AAA: Assembly Welcomes Senate Legislation Opposing Railroad ThatBypa

Armenian Assembly of America
1140 19th Street, NW, Suite 600
Washington, DC 20036
Phone: 202-393-3434
Fax: 202-638-4904
Email: [email protected]
Web:
PRESS RELEASE
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
March 28, 2006
CONTACT: Christine Kojoian
E-mail: [email protected]
ASSEMBLY WELCOMES SENATE LEGISLATION OPPOSING RAILROAD THAT
BYPASSES ARMENIA
Measure Introduced During Assembly’s Pan-Armenian National Conference
Washington, DC – As Armenian Assembly activists stormed Capitol Hill
to promote community concerns to over 80 congressional offices today,
Senators Rick Santorum (R-PA) and Robert Menendez (D-NJ) introduced
a major bill (S. 2461) in the U.S. Senate that would bar assistance
for a proposed $800 million railway that would connect Azerbaijan,
Georgia and Turkey while bypassing Armenia.
The legislation, known as the South Caucasus Integration and Open
Railroads Act, was introduced shortly after participants of the
Assembly’s National Conference met with senior staff representing
Senators Santorum and Menendez – both longtime supporters of Armenian
issues. The three-day National Conference was co-hosted by the AGBU
and Eastern and Western Dioceses of the Armenian Church.
“United States policy in the South Caucasus seeks to foster regional
stability and enhanced cooperation, and includes open borders and
transport corridors,” Santorum told the Assembly. “The proposed rail
link would not only undermine U.S. long-term goals for the region,
but serves to isolate Armenia. Efforts to foster economic integration
and reduce the risk of further tensions are in the best interests of
the United States and the South Caucasus.”
Menendez, echoing Santorum, added that “the sole aim of this costly
project is to further isolate Armenia by enhancing the ongoing Turkish
and Azerbaijani blockades. I look forward to working with my colleagues
in the Senate and members of the Armenian-American community to block
U.S. financial support of this rail project.”
“We commend the leadership of Senators Santorum and Menendez for this
Senate initiative to prohibit funding for this ill-conceived route,
which not only thwarts U.S. policy goals, but is also a continuation
of Azerbaijan’s blockade plus strategy to marginalize Armenia, which
we cannot allow,” said Assembly Board of Trustees Chairman Hirair
Hovnanian. “The realization of this legislation is a testament to the
grassroots activism exemplified throughout this National Conference.”
Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev told an Azeri news agency last
summer that, “We are currently working on a new project – a new rail
road Kars-Akhalkalaki-Tbilisi-Baku..If we succeed with this project,
the Armenians will end in complete isolation, which would create an
additional problem for their future, their already bleak future…”
Armenian government officials have repeatedly said that a new costly
railway is unnecessary given that a railroad linking Armenia, Georgia
and Turkey already exists. The existing Kars-Gyumri route is in
working condition and could be operational within weeks.
Senator Santorum has consistently supported Armenian issues. He is a
strong proponent of U.S. reaffirmation of the Armenian Genocide and a
cosponsor of S. Res. 320, the Armenian Genocide resolution. In 2000, he
also urged the Senate Appropriations Subcommittee on Foreign Operations
to direct economic aid to Armenia, to provide the timely delivery of
humanitarian assistance to Nagorno Karabakh and maintain Section 907
of the Freedom Support Act. Santorum currently serves on the powerful
Senate Finance Committee and is Chairman of the Senate Republican
Conference where he directs the communications operations of the
Senate Republicans and is the third-ranking member of the leadership.
His colleague, Senator Menendez, is a longstanding advocate of the
Armenian-American community and a widely respected voice on foreign
policy. During his tenure in the House of Representatives, Menendez
helped secure robust U.S. humanitarian, technical and developmental
assistance for Armenia, while continuing to push for sustained
humanitarian aid to Nagorno Karabakh. Menendez has also repeatedly
fought for U.S. reaffirmation of the Armenian Genocide, by publicly
commemorating this crime against humanity, co-sponsoring legislation
that would properly recognize the events and urging President Bush,
as well as his predecessors, to accurately characterize the crimes
as genocide.
The Senate bill is modeled after House Resolution 3361, which was
introduced by Congressional Caucus on Armenian Issues Co-Chair
Joe Knollenberg (R-MI), along with Caucus Co-Chair Frank Pallone,
Jr. (D-NJ) and Rep. George Radanovich (R-CA), last year. The resolution
currently has 77 cosponsors to date, and is expected to garner
additional supporters following the Assembly’s advocacy push today.
The Armenian Assembly of America is the largest Washington-based
nationwide organization promoting public understanding and awareness of
Armenian issues. It is a 501(c)(3) tax-exempt membership organization.
NR#2006-024a
Photographs available on the Assembly’s Web site at the following
links:
ss/2006-024a/2006-024a-1.jpg
Caption: Senator Rick Santorum (R-PA)
4a/2006-024a-2.jpg
Caption: Senator Robert Menendez (D-NJ)

www.armenianassembly.org

Millennium Challenge Group Signs Eighth Compact, Third of 2006

U.S. DEPT OF STATE
28 March 2006
Millennium Challenge Group Signs Eighth Compact, Third of 2006
Aid agreement with Armenia calls for country to show more progress toward
democracy
By Kathryn McConnell
Washington File Staff Writer
Washington — The Millennium Challenge Corporation (MCC) March 27 signed its
eighth compact with a low-income country, committing more than $235 million
over five years to reduce poverty in rural Armenia.
The Armenian Millennium Challenge compact — or bilateral aid agreement —
is “affirmation of our confidence that Armenia will continue to enact the
institutional reforms that will support the effective use of our aid,”
including measures to protect electoral processes, John Danilovich, MCC
chief executive officer, said at a signing ceremony at the State Department.
However, Danilovich said, MCC will continue to monitor Armenia’s policy
reforms “throughout the life of the compact.”
Danilovich said that in April he would travel to Armenia with Jim Kolbe,
chairman of the House of Representatives Appropriations Subcommittee on
Foreign Operations and a supporter of the MCC. The two will meet with civil
society groups that will help monitor the use of Millennium Challenge
Account (MCA) funds so that benefits will go directly to the people the
Millennium Challenge projects were designed to help, Danilovich said.
MCC can withhold account payments if a recipient country fails to meet its
commitments to institute reforms, Danilovich said in a January letter to
Robert Kocharian, Armenia’s president.
CONCERNS ABOUT PAST ELECTORAL IRREGULARITIES
In December 2005, Danilovich wrote to Kocharian expressing concerns over
“irregularities” reported during a constitutional election the previous
month. (See related article.)
Parliamentary elections scheduled in 2007 and 2008, at which observers from
the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) will be
present, will be the “test” of progress in instituting “democratic
practices,” said Vartan Oskanian, Armenia’s minister of foreign affairs, at
the signing.
He said that just as economic development is a mechanism to foster
democratization, so too is democracy “a tool for further and deeper economic
development.”
“We know that corruption must not be tolerated and that law must rule,” and
that the principles of democracy must be “transformed to traditions of
democracy” in Armenia, he said.
INVESTING IN ARMENIA’S RURAL POPULATION
The Armenia compact consists of two investments to assist the portion of the
country’s population dependent on agriculture.
One investment will be targeted to improving the country’s rural roads so
residents will have access to health and other basic services and to markets
to sell their products.
Poor rural roads have kept Armenia’s farm-based residents from benefiting
from the increased foreign investment in the country — benefits that have
accrued mostly to residents of the capital, Yerevan, said Vartan Oskanian,
Armenia’s minister of foreign affairs.
The other investment is for an irrigation-and-drainage project that will
increase water supply to rural areas, and help farmers grow more high-value
crops and increase their yields, according to the MCC.
The Millennium Challenge Account compact is “the embodiment” of U.S.
“transformational democracy” because it will empower Armenian men and women
to better their own lives, to strengthen their own communities and to
transform their own future,” said Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice at the
signing. Rice serves as chairman of MCC’s board of directors. The MCC
administers MCA funds.
In the four years MCC has existed, it has awarded $1.5 billion to countries
that have demonstrated commitments to policy reforms.
In March 2005, slightly more than one year after MCC became operational; it
signed its first compact — with Madagascar. MCC signed four more compacts
in 2005 and so far has signed three compacts in 2006.
In addition, MCC has committed more than $100 million to help five
“threshold countries” develop compact proposals. These are countries that
demonstrate significant progress toward meeting the compact eligibility
criteria.
MCC uses 16 criteria to determine a country’s progress in the areas of
encouraging economic freedom, ruling justly and investing in people.
In 2006, MCC replaced the indicator of country credit rating with a new one,
the cost of starting a business, saying the latter measures policies that a
government can control.
MCC also is reviewing suggestions for a new indicator on natural resources
management, which is intended to ensure the environmental sustainability of
projects presented in compact proposals. (See related article.)
ELIGIBILITY CRITERIA
The MCC/MCA criteria are having an “incentive effect” on other low-income
countries wanting to become eligible for MCA funding by implementing new
reforms, according to the MCC.
MCC requires proposals to be developed through a comprehensive consultative
process involving all sectors of a country’s society, including
nongovernmental organizations (NGOs). (See related article.)
Compact recipients also have included NGOs in their MCC governing bodies
representing the beneficiaries of the program.
Even though many of the projects proposed by compact-eligible countries have
been in the agriculture and infrastructure sectors, MCC does not favor any
particular sector, but rather seeks proposals with a high rate of economic
return on investment and broad impact, according to MCC’s economic analysis
guidelines, updated in January.
The guidelines state that proposals must have “good supporting evidence”
that a project will be technically feasible and have “significant impact on
economic growth and poverty reduction.”
A transcript of the signing ceremony is available on the State Department
Web site.
For additional information, see the MCC Web site and Millennium Challenge
Account.
(The Washington File is a product of the Bureau of International Information
Programs, U.S. Department of State. Web site: )

Press Release: NSW Premier Welcomes Armenian Primate And Fellow NSWE

PRESS RELEASE
Diocese of the Armenian Church of Australia & New Zealand
10 Macquarie Street
Chatswood NSW 2067
AUSTRALIA
Contact: Laura Artinian
Tel: (02) 9419-8056
Fax: (02) 9904-8446
Email: [email protected]
29 March 2006
NSW PREMIER WELCOMES ARMENIAN PRIMATE AND FELLOW NSWEC DELEGATES
Sydney, Australia – Today, Premier of NSW, the Hon Morris Iemma MP
welcomed a delegation from the NSW Ecumenical Council that included
His Eminence Archbishop Aghan Baliozian (President NSWEC), Revd Dr
Ray Williamson (General Secretary NSWEC), Most Rev Michael Malone
(Roman Catholic Church) and Revd Dr Ann Wansborough (Uniting Church).
The delegates met with the Premier to extend congratulations on his
appointment and to better acquaint the Premier on the function and
role of the NSW Ecumenical Council. During the course of discussions
points concerning the church were raised with particular focus on
harmony in the community.
The NSWEC is comprised of sixteen member churches throughout the
state of New South Wales and the Australian Capital Territory.
In the words of General Secretary Revd Dr Ray Williamson, “Being
together ecumenically is an expression of those churches’ commitment
to seek a more complete communion with one another on the journey to
rediscovering the visible unity of the Church. Being together also
enables the churches to express a common voice on issues of concern
in society, and to work together on specific projects which touch
upon both the life of the churches and the needs of people in the
wider community.”
Other than theological reflection in a forum of member churches,
the NSWEC also undertakes a number of local initiatives ranging from
social justice, work in aid and development, and assisting refugees
with settlement.

MFA of Armenia: Minister Oskanian concluded two-day working visit to

MINISTRY OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS OF THE REPUBLIC OF ARMENIA
—————————————— —-
PRESS AND INFORMATION DEPARTMENT
375010 Telephone: +37410. 544041 ext 202
Fax: +37410. 562543
Email: [email protected]
PRESS RELEASE
28-03-2006
Minister Vartan Oskanian concluded two-day working visit to
Washington DC
Minister Vartan Oskanian concluded meetings with officials at the
US State Department, on the second day of a two-day working visit to
Washington DC.
In addition to delivering a statement at the signing of the
Millennium Challenge Compact on Monday, March 27, Minister Oskanian
held meetings with Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, Daniel Fried,
Assistant Secretary for the Bureau of European and Eurasian Affairs,
and Matthew Bryza, Deputy Assistant Secretary of State for European
and Eurasian Affairs.
In each meeting, the Minister and US officials discussed bilateral
issues including economic and democratic assistance programs. They
also discussed regional matters, including energy security and
diversification.
Prospects for the negotiation process and the settlement of the Nagorno
Karabakh conflict was also on the agenda. In addition, that was the
focus of a meeting between the Minister and Ambassador Steven Mann,
Minsk Group US co-chair. Minister Oskanian reiterated Armenia’s
readiness to pursue a negotiated resolution.

www.armeniaforeignministry.am

MFA of Armenia: Ambassador Hrach Silvanian Presents his Credentials

MINISTRY OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS OF THE REPUBLIC OF ARMENIA
—————————————— —-
PRESS AND INFORMATION DEPARTMENT
375010 Telephone: +37410. 544041 ext 202
Fax: +37410. 562543
Email: [email protected]
PRESS RELEASE
29-03-2006
Hrach Silvanian, Newly-Appointed Ambassador of the Republic of Armenia
to Georgia, Presents his Credentials
On March 28, Hrach Silvanian, newly-appointed ambassador of the
Republic of Armenia to Georgia, presented his credentials to Mikheil
Saakashvili, President of Georgia.
During the friendly conversation that followed the ceremony, the two
discussed the prospects of bilateral relations development.

www.armeniaforeignministry.am

Antelias: The Armenian Catholicosate of Cilicia participates in theM

Press Release
Catholicosate of Cilicia
Communication and Information Department
Contact: V.Rev.Fr.Krikor Chiftjian, Communications Officer
Tel: (04) 410001, 410003
Fax: (04) 419724
E-mail: [email protected]
Web:
PO Box 70 317
Antelias-Lebanon
Armenian version:
THE CATHOLICOSATE OF CILICIA PARTICIPATES IN THE ANNUAL MEETING OF
THE MECC EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE
The annual meeting of the Middle East Council of Churches’ (MECC)
Executive Committee was held on March 23-24 in the social service
center of the Coptic Church of Cairo.
Archbishop Sebouh Sarkissian (Primate of the Diocese of Tehran)
and Bishop Kegham Khatcherian (Primate of the Diocese of Lebanon)
participated in the meeting on behalf of the Armenian Orthodox Church
(the Catholicosate of Cilicia), one of the four families of churches
comprising the MECC.
The attendants listened to and discussed report presented by the
General Secretary of the MECC, reports presented by the Council’s
Muslim-Christian Dialogue department, Life and Service department,
Human Rights and Justice-Peace departments, as well as reports
prepared by the MECC units on Faith and Unity, Education, Refugees,
Communication and Seminaries.
The participants focused mainly on the financial report of the Council
and proposed spending with care the money granted to the Council
by charity organizations, particularly in light of the economic
difficulties the current world faces.
They once more examined carefully the proposals of His Holiness Aram
I for the imperative need to reorganize the Council’s mission and work.
Archbishop Sebouh had a private meeting with His Holiness Pope Shenouda
III and discussed with him ecumenical issues on behalf of His Holiness
Aram I.
##
The Armenian Catholicosate of Cilicia is one of the two Catholicosates
of the Armenian Orthodox Church. For detailed information about the
Ecumenical activities of the Cilician Catholicosate, you may refer
to the web page of the Catholicosate, The
Cilician Catholicosate, the administrative center of the church is
located in Antelias, Lebanon.

Antelias: COMMUNIQUE (No.:1) – “Culture of Cilicia

Press Release
Catholicosate of Cilicia
Communication and Information Department
Contact: V.Rev.Fr.Krikor Chiftjian, Communications Officer
Tel: (04) 410001, 410003
Fax: (04) 419724
E-mail: [email protected]
Web:
PO Box 70 317
Antelias-Lebanon
Armenian version:
COMM UNIQUE (? 1)
“Culture of Cilician Armenia”
International Conference in Antelias
“Culture of Cilician Armenia” International Conference will take place
January 18-20, 2007, in Antelias-Lebanon by the initiation and under
patronage of His Holiness Catholicos Aram I, in cooperation with the
Catholicosate of the Great House of Cilicia and Yerevan Mashtots
Matenadaran.
The Conference will cover the following areas:
1.. History: History of culture of the Armenian Kingdom of Cilicia:
geopolitical, inter-political and inter-church relations.
2.. Medieval Armenian Universities: The influence of Cilician scriptoria
in the development of Armenian literature and scripture art. Medieval
universities and their cooperation.
3.. Law: Medieval law and Cilician Constitution. Inter-state and
inter-church relations and the aspect of law. Right to heritage and medieval
social relations.
4.. Art: Miniature, applied arts, architecture: monasteries, fortresses,
secular constructions.
5.. Ethnography: Cilician national ceremonies, holidays, dresses, life and
traditions.
6.. Cilician Holy Relics: Relics of Saints brought to Antelias from
Cilicia.
7.. Economy: Cilician money, Cilician trade relations, scales and measure
units, Cilician marine and soil trade ways.
8.. Summery: Cilician phenomenon after the fall of the Armenian Kingdom of
Cilicia.
For more information about the Conference you may visit the following
sites: and or write to the
following addresses:
Arshak Banuchyan, Yerevan Bishop Nareg Alemezian, Antelias
Tel: (+374 10) 56 27 69 Tel: (+961 4) 410001
Fax: (+374 10) 52 04 20 Fax: (+961 4) 417971
E-mail: [email protected] E-mail: [email protected]
[email protected]
Organi zing Committee
##
The Armenian Catholicosate of Cilicia is one of the two Catholicosates of
the Armenian Orthodox Church. For detailed information about the history and
mission of the Cilician Catholicosate, you may refer to the web page of the
Catholicosate, The Cilician Catholicosate, the
administrative center of the church is located in Antelias, Lebanon.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

35 New Deacons Ordained in Holy Etchmiadzin

PRESS RELEASE
Mother See of Holy Etchmiadzin, Information Services
Address: Vagharshapat, Republic of Armenia
Contact: Rev. Fr. Ktrij Devejian
Tel: (374 10) 517 163
Fax: (374 10) 517 301
E-Mail: [email protected]
March 29, 2006
35 New Deacons Ordained in Holy Etchmiadzin
This year on the 23rd of February – the Feast of Sts. Vartanants, 35
young graduates of the Gevorkian Theological Seminary were ordained to
the diaconate during the celebration of Divine Liturgy in the Mother
See of All Armenians. His Holiness Karekin II, Supreme Patriarch and
Catholicos of All Armenians, presided during the liturgy which was
celebrated by His Eminence Archbishop Nerses Bozabalian.
As has become a tradition, the “Feast of St. Vartan the Commander and
His Companions” is celebrated with great pageantry in Holy Etchmiadzin,
as it is one of the most loved feasts of the Armenian nation. The
highlight of the day is the service of ordination which takes place
in the Mother Cathedral. In some years the ordinations are to the
priesthood, and in others, as in this year, they are to the diaconate.
This year’s celebrations resulted in 35 new deacons who joined
the ranks of the Brotherhood of Holy Etchmiadzin as its youngest
members. This was the first time in the modern history of the Armenian
Church that such a large number of young men have been ordained all
at once.
In recent years on this day, Armenians worldwide celebrate the
naming day of the Armenian Pontiff, His Holiness Karekin II. At the
conclusion of Divine Liturgy, a special Pontifical Blessing service
was offered before the Holy Altar of Descent of the Mother Cathedral,
whereby the faithful joined with the class of clergy in raising their
prayers to heaven, wishing His Holiness a long, productive reign,
a healthy and fruitful life, and unshakeable strength and prosperity
for the Mother See of Holy Etchmiadzin.
Among the countless faithful, were hundreds of soldiers from the Armed
Forces of the Republic of Armenia, who had come with their commanding
officers to participate in the Divine Liturgy. His Holiness blessed
the servicemen, calling them the new “Vartans” of our day, asking
that God grant them faith, willpower and a spirit of victory.
##
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Daniel Fried, Assistant Secretary of State at American Assembly ofAm

U.S. Department of State
HomeAssistance Programs (Armenian Version)AnnouncementsConsularPublic
AffairsCurrent IssuesDemocracy ProgramsContacts
Daniel Fried, Assistant Secretary of State
American Assembly of America National Conference
March 27, 2006
Ambassador Fried: Thank you for that kind introduction.
I have the disadvantage of having to follow my friend Vartan [Oskanian,
the foreign minister]. That is a real disadvantage because he’s very
very good.
A good interlocutor, a good friend. Most of the time we agree. When
he disagrees, I am reminded by just how good he is. [Laughter].
It’s a pleasure to be here at the national conference, and I was
happy to accept the invitation from the Assembly and the Armenian
General Benevolent Union and the Eastern and Western Diocese of the
Armenian Church, one of the great ancient churches of Christendom,
to speak to you today. And I understand that this conference is held
in partnership with at least 15 other Armenian-American organizations
and others are in attendance. But let me say in particular that I
value my years of cooperation with the Assembly, and I appreciate
its leadership’s professionalism and their [inaudible] commitment as
Americans to work with us to support democratic and prosperous Armenia.
Now it’s true that we don’t agree on all issues and the Assembly can
be just as frank, which is a diplomatic word — [Laughter] — just as
frank as they have to be in expressing that. But as Americans it’s not
only your right, it’s your duty to speak out to your government when
you agree and when you disagree. That’s never gotten in the way of
our partnership. I appreciate the candid advice from the Assembly and
from the American Armenian community, and I look forward to hearing
more of it. It’s good to hear straight out what’s on your minds,
what you like about what we’re doing, what you don’t like about what
we’re doing. That’s the way a real partnership is made.
I’ve just come back from a visit to Yerevan, and I have to say that it
is beautiful to see a city with Mount Ararat floating in the distance,
the mountains, the snow, and spring just beginning to come to Yerevan.
[Applause].
As Americans, you should be proud that our new embassy compound
is up and running. It’s a physical embodiment of our commitment
to Armenia. It shows that we have put in the money to reflect our
political will to see that Armenia prospers in the 21st Century as
a free country, secure and democratic. [Applause].
While I was in Yerevan I had the privilege of meeting with President
Kocharian, with Vartan Foreign Minister Oskanian, with the Defense
Minister Sargsian, and with political leaders, including leaders of
the opposition.
That’s what we do when we go abroad in the State Department. We meet
with everyone. And we had serious talks. We talked about regional
security, which as you know means Nagorno-Karabakh, relations with
Turkey, Azerbaijan, and Georgia. We talked about strengthening the
economy and promoting democratic reform. And I want to say a few words
about those issues today and talk about key topics that I think are
of interest to you.
President Bush’s new National Security Strategy says that it is the
policy of the United States to seek and support democratic movements
and institutions in every nation and culture. Your efforts here and
your efforts in Armenia, to help Armenia democratize and prosper
economically, matched with U.S. efforts and hopes for the country,
and I thank you for them.
I also thank you because in areas of business transparency the
Armenian-American community is leading by example. I thank you for
that as well.
Now this is a good day in U.S.-Armenian relations. Today the United
States and Armenia will sign its Millennium Challenge Cooperation
Compact. That is a new assistance agreement for $235 million, and that
is new money for Armenia. It is a testament to Armenia’s progress
and its commitment to do more on good governance, economic freedom,
and investment in its people.
Much remains to be done and no community is more aware of the
challenges, as well as the progress, as the Armenian-American
community.
The challenge to sustain Armenia’s status as an MCC recipient is
allowing voters to independently and freely choose their leaders
through elections that meet international democratic standards. We’re
looking at the parliamentary and presidential elections next year
and in 2008 as key tests.
We hope that Armenia is moving in that direction.
We are building and taking at face value assurances from the
government, and with our own election strategy geared to work with
both the government and the Armenian civil society to try and achieve
this goal. We must achieve this goal to sustain our relations.
We believe that Armenia has the potential to be a leader in the
region by showing progress on democratic reforms to keep pace with
its economic expansion.
Let me turn to an issue that is much on our minds at the State
Department and perhaps on yours, which is Nagorno-Karabakh. A solution
to Nagorno-Karabakh remains a key focus. Obviously, and I don’t need to
tell you this, a resolution would open the door to large investment,
deeper integration with the global economy, peace will bring greater
prosperity.
Now we were hopeful last month that the meeting at Rambouillet between
the Presidents of Armenia and Azerbaijan would move us decisively
forward. We were disappointed that it didn’t happen, but we did not
give up, we did not turn away.
Before I went to Yerevan, I went to Baku and met with President
Aliyev. I was sufficiently encouraged by what he said that I went
to Yerevan for further discussions, and based on the help and sound
thinking of the Armenian side, there is a possibility for progress
in 2006. Now this is not easy. Neither side can or will achieve its
maximum aims. Peace will require solutions that meet both sides’
concerns as much as possible. And both Armenia and Azerbaijan must
prepare for a good settlement, and the best can be the enemy of
the good.
The United States is not going to impose a settlement. We’re not
going to force Armenia or Azerbaijan to take anything. We don’t have
that power, and it is not our intention to try to exercise it. But
it is our intention to support a solution if both governments arrive
at it, and if there is a solution we are going to get behind it. If
the government of Armenia agrees to it, we will support them, and I
hope you do as well.
Now we hope, but also anticipate, that a solution on Nagorno-Karabakh
will result in an open border with Turkey, which is a consistent goal
on our agenda with Ankara. From Yerevan, I went to Ankara and I made
this point with the Turkish government that we want the border open,
and we want it open as soon as possible. [Applause].
This has not been easy for Armenia, but even with closed borders to
the east and west, Armenia has a northern border that is open to it
through Georgia, and Armenia’s economic growth is strong. Almost
14 percent last year, which is the fourth straight year of double
digit growth. Construction is up 34 percent, and you can see it when
you’re in Yerevan. We know that your community is helping fuel this
construction boom.
Agriculture is growing, 11 percent last year. Industrial production
is growing, and inflation remains low.
The Armenian government has increased its ability to collect
taxes. That and corporate taxes which increases government revenues
which helps provide better services and the infrastructure for yet
more growth in a virtuous cycle. We’re seeing an increase in Armenian
government expenditure, on education, science, and health. This
investment in citizens will help bring a good future for Armenia.
The U.S.-Armenian relationship is continuing to deepen and our
economic support is continuing. Since independence, the United States
has contributed more than $1.5 billion of assistance. That’s quite
a bit of money for a country the size of Armenia. And many in the
Armenian-American community have also made substantial financial
contributions to, and investments in, Armenia as well.
Our assistance program, well much of it, is aimed at promoting economic
reform to help create the conditions for Armenians to continue their
economic growth in the best possible way.
There’s more work to do. Tax collection is up, but you know better
than I do how much of the economy remains underground. Corruption
is a serious problem. Corruption is a tax on the poor and a tax on
honest entrepreneurs.
That is a drag. An economy saddled with corruption is moving forward
with lead weights tied to each leg.
We want to see greater economic integration between Armenia and
Georgia and Armenia and all the states of the Caucasus. We push
this regularly, and I did so when I was in Baku. We would like
to see greater integration. Now it is difficult in advance of a
Nagorno-Karabakh solution, but we keep raising it, and we will keep
raising it. It’s good not only for Armenia; it would be good for
Turkey and Azerbaijan as well.
Let me talk about regional security and military assistance. We
do support Armenia’s efforts to strengthen its relations with the
Euro-Atlantic community. Armenia has a policy of complementarity,
which means roughly balance in its relations with the West and the
Russians. This is not a problem for us. We don’t want to force Armenia
to choose between its historic friends and its Western identity, but
we do want our relations to grow. We do want our relations to grow,
and we don’t want barriers put in the way.
Our relations in the security field have grown. We value and appreciate
Armenia’s troop contributions in Iraq. There are 46 non-combatant
soldiers serving there now. There are 34 Armenian peacekeepers in
Kosovo. And we hope that Armenia will continue to do its part through
NATO’s Partnership for Peace to contribute to other operations in
the future.
Armenia has increased its cooperation with NATO. The government
is reforming its military in cooperation with the U.S. to make it
more interoperable with NATO. Armenia is pursuing what NATO calls
an individual partnership action plan with NATO. This is basically a
chapeau that lets the Armenian military slowly but as fast as Armenia
wants, grow closer to NATO so we can work together.
Frankly, I want to express my appreciation for the Assembly’s
encouragement last year to Armenia to complete its defense
assessment. That cleared the way for deeper security cooperation
between our two countries.
Now I know that some in your community, in the Armenian-American
community, are concerned about U.S.-Azerbaijani military relations,
so let me address this straight up. The fact is Azerbaijan has
made contributions to the War on Terror and these contributions —
overflight rights, access to Azerbaijani bases, information sharing,
law enforcement cooperation — are useful. Now Azerbaijan faces
security threats not from Armenia, and when I was in Baku I repeated
that Azerbaijan’s security problem really doesn’t come from Armenia,
it comes from other countries. It’s got a rough neighbor to the south,
Iran. And it’s on the Caspian Sea with a lot of oil and gas.
Our security cooperation with and assistance to Azerbaijan is meant
to improve Azerbaijan’s posture against those threats, not against
Armenia. I repeat. Not against Armenia.
President Bush has noted that to succeed in our own efforts, we need
the support of our efforts to fight terrorism, we need the support and
actions of friends and allies. We must join with others to deny the
terrorists what they seek, which is safe haven, financial support,
and the support and protection certain nation states historically
have given them. So we do need to work with all the countries of the
region on a counter-terrorist agenda.
But our assistance to Azerbaijan does not undermine our support for
Armenian security, and it is not designed and will not be used for
offensive purposes against Armenia. So we design our programs with
Azerbaijan very carefully.
Counter-narcotics, counter-terrorism, programs to counter trafficking
in weapons of mass destruction.
Now let me mention a couple of words about energy security. In
January of this year, disruptions of electricity and gas to Georgia
affected Armenia, as well. After this episode, we’re looking at ways to
bolster energy security in the region and strengthen Armenia’s energy
independence. The key to doing this is to support market forces, to
diversify energy supplies, and avoid monopolistic restrictions. We’ve
been discussing this in NATO, we’ve been discussing this in the
European Union and with key countries in the region. We will continue
to look at ways in which the United States can support energy security
for all the countries of the south Caucasus.
We are concerned by increased energy ties with Iran, and so we’re
looking at alternatives. We’ve talked to the Georgians about them.
Now let me conclude with discussion of a tough issue for all of
us. April 24th is less than a month away. I’m not going to duck
this issue.
The U.S. position on events of 1915 has not changed. We believe that a
productive dialogue is the best way to establish a shared understanding
of history that honors the victims of these horrific events, murders
on a mass scale, killings without justification, deportations. Over
1.5 million people lost their lives, innocent victims. But we want to
foster reconciliation and peace based on an understanding of history,
not a denial of it. We believe that the tragedy of 1915, the killings,
is of enormous human significance and its historical assessment should
be determined not on the basis of politics, but introspection among
civic leaders and scholars.
This process has begun in Turkey where it needs to take place.
Now I know from experience and consultations with the Assembly and
other groups that the Armenian American community has a different view,
and I expect that you will express that view, and that is not for
us — I would be surprised if you didn’t, and I welcome the dialogue
we’ve established.
[Applause].
Voice: Horse manure.
Voices: Be quiet. Sit down.
Ambassador Fried: I will value even frank comments, but — [Laughter].
Hopefully a dialogue can be serious.
Sitting here with us is my old friend John Evans, our Ambassador
in Yerevan.
He is the Ambassador, remains the Ambassador, has — [Applause and
cheers].
Like all of us, we all serve at the pleasure of the
President. Ambassador Evans came from Yerevan for the signing of
the Millennium Challenge Account Compact this afternoon, and will
be in the meeting this afternoon between Secretary Rice and Foreign
Minister Oskanian. There has been a great deal of speculation. I
don’t discuss personnel issues, but since my friend is sitting here,
I thought I would recognize Ambassador John Evans. [Applause].
Now I gather there will be some time to take questions. I wouldn’t
be surprised by a frank exchange. [Laughter]. That doesn’t bother me.
I appreciate the chance to meet with you and have a discussion of
all issues, whether we agree or disagree. America is a free country,
and I’m here to listen and to answer your questions the best I can.
Thank you for your attention. I’m glad to see that people were paying
attention. [Laughter]. [Applause].
Moderator: Thank you, Ambassador Fried. You said in Armenia and the
capital of Turkey that Armenians and Turks need to have courage on
the issue. The United States has to have courage on the issue of the
Armenian genocide. [Applause]. And that ambiguity out there in terms
of denial, curriculum that is trying to be inserted in classrooms
around this country, our government needs to be very clear about
their role and mission on this issue.
Your first question: As the U.S. and EU applies increasing pressure
on Iran with the prospects of confrontation grows, will the
U.S. take concrete steps to ensure Armenia’s security and economic
stability? Will the U.S.
guarantee that the border with Turkey will be open before there is
conflict with Iran or potential conflict with Iran that would risk
a border closing?
Ambassador Fried: That’s a fair question, but I don’t have to yet
accept the premise that we are headed for a military confrontation with
Iran because we are now focused on achieving a diplomatic solution
to the problem of Iran’s nuclear weapons ambitions. We are not going
through the motions, we are serious about this. We do not believe
that Iran is North Korea. We do not believe that Iran thrives on
isolation. Iranian society does not want to be shunned by the world
and its leaders to not reflect the consensus in that society, as far as
we can tell. So I believe that our diplomatic efforts can bear fruit.
However, to be responsive to the question, we will continue to have a
serious discussion with Armenia as our thinking develops. And as John
Evans can tell you, this issue came up in our discussions a week and
a half ago in Yerevon. We will continue to work with Armenia to make
sure that its security is part of our thinking and integrated into our
thinking. Can I guarantee that the border with Turkey will be open? I
can’t guarantee that, and to say that I could would not be honest. But
I can say that we take Armenia’s security seriously. Armenia didn’t
choose its neighborhood, but there you are. [Laughter].
We will continue to work to see to it that Armenia is not vulnerable,
particularly on energy issues. And I did have explicit discussions in
Ankara about a future in which Armenia, in which gas and oil flowed
freely through Armenia from the Caspian without political hindrance,
so we are beginning this dialogue.
Moderator: I’m sure you imagine I’m getting a few questions on
Armenian genocide.
Ambassador Fried: I imagine. [Laughter].
Moderator: Why are third parties permitted to dictate America’s
foreign policy vis-à-vis Armenia and Cyprus?
Ambassador Fried: Third parties are not permitted to dictate our
foreign policy, nor do they dictate our foreign policy. We have a
policy which many of you disagree with. I understand. But we have a
policy of seeking to encourage Turkey to reflect more seriously about
subjects which have been taboo for generations in that country. I
said earlier that process has begun in Turkey. You recall that the
famous Turkish writer Orhan Pamuk spoke clearly about this. He is
not the only Turk speaking out. As I said, this process has begun
as Turkish society modernizes, and as it modernizes, as democracy
in Turkey deepens, Turkey will have to go through what many other
countries such as the United States have had to go through in our
own history, which is looking back at the darker spots in our past.
With respect to the United States, those darker spots include things
like slavery and racial discrimination, treatment of American Indians,
and in my opinion, internment of American citizens of Japanese origin
in camps in World War II. Those are painful subjects. Just as dealing
with the history of the mass killings of Armenians is painful for
Turkey. And by the way, I say this to my Turkish friends using the
same words. We keep one set of books.
Now that process has begun in Turkey. It is certainly not going fast
enough to satisfy you. It is not going fast enough to satisfy us. But
this process has begun and it will, I hope, bring greater understanding
to Turks of their own history.
We will continue to have a dialogue about this as April 24th
approaches. I will not attempt to anticipate what the President will
say. I do believe he will issue a statement on April 24th, in fact
I can’t believe there won’t be one. And I expect, as we have in the
past, to consult with the Armenian Assembly about this and to have
a frank set of discussions before and after.
Moderator: How will the U.S. deal with Azerbaijan regarding,
or how will it take to task, regarding the issue of the Armenian
historical landmarks of the Cemetery of Djulfa that was destroyed by
the Azerbaijanis?
Ambassador Fried: When I go to Baku and when U.S. officials go
to Baku, we always raise issues of living — Not just issues of
Nagorno-Karabakh, but issues of long-term peace in the south
provinces. Now I would be happy to raise issues of Armenian
historical sites in Azerbaijan. These historical sites, regardless
of differences over Nagorno-Karabakh, need to be respected and need
to be protected. This is a universal policy of the United States,
and I look forward to hearing from you about some of these sites so
that we can raise it with the Azerbaijani government. [Applause].
Moderator: How does the U.S. policy of promoting freedom and democracy
fit into your policy towards resolution of the Nagorno-Karabakh
conflict?
Especially considering the democratic will of Nagorno-Karabakh to
remain free?
Ambassador Fried: I don’t want to get into the details of the
shape of settlements under discussion. There is nothing worse than
negotiating in public. But the philosophic premise behind the question
is a good one and a fair one. That is how much weight do you give
self-determination, which is clearly a factor at stake here? How
much weight do you give issues of territorial integrity? And how much
weight do you give to well, facts on the ground? All right? Now that
is a difficult issue.
In my view, it is probably a mistake to try to apply rigid precedents
to all similar issues. Nagorno-Karabakh is not the same as Kosovo,
which is not the same as Abkhazia, which is not the same as
Chechnya. These issues are individual, and they need to be handled
individually. We are well aware that the will of the people of
Nagorno-Karabakh has to be respected.
[Applause]. We are also aware that there are issues of territorial
integrity and the challenge that we all face that Foreign Minister
Oskanian and Foreign Minister Mammadyarov and those involved in trying
to help an agreement, have to deal with all of these issues. And I
am convinced that there can be solutions at hand.
I don’t know when they will come about, but I think that 2006 is a
good window for them, and I don’t think that the people of Armenia,
Nagorno-Karabakh, or Azerbaijan deserve to live forever in a state
of uncertainty.
Moderator: Why does real politik trump the moral position in
recognizing the genocide, more in the U.S. than in France? If the
U.S. wants to foster reconciliation and peace in the region it’s true
that introspection needs to be fostered within Turkey. With Turkey’s
export of denialist tactics can peace and truth really be achieved? And
specifically if you could comment on a federal lawsuit in Massachusetts
currently that denialist material be put into the genocide curriculum.
Ambassador Fried: I can’t comment about the lawsuit. The United States
government has never denied the events of 1915. We do not support,
what was the phrase, export of denialist literature or positions. We
do support efforts by Turkey to deal with its history more seriously.
As I said, this process has begun. It has not ended. Efforts such
as the Truth and Reconciliation Commission were serious, and these
were efforts in which Turkish, as well as Armenian scholars, were
involved. It produced a serious look at those issues which we have
recognized officially.
This is not an easy issue. It is not an easy issue for the United
States government, and we are not at the end of the road on this
issue. We will continue to urge our Turkish friends to face difficult
issues of their past seriously, and we will urge Armenia to help the
Turks make this possible without ever sacrificing historical truth
or your position.
Now that is not an entirely satisfactory position for your community,
but again, I value the advice and input and even the criticism from
the Armenian American community and it [inaudible].
Moderator: Is there any truth to reports in the Atlantic Monthly that
the U.S. is upgrading the Baku air bases for potential airstrikes
on Iran?
Ambassador Fried: No. [Laughter].
Moderator: What is your position on recent reports that Ambassador
Evans is being recalled because of his statements last year on the
Armenian genocide issue?
Ambassador Fried: We all serve at the pleasure of the President. I
won’t discuss personnel issues. Ambassador Evans, as I said, is
a friend of more than 20 years standing. He’s our Ambassador. He’s
right here. He will be in the meetings today at the State Department,
as I said. [Applause].
Moderator: Thank you, Ambassador Fried, for this very frank
discussion, as always, and we thank you all for your attention and
for participating. Thank you very much. [Applause].
–Boundary_(ID_+kdV7FEUi13o6V+m1oh71A )–

Lecture: Why Genocide: How can we Understand the Turkish Deportation

PRESS RELEASE
ARPA Institute
18106 Miranda St.
Tarzana, CA 91356
Contact: Hagop Panossian
Tel: (818) 586-9660
E-mail: [email protected]
Web:
ARPA Institute presents the Lecture/Seminar:”Why Genocide: How can
we Understand the Turkish Deportations and Massacres of the Ottoman
Armenians,” by Ronald Grigor Suny, Ph.D., on Friday, April 14, 2006
at 7:30 PM in the Merdinian school auditorium.
The Address is 13330 Riverside Dr., Sherman Oaks, CA 91403.
Directions: on the 101 FWY exit on Woodman, go north and turn right
on Riverside Dr.
Abstract: Genocide is ultimately a crime of hatred initiated by a
few and carried out by the many.
Scholars have tried to explain the causes of the Armenian Genocide by
reference to religious differences between Armenians and Turks or the
racist nationalist ideology of the Young Turks and their ambitions
to create a “Turkey for the Turks.”
Professor Suny looks at the variety of explanations that have been
offered and suggests that in order to understand “why genocide” it
is necessary to supplement ideological and social explanations with
an exploration of the emotions involved.
RONALD GRIGOR SUNY is Charles Tilly Collegiate Professor of Social and
Political History at the University of Michigan, and Professor Emeritus
of Political Science and History at the University of Chicago. A
graduate of Swarthmore College and Columbia University, he taught
at Oberlin College (1968-1981), as visiting professor of history at
the University of California, Irvine (1987), and Stanford University
(1995-1996). He was the first holder of the Alex Manoogian Chair in
Modern Armenian History at the University of Michigan (1981-1995),
where he founded and directed the Armenian Studies Program.
He is the author of 1. The Baku Commune, 1917-1918; 2.
Armenia in the Twentieth Century; 3. The Making of the Georgian Nation;
4. Looking Toward Ararat: 5. Armenia in Modern History; 6. The Revenge
of the Past; and 7.
The Soviet Experiment. Editor of Transcaucasia, Nationalism and Social
Change: and The Structure of Soviet History; and co-editor of Party,
State, and Society in the Russian Civil War; The Russian Revolution
and Bolshevik Victory; Making Workers Soviet; Becoming National;
Intellectuals and the Articulation of the Nation; and A State of
Nations.
Professor Suny has served as chairman of the Society for Armenian
Studies and on the editorial Boards of Slavic Review, International
Labor and Working-Class History, International Journal of Middle East
Studies, The Armenian Review, Journal of the Society for Armenian
Studies, and Armenian Forum. He has appeared numerous times on the
McNeil-Lehrer News Hour, CBS Evening News, CNN, and National Public
Radio, and has written for the New York Times, The Washington Post,
The Los Angeles Times, The Nation, New Left Review, Dissent, and
other newspapers and journals. He was recently elected President of
the American Association for the Advancement of Slavic Studies (2006).
For information please call Dr. Hagop Panossian at(818)586-9660
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress