AZERBAIJAN IN THE RUSSIAN-IRANIAN VISE
CENTRAL ASIA – CAUCASUS ANALYST
Wednesday / March 22, 2006
By Ariel Cohen and Conway Irwin
A shared border and unique geopolitical location make Azerbaijan an
important stakeholder in the confrontation between the West and Iran
over its uranium enrichment program. It is not in Azerbaijan’s interest
to foster animosity with its powerful neighbor, but at the same time, it
is not in its interest to side with rogue regimes, thereby alienating
the U.S. and the West. Russia has been aggressively courting Azerbaijan,
but widespread Western opposition to Iranian nuclear efforts and
Russia’s desire to extend the Karabakh conflict for as long as possible
will give Azerbaijan room to find a way to stay in Russia’s good graces
but out of its `sphere of influence.’
BACKGROUND: On February 21-22, 2006, Russian President Vladimir Putin
visited President Ilham Aliyev in Baku to mark the start of the `Year of
Russian Culture’ in Azerbaijan. The two presidents discussed economic
cooperation, a military-technical commission to facilitate Russian
military sales to Azerbaijan, and, presumably, Azerbaijan’s position on
Iranian nuclear enrichment. Some analysts believe that Putin is
pressuring Aliyev to support Russia in opposing UN sanctions against
Iran and to weaken U.S. influence in the Southern Caucasus, undoubtedly
using as leverage his support for Aliyev’s New Azerbaijan Party in
Azerbaijan’s disputed 2005 parliamentary elections.
Putin and Aliyev also discussed Russia’s proposal for a Caspian Sea
security entity – `Caspian Defense Initiative,’ or CASFOR. CASFOR’s
stated goals are the prevention of terrorism and drug/WMD smuggling
across borders, as well as protection of the economic interests of the
five proposed signatories – Azerbaijan, Iran, Turkmenistan, Kazakhstan,
and Russia.
Such cooperation is inconsistent with the historically complicated
relationships between Azerbaijan, Russia and Iran. Azerbaijan has long
suspected both countries of clandestine support for Armenia in the
conflict over Nagorno-Karabakh, including Russian provision of troops to
the Armenian side. Recent negotiations between Armenia and Azerbaijan
have yielded some progress on the issue, but a solution remains elusive
given recent Armenian backtracking. There is some speculation that
Russia encouraged Armenian President Robert Kocharyan to harden his
position in peace negotiations in February 2006, derailing a
much-expected framework agreement. If true, this could be a signal to
Baku that independent statehood does not free Azerbaijan from Russian
meddling in its traditional sphere of influence.
Despite lingering mistrust, Russia, Iran, and Azerbaijan have announced
the synchronization of their energy systems, with a
Russian-Iranian-Azerbaijani power corridor to be completed in 2009.
Increasing Western indifference to Azerbaijan, or pressure regarding its
political system as well as aggressive moves by Russia to court
Azerbaijan may push Azerbaijani President Aliyev further into the
Russian-Iranian camp, distancing him from the West.
IMPLICATIONS: By joining CASFOR and further increasing political and
economic cooperation with Russia and Iran, Azerbaijan risks unwittingly
positioning itself on the wrong side of the debate over Iranian nuclear
aspirations. Just like the Collective Security Treaty Organization
(CSTO) has been for its members, CASFOR may become a trap for
Azerbaijan, as it stands to be used as a means for Russia to expand its
influence in the Caspian region and continue its efforts to turn
Azerbaijan into a client state. Furthermore, Azerbaijan is not looking
to align itself with Iran amidst a brewing crisis over the Iranian
nuclear program, and create tensions with the U.S. Russia is likely to
seek to avoid sanctions against Iran, given that Iran is a major
importer of Russian arms and nuclear technology . However, as G8
President, unequivocal support for Iran would damage Russia’s
international legitimacy. Russia will continue to seek a diplomatic
solution to the Iranian problem, which only prolongs the crisis, but if
the rest of the G8 agrees that sanctions are necessary, Russia and Iran
are unlikely to win this battle, and Azerbaijan will be facing the
choice: defining its image in the West as a reliable partner or as a
Russian-Iranian vassal.
To encourage Azerbaijan to support the Western position on Iran, it is
crucial for the European Union to support Azerbaijan’s efforts to expand
cooperation with the EU, while the U.S. should be willing to provide
Baku with necessary security guarantees and expanded military
assistance. Moreover, as Russia may be mulling escalation tensions in
the Caucasus, the U.S. needs to talk to Àzerbaijan and Turkey about
coordinating security cooperation, such as joint airspace control.
The worst development which can happen for the West is for Azerbaijan to
become disillusioned with its Euro-Atlantic orientation and follow the
examples of Uzbekistan and Belarus, seeking political patronage in
Moscow, Tehran or even Beijing.
Azerbaijan has strong incentives to expand economic ties with Europe.
Azerbaijan is the EU’s largest trading partner in the Caucasus, and
development of the TRACECA (Europe-Caucasus-Asia Transport Corridor) and
Most Favored Nation (MFN) status with the EU will be cornerstones for
expansion of Azerbaijani trade and investment. A firm partnership with
the EU could also strengthen Azerbaijan’s economic institutions.
Cooperation with Western advisors could help Azerbaijan enact reforms to
tackle the weak regulatory framework, corruption, and potential for
armed conflict that have stymied economic growth and foreign and
domestic investment, and to diversify into sectors other than oil and
gas. Such reforms would enhance economic growth and stability.
Systemic reform will also improve Azerbaijan’s external security. A
pluralistic, democratic Azerbaijan – a secular Shi’i state – can set an
example for other majority-Muslim states in the region, making it an
invaluable ally for the West. Engaging with the West politically,
cooperating on multilateral issues and observing Western standards of
government accountability, democracy, pluralism, and human rights will
contribute to domestic stability in Azerbaijan and improve the
likelihood of Western backing on energy and security issues. As the
country becomes more transparent and develops the rule of law and
better-functioning institution of governance and economic coordination,
Western investments are likely to flow beyond the oil and gas sectors. A
thriving secular, but culturally Muslim democracy will be increasingly
secure as Russia moves to reassert power in its `near abroad’.
CONCLUSIONS: Azerbaijan’s strategic challenge is to stave off choosing
between Russia and the West. Economic cooperation with the U.S. and EU
can inject much-needed capital, technology, and managerial expertise
into the Azerbaijani economy. Security cooperation with Western partners
can ease pressure from Russia and Iran in the Caspian region and provide
Azerbaijan with the backing of strong allies. Azerbaijan should take
into account the dangers of Russian hegemony in its `backyard’ and the
implications of a nuclear Iran, and concentrate on its long-term
national interests. With the political, military and economic support of
Western partners and genuine efforts at growth and reform, Azerbaijan
may develop the capacity to maintain a relationship with Russia based
not on clientelism, but on mutual interests.
AUTHORS’ BIO:
— Ariel Cohen, Ph.D., is Senior Research Fellow in Russian and Eurasian
Studies and International Energy Security at the Heritage Foundation,
and author and editor of Eurasia in Balance (Ashgate, 2005).
— Conway Irwin, SAIS 2005 graduate is an intern at The Heritage
Foundation, D.C. The authors wish to thank Katalin Vinkler for
contributing to this article.
Forum on Genocide at the UN
Permanent Mission of the Republic of Armenia
to the United Nations
119E 36th street, New York, NY 10016
Tel.: 1-212-686-9079
Fax: 1-212-686-3934
E-mail: [email protected]
Web:
April 3, 2006
PRESS RELEASE
Forum on Genocide at the UN
On Thursday, March 30, 2006, the Permanent Missions of Armenia and Rwanda,
and the Armenian General Benevolent Union, organized a Forum on genocide and
its prevention at the United Nations entitled “Genocide Then and Now:
Lessons Learned for the Twenty-first Century.” The Forum attempted to
discuss the lessons learnt from the first and last genocides of the
twentieth century and the international community’s role in prevention of
the future recurrences of this ultimate crime against humanity.
The Panel featured Mr. Juan E. Mendez, Special Advisor to the UN
Secretary-General on the Prevention of Genocide, Mr. Vahakn Dadrian,
Director of Genocide Research at Zoryan Institute, and Ms. Yael Danieli,
Co-President of International Network of Holocaust and Genocide Studies. The
Forum was moderated by Ms. Andrea Kannapell, Weekend Editor of the New York
Times Foreign Desk.
Professor Dadrian spoke about impunity and denial as contributing factors
for repetition of genocide. He analyzed in detail the investigations carried
out by the Turkish authorities in 1918-1920 and the subsequent
determinations of its military tribunals of the time, and the later reversal
of the official policy and embracing of the denial of the Armenian genocide
by Turkey. He stressed the negative impact of the World War I as a factor
used to disguise the atrocities being committed.
Prominent psychologist Yael Danieli focused on the psycho-social aspects of
genocide, specifically stressing the need for healing for the genocide
survivors. She dwelled upon compensation, restitution, rehabilitation and
commemoration as some of the aspects imperative for recovery. Dr. Danieli
also spoke of the important role the gachacha courts play in the current
reconciliation and recovery efforts in Rwanda.
Mr. Mendez elaborated on the UN’s role in the prevention of genocide
mentioning that he was guided by the 1948 Convention on the Prevention and
Punishment of the Crime of Genocide. He emphasized that four steps are
important in the prevention of future massacres: protection of civilians,
accountability, humanitarian relief in all its aspects, including social and
medical, and prevention of the underlying causes of conflict. He underlined
the importance of the civil society in generating political will in places
where it lacks to step up the efforts to prevent or stop genocidal policies.
Mr. Mendez spoke of the importance of prevention and resolution of conflicts
as the latter provide an environment conducive to mass atrocities.
During a brief question and answer session, a Turkish professor,
participating at the Forum, made an unsuccessful attempt to divert the
discussion by making comments in the spirit of denial. Other questions
raised concerned the issues of prevention of genocide and the problems
facing the children that have survived genocide in Rwanda.
END
BISNIS: Export-to Armenia business opportunities
ENVIRONMENTAL LEADS
Armenia Water and Sewage CJSC – World Bank-funded
tender for Procurement of Water Treatment Equipment
ead.cfm?3002
***
Armenian Water and Sewage CJSC (World Bank funded) –
Armenia: Tender for Procurement of Pipes, Pipe
Fittings, Water Meters and Pumps
cfm?3004
***
Armenian Water and Sewage CJSC (World Bank funded) –
Armenia: Tender for Procurement of Pipes, Pipe
Fittings, Water Meters and Pumps
cfm?3005
***
Armenian Water and Sewage CJSC (World Bank funded) –
Armenia: Tender for Procurement of Pumps
cfm?3007
For more information on the Environmental Sector in
the NIS, please contact Chris Christov at BISNIS at
[email protected]
================
MEDICAL SERVICES AND EQUIPMENT LEADS
Armenian Ministry of Health – World Bank-funded tender
for procurement of medical equipment
ead.cfm?3001
***
Armenian Ministry of Health (World Bank funded) –
Armenia: Tender for Procurement of Medical Furniture
ead.cfm?3006
For more information on the Medical Services And
Equipment Sector in the NIS, please contact Desi
Jordanoff at BISNIS at [email protected]
ALMA hosts an exceptional rug exhibit, opening April 20
April 3, 2006
ALMA
65 Main Street
Watertown, MA
Contact Person: Mariam Stepanyan
Web:
Tel: 617.926.2562 ext. 3
Email: [email protected]
ALMA will open an Armenian rug exhibit on April 20.
The Armenian Library and Museum of America (ALMA) will open an
exceptional exhibit of Armenian textiles “Armenian Rugs and Weavings:
Textiles of Hearth and Heart” (Apr 9-Aug 15), which will be showcased in
the Museum’s main gallery. This exhibit will feature a wide range of the
weavings from the mountains of Armenia and the Transcaucasus. ALMA will
host the opening reception on Thursday, April 20, 6-9pm.
The museum’s holdings include over 20,000 artifacts including coins,
maps, religious art, costumes, ceramics, metalwork, paintings, and
almost 4,000 textiles. The new exhibit will include a dozen rugs
carefully selected from the over 200 Armenian Inscribed Rugs in the
collection, plus a wide range of smaller woven textiles (bread covers,
kilims, bedding boxes, saddlebags, oven covers, salt bags and other
domestic examples) that are not usually seen by the public. When one
hears the term “Armenian weavings”, most people think of the striking
oriental rugs, particularly the Kazaks and Karabaghs, which often
overshadow the simpler household pieces.
Many of the textiles to be exhibited are from the museum’s new
Offen-Alimian Collection, and will be publicly exhibited for the first
time. The new exhibit will also include a dozen exceptional works on
loan from the Armenian Rug Society (ARS). The ARS is a national
association of collectors and connoisseurs of Armenian rugs, an ancient
tradition that is too often overshadowed by the extensive weavings of
neighboring Turkey and Iran. The ARS participation will allow the museum
to highlight several genres of Armenian rugs outside of the museum’s own
holdings, to allow visitors to familiarize themselves with the wide
range of Armenian weavings. The ARS rugs are all from private
collections, and rarely seen by the public. ARS members, loaning rugs
for the ALMA exhibit will be arriving for the opening reception at the
Museum.
Although many people erroneously believe that “oriental rugs” are
strictly an “Islamic art”, knotted rug making is also practiced by some
Christian and Jewish groups, including the Christian Armenians (the
museum also includes many examples of the ancient religious arts of
Armenia). Indeed, some scholars believe that the rug weaving traditions
of the Armenians predate the emergence of Islam, and that oriental rug
weaving was originally was a “Christian art”, later adopted by Muslims.
Aside from the exceptional rugs, the exhibit will also examine some of
these conflicting theories on the role of the Armenians in both rug
production and distribution (e.g. the stereotype of the “Armenian rug
merchant”).
In conjunction with the weaving exhibit, Dr. Lucy Der Manuelian, noted
authority and expert on Armenian art, will deliver a lecture at the
opening reception at 8:00 pm entitled “Diamonds, Dragons and Crosses:
The Story of Armenian Rug Weaving”, which will examine the links between
the Armenian folk art traditions and the elite art of architecture and
illuminations. All Armenian arts are interrelated, rooted in and drawing
upon the same ancient artistic motifs for their inspiration. Dr. Der
Manuelian is professor of Armenian Art at Tufts University, and longtime
trustee of the museum.
Aside from the rug exhibits, the museum visitor will also find several
related exhibits in the smaller galleries, including “Undercover:
Armenian Textiles of the Bedroom and Bath”. The museum is the largest
Armenian museum in the world, outside of the Republic of Armenia, and is
the largest ethnic museum in Massachusetts.
ALMA is located at 65 Main Street, Watertown, MA (at the intersection of
Rt. 16 and Rt. 20), just outside of Boston. The new museum hours are:
Thursday 6-9 p.m., Friday and Sunday 1-5 p.m., and Saturday 10AM-2PM.
To arrange for guided tours call 617-926-2562 or visit the Museum’s
website .
Vartkes’s List
=1003
March|April 2006
Vartkes’s List
Of the million or more Armenians executed by Ottoman Turks 90 years
ago, thousands had insurance from New York Life. A slip-and-fall
lawyer uncovered the list of policyholders and, by forcing the company
to pay their heirs, gave voice to the victims of genocide.
By Michael Bobelian
VARTKES YEGHIAYAN ENTERED THE LOS ANGELES FEDERAL COURTHOUSE more
nervous than on any other day of his career. He wore the fraying navy
suit that had seen him through many victories in the slip-and-fall
cases that he typically handled. Sixty-five, his hair white and body
plump, the lawyer Yeghiayan was 14 years into a different kind of
case, a class action lawsuit against an insurance company that had
failed to honor his clients’ policies.
To the surprise and anger of his colleagues, Yeghiayan had turned down
a substantial settlement seven months before. For reasons that don’t
often enter into the calculations of a legal dispute, Yeghiayan wanted
more for his clients than the amount the insurer had offered. His
ancestors were Armenian, and for most of his life he had heard stories
of a day in April 1915 when Ottoman soldiers rounded up Armenian
families to begin a slaughter that would last for eight years and
claim at least a million lives.
His clients, some 2,300, were heirs of the slaughter’s victims who had
purchased life insurance policies that had never been
redeemed. Yeghiayan wanted the insurer to pay his clients so that they
would get the money they were owed, but also as an act of public
recognition for a genocide that most Armenians believed had been too
noticed littleand that its perpetrators had consistently denied. In
Yeghiayan’s view, a settlement could serve both purposes only if it
were large enough to attract the world’s attention. Otherwise, he
would seek the recognition that his people deserved by trying the case
in court.
That November morning in 2001, Yeghiayan was on his way to a
last-minute settlement conference before a hearing on whether his case
would be dismissed. He walked into a small room off the lawyers’
lounge near United States District Judge Christina Snyder’s
courtroom. It was filled with lawyers from each side of the case. The
judge had given them 30 minutes to see if they could reach agreement,
but Yeghiayan didn’t need that much time. The entire group had worked
out terms that they hoped he would accept, and a lawyer slid a
settlement proposal across the table.
“I’m not going to sign,” Yeghiayan said.
THE SOUTHWESTERN CAUCASUS IS A REGION OF RUGGED MOUNTAINS between the
Black and Caspian seas, with deep valleys that intersect like the
boulevards of a city. Mount Ararat dominates the landscape and marks
the center of the ancient Armenian civilization. In the spring,
melting snow and ice flow down the slopes to rivers like the Aras. The
ground surrounding the mountain is dark with lava and scattered with
stones embeddedsome beige and hard, others red and brittle, still
others glossy and black.
Armenians emerged in the Caucasus during the first millennium B.C. It
is not known whether they traveled there from Asia Minor, as the
ancient Greek historian Herodotus claimed, or were native to the
land. In A.D. 301, King Trdat III made Armenia the first Christian
nation. Mythology has it that he converted his empire from paganism in
gratitude to a Christian monk, who made the king human again after he
went on a killing spree and was changed into a wild boar. About a
century later, another monk created the Armenian alphabet, and the
combination of a written language and a state religion solidified the
Armenian culture, allowing it to resist assimilation by Arabs, Tatars,
and others who invaded Armenia over the following centuries.
By the 1800s, most Armenians lived under Ottoman rule. The few
inhabiting the Turkish capital, Constantinople (now Istanbul), were
among the empire’s wealthiest merchants and intellectual elite, while
the rest worked as farmers and artisans in regions to the capital’s
south and east. The Islamic Ottomans treated the Christian Armenians
as second-class citizens, though, and Armenian demands for equality
soon shattered what had long been a largely peaceful relationship
between the peoples.
In 1894, the growing tension provoked Armenians to protest against
their Turkish rulers, and Sultan Abdul Hamid II, the head of the
Ottoman Empire, ordered mass killings of Armenians. The massacres
started in the Black Sea city of Trebizond, 650 miles east of
Istanbul, and quickly spread throughout the empire. The deadliest
incidents occurred in Urfa, near the Syrian border to the south, where
soldiers burned a cathedral with 3,000 Armenians inside. Between
100,000 and 300,000 Armenians perished in the violence from 1894 to
1896. In 1908, troubled by growing disorder in the sprawling Ottoman
Empire, a group of army officers called the Young Turks seized power
from Abdul Hamid and promoted pan-Turkism, a nationalist ideology that
advocated eliminating minorities like the Armenians. In their first
year in power, the Young Turks orchestrated the execution of between
15,000 and 25,000 Armenians.
As this new wave of violence swept the empire, a middle-class merchant
named Setrak Cheytanian watched with horror from his home in Kharput,
a city in central Turkey and a stop on the Silk Road, an ancient
system of caravan trails from China to the Mediterranean Sea. Fearing
the worst for himself and wanting to provide for his wife, parents,
and two children, the 35-year-old Cheytanian bought a life insurance
policy from an agent of New York Life Insurance Company in July
1910. For an annual premium of 155.73 French francs, the policy
obligated the company to pay Cheytanian’s named beneficiaries 3,000
francs (about $580 at the time) plus dividends upon his death or, if
he outlived the policy’s 20-year term at his request.
Life for Cheytanian and other Armenians grew more precarious as World
War I approached. Concern for the Christian minority had prompted
France and Britain to support Armenian rights and, to some extent,
restrain the Ottomans from greater abuses. But in 1914, Turkey entered
World War I on Germany’s side, cutting off Armenians from their
European supporters. At the insistence of her father and her
brother-in-law Cheytanian, Yegsa Marootian and her 9-year-old
daughter, Alice, left Kharput for New York City to join Cheytanian’s
brother, who had emigrated there several years before. As they left,
Cheytanian gave Yegsa his life insurance policy, figuring that if
anything happened to him, it would be easier for her to collect on the
policy in New York, where the insurer was headquartered.
VARTKES YEGHIAYAN WAS BORN IN 1936 to a wealthy family in Ethiopia
that sheltered him excessively, even from the family’s history. His
mother’s close ties to the nation’s family imperialher godmother was
the wife of the Emperor Selassie Haileallowed him entry to the best
schools and, at age 11, he attended an American boarding school in
Cyprus. There he befriended many Turkish students, and he was puzzled
when some of his fellow Armenians would call the Turks “murderers.”
Why they should be called murderers remained a mystery for Yeghiayan
through high school and into college at the University of California,
Berkeley, where his father insisted that he go because, his father
explained, “The future is in America.”
Yeghiayan started as a pre-med major at Berkeley and switched to
history, a course of study that might have explained the connection
between Turks and murder, but Yeghiayan’s teachers never mentioned the
topic. Other Armenian students told him stories of their families’
hardships in Turkey, and he pretended to know what they were talking
about, offering the little he could gather from his reading about
Turkey at the library. But it was not until 1961, when his father died
and he attended the funeral in Ethiopia with his relatives and the
aging friends of his father, that Yeghiayan began to understand
family’s hisand people’s hisunspeakable past.
In the early days of World War I, when the Ottoman military included
Armenian soldiers, an assault on Russian forces at Turkey’s eastern
front backfired, costing the Turks about 90,000 men. Humiliated and
looking for a scapegoat, the Turkish commander blamed the treachery of
Armenian soldiers for the disaster and arranged for their expulsion
from the military. At about the same time, Turkey’s leading Islamic
cleric declared a jihad, or holy struggle, against all Christians
except those living in Germany and other Turkish allies. By 1915, the
Armenians were isolated, largely unarmed, and the targets of a
religious death warrant. Dr. Khachig Boghosian, a prominent
psychologist and leader of the Armenian community in Istanbul,
described in his memoirs what happened on the night of April 23:
After supper, I went to the house of my neighbor . . . and we passed
the time playing backgammon and piano. I left and came home at 1:30
a.m. and went to bed; everything was calm, both inside and outside of
the house. I had just lain down and was on the verge of falling
asleep, when the outside doorbell rang loudly three times. My sister
Esther hurriedly went downstairs, opened the door and, after
exchanging a few words, rushed upstairs and knocked on my door,
telling me that the police wanted me.
Similar scenes played out across Istanbul as 250 Armenian leaders were
arrested and sent to camps in central Turkey. The head of the Armenian
Church pleaded with the United States for help. At the request of
America’s Secretary of State William Jennings Bryan, the
U.S. Ambassador to Turkey, Henry Morgenthau, asked Turkish leaders to
stop their campaign against the Armenians. His appeals were ignored,
and the United States, then neutral in the war it would enter two
years later, could only repeat its request. The Turks began to execute
Armenian leaders across the empire, hoping to preclude any organized
resistance to the massacres that it planned to undertake soon. The
Young Turks declared that they would make Turkey for the Turks alone.
Throughout the spring and summer of 1915, Turkish death squads
systematically assembled large groups of Armenians in Erzerum,
Kharput, and other Armenian enclaves and hung or shot the adult
men. Among the dead in Kharput was the merchant Setrak Cheytanian. The
gangs then evicted women and children and forced them to march through
the desert to camps in central Turkey and, finally, to the outskirts
of the Ottoman Empire in what is now Syria. Carrying almost nothing to
eat or drink, the deportees fought over provisions during the
marches. All were vulnerable to the kidnappings, rapes, and murders
that the Turks and Kurds guarding them committed at random. Countless
women were sold as concubines. Children were pried from their mothers’
arms and given to Turkish families. Describing the deportations,
Leslie Davis, the American consul in Kharput, wrote to his superior in
Istanbul, “I do not believe it is possible for one in a hundred to
survive, perhaps one in a thousand.”
By 1923, the Turks had systematically executed between 1 million and
1.5 million Armenians and evicted 500,000 more from a homeland that
they had occupied for 2,500 years. It was one of the century’s first
instances of mass extermination, and it would become known by
Armenians, and later by much of the world, as the Armenian genocide.
Among the genocide’s survivors was Yeghiayan’s father, Boghos. None of
Boghos’s friends who later attended his funeral could tell Yeghiayan
exactly how or when, in the course of the war and the massacres,
Boghos lost his parents and four sisters in Konya, a city in
southwestern Turkey. Arab nomads found the nine-year-old Boghos and
disguised the green-eyed, flaxen-haired boy with girl’s clothing so
that he could survive in their company. In 1919, according to his
friends, he walked out of the desert and appeared in Aleppo, a city in
northern Syria where tens of thousands of Armenian refugees were
gathered after the war. Going through his father’s possessions after
the funeral, Yeghiayan found in Boghos’s wallet a photograph showing
Boghos dressed in shepherds’ robes. Yeghiayan had never seen the photo
before, because Boghos had apparently never shown it to any member of
his family. He had shared his memories of Turkey and the massacre of
Armenians only with fellow survivors.
THE WAR AND THE DISAPPEARANCE OF SO MANY ARMENIANS hopelessly
complicated the efforts of the New York Life Insurance Company to
operate in Turkey. By 1921, an attorney at the company’s offices in
Istanbul had authorized the payment of death benefits on 1,300 of the
3,600 policies held by Armenians, but, with no one trying to collect
on the other policies, “that was the closing of the book at that
point,” William Werfelman Jr., a vice president at New York Life,
explained recently. The insurer pulled out of Turkey later in 1921.
By then, Yegsa Marootian had been living in Staten Island, N.Y., for
several years, and her family had grown to include three children in
addition to her daughter Alice. Yegsa was largely cut off from news of
Turkey and her Armenian relatives, but somehow she had gotten word by
1925 that her brother-in-law Cheytanian was dead. She had kept the
life insurance policy that he had given her, and, with her family
financially strapped, Yegsa was eager to collect the death benefit of
3,000 francs, by that time worth about $143 (and roughly $1,600
today).
As Cheytanian had instructed, she contacted the New York headquarters
of New York Life about redeeming the policy, and a company agent told
her that she needed a certificate inheritance ofessentially, a
certificate deathto prove that Cheytanian had died. The agent
recommended that she get one through the Armenian Church, as many
other Armenian beneficiaries had done. There is no record of Yegsa’s
response to the agent or of her life over the following 30 years, but
by 1956 she had moved to Los Angeles and obtained the certificate of
inheritance. According to a letter dated in June of that year, New
York Life instructed Yegsa to come to its offices in Pasadena, Calif.,
to “discuss the matter” of her brother-in-law’s insurance policy.
AFTER GRADUATING FROM BERKELEY IN 1959, Yeghiayan worked at a law firm
and earned a degree from Lincoln Law School of San Jose, a night
school, in 1965. He soon joined California Rural Legal Assistance, a
nonprofit group that represented agricultural workers and, after
Ronald Reagan became governor in 1967, gained notoriety as a thorn in
Reagan’s side. But Yeghiayan’s attention never strayed far from his
Armenian heritage. The genocide stories that he had heard from his
college classmates and his father’s friends stayed with him, and,
beginning in the late 1960s, on every 24 Aprilthe anniversary of
genocide thehe tried to lead Armenians in demonstrations at the
Turkish consulate in Los Angeles. “My view was the Turks . . . tried
to exterminate us and failed,” he explained. “On April 24, we should
remind them of that failure.” When he could not be in Los Angeles,
Yeghiayan joined Armenians wherever he was to commemorate the loss. In
1980, after serving five years as an assistant director of
international operations for the Peace Corps in Washington, D.C.,
Yeghiayan set up a law practice in Glendale, Calif. He helped
Armenians immigrate to the United States and handled personal injury
cases for the local Armenian community, which is now the largest in
America.
But Yeghiayan says it was not until 1987, as he approached his 51st
birthday, that he stumbled on the cause that would become his
passion. While reading Henry Morgenthau’s memoir, he came across a
passage that recounted a conversation between the former ambassador to
Turkey and his frequent interlocutor, Mehmet Talaat Pasha, the Turkish
interior minister and one of the leading Young Turks. Talaat was
committed to the elimination of Armenians from Turkey, and while the
slaughter was occurring, he mentioned to Morgenthau the substantial
business that New York Life and other American insurers had done with
Armenians:
“I wish,” Talaat now said, “that you would get the American life
insurance companies to send us a complete list of their Armenian
policy holders. They are practically all dead now and have left no
heirs to collect the money. It of course all escheats to the
State. The Government is the beneficiary now. Will you do so?” This
was almost too much, and I lost my temper. “You will get no such list
from me,” I said, and I got up and left him.
Morgenthau was appalled by the Turk’s greed in trying to squeeze
profit from the Armenians’ slaughter, and the story caught Yeghiayan’s
attention. What happened to these policies? Were they ever paid? If
so, to whom?
He investigated, beginning with a letter to the U.S. State
Department. He was referred to the National Archives, and after
further conversations he received 600 pages of correspondence and
other documents on microfiche. As best Yeghiayan could determine, the
death benefits on thousands of unredeemed insurance policies remained
unpaid.
Yeghiayan saw how he could do more for Armenians than protest in front
of the Turkish consulate every April 24. By his calculation, New York
Life and other insurance companies owed the heirs of genocide victims
millions, maybe tens of millions, of dollars in benefits. So far, the
world had largely ignored the Armenian genocide. Insurance benefits
weren’t reparations, but they would give the victims’ heirs something
of value and, more important, forcing their payment could be a way of
getting people to recognize that something horrible had happened in
Turkey more than 70 years before. “I knew we had to file a lawsuit,”
Yeghiayan said. “The question was, Do we have a client?”
THROUGH THE EARLY 1970s, few Armenians spoke publicly of the massacre,
and most of the survivors were interested more in rebuilding their
lives than in demanding justice. That seemed fine to much of the
world. The Soviet Union, which had invaded and annexed Armenia in
1920, prohibited Armenians from discussing the genocide. The Soviets
did not want to stir nationalist sentiments that might provoke unrest,
and they were eager to gain Turkey as an ally. In the United States,
the phrase “starving Armenians,” used in the 1920s by mothers to
remind their children why they should eat their vegetables, was
quickly forgotten. The American lapse of memory resulted more from
neglect than policy, but there was little incentive to remind people
of the tragedy: The United States wanted to remain an ally of Turkey,
a valuable buffer between the Soviets and the Middle East.
In Turkey itself, the government and most Turks denied that the
genocide had occurred, a position established soon after the founding
of the Republic of Turkey in 1923 by Mustafa Kemal Ataturk, Turkey’s
most successful World War I general and the leader of a nationalist
movement to rid the nation of minorities and foreign influence. Under
Ataturk, official history held that a purely Turkish republic emerged
from a war of liberation with imperialist Europe rather than, in large
part, from a campaign to cleanse Turkey of its Armenian minority. By
describing the nation as “a new birth,” this revision of history
allowed Turks to forget the past. It permitted them to avoid the shame
and other “psychological crises generated by the legacy of the past,”
explained the historian Taner Akcam, a visiting professor at the
University of Minnesota who, in the 1970s, became one of the first
Turkish academics to publicly acknowledge the genocide.
After 1923, Turkish schools taught that thousands of Armenians died
during World War I as an unfortunate consequence of disease, famine,
and war. Other Armenians were executed or deported because they
participated in insurrections, students were told, but total deaths
and deportations numbered far less than a million, because not that
many Armenians lived in Turkey at the time. The Turkish government
reinforced these teachings by prosecuting anyone who publicly
questioned them, including Akcam, who was sentenced in 1976 to 10
years in prison, though he escaped to Germany after a year.
Despite a half century of reticence, many Armenians believed it was
essential to prove that the defining event of their history was not
fiction and, during the 1970s, they began to speak out. In the United
States they created national advocacy organizations like the Armenian
Assembly, started in 1972, and in 1975 they persuaded the U.S. House
of Representatives to designate April 24 as a national day of
remembrance for the genocide (the Senate did not pass the
resolution). Armenian terrorists struck Turkish targets in Europe, the
Middle East, and the United States, killing dozens of Turkish
diplomats. In 1981, they took 60 hostages at the Turkish consulate in
Paris. These and other efforts to gain recognition for the genocide
made Turkey even more determined to block that recognition. In the
United States, the Turks exploited their strategic value as a military
counterweight to the Soviet Union. During a 1987 House debate,
Congressman James M. Leath, a Texas Democrat, explained his opposition
to legislation that characterized the events of 1915 to 1923 as
genocide. “It does not have anything to do with genocide,” he
said. “It does not have anything to do with our feelings against what
happened to the Armenians. The bottom line is that . . . the president
of Turkey, the Turkish people, say if you do this, you hurt your
security.” The legislation failed to pass.
THERE IS NO RECORD OF WHAT HAPPENED after New York Life invited Yegsa
Marootian to its Pasadena offices in 1956. She may not have gone, or
she may have failed to complete some other step required to claim
death benefits under the life insurance policy. In any event, the
company never refused to pay her. When Yegsa died in 1982, the policy
was still outstanding.
Alice Asoian, Yegsa’s oldest child, inherited the policy but thought
little about it until 1989, when she noticed an advertisement in a
local newspaper seeking “insurance papers.” The ad had been placed by
Yeghiayan. It had been running for several weeks, prompting dozens of
local Armenians to send him photos of deceased relatives but no
insurance policies or other evidence that the relatives were
insured. Yeghiayan despaired of finding a client who could get his
lawsuit off the ground, but then he received a phone call from
Alice. When he visited her home in Irvine, she brought out a shoebox
containing the original life insurance policy of Setrak Cheytanian,
all the premium payment stubs, and correspondence between Yegsa and
New York Life dating back to the 1920s. Yeghiayan, it seemed, had a
client.
But the reality was not so simple. In 1994, as Yeghiayan prepared the
lawsuit, Alice died, and the policy’s beneficiary changed again. This
time, it was Alice’s brother, Martin Marootian. Fortunately for
Yeghiayan, Martin took to the role of plaintiff with enthusiasm.
A retired pharmacist and gentle-spoken grandfather, Marootian, 90, was
proud to recount his family’s saga. “This is the man in question,” he
said during a recent interview, pointing to his Uncle Cheytanian
wearing a fez and a walrus moustache in a 1905 photograph. Of the 11
Armenians in the photo, only Marootian’s mother, Yegsa, and his
sister, Alice, had survived the massacre. He stressed that he
appreciated the historic opportunity that the lawsuit represented for
him and for other Armenians. “I wanted,” he said, “to tie the genocide
to our case.”
YEGHIAYAN PLANNED TO MAKE THE CASE A CLASS ACTION LAWSUIT on behalf of
every beneficiary of every life insurance policy purchased from New
York Life by a victim of the genocide. On the basis of historical
records, he estimated the class at 2,300 people. But the case
presented a monumental challenge for Yeghiayan and his four-lawyer
firm in Glendale. His wife, who helped run the firm, was an
immigration lawyer, and Yeghiayan had worked mostly on small
personal-injury cases. Alone, they could not cover the extraordinary
expenses of a lawsuit that would surely take years or handle the
thousands of documents that would be traded between the
parties. Yeghiayan knew that he needed help, and in 2000, after he
filed the case in U.S. District Court in Los Angeles, he hired two Los
Angeles-area lawyers with experience in class actions and an interest
in seeing the Armenian genocide recognized. One was Brian Kabateck,
whose grandparents had survived the genocide. The other was William
Shernoff, who had worked on lawsuits seeking reparations for the
Holocaust.
The team faced serious legal obstacles almost immediately. The biggest
was the expiration of the statute of limitations, the legally
prescribed time limit for suing over the policies. “The only way I was
going to get around the statute of limitations,” acknowledged
Yeghiayan, “was to say . . . there is no statute of limitations on
genocide.” He knew it was a weak argument, and he reached out again
for help, this time to California’s politically powerful Armenian
community. With the assistance of former California Governor George
Deukmejian and state Senator Charles Poochigian, both of Armenian
ancestry, Yeghiayan persuaded the California Legislature to extend the
statute of limitations. With that obstacle to the lawsuit removed,
lawyers on both sides reached a tentative settlement for $10 million
in April 2001.
Kabateck, Shernoff, and New York Life issued press releases announcing
the settlement. But when Marootian learned of the deal, he rejected
it, saying the lawyers were pressuring him to give up. Yeghiayan
immediately denied having agreed to settle and accused his colleagues
of going behind his back. Later in April, he fired Shernoff and
Kabateck.
The falling out threatened to end the lawsuit, but Yeghiayan persuaded
Mark Geragos, another lawyer of Armenian descent, to join him, and
Geragos talked Yeghiayan into reconciling with Shernoff and
Kabateck. No sooner was the team back together, though, than it had to
face the motion to dismiss that New York Life had filed before the
settlement fell through. Among other points, the insurer argued that
the plaintiffs could not sue in Los Angeles, because the policies
specified French or English courts as the forums for any legal
disputes. Yeghiayan’s team responded that it would be unfair to
require elderly clients like Marootian to sue abroad, but the lawyers
feared that the case was on shaky ground. Almost every suit tied to
compensation for long-ago injustices, from the Holocaust to American
slavery to South African apartheid, had failed because of problems
like a lack of evidence. Though this suit was based on insurance
contracts, only Marootian had a documented policy.
On November 28, 2001, the day of the hearing on the motion to dismiss,
Yeghiayan entered Judge Snyder’s courtroom minutes after rejecting the
settlement offer from New York Life. He placed his litigation bag on
the wooden table facing the judge’s bench and sat down. The Marootians
were in the audience behind him, and around them sat dozens of
Armenians whom Yeghiayan had invited.
As they waited for Judge Snyder to take the bench, her clerk appeared
from a side door and announced an unexpected development. There would
be no hearing, because the judge had reached a decision on the motion
to dismiss. The clerk approached the dozen or so lawyers with copies
of the judge’s written ruling, and, almost simultaneously, they turned
to the last page of the decision. “All I wanted to see was that last
sentence,” Yeghiayan recalled. It said, “NYLIC’s motion to dismiss
. . . is hereby DENIED.”
THE VICTORY FORCED NEW YORK LIFE BACK TO THE NEGOTIATING TABLE, but
the case was not over. The company still blamed the rejection of the
April 2001 settlement on Yeghiayan, and it “didn’t trust him after
that,” said Shernoff. “They would say, ‘If he agrees today, how do we
know he’s not going to turn on us tomorrow?’ ”
Mediations before two retired judges and dozens of negotiating
sessions failed to bring the parties closer, and in 2003, Geragos and
Kabateck asked California Insurance Commissioner John Garamendi to get
involved. Garamendi had helped negotiate settlements between insurance
companies and plaintiffs seeking reparations for the Holocaust. In the
fall, he flew to New York City to meet with Seymour Sternberg, the CEO
of New York Life, and after two sessions they broke the deadlock. In
January 2004, New York Life agreed to pay $20 million, twice the
amount offered in 2001. Yeghiayan knew that it was enough.
Dozens of documents gathered as evidence in lawsuit theincluding the
first list of the names, addresses, and occupations of many of the
victims massacre’swere put online, providing fresh details of the
slaughter. Last October, the French insurance company AXA settled a
similar lawsuit (also Yeghiayan’s) for $17 million, prompting Aram I,
a spiritual leader of the Armenian Church outside Armenia, to praise
the two settlements for “raising awareness” of the Armenian
genocide. Hundreds of newspapers and television stations reported the
settlements and mentioned the genocide. The Turkish Daily News,
published in Ankara, was one of the newspapers that ran a story. It
referred to the genocide as “the disputed events between the Ottoman
Empire and its Armenian citizens at the beginning of the 20th
century.”…
Michael Bobelian is a lawyer and freelance journalist based in New York.
ASBAREZ Online [04-03-2006]
ASBAREZ ONLINE
TOP STORIES
04/03/2006
TO ACCESS PREVIOUS ASBAREZ ONLINE EDITIONS PLEASE VISIT OUR
WEBSITE AT <;HTTP://WWW.ASBAREZ. COM
1) Genocide Commemoration Announcement
2) Oskanian Meets with Kofi Annan And UN Leadership
3) Rice and Mamedyarov to Meet in Washington
4) Kurdish Protests Toll Rises to 15
1) Genocide Commemoration Announcement
April 24, Armenian Genocide Commemoration Day, is fast approaching. 91 years
after the Genocide, Armenian people are still deprived of their rights. Turkey
refuses to acknowledge the Genocide, which it thoroughly planned and
perpetrated, and is now launching denialist campaigns throughout the world,
before the international community.
Turkey's denial is not a new crime. It adds to the still unpunished crime
against humanity.
The Armenian people will pursue their rights until a just solution is
reached.
The demand for these rights has only gotten stronger, as Armenians continue
political activities in Europe, the US, and the Middle East, in order put
press
on Turkey, and to gain genocide recognition and restitution for the Armenian
people.
In order to make our voice heard, the political, cultural, and community
organizations of California Armenians will commemorate those who lost their
lives in the Genocide together. The central commemorative event will be
held at
the Genocide Monument in Montebello on Sunday, April 23 at 4 PM.
We call on all Armenians in California to attend this event so that our voice
will be heard throughout the world.
Further information will be provided by the media.
Respectfully,
Western Diocese of the Armenian Church North America
Western Prelacy of the Armenian of Apostolic Church
California Armenian Catholic Community
Armenian Evangelical Community of California
ARF "Dashnagtsutyun" of Western USA
Armenian Democratic Liberal Party (Ramgavar)
Armenian General Benevolent Union
Armenian Society of Los Angeles
Istanbul Armenian Organization
Armenian Youth Association of California
2) Oskanian Meets with Kofi Annan And UN Leadership
Armenian Foreign Minister Vartan Oskanian met last week with Kofi Annan,
Secretary General of the United Nations (UN), Jan Eliasson, President of the
General Assembly of the UN, and Kemal Dervis, Administrator of the UN
Development Program.
During his meetings with Secretary General Annan and Eliasson, Oskanian
discussed the Karabagh resolution process as well as recent ceasefire
violations. He expressed Armenia's serious concern that the military rhetoric
of Azerbaijan's leaders is leading to increasingly more frequent ceasefire
violations by the Azeri military along the line of contact.
Armenia's Foreign Minister also discussed UN reforms, and welcomed the
formation of the new Human Rights Council, reiterating Armenia's desire to
remain engaged in human rights issues.
In these meetings, and during his talks with Dervis, Oskanian also stressed
Armenia's commitment to rural development. He stressed that the Millennium
Challenge Compact, recently signed with the US government, will create a
necessary momentum to spur development and that the Armenian government is
committed to building on this momentum with its comprehensive plan. He said
the
Armenian government's plan for rural development is based on a public-private
partnership, which includes Armenia's diaspora, Armenia's business community,
the Armenian government, and international organizations.
3) Rice and Mamedyarov to Meet in Washington
YEREVAN (RFE/RL/PanArmenian.Net)--Russia's chief Karabagh negotiator and Minsk
Group co-chair Yuri Merzlyakov said Monday that the foreign ministers of
Armenia and Azerbaijan will hold further discussions on the Karabagh conflict
this week in Moscow and Washington respectively.
Azerbaijan's Foreign Minister Elmar Mamedyarov will meet with US Secretary of
State Condoleezza Rice in Washington, DC from April 6-7. At the same time,
Armenia's Foreign Minister Vartan Oskanian is scheduled to meet his Russian
counterpart Sergey Lavrov in Moscow. The Karabagh dispute will be high on the
agenda of both talks.
"The Minsk Group is today working in a more bilateral format. Namely, the
co-chairs plus a representative of Armenia or Azerbaijan," said Merzlyakov.
Merzlyakov said that the peace process is not in deadlock and may still yield
a breakthrough this year. He pointed to a continuing flurry of diplomatic
activity involving top representatives of the conflicting parties as well as
the three nations co-chairing the OSCE Minsk Group.
The Russian diplomat added that the Minsk Group's French co-chair, Bernard
Fassier, will pay a separate visit to Baku and Yerevan later this month. The
group's third, US co-chair, Steven Mann, toured the conflict zone last
month as
part of a high-level US delegation led by Assistant Secretary of State Dan
Fried.
In a March 27 speech in Washington, Fried said he was "sufficiently
encouraged" by what he was told by Azeri and Armenian leaders. He also said
that the United States will not seek to impose any solutions on the parties.
"We're not going to force Armenia or Azerbaijan to take anything," he said.
Merzlyakov also stated that the international mediators do not plan to
arrange
another meeting between Presidents Robert Kocharian and Ilham Aliyev in the
coming months. He said the two leaders could only meet on the sidelines of an
international forum.
"The meeting of the Presidents should be properly prepared and this demands
time," he said.
4) Kurdish Protests Toll Rises to 15
ISTANBUL (Reuters)--Hundreds of Kurds clashed with police in southeast Turkey
on Monday and in Istanbul three people were killed as they fled a bus set
ablaze by protesters, bringing the death toll over the past week to 15.
The latest violence sustained a week of unrest triggered by the funerals
of 14
rebels from the outlawed Kurdistan Workers Party (PKK) who were killed in
clashes with security forces.
It marked some of Turkey's worst civil unrest since the PKK took up arms
against the state in 1984 in an insurgency which has killed more than 30,000
people and fueled fears of an escalation of the conflict.
Demonstrators threw petrol bombs at a bus on Sunday evening and Istanbul's
governor said the three died, apparently crushed by the bus, as they fled.
Anatolian news agency said the three victims were two teenage sisters and a
62-year-old woman.
In Istanbul's Gazi district, which has a sizeable Kurdish population, police
also fired tear gas to break up a 150-strong group of stone-throwing youths
who
had set up barricades and set fire to rubbish containers, CNN Turk reported.
"Molotovs in their bags, massacre on its way," Hurriyet newspaper said in a
headline below a photo of masked youths setting petrol bombs alight.
Police fired tear gas and water cannon to break up a crowd of some 500
protesters in Viransehir near the Syrian border, chanting slogans in
support of
jailed PKK leader Abdullah Ocalan and waving PKK flags, security officials
said.
Police fired shots into the air and the crowd scattered from the main square,
throwing petrol bombs and stones at the security forces and local buildings,
smashing some windows.
The governor's office in the mainly Kurdish region's largest city Diyarbakir
said the toll there had risen to nine after three people died in hospital. Two
people have died in Kiziltepe near the Syrian border and one in the town of
Batman.
"We have launched rapid efforts to heal the wounds... In 10 days 30 of our
citizens have lost their lives," said Diyarbakir mayor Osman Baydemir.
Baydemir said it was "shameful" that an official investigation had been
launched into comments he had made about the latest violence, including the
deaths of the militants.
The cabinet is expected to discuss the violence at a meeting on Monday and
parliament is scheduled to hold a debate on the issue on Tuesday.
Some 360 people have been injured in the violence, including 199 members of
the security forces. Of 566 people detained by police, 354 have been remanded
in custody awaiting trial.
Political analysts and diplomats say the violence reflects local anger over
high unemployment, poverty and Ankara's refusal to grant more autonomy to the
mainly Kurdish region.
Ankara, like the European Union and the United States, regards the PKK as a
terrorist organization responsible for the deaths of more than 30,000 people
since it launched its armed campaign for an ethnic homeland in 1984.
But many Kurds sympathize with the PKK.
The country's main Kurdish political group, the Democratic Society Party
(DTP)
said the government had failed to respond to its calls for talks on the
violence.
"We wanted to talk with (Prime Minister Tayyip) Erdogan, but this was
rejected. There is a lack of dialogue," DTP deputy chairman Hasip Kaplan said
during a visit to the Diyarbakir mayor.
The local DTP leader in Batman turned himself in to police on Monday a day
after police ordered his arrest for calling on locals to take part in protest
marches.
All subscription inquiries and changes must be made through the proper carrier
and not Asbarez Online. ASBAREZ ONLINE does not transmit address changes and
subscription requests.
(c) 2006 ASBAREZ ONLINE. All Rights Reserved.
ASBAREZ provides this news service to ARMENIAN NEWS NETWORK members for
academic research or personal use only and may not be reproduced in or through
mass media outlets.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress
California Courier Online, April 6, 2006
California Courier Online, April 6, 2006
1 – Commentary
Media Criticism Pushes State Dept.
To Respond to Armenian Concerns
By Harut Sassounian
Publisher, The California Courier
2 – Fear Fuels Turkish Denial of Genocide
3 – KCET’s Life & Times Profiles Filmmaker
Dr. J Michael Hagopian on April 12
4 – Commentary
‘Protestcide’ – The Killing of Protest of a Denial of Genocide
By Israel W. Charny
5 – Prof. Ronald Grigor Suny Will
Lecture April 14 at Merdinian
6 – Glendale Names Annual Diamond Award
Recipients for Achievement in the Arts
7 – Armenian Bar Association to
Honor Five Judges on April 12
8 – Ararat Home Dinner Dance
Committee Plans for April 29
9 – LACC Screens ‘Ararat’ on April 23;
Reception for Film Star David Alpay
10 – Armenia Fund Telethon
Story Touches Hearts
******************************************* ******************************
1 – Commentary
Media Criticism Pushes State Dept.
To Respond to Armenian Concerns
By Harut Sassounian
Publisher, The California Courier
As April 24 is drawing near, what Turks apprehensively call “the
approaching Armenian Tsunami” is haunting not only the Turkish government
but also officials at the State Department.
Various newspapers have unleashed a barrage of attacks on the State
Department in recent weeks questioning and even castigating it for not
acknowledging the Armenian Genocide and recalling the U.S. Ambassador to
Armenia, John Evans who had dared to utter the words, Armenian Genocide.
The news of his recall was first reported by this writer last month.
The following articles and editorials were published in the last two weeks:
— The Los Angeles Daily News headlined its March 21st article: “Status of
U.S. ambassador to Armenia questioned.” The paper quoted Cong. Adam Schiff
as saying: “I made it clear [to the State Dept.] I thought any action taken
against him [Amb. Evans] would merely compound the erroneous policy of the
administration.”
— The Los Angeles Times published a lengthy and hard-hitting editorial on
March 22, titled: “It was genocide.” It said: “the State Dept. has long
avoided the word ‘genocide,’ not out of any dispute over history but out of
deference to Turkey…. It is time to stop tiptoeing around this issue and to
accept settled history…. Punishing an ambassador for speaking honestly
about a 90-year-old crime befits a cynical, double-dealing monarchy, not
the leader of the free world.” The editorial concluded: “One day, the
country that was founded as a direct repudiation of its Ottoman past will
face its history squarely, as part of a long-overdue maturing process. Some
day before then, we hope, the State Dept. will too.” The week before this
editorial was published, this writer along with a colleague met with the
editorial board of the L.A. Times.
— The Independent (UK) published on March 23 an article titled: “Row over
US ambassador’s Armenia genocide remark.” The paper reported: “protests are
growing over the possible recall of the US ambassador in Armenia.”
— The Fresno Bee published an editorial on March 24, titled: “Speak the
Truth: U.S. ambassador to Armenia in hot water over use of ‘genocide.'” The
paper’s editors castigated the State Dept. for threatening the career of
Amb. Evnas by saying: “Shame on the State Department.” The Fresno Bee
called on the State Dept., Congress, the administration, as well as the
government of Turkey to recognize the Armenian Genocide: “The facts are
plain. The history is clear. Turkey offends the victims’ survivors with its
intransigence, but hurts itself most of all when it continues to deny what
the entire world knows.”
— The Glendale News Press published a front-page story on March 26,
titled: “Officials question the fate of diplomat.”
— The chain of McClatchy newspapers published on March 28 a lengthy
article titled: “Genocide comment could cost Ambassador to Armenia his
job.” It reported that Cong. George Radanovich (Rep. of Calif.) has called
the State Dept. requesting a meeting to discuss the fate of Amb. Evans.
— The Washington Times published an article on March 31, titled: “Recall
from Armenia?”
Following this barrage of news reports and commentaries, Daniel Fried, the
Assistant Secretary of State for European and Eurasian Affairs, addressed
the Armenian Assembly’s National Conference in Washington, D.C., on March
27. Here are excerpts from his remarks and responses to questions from the
audience:
“The U.S. position on events of 1915 has not changed. We believe that a
productive dialogue is the best way to establish a shared understanding of
history that honors the victims of these horrific events, murders on a mass
scale, killings without justification, deportations. Over 1.5 million
people lost their lives, innocent victims. But we want to foster
reconciliation and peace based on an understanding of history, not a denial
of it. We believe that the tragedy of 1915, the killings, is of enormous
human significance and its historical assessment should be determined not
on the basis of politics, but introspection among civic leaders and
scholars. This process has begun in Turkey where it needs to take place,”
Fried said. He was interrupted by a member of the audience who shouted:
“horse manure!”
Fried then continued: “Sitting here with us is my old friend John Evans,
our Ambassador in Yerevan. He is the Ambassador, remains the Ambassador,
has… [Applause and cheers]. Like all of us, we all serve at the pleasure of
the President. Amb. Evans came from Yerevan for the signing of the
Millennium Challenge Account Compact this afternoon, and will be in the
meeting this afternoon between Secretary Rice and Foreign Minister
Oskanian. There has been a great deal of speculation. I don’t discuss
personnel issues, but since my friend is sitting here, I thought I would
recognize Amb. John Evans [Applause].”
When asked why foreign countries such as Turkey are permitted to dictate
America’s foreign policy vis-à-vis Armenia and Cyprus, Fried replied:
“Third parties are not permitted to dictate our foreign policy, nor do they
dictate our foreign policy. We have a policy which many of you disagree
with. I understand. But we have a policy of seeking to encourage Turkey to
reflect more seriously about subjects which have been taboo for generations
in that country. I said earlier that process has begun in Turkey. You
recall that the famous Turkish writer Orhan Pamuk spoke clearly about this.
He is not the only Turk speaking out. As I said, this process has begun as
Turkish society modernizes, and as it modernizes, as democracy in Turkey
deepens, Turkey will have to go through what many other countries such as
the United States have had to go through in our own history, which is
looking back at the darker spots in our past. With respect to the United
States, those darker spots include things like slavery and racial
discrimination, treatment of American Indians, and in my opinion,
internment of American citizens of Japanese origin in camps in World War
II. Those are painful subjects. Just as dealing with the history of the
mass killings of Armenians is painful for Turkey. And by the way, I say
this to my Turkish friends using the same words. We keep one set of books.
Now that process has begun in Turkey. It is certainly not going fast enough
to satisfy you. It is not going fast enough to satisfy us. But this process
has begun and it will, I hope, bring greater understanding to Turks of
their own history. We will continue to have a dialogue about this as April
24th approaches. I will not attempt to anticipate what the President will
say. I do believe he will issue a statement on April 24th, in fact I can’t
believe there won’t be one. And I expect, as we have in the past, to
consult with the Armenian Assembly about this and to have a frank set of
discussions before and after.”
In response to a question about “Turkey exporting its denialist tactics to
the U.S.,” Fried said: “The United States government has never denied the
events of 1915. We do not support, what was the phrase, “export of
denialist literature or positions.” We do support efforts by Turkey to deal
with its history more seriously. As I said, this process has begun. It has
not ended. Efforts such as the Truth and Reconciliation Commission [the
correct name is: “Turkish Armenian Reconciliation Commission” or TARC] were
serious, and these were efforts in which Turkish as well as Armenian
scholars were involved. It produced a serious look at those issues which we
have recognized officially. This is not an easy issue. It is not an easy
issue for the United States government, and we are not at the end of the
road on this issue. We will continue to urge our Turkish friends to face
difficult issues of their past seriously, and we will urge Armenia to help
the Turks make this possible without ever sacrificing historical truth or
your position.”
When asked a direct question about the recall of Amb. Evans, Fried provided
the usual evasive answer: “We all serve at the pleasure of the President. I
won’t discuss personnel issues. Amb. Evans, as I said, is a friend of more
than 20 years standing. He’s our Ambassador. He’s right here. He will be in
the meetings today at the State Department, as I said. [Applause].”
The above exchange shows that while Dan Fried was trying to be as gracious
as possible to his Armenian hosts, he was nevertheless sticking to the
administration’s unacceptable policy of substituting euphemisms for the
Armenian Genocide. He also continued to avoid making any forthright
comments on Amb. Evans, despite persistent media criticisms.
************************************** ************************************
2 – Fear Fuels Turkish Denial of Genocide
By Jay Logan Rogers
SALT LAKE CITY, UT – The Turkish government refuses to acknowledge the
genocide committed against the Armenians, said Richard Hovannisian,
professor of Armenian and near-eastern history at the University of
California at Los Angeles.
He said there are psychological reasons that Turkey refuses to admit the
genocide occurred.
“They don’t want to believe that their grandparents could’ve been
murderers,” Hovannisian explained. “They also don’t want to deal with the
consequences of recognition, including contrition and restitution.”
Hovannisian commented on the contemporary interpretations of the Armenian
genocide at the Hinckley Institute of Politics on March 23.
Between 1915 and 1918, actions of the government of the Ottoman Empire
(present-day Turkey) resulted in the elimination of a substantial portion
of its Armenian minority population.
While the exact numbers are in dispute, most scholars agree that more than
one million Armenians were killed through outright massacres and mass
deportations to barren deserts, where they were left to starve.
Hovannisian’s talk focused on the scholarly debate over whether the
genocide was premeditated or a “crime of passion” that occurred suddenly
during the tense conditions of war.
He expressed his opinion that the elimination of the Armenians had been
contemplated by the Ottoman government before the outbreak of war, but that
it was wartime conditions that allowed it to turn a “final solution into an
accomplished fact.”
The Ottoman Empire distrusted the Armenians, in part because they were a
tight-knit Christian ethnic group in the middle of a mostly Muslim empire,
Hovannisian said.
While some Armenians were agitating for self-government and autonomy, most
were not involved in any politically dissident activities, he said.
“They were an ethnic group seen as potentially troublesome to an
authoritarian state at war,” he said.
No official government document specifically outlining the Ottoman plan to
eliminate Armenians has been found, although there is overwhelming evidence
that the massacres occurred, he said.
There may be a “smoking gun” somewhere in Turkish archives proving that the
Ottomans premeditated the Armenian genocide, Hovannisian said, but the
nation’s government does not provide Western historians with access to
those materials.
Jonathan Cates, a senior in history and Middle East studies, said he
thought it was a fair explanation of the historical event. “He gave a broad
overview of all the current interpretations and put them in good context,”
he said.
Mariya Mamaeva, a senior in political science and Russian, agreed. “I think
he has very good points and is very insightful,” she said.
************************************************** ************************
3 – KCET’s Life & Times Profiles Filmmaker
Dr. J Michael Hagopian on April 12
LOS ANGELES – Life & Times, KCET television’s signature local news and
public affairs series, profiles Armenian filmmaker Michael Hagopian on
April 12, in a segment that will also be available online at KCET.org.
For 25 years, Hagopian has traveled the world interviewing survivors of
the Armenian mass killings of 1915. Host Val Zavala visits with the former
UCLA professor-turned-filmmaker at his home-based workshop, which contains
about 400 interviews he has captured on film for his next documentary
“Caravans Along the Euphrates.” Life & Times airs Monday – Friday (6:30
p.m. – 7 p.m..) on KCET.
Born in Turkey, Hagopian and his family survived these killings, also known
as the Armenian Genocide, because his father, a skilled physician, was in
great demand. The story of Hagopian’s filmmaking career begins in Fresno,
California, includes stops at prestigious universities, and takes viewers
on a fascinating journey of one man’s passion for communicating the history
of his homeland through film. Hagopian has produced and directed two
documentaries on the Armenian genocide. Now in his 80’s, Hagopian’s third
and current project, “Caravans Along the Euphrates,” is significant because
it uses survivors to tell the story.
KCET broadcasts the premiere of “Le Génocide Arménien” (“The Armenian
Genocide”), the 2005 documentary by French filmmaker Laurence Jourdan, on
April 17 (9 -10 p.m.). The encore of “My Son Shall Be Armenian” by
Armenian-Canadian filmmaker Hagop Goudsouzian airs on April 24 (9 p.m. to
10:30 p.m.), followed by a repeat of the Life & Times segment featuring
Michael Hagopian.
dditional information about the films and filmmakers is available on
KCET.org.
************************************* **************************************
4 – Commentary
Introduction by Richard Kloian
Press Liaison for IAGS
On the heels of a number of articles denying the Armenian Genocide,
beginning in December 2005 and for several weeks afterward, the President
of the International Association of Genocide Scholars (IAGS), Professor
Israel Charny, drafted a critical response to one of the publications,
Commentary, to set the record straight and to criticize them for crossing
the line between responsible journalism, ethical editorial control, and
outright siding with deniers.
The irony in this will not escape those who remember that it was the very
same publication that many years ago published a piece on the Armenian
Genocide by Marjorie Housepian called “The Unremembered Genocide” which
helped trigger new interest in the Armenian Genocide. Israel Charny too
credits that article with his first learning about the Armenian Genocide.
In effect it was a major springboard years later to the first major
conference on Holocaust and Genocide that was held in Tel Aviv in 1982,
organized by Charny and others and it was the conference that for the first
time included papers on the Armenian Genocide.
‘Protestcide’ – The Killing of Protest of a Denial of Genocide
By Israel W. Charny
To what extent does a publication have the right to alter a Letter to the
Editor that criticizes the publication, and then to publish their altered
version of the letter without the full permission of the letter writer,
especially in light of his explicit refusal to approve their revision?
In December 2005, Commentary published a lengthy article denying the
Armenian Genocide by one, Guenter Lewy, a retired professor who has
previously published denials of other genocides as well, including a denial
that the Gypsies were victims of genocide in WW II (Simon Wiesenthal
defended the role of the Gypsies as fellow victims of the Holocaust, and on
several occasions wrote and told passionately of seeing the Gypsies in
Auschwitz in the barracks right next to his); and including a denial that
the Native Americans (Indians) were victims of genocide in America. It is
clear that Lewy has established himself as an arch specialist in denial who
has now relegated no less than three victim peoples to some kind of status
of sufferers other than victims of genocidal mass murder. I think that
readers of this current Commentary piece denying there was a genocide of
the Armenians had a right to know of the author’s previous publications of
denials (one of which was also in Commentary), but not a word was
mentioned.
Lewy’s article in Commentary is entitled, “The first genocide of the 20th
century?” Lewy himself mentions in his article that the International
Association of Genocide Scholars, of which I am the current president, had
passed a unanimous resolution some years ago confirming the validity of the
Armenian Genocide. When Commentary was approached by a colleague as to
whether they would publish a rejoinder to Lewy’s article by me, the editor
agreed immediately to receive a 600-word statement from me. So far to
their credit. But then in the grotesque sequence of censorship and
revisions of my rejoinder that follows, Commentary at first refused to
identify my connection to the same Association that passed the resolution,
and finally did in fact identify me as somehow affiliated with the
Association but eliminated identifying my leadership role. A personal
slight? Then it’s irrelevant. Or is it a diminution of the significance
of my protest? In the meantime, Commentary published a lengthy
rejoinder by Lewy in the same issue with the following statement that, by a
wave of the Lewy-Commentary wand removes any significance to our
association’s informed judgment: “I am less than impressed by the
unanimous vote of the International Association of Genocide Scholars that
the Armenian case ‘was one of the major genocides of the modern era” writes
Denier Lewy conclusively and then presumptuously slams the members of the
association that virtually no one (but him) has done real research.
No matter. Commentary commits more serious infringements to the point of
not allowing me to voice my definite judgment about their question, “The
first genocide of the 20th century?”
In my letter I write about how the Turks also killed other Christian
(therefore non-Turkish) groups such as the Assyrians and Greeks as well as
the Armenians (the first Christian people of Europe) and that this was
“outright genocidal murder.” Commentary removed this vital statement from
my letter. Remember, the article by Lewy they have published is asking
explicitly if this was genocide, and the section of Letters to the Editor
in February is re-entitled, “Genocide?” but my clear-cut rejoinder that it
was “outright genocidal murder” was not permitted.
Moreover, what does Lewy do? I say in my letter that I wonder if readers
of the Jewish-sponsored Commentary (this remark by me is also censored out)
know that the Turks were also responsible for two forced expulsions of Jews
from Jaffa-Tel Aviv in 1914 and 1917, both of which resulted in losses of
life of the elderly, infirm and ill. As if referring to this information,
Lewy says to me in his rejoinder, “Mr. Charny stops short of calling these
occurrences ‘genocide,'” but he and the hard-working editor who we have
seen manages to censor my writing so fastidiously, thus manage to get
across a message that seems to refer to the whole bigger original issue of
the Armenian Genocide. Now, not only have I not been allowed to say what I
did say that there was clear-cut genocide, but it is as if claimed
explicitly that I too don’t call the Ottoman murders genocide.
Higher-class deniers, like Lewy and Commentary, are a fascinating study in
the propagandistic logic-defying language mechanisms they employ —
Commentary also removed from my letter a reference to an article that
Daphna Fromer and myself published in the British journal, Patterns of
Prejudice in which we analyzed the language-logic of earlier deniers of the
Armenian Genocide.
Ultimately, my most serious criticism is that Commentary is fully
responsible alongside of its author for publishing a bald exposition of
denial of an established major genocide. Thus, I conclude my letter,
“Regrettably, Mr. Lewy and Commentary too have now earned places in the
pantheon of genocide Deniers,” but — by now you guessed it — you will
never see that sentence, or an earlier statement similarly critical of
Commentary in the letter they published.
I ask, do responsible publications in a free world have the right to censor
and arbitrarily revise Letters to the Editor beyond considerations of
space, bad language such as epithets, and ad hominem attacks (but not
legitimate major criticisms of an author or the publication!)? Obviously a
publication holds the ultimate power and can simply decline to publish a
letter (who will
ever know?). But to cut and revise and remove and distort the thrust of
the original message, and fail to advise and fail to get approval of
changes? I don’t know if there are legal controls against such tampering
with the lowly institution of a Letter to an Editor and/or op-ed writing,
but I do know such tampering violates the “natural law” of journalistic
integrity, and I think Commentary should be told so by an informed public.
Israel W. Charny is the President of the International Association of
Genocide Scholars, Editor-in-Chief, Encyclopedia of Genocide, and Executive
Director, Institute on the Holocaust & Genocide, Jerusalem.
An e-mail transcript of all texts and correspondence between Charny and
Commentary is available immediately on request to [email protected].
********’********************** *******************************************
5 – Prof. Ronald Grigor Suny Will
Lecture April 14 at Merdinian
SHERMAN OAKS, CA – The ARPA Institute will feature Prof. Ronald Grigor Suny
at a Lecture, “Why Genocide: How can
we Understand the Turkish Deportations and Massacres of the Ottoman
Armenians,” on April 14, at 7:30 PM in the Merdinian school auditorium.,
1330 Riverside Dr., Sherman Oaks, Calif.
Scholars have tried to explain the causes of the Armenian Genocide by
reference to religious differences between Armenians and Turks or the
racist nationalist ideology of the Young Turks and their ambitions to
create a “Turkey for the Turks.”
Professor Suny looks at the variety of explanations that have been offered
and suggests that in order to understand “why genocide” it is necessary to
supplement ideological and social explanations with an exploration of the
emotions involved.
Suny is Charles Tilly Collegiate Professor of Social and Political History
at the University of Michigan, and Professor Emeritus
of Political Science and History at the University of Chicago. A graduate
of Swarthmore College and Columbia University, he taught at Oberlin College
(1968-1981), as visiting professor of history at the University of
California, Irvine (1987), and Stanford University (1995-1996). He was the
first holder of the Alex Manoogian Chair in Modern Armenian History at the
University of Michigan (1981-1995), where he founded and directed the
Armenian Studies Program.
He has authored several books on contemporary Armenian, Russian and
Caucasian history.
Professor Suny has served as chairman of the Society for Armenian Studies
and on the editorial Boards of Slavic Review, International Labor and
Working-Class History, International Journal of Middle East Studies, The
Armenian Review, Journal of the Society for Armenian Studies, and Armenian
Forum. He has appeared numerous times on the McNeil-Lehrer News Hour, CBS
Evening News, CNN, and National Public Radio, and has written for the New
York Times, The Washington Post, The Los Angeles Times, The Nation, New
Left Review, Dissent, and other newspapers and journals. He was recently
elected President of
the American Association for the Advancement of Slavic Studies (2006).
For more information, call Dr. Hagop Panossian at (818) 586-9660.
**************************************** ***************************
6 – Glendale Names Annual Diamond Award
Recipients for Achievement in the Arts
GLENDALE – The City of Glendale Parks, Recreation and Community Services
Department and the Arts and Culture Commission announced the winners of the
First Annual Diamond Awards for Achievement in the Arts. The winners will
be recognized at a public reception on May 3, from 6 to 8 pm in the recital
hall at Brand Library, 1601 W. Mountain.
This new program initiated by the Arts and Culture Commission recognizes
those artists, community members and organizations who have contributed
substantially to the cultural life of the co
mmunity. Nominations were solicited from the community in all categories.
The following winners have been selected as Diamond Award recipients for
2006: David Vartanyan, Young Artist; Mikayel Avetisyan, Artist; Lark
Musical Society, Arts Organization; Ted Osborn, Special Recognition; Edwin
& Hilda Navasartian, Arts Partners – Individual; Jane Friend, Lifetime
Achievement
Recipient Profiles
David Vartanyan is an 8th grade student at Wilson Middle School. He is a
prolific writer of poetry and prose. David is also the Spelling Bee Champ
for his school.
Mikayel Avetisyan is a conductor, composer and instructor at Glendale’s
International School of Music. He received his professional training in
Armenia, Russia, and Europe. He was the principal conductor of the Yerevan
Symphony Orchestra from 1994 – 1997 and the Artistic Director and Principal
Conductor of the Armenian Philharmonic Orchestra from 1997 – 1998. He has
successfully performed throughout the United States, France, Holland,
Greece, Spain, Russia and Turkey. His recordings with the Moscow Symphony
Orchestra were released in 1996 on RCA.
Lark Musical Society was established in 1989 by Vache Barsoumian to instill
the love of music and the arts in its students in a nurturing environment.
Lark actively contributes to fostering an awareness of the interdependence
of Armenian and Western musical arts.
Ted Osborn has been an extremely generous and active supporter of many
community organizations throughout his career; most recently the Alex
Theatre and Glendale’s Animation Initiative. Founder of Osborn Architects,
Ted is retiring in April but will remain in the community as an active
participant.
Edwin & Hilda Navasartian were nominated by Karavan Dance Studio because
of their commitment to the school over the last 5 years. This couple has
supported several dance schools besides Karavan, including Baert Dance
Center in Burbank, Krounk and Arabesq Dance Schools in Glendale
financially, physically and emotionally during concerts and regular dance
practice.
Their dedication and love towards the art of dance and young artists have
made them volunteer many hours.
************************************************* **************************
7 – Armenian Bar Association to
Honor Five Judges on April 12
PASADENA – The Armenian Bar Association (Armenbar) will honor five
outstanding judges on their accomplishments, retirements and
appointments, at an evening reception on April 12, 2006 at the Rococo Room
of Santorini Restaurant in Old Town Pasadena, California. The event is
scheduled to begin at 6:30 p.m.
The honorees include Federal Judge Dickran Tevrizian, Federal Magistrate
Judge Jacqueline Chooljian, and Los Angeles County Superior Court Judges
Richard Kolostian, Ruth Essegian and Maral Injejikian.
“Our organization has a duty to recognize the achievements of these fine
judges, who serve as tremendous role models for attorneys and law students
in the legal community,” said Datev Shenian, Board member of Armenbar.
Tevrizian is a veteran Federal Court judge sitting in the Central District
of the United States District Court. He was first appointed to the Los
Angeles Municipal Court in 1972, at the young age of 31. At that time, he
was the youngest person ever appointed to the bench in Los Angeles County.
He is a nationally recognized jurist who in 1986 became the first person of
Armenian heritage to be appointed to the federal bench. Tevrizian will be
honored for his distinguished career in public service, and upon his change
to senior status on the court.
Judge Chooljian was recently appointed a Magistrate Judge for the U.S.
District Court, Central District of California, where she will preside over
matters in Los Angeles. Prior to her appointment, she served as an
Assistant U.S. Attorney and Special Counsel to the U.S. Attorney for the
Central District of California. She is the first woman of Armenian decent
to be appointed to the federal bench.
Judges Kolostian and Essegian have recently retired from the bench, both
having served at the Northwest District, Van Nuys Courthouse. Kolostian
was appointed to the superior court bench in 1980 by Governor Jerry Brown.
At the time of his retirement in February, 2006, he was the most senior
judge in the Los Angeles County court system, having served 32 years.
During his distinguished term on the bench, he handled a number of matters,
including civil, probate, family law, criminal and juvenile matters. In
1988, he was named Trial Judge of the Year by the San Fernando Valley Bar
Association.
Judge Essegian was appointed in 1989 by Governor George Deukmejian. Prior
to her appointment, she served as a Deputy City Attorney in Pasadena, and
served as a Deputy Attorney General, handling professional licensing cases.
From 1983 to 1987 she joined the Deukmejian administration as a Deputy
Director and Chief of Legal affairs for the Department of Consumer Affairs.
While on the bench, she spent considerable time handling misdemeanor cases
out of the Van Nuys court.
Judge Injejikian was appointed in 1985 by Governor Deukmejian, and has
primarily handled criminal cases. She has had a distinguished career and
has established herself as an experienced trial judge. She is being
recognized for her elevation as the Supervising site judge of the East Los
Angeles Branch Court of the Los Angeles County Superior Court, Central
District.
Armenian delicacies from the kitchen of the award winning Santorini
Mediterranean Restaurant will be served. The fee for admission will be $25.
for Armenbar members, $15. for students and $35. for non-members. For
more information about the event, visit the Armenian Bar Association
website at _www.armenianbar.org_ () .
************************************************* *************************
8- Ararat Home Dinner Dance
Committee Plans for April 29
MISSION HILLS, Calif. – The Ararat Dinner Dance Committee is busy making
arrangements for their annual gala dinner-dance on April 29 in the
Deukmejian Grand Ballroom at the Ararat Home in Mission Hills.
Plans are underway for a very enjoyable evening beginning with a festive
social hour with delectable appetizers, followed by a dinner provided by
Roubina of Roberts Catering.
Armenian and American dance music will be provided by the Continental Band
with Hovig Krikorian. Valet parking is always complimentary.
Nora Hampar, Dinner Dance Chairman states, “We are very fortunate to have
Senator Chuck Poochigian as our Master of Ceremonies. He’s one of the
busiest legislators in Sacramento, and has always been a friend of the
Home.”
The Dinner Dance is known for a very brief and efficient program which all
enjoy. The emphasis has always been on sociability, good food, enjoyable
entertainment, music and dancing.
Since moving this popular event from its regular November time slot into
the spring season, the Committee hopes to bring this event into a less
hectic season for all.
********************************************* ******************************
*
9 – LACC Screens ‘Ararat’ on April 23;
Reception for Film Star David Alpay
LOS ANGELES – The Los Angeles City College Foundation will present an
educational screening of Atom Egoyan’s 2002 film “Ararat,” a dramatic tale
which looks at the issues surrounding the Armenian Genocide, as well as a
reception for David Alpay, the young Canadian actor who portrays the lead
role in that film, at 4 p.m. on April 23, at LACC’s Camino Theatre, 855 N.
Vermont Avenue in East Hollywood.
Steve Maradian, president of LACC, who is also a cosponsor of the event,
noted that the afternoon’s program is being held in recognition and
understanding of the Armenian Genocide, which occurred in Turkey in the
early part of this century and in which approximately 1.5 million Armenians
lost their lives.
The event will serve as a fundraiser to set up scholarships for Armenian
students in the field of theatre and cinema/TV at the college. After the
film screening, a buffet reception will be held in the adjacent Caminito
Theatre and attendees will have the opportunity to meet Alpay.
Critics have called “Ararat” one of Atom Egoyan’s most provocative films to
date. The film is based on Clarence Ussher’s book “An American Physician
in Turkey.”
In the film, Alpay portrays a young man, Raffi, who, after being
interrogated by a customs officer, recounts how his life was changed during
the making of a film about the Armenian genocide. A resident of Toronto,
Alpay has appeared in a number of movies and TV teleplays since his debut
in “Ararat.” The film also features actors Charles Aznavour, Eric Bogosian
and Christopher Plummer.
For ticket information, call the LACC Foundation at (323) 953-4000, ext.
2490.
*************************************** ***********************************
10 – Armenia Fund Telethon
Story Touches Hearts
LOS ANGELES – One of the several documentaries and segments aided during
the 2005 Armenia Fund Telethon, touched the heart of one of the donors to
the Annual benefit, and produced a result that one can only hope is
reproduced many times over.
During the past 2005 Telethon, a story produced by the Telethon production
team featured Anush, a mother of 9 children who recently relocated to
Garnakar village of the Mardakert Region of Karabagh.
Despite the difficult and at times unbearable conditions her family has
gone through, the young mother was very proud of her life. She and her
husband are part of the ever-growing Armenian population of the fledgling
Nagorno-Karabagh Republic.
When asked what she needed at the moment, the woman responded with a humble
request for a cow so she could provide her family with milk, yogurt and
cheese.
Touched by her needs, donor Vrej Ter Petrossian decided to help the family
after viewing the segment last Thanksgiving Day.
After Armenia Fund located the woman and her family in the remote village
in northern Karabagh, Ter Petrossian facilitated for the purchase and
transportation of a cow to the family.
The family could not believe their eyes when they received the milk-bearing
animal.
Got milk?
******************************************** *******************************
*
The California Courier On-Line is a service provided by the California
Courier. Subscriptions or changes of address should not be transmitted
through this service. Information in that regard should be telephoned to
(818) 409-0949; faxed to: (818) 409-9207, or e-mailed to:
[email protected]. Letters to the editor concerning issues addressed
in the Courier may be e-mailed, provided it is signed by the author. Phone
and/or E-mail address is also required to verify authorship.
ANCC: British Columbia Recognizes the Armenian Genocide
Armenian National Committee of Canada
130 Albert Street, Suite 1007
Ottawa, Ontraio
KIP 5G4
Tel. (613) 235-2622 Fax (613) 238-2622
PRESS RELEASE
April 3, 2006
Contact: Art Hagopian
(905) 727-7755
Roupen Kouyoumjian
(514) 336-7095
The Legislative Assembly of British Columbia
Recognizes the Armenian Genocide
Ottawa – The Legislative Assembly of British Columbia unanimously adopted a
Private Member’s Motion 59, recognizing the Armenian Genocide and to
designate April 24th of every year as a remembrance day for the 1.5 million
Armenians who fell victim to the first genocide of the 20th Century.
The debate on the Motion, which was sponsored by Member of the Legislative
Assembly (MLA) Adrian Dix (Vancouver-Kingsway), commenced at 11:00 p.m. and
was voted upon at the end of the allotted one hour according to Private
Member’s Motion rules.
MLAs Adrian Dix (Vancouver-Kingsway), Rob Fleming (Victoria-Hillside), Randy
Hawes (Maple Ridge-Mission), Dave S. Hayer (Surrey-Tynehead), John Horgan
(Malahat-Juan De Fuca), Murine Karagianis (Esquimalt-Metchosin), Leonared
Krog (Naniamo), Kevin Krueger
(Kamloops-North Thompson), John Nuraney (Burnaby-Wellingdon), Micheal Sather
(Maple Ridge – Pitt Meadows), and John Yap (Richmond-Stevenston) spoke in
support of the Motion.
Since last August The Armenian National Committee of Canada (ANCC), The
Armenian National Committee of Canada – West (ANCCW), and The Armenian
National Committee of Vancouver (ANCV), have worked closely with the MLAs
Dix, Hawes, Sather, and Hayer to build non-partisan support for Motion 59.
The ANCC, ANCCW and ANCV delegates had numerous meetings with various MLAs
to brief them on the Motion’s importance as a universal human rights issue.
In addition, the delegates presented historical overview of the Genocide and
supporting documents.
The executive director of The Armenian National Committee of Canada Aris
Babkian, on behalf of the Canadian-Armenian community, thanked MLAs Adrian
Dix and Randy Hawes for their leadership role in the successful adoption of
the Motion. Furthermore, Mr. Babikian thanked members who spoke in favour of
the Motion and the members who voted to adopt it.
Mr. Babikian said: `This is a historic day for our community in Canada and
in British Columbia. The steadfast support and the unanimous vote of the
MLAs demonstrates once again that the Turkish Government’s denial policy and
rewriting of history will not succeed. We call upon the Turkish Government
to be constructive, to come to terms with its dark history and to
acknowledge its predecessors’ guilt and extend a hand of atonement and
reconciliation to the Armenian People.’
-30-
Motion 59 Text
59 Mr. Dix to move –
Be it resolved that this House recognize the genocide of the Armenians as a
crime against humanity. Be it further resolved that this House urge the BC
government to designate April 24th of every year hereafter throughout BC as
a day of remembrance for the 1.5 million Armenians who fell victim to the
first genocide of the 20th Century.
The ANCC is the largest and the most influential Canadian-Armenian
grassroots political organization. Working in coordination with a network of
offices, chapters, and supporters throughout Canada and affiliated
organizations around the world, the ANCC actively advances the concerns of
the Canadian-Armenian community on a broad range of issues.
ANCA: SOAD Coming to DC for Armenian Genocide Recognition Campaign
Armenian National Committee of America
1711 N Street NW
Washington, DC 20036
Tel: (202) 775-1918
Fax: (202) 775-5648
E-mail: [email protected]
Internet:
PRESS RELEASE
April 4, 2006
Contact: Elizabeth S. Chouldjian
Tel: (202) 775-1918
SYSTEM OF A DOWN TO LAUNCH THREE-DAY WASHINGTON, DC
CAMPAIGN FOR ARMENIAN GENOCIDE RECOGNITION
— Band Members to Join Rally at Turkish Embassy; Screen New
Genocide Documentary; Meet with Media and Key Congressional
Officials on Pending Armenian Genocide Legislation
LOS ANGELES, CA – Serj Tankian and John Dolmayan of the Grammy
Award-winning band System of a Down will travel to Washington, DC
on April 24th for a three-day campaign to urge Speaker of the House
Dennis Hastert and other Congressional leaders to end their
complicity in Turkey’s ongoing denial of the Armenian Genocide.
On the evening of Monday, April 24th – starting at 5:00pm – the
multi-Platinum-selling group members will join with the Armenian
National Committee of America and Armenian Youth Federation in
leading a grassroots demonstration outside the gates of the Turkish
Embassy at 2525 Massachusetts Ave, in Northwest Washington, DC.
The Turkish government, through its Embassy in Washington, spends
millions of dollars each year to bully, threaten, and blackmail the
U.S. government not to recognize the Armenian Genocide.
The band members will devote Tuesday, April 25th to providing
interviews to the political media in Washington, and, in the
evening, hosting a Congressional screening of “Screamers,” a new
documentary by filmmaker Carla Garapedian about the band’s
worldwide campaign for Armenian Genocide recognition.
On Wednesday April 26th, System will meet with key Members of
Congress to urge them to allow a vote on legislation recognizing
the Armenian Genocide, and – at 5:30pm – will participate in the
annual Capitol Hill commemoration of the Armenian Genocide. This
event, now in its 11th year, is regularly attended by over 30
Members of Congress, diplomats, ethnic community leaders, human
rights activists, genocide prevention advocates, and Armenian
Americans from across the country.
Beginning on April 24, 1915, the Ottoman Turkish government began a
centrally planned and systematically executed campaign to
annihilate the Armenian people from their ancient homeland. By
1923 over 1.5 million Armenians were killed and hundreds of
thousands deported, in what constituted the first genocide of the
20th century. Congressional legislation recognizing this crime
(H.Res.316 / H.Con.Res.195 / S.Res.320) has broad bipartisan
support, but has been blocked from coming to a vote by
Congressional leaders, despite the fact that, five years ago, U.S.
House Speaker Dennis Hastert promised to allow Members to vote on
this human rights measure.
In September of last year, Serj Tankian and John Dolmayan from the
band traveled to the Speaker’s hometown of Batavia, Illinois to
lead a rally urging him to allow a vote on the Armenian Genocide
legislation. During the rally, Tankian delivered a personal and
powerfully worded message calling on the Speaker to do the right
thing, and stressing that “historical truths should never be denied
in a democracy – especially one with such a proud heritage of
freedom.”
Speaker Hastert has it in his power to accomplish one of System’s
goals – official U.S. recognition of Turkey’s destruction of 1.5
million Armenians between 1915 and 1923. By allowing Congress to
vote on this legislation, Speaker Hastert can end U.S. denial of
this crime and open the doors to justice – to the restoration,
reparation, and restitution owed to the victims of genocide. By
continuing to block a vote on this legislation, Hastert effectively
joins in the denial of this crime against humanity, and the denial
of justice to an entire nation.
The members of System of a Down, Serj Tankian, Daron Malakian, John
Dolmayan and Shavo Odadjian, who are of Armenian descent, all
personally lost family members and family history to the Armenian
Genocide. “Because so much of my family history was lost in the
Armenian Genocide,” said Malakian, “my grandfather, who was very
young at the time, doesn’t know his true age. How many people can
say they don’t know how old they are?” Tankian, Dolmayan and
Odadjian all identify their grandparents’ memories as the only
links they have to their respective family heritages, as most of
their families were obliterated during the Armenian Genocide.
“It’s important for people to be aware of the Armenian Genocide,”
explained Tankian, “and that those actions continue to be covered
up by the Turkish government, the U.S. State Department, Turkey’s
allies in the defense and oil industries, and by our present U.S.
Administration. Had the Armenian Genocide been acknowledged as a
Crime Against Humanity as it was, Hitler might not have thought he
could get away with the Jewish Holocaust. History does and will
repeat itself, unless we stop that cycle.”
#####
Alcatel and Lucent Agree to Merge in $13.4 Billion Deal
Alcatel and Lucent Agree to Merge in $13.4 Billion Deal
The New York Times
April 2, 2006
By VIKAS BAJAJ
Alcatel of France and Lucent Technologies said today that they had
reached agreement on a $13.4 billion merger that would create a
French-American maker of telecommunications equipment with revenue of
$25 billion, 88,000 employees and phone company customers across the world.
The deal comes in response to the increasing competition that Western
telecommunications firms are facing from low-cost Asian manufacturers,
as well as the growing size and purchasing power of a few large
telephone companies. If Alcatel and Lucent are successful at combining
their far-flung operations, which analysts say will be a significant
challenge, it could prompt competitors like Ericsson, Nortel Networks
and Siemens to seek their own deals so they can keep up.
The combined company, which has yet to be named, would be based in
Paris, where Alcatel has its headquarters. Lucent’s legendary Bell Labs
research center would remain in Murray Hill, N.J. Serge Tchuruk,
Alcatel’s chairman and chief executive, would be the non-executive
chairman, and Patricia F. Russo, Lucent’s chairman and chief executive,
would become chief executive of the new company.
Executives said they would lay off about 9,000 people, or 10 percent of
their combined staff, in the next three years as part of an effort to
cut costs by $1.7 billion. The companies did not provide a geographic
breakdown of the job cuts, but they said the cuts would be spread out
fairly. Lucent also dismissed concerns of employees and retirees about
the fate of its pension plans, saying they were financially healthy.
The job cuts would be the first of numerous cross-cultural challenges
faced by the companies, said Gerald R. Faulhaber, a management professor
at the Wharton School at the University of Pennsylvania and a former
Bell Labs researcher. It may take the companies several years to combine
product lines, employee teams and executives dispersed around the world
who are used to different ways of doing business, he added.
“These are not going to magically fit together, particularly when you
have a cross-border merger,” Professor Faulhaber said. “Sometimes it’s
costly and takes time to resolve, and sometimes they never get resolved.”
Alcatel and Lucent ended earlier merger talks in 2001 after executives
could not agree on how to share control of the combined company. Since
then, both companies have cut tens of thousands of jobs as they
struggled to recover from the demise of many of their customers.
Under the deal, Lucent shareholders would receive 0.1952 of an Alcatel
American depository share for each Lucent share, valuing the company at
about $3.01 a share based on Alcatel’s closing stock price on Friday, or
about 4 cents less than Lucent’s Friday closing price. After the merger,
Lucent shareholders would own 40 percent of the combined company, with
Alcatel shareholders owning 60 percent.
To allay concerns about a foreign company having access to the secretive
work that Bell Labs does for American military and intelligence
agencies, the companies said they would create an independent subsidiary
that would be overseen by a board of three American citizens. Military
contractors in similar situations frequently use such corporate
structures to assure government officials that classified research is
not available to foreign powers.
A Lucent spokeswoman declined to say how big the subsidiary would be in
terms of revenue or employees.
In France, the company would assign European citizens to sit on the
board of Thales, a satellite manufacturer that Alcatel jointly owns with
the French government and other investors. Alcatel also said it was
continuing to negotiate a merger of its own satellite business with Thales.
The combined Alcatel and Lucent board would have 14 directors, including
six members each from Alcatel and Lucent, some of whom are already on
their current boards; Mr. Tchuruk and Ms. Russo would be among those
six. The boards of both companies would also jointly appoint two new
directors who are European to add more international diversity, Mr.
Tchuruk said on a conference call with reporters and analysts today.
Lucent and Alcatel executives said the merger would create a
research-and-development powerhouse with a leading position in the two
fastest-growing areas of telecommunications – wireless and broadband
Internet access. “This is an R.& D.-intensive industry and competition
is increasing, and size and scale really matter,” Ms. Russo said.
Mr. Tchuruk said that the companies’ sales were divided in thirds among
Europe, North America and the rest of the world. “There is practically
no customer large or small that is not being reached by Alcatel and
Lucent,” he said.
As measured by revenue, the combined company would be slightly bigger,
but far less profitable, than Cisco Systems, the maker of Internet
routers and related equipment.
The deal was approved by the boards of both companies over the weekend
and is expected to close in 6 to 12 months. It has to be approved by the
companies’ shareholders and regulators in Europe and the United States,
including the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States,
overseen by the Treasury Department, and the Justice Department’s
antitrust division.
Though lawmakers in Congress have so far not expressed significant
concerns about the deal, some experts say the merger could face scrutiny
given Bell Labs’ legacy.
Created in 1925 by AT&T as a research subsidiary, Bell Labs has helped
develop a wide range of commercial and military technologies, from the
transistor to ballistic missiles. The labs became a part of Lucent when
the company was spun out of AT&T in 1996.
There could be other problems in Washington given the rise in
protectionist sentiments, as demonstrated by the furor over a Dubai
company’s proposal to take over terminal operations at six American ports.
The French government is expected to take a more accommodating position
given that the combined company would be based in Paris. It would,
however, take longer to cut jobs in Europe, where worker protections and
unions are stronger.
The Lucent Retirees Organization, a group that represents former
workers, has expressed concerns about the merger’s impact on the
company’s pension plans, saying it would ask the government to oppose
any deal that does not include independent oversight of retiree benefits.
Lucent officials said today that with assets of $34 billion, the
company’s pension plans were overfunded by $3 billion, and that it did
not believe it would have to contribute to the funds until 2008.
But the retirees’ group said the surplus was entirely in the pension
plan for union retirees, while the plan for about 50,000 management
retirees was underfunded by about $1.2 billion. “We are not fighting the
merger,” said Ken Raschke, the group’s president. “All we are saying is
we want protection from it.”
02cnd-lucent.html?ex=1144641600&en=a0457a8ebd6 52636&ei=5070&emc=eta1