On What Side Of The Holocaust Are You On? Olmert And Israeli Hypocri

ON WHAT SIDE OF THE HOLOCAUST ARE YOU ON? OLMERT AND ISRAELI HYPOCRISY
Terry Scott

The People’s Voice, TN
Dec 14 2006

Is it cheeky or just magnificent Israeli chutzpah for Ehud Olmert to
ask the new Pope to condemn Iran’s "Holocaust Conference" in the face
of the worst chapter of human rights abuses against the Palestinians?

Arrogant, diffident and pugnacious Mr. Olmert actually has the cojones
to go to the Vatican and tell the Pope to condemn a conference on
the most untouchable of taboo topics in modern history at the same
time as disallowing the United Nations fact-finding team from being
granted visas to conduct their study of Beit Hanoun??? Has the Anglican
Church become so distant from the Catholic mothership, that Archbishop
Desmond Tutu’s public humiliation by the Israelis can mean so little
to this German pontiff?

[More:]

Is it me or do you also have the distinct nauseating feeling that
Israeli politicians have made the entire world their playground to
stride so brazenly and arrogantly demanding and criticising whatever
they please?

Perhaps the not-to-be-trusted Olmert thought that Pope Benedict’s
comments about Islam earlier this year insinuated a "warming up" of
relations with the Jewish State and that the more recent tete-a-tete
with his German counterpart Merkel, signaled a reconciliation of German
and Jewish interests. What else did Olmert ask from the Germans this
time, more money for "reparations" that no other holocaust equivalent
group received: the Armenians from the Turks?

Cambodians from Pol Pot? Chileans from Pinochet? Japanese from the
Americans?

The Vatican ought at the very least to follow through with the
agreement that was signed with the PLO in early 2000 with these
little-followed goals:

Calling for a peaceful solution of the Palestinian-Israeli conflict,
which would realize the inalienable national legitimate rights
and aspirations of the Palestinian People, to be reached through
negotiation and agreement, in order to ensure peace and security
for all peoples of the region on the basis of international law,
relevant United Nations and its Security Council resolutions, justice
and equity;

Declaring that an equitable solution for the issue of Jerusalem,
based on international resolutions, is fundamental for a just and
lasting peace in the Middle East, and that unilateral decisions and
actions altering the specific character and status of Jerusalem are
morally and legally unacceptable [source].

Did Benedict remind Ehud Olmert of these agreements?

n/blogs/voices.php/2006/12/14/p12921

http://www.thepeoplesvoice.org/cgi-bi

Armenia: Arrest Of Government Critic On Coup Charges Prompts Concern

ARMENIA: ARREST OF GOVERNMENT CRITIC ON COUP CHARGES PROMPTS CONCERNS
Onnik Krikorian

EurasiaNet, NY
Dec 14 2006

As political tensions in Armenia rise ahead of next year’s
parliamentary elections, the arrest of a former Nagorno-Karabakh
military commander critical of the Armenian government’s talks
with Azerbaijan is raising fresh concerns about how the vote will
be conducted.

In a December 10 raid carried out by masked agents of Armenia’s
National Security Service (NSS) at a Yerevan restaurant, Zhirayr
Sefilian, an ethnic Armenian from Lebanon, was taken into custody on
charges of plotting a government coup. Sefilian, a former commander in
Armenia’s war with Azerbaijan over the predominantly ethnic Armenian
breakaway territory of Karabakh, is a decorated, hard-line war hero. He
is an outspoken opponent of any deal with Azerbaijan that includes the
return of territory currently under Armenian control. [For background
see the Eurasia Insight archive].

The press service of the NSS, the successor to Armenia’s Soviet-era
State Security Committee (KGB), has alleged that Sefilian "planned
to interfere in the upcoming political processes [2007 parliamentary
elections] with the use of force." Sefilian has been accused of
"conspiring to overthrow the constitutional order" under Article 301
of the Criminal Code. On December 12, a Yerevan court, in a closed
session, ruled that Sefilian could be jailed for two months while
the NSS further investigates the case.

Pro-opposition media outlets have reported that dozens of members of
Sefilian’s Union of Armenian Volunteers, a small nationalist group
opposed to concessions with Azerbaijan, were also temporarily detained
in separate raids.

Armenia’s main opposition parties see the arrest as a warm-up for
crackdowns against government critics prior to the country’s May 2007
parliamentary elections, or against those who would question the vote’s
conduct. In a December 11 statement, they accused the government
of resorting to Soviet-style repression to stamp out political
dissent. The government has not yet responded to the accusation.

The arrest has also set off alarm bells in nationalist circles,
which see Sefilian’s detention as linked to his position on the
Nagorno-Karabakh negotiations. Recent statements from the Organization
for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE), the talks’ mediator,
indicatedthat the basic principles for the resolution of the conflict
are close to being finalized. [For background see the Eurasia Insight
archive].

A December 5 statement from the OSCE after a meeting in Brussels
between the Armenian and Azerbaijani foreign ministers urged both
countries to "double their efforts in the coming year to finalize
these basic principles as soon as possible."

Although possible breakthroughs in the negotiations are regularly
reported, this time a flurry of other reports about a possible deal
suggest that certain agreements are being reached, albeit behind closed
doors. Last month, for example, the Russian newspaper Nezavisimaya
Gazeta added fuel to such speculation when it published details of
what it said was the peace deal currently being discussed by the
Armenian and Azerbaijani sides. According to that information, as
well as periodical leaks from both Armenian and Azerbaijani officials,
most of the seven Azerbaijani regions currently under Armenian control
surrounding Karabakh would be returned to Baku. A 40-kilometer wide
"corridor" through the strategic town of Lachin, now known as Berdzor,
would remain under Armenian control, connecting Karabakh to Armenia
proper.

Lending credibility to such speculation are a series of articles
published this summer by the local and international media,
including EurasiaNet, reporting that the area around Lachin is
experiencing a massive exodus of ethnic Armenians. [For details,
see the Eurasia Insight archive]. A few weeks after these reports
surfaced, Sefilian accused the authorities in Yerevan and Stepanakert
of pursuing a deliberate policy to clear the region in preparation
for a concessionary peace deal with Azerbaijan.

Speaking for the Protection of Liberated Territories organization,
Sefilian, who holds the rank of a retired lieutenant colonel, alleged
that the population of what is now called the Kashatagh region by
Armenians had declined to 7,500. In 2001, the number of settlers
in what are the Armenian-controlled Lachin, Zangelan and Qubatli
regions of Azerbaijan was around 15,000. A 2005 census, however,
put the population at just under 10,000.

Official sources speaking to EurasiaNet on condition of anonymity
put the number as low as 6,000.

In November, other groups of Karabakh war veterans also made similar
accusations and threatened a campaign of civil disobedience if any
of these territories were returned to Azerbaijan. A written statement
by one such group, the Brotherhood of the Liberation Struggle, urged
all war veterans to unite "to save Armenia and Armenians and restore
justice in all spheres. The lands that we liberated are in danger
today. We urge all our compatriots . . . [to] stop our homeland from
falling into an abyss."

The Armenian newspaper Zhamanak Yerevan already sees a connection
between Sefilian’s arrest and official fears that Karabakh war
veterans might involve themselves in political life ahead of next
year’s parliamentary elections. "It was no coincidence that they
arrested Zhirayr Sefilian, a representative of the defiant section
of the freedom fighters, on the same day that they advised members
of the Yerkrapah Union [of Karabakh War Veterans] to stay away from
politics," the paper wrote on December 12.

In March 2006, the Iravunk newspaper reported that Sefilian had been
warned by the NSS to refrain from criticism of the government’s
position, and of Defense Minister Serzh Sarkisian, at the risk
of possible expulsion from the country. Another newspaper, Azg,
similarly quoted opposition politician Albert Bazeyan as saying that
"threats […] to deport Zhirayr Sefilian, former commander of [the]
Shushi battalion, is conditioned by […] recent tendencies in the
Nagorno-Karabakh conflict settlement."

Undaunted by such threats, Sefilian upped the ante in July by calling
a press conference in which he declared that a "group of former
civil guardsmen" had "already agreed upon certain steps which will
allow us take real and drastic measures to avert vote rigging at the
coming parliamentary and presidential elections." He also spoke of
realizing a "power shift to avert the launching of a new military
conflict with Azerbaijan."

Following Sefilian’s arrest, the NSS issued a written statement stating
that it had irrefutable proof that the ex-commander was planning an
armed uprising to "prod the country’s opposition into staging violent
anti-government protests." No evidence to support this claim has yet
been made available, however.

Few analysts believe that the Armenian or Azerbaijani presidents
would risk a nationalist backlash over a deal ahead of sensitive
parliamentary and presidential polls in both countries during 2007
and 2008. However, with the lack of public evidence against Sefilian
and a recent assertion by Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev that
negotiations are entering their final phase, suspicions about the
authorities’ actions continue to grow.

"I don’t exclude the possibility that he was arrested in connection
with the liberated lands, but I don’t think that any document connected
with Karabakh will be signed in the near future," one of Sefilian’s
associates, Armen Aghaian, stated on December 13.

Commented opposition parliamentarian Grigor Harutiunian, secretary
of the People’s Party: The government’s handling of the case against
Sefilian provides "the basis for some serious conclusions."

Editor’s Note: Onnik Krikorian is a freelance journalist
and photographer working for a variety of publications and
international organizations in Armenia. He has a blog at

http://oneworld.blogsome.com.

BAKU: National Minoities Condemn Nagorno-Karabakh Referendum

NATIONAL MINORITIES CONDEMN NAGORNO-KARABAKH REFERENDUM

AzerTag, Azerbaijan
Dec 14 2006

Representatives of national minorities in Azerbaijan gathered at the
International Press Center in Baku on Thursday to condemn the December
10 referendum in Nagorno-Karabakh.

At the initiative of the Head of Russian community of Azerbaijan
Mikhail Zabelin, the participants of the gathering agreed to establish
the Congress of National Minorities of the Azerbaijan Republic. They
formed a working group, produced a charter of the organization, and
issued an appeal to the UN, OSCE, Council of Europe, U.S. Department of
State and Congress, parliament of France, Russia’s Foreign Ministry and
State Duma, strongly protesting against the so-called "constitutional
referendum" in Nagorno-Karabakh. "This action by the separatist regime
of Nagorno-Karabakh contradicts not only Constitution of Azerbaijan but
also norms and principles of the international law," the appeal says.

It also says that representatives of tens of nationalities and
ethnic groups have been living in Azerbaijan for ages. They enjoy
all the rights of citizens of the sovereign and democratic country,
with the opportunity to preserve and develop their culture, language
and traditions.

The Congress of National Minorities expressed its full support for
the efforts by the leadership of Azerbaijan towards resolution of
the Armenia-Azerbaijan, Nagorno-Karabakh conflict on the base of
Azerbaijan’s territorial integrity, and called for condemnation of
the illegal act, and unrecognizing of the results of the so-called
"referendum".

KEVORKIAN PAROLED: ‘I’m Not Going To Do It Again’

KEVORKIAN PAROLED: ‘I’M NOT GOING TO DO IT AGAIN’
By Kathleen Gray

Detroit Free Press, MI
Dec 14 2006

He says he’ll follow the law and be an advocate

A compassionate doctor to some, a ghoulish murderer to others, Jack
Kevorkian will, in less than six months, become something he hasn’t
been for more than eight years — a free man.

Kevorkian, a frail 78-year-old, was granted parole Wednesday by two
members of the Michigan Parole Board after he promised not to conduct
any more assisted suicides. He will be eligible for release June 1.

Oakland County Prosecutor David Gorcyca said he would not appeal.

"He has served his minimum term, and I did not object to his release,"
Gorcyca said. "I’m certainly not particularly surprised, just due to
his alleged health concerns."

Known as the assisted-suicide doctor and Dr. Death, Kevorkian claimed
to have helped at least 130 terminally or chronically ill people die
during the 1990s, though he told parole board chairman John Rubitschun
that he turned down six or seven prospective patients for every one
he helped.

He told Rubitschun he would push for the legalization of assisted
suicide after his release, but promised to not participate in any
form of assisted suicide or euthanasia.

"You can put any conditions you want on me. I’m not going to do it
again," Kevorkian said in a Dec. 7 hearing, according to an account
based on notes from the meeting. "Anything that will bring me back
to prison, I will avoid. Prison is not a place a live."

Kevorkian was convicted in 1999 of second-degree murder in the Sept.

17, 1998, death of Thomas Youk, 52, of Waterford, a victim of the
debilitating Lou Gehrig’s disease.

The death was different from others in two ways. First, it was
videotaped and aired on the CBS show "60 Minutes." Second, Youk was
unable to press the button to deliver a fatal dose of drugs, and the
tape showed Kevorkian doing it for him, which provided prosecutors with
evidence that Kevorkian had stepped past the assisted-suicide line.

Kevorkian’s defiant approach brought physician-assisted suicide to the
national spotlight. In 1998, an Oregon law went into effect legalizing
the practice. But Michigan passed a law in 1999 banning it.

Kevorkian said he should have gone the legal route to advocate for
assisted suicide.

"If I had to do it again, I would have done it that way," he said.

Although Kevorkian won’t be eligible for release until June 1, his
attorney, Mayer Morganroth, said he’ll once again ask Gov. Jennifer
Granholm to release his client early from the Lakeland Correctional
Facility in Coldwater. The governor has denied requests to commute
the sentence four times.

"Certainly, it’s a relief; it’s a man’s life we’re talking about,"
Morganroth said. "The next thing we have to do is talk to the governor
so he doesn’t die in prison in the next six months."

There is little precedent for such an early release, said Corrections
Department spokesman Russ Marlan.

"Each time he’s done that, he’s said he has less than 12 months to
live," Marlan said. "I’ve personally witnessed that he appears to be
doing pretty well."

If his health hasn’t changed since the last evaluation this summer,
there would be no reason to release him early, Marlan said. Liz
Boyd, spokeswoman for Gov. Jennifer Granholm, said Wednesday that
the governor would have no comment until a commutation request is
turned in.

According to Morganroth, Kevorkian suffers from hepatitis C and high
blood pressure. He takes insulin four times a day and has hardening
of the arteries. He recently fell, breaking two ribs and his wrist.

‘He was very grateful’

Terrence Youk, Thomas Youk’s brother, said Kevorkian never should
have been in prison.

"I was starting to believe that they would never let him out," Youk
said from his home in Montpelier, Vt. "Jack put himself on the line
many, many times. All he wanted to do was help people have a choice
at the end of their life when they don’t have any other choices."

Ruth and Sarah Holmes, a mother and daughter who have become friends
with and frequent visitors of Kevorkian, said he can’t wait to get
home for a turkey wrap, some pickled vegetables and some fresh fruit.

"He was very grateful that the process finally worked," said Ruth
Holmes of Bloomfield Hills, after talking to Kevorkian on Wednesday.

"He was not in great shape when he went in, and he’s had a rough
winter."

Sarah Holmes attended the parole hearing and told Rubitschun that few
people know the side of Kevorkian that she has seen — the musician,
the poet, the painter, the historian, the family man.

"I tried to add the human element of Jack Kevorkian," she said. "He
is the most honest man you would ever meet, when he gives his word,
he sticks with it."

But retired Waterford Police Chief John Dean, who helped investigate
the Youk case, said he would oppose Kevorkian’s parole.

"I’m convinced he’ll do it again to make a statement," he said.

Kevorkian’s first assisted suicide was in June 1990, when Janet Adkins,
a Portland, Ore., woman with Alzheimer’s disease, died in the back
of the pathologist’s rusty Volkswagen van. He helped dozens more
people die over the years in vans, hotel rooms, private homes and in
his Royal Oak apartment. Most of the people were women, and all the
deaths were in Michigan. Many of the patients were from other states.

The state revoked his medical license in 1991 after he had conducted
five assisted suicides. Without a license, he could no longer buy
some of the drugs he used, so he began using different techniques,
which included the use of carbon monoxide canisters.

He was acquitted of murder three times and got a mistrial declared
in a fourth case.

Southfield attorney Geoffrey Fieger defended Kevorkian in all of
the acquittals, at turns disparaging prosecutors and at other times
scolding his famous client for courtroom outbursts.

"He was, at the time he went to prison, perhaps one of the most famous
people in the world," Fieger said Wednesday. "Certainly, he moved
the issue of individuals’ rights not to suffer at the end of lives,
far greater than any person before him."

******************** The parole decision

Dr. Jack Kevorkian became eligible for parole on a 10- to 25-year
sentence of second-degree murder after serving more than eight years
in prison.

A three-person panel of the Michigan Parole Board considers each
eligible case. One member of the panel interviews the prisoner and
passes a recommendation to a second member. If they agree, a third
member of the panel isn’t consulted, and parole is granted.

In Kevorkian’s case, John Robitschun, chairman of the parole board,
interviewed Kevorkian on Dec. 7. He recommended that parole be
approved, and parole board member Miguel Berrios agreed. They announced
their decision Wednesday.

The Oakland County Prosecutor’s Office can appeal the ruling to
the Oakland County Circuit Court, but Prosecutor David Gorcyca said
he won’t.

************************** How lives were ended

With $45 worth of materials in the 1980s, Dr. Jack Kevorkian created
what he called a suicide machine — a simple, effective device for
assisting people who wanted to end their lives.

The contraption was made of three bottles: One contained saline
solution, one held a sedative, and the last had lethal potassium
chloride.

Kevorkian hooked people to the device and allowed them to press a
button, starting the intravenous flow from the bottles.

In 1991, after his medical license was revoked, he switched to a
canister filled with carbon monoxide because he was no longer able
to get potassium chloride.

Ruby Bailey *************************

Jack Kevorkian Age: 78

Claim to fame: Says he helped more than 130 people with various
illnesses end their lives.

Nickname: Dr. Death.

Personal: Son of Armenian immigrants, raised in Pontiac, never married,
no children.

Education: Graduated from the University of Michigan Medical School
in 1952. Trained as a pathologist.

Employment: Worked at Pontiac General, Detroit Receiving and several
California hospitals.

Hobbies: Music, painting, languages, poetry. Published a book,
"Glimericks," while in prison.

************************* Good for a laugh?

In the heyday of his assisted-suicide practice, Dr. Jack Kevorkian’s
name became part of the nation’s popular culture.

A popular paint pattern for fishing spoons used for salmon and trout
is called Kevorkian because it lures the fish to their deaths.

And Kevorkian was a favorite for David Letterman’s lists. Consider:

~U Nov. 18, 1996, ways O.J. Simpson is raising legal funds: Freelancing
for Dr. Kevorkian.

~U July 23, 1996, Dr. Kevorkian pickup lines: "My friends say I
look like Brad Pitt — but they probably just say that so I don’t
kill them."

~U Feb. 14, 1996, signs you’re dating a loser: "He has Dr. Kevorkian
on speed dial."

~U Dec. 1, 1995, other Ann Landers mistakes: Referred "Depressed in
Detroit" to Dr. Kevorkian.

******************************** Photo at
/20061214/NEWS06/612140349/1008/NEWS06

http://www.freep.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=

Last Train Carrying Russian Garrison Property Leaves Georgia

LAST TRAIN CARRYING RUSSIAN GARRISON PROPERTY LEAVES GEORGIA

RIA Novosti, Russia
Dec 14 2006

TBILISI, December 14 (RIA Novosti) – A fourth and final train
transporting equipment and ammunition left Russia’s garrison in
Vaziani, outside the Georgian capital, on Thursday.

Russian military bases are being withdrawn from the post-Soviet
Caucasus state in keeping with Moscow’s commitment to remove them by
the end of 2008.

The remaining hardware will be taken out of the base later in December,
and moved to the 102nd Russian military base in neighboring Armenia.

The Vaziani garrison will be pulled out before the end of the year,
ahead of the earliest of the withdrawal deadlines for Russian forces
in the South Caucasus state, set for 2007. Russia’s defense minister
decided on an early pullout in mid-October, amid a diplomatic feud
between the former Soviet allies.

The Vaziani base had about a hundred items of equipment and 350 metric
tons of ammunition before the first consignment left.

A third trainload left the town on December 1. The garrison’s 387
service personnel will leave once the equipment pullout has been
completed.

Russia and Georgia have been locked in a bitter diplomatic dispute
since September, when four Russian army officers were briefly detained
in Tbilisi, on suspicion of espionage.

The move outraged Moscow, which cut transportation and postal links
with its neighbor in response, deported hundreds of Georgian migrants
and shut down Georgian-run businesses for alleged violations of
Russian law.

Georgia’s Western-leaning leadership, which seeks to join NATO, is
uneasy about Russia’s continued military presence, and has repeatedly
urged Moscow to close its Soviet-era bases.

Under a bilateral agreement signed in March 2006 and ratified by
Russia’s parliament in October, the pullouts from Russian bases in
the southern city of Akhalkalaki and in Batumi, western Georgia, are
to be completed by October 1, 2007, and October 1, 2008, respectively.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Karabakh Defends New Constitution

KARABAKH DEFENDS NEW CONSTITUTION
By Karine Ohanian in Stepanakert

Institute for War and Peace Reporting (IWPR), UK
Dec 14 2006

Karabakh Armenians reject claims that new basic law damages the
peace process.

Voters in Nagorny Karabakh approved a new constitution for the
unrecognised republic in a December 10 referendum, with local officials
insisting it would bolster the democratisation of the territory.

The date of the vote was a symbolic one, occurring on the very day
that the Armenians of Karabakh unilaterally declared independence from
Azerbaijan 15 years ago. Human rights campaigner Karen Ohanjanian
reminded IWPR that December 10 was also International Human Rights
Day and said he wanted the new constitution to be "our visiting card
before the world community, one proving our adherence to the principles
of democracy, justice, equality, peace and goodwill".

The day after the poll, Sergei Nasibian, chairman of the central
commission for the referendum, announced that 78,389 out of 90,077
registered voters had cast their ballots, of whom 98.58 per cent had
voted for the constitution and 0.7 per cent against.

However, the poll was condemned as illegitimate by the international
community, with Terry Davis, secretary general of the Council of
Europe, saying it "will not be recognised … and is therefore of
no consequence".

Karabakh is internationally regarded as being part of Azerbaijan,
although it has been de facto separate for 15 years and is closely
linked to Armenia.

More than 100 non-governmental international observers and journalists
monitored the poll and gave it a positive verdict, saying it was held
to a high international standard.

"I visited the village of Mehmana village in the Martakert District,"
said Luciano Ardezi, a member of the International Human Rights
League. "I must admit that the referendum was very well organised
and took place in accordance with all international requirements. The
voting was free and transparent."

Most irregularities were technical in nature and concerned inaccuracies
in voter lists, voting in closed booths and so on.

Much of the criticism from local observers was centred on the charge
that the population was poorly informed about what they were voting on.

"Many people are not familiar with the text of the basic law," said
Naira Hairumian, an observer from the Open Society organisation.

Pensioner Svetlana Davidian told IWPR that she did not know the
contents of the constitution, but voted for it anyway. "Clever people
worked on this document," she said. "Many of my acquaintances and
I have come to vote for the constitution for a different reason –
because this is yet another move to strengthen our independence,
which we declared in 1991 when we were being bombed by Azerbaijan."

Karabakh president Arkady Gukasian responded to the accusation that
the vote had been ill-prepared by saying, "For the fifteen years that
our state has existed, we’ve been constantly accused either of being
too late or in too much of a hurry to adopt a constitution. Adopting a
constitution is not an end in itself for us. In the past fifteen years,
we have not only managed to defend the path chosen by our people in
a difficult war, but we have also overtaken our neighbour Azerbaijan
in terms of democratisation."

Gukasian called the document "the best democratic constitution in
the former USSR".

In the run-up to the vote, there was speculation that Gukasian might
use the new constitution to run for a third term as leader, when his
second term of office expires next year, on the grounds that the law
has changed. However, the president declared firmly that he had no
intention of running again.

Irina Beglarian, an official with the foreign ministry, spoke
approvingly of the unrecognised republic’s first constitution, saying,
"I like the way it has a clear division of powers, that the prime
minister is appointed by the parliament, that there are mechanisms
to make the legal system work effectively, and, on the whole, that
it has aspects of semi-presidential rule."

Opposition member of parliament Gegham Bagdasarian was more
equivocal. "Of course, the constitution is a step forward towards
Karabakh’s democratisation," he said. "But I think that the basic
law is not as perfect as it could be. In particular, there’s no full
set of mechanisms to restrain and counterbalance branches of power;
there’s no clear basis for an independent legal system; and no
constitutional court."

Former Russian mediator Vladimir Kazimirov told the PanARMENIAN.Net
news agency that although the vote would not be recognised, "it’s
impossible to fully ignore the referendum. Of course, democratic
procedures in Nagorny Karabakh are not faultless, as Azerbaijanis
living in Nagorny Karabakh are not allowed to take part in them. But
it won’t occur to anyone to refuse to recognise elections in [the
Azerbaijani cities of] Baku or Ganje just because Armenians living
there have not participated in them, will it?"

There was condemnation of the vote from the American, French and
Russian co-chairs of the Minsk Group on the grounds that the vote
interfered with the Armenian-Azerbaijani peace process at a delicate
stage.

Azerbaijani foreign minister Elmar Mamedyarov said, "The referendum
in Nagorny Karabakh damages peace negotiations."

But Deputy Foreign Minister Masis Mailian countered, "State building,
both in the Nagorny Karabakh republic and in Azerbaijan, is not
directly linked to the course of the peace process and it can’t hinder
the attainment of peace in this region."

Karine Ohanian works for Demo newspaper in Nagorny Karabakh.

Armenian Women Are Silent Victims

ARMENIAN WOMEN ARE SILENT VICTIMS
By Gayane Abrahamian in Yerevan and Gavar

Institute for War and Peace Reporting (IWPR), UK
Dec 14 2006

Thousands endure beatings but lack means to protect themselves.

Almost half of Armenia’s women have suffered domestic abuse, say
researchers, yet this disturbing problem is being hushed up because
of traditional attitudes.

"Armenian women suffer violence, but they are afraid and keep silent,
as they don’t believe that anything can be done about it," said
Consuelo Vidal, United Nations resident coordinator in Armenia at
the launch of a 16-day programme Campaign Against Gender Violence
that continues until December 16.

For 13 years, Hasmik Hakobian has been married to a man from a
traditional Armenian family in the town of Gavar around 100 kilometres
from Yerevan.

She was just nineteen when her father married her off to a young man,
whom she’d only ever seen from the window of her house.

"I have a black eye permanently so the neighbours have long stopped
asking me what the matter is," said Hasmik. "Happiness for me means
not being beaten and blood not gushing from my nose."

Hasmik said she was beaten for the first time three days after her
wedding, and since then she has lost count of the number of times
she has suffered abuse.

"I was pregnant then,’ she recalled. "I was baking bread. I don’t
know what my mother-in-law had told my husband, but he was mad with
rage when he rushed into the bakery. He snatched the rolling pin
from my hands and hit me on the back and head with it. I came round
in hospital, having already delivered the baby."

Hasmik decided to leave her husband, but her father refused to take
her back home, saying that wives were always beaten by their husbands
and advising her to put up with it and raise her child.

Ethnographer and sociologist Mihran Galstian said that traditional
denigrating attitudes towards women in Armenia has made such violence
possible. Armenian folk proverbs actively encourage beating by
promoting the idea that "a woman is like wool – the more you beat it,
the softer it becomes" or "a woman is made to cry".

Officials and parliamentarians also refuse to acknowledge there is
a problem.

For example, Armen Ashotian, a member of parliament from the governing
Republican Party, said, "Domestic violence is not a feature of our
families. I think that people who want to raise this problem are
really not bothered by the issue but just want to get new grants.

They are lowering the image of Armenia for the sake of their own
pockets.

"There are occasionally cases of it, but domestic violence is not on
a big scale in our society. They shouldn’t present Armenia as some
kind of African tribe, where people eat one another."

Data collected suggests otherwise. In 2004-2005, the Sociometer Centre
for Independent Sociological Studies conducted a poll of 1200 women
in Yerevan and eight towns and eight villages. Forty six per cent
said they were exposed to violence in their family, a quarter in the
presence of their children.

"Our officials refuse to admit that violence does exist in Armenian
families and that serious measures need to be taken to fight it,"
said Susanna Vardanian, director of the Women’s Rights Centre in
Yerevan. "Moreover, they accuse others of destroying our traditionally
strong families in order to get grants."

"Unfortunately, many see the abuse of women as normal. The belief
that violence is an integral part of married life originates in early
childhood: first a girl is beaten by her brother, then by her husband,
and she comes to think that that’s the way it should be," said Adibek
Aharonian, director of the Sociometer centre.

According to Sociometer, 45 per cent of the women suffering abuse
in their families keep quiet about their problem. Only 0.3 per cent
resort to divorce, and no more than 0.4 per cent contact the police.

Vardanian said women had no faith in the police to protect them and
they were afraid of the consequences, "After the police leave, [a
victim] may be subjected to still greater violence, as it’s shameful
to wash your family’s dirty linen in public."

Gulnara Martirosian (not her real name) now lives in an old people’s
home in Yerevan, although she is only 45. Her 25 years of married
life were an endless series of fights not only with her husband,
but also with his mother and brother.

"Anyone who felt like it could beat me," she told IWPR. "If something
was wrong in the house, I was the one who got the blame. They pounced
on me and beat me – all together. Once I tried to defend myself,
I grabbed a chair and hit my husband over the head with it."

This incident, which happened in 2002, cost Gulnara her sight.

"I hit him and darted out of the house, but there was nowhere to run
– my parents are dead, I have no relatives, and I sought refuge in
my neighbour’s house," she went on. "My husband came for me there,
and when he saw me, he splashed acid in my eyes. I remember my face
burning, the pain was so bad I lost consciousness. I was taken to
Yerevan and operated on there, but my sight never returned."

No one from the family comes to see Gulnara and she says her children
have been told that she is dead.

"I couldn’t stand up for my rights, as I had no money, no relatives to
run around the courts for me. That’s how my life has passed," she said.

Since the Centre for Women Rights opened seven years ago,
more than 10,000 women, including over four thousand victims of
domestic violence, have called its hotline, asking for help. Another
organisation, the Motherhood Foundation, has been open for four years
and has dealt with 3,000 women, who said they were exposed to abuse.

"These are rather high figures for Armenia, considering that women
suffering violence tend to seek help from their relatives and friends,
and only those in a hopeless situation turn to organisations like
ours," said Anna Badalian, a psychologist at the foundation.

IWPR randomly polled ten women in Yerevan on the street. Four of them
said they had been beaten by their husbands more than once. And there
was a clear difference in outlook between the generations.

"If couples divorced because of beatings and abuse, there would be
no families left in Armenia," said accountant Satik Kintoian, 78.

"I remember my grandfather saying that a man, when choosing a wife
for himself, should beat her first, and if she cowered in the corner,
that meant she would make a good wife, and if she ran away, then
she wouldn’t.

"I was beaten and loved too. They say the more he beats you, the more
he’ll love you. I have no regrets about my life. I’m not saying that
a wife should be beaten every day, but when she crosses the line,
she should have a beating."

Zaruhi Minasian, a 26-year-old translator, takes a different view.

She said she has never been subjected to physical abuse but she has
experienced psychological pressure.

"I have no respect for men who want to prove themselves by taking
it out against women," she said. "That only proves that these men
are weak."

Gayane Abrahamian is a correspondent for Armenianow.com.

;s= f&o=326150&apc_state=henpcrs

http://www.iwpr.net/?p=crs&amp

BAKU: Shukputov: Kazakhstan Supports Azerbaijan’s Territorial Integr

ANDAR SHUKPUTOV: KAZAKHSTAN SUPPORTS AZERBAIJAN’S TERRITORIAL INTEGRITY

Azeri Press Agency, Azerbaijan
Dec 14 2006

Kazakhstan Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary to Azerbaijan
Andar Shukputov’s exclusive interview to the APA

– You are celebrating the 15th anniversary of Independence of
Kazakhstan. How will you characterize the importance of this date?

– On December 16, 1991 Kazakhstan adopted Constitutional law on the
independence day of the Republic of Kazakhstan. This law was adopted
in the hard periods of Kazakhstan. The economic indicators were low
during those years and the main institutions were not working. But
Kazakhstan’s government had a serious aim and as the result of policy,
we achieved to go out of the crisis. The reforms had been carried
out in all spheres and these reforms contributed to the flourishing
of our country.

– How do you evaluate the work of Azerbaijani Diasporas in Kazakhstan?

– As far as I know the representatives of 130 nations live in
Kazakhstan. During the collapse of the empire, Kazakhstan could
prevent the leaving of its citizens. Even now the number of the
nations living in our country has increased by several times. There
are Azerbaijanis among them too. There is an organization called
the Assembly of Kazakhstan nations. This organization settles
the problems of the development of the statehood. The Azerbaijanis
living in Azerbaijan has a social organization called Turan. Besides,
Azerbaijanis have different social organizations in every region,
such as Gobustan, Vatan, Heydar and others. The leader of the Turan
Azerbaijanis Congress visited Azerbaijan together with Kazakhstan
President Nursultan Nazarbayev last year. As to the problems of the
Azerbaijanis living in Kazakhstan, market economy relations exist
in this country. Everybody can improve his way of living using the
opportunities created for the citizens.

– Azerbaijan-Kazakhstan political relations have always differed
by stability…

– The root of our history and culture is the same. Therefore there
have always been relations between these countries and it continues.

Heydar Aliyev and Nursultan Nazarbayev’s friendship paved the way
for the new stage of relations between the two countries. Azerbaijani
president Ilham Aliyev within three years of his presidentcy visited
Kazakhstan three times. Kazakhstan President also visited Azerbaijan
last year. The activity of Azerbaijan-Kazakhstan intergovernmental
commission has intensified.

– Are you satisfied with the economic relations between the countries?

– The economic relations between our countries are based on the
realization of bilateral projects. We use Baku-Batumi line for
transportation of Kazakhstan’s oil. Within Ilham Aliyev’s visit to
Kazakhstan the presidents signed a treaty on the transportation of
Kazakhstan’s oil by Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan pipeline. I am often asked
when Kazakhstan will join Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan pipeline. The terms
are being agreed on the transportation of Kazakhstan’s oil by the
pipeline. These terms include price, volume and other issues.

Baku-Tbilisi-Akhalkalak-Gars railway project is the second great
project for Kazakhstan. If this railway is built from Baku till Gars
and we get an outlet to Europe. Another great project is connected
with the grain production. There is a big grain terminal in Aktau.

Kazakhstan produces 16 million tons grain a year, 6-7 tons of which
can import to Azerbaijan.

– How does the official Astana estimate the latest processes in the
settlement of Nagorno Karabakh conflict?

– We have expressed our position on Nagorno Karabakh conflict several
times. Kazakhstan supports Azerbaijan’s territorial integrity and
highly estimates the activity of OSCE Minsk Group. We are for the
peaceful solution to Nagorno Karabakh conflict.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Yerevan Hints At Iran Pipeline Delay

YEREVAN HINTS AT IRAN PIPELINE DELAY
By Karine Kalantarian

Radio Liberty, Czech Rep.
Dec 14 2006

The Armenian government on Thursday stopped short of explicitly denying
reports that the ongoing work on a major natural gas pipeline from
Iran will not be complete, as planned, by the end of this month.

Energy Minister Armen Movsisian said last month that the first
41-kilometer section of the pipeline passing through south-eastern
Armenia will be inaugurated on December 20. His deputy Ara Simonian
also spoke of a late December deadline for finishing the Iranian-funded
construction.

But citing unnamed government sources, the Yerevan daily "Haykakan
Zhamanak" reported on Thursday that the pipeline will not come on
stream before next summer.

"The construction of the Iran-Armenia pipeline is proceeding according
to plan, and everything will be done to complete it on time,"
Lusine Harutiunian, a spokeswoman for the Armenian Energy Ministry
told RFE/RL.

"We have said that it will be complete before the end of the year.

Now everything is being done to meet that deadline," she said.

But Harutiunian added that this will happen only "if the weather does
not create surprises." "We can’t tell you a concrete day at this point
because it is now winter and working in such climate conditions is
not easy," she said without elaborating.

The under-construction pipeline was supposed to diversify the
landlocked country’s energy resources that mainly come from Russia
at present. But it is now widely expected to be incorporated into
a Russian-controlled company that owns Armenia’s gas distribution
network. The takeover would be part of a controversial deal that
enabled Armenia to temporarily avoid a steep rise in the price of
Russian gas in return for hading over more energy assets to Gazprom
Russia’s state-run gas monopoly.

PACE To Demand Free Elections In Armenia

PACE TO DEMAND FREE ELECTIONS IN ARMENIA
By Emil Danielyan

Radio Liberty, Czech Rep.
Dec 14 2006

The Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) will likely
demand that Armenia "at last" hold elections recognized as democratic
by the international community when it meets for a regular session
next month, it emerged on Thursday.

The demand is contained in a draft resolution that was approved by
the PACE’s Monitoring Committee this week and is widely expected to
adopted by the Strasbourg-based assembly without major amendments
in late January. It stresses the "particular importance" of proper
conduct of the next Armenian parliamentary and presidential elections
due in early 2007 and 2008 respectively.

"It is essential that the next ballot should at last comply with
European standards for free and fair elections, as proof of Armenia’s
progress along the road to democracy and European integration,"
reads the document posted on the PACE website. It deplores Yerevan’s
failure to ensure the freedom and fairness of the previous elections.

The Monitoring Committee report urges the Armenian authorities to
display the "political will" to prevent a repeat of serious fraud
reported by local and Western observers in the past. "A clear message
must be conveyed that in the next elections fraud will simply not be
tolerated," it says.

Still, the proposed resolution makes a largely positive assessment of
the fulfilment of Armenia’s Council of Europe membership obligations,
singling out the passage of a raft of amendments to the Armenian
constitution in a disputed November 2005 referendum. "The revised
constitution is now consistent with European standards and principles
of democracy and the rule of law and offers a new foundation for
developing the democratic functioning of Armenia’s institutions,"
it says.

The Monitoring Committee will specifically ask the PACE to welcome
greater powers given to Armenia’s parliament, cabinet of ministers,
judiciary and local governments. It will also note the fact that
Armenians are now able to challenge government decisions and laws in
the Constitutional Court.

Armenia’s main opposition forces are highly skeptical about the
positive impact of the Western-backed changes, saying that the
administration of President Robert Kocharian has repeatedly violated
the constitution to cling to power. They point to the authorities’
handling of the constitutional referendum which was strongly criticized
by Council of Europe observers.

The draft PACE resolution acknowledges that the enacted amendments
alone will not make Armenia a more democratic country. "Simply
passing legislation is not enough to implement democratic reforms,"
it says. "The Assembly calls on the Armenian authorities to take the
necessary steps so that the law is effectively applied, which does
not always appear to be the case at present."

In particular, the resolution voices concern at widespread reports of
police torture and the authorities’ continuing grip on the Armenian
electronic media. "The limited number of complaints lodged which result
in members of the police being found guilty of abuse of authority
or of exceeding their authority, as well as the greater number of
allegations concerning which no complaint is lodged for fear of
reprisals, continue to fuel the feeling that impunity prevails,"
it says.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress