People Of Azerbaijan Loses Its Interest In Karabakh Problem, Politic

PEOPLE OF AZERBAIJAN LOSES ITS INTEREST IN KARABAKH PROBLEM, POLITICIAN LEVON MELIK-SHAKHNAZARIAN STATES

Noyan Tapan
Dec 26 2006

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 26, NOYAN TAPAN. "There was no "window" in the
negotition process on peaceful settlement of the Karabakh conflict
in 2006. More, and the next year as well will be a year of a "close
window." Politician Levon Melik-Shakhnazarian stated about it at the
December 26 press conference. In his words, Armenia’s and Azerbaijani
positions, exclusing one another, were the reason for futility of
the negotiations in 2006. On the one hand, the nation’s principle on
self-determination, on the other hand, on territorial integrity.

L.Melik-Shakhnazarian mentioned that the main task of the Armenian
side in the negotiation process is moving of the problem from the
political field to the legal one. In his opinion, the attempt to
solve the Karabakh problem in the political way is not right. He also
reminded that Nagorno Karabakh has never been in the structure of
independent Azerbaijan. L.Melik-Shakhnazarian emphasized the necessity
of participation of the Karabakh side in the negotiations: "During
the recent years the Karabakh side is forced out of the negotiation
process what gives possibility to Azerbaijan to present Armenia as
an aggressor." The politician mentioned that all the warlike calls
of Azerbaijan to settle the conflict in the military way are only
"for the inside consumption."

In reality, Azerbijan has numerous social problems, the problem of
Talyshes, etc. And the population of this country is not ready for
determined actions as it lost its interest in the Karabakh problem and
"does not any longer accept Karabakh as a part of Azerbaijan."

BAKU: Oskanian: "The Only Way Of The Settlement Of Nagorno Karabakh

OSKANIAN: "THE ONLY WAY OF THE SETTLEMENT OF NAGORNO KARABAKH CONFLICT IS TO HOLD REFERENDUM"

Today, Azerbaijan
Dec 26 2006

"The only way of the settlement of Nagorno Karabakh conflict is to
hold referendum," Armenian Foreign minister Vartan Oskanian said.

Expressing his attitude to Azerbaijani president Ilham Aliyev’s
statement Oskanian said that Baku was not in a right way.

"At present the negotiations are on delicate stage that is why any
this kind of statement can cause negative results and break-up of
the process," the minister said.

According to the minister’s words that Azerbaijan should avoid to
make statements about Azerbaijan’s territorial integrity. He said the
only way of removing the controversy appeared between the principles
of territorial integrity and right to the self-determination is to
hold referendum in Nagorno Karabakh.

The minister said the settlement of the conflict will be difficult,
in the case of whether to treat NK as Azerbaijani territory, Armenian
or independent territory. That is why, both Azerbaijani and Armenian
sides do not intend to refuse Karabakh.

"The way out of the problem is to apply the right for
self-determination and to hold referendum," he said.

URL:

http://www.today.az/news/politics/34315.html

Change In U.S. Congress Boosts Prospects For Armenian Genocide Resol

CHANGE IN U.S. CONGRESS BOOSTS PROSPECTS FOR ARMENIAN GENOCIDE RESOLUTION

International Herald Tribune, France
The Associated Press
Dec 26 2006

WASHINGTON: With Democrats taking control of the U.S. Congress,
prospects have increased that lawmakers will approve a resolution
recognizing the World War I-era killings of Armenians as genocide –
despite the objections of President George W. Bush.

The shift in Congress also dims the likelihood that the Bush
administration can break a deadlock over the president’ss nominee
for ambassador to Armenia, Richard Hoagland. Senate Democrats have
blocked Hoagland’s nomination because of his refusal to call the
killings a genocide.

The matters before Congress highlight how the deaths of the 1.5 million
Armenians almost a century ago remain a sensitive international issue
today. The Bush administration has warned that even congressional
debate on the genocide question could damage relations with Turkey,
a moderate Muslim nation that is a NATO member and an important
strategic ally.

Turkey has adamantly denied claims by scholars that its predecessor
state, the Ottoman government, caused the Armenian deaths in a planned
genocide. The Turkish government has said the toll is wildly inflated
and that Armenians were killed or displaced in civil unrest during
the empire’s collapse.

After French lawmakers voted in October to make it a crime to deny
that the killings were a genocide, Turkey said it would suspend
military relations with France.

In Washington, Armenian-American groups have been pressing for years
for a resolution on the genocide issue. The House of Representatives’
International Relations Committee last year endorsed two resolutions
classifying the killings as genocide. But the House leadership,
controlled by Bush’s Republican Party, prevented a vote by the full
chamber.

With Democrats taking over the House, the top leader will be Nancy
Pelosi, who has supported the genocide legislation. A spokesman for
Pelosi, Drew Hamill, says she’ll continue to support the resolutions.

"I think we have the best chance probably in a decade to get an
Armenian genocide resolution passed," said Democratic Congressman
Adam Schiff, a top advocate of the resolutions.

The genocide question was the key issue as the Senate considered
the ambassadorial nomination of Hoagland to replace John Evans,
who reportedly had his tour of duty cut short because, in a social
setting, he referred to the killings as genocide.

Senator Robert Menendez, a New Jersey Democrat, blocked the nomination
over Hoagland’s refusal to use the word genocide at his confirmation
hearing in June. With Democrats taking over the Senate, it will be
even more difficult now for the Bush administration to circumvent
Menendez’s objections.

Early this month, Menendez and the Senate’s top Democrat, Harry Reid
of Nevada, wrote a letter to U.S. Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice
asking the Bush administration to withdraw the nomination.

But an administration official responded in a letter to Menendez that
it was continuing to back Hoagland.

"Despite some claims to the contrary, neither Ambassador-designate
Hoagland nor the administration has ever minimized or denied the fact
or the extent of the annihilation and forced exile of as many as 1.5.

million ethnic Armenians in the final years of the Ottoman Empire,"
Under Secretary of State Nicholas Burns wrote. The letter was provided
to The Associated Press by a congressional aide, who requested
anonymity because the administration had not agreed to its release.

"It would be a shame for the entire Foreign Service should
Ambassador-designate Hoagland, an experienced diplomat with a
distinguished record of service, be denied confirmation due to past
disagreements over Ambassador Evans."

"Orran" Gives New Year Food Packages To 250 Needy Families This Year

"ORRAN" GIVES NEW YEAR FOOD PACKAGES TO 250 NEEDY FAMILIES THIS YEAR

Noyan Tapan
Dec 26 2006

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 26, NOYAN TAPAN. It is already the 7th year that
the "Orran" charity public organization gave food packages to 250
needy families to care New Year needs. Organization Chairwoman
Armine Hovannisian informed the Noyan Tapan correspondent. "I would
like very much that the New Year was celebrated in all the Armenian
families with Armenian traditions, full and abudant tables, New Year
presents, high holiday mood," A.Hovhannisian said. It was mentioned
that a masquerade will be organized on December 27 for the beneficiary
children of the organization during which all the children will get
presents. "Orran," which was founded by Raffi and Armine Hovannisian
in 2000, has showen charity and humanitarian assistance during its
activity to more than 1500 families and children, taking care of their
food, clothes, psychological assistance, education. 75 children and
50 old people are at present involved in the "Orran" programs.
From: Baghdasarian

Turkey And The EU

TURKEY AND THE EU

Washington Times, DC
Dec 26 2006

The European Union did itself a disservice this month with
a decision to suspend eight of the 35 "chapters" of Turkey’s
accession negotiations, the most recent in a series of episodes that
suggest Europe is distancing itself from Turkey. The Turks have been
increasingly frustrated by what they perceive as a double standard
applied to their country’s membership bid, and popular opinion in
Turkey is turning increasingly against the process. The successful
accession would help solidify Turkey as a Western-oriented democracy in
the Muslim world, while a failure would be damaging to its relationship
with Western allies and to the Turkish republic itself.

Economic and political reforms are challenging to accomplish in Turkey,
but the carrot of EU accession makes difficult reforms more palatable
and politically feasible. The EU process also establishes a structural
framework for Turkey’s reforms, for which the entry requirements can
be tremendously valuable as a guide. But if the requirements are set
so as to preclude Turkish membership rather than to encourage and
direct Turkish reforms, the entire process becomes unproductive —
or, at worst, counterproductive by turning Turkey to the East.

The eight "chapters" were suspended this month because of a deadlock
over the Cyprus issue, the decades-old conflict between ethnic Turks
in the north and Greek Cypriots in the south of the island. Turkey
has refused to open its ports to trade with Cyprus, an EU member that
Turkey does not recognize. The EU, in turn, maintains an embargo on the
Turkish-occupied northern part of the divided island. Resolving this
contentious issue is complicated, but it need not cause an impasse
in Turkey’s membership talks. A late proposal from Turkey to open
two ports to trade with Cyprus for a year had merit, at least in as
much as it would have offered a one-step-forward alternative to the
suspension of negotiations.

Heading into an election year in Turkey adds another dimension.

For one, the EU shouldn’t expect Turkish politicians to concede much
on the issues of Cyprus or the Armenian genocide, a dark chapter
in Turkey’s history that the government has not revisited. A rebuff
from Europe to some extent reflects poorly on the ruling Justice and
Development Party (AKP), the leading supporter of EU accession. The
Republican People’s Party (CHP) — AKP’s sole opposition in parliament,
and the best contender to overtake AKP in 2007 — has opposed EU
accession, contrary to the position its own ideology would seem to
dictate, largely because of its role as sole parliamentary minority
party and its chosen course of reflexive opposition to any AKP
initiative.

When the dust from the accession process settles many years down
the road, and Turkey has either joined the EU with full or partial
membership — or has not joined — an undeniably important measure
of the process will be the extent to which Turkey has continued to
enact economic and political reforms that bring it more in line with
its Western allies than its Eastern neighbors. Turkey feels the pull
between two poles: a secular and democratic Europe and a hostile,
undemocratic Middle East. The more it appears that Europe is trying
to close the door to membership, the more likely Turkey will embrace
a more Islamist Middle East. This is a strategic blunder that the
West should not allow to happen.

Armenian Youth Federation And The United Human Rights Council To Fas

ARMENIAN YOUTH FEDERATION AND THE UNITED HUMAN RIGHTS COUNCIL TO FAST AT THE LA TURKISH CONSULATE

ASBAREZ
12/23/2006

Los Angeles, CA–The Armenian Youth Federation (AYF) and the United
Human Rights Council (UHRC) in a joint collaboration will hold a fast
in front of the Turkish Consulate from January 2nd-6th. The fast,
titled "Fast for Remembrance," aims to raise awareness about the
Armenian Genocide, phases of the genocide and the genocides that
followed.

Beginning January 2 at 9am and concluding on January 6 at 5pm,
a group of youth activists will give up all food in order to bring
attention to the massacre of 1.5 million Armenians by Ottoman Turkey,
a crime still denied by subsequent Turkish governments.

"Our ancestors were forcefully starved for weeks while being beaten,
tortured and raped. We are willing to fast for a few days in order
to try to educate others about what our people went through during
the Armenian Genocide" said Soseh Esmaili, a Fast for Remembrance
organizer and faster.

"As a member of the UHRC, I understand how important it is to
educate people about the Armenian Genocide and all genocides. The
cliche, ‘history repeats itself’ is true. Due to the fact that the
perpetrators of the Armenian genocide went unpunished, it showed future
genocide perpetrators that it is ok to try to wipe out an entire race
because there will be no repercussions for it," said UHRC member,
Marie Ghanime.

January 6 will not only mark the end of the fast, it also marks the
day that Armenians worldwide celebrate Christmas.

"Republican Party Is Labor Union Of Officials"

"REPUBLICAN PARTY IS LABOR UNION OF OFFICIALS"

Lragir, Armenia
Dec 26 2006

The establishment of the Bargavach Hayastan Party before the
parliamentary election in 2007 is regular, like the establishment
of the Orinats Yerkir Party before 1998 and the United Labor Party
and other political parties before 2003 was regular. The political
scientist Alexander Iskandaryan expressed this point of view on
December 26 at the Friday Club, saying that in Armenia the political
parties are set up to pursue the interests of some elite rather than
for social reasons. The political scientist says this is typical of
all the world, simply party building is younger in Armenia compared
with other countries.

Alexander Iskandaryan thinks that the newly established political
parties are meant to solve the problem of guarantees of different
groups in different political stages. In this connection, 2007
is peculiar, the political scientist thinks, because it precedes
the presidential election in 2008. And since the president must
be replaced, different representatives of the elite want to have
guarantees in the economic and political spheres under the new
president choosing to establish a political party as a mechanism.

Alexander Iskandaryan agrees that disagreement inside the ruling elite,
namely between the Bargavach Hayastan Party and the Republican Party
is possible. The political scientist thinks it is logical but points
to a nuance. According to him, the disagreement is not between the
Bargavach Hayastan and the Republican Party but different groups inside
the government. The Republican Party is a "labor union of officials",
Alexander Iskandaryan says, where groups with different interests
are opposed to not only the Bargavach Hayastan Party but also to one
another. Alexander Iskandaryan also considers the controversy between
the president and the defense minister as logical, explaining it by
the variety of the same interests. In Armenia the president is not
one person but about 10-12 people who make up this institution and
have different interests, says the political scientist. The clash of
interests in this pyramid of power underlies the political process
in Armenia.

ANCA-WR, Rep. Sherman And "Screamers" Director Carla Garapedian Call

ANCA-WR, REP. SHERMAN AND "SCREAMERS" DIRECTOR CARLA GARAPEDIAN CALL FOR ACTION TO END CYCLE OF GENOCIDE

ASBAREZ
12/23/2006

ENCINO–The Armenian National Committee of America –Western Region
(ANCA-WR), Rep. Brad Sherman (D-CA) and "Screamers" film director
Carla Garapedian called for action to end the cycle of genocide from
the Armenian Genocide of 1915 to the genocide going on in Darfur
today. They also condemned Variety Magazine, which covers the movie
industry, for supporting the Government of Turkey’s on-going Armenian
Genocide denial by casting doubt upon the historical facts of the
Genocide.

Rep. Sherman spoke of the pressing need to stop the on-going genocide
in Darfur in order to break the cycle of genocide that has been
plaguing our world over the last century. The Congressman, who will
be spearheading efforts on an Armenian Genocide resolution in the
House of Representatives next year, noted why the recognition of
the Armenian Genocide is essential if the world is to end the global
cycle of genocide. He said it was "Hitler who proclaimed, who today
remembers the Armenians?" In answer to Variety Magazine casting doubt
upon the historical facts of the Armenian Genocide with their use
of the terminology "so-called Armenian Genocide," he ridiculed the
publication by saying that there are also people who still believe
O.J. Simpson is innocent.

The call to action was made at a press conference organized by the
ANCA-WR outside the Laemmle Theatre in Encino, California, where
the new documentary movie "Screamers" will begin showing on December
22nd. The movie provides a comprehensive examination of how genocide
was first used by Turkey as a state policy in 1915 in order to kill
1.5 million Armenian citizens which Hitler later used as a blueprint
for the Holocaust. Since then genocide has been repeated in Cambodia,
Bosnia, Rwanda and now Darfur. The film looks at the issue through
the eyes and music of the Grammy award-winning rock band System of
a Down, based in Los Angeles, whose members are all grandchildren
of Genocide survivors. Covering the press conference were various
members of the media including FOX News, regional media outlets and
Armenian community media.

"Genocide recognition should never be a currency for better economic
relations or more arms deals with other nations," stated Carla
Garapedian, director of "Screamers." She emphasized that by seeing
"Screamers," people will send a clear message to the whole nation
that this is an issue that they care about and that genocide in our
time can and must be stopped.

Nishan Bostanian, spokesperson for the San Fernando Valley ANC,
thanked Rep.

Brad Sherman for his leadership role in fighting for justice for the
martyrs and survivors of the Armenian Genocide and his role in helping
bring attention to the genocide taking place in Darfur. Bostanian
stated that when the 110th Congress convenes in January of 2007 the San
Fernando Valley ANC looks forward to working closely with Rep. Sherman
in his efforts with Speaker Pelosi and other key members of Congress
to pass a resolution on the Armenian Genocide.

U.S. Understands Armenia

U.S. UNDERSTANDS ARMENIA

Lragir, Armenia
Dec 26 2006

On December 26 at the Friday Club Alexander Iskandaryan, political
scientist, the head of the Caucasian Media Institute found it difficult
to tell how the U.N. Council of Security resolution on the Iranian
nuclear project will affect Armenia. The resolution provides for
sanctions against Iran. According to Alexander Iskandaryan, much
depends on the consistency of the United States, as well as the other
six parties of the nuclear negotiations in applying this resolution.

However, the political scientist points to the circumstance that
Armenia is the only country in the world the United States understands
its relations with Iran. All through this time Armenia has successfully
done what the United States prevents in other countries. According
to him, the United States realizes that Armenia is "doomed" to
cooperation with Iran and it cooperates not because it is against
the United States but because it has no other way out.

Besides, the Iran-Armenia partnership does not involve cooperation
on nuclear programs, says the political scientist.

This Person Is Becoming Dangerous For Nagorno Karabakh

THIS PERSON IS BECOMING DANGEROUS FOR NAGORNO KARABAKH
Haik Aramyan

Lragir, Armenia
Dec 26 2006

After holding a referendum successfully the public of Nagorno Karabakh
can focus on the problem of candidates of president. Life goes on,
and the political elite of Karabakh is growing active, for the country
is coming to the point of necessary changes for development.

However, it is already clear that not everyone welcomes progressive
changes in Karabakh. As it usually happens, most people consider
these changes dangerous for their personal interests. And though it
seems that there cannot be such people in what concerns the people of
Karabakh which has not been recognized by the international community
yet, life shows the opposite. There are a number of people who proceed
from their personal interests in evaluating history and the reality
in Nagorno Karabakh.

There have been a number of such cases recently, which aroused concern
among the Karabakh public. Certain NKR officials were said to have been
involved in games in connection with the problem of adoption of the
NKR Constitution. Apparently, NKR President Arkady Ghukasyan wanted
to put an end to these worries when he confirmed on December 10 the
day of the referendum his decision not to run a third term and even
promised to inform the public on his activities after leaving office.

It appeared that reason won, and the country could go on to tackle the
other problems of state building. But no. Someone has again decided to
question the willingness of Nagorno Karabakh to act in accordance with
the demand of history, and lead people towards his own wishes. And this
someone is not another social climber from President Ghukasyan’s team
but the businessman Ara Abrahamyan, who has been trying to convince
the Armenian people that he is the leader of the Armenians, and he
was born to bring them together under the flag of the World Congress
of Armenians.

Ara Abrahamyan disagrees that the people of Karabakh should elect a
new president. He decided that Ghukasyan is irreplaceable and must
remain president until the country is recognized. Ara Abrahamyan does
not care for the opinion of the NKR people. Moreover, he does not
care for Ghukasyan’s statement to take up another occupation. The
"father" of Armenians denies the course of history; for him history
is the fulfilment of his own dreams.

We could grin at the wish of another rich man and not pay attention
to it. Especially that this figure "generously donated" one million
dollars to Karabakh. Perhaps at some time someone would explain to him
that it is wrong to point it to people. Perhaps President Ghukasyan
could explain the benefactor how unappropriate this is towards people
who made so many sacrifices for the sake of freedom.

However, the problem is that people are growing suspicious that
Arkady Ghukasyan is not involved in the strange actions of the
Diasporan benefactors, who are friends of his. Ara Abrahamyan is
not the first. The society has not forgotten about another friend of
president’s, the gradiloquent speech of the American Armenian Vahe
Karapetyan during the recent telethon of Armenia Foundation when
he stated that he would support Ghukasyan to be elected for a third
term. This man thought his donation of half a million dollars would
make his wish more realistic. At that time, Arkady Ghukasyan standing
near Vahe Karapetyan did not react to his friend’s statement.

Ghukasyan could have explained, if not to Vahe Karapetyan but to
the entire Armenian nation that such notions as the fate of people
must not be played with. Karapetyan would conclude that his words
are impertinent. The fate of a friend may matter more for someone
than the fate of a nation, but history does not forgive helping a
friend at the expense of people. Ghukasyan did not explain, which
means he does not understand either. And if he does not understand,
he makes others think that he undertakes these political games rather
than his Diasporan friends.

The Armenian public has witnessed such "strange" behavior of the
members of Arkady Ghukasyan’s team, who tend to neglect public
statements and vigorously try to stop the history for their own
wishes. Then it became clear that they were fulfilling Ghukasyan’s
wishes rather than their own. But since Arkady Ghukasyan’s plans
are revealed one by one, he pretended that the ideas belonged to
these figures.

Meanwhile, in Ara Abrahamyan’s case Ghukasyan lay himself bare. He
should not have had Ara Abrahamyan utter his own text, since he had
mentioned separate principles to others in private talks. Ghukasyan’s
memory failed, or rather the desire to keep the office prevailed. In
Armenia, Karabakh and the Diaspora everyone knows Ghukasyan’s theses
that "he does not wish to run a third term but there is nobody worth
to replace him." Most people remember Ghukasyan’s words that only he
personally can get money from the Diasporan rich people. The statements
of Ghukasyan’s team that they do not give money to Karabakh but to
Ghukasyan are many.

This is quite different from the words of a statesman who is interested
is something else than his own fate. A person who lives abroad for
months on without giving an explanation to the NKR public.

He knows what he was busy doing there. And how could Ara Abrahamyan
know that by citing Ghukasyan he would place himself and the president
of Armenia in a funny situation? He did not calculate everything,
whereas he could have acted a little more diplomatically.

But diplomacy would hardly be helpful. Ghukasyan’s policy of solving
the problem of his own fate at the expense of people through someone
else is already victious. And in this case ruses will not be helpful.

All this would sound funny if it were not dangerous. Everything is
clear about separate Diasporan benefactors: they know why they give
the money, for people or for their "friends" who have high positions.

Thanks God, these benefactors are few compared with the real friends of
the people of Karabakh. Meanwhile, the people of NKR need to clarify
the problem of its own ingenious figures who have turned their office
and the external relations of NKR into a mechanism of solving their
own problems.

There is already a lot to discuss. First, the public of Karabakh
needs to find out for what services the Diasporan rich men give
the money to Ghukasyan and not to Karabakh. It is clear that if we
believe this thesis of Ghukasyan’s team, nobody would give him money
for "beatiful eyes". Consequently, it is necessary to find out how
Ghukasyan becomes preferable for his "friends". This is absolutely
realistic considering that the money raised by the Armenian Diaspora
in 2005 did not reach its destination, the region of Martakert. In
NKR they still wonder about 1.5 million dollars which did not appear
where it should appear legally.

The media have reported about the transfer of the property of NKR to
Swiss businessmen and gave facts on deals made by the NKR leadership
and rich foreigners. The uncertainty over the activities of the
foundation for maintenance of Goris-Lachin-Stepanakert motorway is
reported, where the visible work does not correspond to the reported
annual expenses (by the way, this project is also related to Vahe
Karapetyan who annually provides 150 thousand dollars for roadworks).

In other words, Ghukasyan does not tell a lie when he says that
the money (at least part of it) is given to him personally not to
Karabakh. And the fact that some rich Diasporans are fussing and
making deals with Ghukasyan openly may have reason. Not only Arkady
Ghukasyan fears leaving office. So they have made efforts to shut
the mouth of the people of Karabakh with "patriotic" speeches that
it is impossible to replace Ghukasyan. It is clear that Ghukasyan is
irreplaceable for them for some reason. But this is their problem.

And the problem of the NKR public and those who are responsible for
legality of Diaspora charity is to prevent anything in the back of
the state and the public. Ghukasyan, who is facing the problem of
leaving office, is becoming dangerous for the people. Not only the
public but also the relevant agencies should hurry to attend to
these problems. It is high time that the parliament, the National
Security Service and the NKR procuracy start official proceedings
with regard to the relations of the NKR government agencies and the
foreign financial sources. Today this is a matter of national security.

The institutions of NKR are established and able to defend the
interests of NKR.