ANKARA: Armenian FM:”We Hope Turkey Opens Its Border During Its EU P

ARMENIAN FM: “WE HOPE TURKEY OPENS ITS BORDER DURING ITS EU PROCESS”
Turkish Press
March 30 2006
Press Review
Milliyet
Armenian Foreign Minister Vartan Oskanian said yesterday that
Yerevan supports establishing diplomatic relations with Turkey. “The
Turkish-Armenian border is the only closed border in Europe,” he
added. “We don’t have any preconditions for opening the border. We
hope Turkey will have to open its border to Armenia during the European
Union process.” Touching on the so-called Armenian genocide, Oskanian
said, “Prime Minister [Recep Tayyip] Erdogan’s proposal was to say
to Europe, ‘We’re following the issue.’ There’s no need to research
the issue again.”

TBILISI: Georgia, Russia To Sign Military Transit,Base Pullout Treat

GEORGIA, RUSSIA TO SIGN MILITARY TRANSIT, BASE PULLOUT TREATIES
Civil Georgia
March 30 2006
On March 31 the Georgian and Russian officials will sign in Russia’s
Black Sea resort of Sochi two agreements – one on timeframe and
modalities of functioning, rules and withdrawal of Russian military
bases from Georgia and another on transit of Russian military personnel
and cargo via Georgia.
Georgian First Deputy Defense Minister Mamuka Kudava will sign these
agreements.
The agreement on withdrawal of the Russian military bases is based
on a joint declaration signed between Russian Foreign Minister Sergey
Lavrov and Georgian ex-Foreign Minister Salome Zourabichvili in May,
2005. Russia has pledged to pull out its military bases from Georgia
by the end of 2008.
The agreement on transit of military personnel and cargo will enable
Russia to gain access to its military base in Gyumri, Armenia via
Georgia.
According to the Russian sources transit agreement obliges Russia to
not transfer any armament transited through the Georgian territory to a
third country. The amount of military cargo that will be transited via
Georgia will be agreed between Russia and Georgia one year in advance.
Russia also undertakes the commitment not to transit biological,
nuclear or chemical substances, as well as weapon of mass destruction
or their components.
According to the draft agreement, Georgia can refuse the transit
of items if the movement of the military cargo poses a threat to
its national security or if the final destination of the transited
military cargo is a location within a conflict zone or a warring state.

More Armenian-Azeri Skirmishes Reported

MORE ARMENIAN-AZERI SKIRMISHES REPORTED
By Emil Danielyan
Radio Liberty. Czech Rep.
March 30 2006
Armenia and Azerbaijan have reported fresh exchanges of fire between
their forces which have disrupted a regular international monitoring
of ceasefire around Nagorno-Karabakh and killed at least one soldier.
The Baku-based ANS television said on Thursday that an Azerbaijani
serviceman was shot dead in the westernmost section of the heavily
militarized Armenian-Azerbaijani frontier. The Azerbaijani Defense
Ministry confirmed the report, alleging an Armenian truce violation.
There was no immediate comment from the Armenian side.
The incident was reported from an area that has seen an upsurge in
cross-border skirmishes this month. Both conflicting parties have
reported casualties among their troops, blaming each other for the
fighting that followed the collapse of a crucial Armenian-Azerbaijani
summit held in France on February 10-11.
Tension has also risen along the main Armenian-Azerbaijani line of
contact east of Nagorno-Karabakh. The latest Azerbaijani casualty
was reported the day after a disruption of ceasefire monitoring
by the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe in the
northeastern section of the Karabakh frontline.
The Armenian Defense Ministry said on Wednesday that OSCE field
observers accompanied by Karabakh officials came under Azerbaijani
gunfire as they were about to carry out what has become a routine
procedure. “Due to a lack of security guarantees from the Azerbaijani
side, Ambassador Andrzej Kasprzyk postponed the monitoring,” the
ministry spokesman, Colonel Seyran Shahsuvarian, told RFE/RL, referring
to the longtime head of the OSCE military mission in the conflict zone.
The Azerbaijani side claimed the opposite, however. The Interfax
news agency quoted an Azerbaijani military spokesman as saying that
Kasprzyk “heard shots fired from the Armenian section of the border
and ordered that monitoring be cancelled.” The OSCE official has not
yet commented on the conflicting statements from Baku and Yerevan.
Meanwhile, Azerbaijan’s dovish Foreign Minister Elmar Mammadyarov was
quoted by ANS as saying that the latest fighting only demonstrates
that the Karabakh conflict is far from being frozen. “Azerbaijani and
Armenian soldiers are killed every week,” Mammadyarov said, adding
that the conflict should therefore be resolved “as soon as possible.”

Diaspora Scholar Warns Of Armenian ‘Failed State’

DIASPORA SCHOLAR WARNS OF ARMENIAN ‘FAILED STATE’
By Ruzanna Stepanian
Radio Liberty. Czech Rep.
March 30 2006
A renowned U.S. academic of Armenian descent launched on Thursday
a scathing attack on the authorities in Yerevan, saying that their
failure to hold free elections and respect political freedoms threatens
to turn Armenia into a “failed state.”
Richard Hovannisian, a senior professor of Armenian and Near Eastern
History at the University of California, Los Angeles (UCLA), claimed
that domestic policies pursued by the administration of President
Robert Kocharian have alienated a large part of the country’s
population and the influential Armenian community in the United States.
“Watching from the outside, we follow with pain the continuing
electoral and other illegalities committed in Armenia,” he told RFE/RL
in an interview. “We would have loved to see freedom of speech and
thought in Armenia, instead of repression, secret police persecution
and lies spread by state media.”
Hovannisian, who is arguably the most famous of Armenian-American
historians, believes that in some respects Armenia is now an even less
democratic state than Turkey, its historical foe regularly castigated
by the West for its poor human and civil rights record.
“Sometimes we condemn Turkey and call it a military dictatorship. But
the fact is that the press is freer there,” he said.
The remark is extraordinary for a scholar who has spent several
decades researching the 1915 Armenian genocide in the Ottoman
Empire and campaigning for its recognition by modern-day Turkey
and the international community. Hovannisian serves on the board
of directors of nine scholarly and civic organizations, including
the International Institute on the Holocaust and Genocide and the
Washington-based Armenian National Institute. He also became in 1990
the first foreign social scientist to be elected a member of Armenia’s
National Academy of Sciences.
Hovannisian did not deny that his perception of the Kocharian
administration has been significantly affected by its controversial
treatment of his equally famous son Raffi who served as independent
Armenia’s first foreign minister and is now a leading opposition
figure. His opposition party called Zharangutyun (Heritage) was
locked out of its Yerevan offices this month in what he considers a
retaliation for his harsh attacks on Kocharian voiced late last year.
In a separate development, Armenian state television accused Raffi
Hovannisian’s wife earlier this year of illegally using U.S.
government assistance to Armenia to finance opposition rallies in
Yerevan. She strongly denied the charges.
“If Raffi Hovannisian had kept silent, acted like a ‘benign’ Diaspora
Armenian here and did not attempt to engage in politics, they would
have not only kept his office open but also accepted and shown him
on their television,” said Richard Hovannisian. “I feel sorry for
the individuals who are now suppressing him. If they had been in
his place, they would not have even thought about moving to Armenia
[from the United States in 1990].”
The veteran scholar claimed that his critical views on
Armenia’s current leadership are shared by a growing number of
Armenian-Americans. “I personally know dozens of individuals who say
that they will not donate money to Armenia anymore because they have
lost faith,” he said.
Leaders of the Armenian communities in the U.S. and elsewhere in
the world rarely speak out on internal political developments in
Armenia and publicly criticize its government’s controversial actions,
preferring instead to concentrate on international recognition of the
Armenian genocide. Accordingly, problems like government corruption
or vote falsifications have rarely been on the agenda of conferences
discussing ways of strengthening ties between Armenia and its Diaspora.
Perj Zeytuntsian, a Diaspora-born Armenian novelist and playwright,
deplored this situation during a roundtable discussion in Yerevan last
August. “We must constantly hear friendly statements like ‘What the
hell are you guys doing?’ That’s what is missing in the Diaspora,”
he complained.
“They really avoid publicly criticizing [the Armenian government],”
said Hovannisian. “Perhaps that is a consequence of the genocide. We
suffered so many losses that we do not want to jeopardize the remaining
small territory called Armenia.”
“But we must not become a failed state. If this state also fails,
we will have no future,” he added. “As long as our rulers fail to
realize that they are not on the right track, that they must accept
the people’s will, that they must allow political freedoms, I won’t
be able to say that there will be positive change in this country.”

Belmont Library Hosts Chamber Music Concert

BELMONT LIBRARY HOSTS CHAMBER MUSIC CONCERT
Lexington Minuteman, MA
March 30 2006
Pianist Levon Hovsepian and cellist Arkady Beletsky will present
an afternoon concert of chamber music at 2 p.m. Sunday, April 2,
at the Belmont Public Library, 336 Concord Ave. The free concert,
which will be held in the Assembly Room, is sponsored by the Friends
of the Library as part of the Music on Sunday series.
Hovsepian and Beletsky, who are both on the faculty of the Indian Hill
Music Center in Littleton, will perform works by Bach, Beethoven,
Brahms, Arutunian, Prokofiev, and Popper. Hovsepian also teaches at
the Powers Music School in Belmont.
Both Hovsepian and Beletsky began performing professionally as
children and achieved performing careers overseas before moving to
the Boston area. A graduate of the Komitas Conservatory in Soviet
Armenia, Hovsepian performed throughout Armenia, Estonia and Moldova
and appeared as a soloist with the Yerevan Symphony Orchestra and
on Armenian national television. After attracting major critical
attention in Armenia, he was invited to study at the Longy School
of Music in Cambridge. He made his New York debut in 1994 and became
known for his compelling interpretive style and expansive technique.
He was a prize winner at the Arlington Concerto Competition and has
appeared as a soloist with the Salem Philharmonic Orchestra, the New
England Philharmonic Orchestra, WGBH radio, and Moscow Radio.
Beletsky was born in Kiev, Ukraine and completed his master’s degree in
music at the Gnesin Institute of Music in Moscow. In 1983 he founded
the Renaissance Chamber Ensemble, which rose to prominence as one of
the most prolific and well-regarded chamber groups in pre-Perestroika
Russia, headlining over 1,000 concerts throughout the 15 republics
of the Soviet Union. In 1989 Beletsky emigrated to the U.S. with his
family. Since then, he has performed solo, chamber and orchestral work
at Jordan Hall, Sanders Theater and Mechanics Hall, has participated
in numerous music festivals, and has made a live appearance on WGBH’s
“Morning Pro Musica.”
For more information about the concert, please call 617-489-2000,
ext. 2870.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Islam’s Uncertain Future

ISLAM’S UNCERTAIN FUTURE
Christianity Today
March 30 2006
Paul Marshall, a senior fellow at Freedom House’s Center for Religious
Freedom, is also the editor of Radical Islam’s Rules: The Worldwide
Spread of Extreme Shari’a Law (Rowman & Littlefield Publishers,
2005). Stan Guthrie, a Christianity Today senior associate editor
and author of Missions in the Third Millennium: 21 Key Trends for
the 21st Century, interviewed Marshall.
You distinguish between two kinds of Shari’ah, or Islamic law, as
understood and implemented by Muslims worldwide. What are they?
In the last three years, I’ve been to various parts of the Muslim
world talking to people about Shari’ah. I use the term extreme
Shari’ah for the sorts of things that happen in Saudi Arabia, Iran, or
Pakistan-people getting accused of blasphemy or stoned for adultery,
and so on. But most Muslims use the term in a very broad sense. In
Indonesia, if you ask people, “Do you think women should be stoned
to death for adultery?” more than 80 percent of the population says
no. If you ask, “Is it okay for Indonesia to have a woman leader?” more
than 90 percent of the population says yes, that’s fine. So they have
something very different in mind from the Taliban.
You get similar results right now in Iraq. [When asked,] “Do you
think Iraq should be governed by Islamic law?” about 80 percent
say yes. If you ask, “Do you think there should be legal equality
between men and women?” about 80 percent say yes. For many Muslims,
the term Shari’ah has a very broad sense that the country should be
governed in a way that God wants.
So most Muslims would not agree that, say, the punishment for theft
should be amputation of one’s hand?
Correct. They see that as something that used to be done, but not
really fitting for the sorts of societies we live in now, that it’s
not the core of what Islam is about.
Does this attitude point to modernizing tendencies in Islam?
There are modernizing tendencies, but [a larger factor is that] the
vast majority of Muslims in the world live in Africa and Asia, not
in the Middle East. Their views on Islam are not very precise. They
don’t read the Qur’an; they can’t read it.
Does that present an opportunity for extreme Islamists to clarify
the Qur’an for them in a way that would be dangerous for heretics
and adulterers?
Very much so. In countries such as Bangladesh or Indonesia, Islam
historically has been very broad and moderate in outlook. But radical
Islamic preachers, especially from the Gulf, especially funded by Saudi
Arabia, are coming in. They’ve built mosques. They’re providing people,
imams, scholarships. And so you’re getting an increasing radicalization
in these populations that beforehand were more or less theologically
illiterate. People are telling them, “If you want to be a true Muslim,
a good Muslim, a proper Muslim, this is what you should do.” This
means, essentially, that they should start imitating Saudis.
How did extreme Shari’ah spread across the world?
In 1975, only one major country practiced these types of laws: Saudi
Arabia. Beginning in 1979, you had the overthrow in Iran of the Shah
by Ayatollah Khomeini, and Iran began to institute similar laws.
There are differences: Iran is Shiite; Saudi Arabia is Sunni. But in
terms of the hudud laws, the criminal laws, which involve amputation,
crucifixion, stoning, and so on, they’re very similar in outlook. In
both cases, the status of women is very, very poor. The status of
minorities is very, very poor.
Within Pakistan, the growth of such laws has been gradual. Through the
1980s, [we’ve seen] the increased influence of Shari’ah law, especially
under General [Muhammad] Zia-ul-Haq, and the introduction of blasphemy
laws for anybody insulting God, the Qur’an, or the Prophet Muhammad.
Beginning in 1983 in Sudan, the National Islamic Front, an offshoot
of the Muslim Brotherhood in Egypt, came into power. It instituted an
extremely draconian form of Shari’ah. It executed people who opposed
these laws on the grounds that opposing its type of Shari’ah was itself
against Shari’ah. That was one of the factors that precipitated the
civil war between the largely Arab, Muslim northern Sudan and the
largely black, African Christian south. In Chechnya, southern Russia,
rebels have been trying to imitate the Sudanese legal code.
How did it come to Nigeria?
Beginning in 1995, the state of Zamfara began to institute these types
of laws. Of 36 states in the country, 12 of them now have these types
of laws on the books. Some are much more severe than others.
But essentially this has happened right across the northern swath
of Nigeria, and there’s increased pressure in the central areas
of Nigeria.
In nearly all of these countries [Iran, Pakistan, Sudan, and Nigeria],
some form of Islamic law had been operating already . laws governing
marriage, divorce, inheritance, and family law. But when I talk
about the spread of Shari’ah, I mean that they changed the criminal
code. They changed the law of evidence within the courts so that
evidence from men and women was given different weight. They segregated
public transportation systems so that unmarried men and women could
not travel together, and so on. It’s a quantum leap in the expression
of Islam.
Has this extreme form of Islam spread elsewhere?
No other countries have adopted it wholesale. In fact, Malaysia has
resisted these types of Shari’ah. In the last ten years, the two
northern states tried to institute these laws. Because Malaysia is
a federation, the federal government has the power to strike down
these laws, and it has. But still, people in those two states have
been arrested for blasphemy. Even though [such treatment] is strictly
illegal, [local] governments can usually find a way to put someone
in prison. Similarly, in Indonesia, there has been strong resistance
at the national level to these types of laws. But at a town level or
a county level, more extreme groups are starting to implement the laws.
Indonesia is a big, sprawling country, and in lots of pockets around
the country, people carry out the laws in their own way. You get
vigilantes operating. In parts of western Java, someone driving a
car on a Friday afternoon, Muslim or Christian, may get [his or her]
car stoned.
You’ll also find this going on in Bangladesh. It’s not the government
doing this, but if you’re in poor, remote areas, you’ll often find
yourself subject to these laws.
What has been the impetus to spread extreme Shari’ah over the last
30 years?
In many of these countries, economically they have not been doing
well. There’s also extremely widespread corruption. Islamist parties,
when they have campaigned, have spoken of poverty. They’ve also
pointed out, correctly, the tremendous corruption. They’ve said,
“The reason for our poverty, the reason our country is not doing well,
is that we are not good Muslims. If we were truly faithful, if we were
strict Muslims, we would do much better.” They also say, “We’re very
committed Muslims. We will not be corrupt.” And a lot of the support
for more extreme forms of Islam comes from people who think, While they
may be much too strict for me, at least they’re going to be honest. I
won’t have to pay a bribe for every single thing I need in life.
Another reason is, again, the export of Muslim missionaries and
literature from Saudi Arabia and Iran.
What percentage of the Muslim world supports extreme Shari’ah?
The percentages are very hard to come by. In Indonesia, people who
support more radical Islamist parties make up about 13 percent or
14 percent of the population. Back in 1983, the National Islamic
Front received about 12 percent of the vote in Sudan. In Pakistan,
the numbers are similar. In Nigeria, support has been much higher,
but mainly, I think, because of anti-corruption motivations. You’re
probably looking worldwide at 10 percent to 15 percent of the
population.
Would that include support for Al Qaeda?
Not necessarily. Certainly, some of those people would. Perhaps
10 percent or 15 percent-that’s a broad estimate, a guess-want to
institute the type of society that Al Qaeda wants. Think of the
Taliban. Think of Iran. Think of Saudi Arabia. Many of them push for
that peacefully. The 10 percent or 15 percent are people who share
the goal, but not the means. They may applaud Al Qaeda. If you ask
them if they like [Osama] bin Laden, very often the answer is yes.
He’s widely admired. If you say, “Do you support the killing of
prisoners by Zarqawi in Iraq?” they’ll say no. And they might add
there’s no evidence that Al Qaeda does those things. So there’s broad
sympathy. The number who would actively engage in and give money to
such movements would be a couple of percent.
What is the ultimate goal of the Islamists?
There are four points. One is to unite Muslims, who are fragmented
into different countries and faiths, as one political unit. Two is
that they will be governed by a caliph-one political and religious
ruler of the united Muslim world. Three, the area controlled by
Muslims will be ruled by forms of extreme Shari’ah law. A fourth
point, which certainly the terrorists share with some others, is that
the reunited Muslim political grouping would organize to wage war,
jihad, against the rest of the world to continue the expansion of
Islam until it has conquered the whole world.
But while all would like to export it, not all believe in trying to
spread it by war. For the moment, they just want to control their own
area, the places where they live, and try to make sure it’s the form
of Islam they feel is right.
Is Islam a religion of peace?
Islam was often warlike in its first centuries. Islamic rule was
spread by military conquests, so it’s certainly not true that Islam
is a religion of peace in the same way that Quakers or the Amish is
a religion of peace. Conflict and war go back a long way in Islamic
history. But I wouldn’t say that war is a necessary feature of Islam,
that whenever you have Islam, you’re going to have war. Islam has
often been a warlike religion. That does not mean it has to be a
warlike religion now.
Is militant Islam the real Islam?
I speak of existing Islam. That is, what is Islam like now, what are
Muslims like now? I’m not in a position to say what authentic Islam
is. I will say that if you go through the Bible, you will also find
the death penalty for idolatry. You’ll find draconian punishments
for adultery. You will find war in the name of God. I know of almost
no Christians, even the most conservative, who believe that it’s
necessary to do those things in order to be a true Christian. We need
to be careful not to have a double standard. There are certain things
within Christianity, within Judaism, that were for a particular time.
We need to allow Muslims to say the same thing.
Is extremist Islam growing in Europe and North America?
Certainly in Europe. One of the frightening things about Europe is
that the second and third generation immigrants are much more radical
than their parents. You’re not getting assimilation; you’re getting
the opposite. In places such as England, the first generation of
immigrants from Pakistan 30 or 40 years ago came in, got menial jobs,
opened shops, and were sort of marginalized but relatively peaceful.
They wanted to make a success of life. The radicals are their children
and in some cases even their grandchildren. As time goes on in Europe,
the Muslim populations are becoming more radical, and, of course,
the total numbers of Muslims are increasing. This is a frightening
phenomenon for Europeans.
In the United States, the sociology of the Muslim population is very,
very different. In Europe, many Muslim immigrants are low income,
very poor, brought in to do menial jobs. In some ways within the
society, they fill the slot that illegal immigrants fill in the
United States. But in the U.S., our Muslim population tends to be
highly educated. I think more than 60 percent have degrees, and,
in general, they do not live in separate neighborhoods. Whether
radicalism is growing, I don’t know. There are indications it is
among African Americans and in prison populations.
Are Islam and democracy compatible?
Yes, they are. Indonesia and Turkey are among the largest Muslim
populations in the world. They’ve got great problems. Often their
elections have not been that clean. But they are functioning
democracies. Mali in Africa is a very poor country, 99 percent
Muslim. It’s very free and has free and fair elections. Islam and
democracy, as a practical matter, do coexist in the world. The big
problem tends to be in the Arab world. Democracies are very hard to
come by [there].
How does extreme Shari’ah affect Christians when Islamists gain
control? Almost immediately, there are restrictions on the building
or repair of churches or the expansion of Christianity. You must
stay where you are; you must stay in a subordinate position. Second,
churches built without permits get destroyed. Third, Christians
are often accused of blasphemy against Islam or of criticizing
Islam. The pressure becomes very bad indeed. You get a community
that is isolated and marginalized. Preaching the gospel to a Muslim
is very strongly forbidden. That can get you killed. Or, if a Muslim
decides to convert to Christianity or, indeed, to any other religion,
there’s a good chance that he or she will be killed as an apostate.
How should Christians under such pressure respond?
It will depend on the situation. If you’re in a situation of severe
threat, such as in Iran or Afghanistan, you keep your head down and
simply manage the best you can. In situations where there are greater
possibilities for change, such as Pakistan or Egypt, the Christian
community becomes more outspoken. In Nigeria, there has been violent
resistance by Christian bodies. Much of the violence consists of
attacks by Muslims on Christians, but there are attacks the other
way around as well. Then you have Sudan, in which-partly because of
Shari’ah-the Christians and others have waged war to resist control by
radical Islam. You see quite a range of options going on, and which
one is right will very much depend on the circumstances. You have to
make a judgment on what is possible.
So is taking up arms sometimes justifiable for Christians in your view?
Oh, yes, very much so. The Armenians have a long history of doing that,
also the Ethiopians. These are areas where Christians still control
territories and have often fought to maintain them. The defense through
arms of a community and territory may well be a legitimate option,
and that was the case in southern Sudan. The government was, in fact,
waging a genocidal war, and the result could very likely have been
the extermination of the Christian community.
That’s happened in many other places, such as Central Asia. I think
on just-war grounds that can certainly be defended.
What should Western Christians do?
Develop strong relations with the Christian communities in those
areas and find out what they need. Also, cultivate relations with
Muslims in those countries and elsewhere to raise these questions.
But remember that it’s much more important for Muslims and Christians
to talk locally. Muslims in the Middle East should talk to Christians
in the Middle East.
As you look at the spread of extreme Shari’ah law and some of the
tensions within Islam, are you hopeful or pessimistic?
If we’re talking about the next few decades, I’m pessimistic. The
influence of extreme forms of Islam and Shari’ah appear to be
growing. Radical sentiment as a whole seems to be on the increase in
the Muslim world. It’s still a minority, but the people pushing for
it are committed, organized, well funded, and have clear goals. The
people who are opposed to them are often not well funded, organized,
or committed, and they don’t have a clear goal. When you have small,
committed groups and a fairly amorphous majority group, the small,
committed groups can make headway. I see that happening around the
world. Regarding the struggle against radical Islam, to the degree that
it’s a war of ideas, it’s a war that so far the radicals are winning.

Ardshininvestbank To Carry Out Large-Scale Mortgage Crediting Only O

ARDSHININVESTBANK TO CARRY OUT LARGE-SCALE MORTGAGE CREDITING ONLY ON “CLASSIC” TERMS
Noyan Tapan
Mar 30 2006
YEREVAN, MARCH 30, NOYAN TAPAN. The Ardshininvestbank will
carry out a large-scale mortgage crediting only on the “classic”
terms, the chairman of the bank’s board Aram Andreasian told NT
correspondent. According to him, it is envisaged that the minimum
loan repayment periods will make 15 years with quite low interest
rates. He noted that this year the bank does not have enough funds
to provide such loans.

Arman Melikyan: “Discrimination Inadmissible”

ARMAN MELIKYAN: “DISCRIMINATION INADMISSIBLE”
Karine Karapetyan Interviewed
DeFacto Agency, Armenia
March 30 2006
March 23-24 an international scientific-practical conference titled
“Stability Models in the Black Sea – Caucasus Region” initiated by
Free Europe Foundation that became the continuation of a forum held
in Geneva at the end of last year titled “Multiculturalism and Ethno
Political models of the XXI Century” was conducted in Sochi. The
Sochi conference’s principal goal was to determine democratic and
internationally recognized bases of the stability models’ formation.
The issue of applicability of the Kosovo settlement’s experience
in the context of the conflicts in Abkhazia, the South Ossetia,
Nagorno Karabakh and Pridnestrovie was discussed at the conference
as a separate subject.
The delegations of Russia, Ukraine, Moldova, Serbia, Georgia, Armenia,
Nagorno Karabakh, the South Ossetia, Abkhazia, Pridnestrovie and
Kosovo participated in the conference. The NKR President’s Foreign
Policy Advisor Arman Melikyan and the NKR President’s Assistant David
Babayan represented the Nagorno Karabakh Republic.
Arman Melikyan told DE FACTO about the conference’s details.
– In my opinion, the idea of such a conference’s convocation
testifies to the fact that Russia has finally decided to regulate its
foreign policy in the South, including the Caucasus. The problems of
unrecognized states, as well as various issues referring to security
sphere, relations between unrecognized states and, provisionally
speaking, their former parent states were discussed in the course
of the conferences initiated by Free Europe Foundation in Geneva and
Sochi. All the issues were also considered in the context of Russia’s
foreign policy. The Russian party was interested in our vision of
Russia’s role in the conflicts’ settlement, which testified to the
search for new approaches and new ideas. Besides, there was interest
in discussing outlooks of settlement of the situation in Kosovo in the
context of an approach voiced by President Putin concerning universal
nature of the Kosovo settlement model. We have always said that any
conflict is unique. From the viewpoint the Kosovo approach can hardly
be applied to other conflicts. And yet, unless independence of Kosovo
is recognized, should we deny our independence then?
– According to the mass media information, representatives of
Azerbaijan turned down an invitation having learned about the Karabakh
experts’ participation.
– The Caucasian Institute for Democracy Development Foundation Vice
President Midhat Sadekov took part in the conference. I do not know
whether he can be considered a representative of Azerbaijan. The
Sadekov’s report was a sort of compilation of the Azeri politicians’
approaches to the Nagorno Karabakh issue, though it was reserved
enough.
– What is your opinion concerning a communique published on the
meeting’s results?
– It is a text, which mainly reflects the organizers’ opinion. We
expressed principal disagreement over a number of issues, in part,
on an item referring to the necessity of observing sane balance
between the principle of territorial integrity and the nations’
right to self-determination. It is absurd to speak about sane balance
in the context of the present realities. The thing is that in the
course of all the conflicts the former parental states used force,
which is criminal. In any state a conflict breaks out as a result of
the authorities’ inability to prevent from the conflict situation,
which ought to be resolved by political means. March of history
is irreversible, and Azerbaijan will have to be tolerant to change
of realities that have also been caused by the Azeri authorities’
incapacity. At present Azerbaijan does not have legal or moral
arguments to state Nagorno Karabakh can become a part of Azerbaijan.
We have chosen our way of independent development and we’ll go on
adhering to it, especially taking into consideration that the threat
to our citizens’ life is deepening. Nowadays Azerbaijan does not speak
about peace; it speaks only about a war. The country’s leadership
has actually deprived itself of possibility of searching for peaceful
decisions. So I think the search for the issue’s political settlement
is very complicated both for the conflict parties and the mediators.
– In the report made at the forum you criticize the mediators’
approaches. Do you consider their approaches to the Karabakh issue
settlement to be blind-alley?
-It is criticism of the approaches being voiced not only by the OSCE
Minsk group, but various international NGOs as well. Such approaches
deprive the Armenians of the former Azeri SSR of the possibility to
search for justice anywhere. About 500 000 people are just excluded
from the negotiation process. And yet, the people’s fate, their
perished relatives, lost property is not discussed at all. The issue
is simply not in the negotiations’ agenda. Hundreds of thousands of
Azeris that have left their homes due to initiation of hostilities
against Nagorno Karabakh by Azerbaijan are present instead. We have
repeatedly stated that we consider the Azeris (about 25-30 thousand
of them), which used to live on the territory, within the frames
of which the NKR has been formed, to be our potential citizens. If
they recognize their citizenship and wish to return to Karabakh, they
may construct their lives equally to all the NKR citizens. However,
it cannot concern those hundreds of thousand of people who left with
the retreating Azeri troops from the territories, which are under
our jurisdiction today. Their considerable part participated in the
military operations against the NKR. Then the territorial fighting
units were formed in the territories adjoining our borders.
It is impossible to speak about the Azeris that have become internally
displaced persons without resolving the Armenian refugees’ problems. I
believe there is some discrimination, asymmetry in the approach.
– In your report you also state the necessity of compensation
of material and moral losses caused to the Armenian refugees and
consider granting the territories presently controlled by the NKR in
their property as a compensation resource. Which mechanisms can be
applied here?
– There are accepted economical mechanisms. I believe in case
Azerbaijan refuses to make compensation to the Armenian refugees –
former citizens of the Azeri SSR – our state may have the right to
grant land to them at the expense of the territories we control at
present. It is a just approach. We will have to precisely formalize
our sovereignty over the territories, for presently only the Nagorno
Karabakh Republic can guarantee safe residence there.
I think the legal issue should be widely discussed. And yet it is
not just the issue of compensation. The territories controlled by
the NKR are a security zone. The world practice has witnessed a lot
of cases of the kind. For instance, in avoidance of Germany’s world
aggression in the future a number of territories were separated from it
after the World War II. The conception may be applied to Azerbaijan,
especially in the context of bloating military budget being declared
and continuous militarist statements. Military rhetoric presumes an
adequate reply.
In my opinion, Azerbaijan’s consent to get a dialogue under way with
Karabakh will be a real step in the direction of settlement. Until
Azerbaijan has granted its consent, its actions are just imitation, and
we should be aware of the fact. We cannot always wait for Azerbaijan
to decide that it is time to talk with Karabakh. Hundreds of thousands
of our compatriots living in the CIS territory are deprived of any
legal status today. By the way, neither Armenia nor Karabakh has made
a point of them. I consider we should devote attention to them and
carry on consecutive work to achieve the aim.

New Tensions Complicate Relations Between Baku And Tehran

NEW TENSIONS COMPLICATE RELATIONS BETWEEN BAKU AND TEHRAN
By Fariz Ismailzade
Regnum, Russia
March 30 2006
More than 600 representatives of Azerbaijani diaspora organizations
in 49 countries assembled in Baku on March 16 for the second World
Azerbaijani Congress. The event was organized by the State Committee
on the Affairs of Azerbaijanis Living Abroad, which was established
in 2003 by a decree from then-President Heydar Aliyev to help unite
all Azerbaijanis abroad.
The event was grandiose both in scale and impact. The goal of showing
the unity of millions of Azerbaijanis around the world for the sake
of an independent, strong, and prosperous Azerbaijan was achieved.
The Congress discussed issues regarding coordination among the
Azerbaijani diaspora organizations, strengthening relations with other
nations’ diaspora organizations, promoting information about Azerbaijan
around the world, and building relations with foreign governments.
As a result of the Congress’ work, a new strategy was developed
regarding the activities of the Azerbaijani diaspora in other countries
and the joint activities of the Azerbaijani and Turkish diaspora
organizations. Moreover, Congress participants adopted a resolution
addressed to Azerbaijanis around the world, foreign governments,
and international organizations regarding Armenian aggression toward
Azerbaijan.
Yet, the Congress made news not so much for its work, but for a row
that erupted between Azerbaijan and Iran after the Congress. The
Iranian ambassador to Azerbaijan, Afshar Suleymani, reacted
very angrily and emotionally to the speeches given at the World
Azerbaijani Congress by some representatives of Azerbaijani diaspora
organizations in Europe. These delegates called for the unification
of North Azerbaijan (the independent Republic of Azerbaijan) and South
Azerbaijan (in northern Iran, populated by Azerbaijanis and considered
by Azerbaijanis as part of a once-unified Azerbaijani state). The
speech by Javad Derekhti, an Azerbaijani from the Iranian Azerbaijan,
was particularly provocative, because he talked about human rights
violations suffered by ethnic Azerbaijanis in Iran (Trend News Agency,
March 16).
The Treaty of Turkmanchai in 1828, which ended the three-decade
Russian-Iranian War eventually divided Azerbaijan into two parts
along the banks of the Araz River. It is estimated that more than 25
million ethnic Azerbaijanis currently live in Iran, but they have no
rights to be educated in their native language and any attempts to
organize movements for cultural autonomy are strongly repressed by
the authorities in Tehran. Iran is extremely touchy about this issue
and has kept its distance from official Baku for most of the 1990s
exactly because of the issue of Azerbaijani separatism in Iran.
Suleymani tore into these speeches in a press release from the Iranian
embassy on March 17. “Iran is deeply upset about the participation
of some anti-Iranian elements in the Congress and their provocative
statements on the issues of Iran’s domestic affairs,” it read. “The
Embassy considers these steps to contradict the friendly relations
between the brotherly nations and those commitments taken by the
Azerbaijani government in the treaty of 2002, sighed in Tehran. The
Embassy is very surprised about the references at the Congress
to the Turkmanchai Treaty of 1828 and mentioning Azerbaijan as a
divided country.”
The Iranian Foreign Ministry also sent a protest note to the
Azerbaijani ambassador in Iran. The row intensified after remarks
by the Iranian ambassador regarding Azerbaijani poets Nizami and
Shahriyar, whom he called “Iranian poets.” This caused an immediate
protest from the Azerbaijani Writers Union, saying, “The Union deeply
regrets and is surprised that the ambassador made such remarks and
demands an immediate end to such uneducated discoveries” (APA News
Agency, March 24).
The Azerbaijani Ministry of Foreign Affairs reacted to the Iranian
ambassador’s complaints by asking him to calm his emotions. Speaking
at a press conference the next day, Tahir Tagi-zadeh, the head of
the informational department of the Azerbaijani Ministry of Foreign
Affairs said, “The speeches made at the World Azerbaijani Congress
by representative of the public organizations are their personal
opinions. The emotional speeches of the ambassadors might spoil
the cooperation based on the principles of friendship and good
neighborliness” (day.az, March 17).
Nazim Ibrahimov, head of the State Committee on the Affairs of
Azerbaijanis Living Abroad, also downplayed the significance of
speeches, saying they were private opinions of Congress participants.
“The State Committee has functioned for three years already, and we
have never interfered in the internal issues of Iran” he explained
(AzTV, March 20).
The issue continues to be a hot topic of discussion in the local
press, with a majority of Azerbaijani politicians and intelligentsia
condemning the actions of the Iranian ambassador and calling for a
renewed discussion of the human rights situation of Azerbaijanis in
Iran. Yet some diplomats and experts in the country believe that the
Iranian ambassador’s remarks were intentionally aggressive, meant to
scare off the United States from using the ethnic card to weaken the
regime in Tehran.

BAKU: Azerbaijan Says Soldier Killed On Armenian Border

AZERBAIJAN SAYS SOLDIER KILLED ON ARMENIAN BORDER
Baku Today, Azerbaijan
March 30 2006
Azerbaijan accused Armenia Thursday of breaking a ceasefire and
responsibility for the death of one of its soldiers on their common
border.
“An Azeri soldier was killed during the habitual violations of the
ceasefire by the Armenian side,” the defence ministry said in Baku.
“Azerbaijan’s positions in the Tovuz region were targeted by Armenian
military units from the Berd area,” it said.
The two neighbours, which fought a war in the early 1990s over
Azerbaijan’s mostly Armenian-populated enclave of Nagorno-Karabakh,
regularly charge each other with ceasefire violations.
Azerbaijan accused Armenia on March 7 of causing the death of an
Azeri soldier in the Karabakh region. Armenia quickly denied the
charge and responded with counter-accusations that Azeri troops had
killed an Armenian soldier the previous week.
From: Baghdasarian