Georgian Air Attack On Russia

GEORGIAN AIR ATTACK ON RUSSIA
by Vladimir Novikov, Gennadi Sysoev
Translated by A. Ignatkin

Source: Kommersant, December 11, 2006, p. 10
Agency WPS
DEFENSE and SECURITY (Russia)
December 13, 2006 Wednesday

TRANSIT FLIGHTS OF THE RUSSIAN AF ACROSS GEORGIA PROHIBITED; Tbilisi
finds new and more ways of making Russia’s life difficult.

The Russian Foreign Ministry demanded from Georgia "an immediate end
to the practice of sabotaging the Accord on military shipments and
personnel transit across Georgia" and accused Tbilisi of deliberate
tension-mounting, last week.

Diplomat Mikhail Kamynin ascribed the demarche to the fact that
"Georgia has ignored the request for the planned Russian flights to the
Russian military base in Gyumri, Armenia" on December 8-22. The request
was forwarded to Tbilisi in advance, but the Georgian authorities
"chose to leave it unanswered" (to quote Kamynin). Moscow took it
as "a deliberate attempt to interfere with the functioning of the
Gyumri base" and with the withdrawal of the Russian troops from
Georgia itself.

As far as the Russian Foreign Ministry is concerned, Tbilisi is
deliberately mounting tension in the bilateral relations. Georgian
Ambassador Irakly Chubinishvili was summoned to the Russian Foreign
Minister and served a note, last Saturday.

Sources in the Georgian Foreign Ministry promise a response to
the Russian statement come Monday. The Georgian Defense Ministry
denies "any sabotage of flights of Russian military transports"
because all planes flying over Georgia are the responsibility of
Gruzaeronavigatsia, a civilian outfit.

A spokesman for the latter who insisted on anonymity claims that
Russia owes Gruzaeronavigatsia money. The source refused to say what
exact sum was meant. "If Russia uses the clearly invented pretext of
Georgian air carriers’ debts to Russia to prohibit air traffic from
Georgia to Russia, then Georgia is also entitled to demand what the
Russian Defense Ministry owes Gruzaeronavigatsia," he said.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

In Poor Country Socialism Can Bring To Bolshevism, Vahan Hovhannisia

IN POOR COUNTRY SOCIALISM CAN BRING TO BOLSHEVISM, VAHAN HOVHANNISIAN SAYS

Noyan Tapan
Dec 14 2006

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 14, NOYAN TAPAN. The ARF can not endanger inner
stability and security of the country in conditions of the legally
unsolved Karabakh conflict. Just for that reason, as RA National
Assembly Deputy Speaker Vahan Hovhannisian mentioned at the December
13 meeting with students of higher educational institutions, having
disagreements with the authorities in some issues, Dashnaktsutyun
makes a part of the authorities today. Touching upon the National
Security conception, V.Hovhannisian said that it is a step on the way
of getting consensus concerning the country fate among the political
forces. He positively estimates the document being discussed in
the academic sense. But in V.Hovhannisian’s words, the way of
implementing the conception does not exist in the document. The
NA Deputy Speaker proposes to fill this ommission, founding an
institutional national security council. Defining the place and role
of the parliamentary forces in the political life, V.Hovhannisian
mentioned that right-left separation does not function in Armenia in
its classic sense. Dashnaktsutiun, being a socialist left-side party,
is often for adoption of liberal laws. In V.Hovhannisian’s words,
they are led by that consciousness that in a poor country socialism
can bring to Bolshevism. That’s why they consider necessary first
to enrich the country, to make it attractive for investments, then
to implement socialist programs. And right parties, arising of the
present conditions of the country, often vote for laws having social
orientation. V.Hovhannisian also expressed confidence that it is a
wastefulness for a small country like Armenia to have 131 deputies.

How To Spend A Billion Dollars

HOW TO SPEND A BILLION DOLLARS
by Dzhasur Mamedov
Translated by Pavel Pushkin

Source: Voenno-Promyshlenny Kuryer, No. 47, December 06-12, 2006, p. 3
Agency WPS
DEFENSE and SECURITY (Russia)
December 13, 2006 Wednesday

Azerbaijan does not have a well considered strategy for spending the
defense budget

AZERBAIJAN: HOW WILL THE INCREASED DEFENSE BUDGET BE DISTRIBUTED?;
In 2007, military expenditures of Azerbaijan will reach a level
unprecedented for the South Caucasus.

In 2007, military expenditures of Azerbaijan will reach a level
unprecedented for the South Caucasus. According to statements of
various official sources, defense budget of the country will amount
to 907 million manats ($1.039 billion). According to Ziyafet Askerov,
deputy speaker of the parliament and chair of the permanent commission
for defense and security issues, in 2007 defense expenditures will
grow 27.9% and the military components will account for 16% of the
budget for 2007.

>>From the sums allocated for military needs the Defense Ministry will
receive 796 million manats ($912.8 million) and 110.2 million mantas
($126 million) will go to the Ministry of Defense Industry. According
to Doktrina center of military studies of journalists, if the budget
of the country reaches this level Azerbaijan will confirm its first
place in the South Caucasus with regard to defense expenditures per
capita. In 2007, defense expenditures of Azerbaijan will amount to
$105 per capita. In Armenia this parameter amounts to $70 per capita
(the national military budget amounts to $220 million) and in Georgia
it will amount to $65 per capita.

Stockholm-based SIPRI points at a 51% growth in defense expenditures
of Azerbaijan between 2005 and 2006, and a 23% growth in defense
expenditures of Armenia. It is believed that Azerbaijan as an oil
producing country actively uses revenues from oil sale for purchase of
armament. According to SIPRI, the speed of growth of the Azerbaijani
defense budget is faster than the average international statistical
parameters.

Colonel General Safar Abiev, Defense Minister of Azerbaijan, also
connects increase of the defense expenditures with growth of economic
might of the state.

Although Azerbaijani independent experts welcome the growth of the
defense budget, they express concern about its wise spending. Hence,
even a small poll was held among military experts as a result of
which it was found out that they would like to receive answers to
the following seven questions related to the budget:

1. What are the exact reasons for annual growth of defense expenditures
in circumstances of absence of a strategy of armed forces buildup
in the country, which representatives of the state substantiate
dramatic increase of the military expenditures and what are their
arguments? Incidentally, up to date, the state of war of Azerbaijan
against Armenia was the pretext for growth of military expenditures.

2. Which part of the money allocated for the army will be spent on
money allowances for servicemen, for food and for uniforms?

Incidentally, according to various sources 70% of the money allocated
for the armed forces was spent on the aforementioned goals. Such
distribution of money is recognized as being far from international
standards.

3. Will increase of the sums allocated for defense result in
improvement of social guarantees for personnel of the armed forces?

4. Which part of the defense budget will be spent on purchase of
modern armament and combat hardware? In circumstances of absence of
a military doctrine, concept of national security and strategy for
buildup of the army from which countries will Azerbaijan buy armament
and combat hardware and with which standards will they comply, those
of NATO or those of Russia?

5. Which role will increase of defense expenditures play in the future
development of the armed forces? What will be the difference of the
army of 2007, spending $1 billion from the army of 1991-2003 existing
with $100-200 million?

6. What is it planned to do for improvement of authority of the
armed forces in society, specifically, for increase of prestige of
the military profession?

7. Are there guarantees of correct spending of the money allocated
for defense and non-appropriation of this money by private
individuals? Which tasks will be set for the law-enforcement agencies
because of this?

Answers to these questions are necessary. The government increases
military expenditures at its own discretion but evades reporting
in any form to society and to parliament. That is why there appear
presumptions of appropriation or possible appropriation of the money
allocated for defense.

It is also necessary to mention the stance of NATO towards increase
of the military expenditures by Azerbaijan. Brussels presumes that
increase of the defense budget along with growth of revenues is
normal. However, Brussels simultaneously advocates transparency of
the military budget to parliament and to society. Representatives of
NATO announced their readiness to help the government of Azerbaijan in
this aspect. The Individual Partnership Action Plan for partnership
between NATO and Azerbaijan (IPAP) clearly outlines goals of defense
planning. According to the document, Partnership Action Plan on Defense
Institution Building (PAP DIB) being a vehicle for implementation of
reforms in the field of defense and security makes democratic control
over the Armed Forces and budget transparency necessary. Incidentally,
for this goal Azerbaijan will form an expert group for implementation
of the plan of defense strategy and will make some aspects connected
with military expenditures open for discussion.

That is why it is possible to presume that in the near future
informing society about defense expenditures will be inevitable
for the government of Azerbaijan. This requires intensification of
relations with NATO. The final evaluation of cooperation between
Azerbaijan and NATO according to IPAP is expected between March and
April 2007. Official Baku will likely have to inform NATO officials
about fulfillment of provisions of the document entitled "Transparent
financing of the defense sector."

According To Final Data, More Than 98% Of Electors Votes For NKR Con

ACCORDING TO FINAL DATA, MORE THAN 98% OF ELECTORS VOTES FOR NKR CONSTITUTION

Noyan Tapan
Dec 14 2006

STEPANAKERT, DECEMBER 14, NOYAN TAPAN. 78.389 people from
the 90.077 citizens having the right of vote took part in the
December 10 constitutional referendum of the Republic of Nagorno
Karabakh. According to the summing up report on the final data made
public by the NKR Central Referendum Commission, 77.279 electors, what
makes 98.58% of voters, voted for adoption of the Constitution. The
number of people voted against it is 554.

Ashot Hovakimian Hands His Credentials To President Of Slovakia

ASHOT HOVAKIMIAN HANDS HIS CREDENTIALS TO PRESIDENT OF SLOVAKIA

Noyan Tapan
Dec 14 2006

BRATISLAVA, DECEMBER 14, NOYAN TAPAN. Ashot Hovakimian handed
Ivan Gasparovic, the President of the Republic of Slovakia, his
credentials of the RA Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary to
Slovakia on December 11. During the conversation taken place between
the President of Slovakia and the Ambassador of Armenia, sides,
estimating as positive the friendly relations established between the
two countries and peoples, at the same time attached importance to the
necessity of stimulating political, economic, cultural cooperation in
marzes (regions). The interlocutors touched upon the issue of future
development and deepening of the bilateral and many-sided cooperation
within the limits of possibilities given by the Armenia-EU Actions
Plan within the framework of the EU New Neighbourhooh Policy. As Noyan
Tapan was informed by the RA Foreign Ministry’s Press and Information
Department, the issue of Gasparovic’s possible visit of return to be
paid to Armenia during 2007 was touched upon during the meeting. Early
on the same day, Ambassador Hovakimian had meetings at the Ministry
of Foreign Affairs of Slovakia with State Secretary Olga Algayerova
to who he handed the copy of his credentials. He had meetings with a
number of other high-ranking officials of the Foreign Ministry as well.

Ambassador Hovakimian had meetings with compatriots living in Slovakia
as well, laid a wreath to the khachkar (cross stone)-monument to
memory of the Armenian Genocide victims, placed in 2005 in the region
of Petrzalka, Bratislava.

Fraught At The Frontiers: Why Europe Is Losing Faith In Its Most Suc

FRAUGHT AT THE FRONTIERS: WHY EUROPE IS LOSING FAITH IN ITS MOST SUCCESSFUL POLICY
By Daniel Dombey And George Parker

Financial Times (London, England)
December 13, 2006 Wednesday
London Edition 1

Fraught at the frontiers: why Europe is losing faith in its most
successful policy EU ENLARGEMENT: European Union leaders are under
pressure to address popular anxieties about expansion but any move
to apply the brakes could be disastrous for those waiting to join,
write George Parker and Daniel Dombey

Jean Monnet, one of the European Union’s 1950s founding fathers,
foretold that in a globalised era, size would count. "Our countries
have become too small for the world . . . measured against America
and Russia today and China and India tomorrow," he once said.

Europe’s leaders have since sought to expand the EU in line with this
vision. But enlargement, often cited as the club’s most successful
policy, has become a political liability. Tomorrow, at a summit in
Brussels, the EU’s member governments will clash over how much further
– and how quickly – the Union can extend to the east.

The debate will raise questions about what it means to be European
and whether the EU can carry on growing without grinding to a halt
or further alienating its citizens. The outcome and tone of the talks
will have hard-edged consequences: is it going to become even tougher
for candidates to join the club?

Senior EU officials say this is a dangerous moment. If the bloc sends
out negative signals to future members, what consequences could it
have for reformers in Turkey, the politically unstable Balkans or
former Soviet republics such as Belarus or Ukraine? The world has a
stake in the message that comes out of Brussels.

The end-of-year summit gives European leaders a chance to take stock
of the club’s "big bang" expansion of May 2004, which saw it expand
from 15 to 25 members. By the time Bulgaria and Romania join on New
Year’s day, the EU will have taken in 10 former communist countries and
increased its population to 490m, almost half as big again as the US.

So what went wrong with the latest enlargement? The simple answer is:
not very much. While some western European countries, including Britain
and Ireland, experienced unexpectedly high levels of immigration from
Poland and other new member states, economic studies say the migrants
filled skills shortages.

Indeed, the creation of a mobile pool of labour – giving Europe’s
economy some of the flexibility taken for granted in the US – seems
to have played a role in pushing EU economic growth above 2.5 per
cent, outstripping America. Unemployment across the bloc has at last
started falling.

While there has been political instability in central Europe and
Poland has proved an awkward partner, 10 dynamic new member states
are being integrated. Europe is using its "soft power" to spread
democratic and economic transformation and stability. Even France,
the most vocal advocate of slowing the pace of enlargement, has in
an official paper called this ambitious reunification of east and
west Europe a "remarkable success".

Yet this week’s summit takes place against a backdrop of public
anxiety, typified by fears that western companies will relocate jobs
and production to the east and that cheap eastern workers will take
jobs in the west. A Eurobarometer poll this year found that only 45
per cent of EU citizens want to see other countries join, a proportion
that falls to less than one in three in France, Germany, Luxembourg
and Austria.

Concerns about the pace of enlargement were cited by both French and
Dutch voters as reasons for their rejection of the EU’s proposed
constitutional treaty in 2005. Sergey Stanishev, Bulgaria’s prime
minister, admits the atmosphere has soured. He says: "Enlargement is
a great success story for Europe but has been very badly communicated."

To allay public concerns, some European politicians want the EU to
agree its final political borders now, arguing that the club risks
getting so big it will no longer be able to act. "A Europe without
borders will become a subset of the United Nations," Nicolas Sarkozy,
the French centre-right presidential candidate, has said. Wolfgang
Schussel, Austria’s chancellor, argues that former Soviet-bloc
countries such as Ukraine, Belarus, Georgia and Armenia should be
told now to forget about full membership and develop other forms of
partnerships with Europe instead.

Most advocates of a "final borders" strategy also share the view of
Mr Sarkozy and Mr Schussel that the line should be drawn west of the
Bosphorus, excluding 80m largely Muslim Turks, whose European destiny
will dominate summit headlines. "We have to say emphatically who is
a European and who is not," Mr Sarkozy has said.

Mr Sarkozy’s proposal would have legal teeth because of an existing EU
treaty declaration that says: "Any European state . . . may apply to
become a member of the Union." If it meets the club’s political and
economic rules and its human rights standards, it should be able to
join, although it needs unanimous support from existing member states:
each has a veto. Defining what is a "European" country is therefore
both vital and elusive. Only once has the EU denied membership to
an applicant country on such grounds, when in 1993 Morocco was told
that it "was not a European country", in spite of its historic and
cultural links.

Europe’s eastern boundaries are notoriously imprecise. Geographically
the continent’s boundary is usually put at the Urals – a huge post
was once erected on the main trail across the mountains to mark
the boundary with Asia, a poignant sight for prisoners en route to
Siberia. Turkey’s prospects for EU membership have been acknowledged
since 1963, in spite of the vast majority of its land mass being in
Asia. Cyprus was admitted in 2004, in spite of its being only 150
miles from Syria and 500 miles from the European continent.

Olli Rehn, the EU’s enlargement commissioner, argues that the term
"European" combines geographical, historical and cultural elements.

"This cannot be condensed into a simple timeless formula – it is
subject to review by each succeeding generation," he said in a recent
policy paper. But even supporters of fixing Europe’s final borders
admit that this will not be possible this week. Instead they are
looking for other tools to "master" – or slow – the accession process.

European diplomats say the summiteers will agree on at least one
key point: the EU should honour its commitments to Turkey and
Croatia, which have started membership talks, and to the countries
of the western Balkans, whose membership aspirations are officially
recognised. But one ambassador admits the club is "split down the
middle" over the pace at which membership talks with Turkey and the
Balkan states should proceed, or indeed whether they will ever end
in success.

France, the Netherlands and Austria are among those who want to define
the EU’s "absorption capacity", including whether an expanded Union
can deliver the deeper integration envisaged by Monnet. It would
also look at the impact of enlargement on the Union’s budget and
its institutions.

Mr Rehn prefers to talk of "integration capacity", a phrase that he
argues applies equally to the candidate country and the Union itself.

But he insists it should not become a new "condition" for entry, a
view supported by pro-enlargement countries such as Britain, Spain,
Italy, Sweden and Poland.

This is likely to be the subject of skirmishes at the Brussels
summit. Paris wants the European Commission, as the executive arm, to
conduct fuller impact assessments and to take more account of political
developments and public opinion during the entry negotiations. "What
they are trying to do is build up an armoury of tools to stop any
enlargement they don’t like," says one senior EU official. France also
has a "nuclear weapon" to halt future expansions: each new member
after Croatia will be able to join only if French voters say Yes in
a referendum.

But France is not alone in wanting to increase political control
over enlargement. The Netherlands has been particularly vocal,
while Austria and other neighbours in what is dubbed in Brussels the
"Habsburg bloc" have concerns over Turkish accession. "The pace of
enlargement depends on the absorption capacity of the Union and not
only on the preparations of the candidate country," says one French
official. In Paris they talk of putting a "pilot" in the cockpit,
to reassure people that someone is in control of enlargement.

That position is seen as "ironic" in Brussels, where officials argue
it was French President Jacques Chirac himself who put the process
on autopilot when he insisted that Bulgaria and Romania should be
guaranteed entry by 2008 at the latest, regardless of whether they
were ready, so that the two, both linguistic affiliates, could inject
a dose of Francophonie into the latest expansion.

Dutch officials meanwhile say that although Europe has a strategic
interest in extending membership into unstable regions, that has to be
balanced against the risk of enlargement creating instability inside
the Union. That could take the form of a breakdown in integration or
the rise of xenophobic political parties in the west.

There is also wide support for the idea that future expansion can
take place only after the EU has updated its institutions – a task
that involves reviving parts of the stalled constitutional treaty. A
painful review of the club’s budget, including the farm subsidy regime,
is also seen as essential.

The problem for potential EU members is that these all appear to be
hurdles over which they have no control. The message seems to be:
you can meet all the criteria but, if the EU has not sorted out its
budget, or its constitution, or if public opinion is hostile, then
you cannot come in. "Of course, that is the conclusion some member
states will take from the summit," says one EU diplomat. "Others
will argue that all of this is blah, blah, blah and there are no new
conditions. The truth is probably somewhere in between."

Whatever the final summit text, equally important will be the political
signal sent to the countries in Europe’s waiting room. It is unlikely
to be positive. Turkey’s refusal to open its ports to shipping from
Cyprus, a 2004 entrant, will result in its membership talks being
partially suspended.

Although Mr Rehn points out that some parts of the negotiations can
continue, there will be some at the summit who believe or hope these
will never be concluded. Mr Rehn fears the negative mood, whether
expressed in the legalese of a summit communique or by the likes of
Mr Chirac in closing press conferences, will also send a message to
others – including the 25m people of the western Balkans – thattheir
path towards the Union isuncertain.

With Kosovo’s future status due to be determined next year, Mr Rehn
argues Europeans have a "major responsibility" for providing stability
in the region – including keeping open the possibility of membership
for countries such as Serbia and Bosnia.

Matti Vanhanen, the Finnish prime minister and summit host, as
his country holds the EU’s rotating presidency, had also hoped to
insert a line into the communique hinting that the door was still
ajar for other future members, but he was rebuffed by a number of
member states. But does this mean that Ukraine, Belarus, Moldova,
Georgia and Armenia – and possibly Azerbaijan and Kazakhstan – will
be denied their claim to be "European" for ever? AsMr Rehn notes,
different generations have different perspectives.

Napoleon Bonaparte, whose imperial ambitions stretched well beyond
the eastern limits of today’s EU, also took a wider view. Brooding in
exile on St Helena, he wrote: "I wished to found a European system,
a European code of laws, a European judiciary. There would be but
one people in Europe."

A Number Of NA Deputies Demands To Immediately Set Free Zhirayr Sefi

A NUMBER OF NA DEPUTIES DEMANDS TO IMMEDIATELY SET FREE ZHIRAYR SEFILIAN

Noyan Tapan
Dec 14 2006

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 14, NOYAN TAPAN. As of December 13, 26 deputies of
the RA National Assembly signed the statement demanding to immediately
set free Zhirayr Sefilian, the coordinator of the "Defence of Liberated
Territories" public initiative, "Shoushi" battalion commander, who
was put under arrest. The initiator of gathering of signatures is
independent deputy Hmayak Hovhannisian.

Members of the "Ardaroutiun" (Justice), "Orinats Yerkir" (Country
of Law) factions and some independent deputies signed under the
statement. After bringing gathering of signatures to the end,
H.Hovhannisian intends to address the statement to the RA National
Security Service, Prosecutor’s General Office and RA President’s
residence.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Adoption Of NKR Constitution Can Not Hinder From Peaceful Settlement

ADOPTION OF NKR CONSTITUTION CAN NOT HINDER FROM PEACEFUL SETTLEMENT OF KARABAKH CONFLICT

Noyan Tapan
Dec 14 2006

STEPANAKERT, DECEMBER 14, NOYAN TAPAN. The NKR Ministry of Foreign
Affairs made a statement on December 13 in which it expressed
perplexity on the occasion of the attitude of the European
international structures, relating to the constitutional referendum
held in the NKR on December 10, which attempt to call into question
the fact of possibility of the Nagorno Karabakh people to be in
the legal field. It is mentioned in the statement that the given
referendum is the next stage to fix the democratic principles in the
main law of the country and, in general, to develop the legislation,
and has a goal to give new filling to formation and development of
new, more free thinking principles in the state government sphere as
well as to the process of improvement of the civil society. "On that
occasion, the attempts of the European instances, fostered democracy
and supremacy of the law, to ignore and deny the democratic and
legislative processes taking place in Nagorno Karabakh seem to be
more than strange," is said in the Foreign Ministry’s statement. The
Ministry at the same time expresses confidence that adoption of the
Constitution can not in any way hinder from international negotiators’
constructive efforts aimed to peaceful settlement of the Karabakh
conflict. The NKR Ministry of Foreign Affairs expresses a hope that
European organizations, led by the democratic principles proclaimed
just by them, will review their preconceived attitude towards the
democratic processes taking place in Nagorno Karabakh.

Is It Time To Lift The Taboo On Holocaust Denial?

IS IT TIME TO LIFT THE TABOO ON HOLOCAUST DENIAL?
by James Kirkup

The Scotsman, UK
December 13, 2006, Wednesday
1 Edition

IT IS difficult to imagine a more grotesque and unpleasant gathering
than the conference taking place in Tehran this week under the
innocuous title of "Review of the Holocaust: Global Vision". For all
its pretence of scholarship and objective analysis, the event’s true
nature is not in doubt, as a glance at the guest-list makes clear.

Whatever else he is, David Duke, a former imperial wizard of the
Ku Klux Klan, is not an objective scholar of 20th-century European
history. Nor are the rest of the bunch that assembled under the
aegis of the Iranian foreign ministry, among them Michele Renouf,
who reportedly enjoys the remarkable distinction of being considered
"too extreme" to address the British National Party.

The whole nasty affair is the work of Iran’s nasty president,
Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, who says it is nothing less than an exercise
of free speech, and one that raises serious questions for the West,
and Europe in particular. Whether he’s rattling his sabre at Israel
or persecuting Iranians who criticise him, Mr Ahmadinejad is at least
as unpalatable as his guests this week. But, uncomfortable as it may
be to admit it, he has raised an important point.

The argument he mounts is that Europe is inconsistent in its adherence
to the values of free speech: deny that Hitler’s Nazi regime killed
six million Jews and you can end up in prison in several European
countries. But publish drawings or writings denying that Mohammed is
the prophet of the one true god and the authorities will defend you
to the hilt.

Mr Ahmadinejad argues that devout Muslims suffer just as much
distress from the latter as Jews do from the former. On one level,
it’s a specious argument, because according to its advocates, banning
Holocaust denial isn’t about preventing emotional distress, it’s about
preventing incitement to another genocide. But the very fact that Mr
Ahmadinejad can even draw the comparison should ring alarm bells:
extremists of all sorts find the most fertile soil in grievances,
real or imagined. By making an exceptional case of the Holocaust,
we risk handing ammunition to those who falsely claim that western
societies are biased, against Muslims and towards Jews.

By the way, Mr Ahmadinejad has never said how he would treat the
author of the blasphemous or offensive cartoons, but I think I have
an idea. Almost seven years ago in Tehran, I met Nikahang Kowsar,
the country’s leading political cartoonist. He’d just finished a jail
sentence imposed because one of his cartoons had offended one of the
hardline clerics who now keep Mr Ahmadinejad in his job. And that
was during one of Iran’s more liberal periods; since then, Mr Kowsar,
like a great many inspirational Iranian journalists, has sought exile
abroad, apparently unwilling to entrust his safety to Mr Ahmadinejad’s
proclaimed commitment to free speech.

There’s another problem with making a legal exception of the German
Holocaust, which is that by giving one atrocity special status above
all others, we make it somehow attractive to the stupid and the
malicious, in a way that other genocides are not.

Not many disaffected European youths are drawn to neo-Stalinist groups
and denials that the Communist tyrant killed 20 million.

Outside Turkey at least, not many demagogic politicians can make
capital out of denials that the Turks killed hundreds of thousands
of Armenians in 1915. Its near-sacred position in our collective
imagination has made the Nazi genocide into a malign cause celèbre,
and its sceptics into martyrs.

CONSIDER one of the missing guests at the Tehran conference,
David Irving. In 2000, Irving was a discredited pseudo-historian,
his amateurish attempts to deny the Holocaust shattered in a London
courtroom by a genuine historian, Deborah Lipstadt, in a defamation
case he brought. But last year, Irving was jailed in Austria,
where his pathetic writings constitute a crime. A quick trawl of the
internet confirms that his jailing has elevated him to the status of
demi-god among the far-right; his name was intoned with reverence at
the Tehran conference.

According to the Holocaust Memorial Day Trust, three-quarters of young
British people know when the Holocaust took place; more have heard
of Auschwitz. That is unquestionably a good thing. But how many of
them have reached the conclusion that Jews were slaughtered in their
millions because they have inspected and weighted the evidence of
the Holocaust, or at least read the work of credible historians who
have done so? Given the parlous state of history teaching in most
British schools, I fear Steven Spielberg’s Schindler’s List is more
significant here than less cinematic but more objective works such
as Raul Hilberg’s The Destruction of the European Jews or Christopher
Browning’s The Origins of the Final Solution.

There’s nothing wrong with getting interested in history because of
films. But films aren’t history; just consider the ruinous effects
Braveheart has had on Scottish political discourse. True historical
understanding comes only from calmly and coldly sifting the facts
from the assertions, the evidence from the propaganda. Despite the
undoubted good intentions behind them, Europe’s social and legal
taboos on discussion of the Holocaust risk suppressing that discussion.

Anyone who believes that the memory of the Holocaust is important, that
it must not be forgotten, should always recall the priceless advice
of JS Mill’s Essay on Liberty: "However unwillingly a person who has
a strong opinion may admit the possibility that his opinion may be
false, he ought to be moved by the consideration that, however true
it may be, if it is not fully, frequently, and fearlessly discussed,
it will be held as a dead dogma, not a living truth.

Western society is nothing if it is not free, and our beliefs are
nothing if they are not questioned. It is regrettable if it takes
someone as illiberal as Mr Ahmadinejad to remind us of that.

–Boundary_(ID_JJ6AAxhp8QC019VzX94V5g)–

V.Hovhannisian: "I Do Not Think That They Will Ever Arrest In Armeni

V.HOVHANNISIAN: "I DO NOT THINK THAT THEY WILL EVER ARREST IN ARMENIA ANYBODY WHO IS AGAINST GIVING TERRITORY TO AZERIS"

Noyan Tapan
Dec 14 2006

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 14, NOYAN TAPAN. "The accusation presented to
Zhirayr Sefilian, which was at least stated at this stage, relates
to the anti-constitutional activity, there is no issue connected with
giving the liberated territories." Vahan Hovhannisian, the NA Deputy
Speaker, ARF Bureau member expressed this opinion on December 13 at
the Parliament, answering journalists’ questions. "I do not think
that they will ever arrest anybody in Armenia who is against giving
territory to Azeris: then, they must start with me," he said. The NA
Deputy Speaker at the same time mentioned that he considers premature
conversations about giving territories.