Sociologist Expects More Election Fraud

Panorama.am

17:13 03/02/2007

SOCIOLOGIST EXPECTS MORE ELECTION FRAUD

‘The election campaign will be more tense this year with more election
fraud because about 50,000 people participate in the election process
starting from election committee members and finished with authorized
persons,’ Aharon Adibekyan, a renowned sociologist in Armenia, told a
debate with the editor-in-chief of Aravot daily.

In his words, they are uncontrollable for each other because of
conflict of interests. On the other hand, new players have come about
in the political field and the struggle is within the governing
power. The Prosperous Armenia, which has gained big power, is
center-oriented and is approaching to the Armenian Republican Party
(HHK), he said.

`However, if they reach a gentleman agreement and commit as little
violations as possible, it will be possible to have democratic
elections in Armenia,’ Adibekyan said. In his words, the developments
show that the two parties will reach such an agreement.

Aram Abrahamyan, editor-in-chief of Aravot daily, believes that the
elections are already faked. In his words, the authorities own all
administrative resources to attract the public. `The authorities have
power which are not connected to money,’ he said. Abrahamyan also
predicts that if Prosperous Armenia and HHK do not conflict each
other, no major violations will be reported. Abrahamyan believes the
Armenian Revolutionary Federation and United Working Party will get
only `left-outs’ of power.

Source: Panorama.am

It’s a war of the words

The Brunei Times, Brunei Darussalam
Jan 3 2007

It’s a war of the words

George P Fletcher
03-Feb-07

NOWADAYS, words are often seen as a source of instability.

The violent reactions last year to the caricatures of the Prophet
Muhammad (PBUH) published in a Danish newspaper saw a confused
Western response, with governments tripping over their tongues trying
to explain what the media should and should not be allowed to do in
the name of political satire.

Then Iran trumped the West by sponsoring a conference of Holocaust
deniers, a form of speech punished as criminal almost everywhere in
Europe.

As Turks well know, it is dangerous to take a position on the
Armenian genocide of 1915. The most recent Nobel laureate in
literature, Orhan Pamuk, was prosecuted in Istanbul for denying
Turkey’s official history by saying that the Armenian genocide
actually occurred.

Other Turks have faced prosecution in Western Europe for saying that
it did not.

So words are now clearly a battlefield in the cultural conflict
between Islam and the West.

The West has learned that, simply as a matter of self-censorship, not
legal fiat, newspapers and other media outlets will not disseminate
critical pictures of the prophet, and the Pope will no longer make
critical comments about Islam. But these gestures of cooperation with
Muslim sensibilities have not been met by reciprocal gestures.

Instead, Mahmoud Ahmedinejad, Irans president, has threatened to wipe
Israel off the map. The Israeli Foreign Ministry now seeks
prosecution of Ahmedinejad for incitement to commit genocide a
violation of international law.

But the Israeli press is also bellicose. Israeli newspapers regularly
carry stories about why Israel may need to attack Iran to prevent it
from acquiring an arsenal of nuclear weapons.

United States President George W Bush has made similarly ominous, if
more vague, statements about Iran.

In Germany, preparing and calling for preemptive military strikes
from within the government are subject to criminal sanctions.

The worlds different legal systems have never been in much agreement
about the boundaries of free speech.

Even between good neighbours like Canada and the US, there is little
agreement about punishing hate speech.

Canadians punish racial insults, but Americans do not, at least if
the issue is simply one of protecting the dignity of racial
minorities.

But threatening violence is more serious. Many countries are united
in supporting the principle that if, say, Ahmedinejad does meet the
criteria for incitement of genocide, he should be punished in the
International Criminal Court. Indeed, the International Criminal
Tribunal for Rwanda punished radio station operators who made
aggressive public broadcasts urging Hutus to pick up their machetes
and murder Tutsis.

A decade ago there would have been a good argument in international
law that the Hutu-Tutsi example supports prosecution only after the
damage has been done.

All the international precedents from Nuremberg to the present
concern international intervention after mass atrocities.

Domestic police may be able to intervene to prevent crime before it
occurs, but in the international arena there is no police force that
can do that.

It follows, therefore, that the crime of incitement should apply only
to cases like Rwanda, where the radio broadcasts actually contributed
to the occurrence of genocide.

In cases where bellicose leaders make public threats to bury another
country (remember Khrushchev?) or to wipe it off the map, the courts
should wait, it was said, until some harm occurs.

But the international community has become ever more intrusive in
using legal remedies against persons who engage in provocative and
dangerous speech. In September 2005, the United Nations Security
Council passed Resolution 1624 paradoxically, with American approval
calling upon all member states to enact criminal sanctions against
those who incite terrorism.

The model of incitement they had in mind is the same one that British
Prime Minister Blair has publicly invoked: Muslim leaders standing up
in their mosques and urging their congregations to go out and kill
infidels.

Americans have traditionally said that, absent a risk of immediate
unlawful violence, this form of speech should be protected under the
First Amendment.

US courts reasoned that it is better to allow the release of hateful
sentiments than to call attention to them by showcasing them in
court.

But when it comes to terrorism in todays world, most countries,
including the worlds democracies, are not as tolerant as they used to
be.

So the traditional liberal position in support of giving wide scope
to freedom of speech, even for extremists, is losing ground
everywhere.

When it comes to fighting terrorism and the prospect of genocide, the
world is now becoming afraid of dangerous words.

George P Fletcher is Cardozo Professor of Jurisprudence at Columbia
University. His latest book is Romantics at War: Glory and Guilt in
the Age of Terrorism.

Project Syndicate

hp?shape_ID=19492

http://www.bruneitimes.com.bn/details.p

TIME carries documentary, adopts policy on Armenian Genocide

Financial Mirror, Cyprus
Jan 3 2007

TIME carries documentary, adopts policy on Armenian Genocide

03/02/2007

The Feb. 12, 2007 issue of the European edition of TIME magazine —
available in newsstands throughout Europe as of Feb. 2 — carries a
full-page factual announcement on the Armenian Genocide, along with a
complimentary DVD, in English and French, which contains a compelling
52-minute documentary on the Armenian Genocide by French director
Laurence Jourdan. The DVD also includes a 46-minute interview with
Dr. Yves Ternon, a leading expert on the Armenian Genocide.

Both the DVD and the full-page ad were provided free of charge by
TIME Europe (circulation 550,000) after realizing that its staff,
without proper review, had inserted in the June 6, 2005 issue of TIME
Europe a Turkish DVD as a paid advertisement under the guise of
promoting tourism to Turkey. The Turkish DVD, paid for by the Ankara
Chamber of Commerce, was a deceitful attempt to spread malicious lies
and denialist propaganda on the Armenian Genocide.

To correct this error, TIME (Europe) published, in its October 17,
2005 issue, a critical page-long letter to the editor jointly signed
by five French organizations. In an Editor’s note appended to the
letter, TIME apologized for disseminating the Turkish DVD.

In December 2005, the five organizations along with the
Switzerland-Armenia Association (SAA), the French Association of
Armenian Lawyers and Jurists (AFAJA), the European – Armenian
Federation for Justice and Democracy (EAFJD), and The California
Courier newspaper reached an amicable agreement with TIME executives
ensuring that the facts of the Armenian Genocide are not distorted
again in the pages of the magazine.

Subsequently, Michael Elliott, the Editor of TIME International,
issued the following public statement: "Please be advised that, in
common with other leading news organizations, it is TIME’s policy and
practice to refer to the Armenian genocide as a historical fact.
Accordingly, I will be informing our correspondents and editors that
the term ‘Armenian genocide’ should be used without qualification."

The abovementioned organizations said in an announcement that are
fully satisfied with the corrective steps taken by TIME magazine.
They are also pleased that the Turkish attempt to distort the facts
of the Armenian Genocide, supported by considerable financial
resources, was properly countered as a result of these organizations’
close cooperation with TIME which placed journalistic ethics above
all other considerations.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Schiff calls for genocide recognition

Burbank Leader, CA
Jan 3 2007

POLITICAL LANDSCAPE:
Schiff calls for genocide recognition

Rep. Adam Schiff, who represents Glendale and Burbank, announced the
introduction of a resolution Tuesday recognizing and commemorating
the Armenian genocide.

It is the second year Schiff has introduced such a resolution, but
looked for Congress’ new leadership to help him pass the resolution
this year.

It received support in the form of 165 co-signing members of
Congress.

The resolution has the support of the Armenian National Committee of
America, the Armenian Assembly of America and the U.S. Armenia Public
Affairs Committee

Schiff stated that the U.S. has both compelling moral and historical
reasons to formally recognize the Armenian genocide as well as the
ability to bring further attention the genocides currently taking
place in other parts of the world.

Legislature honors slain journalist advertisement

Assemblyman Paul Krekorian and state Sen. Jack Scott made tributes on
Thursday when both houses of the California State Legislature
adjourned in memory of Armenian journalist Hrant Dink, who was shot
by a Turkish man in Istanbul Jan. 19.

Krekorian called Dink a "courageous symbol of free speech," who spoke
out about the Armenian genocide, as well as fought for the rights of
women and ethnic minorities.

Members of Krekorian’s own family were lost during the genocide.

Scott said Dink was a man who died for his ideals and his has sparked
an outcry from people worldwide who believe in truth.

Turkish Sec officials removed from office over inappropriate TV img

People’s Daily Online, China
Jan 3 2007

Turkish security officials removed from office over inappropriate TV
image of journalist murder suspect

Four police officers and four gendarmery officers were removed from
offices in Turkey’s northern city of Samsun on Friday, over footage
showing some security troops posing for "souvenir pictures" with the
alleged murderer of Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink.

According to the semi-official Anatolia news agency, the Turkish
Interior Ministry announced its decision to dismiss four police
officers in Samsun where Ogun Samast, 17, the alleged murderer of
Dink, was arrested.

Furthermore, the Gendarme General Command also transferred four of
its staff, said the report.

Anatolia reported that this happened after private TGRT television
channel broadcast on Thursday night a video footage showing Samast,
who has confessed to the murder of the journalist, posing in front of
a Turkish flag, flanked by some uniformed security officials.

The images and footage were taken at the anti-terror department in
Samsun, where Samast was arrested 32 hours after Dink was shot dead
outside his newspaper offices in Istanbul on Jan. 19, it was
reported.

The footage had emerged as an embarrassment for Samsun security
forces, which were accused by the press as having treated Samast the
murderer as a "hero."

During a weekly press briefing in Ankara, the spokesman of the
Security Directorate General Ismail Caliskan said a probe had been
launched to find out by whom or why the video footage and images were
shot.

Caliskan added that inspectors of the interior ministry have been
carrying out an investigation in northern cities of Trabzon, Samsun,
Istanbul and Ankara.

Hrant Dink, a 53-year-old Turkish citizen of Armenian descent, was
well-known for writing controversial articles about the alleged
Armenian genocide by Ottoman Turks during World War I and had
received a six-month suspended sentence.

Dink had received threat from nationalists who considered him as a
traitor. Turkish officials said that they have charged seven people
over the murder of Dink.

ANKARA: TIME yields to the Armenian lobby too

Sabah, Turkey
Jan 3 2007

TIME yields to the Armenian lobby too

The eminent news magazine of the USA, Time, propitiated the European
Armenian lobbies who reacted to the Turkey publicity DVD Time gave
free in 2005. At the European edition, Time distributed free
"Armenian genocide" DVD.

America’s world famous weekly news magazine, Time gave free Armenian
genocide DVD and poster at its European edition. Behind this
promotion decision of the magazine lied the reactions of Armenian
lobbies to Turkey publicity DVD Time gave free in 2005. The DVD
contains an interview of 46 minutes with the French historian Yves
Ternon and a documentary named "Armenian genocide" by French director
Laurance Jourdan.

ANKARA: Armenian lobby hits back with Time’s help

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
Jan 3 2007

Armenian lobby hits back with Time’s help

Time magazine on Friday released a 52-minute documentary by French
director Laurence Jourdan on the Armenian `genocide.’
With a full-page advertisement by `a coalition of Armenian Groups,’
the DVD also includes a 46-minute interview with Dr. Yves Ternon on
the Armenian `genocide.’ The DVD and the advertisement have been paid
for by Time, according to European Armenian Federation.
Delighted with Time’s reaction, the Armenian lobby announced that
Michael Elliot, the director of Time International, had said Time had
decided to call the 1915 events a genocide and called on all editors
and correspondents to describe 1915 only as a genocide.
Time’s decision to distribute the DVD came after a CD made by the
Ankara Chamber of Commerce last year was distributed by Time.
According to the European Armenian Federation, Time decided to
correct this mistake and agreed to financially back and distribute
the documentary.
The distribution of 550,000 copies with the European edition of Time
comes in the wake of the assassination of Hrant Dink. In addition,
while a French bill criminalizing the denial of an Armenian genocide
is awaiting Senate approval, EU term president Germany has proposed a
pan-European law to imprison deniers of genocide, war crimes and
crimes against humanity.
There are serious allegations in the one-page advertisement, which
are considered to be baseless by Ankara. Some of them are:
`Who after all, speaks today of the annihilation of the Armenians?’
Hitler posed this question on Aug. 22, 1939 before embarking on the
Holocaust.
The New York Times, the Los Angeles Times, the Boston Globe, the
Montreal Gazette and Time magazine call 1915 a genocide.
The UN Sub-Commission on Prevention of Discrimination and Protection
of Minorities and over a dozen European countries affirmed that the
1915 events were a genocide.

03.02.2007

Selçuk Gültaþlý Brussels

ANKARA: NGOs send the ball back to government’s court on 301 changes

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
Jan 3 2007

NGOs send the ball back to government’s court on 301 changes

A group of non-governmental organizations which gathered in Ankara
yesterday to discuss possible changes to the infamous Article 301 of
the Turkish Penal Code has failed to come up with a joint proposal on
desired amendments and said instead that they were ready to assess a
concrete proposal to be outlined by the government.

`We agreed that first the political will must take a concrete step,’
said Özdemir Özok, the chairman of Turkish Bar Association (TBB)
whose association initiated yesterday’s meeting, after the five-hour
talks. "There was a consensus that the government’s step in this
regard should be assessed and that efforts [for amendments] should
continue." Özok said there was no specific plan to hold a second
meeting to discuss Article 301, although similar gatherings may
convene according to future developments.

The meeting came after the government repeatedly said it expected
non-governmental organizations to come up with concrete proposals on
how Article 301, which critics say restricts freedom of expression,
should be amended. The law makes `insulting Turkishness’ a crime
punishable by up to three years in prison. The government has said it
was ready to introduce amendments in a limited scope, like a decrease
in penalties if the `crime’ was committed abroad.
The government is under growing pressure to change Article 301 since
Hrant Dink, a Turkish-Armenian journalist who had been tried and
convicted under it, was killed by a teenage assailant who reportedly
confessed to killing because Dink had insulted `Turkish blood.’
Mourners at Dink’s funeral procession, which drew up to 100,000
people, carried banners that read `Murderer 301.’
Yesterday’s meeting of some 18 NGOs, primarily representing labor
unions, employee organizations and professional chambers, was marred
by disagreements from the beginning. Representatives from the
Confederation for Public Servants (KAMU-SEN) and the Turkish
Veterinary Union (TVHB) left the meeting saying that they were
against any amendments to Article 301.
TVHB Chairman Mehmet Alkan said after leaving the meeting that the
TVHB was against any amendments to the Article 301. `Turkish society
does not need an amendment on this. This is being imposed on us from
outside. Society does not have the will and wish for amendments to
Article 301. In my opinion, punishments for insulting Turkishness are
even less than they should be. Plus, in every country, there are
articles like this one,’ Alkan said.
Similarly, KAMU-SEN Chairman Bircan Akyýldýz echoed the idea that
amending Article 301 was being imposed from outside and claimed this
meant it was against the national will. Akyýldýz also added that the
government’s insistence on hearing from NGOs concerning Article 301
was questionable because when it came to other matters, for example
economic and social affairs, the government did not have the same
attitude.
Some criticized the fact that relevant NGOs were not invited to
yesterday’s meeting. Human Rights Association (ÝHD) Chairman Yusuf
Alataþ, who was not invited to the meeting, said that civil society
was a wide concept and if the subject was Article 301 it must be
discussed by relevant NGOs.
`There are two aspects of Article 301: one related to freedoms and
the other to laws. If there are to be any discussions, it must be
discussed by relevant organizations, not by professional chambers.
Otherwise we could easily think that either a solution is not desired
or there is a tailor-made solution in mind and others have been
invited to give approval to it.’

03.02.2007

AYÞE KARABAT ANKARA

Book Review: Ghosts of Turkey’s past

Minneapolis Star Tribune , MN
Jan 3 2007

Ghosts of Turkey’s past

FICTIONA Turkish girl with no father and an American-Armenian girl
with no past begin a complicated friendship in Istanbul.
By John Freeman, Special to the Star Tribune
Last update: February 02, 2007 – 4:32 PM

It is unfortunate that the first thing readers might know about this
bold and raggedly beautiful new novel is that writing it nearly cost
Elif Shafak her freedom. Like fellow countryman and Nobel laureate
Orhan Pamuk, Shafak was charged under Article 301 of the Turkish
criminal code for "public denigration" of Turkishness, the punishment
for which is up to three years in prison. (A Turkish journalist
guilty of the same "crime" recently paid with his life.) Shafak was
acquitted, however, and now U.S. readers can pick up this still
vibrating book with newfound appreciation.
As with Pamuk, Shafak’s true crime wasn’t insulting Turkishness, but
rather daring to speak about what is known ultra-euphemistically as
the "Armenian question." In many other corners of the world, it is
referred to as the Armenian genocide — the forced evacuation and
deaths of more than 1 million Armenians between 1915 and 1917, the
waning years of the Ottoman Empire. While the Turkish government
argues that these deaths resulted from the chaos of World War I,
there is mounting evidence that it was a state-sponsored plan of
ethnic cleansing. The novel filters the anguish of this event through
the lives of an Armenian family in San Francisco and Arizona, and a
Turkish family in Istanbul. Following them over the course of a year,
it meditates on the power of memory and the way time tends to bend
the rules about killing. What happens when grief and suffering are
denied? Do historical grudges grow more powerful when one leaves a
country, or do they wash away?

Not surprisingly, rain is one of the recurring metaphors Shafak
employs effectively. It sluices through the action, whisking scenes
away. In the opening pages, Zeliha, one of four headstrong Turkish
sisters (known as the Kazanci women), walks to an abortion clinic in
a downpour. "Rain, for us, isn’t necessarily about getting wet,"
Shafak writes. "It’s not about getting dirty even. If anything, it’s
about getting angry. It’s mud and chaos and rage."

Zeliha doesn’t go through with the abortion, and the result is Asya,
the bastard of the book’s title. Asya has three aunts: Feride, a
hypochondriac who collects arcane knowledge about the ozone layer and
medicine; Banu, who believes she is a clairvoyant, and Cevriye, a
widowed high-school teacher. The one Kazanci man, Mustafa, has moved
to Arizona and lives with a woman named Rose. A daughter from Rose’s
previous marriage to an Armenian man, Amanoush, splits her time
between San Francisco and Tucson, until she decides she needs to
explore her Turkishness. So she’s off to Istanbul, where she
eventually encounters and befriends Asya.

This development sets up a certain bit of ambiguity to the book’s
title. Is the real bastard of Istanbul Asya, the girl with no father?
Or is it Amanoush, the girl with no past? Round and round we go, with
Shafak pushing the action along with a variety of devices. Each
chapter is titled after an ingredient, from sugar to cinnamon and
dried figs.

Throughout the story, Shafak gives the reader a guided tour of her
native city. "March is most unbalanced in Instanbul," she writes,
"both psychologically and physically. March might decide she belongs
to the spring season … only to change her mind the very next day."

Although this book is crowded with characters, its most vivid one is
not one of the Kazanci matriarchs but Istanbul itself. It is a city
plagued by ghosts, talkative and thronged to the extreme but notable
for what it is silent about. As Shafak sketches it, Istanbul also is
a bastard city. The past has abandoned it — or it has abandoned the
past. So, like all bastards, Istanbul lives slightly adrift under the
pretense that only the present matters when in truth history is its
mother and father — something it will have to confront when the past
comes to claim it again.

John Freeman, president of National Book Critics Circle, lives in New
York City.

THE BASTARD OF ISTANBUL

By: Elif Shafak.

Publisher: Viking, 360 pages, $24.95.

Review: Shafak boldly and beautifully explores sensitive issues of
Turkish identity and history — at the risk of her own freedom.

Event: Because of recent events in Turkey, the author is not
traveling, and an event scheduled for Thursday at Minneapolis Public
Library has been cancelled.

Genocide Denial Comedy

Brussels Journal, Belgium
Jan 3 2007

Genocide Denial Comedy

>From the desk of Elaib Harvey on Fri, 2007-02-02 22:57
I have it on good authority that the distinguished British historian
Norman Stone is minded to see what happens when you flout the
illiberal genocide denial laws being touted by the EU [pdf].

My own idea is to get a large crowd of liberty lovers gather in the
European Parliament in front of the media on the day that this piece
of monstrous thought crime legislation is passed by the statists that
represent you in the palace of vanities that is the EP.
Simultaneously they will proclaim that they don’t believe that the
Gulag ever happened. After all the mass murder of the Kulaks,
Cossacks, oh just about anybody by the Communists is not on the list
of the forbidden.

But back to Professor Stone. In today’s Telegraph piece he is quoted,

Norman Stone, the professor of history at Turkey’s Koç University,
argues that any attempt to legislate against genocide denial is
`quite absurd’.
`I am dead against this kind of thing,’ he said. `We can not have EU
or international legal bodies blundering in and telling us what we
can and can not say.’

What was missed from the article was how he is proposing to do
something about it. He is after all involved in the great Armenian
genocide massacre argument. The French Government is legislating at
present to make Armenian Genocide denial a criminal offence, a law
that I believe will be enacted sometime in the late spring. According
to my source, the British historian is ready to risk prison to
confront Socialist backed French moves to outlaw Armenian genocide
denial.

`This is a ridiculous and contemptible business – bad history and
worse politics, ` he said.
`I would volunteer, myself, to provoke some trouble in France.’

What this seems to entail is giving a lecture in France after the
legislation has been passed bringing into question the facts
surrounding the Armenian massacres. Then going hot foot to the UK.

>From there he will be liable to extradition under the European Arrest
Warrant. The French authorities will apply for one, get it, send it
to the UK authorities, who because they have signed up to the bloody
thing, send the plod round to his door.

As is the tradition at 6 am, some size twelve boot will be applied to
his door.

`Professor Stone?’
`Yes’
`Under the authority of the European Union I am arresting you.’ Here
our enterprising young plod (no doubt with armed back up) will wave a
pair of handcuffs under the professor’s nose, for an offence that is
not on British statute book and for which their is no Common Law
criminal precedent. `I have to advise you that any statement you make
will be translated into the 22 official languages of the European
Union and you will be kept in a French prison until they can be
bothered to hear your case.’

Or in the words of one EU Commission official asked about the case:

`Individuals who could be surrendered for denial offences that took
place in another member state since racism and xenophobia is included
in the list of offences mentioned by the European arrest warrant.’

There is one slightly interesting side to this though. If Turkey
joins the EU then we will have the comedy situation that denial of
the Armenian Holocaust is a criminal offence in France, whilst
mentioning it is a criminal offence in Turkey. The happy result of
this could be that the entire population of France could be lifted
and placed, Midnight Express like in Turkish prisons. Of course the
entire population of Turkey could then find itself extradited to
France and imprisoned there.

http://www.brusselsjournal.com/node/1886