“The Children Of Gyumri”

“THE CHILDREN OF GYUMRI”
Victoria Dalkey, Bee art correspondent
Sacramento Bee (California)
March 31, 2006 Friday
Metro Final Edition
Coffee Works
“The Children of Gyumri,” a remarkable show of artwork by students at
the Gyumri Aesthetic Center in Armenia, presents vibrant and joyful
images of brides, princesses, circuses, zoos and other delights. The
center, a school and orphanage, offers classes in drawing, painting
and carpet weaving to students ages 4 to 20 in an area of Armenia that
was devastated by an earthquake in 1988. All proceeds from sales of
the works will benefit the center and the children and teachers who
work, live and learn there. The show will be up through April 30 at
Coffee Works, 3418 Folsom Blvd. (916) 452-1086.

Remark Raises Debate On Envoy To Armenia

REMARK RAISES DEBATE ON ENVOY TO ARMENIA
by Michael Doyle Bee Washington Bureau
Fresno Bee (California)
March 29, 2006 Wednesday
FINAL EDITION
Ambassador John Evans is unfailingly diplomatic about his fate as
the plain-speaking U.S. envoy to Armenia.
Others, including California lawmakers and Armenian-American activists,
are more blunt.
Unhappy lawmakers and activists contend Evans is being forced from his
post because he conceded last year that the term “Armenian genocide”
appropriately described the slaughter of Armenians between 1915 and
1923. His potential career problem is that the State Department and
the government of Turkey do not accept the term.
On Tuesday, sounding as if he were reciting carefully prepared talking
points, Evans spoke delicately about his current status.
“I am still the ambassador,” Evans said in a brief interview during
a Washington visit. “I have not submitted my retirement papers.”
At the same time, the career foreign service officer underscored the
temporary nature of any diplomatic posting. In June, he will have
served in Armenia for two years — and he also will have reached the
35-year mark in the State Department.
“No ambassador stays forever,” Evans said, twice.
A Yale graduate who speaks four foreign languages and is studying
Eastern Armenian, Evans is the subject of considerable speculation
by politically active Armenian-Americans and their congressional
champions. Ever since rumors began several weeks ago that Evans was
to be recalled or otherwise disciplined, interest groups and lawmakers
with large Armenian-American constituencies have been weighing in.
Most recently, Rep. George Radanovich, R-Mariposa, has called the
State Department to request a meeting. It has not yet been scheduled.
Other lawmakers, too, have been increasing the pressure. At least
three members of Congress, including Democratic Reps. Adam Schiff,
D-Pasadena, and Grace Napolitano, D-Santa Fe Springs, have leveled
written blasts at the State Department.
“I do not believe it is possible for any ambassador to Armenia to
function with any credibility if he does not recognize the genocide,”
Rep. Frank Pallone, D-N.J., wrote Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice
on March 10. “It is simply wrong for the State Department to punish
Ambassador Evans for statements he made that are factually correct.”
The reporter can be reached at [email protected] or (202)
383-0006.

New Digs For Metallon

NEW DIGS FOR METALLON
Julie Bain reports that Mzi Khumalo has operations in ex-Soviet states
cle.aspx?ID=ST6A175704
02 April 2006
METALLON Gold, which has had its fair share of troubles in recent
months, is expanding into a number of former Soviet states.
Andile Reve, chief executive of Metallon Corporation, which controls
the Metallon group of companies, said mining had started at one of
the company’s two prospects in Armenia just a few days ago.
“Profit for 12 months’ production of about 60000 ounces is put at
$12-million to $15-million,” he said.
The open-pit mine is about 300km from Yerevan, the Armenian capital.
Exploration at a second prospect is under way and Reve said Metallon
could prove up a resource of about one million payable ounces in
eight to 10 months.
“We are very excited. After the reserves are proved we will make a
decision on whether to take [these projects] to market,” he said.
Metallon Gold also has a prospect in Georgia, where further exploration
work is being carried out, and it is looking at a prospect in
Kazakhstan.
Last month Metallon Gold was knocked by the resignation of CEO Greg
Hunter. He seems to have been frustrated at the hurdles that have
stymied the company’s strategy, and decided to quit.
Metallon Gold had planned to list in SA in May last year but a dispute
with the Reserve Bank has put paid to this.
Reve said Metallon Corporation chairman Mzi Khumalo was negotiating
with the Bank about the conditions under which Metallon’s Zimbabwean
gold assets, which are held in a British company, could be repatriated.
He said the gold companies were now running as separate units.
“We will admit the failure to list was a serious setback,” he
added. “It is a big opportunity to list a gold company in this
environment, at these prices.
“The capital coming out of that would have been great; it would have
made our lives much easier. And because of that we have had to regear
ourselves and change strategies.”
Metallon Corporation was also hit by a Zimbabwean court ruling this
month ordering it to pay $7.4-million to a former business partner
for breach of contract.
But Reve said the company would appeal the decision.
In the past month Khumalo has also come under fire over the sale of
some of Metallon Ventures’ shares in construction company Basil Read.
Last year Metallon Ventures and Amabubesi, headed by former Scorpions
boss Bulelani Ngcuka, bought a 51.2% stake in Basil Read from French
company Bouygues.
The sale has attracted attention because of Khumalo’s sale of
empowerment shares in Harmony Gold a few years ago. It also raised
eyebrows because it reduced empowerment in Basil Read and there has
been talk of a disregarded lock-in agreement.
Basil Read CEO Marius Heyns said a 6.3% stake was sold, leaving
empowerment in the company well above the 26% threshold. Amabubesi
now has 25.6% and Metallon Ventures 19.3%.
Asked if the sale could have any negative implications for the company,
Heyns replied by e-mail: “It could possibly, but it is difficult
to ascertain.”
The company was not informed of the sale, but Heyns pointed out that
Bouygues and the empowerment consortium had a private contract.
Reve said the sale of the 6.3% to Mawenzi Asset Managers — in which
Khumalo has a controlling stake — at the original deal price was
agreed when the original deal was reached last year. There is no
further agreement with Mawenzi for any sale on similar conditions.
There were no plans to sell more of Metallon Ventures’ stake in Basil
Read, but Reve did not rule this out entirely.
“There really should not be such a fuss about a share sale that was
part of the funding agreement,” he said.
“We are a company like any other, we just that we happen to be black.”
The purchase of the stake in Basil Read was conducted with Bouygues
and it was not billed as an empowerment deal, Reve added.
If there was any future sale there is a so-called “tag-along clause”
with Bouygues, meaning it would have to be informed, he said.

72 Private Universities In Armenia

72 PRIVATE UNIVERSITIES IN ARMENIA
Lragir.am
03 April 06
Such a figure exceeding far beyond the number of state universities
suggests that quantity is not necessarily quality. Five out of these
72 are branches of foreign universities, 28 have state accreditation.
Only 7 out of the 72 have state-accredited specialties. According to
Mher Makichyan, the head of the Agency for Licensing of the Service
of Accreditation of the Ministry of Education and Science, there are
over ten universities, which got state accreditation via courts. The
head of the agency declined to say how the courts reached such a
deal. Maybe the answer is apparent.
The accreditation of private universities by the Ministry of Education
and Science began in 2001. From February 7 to March 14 of 2006 the
Ministry started qualification of 20 private educational institutions
with 24 higher educational and 19 vocational specialties. In the final
stage of qualification tests in 70 subjects were held, 6 educational
institutions and 11 specialties failed.
These educational institutions were rejected the right to participate
in the next stage of qualification.
The Ministry of Education and Culture is going to extend the improved
plan of accreditation to the government of Armenia. The unlimited
accreditation will be replaced by a 5-8 year accreditation.

Fifty Dollars For Anti-ARF Articles

FIFTY DOLLARS FOR ANTI-ARF ARTICLES
Editorial
Yerkir.am
April 01, 2006
We are often asked why we don’t respond to many anti-ARF reports or
statements. If readers follow more attentively, they would find that we
respond to those, which contain certain arguments and logical criticism
or contain disagreements with the ARF’s positions. With responding
to them we aim at not convincing our opponents that our positions
are right but are truing to explain and rationalize our positions.
But when we see articles that are not just critical but are built on
blatant deception, made-up ‘arguments,’ and gossip, we see no reason
to respond.
Why and what to react to articles whose authors know well that what
they had written is a lie, their ‘arguments’ are fake and the facts
distorted? What sense does it make to explain the truth to a person
who knows he is lying but is doing so because he is paid?
There is a market for articles and authors who write anti-ARF articles.
There are order-givers and order-takers. And where there is a ‘demand,’
there is a ‘supply,’ but since the ‘supply’ is not in much demand,
the prices for such articles are low in the ‘market.’
An anti-ARF article can be ordered to andexpert’ or an ‘analyst’
by only 50 dollars. This ‘expert’ then writes an article against
the ARF and then feels free to go and participate in a roundtable
discussion or seminar devoted to democracy, principles or human
rights. But what strikes the most is that some of those ‘experts’
are really shameless. A few days ago, one such ‘analyst’ said, “I
have written articles against the ARF for $50; if the ARF pays me
$100 I’ll stop writing against the ARF and will write against those
ordering me anti-ARF articles.”
But when he was told it was disgusting, he was really surprised.
Such people are really disgusting, but more disgusting are those
who during discussions make use of the articles they have paid to
be written.

Armenian MP: Optimal Settlement Of NK Problem Is Preservation OfStat

ARMENIAN MP: OPTIMAL SETTLEMENT OF NK PROBLEM IS PRESERVATION OF STATUS-QUO
Regnum, Russia
April 1 2006
Despite numerous statements that 2006 is auspicious for settlement
of the Nagorno Karabakh conflict, the problem will not be settled
this year, Armenian MP Armen Ashotyan is quoted as saying at a news
conference on April 1. According to him, proposals on deployment of
peacekeeping corps in the conflict settlement and staging a referendum
in Nagorno Karabakh in 15 years are illusions. “We do not know what
the situation will be in 15 years, what demographic situation will be
in Nagorno Karabakh. We should not trust our enemies. So, we should
not hope that the question will be settled in favor of Armenians,”
the Armenian MP noted and added that, as history has shown, the
documents signed would not obtain legal basis.
Armen Ashotyan noted that to settle the Nagorno Karabakh conflict
several models are proposed, in particular, Nagorno Karabakh joining
Azerbaijan, its independence or joining Armenia, but all these models
are inadmissible either for the Armenian, or the Azerbaijani side.
“The only optimal variant of the problem solution is preserving the
status quo. In this period it is necessary to increase investments
in the country, as well as increase human resources in Nagorno
Karabakh,” believes the MP. According to him, political forces in
Armenia should serve to the interests of international political
forces. “The question of Nagorno Karabakh should be used for serving
domestic political interests,” noted Armen Ashotyan.
As the MP thinks, Kosovo’s model cannot become a precedent for
settlement of the Nagorno Karabakh conflict. “The statement of the
Russian side that Kosovo’s model can be precedent for settlement of
ethnic conflicts in the post-Soviet territory is disputable for the
Armenian authorities,” believes the MP. If Russia is an interested
party in settlement of the Ossetian, Transdnestr and Abkhaz conflicts,
in case of Karabakh conflict the Armenian people is the interested
party, says Ashotyan.

BAKU: Azerbaijan Won’t Agree With Division Of Its Lands,But Prevent

AZERBAIJAN WON’T AGREE WITH DIVISION OF ITS LANDS, BUT PREVENT IT – ARAZ AZIMOV
Author: E.Huseynov
TREND Information, Azerbaijan
April 1 2006
“The United States must understand, while Armenia must remember that
Azerbaijan won’t agree with division of its lands, but prevent it. It
should be interpreted as toughening of our positions. It is principal
position held by Azerbaijan from the beginning of the conflict. We
will remain in this position,” Trend reports quoting Araz Azimov,
the Deputy Foreign Minister, as stating Azertaj.
According to Azimov, the USA comes out for urgent regulation of the
conflict and it is ready to intensify efforts in this direction.
“Azerbaijan supports peaceful co-existence of the Azerbaijani and the
Armenian communities in Nagorno-Karabakh, and issue of appropriate
guarantees to them. I’m sure Azerbaijan will achieve it at any stage,
as we have no other way,” he said. The same time Azerbaijan is ready
to show appropriate flexibility in the settlement of the conflict.
“Addressing to my compatriots, I say the Armenian community living
in Nagorno-Karabakh must be given self-government in any framework.
Armenians alleged that the Azerbaijani political forces were for exile
of the Nagorno-Karabakh Armenians from the region. It is not true. We
never protested against living of the Nagorno-Karabakh Armenians as
Azerbaijani citizens in the region. Quite contrary, we think these
people must have appropriate social-public-political freedoms, which
are necessary to be ensured,” the Minister underlined.
Azimov said the Azerbaijani community must certainly return to
Nagorno-Karabakh. “We should ensure use of the same self-government
model by the both communities within the Azerbaijani legislation. It is
constructive position of Azerbaijan. We are ready to refuse from tough
position as non-recognition of Armenians’ rights in favor of moderate
one as ensuring of their rights. Armenia and Azerbaijan can come to a
common denominator in that way. It is early and not important to give
definite name to this. First, the territorial integrity of Azerbaijan
must be restored under assistance of international community and
rights of the Armenians living in Nagorno-Karabakh must be ensured,”
he stressed.
According to Azimov, the issues were discussed with Steven Man,
the OSCE Minsk Group co-chair from the USA, in Washington. Besides,
the Foreign Minister intends to continue the discussion in the USA
during his visit next week.

Russia Doubles Gas Price For Armenia

RUSSIA DOUBLES GAS PRICE FOR ARMENIA
RIA Novosti, Russia
April 1 2006
MOSCOW, April 1 (RIA Novosti) – Russia will double Saturday the
price for its natural gas supplied to Armenia from the current $54
per 1,000 cu m to $110.
A Russian-Armenian joint venture, ArmRosgazprom, which is owned by
the Armenian Energy Ministry (45%), Russian energy giant Gazprom (45%)
and independent Russian oil and gas company Itera (10%), has a monopoly
right to supply and distribute gas on Armenia’s domestic market.
ArmRosgazprom requested the Armenian commission for the regulation
of public services to raise natural gas tariffs from $131 to $240 per
1,000 cu m for private consumers and from $175 to $322 for commercial
consumers using more than 10,000 cu m. A relevant decision will come
into force a month after the request is approved.

Nagorno Karabakh: Stalin’s Shadow Looms Over Trans-Caucasus Pipeline

NAGORNO-KARABAKH: STALIN’S SHADOW LOOMS OVER TRANS-CAUCASUS PIPELINE
by Rene Wadlow
World War 4 Report, NY
April 1 2006
The president of Azerbaijan, Ilhan Aliyev (son of the long-time
president Heydar Aliyev), and Robert Kocharian, president of Armenia,
met outside Paris, in Rambouillet Feb. 10-11, to discuss the stalemated
conflict over Nagorno-Karabakh. Rambouillet had also been the scene
for the last-chance negotiations on Kosovo just before the NATO
bombing of Serbia began in 1999.
During the two years of fighting in Nagorno-Karabakh, 1992-1994,
at least 20,000 people were killed and more than a million
persons displaced from Armenia, Azerbaijan and the 12,000 square
miles of Nagorno-Karabakh itself. Armenian forces now control
the Nagorno-Karabakh area-an Armenian-populated enclave within
Azerbaijan. Since 1994, there has been a relatively stable ceasefire.
Nagorno-Karabakh has declared its independence as a separate state.
No other state-including Armenia-has recognized this independent
status, but, in practice, Nagorno-Karabakh is a de facto state with
control over its population and its own military forces. Half of
the government’s revenue is raised locally; the other half comes
from the government of Armenia and especially the Armenian diaspora,
strong in the United States, Canada, Lebanon, and Russia.
In addition to Nagorno-Karabakh, the Armenian forces hold seven small
districts around the enclave, some 5,500 square kilometers that
had been populated by Azeris and that are considered as “occupied
territory.” One of the ideas being floated during these negotiations
is an Armenian withdrawal from these occupied territories accompanied
by international security guarantees and an international peacekeeping
force, probably under the control of the Organization for Security
and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) which has been the major forum for
negotiation on the Nagorno-Karabkh conflict.
The USA, France, and Russia are the co-chairmen of a mediating effort
called the “Minsk Group” after an OSCE conference on Nagorno-Karabakh
which was to have been held in Minsk-but then indefinitely postponed
as there was no clear basis for a compromise solution. Part of the
negotiating guidelines of the Minsk Group meetings is that no official
report is made on the negotiations, so that analysis is always an
effort at putting pieces together from partial statements, leaks,
and “off-the-record” interviews with the press. This blackout on
direct statements opens the door to highly partisan analysis in both
countries, where the press has always been hard line. There are those
who believe that both presidents are “ahead of their people” in their
willingness to compromise and to move beyond the current “no war,
no peace” situation which is a drain on economic and social resources.
However, in both countries, the media is under tight control of the
respective governments-so the militaristic tone of the press is not
against government policy. The blackout on press statements is also
due to the monopoly on both sides of a small, tight group of people
responsible for the negotiations. Informal “Track Two” meetings are
very difficult and the few held were met by general suspicion or
hostility. There is a need for a broader-based pubic peacemaking
effort to counter the current narrow, militant rhetoric.
The Nagorno-Karabakh issue arises from the post-Revolution/Civil
War period of Soviet history when Joseph Stalin was Commissioner
for Nationalities. Stalin came from neighboring Georgia and knew the
Caucasus well. His policy was a classic “divide and rule”-designed
so that national/ethnic groups would need to depend on the central
government in Moscow for protection. Thus in 1922, the frontiers
of Azerbaijan, Armenia and Georgia were hammered out in what was
then the Transcaucasian Federative Republic. Nagorno-Karabakh,
an Armenian-majority area, was given a certain autonomy within
Azerbaijan but was geographically cut off from Armenia. Likewise,
an Azeri majority area, Nakkickevan, was created as an autonomous
republic within Armenia but cut off geographically from Azerbaijan.
Thus both enclaves had to look to Moscow for protection. This was
especially true for the Armenians. Many Armenians living in what
had been historic Armenia which came under Turkish control had
been killed during the First World War; Armenians living in “Soviet
Armenia” had relatives and friends among those killed by the Turks,
creating a permanent sense of vulnerability and insecurity. Russia
was considered a historic ally of Armenia.
These mixed administrative units worked well enough-or, one should
say, there were few criticisms allowed-until 1988 when the whole
Soviet model of nationalities and republics started to come apart. In
both Armenia and Azerbeijan, natioanlistic voices were raised, and a
strong “Karabakh Committee” began demanding that Nagorno-Karabakh be
attached to Armenia. In Azerbaijan, anti-Armenian sentiment was set
aflame. Many Armenians who were working in the oil-related economy
of Baku were under tension and started leaving. This was followed
somewhat later by real anti-Armenian pogroms. Some 160,000 Armenians
left Azerbaijan for Armenia, and others went to live in Russia.
With the break up of the Soviet Union and the independence of Armenia
and Azerbaijan, tensions focused on Nagorno-Karabakh. By 1992,
full-scale conflict broke out in and around Nagorno-Karabkh and went
on for two years, causing large-scale damage. The Armenian forces of
Nagorno-Karabakh, aided by volunteers from Armenia, kept control of
the area, while Azerbaijan faced repeated political crises.
The condition of “no peace, no war” followed the ceasefire largely
negotiated by Russia in 1994. This status quo posed few problems to
the major regional states, all preoccupied by other geo-political
issues. Informal and illicit trade within the area has grown.
However, interest in a settlement of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict
has grown as the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan oil pipeline opened in May 2005.
The pipeline is scheduled to carry one million barrels of oil a day
from the Caspian to the Mediterranean by 2009. The pipeline passes
within 10 miles of Nagorno-Karabakh.
The crucial question for a settlement is the acceptance by
all parties and by the OSCE of an independent “mini-state.” An
independent Nagorno-Karabakh might become the “Liechtenstein of
the Caucasus.” After 15 years of independence, Karabakh Armenians
do not want to be at the mercy of decisions made in distant centers
of power but to decide their own destiny. However, the recognition
of Nagorno-Karabakh as an independent states raises the issue of the
status of other de facto mini-states of the region, such as Abkhazia
and South Ossetia in Georgia, Transnistria in Moldova, and Kosovo in
Serbia. Close attention must be paid to the potential restructuring
of the area. Can mini-states be more than a policy of divide and
rule? The long shadow of Joseph Stalin still hovers over the land.
——
Rene Wadlow is editor of the online journal of world politics
Transnational Perspectives and an NGO representative to the UN,
Geneva. Formerly, he was professor and Director of Research of the
Graduate Institute of Development Studies, University of Geneva.
This piece originally appeared in Toward Freedom, March 21

BAKU: Trial Of Ruslan Bashirli, Ramin Tagiyev And Said Nuri Started

TRIAL OF RUSLAN BASHIRLI, RAMIN TAGIYEV AND SAID NURI STARTED
Today, Azerbaijan
April 1 2006
Preparatory trial of Yeni Fikir Youth Movement Chief Ruslan Bashirli,
Chief assistant Ramin Tagiyev and Coordinator Said Nuri was held in
the Grave Crimes Court.
As APA reports, they are accused due to the Criminal Code article 278
(to seize the power by force) and 192 (illegal entrepreneurship). The
sitting started an hour late as the lawyers did not come. But then the
both lawyers – Osman Kazimov and Elchin Gambarov joined the sitting.
The trial was presided over by Tofig Pashayev. The Republic
Prosecutor’s Office representative Shahin Rahimov, acted as the Public
Prosecutor. Ruslan Bashirli demanded that Lider TV correspondent
should leave the trial hall and victims of March 31 Genocide of
Azerbaijanis should be commemorated in one minute silence. The
lawyer Osman Kazimov submitted a list of evidences to the defense
side and made some claims. He demanded that names of alleged Armenian
intelligence officers should be publicized, Osman Alimuradov’s video
cassette should be submitted and fact that Ruslan Bashirli received
bribes from the embassies should be given to the trial.
“Statements against Ruslan Bashirli are reflected in investigation
materials. All of the statements were not included in the materials.
PFPA chief Ali Kerimli’s statement was excluded from the materials.
There is no evidence in the material proving relation of Ruslan
Bashirli to Armenian intelligence bodies.”
The Public Prosecutor said that the cassette will be submitted to
the trial in the next sitting and there is no need to give the other
evidences to the trial now.
Bashirli said that he underwent tortures during the arrest time and
got brain injury. He demanded that the law enforcement bodies who
tortured should be held accountable.
The Public Prosecutor also proposed to hold closed trial because
there is intelligence and state secret in the investigation. Lawyers
and the accused objected this proposal.
URL: