GEORGIA’S PM GETS POISONED BY GAS WHILE PLAYING BACKGAMMON
TBILISI, FEBRUARY 3. ARMINFO. Georgia’s Prime Minister Zurab Zhvania
got poisoned by gas while playing backgammon in his friend Raul
Yusupov’s house.
Georgia’s Interior Minister Vano Merabishvili says that it was an
accident caused by gas escape from an Iranian gas heater.
Zhvania’s bodyguards found him in the drawing room while Yusupov was
in the kitchen. “They must have been playing backgammon,” says
Merabishvili.
The bodyguards immediately reported of the accident to their chief,
vice PM Georgy Baramidze, President Mikhail Saakashvili and the
prosecutor general. Investigation is underway.
ITAR-TASS reports that gas heater failure is a usual thing for Tbilisi
– dozens of people died of them there in the last months.
Interfax reports that Pres.Saakashvili has called an extraordinary
government meeting.
President of Abkhazia Sergey Bagapsh says that Zhvania’s death will
not aggravate the situation in the Georgian-Abkhazian conflict
zone. “This is Georgia’s internal affair and it is the task of their
police to investigate into the accident,” he says to Interfax.
NOTE: Zurab Zhvania was 42. He was biologist. In 1989 he led a party
of greens and co-chaired the party of greens of Europe. In 1993 he led
the Union of Georgian Citizens party supporting President Eduard
Shevardnadze. In 1992-1995 and 1995-1999 he got into the parliament
and was elected speaker. In 1999 he was reelected speaker but left the
post in 2001.
Before the Rose Revolution Zhvania was believed to be the key official
successor of Shevardnadze as president of Georgia. He was known for
his pro-western views and for regarding Georgian-Russian relations as
“close to cold war.” In 2002 he led the United Democrats party. In Nov
2003 he was appointed Georgia’s Prime Minister.
Category: News
The Kurdish State Will Emerge – if USA is Willing
THE KURDISH STATE WILL EMERGE – IF USA IS WILLING
Azg/arm
4 Feb 05
The Iraqi parliamentary elections were launched to set a national
assembly of 275 lawmakers that would choose a president and two
vice-presidents of the country from among its members and the latter
would chose a prime minister.The primary task of the would-be national
assembly is to prepare a draft constitution that will be voted on
October 15.
In case the constitution passes new parliamentary elections will be
held in Iraq on December 15 that will form the executive and the
legislature on the constitutional basis.
In other words the elections are important as regards the Iraqi
constitution and the constitution is vital for Iraq’s political
future. If the Iraqi constitution turns Iraqi state into federation
that will put the country onthe edge of falling apart.
A referendum held along with the elections on January 30 in 4 Kurdish
cities of Northern Iraq showed that 99.5 percent of population demands
independence. Masut Barzani, president of Democratic Party of
Kurdistan, made an interesting statement regarding Kurdish
population’s orientation. Turkish Yeni Shafaq newspaper informed on
January 31 that Barzani met journalists in Salahaddinwhere he stated
that there is no such question if a Kurdish state will be created but
when will it be created. `Kirkuk’s identity is Kurdish.Neither Turkey
nor any other state has the right to draw conclusions about Kirkuk or
any other Iraqi state’.
Barzani’s words caused Turkey’s active confrontation. Chairman of
Turkish parliament, Byulent Arnc, called Barzani arrogant noting that
the American has petted him. Apparently Arnc’s words missed the point
as Barzani made his second statement on February 3: `Independence is
inevitable; demand for independence is the most natural right of
Kurdish people’. A Kurdish politician and foreign minister of Iraqi
temporary government, Khoshyar Zebar, added to Barzani’s words:
`Hopefully the Iraqi Kurdistan will become Europe’s neighbor in near
future’.
Regardless of Barzani’s and Zebar’s views, America’s position and
plans for Iraq’s reconstruction will be decisive. Turkish foreign
minister Abdullah Gul who is paying an official visit to China
declared in Beijing on February 2:` The US has to take tough measures
to neutralize insurgency in Northern Iraq’. Meanwhile he reminded
that Turkey stands for Iraq’s territorial integrity.
Condoleezza Rice, US Secretary of State, who is going to visit Ankara
on February 5, will possibly discuss the issue of Kurdish state as
well as issues concerning Iraq’s reconstruction with Abdullah Gul.
By Hakob Chakrian
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress
Inquiry Severely Criticizes U.N.’s Oil-for-Aid Program
The New York Times
February 3, 2005
Inquiry Severely Criticizes U.N.’s Oil-for-Aid Program
By JUDITH MILLER
An interim report by a United Nations-appointed panel investigating
the oil-for-food program in Iraq severely criticizes its director and
depicts the program as “tainted” for failing to follow the
organization’s own procedures.
In an essay appearing today in The Wall Street Journal, Paul
A. Volcker, the former Federal Reserve chairman who heads the
three-member commission investigating the oil-for-food program, said
its procurement system had failed to follow “the established rules of
the organization designed to assure fairness and accountability.”
He said the report, which is scheduled to be made public today, also
accuses Benon Sevan, the Cypriot who had headed what was once the
world body’s largest humanitarian effort, of “irreconcilable conflict
of interest.”
Citing what he called “conclusive” evidence, Mr. Volcker wrote that by
“effectively participating in the selection of purchasers of oil under
the program,” Mr. Sevan had violated both “specific United Nations
rules and of the broad responsibility of an international civil
servant to adhere to the highest standards of trust and integrity.”
One official who has seen parts of the report said that it also
criticized another senior United Nations official, Joseph Stephanides,
a senior official on the Security Council staff, for failing to ensure
that the organization’s own rules for buying oil, selling goods and
selecting contractors were followed.
Telephone calls were made last night to the offices of both Mr. Sevan
and Mr. Stephanides, but neither man could be reached for comment.
In his essay, Mr. Volcker said the report explored in “excruciating
detail” three “potentially vulnerable” parts of the $64 billion
program, which was aimed at easing the debilitating effects of
economic sanctions on the Iraqi people between 1996 and 2003 by
ensuring that Iraq’s oil revenues were used to buy food, medicine and
other necessities for its people.
Specifically, he said the interim report discussed the initial
selection of major contractors hired to inspect Iraqi oil exports,
imports of ostensibly humanitarian goods, and how the program’s funds
were spent and managed. The report also discusses internal program
audits, many of which have already been disclosed, and how the program
spent its own administrative funds, he wrote.
“The findings do not make for pleasant reading,” Mr. Volcker
concluded.
His interim report, which has been eagerly and skeptically awaited by
United Nations critics, is months overdue. Hampered by what
investigators and diplomats called a reluctance among some member
countries to cooperate and a lack of subpoena power, Mr. Volcker’s
panel has had difficulty obtaining evidence. Conservatives and other
critics have accused him of being insufficiently impartial and
independent, a charge he has denied. And John Danforth, who recently
left his position as American ambassador to the United Nations, said
Mr. Volcker, with a staff of over 60 people and a budget of some $30
million, lacked some tools needed to conduct a thorough inquiry.
Mr. Volcker was particularly critical of the oil-for-food program’s
procurement system. “We have found in each case that the procurement
process was tainted,” he wrote, by a failure to follow established
rules.
“Perhaps not surprisingly,” he added, “political considerations
intruded, but in a manner that was neither transparent nor
accountable.”
Repeating criticisms the commission, officially known as the
Independent Inquiry Committee, made in an earlier report, Mr. Volcker
said the interim report concluded that the auditing system was
“underfunded and undermanned” and hence, “unable to meet effectively
the challenge posed by a really unique, massive and complex program of
humanitarian assistance.”
Despite the “skill and dedication of auditing professionals,” he
wrote, the auditing system lacked “clear reporting lines and the
management responsiveness critical to achieving a fully effective
auditing process.”
Even though no evidence of “systematic or widespread abuse” was found
in how the program’s administrative funds were spent, Mr. Volcker
wrote, the commission still found what he called “a clear lapse from
disciplined judgment.”
Mr. Volcker called his panel’s initial findings about Mr. Sevan “more
disheartening.” He indicated that the investigation of Mr. Sevan, an
aide to Kofi Annan, was continuing, as was his investigation of how
and why Cotecna Inspection, a Swiss-based company that was hired to
inspect humanitarian goods bought by Iraq and that employed
Mr. Annan’s son, got its own contract.
Mr. Annan has denied charges of nepotism within his organization and
said he had not known that his son, Kojo, had continued being paid by
Cotecna after leaving the company. Mr. Sevan have also previously
denied charges of wrongdoing, but he has declined for many months to
meet with or talk to reporters.
Under the rules of the oil-for-food program created by the United
States and other members of the Security Council, Iraq could chose to
whom it would sell its oil and buy humanitarian goods. Congressional
investigators have said that because of the program’s structure,
secrecy and poor oversight, billions were diverted from the program.
Mr. Annan told reporters yesterday that the United Nations would adopt
reforms in response to Mr. Volcker’s criticisms and recommendations,
and that he was already doing so.
UN Official Solicited Oil Deal from Iraq -Report
UN Official Solicited Oil Deal from Iraq -Report
Thu Feb 3, 4:44 PM ET World – Reuters
By Evelyn Leopold and Irwin Arieff
UNITED NATIONS (Reuters) – A senior U.N. official solicited and
received allocations of oil from Iraq (news – web sites) for a trading
company while he was directing the U.N. oil-for-food program, a key
investigative report said on Thursday.
The official, Benon Sevan of Cyprus, engaged in conduct that was
“ethically improper and seriously undermined the integrity of the
United Nations (news – web sites),” said the report by Paul Volcker,
the former U.S. Federal Reserve (news – web sites) chairman.
Volcker was appointed by the United Nations to lead a probe of the
now-defunct $67 billion program and on Thursday gave an interim
report. The final analysis is expected in June.
The report did not say that Sevan received bribes but mentioned that
he got $160,000 in cash from 1999 to 2003 from his aunt in Cyprus, who
has now died. The report said the aunt’s lifestyle did not suggest
wealth.
But Volcker said Sevan solicited and received allocations of oil on
behalf of the African Middle East Petroleum Company, a small trading
firm, registered in Panama with offices in Switzerland, Monaco and
elsewhere. It was run by Egyptian Fahkry, a cousin of former
U.N. Secretary-General Boutros Boutros-Ghali, who left office at the
end of 1996.
It was “highly unlikely” that such a company would have been allowed
to buy oil unless someone lobbied Baghdad. In return for the
allocations, Sevan was expected to make a case for Iraq receiving cash
to upgrade its deteriorating oil facilities, which he and several
Security Council members did.
“Mr. Sevan repeatedly solicited allocations of oil under the program,”
the report said. Iraqi officials in return expected Sevan’s support on
such issues as funds for repairing Iraq’s crumbling oil facilities, it
said.
The oil-for-food program, which began in December 1996 and ended in
November 2003, allowed Saddam Hussein (news – web sites)’s government
to sell oil in order to buy humanitarian goods. It was intended to
ease the life of ordinary Iraqis under 1990 U.N. sanctions.
But in his report of more than 200 pages, Volcker told a news
conference that “we have not found a systematic misuse of funds
dedicated to the administration of the oil-for-food program.” He said
the investigation was continuing.
Since the U.S. invasion of Iraq, documents have emerged that show
Saddam Hussein skimming funds from the program, selling oil illegally
outside the program, often with the knowledge of big powers on the
Security Council, and bribing a variety of officials around the world.
Volcker also said that U.N. officials ignored procurement procedures
and safeguards from the very start of the program.
Investigators found “convincing and uncontested evidence” that the
selection process was tainted by irregularities for each of the first
three contractors selected — the French bank Banque Nationale de
Paris, the Dutch firm Saybolt Eastern Hemisphere BV and the British
Lloyd’s Register Inspection Ltd, the report said.
A CIA (news – web sites) investigation last September found Saddam
earned $1.7 billion through kickbacks and illegal surcharges on the
program from 1996 to 2003. He got an additional $8 billion in illegal
oil sales to Jordan, Turkey and Syria, which were known to the
Security Council, including the United States, in its supervision of
the program.
Volcker said it was a matter of record that the United States, among
others, have given Jordan and Turkey a waiver to receive Iraq oil
outside of the U.N. program because they suffered hardships from the
sanctions.
Volcker said allegations of conflict of interest by Annan would be
handled in a later report. Annan’s son Kojo, had once worked in West
Africa for a firm under contract to the United Nations in Iraq. Annan,
who only became secretary-general in 1997, has said he had no hand in
assigning contracts.
The report also said that another senior official, Joseph Stephanides,
who was involved in the program in 1996 and before Sevan took over the
operation, intervened in procuring major contracts for large firms.
“The evidence amply demonstrates that a tainted procurement process
took place in 1996, when the program was just getting under way,”
Volcker said, adding that political considerations came into play.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress
Annan Vows Action Against UN Staff in Iraq Program
Annan Vows Action Against UN Staff in Iraq Program
By Evelyn Leopold
UNITED NATIONS (Reuters) – A probe into the U.N. oil-for-food program
for Iraq (news – web sites) said the director of the operation got oil
allocations for a firm run by a friend, and U.N. Secretary-General
Kofi Annan (news – web sites) vowed to discipline him.
Benon Sevan, who ran the humanitarian program, was accused in a report
from Paul Volcker, the former head of the U.S. Federal Reserve (news –
web sites), of soliciting and getting the allocations for a trading
firm connected to the family of former Secretary-General Boutros
Boutros-Ghali.
A second official, Joseph Stephanides, now director of Security
Council affairs, was alleged to have intervened in selecting large
contractors for the program he helped organize in 1996, before Sevan
took over in late 1997.
Annan said he too would be disciplined and that if criminal acts were
committed, diplomatic immunity would be lifted.
The oil-for-food program, which began in December 1996 and ended in
November 2003, allowed Saddam Hussein (news – web sites)’s government
to sell oil in order to buy humanitarian goods. It was intended to
ease the life of ordinary Iraqis under 1990 U.N. sanctions.
The fraud allegations have cast a shadow over the world body and Annan
himself, who chose Volcker to lead an independent investigation.
“I think it is a fact that Mr. Sevan placed himself in a grave and
continuing conflict of interest situation that violated explicit
U.N. rules and violated the standards of integrity essential to a
high-level international civil servant,” Volcker told a news
conference.
Sevan, a Cypriot, issued his own statement.
“Mr Sevan never took a penny,” his lawyer Eric Lewis
said. “Unfortunately, in the current political climate, the
Independent Inquiry Committee needs to find someone to blame.”
But Annan, who took over the top U.N. post from Boutros-Ghali in
January 1997, said in a statement the report contained “extremely
troubling evidence of wrongdoing” by Sevan, who has retired from the
United Nations (news – web sites) but gets a token salary because of
the inquiry.
‘THE SECRETARY-GENERAL IS SHOCKED’
“The secretary-general is shocked by what the report has to say about
Mr. Sevan,” Annan’s chief of staff, Mark Malloch Brown, told a news
conference. “He very much doubts there can be any extenuating
circumstances to explain the behavior, which appears proven in the
report.”
But he noted, “we got a thumbs up” on administration of the program
and Iraq should be encouraged that the funds were used as intended.
Volcker said few institutions had subjected themselves to such
“intensity of scrutiny.”
The report also cited “convincing and uncontested evidence” that three
firms: Banque Nationale de Paris; the Dutch Saybolt Eastern Hemisphere
and Britain’s Lloyd’s Register Inspection were awarded contracts
without competitive bidding in 1996.
But Volcker said in the interim report — the final one will be in
June — the most serious violations of the U.N. sanctions involved
illegal oil sales outside oil-for-food.
“And there is no question that those sales were known by the
U.N. Security Council,” which included the United States.
A CIA (news – web sites) investigation in September found Saddam
earned $1.7 billion via kickbacks on goods and oil under the
program. He got an additional $8 billion in oil sales to Jordan,
Turkey and Syria, which were known to the council.
Volcker said he was concentrating on wrongdoing by U.N. officials.
Specifically, the report said Sevan had convinced Iraq to sell oil
allocations to African Middle East Petroleum company, an obscure
trading firm registered in Panama with offices in Switzerland and
Monaco.
The company is headed by Egyptian Fahkry Abdelnour, a cousin of
Boutros-Ghali. The deal was also helped along by Fred Nadler, the
former secretary-general’s brother-in-law, the report said.
He also questioned Sevan’s assertion that an aunt in Cyprus, now
deceased, had given him some $160,000 over several years. The trading
firm, according to Iraqi records, netted a profit of $1.7 million, the
report said.
Volcker said allegations of conflict of interest by Annan would be
handled in a later report. Annan’s son Kojo once worked in West Africa
for a Swiss firm Cotecna, under contract to the United Nations in
Iraq.
Annan has said he had no hand in assigning contracts and his son says
he had left the company when the deal was made.
Even Lincy Funds Did Not Help
A1 Plus | 13:52:19 | 03-02-2005 | Regions |
EVEN LINCY FUNDS DID NOT HELP
The cultural centers of Gyumri including museums have not been heated
for several years. The heaters purchased and placed by the Lincy
Foundation last year are not appropriate for heating museums. In order
to provide normal temperature all the heaters should work according to
10-hour schedule which demands considerable expenses. The funds
assigned by the budget are not enough to provide more or less
appropriate heating.
“If we try to save the funds during summer and spend them on heating
in winter, this will be sufficient for a month only,” Director of the
the Museum of Folk Architecture and Urbanism Sona Harutyunyan told our
colleagues from Tsayg TV Company.
Optimal temperature for keeping the displays is 17-20 degrees
Celsius. According to the museum directors, stable temperature should
be maintained in the halls otherwise sharp temperature drops will
result in spoiling of the exhibit and canvases.
Administrations of the cultural centers hope that the electric heaters
will be replaced by gas ovens or heaters. City Hall officials promised
to solve the problem by supplying the museums with natural gas.
Deceased Georgian PM to be buried on 6 February – Russian radio
Deceased Georgian PM to be buried on 6 February – Russian radio
Ekho Moskvy radio, Moscow
3 Feb 05
The funeral of Georgian Prime Minister Zurab Zhvania will take place
on 6 February at 1400 [local time, 1100 gmt], Ekho Moskvy has been
told by Georgian Minister of State for Settlement of Conflicts Giorgi
Khaindrava.
He said the funeral service will be held at the Cathedral of the Holy
Trinity, which has recently been consecrated in Tbilisi. [Passage
omitted: background to Zhvania death]
Russian MP says Georgian premier’s death was an assassination
Russian MP says Georgian premier’s death was an assassination
Ekho Moskvy radio, Moscow
3 Feb 05
The death of Georgian Prime Minister Zurab Zhvania is down to Georgian
patriots who want the country to be re-united with Russia, the leader
of the Liberal Democratic Party of Russia (LDPR) and deputy speaker of
the Russian State Duma, Vladimir Zhirinovskiy, has said.
Reporting on the reaction among Russian parliamentarians to Zhvania’s
death, Russian Ekho Moskvy quoted Zhirinovskiy as saying that he had
“long predicted that, following the velvet revolution, the events in
Georgia would take precisely this course. There have been frequent
attempts on the lives of the leaders of that republic in the past,
too, but according to Zhirinovskiy, the powerful KGB structure
prevented possible murders. Now the system of security is
insufficiently developed in Georgia and that is why Zhvania
died. Moreover, the leader of the Liberal Democratic Party of Russia
has no doubt that it was an assassination rather than an accident
because a normal adult would always be able to detect the smell of
gas. Moreover, Zhirinovskiy is sure that this tragic situation will
continue to develop further. Zhvania’s death is most likely to have
been caused by Georgian patriots who are for re-unification with
Russia. This is merely the first stage. It is a warning to [Georgian
President Mikheil] Saakashvili that he will be the next to
go. Georgia’s only way out, Zhirinovskiy opines, is to ask for
re-unification with Russia. If Saakashvili decides not go for that, he
too will be killed, the deputy added,” the radio said.
BAKU: Russia states readiness to assist in Garabagh conflict res.
Assa-Irada, Azerbaijan
Feb 3 2005
Russia states readiness to assist in Garabagh conflict resolution
BAKU
Azerbaijani Foreign Minister Elmar Mammadyarov and his Russian
counterpart Sergey Lavrov discussed the Caspian legal status, the
Upper Garabagh conflict, prospects for developing Russo-Azeri
relations and other issues in Baku on Wednesday.
Mammadyarov, touching on the Garabagh conflict at a news briefing
following the meeting, said that the Russian Minister indicated
Russia’s interested in establishing stability in the region.
`Our northern neighbor (Russia) is ready to take the necessary steps
with regards to the conflict settlement, and Lavrov confirmed this
once again.’
The Russian Minister said that his country is actively working in the
area of the conflict resolution, voicing his satisfaction with the
activity of the Russian co-chair of the OSCE Minsk Group Yuri
Merzlyakov.*
Georgian politics may lose predictability with death of PM – Rus.
Georgian politics may lose predictability with death of PM – Russian expert
RIA news agency
3 Feb 05
MOSCOW
With the death of Georgian Prime Minister Zurab Zhvania, Georgian
politics may lose an important element of predictability, according to
Konstantin Zatulin, a State Duma deputy and director of the Institute
of CIS Countries.
“On the whole, Georgian politics has lost an important
element. Zhvania was less prone to emotions. He was more pragmatic and
predictable than the Georgian president, who is more prone to
superficial effects and populist moves,” Zatulin told RIA-Novosti.
“The situation inside Georgia and around Georgia has become more
complicated,” the expert said, predicting an exacerbation in
Georgian-Abkhaz and Georgian-Ossetian conflicts.
“In particular, changes of policy may affect the conflict zones. I
think [Georgian President Mikheil] Saakashvili will be daring. Zhvania
would have preferred more subtle ways,” Zatulin said. He recalled that
it had been Zhvania who had conducted peace talks with both Abkhazia
and South Ossetia.
“One of the most capable and active behind-the-scenes figures of the
triumvirate that came to power as a result of the rose revolution is
gone,” Zatulin said in conclusion.