NAGORNO-KARABAKH: VIEWING THE CONFLICT FROM THE GROUND
International Crisis Group, Belgium
Sept 14 2005
Europe Report N°166
14 septembre 2005
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The conflict between Azerbaijan and Armenia over Nagorno-Karabakh
is the most significant obstacle to peace and stability in the South
Caucasus. Eleven years into a ceasefire, the parties have been unable
to sign a single document bringing them closer to a settlement.
Whatever is being done at the internationally mediated negotiations,
at ground level resumed war appears a real possibility. There is need
to counter the hate propaganda and demonising engaged in by both sides
and unlock the potential for confidence building and dialogue between
average Azeris and Armenians before the memories of cohabitation fade
and the divide becomes virtually unbridgeable.
Nagorno-Karabakh has aspirations for independence and argues with
some reason that it has a democratically-elected government that is
meeting the preconditions of statehood. However, it is internationally
recognised as part of Azerbaijan and is still highly dependant
on Armenia for its military security and economic survival: over
half its army are believed to be Armenian citizens, while Yerevan
covers 50 per cent of the budget through an “interstate loan” that
is virtually interest free and unlikely to be paid back. Azeris
do not participate in its political, economic, cultural and social
institutions. Nagono-Karabakh has mono-ethnic institutions and become
one of the world’s most militarised societies.
Deprived of the basic right to return to their homes, over half a
million Azeris displaced from Nagorno-Karabakh and seven adjacent
districts have become highly dependent on the Azerbaijani state,
without a clear sense of their future. For years Baku’s policies
toward the displaced were designed to meet short-term needs, with
the expectation they could return home soon. There was more than a
hint that efforts to integrate them better were not pushed so as to
use their plight to score political points. The government’s current
strategy emphasises more sustainable solutions but the displaced remain
poorer and more disadvantaged than their fellow citizens, struggling
to increase participation in political life not only to speed up
prospects for return but also to improve their immediate situation.
Armenian and Azerbaijani public opinion on how to resolve the conflict
is as divided as ever. Nothing has been done to prepare people in
either country for any agreement. Karabakh Armenians’ expressions
of confidence about their independent future, and Karabakh Azeris’
frustration and anger about their plight as displaced persons are
deeply at odds. Neither community appears prepared to agree to the kind
of steps toward resolution of the conflict currently being considered
by the Armenian and Azerbaijani foreign ministers in the negotiations
sponsored by the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe
(OSCE).
For many historical, demographical, geographical, and economic
factors, Azeris and Armenians living in and around the conflict zone
are dependent on each other. Yet they are deeply divided by mistrust.
Demonisation of the “other”, rising military expenditures, and
increasing ceasefire violations are all ominous signs that time for
a peaceful settlement may be running out.
Parallel processes are needed for a stable settlement. This report
explores how the Armenian and Azeri communities from Nagorno-Karabakh
and the surrounding districts live today and view the potential
resolution of the conflict. A subsequent report will shortly assess the
OSCE-sponsored diplomacy and attempt to bridge the gap between it and
the situation on the ground, focusing with specific recommendations
on both the main issues that must be treated in a peace agreement
and on what needs to be done to further inter-communal reconciliation.
;l=2
–Boundary_(ID_znGYcXWxGxd0wn36edERFw)–
EU Official Accuses Turkey Of Provocation
EU OFFICIAL ACCUSES TURKEY OF PROVOCATION
By Jan Sliva
The Associated Press
09/13/05 17:26 EDT
BRUSSELS, Belgium (AP) – The official in charge of European Union
expansion accused Turkey of provocation on Tuesday, saying it was no
coincidence that the trial of a Turkish novelist would clash with a
EU summit.
Olli Rehn, the EU commissioner overseeing expansion plans, said the
prosecution of author Orhan Pamuk violated a human rights convention.
He also said it would take at least 10-15 years to finish negotiations
with Turkey on its possible accession to the bloc, and warned Ankara
that the pace of the talks will depend on how quickly it recognizes
Cyprus.
“The Pamuk case raises serious questions about the interpretation of
Turkey’s new penal code. The Dec. 16 date can’t be just a coincidence,
it has to be a provocation,” Rehn told the European Parliament’s
foreign affairs committee. Dec. 16 is also the date of an EU summit.
Rehn added that the case violated the European Convention on Human
Rights.
Pamuk has been charged with insulting Turkey’s national character and
could face prison for his comments on Turkey’s killing of Armenians
and Kurds.
“Thirty-thousand Kurds and one million Armenians were killed in these
lands and nobody but me dares to talk about it,” Pamuk was quoted as
saying in an interview with a Swiss newspaper magazine in February.
The “one million Armenians” refers to Armenians killed by Ottoman
Turks around the time of World War I, which Armenians and several
other nations recognize as the first genocide of the 20th century.
Turkey vehemently denies that a genocide took place, saying the
death toll is inflated and Armenians were killed in a civil war as
the Ottoman Empire collapsed, eventually giving way to the Turkish
Republic in 1923.
Turkey, which has been trying to improve its human rights record
as it vies for EU membership, is extremely sensitive about both the
Armenian and Kurdish issues, and the new Turkish penal code makes it
a crime to denigrate Turkey’s national identity.
The code – adopted at the EU’s insistence – was debated earlier this
year and freedom of speech advocates said the clause on national
identity was too vague and could lead to the imprisonment of artists,
scholars and journalists.
Rehn said the European Commission will continue to closely monitor
human rights issues in Turkey, but still expects the accession
negotiations to start on Oct. 3 as scheduled, despite EU government
grumbling over Turkey’s refusal to recognize Cyprus.
In August, Turkey signed a customs protocol extending its existing
customs arrangements with the 25-member EU to the 10 new members
including Cyprus. But it accompanied its signature with a separate
declaration saying this did not mean it was formally recognizing the
divided Mediterranean island.
Rehn said formal recognition “was not a precondition” to start the
Oct. 3 talks. “However, it is regrettable that Turkey had to issue
a declaration accompanying the protocol,” he said.
The European Court of Human Rights – based in Strasbourg, France –
ordered Turkey on Tuesday to pay more than $85,932 to the relatives
of two suspected members of the outlawed Kurdistan Workers’ Party
who were killed in a police raid in 1996.
An anti-terrorist squad shot Omer Bayram and Ridvan Altun in an
operation which the court said violated three articles of the human
rights convention.
Second Azerbaijani Opposition Youth Activist Detained
SECOND AZERBAIJANI OPPOSITION YOUTH ACTIVIST DETAINED
The Associated Press
09/13/05 06:35 EDT
BAKU, Azerbaijan (AP) – An activist of Azerbaijan’s Yeni Fikir
(New Thought) opposition youth movement was detained, lawyers and
prosecutors said Tuesday, in the latest sign of rising tensions in
the run-up to the November parliamentary election.
Said Nuriyev was taken into custody Monday as a suspect in the case
already launched against the movement’s leader, Ruslan Bashirli, said
Tarana Velizade, a spokeswoman for the Prosecutor-General’s office.
Bashirli was accused of taking part in a meeting with agents from
Azerbaijan’s rival neighbor, Armenia, aimed at organizing an uprising
by pro-democracy forces in Azerbaijan.
Nuriyev was accused of receiving instructions for carrying out a coup
in Azerbaijan during a trip to Poland, his lawyer Yaver Huseyn said,
citing the warrant.
<< Big Business>> In The Sport-Concert Complex
“BIG BUSINESS” IN THE SPORT-CONCERT COMPLEX
A1+
| 15:46:00 | 14-09-2005 | Social |
The trade-industrial exhibition “Armenia Expo-2005” will be held in
the hall of the Sport-Concert Complex after Karen Demirchyan for three
days. The event is unprecedented as it is the largest ever organized
in independent Armenia.
“The exhibition proves that Armenia has become a regional systematizing
business center”, said head of the Union of Industrialists and
Businessmen Arsen Ghazaryan. The organizers of the exhibition are
elated by the fact that not only the local producers (there are about
62 of them), but also 20 organizations from abroad have represented
their products in the exhibition.
The guests f the exhibition represent 15 countries – Russia, Romania,
Moldova, China, Japan, Great Britain, etc.
By the way, within the framework of the three-day “Expo” an
Armenian-Russian business meeting will be held, and US and China
business days will be organized. Nevertheless, the most important
event for the producers is the competition titled “High quality”.
Joint Post
JOINT POST
A1+
| 14:25:31 | 14-09-2005 | Official |
Robert Kocharyan signed decree on appointing RA Ambassador
extraordinary and plenipotentiary to UK Vahe Gabrielyan pluralistically
RA Ambassador to Ireland (residence in London).
Attention To Agriculture
ATTENTION TO AGRICULTURE
A1+
| 15:16:57 | 14-09-2005 | Politics |
Today in New York UN General Assembly 60th session high-level meeting
started. Heads of Governments of more than 170 countries participate
in the summit, including the RA Prime Minister Andranik Margaryan.
On September 13 Andranik Margaryan met the «Millennium Challenges
Corporation» (MCC) heads temporary executive director Charles Setnes
and deputy head of the Countries’ Program John Hugo. During the
meeting issues about cooperation with the MCC have been discussed.
The sides have expressed their pleasure with the cooperation of the
working groups. The MCC has expressed its approval of the Millennium
Challenges Armenian draft program represented by the RA Government.
During the meeting the RA Prime Minster mentioned that special
attention must be paid to agriculture, especially to farms. The
representative of MCC found the provision of transparency in the works
of the MCC governing council extremely important. He mentioned that
with that aim representatives of non-governmental organizations and
civil society must be included in the Council.
In this concern the Prime Minister mentioned that the RA Government is
for transparency of processes, and the choice of the above mentioned
organizations can be realized by joint efforts of the representatives
of MCC and non-governmental organizations and civil society.
–Boundary_(ID_keiTL5MKnIsIxgFYxYCuYg)–
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress
Constitutional Referendum In Armenia Likely To Be Held November 20
CONSTITUTIONAL REFERENDUM IN ARMENIA LIKELY TO BE HELD NOVEMBER 20
Pan Armenian News
14.09.2005 02:49
/PanARMENIAN.Net/ The constitutional referendum in Armenia is likely
to be held on November 20, head of the Dashnaktsutyun faction (ARFD)
Levon Mkrtchian stated. In his words, the agreement was achieved
at the meeting of the coalition and Armenian President Robert
Kocharian. During the meeting the parties discussed some technical
details of the upcoming referendum.
According to leader of the Republican Party of Armenia Galust
Sahakian, the draft constitutional amendments were submitted to the
Venice Commission. The meeting participants also noted that possible
failure of the referendum is not considered. “Such things should not
be discussed. We should be resolute.
The matter concerns a Constitution that has no analogue in the CIS,”
Galust Sahakian said. In his words, the reviewed Constitution will
convey a positive impulse to the development of democracy and justice,
reported IA Regnum.
From: Baghdasarian
Armenian Defense Minister Met Newly Appointed Iranian Attache InArme
ARMENIAN DEFENSE MINISTER MET NEWLY APPOINTED IRANIAN ATTACHE IN ARMENIA
Pan Armenian News
13.09.2005 08:59
/PanARMENIAN.Net/ Today Secretary of the National Security Council
at the RA President, Defense Minster Serge Sargsyan received Iranian
Ambassador to RA Alireza Haqiqyan and newly appointed military attache,
Colonel Bijan Hamzeil Hashame. At the beginning of the meeting the
Ambassador conveyed to Serge Sargsyan the greetings of the Iranian
Security Council Secretary and Defense Minister and expressed hope
that the Armenian-Iranian joint programs will be successfully launched.
Armenian Leader Upbeat On War Game With Russia
ARMENIAN LEADER UPBEAT ON WAR GAME WITH RUSSIA
Public Television of Armenia, Yerevan
13 Sep 05
[Correspondent] The Armenian president and commander-in-chief,
Robert Kocharyan, has thanked servicemen involved in the joint
Armenian-Russian military exercises in an address he gave after the
war game.
[Kocharyan speaking in Russian with Armenian voice-over] I would like
to thank you for your services to the motherland. Brotherhood between
Armenia and Russia is continuing. This brotherhood is reflected in the
agreement thanks to which the Russian military base exists in Armenia
today and we conduct the joint exercises. The exercises are aimed at
ensuring our countries’ security. I thank all of you for your services.
[Video showed Kocharyan awarding servicemen at the Marshal Bagramyan
training ground]
Karabakh Issue Likely To Be Discussed During Talvitie’s Visit To Bak
KARABAKH ISSUE LIKELY TO BE DISCUSSED DURING TALVITIE’S VISIT TO BAKU
Pan Armenian News
14.09.2005 04:49
/PanARMENIAN.Net/ During his visit to Baku EU Special Representative
to the South Caucasus Heikki Talvitie is scheduled to discuss the
forthcoming parliamentary election in Azerbaijan, Azeri Deputy FM
Mahmud Mamedkuliyev reported. “Besides, the Karabakh issue can be
also discussed,” Mamedkuliyev noted. To remind, Mr. Talvitie’s visit
to Baku started on September 12, the 525-th newspaper reported.