UN asks if world can stop future genocide
By Evelyn Leopold
UNITED NATIONS, Jan 24 (Reuters) – If the world had listened to the
horrors of the Nazi death camps, perhaps genocide in Cambodia, Bosnia
and Rwanda could have been prevented, speakers told the first-ever
U.N. General Assembly session on the Holocaust.
Both U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan and Nobel Laureate author Elie
Wiesel, a World War Two death camp survivor, questioned whether the
nations had the will to stop mass murder in the future.
“If the world had listened, we may have prevented Darfur, Cambodia,
Bosnia and naturally Rwanda,” Wiesel said.
“We know that for the dead it is too late. For them, abandoned by God
and betrayed by humanity, victory did come much too late,” Wiesel
said. “But it is not too late for today’s children, ours and yours. It
is for their sake alone that we bear witness.”
Annan told the assembly that at this moment, “terrible things are
happening today in Darfur, Sudan.” He asked the U.N. Security Council
to take action once it received a new report determining whether
genocide had occurred in Darfur and identifying gross human rights
abuses.
The special session, at which survivors and the foreign ministers of
Germany, France, Argentina, Armenia, Canada and Luxembourg spoke, is a
memorial to the 60th anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz, the
largest Nazi death camp.
The meeting was first called by the United States and backed by Annan,
who polled the 191-member assembly.
More than 150 nations agreed to the session, including Islamic
nations. But among Muslim nations, only Afghanistan and Jordan’s
U.N. ambassadors are scheduled to speak to the General Assembly, often
accused by Israel of being anti-Semitic.
BACH AND SCHILLER
The liberation of Auschwitz is to be observed this year as Holocaust
Memorial Day, with world leaders attending ceremonies in Poland on
Jan. 27, exactly 60 years after Soviet Red Army troops liberated the
camp.
Up to 1.5 million prisoners, most of them Jews, were killed in
Auschwitz alone, dying in gas chambers or of starvation and
disease. During the war, six million Jews overall were exterminated
and millions of others including Poles, homosexuals, Russians and
Gypsies were killed or used as slave labor, at several Nazi death
camps.
“How could intelligent, educated men, or simply law-abiding citizens,
ordinary men, fire machine guns at hundreds of children every day” and
read Schiller and listen to Bach in the evening,” Wiesel asked.
To warm applause, German Foreign Minister Joschka Fischer called the
Holocaust “barbaric. “For my country it signifies the absolute moral
abomination, a denial of all things civilized without precedent or
parallel,” he said.
He assured Israel that it could “always rely” on support because “the
security of its citizens will forever remain nonnegotiable fixtures of
German foreign policy.”
U.S. Deputy Defense Secretary Paul Wolfowitz, who lost most of his
extended family in the Holocaust, said if there was one thing the
world had learned, it is that nations “cannot close their eyes and sit
idly by in the face of genocide.”
“We know that there have been far too many occasions in the six
decades since the liberation of the concentration camps when the world
ignored inconvenient truths so that it would not have to act or acted
too late,” Wolfowitz said.
And Israel’s foreign minister, Silvan Shalom, warned that “the brutal
extermination of a people began not with guns or tanks but with words
systematically portraying the Jews and others as not legitimate,
something less than human.”
He said one would never know if the United Nations, born from the
ashes of World War Two and instrumental in the founding of the State
of Israel, could have prevented the Holocaust. But he said each
U.N. member state needed “to rededicate ourselves to ensuring that it
will never happen again.”
Wiesel also drew attention to the indifference of the West during the
war to accept more refugees, allow more Jews to go to Israel, or bomb
the railway lines to the vast Auschwitz-Birkenau camp site.
“In those times those who were there felt not only tortured, murdered
by the enemy but also by what we considered to be the silence and
indifference of the world,” Wiesel said. “Now, 60 years later, the
world at least tries to listen.”
French Foreign minister Michel Barnier acknowledged that German
occupiers were helped by the Vichy government in deporting Jews but
that others resisted.
“When the first signs of persecution of the Jews announcing the Shoah
occurred, how many stood up? How many spoke out?,” Barnier asked.
01/24/05 14:37 ET
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress
Category: News
PM to attend ceremony of liberation of Nazi death camp in Poland
ArmenPress
Jan 24 2005
ARMENIAN PM TO ATTEND CEREMONY OF LIBERATION OF NAZI DEATH CAMP IN
POLAND
YEREVAN, JANUARY 24, ARMENPRESS: Armenian prime minister Andranik
Margarian and several other government officials are flying to Polish
Krakow to attend January 27 ceremonies there marking the 60-th
anniversary of liberation of the Auschwitz death camp by Soviet
troops near the town of Oswiecim.
The ceremonies will be attended by many heads of states and
governments. Armenian officials will meet also with members of the
Armenian community of Poland.
For the first time in its history, the United Nations on Monday
marks the liberation of Nazi death camps during World War II.
Foreign ministers of Israel, Germany, France, Argentina, Armenia,
Canada and Luxembourg, representing the European Union, are scheduled
to speak. Between 1 million and 1.5 million prisoners, most of them
Jews, were killed in Auschwitz alone, dying in gas chambers or of
starvation and disease. Six million Jews overall were exterminated in
Nazi death camps.
Some 600,000 citizens of Soviet Armenia, then a republic of less
than two million inhabitants, took part in the WW II . Only half of
them stayed alive.
Agency outlines prospects for Armenia in USA’s Middle East plans
Agency outlines prospects for Armenia in USA’s Middle East plans
Mediamax news agency, Yerevan
24 Jan 05
The Armenian news agency Mediamax has praised government’s decision to
send peacekeepers to Iraq as this move is in line with processes going
on in the Middle East. The USA will probably prefer Armenian President
Robert Kocharyan’s pragmatic policy to the opposition’s pro-Russian
orientation, it said. The following is an excerpt from report in
English by Armenian news agency Mediamax; subheadings as published:
On 18 January, with a difference in only several hours 46 Armenian
peacekeepers and Armenian Foreign Minister Vardan Oskanyan left for
the Middle East. The peacekeepers’ destination was Kuwait, and the
Armenian foreign minister’s – Egypt. Despite the fact that the visits
were not interrelated, this coincidence became very symbolic.
Non-combatant unit of the Armenian armed forces, which includes
sappers, medical officers and drivers, will stay in Kuwait for two
weeks. After it, they will leave for Iraq where they will serve as
part of multinational division under the Polish command.
Vardan Oskanyan arrived in the capital of Egypt to sign a memorandum
with the Arab League countries on granting Armenia with a status of a
special invitee to this organization. According to Oskanyan, “the
signing of this document is undoubtedly a historic event. I consider
that it opens the new page for the further development and
intensification of the Armenian-Arab relations”.
According to the official Egyptian news agency MENA, Arab League
Secretary-General Amr Musa has said at the meeting with Oskanyan that
Condoleezza Rice, designated US Secretary of State, used “new
language” when talking about the USA’s Middle East policy at last
week’s confirmation hearing in the Senate. “We hope that the new
language used by Rice will transform into new actions,” the
secretary-general of the Arab League countries said.
We would like to mention that it is hardly that the Armenian foreign
minister deliberately scheduled the terms of signing the memorandum
with the League so that it would coincide with the dispatch of the
Armenian peacekeepers to Iraq, thus softening the hypothetical
negative reaction of the Arab countries to the decision of official
Yerevan.
However, the symbolism does not become smaller from this. The
coincidence, which took place, was the vivid example of the fact that
Armenia can play certain role in the US project on the democratization
of the region, which is now more often called the Greater Middle East.
The first step
On 24 December 2004 the Armenian National Assembly ratified at the
closed meeting the memorandum on the dispatch of 46 Armenian medical
officers, drivers and sappers to Iraq. 91 deputies voted for and 23 –
against the ratification. In particular, the factions of Justice
opposition bloc and the Armenian Revolutionary Federation
Dashnaktsutyun Party, which makes part of the ruling coalition, voted
against the dispatch of Armenian humanitarian contingent to Iraq.
The dispatch of the peacekeepers to Iraq, being a purely foreign
policy event, has become a subject of internal political speculations
in the course of the several last months. By the highest standards,
nobody in Armenia wanted to risk the lives of its citizens in Iraq
reigned by chaos and uncertainty. The problem should be considered
exclusively in the context of political necessity. If the Armenian
authorities managed to advance serious reasons in defence of their
position, the opposition again demonstrated lack of principles and
absence of any ideological motivation.
Mediamax learned from the informed sources that the higher echelons of
the Armenian leadership gave a command to speak about the motives of
the dispatch of Armenian contingent to Iraq as rare as possible. It is
obvious that Armenia w ould never send its servicemen to Iraq but for
certain commitments before the USA. The main burden of “explanatory
work” fell on the shoulders of Armenian Defence Minister Serzh
Sarkisyan, who, to give him his due, managed to formulate the motives
of official Yerevan’s decision in accordance with the stylistics
commonly accepted in the Euro-Atlantic community.
Still in December the head of the Defence Ministry said that “Armenia
is obliged to dispatch a contingent to Iraq”. “If we bear losses in
case of the dispatch of our contingent to Iraq, they will be
considerably small than if we stay aside these processes,” Serzh
Sarkisyan said.
On 18 January, the day of the dispatch of the peacekeepers to Kuwait,
the defence minister said that “Armenia is being involved in a
process, which, despite the ambiguous perception on the part of the
international community, as well as by Armenian society, is one of the
most important components of building international security”. This
has become first such statement of Armenia, which was the only country
in the South Caucasus that did not support the USA’s war against Iraq.
As to the opposition, discussing the issue on the dispatch of the
peacekeepers to Iraq, it did not think about Armenia’s participation
or, vice versa, Armenia’s non-participation in the establishment of
stability in the Middle East at all, it was involved in achieving its
own aims. How, for example, can we explain the fact that last October
the secretary of the National Unity opposition faction, Aleksan
Karapetyan, spoke about the “unacceptability of the dispatch of
Armenian contingent to Iraq as it can turn into Armenians’ mass
emigration from the Arab countries” and on 25 December this faction
unanimously voted for the dispatch of the peacekeepers? It can be
explained, most likely, by the unwillingness to spoil the relations
with Washington and not by radical rethinking of its approaches to the
issues of providing regional security.
Yerevan’s Aykakan Zhamanak newspaper, which is one of the most radical
critics of the Armenian authorities, informed on 20 January about the
details of the meeting between the representatives of the Armenian
opposition and the delegation of advisers and assistants of the US
congressmen held in Yerevan in mid-January. According to the
newspaper, the leader of the National Unity Party, Artashes Gegamyan,
decided not put the Justice bloc in “inconvenient position” and told
the members of the US delegation that his opposition colleagues
abstained from voting on the issue of the dispatch of the peacekeepers
to Iraq.
Aykakan Zhamanak notes with indignation that the leader of the Justice
bloc, Stepan Demirchyan, who was Armenian President Robert Kocharyan’s
opponent at the second stage of the presidential elections of 2003,
kept silence and did not mention that he himself and his colleagues
did not abstain and voted against the dispatch of the peacekeepers to
Iraq.
Sometimes the Armenian opposition demonstrated elementary
unawareness. On 29 October, one of the leaders of the opposition
Republic Party, Albert Bazeyan, called to take into account the fact
that “Armenia is in the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO)
and the forces of its member states are not present in Iraq”. The
Armenian defence minister’s answer was short: first, we are not the
first CSTO member state, the servicemen of which are taking part in
the operation on the stabilization of Iraq (the matter concerns CSTO
member state – Kazakhstan); second, “Armenia informed its allies in
CSTO of the intention to send a contingent to Iraq”.
It is natural that nobody has the right to condemn a political force
for its adherence to this or that position. However, in our case the
problem is that the opposition did not manage to bring even one
trustworthy argument in support of its thesis that the participation
of Armenian sappers and drivers in the restoration of Iraq would
negatively affect Armenia’s relations with the Arab world.
One of the Justice representatives and leader of the Democratic Party
of Armenia, Aram Sarkisyan, said in the interview published in Russian
Nezavisimaya Gazeta on 19 January: “A great number of Armenians have
been living on the territory of the Middle East countries for hundred
years after the genocide. The authorities of the Arab countries gave
them not only shelter but also an opportunity to develop their
individuality. That’s why, we find it wrongful to interfere in the
affairs of the Arab countries. We possess information that already
today a wave of anti-Armenian moods aroused in the Arab countries,
especially in Iraq, Lebanon, Syria and the United Arab
Emirates. Moreover, we do not rule out dramatic consequences for our
country as well after the decision of the Armenian leadership.”
There is not a single concrete evidence of “a wave of anti-Armenian
moods in Arab countries”. In case of existence of such a “wave” Vardan
Oskanyan would hardly decide to visit Egypt, and Amr Musa, in his
turn, would not hurry with granting Armenia with a special status in
the Arab League countries.
We are not so naive to explain the Armenian authorities’ decision on
the dispatch of Armenian peacekeepers by a desire to make a real
contribution to the democratization of Iraq. The Armenian president’s
negative approach to the US incursion into Iraq is well
known. However, Kocharyan proved that he possessed the political
resource necessary for making unpopular decisions. Moreover, Armenia
is sending a contingent to Iraq at a time when other countries stop
taking part in the peacekeeping operation, and this fact will,
undoubtedly, bring additional dividends to him in his relations with
the West.
The Armenian opposition, vice versa, again demonstrated that it is not
only unable to set tasks and solve them but also has difficulties to
formulate its strivings. Voting against the dispatch of the contingent
to Iraq, the Justice bloc was guided by two main factors: the desire
to oppose everything suggested by the authorities and the desire “not
to anger” Russia. In any case, the same Albert Bazeyan openly stated
in October that Moscow “would not like” the decision of official
Yerevan, and in case of the dispatch of the Armenian contingent to
Iraq “Russia may apply certain sanctions in relation to Armenia”.
But two questions remained unanswered. First, why should Armenia
always do things which Russia likes? Second, why did Bazeyan think
that Moscow would not like Armenia’s decisions? The absence of answers
to these questions reveals the main problem of the Armenian opposition
Justice bloc – its leaders continue to mechanically defend Russian
interests even at a time when they are not asked. Not to mention that
the dispatch of the Armenian sappers and doctors to Iraq can hardly be
called an event, which touches upon Russia’s interests.
Long-term choice
The task of sending the peacekeepers to Iraq was solved by the
Armenian authorities quite successfully. At the same time, there are
serious reasons to doubt that official Yerevan has a formulated
strategy of relations with a huge region, which the Americans call the
Greater Middle East. Or, if we reformulate the question, will Armenia
recognize itself a constituent part of Greater Middle East? The only
official, who has stated Armenia’s belonging to the Greater Middle
East until now, is the Armenian ambassador to Washington, Arman
Kirakosyan. Speaking at the conference in Virginia University on 12
November, he said that “being a part of the Greater Middle East,
Armenia has been and is concerned about the situation in Iraq”.
Active talks on the Greater Middle East Initiative (GMEI) started in
February 2004, when the London-based Arabic newspaper Al-Hayat
published a “leaked” US-compiled document. The original document was
meant to signal a new US plan for reform of the Middle East and some
other Muslim-majority countries such as Pakistan, Iran and Turkey. A
number of non-Arab countries such as Afghanistan, Pakistan, Iran and
Turkey have been mentioned as candidates for the initiative. However,
speculation is growing that the US plan may also have an impact on
other Muslim countries such as Indonesia, Bangladesh and the Central
Asian countries of Uzbekistan, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Turkmenistan
and Tajikistan.
The essence of the GMEI was reflected in the speech by US President
George Bush in November 2003 before the most influential
neoconservative organization in Washington, the American Enterprise
Institute. In his speech, Bush spoke of a “freedom deficit” in the
Middle East.
“In many nations of the Middle East, democracy has not yet taken
root. And the questions arise: are the peoples of the Middle East
somehow beyond the reach of liberty? I, for one, do not believe it. I
believe every person has the ability and the right to be free,” the US
president said. If we take into account the fact that the idea of
spreading liberty was the key moment in the US president’s
inauguration speech last week, there must be no doubt that the
negative and in some cases openly hostile attitude of the Arab leaders
towards the GMEI will not make the US administration give up their
plans on the practical realization of the initiative.
Many people in our country may ask – what does Armenia have to do
here? The adherents of such an approach may say that Armenia should
work out tactics of behaviour in case of aggravation of situation
around Iran, its direct neighbour, and should stay aside from the
Greater Middle East. However, the case in point is that the GMEI
authors, as well as the experts, who carried out the “modernization”
of this initiative, have already included the South Caucasus and
Armenia into the wider Black Sea region, which they consider to be the
key for the successful realization of the GMEI.
Passage omitted: quote from article published in the Policy Review
The case in point is not whether Armenia believes in the possibility
of successful realization of the GMEI ideas or how much democratic the
USA’s intention to implant democracy is. The matter is that this
process exists, develops and, most likely, will be actively put into
life during George Bush’s second term whether Armenia wants it or
not. And here comes a situation, which contains big challenge for
Armenia – should it observe the situation from the outside or take
active participation in the process?
If we judge by the persistence and determination with which the
Armenian authorities solved the issue of the dispatch of the
peacekeepers to Iraq we can draw a conclusion that Yerevan realized
the necessity to assume a certain role. On the other hand, the
Armenian authorities like their Azerbaijani and Georgian counterparts
must consecutively work on themselves and one another for a long time
in order to solve the existing democratic and economic problems and
conflicts.
The mediations over these themes are much more important than the
hackneyed speculations whether the USA is going to “export” to Armenia
the “rose revolution” from Georgia or the “orange revolution” from
Ukraine. First, the comparison between the behaviour of the
authorities and the opposition on the Iraq proves that it is
advantageous for the West to deal with Kocharyan. Second, even if we
assume that the USA is really going to “export” a revolution to
Armenia, we must understand why they want to have more compliant
partners in Yerevan. Third, the Armenian leadership has to more
decisively establish order inside its own country, to more actively
get rid of corruption and other negative things hampering the normal
development of the country.
Still in June 2001, president Robert Kocharyan, meeting Belgian
senators in Brussels, said that “being at the junction of
civilizations, Armenia is the guard of European values”. It looks as
if it is high time for the “guard” to begin acting and prove its
readiness to defend these values in practice.
Armenian FM Leaves For New York to Attend UN Special Session
ARMENIAN FOREIGN MINISTER LEAVES FOR NEW YORK TO ATTEND UN SPECIAL
SESSION DEVOTED TO 60TH ANNIVERSARY OF RELEASE OF HOSTAGES FROM
CONCENTRATION CAMPS
YEREVAN, JANUARY 24. ARMINFO. Armenian Foreign Minister Vardan
Oskanyan has left for New York to participate in a special session of
the UN, today. The event is devoted to the 60th anniversary of release
of hostages from, concentration camps in the course of the World War
II.
Minister Oskanyan will also speak at the special session. Earlier, he
reported that the major topic of his speech would be prevention of
genocides through their recognition and condemnation. Foreign
Ministers of Germany, France, Argentina, Canada, Israel, Armenia and
Luxembourg will speak at the session. UN Secretary General Kofi Annan
and Chairman of the 59th session of General Assembly Jean Ping will
open the session. The idea of the session was supported by 150 of 191
UN member-states. The initiators are Australia, Canada, Israel, New
Zealand, Russia, the USA and EU member-states.
Wednesday, talking to journalists, Kofi Annan told that the world
community must not allow repetition of the horrors at Nazis camps. The
estblishment of the UN was a direct result of the Holocaust, he said.
Executive for Human Rights in the Russia Federation Vladimir Lukin is
also expected to make a speech at the session. Photo-exhibitions
telling about the horrors suffered by the hostages of Osvencim and
Majdanek will be held at the foyer of UN headquarters.
“Nairit Factory” CJSC Resumes Production
“NAIRIT FACTORY” CJSC RESUMES PRODUCTION
YEREVAN, JANUARY 24. ARMINFO. One of the world leader of the chemical
industry – Armenian “Nairit Factory” CJSC will resume the production
of synthetic rubber within the nearest two days, Director of the
factory Rouben Saghatelyan told ARMINFO.
According to him, the enterprise standing idle since August of 2004
has resumed the production of hydrate of sodium, liquid chlorine for
purification of drinking water and other non-basic production from the
beginning of 2005. Saghatelyan noted that the enterprise was
transferred to management the Armenia’s Ministry of Energy, but he
refused to inform the terms of the transfer.
Earlier, in the Armenian Parliament, Prime-Minister Andranik Margaryan
stated that “after two failed attempts of selling the factory the
Government undertook its management and decided to resume its activity
itself to increase the investment attraction”. He added that Armenia’s
Government will look for an investor for resumption of rubber
production on butadiene base for which from 10 to 12 mln USD will be
need.
To note, the accounts of “Nairit factory” CJSC were arrested in the
summer of 2004 because of payables. The sum of factory’s debts total
about 30 mln USD. -R-
ASBAREZ Online [01-21-2005]
ASBAREZ ONLINE
TOP STORIES
01/21/2005
TO ACCESS PREVIOUS ASBAREZ ONLINE EDITIONS PLEASE VISIT OUR
WEBSITE AT <;HTTP://
1) US Assistant Secretary of State Apologizes for Statement About Karabagh
2) ANCA Congratulates President Bush on His Second Inauguration
3) Turkey Begins Self Reflection over Armenia
4) Community Honors California State Senator Charles Poochigian
1) US Assistant Secretary of State Apologizes for Statement About Karabagh
YEREVAN (Noyan Tapan)--Foreign Minister Vartan Oskanian told the Armenian
public on Friday that US Assistant Secretary of State Elizabeth Jones has
conveyed her apologies for a recent statement on Mountainous Karabagh.
In an interview on Armenian Public Television, Oskanian said that Jones
assured him that she was not referring to Mountainous Karabagh and its
authorities when saying "criminal secessionists" must be removed from power.
During a January 13 video conference with journalists in US Embassies in
Moscow, Rome and Bratislava, Jones, in discussing US bi-lateral relations with
Russia, called for increased engagement in resolving regional conflicts in the
former Soviet Union, stating:
"It is in Russia's interest for these areas, for Transnistria, Abkhazia,
South
Ossetia, Nagorno-Karabakh, for these areas to be stable, for corruption to end
there, for the criminal secessionists who rule there to be removed. It is not
appropriate for this kind of instability and criminality to exist right in the
middle of Europe."
The statement caused a wave of protests in Armenia and in Armenian
communities
abroad.
Azbarez has also learned that the US Ambassador to Armenia John Evans also
appeared on TV in Armenia to clarify the US position on this matter. The exact
nature, however, were not yet known as we were going to press.
2) ANCA Congratulates President Bush on His Second Inauguration
Calls for stronger ties, constructive dialogue between White House and
Armenian American Community
WASHINGTON, DC--The Armenian National Committee of America (ANCA)
congratulated President George W. Bush on his inauguration to his second term
as President of the United States, wishing him well as he prepares to lead the
nation for the coming four years.
The ANCA, in a letter to the President, welcomed his second Administration as
an opportunity to build strong ties between the White House and America's one
and a half million citizens of Armenian heritage, to strengthen US-Armenia
relations, constructively address outstanding issues of concern to the
Armenian
American community, and to reinforce the longstanding friendship of the
American and Armenian peoples.
During the course of the hard-fought and closely contested 2004 Presidential
election campaign, Armenian Americans demonstrated an unprecedented level of
activism - as voters, party activists, policy advocates, and financial
contributors. Armenian American contributions to federal-level Republican
candidates and committees totaled well over $1,500,000 during the 2004
election
cycle, with more than $350,000 going directly to the Bush-Cheney re-election
effort. An additional $430,000 was raised for the Republican National
Committee; $140,000 for the National Republican Congressional Committee, and;
$24,000 for the National Republican Senatorial Committee. In addition to these
figures, Armenian Americans contributed over $550,000 directly to the
campaigns
of Congressional Republicans.
3) Turkey Begins Self Reflection over Armenia
ISTANBUL (AFP)--While an exhibition in Istanbul devoted to the daily life of
the Armenians in Anatolia at the start of the 20th century is breaking
attendance records, Turkish society is beginning to reflect on the Armenian
question, erased from official history for the past 90 years.
According to organizers, The exhibition "My Dear Brother," which opened on
January 8, has attracted 6,000 visitors in 12 days--a record for local
galleries.
Through 500 postcards from the period, the exhibition seeks to portray, city
by city and with supporting figures, how omnipresent Armenian communities were
across the Ottoman territory and their role in society.
"In Turkey, history has always been taught about one people--the Turks, as if
there had never been any other people on the territory. When we speak of
Armenians, they are not described as an integral group of society, but as a
source of problems," explains exhibit director Osman Koker.
"It's to fill this void, because I have an 11-year-old daughter who is
getting
this kind of education at school, that I have decided to publish a book and
put
on this exhibition," said Koker, a historian turned editor.
"Without this realization, it will remain impossible to discuss the events of
1915," he said, referring to the Armenian massacres committed between 1915 and
1917 by the Ottoman armies.
Convinced of Turkish society's growing curiosity about its past, Koker,
nonetheless acknowledges that any change in mentality will take time.
"A majority of the public, especially in the rural areas, consider the simple
word 'Armenian' an insult," he said.
Even if a handful of academics and amateur historians have attempted to
re-examine Turkish history, it is not easy to break the deep taboo which has
been deeply ingrained in the general consciousness by official history.
"Until 1980, Turkish school textbooks quite simply didn't mention the
Armenian
massacre," explained Fabio Salomoni, author of a book on the Turkish education
system.
"With the first acknowledgments of 'genocide' by Western governments and the
increasing number of attacks by Armenian Secret Army for the Liberation of
Armenia (ASALA), a paragraph was then added excluding all Turkish
responsibility for the deaths of Armenians, explaining [their deaths] in the
context of a war..." he said.
Even if Turkey acknowledges the massacres, it objects to the term 'genocide'
and the figures of 1.2 to 1.3 million killed, and estimates the numbers to be
between 250,000 to 300,000.
Even though Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan recently opened an
Armenian museum in Istanbul--just before the European summit in Brussels which
gave a date to Ankara to start negotiations for joining the European
Union--there is no question of overturning the existing orthodoxy concerning
the Armenians.
Several [Turkish] state-subsidized organizations continue to conduct research
aimed at showing that if there was a genocide, it was more likely committed by
Armenians against the Turks.
"We can't talk of a major change at the level of the state," said Tarin
Karakasli, of the Armenian newspaper Agos. Even though "an evolution has
occurred amongst the elite intellectuals who are starting to openly discuss
the
subject and to encourage the publication of alternative books".
Karakasli congratulated the EU and the role it has played in "breaking the
Armenian taboo" by encouraging the democratization of Turkey--but criticized
the position of France, which has sought to make acknowledgment of the
genocide
a precondition for joining the EU.
"These pressures will achieve nothing, the question can only be resolved by
internal dynamics," she said.
"The Turkish population has still not fully acknowledged the problem; in this
context, imposing a solution can only provoke hostile reactions," said Etyen
Mahcupyan, an Armenian from Istanbul and writer for the daily newspaper
Zaman.
4) Community Honors California State Senator Charles Poochigian
On January 13, 2005, Armenian-American community leaders, activists and
philanthropists from all over Southern California gathered at the Universal
Sheraton to honor one of California's favorite Armenians sons, State Senator
Charles Poochigian. Over 600 people gathered to thank the Senator for his
years
of service in two Governors' administrations and as a prominent and highly
respected State Senator. Boardmembers of the Armenian National Committee of
America--Western Region, ARF Central Committee members, as well as the
Armenian
Cultural Foundation and a number of other civic and philanthropic
organizations
turned out to support the Senator who is a candidate for state wide office.
The
evenings guest speakers were former Congressman Kuykendallband former Governor
George Deukmejian.
All subscription inquiries and changes must be made through the proper carrier
and not Asbarez Online. ASBAREZ ONLINE does not transmit address changes and
subscription requests.
(c) 2005 ASBAREZ ONLINE. All Rights Reserved.
ASBAREZ provides this news service to ARMENIAN NEWS NETWORK members for
academic research or personal use only and may not be reproduced in or through
mass media outlets.
Caucasus No Longer the Source of Discord for Russia and Turkey
Global Politician, NY
Jan 24 2005
EXPERT INTERVIEW: Caucasus is No Longer the Source of Discord for
Russia and Turkey
By GP Interview Staff
Ruben Safrastyan, Ph.D. is a Professor of International Relations at
Acharyan University in Yerevan, Armenia. He’s also the Director of
the Department of Turkish Studies at the Armenian National Academy of
Sciences. In the past, he served as a Counselor of the Armenian
Embassy in Germany and was the Deputy Director of the Department of
Political Analysis for the Office of the President of Armenia.
Mr. Safrastyan, the results of the visit of Vladimir Putin to Ankara
and the following visit of Turkish Prime Minister R. T. Erdogan to
Moscow testify that Russian-Turkish relations have become closer.
Only the fact that 600 Turkish businessmen accompanied Erdogan
testifies much. How great is the potential of political rapprochement
of Turkey and Russia in your opinion? Or the observed processes come
to lobbying of the interests of Russian business in Turkey?
Well, as regards 600 Turkish businessmen, it is an absolute record.
Usually, prime ministers take with them some 200 people. Of course,
it testifies that the Turkish business circles are rather interested
in Russia. The volume of Turkish investments in Russia is rather
great, at present. The economic interests prevail on the part of
Russia as well. In general, Putin’s Administration has marked the
economic direction as a priority, as I understand. In this
connection, I’d like to mention the statement of Anatoliy Chubays
about the liberal empire, which, by the way, made enough fuss in
Armenia as well. Anyhow, it is evident that both Russia and Turkey
are interested in development and deepening of the economic component
of the cooperation in various spheres. It is the most important, but,
at the same time, just one side of the medal.
The second factor is that both Russia and Turkey are not enough
satisfied with their present positions in the world. These states are
dissatisfied with the fact that they are not the leading players in
the world arena, and this dissatisfaction makes them closer, to some
extent. The changes which took place in the foreign policy of Turkey
during the last years connected with worsening of its strategic
relations with the USA, and, which is the most important, worsening
of the Turkish-Israeli relations, testify to a new direction in the
Turkish policy. That is, aspiration for more independence. The same
concerns Russia. Moscow tries to use the privileges gained during the
last years due to high prices for oil not only in the economic
sphere, but also to make it a certain strategic unit. Thus, the two
super powers dissatisfied with their role in the world try to find
their new place, a new niche in the world policy. In this background,
rapprochement of Russia and Turkey is possible not only in economy,
but also at a strategic level. The declaration on the results of
Putin’s visit to Ankara contained such a concept as multilateral
cooperation for the first time. In the course of Erdogan’s last visit
to Moscow, the strategic cooperation was already in question, though
it was not put on paper. Meanwhile, the term `multilateral
cooperation’ was not only fixed, but also was perceived and presented
by the parties to the world as a new degree in the bilateral
relations. It is necessary to pay attention to another circumstance.
Putin stated in Astana that quite unexpectedly for him Turkey had
displayed an interest in Shanghai Cooperation Organization
(Kazakhstan, China, Kirgizistan, Russia and Uzbekistan are included
in SCO – ed.). The Shanghai six is known to try to lay a foundation
of a new union of states, which will play a considerable role in that
region in future, as SCO leaders think. Russia and China are mainly
in question. The fact that Turkey has displayed an interest in SCO is
an evidence of rather serious changes in the foreign policy of that
country. In this connection, it is necessary to mention the concept
presented by Erdogan’s adviser for foreign policy, Professor Ahmet
Davutoglu in his book entitled `Strategic Depth’ in 2000. The term
strategic depth itself belongs to military science and characterizes
an interest of a country that its strategic facilities are in the
depth inaccessible for a possible rival. However, during the last
decades, several states, in particular, Pakistan, Israel, applied the
given concept to general political and strategic issues. It was just
in this light that Professor Davutoglu tried to apply the given
concept to Turkey perceiving the strategic depth not only in the
spatial, but also historical expression. He speaks of Turkey like a
country having a historical depth and entering the 20th century
alongside with seven empires controlling over the big regions in the
world. At the same time, he draws a conclusion that Turkey must play
a great role in the world arena and it must not be treated as a small
European country. According to the concept, all the territories once
included in the Ottoman Empire are strategically important
territories for present day Turkey and it must play a special role
there. In the special expression, the strategic depth is interpreted
by Davutoglu as establishment of not only good-neighbored relations
with the direct neighbors of Turkey, but also an aspiration that
these states enclose the greatest part of their policy in Turkey. For
example, for Georgia and Bulgaria cooperate through Turkey. In this
connection, Davutoglu is perceived in Turkey as a supporter of
neo-Ottomanism.
Giving an analysis to the Party Justice and Development (PJD) ruling
in Turkey, we arrive to a conclusion that it tried to put the
aforementioned concept into practice. Today Turkey exerts great
efforts to improve the relations with its neighbors. For example, at
the end of the 20th century, Turkey was in disagreeable relations
almost with all its neighbors, both in the Arab world and in the
Caucasus and with Iran. The picture is different at present. One
should not ignore the Eurasian subject matter either. The program of
the PJD mentions the Eurasian subject matter as well. An agreement of
cooperation in Eurasia was signed between Turkey and Russia in New
York in 2001. According to this document, task groups at a high level
were formed, which would coordinate the policy of the two countries
in the Eurasian space. Despite the fact that these groups gathered
some three of four times in that period of time, the attempt to
coordinate geo-strategies between Turkey and Russia in the Eurasian
space testifies much.
As a result, if one studies the conceptual basis of the existing
Russian-Turkish relations, the following two concepts go into it:
strategic depth and Eurasian subjects. In this aspect, the existing
trends can be characterized as an aspiration of the two regional
super powers to deaden regional cooperation, which, of course, still
remains, to strengthen economic cooperation and gradually begin to
solve geo-strategic tasks.
Let us suppose that Russia and Turkey are dissatisfied with their
positions in the world arena and try to coordinate their acts to
increase their rating. How will the USA and Europe response to it? It
is right to consider the rapprochement with Russia an alternative for
Turkey in the issue of joining the EU, taking into account the
tension in the relations of Russia with the EU?
I shall start with the last question. In the course of his visit to
Ankara, Putin, in particular, said the following: you needn’t
admission to the European Union; you’d better deepen the cooperation
with us. If Turkey becomes a EU-member, it will be more difficult for
it to cooperate with Russia. It was in early December. By the way,
these words of Putin arouse a negative response of Turkey. However,
already on December 17, the situation changed. In the course of
Erdogan’s visit to Moscow, Putin made a cardinally opposite statement
coming to the following: it is very good that the EU has made a right
decision and Turkey will be admitted to the EU. As a result, our
cooperation will even more strengthen.
There are rather influential forces in Turkish elite, which thinks
about the following: Europe is a good think, indeed, and we should
become part of it, but to be respected, we must have a reliable and
influential rear. And the greater is the influence outside the EU,
the more influence we shall gain inside it. Thus, Turkey, of course,
will do everything to use the privileges gained during the last
two-three years in the aspect of the increase in its influence and
reputation in the eyes of Europeans, including though development of
relations with Russia. It is the meaning of a group.
These is also a pro-American group sure that Turkey should aspire for
maintenance of special relations with the USA, and that aspiration
for the EU and the relations with Russia are of secondary importance,
in the given case. At present, this group is ousted from big
politics, but it is still very strong. The Eurasian group, which is
marginal, belongs to the third wing. It is for the necessity of
deepening relations with Iran, as well as with Russia and China,
including, within the frameworks of SCO.
As regards the top ruling over Turkey at present, one should not
forget that these people belong to the traditional Turkish elite.
There is a very interesting opinion that today Turkey is coming back
to the very natural appearance it must be in. It is connected with
the fact that the ruling party expresses the aspirations and
interests of the greatest part of the population unlike all the other
Turkish rulers, starting from Young Turks, who implanted definite
concepts contradicting to the Turkish mentality. In this aspect, the
greatest part of the Turkish elite does not perceive seriously the
people who are in power at present. The first think that Turkey must
not exceed the frameworks of the traditional policy, as it is
stronger in an alliance with the USA. Thus, anti-Americanism in
Turkey cannot bring any considerable political dividends, though, at
the same time, the country itself is one of the most anti-American
ones, as to public sentiments, leaving behind the same Iran. It is
this public anti-Americanism that is used by the PJD ruling in
Turkey. They play on it and it is part of their very big internal
popularity.
What do you think of Moscow’s position on the Cyprus problem,
especially in the light of the failure of UN Secretary General’s
plan?
After the Turkish part of Cyprus voted for Kofi Annan’s plan,
Vladimir Putin stated that it is absolutely senseless and foul to
continue isolating the Turkish part of Cyprus. Of course, Turks were
pleasantly surprised with the words of the Russian President. Judging
by the official reaction of the Greek and Cyprian parties, they have
seen no real sign of a change in Moscow’s policy in this issue yet.
The EU is known to prepare for presentation of a new plan of
resolution to Cyprian problem, however, as I know, Russia is for
Annan’s plan and it will not support that of the EU. I think, the
fact that Turks provided Russia with an opportunity to occur in the
internal gas, oil and now energy markets of Turkey played a definite
role here. The privatization of Turkish energy distribution networks
is in process, with Russia displaying an interest in it. Besides, a
possibility of laying electricity transmission lines along the bottom
of Black Sea is currently under consideration. It is most probably
that Russia also gave its agreement on the construction and even
financing of the Trans-Thracian oil pipeline. Construction of a gas
terminal in the port Ceyhan is supposed to become the largest Russian
investment program abroad, though no official announcements have been
made in this connection.
It is necessary to assess as another factor that 40,000-strong
Turkish army is dislocated in Cyprus, which is favorable for the USA
as Cyprus is close to Egypt, Lebanon, Syria and, which is the most
important, to Ceyhan. Factually, in the strategic aspect, Cyprus
protects Ceyhan, i.e. the uninterrupted supply of oil from Ceyhan
terminal. Americans plan to construct a military base in Cyprus,
where they have a tracking base, which is the largest in the Middle
East controlling over the South Caucasus, Middle East and Arab
states. As regards Europe, it is also favorable for it that Cyprus be
restored as a united state. If Annan’s plan were accepted, Europe
would have to allocate over $20 billion for its implementation.
Still, how real is Turkey’s full membership at the EU? Whether
Europe’s response will be in favor of Ankara in this connection?
I do not think the prospect of a positive response so simple. Turkey
may receive a negative answer as well. In my opinion, the European
public is not satisfied with the decision to start talks for Turkey’s
admission to the EU adopted on December 17. In their turn, France and
Austria stated that they would announce a referendum on the given
issue. Meanwhile, it is a factual rejection to Ankara taking into
account the existing realities. Evidently, there is a great field for
bargaining here and the result will depend on Turkey’s state. Let’s
think of the issue seriously. Europe feels no need in Turkey. Just
one geo-political factor can be a clear answer to it – EU with Turkey
is one thing, while EU without Turkey is quite another. On the other
hand, I have grounds to suppose that Armenia will become a EU
member-state sooner than Turkey.
In the course of Russian-Turkish negotiations in Moscow, the issues
of the Armenian agenda, including Karabakh problem and the blockade
of the Armenian-Turkish boundary, were also in question. What do you
think, whether the rapprochement of Russia and Turkey is able to
influence the position of the Russian party on the Karabakh problem
or become a reason for an unfavorable shuffle of the Armenian cards?
Before answering the question, I’d like to draw your attention to
data of a survey carried out by the Russian Center for Public Opinion
Studies (VCIOM) on the attitude of Russians to Turkey. According to
these data, 71% of Russians display a positive attitude to Turkey,
51% consider it a reliable trade-and-economic partner, and 16% think
it a fraternal country. The Gallop International in Georgia asked a
similar question. The following data were fixed: only 7% of Georgians
consider Turkey a reliable partner, another 13% see some danger in
that country. To compare, only 3% of Russians think that Turkey is an
enemy country and a probable rival.
Deepening of political cooperation of Russia with Turkey is in the
background of a factual closure of Turkey’s approach to the South
Caucasus. I think the spring of 2002 a crucial point in this respect.
Then Americans made a decision to dispatch a limited contingent of
military instructors to Georgia. As I know, dispatch of Turkish
specialists to Georgia was considered initially. However, in future,
Washington refused from that idea. Probably, Turkey’s role as a
junior partner, assistance of the USA in its expansion to the South
Caucasus, is brought to the minimum at present. Though, we
mechanically keep considering Turkey the major guide of US policy. It
is not so. I think, establishment of new type mobile bases of the USA
in Georgia is a question of time, but probably it will happen in
Azerbaijan at first. So, in this respect, in the Caucasus, Turkey is
no longer dangerous for Russia. That is, the Caucasus, which was an
apple of discord for the two empires for centuries, is
no longer the same. It should be noted that at the beginning of the
last century, the Caucasus was divided between Soviet Russia and
Kemalist Turkey, in the first half of 90s when Russia’s withdrawal
resulted in vacuum in the Caucasus, Turkey tried to fill that vacuum.
Then Russia began returning and Turkey withdrawing again. But, then
occurred the USA, which neglected both Russia and Turkey in the same
way and acted as it thought fit. Hence, the geo-political rivalry of
Russia and Turkey in the Caucasus has been brought to the minimum,
which made their deeper cooperation possible, on the whole. In this
background, of course, the Turkish party each time raises an issue to
Moscow concerning the pressure on its ally, Armenia, to make it
release the territories. Turkey raised this issue in the course of
Putin’s visits to Ankara and to Moscow recently. However, to all
appearances, Russia each time rejects it. Speaking at a press
conference, Putin stated rather exactly that Russia had no intention
to exert pressure on any country; it would limit itself with the role
of a mediator and a guarantor of fulfillment of the agreements to be
signed by the parties. Sergey Ivanov stated almost the same in the
USA. That is, I do not share the concerns of definite political
circles of Armenia that Russia will expert pressure on us in the
issue of Karabakh in favor of Turkey. There are no real grounds for
it. Russia and Turkey have many other spheres to go on compromises.
But, I repeat, at the present level of Russia-Turkey and
Russia-Armenia relations a pressure on Yerevan on Karabakh problem is
ruled out.
Is it possible that Moscow exerts pressure both on Armenia and
Azerbaijan demanding resolution of the issue in the nearest future?
Turkey is not a country able to affect the process of Karabakh
conflict’s resolution within the framework of OSCE Minsk Group. It
can influence the process as it did one or two times torpedoing
almost ready agreements in 90s using all its influence on Azerbaijan.
At the given stage, Turkey is unable to influence Russia in order
that it, in its turn, influences Armenia. Moscow will not go on it.
A decision to start negotiations with Turkey for its admission to the
EU was made on December 17. Naturally, the process will last long.
What do you think, how heavy factor of pressure on Turkey by Europe
can become the Armenian Clause?
At first, Armenia does not perceive adequately what has happened. The
Armenian Clause is included into the agenda of the big European
politics. That is, it has happened what Armenians aspired for
decades. It is a fact, which Armenia is not fully aware of. By the
way, it does not mean that this issue cannot be in the same agenda.
Yet at the beginning of the last year, Chirac said although the fact
of the Genocide was adopted by the French Parliament, the issue of
recognition of the Armenian Genocide by Turkey must be solved by
Ankara and Yerevan; but, everything changed by the end of the year.
It was not only Chirac that pointed out the necessity of raising the
issue of recognition of the Armenian Genocide by Turkey, but also one
of the leading politicians N. Sarkozy and Foreign Minister M.
Barnier.
One should not forget that Armenia is a sovereign state, which is
able to play a definite role and does it. At the same time, for me
personally, dividends can be exclusively moral. Recognition of the
Genocide by Turkey is my duty to the annihilated generations. What is
the policy of the European Union? These are political decisions
adopted by bureaucratic structures of the EU and the EU
member-states. However, not only pragmatic calculations and political
interests, but also public opinion influence the adoption of these
decisions. It is a very strong resource of influence on the policy of
the EU in the Armenian Clause. I think Armenia does not use it fully.
I think diplomacy is diplomacy, but the public resource must be used.
Today Turkey exerts great efforts to protect its interests in the
issue of Genocide. At the end of December, the Foreign Minister of
Turkey, Abdullah Gul, met MPs and stated, in particular, the
following: the issue of admission to the EU comes to that of
recognition of the Armenian Genocide. That is, as to the remaining
issues, compromises can be found. Meanwhile, there is no compromise
in the issue of the Genocide, either Turkey recognizes it or not. I
think Europe will be adherent in this issue. Meanwhile, one should
not hope for Diaspora, but to express its position exactly and insist
on it.
What do you think, whether the crisis in the American-Turkish
relations is able to lead to recognition of the Armenian Genocide by
Turkey, taking into account Washington’s statements that Turkey
should not forget about the events of the beginning of the last
century when raising the issue of Kirkuk? It is necessary to mention
that 30 States have recognized the Armenian Genocide.
The Armenian Diaspora of the USA has rather wide lobbying activities.
However, I think that it made a very big fault. In the course of the
last presidential election in the USA, it supported John Kerry only
and has practically broken its ties with Republicans unlike the first
elections. Definite attempts of diversifications are currently made,
however, the positions of the Armenian lobby in the USA have become
considerably weak. Even without taking it into account, I do not
think that the Republican Administration of the White House will go
on recognition of the Genocide. In my opinion, neo-conservatives just
dislike Armenians.
Today the Armenian public is concerned for the possibility of
Armenia’s being bypassed by the new project to build a railroad
connecting Turkey with Georgia and Azerbaijan. Do you see any good
grounds in the urges for abandoning the idea of the Armenian Genocide
recognition in order to avoid the lot of a deadlock country for
Armenia?
I don’t accept such a formulation. There can be no 100% benefit or
detriment from one or another decision. As for concerns, they are
inspired by Turkey and come to one single formula – cooperation or
deadlock. Meanwhile, Armenia has a big advantage over the other South
Caucasian states. We have preserved our territorial integrity unlike
Georgia and Azerbaijan, which, according to the well-known concept,
is the first feature of a full-fledged state. Armenia has been
controlling big (in regional dimensions) territories for ten years
already managing in the meantime to enhance its economic growth.
These two factors alone show that Armenia cannot be a deadlock
country. On the contrary, today we are the dominating center of this
geo-political area and being in the center both geographically and
geo-politically one cannot simply get in a deadlock. This is an
axiom. Of course, Turkey and Azerbaijan may want to bypass Armenia.
But I don’t think that Georgia might want the same. The real actors
on the global arena, such as the US and Russia, will nonetheless be
guided by geo-political ends in the first place. It’s not a
coincidence that Armenia has been officially included in the
`North-South’ international transport corridor. As for the
above-mentioned Kars (Turkey)-Akhalkaki (Georgia) railroad, this idea
was first expressed by Shevardnadze while Saakashvili signed the
agreement already. As you may know Saakashvili has an idée fix to
make Batumi a big transport center with an airport of international
importance. To have a free hand he needs to connect Batumi with Kars
– this project is part of his plan. In any case, I don’t see any big
threat for Armenia – if the South Caucasian borders are opened we
will be able to join this road at any moment.
The interview was originally conducted by the Regnum News Agency and
provided to the Global Politician by Prof. Safrastyan.
Harry the Nazi
Ramallah Online, Palestine
Jan 24 2005
Harry the Nazi
by Brady Long, Ramallah Online Columnist
I will be the first to express my indignation at the choice of
costume by Prince Harry.
But what troubles me is the righteousness coming from various world
leaders, including Israelis, as if this costume and symbol are alone
in their representation of evil of the 20th century. The European
Union would like to see this symbol banned. Is it time to put the
Nazi atrocities including the holocaust into the context of 20th
century genocides?
During the program, Dateline London, BBC, one of the guests asked if
there would have been a similar outcry if the Prince had costumed
himself as Stalin, Hirohito, Mussolini, Mao, Mugabe, the Young Turks
circa Turkey 1915, etc. The Jewish guest reacted swiftly by stating
that there was no comparison to what Hitler did to the Jews to any
other figure of the 20th century. During a conversation with a close
friend, he echoed a similar response by referring to the ghastly
images of the trains, the crematoria, and the snarling dogs. In one
sense I agreed but then again if nobody witnesses the falling of a
tree does it diminish the falling of the tree? This reality has
spurred me on to search out past and, in some cases, present
holocausts/genocides.
Whereas the holocaust was horrific, it pales to what Stalin inflicted
on the five to seven million Ukrainians, murdered by starvation, the
Chechnyans, the Cossacks and many others. From 1917 to 1987, the
Communist government murdered about forty-one million.
Ask the relatives of the five million Poles who also were killed by
the Nazis if they had received preferential treatment when they were
forced into the gas chambers or summarily executed.
The first holocaust of the 20th century occurred in what is now known
as Namibia; this was the first genocide of the 20th century. Some
Hereros have suggested that the Nazi Holocaust was patterned after
this genocide some three and a half decades later. `Germany ruled
Namibia from 1880 to 1915. In 1904, Herero warriors were angered at
the German settlers who had enslaved their people, lynched their men,
and stolen their land, cattle and women. On Jan 12, they massacred
about two hundred German civilians. Although the uprising ended on
1904-Aug-11, the German army continued to exterminate the Hereros
until 1907, resulting in the deaths of perhaps 65,000 persons. As is
usual in these mass slaughters, the number of victims is unknown. The
Herero population alive at the time range from 50,000 to 120,000.
About 15, 000 survived.’ ( )
“The [Christian] Armenian genocide of 1915-1916 effectively wiped out
the Armenian population of Turkey, claiming some 1.5 million victims.
Perhaps 75,000 Armenians endure in Turkey today, most of them in
Istanbul. The Armenian Genocide occurred in a systematic fashion,
which proves that it was directed by the Turkish government — the
Young Turk government of the Ottoman Empire. First the Armenians in
the army were disarmed, placed into labor battalions, and then
killed. Then the Armenian political and intellectual leaders were
rounded up on [1915-] April 24 and killed. Finally, the remaining
Armenians were rounded up, told they would be relocated, and then
marched off to concentration camps in the desert between Jerablus and
Deir ez-Zor where they would starve and thirst to death in the
burning sun…The authorities in Trebizond, on the Black Sea coast,
did vary this routine: they loaded Armenians on barges and sank them
far out at sea. Three current and past governments of Turkey have
denied that the genocide actually happened. On January 18th 2001,
France passed a law branding as genocide the mass murder of Armenians
at the hands of the Ottoman Turk.’ (This information has been taken
from the following sources,
“The Armenian
Genocide,” at: )
Croatia, 1941 to 1945, was the arena of another holocaust whose
intent was racial purification.
`These atrocities were perpetrated by the Ustaša regime, the
Independent State of Croatia, which was established in power by the
Nazi government of Germany during World War II. They fiercely hated
Serbs, Jews, Communists and all other non-Catholics. Their goals were
to convert Croatia into a pure Croatian and Roman Catholic
independent state. On July 22nd, 1941 Dr. Mile Budak, the Ustaša
Minister of Education and Cults, said: “The movement of the Ustashi
is based on religion. For minorities-Serbs, Jews and Gypsies, we have
three million bullets. We shall kill one part of the Serbs. We shall
transport another, and the rest of them will be forced to embrace the
Roman Catholic religion. Thus, our new Croatia will get rid of all
Serbs in our midst in order to become one hundred percent Catholic
within ten years.” (“The embodied devils: Who was who in NDH?” Balkan
Repository Project, at: )
Other examples of ethnic/ideological cleansing in the 20th century
include:
Nanking, China- December 12th, 1937 – 320 thousand
China-1949 to1987 – 35million.
Cambodia-1975 to1979 – 2 million.
East Timor-1975 to1999 – 200 thousand.
Rwanda – 1994 – 800 thousand.
Bosnia/Herzegoviana-1975 to 1999, – 200 thousand.
Kosovo- 1998 to 1999 – deaths unknown.
Democratic Republic of Congo- 1997 to the present – 3 to 5 million.
Indonesia- 1965-1966, 1972 – 500 thousand.
Burundi- 1972 – 100 to 200 thousand.
Palestine- 1947 – 2005 ????????????
Before we jump to the conclusion that all of these holocausts were
the result of totalitarian regimes, look at the following examples of
pre-20th century holocausts closer to home.
….`For about 300 years, during the late Middle Ages and Renaissance
periods, the Christian church was directly or indirectly responsible
for the arrest, torture and execution of persons believed to worship
Satan or express heretical religious ideas. Civil courts, not by the
Catholic Church, passed most of the death sentences. However, the
church was indirectly involved: It provided the theological
foundation for the persecution of heretics in civil courts. It
created a false and unsupportable belief that large numbers of
worshipers had sold their soul to Satan and were committing evil and
homicidal acts. Belief in Witches gradually dissipated during the Age
of Enlightenment, as people began to question the reality of many
long-held religious beliefs. Estimates on the number of victims range
from 3,000 (from a Roman Catholic source) to 9,000,000 (from various
Neopagan sources).’
`…For his second voyage to the Americas, Columbus took the title
Admiral of the Ocean Sea and proceeded to unleash a reign of terror
unlike anything seen before or since. When he was finished, eight
million Arawaks — virtually the entire native population of
Hispaniola — had been exterminated by torture, murder, forced labor,
starvation, disease and despair. Later European Christian invaders
systematically murdered additional tens of millions of Aboriginal
people, from the Canadian Arctic to South America. The exact number
is unknown. Natives were murdered by warfare, forced death marches,
forced relocation to barren lands, intentional and accidental spread
of disease, poisoning, the promotion of suicide through the
destruction of their cultural and religious heritage, etc. Even
today, Canadian Natives have the highest suicide of any population
group in the world.’ The genocide against American Aboriginals is one
of the most massive, and longest lasting genocidal program in human
history.
`… The European invasion of Australia started in 1788. The population
of Aboriginals in the country was approximately 750,000. By 1911, the
number had been reduced to 31,000. Diseases introduced by the
invaders decimated most, against which the Aboriginals had no
defense. Some 20,000 were murdered. In those days, “The Sydney Herald
claimed that blacks had ‘bestowed no labor upon the land-their
ownership, their right, was nothing more than that of the Emu or the
Kangaroo.’ Courts rejected Aboriginal evidence, because
non-Christians could not swear oaths, and white killers used ‘the
defense that Aboriginal morality did not exist’. The extermination of
Aboriginals in Tasmania was particularly brutal; many white settlers
would shoot them on sight. In 1830, the remaining 300 Aboriginals
were ethnically cleansed from Tasmania. They were captured and
transferred to Flinders Island. They signed a treaty, which
guaranteed their later return. It was never honored. By 1843, only 50
remained alive. The atrocities continued into the 20th century.
Between 1910 and 1970, between one in three and one in ten indigenous
children were forcibly removed from their families. They were placed
with white families in order to absorb these people into the general
population. Aboriginals were finally granted citizenship in 1967.
They still await an apology from the Government of Australia.’
Why is it that we gravitate to the persecution of the Jews but not to
the millions of other victims? One answer may be ignorance while the
other is ominous in its prejudicial nature. The following excerpt
from the archives of MacLean’s may shed light upon the latter.
`It was not possible to get very close to the Russians nor to find
out anything much about them. They were a dumb, passive lot, knowing
no language but their own and quite devoid of intelligence for the
most part. ‘(Canadian POW/WW1 speaking about a fellow Russian POW)
One reality that is irrefutable is that Jewish persecution is the
longest in human history, (not the longest genocidal program-
American Aboriginals-) but that fact must not diminish the suffering
of all peoples who have and are being persecuted. The city of
Montreal, Canada came up with a novel idea
‘There are many monuments dedicated to various particular Human
tragedies in the world. In 1998 however, the City of Montréal was
innovative in this field by erecting a monument called La Réparation
– Monument á la mémoire des victimes de génocides, created by artist
Francine Larivée. This monument was dedicated to all victims of
genocides in the 20th century”, says the Ukrainian Canadian Congress.
La Presse, 1998.
Sadly Sharon and Bush, his chief ally, refuse to reflect on the past
and have chosen to do to the Palestinians what many are saying is
another attempt at ethnic persecution and in some cases ethnic
cleansing. Also, Bush and his coalition of the willing are
spearheading a war, not on terror, but on a crusade against Islam.
The first attempt took place one thousand years past and ended in
tragedy; this crusade is reaping the same results.
To conclude, if Prince Harry’s choice of the swastika is to be banned
and he should be forced to go to the 60th anniversary of the
liberation of Auschwitz and repent, should not the bearers of the
Star of David and the Star Spangled Banner be subjected to a similar
fate and be forced to go to the many places upon which they have
inflicted death and destruction and should many of us who have
ignored the plight of the Palestinians, and so many others, be made
to do the same?
;file=article&sid85
BAKU: Moscow trying to get Azerbaijan in military bloc
Moscow trying to get Azerbaijan in military bloc, political analyst says
Yeni Musavat, Baku
24 Jan 05
Text of report by Elsad in Azerbaijani newspaper Yeni Musavat on 24
January headlined “Lavrov comes to ‘pressure’ Azerbaijan” and
subheaded “Moscow wants to get Baku in its military-strategic orbit”
Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov’s expected visit to Azerbaijan
[on 2-3 February] has raised some questions. Even, some speculate that
Moscow is trying to take over the initiative in the region in the
run-up to the Iran operations to prevent US plans to use Azerbaijani
territory. Moscow is believed to be sending Lavrov to Baku to get
Azerbaijan aligned with the CIS Collective Security Treaty. The fact
that the Russian president openly spoke about it in his last expanded
news conference was a herald of this intention of the [Soviet]
empire’s successor. Undoubtedly, if Moscow, which is against the Iran
operations, manages to have Baku agree to join this treaty, there will
be problems for the USA in using Azerbaijani territory.
Stressing that a proposal of this kind has been made [on Azerbaijan’s
membership of the Collective Security Treaty], political analyst [and
former head of the Azerbaijani presidential secretariat] Eldar Namazov
has however said that this is not taken quite positively in
Azerbaijan. “It would be ridiculous for Azerbaijan to be in the
military bloc with the occupying country. I do not think anybody can
see Azerbaijan in that bloc before Armenia liberates the Azerbaijani
territories.”
The expert recalled that Lavrov will visit Azerbaijan for the first
time against the background of the recent developments in the CIS,
namely in Georgia and Ukraine. “Therefore, it will be an interesting
visit for all. Namely, does Russia have any corrections over the
recent developments in the CIS? We will find an answer to this
question during Lavrov’s visit.”
“A revolution has turned into an actual threat in Russia. I already
see a lot of young people among protesters. From this viewpoint,
Moscow should end playing with our fate,” another political analyst
[and former presidential advisor on foreign policy issues] Vafa
Quluzada has said. It is “inadmissible” for Azerbaijan to follow
Russia, he believes. “It is possible to maintain relations with Russia
after a normal government is established there.” Quluzada believes
that Lavrov is coming to pressure official Baku to ensure that
Azerbaijan joins the Collective Security Treaty.
“Visits of this kind will not have negative results if Azerbaijan does
not join the treaty. If otherwise, adverse results for our national
interests are inevitable.”
Armenian Coalition To Mull Proposed Deal With Opposition
Radio Free Europe, Czech Rep
Jan 24 2005
Armenian Coalition To Mull Proposed Deal With Opposition
Leaders of the Armenian parliament’s pro-government majority promised
on Friday to consider an unexpected opposition offer to reach a
compromise agreement on constitutional amendments put forward by
President Robert Kocharian.
Parliament speaker Artur Baghdasarian told a senior opposition
lawmaker, Victor Dallakian, that he will begin `political
consultations’ with fellow majority leaders over three constitutional
changes demanded by the Artarutyun bloc and the National Unity Party
(AMK).
The changes would empower the National Assembly to endorse
prime-ministerial candidates nominated by the president, seriously
limit the latter’s controversial authority to appoint and sack judges
as well as make the mayor of Yerevan an elected official. The two
opposition groups have indicated that they will endorse Kocharian’s
package of draft amendments if their proposals are incorporated into
it.
Dallakian told reporters that Baghdasarian promised to finish the
consultations within ten days. `We put forward a package proposal,’
he said. `If two coalition parties accept but the other rejects them,
we will not participate in this process.’
The opposition has previously rejected Kocharian’s constitutional
amendments as undemocratic and vowed to scuttle his efforts to push
them through a referendum expected this summer. Leaders of the three
parties represented in Kocharian’s government reacted positively to
the softening of the opposition stance.
`We will consider that proposal,’ said Gagik Minasian of the
Republican Party (HHK), the biggest parliamentary force.
`Most of the [opposition] proposals are quite sound ones,’ said Armen
Rustamian of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation (Dashnaktsutyun).
The coalition parties had offered the opposition the right of veto in
the reform process, in an unsuccessful attempt to stave off a
campaign of anti-Kocharian street protests last spring. Both Minasian
and Rustamian told RFE/RL that the offer may no longer be on the
table.
`It is strange that they are reacting to that offer now,’ said the
HHK representative.
`I am glad that our colleagues now accept our offer made at that
time. But there is a problem of missing the right moment,’ said
Rustamian. `The political situation makes some things possible at one
point and problematic at another. The situation has changed a bit. So
has our mood.’