Is Religion an Obstacle to Progress?

The Word, Ireland
Dec 29 2006

Is Religion an Obstacle to Progress?

This is a fascinating question, not least because of the ambiguity of
the two main terms used: religion and progress. Religion as a human
phenomenon, history teaches, is subject to all the ambiguities of the
human heart, which can pervert even the highest of human ideals. And
yet, for all its shadow side, religion as a notion retains its
positive claim to heal the wayward human heart and enable it to rise
above the mundane.

Progress is even more ambiguous. The main movement behind the
genocide of Armenians in Turkey at the beginning of the last century
called itself the `Committee of Union and Progress’. It would not be
the last time in that century just past when the notion of progress
would be used to justify mass murders of the so-called enemies of the
march of progress, as, for example, defined by the Communist Parties.
In Czechoslovakia, before the Velvet Revolution, dissidents there,
such as Vaclav Havel and the signatories of Charter 77, were labelled
as `conservatives’ and `reactionaries’ by the powers-that-be.

In common with all the great world religions, Christianity is
ultimately concerned with eternity, with what is beyond the mundane.
It thereby gives our daily life its meaning and so makes material
progress truly human. But Christianity goes one step further.
Rejecting the fatalism of the pagan religions of its day,
Judeo-Christianity introduced the notion of progress into world
history – namely the conviction that social conditions can, indeed
must, be improved.

The French Revolution’s `Cult of Reason’ – Chaumette unveiling
‘Reason’ (Notre Dame, 10 Nov 1793). Chalk lithograph by R. Weibezahl.
Courtesy: akg-images

However, in the Age of the Enlightenment, progress itself became a
religion. The main theoretician of the religion of progress was a
Catholic priest, the Abbé de St Pierre. The influence of his ideas
can be traced down to our day. Most of his ideas – including free
education, the reform of female education, and the abolition of
poverty – have been the stock-in-trade of Liberals for the past three
centuries.

More significant is `[the French cleric’s] fundamental doctrine of
the `perpetual and unlimited increase of universal human reason’,
which will inevitably produce the golden age and the establishment of
paradise of earth’. The main point is that belief in progress is
itself a religion, more precisely a Christian heresy – moreover an
extremely irrational one, despite its glorification of reason (or
perhaps because of it), since it flies in the face of reality, namely
the fact that the bloodiest of all centuries was the 20th century
that prided itself as progressive.

The 2003 McGill Summer School papers provide a sober estimate of the
contemporary Irish situation. They celebrate the astonishing material
development of our small country over the past decades and at the
same time they recognize frankly the equally extraordinary collapse
of the moral fabric of society in tandem with it. That sober estimate
acknowledges, on the one hand, our new self-confidence as a nation
and yet, on the other hand, they appear to be perplexed in the face
of the equally new phenomenon of alienation, lack of trust in public
institutions of Church and State, and the various forms of escapism
and breakdown of civilized behaviour that are creating a black hole
in society.

And yet the paradox is that, according to various European value
surveys, we are the happiest people in Europe, a factor linked
perhaps to the still more or less vibrant faith of so many Irish
people, who make up the highest percentage of regular Sunday
Mass-goers in Western Europe.

In Ireland today, few want to be called conservative and those who do
are often an embarrassment. Most want to be seen as liberal and
progressive – even if only a tiny minority want to be progressive
democrats! Progress tends to be seen as being of its nature something
unequivocally good and positive. The Catholic Church in Ireland has
been increasingly attacked as the major obstacle to progress: it is
accused of being traditional, conservative, even reactionary, in the
face of so-called liberal values that a highly motivated minority
seek to impose on the majority. The paradox is that the Church’s own
massive investment in education over the past two centuries arguably
provided one of the conditions for our present economic progress.

Irish Catholic Church leaders since Vatican II often lacked a
critical theological sense and were themselves afraid of being
labelled conservative (or pre-Vatican II). Consequently, they have
been less than convincing in their defence of traditional Catholic
faith and practice. More recently, they have been intimidated into
quasi-silence by clerical sexual scandals. And yet, at the
grass-roots level, the Church is stronger and more vibrant than many
imagine. There, participation in Church life is not experienced as an
obstacle to progress but the means by which people rise above the
flat meaningless of an increasingly grey world of material progress.
I would argue that secularism is the ultimate source of that bleak
world.

`Soviet Communism and Liberal Capitalism share the same basic
convictions about reality. Both worldviews are materialist, in the
sense that they hold that matter is primary, spirit being simply the
product of matter. This is the dogma of evolutionism. As a result,
both worldviews deny explicitly or implicitly the primacy of the
human being. Both claim the end justifies the means, which is the
perversion of one of the most fundamental moral axioms, namely that
the end cannot ever justify the means.’

Secularism, as is well known, has its roots in the reduced form of
reason which the Enlightenment embraced. It is better described as
rationalism since it excludes God from its scope. The power and the
fragility of this restricted form of reason gave modern Europe the
specific shape we know today. The power unleashed by this form of
reason gave rise to phenomenal developments in science and
technology, and it created the modern notion of human rights that
fuelled the American and French revolutions. These are positive
achievements. On the downside is the fragility of this understanding
of reason, which was manifested in the reign of terror first
unleashed by the French Revolution. It found its most horrific
expression in Marxism and Nazism, both products of that particular
kind of reason, which first emerged in the Enlightenment. Why?

God was left out of the equation, and so man sought to redeem himself
by trying to formulate his own moral norms and to create a perfect
society on earth through social engineering. Liberal capitalism,
Marxism, and Nazism are all attempts to achieve this goal, the most
successful being liberal capitalism. Despite their obvious
differences, both Soviet Communism and liberal capitalism share the
same basic convictions about reality, as Vaclav Havel pointed out
some years ago, when he was still a dissident. Both worldviews are
materialist, in the sense that they hold that matter is primary,
spirit being simply the product of matter. This is the dogma of
evolutionism. As a result, both worldviews deny explicitly or
implicitly the primacy of the human being. Finally, both claim the
end justifies the means, which is the perversion of one of the most
fundamental moral axioms, namely that the end cannot ever justify the
means.

When the Absolute, God, is denied, then those aspects of social life
that should be relative become absolute. As a result, individuals are
freely sacrificed on the altar of a new god: race, nation, the myth
of progress articulated in political ideologies, or, as increasingly
in Ireland today, the economy. (The Government’s failure to oppose EU
funding for destructive embryonic stem-cell research lest we would be
left out of possible economic benefits is a case in point.) At the
heart of such a society, where only wealth counts, and where might
increasingly becomes right, a void opens up that leads to escapism of
every kind, from drugs to suicide.

Furthermore, totalitarianism is not something of the past, but is a
real threat today in Europe, Ireland included. Its shadow can be
found in the thinly veiled threats made last year by a member of the
Government-appointed Crisis Pregnancy Agency to the few chemists left
in Ireland that still refuse on conscientious grounds to sell
contraceptives. In a totalitarian State, even when it calls itself
pluralist, all must conform.

Celtic cross from Clonmacnoise.

The Church is not an obstacle to real progress, but it is an obstacle
to the false religion of progress based on the myth of creating a
perfect society on earth. Pure religion is the conditio sine qua non
for genuine progress and the creation of a truly human civilization,
a civilization of love. The existential question is: is the Church of
the majority in Ireland at present capable of rising to the task of
supplying this pure religion?

D. Vincent Twomey, SVD, is the author of The End of Irish
Catholicism?, Veritas, 2003. His new book, Benedict XVI, Conscience
of Our Time will be published by Ignatius Press in April.

ml

http://www.theword.ie/cms/publish/article_484.sht

Man detained in connection with alleged coup plot probe in Armenia

International Herald Tribune, France
Dec 29 2006

Man detained in connection with alleged coup plot probe in Armenia
The Associated PressPublished: December 29, 2006

YEREVAN, Armenia: Security officers in Armenia have detained a man in
connection with an alleged coup plot by opposition activists,
officials said Friday.

Vaan Aronian was arrested at his home in the village of Lusatar in
western Armenia, where security officers found weapons and ammunition
including guns, grenade launchers and a shoulder-fired missile
launcher, the National Security Service said in a statement.

It said the detention was linked to a probe that led to the arrest
earlier this month of Zhirair Sefilian, a Lebanese citizen who heads
the Association of Armenian Volunteers, and another activist of the
group, Vadan Malkhasian.

The two are accused of plotting a coup, making public demands for the
government’s ouster, and possessing illegal weapons – charges they
have denied. A court in mid-December ordered them to be held in jail
for two months as the investigation continues.

Members of the Association of Armenian Volunteers have said the
arrests were part of an attempt by the authorities to stifle dissent
in the run-up to parliamentary elections next year.

Sefilian is a veteran of the 1988-1994 war in the disputed enclave of
Nagorno-Karabakh, which ended when Armenia-backed separatists drove
out Azerbaijan’s government forces.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Torosyan: Attitude of CoE & Armenia towards regional issues coincide

Arka News Agency, Armenia.
Dec 29 2006

TOROSYAN: ATTITUDE OF COE AND ARMENIA TOWARDS REGIONAL ISSUES COINCIDE

YEREVAN, December 29. /ARKA/. The attitude of the Council of Europe
(CoE) and Armenia towards regional issues coincided with each other,
Speaker of the RA National Assembly Tigran Torosyan said.
He said that the Parliamentary Assembly of the CoF was an important
structure for Armenia from the viewpoint of the international
cooperation. "Political and democratic constituent of Armenia’s the
eurointegration was being formed in the scope of the PACE", he
pointed out.
In that connection Torosyan emphasized that in 2006 the PACE had
approved two important resolutions. "In April I adopted a resolution
on the state of refugees in South Caucasus, according to which the
situation in Armenia was incomparably better that in Georgia and
Azerbaijan", he said.
Torosyan pointed out that the number of Azerbaijani refugees,
totaling 83ths people, was fixed in the report, and the number of
displaced people from regions, bordering Nagorno-Karabakh, slightly
topped 500 thsd.
"After this many high-ranking officials and representatives of
international organizations began indicating it", he informed and
added that those figures were also noted in the PACE report on
Stability Pact for the South Caucasus.
Torosyan finds that it’s a rather important step to break the
stereotype that the Azerbaijani side tried to thrust on the
international community regarding this issue.

BAKU: ICRC representatives meet with captured Azerbaijani soldier

Azeri Press Agency, Azerbaijan
Dec 29 2006

ICRC representatives meet with captured Azerbaijani soldier

[ 29 Dec. 2006 17:48 ]

The representatives of International Committee of Red Cross Armenia
Office visited the Azerbaijani Soldier Samir Mammadov Nazim who was
captured by Armenians on December 24, ICRC Baku Office told APA.

According to the information got from the office, the officers of the
organization delivered him his family’s letter. This is their third
visit to the soldier.
It should be noted that Samir Mammadov was drafted from Barda
Military Registration department and was captured in neutral zone-
Gazakh-Ijevan border. The soldier did not have weapon. /APA/

BAKU: Ibrahimov: not satisfied with inactivity of Azerb. Diaspora

Azeri Press Agency, Azerbaijan
Dec 29 2006

Nazim Ibrahimov: I am not satisfied with the idea of inactivity of
Azerbaijani Diaspora

[ 29 Dec. 2006 17:23 ]

There is no controversy among Azerbaijani Diasporas

The chief of State Committee on Work with Azerbaijanis Living Abroad
Nazim Ibrahimov’s interview to APA

– Are you satisfied with the present situation of Azerbaijani
Diasporas?
– Azerbaijani Diasporas are developing rapidly. We have not thought
about so dynamic development of the Diasporas. President Ilham
Aliyev’s special care created turning point in the development of our
Diasporas. Now we should prefer to strengthen lobbyism and to choose
the tactics of attacking using our solidarity. We have begun to work
on it. Azerbaijan has always had Diaspora. If Azerbaijani citizen
lives abroad, it means our Diaspora exists.
– How would you estimate the power of the Diaspora?
– Every Diaspora has its history and it has subjective and objective
factors. We have begun to work with our Diasporas recently. At the
same time I do not agree with the idea of the inactivity of
Diasporas. Our national self-esteem does not lag behind, but goes
forward. Some forces tried to make Azerbaijanis forget national
back-ground. Azerbaijanis living abroad establish their organizations
and strengthen. And it means that Azerbaijani Diaspora is strong. In
future we will be able to say that Azerbaijani Diaspora is the
strongest Diaspora of the world.
– You are speaking about the power of Azerbaijani Diaspora, but we do
not observe real solidarity.
– When Heydar Aliyev returned from Moscow, I asked him whether the
growth of industrial potential of some USSR countries depend on
leadership or there is another reason. He retold me an interesting
event. He noted that, USSR Political Bureau raised some issues to
take Air-conditioner Plant to Baku. But this plant was built in
Ukraine. Actually not leadership of Ukraine, but the leadership of
the union realized it. If we compare the activity of the Diaspora
with this event, we can say that Armenian Diasporas do not have their
own power. On the other hand there is another factor. Some forces are
for Armenians in information war between Azerbaijan and Armenia. We
should struggle to make world believe that we are just. Though there
are no Armenian Diasporas in some countries of the world, they are
supported. It means when we say that Armenian Diaspora is stronger,
every-one should understand that it is not their power. Azerbaijan
remained under occupation of other empires and states for centuries
and our compatriots lived in different social structures. Therefore
there is difference in mentality. Sometimes it impedes our
solidarity.
– The information was spread that an Armenian living abroad
transferred $120m to Armenian state budget. Why don’t we observe
these facts in our country?
– We have not reached this stage yet. Our aim is to help strengthen
the Diaspora in the countries where Azerbaijanis live. You know that
there are strong Armenian businessmen in the world…
– But there are strong Azerbaijani businessmen in the world too.
– We are different from Armenia… I think that Azerbaijan’s economy is
developing rapidly and our financial sources are enough to provide
the country. We intend to help most Azerbaijani organizations in the
world to strengthen. A day will come when rich Azerbaijanis will
define what spheres need help. But now we have no intention to ask
somebody for help.
– Several Diaspora organizations have separated recently, and in most
cases the committee you lead was said to be the cause of it.
– Azerbaijani government’s care and attention on Diasporas’ activity
caused fight for the leadership in a number of Diaspora
organizations. There is no controversy in Diaspora organizations.
Even separated organizations unite around Azerbaijan. They can not
agree on the problem leadership.
– What about people leaving Azerbaijan and coming to the country?
– Most of the people left Azerbaijan repent. Most of the emigrants
have returned. We get a lot of letters from Azerbaijanis living
abroad. The majority of them want to return to the country.
– How many Azerbaijani organizations are there in the world?
– Over 300.
– Where is our strongest Diaspora?
– I do not want to answer. Most of our Diaspora Organizations are
working hard.
– When Ramil Safarov murdered Armenian officer Gurgen Markaryan, your
approach to the case was not welcomed. You said that his actions were
not heroic and it was against Azerbaijan. Later you realized several
programs in the direction of recognition of Azerbaijan in Hungary.
What were the results of it?
– We did much. We have never made idle statements. Those who want to
form their policy on Ramil Safarov’s actions are wrong. Ramil
Safarov’s actions had a negative influence on the international image
of Azerbaijan.
– But some think that this incident had positive features…
– Armenians claim in the international organizations that
Azerbaijanis are cut-throat and display facts. I repeat that this
incident had a negative influence on Azerbaijan.
– What is the State Committee established on the struggle against
illegal migrants in Russia doing?
– There is nothing to worry. Corresponding bodies of both countries
are working on it. We try to solve the problem quietly. Azerbaijan
state supports every Azerbaijani. /APA/

Venice councilman was a problem-solver

Sarasota Herald-Tribune, FL
Dec 29 2006

Venice councilman was a problem-solver
By PATRICK WHITTLE

VENICE — More than a longtime Venice councilman or tireless public
servant, John Kalajian will be remembered as a man who cared about
solving problems in his community, his wife said Thursday.

"If there was a challenge, John always had a creative way to meet the
challenge," said Sarabeth Kalajian.

Kalajian, a Venice City Council member from 1978 to 1987 and a local
volunteer, fundraiser and community leader for many years, died Dec.
27 of cancer. He was 61.

Family members and former public officials and co-workers remembered
Kalajian as energetic, idealistic and motivated. During his time in
Venice, he served on the boards of a host of community organizations,
including the founding board of the Community Foundation of Sarasota
County. He also worked as a government relations consultant.

Stewart Stearns, president and CEO of the Community Foundation,
recalled a meeting when Kalajian worked for a drug education program
for youths. Kalajian put a chair in the middle of a circle of 60
youths and said: "Here, Stewart; here’s where you sit," Stearns said.

"I said ‘Why did you do that to me, John?’ He said, ‘Stewart, you
needed to learn as much as they did,’" Stearns said. "John expressed
a real deep concern for kids."

Kalajian’s path to Venice was circuitous: The son of ethnic
Armenians, he emigrated to Boston from Germany at age 4. The
Kalajians originally planned to move to California, but ended up
settling in Boston when John’s father became ill. In 1974, John
Kalajian moved to Venice to work as a nurse anesthetist.

Some Venice residents recognize Kalajian for helping to build the
Centennial Park Gazebo and to refurbish the Venice Fishing Pier. Ed
Taylor, a former City Council member who served with Kalajian,
remembers him as "just a real straight shooter."

"All of us were enamored of John’s patriotism and his commitment to
the city," Taylor said.

Kalajian is survived by his wife, Sarabeth, a son, Matthew Kalajian
of Charlotte, N.C.; a daughter, Jill Kalajian of Tampa; parents Paul
and Araxi Kalajian of Boston; and sisters Karen Kalajian of Windham,
Maine, Alice Hunter of Philadelphia and Audrey Kalajian of Arlington,
Mass.

A service for Kalajian is planned for 1 p.m. Jan. 2 at the Selby
Botanical Gardens Great Room by the Bay.

The John L. Kalajian and Sarabeth A. Kalajian Fund for Children’s
Literacy at the Community Foundation of Sarasota County Inc. is
accepting memorial contributions.

The address is P.O. Box 49587, Sarasota, FL 34237. Contributions can
also be made to TideWell Hospice and Palliative Care, 5955 Rand
Blvd., Sarasota, FL 34238.

ANKARA: Courts Pressure Translators Too

BİA, Turkey
Dec 29 2006

Courts Pressure Translators Too
Publisher Zarakolu’s trial for "insulting the Republic" by publishing
books of two Armenian writers took a twist when the judge postponed
the case to include the translators. In two other incidents
translators were tried in freedom of expression cases.

BIA News Center
18/12/2006 Erol ONDEROGLU

BİA (Istanbul) – Publisher Ragip Zarakolu’s case where he’s
tried with 13.5 years imprisonment for "insulting the republic, its
institutions and Ataturk" by publishing two books of Armenian
writers, continued on December 14.

The judge postponed the case, ordering the translator of the books to
be brought to court. This is seen as another attempt to try
translators in freedom of expression cases.

Shafak and Tirman’s translators

Zarakolu stands trial because of publishing Prof. Dora Sakaryan’s
"The Memorials of an Armenian Doctor" and George Jerjian’s "Reality
Will Set Us Free".

Prosecution demands 7.5 years in prison for "insulting and ridiculing
the Republic and the State" of the first case and 6 years for
"insulting Turkishness and the armed forces" for the latter.

Translators Lutfi Taylan Tosun and Aysel Yildirim are being
prosecuted alongside Aram Publishing House owner Fatih Tas for the
Turkish language copy of John Tirman’s book "Spoils of War: The Human
Cost of America’s Arms Trade".

Writer Elif Shafak’s translator Aslı Bicen was also tried when
her book "Father and Bastard" put onto court with the claim of
"insulting Turkishness".

Zarakolu’s cases will continue in March 15.(EO/EU)

ANKARA: Tariq Ali Diary on Diyarbakir and More

BİA, Turkey
Dec 29 2006

Tariq Ali Diary on Diyarbakır and More

The PKK decision offers the possibility of genuine reforms and
autonomy, but this will happen only if the Turkish army agrees to
retire to its barracks. Economic conditions in the Kurdish areas are
now desperate.

London Review of Books
22/11/2006 Tariq ALI

BİA (London) – It was barely light in Istanbul as I stumbled
into a taxi and headed for the airport to board a flight for
Diyarbakir, the largest Kurdish city in eastern Turkey, not far from
the Iraqi border. The plane was full, thanks to a large party of what
looked like chattering students with closely shaved heads, whose
nervous excitement seemed to indicate they’d never left home before.

One of them took the window seat next to my interpreter. It turned
out he wasn’t a student but a newly conscripted soldier, heading east
for more training and his first prolonged experience of barrack-room
life, perhaps even of conflict.

He couldn’t have been more than 18; this was his first time on a
plane. As we took off he clutched the seat in front of him and looked
fearfully out of the window. During the flight he calmed down and
marvelled at the views of the mountains and lakes below, but as the
plane began its descent he grabbed the seat again. Our safe landing
was greeted with laughter by many of the shaven-headed platoon.

Only a few weeks previously, some young soldiers had been killed in
clashes with guerrillas belonging to the Kurdistan Workers’ Party
(PKK). It used to be the case that when Turkish soldiers died in the
conflict, their mothers were wheeled on to state television to tell
the world how proud they were of the sacrifice. They had more sons at
home, they would say, ready and waiting to defend the Fatherland.
This time the mothers publicly blamed the government for the deaths
of their sons.

Diyarbakir is the de facto capital of the Turkish part of Kurdistan,
itself a notional state that extends for some six hundred miles
through the mountainous regions of south-eastern Turkey, northern
Syria, Iraq and Iran. Turkish Kurdistan is home to more than 14
million Kurds, who make up the vast majority of the region’s
population; there are another four million Kurds in northern Iraq,
some five million in Iran and a million in Syria.

The Turkish sector is the largest and strategically the most
important: it would be central to a Kurdish state. Hence the paranoia
exhibited by the Turkish government and its ill-treatment of the
Kurdish population, whose living conditions are much worse than those
of the Kurds in Iraq or Iran.

Kurdish language and culture were banned at the foundation of the
unitary Turkish Republic in1923. The repression intensified during
the 1970s, and martial law was imposed on the region in1978, followed
by two decades of mass arrests, torture, killings, forced
deportations and the destruction of Kurdish villages.

The PKK, founded by the student leader Abdullah Öcalan in 1978, began
a guerrilla war in1984, claiming the Kurds’ right to
self-determination within (this was always stressed) the framework of
a democratised and demilitarised Turkish state. By ‘democratisation’
Kurds mean the repeal of laws used to harass minorities or to deny
them basic political rights. The constitution, for example,
established in 1982, requires a party to get 10 per cent of the vote
nationally before it can win parliamentary representation – the
highest such threshold in the world. Kurdish nationalists
consistently receive a majority of the votes in parts of eastern
Turkey but have no members of parliament.

When, in 1994, centre-left Kurdish deputies formed a new party to get
over the 10 per cent barrier, they were arrested on charges of aiding
the PKK and sentenced to 15 years in jail.

An estimated 200,000 Turkish troops have been permanently deployed in
Kurdistan since the early 1990s, and in 1996 and 1998 fierce battles
resulted in thousands of Kurdish casualties. By February 1999, when
the fugitive Öcalan was captured in Kenya – possibly by the CIA – and
handed over to Turkey, more than 30,000 Kurds had been killed and
some 3000 villages burned or destroyed, which resulted in a new
exodus to Diyarbakir; the city now has a population of more than a
million.

At the end of 1999, after heavy American lobbying, the EU extended
candidate status to Turkey, with further negotiations conditional on
some amelioration, at least, of the Kurdish situation. The pace of
reforms accelerated after the election of Recep Tayyip Erdogan ‘s
government in November 2002. In 2004, the Kurdish deputies who had
been arrested ten years earlier were finally released, and a
Kurdish-language programme was broadcast for the first time on state
television. In line with EU cultural heritage provisions, restoration
work began on the old palace in Diyarbakir – even while Kurdish
prisoners were still being tortured in its cellars.

My host, Melike Coskun, the director of the Anadolu Cultural Centre,
suggested a tour of the walls and the turbot-shaped old town. We
picked up Seymus Diken, cultural adviser to the recently elected
young pro-PKK mayor. He took us to a mosque that was once a cathedral
and before that a pagan temple where sun-worshippers sacrificed
virgins on large stone slabs in the courtyard. It was a Friday during
Ramadan and the mosque was filling up. The majority belonging to the
dominant Sunni Hanafi school occupied the main room while the Shafii
prayed in a smaller one.

We then visited three empty Christian churches. The first was
Chaldean, built in 300 ad, and its brick dome was exquisitely held in
place by intertwined wooden arches. The second, which was Assyrian,
was square, and even older, with Aramaic carvings on the wood and
stones. The caretaker lives in rooms attached to the church and grows
vegetables in what was once the garden of the bishop’s palace.

Hens roamed about, occasionally laying eggs beneath the altar. The
Armenian church was more recent – 16th century – but without a roof.
It was a more familiar shape, like a Roman Catholic church, and the
priest confirmed that the Armenians who had once worshipped here were
Catholics. Seymus began to whisper something to him. I became
curious. ‘It’s nothing,’ Seymus said. ‘Since my triple bypass the
only drink I’m allowed is red wine and there is a tiny vineyard
attached to a monastery in the countryside. I pick up a few bottles
from this church. It’s good wine.’ This was strangely reassuring.

We walked over to the old city walls, first built with black stone
more than 2000 years ago, with layers added by each new conqueror.
The crenellated parapets and arched galleries are crumbling; many
stones have been looted to repair local houses. From an outpost on
the wall, the Tigris is visible as it makes its way south. Seymus
told me that he had been imprisoned in the palace cells by the
Turkish authorities.

‘The next time you come,’ he promised, ‘this building will be totally
restored and we will sip our drinks and watch the Tigris flow.’ In a
large enclosed space below the wall there was an exhibition of
photographs of Diyarbakir in 1911. The images, of a virtually intact
medieval city, seemed to have little interest in the people who lived
there but concentrated on the buildings.

The photographer was Gertrude Bell,who later boasted that she had
created modern Iraq on behalf of the British Empire by ‘drawing lines
in the sand’. These lines, of course, also divided the territory of
the Kurdish tribes, which claim an unbroken history in this area,
stretching back well before the Christian era.

The first written records come after the Arab Muslim conquest. In the
tenth century, the Arab historian Masudi listed the Kurdish mountain
tribes in his nine-volume history, Meadows of Gold. Like most of the
inhabitants of the region they converted to Islam in the seventh and
eighth centuries, and were recruited to the Muslim armies.

They were rebellious, however, and took part in such uprisings as the
Kharijite upheavals of the ninth century. (The Kharijites denounced
the hereditary tradition as alien to Islam and demanded an elected
caliph. They were crushed.) The Kurds settled around Mosul and took
part in the epic slave revolt of the Zanj in southern Mesopotamia in
875. This, too, was defeated. Subsequently Kurdish bands wandered the
region as mercenaries. Saladin’s family belonged to one such group,
whose military skills soon propelled its leaders to power. During the
16th-century conflicts between the Ottoman Empire and the Safavids
who ruled Iran, Kurdish tribes fought on both sides. Inter-tribal
conflicts made Kurdish unity almost impossible.

When Gertrude Bell visited Diyarbakir in 1911, Muslims (mostly Kurds)
constituted 40 per cent of the population. Armenians, Chaldeans and
Assyrians, groups that had settled in what is now eastern Turkey well
over a thousand years before the Christian era, remained the dominant
presence. Istanbul was becoming increasingly unhappy with the idea of
such a mixed population, and even before the Young Turks seized power
from the sultan in 1909, a defensive nationalist wave had led to
clashes between Turks and Armenian groups and small-scale massacres
in the east.

The Armenians began to be seen as the agents of foreign countries
whose aim was to dismember the Ottoman Empire. It’s true that various
wealthy Armenian (and Greek) factions were only too happy to cosy up
to the West during the dying days of the Ottoman Empire, but much of
the Armenian population continued to live peacefully with their
Muslim neighbours in eastern Anatolia. They spoke Turkish as well as
their own language, just as the Kurds did. But Armenian nationalist
revolutionaries were beginning to talk of an Armenian state and the
communities increasingly divided along political lines.

Kurdish militia was set up by the sultan to cow the Armenians, and
then Mehmed Talat, the minister for the interior (who would be
assassinated by an Armenian nationalist), decided to get rid of them
altogether. The Kurdish irregulars carried out the forced expulsions
and massacres of 1915 in which up to a million Armenians died.

Melike told me that her grandmother was Armenian, and that Kurdish
families had saved many lives and given refuge to Armenian women and
children who had converted to Islam in order to survive. Two years
ago Fethiye Çetin, a lawyer and a historian, published a book about
her grandmother, who in old age had confessed to Çetin that she
wasn’t a Muslim, but an Armenian Christian. The book was launched at
the cultural centre Melike runs. ‘The hall was packed with women who
had never been near our centre before,’ Melike said. ‘After Fethiye
had finished so many women wanted to speak and discuss their Armenian
roots. It was amazing.’ Çetin writes that her grandmother was a
‘sword leftover’ child, which is how people whose lives had been
spared were described: ‘I felt my blood freeze. I had heard of this
expression before. It hurt to find it being used to describe people
like my grandmother. My optimism, which was formed with memories of
tea breads, turned to pessimism.’

The political logic of ultra-nationalism proved deadly for both
victim and perpetrator. The aim of the Young Turks had been to expel
the non-Muslim minorities with a view to laying the foundations of a
new and solid unitary state. The exchange of populations with Greece
was part of this plan.

In 1922 Atatürk came to power and made the plan a reality under the
slogan ‘one state, one citizen and one language’. The language was
Latinised, with many words of Arab and Persian origin cast aside very
much like the unwanted citizens. Given that virtually the entire
population was now Muslim, the secular foundations of the new state
were extremely weak, with the military as the only enforcer of the
new order. The first blowback came with the 1925 Kurdish uprising.
Then, as now, religion could not dissolve other differences. The
rebellion lasted several months, and when it was finally put down all
hopes for Kurdish autonomy disappeared. The Kurds’ culture and
language were suppressed. Many migrated to Istanbul and Izmir and
other towns, but the Kurdish question would never go away.

I had been invited to give a lecture in Diyarbakir on the Kurdish
question and the war in Iraq. Four years ago, while the war was still
being plotted in Washington, Noam Chomsky and I were invited to
address a public sector trade-union congress in Istanbul. Many of
those present were of Kurdish origin. I said then that there would be
a war and that the Iraqi Kurds would whole-heartedly collaborate with
the US, as they had been doing since the Gulf War, and expressed the
hope that Turkish Kurds would resist the temptation to do the same.
Afterwards I was confronted by some angry Kurds.

How dare I mention them in the same breath as their Iraqi cousins?
Was I not aware that the PKK had referred to the tribal chiefs in
Iraqi Kurdistan as ‘primitive nationalists’? In fact, one of them
shouted, Barzani and Talabani (currently the president of Iraq) were
little better than ‘mercenaries and prostitutes’. They had sold
themselves successively to the shah of Iran, Israel, Saddam Hussein,
Khomeini and now the Americans. How could I even compare them to the
PKK? In 2002 I was only too happy to apologise. I now wish I hadn’t.

The PKK didn’t share the antiwar sentiment that had engulfed the
country in 2003 and pushed the newly elected parliament into
forbidding the US from entering Iraq from Turkey. But while Kurdish
support for the war was sheepish and shame-faced in Istanbul, no such
inhibitions were on display in Diyarbakir.

Virtually every question after my talk took Kurdish nationalism as
its starting point. That was the only way they could see the war.
Developments in northern Iraq, or southern Kurdistan, as they call it
in Diyarbakir, have created a half-hope, half-belief, that the
Americans might undo what Gertrude Bell and the British did and give
the Kurds their own state. I pointed out that America’s principal
ally in Turkey was the army, not the PKK.

‘What some of my people don’t understand is that you can be an
independent state and still not free, especially now,’ one veteran
muttered in agreement. But most of the people there were happy with
the idea of Iraqi Kurdistan becoming an American-Israeli
protectorate. ‘Give me a reason, other than imperial conspiracy, why
Kurds should defend the borders which have been their prisons,’
someone said. The reason seemed clear to me: whatever happened they
had to go on living there. If they started killing their neighbours,
the neighbours would want revenge. By collaborating with the US, the
Iraqi Kurdish leaders in the north are putting the lives of fellow
Kurds in Baghdad at risk. It’s the same in Turkey. There are nearly
two million Kurds in Istanbul, including many rich businessmen
integrated in the economy. They can’t be ignored.

As I was flying back to Istanbul the PKK announced a unilateral
ceasefire. Turkey’s moderate Islamist government must be secretly
relieved. The PKK decision offers the possibility of genuine reforms
and autonomy, but this will happen only if the Turkish army agrees to
retire to its barracks. Economic conditions in the Kurdish areas are
now desperate: the flow of refugees has not stopped and increasing
class polarisation is reflected in the growth of political Islam.

A Kurdish Hizbullah was formed some years ago (with, so it’s said,
the help of Turkish military intelligence, which hoped it might
weaken the PKK), and the conditions are ripe for its growth. Its
first big outing in Diyarbakir was a 10,000-strong demonstration
against the Danish cartoons. If things don’t change, the movement is
bound to grow. (TA/EU)

* This article of Tariq Ali was published in London Review of Books
on 16 November.

BAKU: Armenia accused for non-execution of PACE commitments

Azeri Press Agency, Azerbaijan
Dec 29 2006

Armenia accused for non-execution of PACE commitments

[ 29 Dec. 2006 12:04 ]

The report on implementation of Armenia’s PACE commitments will be
announced in PACE winter session, APA reports.

Some items about non-execution of the commitments are reflected in
the report. The report contains some notes about Armenia’s holding
elections not on international principles, falsification in election
process and unpunished persons having serious legal irregularities.
/APA/

2006 significant year for Armenia in terms of HR protection

ARKA News Agency, Armenia
Dec 29 2006

2006 SIGNIFICANT YEAR FOR ARMENIA IN TERMS OF HUMAN RIGHTS PROTECTION
AND DEMOCRATIC DEVELOPMENT

YEREVAN, December 28. /ARKA/. 2006 was significant for Armenia in
terms of human rights protection and democratic development, the New
Year greeting message of Speaker of the Armenian parliament Tigran
Torosyan says.
He said that in 2006, due to constitutional reforms every citizen and
the parliamentary opposition received an effective mechanism for
protection of their rights at the Constitutional Court.
Speaker pointed out that the current year was important from the
viewpoint of the Nagorno-Karabakh’s conflict resolution. "After the
PACE adopted the resolution on rights for self-determination of
nations, it was included in the principles of the Karabakh conflict
settlement by the OSCE Minsk Group co-chairs. It was also reflected
in the approaches of all of the European organizations," Torosyan
said.
The Speaker also pointed out that the economic growth of the previous
several years has strengthened economy and provided a fundament that
the growth of state revenues would be first of all aimed at
supporting education, science and culture, and ensure fair and
proportional allocation of the revenues to contribute to a tangible
increase in the citizens’ welfare. R.O. -0–