Documentarian bands with rockers to target genocide

Boston Globe, MA
Feb 4 2006

Documentarian bands with rockers to target genocide
Armenian ties drew Garapedian to System of a Down

By Sarah Rodman, Globe Staff | February 4, 2007

Carla Garapedian recognizes the irony of her initial reaction to the
music of System of a Down.

"To me it just sounded like they were screaming," she says of the
multiplatinum band’s heavy-duty rock.

But the former BBC anchor and documentary filmmaker is a fan of
raised voices. Her new film "Screamers," which opens Friday, is about
just that, people speaking up.

Having tackled tough issues in award-winning films such as "Beneath
the Veil," which profiled women in Afghanistan, and "Iran
Undercover," about that country’s student movement, Garapedian found
common ground with the politically outspoken members of System of a
Down. In fact, the quartet and the filmmaker, all Armenian-Americans
from Los Angeles, had been screaming about the same issue for several
years: getting the United States and world governments to officially
recognize the Armenian genocide of 1915. Beyond that first listen,
Garapedian realized that the band would be the perfect vehicle to
drive this long-gestating project.

For "Screamers," Garapedian followed System of a Down on its 2005
European and US concert tours as the band played music and spread its
message. The musicians also visited with survivors, including lead
singer Serj Tankian’s grandfather, and lobbied then-House Speaker
Dennis Hastert to allow a vote on a resolution that calls for the US
government to recognize the atrocities committed in 1915. (The
Turkish government attributes the deaths to famine, disease, and
internecine fighting during World War I.)

Beyond that, the band members’ and Garapedian’s common goal with the
film is to shine a light on the more recent and current genocides
occurring around the globe in places such as Rwanda and Darfur.
Garapedian interviewed authors, politicians , and historians,
including Henry Morgenthau III, whose grandfather was US ambassador
to Turkey at the time and bore witness to the massacres, and Pulitzer
Prize-winning Harvard professor Samantha Power , who authored the
2002 book "A Problem From Hell: America and the Age of Genocide."

Garapedian stopped by the Globe offices recently to discuss the film.
Power will also host a screening at Harvard’s Kennedy School of
Government tomorrow night at 6:30. The director, Power , and others
will participate in a panel discussion afterward.

Q So you discovered that you grew up in the same area of Los Angeles
as the band members but didn’t know them?

A Yes, in fact my mother taught in the public school a block away
from where [three of the band members] went to school. In a way ,
that’s why it was easy to work with them even though the rock world
is so alien to me with the groupies, the entourage, and the politics
of how things are. But because they were Armenians they treated me
like a relative : "Carla’s a nice Armenian girl and we’re nice
Armenian boys. We want to look after her." That made it a pleasant
experience.

Q How did you become familiar enough with the band to know you wanted
to use them for the film? And are you a fan of the music now?

A Yes. [System of a Down has ] held three concerts on Armenian
Commemoration Day in Los Angeles. The first one was in 2003, I went
to one in 2004 , and then I filmed the one in 2005. They encourage
human-rights organizations to set up tables outside the concert area.
I was sitting at a table called the Armenian Film Foundation with my
little pamphlets not really knowing the music at all , and what
impressed me was the fans coming up to the table, kids who were like
15, 16, 17 years old and a lot of them already knew about the
Armenian genocide and other genocides because the band’s message is
to recognize all genocide and that they are all linked.

These fans had been politicized and I didn’t know if they were fans
who were naturally political who were attracted to the band or
whether it was the other way around, but I was really shocked. And
they represented every social group, ethnic group in Los Angeles. I
thought, "My God, they’re reaching out to a generation of young
people. Maybe that’s something I can work with." Because how do you
tell the story of genocide in the last century that will reach out to
people and not turn them off?

And meeting the band and Serj Tankian made me realize that he was
very much about educating people. And he said, "If you make a film
about the denial of all genocides, then count me in. If you make it
just about the history of the Armenian genocide , that’s not enough
for me because it’s about the denial of all genocide." So we were
very much on the same page and that’s what began it.

Q There are some very disturbing images in the film of everything
from the corpses of children in the Holocaust to video of attacks in
Rwanda.

A It’s upsetting when you’re seeing it but I was looking for that.
It’s to access our outrage. We say "never again" but we have allowed
genocides to happen consistently since the Holocaust. And the
Armenian genocide happened before the Holocaust. I thought it was
very important to show children in each of the genocides because
that’s really what genocide’s about, it’s about killing everybody or
going after everybody.

Q What do you hope people do when they see the film?

A What I would like to have happen is that people who see the film,
at the very least, access their emotions and their outrage. And at
the other side of it feel that they can actually do something to stop
genocide.

On Jan. 19, two weeks after our initial interview, Armenian
journalist Hrant Dink, who is featured in "Screamers," was shot to
death outside the offices of the Agos newspaper in Istanbul. Dink was
editor of the bilingual newspaper and after writing about the
genocide of the Ottoman Armenians had been charged under Turkish
penal code 301 for "insulting Turkish identity." We called to follow
up with Garapedian, who last saw Dink at the "Screamers" premiere in
LA this past November.

Q How disturbing is this, not just on a personal level, but on a
symbolic level?

A I think because the film is called "Screamers," the obvious
parallel is to say Hrant Dink was a screamer and look what happened
to him. Unfortunately we have to do what we have to do. We make
choices in our lives. He said to me, "If I go to prison I’ll struggle
in prison. If I’m out of prison, I’ll continue the struggle. This is
who I am and this is what I’m going to do." And I think that goes for
all of us.

The band is going to do its music and I’m going to continue the
national release of this film. People of good conscience just have to
keep doing what they’re doing and keep screaming, because we do have
a genocide going on now [in Darfur]. It’s not just this little crisis
going on in a little place somewhere in Africa that nobody cares
about. It is actually a genocide going on now, so we have to scream,
it’s our responsibility to scream.

LATimes: What did we say about The Genocide as it was happening?

Los Angeles Times, CA
Feb 4 2006

What did we say about the Armenian genocide as it was happening?

Since Armenian-genocide publishing issues are always popular for
vigorous debate, and since there were at least two big related bits
of news this week — Rep. Adam Schiff (D-Burbank) reintroducing the
non-binding genocide-recognition resolution, plus the ongoing and
haunting fallout from the Hrant Dink assassination — we thought it
might be interesting to see how the L.A. Times editorialized about
the Armenian genocide as it was happening.

The first of five snippets from separate editorials comes from Dec.
18, 1917:

THE END OF TURKEY

There is as much cause for including Turkey and Bulgaria in our
declaration of war as there is for including Austria Hungary. There
are as good reasons for the extinction of the Ottoman empire as thee
are for the overthrow of the government of the Kaiser. For 500 years
the Turks have been a curse to Christendom, engaged in war after war
and massacre after massacre. […]

At least half of the Armenian people have been slaughtered in cold
blood and the remnant is only preserved now because a large part of
Armenia has falled under Russian control and the other Armenians have
taken refuge there.

Four more, after the jump.

Continuing with our contemporaneous Armenian-genocide editorials,
here’s one from Feb. 26, 1918:

When a peace of victory is finally achieved Germany must answer for
her inhumanities in Belgium; Austria for the depopulation of Serbia,
and Turkey for the almost total annihilation of the Armenians. […]

If the war continues for another year with Serbia in possession of
its arch enemies, it will be impossible to repatriate the Serbian
people, for it will have ceased to exist. The same is true to an
equal extent with Armenia; but the slaughter has been greater there
because the population was greater. In six years the native
population of Armenia has sunk from 16,000,000 persons to less than
800,000. Those who have approved this policy of extermination must be
made to settle. The German, Austrian and Turkish peoples have
approved and taken part in this wholesale murder; they should be
forced to pay a huge indemnity.

March 3, 1918:

When the President said the peoples should not be bartered about from
sovereignty to sovereignty, he had in mind the combined force and
intrigue by which Germany holds Alsace-Lorraine today, by which
Austria continues to dominate and enslave Hungary, and by which
Turkey is depopulating Armenia and Arabia.

May 28, 1919:

Armenians for centuries have been ceaselessly disinherited and
destroyed. So today even in Armenia proper they are hopelessly
outnumbered by the Turks and Kurds. Either these Turks and Kurds
would have to be violently deported or some stronger nation would
have to keep a permanent army of occupation in this inhospitable
country to insure the Armenians against daily revolutions.

June 6, 1919:

Unquestionably the United States is best qualified to handle the
affairs of Turkey and Armenia. First, we have no national "ax to
grind." No European nation has the slightest reason for jealousy of
us or for suspicion as to our intentions and motives. Second, the
Turks and Armenians themselves would both prefer us as rulers to any
other nation. While unsparingly condemning his atrocious crimes, to
the Turk we have been friendly as it is possible to be. American
missionaries and Robert College, established by them at
Constantinople, have given the Turk a large share of the limited
culture and civilization which he has been capable of assimilating.
To the Armenian we have been the best of friends. We have fed him in
the hour of need; we have often protected him from atrocities at the
hands of the Turks. To the Armenian, fleeing from the Turk, the
United States is the Land of Promise, his hope and refuge.

To post a comment:
/02/what_did_we_say.html

http://opinion.latimes.com/opinionla/2007

New hope for genocide resolution

Los Angeles Times, CA
Feb 4 2006

EDITORIAL
New hope for genocide resolution

Measure calling for the president to acknowledge the Armenian
genocide might finally pass Congress.
February 4, 2007

LAST WEEK, Rep. Adam B. Schiff (D-Burbank) engaged in what has become
a biannual congressional ritual: Introducing a nonbinding resolution
instructing the president of the United States to call Turkey’s
Ottoman-era slaughter of Armenians a genocide. Unlike in years past,
however, this time the symbolic but important legislation actually
has a legitimate chance at passage.

Two recent developments have created momentum. First, the Democratic
Party, which has historically been more sympathetic to the
resolution, now controls Congress. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-San
Francisco) in particular has taken a keen interest in bringing the
matter to a vote. Second, a 17-year-old gunman last month executed in
cold blood the respected Turkish Armenian journalist Hrant Dink on a
crowded Istanbul street.

The slaying of Dink, who had been prosecuted for acknowledging the
genocide, has sent a collective shiver down Turkey’s spine,
triggering street demonstrations and renewed calls for the government
to change its policy. It is still a crime in Turkey to speak the
truth about a period of history whose accepted worldwide
interpretation Ankara still denies.

Schiff’s resolution merely calls on the president to ensure that U.S.
foreign policy "reflects appropriate understanding and sensitivity"
regarding the genocide and that he use the G-word during his annual
message commemorating the National Day of Remembrance of Man’s
Inhumanity to Man on April 24, the date in 1915 when Turkey rounded
up 250 Armenian intellectuals to be slaughtered. That the resolution
is so mild makes the White House’s opposition all the more vexing.

Even though President Bush made a campaign promise in 2000 to use the
word "genocide," his flip-flop is neither surprising nor mysterious –
Ankara has considerable diplomatic influence, and Turkey is too
valuable an ally to alienate with congressional resolutions. Yet the
U.S. is at its best when it chooses truth over expedience, especially
in matters as grave as genocide. It’s hard to say "never again"
convincingly if you’re too afraid to speak bluntly about what you aim
to prevent.

Turkey faces world jury after editor’s killing

Washington Times, DC
Feb 4 2006

Turkey faces world jury after editor’s killing

WORLD BRIEFINGS
By Andrew Borowiec
THE WASHINGTON TIMES
February 4, 2007

NICOSIA, Cyprus — The bullet that killed a Turkish-Armenian
newspaper editor last month has put Turkey and its legal system
before a world jury.
Hrant Dink, editor of the Agos weekly, died because an unemployed
17-year-old boy, Ogun Samast, claimed the editor had insulted
"Turkishness," a concept that enshrines as sacrosanct the country’s
identity, state institutions and its army.
Critics of the concept are treated as criminals under Article 301
of Turkey’s criminal code. Prominent writers, including Nobel Prize
winner Orhan Pamuk, have been tried under the article.
The young assassin apparently acted according to the principles
of patriotism instilled in him and in millions of others. His victim
was a critic of some of the acts protected by a system he judged to
be unjust and was a member of the Armenian minority all but extinct
in Turkey.
Turkish liberals, international human rights organizations and
European editorial writers demand a change in Article 301, which, if
retained in its current form, is likely to keep Turkey out of the
European Union. Turkey’s EU membership negotiations are now stalled.
EU entry at risk
At Mr. Dink’s funeral under the gray January sky of Istanbul,
mourners carried placards denouncing the "301 Killer."
In Strasbourg, France, the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council
of Europe, an advisory body, formally asked for changes in Turkey’s
criminal code, saying it "judicially limits freedom of expression and
validates legal and other attacks against journalists."
Under the pressure of Mr. Dink’s assassination, liberals hope for
evolution in Turkish attitudes and laws, but rising nationalism
across the country and the issues involved in parliamentary and
presidential elections this year appear to preclude a change in the
foreseeable future.
The country has become steeped in chauvinism, with schoolchildren
reciting one of the favorite slogans of Mustafa Kemal Ataturk,
founder of the Turkish Republic: "Lucky is he who can say, ‘I am a
Turk,’ " and troops on parade roar, "One Turk is worth the whole
world."
Although Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan promised to submit a
review of Article 301 to parliament, his absence at the funeral that
drew about 100,000 mourners was seen as less than encouraging.
"Evidently, the prime minister is unwilling to lose nationalist
votes," commented the daily Kathimerini in Athens.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Spotlight on Armenia

The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
February 4, 2007 Sunday
Main Edition

SPOTLIGHT ON: ARMENIA

* Distance between Atlanta and Yerevan: 6,392 miles.

* Time difference between Atlanta and Yerevan: If it’s noon in
Atlanta, it’s 9 p.m. in Armenia.

* Atlantans of Armenian descent: 1,973

* A 1999 Georgia Senate resolution honored the worldwide victims of
genocide and recognized April 24, 1999, as a "Georgia Day of
Remembrance of the Armenian Genocide of 1915-1923."

* Armenian National Committee of Georgia (affiliated with the
Armenian National Committee),

* Armenian Church of Atlanta ()

* Armenian Independent Cultural Association of Atlanta
( z.html)

Armenia at a glance

* Size: 11,506 square miles (slightly smaller than Maryland)

* Capital: Yerevan

* Population: 2,976,372

* Population growth rate: -0.19 percent

* Infant mortality: 22.47 deaths/1,000 live births

* Life expectancy: 71.84 years

* Ethnic groups: Armenian, 97.9 percent; Yezidi (Kurd), 1.3 percent;
Russian, 0.5 percent; other, 0.3 percent (2001 census)

* Religious groups: Armenian Apostolic, 94.7 percent; other
Christian, 4 percent; Yezidi (monotheist with elements of nature
worship), 1.3 percent

* Principal language: Armenian, 97.7 percent; Yezidi, 1 percent;
Russian, 0.9 percent; other, 0.4 percent (2001 census)

* Government: Republic

* Head of government: Prime Minister Andranik Margaryan.

* Chief of state: President Robert Kocharian.

* Economy: Armenia endured a severe economic decline in the early
1990s, but has since managed to slash inflation, stabilize its
currency and privatize many businesses. It joined the World Trade
Organization in 2003.

* Labor force: 1.2 million

* Gross domestic product per capita: $15.99 billion

* Unemployment rate: 7.6 percent

* Currency: 1 Armenian Dram (AMD) = $0.002751 U.S.

History

One of the earliest nations to adopt Christianity (in 301 A.D.),
ancient Armenia existed for centuries in the areas today known as
Turkey, Iran and Armenia. Armenia’s shifting borders came under the
sway of various empires, including the Roman, Byzantine, Arab,
Persian and Ottoman.

In the 19th century, eastern Armenia was annexed by the Russian
empire.

During World War I in the western portion of Armenia, the Turkish
Ottoman Empire instituted a policy of forced mass resettlement that
Armenians said led to the deaths of approximately two-thirds of their
people.

Armenia was conquered by the Soviet Red Army in 1920, and the Soviet
Republic of Armenia was established in April 1921.

In 1936, the Soviet Republic of Armenia was dissolved and Armenia
became a constituent republic of the Soviet Union. Armenia declared
independence in September 1991 and became an independent state when
the Soviet Union disbanded that December.

Fighting between mostly Christian Armenia and mostly Muslim
Azerbaijan escalated in 1992. Each country claimed Nagorno-Karabakh,
an enclave in Azerbaijan that has a majority population of ethnic
Armenians. A temporary cease-fire was announced in May 1994, with
Armenian troops in charge of the enclave.

Voters approved a new constitution in 1995 that increased
presidential powers. Gunmen stormed the Parliament on Oct. 27, 1999,
killing the prime minister and seven others.Armenia at a
glanceAtlanta connectionSources: CIA World Factbook, McClatchy
Newspapers, Associated Press, Encyclopedia Britannica, Georgia
General Assembly

— Compiled by news staff researcher Nisa Asokan

www.anca.org
www.armenianchurchofatlanta.org
www.geocities.com/atlantaarmenians/organi

US debates ‘genocide’: Term for Armenian deaths affects diplom. ties

The Atlanta Journal-Constitution
February 4, 2007 Sunday
Main Edition

U.S. debates ‘genocide’;
Term for Armenian deaths affects diplomatic ties

The touchy subject of the deaths of 1.5 million Armenians at the end
of World War I is back in the news again, as a bipartisan group of
lawmakers in the U.S. House of Representatives last week introduced
the latest version of an Armenian genocide resolution.

After years of trying, members of Congress and their politically
active Armenian American allies now think they can prevail over the
Bush administration’s strong opposition to a measure that is
guaranteed to incite controversy with Turkey, a key U.S. ally.

The 10-page resolution, whose chief sponsor is Rep. Adam Schiff
(D-Calif.), is being called the "affirmation of the United States
record on the Armenian Genocide."

Essentially, it would put the House on the side of Armenians and many
historians who have studied the period between 1915 and 1923.

Some 1.5 million Armenians were killed as part of a policy of
extermination conducted during the final days of the Ottoman Empire,
the resolution asserts. The nonbinding resolution further calls upon
President Bush to use the word "genocide" in his annual April message
commemorating the horrific events.

Bush and preceding presidents, attentive to the concerns of Turkey
and the State Department, have delicately avoided using the term when
referring to Armenia. Turkey has adamantly denied claims by scholars
that its predecessor state, the Ottoman government, caused the
Armenian deaths in a genocide.

The Turkish government has said the toll is wildly inflated, and
Armenians were killed or displaced in civil unrest during the
disarray surrounding the empire’s collapse.

"Armenian Americans have attempted to extricate and isolate their
history from the complex circumstances in which their ancestors were
embroiled," the Turkish Embassy declared in a statement last week.
"In so doing, they describe a world populated only by white-hatted
heroes and black-hatted villains."

In Turkey, it is a crime to use the word "genocide" to describe the
deaths, and people have been prosecuted for it.

Turkey has no diplomatic relations with Armenia.

Diplomatically, it’s an acutely sensitive issue. The Bush
administration has warned that even congressional debate on the
matter could damage relations with Turkey.

After French lawmakers voted in October to make it a crime to deny
that the killings were genocide, Turkey said it would suspend
military relations with France.

Turkey provides vital support to U.S. military operations. Incirlik
Air Force Base, a major base in southern Turkey, has been used by the
United States to launch operations into Iraq and Afghanistan and was
a center for U.S. fighters that enforced the "no-fly zones" that kept
the Iraqi air force bottled up after the 1991 Gulf War.

A member of NATO now hoping to join the European Union, Turkey enjoys
its own Capitol Hill clout with the assistance of well-placed
lobbyists, including one-time congressman Bob Livingston.

"I do think we have the best opportunity in a decade to succeed,"
said Schiff, "but no one should be under the illusion that this will
be easy."

Return of the G-word

Los Angeles Times
February 4, 2007 Sunday
Home Edition

Return of the G-word;
A resolution calling for the president to acknowledge the Armenian
genocide might finally pass Congress.

LAST WEEK, Rep. Adam B. Schiff (D-Burbank) engaged in what has become
a biannual congressional ritual: Introducing a nonbinding resolution
instructing the president of the United States to call Turkey’s
Ottoman-era slaughter of Armenians a genocide. Unlike in years past,
however, this time the symbolic but important legislation actually
has a legitimate chance at passage.

Two recent developments have created momentum. First, the Democratic
Party, which has historically been more sympathetic to the
resolution, now controls Congress. House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-San
Francisco) in particular has taken a keen interest in bringing the
matter to a vote. Second, a 17-year-old gunman last month executed in
cold blood the respected Turkish Armenian journalist Hrant Dink on a
crowded Istanbul street.

The slaying of Dink, who had been prosecuted for acknowledging the
genocide, has sent a collective shiver down Turkey’s spine,
triggering street demonstrations and renewed calls for the government
to change its policy. It is still a crime in Turkey to speak the
truth about a period of history whose accepted worldwide
interpretation Ankara still denies.

Schiff’s resolution merely calls on the president to ensure that U.S.
foreign policy "reflects appropriate understanding and sensitivity"
regarding the genocide and that he use the G-word during his annual
message commemorating the National Day of Remembrance of Man’s
Inhumanity to Man on April 24, the date in 1915 when Turkey rounded
up 250 Armenian intellectuals to be slaughtered. That the resolution
is so mild makes the White House’s opposition all the more vexing.

Even though President Bush made a campaign promise in 2000 to use the
word "genocide," his flip-flop is neither surprising nor mysterious
— Ankara has considerable diplomatic influence, and Turkey is too
valuable an ally to alienate with congressional resolutions. Yet the
U.S. is at its best when it chooses truth over expedience, especially
in matters as grave as genocide. It’s hard to say "never again"
convincingly if you’re too afraid to speak bluntly about what you aim
to prevent.

Ghosts of Turkey’s past

Star Tribune (Minneapolis, MN)
February 4, 2007 Sunday

Ghosts of Turkey’s past

by John Freeman, Star Tribune, Minneapolis

Feb. 4–It is unfortunate that the first thing readers might know
about this bold and raggedly beautiful new novel is that writing it
nearly cost Elif Shafak her freedom. Like fellow countryman and Nobel
laureate Orhan Pamuk, Shafak was charged under Article 301 of the
Turkish criminal code for "public denigration" of Turkishness, the
punishment for which is up to three years in prison. (A Turkish
journalist guilty of the same "crime" recently paid with his life.)
Shafak was acquitted, however, and now U.S. readers can pick up this
still vibrating book with newfound appreciation.

As with Pamuk, Shafak’s true crime wasn’t insulting Turkishness, but
rather daring to speak about what is known ultra-euphemistically as
the "Armenian question." In many other corners of the world, it is
referred to as the Armenian genocide — the forced evacuation and
deaths of more than 1 million Armenians between 1915 and 1917, the
waning years of the Ottoman Empire. While the Turkish government
argues that these deaths resulted from the chaos of World War I,
there is mounting evidence that it was a state-sponsored plan of
ethnic cleansing. The novel filters the anguish of this event through
the lives of an Armenian family in San Francisco and Arizona, and a
Turkish family in Istanbul. Following them over the course of a year,
it meditates on the power of memory and the way time tends to bend
the rules about killing. What happens when grief and suffering are
denied? Do historical grudges grow more powerful when one leaves a
country, or do they wash away?

Not surprisingly, rain is one of the recurring metaphors Shafak
employs effectively. It sluices through the action, whisking scenes
away. In the opening pages, Zeliha, one of four headstrong Turkish
sisters (known as the Kazanci women), walks to an abortion clinic in
a downpour. "Rain, for us, isn’t necessarily about getting wet,"
Shafak writes. "It’s not about getting dirty even. If anything, it’s
about getting angry. It’s mud and chaos and rage."

Zeliha doesn’t go through with the abortion, and the result is Asya,
the bastard of the book’s title. Asya has three aunts: Feride, a
hypochondriac who collects arcane knowledge about the ozone layer and
medicine; Banu, who believes she is a clairvoyant, and Cevriye, a
widowed high-school teacher. The one Kazanci man, Mustafa, has moved
to Arizona and lives with a woman named Rose. A daughter from Rose’s
previous marriage to an Armenian man, Amanoush, splits her time
between San Francisco and Tucson, until she decides she needs to
explore her Turkishness. So she’s off to Istanbul, where she
eventually encounters and befriends Asya.

This development sets up a certain bit of ambiguity to the book’s
title. Is the real bastard of Istanbul Asya, the girl with no father?
Or is it Amanoush, the girl with no past? Round and round we go, with
Shafak pushing the action along with a variety of devices. Each
chapter is titled after an ingredient, from sugar to cinnamon and
dried figs.

Throughout the story, Shafak gives the reader a guided tour of her
native city. "March is most unbalanced in Instanbul," she writes,
"both psychologically and physically. March might decide she belongs
to the spring season … only to change her mind the very next day."

Although this book is crowded with characters, its most vivid one is
not one of the Kazanci matriarchs but Istanbul itself. It is a city
plagued by ghosts, talkative and thronged to the extreme but notable
for what it is silent about. As Shafak sketches it, Istanbul also is
a bastard city. The past has abandoned it — or it has abandoned the
past. So, like all bastards, Istanbul lives slightly adrift under the
pretense that only the present matters when in truth history is its
mother and father — something it will have to confront when the past
comes to claim it again.

John Freeman, president of National Book Critics Circle, lives in New
York City.

THE BASTARD OF ISTANBUL

By: Elif Shafak.

Publisher: Viking, 360 pages, $24.95.

Review: Shafak boldly and beautifully explores sensitive issues of
Turkish identity and history — at the risk of her own freedom.

Event: Because of recent events in Turkey, the author is not
traveling, and an event scheduled for Thursday at Minneapolis Public
Library has been cancelled.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

In standing up for truth, Hrant Dink no longer stands alone

February 05, 2007 edition

-coop.html

In standing up for truth, Hrant Dink no longer stands alone

The 100,000 mourners of the murdered Armenian-Turkish journalist showed how truth triumphs over censorship.

By Garin K. Hovannisian

LOS ANGELES

"We are all Hrant Dink." That was the appropriate, if not very
accurate, placard held aloft by tens of thousands of mourners last
month when Istanbul buried its famed – and defamed – slain hero.

Mr. Dink was an Armenian-Turkish editor of the weekly newspaper Agos,
but it was not as an editor that he won lasting honors. He will be
remembered by Armenians as the gentle usher on the bridge from
Istanbul’s Armenian community to its Turkish commonwealth – and
ambassador to both from the democratic dream. He should be remembered
by all as an intellectual warrior leading the fight against
censorship.

Even the Turkish government, which convicted Dink in 2005 of
"insulting Turkishness" for writing about the Armenian genocide of
1915, splashed its imperial tears – sourced in self-pity though they
were. From the government’s perspective, the confessed killer, 17-year
old Ogun Samast, had just issued an inconvenient press release on the
eve of Turkey’s accession talks with the European Union. "I shot the
infidel," Samast reportedly yelled after shooting Dink in the
back. Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s strange lament on "the
attack on our peace and stability" bemoaned not the dead Armenian, but
the afternoon’s collateral casualty: the illusion of Turkey’s
democratic revival.

Official Turkey may condemn Samast as an ultranationalist vigilante,
but it can’t in good faith call him a traitor. If the mention of
genocide was an act of sedition under Article 301 of the country’s
penal code, then Samast had delivered the just punishment to its
violator. The killer had merely packed Turkey’s state spirit into a
bullet and sent it to its final destination.

Indeed, video footage shows Turkish security officers giving Samast a
hero’s treatment as they posed with him in front of a Turkish flag
shortly after his arrest.

Dink, on the other hand, was found guilty of treason and denied police
protection even as he reported death threats. For his commentaries on
the Armenian genocide, Dink was labeled an enemy to the Turkish
people. He took on that role with understanding but not acquiescence,
defying injustice with truth – and censorship with incorruptible free
speech.

Of a character in Dink’s position, Henrik Ibsen has written, "The
strongest man in the world is he who stands alone." Raised in an
Istanbul orphanage, almost trained for the lonely task of bringing
truth to power in Turkey, Dink often stood alone outside Turkey.

When I first saw Dink in November 2006 at a lecture in Los Angeles – a
great outpost of the Armenian diaspora – he was chatting his way
politely through a crowd of Armenians. The gray-haired and spectacled
journalist, unlike many writers, looked at home in the mass, treating
each nameless face with refreshed interest and respect. But what first
seemed a fitting capture of his timid mannerism, the surname "Dink"
was really a highly misleading onomatopoeia – both to his personality
and to his role in history. Underneath the gentle erudite exterior was
the chiseled soul of a warrior.

By large margin, Armenian communities had celebrated France’s bill
last year to criminalize denial of the Armenian genocide. But Dink, a
luminary of genocide recognition, explained to his compatriots why the
bill (still not law) was wrong, why freedom of speech and truth must
be championed together – the first upheld to guarantee the permanence
of the second.

Damned by Turkey for crying the truth and damned by some Armenians for
tying truth to justice, the man who stood alone was right. The 100,000
attendees at Dink’s funeral were the final proof that censorship could
not cover Turkey’s lie – and it would not protect Armenia’s truth.

But in life, against the myopia of his people abroad and the brute
fascism of his countrymen at home, Dink held out hope. The death of
Hrant Dink is the tragic spectacle of a clash of civilizations at the
confluence of civilizations.

On one end, the Turkish state insists on being angered at Dink’s
assassin, as its laws continue to punish speech and its textbooks
stifle truth. On the other, freethinking Turks joined their Armenian
countrymen at the funeral of their unlikely insurgent who, now passed,
no longer stands alone. A combustion is coming. It is Dink’s legacy
that he yelled fire in Istanbul – and charged the world with
extinguishing it.

* Garin K. Hovannisian is a writer living in Yerevan, Armenia; and Los
Angeles.

Copyright © 2007 The Christian Science Monitor. All rights reserved.

http://www.csmonitor.com/2007/0205/p09s02

Islamists Versus Kemalists: The Coming Storm in Turkey

ISLAMISTS VERSUS KEMALISTS: THE COMING STORM IN TURKEY

newsid=6317&lang=US

By Dr. Christos Evangeliou

Professor of Philosophy

Mustafa Kemal Ataturk and the national movement of Kemalism which he
initiated in the 1920’ies, may finally meet their nemesis in the
person of Mr. Recep Tayyip Erdogan, the charismatic leader of the
ruling Islamist Party and current Prime Minister of Turkey. The year
2007 did not begin well for Turkey, with the hideous murder of Hrant
Dink, Editor-in-Chief of Agos, the main newspaper of the Armenian
Community in Constantinople. But, in all probability, this year will
be fateful for Turkey’s future, for it will be a year of elections for
a new President as well as a new Government, perhaps with many
surprises.

It is reasonable, therefore, that the question in the minds of many
thinking Turks and their friends these days is whether the history of
the 1997 will be repeated, with Mr. Erdogan in the role of
Mr. Erbakan. Some also wonder whether Erdogan will decide finally to
use his current parliamentary majority to have himself elected
President, in the parliamentary election of the President in the
spring, leaving thus his trusted friend, Mr. Abdullah Gul, to lead the
Islamist Party (AKP) to a renewed victory in the fall of 2007.

However, such possible development will not go down well with the
powerful Turkish Military, which is the real political power in Turkey
since the time of Ataturk. Traditionally, the Turkish Military has
kept a vigilant eye on the political developments and has intervened
regularly every ten years or so to put Turkey back in the `right
track,’ any time the poor country tried to breathe a little more
freely and more democratically.

These days the Turkish Military, under the leadership of General
Buyukanit, does not seem thrilled with the possibility of having the
headscarves of Mrs. Erdogan and her Islamist friends in and out of
the Presidential Palace of the nominally `secular’ Turkey. But, given
Erdogan’s demagogic appeal to the Islamic masses, the Kemalists may
not have a choice, unless they decide to take drastic action
soon. Hence the possibility of a collision between Erdogan’s Islamists
(the same as Erbakan’s in 1997) and Kemalists, who seem determined to
keep Turkey `secular’ and under their control in perpetuity.

This may sound strange and paradoxical in view of the fact that Turkey
desires to become a member of the European Union, where militaries are
under ` political control.’ The Erdogan Government, so far at least,
has played very skillfully the card of a process of possible
membership in the EU in the distant future, in order to weaken the
Military’s grip on power in Turkey, while at the same time it has
advanced the interests of the AKP. But it is doubtful that the
Kemalists will allow Erdogan and his Party to proceed further in a
direction which, in their minds, under-mines the `secularism’ of
Ataturk’s legacy.

Kemalism, as a political phenomenon, was the product of political
conditions that obtained at the end of World War I, the Great War that
brought an end to three Empires: the Austrian, the Russian, and the
Turkish. Several nationalistic, militaristic, and secular movements
took shape at the period between the end of the First and the Second
World War in Europe, in response to the Bolshevik Revolution in Russia
in 1917: Fascism in Italy, Kemalism in Turkey, Nazism in Germany, and
the dictatorial regimes of Franko in Spain and Metaxas in Greece. Of
these regimes, Kemalism proved to be most durable.

It is a mark of Ataturk’s genius that Kemalism is still active in
Turkey, while the other revolutionary regimes of the 20th century have
been dead and forgotten a long time ago. The creations of Metaxas,
Franko, Mussolini, Hitler, and even Lenin and Stalin, are history
now. Only Ataturk’s structure was able to survive to this day. This
may be partly due to the fact that, even after his Party gave up the
monopoly of political power, real power remained with the Turkish
Military (that is, the National Security Council). The parties were
allowed to play their political game of holding elections periodically
and succeeding each other in government, so long as they did this by
following the rules of the game as established by the NSC. Until now,
the scheme has worked remarkably well.

But now the Islamists in power in Turkey may decide to change the
rules of this old game that is getting to their nerves. Since they do
have the majority of the vote, they may undo democratically the
`secularism’ that General Kemal established dictatorially. Following
the example of the Iranian Islamist Revolution, they may set new rules
for the game, with controlling power in the hands, not of Generals,
but Imams, Ayatollahs, or a Caliph. Such development will certainly
make Mustafa Kemal turn in his grave, and make Kemalism history
finally. Such possible development will be in accord with the spirit
of revival revolutionary Islam that is spreading in the Middle East
and in Anatolia. But will Kemalists permit its coming, if they think
that they have the power to prevent it?

That is the question to which this year, as we said, is expected to
provide the answer.

The situation is serious, and not only for Turkey and its political
future. Judging by certain recent moves and pronouncements of the
Turkish NSC regarding the Cyprus problem, they seem to contradict the
statements of the Erdogan Government and its expected moves to meet
its responsibilities to the EU that will allow the process of
negotiations to continue.

So, Cyprus may be used once again as a pretext for the Turkish
Military to take action to frustrate the designs of Erdogan’s
Party. The Greek diplomacy would do well to keep an eye on forthcoming
political developments in Turkey and to be prepared to act
accordingly. Given its recent history of `surprises,’ it should not be
surprised this time.

Alternatively, the Turks may decide to interfere in the politics of
Northern Iraq. This could happen especially if the Turkish militarists
believed that the US has by now forgotten the Turkish refusal of its
request to open a second front in the North in the crucial face of the
Iraq war, in the spring of 2003. The US paid a heavy price for
that. It cannot forget, although it seems that it has forgiven the
Erdogan Government and the Turkish Military for being uncooperative
and even unfriendly in a time of need. That is not what was expected
from an ally, on whose military America has invested so many billions
of dollars for so many years. Communism may be dead, but Islamism is
re-born.

Dr. Christos Evangeliou is Professor of Hellenic Philosophy at Towson
University, and author of several books including the latest, Hellenic
Philosophy: Origin and Character.

http://www.hellenicnews.com/readnews.html?