"We are all Armenian" by Atom Egoyan

The Globe and Mail (Canada)
Feb 3 2007

BOOK REVIEW; Pg. D15

"We are all Armenian’;
The murder of a journalist in Turkey has reopened the discussion
about genocide and its denial, filmmaker ATOM EGOYAN says

by ATOM EGOYAN

The first book I ever read about the Armenian genocide was written by
an Austrian Jew. Franz Werfel’s epic novel Forty Days of Musa Dagh
(Viking Press, 1934) created a sensation when it was published.
Meticulously researched and written with an astute sense of
psychological detail, the novel was intended as a wake-up call to
European Jewry. If it could happen to Armenians in 1915, it could
happen anywhere.

But what exactly happened to Armenians in 1915? The enduring value of
Werfel’s great book is his ability to render all aspects of Armenian
life in the Ottoman Empire with a startlingly vivid clarity and
nuance. Very much in the tradition of the works of Thomas Mann (they
were contemporaries), every character is observed with a sense of
psychological magnification and kaleidoscopic vision.

Faced with certain death at the hands of the Turks, an Armenian
village mobilizes itself into action. Five thousand are led into the
impenetrable mountain area of Musa Dagh, where they heroically defend
themselves. The plot is linear and straightforward, yet each of the
main characters is infused with marvellous complexity. Werfel
presents the terrible events of 1915 with grandeur and scope, yet
fills every detail with precision and tenderness.

A defining aspect of the Armenian genocide is the methodical and
highly efficient denial of its perpetrators. Many scholarly works
have been published on this subject, including the Turkish academic
Taner Akcam’s A Shameful Act (Henry Holt, 2006). The most succinct
and compelling explanation of this history is offered in Robert
Fisk’s recent The Great War for Civilization (Fourth Estate, 2005).

Fisk has been in the forefront of the Middle East’s conflicts for 30
years, and this monumental work is a passionate and heartfelt
indictment of the lies and deceit that have defined the politics of
the region. In many ways, the collapse of the Ottoman Empire – and
the subsequent dividing of its spoils by the West – set the stage for
the instability of the entire region. Fisk devotes an entire chapter
(titled The First Holocaust) to the Armenian Question.

In fewer than 50 pages, Fisk brilliantly sets out the brutal
machinery of genocide, chronicling Hitler’s familiarity with the
mechanics and – just as ominously – its denial. He clearly explains
how the issue of the Armenian genocide began to fade from European
and U.S. attention after the First World War, despite the huge amount
of attention the massacres received at the time.

Hrant Dink, the Armenian journalist who was murdered in Turkey three
weeks ago, used this point as a way of explaining the event to his
Turkish countrymen. Turkey has been able to suppress "the Armenian
Question" because the West has allowed it to do so. Even with a
growing number of countries (including Canada) recognizing the
genocide, it still runs counter to general Western interests to
pursue the matter.

When MGM tried to make a film of Forty Days of Musa Dagh in the
mid-thirties, the Turkish ambassador filed a protest with the U.S.
State Department. If the film were to be made, Turkey would ban all
U.S. films from entering the country. After a year of exchanges
between the two governments, the State Department acquiesced to the
Turkish demand, and the project was dropped.

Peter Balakian, in his highly charged memoir Black Dog of Fate
(HarperCollins, 1997), wonders how Franklin Roosevelt’s State
Department could care so little about artistic freedom, especially in
light of what was about to happen to the Jews of Europe. Like Fisk,
Balakian is obsessed with the question of how a catastrophe that
loomed so large in the U.S. consciousness could slip from collective
memory (his most recent book, The Burning Tigris: The Armenian
Genocide and America’s Response, explores how and why the Armenian
crisis became for the United States, its first international
human-rights movement.

Balakian is a wonderful poet, and if I were to suggest one book that
combines carefully researched history with an emotionally charged
journey into the contemporary Armenian soul, this is certainly the
one to read.

Black Dog of Fate presents Balakian’s upbringing in the optimistic
years of 1950s and ’60s U.S. suburbia. With warmth and affection,
Balakian describes an adolescence of athletic seasons (football,
basketball, baseball), Sunday feasts of Armenian food and beautiful
evocations of his family and relatives. Balakian is a great lover of
carpets, and he weaves his words and highly charged imagery in a
masterful way. The unexpected discovery of how his grandmother made
an actual legal claim against the Turkish government after the First
World War is unforgettable. Balakian sets up his beloved
grandmother’s fragmented dreams and whispered stories, disarming the
reader with a poetic sense of melancholic reverie.

Balakian then presents a dry legal document he discovers that lists
the family she lost to the genocide (husband, brothers, sisters,
nieces and nephews), as well as a complete itemization of the
plundered goods of the family business. The plaintive claim for
compensation is simply devastating.

Balakian’s grandmother, signing this legal document on Jan. 31, 1920,
states, "The Turkish government is responsible for the losses and
injuries. . . . I am a human being and a citizen of the U.S.A. and
under the support of human and International law." Needless to say,
there was no response to this claim.

Last month, thousands of Turks poured into the streets of Istanbul
after Hrant Dink’s murder, yelling, "We are all Hrant Dink. We are
all Armenian." In the face of such confusion, pain and hatred, there
is an urgent human need to find empathy. Great literature strives for
this generosity of spirit, and these three authors will leave a
lasting impression on the reader.

Atom Egoyan is working on Auroras, a meditation on the Armenian
genocide. This installation will be exhibited during Luminato,
Toronto Festival of Arts & Creativity, in June, 2007. Among his many
films is Ararat, about the 1915 massacre of Armenians in Turkey.

Turkey: Officer suspended after posing with Dink suspect

Ottawa Citizen
February 3, 2007 Saturday
Final Edition

Turkey: Officer suspended after posing with Dink suspect

Four police officers have been suspended from duty after posing in
front of a Turkish flag with the suspected murderer of an ethnic
Armenian journalist. Another four security police have been
transferred to other duties after film of the incident was shown on
Turkish television. It shows officials, some in uniform, arm-in-arm
with Ogun Samast, who has confessed to the murder of Hrant Dink, the
editor of Agos, a bilingual Armenian-Turkish newspaper. Mr. Dink, 52,
was hated by ultra-nationalists for his writings about the mass
killing of Armenians on Ottoman soil during the First World War.

ANKARA; Turkish Foreign Minister Gul to visit USA on 4 February

Anatolia News Agency, Turkey
Feb 3 2007

Turkish minister to visit USA on 4 February

Ankara, 3 February: Turkish Foreign Minister and Deputy Prime
Minister Abdullah Gul will leave for the United States on Sunday [4
February] to hold a series of talks.

Turkish Ministry of Foreign Affairs officials told the Anatolia that
Gul was scheduled to meet US Vice-President Dick Cheney, Secretary of
State Condoleezza Rice, Secretary of Defence Robert Gates and
National Security Adviser Stephen Hadley in Washington, D.C.

He will also hold talks with US House of Representatives Foreign
Affairs Committee Chairman Tom Lantos and members of the committee.
Gul will deliver a speech at the German Marshall Fund.

He will proceed to New York on 8 February to meet with United Nations
Secretary-General Ban Ki-Moon.

Issues such as recent developments in Iraq, and the draft resolution
on so-called Armenian genocide which was submitted to the House of
Representatives will be high on agenda of Gul’s meetings with US
authorities.

Gul is expected to return to Turkey on 9 February.

Opposition is not alternative today

Hayots Ashkharh, Yerevan,
Feb 2 2007

Opposition is not alternative today
ARMENIAN AIDE SAYS OPPOSITION’S ELECTION CHANCES SLIM

by Harutyun Gevorkyan

An interview with the [Armenian] president’s adviser on security
issues, Garnik

Isagulyan.

[Correspondent] Opposition leaders have been saying that the
forthcoming parliamentary election will be held in a very tense
domestic political situation. Are there grounds for such anxiety?

[Isagulyan] There is nothing unusual in the domestic political
situation in Armenia and all pre-election processes have been
developing in a natural and peaceful way. I am sure that the election
campaigns of political forces that will run in the election will pass
off calmly as well. As for an outcome, it will be more correct to
speak about it in post-election time.

[Correspondent] Mr Isagulyan, what is hidden behind the slogan "the
election will be rigged"?

[Isagulyan] I have got an impression that what the opposition leaders
say today was earlier said by somebody else. Unfortunately, the
entire opposition camp is in agony. They always point at some
mistakes and shortcomings without any grounds. But they do not try to
suggest any way out from the "difficult" situation of the country. If
they say that Armenia has found itself outside international
cooperation programmes, they almost always mean ceding the NKR
[Nagornyy Karabakh republic] and adding Meghri [southern Armenia] to
that [territory] for having good relations with Azerbaijan and
Turkey. This is political will of the opposition.

But it is not a political position when a political force is ready to
cede what it has in order not to be forgotten and for having at least
one pipeline running via our territory. All this is a component of
the slogan "the election will be rigged". The opposition simply
understands that it does not have chances to get sufficient votes
from the people to come to the power. This is a good reason for a
hullabaloo. I think that they should refrain from misinforming
society and foreign forces at least at the pre-election stage.

[Correspondent] A board member of the Armenian Pan-National Movement
[APNM], Aram Manukyan, has said that he is against velvet and
coloured revolutions, but they [presumably the party] will be
involved in the same kind of events which have taken place in Ukraine
and Georgia.

[Isagulyan] The opposition realizes very well that our state has been
established and all the power and law-enforcement structures fulfil
their duties in full. There is no a revolutionary situation in our
country. There is need of revolution neither from below nor

from above. If the opposition has in fact expected for 15-20 per cent
support of the people, it would not be in a situation of this kind.
They understand that they have lost the entire resource of confidence
and they have nothing more than pin hopes on coloured revolutions.

I said long ago that the entire opposition camp is led by the APNM as
major intellectual potential of the opposition is accumulated in this
party. As for the APNM itself, the party sees that the election will
not be rigged and so there is no way for them to come to power.

[Correspondent] To what degree are foreign forces concerned about the
possibility of a coloured revolution in Armenia?

[Isagulyan] Foreign forces always prefer to create a situation in
other countries when they can influence authorities. But I think that
they do not make such calculations regarding Armenia. There is a
balance of foreign forces’ influence in our country and any attempt
of interference from their side will not succeed. Foreign forces
establish their relations with any state taking the reality into
account. It is difficult to rely on the opposition’s view that 80 per
cent of the people are displeased with the authorities. It is not
ruled out that many people could be displeased with the authorities
but they do not consider the opposition an alternative.

BAKU: Azeri soldier arrested after return from Armenian captivity

Azeri Press Agency, Azerbaijan
Feb 2 2007

AZERI SOLDIER ARRESTED AFTER RETURN FROM ARMENIAN CAPTIVITY

Baku, 2 February: A soldier of the Azerbaijani army, Vusal Qaracayev,
captured by Armenians on 7 December [2006] has been arrested, APA
news agency has learnt from the republic’s Military Prosecutor’s
Office. According to this report, criminal proceedings against
Qaracayev have been instituted at the investigative department for
serious crimes of the Military Prosecutor’s Office under Articles 274
(high treason) and 338.1 (abuse of rules of performance of military
service) of the Criminal Code. An investigation is under way.

We should note that Qaracayev, born in 1988, was called up this year
[as published, actually last year] by the Balakan district military
conscription office [northern Azerbaijan]. He was captured on 7
December on the territory of Agdam [district partly occupied by
Armenia] and freed on 23 December [2006].

Kosovo scenario to influence Karabakh settlement

Mediamax News Agency, Armenia
Feb 3 2007

Kosovo scenario to influence Karabakh settlement

Any decision on the status of Kosovo will have an impact on the talks
on the settlement of the Nagornyy Karabakh conflict, the Armenian
news agency Mediamax has said in its weekly analytical edition.
Although these two conflicts have own peculiarities, Kosovo may
become a precedent as seen by one of the mediator countries, Russia.
The agency however criticized the latter for "double standards" with
regard to Nagornyy Karabakh and other conflicts in the post-Soviet
area. The following is an excerpt from report in English by Armenian
news agency Mediamax headlined "Russia, the USA, Kosovo and Nagornyy
Karabakh"; subheadings inserted editorially:

On 2 February, the special representative of the UN
Secretary-General, Martti Ahtisaari, presented his plan on the
settlement of the Kosovo conflict. According to the presented
formula, Kosovo will not become automatically independent, but will
gain many rights of an independent state, in particular, the right to
sign agreements with other states and to get membership in
international organizations. It is expected that in February Belgrade
and Pristina will prepare comments and proposals, which Ahtisaari
will try to include in his plan. The next round of consultations is
to take place on 13 February, and in March, the document will be sent
to the UN Security Council, which will determine the future of
Kosovo.

It is obvious that the discussions of the Kosovo problem in the
Security Council will not be facile, just taking into consideration
the fact that Russia and the USA stick to diametrically opposite
stances. Moscow thinks that the Kosovo decision will become a
precedent, and Washington strongly rejects that prospect.

No return to previous status both in Kosovo and Karabakh

The Armenian authorities openly declare that the Kosovo independence,
proclaimed in this or that wording, is an expected event, at the same
time noting that they do not expect it to have direct influence on
the process of the Karabakh conflict settlement.

[Passage omitted: the Armenian president and foreign minister have
spoken on the issue]

We should note that there is really no sense drawing direct
comparison of the conflicts in Nagornyy Karabakh and Kosovo, because
of a number of reasons. At the same time, it is obvious that a number
of approaches to the settlement of the situation in Kosovo can be
referred to Nagornyy Karabakh also – not wishing to blindly copy the
reached solutions, but basing on common sense.

For instance, US Assistant Secretary of State for European and
Eurasian Affairs Daniel Fried stated this January that while
determining the Kosovo status, there could be no return to the
situation that was present before 1999. We believe that no one will
argue that in the case with Nagornyy Karabakh, there cannot be a
return to the situation which was before 1988, that is, there can be
no return to the autonomy. The difference lies in the fact that as
opposed to Kosovo, they do not state it openly here: neither the
mediators, nor especially the Azerbaijani leadership.

OSCE mediators differ on Kosovo "precedent" for Karabakh

The fact that the OSCE Minsk Group co-chairs have different opinions
as to the "precedent nature" of Kosovo, is proved by their last visit
to the region. Answering the questions of the journalists after the
meeting with the leader of Nagornyy Karabakh, Arkadi Ghukasyan,
Russian co-chair Yuriy Merzlyakov stated that the decision on Kosovo
"will make a precedent, as for the first time in the European
territory the case concerns a former autonomy". However, the French
and the US co-chairs of the OSCE Minsk Group, Bernard Fassier and
Matthew Bryza, opposed using the Kosovo settlement model as a
universal one. "Each conflict has its peculiarities and complications
and for each of them a certain solution should be found," Matthew
Bryza stated.

[Passage omitted: comments of the same nature by the co-chair
countries]

At the same time, we should note that, insisting during the year of
2006 on the "precedent nature" of the Kosovo case, Russia continually
drew analogies with South Ossetia and Abkhazia, more seldom with the
Dniester region and almost not once with Nagornyy Karabakh. In this
case, Moscow can also be suspected of double standards; as such
analogies were used by Russia mainly to put pressure on Georgia and
Moldova. A circumstantial evidence of that can be the fact that in
the whole course of 2006, the Russian Foreign Ministry not once in
this or that form expressed support for the elections and the
referendums in South Ossetia, Abkhazia and the Dniester region.
However, it did not show such an attitude as to the referendum on the
constitution in Nagornyy Karabakh.

No matter what the decision on the Kosovo status is, it will
undoubtedly have a direct or indirect influence on the settlement of
the Nagornyy Karabakh conflict. However, the most important in the
given situation is that the discussion on the degree of this
influence does not distract the sides of the conflict from the very
talks. An experience shows that very often the sides just look for an
occasion to avoid the real negotiations. Kosovo can perfectly become
such an occasion.

Roland Rey Has Made Up His Mind

A1+

ROLAND REY HAS MADE UP HIS MIND
[03:37 pm] 02 February, 2007

Head of cultural center «Minora», producer and singer
Roland Rey is going to sue the authors of the TV
program «32 teeth» broadcast by the Public Television
if they do not apologize publicly.

During the January 21 program one of the authors
included Rey’s name in the so-called «Top Stupid Ten»,
alongside with several other singers.

According to Roland Rey, «32 teeth» is the stupid
version of «Comedy Club». «If they say it is their
format, then why do they speak about only several
singers? If they are doing it, let them speak about
everyone. I have never allowed them to speak about
myself».

Roland Rey has spoken to representative of «Comedy
Club» Tatiana Vichenko who accepted that the action of
the presenters was not correct. Besides, Rey was not
present in the club: according to the Russian variant,
the person who is being made fun of must be present in
the club and give his permission.

CEC Member Says Police and Sick People Source of Double Voting

Panorama.am

19:25 02/02/2007

CEC MEMBER SAYS POLICE AND SICK PEOPLE SOURCE OF DOUBLE VOTING

`Do not have a hope that we will have normal elections because there
are preconditions for that,’ Feliks Khachatryan, Central Electoral
Committee (CEC) member and representative of Justice Alliance,
said. In his words, `The authorities have no wish to conduct normal
election because they are fond of their posts.’

CEC member said it is not acceptable to say now that the elections are
faked. He said it should be done during the campaign and
elections. However, Khachatryan said, `There are plans to fake
elections.’

In his words, two harmful things were possible to prevent for these
election. It was decided to make a note in the military book of the
soldiers in order to prevent double voting of soldiers. `The military
books of the soldiers will be stamped so that they cannot go to the
electoral unit and vote for the second time,’ Khachatryan said.

CEC member said, `The process of pouring extra voter lists have become
difficult,’ saying that voters must put their voter ticket into an
envelope which must be signed before putting into the bulletin box.

`Now they cannot even add extra 100 into the bulletin box,’
Khachatryan said happily.

Khachatryan warned again double voting as a source of election
fraud. He said the police and sick people may be potential voters for
double voting.

According to the law the citizen registry offices and OVIR must list
out the police on duty in different election centers from their
communities and list them in the election centers where they perform
their duties three days before the elections. `This is practically and
theoretically not possible. As a result there will be 20,000 people
more,’ Khachatryan said. The same refers to sick people who are in
hospital. He said they will vote in hospitals and their names should
be taken out from the community lists.

Source: Panorama.am

Nushikyan Association Breaks Water Pipeline

Panorama.am

19:45 02/02/2007

NUSHIKYAN ASSOCIATION BREAKS WATER PIPELINE

`About an hour ago the truck of Nushikyan Association broke the water
pipeline supplying water to the area. The whole area is out of water
now,’ committee members defending the rights of 19 Aghayan and 56
Teryan building residents said in a disturbing call to Panorama.am.

`Nushikyan people do not stop and the construction workers have built
something like Paplovok café in the place,’ the members said also
saying the police and the Water Company do not react.

Asked what measures the Water Company will take, press spokesman Murad
Sargsyan of the company said a letter must be written to company head
Serzh Popoff.

Source: Panorama.am

OY Leader: I Don’t Seek The Title of "Opposition Leader"

OY LEADER: I DON’T SEEK THE TITLE OF "OPPOSITION LEADER"

Yerevan, February 3. ArmInfo. I don’t seek the title of "opposition
leader" – the leader of the opposition is the people, the leader of
Orinats Yerkir party, ex parliamentary speaker Artur Bagdassaryan says
in an interview to Kentron TV.

Bagdassaryan thanks almost 200,000 people who gave their votes to his
party during the parliamentary elections 2003. After his resignation
and the split of OY from the opposition, his party has gone through
many privations. "We have seen slander and treason but we have got
even stronger," says Bagdassaryan.