ANKARA: Negotiations Will Start; However, We Enter A Stony, Mined Ro

NEGOTIATIONS WILL START; HOWEVER, WE ENTER A STONY, MINED ROAD
By Turhan Bozkurt
Zaman, Turkey
Oct 3 2005
zaman.com
Koc Holding Honorary Chairman Rahmi Koc talked in a hopeful way
about Turkey’s European Union (EU) membership bid. Koc said that
Austria’s attitude should be taken into consideration as he explained,
“The biggest threat within the EU comes from the Austrians. They are
insistent on starting membership negotiations for Croatia. I think
the EU will start negotiations with Turkey anyway; however, we will
enter a stony, mined road, which is full of barricades.” Stressing
that Turkey will continue its own way no matter what the answer is
from Brussels, Koc showed the positive views Turkey receives from
foreign capital as a ground for this.
“Even if the bonds are cut, they may say ‘stop for a while’. The
investments are shaped in three or four year’s time.” According
to Koc, the foreign investors will take the long term profits into
consideration and look for ways to become permanent in Turkey instead
of thinking of short term profits.
Criticizing the EU’s attitude towards Turkey, “I was afraid the
Cyprus issue would come to the agenda and they brought it. They
brought the Armenian issue to the agenda as well. The acts of these
Europeans cannot be predicted. They may bring the Kurdish issue to the
agenda, too,” Koc admitted. Indicating that Turkey should find sincere
partners for itself within the EU to get the support of Europeans, Koc
continued, “When we are purchasing a bank, we make partnership with the
expert of that business just like this, Turkey should find partners for
itself even in the dynamics of the European community. Our diplomats
are very skilled, they fulfill their responsibilities; however,
we need to get the support of very experienced Europeans. Spain and
Portugal worked with these kinds of people.”

ANKARA: Opinion : What Could Have Been Done With The Effort Wasted T

OPINION : WHAT COULD HAVE BEEN DONE WITH THE EFFORT WASTED TO PERSUADE AUSTRIA?
Baris Sanli , JTW Columnist
Journal of Turkish Weekly
Oct 3 2005
After long hours of meetings and news, now I am heading back to my
home. The two days and the stress caused by Austria to my psychology
has been destructive on me. I do not expect an official apology from
Austria, but they literally wasted my time with their five star,
gold medalist stubbornness. Now everyone is happy, as usual except me.
But how about the time, diplomacy and the effort given to persuade
Austria? It could have been used for more important causes. Now
what is different, for two days they just tested the nerves of
European Foreign Ministers and most importantly me. For what? Just
to turn a historic chance to a political circus. Some may say this
is how diplomacy works, but I will call it “this is how diplomacy is
wasted”. After all, the situation is no different than 1st October.
So I decided to write a list of things to be done with the resources
wasted to persuade Austria. Here is my list as a product of my ruined
psychology, enjoy it:
– I could have written annoying articles to annoy Armenians.
– My Armenian readers could have written more annoying emails to me
to annoy me.
– I could have been treated from my mental problems.
– Even North Korea can start the accession talks with EU with this
much of effort – I would like to add Antarctica to previous article.
– and Zimbabwe – Bush could be teached to find the Iraq on the
world map.
– Blair could be persuaded to leave his place to Gordon Brown.
– Sarkozy can be sent to space.(For peaceful purposes like the first
French president to be to enjoy space) – Austrians can be informed
about the collapse of the Ottoman Empire.
– Greek Cyprus could be persuaded to UN talks.
– Karen Hughes can win the hearts of Turkish women. (I have never
ever achieved such a thing) – Washington Times could be converted
into democratic and open minded newspaper.
– Usame Bin Laden could be persuaded that killing innocents is not
a way to deal with problems.
– Serbians could be teached that Bosnian Muslims are not bad –
Poverty problem could have been solved.
– Third world could have been transformed into a bunch of Silicon
valleys.
– The whole world could be informed that Turkey is not a desert and
is not a place where people use camels for transportation and Turks
are not barbarians, it was Conan the Barbarian.
– And I could have been persuaded not to write any more articles in
this aggressive tone.

ANKARA: Reinstitution Of Turkish – Armenian Friendship

REINSTITUTION OF TURKISH – ARMENIAN FRIENDSHIP
Zaman, Turkey
Oct 3 2005
SAHIN ALPAY
The crux of my speech at the panel on “The Armenian Problem and Turkish
Democracy” in the “Ottoman Armenians” conference was the following:
I am not a historian. As a political scientist and public commentator,
my interest is focused on the current issues and problems of Turkish
politics.
I believe that the resolution of the “Armenian problem” is
indispensable for consolidation of liberal and pluralist democracy, and
for peace culture to prevail in Turkey. Consequently, I am interested
more in the future than in the past. My problem is: What can be done to
reinstitute Turkish – Armenian friendship? There certainly are people,
among both Turks and Armenians, who want to reach conciliation and
resolve the problem. These today constitute a minority, but they may
well become the majority in the future. To this end, those who favor
a solution need to reach a consensus on some basic points.
Regarding history: What was experienced at the end of the19th and the
beginning of the 20th centuries is the story of the dissolution of
the multi-religious and multi-ethnic Ottoman Empire as a result of
conflicting religious and ethnic nationalisms backed by imperialist
European powers. It is the story of millions of people who were
subjected to ethnic cleansing, deportation and massacres. Almost all
of the ethnic and religious which made up the Ottoman Empire had their
share of this tragedy. The Union and Progress Party government decided
to put Anatolia fully under its control, and to cleanse this region
of ethnic and religious elements whose loyalty it did not trust. When
in 1915 – 16 the Unionists in order to punish Armenian separatists
who sought to establish an independent Armenia by cooperating with
the Russians deported Armenians living in all parts of the country
to Syria (Zor province), Armenians became the religious and ethnic
group which suffered most during the course of the dissolution of
the empire. Not only those living in the war zone but all Armenians,
except those living in Istanbul and Izmir were subjected to the
forced deportations. In the process hundreds of thousands of them
were killed or died as a result of famine or illness. Some escaped
deportation by converting to Islam, others managed to survive by
converting to Islam after being rescued by Muslims. Some of those who
managed to reach Syria alive settled there, while many emigrated to
France and the US. Turkish people know very little about the tragedy
of the Ottoman Armenians, and a solution to the “Armenian problem”
is not possible until they are sufficiently informed about it.
Neither is it possible to reach a consensus on the claim that Armenians
were subjected to genocide. Some will continue to insist on this claim,
while others will never accept it. It is, however, clear that this
claim hinders Turkey from discussing freely what really happened in
history. Holding all Turks then and now accountable for the crimes
committed by the Ottoman Unionist government, and using the genocide
allegation to fan racist hatred and enmity against all Turks, is surely
unacceptable. If a broad consensus on the above facts is achieved,
it is possible to move forward towards a solution.
Our tasks as those in Turkey who favor of reconciliation are obvious:
We must first of all exert our utmost efforts to ensure that our
Armenian citizens enjoy equal citizenship rights and that their
minority rights are secured. Historians should, with courage and
determination, work to shed light on what really happened and on those
who were responsible. We should try to win over the public opinion in
favor of the establishment of diplomatic relations between Turkey and
Armenia, and opening of the borders between the two countries. Ankara
can thereby even contribute to peace between Azerbaijan and Armenia. We
should also try to enhance the links and dialogue between the Turkish
and Armenian civil societies. If we can do all these, it will one day
be possible to erect a monument in Anatolia in memory of the great
suffering Ottoman Armenians lived through.

ANKARA: One More Push!

ONE MORE PUSH!
Selcuk Gultasli
Zaman, Turkey
Oct 3 2005
The rule that “every draft the EU prepares about Turkey does not get
its final form without getting toughened” did not change. Where did the
Cyprus declaration begin, and where did it end? The EU virtually said
to the Greek Cypriots “Write it down, we will put a signature on it.”
The declaration for which the Greek Cypriots, with the support of
the French, took EU as hostage turned out to be a legally binding
paper despite the British rhetoric that “it is not a legally binding
document and will be forgotten within six months, why give a damn?”
Moreover, even if the EU does ever forget something, it will be
decisions for the benefit of Turkey. The commitment given by Greece
back in 1981 that she would not interfere in Turkey-EU relations,
the declaration from France, Germany, Netherlands and Italy in 1998
declaring that “the Greek Cypriots will not become a member of the
EU before a solution is reached in Cyprus”, the Council’s decisions
that will bring an end to the isolation of the Turkish Cypriots in
2004 were all too easily forgotten.
The framework document is also becoming more stringent. It has not
yet been approved, and it probably won’t be until the last days and
many elements -excluding the privileged partnership that Turkey cannot
accept- will be introduced into this document.
The situation is as follows: Those who had been promised for 46 years
will announce their engagement on October 3. The EU part does all it
can to ensure that the engagement will not end up with a marriage. It
will sit at the table of engagement, just because it promised once,
but it prepares many pretexts in order to toss the ring away just after
the engagement. Turkey, too, is not happy as it sits at the table,
she is convinced that the EU is unwillingly sitting at the table. In
this case, almost everybody foresees that the negotiations will fail
to continue even if they do start on October 3 and that this will halt,
anyway, in 2006 when the additional protocol is revised.
The EU made the negotiations “unsustainable” with the declaration of
Cyprus, and allowed the UN ground for a possible solution to erode
and most importantly confirmed that it now sees the issue from a Greek
Cypriot view. From now on, in the Cyprus issue the EU cannot go beyond
the parameters cited in the declaration. The Greek Cypriots will get
what they want unless the political atmosphere in Europe goes through
a radical change-which is impossible in the short term.
The next crisis pending between the EU and Turkey is the additional
protocol waiting to be approved in the Assembly. As the screening
process will start on October 3, negotiations will most probably
start at the end of the term presidency of the UK, namely in December.
And in the worst case scenario, the start of negotiations will take
place following the scanning process and this will happen in the
term presidency of Austria. There is no need to offer any detailed
explanation of how Austria, which has the hysteria that the Turks
besieged Vienna for the third time, will approach the negotiations.
As the Greek Cypriots will ask the additional protocol to be approved
and implemented immediately after October 3, Turkey will face a
serious dilemma before it can even start the real negotiations.
As the opponents in Europe have plenty of supporters in Turkey,
sabotaging the negotiations will become easier. The guardians of the
established system whose entire comfort will be overwhelmed with the
start of negotiations will clearly show their European allies that
“Turkey has not changed” with a few provocations just as happened
at the Armenian conference. And in the words of Fuat Pasha that are
even more relevant today, “They from the outside, we from the inside,
together” will obstruct the start of negotiations! Come on guys!

Croatia EU Entry Talks Start

CROATIA EU ENTRY TALKS START
Written by Brussels journalist David Ferguson
Euro-reporters.com, Belgium
Monday, 03 October 2005
“This is not the case of Croatia versus Carla del Ponte or Carla del
Ponte versus Croatia. This is Croatia and Carla del Ponte working
together. This is the case of General Gotovina being in The Hague,”
said Croatian Prime Minister Ivo Sanader.
Speaking in Luxembourg, after meeting EU Foreign Ministers,
Sanader received good marks from Carla del Ponte, Prosecutor of the
International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY). “I
would like to have the same cooperation from Serbia Montenegro as the
one I have from Croatia,” said del Ponte, speaking alongside Sanader.
Negotiations on Croatian EU entry were originally scheduled for
March. Zagreb, however, had to prove that it was fully cooperating with
the ICTY. This included making ‘more convincing efforts’ to bring war
crimes indictee former general Ante Gotovina to the UN tribunal. UK
Foreign Affairs Minister Jack Straw has repeatedly stressed that EU
negotiations can begin as soon as possible once full cooperation has
been established.
At a joint press conference with Sanader, Del Ponte refuted suggestions
that she had given in to pressure from certain EU member states to
give a positive report on Croatia: “I did not have any pressure. After
six years work everybody knows that I am not moved by pressures.”
Austria, which opposes EU negotiations with Turkey, had argued that
negotiations with Zagreb could start, especially in the light of
continuing human rights problems in Turkey and Ankara’s non-recognition
of Cyprus or the Armenian genocide.
In Luxembourg, Del Ponte also reiterated her desire for the Vatican
to cooperate fully in the Gotovina case: “We had certain information
about the possibility of General Gotovina hiding in a monastery. My
request was to help us identify the monastery, if he was actually
hiding in a monastery.”
;task=view&id=200&Itemid=1

Areva’s Cogema Picked By Armenia To Build 10 Mln Eur Nuclear WasteFa

AREVA’S COGEMA PICKED BY ARMENIA TO BUILD 10 MLN EUR NUCLEAR WASTE FACILITY
Forbes
Oct 3 2005
YEREVAN, Armemia (AFX) – The Armenian energy ministry said the Cogema
Logistics unit of French engineering group Areva has been chosen
to build a new 10 mln eur nuclear waste facility for the country’s
controversial Metsamor reactor.
Cogema Logistics will build a second waste disposal facility in
three phases between 2007 and 2018, said ministry spokesperson Lucin
Arutyunian.
The EU has asked Armenia to close the Metsamor reactor because of
safety concerns, but the power station, built in 1977, accounts for
about 40 pct of electricity production in the country.

Turkey And Europe Agree To Talks On Joining

TURKEY AND EUROPE AGREE TO TALKS ON JOINING
By Craig S. Smith
New York Times
Oct 3 2005
LUXEMBOURG, Oct. 3 – Turkey and the European Union agreed late today to
formally begin talks on Turkey’s historic bid to join the organization,
setting into motion a process that will likely take a decade or more
but could end with the union extending its borders eastward into Asia
to embrace the predominantly Muslim country.
Turkey has worked for more than four decades to join the evolving
union, restructuring its legal system and economy to meet European
standards even as Europe added demands and refused to start formal
negotiations. The agreement to open the talks was a victory for the
country’s prime minister, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, who has staked his
political credibility on getting the talks under way.
“We reached an agreement and, God’s willing, we are heading to
Luxembourg,” said Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul as he headed to the
airport in Ankara.
But the talks come at a difficult time for Europe, which is mired in
an identity crisis and whose consensus-based, decision-making process
is already bogged down by last year’s addition of 10 new members.
Many Europeans oppose Turkey’s membership, arguing that while the
country has a toehold in Europe, it is not European at its core. They
worry that because Turkey would be the largest country in the union by
the time it joined, it would skew the already complex European agenda.
The ceremony opening the membership negotiations was delayed until
late this evening as European member states haggled over an Austrian
demand that the talks include an alternative to full membership that
would ultimately give the union a diplomatically palatable option to
inviting Turkey to join.
The last-minute diplomacy kept the Turkish foreign minister, Abdullah
Gul, waiting in Ankara and frayed nerves on both sides. “Either it
will show political maturity and become a global power or it will end
up a Christian club,” Mr. Erdogan said of the European Union on Sunday.
In fact, it is just that question that is haunting Europe. The European
project, begun as a means to ensure peace among historic enemies,
has faltered since the end of the Cold War, which helped define
it. In the 15 years since German reunification, the union has grown
but weakened as it absorbed much of formerly Communist central Europe.
The deep differences within the union, particularly between incoming
and traditional members, broke into the open over the American-led
invasion of Iraq, which many of the new members supported but the
older members did not. The debate over Iraq was about a philosophic
view of the use of power as much as it was about Iraq. Many of the
older European Union member states, harkening back to their World
War II wounds, are wary of using military force to settle disputes.
“Building a consensus is difficult if you don’t have common values,”
said Constanze Stelzenmulle, of the German Marshall Fund in Berlin.
“There has been a loss of focus, a loss of the sense of commonality,
a loss of common interests in Europe.”
Many people worry that adding a country with such a vastly different
cultural and economic heritage such as Turkey to the mix will only
soften that focus further.
Meanwhile, economic malaise in much of Europe has made people wary
of the heralded “ever closer union” that for many simply means lost
jobs. Those fears helped defeat referendums on a proposed European
constitution in France and the Netherlands earlier this year,
stalling the union’s momentum and leading many opinion-makers to
openly question what it was that Europe wanted to become. Turkey’s
membership naturally became a focus of that debate.
Part of the problem is that the generation of leaders that had an
emotional attachment to the European project as a unifying ideal is
now mostly gone, replaced by politicians who regard the union more as
a practical arrangement to promote national interests. European-wide
restructuring of postwar welfare systems and questions about the role
that Europe should play in the world have taken a backseat to more
local issues of political survival and short-term economic goals.
The union hasn’t even be able to agree on a budget for the 2007 to
2013 period, which should have been set months ago.
“At the moment the solution to that crisis isn’t even on the horizon,”
said Marco Incerti, a research fellow at the Center for European
Policy Studies in Brussels.
The crisis has been made worse by faltering leadership in Germany
and France, the traditional engines of the European Union, which
are now consumed by domestic politics. Germany is distracted by
efforts to forge a coalition government there, while France has
lost steam since the May defeat of the constitutional referendum,
leaving President Jacques Chirac largely sidelined while his would-be
successors dominate the political stage.
“For the longest time you could rely on a couple of countries who were
more strongly invested than others getting together and laying out
a solution and getting the others on board,” Ms. Stelzenmuller said.
The lack of leadership has allowed smaller countries like Austria to
dominate the agenda, political analysts say, and has led even Turkey
to question the union’s viability in its current form.
“Everyone is aware of the identity crisis within the E.U.,” said Eser
Karakas, a political scientist at Bahcesehir University in Istanbul.
“The frustration caused by Austria in these past few days proves that
it is time to reform the European Union structure.”
He argued that Turkey should start focusing on what role it can play
in reshaping the union.
Turkey became an associate member of what was then the European
Economic Community in 1963 and formally applied for full membership
on April 1987. It was only officially recognized as a candidate in
December 1999, and it wasn’t until last December that the union agreed
to set a date for membership negotiations to begin.
As part of its campaign to meet European standards, Turkey has
abolished the death penalty, improved its human rights record and
allowed broader use of the Kurdish language among its large Kurdish
minority. But the country is still criticized for refusing to explore
the killing of Armenians in the waning days of the Ottoman Empire
and has refused to recognize the Greek-dominated Republic of Cyprus,
which became a European Union. member last year.
Supporters of Turkey’s membership argue that extending the union’s
single market to include Turkey’s vast Asian hinterland beyond the
Bosphorus Strait will help more than hurt the rest of Europe. They
also argue that bringing Turkey into the European club will help
spread democracy into the Middle East and increase regional security.
Critics, though, question whether that is true, pointing out that
Turkey, which has close ties to Israel, is still remembered in much
of the Arab world as a former colonizer under the Ottoman Empire.
They say that the union would have difficulty absorbing such a large,
poor country and complain that Turkey’s membership will open the
doors for a potentially huge wave of Muslim immigrants.
By the time it could be expected to join, the country’s current
population of 70 million people would likely have grown to outnumber
that of Germany, now the largest European state. Under current rules,
its population would also give it the most seats in the European
Parliament.

Spoils Of War

SPOILS OF WAR
by Lutz Kleveman
New Statesman
October 3, 2005
Spoils of war: Years of work in battle zones have convinced Lutz
Kleveman that the role energy resources play in causing conflicts is
the big story behind the headlines
About three years ago, I visited the American airbase of Bagram in
Afghanistan. A US army public affairs officer gave me a tour of the
sprawling camp, set up after the ouster of the Taliban in December
2001. As we walked past the endless rows of tents and men in desert
camouflage uniforms, I spotted two makeshift wooden street signs.
They read “Exxon Street” and “Petro Boulevard”. Slightly embarrassed,
the officer explained: “This is the fuel handlers’ workplace. The
signs are a joke, a sort of irony.”
As I am sure they were. It just seemed an uncanny sight given that
I was researching potential links between the “war on terror” and
American oil interests in Central Asia. Years of work in war zones
have convinced me that the role energy resources play in causing armed
conflicts is the big story behind the headlines. Dwindling supplies and
the ever-surging global consumption of oil, especially in China and
India, have caused its price to soar to new heights. As doubts grow
about the true size of Saudi reserves, global production is expected
to peak soon, making oil unaffordable to many people and countries,
and raising the prospect of a “last man standing” oil endgame.
The deepening rivalry over fossil reserves, especially between the
US and China, makes energy wars increasingly likely. No Iraqi I know
believes America would send soldiers to the Gulf region if there
were only strawberry fields to protect. My research in places such as
Nigeria, Azerbaijan and Iraq has shown that oil wealth is more of a
curse than a blessing. In all oil-producing countries (except Britain
and Norway), it has led to environmental degradation, economic decline,
corruption, political instability, coup d’etats or even civil wars.
Central Asia offers a perfect case study of what is the trouble
with oil. The warlords, diplomats, politicians, generals and
oil bosses I have interviewed in the region are all players in a
geostrategic struggle that has become increasingly intertwined with
the anti-terrorist campaigns: the “New Great Game”. The main spoils
in this rerun of the 19th-century “Great Game” are the Caspian oil
and gas reserves, the world’s biggest untapped fossil fuel resources.
While estimates range widely, the US Energy Department believes that
Azerbaijan and Kazakhstan alone could sit on more than 130 billion
barrels of crude. Oil giants such as ExxonMobil, ChevronTexaco and
BP have already invested more than $40bn in new production facilities.
In May 2001 Dick Cheney, the US vice-president and ex-CEO of
Halliburton (a provider of products and services to the oil and
gas industries), recommended in the seminal national energy policy
report that “the president make energy security a priority of our
trade and foreign policy”, singling out the Caspian Basin as a
“rapidly growing new area of supply”. Since 11 September, the Bush
administration has accordingly used the “war on terror” to further
American energy interests in Central Asia, deploying thousands of
US troops not only in Afghanistan, but also in the newly independent
republics of Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan and Georgia.
By 2010, the US will have to import more than two-thirds of its
energy needs, and the Caspian region has become vital to its policy
of “diversifying energy supply”, designed to wean America off its
dependence on the volatile Middle East. Yet Central Asia is no less
volatile than the Middle East, and oil politics are making matters
worse. Disputes persist over pipeline routes from the Caspian
region to high-sea ports. While Russia promotes crude transport
across its territory, China wants to build eastbound pipelines from
Kazakhstan, and Iran is offering its pipeline network for exports via
the Persian Gulf. Washington, on the other hand, has championed the
$3.8bn Baku-Ceyhan oil pipeline through the South Caucasus, which was
recently inaugurated amid much pomp. Controversial for environmental
and social reasons, the project has also perpetuated instability in
the South Caucasus.
With thousands of Russian troops still stationed in Georgia and
Armenia, Moscow has for years sought to deter western pipeline
investors by fomenting bloody ethnic conflicts near the pipeline
route, in the Armenian enclave of Nagorno-Karabakh and in the
Georgian breakaway regions of Abkhazia, South Ossetia and Ajaria. In
return, the US has despatched 500 elite troops to Georgia. Moscow
and Beijing resent the growing US influence in their energy-rich
strategic backyard, and have repeatedly demanded that the Americans
pull out. Russia’s president, Vladimir Putin, has signed new security
pacts with the Central Asian rulers and, in 2003, personally opened
a new Russian military base in Kyrgyzstan, only 50km away from a US
airbase. China, in turn, has conducted major military exercises with
Central Asian states. In August, China’s biggest state-owned oil
company bought a major oil producer in Kazakhstan for $4,2bn. The
purchase fits in with China’s efforts to quench its enormous thirst
for oil by intensifying ties to major energy-producing countries and
buying a wide array of foreign petrol assets.
Besides raising the spectre of interstate conflict, energy imperialism
also exacerbates the terrorist problem. Many Muslims hate America
because for decades successive US governments, in a Faustian pact,
were indifferent towards how badly the Middle Eastern regimes treated
their people – as long as they kept the oil flowing. In Central Asia,
the Bush administration repeats the mistakes that gave rise to Bin
Ladenism in the 1980s and 1990s. Oil-motivated American support
for Central Asian autocrats – such as Azerbaijan’s Ilham Aliyev,
Kazakhstan’s Nursultan Nazarbayev and Uzbekistan’s Islam Karimov –
causes more and more of their disgusted subjects to embrace militant
Islam and anti-Americanism. The Caspian region may be the next big
gas station but, as in the Middle East, there are already a lot of
men running around throwing matches.
Ultimately, no matter how many troops are deployed to protect oilfields
and pipelines, the oil infrastructure might prove too vulnerable
to terrorist attacks such as in Iraq to guarantee a stable supply
anyway. In Iraq, chaos and violence have so far prevented any major
oil companies from investing a huge amount in the country’s old petrol
industry. Efforts by Halliburton and the US army corps of engineers
to rehabilitate the oilfields near Kirkuk and Basra have been largely
undermined by insurgent attacks on pipelines. To make matters worse,
conflicts have broken out between Iraq’s Kurds and Arabs over who
should control the Kirkuk oilfields.
With so much oil-related trouble looming, old-style policies of
yet more fossil fuel production and waste continue in the wrong
direction. The only wise strategy is a sustainable alternative
energy policy that will steer us into the post-oil era. Reducing
our dependence on oil will go a long way towards “defuelling”
terror-breeding regimes and lessening international tension. This
policy will require saving energy through more efficient technologies,
increasing the role of other energy carriers (including gas but not
nuclear power) and introducing next-generation transport fuels on a
huge scale.
A new energy policy is badly needed anyway to slow the greenhouse
effect and global climate change, which might turn out to be the
worst energy-related source of conflict. Hurricane Katrina – with
violence, anarchy and refugees in its wake – gave merely a foretaste
of the suffering that global warming could cause. That was nature,
some say with a shrug, but in fact it was nature on drugs – and we
need a detox soon.
Lutz Kleveman ([email protected]) is the author of The New Great Game:
blood and oil in Central Asia (Atlantic Books, ),
and the host of an authors’ conference on climate change. For more
information visit
Natural gas is by some distance the least fascinating of all energy
sources – at least, it is to most British citizens and their media.
In the “debate” on energy and carbon policy, which largely amounts to
special pleading for government funding or regulatory protection for
(in particular) clean coal and nuclear power, there is virtually no
interest in gas. The subject surfaces mainly in the context of claims
made by supporters of other forms of generating capacity that, in 15 to
25 years from now, the power sector will be overwhelmingly dependent
on imported gas from “unstable” countries, and that this will expose
the British public to unacceptable security risks. A BBC2 docudrama –
set in the future – showed Chechen terrorists blowing up a gas pipeline
running from Russia’s Baltic coast to Britain, plunging London into
darkness an hour later. The debate that followed was largely about the
future of nuclear power, rather than the unreality of such a scenario.
This lack of public interest in, or information about, gas is slightly
strange given that it is the country’s most important source of energy,
accounting for 41 per cent of primary energy last year (compared
with oil at 34 per cent), and 40 per cent of electricity generation
(compared with 33 per cent from coal and 19 per cent from nuclear
power). This was never intended to happen. But the post-privatisation
“dash for gas” in power generation – partly a dash away from the
problems of the coal and nuclear power industries – was followed by
a realisation that the switch from coal-fired to gas-fired generation
had made a big contribution towards meeting CO2 reduction targets.
In 2000, North Sea gas production peaked and began to decline at
a faster rate than had been anticipated. Over the past few years,
there has been a growing tightness of supply in the winter months,
when gas usage peaks. This has been accompanied by much higher
levels of prices, with substantial volatility and price spikes. These
developments have caused regulatory and parliamentary investigations
into the functioning of gas markets and improper corporate behaviour,
which have failed to substantiate any allegations of wrong-doing. At
the same time, an unprecedented amount of new import infrastructure
is under construction, with two new pipelines, the expansion of an
existing line, and three new liquefied natural gas (LNG) terminals.
This sudden interest in supply, demand and prices is a far cry from
the focus of the past two decades, which has been on developing
competition in utility markets. Since the mid-1980s, politicians,
regulators and consultants have marched around the world lecturing
the less fortunate on the wonders of “British experiment”. The answer
to all problems was to “privatise and leave it to the market”, which
would produce “the most efficient outcome”. This proved to be the
case for much of the 1990s and early 2000s, when British businesses
and citizens enjoyed substantially cheaper gas prices than their
counterparts in Continental Europe, where governments have been
reluctant to liberalise their markets.
Gas production was allowed to proceed at the fastest possible rate –
abandoning the careful “depletion policy” of the nationalised industry
era, which was designed to eke out UK resources with the judicious use
of imports. Government was also responsible for starting the process
that resulted in a pipeline between Britain and Belgium exporting
surplus UK gas, with the aim of accelerating European competition. With
the peaking of domestic production, that pipeline is increasingly being
used to import, and 2004 marked the end of the country’s relatively
short-lived spell as a net gas exporter, giving rise to dire warnings
of impending disaster arising from dependence on foreign supplies.
Large-scale imports, when they begin in 2007-08, will initially return
the UK to the position 20 years ago, when more than 20 per cent
of gas demand was imported from Norway. Subsequently, and assuming
higher prices do not stimulate the discovery and production of new
gas, import dependence on piped and liquefied gas will increase
from a variety of sources: Norway, Netherlands, Russia, Algeria,
Egypt, Qatar and others. The diversity of sources and supply routes
provides protection against problems with any individual supplier or
facility. Gas imports, far from being the main problem, are going to
be a large part of the solution to supply problems.
“Unreliable and nasty foreigner” theories of security ignore the
most important current problem – the reliability of ageing North Sea
infrastructure and concern about how these may perform in severe
weather conditions. The impact of severe weather on offshore and
coastal oil and gas infrastructure – as demonstrated by Hurricane
Katrina – is a major potential problem.
Both Transco and Ofgem have given assurances that, even if it is
very cold, there will be sufficient gas and delivery capacity to get
through next winter. But experience of the past year suggests that
any significant supply problem or severe weather causing increases
in demand, even of short duration, will at the very least lead to
short-term price spikes. After this winter, imported supplies start
to flood in and new gas storage (which was not needed when supply
was overwhelmingly from domestic sources) will open up, making the
position much more comfortable. In fact, so much new supply will be
available that, through the early 2010s, exports may continue for a
significant part of the year.
The future of UK energy supplies may be renewables, clean coal, some
form of nuclear power and, more distantly, hydrogen. For the next 20
years, and probably for a great many more, natural gas will dominate
the UK energy balance outside the transport sector. This is a closely
guarded secret revealed only in discussions about supply security.
But there is no specific reason to think that security of gas supplies
will be a major problem – once we get through this winter.
Jonathan Stern is director of gas research at the Oxford Institute
for Energy Studies and honorary professor at the Centre for Energy,
Petroleum and Mineral Law and Policy, University of Dundee

www.newgreatgame.com
www.ankeloheconversations.com

Bridging The Bosporus: ‘Turkey Has Always Represented A DifferentCon

BRIDGING THE BOSPORUS: ‘TURKEY HAS ALWAYS REPRESENTED A DIFFERENT CONTINENT’
by Peter Goodspeed
National Post (Canada)
October 3, 2005 Monday
National Edition
Lined with tea gardens, Ottoman villas and ancient fortresses,
the straits twist and turn for 35 kilometres, linking the Sea of
Marmara to the Black Sea. With an intoxicating mix of splendour,
simple beauty and cruel history, this sliver of Turkey has become
one of the world’s great cultural frontiers.
This is where the Orient meets the Occident, where Christianity
encounters Islam, where tradition collides with modernity — a bustling
crossroads to Europe and the Balkans, the Middle East and the Caucasus.
Now, the straits and all of Turkey are about to become the focus of
an intense international debate as diplomats prepare to negotiate
Turkey’s application for membership in the European Union.
The talks, scheduled to get underway in Luxembourg today barring a
last-minute veto by Austria, which opposes full EU membership for
Turkey, could last a decade. By the time they end, neither Europe
nor Turkey will be the same.
Turkey’s application to join the EU is already forcing Europe to
question its identity as never before. EU members are struggling
to define their future, while juggling centuries-old fears against
new ambitions.
Even as diplomats debate the terms of Turkey’s entry, Europe has been
swept by a bitter public backlash against the move.
Last spring’s rejection of the EU’s draft constitution by voters in
France and the Netherlands was said to be fuelled by fears of Turkey
joining Europe.
More recently, an opinion poll carried out by the European Commission
claims 52% of Europeans are opposed to letting Turkey join their
club. Only 35% agree.
Seventy per cent of French voters, almost three-quarters of Germans
and 80% of Austrians are against Ankara’s membership.
Angela Merkel, leader of Germany’s Christian Democratic Union and
possibly Germany’s next chancellor, launched a campaign last month
to block Turkey’s entry into the EU, sending letters to European
leaders asking them to offer Turkey only a “privileged partnership,”
not full membership.
“We are firmly convinced,” she wrote, “that Turkey’s membership would
overtax the EU economically and socially and endanger the process of
European integration.”
Opponents of Turkey’s admission to the EU cite everything from
clashing values to different cultures, a lack of a common geography,
differences in religion and Ankara’s record on human rights.
Valery Giscard d’Estaing, the former president of France who drafted
the latest version of the EU constitution, rejects Turkey’s membership,
declaring, “It would be the end of Europe.”
“There is an obvious contradiction between the pursuit of Europe’s
political integration and Turkish entry into European institutions,”
he says.
Former EU commissioner Frits Bolkestein, a Dutchman who used to be
responsible for the EU’s internal markets, taxation and customs union,
warns that letting Turkey join the EU will trigger a massive wave of
migration that could result in Europe being “Islamized.”
“The liberation of Vienna in 1683 [from a siege by the Ottoman Turks]
would have been in vain,” he says.
Even Pope Benedict XVI has waded into the debate. Last year, when he
was still Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, he told the French newspaper Le
Figaro Turkey threatens European culture.
“Turkey has always represented a different continent, in permanent
contrast to Europe,” he said. “Making the two continents identical
would be a mistake. It would mean a loss of richness, the disappearance
of the culture to the benefit of economics.”
“Europe has a culture which gives it a common identity,” the
then-Cardinal said. “The roots which formed this continent are those
of Christianity.”
On the eve of today’s talks, Austria made a last-ditch attempt to
block any agreement on the ground rules for the negotiations by
demanding diplomats should clearly set out “alternatives” to giving
Turkey full EU membership.
Last week, the European Parliament grudgingly approved opening
negotiations with Turkey, but passed a non-binding resolution that
insists Turkey must acknowledge that the killing of Armenians under
Ottoman rule in 1915 was genocide before it will be admitted to the
EU. Those moves have infuriated Turkey, which has patiently been
trying to get into the EU for 42 years.
Turkish Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul has already warned “should [the
EU] place anything short of full membership [on the table], or any
new conditions, we will walk away. And this time, it will be for good.”
Turkish public opinion, which overwhelmingly favours joining the EU,
has grown increasingly frustrated over European preconditions.
In 1963, when John Kennedy was still president of the United States
and Turkey was a bulwark against communism and a key member in NATO,
the Turks were granted associate membership in the European Economic
Community, the EU’s predecessor.
But after Ankara applied for full, formal membership in 1987 it had
to wait until 1999 to be recognized as an EU “candidate.”
In the meantime, such fledgling democracies as post-Franco Spain,
post-Salazar Portugal, Greece, after it sent the military back to
their barracks, and the former communist countries of Eastern Europe
were all accepted into the EU.
Turkey still waits and successive Turkish governments have repeatedly
adopted EU-recommended reforms to pave the way for its admission.
They’ve passed laws to end torture, to abolish state security courts
and to reduce the political role of the military. They reformed
Turkey’s civil code, gave women equal rights to household property
and ended their need to obtain their husband’s permission to work
outside the home.
They’ve abolished the death penalty, rewritten the criminal code,
and legalized the use of Kurdish in education and broadcasting.
Despite growing opposition from hard-line Islamists and nationalist
politicians, Ankara’s moderate Islamic government continues to press
for EU membership.
Turkey’s elite, infatuated with the promises of liberal democracy,
long to be regarded as part of Europe, without becoming Westernized.
Turkey’s poor lust after the economic advantages of EU membership.
Still, there are Islamist religious leaders who warn of being corrupted
by the West and Turkish nationalists who feel their country is being
humiliated.
Britain, one of the strongest supporters of Turkey’s EU candidacy,
says it wants to see a staunch NATO ally, who straddles a strategically
crucial piece of real estate, safely inside Europe.
The possibility would allow Europe to shape a new accommodation between
Islam and the secular West and might even give the continent a bigger
say in the Middle East.
“It would be a huge betrayal of the hopes and expectations of
the Turkish people and of [Turkey’s] Prime Minister [Recep Tayyip]
Erdogan’s program of reform, if, at this crucial time, we turned our
back on Turkey,” British Foreign Secretary Jack Straw said last week
at the Labour Party conference in Brighton.
Still, a clash of cultures that assumes religious overtones could
have serious security repercussions for Europe, which already has 23
million Muslims living inside its borders.
“For the EU to cross the Bosporus is to move from a community based
on centuries-old notions of shared history and geography to one based
on shared democratic standards and the future,” argues Timothy Garton
Ash, an Oxford University historian.
“Two logics clash at the gates of the Bosporus: the logic of unity
and the logic of peace,” he says.
“If Europe is mainly about creating a coherent political community,
with some aspirations to be a superpower, it stops on the western
side of the Bosporus — for another decade, at the least,” he says.
“If we think it is more urgent to promote democracy, respect for
human rights, prosperity and therefore the chances for peace in the
most dangerous region in the world, we step on to that bridge.”
GRAPHIC: Black & White Photo: STR, AFP, Getty Images; Members of
the Turkish Nationalist Movement Party …; Black & White Photo:
Umit Bektas, Reuters; …chant “no to Europe” during an anti-EU
demonstration in the capital, Ankara, yesterday. Some 100,000 people
turned out to protest their government’s negotiations with the European
Union, which open in Luxembourg today.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

U.S. Intervenes To Rescue Stalled EU Turkey Talks

U.S. INTERVENES TO RESCUE STALLED EU TURKEY TALKS
Reuters
10/03/05 09:53 ET
LUXEMBOURG, Oct 3 (Reuters) – The United States intervened on Monday
to try to rescue membership talks between the European Union and
Turkey as a diplomatic deadlock deepened hours before the historic
negotiations were due to open.
EU president Britain said the 25-nation bloc was “on the edge of
a precipice” after Turkish objections to a clause it fears could
affect NATO membership piled on top of Austrian demands that the
Muslim nation be offered an alternative short of full membership.
U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice telephoned Turkish Prime
Minister Tayyip Erdogan to assure him that the proposed EU negotiating
framework would not impinge on NATO, diplomats said.
A presidency spokesman said Britain still hoped to hold the opening
ceremony on Monday but it would clearly be later than the planned 5
p.m. (1500 GMT) start.
Turkish Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul was waiting nervously in Ankara
for the EU to adopt a negotiating mandate before he could set off
for Luxembourg.
British Foreign Secretary Jack Straw telephoned Austrian Chancellor
Wolfgang Schuessel to try to clinch agreement on a formula to satisfy
Austrian concerns that the EU may not be able to absorb the vast,
poor, Muslim country, diplomats said.
The United States had also contacted Vienna to try to overcome
objections fuelled by overwhelming public hostility to Turkish
membership, they said.
Turkish financial markets yo-yoed amid the uncertainty. Stocks fell
some 2.3 percent from Friday’s close and the lira was down nearly 2
percent against the dollar, but both recovered in mid-afternoon amid
hopes the problems would be resolved.
Rice’s involvement was potentially embarrassing for the EU,
highlighting its inability to solve its problems alone.
“CATASTROPHIC”
Straw told the 24 other EU foreign ministers upon resuming talks
after only a couple of hours’ sleep: “Yes, we are near (to a deal)
but we are also on the edge of a precipice.
“If we go the right way we reach the sunny uplands. If we go the
wrong way, it could be catastrophic for the European Union.”
In Ankara, Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan told a meeting of the ruling
AK party that Turkey was not prepared to compromise further on the
conditions for opening the long-awaited talks.
“Those in the EU who cannot digest Turkey being in the EU are against
the alliance of civilisations. What I declare is this: the costs
resulting from all this will be paid by them.”
Turkey has frequently portrayed its entry to the EU as a way of
bridging a gap between the Christian and Islamic worlds and easing
tensions that may have fostered islamic militancy.
Diplomats said Ankara had objected to a clause in the EU negotiating
mandate that stipulates it may not block accession of EU states to
international organisations and treaties.
Turkish nationalists and the powerful military argued that might
prevent Turkey blocking a divided Cyprus from joining NATO. Cyprus
refused to let the EU change the wording.
But diplomats said Straw and EU foreign policy chief Javier Solana
hoped to assuage Ankara with a letter clarifying that the clause did
not impinge on sovereign defence arrangements.
TIME RUNNING OUT
As the clock ticked down, German Foreign Minister Joschka Fischer
told ministers: “Time is running out. We have got to get this right.
We seem so close. We cannot let this opportunity slip away.”
Failure to start the talks could deal a blow to political reform and
foreign investment in Turkey, a strategic country of 72 million people
straddling Europe and the Middle East.
It would also deepen a sense of crisis in Europe, after referendum
defeats for the draft EU constitution in France and the Netherlands,
and an acrimonious failure in June to agree on a long-term budget
for the enlarged bloc.
“If there is no deal, my personal judgement is that we are increasingly
starting to look like a Union of failing states because we cannot make
any decisions,” Latvian Foreign Minister Artis Pabriks told Reuters.
Ratcheting up pressure on Austria, Straw postponed a planned review
of Austrian ally Croatia’s progress towards EU entry talks until the
Turkey issue was sorted out.
A Turkish official said nerves in Ankara were “extremely stretched
… Every minute that passes is making things more bitter and it
won’t be nice starting negotiations with all these bruises.”
The European Parliament compounded Turkish irritation last week by
saying Turkey must recognise the 1915 killings of Armenians under
Ottoman rule as an act of genocide before it can join the wealthy
European family.
Several hundred Armenians staged a noisy demonstration outside the
EU meeting, demanding that Turkey be forced to make amends for what
they called the Armenian genocide.