La Chine et l’Arménie promouvront leurs relations bilatérales
Xinhua News Agency – French
27 septembre 2004 lundi 11:01 AM EST
BEIJING – La Chine et l’Arménie souhaitent intensifier leurs échanges
dans divers secteurs afin de promouvoir le développement de leur
coopération amicale, selon une déclaration conjointe sino-arménienne
publiée lundi à Beijing.
La déclaration, signée par le Président chinois Hu Jintao et
son homologue arménien Robert Sedrakovich Kocharyan, indique que
les deux parties apprécient la coopération fructueuse entre les
deux pays dans les domaines politique, économique, commercial,
scientifique, technologique, culturel et dans d’autres secteurs
depuis l’établissement des relations diplomatiques entre les deux
pays en 1992.
Les deux parties sont satisfaites du développement régulier des
relations bilatérales et continueront à promouvoir les échanges de
haut niveau, affirme la déclaration.
Les deux parties encouragent et soutiennent la coopération entre les
entreprises des deux pays dans le but de renforcer le niveau de la
coopération économique et commerciale entre la Chine et l’Arménie.
L’Arménie a réitéré que la République populaire de Chine était
le seul gouvernement légitime représentant l’ensemble de la Chine
et que Taiwan était une partie inséparable de la Chine. L’Arménie
n’établira aucun contact officiel avec Taiwan et s’oppose à la soi-
disant “indépendance de Taiwan”, dit la déclaration.
La Chine soutient les efforts déployés par la communauté internationale
pour trouver une solution pacifique au problème Nogorno-Karabakh,
souhaitant que le conflit puisse être résolu de manière juste et
raisonnable conformément aux normes et aux principes internationaux
interessés, selon la déclaration.
Category: News
Entretien entre les =?UNKNOWN?Q?pr=E9sidents?= chinois et=?UNKNOWN?Q
Entretien entre les présidents chinois et arménien
Xinhua News Agency – French
27 septembre 2004 lundi 11:01 AM EST
BEIJING — Le Président chinois Hu Jintao s’est entretenu, lundi à
Beijing, avec son homologue arménien Robert Sedrakovich Kocharyan,
qui effectue actuellement sa première visite d’Etat en Chine en tant
que président arménien.
Hu a déclaré que la Chine était prête à travailler avec l’Arménie
afin de promouvoir les relations bilatérales à un nouveau palier.
Il a appelé à renforcer les échanges et la coopération bilatéraux
dans tous les domaines, tout en ajoutant que la Chine encourageait
les entreprises chinoises à coopérer avec la partie arménienne,
à augmenter leurs investissements et à participer à la construction
des infrastructures en Arménie.
La Chine apprécie la politique diplomatique arménienne et remercie
l’Arménie pour son soutien aux problèmes de Taïwan et de Tibet,
a ajouté le Président chinois.
Kocharyan a souligné que son pays souhaitait renforcer les relations
bilatérales avec la Chine ainsi que leur coopération dans les
domaines d’énergie, d’industrie chimique, d’agriculture et de
technologie. L’Arménie reconnaît le statut d’économie de marché de
la Chine, a-t-il fait remarquer.
Il a aussi ajouté que l’Arménie continuerait à soutenir la politique
d’une seule Chine et la réunification de la Chine.
Les deux parties ont signé une déclaration conjointe à l’issue de cet
entretien et assisté à une cérémonie de signature de trois accords
coopératifs.
From MFA Media Desk
MINISTRY OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS OF THE REPUBLIC OF ARMENIA
—————————————— —-
PRESS AND INFORMATION DEPARTMENT
375010 Telephone: +3741. 544041 ext 202
Fax: +3741. .562543
Email: [email protected]:
PRESS RELEASE
28 September 2004
On 27 September Foreign Minister Vartan Oskanian held several meetings
in New York, within the framework of the 59th General Assembly of the
United Nations. In their fourth meeting, Turkish Foreign Minister
Abdullah Gul and Minister Oskanian explored bilateral issues as
well as regional concerns. This meeting followed a meeting with
Minsk Group co-chairman Ambassador Steven Mann. Earlier in the day,
the Minister had met with US Undersecretary of State Mark Grossman,
with whom they explored bilateral issues, including the upcoming
Armenia-US Task Force meeting and the Millennium Challenge Account.
The Minister also met with Jean Obeid, Foreign Minister of Lebanon,
who was also in New York for the UN General Assembly.
The Minister will remain in NY through Wednesday September 29 when
he will address the General Assembly.
Tensions high in disputed Caucasus territory
Tensions high in disputed Caucasus territory
By Onnik Krikorian
Great Reporter
Sept 27 2004
In Greek mythology, the Caucasus was a pillar supporting the world,
but today the developing region is a hotbed of discontent that
threatens to erupt into conflict once more…
Anyone taking the road from Goris to Stepanakert has passed through
Lachin, the strategic, main artery in the lifeline between Armenia
and the self-declared Republic of Nagorno-Karabakh. Few actually
visit the town now of course, perhaps unsurprisingly given the
destruction evident throughout. The only interest for many passing
through is that Lachin lies not in Karabakh, but within what the
international community considers sovereign Azerbaijani territory.
Conflict erupted over Nagorno Karabakh in 1988 after this tiny
enclave, mainly inhabited by Christian Armenians but governed by
Azerbaijan, demanded reunification with Armenia. Moslem Azerbaijan
refused. At least 25,000 died during the following six years of
fighting, and one million were forced to flee their homes. By the
time a ceasefire agreement was signed in May 1994, Armenian forces
controlled 14 per cent of Azerbaijan.
Most of the 700,000 Azeri refugees that ended up living in squalid
camps in Azerbaijan come from territory outside of Karabakh proper,
and for the international mediators charged with the task of finding
a peaceful solution to the 13-year-old conflict; any settlement must
include the return of refugees to their former homes. The reality at
ground zero, however, is that those villages and towns have long
since been razed.
For most Armenians, this bridge between Armenia and Karabakh is part
of an ancient historical motherland usurped long ago from its
rightful owners by nomadic Turkic interlopers and is now being
resettled. For Azeris, this is their land, recognised internationally
and seized illegitimately. Nearly eight years after the ceasefire,
the issue still has the power to pull Azeris out onto the streets,
demanding, as they have in recent weeks and months, that their
government take military action to reclaim the territory.
Into the buffer zone
The daily van that departs for Lachin from Yerevan should make the
trip in five hours, but, driving at a snail’s pace, it takes seven.
The landscape is scenic but the journey arduous, and the road itself
says much about the region’s recent history. After passing the border
where Armenia theoretically ends, the road is immaculately asphalted,
but rubble from the war still lies strewn across the landscape.
Further on, wires strung across the valley, originally intended to
prevent low-flying helicopters from evading radar detection, still
remain.
On the outskirts of Lachin, a recently constructed church belies the
fact that this town, now renamed Berdzor, was once inhabited by at
least 20,000 Azeris and Kurds. During the war, both sides pursued
tactics designed to prevent inhabitants from returning to their
homes, and the destruction unleashed on Lachin was considerable.
Houses are being rebuilt however, but this time for approximately
3,000 Armenians relocated in an effort to repopulate the region.
The aim is to increase the population of the unrecognised republic
from under 150,000 in 1994 to 300,000 by 2010. Given the size of
Karabakh, it is hard to imagine that the plan does not also include
towns such as Lachin that lie outside Karabakh proper, in the buffer
zone connecting the enclave to Armenia. Moreover, while the official
line suggests that those relocating to Karabakh and elsewhere are
Armenian refugees from Azerbaijan, the reality on the ground suggests
otherwise.
New arrivals
Zoric Irkoyan, for one, is not a refugee. Arriving six years ago from
Yerevan, he openly admits that most of those inhabiting the disputed
territory are from Armenia and that few refugees have joined the
resettlement program. “Not many came because they were used to their
life in Baku and Sumgait [in Azerbaijan],” explains Irkoyan. “Many
now feel safer in Armenia, and like a million other Armenians, some
have left for Russia.”
Not surprising, perhaps.
What Irkoyan, his wife and two young daughters have come to is a
simple, virtually unfurnished shack. Chickens run free in the yard
outside, while a hole in the ground serves as the toilet for the
entire family. Cooking is on a simple electric stove that just about
manages to boil oriental coffee in 15 minutes, and water collects
every morning in the makeshift sink assembled outside.
An old, dilapidated television barely picks up Russian television,
and Armenian TV broadcast from Yerevan is even worse. Homes like
these are among the poorest to be found anywhere the Caucasus, and
while life may be difficult throughout the region, things are even
tougher in Lachin. Still, Irkoyan does have a good job now, working
as the chief education specialist for the local department of
education, youth affairs, and sports.
The flag of the unrecognized Republic of Nagorno-Karabakh flies over
his offices, a municipal building serving as the administrative
centre for most of the territory sandwiched between Armenia and
Karabakh. Stretching from Lachin to the Iranian border, what has
become known as the occupied territories is marked on Armenian maps
as Kashatagh, while to the north; Kelbajar is part of the New
Shahumian region. For the traveller, though, only the rather
insignificant border crossing indicates that this is not Armenia.
Irkoyan’s 45-minute journey to work takes him along terrible roads
that are, in some places, nonexistent. As we pass the remains of
devastated and derelict buildings, Irkoyan admits that conditions are
bad, but says that there are plenty more waiting to come.
Fifteen thousand Armenians already live in Kashatagh, and buses bring
the new arrivals to Lachin every week to claim social benefits
dispensed from the window of the building opposite.
It would seem that for many in Armenia, conditions can be even worse,
but in Lachin virtually everyone has work. Schools and other social
services have been established to cater to the needs of the settlers,
and there is also the lure of other benefits. Anyone intending to
relocate to Kashatagh receives financial incentives, cattle and
livestock worth about $240, land, and a ruined Azeri home that they
can call their own.
None of that influenced Irkoyan’s decision to resettle here, he says.
Part of the military force that seized the town 10 years earlier, he
considers it his duty. “It was our dream to liberate Lachin,” he
explains, “and when I heard that there were schools in the liberated
territories that needed specialists, I decided to move. If we were
occupying someone else’s land, I would never have come, but there are
Armenian churches and monuments destroyed by the Azeris everywhere.”
“While those who once lived here could say they that were fighting
for their birthplace,” he continues, “they could not say that they
were fighting for their historical motherland.
If some Azeris wanted to return we might consider giving them homes,
but they don’t.” Irkoyan adds that he even keeps the photograph of
the former occupants of the home he has since rebuilt. “They looked
like normal people,” he admits.
Future perfect?
The sound of construction work can be heard throughout Lachin and
there are even two markets, dozens of small shops, and a café. The
shops may carry the names of regions long since lost to Turkey, but
on the shelves, somewhat ironically, there are dozens of boxes of
Azeri tea (Azercay) imported via Georgia. Irkoyan says that he has
“no problem with establishing cultural or economic contact with the
Azeris.”
In contrast, Calouste, a 39-year-old former computer programmer from
the Bangladesh district of Yerevan who opened a grocery store in
Lachin four years ago, says that if there were enough Armenian goods
to sell, he wouldn’t stock a single imported item. That is his goal,
and when that happens, everything will be perfect.
Life may not yet meet Calouste’s definition of perfection and there
is much hardship here, but there is a sense that Lachin is developing
into a community, although of course, nothing is ever that simple in
the Caucasus. With salaries low throughout the region, many still buy
goods on credit. One customer has come in that day to settle his
account, handing 6,000 Armenian dram (about $12) over the counter
while Calouste’s sister crosses his name off a list that stretches
several pages.
Another waits in line to buy vodka and wine while Calouste encourages
him to buy goods produced in Armenia from a selection largely made up
of imported items. He already offers bottles of wine named after the
disputed city of Shushi in Karabakh, along with Armenian cigarettes,
vodka, light bulbs, chocolate, ice cream, and fruit juices. There is
even talk of growing tobacco nearby to supply cigarette producers in
Armenia.
“We don’t want help,” he says, apologising that he’s a nationalist.
“If Armenians living in the Diaspora just send us money, we’ll forget
how to help ourselves.”
Present imperfect
The next day, Irkoyan takes me northward in the direction of Herik,
formerly the Azeri village of Ahmadlu. Until around 1918, when the
Azeris came and displaced its Armenian population, it was the
Armenian village of Hayri. Herik lies 50 kilometres along a road that
passes the 5th Century Armenian monastery of Tsitsernavank, but it
seems like more than 200. Meandering through a pastoral scene that
contrasts sharply with the sight of towns and villages long since
razed to the ground, cows brought over the border with Armenia now
graze among the ruins.
In these parts, it is not always easy to talk, like Calouste, of
self-sufficiency. In Melikashen, a little village not far from
Lachin, one family invites us in for coffee. Amid the dirt and
dilapidation of their new home, “repossessed” from its former owners,
the new arrivals explain that the Armenian Diaspora must invest in
these new communities while Irkoyan is more interested in validating
Armenian claims to this land by taking me to see an old Armenian
castle. An Azeri house has been built into its side.
Behind the remains of an Armenian stone cross now broken in two, pigs
are being herded into an outhouse while an old woman skins the head
of a slaughtered sheep on the balcony above. Her husband invites us
in, insisting, as duty demands, that we have some tan, a drink
similar to yogurt, before we leave. A passing car throws up a cloud
of dust, momentarily obscuring the view.
The next stop on a road that takes us past the remains of Azeri
villages, towns, cemeteries, and the occasional Armenian monastery
perched high overhead is Moshatagh. The village head, another new
arrival from Jermuk, once a popular tourist destination in Armenia,
sits with his family of eight on the veranda of their new home. His
four-wheel drive is needed to make the journey to Herik, high in the
surrounding hills, but even then, the twisting, narrow road will be
difficult.
Upon our arrival, children in threadbare clothing clamour to have
their photographs taken outside the 16th Century church that the
Azeris once used as a cattle shed. Conditions must have been
significantly worse in Armenia for families to consider relocating to
Herik. There are no telephones, and water has to be collected from a
hosepipe that serves as the irrigation system for the entire village.
Irkoyan says that 50 per cent of the villages now being resettled
have no electricity.
And for some, the conditions are too hard. Another family invites us
in. Their living conditions are the worst I have seen anywhere. They
have decided enough is enough and have since moved their seven
children to Lachin as the winter set in. Another family from the 13
who originally came here has also left.
Others, however, are more resilient and defiant. Feasting on barbecue
and lamb stew, perhaps as many as 100 sit around plastic sheets that
serve as makeshift tablecloths. The vodka flows as freely as the
nearby river, and toasts made by former fighters still in uniform are
simple and to the point. For them, this is Armenian land, and it will
never be given back.
Future imperfect?
Their toasts may be defiant, but there is a fear that gnaws the
villagers as they eat – that Armenian President Robert Kocharian
might make concessions in order to bring much-needed stability and
economic investment to the region. Reports from Key West, Florida,
where the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE)
attempted to broker an agreement, worry them.
So too do reports suggesting that in order to restart the peace
process after it stalled in June, Armenia would have to first
withdraw its troops from the occupied territories and return the land
to Azerbaijan. The aim may be peace, but such talk could bring the
sides closer to war again. Nationalists in both Armenia and
Azerbaijan have already said they would rather resume hostilities
than concede any territory to the other, and when Vardan Oskanian,
Armenia’s foreign minister, referred to Kashatagh as “occupied”,
political parties instead called for his resignation.
Echoing these sentiments, Irkoyan says he would refuse to leave.
“Some might have moved here because of the social conditions in
Armenia,” he says, “but others did not. I can’t guarantee that I will
always live in Lachin, but there is a connection with this land. It
is our life, and if we lose that, there is nothing. While I am not
saying that everybody will fight again, at least 30 per cent would.
Nobody can tell us what to do, not even the Americans.”
“There could be concessions from some parts of Fizuli and Aghdam,” he
continues, “but anyone who knows this territory understands that
nothing else can be returned. In my opinion, not one centimetre
should be given back. If we return anything, we will again be risking
the security of Armenians living in Karabakh. The most effective
peacekeeping force is our own.”
Further south, Razmik Kurdian, an Armenian from Lebanon who heads the
tiny village of Ditsmayri situated between Zangelan and the Iranian
border, puts it more bluntly. “This land was paid for in blood, and
will only be given back with blood,” he says, in between impromptu
renditions of old nationalist songs glorifying victories over the
Turks. “If anyone ever thought of returning this land, they would be
betraying the memory of those who died.”
For Irkoyan, Kurdian, and many others, therefore, this land will
always be Armenian but while they admit that small pockets of
territory outside Nagorno-Karabakh proper, in particular Aghdam and
Fizuli, could conceivably be given back, it is unlikely that
Azerbaijan and the international mediators will ever consider any of
this land as Armenian. For the peacemakers, then, conflicting claims
to the land that lies between Armenia and Nagorno-Karabakh could
prove as sensitive an issue as the status of Karabakh itself.
;file=article&sid=291
PACE session (4-8 October, Strasbourg)
PACE session (4-8 October, Strasbourg):
Urgent debate on terrorism
The situation in the Chechen Republic
Monaco accession ceremony
Strasbourg, 27.09.2004 – An urgent debate on the challenge of terrorism in
Council of Europe member states as well as a joint debate on the political,
human rights and humanitarian situation in the Chechen Republic are among
highlights of the session of the Council of Europe Parliamentary Assembly
(PACE), which takes place in Strasbourg from 4 to 8 October 2004.
Other items due for debate include the functioning of democratic
institutions in Serbia and Montenegro and in Azerbaijan, the honouring of
obligations and commitments by Armenia, as well as women’s participation in
elections.
Guest speakers include Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan, Crown
Prince Albert of Monaco – who is due to address the parliamentarians just
before the ceremony for Monaco’s accession – and the President of the new
Pan-African Parliament Gertrude Mongella.
Klaus Töpfer, Executive Director of the United Nations Environment
Programme, is due to participate in a debate on global warming. The annual
enlarged debate on the OECD and the world economy will take place in the
presence of its Deputy Secretary-General Berglind Asgeirsdottir. The
Director General of the World Trade Organization Supachai Panitchpakdi will
address parliamentarians during a debate on the Doha Development Agenda:
world trade at a crossroads.
The Norwegian Foreign Affairs Minister and Chairman of the Council of
Europe’s Committee of Ministers Jan Petersen, the Organisation’s Secretary
General Terry Davis, the President of its Congress of Local and Regional
Authorities Giovanni Di Stasi and the President of the “Venice Commission”
Antonio La Pergola will also address PACE. Council of Europe Commissioner
for Human Rights Alvaro Gil-Robles will take part in the debate on the
situation in the Chechen Republic.
The first ever meeting of women members of the Assembly is also due to take
place on the fringe of the session (Tuesday 5 October).
_________
Peter Schieder, President of the Parliamentary Assembly, will give a press
conference on Monday 4 October at 11 a.m. (Room 1). Other press conferences
will be announced on the spot.
./..
The following is a provisional order of business which may be altered by the
Assembly on the first day of the session.
Monday 4 October
? Statement by Gertrude Mongella, President of the Pan-African
Parliament
? Progress report of the Bureau of the Assembly and the Standing
Committee
? Statement by Antonio La Pergola, President of the European
Commission for Democracy through Law (“Venice Commission”)
? Communication from Terry Davis, Secretary General of the Council of
Europe
? The Doha Development Agenda: world trade at a crossroads and
statement by Supachai Panitchpakdi, Director General of the World Trade
Organization (WTO)
Tuesday 5 October
* Functioning of democratic institutions in Serbia and Montenegro
* Communication from the Committee of Ministers to the Parliamentary
Assembly presented by Jan Petersen, Minister for Foreign Affairs of Norway
and Chairman of the Committee of Ministers
* Address by H.S.H. Crown Prince Albert of Monaco
* Implementation of Resolution 1358 (2004) on the functioning of democratic
institutions in Azerbaijan
* European strategy for the promotion of sexual and reproductive health and
rights
* Women’s participation in elections
Wednesday 6 October
* Election of a judge to the European Court of Human Rights with respect to
Slovakia
* Statement by Giovanni Di Stasi, President of the Congress of Local and
Regional Authorities of the Council of Europe
* Possible urgent debate:Challenge of terrorism in Council of Europe member
states
* Address by Recep Tayyip Erdogan, Prime Minister of Turkey
* The OECD and the world economy and statement by Berglind Asgeirsdottir,
Deputy Secretary-General of the OECD
Thursday 7 October
* Joint debate on the political situation in the Chechen Republic: measures
to increase democratic stability in accordance with Council of Europe
standards, the human rights situation in the Chechen Republic and the
humanitarian situation of the Chechen displaced population
* Implementation of Resolutions 1361 (2004) and 1374 (2004) on the honouring
of obligations and commitments by Armenia
* Global warming: beyond Kyoto and statement by Klaus Töpfer,
ExecutiveDirector of the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP)
Friday 8 October
* New concepts to evaluate the state of democratic development
* Campaign to combat domestic violence against women in Europe
* Education for Europe
* Population trends in Europe and their sensitivity to policy measures
See the Assembly’s website, , for further details.
Additional information may also be found on the Council of Europe web
portal,
Contact:
Communication Unit of the Council of Europe Parliamentary Assembly
Tel. +33 3 88 41 31 93 Fax +33 3 90 2141 34; e-mail: [email protected]
2
Press Release
Parliamentary Assembly Communication Unit
Ref: 451a04
Tel: +33 3 88 41 31 93
Fax :+33 3 90 21 41 34
[email protected]
internet:
The Parliamentary Assembly brings together 626 members from the national
parliaments of the 45 member states.
President: Peter Schieder (Austria, SOC); Secretary General of the Assembly:
Bruno Haller.
Political Groups: SOC (Socialist Group); EPP/CD (Group of the European
People’s Party); LDR (Liberal, Democratic and Reformers’ Group);
EDG (European Democratic Group); UEL (Group of the Unified European Left).
ANKARA: Reconsidering Turkey
Reconsidering Turkey
By Richard Falk
Zaman, Turkey
Sept 27 2004
There is an exciting process of reform and reorientation taking place
in Turkey during the last few years that has been hardly noticed in
America, and certainly not properly appreciated.
To the extent any attention has been given, it has been to whether
the soft Islam of the AK Party provides the United States with an
opportunity to demonstrate its willingness and capacity to abide a
moderate Muslim outlook on the part of a foreign country in the
Middle East.
This possibility was severely strained in the weeks leading up to the
Iraq War when the Turkish Parliament twice narrowly turned down an
American request to use Turkish territory to launch its invasion.
This was at the time an unexpected show of strategic independence on
the part of Turkey, especially in the face of an American offer to
provide Turkey with much needed financial assistance in the amount of
$16 billion. It is worth remembering that during and after the cold
war Turkey had shaped its foreign policy entirely on the basis of
being a subordinate ally of the United States, and regionally since
the early 1990s, by working in an avowed partnership with Israel.
What was most surprising, and in the end revealing, about the Iraq
decision initially so resented in Washington was that the Turkish
military stayed in the barracks. In the recent past, any elected
government in Turkey was subject to repudiation by a military coup or
takeover if it crossed the red lines of either ‘secularism’ or the
strategic relationship with the United States and Israel. There
existed little room for maneuver on the part of politicians, and
foreign policy in particular was regarded as the domain of ‘the deep
state,’ the non-elected, non-accountable army leadership that had
claimed for itself the uncontested role of guarding the
constitutional order of republican Turkey as established by its
founding leader [Mustafa] Kemal Ataturk. What is fascinating about
this recent phase of Turkish foreign policy is this silent process of
fundamental change that has been taking place without attracting
notice except on an issue by issue basis. The scope and cumulative
weight of these changes should not be exaggerated. The deep state
remains in ultimate control of the political destiny of Turkey, and
the red lines still limit the options for elected leaders. But the
softening of these constraints is also part of the unfolding reality,
and deserves more attention than it has so far received.
Why this softening? I think the strength of the mandate received by
the AK Party in the last round of national elections over two years
ago, and the admitted absence of a secular alternative, has been
crucial. But also significant is the skill and creativity of its
leaders, particularly its Prime Minister, [Recep] Tayyip Erdogan, and
Foreign Minister, Abdullah Gul, in taking steps forward in a manner
made acceptable to the hidden military overseers, including even the
civilianizing of the Turkish National Security Council. And overall,
the unexpected success of the present leadership in Ankara of
stabilizing runaway Turkish inflation while generating one of the
world’s fastest rates of economic growth has given the government an
underpinning of credibility.
The most obvious explanation of this Turkish opening is undoubtedly
the consensus in Ankara that it is in the national interest of the
country to obtain membership in the European Union at the earliest
possible time. And it is agreed on all sides that this goal is
attainable, if at all, only if Turkey demonstrates a willingness to
clean up its human rights record and solve its main internal and
external problems. This pressure was present even before the AK
leadership arrived, and first became visible in earthquake diplomacy
in which the Greek humanitarian response to the Turkish disaster in
1998 led to a dramatic thawing of Greek/Turkish tensions, initiating
a process that removed a major source of resistance to Turkey’s
presence in the EU. In that instance, Turkey responded positively,
but it was Athens that took the initiative. But what has been
happening more recently discloses a much greater Turkish willingness
to take bold initiatives in foreign policy.
I would mention several notable developments, but there are more. The
Turkish government overcame the influence of its own formidable
rejectionists to accept the carefully balanced proposals by Kofi
Annan, on behalf of the United Nations, to solve the long-festering
Cyprus crisis. When Turkish Cypriots voted to accept the plan, and
Greek Cypriots voted to reject it, there emerged a new European and
global realization that Turkey was moving away from its earlier
pattern of rigid nationalism. It was also a clear signal that Turkey
was ready to become a responsible member of the EU.
More impressive, and more subtle, were the Turkish moves to improve
their relations with their Islamic neighbors. Prime Minister Erdogan
engaged in successful goodwill diplomacy with most of Turkey’s
neighbors, achieving a dramatic breakthrough by establishing an
accommodation with Syria, and notably improved relations with Iran
and Egypt. The Turkish government criticized Israel for the targeted
assassinations of Hamas leaders, further solidifying its new image as
a truly independent sovereign state that was now conducting its
foreign policy according to ethical and legal principles, as well as
on the basis of real politik.
Recently, I had the benefit of long conversations with Ahmet
Davutoglu, Chief Advisor to the Prime Minister and Foreign Minister,
who confirmed these trends, speaking of ‘a new paradigm’ in Turkish
foreign policy. This influential policy advisor, previously a leading
intellectual presence in the country, saw Turkey as playing a
decisive role as participant in an emerging multi-dimensional world
order, being still in a positive relationship with the United States
and Israel, but also an active player in Europe, the Middle East, and
Central Asia. Davutoglu represents a new cultural and political trend
in Turkey associated with a deliberate revival of the Ottoman past,
both as a matter of cultural enrichment, but also as a source of an
enriched Turkish identity as a political actor. What Davutoglu
particularly celebrates is what he calls the ‘accommodative’
character of the Ottoman Empire at its height, that is, the
willingness to appreciate and respect civilizational and ethnic
diversity, and to deal with political conflict in a spirit of
compromise and reconciliation. Davutoglu seeks what he calls ‘a zero
conflict’ foreign policy for Turkey, as well as a balance between
relations with Europe, the Middle East, Asia, and with the United
States. He agrees that much of this hinges in the end on the
willingness of Europe to set a schedule for Turkish accession to the
EU, and thereby confirm the benefits of this innovative approach
being taken by the AK leadership in Ankara. Without this tangible
positive result, there are dangers of a return to the earlier rigid
and narrower Turkish nationalism that approached conflict in a
somewhat paranoid and zero-sum fashion that seemed incapable of
reaching peaceful solutions because of its intense fear of being seen
as ‘weak.’
There are additional lingering difficulties with this rather hopeful
line of assessment. It is still not entirely clear which way the army
will jump in future crises, especially if it views its guardian role
as being subverted. Furthermore, Turkish urban elites are deeply
suspicious of the AK leadership, fearing that it conceals an
undisclosed agenda to turn the country into an Islamic republic.
Turkish society is quite polarized, as Kemalists refuse to
acknowledge the progress being made, contending unconvincingly that
any leadership would have taken similar steps. Also, there are some
remaining open wounds that the current leadership has not yet healed.
The acknowledgement of the Armenian genocide is still resisted, and
keeps this disturbing issue alive. And although the AK leadership has
taken some notable positive moves with respect to its large Kurdish
minority, on such matters as language and cultural rights, it has not
gone nearly far enough in providing the Kurdish regions in the
Eastern part of the country with a measure of self-rule. As well, the
economic picture is not rosy for the Turkish masses as unemployment,
poverty, and a low average standard of living torment most of the
society.
Yet on balance, considering the darkness that has descended on so
much of the world since 9/11, the Turkish story is encouraging. And,
in fairness, the Bush administration has, despite the refusal of
Turkey to join actively in the Iraq War, has welcomed these shifts in
Turkish foreign policy, and this has mad the process possible. At
this point, what will push the process forward is a positive response
from Europe, setting a date for the start of accession process, which
even optimists will take more than a decade and will be confronted by
roadblocks along the way. Nevertheless, at this moment, those that
believe in democracy and a peaceful world order should take heart
from Turkey’s impressive efforts to reform its foreign policy, and
congratulate the Turkish foreign ministry for exploring the frontiers
of the politically acceptable.
This has been a commentary exclusively written by Mr. Falk for ZAMAN
daily.
Armenia recognizes China’s full market economy status
Armenia recognizes China’s full market economy status
Xinhua, China
Sept 27 2004
BEIJING, Sept. 27 (Xinhuanet) — Armenia recognizes China’s full
market economy status, according to a joint statement between China
and Armenia issued here Monday.
The statement, signed by Chinese President Hu Jintao and the
visiting Armenian President Robert Sedrakovich Kocharyan, says such
a recognition is conducive for enhancing economic and trade ties
between China and Armenia.
The two countries agreed that the challenge for developing countries
caused by economic globalization should be acknow; edged,and
international society should take active measures to direct the
development of economic globalization towards common prosperity.
China and Armenia, both members of the World Trade Organization,support
the negotiation on the Doha Development Agenda and are willing to
increase communication during the negotiation process to maintain
long-term and steady growth of world economy and trade,said the
statement. Enditem
Lecture on Armenian Christianity at NAASR
NEWS RELEASE
National Association for Armenian Studies and Research
395 Concord Avenue
Belmont, MA 02478
Tel.: 617-489-1610
E-Mail: [email protected]
Contact: Marc Mamigonian
ARMENIAN CHRISTIANITY TO BE
EXAMINED IN LECTURE AT NAASR
The place of Armenian Christianity within the larger context of world
Christianity will be the subject of a lecture by Dr. Ara Dostourian
on Thursday evening, September 30, at 8:00 p.m., at the Center and
Headquarters of the National Association for Armenian Studies and
Research (NAASR), 395 Concord Ave., Belmont, Mass.
Dostourian, a retired Professor of History at West Georgia State
University and former research fellow in Armenian Studies at
Harvard University, has spent decades studying the development and
characteristics of Christianity as practiced historically by the
Armenian people.
Importance of Broad Context of World Religions
Frequently, when Armenian Christianity is analyzed it is viewed
without reference to world Christianity and other Christian traditions.
Moreover, the national or ethnic character of Armenian Christianity is
emphasized rather than its position within a larger Christian context.
Dr. Dostourian will present an overview of basic Christianity and its
relationship to the other Abrahamic faiths (Judaism and Islam) as well
as the two major non-Abrahamic world religions (Hinduism and Buddhism)
and place Armenian Christianity within the context of the three major
Christian traditions: Orthodoxy, Catholicism, and Protestantism.
A special emphasis will be placed on Armenian Christianity’s
relationship with Orthodox Christianity, as the Armenian tradition is
part of the Oriental Orthodox family of churches (with Syriac, Coptic,
Ethiopian, and Indian). Armenian Orthodoxy will be compared with that
of the Eastern Orthodox family (Greek, Russian, Ukrainian, Serbian,
Bulgarian, etc.). Finally, the uniqueness of Armenian Christianity as
a faith that took root in a particular place and historical context –
political, economic, and cultural – will be discussed.
Lecturer with Background in History and Religion
Dr. Ara Dostourian received a Ph.D. in Byzantine History from Rutgers
University, having earlier received an MA in Medieval History from
Fordham University and a Masters of Divinity from the Episcopal
Divinity School in Cambridge, MA. He is the author of numerous articles
on Armenian history and religion, and is the translator and editor
of Armenia and the Crusades, 10th to 12th Centuries: The Chronicle
of Matthew of Edessa.
Admission to the event is free (donations appreciated). The NAASR
bookstore will open at 7:30 p.m. The NAASR Center and Headquarters is
located opposite the First Armenian Church and next to the U.S. Post
Office. Ample parking is available around the building and in
adjacent areas.
More information about the lecture is available by calling
617-489-1610, faxing 617-484-1759, e-mailing [email protected], or writing
to NAASR, 395 Concord Ave., Belmont, MA 02478.
Priests in Punch-Up at Christianity’s Holiest Shrine
Priests in Punch-Up at Christianity’s Holiest Shrine
The Scotsman, UK
Sept 27 2004
“PA”
Rival priests got into a fight in the Church of the Holy Sepulchre,
Christianity’s holiest shrine in Jerusalem, after arguing over whether
a door in the basilica should be closed during a procession.
Dozens of people, including several Israeli police officers, were
hurt in the brawl at the shrine, built over the spot where tradition
says Jesus was crucified and buried.
Jerusalem police spokesman Shmulik Ben-Ruby said four priests were
arrested.
Custody of the Church of the Holy Sepulchre is shared by several
denominations that jealously guard territory and responsibilities under
a fragile deal hammered out over the last centuries. Any perceived
encroachment on one group’s turf can lead to vicious feuds, sometimes
lasting centuries.
Today’s fight broke out during a procession of hundreds of Greek
Orthodox worshippers commemorating the 4th century pilgrimage by
Helena, mother of Emperor Constantine, to Jerusalem. Tradition says
that during the trip, Helena found the cross on which Jesus had
been crucified.
Church officials said that at one point, the procession passed a
Roman Catholic chapel, and priests from both sides started arguing
over whether the door to the chapel should be open or closed.
Club-wielding Israeli riot police broke up the fight, witnesses said.
After the brawl, the procession continued.
Greek Orthodox priests, dressed in black robes and donning elaborate
head-dresses, marched out of the church as bells rang loudly.
Carrying gold staves and roses, they marched through the church
courtyard and down a narrow stone alley as Greek Orthodox Christians
clapped and cheered.
In 2003, Israeli police threatened to limit the number of worshippers
allowed to attend an Easter ceremony if the denominations did not
agree on who would lead the ceremony. Police brokered a last-minute
deal and the ceremony passed peacefully.
But a year earlier, the Greek patriarch and Armenian clergyman
designated to enter the tomb exchanged blows after a spat over who
would be first to exit the chamber.
Kerkorian’s main man looks to post-MGM life
International Herald Tribune, France
Sept 27 2004
Kerkorian’s main man looks to post-MGM life
Andrew Ross Sorkin NYT
He says sale wasn’t goal for him or boss
LAS VEGAS Alex Yemenidjian, the chairman and chief executive of
Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer, was sitting at his private pool outside his
high-roller villa at the Bellagio Hotel and Casino here recently.
He had just struck a $5 billion deal to sell MGM, the Hollywood studio
famous for its roaring-lion mascot and film franchises including
James Bond, to Sony and a group of investors after an agonizingly
long auction.
But he was not interested in talking about the deal. He wanted to
discuss why he never wanted to sell the company and why his boss,
the elusive billionaire Kirk Kerkorian, who controls MGM and who
has now bought and sold the studio three times since 1969, did not
especially want to give it up, either.
“There is a perception out there that Kirk is a seller if somebody
gives him a good price,” said Yemenidjian, cutting a Bond-like figure
in a double-breasted blue blazer with a yellow silk handkerchief
protruding from the breast pocket. “That isn’t true. I think it bothers
him that Hollywood thinks that he treated MGM as an investment toy. Not
one time did either Kirk or the board tell me, ‘I want you to clean
this company up and prepare it for sale.’ Not once.”
Yemenidjian, 48, has been dogged by his reputation as MGM’s
flipper-in-chief ever since Kerkorian installed him as its boss
in 1999. Back then, the company was beaten and battered, written
off as a has-been, a debt-laden stepchild of the studio that once
produced films like “Gone With the Wind” and “The Wizard of Oz.” And
when Yemenidjian arrived on the scene, he was a virtual unknown
in Hollywood. If anything, he was considered Kerkorian’s henchman,
an accountant experienced in making deals, not movies.
Yet within five and a half years, Yemenidjian turned around the
business by drastically scaling back productions, scoring a few
unexpected hits like the comedy “Barbershop” and the documentary
“Bowling for Columbine,” and by milking its library of more than
4,000 films.
He won respect on Wall Street, if not fans among the Hollywood elite.
Then he performed the final scene of the script that had been written
by critics the day he arrived: He sold the studio. In doing so,
he made a bundle for Kerkorian – who banked at least $2 billion –
as well as a small fortune for the company’s minority shareholders.
“Bringing an outsider’s viewpoint to Hollywood may not have
necessarily endeared him to the agents, movie stars and the rest
of the quote-unquote Hollywood community,” said Jack Liebau, the
principal at Liebau Asset Management, one of MGM’s largest minority
shareholders. “But from a shareholder’s standpoint, he’s exactly what
you’d want in the CEO of a publicly held company.”
But as Yemenidjian leaned back in his faux 17th-century Tuscan chair,
he said he still wished he could have ordered a rewrite and made his
own blockbuster acquisitions instead of selling.
“We tried to acquire other companies and they weren’t available,”
he said in a rare interview.
He listed targets that he said he had pursued vigorously: Vivendi
Universal, Sony Pictures, Paramount Pictures.
“There was nothing left to buy,” he said with a shrug. “There was no
place for us to go.”
How Yemenidjian, who, like Kerkorian, is of Armenian descent, became
Kerkorian’s top lieutenant, to run the last independent studio in
Hollywood and to sell it in a heated auction between Time Warner and
Sony could be its own dramatic release. There is even a potential
sequel: for all the sniping in the industry, Yemenidjian is being
talked of as a possible successor to Michael Eisner, who will step
down as chief executive of Walt Disney in 2006.
Yemenidjian was born in Argentina; his father was a shoemaker who
had fled Armenia. The family moved to Los Angeles when Alex was 13.
Yemenidjian graduated from California State University at Northridge
in 1977 and founded his own accounting firm. In 1989, Yemenidjian
went to a lunch that would change his life. A mutual friend of his
and Kerkorian’s, George Mason, a managing director of Bear Stearns,
planned for them to meet.
Two days later, he recounted, “Kirk asked me if I would take a leave
of absence from my firm for six months to work on a special project.”
Yemenidjian continued: “He never told me what the project was and
I never asked. When I showed up on January 1, 1990, I found out the
project was selling MGM.”
That was the second time Kerkorian would sell MGM. He had bought it in
1969, sold it to Ted Turner in 1986 and bought back a large chunk of
it only months later, when Turner’s financing fell apart. The second
sale, with Yemenidjian’s help, was to the Italian financier Giancarlo
Parretti in 1990. But Kerkorian would buy it back again in 1996.
The two hit it off immediately, creating what friends and associates
describe as almost a father-son relationship.
“He was the perfect man for Kirk – just perfect,” said Mason, who
plays a doubles tennis game at Kerkorian’s house every Sunday with
Yemenidjian and other friends. “People say Alex would throw himself
off a cliff for Kirk. He’s always had that attitude.”
Kerkorian, 87, who has not given an interview to the news media
in decades, said through a spokeswoman, “Alex is one of the most
accomplished CEOs I have worked with, and I am very happy with what
he and his team have achieved at MGM.”
Throwing himself into the role of Kerkorian’s right-hand man,
Yemenidjian worked on his mentor’s attempted takeover of Chrysler,
an effort to rescue Trans World Airlines and a bid for Pan Amercan
Airways. In 1995, Kerkorian sent him to Las Vegas to become the
president and chief operating officer of the hotel and casino company
now known as MGM Mirage.
But his Las Vegas act was cut short in 1999. Kerkorian had assigned
him to help find a replacement for Frank Mancuso, who was retiring
as MGM’s chief. Kerkorian rejected all the candidates and gave the
job to Yemenidjian, who had never worked in movies.
It was an audacious move. Yemenidjian hired Chris McGurk, president
and chief operating officer at Universal Pictures, as his own chief
operating officer, and the two went about shaking up MGM’s business
model.
Out went high-priced, risky picture deals. The James Bond films,
which had been released every two years, were moved to a three-year
schedule. Production budgets were cut.
The centerpiece of the turnaround was a renewed focus on additional
sales from the company’s library, typically an afterthought at other
studios. Bonuses were attached to sales of digital video disks and
marketing was redesigned. By 2003, the plan had succeeded. They may not
have created the next Miramax, but the company was no longer bleeding.
The New York Times