Armenian Providers – Team Up!

ARMENIAN PROVIDERS – TEAM UP!
Vyacheslav Khachatryan

ArmInfo. January 30, 2007.

In September, 2006, the National Commission for settlement of public
services of Armenia has represented and constituted in December
the new rules for the cell operators of Armenia. In particular,
to assure a high-quality communication service, the changes will
touch upon the registration, a relevant designing and documenting of
networks, including all the associating permissive documents. However,
a sufficient requirement is a payment of state dues of 2 mln drams
for the work in Armenia’s capital and 500,000 drams in RA regions,
which are fixed in the Law on State Dues. The network operators
will have to pay 3 mln drams of the state due during the work both
in Yerevan and in the regions. At that, all the network operators,
having received this license, will probably get equal rights with
today’s network operators. ArmInfo correspondent has addressed the
Technical Director of "Arminco" Company, the biggest company that
renders an Internet access in Armenia, Grigory Saghyan, for comments
about the influence of changes on Armenia’s Telecom.

Mr. Saghyan, how the regulation is carried out with coming of the
new Law into effect?

According to the new Law, we have two licenses: for rendering of
services by the network, that belongs to the third person (licensed
network operator) or licenses for rendering of network services
(is given to the network operator). According to the Law, if you
are a network operator and you have a network, at that, it is of
no importance whether it is fiber-optic or wireless, the services
should be rendered properly. Because of the absence of standards
in Armenia in this area, it is necessary to be guided by a so-called
business-practice. Let’s consider, for example, the present practice of
"ArmenTel" or "KTelecom" Companies. All the stations of "ArmenTel"
have an uninterruptible power supply, battery rooms, independent
current supply lines, sliders, formal contracts for the rent of areas
for base stations, contracts with the power network. Most likely, the
same demands will be made to those claiming to the network licenses. In
the wide sense, the licenses are given by the state to assure a proper
quality of services based on the user’s interests. You see, the user
should not face the problem that when he wants to be connected up,
somebody had installed a base station, powered by a "friendly user",
or a neighbor had turned it off as it was hiding the view.

How can it be achieved?

First of all, by technical requirements to the network under
construction.

We have no Armenian standards but an actual practice. Following the
logic of decisions, one may suppose that the licenses will be given
to the companies who build the networks in line with the following
standards: reliability, qualified staff and a relevant documentary
completion. In my opinion, these requirements are justified. As for the
small companies, the world experience shows that it is more comfortable
and correct for the regulating authority to influence the network owner
for the latter to enable the small organizations to render services,
using a big operator’s network. The big networks should assist the
others in using all their resources more completely. A simple license
will be probably given for such services (the state due rate is 100,000
drams), which presumes the using of other’s network. This will free the
organizations, rendering such services (a term "value added services"
is sometimes used), from a number of problems: payment of huge means,
a great volume of building and organizational measures.

What is the reason of such rise in prices?

There was no increase of the rates of state dues in 2006, they
had been fixed, if I am not mistaken, in 2004, when the Parliament
adopted an addition to the Law on State Dues. It is very difficult
to carry out an economic calculation of the state due rates: there
are neither formulas nor specific recommendations. Most likely,
it is a question of succession. There was a state due for a license
at the time of the USSR. Probably, this value serves a basis during
establishment of new values, taking into account the change of the
living standard and the sizes of the basket of goods. There is no
definite economic calculation. However, there were probably some
general considerations the Parliament was guided by during adoption
of changes and additions to the Law on State Dues: 100,000 drams for
a simple license and 2,000,000 drams for a network license. If the
network was of a republican scale, the state due made up 3,000,000
drams, if the network is built in a separate region (marz), the state
due is 500,000 drams. By the decision of the Regulating Commission,
the companies which had a simple license (a license for Data Transfer),
are enabled to get a license in a simplified sequence. The companies,
which have no branched infrastructure, can receive the licenses
for operation using the network of another operator. In this case,
connection to the operator’s network is necessary – this is the
"ArmenTel" Company, in our case, to the network of which it is
possible to be connected up from all the regions of Armenia. However,
the connection quality is acceptable not in all the regions. It is
possible to be connected up to the fiber-optic network of "ArmenTel"
in 25 towns of Armenia, while it is impossible in the others, that is
about 22-23 towns. There is no fiber-optic cable there as yet, so the
Soviet infrastructure of communication is still used there. Judging
by the latest information, the Russian companies, including the
"VympelCom", intend to make one and a half-billion investments in
Armenia, and probably, this issue will also be considered.

What is the further development of events?

The further development is completely determined by the policy of the
regulating authority of communications. At least, the last year, the
regulating authority has been inviting, during three months, all the
interested sides to conferences to discuss the issues for separation
of terms of a network service and a service for data transfer. As a
result of these discussions, the regulating authority has resolved,
and I think, quite soundly, that availability of the own wire or
wireless infrastructure falls under the term of a network service. If
the service is rendered through the networks of other operators,
this is not a network service. In this regard, the use of a small
modem with WiFi technology (this is equivalent to a great quantity of
wireless lines and these lines belong to this operator) is, probably,
a network service, for which the payment of a state due makes up 2 mln
drams. It is rather a great amount for that rendering a WiFi service
and a legal rendering of network services by him is unlikely. Taking
into account the society’s demand in such services and the absence
of offer by traditional operators, it makes sense to fix a standard
state due at the rate of 100,000 drams. There is no load on the
budget in this case, since it is rather simple to attract 20 small
companies. The same applies to the regions. The activity of users
there is not so great and it is difficult to find a sufficient amount
of means for these payments. A payment of 2 mln drams for a boundary
region’s operator is difficult, so he will turn to a "shadow activity".

Based on the aforesaid, could you say that high state dues will retard
the development of the branch and of the Internet, in particular?

Yes, the small organizations in this situation have either to fall
back into the shadow, that is not so good, or to combine with big
organizations, which, somehow or other, are able to pay the due of
2 or 3 mln drams per year.

Each organization should decide for itself how to act in the existing
situation.

What steps have been taken to reduce the licensing tariffs?

We have planned to organize a meeting of telecom-companies with
representatives of the active part of the population, which influences
the policy, for them to further the revision of this issue after
having got acquainted with the problem. It will allow a great number
of organizations to keep on rendering the serveces. Moreover, the
issue was revised in many organizations, as well as at the session of
the Council for promotion of information technologies under RA Prime
Minister. Though the authorities are well informed of the situation but
it is aggravated by the fact that several sessions of RA Parliament
of this convocation are left, and it is unlikely that time will be
found at the sessions for this problem solution, since new elections
are assigned for May 12. On the other hand, one may only hope that,
before elections, the representatives of parties will be interested
in a collection of more voices. Such an approach as improvement of
conditions for small companies, reduction of the amount of state dues,
may be positively percieved by the electorate.

How can this high price affect the Internet price?

It is a due, paid by operators, and increase of the license cost
will finanly have a possible affect on the Internet connection
prices. However, I do not think this will be so noticeable for
the users.

What number of companies may suffer from such a solution of the
regulating authority?

I think, all the small providers both in Yerevan and in the regions
will suffer from such a solution. Then changes will especially affect
the companies which operate in Armenia’s regions. A regional network
operator, for example, in the Gegharkunic region, cannot provide a
high-qaulity communication by investing great means and giving an
Internet-access to 20-30 users only. It is commercially not lucrative.

Does it mean that the regions of Armenia may be deprived of an Internet
communication at all?

Of course, not. A possibility of a commutated access (by phone)
remains in any case. That is, one can reach just by an Automatic
Telephone System.

Finally, the regulating authority also realizes the consequences,
even better than me, and it always has all the opportunities to make
a decision for every specific case.

Please, tell about the plans of "Arminco" Company and what is your
prediction of the telecom development in the Republic?

Like 15 years ago, the Internet development is determined by the
"ArmenTel" Company’s policy. We have passed its different stages for
this period, since different owners had different policy. For example,
the "TWT" Company’s policy was aimed, by expression of one of the
managers, Steve Walker, at "Dressing the "ArmenTel" beautifully for
sale". For this reason, the "TWT" displayed no special activity. The
only result was a construction of a fiber-optic circle in Yerevan
and two-three base stations. The Greek"OTE", as we understand now,
also tried to keep a high cost for sale. As for the new owner,
the "VympelCom", we were informed that it is going to make great
investments in the infrastructure. Today, we may say with confidence
that the level of "VympelCom" services gives grounds for optimism.

Then how will you explain the continuation of history with Armenia’s
IP-telephony companies?

First of all, the IP-telephony uses the element of cross financing. The
level of the cost price of services the "ArmenTel" renders by the
local telephone lines is a little lower than they cost in fact. The
"ArmenTel" covers the difference between the actual cost due to high
tariffs for international telephone calls. In fact, the IP-telephony
providers use an expensive telephone network by a tariff lower than
the cost price. The subsidies of "ArmenTel" for keeping the intercity
network operable come from the international calls. It turns out
that the "ArmenTel" subsidizes all the operators of IP-telephony at
the expense of incomes it receives due to a cell communication and
international calls. It is reasonable to assume that as soon as the
"ArmenTel" submits new tariffs to the regulating authority, eliminating
this disproportion, we are in for some raise of tariffs for the local
telephone talks with simultaneous reduction of prices for international
talks. In this case, it will be profitable for "ArmenTel" to render
the local intercity telephone network for services to IP telephone
operators, the telephone company will be interested in the availability
of organizations, which widely use a local telephone network.

In 2006, the regulating authority did not accept the inquiry for
increase (balancing) of tariffs probably because of insufficiently
well-reasoned basis.

The permission for rendering of IP-telephony services will be most
likely given just after these services are profitable to all the
participants: the network operator, the service providers and the
users.

What about the covering of Yerevan with WiFi communication?

Unfortunately, this is a sore point, since if it is possible not
to determine the providers of WiFi services as network operators,
the whole Yerevan would be covered within a month or two.

What projects are under development of "Arminco" Company today?

The "Arminco" is presently working over implementing an
Internet-Television project. Today we provide an access to 40
TV-channels in a test mode. The Company’s specialists are debugging
the network. The problem now is to assure the delivery of these TV
programs to the final user.

Could you, please, tell about the technologies in details.

It has become possible today to transfer great massifs of information
by networks. For example, a TV program requires 2 Mbits/sec. You see,
the television uses the same terms as the Internet and the digital
telephony.

Implementation of a high-definition television (HDT), which requires
20 Mbits/sec, ten times more than the usual MPEG-2, is considered
a very interesting project today. It cam be compared only with a
cinema screen. However, this technology is very sensitive to the loss
of information: "cubes" immediately appear on the screen at a small
information loss. In our case, the only way to connect the final user
to HDT is a fiber-optic network.

When it will be possible to watch this television?

It will be possible to watch it when the population can stably pay for
a high-quality service. For example, the quality of telephone services
in the world is determined by calculation of an average income per
head. If the annual income per head in Armenia makes up a little
more than $1000, in the USA – tens of thousands, it is, of course,
incorrect to compare the opportunities from the viewpoint of a service
level. Those, who invest money in the network services, hope to get a
profit from it, while in a country with a very low level of incomes,
no serious company will make billion investments. In view of this,
one may be sure that our country will create as better conditions as
possible for the development of entrepreneurship, competition support
that, in its turn, will contribute to the growth of the population
welfare and a chance to get high-quality services.

CE Secretary General: Both Azerbaijan And Armenia Have Undertaken Co

CE SECRETARY GENERAL: BOTH AZERBAIJAN AND ARMENIA HAVE UNDERTAKEN COMMITMENTS TO SOLVE KARABAKH CONFLICT BY PEACEFUL MEANS

Yerevan, February 5. ArmInfo. "I believe that there is always a window
of opportunity as long as there is a political will to settle the
conflict", CE Secretary General, Terry Davis, said in an interview
to "Trend", asked about his views on the prospects of a conflict
settlement.

"I also understand that an agreement has been reached on many of
the basic principles. I can only encourage the parties to take the
courageous step to agree on the last decisive matters. It must also
be recalled that both Armenia and Azerbaijan have undertaken the
commitment to solve the conflict over Nagorno-Karabakh by peaceful
means only when joining the Council of Europe. This is a binding
commitment", T. Davis said.

As for the activities of OSCE Minsk Group and the possibility of
changing the mediatory mission’s format, Terry Davis noted: "First of
all it is up to the two countries to settle the conflict. It is in
their direct interest to end this conflict by peaceful means. Since
the Minsk Group has showed a new dynamism in the peace process
during the last six months, I wonder why anyone would suggest that
the conflict settlement mechanism should be changed. After all, the
OSCE Minsk Group, which has the task of mediating in this conflict,
is very familiar with all aspects of this complex process".

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Armenian Citizens Arrested For Contraband With Cigarettes

ARMENIAN CITIZENS ARRESTED FOR CONTRABAND WITH CIGARETTES

Yerevan, February 5. ArmInfo. The press-service of the Federal Tax
Service (FTS) has spread an information about the completion of a
"multimonth international operation " for suppression of activities
of a group of contrabandists who had been supplying the Russian
cigarettes to Europe.

According to the information of FTS’s press-service, "the
contrabandists were dealing with illegal export of tobacco production
to the Western European countries within 2004-2006". The group "had
an inter-ethnic character and supported stable relations with natives
of Georgia and Chechnya, permanently living in EU countries. They
were entrusted with a task of selling the illegal goods in Europe.

The system was worked out in details. According to the data of FTS,
the investigation even suspected "regarding a possible use of these
means for financing of illegal armed formations in Caucasus".

President Of Chess Federation Of Armenia Forecasts Further Victories

PRESIDENT OF CHESS FEDERATION OF ARMENIA FORECASTS FURTHER VICTORIES BY ARMENIAN CHESS-PLAYERS

Yerevan, February 5. ArmInfo. Armenian Defense Minister, President
of the Chess Federation of Armenia Serzh Sargsyan forecasts further
victories by Armenian chess-players.

In an interview to Armenia TV Sargsyan noted that Armenia is one of
the few countries to have won the Chess Olympic Games but this is just
the beginning of big work. In Jan alone Armenia had three victories:
the best one was Levon Aronyan’s victory in Wijk aan Zee.

Now Armenian chess-players are getting ready for European team cup in
the autumn 2007, while in May Aronyan will start battling for world
championship. "Lets wish him success," Sargsyan said.

Armenia Should Resolve A Number Of Own Problems Before Integrating I

ARMENIA SHOULD RESOLVE A NUMBER OF OWN PROBLEMS BEFORE INTEGRATING INTO EUROPEAN FAMILY

Yerevan, February 5. ArmInfo. "The Process of Eurointegration is a
long process, especially if consider that the Europeans are hardly
waiting for us", RA DM, Serzh Sargsyan, said in an interview to
"Armenia" TV channel.

"This is a very long process during which we should try to resolve
serious problems. On of them is the settlement of the Karabakh
conflict. We cannot enter the European family with this problem and we
have no right to impose our problem on them . Moreover, we have still
a number of problems to be resolved", the Minister said. Among these
problems, he noted the necessity of the society’s democratization.

US Office Of Defense Cooperation Provides Mobile Expeditionary Medic

US OFFICE OF DEFENSE COOPERATION PROVIDES MOBILE EXPEDITIONARY MEDICAL SUPPORT (EMEDS) FIELD HOSPITAL AND TRAINING

ArmRadio.am
05.02.2007 11:07

The US Embassy’s Office of Defense Cooperation (ODC) announced that it
had provided the Armenian military with a new Mobile Expeditionary
Medical Support (EMEDS) field hospital. The hospital is a $1.2
million facility that can be deployed anywhere in the world to allow
the Armenian military to provide medical and surgical services to
its soldiers. The US ODC also held a week-long "Mobile US EMEDS
Contingency Hospital Training Course" at the Armenian Ministry of
Defense’s military hospital in Erebuni. US officers and enlisted
instructors from various medical specialties provided training on
field and garrison hospital operation concepts for 43 Armenian medical
personnel assigned to operate the EMEDS facility.

US Chargé d’Affaires Anthony F. Godfrey; General Major Melkonyan,
Chief of the Foreign Relations and Military Cooperation Department;
and Colonel Michael Michaelyan, Deputy Chief of the Military Medical
Department, participated in the ceremony. During the event, Chargé
d’Affaires Godfrey noted that this facility will be integral to
supporting future Armenian military deployments with coalition
or NATO forces, providing medical relief for humanitarian crises
related to natural disasters, and improving joint medical operations
with NATO medical services, and that it will help Armenia develop a
"niche capability" which could be of great value in multinational
operations. Lieutenant Colonel Doug Peterson, the chief of the
U.S. Office of Defense Cooperation, commented that this event marked
the beginning of intensive medical training and cooperation between
the armed forces of Armenia and the United States. He noted that
additional medical training events are already being coordinated
for later in 2007, and additional equipment for the EMEDS system is
already on order for delivery in late 2007 or early 2008.

–Boundary_(ID_+6xg1zPgiOxN9C4FkMJMdg)–

CESS Annual Conference call for papers – October 18-21, 2007

Central Eurasian Studies Society
c/o John Schoeberlein
1730 Cambridge Street, Room S-327
Cambridge, MA 02138 U.S.A.
e-mail: [email protected]
fax: +1 / 617-495-8319

Call For Papers

Central Eurasian Studies Society Eighth Annual Conference (2007)

October 18-21, 2007
University of Washington, Seattle, Washington, U.S.A.

The Central Eurasian Studies Society (CESS) invites panel and paper
proposals for the Eighth CESS Annual Conference, October 18-21, 2007,
in Seattle, Washington. The event will be held at the University of
Washington, hosted by the Ellison Center for Russian, East European
and Central Asian Studies. Panels begin Friday morning, October 19,
and continue through mid-day on Sunday, October 21.

Panel and paper topics relating to all aspects of humanities and
social science scholarship on Central Eurasia are welcome. The
geographic domain of Central Eurasia extends from the Black Sea and
Iranian Plateau to Mongolia and Siberia, including the Caucasus,
Crimea, Middle Volga, Afghanistan, Tibet, and Central and Inner Asia.
Practitioners and scholars in all humanities and social science
disciplines with an interest in Central Eurasia are encouraged to
participate.

The program will feature approximately 60 panels and there will also
be a supplementary program including cultural events, a welcome
reception on Thursday, a conference dinner and a keynote speaker.

Deadline for submission of panel/paper proposals: Friday, April 6, 2007.

Submissions of pre-organized panels are strongly encouraged and will
be given some preference in the selection process. Individual papers
are also welcome and will be assigned by the program committee to an
appropriate panel with a chair and a discussant. Only electronic
submissions will be accepted (see the webform on the CESS website:
ce.html).

FULL DETAILS of Conference Participation

There has been a huge growth in interest in the CESS conference as our
society has become more established. Over the past three years,
attendance has averaged about 500 per year, with dozens of countries
and all major fields of scholarship represented. We expect a similar
number to attend in 2007.

Please note that due to this high level of interest, and the fact that
the total number of participants in CESS 2007 will be limited due to
space constraints, we anticipate that the selection of papers will be
very competitive, and we encourage all who hope to attend to consider
working with colleagues to arrange a pre-organized panel, as this will
improve your chances of acceptance.

The Conference Committee accepts electronic submissions only — either
by webform (see the CESS website:
ce.html), or by an e-mailed
form in MS Word format in the case of those who don’t have web access
(please contact us by e-mail to obtain the form in MS Word format).
We require electronic format because website submissions can more
easily be processed than other methods, and we have limited resources
to manage the hundreds of submissions that we anticipate receiving.

The following information is required for submissions; we suggest that
you prepare the text before accessing the website so you can simply
paste the information into the form (but do not send it without the form!):

For Paper Presenters: 1) Name, 2) Current institutional affiliation,
3) Title/position, 4) E-mail, 5) Postal address, 6) Telephone, 7) Fax,
8) Title of Paper, 9) Abstract of Paper (a summary of the paper of
200-300 words; abstracts longer than 300 words may be rejected), 10)
Any audio-visual equipment requests (specify — e.g., overhead
projector, slide project, video player), 11) A one-page CV which
contains the information which the panel chair may require for
introductions, and includes the presenter’s educational background
(highest degree, year awarded, awarding institution, and field of study).

For Panels: Proposals may be submitted for regular panels (with
presentation of scholarly papers) and roundtable panels (featuring
discussion of a current topic in the field).

Regular Panels: In addition to the information for paper presenters
(as indicated above), the following are also required: a) a title for
the proposed panel, and b) name, affiliation, and contact information
of the panel chair and discussant. Panels should have three or four
paper presenters, a chair, and a discussant. The program committee can
accept panel submissions which lack one or two of these, but no panel
proposal should have fewer than four people who have given a firm
assurance that they definitely plan to participate in the conference
unless they are prevented by circumstances out of their control. If
the panel as proposed does not include a full complement of panelists
(i.e., 3-4 presenters, discussant and chair), the other panel
participants may be filled in as necessary by the program committee if
the panel proposal is accepted. Pre-organized panels should be
thematically coherent and may be organized/sponsored by a scholarly
organization (optional).

Roundtable Panels: A roundtable has four or five presenters and a
chair/moderator. For roundtable proposals, the organizer must provide
a paragraph describing the panel objectives and providing
justification for use of the roundtable format. The same information
is required of each participant as for regular panels with the
exception that abstracts and paper titles are not required.

Sponsored Panels: CESS encourages other institutions supporting the
study of Central Eurasia, such as regional scholarly associations, to
organize "sponsored panels" at the CESS conference — i.e., panels
organized by the sponsoring institution, involving their members and
receiving their imprimatur.

Best Paper Graduate Student Award: There will be an award in the
amount of $500 given to the best graduate student conference paper
submitted to the Awards Committee for consideration. The deadline for
submissions is Friday, Sept. 21, 2007, 5:00 pm Eastern Time. See the
CESS awards webpage for details, or contact the Awards Committee
Co-chairs, Dr. Douglas Northrop <northropumich.edu>, and Dr. Uli
Schamiloglu <uschamilwisc.edu>.

IMPORTANT NOTES for submissions:

1. Submission Format: Do not send your proposal in any format other
than the webform or the MS Word form, as the committee will not
consider it in that case.
2. Ensuring Quality Proposals: Since the selection process is expected
to be quite competitive, we strongly advise you to follow the
Guidelines for Writing Abstracts available on the CESS website. Those
who do not do this will have significantly lower chances of their
proposal being accepted. If you do not have web access, we can send
you the guidelines by e-mail upon request.
3. Commitment to Participate: By submitting a proposal, you are
indicating your serious intention to participate in the conference —
including your commitment to take the necessary steps to obtain any
required visa or funding — unless prevented by circumstances out of
your control. You will be asked to confirm your commitment in June
after your proposal is accepted. Note that, because withdrawal after
the program has been put together is very disruptive and harms the
quality of panels, and prevents us from including people in the
program who would indeed be able to attend, CESS rules stipulate that
those who withdraw after August 1 without a good reason are barred
from participating in the conference the following year, and those who
fail to appear at the conference without timely notice to the
Conference Committee will be considered "no-shows" and will be barred
from participating for the next two years. The deadline for such
notification is September 28, and after this date, no registration
fees can be refunded.
4. E-mail Contact: Since all communication with prospective
participants is via e-mail, and we will require your confirmation of
participation in June after proposals are accepted and again in
September when all of your visa and travel arrangements should be in
place, it is vitally important that you make sure we always have an
e-mail address that will reach you. If we LOSE CONTACT with you after
your proposal is accepted, you will be dropped from the program, will
be counted as a "no-show", and will not be able to participate in the
conference.
5. Abstracts of Publishable Quality: If you are accepted and
participate in the conference, your abstract will be published on the
CESS website, so please write it carefully to avoid errors and ensure
that it conforms with the criteria for a good abstract (see Guidelines
for Writing Abstracts).
6. Program Limitations: No participant may present more than one paper
at the conference. Without special justification, the program
committee will not schedule any individual to appear on more than two
panels as a presenter or discussant. If you have a paper included on
a pre-organized panel and you also submit an individual paper, the
pre-organized panel takes precedence and if it is accepted, your other
paper proposal will not be considered.

Schedule of Key Dates

Deadline for submission of panel/paper proposals: Friday, April 6, 2007.
– Note: Submissions after this date may be accepted only in the case
of special justifying circumstances and at the discretion of the
program committee.

Notification of acceptance: by June 5, 2007.
– The host institution will provide, upon request, mailed or faxed
invitation letters to support an application for a visa or travel
funds; these will be sent in the second half of June. Note: Obtaining
a U.S. visa can take a long time, and we urge participants to begin
the process immediately upon notification of their proposal’s acceptance.

Deadline for notification of audio-visual requests: Friday, September 14 .

Pre-registration deadline: Friday, September 14 .
– Note: Pre-registration and CESS membership is required for all
presenters, and entitles you to significantly reduced registration
fees. For those not on the program, pre-registration reserves a space
at the conference, in the event that attendance reaches the
maximum capacity.

Papers should be submitted to chairs/discussants: by Friday, September 28.
– Paper presenters will be informed via e-mail by mid-September of
the e-mail addresses of their panel’s chair and discussant, to whom
they should send their papers by the deadline.

Deadline for confirmation of participation: Friday, September 28.

– Paper presenters who have not pre-registered will be requested via
e-mail in late August to confirm their participation in the
conference. Any who do not respond within 1 month will be removed
from the program. Anyone withdrawing from the conference after this
date will not be eligible for a refund of conference fees and may be
ineligible to participate in the subsequent year’s conference.

Conference: October 18-21, 2007 .
– Arrival to Seattle is on the afternoon/evening of Thursday, October
18 — registration opens in the afternoon followed by a reception in
the evening. Panels begin Friday morning, October 19, and continue
through mid-day on Sunday, October 21.

Registration

Each conference participant is required to pay a registration fee and
presenters are required to pre-register. The fee is reduced for CESS
members, for University of Washington students, and for those who
pre-register before the pre-registration deadline — September 14 .
The level of the fee also depends on your CESS membership dues
category (with some members being entitled to reduced dues — see the
CESS Membership Form for details).

Payment of registration fees IS REQUIRED for all attending the
conference, and cover an welcoming reception on Thursday and the
conference dinner on Friday.

Panel participants may submit the registration fee at the same time as
submitting this form, or at any time before the pre-registration
deadline of September 14. We accept payment by 1) cash (only at the
conference), 2) check or money order (if not from a US bank, please
contact us to find out what form is acceptable from your country),
3) credit card (see the Credit Card Payment Form on the CESS website).
Payments should be mailed to: Central Eurasian Studies Society, c/o John
Schoeberlein, 1730 Cambridge Street, Room S-327, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA.
Please consult the CESS Membership Form for full details on methods of
payment () .

NOTE: CESS does not have funds to support the costs of conference
participation, and does not waive the conference fee for participants
who cannot afford it. Paper presenters, other panelists, and
conference attendees are required to pay the registration fee, and
additionally, those included on the program (paper presenters,
roundtable panelists, discussants, etc.) are required to be CESS
members in good standing — i.e., to have paid any dues they owe.
Participants must obtain their own funding — from personal resources,
their own institutions, or grant-giving organizations which provide
conference travel grants. Some further information about possible
sources is available on the conference website.

Travel and Accommodations

Information about the University of Washington and the city of
Seattle, transportation options, maps, and lodging information will be
available on the University of Washington’s CESS Conference
Information page at
Ple ase be sure to visit this webpage for detailed information.

All conference participants are responsible for making their own
arrangements for travel and accommodations. CESS does not have
sufficient resources to subsidize travel and accommodations for
conference participants, nor can we make hotel reservations on your
behalf.

Further Information

The Co-chairs of the Conference Committee are:

Dr. Laura Adams (Harvard University; [email protected])
Dr. Michael Rouland (Miami University of Ohio; [email protected])
Dr. Stephen Hanson (University of Washington, Seattle;
[email protected])

Full information about CESS 2007 in Seattle may be found on the
conference webpages:

* Main conference website:
* Registration:
* Program (preliminary version available in July 2007):

* Full information about hosting and location at the University of
Washington:

Vir tually all informational questions about the conference can be
answered by consulting the above-mentioned webpages. If you don’t
have web access, or if you don’t find the answer to your questions
there, you can contact the conference organizers by e-mail at
<[email protected]>.

Conference -related correspondence should be addressed as follows:

Communications regarding local arrangements, including invitation
letters, should be addressed to:

CESS 2007 Annual Conference
Allison Dvaladze
Outreach Coordinator for the Ellison Center for Russian, East European
and Central Asian Studies
203B Thompson Hall, Box 353650
University of Washington
Seattle, Washington 98195, U.S.A.
[email protected].
fax: +1 / 206-543-4852
tel.: +1 / 206-685-0668

Communications about proposal submission, program matters,
registration matters, the mailing list, and data updates should be
sent to the CESS Secretariat. Please send payments also to:

Central Eurasian Studies Society
c/o John Schoeberlein
1730 Cambridge Street, Room S-327
Cambridge, MA 02138 U.S.A.
e-mail: [email protected]
fax: +1 / 617-495-8319

Key Web Addresses:

CESS 2007 at the University of Washington:

Conf erence Info.:
C onference Registr.:
CES S Member Registr.:

http://cess.fas.harvard.edu/CESS_Conferen
http://cess.fas.harvard.edu/CESS_Conferen
http://cess.fas.harvard.edu/CESS_Membership.html
http://jsis.washington.edu/ellison/CESS.shtml.
http://cess.fas.harvard.edu/CESS_Conference.html
http://cess.fas.harvard.edu/CESS_Conf-Reg.html
http://cess.fas.harvard.edu/CESS_Program.html
http://jsis.washington.edu/ellison/CESS.shtml
http://jsis.washington.edu/ellison/CESS.shtml
http://cess.fas.harvard.edu/CESS_Conference.html
http://cess.fas.harvard.edu/CESS_Conf-Reg.html
http://cess.fas.harvard.edu/CESS_Membership.html

Book Review: A History of Amnesia: "Bastard of Istanbul"

The Straits Times (Singapore)
February 4, 2007 Sunday

A history of amnesia;
Elif Shafak’s controversial The Bastard Of Istanbul is an epic soap
opera that tackles the genocide question

by Stephanie Yap, ARTS REPORTER

MOST writers and journalists would have been riveted by the recent
drama that surrounded Turkish novelist Elif Shafak. Last year, she
was put on trial for ‘insulting Turkishness’, and faced three years’
imprisonment under Article 301 of the country’s penal code.

More than 60 writers, including Nobel Prize winner Orhan Pamuk, had
been charged under that law since its introduction in June 2005, but
Shafak’s case was the first time it had been applied to a work of
fiction.

That controversial work? Her sixth novel and her second in English,
The Bastard Of Istanbul, in which characters refer to the exile and
deaths of thousands of Armenians in the Ottoman Empire from 1915 to
1917, as genocide. Turkey, the Empire’s modern-day descendant, denies
it was genocide.

Readers searching for the controversial parts are rewarded early in
the book. An Armenian American man scolds his nephew for doing
nothing while the latter’s ex-wife, who raises their daughter,
marries a Turkish man:

‘What will that innocent lamb tell her friends when she grows up? …
I am the grandchild of genocide survivors who lost all their
relatives at the hands of the Turkish butchers in 1915, but I myself
have been brainwashed to deny the genocide because I was raised by
some Turk named Mustafa!’

Emotions and exclamation marks run rife in this epic soap opera,
which shuttles between a Turkish family in Istanbul and an Armenian
American family in San Francisco. At the heart of each is a teenage
girl.

On the Armenian side is Armanoush, the beautiful and bookish daughter
of an Armenian American father and a white mother. Her mother sparks
the tirade above when she marries a Turkish man, Mustafa Kazanci.

Armanoush visits her stepfather’s family in Istanbul in a quest to
discover her Armenian ancestors’ haunts. She meets four generations
of Kazanci women, including her stepfather’s four sisters – variously
a clairvoyant, a history teacher, a schizophrenic and a tattoo artist
– along with their moody mother and their Alzheimer’s-stricken
grandmother.

Lastly, there is Asya, the daughter of the tattoo artist, and the
bastard of the title. Unlike Armanoush, the headstrong, Johnny
Cash-loving Asya has no knowledge of – or interest in – her ancestry.

Armanoush represents the Armenians’ unwillingness to forget, while
Asya embodies the Turkish people’s blindness, deliberate or
otherwise, to the past.

In her eagerness to tackle the genocide question head-on, Shafak’s
writing can get heavy-handed and didactic, reading like a dramatised
textbook as characters reel off dates and statistics in conversation.

Just as often, though, she effectively uses the domestic setting to
explore a nation’s psyche. When Armanoush tells the Kazancis about
the deaths of her ancestors, she is initially surprised that the
women are unapologetic. But she then realises it is ‘not because they
had not felt for her… but because they had seen no connection
between themselves and the perpetrators of their crimes’.

However, as characters reel from the onslaught of revelations that
rain down in the last few chapters – some more believable than others
– even Armanoush might be tempted to admit that ignorance is bliss.

As the clairvoyant Auntie Banu, the one character who has access to
the whole truth, wonders: ‘Was it really better for human beings to
pine to discover more of their past? Or was it simply better to know
as little of the past as possible and even to forget what small
amount was remembered?’

Shafak does not provide the answer, but she has taken the first step
in realising that the question should be asked.

If you like this, read: The Black Book by Orhan Pamuk (1990, $23.10
with GST, Books Kinokuniya).

An Istanbul lawyer takes on the identity of a journalist while
searching for his runaway wife.

[email protected]

THE BASTARD OF ISTANBUL By Elif Shafak Viking/Hardcover/ 357 pages/
$39.90 (with GST)/ Major bookstores/*****

EU bid to outlaw genocide denial faces backlash

EU bid to outlaw genocide denial faces backlash
Bruno Waterfield in London
February 3, 2007

PEOPLE who question the official history of conflicts in Africa and
the Balkans could be jailed for up to three years for "genocide denial",
under proposed European Union legislation.

Germany, the current holder of the union’s rotating presidency, is to
table legislation to outlaw "racism and xenophobia". Included in the
draft EU directive are plans to outlaw Holocaust denial, creating an
offence that does not exist in British law.

But the proposals, seen by the Telegraph of London, go much further and
would criminalise those who question the extent of war crimes that have
taken place in the past 20 years.

Deborah Lipstadt, professor of modern Jewish and Holocaust studies at
Emory University, Atlanta, said the proposals were misplaced. "I adhere
to that pesky little thing called free speech and I am very concerned
when governments restrict it," Professor Lipstadt said.

"How will we determine precisely what is denial? Will history be decided
by historians or in a courtroom?"

The proposals extend the idea of Holocaust denial to the "gross
minimisation of genocide out of racist and xenophobic motives", to
include crimes dealt with by the International Criminal Court.

The text states: "Each member state shall take the measures necessary to
ensure that the following intentional conduct is punishable: ‘publicly
condoning, denying or grossly trivialising of crimes of genocide, crimes
against humanity and war crimes as defined in’?â??¦ the Statute of the ICC."

General Lewis MacKenzie, the former commander of United Nations
peacekeepers in Bosnia, courted controversy two years ago by questioning
the number of Bosnians killed at Srebrenica in 1995. He took issue with
the official definition of the massacre as genocide. "The math just
doesn’t support the scale of 8000 killed," he wrote.

Balkans human rights activists have branded General MacKenzie an
"outspoken Srebrenica genocide denier" and, if approved, the EU
legislation could see similar comments investigated by police or
prosecuted in the courts.

"Whether a specific historic crime falls within these definitions would
be decided by a court in each case," a German Government spokesman said.

But the legislation faces stiff opposition from academics who fear it
would stifle debate about some of the biggest issues in international
relations.

Norman Stone, a professor of history at Turkey’s Koc University, argues
that any attempt to legislate against genocide denial is "quite absurd".

"We cannot have EU or international legal bodies blundering in and
telling us what we can and cannot say," he said.

Professor Lipstadt agrees. "When you pass these kinds of laws it
suggests to the uninformed bystander that you don’t have the evidence to
prove your case," she said.

Telegraph, London

CNN Larry King: Discussion of the Book "Beyond a Reasonable Doubt"

CNN
SHOW: CNN LARRY KING LIVE 9:00 PM EST
February 3, 2007 Saturday

Discussion of the Book "Beyond a Reasonable Doubt."

HOST: Larry King

GUESTS: Mark Geragos, Owen LaFave, Daniel Petrocelli, Gerry Spence

Defense attorneys who wrote a portion of the book "Beyond a
Reasonable Doubt" discuss the book.

LARRY KING, CNN HOST: Tonight Owen LaFave on his ex-wife, the sex
criminal teacher.

OWEN LAFAVE, HUSBAND OF DEBRA LAFAVE: She didn’t serve any jail time
but if it was a male sexual offender he would have gotten three to
five years.

KING: Plus, three of America’s highest profile attorneys, Mark
Geragos. He represented Scott Peterson.

MARK GERAGOS, DEFENSE ATTORNEY: The presumption of guilt was
overwhelming. They wanted to get onto that jury. And they wanted to
get on that jury to fry him.

KING: Attorney Daniel Petrocelli. He got a wrongful death charge for
O.J. Simpson, after a criminal trial that shocked the nation.

DANIEL PETROCELLI, DEFENSE ATTORNEY: They had more evidence on
Simpson than you could possibly imagine. And yet, the jury acquitted
him.

KING: And Gerry Spence.

GERRY SPENSE, DEFENSE ATTORNEY: I seated 12 jurors, all of whom said
they believed he was guilty. And they acquitted him.

KING: It’s an hour that will change maybe the way you looked at
America’s criminal justice system. "Beyond a Reasonable Doubt" next
on "LARRY KING LIVE."

There’s a new book out that I am very proud to have written the
introduction for. It’s "Beyond a Reasonable Doubt". There you see its
cover.

A lot of diverse people contributed to this book giving their
thoughts and opinions on this book that is what a reasonable doubt is
and what is beyond it.

To discuss it we have Mark Geragos, the famed Los Angeles defense
attorney. His clients have included Wynnona Wider, Michael Jackson,
Scott Peterson. His contribution to this book is titled, "I Know
Beyond a Reasonable Doubt that there was an Armenian Genocide."

Owen LaFave is here in Los Angeles as well, the ex-husband of Debra
LaFave — we said this was a diverse participation — the former
Florida school teacher, convicted of having a sexual relationship
with a 14-year-old male student.

Owen has written a book about the case titled "Gorgeous Disaster".
His contribution to this book, which I wrote the introduction, is an
essay called, "My Wife the Sex Criminal: Why the Double Standard?"

In Minneapolis, the famed attorney Daniel Petrocelli, who sought and
got a civil verdict against O.J. Simpson when the Browns and
Goldman’s sued Simpson for the wrongful deaths of O.J.’s ex, Nicole,
and her friend Ron. His essay in the book is titled, "Outside the
Courtroom".

And in San Francisco, our friend Gerry Spence, once was a prosecutor.
Best known as a defense attorney. His clients have included Imelda
Marcos and the family of the late Karen Silkwood. Gerry’s essay in
the book is called, "We, the Killers".

He’s also a successful author. You’ll see if you visit his website,
gerryspence.com, and that Gerry with a "G."

"Beyond a Reasonable Doubt" is the title. I wrote the introduction.

Let’s begin right with the start with Mark Geragos.

Why did you choose the Armenian genocide to back up the point?

GERAGOS: I’m Armenian. All four of my grandparents fled the genocide.
Came to America as a result of the Turk’s brutally killing a million
and a half Armenians.

It’s topical today because now with Turkey trying to get into the
European Union, recognizing the Armenian genocide is a precondition
that a lot of the European countries have.

In fact, last week we suffered a tremendous loss in the community.
There was a story that’s international and especially big in Europe
is the assassination of Huron Tadink (ph), who was the editor of the
paper.

He was an outspoken person talking about the genocide in Turkey. And
it’s actually criminal in Turkey. Section 301 makes it a crime to
denigrate Turkishness. And by saying that there was genocide, that
apparently denigrates Turkishness. He was prosecuted.

KING: How does that relate to "Beyond a Reasonable Doubt?"

GERAGOS: The Turks never admitted there was genocide. There was a
book that talks about beyond a reasonable doubt. Here you’ve got a
crime, a crime against humanity. I know beyond a reasonable doubt
that there was genocide.

KING: I’m going to ask each guest to give us their definition, but,
first, to explain their article.

Daniel, what did you mean by "Outside the Courtroom?" PETROCELLI:
Larry, oftentimes too many people, lawyers included, believe that
justice depends solely upon what happens inside the courtroom. And in
high-profile cases, case of great public interest, that is not always
the case.

And I’ve had the opportunity to be involved in two such cases. One is
the one you mentioned, the Simpson trial, and the other one is the
one I finished last year, representing Jeffrey Skilling, the former
president of Enron in the criminal trial against him.

And drawing upon those two cases to make the point, I wanted to
explain to the readers how what happens outside the courtroom can
very much dictate and influence the verdict and the result that
occurs inside.

KING: In a sense, you were saying that Mr. Skilling did not get
beyond a reasonable doubt — he did not get that factor?

PETROCELLI: I certainly do not believe that the proof in that case
rose to the level of proof beyond a reasonable doubt.

But the point that I was trying to make about the Skilling trial, in
particular, was that the community pressures and influences that were
brought to bear on that trial on all the participants in that trial,
in particular the jury, made it very difficult for the jury to hear,
understand, receive, and deliberate the evidence with an open mind.

KING: Owen LaFave, were you surprised to be asked to participate?

LAFAVE: Actually, I was. You know, I feel like I’m in great company.
I believe if I counted correctly there were 86 contributions and only
17 were attorneys.

I’m not sure if I’m in good company or bad company with those 17. All
very well written. But there’s, you know, a few on Death row in there
and I’m lumped in with the 17.

KING: But you wrote about your wife?

LAFAVE: Correct.

KING: Because?

LAFAVE: We talk about beyond a reasonable doubt. I think in her
particular circumstance there was — it was beyond a shadow of a
doubt that she did have a sexual relationship with one of her
students.

But yet I believe there’s a double standard in society, as well as in
our legal system. Because, you know, she didn’t serve any jail time.
If it was a male sexual offender — Mark and I had a conversation
prior to the show tonight that he would have at least gotten three to
five years.

KING: So she became the opposite. She got the sole beneficiary double
standard.

LAFAVE: Exactly.

KING: It went all in her favor?

LAFAVE: Exactly.

KING: So she went beyond it…

GERAGOS: She got a real presumption of innocence.

KING: She was really beyond a reasonable doubt.

LAFAVE: You’re absolutely right. There was clear DNA evidence and
taped conversation. There’s an inequal penalty given out and I think
that’s something as a society we need to readdress.

KING: And Gerry Spence, good to have you back with us, Gerry. You
titled yours "We, the Killers. Explain.

SPENCE: Well, beyond a reasonable doubt, as far as I’m concerned,
Larry, the death penalty is something that’s very savage and
un-American and an issue we need to deal with.

And I’ve talked about it in detail in my essay. About the death
penalty, I mean, who really gets penalized? We don’t penalize the
killer. How do you penalize somebody that you kill?

We certainly penalize his mother, the little old widow sitting back
there with nobody to hold her hand while they kill her son.

We punish the kids in the family when the father is executed. We
don’t punish the killer.

KING: So we kill them.

SPENCE: We kill. And that’s hardly any punishment.

KING: Not punishment?

SPENCE: No. What’s really punishment is what we do to ourselves. We
become killers ourselves.

KING: How does that relate to reasonable doubt, Gerry?

SPENCE: I wondered that when I wrote the piece. And I said, beyond a
reasonable doubt, this is something that America has to put aside.
And we can’t join people like China or join people like Iraq.

KING: No.

SPENCE: And engage in this kind of savage, primal sort of conduct. We
have to quit it. We have to quit it now.

KING: We’re one of the few countries that still do it.

GERAGOS: I believe only three or four of the civilized — so- called
civilized world.

KING: Let’s get a definition.

What is a reasonable doubt, Mark?

GERAGOS: The legal definition is an abiding conviction of the truth
of the charge.

KING: Abiding conviction. What does abiding mean.

GERAGOS: Abiding means it’s unrelenting, no matter, you’re going to
still believe it.

A lot of trial lawyers will describe it, and of the people in the
book describe it as, can you wake up each morning with the same kind
of belief, the same certainty that the decision you made was right.

Other lawyers I’ve heard in arguments have said, is this something
that you would — based on the information you have, would you make a
major decision based on this? Would you buy a house based on this
decision, marry somebody based on this decision.

I like based on a witness, do you believe that witness based on a
reasonable doubt, would you like that witness baby-sit your kids? So
there’s all kinds of reasonable doubt definitions.

Somebody — I wish I could remember who — I think gave the best and
compared it to the justice of the Supreme Court who talked about
obscenity. You know it, when you see it. That is ultimately what
happens.

That ties into Daniel’s comment about outside of the courtroom.
Because what happens is beyond a reasonable doubt really is a
function of the presumption.

If you have no presumption of innocence, if you start off with a
presumption of guilt then beyond a reasonable doubt is very low. It’s
whatever you think it is because you started off with guilt.

If you’ve got a presumption of innocence, then it’s a really high
standard. And you will, as Gerry will talk about with the death
panty, how you can put somebody to death if you are adhering to
beyond a reasonable doubt.

KING: We’ll take a break. We’ll be back to get the opinions of the
others while they define it. Fascinating topic. Don’t go away.

(BEGIN VIDEO CLIP)

GERAGOS: We’re not into arguing reasonable doubt in this case. We’ve
set the bar extremely high. And that’s to prove that Scott is not
only factually innocent, but to figure out exactly who it is who did
this horrible thing to Scott’s wife.

(END VIDEOTAPE)

KING: The book is "Beyond a Reasonable Doubt." By the way, any
proceeds I get from having written the introduction go to the Larry
King Cardiac Foundation.

We have an outstanding panel and a great group of people contributed
to this book. John Walsh is in it. Dr. Kevorkian is in it. He’s going
to get out of jail soon.

PETROCELLI: Fellow Armenian, too.

KING: Daniel Petrocelli, your definition of reasonable doubt?

PETROCELLI: Well, I think Mark hit it on the head. It’s a kind of
proof you would require such that you wouldn’t hesitate in conducting
your own affairs, entrusting your child to another person.

Would you hesitate in trusting that child to that babysitter? If you
hesitate for even one moment, that’s reasonable doubt right there.

And this is what the juries are typically instructed.

Now that said, as Mark points out, it’s not as though the juries
actually understand and apply that standard. If they did, there would
be far, far more acquittals.

They may apply it depending on the outcome they feel the society and
the community in which they live are expecting.

You know, take, again, the Skilling case. Houston was expecting,
everyone in that town was expecting a conviction. It was asking too
much of 12 people to acquit Mr. Skilling and then go back to their
communities.

So reasonable doubt played a much lesser role in that trial.

Take the Simpson case by contrast, the criminal case. I heard Owen
talk about DNA evidence and taped evidence. Well, they had DNA on
Simpson. They had tapes on Simpson. They had more evidence on Simpson
than you could possibly imagine. Yet, the jury acquitted him in under
four hours.

And that’s because what was important in that trial, in the minds of
those jurors was not the question of the quality or quantum of the
proof, but the question of race. That became a referendum on race
relations in this country.

That’s what those jurors were wrestling with.

KING: Owen, you believe the woman in a sex case gets a break the man
doesn’t get?

LAFAVE: Absolutely. It’s abundantly clear. Obviously, Mary Kay
Letourneau (ph) probably was a catalyst behind the whole movement.
But of course, my wife — and since then, there have been a number of
others. But time and time again, and recently in the news, female
sexual perpetrators get limited to no jail time. It’s a huge
disservice.

KING: Why?

LAFAVE: There’s a number of.

KING: What are you laughing at? Why?

GERAGOS: I’m laughing because it’s every male’s fantasy. I’ve said it
before. Every male who is sitting in a locker room in a junior high
school or a high school has a fantasy about the teacher. And I
mentioned it before — look at Van Halen’s "Hot for Teacher."

KING: But don’t females — do those females have a fantasy?

FER: We have a double standard when it comes do that. When you look
at it, look how the media portrays when it’s a female teacher with
the student as versus a male teacher with the student. There’s no
comparison. The male teacher looks like leach.

LAFAVE: You’re right. And it’s romanticized. I think part of the
problem is society doesn’t view the boys as victims. Where I think
they are. You know, I did a lot of research when I wrote my book. And
I’m also working on a documentary as well. I talked to a number of
experts. Talked to a number of victims.

More than half the men out there thought that, good for the boy. Give
him a pat on the back.

Once I had the opportunity to sit down in the same room with these
people and hear their stories and how their lives are affected, they
are victims and these women need to go to jail.

KING: Gerry Spence, what’s your definition of reasonable doubt?

SPENCE: I talk to juries. And when I talk to juries I say this. You
know, reasonable doubt really isn’t for the defendant. It is for you.
I want you to be able to go home at night and lay your head down on
the pillow and close your eyes and say I am — I’m satisfied. I don’t
ever have to worry again. I’m applying reasonable doubt. And if
there’s reasonable I’m going to acquit. And I’m going to sleep the
rest of my life.

I think reasonable doubt ought to be viewed from the standpoint that
it’s not only for the criminal that’s being charged, the alleged
criminal, but also those who charged him.

KING: If I’m — I’m a juror. And circumstantial evidence is
presented. In other words, there’s no eye witness to the scene. And I
have to judge what was sitting before me. And two psychiatrists make
competing arguments. How do I present it?

If I go into a courtroom, should we go into Baghdad based on the
evidence on the evidence of weapons of mass destruction? Could I have
had reasonable doubt? SPENCE: I think any reasonable person would
have had reasonable doubt about that.

KING: Couldn’t we have reasonable doubt on almost anything?

SPENCE: Absolutely. Reasonable doubt — here’s another way I think
about reasonable doubt. I go to bed at night. I do a lot of my
thinking, as you must see, when I go to bed at night.

And I’m thinking about, did I turn the alarm on. I can’t be sure. I’m
sure — I’m not sure. And I have to get up to look. That’s reasonable
doubt.

KING: That’s well put. And we’ll take a break and come back.

LAFAVE: It’s also old age.

KING: Yes. We’ll be back with more. Don’t go away.

KING: We’re back.

Mark Geragos, how well, then, do juries apply it or what’s gone wrong
if we know 200 people have been released from death row who did not
commit the crime?

GERAGOS: People always forget about the DNA exonerations. The numbers
are astronomical.

KING: Did that mean the jury did not — was not correct?

GERAGOS: Clearly what happened, at least in my experience, is if a
jury or jurors come to a case predisposed, no matter how great a
lawyer you are, you’re not going to be able, in whatever period of
time the trial lasts, to get away from all the experiences they built
up for 10, 20, 30, 40, 50 years.

And all of a sudden you, as a lawyer, are going to turn them around
and reconfiguration the way they think. So what you need to do as a
lawyer is to make them understand.

Like Gerry says, it’s not for the criminal or the accused criminal,
it’s for you. You have to make the jury or the juror understand that
they are invested in this process as your client is.

And one of the ways to do that is the expression about Edward Bennett
Williams. You told me many times that one of the things he thought
was most important in any trial is to make the jurors have that
feeling that they’re for the grace of God for a defendant.

If you can’t do that, then it doesn’t matter whether the standard is
a strong suspicion, which is low; preponderance, which is higher than
that; clear and convincing, which most people say, well, clear and
convincing, that sounds like a lot of evidence. That’s lower than
beyond a reasonable doubt. PETROCELLI: Larry, you made the comment in
response to Gerry that couldn’t you have reasonable Doubt about
anything?

KING: Yes.

PETROCELLI: Well, the truth is, if you had reasonable doubt about a
lot of cases, that’s a good thing. Keep in mind that criminal cases
should be reserved for the most egregious affronts to society. These
are crimes against society.

We have a dual justice system in our country, and most can address
their grievances by going to civil courts.

Criminal cases should be reserved for the most serious wrongdoing
committed by people.

And to protect life and protect liberty and protect people’s
freedoms, the government should only win and get convictions on very
clear-cut cases.

If there’s any kind of a close call, like you said, there’s two
psychiatrists or two psychologists testifying, you don’t know who to
believe, you can’t convict that defendant in that circumstance.
That’s the way it should be.

KING: Owen, how do you look at reasonable doubt?

LAFAVE: I thought it was interesting a couple of the comments of Mark
and Danny and you yourself in your introduction wrote. We tell people
to assume innocence. And what you’re asking people to do is not only
presume that the defendant is innocent, but you’re also asking them
to leave behind any type of preconceived notions they have or any
opinions or really who they are as a person.

And I think it’s virtually impossible for that to happen. And, you
know that burden of beyond a reasonable doubt and that innocence, I
think, is the core to our legal system.

But I think it’s almost virtually impossible to actually, you know,
have that be exactly true.

KING: Isn’t that true, Gerry?

SPENCE: You know, Larry, I have never, ever acquitted a client based
on reasonable doubt. If you start talking to juries about reasonable
doubt, what they say is, here’s the jury.

Let me be the juror a minute. You know, Spence is out there talking
about reasonable doubt. That’s just a cute lawyer trick. It really
means that he’s guilty but he hasn’t proven him guilty enough. The
prosecution hasn’t done its job quite well enough. But they know and
we know and the defense knows and the defendant knows, everybody
knows and we know that he’s guilty. So this reasonable doubt is just
lawyer talk, and let’s get down to the nubbins here and get this case
decided in accordance with justice. That’s what jurors do. Now, that
being the case, I have the responsibility, contrary to the law,
contrary to the business of presumption of innocence, I have the duty
to prove my client innocent. And if I don’t carry that burden, my
client is going to be convicted.

KING: I never heard it put that way. Do you agree, Mark?

GERAGOS: There really is no presumption of innocence. There is no
presumption of innocence. If you get somebody to be honest with you,
when they see you next to your client on that side of the counsel
table, virtually everyone will tell you, if they’re honest, you know,
where there’s smoke there’s fire. If this guy didn’t do it, why would
he be here? Or if he didn’t do this, he did something else.

So when you’re asking jurors, at least my experience, whether or not
— as you sit here, can you presume my client to be innocent and they
say, oh, yes.

And you say they just read off 15 charges in the indictment that
charged him with all these heinous crimes. Do you have any reaction?
And the juror said, oh, no, I have no reaction at all.

You know they’re lying through their teeth at you, and you have to
understand that.

I don’t know about Gerry, but I often prefer a juror that says, yes,
when I looked at him, I figured there’s something here. Where there’s
smoke there’s fire.

At least then, I have somebody I can engage in an honest dialogue and
they’re not lying through their teeth at you.

SPENCE: Can I tell a story?

KING: Yes, when we come back, we’ll tell the story.

We’ll take a break. We’ll be right back. The book is "Beyond a
Reasonable Doubt." Don’t go away.

(COMMERCIAL BRERAK)

KING: Welcome back to this Super Bowl eve edition of "LARRY KING
LIVE." We’re discussing the book "Beyond a Reasonable Doubt." I wrote
the introduction.

Owen LaFave has as wonderful book out, "Gorgeous Disaster," the
tragic story of Debra LaFave.

All right, Gerry, what’s the story?

SPENCE: OK. I’m defending a sheriff of having killed his undercover
agent, shot him between his eyes in the back seat of the sheriff’s
car. It’s been publicized all over. It’s been on "60 Minutes "and all
the rest and everybody says this sheriff ought to be hung for killing
his undercover agent. So I go to the jury and I begin to do just what
Mark Geragos says. You’ve read all this. Do you think he’s guilty?
Oh, no. Well, do you think he’s guilty? Well, some of them say, well,
yes. A few of them said yes. Some more of them said yes. Then a bunch
of them said yes. Then there were three or four that said no.

I turned to my client and said, who should we take on this jury. His
name was Ed Cantrell. Ed, do you want me to take the liars that think
— say you’re guilty — or innocent or should we take those that are
telling the truth that think that you are guilty?

He said, Gerry, he says, let’s go with them that are telling the
truth. And I seated 12 jurors, all of whom said they believed he was
guilty. And they acquitted him.

PETROCELLI: The more publicized the case is, the more irrelevant
concepts like presumption of innocence and proof beyond a reasonable
doubt become. Because people who take great interest in reading about
upcoming trials, they form their opinions long before they’re seated
as jurors.

Just as Gerry and Mark are saying, when you talk to these People
beforehand, they really fall into two categories. You have the
campaigners. Those are the people who want to get on the jury. Okay.
Because this is an interesting case. It’s a high-profile case. Maybe
they can even write a book about it.

In the O.J. trial, everybody wrote books, including the bailiff.

Then you get the other juror, probably the honest person, but doesn’t
want to have anything to do with this. So he or she might lie to get
off the jury. So it becomes exceedingly difficult in cases of great
public interest to get 12 good jurors.

And what’s more difficult is that with the explosion of the media
covering the legal system over the last 10, 15 years, you have like a
collision between the world of entertainment and media, and the
justice system. It’s becoming very, very tough to get good, solid,
quality justice delivered in high-profile cases, in particular.

KING: So what does that say, Daniel, for our legal system?

PETROCELLI: Well, I do think some reform would be very useful. I
think that federal judges, in particular, need to allow lawyers much
more time and leeway to question jurors.

In the O.J. civil trial, for example, when everybody on the planet
had an opinion about whether he did it or didn’t do it, the judge
gave us 30 days.

In the Enron trial, there were three hours. And we had virtually no
opportunity to question the jurors.

And the other thing that plays into here is I think more people have
to become involved as jurors. Oftentimes you get a certain couple of
substrata or segments of society that participate as jurors. And a
lot of good people don’t serve their jury time. And that’s what
really needs to change, I think.

KING: Did your wife have a jury trial, Owen?

LAFAVE: No. They had a plea bargain before that. I would like to
comment as a layman, not being involved in the legal system and being
asked to serve on a jury.

You know, it’s unfortunate to say it’s a great honor to our country.
You look for every way to get out of it. Especially in the a case
like the O.J. case or Scott Peterson case where you have media
coverage and the potential to sit on a jury day in and day out for
the course of six months. That’s a huge sacrifice to ask.

And the system weeds out good, potential jurors.

KING: So we don’t get the best of the crop?

LAFAVE: Exactly.

GERAGOS: It’s interesting. California has revamped the jury service
recently here and gone to — it used to be, in the old days, you
would be on the hook for 30 days. Everybody had an excuse.

Then it went down to 10. Now you’ve got one day, one trial. Where
everybody comes in. As long as the case is under seven days, nobody
gets off for financial hardship.

If you have less than a seven-day case now in California you tend to
get a much better cross-section of jurors than you did previously.

That’s not the case for what I call the super size cases. In cases as
Danny had, in cases like that, where they are lengthy cases and
there’s pretrial publicity and ongoing publicity, it’s virtually
impossible to ferret out what I call stealth jurors. These jurors,
who want to get on, have got an agenda. If you’re not allowed to
question them, how do you identify them?

KING: This guy in Missouri, the alleged kidnapper, Gerry, of this
15-year-old boy, kidnapped at 11, held for four years. Can he be
presumed innocent?

SPENCE: I don’t think anybody in these national cases can be presumed
innocent. In the national cases that you’re guests have been involved
in. Everybody had their mind made up before they went in. It isn’t
possible.

It really isn’t possible today in this huge — this time of media
where no matter what station you’re on the television set, that case
is being discussed, people are being — are talking about it. People
— so-called experts tell you what the facts and the law is.

By the time the jury is selected, there isn’t any possibility of
removing those preconceived ideas from the juror’s head.

KING: We’ll take a quick break. And we’ll be right back with more of
our panel. The book is "Beyond a Reasonable Doubt." Owen LaFave’s
book is "Gorgeous Disaster." We’ll be right back.

KING: We’ll take some individual cases as we get back.

Mark Geragos, was Scott Peterson judged beyond a reasonable doubt?

GERAGOS: No. The presumption was overwhelming. We had jurors who came
in there and absolutely had a preconceived notion. They wanted to get
onto that jury and they wanted to get on that jury to fry him. And we
actually caught three of those jurors in jury selection. I still
think a couple got through.

It’s on appeal. And I don’t have any doubt that the verdict in that
case will be reversed on a number of grounds.

And talking about what — following up on what Dan said, you know, at
a certain point in these — only in the most super sized of case, I
think we need to import the Contemptive Court Act that they have in
England. Where once you start, there is a clamp down on whatever
coverage. And you delay it until after the case is over.

KING: You get fined.

GERAGOS: It gives the judge real teeth with which to do so.

KING: Daniel, did Jeffrey Skilling have the presumption of Innocence?

PETROCELLI: He had no presumption of innocence. The day that he was
indicted, Larry, his indictment was announced in a nationally
broadcast press conference by, I think, the second highest official
of the United States Department of Justice, flanked by a number of
other officials pronouncing that they got their man. And that he was
a corporate crook.

Now, these are supposed to be officers of the court. And these are
supposed to be people who were paid to do justice, not, frankly, to
win a case, even though they’re public prosecutors.

I mean, they trampled over the presumption of innocence. In jury
selection, they argued — the government did, and convinced the
judge, that not only would we have a change of venue — and we agreed
that we would change venue to any city in the country, other than
Houston — we didn’t get any jury selection. We didn’t get the chance
to question jurors at all.

We ended up having jurors on our panel, Larry, who, going in, in
their questionnaires, said they thought these guys were guilty.

And afterwards some of the jurors have been interviewed publicly. And
at least one said publicly, the only question I had in my mind
throughout that whole trial is why they did it.

Now, that is doing an assault to the presumption of innocence. KING:
Owen, your wife had complete presumption of innocence, right? She had
the reverse of what we’re talking about?

GERAGOS: When you look like her, you’re presumed innocent.

LAFAVE: I suppose there was a certain element to that.

KING: So you think a beautiful woman has an edge.

GERAGOS: Yes, unless it’s a jury trial and you have females in the
jury.

LAFAVE: And her case is a little unique. She did end up pleading
guilty to her charges and didn’t get any jail time. We talked a
little bit about reform. Actually, what I would like to see, to take
some of the objectivity out of the sentencing, you know, is if you
commit a sexual crime, you get a minimum two years.

And of course, you know the Judge and all the parties involved can
argue why it should be more or should be less. Not that it should be
less, but minimum two years.

PETROCELLI: Larry, on that point that Owen is talking about, about
sentencing, another thing that has gone haywire in this country is
the sentencing that judges are meted out.

The highest sentences that are given in the federal system, higher
than murders, higher than terrorists, higher than kidnaps, are
officers and directors of public companies who get accused of
securities fraud, cases that wouldn’t make it through the civil
system.

If they’re convicted, though, in the criminal system, they go to jail
for life.

KING: Gerry, you had a story about being a prosecutor and on two
occasions sought the death penalty, one of them involving prosecuting
the Mark Hopkinson murder case. What was that about?

SPENCE: I’ve hated this death penalty from the time that I first
began practicing law 54 years ago. And I can remember as an early
prosecutor I got a death penalty case. I was a prosecutor.

And, you know, we’ve all sinned. And I was a prosecutor, got a death
penalty verdict against a sheepherder that shot his roommate while he
was asleep. And I just overdid that case. I was just too good for the
opposing counsel even when I was a kid.

And, well, come on, there aren’t many great lawyers like you’ve got
on your program here sitting with you.

But in the Mark Hopkinson case, which I was appointed on as a special
prosecutor, it was a serial killer, in effect, and who killed people
while he was in jail, and tortured them through people that worked on
his behalf. And I argued to the jury that, you know, I hate the death
penalty, I said. The death penalty doesn’t do us any good. And I had
all the arguments that I mentioned to you at the beginning of this
program.

But I want to tell you something, we’re entitled to self-defense. And
this man can kill while he’s behind bars. Maybe we need to defend
ourselves. I’ll be darned they gave him the death penalty. And I
thought I was smart enough — Gerry Spence thought he was smart
enough to figure out a way to get around that death penalty, but I
wasn’t.

I went to the governor. I wrote to editorials in the newspaper. I did
about — although this man was guilty, and horridly guilty, and did
the most heinous things. Nevertheless, they executed him.

KING: We’ll be back with out remaining moments discussing "Beyond a
Reasonable Doubt," right after this.

KING: We’re back with our panel.

Do many countries have, Mark Geragos, presumption of innocence beyond
a reasonable doubt?

GERAGOS: No, not a whole lot. In terms of the civilized world, I
think we’re on a very short list. Most countries have — there’s a
lot of European countries have an inquisitorial system. A lot of them
have an investigatory system. A lot of them don’t have defense
lawyers in the framework that they have.

KING: Are we most like Britain?

GERAGOS: Very similar. We have certain fundamental differences. But
that is our closest. And that’s where our heritage comes from.

KING: Is it true, Daniel Petrocelli — F. Lee Bailey told me this a
long time ago — that the military court, you’re presumed guilty. And
you must prove yourself innocent. However, it’s a fairer trial
because you’re judged by people who can put their personal things
aside and be disciplined enough to rule on the evidence alone.

PETROCELLI: Right. They’re the equivalent of professional jurors
rather than lay people. There’s been a lot of talk about
incorporating that into our modern jury system.

But before we sign off here, Larry, I do want to commend you for…

KING: I still have another segment. I could be wrong. But go ahead.

PETROCELLI: Let me commend you anyway. I want to commend you for
putting this collection of essays together in book you’ve come out
with. It’s an extraordinary book because it talks about a lot of
imperfections and injustices in our system. I mean, the injustices
that Mark and Owen and Gerry describe in their essays I find to be
very appalling. And at the same time, very enlightening that you can
have that kind of a discourse.

Because after all is said and done, we still have the best system in
the world. And it’s a system that can be made better if the people
who work in the system do a better job by the system.

But it’s a wonderful diverse array of stories.

KING: Thank you.

PETROCELLI: And as a lawyer reading it, it was a very informative,
enjoyable book.

KING: Do you think things will change to your liking, Owen?

LAFAVE: Unfortunately, not. But I hope to be part of that by speaking
out, by writing the book "Gorgeous Disaster," working on my
documentary and having an opportunity to speak in formats like this.

I’m hoping to just create an awareness when it comes to female sexual
predators.

I’d like to believe that by my speaking out, it is doing some good.
And there will be some changes.

KING: Are there a lot of them?

LAFAVE: You would be surprised.

KING: Do we know?

LAFAVE: We don’t have an actual number. But in the school system,
about one-third of all incidences involve female teachers.

KING: Do you think, Mark, that people bring their hatreds to the
courtroom?

GERAGOS: Absolutely. Absolutely. When I was talking about stealth
jurors, that’s what I’m talking. I had experience with jurors who
were in there who had, not only agenda, but we’ve been able to
document that they wanted to fry the defendant. And they were lying
their way onto a jury in order to do it.

That’s what is so scary about this whole concept of this — the media
getting inside of the jury box. Because if that happens, you can’t
ever, you can’t ever get a fair trial. You can’t ever have a
presumption of innocence.

And that really is one of the scariest things for somebody, who has
been in the system nowhere near as long as Gerry, but that’s truly
the most frightening thing.

If these bloodthirsty bitches can insinuate themselves into the jury
box, you’ve got a real, real problem in America. KING: And now we’ll
be back with our remaining moments on this edition of "LARRY KING
LIVE." The book, "Beyond a Reasonable Doubt." Don’t go away.

RICK SANCHEZ, CNN ANCHOR: I’m Rick Sanchez in the CNN Newsroom. Where
we’ve been putting a lot of information together for you tonight.
We’ll be bringing to you, first of all, family secret, bizarre
mystery. Twister tragedy as well that we’re going to be focusing on.
All this, next in CNN Newsroom. And we’re going to bring it to you
right here after "LARRY KING LIVE." Stay with us. We look forward to
seeing you.

KING: We’re back with our panel, all are participants in this book
"Beyond a Reasonable Doubt." I wrote the introduction.

When a jury comes into a courtroom, Daniel, and the trial is going
on, or at the end of the trial, does the judge present to them what
beyond a reasonable doubt is?

PETROCELLI: In a very perfunctory way. At the end of the trial, the
jurors are given jury instructions, which define what reasonable
doubt is. But the judges typically leave it up on the lawyers in
closing arguments to explain it.

By then it’s too late because the jurors have pretty much made up
their mind, and sometimes even before the trial begins, they’ve made
up their mind if they have an agenda.

KING: There is no written thing, this is what beyond a reasonable
doubt is.

PETROCELLI: Yes. Each state and federal circuit throughout the
country have their own working definition of reasonable doubt along
the lines that we were discussing at the outset of the program, which
are set forth and what are known as jury instructions that are put in
writing and given to the jury at the end of the case.

KING: Is it different federal to civil — federal to local?

PETROCELLI: The instructions are virtually the same. They pretty much
mean the same thing. At the same time, if you ask a juror what does
reasonable doubt mean, I don’t think they could tell you what it
means.

KING: Do you ever here from Debra LaFave?

LAFAVE: No, surprisingly not. We settled our divorce. She’s working
as a waitress in a cafe in town. She’s pretty much dropped off the
face of the map, which is good.

KING: What have you done with your life?

LAFAVE: My life has been amazing. I wrote the book "Gorgeous
Disaster." I’m working on a featured documentary right now, studying
the sexual abuse in our school system.

And, you know, I got remarried. And I’m still doing commercial real
estate in Tampa.

KING: What does your wife do? Don’t teach?

LAFAVE: No. And she’s brunette, both prerequisites. She’s a
homemaker. We have a newborn son.

KING: Congratulations.

Gerry, you stay as active as ever?

SPENCE: Yes. Larry, I’m getting ready to go to Guantanamo to
represent some of those poor devils over there, to see whether or not
it’s possible that we, Americans, who propose and tell the world that
we’re a democracy and care, see if we can’t get some of those basic
rights given to ordinary defendants over there.

KING: Have you been retained? I thought a lot of them can’t have
lawyers, right?

SPENCE: Well, I’ve been asked to go over there by one of the kids of
the JAG Corps. He said, come over and help me. I need help, Mr.
Spence. So I’m getting ready to do that.

KING: Have you tried military before?

SPENCE: Never have. At my age, it’s just a bright day to learn
something new.

KING: Do you still get excited, Mark?

GERAGOS: Every day. It really is — being a criminal defense lawyer,
to my mind, there’s no better job. Every day I get to go to court.
I’m in trial maybe 200 days a year. I get to talk to juries and I get
to cross-examine witnesses.

And it truly is, you know — I think it’s the most noble profession
that there is. We sit there. We take a lot of abuse. We are
denigrated.

But you are — yeah, you’re hooked with your client and everything
else.

When I got into this, I did it because Perry Mason was the good guy.
I always thought it was the noblest thing in the world. I always look
at it is we stand between a government, pushing the envelope and
trampling over you.

KING: We thank you all very much.

Mark Geragos, the famed Los Angeles defense attorney; Owen LaFave,
the ex-husband of Debra LaFave and author of "Gorgeous Disaster;"
Daniel Petrocelli the well known civil attorney. His essay in my book
is "Outside the Courtroom." And Gerry Spence. You can find out all
about that new book by going to gerryspence.com.

The book "Beyond a Reasonable Doubt" is available everywhere books
are sold.

If you’re in the market, by the way, for a political thriller, check
out "America’s Last Days" by Douglas McKinnon. Doug’s a syndicated
columnist. He used to work at the White House and the Pentagon. A
good friend of ours. And he knows his way around Washington. It’s a
provocative page turner that will have you asking, could this really
happen? The book is "America’s Last Days" by Douglas McKinnon.

Thanks for joining us. Have a great rest of the weekend.

And my pick is the Indianapolis Colts, 27, the Chicago Bears, 7.
Don’t get mad, Chicago.

Happy Super Bowl. Good night.