EBRD TO IMPLEMENT MORTGAGE CREDITING PROGRAM WITH ARMENIAN BANK
Noyan Tapan
Mar 30 2006
YEREVAN, MARCH 30, NOYAN TAPAN. By late 2006, the European Bank for
Reconstruction and Development (EBRD) will allocate funds to one of
the Armenian commercial banks to carry out mortgage crediting. NT was
informed at the EBRD that negotiations on the program’s implementation
are underway with this bank.
It is envisaged that the annual interest rates of the mortgage loans
to be provided from these resources will make about 12-13%.
Levon Aronian In 10th Place Before Last Tour In “Amber” Tournament
LEVON ARONIAN IN 10th PLACE BEFORE LAST TOUR IN “AMBER” TOURNAMENT
Noyan Tapan
Mar 30 2006
MONTE CARLO, MARCH 30, NOYAN TAPAN. The games of the penultimate,
10th tour are over in the “Amber” chess tournament being held in
Monte Carlo.
Representative of Armenia Levon Aronian competed with Indian
chess-player Vishvantan Anand and was defeated with a score of 0.5
to 1.5. The first game by the rules of “blind” chess ended with
Anand’s victory, and the second game by the rules of quick chess was
drawn. Vishvantan Anand is the only leader of the tournament. He
gained 13.5 points out of 20 possible ones. Alexander Morozevich
(Russia, 13 points) is in second place, Francisco Valekho (Spain,
11.5 points) in third palce. L.Aronian gained 8.5 points and takes
tenth place among 12 participants. In the last, 11th tour Aronian
will compete with Pyotr Svidler (Russia).
From: Baghdasarian
Deputy Foreign Ministers Of Armenia And Greece Discuss Present Stage
DEPUTY FOREIGN MINISTERS OF ARMENIA AND GREECE DISCUSS PRESENT STAGE OF TWO COUNTRIES’ RELATIONS WITH NEIHGBORS
Noyan Tapan
Armenians Today
Mar 30 2006
YEREVAN, MARCH 30, NOYAN TAPAN – ARMENIANS TODAY. Bilateral relations
and regional issues, particularly, the present state of relations
of Armenia and Greece with neighbors were discussed at the March
29 meeting of Arman Kirakosian, the RA Deputy Foreign Minister,
with Evripidis Stylianidis, the Chairman of the Armenian-Greek
Intergovernmental Commission, the Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs of
Greece. As Noyan Tapan was informed by the RA Foregin Ministry’s Press
and Information Department, during the promoted friendly conversation,
the Deputy Ministers touched upon some issues connected with energy
safety and communication ways of Armenia as well. E.Stylianidis
presented briefly the results of the regular sitting of Armenian-Greek
Intergovernmental Commission and the agreements they reached. RA
Deputy Foreign Minister presented the peaceful settlement process of
the Nagorno Karabakh conflict and approaches of Armenia.
King Vramshapuh And Sahak Parthev
KING VRAMSHAPUH AND SAHAK PARTHEV
Lragir.am
30 March 06
On the 1600th anniversary of invention of letters the Central Bank of
Armenia will issue two sets of silver coins on March 31, dedicated
to King Vramshapuh and Catholicos Sahak Parthev. The press service
of the Central Bank informed the news agency ARKA that the nominal
value of the coins is 100 drams. The coins are made of solid 925
silver and weigh 31.1 grams. Each set contains 500 coins.
On the one side of the coin the emblem of the Republic of Armenia
is pictured, beneath it the nominal value of the coin is. On the
other side of the coin King Vramshapuh and Catholicos Sahak Parthev
are pictured.
1st, 2nd Rounds Of Elimination Of Melange Supply FinishedSuccessfull
1ST, 2ND ROUNDS OF ELIMINATION OF MELANGE SUPPLY FINISHED SUCCESSFULLY: VLADIMIR PRYAKHIN
ARKA News Agency, Armenia
March 30 2006
YEREVAN, March 30. /ARKA/. First and second rounds of elimination
of propellant components (melange) finished successfully in Armenia,
Press Secretary of the Defense Minister Seyran Shakhsuvaryan reported
that Vladimir Pryakhin stated this during the meeting with the RA
Defense Miinister Serj Sargsyan.
Pryakhin also touched upon the activities, planned for the third
round. According to him, the propellant will be reprocessed in
acceptable and ecologically clean fertilizer with a low acid-base
balance.
Issues of the further cooperation in the field of democratic control
over armed forces, and alternative military service were also discussed
during the meeting.
Pryakhin emphasized the assistance of the RA Ministry of Defense in
implementing the programs of the OSCE Yerevan Office.
Armenian Minister of Defense Serj Sargsyan and Head of the OSCE Yerevan
Office Vladimir Pryakhin signed the memorandum of understanding for
implementation of the third round of the program on elimination of
the propellant.
RA President And FSDCC Director Of Russia Discuss Issues Of Struggle
RA PRESIDENT AND FSDCC DIRECTOR OF RUSSIA DISCUSS ISSUES OF STRUGGLE AGAINST ILLEGAL DRUG CIRCULATION
ARKA News Agency, Armenia
March 30 2006
YEREVAN, March 30. /ARKA/. Issues of toughening control in the
sphere of struggle against illegal drug circulation on territories
of CSTO-member countries were discussed duirng the meeting of the RA
President Robert Kocharyan with the Director of the Federal Service
of Drug Circulation Control (FSDCC) of the RF Viktor Cherkesov on
March 29.
According to the Press Service of the RA President, Kocharyan and
Cherkesov discussed issues of taking complex measures in this sphere.
During the meeting they emphasized that cooperation within the bounds
of the Coordinating Council of heads of responsible authorities of
the CSTO-member countries against illegal drug circulation will enable
to secure much more effectiveness than when struggle separately.
Session of the CSTO member- countries’ plenipotentiary authorities
struggling against illegal drug circulation was held in Yerevan on
March 29.
At the moment the Coordinating Council of this structure is headed
by the Director of the FSDCC of Russia Viktor Cherkesov. Armenia,
Byelorussia, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzia, Tajikistan and Russia are
CSTO-member countries.
BAKU: Samad Seyidov: We Can Change Report By Latvian MP Boris Silevi
SAMAD SEYIDOV: WE CAN CHANGE REPORT BY LATVIAN MP BORIS SILEVICH
Today, Azerbaijan
March 30 2006
31 March 2006 [00:20] – Today.Az
“If the report by Latvian MP Broris Silevich includes the items
unsatisfying Azerbaijan, we will be able to change it,” Samad Seyidov,
the Head of the Azerbaijani delegation to PACE, stated.
According to Trend, the document, worked out by Latvian MP Boris
Silevich and put on the agenda of the spring session of PACE,
reflects moments contradicting to Azerbaijani position on refugees
and internally displaced people.
The Latvian MP wrote the number of the Azerbaijani IDP was 580,000,
while 8,000 refugees came from Chechnya, Iran, Afghanistan and Iraq.
The report also says that 250,000 IDP live in Armenia with 15,000
people received citizenship. The rest 235,000 Armenians are regarded
as Azerbaijani citizens.
The report is not related only to Azerbaijan. “It also reflects
the state of the refugees in Georgia and Armenia. Similar report
was worked out earlier and also included the items unsatisfying
Azerbaijan. Under the rules of the procedure, if the report includes
the items unsatisfying Azerbaijan, we will be able to interfere and
change the report,” Seyidov said.
URL:
Language Rights Issue Fuel Discord In Georgia
LANGUAGE RIGHTS ISSUE FUEL DISCORD IN GEORGIA
Paul Rimple
EurasiaNet, NY
March 30 2006
Discontent is rising within Georgia’s Armenian community, the
country’s largest ethnic minority, driven by complaints concerning
the central government’s language policy, as well as perceptions
of discrimination. The building tension between ethnic Armenians
and Georgian government officials has been linked to recent rioting
and violence.
A March 9 altercation between ethnic Armenians and Svans in the Kvemo
Kartli village of Tsalka led to the death of 24-year-old Gevork
Gevorkian, an ethnic Armenian, and incited a mob to raid a local
administrative building. Two days later, in response to Gevorkian’s
death, several hundred protestors in Akhalkalaki, a predominantly
ethnic Armenian town in the neighboring region of Samtskhe-Javakheti,
stormed the local branch of Tbilisi State University, a court building
and the office of a Georgian Orthodox Church archbishop.
Responding to the violence, Parliament Speaker Nino Burjanadze on March
13 placed the blame on “serious forces, who [are] try[ing] to trigger
destabilization in this region,” the Civil Georgia web site reported.
Some ethnic minorities in the region have a different interpretation.
“The murder of the Armenian [Gevork Gevorkian] wasn’t a political act,
it was criminal,” suggested Makhare Matsukov, an Akhalkalaki business
leader and ethnic Greek. “But politics created the situation that
exists in Tsalka and the situation here in Akhalkalaki.”
Local leaders say that protests are the only way they can get the
central government to listen to their complaints. There is talk
of boycotting local elections in October if no progress is made in
opening a dialogue with the central authorities in Tbilisi.
Frustration with what is perceived as the central government’s
disregard for Georgia’s Armenian minority prevails in both Tsalka
and Akhalkalaki, but the roots of the particular issues differ.
Once numbering 30,000, Tsalka’s Greek population is now about 1,500
and shrinking. A mass exodus occurred during the 1990s when thousands
of families relocated to Greece for work. As Greeks left, natural
disaster victims from the northern Georgian region of Svaneti and
the western Black Sea region of Achara began to move into vacant homes.
Squatters took over many abandoned houses; pillagers ransacked
others. As economic conditions in Tsalka worsened, and the town’s
crime rate increased, remaining villagers (12,000 Armenians, 1,500
Azeris and 1,500 Greeks) started to view their “guests” as a threat.
“Before the Svans arrived, there was never any trouble in Tsalka. Why
doesn’t the government do something to help? Is it because we aren’t
Georgian?” fumed Armen Darbinyan, an ethnic Armenian and chairman
of the Javakheti Citizens Forum, a non-governmental organization
sponsored by the European Center for Minority Issues.
Meanwhile, in Akhalkalaki, many say that the strained relationship
with Tbilisi (which locals call “Georgia”) began after the 2003 Rose
Revolution. After coming to power, President Mikheil Saakahsvili’s
administration overhauled the local political machinery, replacing
local officials with appointees from Tbilisi. First Deputy Governor
Armen Amirkhanyan said many local residents in this poverty-stricken
area believed the changes were driven by prejudice. Ethnic Armenians
make up 60 percent of the region, and “their rights must be defended,”
Amirkhanyan added.
The need to have a working knowledge of Georgian lies at the heart
of most complaints.
Georgian government statistics on election registration estimate
the number of ethnic Armenians in Akhalkalaki at 95.8 percent of the
town’s population of 10,000. (Local Armenians put the number at 98
percent.) Since the entire region of Samtskhe-Javakheti functions
primarily in Armenian, few Akhalkalaki residents speak Georgian. At
the same time, Russian is frequently spoken thanks to the presence
of a former Russian military base.
“We can’t get good jobs unless we speak Georgian, but how can you learn
Georgian so well when you’re 30 or 40 years old?” said a resident of
Ninotsminda, a nearby village not far from the Armenian border. “If
we can’t get work here, we will continue to move to Russia for work,
if we can get visas.” Unofficial estimates put the number of Javakheti
men who work seasonally in Russia at 80 percent.
Incentives offered by the Saakashvili government to promote Georgian
language instruction, as well as to promote the integration of
Armenians into the Georgian mainstream, have fallen flat, according
to Javakheti residents. “In 2004, Saakashvili came to Akhalkalaki
and promised to integrate 100 students into the university system in
Tbilisi and Kutaisi with stipends,” said Akhalkalaki Mayor Iricya
Nairi. “That’s great, we thought.” But Nairi claims local students
couldn’t pass the Georgian language university entry exams, which
were a result of the government’s education reforms.
Darbinyan says that he doesn’t understand how people are expected to
learn Georgian well enough to pass exams, when they have few chances to
learn it. Out of Akhalkalaki’s five secondary schools, only one teaches
courses in Georgian. Three teach in Armenian and one in Russian.
Mayor Nairi cites the recent influx of Georgian students to the
Akhalkalaki branch of Tbilisi State University as further evidence
that the government does not want to treat ethnic Armenians equally.
After Georgian students were brought to Akhalkalaki to study for
free, Nairi charged, the number of Armenians studying at the local
university dropped to four. By contrast, he said, under former
president Eduard Shevardnadze 60 percent of the university’s 650
students were Armenian. “Why would they open a university here and
bring Georgians if they didn’t plan to change the demographics of
our region?” he wondered.
Deputy Education and Science Minister Bela Tsipuria, however,
rejects the contention. “The only reason Georgian students are
studying in Akhalkalaki is because the competition to study there is
lower than in Tbilisi or Kutaisi,” Tsipuria stated. Complaints about
the difficulty of Georgia’s new university entrance exams were not
limited to Javakheti, she added. “Young people today have to work
hard to compete in modern Georgia. This is an entirely new concept.”
Tsipuria argues that Javakheti’s problems have more to do with a lack
of educational opportunities than language – a problem not unique to
Samtskhe-Javakheti. President Saakashvili, she stressed, has promised
that hundreds of Armenian students will have the opportunity to
receive sufficient education to find work within the civil service.
The government is currently training teachers and introducing new
methodology, Tsipuria continued. “But people don’t understand these
things take time.”
First Deputy Governor Amirkhanyan believes that education reform must
be accomplished while taking the interests of national minorities
into account. “We must learn Georgian if we want to get ahead. It
would be easier on all levels, from civic positions to farmers who
commute to Tbilisi to sell their goods.”
The issue seems to spill over easily into other areas, as well. The
February dismissal of three ethnic Armenian judges for allegedly having
an insufficient knowledge of Georgian has generated considerable
resentment. “If you don’t know the state language, then you must
go!” commented Nairi.
Similarly, the archbishop’s office was targeted by locals who assume
that the Georgian Orthodox Church is attempting to exercise excessive
influence in the region. The office was rumored to contain a cache
of weapons. The cache never materialized.
Calls have gone out recently for Samtskhe-Javakheti to be made an
autonomous region, with broader self-governance rights, and for
Armenian to be named the region’s official language. Local leaders
and most activists, however, maintain that protests against perceived
cultural assimilation should not be interpreted as a separatist
drive. Said Javakheti Citizens Forum Chairman Darbinyan: “They call
us separatists because we’re asking for cultural autonomy, but we
want democracy and decentralization.”
Editor’s Note: Paul Rimple is a freelance journalist based in Tbilisi.
Kenya: Armenian Now Sues Raila For Defamation
ARMENIAN NOW SUES RAILA FOR DEFAMATION
By Richard Munguti
Kenya Times, Kenya
March 30 2006
THE man at the centre of mercenary allegations Artur Margaryan
yesterday filed a defamation suit against Lang’ata Member of Parliament
Raila Odinga.
Margaryan claims that Raila has defamed him by referring to him as
a mercenary.
He denies that he was engaged in mercenary activities and claims
that he was a businessman of International standing, with investments
spread across five countries, Kenya included.
In a court action commenced through Ndonye, Mbugua, Atudo and Macharia
Advocates, Margaryan, who maintains he is an Armenian despite the same
being contested, says that his reputation has sufferred imensely as
a result of Raila’s unfounded, malicious and false allegations.
He claims that Raila made the allegations purposely to discredit and
have him deported to avoid paying back monies he allegedly loaned
him in Dubai.
Margaryan has sued Raila seeking unquantified damages over the alleged
slur, to the effect that he was a mercenary hired by the Government
to eliminate those opposed to the Kibaki administration.
Margaryan is asking the court to compell Raila to publish an apology an
unqualified apology in all the local newspapers, radio and TV stations,
as well as in the international media in a manner commensurate to
the publications.
He is further praying that the court restrains the defendant from
publishing, writing and/or causing to be written or published any
defamatory matters about him (Margaryan).
Remarks At The Armenian Assembly Of America National Conference
REMARKS AT THE ARMENIAN ASSEMBLY OF AMERICA NATIONAL CONFERENCE
Aktif Haber, Turkey
March 30 2006
Daniel Fried, Assistant Secretary of State for European and Eurasian
Affairs
Mayflower Hotel
Washington, DC
March 27, 2006
Ambassador Fried: Thank you for that kind introduction.
I have the disadvantage of having to follow my friend Vartan [Oskanian,
the foreign minister]. That is a real disadvantage because he’s
very very good. A good interlocutor, a good friend. Most of the
time we agree. When he disagrees, I am reminded by just how good he
is. [Laughter].
It’s a pleasure to be here at the national conference, and I was
happy to accept the invitation from the Assembly and the Armenian
General Benevolent Union and the Eastern and Western Diocese of the
Armenian Church, one of the great ancient churches of Christendom,
to speak to you today. And I understand that this conference is held
in partnership with at least 15 other Armenian-American organizations
and others are in attendance. But let me say in particular that I
value my years of cooperation with the Assembly, and I appreciate
its leadership’s professionalism and their [inaudible] commitment as
Americans to work with us to support democratic and prosperous Armenia.
Now it’s true that we don’t agree on all issues and the Assembly can
be just as frank, which is a diplomatic word — [Laughter] — just as
frank as they have to be in expressing that. But as Americans it’s not
only your right, it’s your duty to speak out to your government when
you agree and when you disagree. That’s never gotten in the way of
our partnership. I appreciate the candid advice from the Assembly and
from the American Armenian community, and I look forward to hearing
more of it. It’s good to hear straight out what’s on your minds,
what you like about what we’re doing, what you don’t like about what
we’re doing. That’s the way a real partnership is made.
I’ve just come back from a visit to Yerevan, and I have to say that
it is beautiful to see a city with Mount Ararat floating in the
distance, the mountains, the snow, and spring just beginning to come
to Yerevan. [Applause].
As Americans, you should be proud that our new embassy compound is up
and running. It’s a physical embodiment of our commitment to Armenia.
It shows that we have put in the money to reflect our political will
to see that Armenia prospers in the 21st Century as a free country,
secure and democratic. [Applause].
While I was in Yerevan I had the privilege of meeting with President
Kocharian, with Vartan Foreign Minister Oskanian, with the Defense
Minister Sargsian, and with political leaders, including leaders
of the opposition. That’s what we do when we go abroad in the State
Department. We meet with everyone. And we had serious talks. We talked
about regional security, which as you know means Nagorno-Karabakh,
relations with Turkey, Azerbaijan, and Georgia. We talked about
strengthening the economy and promoting democratic reform. And I want
to say a few words about those issues today and talk about key topics
that I think are of interest to you.
President Bush’s new National Security Strategy says that it is the
policy of the United States to seek and support democratic movements
and institutions in every nation and culture. Your efforts here and
your efforts in Armenia, to help Armenia democratize and prosper
economically, matched with U.S. efforts and hopes for the country,
and I thank you for them.
I also thank you because in areas of business transparency the
Armenian-American community is leading by example. I thank you for
that as well.
Now this is a good day in U.S.-Armenian relations. Today the United
States and Armenia will sign its Millennium Challenge Cooperation
Compact. That is a new assistance agreement for $235 million, and that
is new money for Armenia. It is a testament to Armenia’s progress
and its commitment to do more on good governance, economic freedom,
and investment in its people.
Much remains to be done and no community is more aware of the
challenges, as well as the progress, as the Armenian-American
community.
The challenge to sustain Armenia’s status as an MCC recipient is
allowing voters to independently and freely choose their leaders
through elections that meet international democratic standards. We’re
looking at the parliamentary and presidential elections next year and
in 2008 as key tests. We hope that Armenia is moving in that direction.
We are building and taking at face value assurances from the
government, and with our own election strategy geared to work with
both the government and the Armenian civil society to try and achieve
this goal. We must achieve this goal to sustain our relations.
We believe that Armenia has the potential to be a leader in the
region by showing progress on democratic reforms to keep pace with
its economic expansion.
Let me turn to an issue that is much on our minds at the State
Department and perhaps on yours, which is Nagorno-Karabakh. A solution
to Nagorno-Karabakh remains a key focus. Obviously, and I don’t need to
tell you this, a resolution would open the door to large investment,
deeper integration with the global economy, peace will bring greater
prosperity.
Now we were hopeful last month that the meeting at Rambouillet between
the Presidents of Armenia and Azerbaijan would move us decisively
forward. We were disappointed that it didn’t happen, but we did not
give up, we did not turn away.
Before I went to Yerevan, I went to Baku and met with President
Aliyev. I was sufficiently encouraged by what he said that I went
to Yerevan for further discussions, and based on the help and sound
thinking of the Armenian side, there is a possibility for progress
in 2006. Now this is not easy. Neither side can or will achieve its
maximum aims. Peace will require solutions that meet both sides’
concerns as much as possible. And both Armenia and Azerbaijan must
prepare for a good settlement, and the best can be the enemy of
the good.
The United States is not going to impose a settlement. We’re not
going to force Armenia or Azerbaijan to take anything. We don’t have
that power, and it is not our intention to try to exercise it. But
it is our intention to support a solution if both governments arrive
at it, and if there is a solution we are going to get behind it. If
the government of Armenia agrees to it, we will support them, and I
hope you do as well.
Now we hope, but also anticipate, that a solution on Nagorno-Karabakh
will result in an open border with Turkey, which is a consistent goal
on our agenda with Ankara. From Yerevan, I went to Ankara and I made
this point with the Turkish government that we want the border open,
and we want it open as soon as possible. [Applause].
This has not been easy for Armenia, but even with closed borders to
the east and west, Armenia has a northern border that is open to it
through Georgia, and Armenia’s economic growth is strong. Almost
14 percent last year, which is the fourth straight year of double
digit growth. Construction is up 34 percent, and you can see it when
you’re in Yerevan. We know that your community is helping fuel this
construction boom.
Agriculture is growing, 11 percent last year. Industrial production
is growing, and inflation remains low.
The Armenian government has increased its ability to collect taxes.
That and corporate taxes which increases government revenues which
helps provide better services and the infrastructure for yet more
growth in a virtuous cycle. We’re seeing an increase in Armenian
government expenditure, on education, science, and health. This
investment in citizens will help bring a good future for Armenia.
The U.S.-Armenian relationship is continuing to deepen and our
economic support is continuing. Since independence, the United States
has contributed more than $1.5 billion of assistance. That’s quite
a bit of money for a country the size of Armenia. And many in the
Armenian-American community have also made substantial financial
contributions to, and investments in, Armenia as well.
Our assistance program, well much of it, is aimed at promoting economic
reform to help create the conditions for Armenians to continue their
economic growth in the best possible way.
There’s more work to do. Tax collection is up, but you know better
than I do how much of the economy remains underground. Corruption is a
serious problem. Corruption is a tax on the poor and a tax on honest
entrepreneurs. That is a drag. An economy saddled with corruption is
moving forward with lead weights tied to each leg.
We want to see greater economic integration between Armenia and
Georgia and Armenia and all the states of the Caucasus. We push
this regularly, and I did so when I was in Baku. We would like
to see greater integration. Now it is difficult in advance of a
Nagorno-Karabakh solution, but we keep raising it, and we will keep
raising it. It’s good not only for Armenia; it would be good for
Turkey and Azerbaijan as well.
Let me talk about regional security and military assistance. We
do support Armenia’s efforts to strengthen its relations with the
Euro-Atlantic community. Armenia has a policy of complementarity,
which means roughly balance in its relations with the West and the
Russians. This is not a problem for us. We don’t want to force Armenia
to choose between its historic friends and its Western identity, but
we do want our relations to grow. We do want our relations to grow,
and we don’t want barriers put in the way.
Our relations in the security field have grown. We value and appreciate
Armenia’s troop contributions in Iraq. There are 46 non-combatant
soldiers serving there now. There are 34 Armenian peacekeepers in
Kosovo. And we hope that Armenia will continue to do its part through
NATO’s Partnership for Peace to contribute to other operations in
the future.
Armenia has increased its cooperation with NATO. The government
is reforming its military in cooperation with the U.S. to make it
more interoperable with NATO. Armenia is pursuing what NATO calls
an individual partnership action plan with NATO. This is basically a
chapeau that lets the Armenian military slowly but as fast as Armenia
wants, grow closer to NATO so we can work together.
Frankly, I want to express my appreciation for the Assembly’s
encouragement last year to Armenia to complete its defense
assessment. That cleared the way for deeper security cooperation
between our two countries.
Now I know that some in your community, in the Armenian-American
community, are concerned about U.S.-Azerbaijani military relations,
so let me address this straight up. The fact is Azerbaijan has
made contributions to the War on Terror and these contributions —
overflight rights, access to Azerbaijani bases, information sharing,
law enforcement cooperation — are useful. Now Azerbaijan faces
security threats not from Armenia, and when I was in Baku I repeated
that Azerbaijan’s security problem really doesn’t come from Armenia,
it comes from other countries. It’s got a rough neighbor to the south,
Iran. And it’s on the Caspian Sea with a lot of oil and gas.
Our security cooperation with and assistance to Azerbaijan is meant
to improve Azerbaijan’s posture against those threats, not against
Armenia. I repeat. Not against Armenia.
President Bush has noted that to succeed in our own efforts, we need
the support of our efforts to fight terrorism, we need the support and
actions of friends and allies. We must join with others to deny the
terrorists what they seek, which is safe haven, financial support,
and the support and protection certain nation states historically
have given them. So we do need to work with all the countries of the
region on a counter-terrorist agenda.
But our assistance to Azerbaijan does not undermine our support for
Armenian security, and it is not designed and will not be used for
offensive purposes against Armenia. So we design our programs with
Azerbaijan very carefully. Counter-narcotics, counter-terrorism,
programs to counter trafficking in weapons of mass destruction.
Now let me mention a couple of words about energy security. In
January of this year, disruptions of electricity and gas to Georgia
affected Armenia, as well. After this episode, we’re looking at ways to
bolster energy security in the region and strengthen Armenia’s energy
independence. The key to doing this is to support market forces, to
diversify energy supplies, and avoid monopolistic restrictions. We’ve
been discussing this in NATO, we’ve been discussing this in the
European Union and with key countries in the region. We will continue
to look at ways in which the United States can support energy security
for all the countries of the south Caucasus.
We are concerned by increased energy ties with Iran, and so we’re
looking at alternatives. We’ve talked to the Georgians about them.
Now let me conclude with discussion of a tough issue for all of us.
April 24th is less than a month away. I’m not going to duck this issue.
The U.S. position on events of 1915 has not changed. We believe that a
productive dialogue is the best way to establish a shared understanding
of history that honors the victims of these horrific events, murders
on a mass scale, killings without justification, deportations. Over
1.5 million people lost their lives, innocent victims. But we want to
foster reconciliation and peace based on an understanding of history,
not a denial of it. We believe that the tragedy of 1915, the killings,
is of enormous human significance and its historical assessment should
be determined not on the basis of politics, but introspection among
civic leaders and scholars. This process has begun in Turkey where
it needs to take place.
Now I know from experience and consultations with the Assembly and
other groups that the Armenian American community has a different view,
and I expect that you will express that view, and that is not for us —
I would be surprised if you didn’t, and I welcome the dialogue we’ve
established. [Applause].
Voice: Horse manure.
Voices: Be quiet. Sit down.
Ambassador Fried: I will value even frank comments, but —
[Laughter]. Hopefully a dialogue can be serious.
Sitting here with us is my old friend John Evans, our Ambassador
in Yerevan. He is the Ambassador, remains the Ambassador, has —
[Applause and cheers].
Like all of us, we all serve at the pleasure of the President.
Ambassador Evans came from Yerevan for the signing of the Millennium
Challenge Account Compact this afternoon, and will be in the meeting
this afternoon between Secretary Rice and Foreign Minister Oskanian.
There has been a great deal of speculation. I don’t discuss personnel
issues, but since my friend is sitting here, I thought I would
recognize Ambassador John Evans. [Applause].
Now I gather there will be some time to take questions. I wouldn’t
be surprised by a frank exchange. [Laughter]. That doesn’t bother me.
I appreciate the chance to meet with you and have a discussion of
all issues, whether we agree or disagree. America is a free country,
and I’m here to listen and to answer your questions the best I can.
Thank you for your attention. I’m glad to see that people were paying
attention. [Laughter]. [Applause].
Moderator: Thank you, Ambassador Fried. You said in Armenia and the
capital of Turkey that Armenians and Turks need to have courage on
the issue. The United States has to have courage on the issue of the
Armenian genocide. [Applause]. And that ambiguity out there in terms
of denial, curriculum that is trying to be inserted in classrooms
around this country, our government needs to be very clear about
their role and mission on this issue.
Your first question: As the U.S. and EU applies increasing pressure
on Iran with the prospects of confrontation grows, will the U.S. take
concrete steps to ensure Armenia’s security and economic stability?
Will the U.S. guarantee that the border with Turkey will be open
before there is conflict with Iran or potential conflict with Iran
that would risk a border closing?
Ambassador Fried: That’s a fair question, but I don’t have to yet
accept the premise that we are headed for a military confrontation with
Iran because we are now focused on achieving a diplomatic solution
to the problem of Iran’s nuclear weapons ambitions. We are not going
through the motions, we are serious about this. We do not believe
that Iran is North Korea. We do not believe that Iran thrives on
isolation. Iranian society does not want to be shunned by the world
and its leaders to not reflect the consensus in that society, as far as
we can tell. So I believe that our diplomatic efforts can bear fruit.
However, to be responsive to the question, we will continue to have
a serious discussion with Armenia as our thinking develops. And as
John Evans can tell you, this issue came up in our discussions a week
and a half ago in Yerevon. We will continue to work with Armenia to
make sure that its security is part of our thinking and integrated
into our thinking. Can I guarantee that the border with Turkey will
be open? I can’t guarantee that, and to say that I could would not
be honest. But I can say that we take Armenia’s security seriously.
Armenia didn’t choose its neighborhood, but there you are.
[Laughter].
We will continue to work to see to it that Armenia is not vulnerable,
particularly on energy issues. And I did have explicit discussions in
Ankara about a future in which Armenia, in which gas and oil flowed
freely through Armenia from the Caspian without political hindrance,
so we are beginning this dialogue.
Moderator: I’m sure you imagine I’m getting a few questions on
Armenian genocide.
Ambassador Fried: I imagine. [Laughter].
Moderator: Why are third parties permitted to dictate America’s
foreign policy vis-a-vis Armenia and Cyprus?
Ambassador Fried: Third parties are not permitted to dictate our
foreign policy, nor do they dictate our foreign policy. We have a
policy which many of you disagree with. I understand. But we have a
policy of seeking to encourage Turkey to reflect more seriously about
subjects which have been taboo for generations in that country. I
said earlier that process has begun in Turkey. You recall that the
famous Turkish writer Orhan Pamuk spoke clearly about this. He is
not the only Turk speaking out. As I said, this process has begun
as Turkish society modernizes, and as it modernizes, as democracy
in Turkey deepens, Turkey will have to go through what many other
countries such as the United States have had to go through in our
own history, which is looking back at the darker spots in our past.
With respect to the United States, those darker spots include things
like slavery and racial discrimination, treatment of American Indians,
and in my opinion, internment of American citizens of Japanese origin
in camps in World War II. Those are painful subjects.
Just as dealing with the history of the mass killings of Armenians is
painful for Turkey. And by the way, I say this to my Turkish friends
using the same words. We keep one set of books.
Now that process has begun in Turkey. It is certainly not going fast
enough to satisfy you. It is not going fast enough to satisfy us. But
this process has begun and it will, I hope, bring greater understanding
to Turks of their own history.
We will continue to have a dialogue about this as April 24th
approaches. I will not attempt to anticipate what the President will
say. I do believe he will issue a statement on April 24th, in fact
I can’t believe there won’t be one. And I expect, as we have in the
past, to consult with the Armenian Assembly about this and to have
a frank set of discussions before and after.
Moderator: How will the U.S. deal with Azerbaijan regarding,
or how will it take to task, regarding the issue of the Armenian
historical landmarks of the Cemetery of Djulfa that was destroyed by
the Azerbaijanis?
Ambassador Fried: When I go to Baku and when U.S. officials go
to Baku, we always raise issues of living — Not just issues of
Nagorno-Karabakh, but issues of long-term peace in the south
provinces. Now I would be happy to raise issues of Armenian
historical sites in Azerbaijan. These historical sites, regardless
of differences over Nagorno-Karabakh, need to be respected and need
to be protected. This is a universal policy of the United States,
and I look forward to hearing from you about some of these sites so
that we can raise it with the Azerbaijani government. [Applause].
Moderator: How does the U.S. policy of promoting freedom
and democracy fit into your policy towards resolution of the
Nagorno-Karabakh conflict? Especially considering the democratic will
of Nagorno-Karabakh to remain free?
Ambassador Fried: I don’t want to get into the details of the
shape of settlements under discussion. There is nothing worse than
negotiating in public. But the philosophic premise behind the question
is a good one and a fair one. That is how much weight do you give
self-determination, which is clearly a factor at stake here? How
much weight do you give issues of territorial integrity? And how much
weight do you give to well, facts on the ground? All right? Now that
is a difficult issue.
In my view, it is probably a mistake to try to apply rigid precedents
to all similar issues. Nagorno-Karabakh is not the same as Kosovo,
which is not the same as Abkhazia, which is not the same as Chechnya.
These issues are individual, and they need to be handled
individually. We are well aware that the will of the people of
Nagorno-Karabakh has to be respected. [Applause]. We are also aware
that there are issues of territorial integrity and the challenge
that we all face that Foreign Minister Oskanian and Foreign Minister
Mammadyarov and those involved in trying to help an agreement, have
to deal with all of these issues. And I am convinced that there can
be solutions at hand.
I don’t know when they will come about, but I think that 2006 is a
good window for them, and I don’t think that the people of Armenia,
Nagorno-Karabakh, or Azerbaijan deserve to live forever in a state
of uncertainty.
Moderator: Why does real politik trump the moral position in
recognizing the genocide, more in the U.S. than in France? If the
U.S. wants to foster reconciliation and peace in the region it’s true
that introspection needs to be fostered within Turkey. With Turkey’s
export of denialist tactics can peace and truth really be achieved?
And specifically if you could comment on a federal lawsuit in
Massachusetts currently that denialist material be put into the
genocide curriculum.
Ambassador Fried: I can’t comment about the lawsuit. The United States
government has never denied the events of 1915. We do not support,
what was the phrase, export of denialist literature or positions. We
do support efforts by Turkey to deal with its history more seriously.
As I said, this process has begun. It has not ended. Efforts such
as the Truth and Reconciliation Commission were serious, and these
were efforts in which Turkish, as well as Armenian scholars, were
involved. It produced a serious look at those issues which we have
recognized officially.
This is not an easy issue. It is not an easy issue for the United
States government, and we are not at the end of the road on this
issue. We will continue to urge our Turkish friends to face difficult
issues of their past seriously, and we will urge Armenia to help the
Turks make this possible without ever sacrificing historical truth
or your position.
Now that is not an entirely satisfactory position for your community,
but again, I value the advice and input and even the criticism from
the Armenian American community and it [inaudible].
Moderator: Is there any truth to reports in the Atlantic Monthly that
the U.S. is upgrading the Baku air bases for potential airstrikes
on Iran?
Ambassador Fried: No. [Laughter].
Moderator: What is your position on recent reports that Ambassador
Evans is being recalled because of his statements last year on the
Armenian genocide issue?
Ambassador Fried: We all serve at the pleasure of the President. I
won’t discuss personnel issues. Ambassador Evans, as I said, is
a friend of more than 20 years standing. He’s our Ambassador. He’s
right here. He will be in the meetings today at the State Department,
as I said. [Applause].
Moderator: Thank you, Ambassador Fried, for this very frank
discussion, as always, and we thank you all for your attention and
for participating. Thank you very much. [Applause].
hp?nID=66236