Pan Armenian News
OSKANIAN AND SCOTT DISCUSSED PROSPECTS OF ARMENIA-CALIFORNIA RELATIONS
22.09.2005 08:38
/PanARMENIAN.Net/ Today Armenian FM Vartan Oskanian met with California
Senator Jack Scott, reported the Armenian MFA Press Service. In the course
of the meeting the parties discussed prospects of development of
Armenia-California relations, noting the importance of visits of
politicians, as well as contacts between businessmen and ordinary citizens.
The Armenian FM appreciated Senator’s personal contribution to the opening
of the Trade Center in California, as well as recognition of the Armenian
Genocide by the State. In his turn J. Scott assured he will continue active
participation in the solving of the Armenian issue. The Senator is sure that
the opening of the Trade Center will bridge Armenian and American nations.
He remarked that besides Armenia the Center will comprise neighboring
states.
Greek Ambassador Completing Diplomatic Mission In Armenia
Pan Armenian News
GREEK AMBASSADOR COMPLETING DIPLOMATIC MISSION IN ARMENIA
22.09.2005 08:23
/PanARMENIAN.Net/ Today Armenian FM Vartan Oskanian met with Greek
Ambassador to Armenia Antonios Vlavianos, who is completing his diplomatic
mission in Armenia, reported the Armenian MFA Press Service. In the course
of the meeting V. Oskanian appreciated the dynamically developing
Armenian-Greek relations in all fields. He also noted Ambassador’s personal
contribution in strengthening the friendship between the two countries. In
his turn Mr. Vlavianos said economic growth is obvious in Armenia within the
3 years of his tenure. Mentioning the growing international interest towards
Armenia, the Ambassador said he is sure Armenia can secure sustainable
development and solve major social and economic issues in near future.
US Senator Hopes for Congress Recognition of Armenian Genocide
Pan Armenian News
US SENATOR HOPES FOR CONGRESS RECOGNITION OF ARMENIAN GENOCIDE
22.09.2005 07:45
/PanARMENIAN.Net/ Today Chairman of the National Assembly of Armenia Artur
Baghdassaryan received California Senator, Republican Jack Scott, reported
the Press Service of the Armenian Parliament. J. Scott has arrived in
Armenia to open a regional Trade Center of California. The decision to open
the Center was passed by the Californian Senate in the presence of Mr. Scott
in 2001. The Senator is well-known for his activities favorable for Armenia
and promotion of recognition of the Armenian Genocide by the California
Senate. In the course of the meeting the Senator said that he hoped for the
US Congress to recognize the Armenian Genocide taken place in 1915. In his
opinion, the Trade Center will promote not only mutually favorable
commercial ties, but also tourism. A. Baghdassaryan expressed satisfaction
with the opening of the Trade Center. He underscored readiness to promote
strengthening the trade and economic relations. The parties noted the
importance of establishment of relations between parliaments of California
and Armenia. It was also noted in the course of the conversation that
interparliamentary ties had already been discussed with US House Speaker
Dennis Hastert.
Harvest Gallery Presents the Paintings & Drawings of Anahit Ar
Harvest Gallery
938 N. Brand Blvd.
Glendale, CA
PRESS RELEASE
September 19, 2005
HARVEST GALLERY presents Anahit Ar
Artist Opening Reception: Friday, September 30, 6:00 p.m. to 10:00
p.m.Exhibition Dates: September 30 through October 2 Harvest Gallery:
938 North Brand Blvd., Glendale, CA
Glendale, CA (September 19) – Harvest Gallery is proud to present the
paintings and drawings of Anahit Ar, an exhibition opening on Friday,
September 30 in Glendale, California.
Working with numerous art forms including graphic art and costume
design, Anahit Ar’s paintings showcase figurative compositions and
portraits that are strong, expressive and dramatic yet flow with a
sense of elasticity. Her work has been displayed in several
exhibitions and shows in fine art museums throughout Russia and
Armenia, as well as in private art collections.
Anahit Ar was born into a family of artists whose artistic roots span
three generations. Earning a bachelor of fine arts from Terlmezyan
Fine Arts College and a doctorate in art from the University of Fine
Arts and Theater in Armenia, Anahit Ar became an accomplished
artist-painter and international costume designer with extensive
associations with Russian drama theaters, ballet organizations and
opera houses, including the world-renowned Bolshoi Ballet.
Anahit Ar’s exhibit will be on display from Friday, September 30
through Sunday, October 2. Gallery hours are Tuesday – Sunday from
11:00 am to 7:00 pm.
For information about the exhibit, please call Harvest Gallery at
818.546.1000 or visit
###050919
Vic Darchinyan to Attend Opening of Boxing School
Armenpress
VIC DARCHINYAN TO ATTEND OPENING OF BOXING SCHOOL
YEREVAN, SEPTEMBER 20, ARMENPRESS: An Australia-based Armenian boxer Vic
Darchinyan, who retained his 2004 International Boxing Federation and 2005
International Boxing Organization flyweight titles, told during a rare visit
to his homeland he was preparing to defend one of his titles versus Damian
Kelly from Ireland.
Vic Darchinyan retained his International Boxing Federation flyweight
title with a fifth-round technical knockout on August 24 over Jair Jimenez
at the Sydney Entertainment Center.
This is his first visit to homeland in two year time. Darchinyan who is
from Vanadzor said he will be present at a September 21 opening of a boxing
school in his native town. Darchinyan won all 24 fights, 19 by knock outs.
He also said he may move from Australia to US where professional box is more
developed.
National Citizens’ Initiative Takes On Youth Issues
PRESS RELEASE
The National Citizens’ Initiative
75 Yerznkian Street
Yerevan 375033, Armenia
Tel.: (+374 – 10) 27.16.00, 27.00.03
Fax: (+374 – 10) 52.48.46
E-mail: [email protected]
Website:
September 22, 2005
National Citizens’ Initiative Takes On Youth Issues
Yerevan–The National Citizens’ Initiative (NCI) today convened a youth
roundtable on “The Generation of Independence: Present and Future Tasks.”
The meeting brought together young public and political figures, heads of
student and other non-governmental associations, human rights advocates,
analysts, experts, and media representatives.
NCI coordinator Hovsep Khurshudian welcomed the audience with opening
remarks. “The nationwide awakening in 1988 and, starting from 1991, the
institution of Armenia’s sovereignty inspired hope that the new generation
that was formed under the conditions of an independent statehood would
inherit the values of those years, possess the push for becoming the masters
of their country, and be prepared to shoulder the heavy burden of
responsibility for the integrity of the state. Today, however, we are
bearing witness to a profound apathy among youth circles in regard to
national matters. An overwhelming majority of young people do not see
themselves as owners of the country, but rather its tenants at best. High
concepts, for one reason or another, were not passed on to the new
generation. And today we convene this roundtable in order to identify its
causes,” Khurshudian said.
In his intervention entitled “The Question of the Youth’s Perception of
Independence,” chairman Mihran Hakobian of Yerevan State University’s
Student Council deemed the discord among the youth as one of the impediments
to the establishment of “the independence generation” in the country. He
criticized the authorities’ youth policy and accused them of ineffective use
of state means in and for youth affairs. “The ‘Baze-2′ gathering, for the
organization of which a tremendous amount of money was allocated from state
budget, in fact was a failure,” Hakobian said. He also harshly disapproved
of the recent government-endorsed laws and regulations diminishing the
autonomy of university administration. In essence, he continued, the most
conscientious and devoted of the independence generation are alienated from
the country’s governance, the precept of natural selection is encroached
upon, and those young people who are guided not by principles but by
self-serving pettiness are penetrating into power.
In his talk on “The Yesterday and Today of the Independence Generation: A
Comparative Briefing,” NCI program coordinator Edgar Hakobian touched upon
the history of the youth movement in Armenia starting from 1988. Since then,
he said, the characteristics of the youth have largely changed, with guiding
ideals such as patriotism, dedication, and spirituality succumbing to
egotism, consumer mentality, and a readiness to rank petty self-interests
above vital national interests. “Speaking in the name of the entire youth, a
group of pro-governmental young people formed by the authorities themselves
is trying to secure its own financial welfare,” Hakobian concluded.
Moreover, the greater part of the youth is extremely passive when it comes
to the resolution of numerous public problems. This refers to the rights of
those serving in the army as well as the protection of those citizens who
have been illegally evicted from the Northern Avenue-Biuzand Street
construction zone. Hakobian made an appeal for youth organizations to
intensify their participation in these and related processes.
During his address entitled “Youth Obligations for the Sovereignty of the
Country,” Aren Manukian of the “Development of Knowledge” group said that
while the old generation played a meaningful role in achieving Armenia’s
independence, a solution to the Artsakh question, and consolidation of the
country’s sovereignty, the new generation has not yet demonstrated a
capacity to continue the work of its elders and to assume responsibility for
the country’s future. In his opinion, without the engagement of the youth en
masse, the involvement of a number of young activists in matters concerning
the restoration of the rule of law in Armenia would have only limited
effect. “When the matter referred to granting postponement of military
service to graduate students, we succeeded in having thousands of students
hold protests, but now that we are taking part in the reinstatement of the
rights of citizens who have been thrown out of their homes in the Northern
Avenue and Biuzand Street construction belt, you can count on your fingers
the number of people who come with us,” Manukian worried aloud.
The day’s final speaker, Armenian Center for National and International
Studies (ACNIS) analyst Syuzanna Barseghian, introduced and analyzed the
results of a series of sociological surveys recently conducted by ACNIS on
“generation next” and its outlook on Armenia’s independence, avenues for
resolving the Karabagh issue, the Genocide, and Armenia’s European
integration process. According to those findings, although Armenian youth
are prepared to take part in the defense of the Homeland if Armenia or
Karabagh is again attacked, the bulk of respondents find that Armenia’s
independence has brought with it more setbacks than accomplishments. In
Barseghian’s words, such thinking by the new generation is exceedingly
dangerous.
Also noteworthy were interventions by ACNIS analysts Alen Ghevondian and
Hovhannes Vardanian; “Development of Knowledge” group representatives Arsen
Kharatian and Ararat Mirzoyan; Heritage Party members Armen Martirosian and
Sargis Manukian; and many others.
In his closing remarks, NCI coordinator Hovsep Khurshudian accentuated this
matter’s significance for Armenia and the Armenian public. “The youth are
the tomorrow of this country, and the future of the sovereignty of the
Republic of Armenia and the prospects for the institution of civil society
are dependent on them,” Khurshudian concluded.
The National Citizens’ Initiative is a public non-profit association founded
in December 2001 by Raffi K. Hovannisian, his colleagues, and fellow
citizens with the purpose of realizing the rule of law and overall
improvements in the state of the state, society, and public institutions.
The National Citizens’ Initiative is guided by a Coordinating Council, which
includes individual citizens and representatives of various public,
scientific, and educational establishments. Five commissions on Law and
State Administration, Socioeconomic Issues, Foreign Policy, Spiritual and
Cultural Challenges, and the Youth constitute the vehicles for the
Initiative’s work and outreach.
For further information, please call (37410) 27-16-00 or 27-00-03; fax
(37410) 52-48-46; e-mail [email protected]; or visit
Seminar On Turkish Genocide Of Assyrians To Be Held In Stockholm
SEMINAR ON TURKISH GENOCIDE OF ASSYRIANS TO BE HELD IN STOCKHOLM
Assyrian International News Agency, AINA
Sept 23 2005
A seminar on the World War One Turkish genocide of Assyrians, Armenians
and Greeks will be held in Stockholm on September 24. The following
is a press release of the Assyrian Youth Federation of Sweden, which
is sponsoring the seminar.
The Armenian researcher Ara Sarafian is invited to give a lecture
during the Seyfo Seminar taking place at the University of Stockholm on
September, 24th. For the majority of us he might be yet an unknown
character who will be visiting us. However, Mr. Sarafian has an
impressive academic past with many years of studies behind him. He
is also a frequently hired lecturer on issues concerning Armenian
history. What sets him definitely apart from the rest of the Armenian
researchers is his knowledge of the Assyrian Genocide. In purpose
of presenting him and his ideas in advance to the seminar, he has
answered five questions for us.
Q: Mr. Sarafian, what view do you have on the Assyrians and their
history?
A: My knowledge about Assyrians is bad. I know about the ancient
Assyrians, but not about Assyrians of the current times. Their name is
mentioned in Armenian books, often rapidly, but Assyrians as a nation
remain invisible. Even today, where there is an Assyrian minority
in Armenia, there is no information on their language, culture or
history in the general Armenian society. One exception of which I
remember is William Saroyan, who wrote about Assyrians in one of his
short stories. And that was the first time I thought of Assyrians as
a modern people. I was touched already as early as then, because they
were like us Armenians, however living under worse conditions.
Q: Why are you one of very few, or maybe the only Armenian genocide
researcher, who mentions that a genocide was committed even against
the Assyrians?
A: I mention the genocide on the Assyrians, because I know that even
they were murdered in large numbers during 1915. But I am ashamed about
not knowing more. I am also ashamed that our elders did not tell us
more about the Assyrians. I believe that it has to do with that a lot
of Armenians still hold on to the assumption that the attention given
to the Assyrian and Greek genocide in the Ottoman Turkey minimizes
the Armenian aspect. It is a little like “the holocaust’s uniqueness
theoreticians” that minimizes the aspect of Roma and other groups in
the Nazi occupied Europe.
Q: Do you think that Armenians and Assyrians should cooperate on the
recognition of the genocide or continue to work separately?
A: I think that there is a big space for cooperation, but for
many Armenians the genocide is nothing they work with. It is more
a confession, and that confession seems to include the conviction
that the destruction of the year 1915 was only pointed against the
Armenians. Assyrians, Armenians, Turks and Kurds can all cooperate,
or work parallel with each other in purpose of lifting up history. I
would like to see that the Assyrians, for example, translate a few
main writings concerning the Assyrian genocide into English – today’s
most dominant academic and political language – in purpose of breaking
the ice. By confronting others with such important writings, they will
receive much more support for their cause. And I know there are such
important writings. I would also like to recommend that the Assyrians
build their own libraries, research centres and academics so that
their voice will be well articulated and heard within the academic
world. I know that such steps are already taken and I hope that I
will be able to take part of the knowledge that will be gathered.
Q: When did your interest in the Armenian genocide start and why?
A: I became an historian during the 1980’s, because I wanted to
find out the truth about the Armenians. I was privileged enough to
make that decisions. At that time I lived in Turkey, where I found
some good friends, and came to realize how close Armenians and Turks
stood to each other. After that I went to the USA and the University
of Michigan where I started to study Ottoman-Turkish and Armenian
history, and that led me unavoidably to the question of the genocide.
My real area of interest was about the internal organisation of the
Armenian people in the late Ottoman empire. I am seldom asked to
lecture about that area even though it interests me a lot. Five years
ago I stepped out of the formal Armenian academic establishment in the
USA, because I found that many of the establishment’s characters were
chauvinists. Just because the Armenians had been victims, it does not
mean they can not be chauvinists. Even today many Armenian historians
have the opinion that “history” is not about seeking the truth, it
is a practise that compromises a necessary element of “adjusting”
the truth for ideological and personal purposes. Maybe the excluding
of the Assyrian question has been a part of this adjustment.
Q: Do you think that Turkey will recognize the genocide against
Armenians, Assyrians and Greeks?
A: I think that Turkey will recognize the genocide and other injustices
that Greeks, Armenians, Assyrians, Kurds and others have suffered
from, mainly because more and more Turks are becoming interested in
those questions and they do not want to carry the burden from that
time on their shoulders, as little as they want to lie about such
questions. I hope that even we act in a way that invites them to go
through this phase. Establishing individual contacts with the Modern
Turkey and working for a democratisation of that country, will help
this development.
Translated from Swedish by Nahrin Akguc
From: Baghdasarian
Reporters Tackle Armenian Eatery
REPORTERS TACKLE ARMENIAN EATERY
By Lauren Phillips And Kris Turner
The State News, MI
Sept 23 2005
JOSH GRASSO The State News
The House of Kabobs, 1825 E. Michigan Ave., serves Armenian fare,
including Armenian Cheese Bouregh and Kutabi, House Kabob Delight,
foreground, and the Red Bean Bon Apetit, center.
Editor’s note: State News reporters Lauren Phillips and Kris Turner
set out to review an Armenian restaurant, House of Kabobs, 1825 E.
Michigan Ave., in Lansing. The restaurant is owned by two Armenian
families – one of which owned a large restaurant in Moscow. House of
Kabobs has plans to introduce a “student day,” which will be the last
Friday of every month and feature discounts on food and an opportunity
to learn about Armenian culture, co-owner Elmira Govorkyan said.
Blinded by the sunset as we drove down Michigan Avenue, we passed
House of Kabobs on the right, despite its noticeable exterior with
pink accents. The small size of the restaurant, perched on the edge
of a neighborhood in Lansing’s East side, makes the eatery look like
a cozy deli or diner. We finally make it into the small parking lot
and walk inside.
Lauren Phillips: It looks like a deli. I don’t like the fluorescent
lighting, but the wood chairs give it a homemade touch.
Kris Turner: It looks like Valentine’s Day exploded in here. The
bright reds and pinks (on the walls) are slightly nauseating. And
there are knickknacks everywhere.
We sat at a table, covered in trinkets and red cloth. We started with
appetizers, potato piroshki, $3.50, and blinchikee, $3.75.
LP: This soft meat-filled thing is called a “blinchikee.” I like the
little pancake wrap.
KT: Now that’s what I like. It’s in your mouth and all of a sudden
it kind of explodes with flavor. (The meat’s) kind of like Hamburger
Helper.
LP: What’s Hamburger Helper?
KT: You don’t know what Hamburger Helper is?
LP: No …
KT: Do you remember the little glove thing from when we were kids
on TV? It’s like hamburger and you put all this stuff in it and it’s
like a meal. Did you never eat Hamburger Helper in your whole life?
LP: Um, no.
KT: (dead silence, open-mouthed stare.)
LP: This potato piroshki (an order comes with two) is like a soggy
ball of bread, about the size of a potato, stuffed with mashed potatoes
and spices. I kind of like it.
KT: It’s mushy in your mouth and has a weird consistency, but it’s
kind of hard to cut with a knife. I’d say it’s OK in my book.
Turner leans in closer to the remaining potato piroshki.
KT: There’s a hair on it!
LP: (leans in too) No! Oh geez…
Both: Ewwww.
For dinner, Turner had a chicken shish kabob wrap, which has seasoned
and marinated cubes of grilled chicken breast with green peppers,
tomatoes and onions, for $5.75. It comes with a side of marinated
cabbage and a pickle.
KT: My wrap arrived warm, which is always good. It’s sprinkled with
some kind of seasoning – not spicy, a little like Lawry’s salt,
but good.
KT: I can taste tomato and the vegetable. It’s enjoyable, but not
soggy, which is nice. But, it got a little messy, leaking onto
the plate.
LP: The grilled chicken is really good. It is what you would expect
from a wrap from Caf-II-Go, but grilled and marinated.
Tasting Turner’s side of marinated cabbage:
KT: Just say no to cabbage! Ick.
LP: Tasting that cabbage reminds me of the time my dad took me to
his friend’s cow farm.
Phillips gets her meal, a house “Luleh” shish kabob plate, $8.75. The
kabob meat is a grilled mixture of ground lamb and beef. It comes with
two types of rice pilaf with imported basmati rice, tossed green salad,
homemade tomato sauce and homemade Armenian bread.
LP: There’s two sausage-sized meat things on the kabob and a side of
marinated veggies and rice with some kind of seasoning.
LP: How do you eat a kabob, Turner?
KT: Don’t you just pull it off the stick and shove it all in your
mouth?
LP: It’s one of those Popsicle conundrums.
LP: Back to my meat on a stick. It’s sizzling steak and lamb at the
same time… interesting to have the two flavors in your mouth like
that at once. It’s a little tough to chew.
KT: I wasn’t that impressed. It didn’t make me go “wow.”
LP: The rice is really spicy.
KT: It doesn’t bother me, really. My one concern with the rice is,
well, some of the granules are hard.
LP: Yeah. It’s not hot, either.
We pay and on the ride home, reflect on our meals, which notably
didn’t give us indigestion.
LP: So Turner, what’d you think?
KT: Overall, a gross experience. The hair in the food was really a
turn-off. While the food was OK, it lacked a certain something. I
won’t be coming back anytime soon.
LP: Yeah, I’m definitely kind of broke right now, so I wouldn’t be
able to afford driving out here and paying this kind of money. The plus
side, though, is the appeal of the opportunity to learn about another
culture and to taste food from it. I just wish the food was better.
ANKARA: 16 Armenian Schools In Turkey Opens First Semester
16 ARMENIAN SCHOOLS IN TURKEY OPENS FIRST SEMESTER
Journal of Turkish Weekly
Sept 23 2005
ISTANBUL – The new education period has been started. The minority
schools also opened the education session. There are 16 Armenian
schools with 3219 students and 412 teachers. Many more Armenian
students attend the ‘normal’ schools.
This year about 454 children were registered to the Armenian
kindergartens. 2107 students were registered to the primary and
secondary schools. 658 Armenian students were registered to the
Armenian high schools.
Apart from the normal courses, the Turkish Armenian schools also give
Armenian language and Armenian religion courses to their students.
Patriarch Mesrop II, religious leader of Turkish Armenians, said that
the Armenian language courses and Armenian culture courses in these
schools are crucial to maintain the existence of Armenian minority
in Turkey. The main problem of the Armenian population in Turkey is
voluntary ‘assimilation’. Many Armenians do not attend the Armenian
Church and Armenian schools. Another problem is the mixed marriages.
There are about 100.000 Armenians in Istanbul and they have all
the rights to take education in their own schools. Apart from the
Armenian schools there are Armenian health institutions, sport clubs
and cultural-social organizations. Moreover 3 Armenian newspaper are
published in Istanbul.
Apart from the Turkish Armenians, more than 50. 000 Armenians come
to ýstanbul to work from Armenia.
Armenian Schools in Istanbul and Student Numbers:
Aramyan: 142 students.
Bezciya: 161 students.
Bomonti Mihtaryan: 40 students.
Kalfayan: 101 students.
Dadyan: 411 students.
Esayan: 313 students.
Getronagan: 211 students.
Karagozyan: 175 students.
Levon Vartuhyan: 123 students.
Ferikoy: 237 students.
Pangalti Mihtaryan: 362 students.
Sahakyan: 400 students.
Samatya Anarat Higutyun: 74 students.
Ortakoy Tarkmancats: 143 students.
Tibrevank: 78 students.
Yesilkoy: 248 students.
JTW, with Agos and Bolsohays.
–Boundary_(ID_OxXxRgao7L1brUT4/NSM1w)–
Time For A Change, Not A Revolution
TIME FOR A CHANGE, NOT A REVOLUTION
By Ednan Agayev
The Moscow Times, Russia
Sept 23 2005
All but invisible to the wider world, a crisis is developing within
Azerbaijan that could threaten regional stability and the future
development of Caspian basin oil and gas.
Though largely self-created, by a combination of endemic corruption
and institutional underdevelopment, the emerging calamity is being
greatly aided by opportunistic measures by others, including Russia,
the United States and especially Iran.
In many ways, this is developing into a 21st-century version of the
Great Game — that epochal struggle between the British and Russian
empires, which dominated the lives of all sorts of tiny Eurasian
countries throughout the 19th century and well into the 20th century.
But Azerbaijan is not Afghanistan, which has had the misfortune
of historically always having been someone else’s buffer state or
strategic beachhead.
Azerbaijan is a prize in its own right. It can claim one-fifth of the
oil and gas of the Caspian Basin, one of the world’s last great pools
of hydrocarbon wealth. Led by BP, the Baku-Tblisi-Ceyhan pipeline
has just opened, creating a new gateway to world markets for Azeri oil.
With gross national product growth increasing at about 11 percent
annually, this should be the most economically successful of the
former Soviet states. Should be, and in some ways is — but not in
nearly enough ways to make Azerbaijan the happy and stable place it
ought to be.
Instead, it is a place that is starting to come unglued. Run until
recently by an authoritarian, but politically astute, former KGB
general named Heidar Aliyev, Azerbaijan is now run by a fractious
group of his ministers, ruling in the name of Heidar’s son, Ilham.
Ilham Aliyev is an intelligent, quite well-educated man of 44 whose
instincts do not appear to run to strong-arm tactics or dictatorship.
But he is surrounded by ministers and minders for whom there is much
to lose in the event of a regime change. Billions of dollars, in fact.
This is because Azerbaijan, under the elder Aliyev, functioned as
a giant franchising operation, with nearly all aspects of Azeri
national life hived off as vertically integrated businesses. If you
want to pass a university exam, you pay the instructor $50, a large
part of which he pays to his supervisor, who then pays part to his
superior, and so on all the way to the top. To be named police chief
in a medium-sized town costs about $10,000, most of which winds up
with whoever’s signature is required for such an appointment.
This was a relatively stable and predictable situation under Heidar
Aliyev, because he was imaginative enough to control its excesses
and tough enough to be able to do so.
There is room to doubt that Ilham Aliyev has that kind of authority.
He has in fact replaced few of his father’s lieutenants and has
remarkably few allies of his own in government from his own generation
or cohort. Increasingly, he appears to be more dependent on his
father’s aging cronies than they are on him.
Apart from the personalities at the top, the world around them
has changed utterly. Part of the change occurred in the streets of
Tbilisi, in neighboring Georgia, where just a month before Heidar
Aliyev’s death in 2003, the Rose Revolution replaced another former
KGB chieftain’s regime.
Understandably, a lot of people have been sticking colored pins
in their wall maps of the former Soviet Union ever since, trying
to guess in which state the next so-called color revolution might
happen: Tbilisi, Kiev, Bishkek — and now Baku? With parliamentary
elections set for Nov. 6, the Azeri opposition parties are playing up
that trend for all it is worth. But many of the opposition leaders
in Azerbaijan are every bit as corrupt and as much a part of the
old guard as the men they wish to replace. Many were involved in an
ill-fated 1992-93 government, almost universally condemned for chaos,
corruption and incompetence.
But the color revolutions have had an important influence, if not
domestically then externally.
For one thing, they have made it more difficult for Russia, still
the leading power in the region, and the United States, the remaining
world superpower, to collaborate, even when it is practical to do so.
The United States now faces a dilemma in dealing with the former
Soviet states with which it is friendly, including Azerbaijan. For
commercial and geopolitical reasons, Washington would obviously prefer
stability over chaos. But it can also no longer afford to be seen to
be propping up an unreformable kleptocracy.
Meanwhile, Moscow also would prefer stability instead of another
revolution in its own backyard.
For both, there are other complications. Iran, along the southern
Azeri border, is chief among them. There are 20 million to 25 million
ethnic Azeris in Iran, and the dominant religion in both nations is
Shiite Islam. Fundamentalism has started to surface in Azerbaijan’s
border areas, and there are reports that some theological schools
across the country are leaning toward Iranian-style militancy. In an
otherwise secular state, these are disturbing developments.
This must be disturbing Washington too. Rumors abound that it is
looking to redeploy military contingents from Uzbekistan, which has
asked the U.S. Army to vacate a military base there, to Azerbaijan,
including to one site close to the Iranian border.
Rumors also abound that Russia is redeploying troops formerly based
in Georgia to regions of Armenia that border Azerbaijan. Apart from
the historic enmity between Armenia and Azerbaijan over the disputed
territory of Nagorno-Karabakh, such movements could redraw the military
map of the entire region.
But is a U.S.-Russian rivalry in the area inevitable? The truth is
that Moscow and Washington have more interests in common than they
have in conflict, particularly with respect to Iran, which is a source
of even bigger worry to Russia than to the United States.
Intriguingly, in recent weeks, some members of the Russian media have
been playing up the disruptive influences in Azerbaijan of Wahhabi
militants. But Wahhabism is used as a catch-all term for all forms
of radical Islam, whether Sunni or Shiite.
There may well be some Wahhabi activists in Azerbaijan, especially
in the north, where Chechen and Dagestani refugees have settled. But
the real fundamentalist threat is overwhelmingly from the south,
from Iran. The Kremlin certainly knows this, but, for complex and
remarkably narrow commercial reasons — the sale of nuclear reactor
technology — it cannot bring itself to say so publicly.
And that, almost literally, is what is keeping Russia and the United
States from collaborating in Azerbaijan. In nearly all other matters
of consequence, their interests in Azerbaijan coincide: stability,
moderate reform, and even curbing corruption — since even Russian
companies like LUKoil must be finding the spiraling cost of graft
hard to manage.
There does not need to be a color revolution in Azerbaijan. There
does need to be fundamental change, bringing new young modernizers
into power and giving the rising middle class its say in the country’s
future.
But with Moscow eyeing the Americans with suspicion, and Washington
unable to rely on the Russians while facing Iran, Azerbaijan appears
headed unstoppably toward a less-than-promising future.
Ednan Agayev, an Azeri-born former senior Russian diplomat and
executive vice president of the Russian-American Business Council,
contributed this comment to The Moscow Times.