Nagorno-Karabakh: Eurasia’s Forgotten Conflict

The National Interest
Dec 17 2023

With Azerbaijan’s establishment of control over Nagorno-Karabakh now complete, questions remain about refugees now settling in Armenia.

by Mark Temnycky

Last week, representatives from the Armenian and Azerbaijani governments met to discuss the delimitation of their borders, where they debated the Nagorno-Karabakh region. The event was the latest development in what appears to be the end of the over three-decade conflict between the two countries.

Since the late 1980s, Armenia and Azerbaijan have fought over the Nagorno-Karabakh region. To date, thousands have died in the conflict, and many more have been injured. Over the past few decades, numerous ceasefires have been implemented, and negotiations between the two countries have been ongoing. But several ceasefire violations occurred, the fighting continued, and peace talks have constantly failed. More recently, the United States and the European Union attempted to de-escalate the conflict by providing humanitarian and financial assistance. This aid, however, came to no avail, and the conflict continued. Meanwhile, Russia and Turkey brokered a ceasefire in 2020 during a renewed skirmish between Armenia and Azerbaijan. Eventually, this ceasefire was also broken, and Russia and Turkey could not lead Armenian and Azerbaijani officials to new negotiations.

Given the international community’s continued inability to achieve a peaceful resolution, the Azerbaijanis finally took matters into their own hands. First, the Azerbaijani forces established a blockade over the Lachin corridor, a pathway that connects Armenia to Nagorno-Karabakh. For nearly a year, Armenians in the region had limited access to food, medicine, and fuel. There were also reports that there were shortages in the region and that Armenians in Nagorno-Karabakh were going hungry. Then, Azerbaijani forces launched a brutal attack on the region. After a brief period of fighting, the Azerbaijanis announced that they had taken control of the territory, and thousands of Armenians began to flee the region. Now, over 100,000 ethnic Armenians are displaced.

The Armenian state is attempting to help these displaced individuals. Recently, the Armenian government approved the “procedure for determining and issuing pensions to those from Nagorno-Karabakh.” The program will seek to help ethnic Armenians displaced from Nagorno-Karabakh due to Azerbaijan’s recent attack. The pension, however, will only apply to retirement-age individuals. In addition, this form of assistance will only last until June 2024, meaning individuals will only receive this aid for six months. Finally, the financial amount of the pension will be “calculated according to local legislation,” meaning it is unclear how much financial assistance these ethnic Armenians will actually receive.

There are also further complications. First, the pension will not apply to working-aged individuals. Second, over 100,000 ethnic Armenians have fled Nagorno-Karabakh. These refugees will need food, clothing, and shelter. They will also hope to join the workforce. Given this large influx of individuals entering Armenia, it is likely that the country could “encounter substantial difficulties in meeting the needs of the displaced individuals.” This may lead to additional problems for the Armenian government. Why might this be the case?

According to the World Bank, the unemployment rate in Armenia in 2022 was 12.6 percent. In addition, the World Food Programme reported that the poverty rate in Armenia in 2022 was 27 percent. Twenty-one percent of the population was also listed as food insecure. In other words, roughly one-fourth of the country lives below the poverty line, and one-fifth of Armenians do not have sufficient access to food to meet their basic needs. Given these challenges, and with the recent influx of Nagorno-Karabakh refugees, this will likely further complicate matters for the Armenian state. Nonetheless, the government is attempting to work through these challenges so that they can take care of these individuals.

Meanwhile, Azerbaijanis are now moving into Nagorno-Karabakh. The Azerbaijani government is working to fully incorporate the region into its territory. It is unclear, however, what this reintegration effort will entail. The Azerbaijani government has also not specified how it will protect ethnic Armenians who did not flee the region during the recent onslaught. Finally, Azerbaijani officials have yet to negotiate the transfer of Nagorno-Karabakh with the Armenians. In other words, while Azerbaijan declared that it has retaken the area, there are many uncertainties about what will happen next.

Overall, the situation in and around Nagorno-Karabakh remains tense. Azerbaijani officials have stated that they have reclaimed the territory and that reintegration efforts will begin, but there is little guidance on how this will occur. Meanwhile, Armenian officials have been faced with a refugee crisis, where they are attempting to help these individuals integrate into their country. At this time, these challenges remain unresolved, and they are being pressed for time as both Armenia and Azerbaijan prepare for what may be a brutal winter.

Time is running out to help the current and displaced citizens of Nagorno-Karabakh. With the unsuccessful attempts by the international community to try and resolve the conflict, individuals from the region have sadly become victims of this forgotten war. The international community has failed them, and this injustice should not be overlooked. Such inaction cannot happen again.

Mark Temnycky is an accredited freelance journalist covering Eurasian affairs and a nonresident fellow at the Atlantic Council’s Eurasia Center. He can be found on X @MTemnyck

https://nationalinterest.org/feature/nagorno-karabakh-eurasia%E2%80%99s-forgotten-conflict-208007

Ces Arméniennes qui se battent pour sauver leur pays

Marie Claire, France
14 Dec 2023
PAR CATHERINE DURAND
Menacée par l'expansionnisme du puissant Azerbaïdjan, l'Arménie voit ressurgir, à travers le conflit de l'Artsakh (Haut-Karabakh), le spectre du génocide et de l'exode. À Erevan, nos reporters ont recueilli les témoignages de ces femmes qui s'organisent pour aider les milliers de déplacés. Et luttent pour que les exactions ne soient pas passées sous silence.

Dans ce joli café d'Erevan, sur la place Cascade, Siranouch Sargsian a commandé un expresso. "Être privée de café, c'est terrible. Ici, dès que j'entre dans un magasin, je revois les enfants affamés et ça me bouleverse", dit-elle les larmes aux yeux. Comme les 120 000 Arménien·nes d'Artsakh, Siranouch a subi le blocus de dix mois, puis l'exode sans retour de cette terre où ils et elles vivaient sans interruption depuis 3000 ans. Une épuration ethnique opérée dans le silence assourdissant de la communauté internationale.

Il faut connaître ses prémices pour comprendre cette tragédie : l'Artsakh, berceau historique de la Grande Arménie, a été rattachée à l'Azerbaïdjan par Staline en 1921. À la chute de l'Union soviétique en 1991, cette enclave chrétienne peuplée à 95 % d'Arménien·nes proclame son indépendance. Plusieurs guerres s'ensuivent avec l'Azerbaïdjan : victorieuse d'un premier conflit en 1994, l'Artsakh perd ensuite les trois quarts de son territoire à l'issue de la "Guerre des 44 jours" en 2020. Le corridor de Latchine, véritable ligne de vie pour les habitant·es de l'enclave, est alors placé sous la garde d'une force d'interposition envoyée par Moscou.

"Je n'étais plus un être humain"

"Des milliers de personnes ont été déplacées, mon immeuble à Stepanakert était peuplé de réfugiés, raconte Siranouch. À partir de 2021, plus aucun étranger ne passait la frontière, l'information était bloquée, on vivait dans un ghetto. Professeure d'histoire, j'ai décidé de devenir journaliste pour témoigner et oublier mon chagrin [elle a tenu son journal de guerre sur X (ex-Twitter), ndlr]".

La victoire ayant un goût d'inachevé, Ilham Aliev, le président azerbaïdjanais, envoie son armée verrouiller progressivement l'accès au corridor de Latchine en décembre 2022. "Ils ont coupé le gaz et l'électricité, poursuit Siranouch. On a survécu avec des bons alimentaires, sans essence, les gens se déplaçaient à cheval. Dès le premier jour, les Azéris nous ont terrorisés. Peu à peu privée de tout, je n'étais plus un être humain. Et puis le 19 septembre, le silence imposé par le blocus a été brisé par les explosions. Quand les soldats azéris sont entrés dans Stepanakert, j'ai dû partir, j'étais une cible."

Elle quitte à jamais son appartement et sa vie confortable, un sac sous le bras. "J'ai pris mon ordi, mes boucles d'oreilles, mes beaux vêtements, et des livres. Après trente heures d'enfer jusqu'à la frontière, je suis enfin arrivée en Arménie. Je n'avais rien avalé depuis trois jours, j'ai compris que j'étais devenue une réfugiée quand un humanitaire m'a tendu un repas." Elle ne le sait pas mais ce premier repas chaud a été préparé par la célèbre cheffe libano-arménienne Aline Kamakian.

"Dès qu'ils ont ouvert le corridor de Goris après les bombardements, je m'y suis précipitée, raconte cette dernière. Avec le World Central Kitchen (WCK) et l'Union générale arménienne de bienfaisance (UGAB), nous avons mis en place tout un système pour offrir plusieurs milliers de repas chauds par jour, des repas goûteux avec 150g de protéines minimum. J'ai craqué plusieurs fois en voyant des femmes enceintes maigres comme des cure-dents, des enfants affamés, déshydratés, dont certains pleuraient leur mère morte dans l'exode. Ces gens ont tout perdu : leur terre, leur histoire, leurs biens, même la tombe de leur fils mort au combat. Aujourd'hui, nous ne sommes plus dans l'urgence mais nous devons les aider jusqu'à ce qu'ils puissent s'intégrer."

Personne ne bouge, ni le Pape, ni l'Union européenne.

C'est désormais à Erevan, dans de vastes locaux, que s'organisent la préparation et la distribution à la fois de repas chauds et de boîtes alimentaires dans les villes où ont été relocalisé·es les réfugié·es de l'Artsakh. Petite-fille de rescapé·es du génocide de 1915, au cours duquel un 1 200 000 Arménien·nes de Turquie furent exterminé·es, Aline Kamakian ne décolère pas : "J'ai grandi avec ce bagage d'histoires atroces pensant que sans télévision ni Internet, on avait pu ignorer ce qu'il se passait. Mais aujourd'hui, tout est en 'live' et personne ne bouge, ni le Pape, ni l'Union européenne dont la présidente Ursula von der Leyen achète du gaz aux Azéris, en fait le gaz russe bloqué par les sanctions économiques. Elle donne ainsi carte blanche à ce dictateur fou d'Aliev !".



Livre: Karabakh, couloir des oubliés

Dec 2023
On December 3, 1991, under the stars of Talish, a small village in Armenian Nagorno-Karabakh, three children were born. Atom, his twin sister Sona and little Samvel. Throughout History, they attempt to write their own. From drama to drama, from war to war, the three children navigate a chaotic path while preserving their complicity, their friendship, their love. Sometimes History is stronger than life, to the point of stifling the most beautiful feelings. From Talish in Karabakh, to Talin in Armenia, they avoid bombs, rockets, traps set by culture, religion, geopolitics… Until when? 1991-2023, thirty-two years, barely enough time for the flower of life to bloom, thirty-two years on the time scale, the moment of a sigh, that of Armenia in tears for centuries. Thirty-two years during which many regions, countries, cultures will have to endure the inconsistencies, the intolerances, the absurdities of a humanity constantly searching for its own.

https://actualitte.com/livres/1577433/karabakh-couloir-des-oublies-laurent-robert-9782375221624

Armenian PM optimistic about peace agreement with Azerbaijan

MEHR News Agency, Iran
Dec 14 2023

TEHRAN, Dec. 14 (MNA) – Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan said a peace treaty with Azerbaijan could be signed soon if Baku reaffirms the principles coordinated between the leaders of the two South Caucasus countries.

"If Azerbaijan reaffirms the given principles, a peace agreement could be signed soon," Pashinyan said, addressing the opening ceremony for a ministerial meeting of landlocked countries, TASS reports.

The Armenian premier also mentioned Yerevan’s three key principles, namely the reopening of regional transport links while upholding the national sovereignty of the countries involved; public recognition of the territorial integrity of Armenia and Azerbaijan on land areas of 29,800 square km and 86,600 square km, respectively; and the delimitation of the border based on the final maps of the area published before the demise of the Soviet Union.

"Yesterday’s exchange of POWs makes us optimistic that [a] peace [agreement] could be signed soon," Pashinyan added.

On Wednesday, Armenia’s head of government wrote on his page on Facebook that Baku had handed over 32 Armenian prisoners of war to Yerevan based on a joint agreement between his government and the administration of Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev.

SD/PR

https://en.mehrnews.com/news/209592/Armenian-PM-optimistic-about-peace-agreement-with-Azerbaijan

Armenpress: Foreign Minister Mirzoyan congratulates Georgia, Ukraine and Moldova on progress towards EU membership

 00:05,

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 15, ARMENPRESS. Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan has congratulated Georgia, Ukraine and Moldova on progress towards EU membership.
"I congratulate my counterparts from Georgia, Ukraine and Moldova Ilia Darchiashvili, Dmytro Kuleba and Nicu Popescu and the people of three countries for landmark decisions by EUCO.

 This is a historic day for the European family, for those sharing democratic principles," Mirzoyan posted on X. 

On December 14, the European Council made a decision to grant Georgia the status of a candidate for EU membership, and to start negotiations on EU membership with Ukraine and Moldova.



Armenia’s Hayk Martirosyan sole leader in the European Rapid and Blitz Chess Championship

 10:48,

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 15, ARMENPRESS. Grandmaster Hayk Martirosyan is the sole leader in the European Rapid and Blitz Chess Championship 2023.

Haik Martirosyan has won the first 6 rounds of the tournament being  in Zagreb, the capital of Croatia.

150 chess players are taking part in the European Rapid and Blitz Chess Championship. 

The current world bronze medalist in Rapid and Blitz Chess, Hayk Martirosyan is among  the top ten chess players of the tournament

The price of Russian gas for Armenia will remain unchanged in 2024 – Deputy PM Grigoryan

 13:58,

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 15, ARMENPRESS. The price of Russian gas for Armenia will not change in 2024. Accordingly, the tariff for consumers will remain unchanged as well,  Armenian Deputy Prime Minister Mher Grigoryan told "Armenpress".

"As of now, we have clear information that the gas price at the border will not change in 2024. And I am confident,  based on that, the tariff for consumers will stay unchanged, as well," clarified Grigoryan.

According to the Deputy Prime Minister, 'Gazprom Armenia' has already signed a contract with 'Gazprom' for 2024, according to which no price changes are envisaged.

The cost of Russian gas at the border with Armenia is 165 USD per 1000 cubic meters.

Russia supports the implementation of the "Crossroads of Peace" project – Russian Deputy Prime Minister

 15:21,

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 15, ARMENPRESS. The Russian Federation actually supports the implementation of the 'Crossroads of Peace' project presented by Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan, Deputy Prime Minister of the Russian Federation Alexey Overchuk said on December 15 at the intergovernmental session on economic cooperation between the Republic of Armenia and the Russian Federation. 

“We actually support the implementation of the “Crossroads of the World” presented by the Prime Minister of the Republic of Armenia Nikol Pashinyan, financing the construction of the fourth tranche of the North-South road corridor  with the funds from the Eurasian Fund for Stabilization and Development.

The amount of support in this direction now amounts to $150 million. The decision to support the construction of the Kajaran tunnel is now at the stage of agreement between the collegial bodies of the fund. The amount of support  for the tunnel will be $200 million,” Overchuk said.

Negotiations underway for the construction of nuclear power units in Armenia: Overchuk

 15:31,

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 15, ARMENPRESS. The Armenian and Russian parties are currently negotiating regarding the construction of new nuclear power units in Armenia, Deputy Prime Minister of the Russian Federation Alexey Overchuk said on December 15 at the intergovernmental session on economic cooperation between the Republic of Armenia and the Russian Federation. 

The Deputy Prime Minister of the Russian Federation emphasized that cooperation in the field of peaceful uses of nuclear energy is an extremely important topic in relations between Russia and Armenia.

"We are grateful that the decision has been made to extend the term of operation of the Armenian NPP, and the Russian company has been appointed as the executor," Overchuk said.

“As for the new nuclear power units, negotiations are also underway," concluded Russian Deputy Prime Minister.

Prime Minister chairs consultation with the participation of representatives of IT companies

 16:16,

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 15, ARMENPRESS. A consultation was held today chaired by Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan, in which representatives of about 30 large IT companies participated.

Vice President of the National Assembly Hakob Arshakyan, Minister of High-tech Industry Robert Khachatryan, Minister of Finance Vahe Hovhannisyan and other officials also participated in the consultation, the Prime Minister's Office said in a readout.

"At the beginning of the meeting, the Prime Minister noted that the purpose of the consultation is to understand what problems exist in the sector, to find out the effectiveness of the policies implemented by the government for the development of the sector, as well as to discuss the future tasks.

The representatives of the IT sector presented the problems solved in the sector through the programs carried out by the government, presented their ideas on improving the existing regulations, as well as suggestions for long-term solutions of the existing problems in the sector, reads the statement.

According to the source, based on the results of the discussion, the Prime Minister instructed to create a working group, to carry out follow-up work on the raised issues, to develop an effective solution model, to set a timetable and to present it at the next meeting. The Head of the Government emphasized that seeing Armenia as a technological and technologically developed country has been a strategic goal since 2018. "My message is that the government has that political will, and it is a program thesis for us," added the Prime Minister.