Armenia and Azerbaijan Advance Peace Talks, Release Joint Statement

Dec 29 2023

By: Momen Zellmi

In a major breakthrough in the volatile Caucasus region, Armenia and Azerbaijan have announced significant progress in peace talks as 2023 draws to a close. The culmination of these negotiations has been the release of a joint statement – a historic first since the republics gained independence – outlining the commitments of both nations to normalize relations and reach a peace agreement. This major diplomatic development has been welcomed by global powers such as Turkey, the US, the EU, and Russia.

The key turning point in these peace talks was Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan’s agreement to three out of five articles proposed by Azerbaijan for peace. This paved the way for the 6th round of negotiations, leading to a finalized written peace text. Further, Azerbaijan’s President Ilham Aliyev confirmed the resolution of many issues within the peace agreement framework, and the Delimitation and Demarcation Commission reported considerable progress.

In a significant confidence-building move, Azerbaijan released 32 Armenian soldiers while Armenia reciprocated by releasing 2 Azerbaijani soldiers. Additionally, Armenia withdrew its candidacy to host COP29, yielding to Azerbaijan, which in turn backed Armenia’s candidacy for the COP Bureau of the Eastern European Group. These actions, coupled with bilateral statements released without third-party mediation and mutual support in international matters, underscore the major strides towards peace.

Several key factors contributed to this shift in diplomatic dynamics. The Azerbaijani army’s anti-terrorism actions against Armenian forces in Karabakh in September led to changes in military and diplomatic leverage. Moreover, the International Court of Justice (ICJ) rejected 7 out of 10 Armenian demands, affirming Azerbaijan’s sovereignty in the others, which significantly influenced the negotiation climate. Armenia’s strategy to leverage EU and US support against Azerbaijan risked the West’s neutral mediator role and their strategic interests in the region, leading to a shift in Armenia’s diplomatic approach.

To conclude, this joint statement, released on December 7, 2023, marked an unprecedented milestone in the peace process between Armenia and Azerbaijan. The absence of external pressure and the mutual support in international matters has been a significant step towards peace, signaling a new era of diplomatic relations in this historically tense region.

https://bnnbreaking.com/world/azerbaijan/armenia-and-azerbaijan-advance-peace-talks-release-joint-statement/

New museum in Armenia to tell story of Charles Aznavour, French crooner who loved Jews

The Times of Israel
Dec 29 2023

YEREVAN, Armenia (JTA) — His haunting French rendition of “La Yiddishe Mama” is legendary, as is his spirited performance of “Hava Nagila” in a duet with Algerian Jewish singer Enrico Macias. In 1967, he recorded the song “Yerushalayim” as a tribute to Israel’s Six Day War victory.

Yet Charles Aznavour, a diminutive singer and songwriter later nicknamed the “Frank Sinatra of France,” wasn’t Jewish. Born in Paris into a Christian Armenian family that prized culture, the young tenor learned basic Yiddish while growing up in the city’s Jewish quarter. And when the Nazis occupied Paris in 1940, the Aznavourians (their original surname, before Charles shortened it) risked their lives to save Jews from deportation.

Aznavour died in October 2018 at the age of 94. During his nearly 80-year career, he recorded over 1,400 songs in seven languages, sold around 200 million records and appeared in more than 90 films. His duets with other stars, including “Une vie d’amour” with Mirelle Mathieu, and his witty multilingual lyrics — the 1963 hit “Formidable” is a prime example — thrilled audiences worldwide. In 1998, Aznavour was voted Time magazine’s entertainer of the 20th century.

TIBBON/AFP)

YEREVAN, Armenia (JTA) — His haunting French rendition of “La Yiddishe Mama” is legendary, as is his spirited performance of “Hava Nagila” in a duet with Algerian Jewish singer Enrico Macias. In 1967, he recorded the song “Yerushalayim” as a tribute to Israel’s Six Day War victory.

Yet Charles Aznavour, a diminutive singer and songwriter later nicknamed the “Frank Sinatra of France,” wasn’t Jewish. Born in Paris into a Christian Armenian family that prized culture, the young tenor learned basic Yiddish while growing up in the city’s Jewish quarter. And when the Nazis occupied Paris in 1940, the Aznavourians (their original surname, before Charles shortened it) risked their lives to save Jews from deportation.

Aznavour died in October 2018 at the age of 94. During his nearly 80-year career, he recorded over 1,400 songs in seven languages, sold around 200 million records and appeared in more than 90 films. His duets with other stars, including “Une vie d’amour” with Mirelle Mathieu, and his witty multilingual lyrics — the 1963 hit “Formidable” is a prime example — thrilled audiences worldwide. In 1998, Aznavour was voted Time magazine’s entertainer of the 20th century.

00:08

04:52

May 22, 2024, will mark the 100th anniversary of Aznavour’s birth, and many events are planned next year to celebrate that milestone. A violent conflict in September between Armenia and neighboring Azerbaijan has made the rollout more difficult, but eventually, his admirers hope to inaugurate a large museum and cultural center in Yerevan to honor the various facets of Aznavour’s life — including the warm ties he cultivated with Israel and Jews.

“We started to work on this idea while my father was still among us,” said Nicolas Aznavour, 46, son of the famous chansonniere and co-founder of the nonprofit Aznavour Foundation. “He recorded the audio guide, so he’s the narrator of his own story.”

The foundation occupies a large building overlooking the Cascades, a series of giant limestone stairways that form one of Yerevan’s most prominent landmarks. A forerunner of the charity, the Aznavour for Armenia Association, was established in 1988 following the massive earthquake that struck Armenia — then a Soviet republic — killing 25,000 people, leaving hundreds of thousands homeless and propelling Aznavour’s philanthropic work.

Since then, the family has raised money for humanitarian projects throughout Armenia, while also funding cancer and Alzheimer’s research and aiding victims of Haiti’s 2010 earthquake.

After Armenia’s bruising 44-day war in 2020 with Azerbaijan over the disputed territory of Nagorno-Karabakh, the foundation delivered 175 tons of food, clothing, medical supplies and other aid to more than 42,000 ethnic Armenians displaced by the fighting.

Between that war, the COVID-19 pandemic and Azerbaijan’s recapture of the area three months ago — leading to the exodus of close to Karabakh’s entire population to undisputed Armenian territory — the foundation’s $10 million museum and cultural center has endured numerous delays.

Upon completion, one room of the future museum will contain the nearly 300 prizes Aznavour received from around the world during his lifetime. That includes the Raoul Wallenberg Award, presented to Aznavour in 2017 by Israel’s former president, Reuven Rivlin, in Jerusalem, in recognition of his family’s efforts to protect Jews and others in Paris during World War II.

Aznavour’s son was present when his father, then 93, received the medal from Rivlin on behalf of the singer’s parents and his older sister Aida, who is now 100.

“It’ll be an important part of the exhibit,” he told the Jewish Telegraphic Agency in a recent interview. “My grandparents, who had fled the Armenian genocide in Turkey, settled in France but ultimately wanted to go to the US. And when they saw what was happening to the Jews, they could not stay idle.”

That compassion is what led the family to shelter Jewish acquaintances in their small, three-room apartment at 22 rue de Navarin, in the 9th arrondissement of Paris. The eventual museum will consist of 10 rooms, taking visitors on a journey that begins with the Armenian genocide and continues with Aznavour’s early life in Paris.

“We want to tell the story of their resistance, how they helped not only Jews but also Armenian soldiers who were recruited by the Germans against their will,” said Tatev Sargsyan, chief operating officer of the Aznavour Foundation. “His father worked in a restaurant where the Nazis visited.”

According to a 2016 book by Israeli researcher Yair Auron, “Righteous Saviors and Fighters,” Aznavour and his sister would help burn the Nazi uniforms of Armenian deserters and dispose of the ashes. They also hid members of a French underground resistance movement who were being pursued by the Gestapo — something the modest Aznavour rarely talked about.

“It’ll be more of an immersive experience — something that you feel rather than just see,” Nicolas Aznavour said of the planned 32,000-square-foot museum. Hundreds of artifacts besides the medals and awards will be displayed, including Aznavour’s clothing, his favorite sunglasses and dozens of posters advertising movies in which he starred. (Among them: “The Tin Drum,” a 1979 German thriller in which Aznavour plays a kind Jewish toy vendor who kills himself after the Nazis vandalize his store and burn down the local synagogue.)

“Aznavour didn’t want this to be just a museum commemorating himself. He wanted it to be a cultural and educational center,” said Sargsyan. “He always spoke about the importance of empowering youth because he had so few opportunities when he was starting out in Paris. The idea is to create a platform for local musicians, and the museum is just one of the components.”

The foundation has formed a partnership with the French government to establish a French Institute within the future center, which will offer a wide range of cultural and educational activities. Among other things, there will be music lessons with hands-on experience in a recording studio. Artists will have the opportunity to perform live on stage.

In addition, experts will teach courses in film, theater and production. These classes will include film screening, featuring some of the 90 movies in which Aznavour himself starred.

Aznavour’s music remains immensely popular not only in France and other francophone countries such as Belgium, Canada, Lebanon, Syria, Morocco and Tunisia, but also in Argentina, Brazil, Israel, Japan, Russia and, of course, at home.

“Aznavour is a national treasure for the Armenian people,” said Lilit Papikyan, human resources manager at DataArt, a Yerevan software company. “His music evokes feelings of nostalgia, longing and pride in the hearts of all Armenians, both here and in the diaspora.”

Last April, the Tel Aviv suburb of Petah Tikva renamed a municipal park after Aznavour, in the presence of Mayor Rami Greenberg and Arman Hakobian — Armenia’s ambassador to Israel — as well as officials of the French Embassy and the Armenian Patriarchate of Jerusalem.

“During World War II, the Aznavourian family saved numerous Jewish lives,” said community leader Artiom Chernamorian, founder of a nonprofit group called Nairi Union of Armenians in Petah Tikva. The suburb which is home to a sizable Armenian ethnic community. “This gesture symbolizes the unbreakable bond between the Armenian and Jewish people, two nations that have endured unspeakable tragedy.”

Yet the influential singer wasn’t shy about calling out his Jewish friends over Israel’s refusal to officially recognize the Ottoman Turkish genocide of 1.5 million Armenians during World War I. Nor did he hold back criticism of Israel’s growing friendship with energy-rich Azerbaijan, which since 1993 has been ruled by the Aliyev family dynasty and is home to some 15,000 Jews.

This past March, amid warming ties between Israel and Turkey, Azerbaijan opened an embassy in Tel Aviv, becoming the first Muslim Shiite country to do so. The two now enjoy extensive economic links: Azerbaijan supplies over half of Israel’s crude oil imports and has also become its top buyer of weapons after India, a fact that clearly pains the younger Aznavour.

In early October, four days before the Hamas massacre of 1,200 people in Israel sparked the current war in Gaza, vandals protesting Israel’s alliance with Azerbaijan desecrated Armenia’s only synagogue. They later posted on social media that “Jews are the enemies of the Armenian nation, complicit in Turkish crimes.” No arrests were made.

“I think it’s a complex situation,” Nicholas Aznavour told JTA. “We have friends who totally support recognition of the Armenian genocide. But more than the Turkish reaction, there’s a political reality, and the reality is that the interests of Israel align with those of Azerbaijan.”

Politics aside, that’s a “dangerous compromise,” he warned. “In the long term, it’s a bad strategy, because when you align yourself with dictatorships, it’s like putting one foot in the grave.”

Armenian Quarter in al-Quds faces ‘existential threat’ amid attack

Dec 29 2023

Thirty armed men attack the Armenian Quarter and the Armenian Patriarchate Of Jerusalem explains that the clergy, indigenous Armenians, and the historical Armenian culture in al-Quds are faced with a real 'existential threat'.


The Armenian Patriarchate Of Jerusalem issued an "urgent communique" confirming that "a massive and coordinated physical attack was launched on Bishops, Priests, Deacons, Seminarians and other Armenian community members" in the Armenian quarter of occupied al-Quds.

The communique explained, "Over 30 armed provocateurs in ski-masks with lethal and less-than-lethal weaponry including powerful nerve-agents that have incapacitated dozens of our clergy broke into the grounds of the Cow's Garden [in the Armenian Quarter] and began their vicious assault," adding that the assault resulted in serious injuries of "several priests, deacons and students of the Armenian Theological Academy along with indigenous Armenians."

SETTLERS CONTINUE THEIR ATTACKS ON THE ARMENIAN QUARTER. A group of 30 violently attacked Armenians as israeli settlers have been attempting to seize 25% of the Quarter. A dozen Armenians were attacked and two were detained for defending themselves. pic.twitter.com/LFdn3nf4xu

The Communique highlighted that this comes after the Patriarchate had filed a lawsuit for the Cows' Garden in the Armenian quarter against Australian-Israeli businessman Danny Rothman (Rubenstein)  and George Warwar (Hadad), noting that this attack is the "criminal response we received" for filing the lawsuit.

Moreover, the Patriarchate stressed that the "existential threat is now a physical reality," and that the Armenian church in occupied al-Quds, alongside the clergy and all indigenous Armenians, "are fighting for their very lives on the ground."

In turn, the Save the ArQ Movement also released a statement calling the situation a "series of alarming incidents targeting the peaceful Armenian community," in the Old City of occupied al-Quds. The statement highlighted that the attacks have been taking place repeatedly "in the past two months" as part of a "broader campaign" by Xana Capital, a company, to "illegitimately and illegally seize control of the historic Cows' Garden [Armenian Gardens in the Armenian Quarter]."

These attacks, according to the statement have also been "placing the safety and integrity of the community and all Christians in the Old City at severe risk."

In its update, the Save the ArQ movement underscored that following the attack, the Israeli occupation forces showed up at the scene but "rather than addressing the aggressors solely, they arrested two innocent members of our community, Paul Djernazian and Bedig Giragossian."

Armenians in occupied Palestine said "ENOUGH IS ENOUGH!" and demanded the "immediate release of unlawfully detained community members…and those responsible for the violent acts" to be held accountable.

"Make no mistake, this is an existential threat and requires immediate and decisive action from everyone," the statement said.

Today, a new statement by the movement announced that the two Armenians who were arrested earlier have been released.

https://english.almayadeen.net/news/politics/the-armenian-quarter-in-al-quds-faces–existential-threat–a

Also watch: https://english.almayadeen.net/videos/israeli-settlers-attack-armenian-community-in-occupied-al-qu

Israeli police fails to stop new mob attack on Jerusalem Armenian Quarter amid ‘land grab’

The New Arab
Dec 29 2023
Israeli police fails to stop new mob attack on Jerusalem Armenian Quarter amid 'land grab'
Ibrahim Husseini
Jerusalem
The attack comes as The New Arab publishes a series of investigations into a murky deal to acquire land in Jerusalem that underpins violence against Armenians

Masked men numbering around 30 stormed the Armenian Quarter in occupied East Jerusalem on Thursday, assailing community members with the Israeli police late to intervene, according to eyewitnesses. 

A widely shared video from the scene shows masked men throwing rocks and other objects at members of the Armenian clergy. 

Police later arrived at the scene and cleared the area. It is unclear if arrests have been made. 

The identity of the assailants was not immediately clear, but Armenian activists in Jerusalem blamed the attack on George Warwar. Warwar is a Jaffa man thought to be involved in a controversial and now cancelled deal to acquire a plot of land in the Armenian neighbourhood ostensibly to build a luxury hotel by Jewish investors.

The New Arab has published a series of investigations into the deal and its links with the extremist Israeli settler movement. The controversy prompted companies signed up to the project to scale back their involvement, including Safdie Architects.

Christian Armenian activists accuse Jewish settler groups of trying to assert control over the disputed piece of land that has been in the possession of the Armenian Patriarchate for centuries. These settler groups are believed to be linked to Itamar Ben Gvir, Israel's far-right national security minister. 

Xana Capital, a company owned by Danny Rubenstein, also known as Danny Rothman, is claiming a large property in the Armenian Quarter after signing a questionable deal with the Armenian Patriarch Nourhan Manougian several years ago. The Armenian Patriarchate has since withdrawn from the agreement, and the matter is now in the courts.

RELATED
Investigations

The details of the agreement between the Patriarch and Danny Rubenstein are not entirely transparent, but community members are determined to annul the deal and maintain hold of the land. 

The Armenian Patriarchate issued a strong message referring to the violent episode as an "existential threat", stating that "Bishops, Priests, Deacons, Seminarians and indigenous Armenians are fighting for their very lives". 

"We call upon the Israeli government and the Police to start an investigation against Danny Rothman and George Warwar for organising their criminal attacks on the Armenian Patriarchate and community, attacks which seem to have no end in sight", the statement added. 

Similar attacks against the Armenian community occurred recently.

Last month, on two separate occasions, private security guards and Israeli and Jewish settlers burst into the Armenian Quarter accompanied by two bulldozers.

To find out more, watch our video explainer of the dispute over the Armenian Quarter.

Safdie Architects group suspends invovlement in controversial Armenian Quarter project in Jerusalem, following TNA investigation into Israeli settler links

The New Arab
Dec 28 2023
Anas Ambri


Architecture firm tasked with designing hotel in Jerusalem's Old City is suspending its work on the project due to settler links revealed by TNA investigations

Safdie Architects, the firm tasked with designing a luxury hotel in the Armenian Quarter of the Old City of Jerusalem, announced it has suspended work on the project "after becoming aware of the controversy surrounding the land lease agreement this summer". This follows The New Arab's investigative series, the Armenian Quarter Files, which revealed links between representatives of a company involved in the project and the extremist Israeli settler movement.

The controversy centers around Danny Rothman, a "mysterious" Australian Jewish investor that TNA profiled in August 2023.

In July 2021, Mr. Rothman, through his company Xana Gardens, concluded a deal with the Armenian Patriarchate for the lease of around 13% of the Armenian Quarter in Israeli-occupied East Jerusalem to construct a luxury hotel.

Information about the deal was kept hidden from the Armenian community until April 2023, when some local residents found out their homes were included in the land deal.

Indignation over the potential displacement of members of the declining Jerusalem's Armenian community led to the defrocking of Baret Yeretzian, then-director of the Department of Real Estate of the Patriarchate.

In its Armenian Quarter Files, TNA revealed links between representatives of Xana Gardens and extremist members of the Israeli settler movement.

These settlers, armed with guns and dogs, confronted the local Armenian community on November 4-5, after the Armenian Patriarchate announced it has canceled the deal.

TNA was also able to expose links between these settlers and current Israeli politicians, such as minister of national security Itamar Ben-Gvir and Jerusalem Deputy Mayor Arieh King.

In a 19 December statement published by the UK NGO Business & Human Rights Resource Centre (BHRRC), Safdie Architects stated that they "were startled when we learned of the objections by members of the Armenian community, which arose after many months of working on [the project]".

Established by Moshe Safdie in Montreal in 1964, the firm is most famous for designing Marina Bay Sands, an integrated resort in Singapore and the city-state's most notorious landmark.

According to their statement, Safdie Architects were brought onto the project by One&Only Resorts, the hospitality firm allegedly tasked with managing the hotel after its construction.

Dubai-based Kerzner International, which owns the One&Only brand, has so far failed to respond to allegations of its involvement in the project, according to BHRRC.

Armenian Christians say they were assaulted over contentious Jerusalem land deal

Dec 29 2023

Armenian clerics seriously wounded in clashes with Muslim Arabs amid claims of ‘coordinated physical attack.’

By World Israel News Staff

A number of Armenian Christian clerics were injured during a physical altercation with Muslim Arabs in the Old City of Jerusalem.

The incident occurred on Thursday, police said, with officers forced to intervene to separate dozens of Muslim Arabs and Armenian Christians during what Deputy Jerusalem Mayor Fleur Hassan-Nahoum called a “brawl.”

“There was an unfortunate incident where some Arab Muslim men and some men from the Armenian community got into a brawl in the old city of Jerusalem,” Hassan-Nahoum said in an interview with The Jerusalem Post.

“Police came promptly to separate the parties, and arrests were made on both sides. The city of Jerusalem will not tolerate any criminal activity, whether religiously motivated or otherwise, and the police will prosecute those responsible.”

Leaders of the Armenian community in the Old City of Jerusalem said, however, that the incident was in fact a planned assault targeting the clerics and Christian seminary students.

In a letter addressed to the police department and obtained by the Post, the Armenian Patriarchate wrote that “A mass and coordinated physical attack was launched.”

“Several priests, students, and indigenous Armenians are seriously injured.”

Armenian leaders say the attack was retribution for their decision to sue for the cancellation of a land lease agreement signed two years ago.

Known as the Cows’ Cardel Land Deal, the agreement would lease out a plot of land owned by the Armenian Patriarchate in Jerusalem to a pair of businessmen – one a Christian Arab and the other an Australian Jew.

The two developers, George Warwar and Danny Rothman, plan on turning the property, which currently serves as a parking lot and houses a seminary and several residential structures, into a luxury hotel.

Under heavy pressure from Armenians both in Jerusalem and abroad, the patriarchate decided to renege on the deal, filing a suit in the Jerusalem District Court to annul the 99-year lease.

After penning a letter to the developers two months ago insisting that the deal be cancelled, Armenian leaders claim they were targeted in a violent assault similar to Thursday’s incident.

https://worldisraelnews.com/armenian-christians-say-they-were-targeted-over-contentious-jerusalem-land-deal/


Historic Armenian Quarter in Jerusalem Facing Demolition in Luxury Hotel Dispute CHUCK HOLTON

Dec 29 2023
CHUCK HOLTON

JERUSALEM – Here in Jerusalem's Armenian Quarter, an ancient Christian community is fighting to protect its historic land. They're resisting an attempt to put a hotel on property they've owned for centuries, and they believe the issue raises broader concerns for the Christian presence in the city. 

The Armenian Quarter, with its ancient heritage, is facing a land dispute that has implications beyond these ancient walls. A land deal with a Jewish businessman leased a large portion of the Armenian quarter of the old city, and the investor plans a luxury hotel that would demolish homes where Armenians have lived for centuries.

Armenian Resident Garo Nalbandian told CBN News, "My family comes in 1920s after the Turkish massacres. My father come along with the sister without their families."

"I was living, 1948, inside the convent. Afterwards, when we start to work, we make the money… But when we get married… I took from the Patriarchate, this house. (Since) 1969, when I married, until now, I am living there," he said.

Another Armenian resident, Hagop Djernazian, told us, "Two years ago, an illegal deal was signed to lease this land for a hotel. We were shocked to learn that the deal included not only the community parking lot but also houses, the patriarch's garden, and the seminary school."

The Armenian community in Jerusalem is deeply rooted in the city's history, and now finds itself at the forefront of a struggle for preserving its identity and heritage.

Djernazian explained, "Since the fourth century, the Armenians, continue to live here in the Old City on the highest point in the Old City, which is Mt. Zion. And, we have our own quarter. It is important to mention that the Armenian presence in Jerusalem is an uninterrupted presence."

While the deal is tied up in court battles, the developer is attempting to begin demolition.  Armenians took a stand to keep that from happening, facing violence from representatives of the corporation. Now, they're camping out here to avert any further demolition.

"We stopped the bulldozers, we stood in front of them, and we are staying here, we are guarding all day…" Djernazian said. "They will take the land in order to prevent from armed settlers and security guards from the company to attack or take over the land."

Armenians have been the caretakers of this piece of Jerusalem in the old city since the fourth century, and it might not seem like such a big deal that somebody wants to lease this property and build a hotel on it. But if you come from a people group that has faced genocide and ethnic cleansing as recently as just a couple of months ago in Armenia, when Azerbaijan pushed out 120,000 Armenians off their ancestral lands and made them refugees in their own country, you can start to understand why this is a much bigger deal.

Nalbandian said if Armenians are ousted from their quarter in Jerusalem, he says it will result in "the end of the Christians in Jerusalem."

"Not going to leave…whatever is happening, I going to stay. If they shut my house, I going to put (up a) tent. I'm not looking for the money. I love this place. This is kind of Armenian home and this land. It doesn't belong to the Armenian Jerusalem. Its belong to all Armenians around the world," Nalbandian said.

The land dispute in the Armenian Quarter might be lost in the news coming out of Gaza, but for these people, it's a life-or-death issue. And it's not just Armenians who are concerned; the wider Christian community in Jerusalem also sees this as a pivotal moment for religious and cultural preservation. 

https://www2.cbn.com/news/israel/historic-armenian-quarter-jerusalem-facing-demolition-luxury-hotel-dispute

Jerusalem’s Armenians vow to keep up fight against ‘settler’ project

France 24
Dec 29 2023

Jerusalem (AFP) – Residents of Israeli-annexed east Jerusalem's historic Armenian quarter rapidly mobilised when bulldozers rolled in to start work on a luxury hotel, a project they fear threatens the ancient but dwindling community.

The real estate deal which gives an Australian-Israeli investor roughly 25 percent of the Old City's Armenian quarter has sparked anger and concern among its residents.

"The youth arrived in large numbers and positioned themselves in front of the bulldozers," recalled resident Kegham Balian of the escalation last month.

"The settlers underestimated our community," said the Armenian merchant.

"We are waging a peaceful struggle, and we are not afraid."

Ever since the construction began, Armenians have set up camp, bringing tents, stoves, mattresses and even a TV to a weeks-long sit-in to guard the contested land.

Inside a tent, wooden planks patch up the holes left by construction equipment.

On Thursday, "over 30 armed provocateurs" attacked members of the Armenian community including clergymen, the Armenian Patriarchate of Jerusalem said in a statement.

It accused the real estate developer, Danny Rothman, of being responsible for the "massive and coordinated physical attack" shortly after the patriarchate had taken to the court to annul the controversial land sale.

East Jerusalem and the Old City — divided into Muslim, Christian, Jewish and Armenian quarters — was seized by Israel in 1967 and annexed in a move not recognised by the international community.

Land rights are a key point of tension in east Jerusalem and the occupied West Bank, where Israel has built and expanded settlements, considered illegal under international law.

Only around 2,000 Armenians remain in the Old City quarter after waves of immigration primarily to the United States and Europe since the 1960s.

Like Palestinians in the rest of east Jerusalem, most Armenians do not hold Israeli citizenship but only residency.

Panic first erupted among the minority community in April, after it was revealed that the Armenian Patriarchate of Jerusalem and Father Baret Yeretzian, in charge of real estate affairs, struck a deal in 2021 with a Tel Aviv-based company.

The firm, which won a 99-year lease on the land, is Rothman's Xana Gardens Ltd, according to Israeli lawyer and Jerusalem specialist Daniel Seidemann.

"The agreement was reached by the patriarchate without the knowledge and without the consent of the residents of the Armenian quarter or their institutions," Seidemann told AFP, an assertion echoed by community members.

The contract included "11,500 square metres (2.8 acres) of land, including a parking lot, five residences, and the patriarchate's seminar hall," said Setrag Balian, co-founder of Save the ArQ, a movement by Armenian quarter residents.

Despite the Armenian Patriarchate saying it had subsequently "withdrawn from negotiations" after discovering "problems behind this transaction", many community members still feel betrayed.

Yeretzian, the priest behind the contract has been defrocked.

The latest escalation came after Nourhan Manougian, the Armenian patriarch of Jerusalem, on October 27 sent a letter to Xana Gardens formally notifying the firm of the "cancellation of the agreement".

Then, "bulldozers, armed settlers accompanied by dogs, and residents of the Jewish quarter" arrived to the area, said the activist Balian, 27.

The takeover attempt "took advantage of the chaos of October 7," he said, referring to the bloody attack by Palestinian militant group Hamas on Israel that triggered all-out war.

"They managed to demolish part of the wall surrounding the parking lot."

Rothman's lawyer, Avi Savitzki, declined to comment when contacted by AFP.

– 'We are ready'-

Campaigners say they are trying to preserve the land of the Armenian community, whose presence in Jerusalem dates as far back as 1,500 years.

Save the ArQ is also supported by Armenian diaspora communities with legal assistance and media coverage.

"Every day, families come to see us and bring us food," said Kegham Balian of the sit-in, where young and old take turns sleeping at the site.

They hope the land does not befall the same fate of some Greek Orthodox Church property in Jerusalem.

Israeli settler group Ateret Cohanim, using front companies, in 2004 acquired leasing rights on three building belonging to the church.

After years legal battles, Israel's top court eventually allowed Ateret Cohanim to take hold of the property.

This judicial setback "endangers the Christian presence and the integrity of the Christian quarter," said activist Hagop Djernazian.

To Balian, "we know the political stakes" in the divided holy city, a focal point of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

"It will not be an easy battle, especially since we are not just fighting against a private company but also against settlers," he said.

But "we are ready."

https://www.france24.com/en/live-news/20231229-jerusalem-s-armenians-vow-to-keep-up-fight-against-settler-project

Turkish Press: Armenians in Jerusalem vow to oppose Israeli occupation project

Daily Sabah, Turkey
Dec 29 2023

Occupied East Jerusalem's Armenian community mobilized against Israel's project to build a luxury hotel in their quarter in the city, as their existence, like other communities, is threatened by Israel's unlawful settler projects.

The real estate deal, which gives an Australian-Israeli investor roughly 25% of the Old City's Armenian quarter, has sparked anger and concern among its residents.

"The youth arrived in large numbers and positioned themselves in front of the bulldozers," recalled resident Kegham Balian of the escalation last month.

"The settlers underestimated our community," said the Armenian merchant.

"We are waging a peaceful struggle and are not afraid."

Ever since the construction began, Armenians have set up camp, bringing tents, stoves, mattresses and even a TV to a weeks-long sit-in to guard the contested land.

Inside a tent, wooden planks patch up the holes left by construction equipment.

On Thursday, "over 30 armed provocateurs" attacked members of the Armenian community, including clergymen, the Armenian Patriarchate of Jerusalem said in a statement.

It accused the real estate developer, Danny Rothman, of being responsible for the "massive and coordinated physical attack" shortly after the patriarchate had taken to court to annul the controversial land sale.

East Jerusalem and the Old City – divided into Muslim, Christian, Jewish and Armenian quarters – was seized by Israel in 1967 and annexed in a move not recognized by the international community.

Land rights are a key point of tension in East Jerusalem and the occupied West Bank, where Israel has built and expanded settlements, considered illegal under international law.

Only around 2,000 Armenians remain in the Old City quarter after waves of immigration primarily to the United States and Europe since the 1960s.

Like Palestinians in the rest of east Jerusalem, most Armenians do not hold Israeli citizenship but only residency.

Panic erupted among the minority community in April after it was revealed that the Armenian Patriarchate of Jerusalem and Father Baret Yeretzian, in charge of real estate affairs, struck a deal in 2021 with a Tel Aviv-based company.

The firm that won a 99-year lease on the land is Rothman's Xana Gardens Ltd, according to Israeli lawyer and Jerusalem specialist Daniel Seidemann.

"The patriarchate reached the agreement without the knowledge and the consent of the residents of the Armenian quarter or their institutions," Seidemann told Agence France-Presse – (AFP), an assertion echoed by community members.

The contract included "11,500 square meters (2.8 acres) of land, including a parking lot, five residences, and the patriarchate's seminar hall," said Setrag Balian, co-founder of Save the ArQ, a movement by Armenian quarter residents.

Despite the Armenian Patriarchate saying it had subsequently "withdrawn from negotiations" after discovering "problems behind this transaction," many community members still feel betrayed.

Yeretzian, the priest behind the contract, has been defrocked.

The latest escalation came after Nourhan Manougian, the Armenian patriarch of Jerusalem, on Oct. 27 sent a letter to Xana Gardens formally notifying the firm of the "cancellation of the agreement."

Then, "bulldozers, armed settlers accompanied by dogs, and residents of the Jewish quarter" arrived in the area, said the activist Balian, 27.

The takeover attempt "took advantage of the chaos of Oct. 7," he said.

"They managed to demolish part of the wall surrounding the parking lot."

Rothman's lawyer, Avi Savitzki, declined to comment when contacted by AFP.

Campaigners say they are trying to preserve the land of the Armenian community, whose presence in Jerusalem dates as far back as 1,500 years.

Save the ArQ is also supported by Armenian diaspora communities with legal assistance and media coverage.

"Every day, families come to see us and bring us food," said Kegham Balian of the sit-in, where young and old take turns sleeping at the site.

They hope the land does not befall the same fate as some Greek Orthodox Church property in Jerusalem.

Israeli settler group Ateret Cohanim, using front companies, in 2004 acquired leasing rights on three buildings belonging to the church.

After years of legal battles, Israel's top court eventually allowed Ateret Cohanim to take hold of the property.

This judicial setback "endangers the Christian presence and the integrity of the Christian quarter," said activist Hagop Djernazian.

To Balian, "we know the political stakes" in the divided holy city, a focal point of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

"It will not be an easy battle, especially since we are not just fighting against a private company but also against settlers," he said.

But "we are ready."

RFE/RL Armenian Servie – 12/29/2023

                                        Friday, 


Armenian Envoy Sacked After Collapse Of Father’s Deal With Pashinian

        • Satenik Kaghzvantsian

Armenia - Ambassador to Iraq Misak Balasanian.


Armenia’s ambassador to Iraq was sacked on Friday three weeks after the ruling 
Civil Contract party pulled out of a power-sharing agreement in Gyumri with a 
local political group unofficially led by his father.

Misak Balasanian was recalled through a presidential decree initiated by Prime 
Minister Nikol Pashinian. It came less than four months after Balasanian, who 
had no prior diplomatic experience, was appointed as ambassador.

The appointment was widely linked with the agreement reached following the 
October 2021 municipal elections in Gyumri. Armenia’s second largest city was 
run until then by Balasanian’s father Samvel, a local wealthy businessman.

Although Samvel Balasanian decided not to seek another term in office, a newly 
created bloc bearing his name participated in the elections and garnered most 
votes. But it fell short of a majority in the local council electing the mayor.

The Balasanian Bloc teamed up with Civil Contract, to install a relative of 
Balasanian, Vardges Samsonian, as new mayor of Gyumri. In return, two Civil 
Contract figures became deputy mayors. Three dozen other members of Pashinian’s 
party were also given posts in the municipal administration.

All those officials stepped down after Civil Contract unexpectedly announced on 
December 6 the end of the power-sharing arrangement. It said it does not want to 
be part of “shady governance,” implying that Balasanian Sr. is continuing to 
pull the strings in Gyumri.

Armenia -- Gyumri Mayor Samvel Balasanian speaks to journalists, April 24, 2018.

Commentators suggested that the ruling party will try to gain control of the 
municipality despite holding only 11 seats in the 33-member city council. The 
Balasanian Bloc indicated that it will not give up the post of mayor.

In another sign of mounting tensions between the two political forces, council 
members representing Civil Contract blocked on Friday the passage of the city’s 
2024 budget drafted by Mayor Samsonian. The latter rebuked them as well as 
councilors from two opposition groups who also voted against the budget.

Samsonian secured the insufficient backing of the third opposition force 
represented in the Gyumri legislature, the former ruling Republican Party (HHK) 
to which Balasanian was allied before Pashinian’s rise to power. Knarik 
Harutiunian, who leads the Civil Contract group in the council, scoffed at this 
fact.

Incidentally, Iraqi President Abdullatif Jamal Rashid travelled to Gyumri on 
November 23 during an official visit to Armenia. Misak Balasanian, who 
accompanied him on that trip, was sacked less than two months after handing his 
credentials to Rashid.




Armenian Church Facing ‘Existential Threat’ In Jerusalem

        • Artak Khulian

A view of the Cows' Garden property of the Armenian Apostolic Church in 
Jerusalem. (Photo by the Armenian Patriarchate of Jerusalem.)


The Jerusalem Patriarchate of the Armenian Apostolic Church claimed to be facing 
an “existential threat” following a violent incident on Thursday which it 
attributed to an Israeli-Australian businessman’s efforts to take over one of 
its largest properties in the city.

A group of Armenian clerics and laymen were reportedly attacked by a violent mob 
as they held a vigil at Jerusalem’s Cows’ Garden property currently used as a 
parking lot.

The Patriarchate controversially agreed in 2021 to lease the former garden 
occupying one-quarter of the Old City’s Armenian Quarter to Jewish real estate 
developer Danny Rothman and his Christian Arab partner George Warwar for 99 
years. Their Xana Gardens company wants to build a luxury hotel there.

The lease agreement signed by the two sides enraged the local Armenian community 
and also drew strong condemnation from the Palestinian Authority and Jordan. 
Patriarch Nourhan Manougian subsequently blamed the “fraudulent and deceitful” 
deal on a now-defrocked priest, saying that he was misled by the latter.

Manougian’s office announced about two months ago that it has decided to scrap 
the lease and asked an Israeli court to validate the decision. Armenian 
clergymen and community activists began the daily vigil at the Cows’ Garden 
after Xana tried to start the construction.

An Armenian flag on the building of the Armenian Patriarchate of Jerusalem, 
August 30, 2021.

A mobile phone video filmed by one of the priests showed the Armenians clashing 
with dozens of masked men apparently trying to drive them out of the property on 
Thursday. Several of them were reportedly injured as a result.

“Fortunately, our youths present at the scene managed to resist and repel the 
attackers,” Hagop Djernazian, a community activist, told RFE/RL’s Armenian 
Service on Friday. He claimed that the attackers were “sent” by the real estate 
developers.

“This is how the Australian-Israeli businessman Danny Rothman (Rubenstein) and 
George Warwar (Hadad) react to legal procedures,” the Armenian Patriarchate said 
in a statement issued the previous night.

“The Armenian Patriarchate’s existential threat is now a physical reality,” it 
said, urging the international community to “help us save the Armenian Quarter 
from a violent demise.”

“It is obvious that the provocateurs are once again trying to seize the ‘Cow’s 
Garden’ estate through terror, threats and violent actions, violating the 
procedures established by the law,” read a separate statement released by the 
Armenian Apostolic Church’s Mother See in Echmiadzin, Armenia. It urged Israeli 
authorities to stop the “criminal acts against the Patriarchate and the Armenian 
community.”

An Armenian religious procession in the Old City of Jerusalem, June 24, 2021.

Jerusalem’s Deputy Mayor Fleur Hassan-Nahoum described Thursday’s incident as a 
brawl between “some Arab Muslim men and some men from the Armenian community.” 
She did not link it to the dispute over the Cows’ Garden.

“The city of Jerusalem will not tolerate any criminal activity, whether 
religiously motivated or otherwise, and the police will prosecute those 
responsible,” The Jerusalem Post newspaper quoted Hassan-Nahoum as saying.

Rothman and his company did not comment on the clash. The businessman did not 
answer questions e-mailed by RFE/RL’s Armenian Service.

Armenia’s government also did not react to the violence as of Friday evening,

The Foreign Ministry in Yerevan expressed “deep concern” but refrained from 
demanding any action by Israeli authorities after a series of fresh attacks on 
Jerusalem Armenians reported a year ago and blamed on Jewish extremists.

In one of those attacks, an angry mob wreaked havoc on a restaurant located in 
the Armenian Quarter. According to the restaurant owner, they shouted “Death to 
Christians!” and “Death to Arabs!”

The Armenian Church has for years accused radical Jews of regularly cursing and 
spitting at its clergymen in the streets of Jerusalem’s Old City. Two Israeli 
soldiers were briefly detained by police in November 2022 for doing so during a 
religious procession led by an Armenian archbishop.




Armenia Maintains Flight Service To Border Town Despite Security Risk


Armenia - An L-410 plane carrying Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian lands at Kapan 
airport, August 17, 2023.


Regular commercial flights between Yerevan and Kapan have continued even after 
Azerbaijani troops repeatedly fired at the Armenian border town’s airport four 
months ago, Minister of Territorial Administration and Infrastructures Gnel 
Sanosian said on Friday.

According to Armenia’s state border guard service, the small airport first came 
under cross-border fire on August 18 less than 24 hours after a plane carrying 
Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian landed there. It said gunshots fired from 
Azerbaijani army positions overlooking the facility damaged the airports roof 
and one of the windows.

Another shooting incident was reported on August 19 just minutes after a plane 
carrying other Armenian officials touched down on the runway. Local officials 
accused Azerbaijan of trying to disrupt the first post-Soviet flight service 
between Yerevan and Kapan launched by the NovAir airline on August 21.

Later in August, the Armenian government notified the International Civil 
Aviation Organization (ICAO) about the shootings and asked the 193-nation body 
to help prevent a repeat of such incidents. The local airport was reportedly 
again hit and damaged by gunfire on September 1. But no further shooting 
incidents were reported in the following months.

Sanosian told reporters that the twice-weekly service has continued since then 
and will be maintained next year. He said the government has purchased more 
sophisticated navigation and meteorological equipment for the Kapan airport that 
will minimize flight disruptions caused by bad weather.

Armenia - Minister of Territorial Administration and Infrastructures Gnel 
Sanosian holds a news conerence in Yerevan, .

NovAir uses small L-410 aircraft capable of carrying up to 17 passengers. 
According to Sanosian, the private airline has carried out 22 flights since 
August, transporting a total of just 189 passengers to and from Kapan. The 
minister acknowledged that the lingering security risk discourages many people 
from taking the 50-minute flights.

“Most of the time, the flights are not sold out,” he said. “We understand the 
reason for that but will not stop the flights.”

Kapan is the administrative center of Armenia’s southeastern Syunik province 
sandwiched between Azerbaijan and its Nakhichevan exclave. Baku has for years 
demanded an extraterritorial corridor to Nakhichevan passing through Syunik, 
which is also the sole Armenian province bordering Iran. Yerevan rejects those 
demands.

Azerbaijan’s recent recapture of Nagorno-Karabakh raised more fears in Yerevan 
that it could also invade Syunik to try to open the so-called “Zangezur 
corridor.” Iran as well as Western powers have warned Baku against doing that.

Tehran opened a consulate in Kapan in 2022. Russia and France are expected to 
follow suit in 2024.



Reposted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2023 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.