Turkish Press: Free elections in Karabakh and the meaning of the Turkic States Organization

Yeni Şafak
Turkey – Feb 10 2024
Free elections in Karabakh and the meaning of the Turkic States Organization
by Ihsan Aktas

After the end of the Cold War, states under the umbrella of Russia's calendar declared their independence one by one. The first place where the fire of independence ignited was Azerbaijan, which declared its independence with great enthusiasm.


Not long after the declaration of independence, a war broke out between Armenia and Azerbaijan, and Armenia occupied one-third of Azerbaijani territory. This period of occupation was a great trauma for the Azerbaijani people. Almost a generation experienced this trauma day by day. During the years of occupation, Azerbaijani youth mourned.


People who moved from Karabakh to Baku and other cities lived a nomadic life and did not largely settle down in the hope of returning to Karabakh one day.


From the days of occupation until today, Azerbaijan has developed economically and had the opportunity to sell oil and natural gas. While they were making their cities prosperous on one hand, they also strengthened their armies on the other hand. During the recovery process, Azerbaijan had a chance, with the spiritual support of one of the world's most sophisticated and powerful armies, like Türkiye, by its side.


In a way, Azerbaijan was focusing on completing its own development day and night, 24/7, while also aiming to reclaim the lost territories.


When Armenian forces attacked Azerbaijan, Azerbaijan initiated a ground war, which turned into an opportunity for them. Within 40 days, Azerbaijan fought an important front-line battle and regained its territory.


Azerbaijan's reclaiming of its own territory also marked a turning point in the geopolitics of the Caucasus. Throughout history, Turks have established great empires around the world. Especially between the 14th and 16th centuries, more than half of the empires in the world were under Turkish rule.


After the Cold War, Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, Turkmenistan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan, and Azerbaijan, that is, each of the Turkic states, occasionally came together. They held some meetings mostly consisting of cultural content.


Türkiye was largely in a position where it was not vocally advocating its full independence, largely adhering to the NATO concept. It was also not in a position to help newly emerged states from the Cold War climate. The death of Turgut Özal was an important loss for the Turkic states.


In the past 30 years, there have been significant changes in the world's conjuncture. Especially in the last decade, the AK Party governments have gradually turned Türkiye into a regional power.


Türkiye completed its infrastructure, made significant developments in the defense industry. It created an influence in Syria, Libya. At the same time, with its sophisticated support in the Karabakh War, it played an important role in changing the fate of the war for Azerbaijan.


At this very moment, the Turkish States Organization occasionally held meetings under the leadership of Türkiye. Until now, this community, which has been almost a cultural union, has also turned into a community with strategic depth and meaning integrity.


The Karabakh War, in a way, reminded the Turkic states that any Turkic state can solve its problems together with its partners. In interstate relations, of course, cultural proximity, language unity, and national unity are important, but the formation of an economic power also contributes to the deepening and meaningfulness of these relations.


One opportunity presented by the Karabakh War to the Turkic states is the direct connection between Türkiye and the Turkic world with the opening of the Zangezur Corridor. The establishment of a land connection and a cultural and geopolitical line stretching from Istanbul to Tashkent is quite valuable.


We went to Baku as observers for the presidential elections in Azerbaijan. On this occasion, we also visited Fuzuli and Shusha, which were liberated from Armenian occupation in Karabakh.


This seems to be due to the culture of Armenian resentment and anger; not a stone was left unturned in the city of Fuzuli. There is hardly a single house with a roof or chimney left.


Some buildings in Shusha have managed to survive.


Azerbaijan has launched an investment mobilization in all the provinces of Karabakh with its strong economic structure; roads, new buildings, and settlements…


Ilham Aliyev, staying overnight in Hankendi, one of the most important cities of Azerbaijan, which was once used as the "capital" by the separatist Armenian administration, and casting his vote there with his family, was a very political and symbolic image. This situation is a sign that Azerbaijan will forever keep the territories it has liberated from occupation in its own hands.


At first glance, the Karabakh War may seem like Azerbaijan's liberation of its own territories from Armenian occupation, but essentially it has empowered the Turkic States Organization and deepened its meaning, integrity, and unity. The 40-day Azerbaijan-Armenia War may shape the thousand-year future of the Turkic world.

https://www.yenisafak.com/en/columns/ihsan-aktas/free-elections-in-karabakh-and-the-meaning-of-the-turkic-states-organization-3677243

Aliyev’s representative proposes absurd demands against Armenia reminiscent of medieval expansionism

Feb 10 2024

Azerbaijan continues its unsubstantiated demands on Armenia, as recently demonstrated by Elchin Amirbekov, Azerbaijan’s senior envoy for special assignments. This information is conveyed by Joshua Kucera, a contributor to “Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty” (RFE/RL), in his article titled “As Peace Negotiations Advance, Armenia And Azerbaijan Are Going It Alone.”

As negotiations progress, it becomes increasingly apparent that Azerbaijan’s demands extend beyond reasonable expectations. These demands are not only unsupported by credible evidence but also raise questions about the legitimacy of Azerbaijan’s claims. The lack of transparency in their assertions further complicates the already delicate peace talks, creating a potential obstacle to finding a sustainable resolution.

Upon a preliminary examination of Joshua Kucera’s article, a discernible bias is evident, particularly in the way he introduces the topic before quoting Amirbekov. Kucera asserts that Azerbaijani officials have expressed dissatisfaction with Armenia’s formal claim to Karabakh in its constitution, citing a preamble referring to a 1989 act advocating for the unification of Karabakh with Armenia. While Kucera notes the lack of response from the Armenian Ministry of Foreign Affairs, he includes a statement from Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan on January 25, attempting to link it to the narrative presented by Amirbekov.

“Azerbaijani officials have complained that Armenia continues to stake a claim to Karabakh in its constitution formally, the preamble of which makes reference to a 1989 act calling to unify Karabakh with Armenia.

Amirbayov said there are several other such claims in Armenia’s formal statements and legislation. For example, when Armenia’s legislature ratified the 1991 Alma Ata accords, which accepted Soviet republic borders as the borders of the newly independent states, lawmakers added language saying that it did not apply to Karabakh. He also called attention to language on the Armenian Foreign Ministry website saying that Nagorno-Karabakh is “an integral part of historic Armenia,” and recent Armenian filings in the European Court of Human Rights that imply a claim on Azerbaijan.

“We have pointed the attention of the Armenian side to those facts many times, during our [in-person] negotiations, but also through different exchanges of comments,” he said. “And the Armenian side acknowledges that this is the fact, but nothing is being done…. When they try to cheat, if I may use the word, if they try to put all the blame and the responsibility on our shoulders, and at the same time in the back of their minds still having these territorial claims against us, it’s not going to work,” he said”, Kucera writes in his article, quoting Amirbayov’s words

Upon closer inspection of the article, Amirbekov’s assertions become increasingly dubious. Notably, he claims that the Armenian Ministry of Foreign Affairs website acknowledges Karabakh as an “integral part of historical Armenia.” However, this assertion aligns with historical facts widely accepted within academic circles. Amirbekov’s demand to negate this historical fact appears unreasonable, especially when considering that historical truths should not be subject to revisionist interference based on individual whims. It is worth mentioning that Amirbekov’s ancestors are historically associated with nomadic tribes residing in the steppes of Turkestan until the mid-Middle Ages, a fact supported by numerous academic monographs, establishing it as an accepted and proven historical reality.

Amirbekov’s unfounded statements extend beyond this point. He raises Armenia’s claims against Azerbaijan at the European Court of Human Rights (ECHR), a topic that seems to surpass the boundaries of reasonable discussion, particularly given the substantial evidence of Azerbaijani crimes, including those committed against civilians. Intermediate decisions from the International Court of Justice (ICJ) further affirm the groundlessness of Amirbekov’s accusations. Unfortunately, the article fails to include these crucial facts when describing the Armenian-Azerbaijani negotiation process.

In conclusion, Amirbekov’s position appears devoid of coherence and logical consistency, marked by tendentious and misleading disinformation disseminated by a representative of the Azerbaijani president. The article, in its current form, neglects to provide a balanced perspective and overlooks significant facts that could contribute to a more comprehensive understanding of the ongoing Armenian-Azerbaijani negotiation process. It is imperative to approach such complex geopolitical issues with a commitment to unbiased reporting and a thorough consideration of all relevant information.

By Deputy Editor-in-Chief of “ARMENPRESS”, Ararat Petrosyan. His Twitter.

https://greekcitytimes.com/2024/02/11/aliyevs-representative-proposes-absurd-demands-against-armenia-reminiscent-of-medieval-expansionism/

Armenia’s Pashinyan congratulates new Georgian PM

 15:31, 9 February 2024

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 9, ARMENPRESS. Prime Minister of Armenia Nikol Pashinyan has congratulated the new Georgian Prime Minister Irakli Kobakhidze on assuming office.

“Congratulations to the newly appointed Prime Minister of Georgia Irakli Kobakhidze,” Pashinyan said in a post on X. “I expect the Armenian-Georgian strategic partnership, which is based on the common values, strong friendship and the idea of democracy, to strengthen further.”

The Georgian parliament on Thursday approved Irakli Kobakhidze, the former Chair of the ruling Georgian Dream party, as the Prime Minister of Georgia, following the resignation of PM Irakli Garibashvili.

Armenian Ombudsperson meets with UNICEF Deputy Regional Director

 16:21, 9 February 2024

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 9, ARMENPRESS. Human Rights Defender of Armenia Anahit Manasyan on February 8 in Geneva, Switzerland met with the UNICEF Deputy Regional Director for Europe and Central Asia Octavian Bivol.

UNICEF Representative in Armenia Christine Weigand also participated in the meeting.

The discussion focused on the projects implemented in cooperation between UNICEF and the Human Rights Defender's Office, the existing problems in the field of protection of children's rights and ongoing work to resolve them. Other possible directions of cooperation were also outlined, Manasyan's office said in a readout.

Germany extradites fraud fugitive to Armenia

 16:48, 9 February 2024

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 9, ARMENPRESS. German authorities have approved an extradition request filed by the General Prosecution of Armenia and a fugitive suspected of embezzling over 28,000,000 drams has been handed over to Armenian authorities.

In a statement, the Armenian General Prosecution only released the initials of the fugitive M.M. The fugitive’s transfer to Yerevan was ensured by Armenian police officers.

Central Bank of Armenia: exchange rates and prices of precious metals – 09-02-24

 17:24, 9 February 2024

YEREVAN, 9 FEBUARY, ARMENPRESS. The Central Bank of Armenia informs “Armenpress” that today, 9 February, USD exchange rate up by 0.08 drams to 404.55 drams. EUR exchange rate down by 0.19 drams to 435.46 drams. Russian Ruble exchange rate up by 0.02 drams to 4.45 drams. GBP exchange rate down by 0.55 drams to 509.89 drams.

The Central Bank has set the following prices for precious metals.

Gold price down by 163.19 drams to 26385.80 drams. Silver price up by 0.84 drams to 290.70 drams.

Prime Minister receives the newly appointed Ambassador of Japan to Armenia

 17:55, 9 February 2024

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 9, ARMENPRESS.  Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan received the newly appointed Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary of Japan to Armenia Aoki Yutaka.

The Prime Minister congratulated the Ambassador on assuming the diplomatic mission, attaching importance to the Armenia-Japan cooperation in all fields. In particular, Nikol Pashinyan emphasized the need for consistent development of economic relations and the implementation of consistent steps in that direction. At the same time, the Prime Minister highly valued the cooperation with Japan in the field of crisis management, the PM's Office said.

According to the source, Aoki Yutaka noted that he will make every effort to promote the development of bilateral relations in various directions. The Ambassador emphasized that the government of his country is interested in the "Crossroads of Peace" project presented by the Armenian government.

The interlocutors exchanged ideas on various issues of mutual interest.

Prime Minister Pashinyan wished the Ambassador an effective work for strengthening the cooperation between the two countries.

BBC Travel publishes article about the Armenian alphabet

 18:38, 9 February 2024

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 9, ARMENPRESS.  BBC Travel has published an article about the Armenian alphabet. Sugato Mukherjee, the author of the article entitled “How a 1,600-year-old alphabet shaped Armenian identity", has noted that the Armenian alphabet is not just a writing system, but it's also a numerical system used for mathematical calculations and recording calendar dates, as well as a national point of pride.

In the article, the journalist also has shared his impressions from his visit to the Armenian Alphabet Monument and Matenadaran.

 “I knew that the aesthetically eloquent shapes of Armenian letters, with their long usage in folk art and calligraphy, have made it onto Unesco's Lists of Intangible Cultural Heritage. But I had no idea that the dainty, artistic designs are also imbued with secret codes and cryptographs, and endowed with hidden properties.

All the original 36 letters also have an assigned numerical value based on their order in the alphabet. When arranged in four columns and nine rows, the letters in each column respectively represent digits in singles, tens, hundreds and thousands,’’ writes Mukherjee.

Azerbaijan bought new Akıncı attack drones from Turkey

 19:20, 9 February 2024

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 9, ARMENPRESS. Azerbaijan has purchased new Akinci attack unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) from Turkey, Trend reports.

According to the information, Akinci attack UAVs have already been adopted into the service of the Azerbaijani Army.

It is noted that President of the Republic of Azerbaijan Aliyev and his son Heydar Aliyev have visited the Air Force military facilities and watched the flyover of the Akinci attack UAVs, put into service.

Pashinyan sends congratulatory message to the newly elected Prime Minister of Georgia

 19:25, 9 February 2024

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 9, ARMENPRESS.  Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan sent a congratulatory message to Georgian Prime Minister Irakli Kobakhidze on the occasion of assuming the post of the Head of the Government, the Prime Minister's Office said.

The message states: "I warmly congratulate you on assuming the position of the Head of the Government of Georgia and wish you success in serving this important and responsible mission for the benefit of Georgia and the Georgian people.

The development and deepening of multifaceted cooperation with friendly Georgia is one of the priorities of the Armenian government's foreign policy.

I believe that establishing a strategic partnership between the Republic of Armenia and Georgia will reveal new horizons for further expanding bilateral cooperation in all fields.

I reaffirm the readiness of the Armenian government and myself to cooperate closely with your government for the benefit of our countries and brotherly peoples."