for the construction of
the 40-kilometer-long Armenian section, the press service of the
Armenian government told Itar-Tass. An agreement on that was signed
when Iranian President Mohammad Khatami paid an official visit to
Yerevan last September.
The construction of the pipeline will be launched simultaneously on
both sides. A total of 100 kilometers of the pipeline will run across
Iran. The construction is expected to be finished in January 2007,
after which the gas systems of the two countries will be united.
Armenia expects to pay for the supplies of Iranian gas with
electricity.
The Armenian leadership is confident that the gas pipeline from Iran
will strengthen the republic’s energy security.
Boxing: Vic sharpens body blows – Fight in toy town far from kids’
The Daily Telegraph (Sydney, Australia)
December 14, 2004 Tuesday
Vic sharpens body blows – Fight in toy town far from kids’ stuff
by GRANTLEE KIEZA
BOXING fans can see Vic Darchinyan’s world title fight on Friday for
the donation of a toy but there will be no playing around when he
faces Colombian IBF champ Irene Pacheco.
Darchinyan, 28, who fought for Armenia at the Sydney Olympics before
settling in Ryde, is planning a relentless body attack against the
world title holder in a battle of southpaws in Hollywood, Florida.
“All this week I’ll be trying to get inside Vic’s head and tell him
not to go into the fight over-confident,” said Darchinyan’s trainer
Jeff Fenech.
“Vic has to realise that if he goes head-hunting against
Pacheco he’s going to miss all night. Pacheco is a very talented
boxer but because Vic is such a great puncher he thinks he can bowl
everyone over.
“But against Pacheco he is going to have to work very hard to wear
down the champion.”
The fight was rescheduled from September 3 because of Hurricane
Francis.
The card is part of the celebrations for the grand opening of a new
arena at the casino in Hollywood and a toy donated for a charity will
get patrons a seat.
But that’s where the fun and games finish.
Pacheco, 33, is undefeated in 30 professional fights with 22 KOs,
while Darchinyan is unbeaten in 21 with 16 KOs.
The world champ hasn’t fought for 15 months but he has held the world
crown since 1999 and four of his six title defences have been by
knockout.
* TWO-TIME Australian champion Josh Clenshaw announced his retirement
on Sunday after losing an Australian middleweight title fight against
Perth’s undefeated Daniel Dawson.
Clenshaw, one of boxing’s most earnest triers, was outpointed over 10
rounds before a packed house at Penrith Panthers.
EU digests Turkey in pre-summit talks
Agence France Presse — English
December 13, 2004 Monday 4:59 PM GMT
EU digests Turkey in pre-summit talks
BRUSSELS
The European Union Monday launched a week of furious haggling on
Turkey with the bloc’s Dutch presidency upbeat on its EU prospects
but critics raising the stakes against the Muslim-majority country.
With EU leaders set this week to decide whether to launch
long-delayed accession talks with Ankara, Turkey’s Prime Minister
Recep Tayyip Erdogan said its EU bid was nothing less than the
“project of the century”.
The Netherlands, Britain and Germany all reaffirmed their backing for
Turkey’s EU bid. But discord in the 25-nation bloc simmered as EU
foreign ministers held talks to set the stage for the summit Thursday
and Friday.
The heads of government are expected to give a green light for Turkey
to open accession negotiations fully five years after it was formally
endorsed as an EU candidate.
But their approval will be hedged with a raft of conditions and
accompanied by warnings that the talks could be suspended if Turkey
flagrantly violates EU principles, and that there is no guarantee of
membership at the end of the day.
According to diplomats, the foreign ministers failed to make any
headway on the most pressing question — when should the talks start?
Turkey wants the EU to abide by a promise to launch the negotiations
“without delay”.
But the latest draft summit conclusions left the date open, with
France for one pushing for it to be held back until the second half
of 2005 to avoid the Turkey question clouding a French referendum on
the EU’s constitution.
French Foreign Minister Michel Barnier upped the ante by calling on
Turkey to admit to the World War I massacre of Armenians by their
Ottoman rulers during its EU negotiations.
And while Austria renewed its demand for Turkey to be offered a
“privileged partnership” rather than full EU membership, Cyprus
demanded Turkey move by next March on normalising its ties with the
divided Mediterranean island.
But meeting in Berlin, Dutch Prime Minister Jan Peter Balkenende and
German Chancellor Gerhard Schroeder said the EU would offer Turkey
nothing short of membership negotiations at this week’s summit.
“We agree on several points: first, the aim is membership and the aim
will not be watered down,” Schroeder told reporters after talks with
Balkenende, whose country currently holds the EU presidency.
“Secondly, there will be a date (for the start of membership
negotiations) and thirdly, as the commission already stated, the
negotiation process will take a long time. We expect 10-15 years with
an open outcome to the talks.”
“I have the feeling that we will reach consensus at the end of the
week,” Dutch Foreign Minister Ben Bot said here, while rebuffing talk
of a privileged partnership.
“Turkey is a candidate (for EU membership). Turkey is also aiming for
membership and that will be, let’s say, the objective of
negotiations,” he told reporters.
Cypriot Foreign Minister George Iacovou had earlier evoked the threat
of Nicosia vetoing Turkey’s EU bid unless it recognises his
internationally backed government, rather than the breakaway
Turkish-Cypriot republic.
But he later told reporters at the EU talks here: “We have not asked
for legally defined recognition but normalisation of relations in
general and in particular, in the bilateral field.”
Austrian Chancellor Wolfgang Schuessel meanwhile reiterated his
opposition to full Turkish membership of the EU, pointing to adhesion
costs estimated at between 25 billion and 30 billion euros a year.
“Who should pay that?” he asked the economic magazine Trend in an
interview to appear Tuesday.
Ankara, however, believes that it has earned the right to a date to
open EU accession talks by ramming through a raft of tough reforms to
its political system, judiciary, military and economy.
“Turkey has kept to its side of the bargain,” British Foreign
Secretary Jack Straw said here, rejecting the imposition of new
conditions on Erdogan’s government.
As for Erdogan, nothing less than harmony between the West and Islam
is at stake.
“To have a country like Turkey, where the cultures of Islam and
democracy have merged together, taking part in such an institution as
the EU will bring harmony of civilisations,” he told Britain’s daily
The Independent.
French Min: Turkey must come clean with Ottoman record in Armenia
Associated Press Worldstream
December 13, 2004 Monday 2:06 PM Eastern Time
French minister: Turkey must come clean with its Ottoman record in
Armenia
ROBERT WIELAARD; Associated Press Writer
BRUSSELS, Belgium
France will insist Turkey acknowledge its record regarding the
killing of Armenians in the early 20th century if it wants to join
the European Union, France’s foreign minister said Monday.
EU leaders holding a summit on Thursday and Friday are to discuss
setting a start date for negotiations for Turkey to join the
25-nation bloc.
“In the course of the accession negotiations, France will ask for a
recognition of the tragedy at the outset of the 20th century,” Michel
Barnier said.
Armenia accuses Turkey of genocide in the killings of up to 1.5
million Armenians as part of a 1915-1923 campaign to force them out
of eastern Turkey. At that time, Armenia was part of the Ottoman
Empire.
Turkey remains extremely sensitive to the issue. It denies the
genocide, says the death count is inflated and that Armenians were
killed or displaced along with others as the Ottoman Empire tried to
quell civil unrest.
Barnier was careful to avoid using the term “genocide,” but said that
“Turkey must reconcile itself with its past.”
Barnier said that “The European (unification) project is built on
reconciliation,” citing Germany and France, two EU members with a
rich history of wars that led to enormous loss of life.
Under EU rules, countries can only join if they are democracies, have
functioning market economies and live in peace with their neighbors.
Armenia and Turkey do not have diplomatic relations at the moment
because of past friction.
They are also at odds over Nagorno-Karabakh, a region within
Azerbaijan that has been under ethnic Armenian control since a war
that ended in 1994 without a political settlement. Azeris and Turks
share close ethnic ties, although recently Turkey has expressed a
willingness to improve relations with Armenia.
French-Turkish ties became strained in 2001, when French parliament’s
recognition of the killings as a genocide sparked a boycott of French
goods and an exclusion of French companies from Turkish defense
contracts.
“TURKISH BORDERS WITH ITS NEIGHBORS SHOULD NOT BE CLOSED”
“TURKISH BORDERS WITH ITS NEIGHBORS SHOULD NOT BE CLOSED”
Armenia Suffers Losses Amounting to $1 Billion
Azg/arm
14 Dec 04
“The Turkish Foreign Policy should keep in line with the policy
conducted by Brussels. This means that the Turkish borders with its
old neighbors shouldn’t be closed,” Vartan Oskanian stated in the
interview to Reuters, emphasizing that in the course of the last 10-15
years Armenia suffered losses amounting to $1 billion, as a result of
the closed borders.
“The membership to the EU should contribute to the formation of a more
open society in Turkey that will open the border-gates with Armenia
and will recognize the Armenian Genocide”, Freedom radio station
quoted Vartan Oskanian as saying.
“Armenia would like the issue of opening the borders be touched upon
at the EU more consequently, loudly, even aggressively, as it is an
important issue for the EU, as well,” Oskanian said, touching upon the
December 17 decisionto begin the negotiations around Turkey’s
membership to the EU.
Oskanian said that the opening of the Armenian-Turkish borders
achieved under the pressure of the EU member countries could
contribute to the development of trade, support the Eastern poor
regions of Turkey and the economic development of Armenia. Reminding
that Armenia together with Georgia and Azerbaijan was included in
“Enlarged Europe. New Neighbors,” program, Oskanian said: “If Turkey
doesn’t want to meet the commitments it undertook and use the created
opportunity, the whole program is not in time, at least for Armenia.”
As for the settlement of Nagorno Karabakh conflict, Oskanian said that
he is optimistic in the issue of establishing peace with Azerbaijan in
this complicated period, when Ilham Aliyev came to power after the
death of Heydar Aliyev who led Azerbaijan for many years.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress