Kurds and the Kurdistans

Global Politician, NY
Jan 24 2005
Kurds and the Kurdistans
1/23/2005
By Antero Leitzinger
Western thinking leads us to figure out nations on the basis of a
common language or religion. According to the principle of
nation-state, each nation must have a homeland. But are the Kurds one
united nation, or rather a heterogeneous group of various nations in
the same way as, for instance, the Scandinavians [Swedes, Danes,
Norwegians, Icelanders] or the Baltic Finns [Finns, Estonians,
Karelians, Ingrians, Veps, Livonians]?
The Kurds speak several languages and confess even more religions.
Equally big differences prevail between Kurdish languages as between
them and Persian. If Gurani and Luri are just dialects of one and
same language, then are not also Sorani and Kurmandji dialects of
Persian? If the Kurds still need a state separate from other Iranic
nations, would there next be a liberation movement of Zazakistan
within independent Kurdistan?
There are several Kurdistans, “lands of the Kurds”, in the world –
not only because the traditional territory inhabited by Kurds is
divided between at least six states, but also because each Kurdish
party has their own idea of the borders, governance and future of
their ideal state. The Kurds have dozens of nationalist parties, and
besides, many Kurds support cross-country parties that exceed ethnic
boundaries in those countries where free party activity is legal at
all.
In Iran, there is a province called Kordestan, rooted in medieval
times, but the Kurdish state that declared independence in 1946 was
not located in Kordestan, but in the province of Western Azerbaijan.
In Iraq, the Kurdish region is divided into three parts: the stripe
governed by the Baath party, and the territories of the competitor
Kurd parties KDP and PUK. The “Red Kurdistan” that officially belongs
to Azerbaijan, is presently ruled by Armenia. Part of Syria’s Kurds
have lacked citizenship and civil rights for four decades already. In
Turkey, the position of Kurds is better than in any of her
neighbouring countries, but still it is the Turkish Kurds, whose
human rights are usually covered by international media.
Whose Kurdistan is the right one? The Iraqi Kurds are under the
protection of the NATO, but the PKK considers NATO their enemy.
Founding a national state in the Middle East has its model in Israel,
but the idea was once agitated by the Soviet Union. The Kurdish
national identity is often shaped among the immigrants in Europe, and
under the influence of controversal political programmes. The problem
touches Europe, but is it necessarily a problem?
——————————————————————————–
KURDS AND THE KURDISTANS
The Kurds and Kurdistan – a nation and a state? Western line of
thinking leads us to the idea of nation-state, but can it be suited
to the reality of Middle East? What is a nation? Does every nation
need a state on their own? Does one Kurdistan exist, or are there
several of them?
ENVIRONMENT: THE MIDDLE EAST
Before we concentrate in the Kurds, it is a good idea to pay some
attention on their bigger neighbour nations: the Turks, the Arabs,
and the Persians.
– The Turks are linguistically and culturally a very united nation.
They inhabit a very wide zone from Cyprus to the Great Wall of China.
Only about half of the world’s Turks are living in Turkey. The core
area is Turkestan, “land of the Turks”, in Central Asia. It is
divided by at least seven states. When Turkish nationalism developed
in the 1800s, it adopted the model from Europe, but this
European-modelled national idea has still not yet spread very deep
into east.
– The Arab nation is divided into dozens of states, among which none
was entirely independent hundred years ago. Arab nationalism was
connected with Arab socialism, but still failed in its attempts to
unite the Arab world in the 1900s. What remained was a lot of
bitterness and chronical problems of international politics.
– The Persians belong to the Iranic peoples. They have their nominate
state Iran, which was earlier called Persia abroad. Also Tajikistan
and Afghanistan are Iranic states.
The relationship between Iran and Turkey is interesting. Every fourth
Iranian is ethnically Turk. In Iran’s Southern Azerbaijan there are
more of Turkish “Azeris” than in the formally independent Northern
Azerbaijan. Iran also has Turkmen population larger than
Turkmenistan. These Turkish tribes differ from each other about as
much as Savonians and Karelians [two Finnish tribes].
Azerbaijan and Kurdistan are in many ways like mirror images of each
other. Both were promised independence at the end of the World War I.
Both got to taste Soviet-styled independence after the World War II.
Ten years ago, Northern Azerbaijan and Southern Kurdistan became free
from the occupation of Russia and Iraq, but their independence is
still weak. On the other hand, Iran, now surrounded by newly
independent states, fears more than ever before that her Western
parts would split up.
The world around the Kurds is not whole and not simple. The problems
are common.
LANGUAGE
Are the Kurds one, united nation, or are they a group of Iranic
tribes? Can the difference between a nation and a tribe be
objectively defined?
According to the Persians, the Kurds speak various dialects of
Persian. According to others, Kurdish is a distinct relative language
to Persian. The boundary is soft, and Luri might be as well a Persian
dialect as a Kurdish language. After all, the choice is political:
which group one wants to be identified with.
Between Kurdish dialects or languages there are so big differences
that they must be taken into consideration in interpretation. The
differences are bigger than between German and Danish or between
Spanish and Portuguese.
In Iran, three important Kurdish languages are spoken:
– Gurani is the liturgical language of the “People of Truth”
(Ahl-i-Haqq). They constitute an old religious group, which lives in
the historical core of Kurdistan, in the area of the medieval khanate
of Ardalan.
– Sorani is the most studied and best-known Kurdish language. It has
an official status in Iraq, where it is spoken by the Kurds living
around Suleymania. They, too, believe that they descend from the
Ardalan Khanate.
– Kurmandji is spoken in all the Kurdish homelands. In Northern Iraq,
the Kurmandji area is governed by the Kurdistan Democratic Party
(KDP), which uses Arabic script. The Turkish Kurmandjis use Latin
alphabet of the Turkish model. In the Soviet Union, Kurmandji was
also written with Cyrillic letters.
The fourth important Kurdish language is Zaza or Dimili, which is
spoken in Turkey. Many Zazas aim at forming a special area of
Zazakistan, instead of independent Kurdistan. Despite their
geographic distance, Zaza and Gurani are closer to each other than to
Sorani or Kurmandji. This is due to the fact that Kurdish settlement
has spread westwards with rapid and long pulses.
Linguistic disunity is not as such a hindrance to united national
feeling. Nationalism has often been based on a hardly common written
language. In the neighbourhood of the Kurds, the Georgians and the
North Caucasians have proved this. Also Italian language and the
Slavonic languages of the Balkan countries were only created in the
1800s to support the ideas of national unification and political
independence.
The Kurdish languages are strongly based on Arabic loan words. So
were also Persian and Turkish based on Arabic loans before the
linguistic reforms of the 1900s, in which the written language was
“cleaned” of “alien” elements. When the differences between the three
great linguistic groups of the Middle East were emphasised, the
Kurdish languages fell in between. In a way, the Kurds were born in
the vacuum left by the narrow interpretation of the dominant
cultures.
One Kurdish dictionary has been published in Finnish, by Lokman
Abbas. The Kurdish in it is Sorani. In Sweden one has published a
pocket dictionary in Kurmandji. Also in other European languages
there are Kurdish vocabularies, but the quality differs. Kurdish
literature is plentiful but developing a useful written language
still takes its time. Culture cannot be ordered like a home pizza;
one has to toil for it devotedly, and there must be lasting need for
it.
RELIGION
Besides language, religion can be used to unite or separate nations.
Most of the Kurds are Sunnite Muslims of the Shafi discipline.
Disciplinary differences are however that small that they do not
relevantly separate the Kurds from their Hanafi neighbours, the Turks
and the Arabs.
As Sunnite Muslims, most Kurds are separated from the Shi’ite Islam,
which is the state religion of Iran. Yet the Iraqi Feilis are Shi’ite
Kurds. Besides, many sects with Shi’ite origin are represented among
Kurds, and many of these sects also have strongly non-Islamic
influences.
Many believe that the most genuine Kurds are the Yesids, whose
religion is a strange mixture of Islam, Christianity, Judaism and
Zoroastrianism. On the other hand the Yesids feel deep distrust at
all outsiders, and often they are not even classified as actual
Kurds.
Nowadays the Assyrian Christians of Northern Iraq declare they are
Kurds. The Jewish Kurds were once evacuated to Israel. So, there are
Kurds belonging to every main religion of the region.
The Kurds cannot be exclusively defined by language, religion or any
single cultural feature. Even the spring celebration Nevruz, which
the Kurds will celebrate after two weeks at the time of the spring
equinox, is an old all-Iranian tradition. It is also celebrated by
Central Asian Turks.
The Kurdish culture changes in time. Some “age-old Kurdish
traditions” were in fact born in Germany in recent decades. This is
nothing unusual, as many nations without state have found their
identity in exile, in Diaspora.
The strength of the Kurds and the vitality of Kurdish culture are in
their ability to create new, and to combine traditions of the Middle
Eastern dominant cultures and numerous minorities. The variety and
flexibility of expression, typical for spoken language, the religious
plurality, and the whole wide scale of culture are not necessarily
weaknesses splitting up the community, and by no means they are
reasons for shame. The Kurds have not succeeded in imitating European
nationalism of the 1800s, but they have succeeded in what today’s
Europeanity is dreaming about: unity in variety.
PARTIES
A nation without state may feel orphan or homeless. In that case,
however, the state has been given tasks that it could hardly fulfil.
The main Kurdish parties are all state-centrist, their background
being hard-line socialist. The KDP and its Iranian brother party were
founded in Stalin’s protection. In that time the Kurds were hailing
Stalin as “the liberator of small nations”.
When the KDP was released from the Soviet Union’s guidance in the
1960s, the PUK was founded to defend fundamentalist Marxism. The
Kurdish section Komala was split up from the Iranian Communist Party.
By time, the number of Kurdish parties was increased by splitting.
Those shocked of the collapse of Soviet power founded Workers’
Communist Party (WCP) in Iraq and Iran. This party has spectacular
presence in the virtual reality, in internet.
Also “Marxism-Leninism, Mao Tse Tung’s thought” gained supporters
among Kurds. They founded the Kurdish Workers’ Party, PKK, which is
internationally the best-known, but by no means the only, Kurdish
organisation.
There are dozens of specially Kurdish parties. Many of them are
one-man enterprises or stages of the main parties. All in all, they
share a common belief in the idea that a state on their own would
solve all the problems of the Kurds, and the problems are understood
as basically economic exploitation.
Because the Kurds have many but dear parties, also the goals of
independence are rather party politics than national projects. There
is no consensus on Kurdistan’s borders, form of government and
symbols like flag. Each party has its own Kurdistan. Each party also
has its own army, its schools, and its health system. The parties
have adopted many tasks of tribes. Membership in a party is often
strategic allegiance of family and tribe, not free and ideological
choice of the individual.
Each party has its international sponsors: PUK has historically
leaned at Syria, and KDP at Turkey. PKK has leaned at both Syria and
Iraq. Exploitation has been mutual.
The Kurdish parties are fighting each other. For three years now, KDP
and PUK have respected their ceasefire, mainly due to external
pressure, but meanwhile, PKK has fought against both these Iraqi
Kurdish parties.
In democracy it is natural that parties disagree. Usually they do,
however, agree on large-scale national questions, and in the times of
war they act under common war command. For example, the Chechens
demand independence before all, and only secondarily come the
questions of the country’s future systems of justice and economy. The
Finnish Jäger [Finnish freedom fighters trained in Germany before the
independence] included Red and White, Monarchists and Republicans.
Among the Kurdish parties, such agreement is missing.
REGIONS
Kurdistan has been founded many times and in many places.
In Iran, the Kurds declared independence in 1946, but it happened in
the city of Mahabad, not in the actual province of Kordestan.
The Kurdish autonomy in Iraq, recognised by the Iraqi government in
1970s, the de facto independent regional administration of Kurdistan
since 1991, and the no-flight area controlled by NATO, do not
entirely coincide in coverage. Besides, KDP and PUK have divided
their interest spheres along the dialect boundary.
In Turkey, Kurdistan has never been profoundly defined. It has been
at its best a vague anthropological conception, a bit like the “wolf
zone” in Finland [expression of periphery].
In the World War I, the European colonial powers Russia, France and
Britain were seizing new colonies by sharing the Middle East between
each other. They planned to found two newly old Christian
protectorats in Eastern Turkey: Armenia and Assyria. Both these
regionally overlapped with Kurdistan. Hatred was incited between the
Christian groups and the Islamic Kurds. This resulted massacres, for
which it is nowadays fashionable to blame Turkey, while the guilt of
the European counterparts is forgotten.
Turkey’s enemy in the World War I [Russia] as well as the fanatic
bandit groupings of the different parties have apparently got
absolution from their sins. Instead of Armenia and Assyria, Kurdistan
has appeared on the maps. It has traditionally had dangerous results
when European powers [like Russia and France] have started to redraw
Middle Eastern maps.
Today, Turkey’s Kurdistan could be defined in accordance with those
provinces that have state of emergency. However, most Turkish Kurds
live outside that region – many of them in the Turkish metropoles far
west from Kurdistan. For them, cultural autonomy would sound more
sensible than regional privileges.
HUMAN RIGHTS
Separation of the three dominant cultures of the Middle East left the
Kurds in between. As the Kurds were not “good” Arabs, and all of them
did not become “proper” Iranians or Turks, they were pushed aside and
they had to search for their own identity.
This has not always been the case and it need not be so forever. An
American journal appointed as “the man of 12th century” the Kurdish
chief Saladin, who led Islamic troops against the Crusaders. Saladin
is also the Arabs’ hero, and a historical regent admired by even his
European enemies. He was known for his religious tolerance and the
nobility of his character. Saladin was not profiled as rebel or
terrorist leader, but as the one who united the Middle East.
Kurdish nationalism and political activity is for a great part a
reaction to the policy of the states in the region. When the Kurds
have been respected, they have produced great statesmen like Saladin
for the honour of the whole Middle East. When the Kurds have been
despised, they have corroded the structures of all the states in the
region.
The most miserable situation prevails in Syria, where most of the
country’s Kurdish population has lacked all citizen rights for 40
years – literally.
Iraq’s situation is formally decent, but what value do laws and
contracts have, if the government cannot be trusted? In 1988, Saddam
Hussein’s troops murdered with gas raids estimated 200’000 Kurds
within only half a year. Is it then a wonder that the Iraqi Kurds
want to establish a humanitarian refuge for themselves and their
families in Europe, anticipating the worst?
When Armenia conquered territories from Azerbaijan, thousands of
Muslim Kurds were murdered and expelled from their home villages.
Only the Yesids got mercy from Armenians.
Guerrilla war took place in Iran and Turkey in 1980s and 1990s. In
both countries 40’000 people were killed, in Iran probably more.
Leaders of Iranian Kurds were assassinated in Europe, but for some
reason the Western press has been mainly interested in the arrest of
the Turkish PKK, Abdullah Öcalan, two years ago.
Yet Öcalan is about the worst possible example of a typical Kurd.
Öcalan speaks Turkish. The emissaries of the PKK in Europe speak
Turkish with each other. Öcalan has not for a single day fought as a
guerrilla, but still he has ordered death penalties to traitors,
deserters, school teachers and dissidents of his party. Öcalan’s
original idols were Che Guevara and Pol Pot. A Kurdish activist
hiding in Germany, Selim Cürükkaya, published a book named `PKK’ four
years ago. In his book, Cürükkaya describes the horrible ways of
discipline, paranoia and personal cult prevailing in the PKK. The
fanaticism of the supporters, child soldiers and suicides by burning
have caused immense damage to the reputation of the Kurds and their
cause. It is not without reason that Germany, France, Britain and the
United States have prohibited the PKK as a criminal organisation.
Hikmet Cetin, who has acted as the chairman of the Turkish parliament
and even as the acting president, is not at all less a Kurd than
Öcalan, even though he condemns the PKK. Every fifth parliamentarian
in Turkey is a Kurd. Also in Iran, the Kurds are represented in
government, police and army. All Kurds do not support specially
Kurdish parties and they do not demand a special Kurdish state. In
the violence of Turkey and Iran, there have been features of a
Kurdish civil war.
Iraq’s Kurds have their own great leaders. The deceised Mulla Mustafa
Barzani was virtuously leading his guerrillas, the “peshmergas”, in
the mountains of four countries for 30 years. Barzani’s son and
colleague are now leading opposite parties.
An average Kurd, however, is not a politician and not even
politically persecuted. Hundreds of thousands of Kurds are living in
Europe, a couple of thousands of them in Finland. Most of them are
ordinary, honest and hard-working immigrants, in whose home villages
the emigration started as early as in 1960s. They try to earn their
living and secure the future of their families. They want to save
their mother tongue, their religion and their customs on the level of
ordinary life. As citizens of Finland they are faithful to their new
fatherland, although Kurdistan remains in their memories and dreams.
Many nations without state have to keep nationality apart from
citizenship.
ENVIRONMENT: EUROPE
Nobody denies that the Kurds as individuals would deserve full human
rights and that these rights have been violated in many countries.
However, are the Kurds also a nation? According to the British
researcher David McDowall, the Kurds became a nation at the end of
the World War I. Many other researchers are still confused at the
question.
Who has the right to represent a nation? Are there some particular
“collective rights” that belong to a nation or its representatives?
Unfortunately we do not even know the actual number of Kurds, because
all the estimations appearing in the literature are based on other
estimations made decades ago. A nation without state is like a soup
without case – it slips out of hands and avoids attempts to define.
“Kurdistan” is a word that raises passions. Many governments are
allergic to it. On the other hand, many European politicians and
journalists are connecting rather romanticised ideas with Kurds.
Superficial and sensational supply of information is presenting
things in a simplistic form.
Europe has had the bad habit of playing hypocrite with human rights.
Minorities have been used as tools in superpower politics, but in
critical situations the minorities have been betrayed and abandoned.
The Kurds have gained selective publicity, whenever European powers
have wanted to avoid speaking about Basques or Bretons. The Turkish
idea of understanding all citizens of Turkey as “Turks” does not
differ from the similar conception of nationality in France and
Spain.
The Kurds have also been employed as examples of the Marxist theory
of empoverishment. The Australian Paul J. White, who published a book
on Kurds last year (`Primitive Rebels or Revolutionary Modernizers’),
still in our times describes the Kurds as Turkey’s “proletariat”.
This is artificial, condescending and insultive. Equally well the
Savonians and Karelians could be branded as Finland’s discriminated
proletarians, who is suffering in Helsinki’s suburbs. All Kurds would
not like to be characterised as eternal losers and they do not want
to mourn their fate and beg for sympathy.
Sometimes national identity is being interpreted in so purpose-bound
ways and so widely that it is hard to be taken seriously. A Turkish
Arabic-speaking Christian declares himself as a Kurd, because he
feels different and discriminated in his home country. If he becomes
unemployed, his bad luck is easy to explain as “persecution”. Is
anybody a Kurd if he feels loser?
According to an increasing point of view, the Kurds are present
Europe’s nomads, wandering asylum-seekers. But is this really only
due to difficult circumstances in the coutries of origin, or is it
rather due to the reluctant immigration policy of Europe, which
prefers sharing social support to admitting work permissions? To what
extent do the European countries encourage to apply and wait for an
asylum instead of giving equal treatment and fair chance to work and
embrace one’s own culture?
The Kurds are an inseparable part of the whole Middle East’s cultural
heritage. In them, also the best sides of Turkey, Iran and the Arab
countries are combined. Far too often the European discussion
connects the Kurds with problems, and presents the Kurds as evidence
of the social undevelopment of the Middle Eastern countries. This
only strengthens the negative attitudes in these countries.
Kurdistan is situated where Turkey, Persia and Arabia meet. Whether
it is a point of friction or a meeting-point, a gap or a bridge, is a
crucial question for the Kurds and their home countries still for a
long time for future.
The Kurds also belong to Europe. They are permanently present among
us.
Europe has always been involved in the Middle Eastern affairs, and
thus she cannot avoid her responsibility when things are entangled
into troubles. Responsibility calls for knowledge and knowledge
demands research. The Kurds still deserve even more research and from
broader views. Also difficult questions most be discussed without
fervour.
The edition is based on Antero Leitzinger’s lecture in the University
of Helsinki, in the Studia Generalia series “Crisis Kettles and
Religions in World Politics”, part “Nations without State” on March
8, 2001. The article was originally written around the same time.
Antero Leitzinger is a political historian and a researcher for the
Finnish Directorate of Immigration. He wrote several books on Turkey,
the Middle East and the Caucasus.

FM Oskanian’s Addresses UN Special Session

PERMANENT MISSION OF ARMENIA TO THE UNITED NATIONS
Contact: Dziunik AGHAJANIAN
Minister-Counsellor
Deputy Permanent Representative
119 East 36th Street, New York, NY 10016, USA
Tel: 1-212-686-9079
Fax: 1-212-686-3934
E-mail: [email protected]
Web:
January 24, 2005
PRESS RELEASE
MINISTER OSKANIAN ADDRESSES UN SPECIAL SESSION
Armenia’s Minister of Foreign Affairs Vartan Oskanian was among a select
group of foreign ministers who addressed the UN 28th Special Session, on the
60th Anniversary of the Liberation of the Nazi Concentration Camps. The
session was held just a few days before the 60th anniversary of the
liberation of the Auschwitz concentration camp, by Soviet troops, near the
end of World War II.
UN Secretary General Kofi Annan spoke about the role of the UN, which was
founded immediately following the Second World War. The massive violations
of human rights during the war were an impetus for the formation of this
international institution, 60 years ago, he explained.
The Secretary General was followed by Holocaust Survivor, writer, Nobel
Prize Winner for Peace, Professor Elie Wiesel, and former UN Undersecretary
Sir Brian Urquhart. Elie Wiesel evoked images of the horrors that
concentration camp inmates had to endure, and repeatedly expressed amazement
at humanity’s capacity for such evil, and for such indifference. Sir Brian,
then a member of the Allied Forces that liberated the camps, stressed
humanity’s collective responsibility in the prevention of genocides and in
bringing to justice the perpetrators.
They were followed by Silvan Shalom, the Foreign Minister of Israel, the
Special Representative of Poland, Mr. Bronislaw Geremek, Vladimir Lukin, the
Commissioner for Human Rights of the Russian Federation, Paul Wolfowitz, US
Deputy Secretary of Defense, Jean Asselborn, the Minister of Foreign Affairs
of Luxembourg, on behalf of the European Union, and Marcello Pera, Speaker
of the Italian Senate.
Together with Minister Oskanian, also on the rostrum were other foreign
ministers: Joschka Fischer, Germany, Michel Barnier, France, Pierre
Pettigrew, Canada, Ilinka Mitreva, Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia, as
well as representatives of Greece, Romania, Norway, Austria, Hungary, the
Netherlands and Great Britain.

Antelias: HH Aram I receives National Council of Churches USA

PRESS RELEASE
Catholicosate of Cilicia
Communication and Information Department
Contact: V. Rev. Fr. Krikor Chiftjian, Communications Officer
Tel: (04) 410001, 410003
Fax: (04) 419724
E- mail: [email protected]
Web:
PO Box 70 317
Antelias-Lebanon
HIS HOLINESS ARAM I RECEIVES THE DELEGATION
OF THE NATIONAL COUNCIL OF CHURCHES USA
Antelias, Lebanon – On Saturday, January 22, 2005, His Holiness Catholicos
Aram I received a delegation of the National Council of Churches USA at the
Armenian Catholicosate of Cilicia, Antelias-Lebanon. The representatives of
the Middle East Council of Churches and His Grace Bishop Nareg Alemezian
(Ecumenical Officer) were also in attendance. The delegation is visiting the
Middle East to be acquainted with the situation more closely and to express
its solidarity to the peace process.
His Holiness shared with his guests the emerging religious, social and
political concerns in Lebanon and the Middle East and underlined the
importance of overcoming violence and establishing a peaceful society
enhanced by Christian-Muslim long-standing co-existence.
His Holiness spoke about the challenges facing the ecumenical movement and
identified areas where the Churches should co-operate and support each
other. His Holiness underlined that ecumenical advocacy and solidarity
should be expressed through the tangible actions and continuous support of
Churches towards each other. “We do not live in isolation. Global, regional
and local challenges are inter-connected and we need to adopt a policy of
facing them together and responsibly. In this respect, the role of the
Churches should be expressed as bridge-builders and promoters of dialogue
and collaboration, and the Armenian Catholicosate of Cilicia is strongly
committed to this principle” underlined His Holiness.
Referring to the situation in Iraq and Jerusalem, His Holiness reminded all
the Churches and especially the USA Churches to encourage their governments
to work for peace and justice all over the world and to embark on the
establishment of communities living in an atmosphere of mutual respect and
trust. “The Armenians in the Holy Land and Iraq are integral part of the
population of these countries who are the focus of our prayers and
attention. We are sharing all the difficulties in the region and
contributing to the peace process with a firm commitment to the
Christian-Muslim co-existence and the promotion of the common values that
have sustained us for centuries,” stated His Holiness.
The delegation expressed its gratitude for this opportunity and invited His
Holiness to address the National Council of Churches USA Board meeting in
October, in New York.
##
View printable pictures here:
***********
The Armenian Catholicosate of Cilicia is one of the two Catholicosates of
the Armenian Orthodox Church. For detailed information about the Ecumenical
activities of the Cilician Catholicosate, you may refer to the web page of
the Catholicosate, The Cilician Catholicosate, the
administrative center of the church is located in Antelias, Lebanon.
From: Baghdasarian

FM OSkanian’s speech at the 28th special session

PERMANENT MISSION OF ARMENIA TO THE UNITED NATIONS
Contact: Dziunik AGHAJANIAN
Minister-Counsellor
Deputy Permanent Representative
119 East 36th Street, New York, NY 10016, USA
Tel: 1-212-686-9079
Fax: 1-212-686-3934
Mobile: 1-917-940-5665
STATEMENT
by H.E. Mr. Vartan Oskanian
Minister of Foreign Affairs of Armenia
to the 28th Special Session
of the UN General Assembly
Mr. President
Your Excellencies
Dear Friends,
On behalf of the people and government of Armenia, and as a descendant of
genocide survivors, I feel compelled to be here today, to join other
survivors and descendants, of both victims and perpetrators, to take part in
this commemoration. I am also duty-bound to urge us all to confront more
effectively the threat of genocide anywhere, at any time, regardless of cost
and political discomfort.
The liberation of Auschwitz is, indeed, cause for commemorative celebration.
However, in this commemoration, with each uttering of the name Auschwitz, we
are forced to reflect: to look back, look around, look deep, look at the
other, but also look inward, at ourselves.
After 9/11 and reacting to the unusually high number of victims of a
singular event, an editorialist proclaimed “We are all Americans”. Sympathy,
solidarity, anxiety, and indignation bound us together. How much more
intense our feelings about Auschwitz and the singularity of its horror, its
synonymity with the technology of death-making, its eerily ordinary
commitment to efficiency, to pragmatic, effective, result-oriented
administration.
After Auschwitz, we are all Jews, we are all Gypsies, we are all unfit,
deviant and undesirable, for someone, somewhere. After Auschwitz, the
conscience of man cannot remain the same. Man’s inhumanity to men, to women,
to children, and to the elderly, is no longer a concept in search of a name,
an image, a description. Auschwitz lends its malefic aura to all the
Auschwitzes of history, our collective history, both before and after.
In the 20th century alone, with its 15 genocides, the victims have their own
names for places of infamy. What the French call ‘les lieux infames de
memoire’ are everywhere. Places of horror, slaughter, of massacre, of the
indiscriminate killing of all those who have belonged to a segment, a
category, an ethnic group, a race or a religion. For Armenians, it is the
desert of Deir-El-Zor, for Cambodians they are the killing fields, for the
children of the 21st century, it is Darfur. For the Jews and Poles and for a
whole generation of us growing up after The War, it is Auschwitz.
Mr. President,
Just as we all were, or are, or might be victims, we all were or are or
might also be guilty. It is only through the engagement of those who have
seen and done the unimaginable, and who have had the dignity, the grace, the
sensitivity, the decency and courage to acknowledge wrongdoing, that we may
achieve the requisite collective political will and its expression.
This is not as naïve, unrealistic, idealistic as some might wish to label
it, perhaps in order to dismiss it. Genocide is not about individuals who
act insanely, do evil, commit crimes, perpetrate irrevocable wrongs.
Genocide is the undertaking of a state apparatus, which must, by definition,
act coherently, pragmatically, with structure and organization.
Thus, this is not a plea to reform human beings, but an appeal to take
conscious account of the role of our national institutions and international
institutions must play to insure that no one can expect to enjoy impunity.
After Auschwitz one would expect that no one any longer has a right to turn
a blind eye or a deaf ear. As an Armenian, I know that a blind eye, a deaf
ear and a muted tongue perpetuate the wounds. It is a memory of suffering
unrelieved by strong condemnation and unequivocal recognition. The catharsis
that the victims deserve, which societies require in order to heal and move
forward together, obligates us here at the UN, and in the international
community, to be witness, to call things by their name, to remove the veil
of obfuscation, of double standards, of political expediency.
Mr. Presidents,
Following the Tsunami-provoked disaster, we have become painfully aware of a
paradox. On the one hand, multilateral assistance efforts were massive,
swift, generous and without discrimination. But, when compared and
contrasted with today’s other major tragedy, in Africa, it is plain that for
Darfur, formal and ritual condemnation has not been followed by any
dissuasive action against the perpetrators.
The difference with the Tsunami, of course, was that there were no
perpetrators. No one wielded the sword, pulled the trigger or pushed the
button that released the gas.
Recognizing the victims and acknowledging them is also to recognize that
there are perpetrators. But this is absolutely not the same as actually
naming them, shaming them, dissuading or warning them, isolating or
punishing them.
If these observations signal a certain naiveté that overlooks the enduring
structures of our political and security interests, then, on this occasion,
when we have gathered to commemorate this horrible event, then allow me this
one question: if not here and now, then where and when?
Mr. President,
The Spanish-American philosopher George Santayana, who has been quoted here,
admonished us to remember the past, or be condemned to repeat it. This
admonition has significance for me personally, because the destruction of my
people, whose fate in some way impinged upon the fate of the Jews of Europe,
should have been viewed more widely seen as a warning of things to come.
Jews and Armenians are linked forever by Hitler. Who, after all, speaks
today of the annihilation of the Armenians? said Adolf Hitler, days before
he entered Poland.
Hitler’s cynical remembrance of Armenians is prominently displayed in the
Holocaust Memorial in Washington because it is profound commentary about the
crucial role of third parties in genocide prevention and remembrance.
Genocide is the manifestation of the break in the covenant that governments
have with their peoples. Therefore, it is third parties who become crucial
actors in genocide prevention, humanitarian assistance and genocide
remembrance.
We are commemorating today, because the Soviet troops marched into Auschwitz
60 years ago. I am here today because the Arabs provided sanctuary to
Armenian deportees 90 years ago.
Third parties, indeed, can make the difference between life and death. Their
rejection of the behaviors and policies which are neither in anyone’s
national interest nor in humanity’s international interest, is of immense
moral and political value.
What neighbors, well-wishers, the international community can’t accomplish,
is the transcending and reconciling which the parties must do for
themselves. The victims, first, must exhibit the dignity, capacity and
willingness to move on, and the perpetrators, first and last, must summon
the deep force of humanity and goodness and must overcome the memory of the
inner evil which had already prevailed, and must renounce the deed, its
intent, its consequences, its architects and executors.
Auschwitz signifies the worst of hate, of indifference, of dehumanization.
Remembrance of Auschwitz and its purpose, however abhorrent, is a vital step
to making real the phrase “Never Again”.
Thank you.

Patriarchate Takes Legal Action to Keep Melkonian Institute Open

PRESS RELEASE
ARMENIAN PATRIARCHATE
TR-34480 Kumkapi, Istanbul
Tel: +90 (212) 517-0970
Fax: +90 (212) 516-4833
[email protected]

ARMENIAN PATRIARCHATE TAKES LEGAL ACTION TO KEEP MELKONIAN INSTITUTE OPEN

CONTACT: RAFFI ZINZALIAN
951-453-9917
On behalf of Melkonian alumni, around the world, the Patriarch of the
Armenian Patriarchate of Turkey, Mesrob Mutafyan, as the original trustee of
the Melkonian gift, filed a lawsuit on January 13, 2005, with the Superior
Court of the State of California, against The Armenian General Benevolent
Union seeking to continue the Institute as the premier Armenian educational
facility in the world and enforce the terms of the Garabed Melkonian Trust.
The suit will be prosecuted by MacCarley & Rosen, PLC of Los Angeles,
California.

Devoted alumni from around the world have banded together to oppose the
closing of their beloved Melkonian Educational Institute, a treasure of
Armenian culture and education in Nicosia, Cyprus. Using the proceeds of a
large financial gift from Garabed Melkonian, a benefactor, the Armenian
Patriarch of Constantinople, Zaven Der Yeghyayan, in 1923 established the
Melkonian Educational Institute in Cyprus. It has nurtured three generations
of Armenian teachers, educators, lawyers, doctors, poets, scientists, and
leaders. Its location in Cyprus puts it at the crossroads of the Armenian
culture-between the Armenia homeland and the millions of Armenians who have
immigrated to Europe and the America’s.

In 1925, the Armenian Patriarch of Constantinople with Garabed Melkonian’s
concurrence thereafter conveyed the entire gift, including the Melkonian
Educational Institute, in trust to the Armenian General Benevolent Union,
with the express direction and expectation that the AGBU would maintain the
Institute in Cyprus and continue to educate Armenian youth long into the
future. The Melkonian School now educates over 200 students from throughout
the world every year at its 40 acre campus in Nicosia.

The AGBU has recently announced that the Melkonian Institute will be closed
at the end of the 2005 school year. Melkonian graduates from around the
world have united in vigorous opposition to any effort to sell off the
School and to do injustice to Garabed Melkonian’s vision and foresight. So
far, individual calls to AGBU to retain the school have gone unanswered.

Remembering the 15th Anniversary of The Victims of Baku & Azerbaijan

PRESS RELEASE
Diocese of the Armenian Church of Australia & New Zealand
10 Macquarie Street
Chatswood NSW 2067
AUSTRALIA
Contact: Laura Artinian
Tel: (02) 9419-8056
Fax: (02) 9413-1709
Email: [email protected]
24 January 2005
REMEMBERING THE 15TH ANNIVERSARY OF THE VICTIMS OF BAKU & AZERBAIJAN
Sydney, Australia – On Sunday, 23 January, 2005, a solemn requiem service
was held during the Divine Liturgy in memory of the many hundreds of
Armenians killed in the course of the pogroms in Baku, Sumgait and other
regions of Azerbaijan in January 1990. The commemoration of the victims was
observed by Armenian churches worldwide at the call of His Holiness Karekin
II Supreme Patriarch and Catholicos of All Armenians.
In his sermon, His Eminence Archbishop Aghan Baliozian, Primate of the
Diocese of Australia and New Zealand remembered the tragic events that led
to the campaign of persecution directed at the Armenians of Baku. As
history shows, the sacrifice of life is not uncommon for the Armenian people
but the memorial of Armenian martyrs will remain forever in the fibre of the
Armenian identity. Archbishop Aghan called on the voices of power to
condemn and remedy the injustices that were executed upon the Armenian
victims of Azerbaijan.
The congregation was led in prayer for the repose of the souls of these
victims.

Visit by Russian FM to Baku to help discuss reforming CIS-spokesman

ITAR-TASS News Agency
TASS
January 23, 2005 Sunday 8:22 AM Eastern Time
Visit by FM to Baku to help discuss reforming CIS-spokesman
BAKU, January 23
A visit by Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov to Baku on February 1-2
“will help to discuss several questions on reforming the CIS”, along
with bilateral relations and pressing international problems, said
here on Sunday Russian Foreign Ministry spokesman Alexander
Yakovenko.
According to spokesman, Russia “heads this work in the Commonwealth
and now collects proposals from member countries”. Yakovenko noted
that Lavrov “plans to visit in the near future all the CIS states for
such discussion. For instance the diplomat noted, a trip to Georgia
is planned for February. “There are plans on visits to other
countries as well,” Yakovenko noted.
“The situation in ‘flash spots’, including Nagorno-Karabakh, will be
one of topics for talks of the Russian minister in Azerbaijan.
“Russia is a member of the Minsk Group,” Yakovenko noted. “We believe
that it is necessary to reach understandings and to follow
attentively processes in the region.”
He reported that “important events are in store” in the life of the
two countries. “2005 is Year of Azerbaijan in Russia, while 2006 –
Year of Russia in Azerbaijan.” “We are interested in consolidating
bilateral cooperation,” Yakovenko emphasized.
Speaking in Baku on Sunday at the roundtable “Russia and Azerbaijan.
United information space: issues and prospects”, the diplomat
reported that he “held today first consultations on information
coverage of foreign policy”. For instance he discussed cooperation on
such topics as struggle against terrorism, organized crime and drug
trafficking.
The spokesman underlined importance of “promoting objective
information on the contribution of our countries to the Victory in
the Great Patriotic War, 1941-1945”.

All-Women Games open in Iran

All-Women Games open in Iran
By NASSER KARIMI
.c The Associated Press
TEHRAN, Iran (AP) – About 600 women from 17 countries will participate
in the All-Women Games for Muslim and Asian Capitals, and men will be
barred from watching all but one of the events.
The only sport that will be open to all spectators is shooting, the
lone event in which women’s bodies will be completely covered. Other
sports at the weeklong competition – which has drawn athletes from
countries including Afghanistan, Armenia, Iraq and Thailand – include
athletics and swimming.
“The Islamic Republic of Iran promotes women sports while it
safeguards cultural values,” parliament speaker Gholam Ali Haddad
Adel said to about 10,000 men and women attending Sunday’s opening
ceremony.
“We like to prove to the world women could compete and observe the
Islamic dress code as well.”
In the past, Iranian female athletes were restricted from
participating in sporting events because of their country’s strict
dress code. In public, Iranian women are required to wear baggy
smocks and head scarves in line with strict Islamic teachings. More
traditional women cover themselves with chadors, or loose unsewn black
sheets.
Iran also bars mixed competition and restricts mingling between
unrelated males and females in public.
Iranian women have often participated in international shooting or
chess competitions, where they can keep their headscarves and
full-length outfits. Iranian women took part in the shooting events
at the 2004 Olympics in Athens and the 2000 Sydney Games.
Conservative clerics have opposed women in sports, but moderates have
succeeded in promoting the idea, gradually convincing some members of
the conservative camp to soften their opposition.
Iran co-organized the Muslim Women Games with other Muslim countries
in the mid-1990s, and hosted the Third Muslim Women Games in 2001.
01/23/05 17:48 EST

France: l’UDF en congres vote pour la Constitution europeenne

SwissInfo, Suisse
Dimanche, 23 janvier 2005

France: l’UDF en congrès vote pour la Constitution européenne

PARIS – Quelque 2000 élus et militants du parti français de
centre-droit UDF ont entériné leur volonté de faire campagne pour le
“oui” au référendum sur la Constitution européenne. Ils ont réaffirmé
leur opposition à une adhésion de la Turquie à l’UE.
Les participants ont approuvé samedi soir à une écrasante majorité,
lors d’un vote à main levée, un texte disant que “l’UDF partage
l’inquiétude de ceux qui voient dans l’élargissement à des pays non
européens comme la Turquie un risque de dissolution du projet
européen”.
L’UDF “considère que la perspective d’un partenariat privilégié
aurait dû figurer dans l’accord d’ouverture des négociations (avec la
Turquie), exigeant en même temps la reconnaissance de Chypre, du
génocide arménien” et de la question kurde par Ankara, poursuit le
texte adopté à l’issue d’un débat.
Le document stipule aussi que “plus il y a risque de dissolution,
plus vite il faut rendre l’Europe solidaire et démocratique. L’UDF
votera donc oui et fera campagne résolument pour le oui au référendum
sur la Constitution européenne”.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

LA: Donald Kuspit To Speak on Arshile Gorky

Donald Kuspit To Speak on Arshile Gorky
ArtDaily.com
January 21, 2005
LOS ANGELES, CA.- Donald Kuspit, one of America’s most distinguished
art critics, is making a rare speaking appearance in Los Angeles at
Jack Rutberg Fine Arts, 357 N. La Brea Ave., on Friday, January 28,
7:30 p.m. Dr. Kuspit will present “A Discussion on Arshile Gorky”, on
whom he has written and lectured extensively.
In his roles as a critic, art historian, author of countless articles
and more than twenty books, Donald Kuspit is among the most respected,
prolific and at times provocative commentators on modern and
contemporary art.
Donald Kuspit is Professor of Art History at Stony Brook University,
New York. Winner of the prestigious Frank Jewett Mather Award for
Distinction in Art Criticism given by the College Art Association, he
is a Contributing Editor at Artforum, Sculpture, and Tema Celeste
magazines, the Editor of Art Criticism, and on the advisory board of
Centennial Review.
“An Evening with Donald Kuspit” at Jack Rutberg Fine Arts, 357 N. La
Brea Ave. in Los Angeles is sponsored by the Hans G. and Thordis
W. Burkhardt Foundation and is free and open to the public, but space
is limited. This lecture is presented in conjunction with “Arshile
Gorky – The Early Years,” an exhibition of 67 works by this important
20th Century artist. The exhibition extends through February 26. Those
wishing to attend should R.S.V.P. to (323) 938-5222 to reserve
seating.
;int_new=12396