Saakashvili Strikes Gas In Turkey

SAAKASHVILI STRIKES GAS IN TURKEY

Kommersant, Russia
Dec 21 2006

Georgia will get most of its natural gas in 2007 from the Shah
Deniz deposit in Azerbaijan, which is being developed by BP. This
was announced by Georgian President Mikheil Saakashvili after his
negotiations with Turkish President Ahmet Necdet Sezer in Ankara
during his three-day official visit. Turkey is transferring gas it has
contracted for to Georgia, Greece and Azerbaijan, and the price of that
gas will be lower than the proposals made by Gazprom. Armenia comes out
the loser in the plan, which will be confirmed on December 21 and 22.

The idea of splitting up Turkish gas arose in October, after Gazprom
announced that Georgia and Azerbaijan would be paying $230 per 1000
cu. m. of gas in 2007 and that the quota on supplies to Azerbaijan
would be lowered from 4.5 billion c. m. to 1.5 billion cu. m. In
response to that, BP stepped up development at the Shah Deniz deposit,
gas from which is to flow to the Transcaucasian countries, Turkey and
Europe next year. Saakashvili and Azeri President Ilham Aliyev reached
an agreement in principle on deliveries of Azeri gas to Georgia at the
CIS summit in Minsk. Turkey, Georgia and Azerbaijan began negotiations
on the details of the gas supplies in the middle of this month.

It has been learned so far from sources at the negotiations that 800
million cu. m. of gas from the Turkish quota will go to Georgia,
which will receive another 50 million cu. m. in payment for gas
transit on the Baku-Tbilisi-Erzerum gas pipeline, which originates
at Shah Deniz. The country will receive 250 million cu. m. at the
discounted price of $60 per 1000 cu. m. and will receive about 100
million cu. m. from Gazprom, even without a contract, as payment for
the transit of Russian gas to Armenia. Armenia has been guaranteed
1.2 billion cu. m. of natural gas from Russia. Of that volume, 400
million cu. m. will be supplied to Georgia at a price lower than $60
per 1000 cu. m. and 800 million cu. m. at a price to be agreed on by
December 22.

A Kommersant source in the Georgian Ministry of Energy said that
"the price for Shah Deniz gas will be lower than Gapzrom’s price, of
course, but it will still probably be over $100." Georgia consumes
1.5-1.7 billion cu. m. of natural gas a year. The remaining 300
million cu. m. will have to be obtained from Iran or Russia, but the
price will not have a great effect on the overall average price.

Turkey has stated that the gas from Shah Deniz is not needed by
it for its 2007 energy needs. Turkey receives a significant part
of its gas from Gazprom via the Blue Flow pipeline. Its contract
stipulates hefty fines for Gazprom is it curtails supplies. The
Turkish president stated almost openly that Turkey was giving up
its gas quota in exchange for the beginning of the construction of
a Kars-Akhalkalaki-Baku rail line bypassing Armenia. Turkey is also
insisting on the return of the Meskhetian Turks to southern Georgia,
which is strongly opposed by the Armenian community in that area.

846 Schools To Be Equipped With Computers In 2007

846 SCHOOL TO BE EQUIPPED WITH COMPUTERS IN 2007

Arka News Agency, Armenia
Dec 21 2006

YEREVAN, December 20. /ARKA/. By the end of 2007, 846 Armenian
schools will be equipped with computers, which amounts to 57.6% of
the total number of the country’s schools. Minister of Education and
Science of Armenia Levon Lazarian told reporters Wednesday that the
computerization of schools is implemented by the ministry together
with the World Bank.

He said that computers were provided for 367 schools in 2005.

Distribution and installation of computers is under way at 368 schools
in 2006. "In 2007 we have to provide 311 schools with computers,"
he reported.

"We plan to equip our library in every Armenian school. Besides
literature, it will have a special computer lab," Lazarian said.

The minister reported that it is planned to have at least one
modernized school having a library with computers in every region by
the end of 2007.

"If our plans are implemented successfully, we intend to provide
these schools also with laboratory equipment in future," he said.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Bill On Electoral Fraud By One Person

BILL ON ELECTORAL FRAUD BY ONE PERSON

Lragir, Armenia
Dec 21 2006

On December 20 and 21 the Electoral Code of Armenia finally "reached"
the agenda of the National Assembly and was discussed. Hardly twenty
out of 131 members of parliament attended the meeting, mainly members
of the opposition or independent members of parliament. 5-6 members
of parliament from the three majority parties were present, only 3
made speeches. According to the opposition, by these amendments to
the Electoral Code the majority is likely to create conditions for
electoral fraud in 2007. The pro-government forces think that the
electoral code is not perfect but ensures progress.

Member of Parliament Hovanes Margaryan, Orinats Yerkir Party, said
the code worked out in a year and a half was changed within 4 days.

Alexan Karapetyan, National Solidarity, stated that the code which
is constantly amended should work perfectly but our law does not.

The provision which does not require quorum for the meetings of the
electoral commissions added to the fears of the opposition on parity
of the staffs of electoral commissions, a proportional system of
election, etc. "We are discussing a bill which can be described as
a bill for electoral fraud by one person. There is no country in the
world which would allow holding a meeting of the electoral commission
if only one member is present," stated Victor Dallakyan and noted that
the figures are speaking about free, fair and transparent elections
who are specialized in electoral fraud.

Anti-Criminal Goes To The Street

ANTI-CRIMINAL GOES TO THE STREET

Lragir, Armenia
Dec 21 2006

On December 21 public hearings of the anti-criminal movement took
place, which is the last event of the anti-criminal movement in 2006.

Aram Karapetyan, the leader of the Nor Zhamanakner Party, said the
events will continue after the holidays and it is possible that the
movement will take more definite actions in the street. Aram Karapetyan
mentioned that many political parties of the movement have agreed.

The leader of the Nor Zhamanakner Party said it is impossible to change
power in Armenia through an election, and in this case there can be
two ways: either to come together and lose the country or to come
together and fight through all the possible means. Aram Karapetyan
stated that the peaceful way is the most preferable form of civil
disobedience and he is against hard struggle.

"The UN convention states that if the government is against the people,
defies the principles of democracy, does not ensure progress, has
usurped power, anyone and any group of people can revolt against such
a government," Aram Karapetyan stated. He said when the repressive
administration moves forward by crushing everything on its way,
the civil disobedience can be rather tough.

Although Aram Karapetyan has stated that it is impossible to change
power in Armenia through an election, he mentioned that the upcoming
election is the crucial political moment that must be used for a change
of power. The leader of the Nor Zhamanakner Party said personally
he would prefer applying the Georgian model of the change of power
to Armenia.

"Mer Hayrenik" Is Not ARF Dashnaktsutyun’s Anthem

"MER HAYRENIK" IS NOT ARF DASHNAKTSUTYUN’S ANTHEM

Lragir, Armenia
Dec 21 2006

On the second day of the extraordinary meeting of the National Assembly
Speaker Tigran Torosyan did not put the bill on the anthem of the
Republic of Armenia to voting. "The voting will be tomorrow morning,"
said Speaker Tigran Torosyan to news reporters.

His decision not to put the question to voting gave rise to opinions
that the speaker of the National Assembly was not sure the outcome
would be as they had planned. Tigran Torosyan disagrees, "We must be
very responsible towards this question, and Armenia cannot start 2007
without an anthem."

During the debate on this bill the focus was on the provisional article
of the bill that "Mer Hayrenik" is our anthem until the adoption of
a new anthem. Tigran Torosyan thinks that the government, which is
the author of the bill, will not have withdrawn this provision. The
main opponent of the bill was the ARF Dashnaktsutyun.

In this connection, Tigran Torosyan noticed that it is wrong to
think that "Mer Hayrenik" is the anthem of the ARF Dashnaktsutyun,
and reminded that "Mer Hayrenik" was the anthem of Armenia in the
early 20th century and until December 6, 2006.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

There Was Shooting At The Office Of Bargavach Hayastan In Abovyan To

THERE WAS SHOOTING AT THE OFFICE OF BARGAVACH HAYASTAN IN ABOVYAN TOWN

Lragir, Armenia
Dec 21 2006

The leader of the Nor Zhamanakner Party Aram Karapetyan questioned
the activities of the National security of Armenia and the law
enforcement agencies during the meeting of the anti-criminal movement
on December 21. According to him, these activities arouse more answers
than give answers on the threats against the state. Aram Karapetyan
particularly dwelled on the statement of the leader of the National
Security Service Gorik Hakobyan that the National Security Service
has arrested a foreign spy named Valakhmetov.

Aram Karapetyan asks why the National Security Service fails to
announce which country’s citizen Valakhmetov is. He thinks that
Valakhmetov cannot be Azerbaijani because an Azerbaijani citizen would
not work in Armenia with an Azerbaijani passport. "If Valakhmetov,
because the surname suggests that he could be from the North Caucasus,
we are not sure, is a citizen of Russia, how about the agreement
that two countries, Russia or the countries of the CIS, should not
spy each other?" Aram Karapetyan asks.

He is surprised about the innumerable medals that the president and
the leaders of the law enforcement agencies gave Gorik Hakobyan and
other NSS officers on the day of the National Security Officer.

"Maybe it was an effort of encouraging the arrests," says Aram
Karapetyan. He means the arrest of Jirair Sefilyan and Vardan
Malkhasyan by the National Security Service.

"Aren’t we thereby becoming closer to Chaushesku’s regime, or the
regimes of Latin America where awards were pledged for the head of an
oppositionist and were paid?" asks the leader of the Nor Zhamanakner
Party.

He also had questions for the National Security and law enforcement
agencies on the fresh examples. Aram Karapetyan is interested whether
the law enforcement agencies and the National Security work as hard
to investigate the murder of the mayor of the village of Nalbandyan.

"Are the law enforcement agencies aware that 20 days ago the office
of the Bargavach Hayastan Party in Abovyan was attacked, there was
shooting, then people drove away in their cars? Did they say who they
are and where they are waiting for the leadership of the political
party?" asks Aram Karapetyan saying that the government never reacts
and denies the mentioned facts. As a recent example, Aram Karapetyan
mentions the recent order to the police force. According to him,
the internal force was ordered to be ready to repress and prevent
every mass public protest connected with the election.

Aram Karapetyan says he will release more detailed information after
the news is refutted officially.

Suspects And Criminals Deprived Of Nationality

SUSPECTS AND CRIMINALS DEPRIVED OF NATIONALITY

Kommersant, Russia
Dec 21 2006

An unscheduled session of the Moscow City Duma will consider
introducing a legislative initiate into the State Duma to prohibit
mentioning the ethnicity of suspected or accused criminals and victims
of crimes in the media and on computer networks. The United Russia
Party is proposing the amendment to the law "On the Media" because
it holds that the mention of such information inflames ethnic strife.

The drafters of the amendment say that, because only a citizen himself
can define and indicate his ethnic membership under the Constitution
of the Russian Federation, such indications in the media "without
sufficient bases can be seen as unsubstantiated information and a
violation of civil rights." Leader of the United Russia faction in
the Moscow Duma Andrey Metelsky also mentioned that that information
could lead to ethnic strife.

The opposition in the Moscow Duma reacted to the initiative without
enthusiasm. "If crime has an ethnic element, it makes no sense to hide
it," commented Communist faction leader Vladimir Ulas. Yabloko faction
coordinator in the Moscow Duma Sergey Mitrokhin told Kommersant that
"often the ethnicity of a criminal can be guessed from his name or
photograph. This can be taken to the absurd. As a result, a journalist
might suffer for objective coverage of a situation."

Representatives of ethnic organizations in Moscow took a different
view. Samvel Grigoryan, chairman of the board of the National-Cultural
Autonomy of Armenians of Moscow, approved of the initiative, stating
that such information "enflames ethnic strife whether intentionally or
not." Tofik Melikov of the Ochag Azeri cultural center saw unequal
treatment of Slavs and non-Slavs in the press "with the goal of
forming a negative image of certain nationalities."

Alexander Belov, leader of the Movement against Illegal Immigration,
was critical of the initiative, saying that it "treats the symptom, not
the cause." "There are peoples who commit more crimes than others," he
added. "There are a lot of societies with no media at all, somewhere in
Africa, but peoples there hate each other and cut each other up too."

Yearender: Nagorno-Karabakh Fails To Make Progress After 12 Years

YEARENDER: NAGORNO-KARABAKH FAILS TO MAKE PROGRESS AFTER 12 YEARS
by Dan Shea, dpa

Deutsche Presse-Agentur
December 20, 2006 Wednesday 5:01 AM EST

Though negotiations are wrapped in secrecy to hide 12 years of failure,
the former Soviet Union’s bloodiest conflict pitting Armenia against
Azerbaijan may be edging closer to talks that could yield peace –
or destroy current diplomatic efforts entirely.

Earlier this year, a raft of new proposals for Nagorno-Karabakh,
a breakaway region in the oil-rich Caucasus republic of Azerbaijan,
received rare positive assessments among international mediators in
Moscow, Paris, Bucharest and Brussels.

But despite several meetings during 2006 between Azeri President
Ilham Aliyev and and Armenian President Robert Kocharyan, no progress
appears to have been made on resolving the conflict.

Aliyev has warned that if talks fail, "Azerbaijan will definitely
reconsider its strategy, tactics and behaviour."

The 4,400-square-kilometre enclave in western Azerbaijan – populated
almost entirely by ethnic Armenians – was ravaged by war in 1988-94
and is today occupied by Armenian troops.

Underscoring the sensitivity of a conflict that left an estimated
35,000 dead and threatens to reignite, the proposals made earlier
this year were kept secret.

Since hostilities ended, the Armenian leadership in Yerevan has
insisted on independence for the region. Baku says it will allow "the
greatest measure" of autonomy, but refuses to part with the enclave.

"The position of Armenia is founded on dreams and illusions. They
think a temporary military supremacy gives them the right to think
about the separation of Nagorno-Karabakh from Azerbaijan," Aliyev says.

Efforts aimed at talks come amid a strong flow of petrodollars into
Aliyev’s coffers, with BP’s 4-billion-dollar Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan
pipeline well into its second year of operation.

President Aliyev has made it clear he wants to spend these funds on
arms. Last summer he told his country’s parliament that Azerbaijan’s
defence budget should surpass Armenia’s entire state spending.

Almost all the 500,000 Azeris that once lived in Nagorno-Karabakh
having long since fled. The region’s residents buy their food using
the Armenian dram and the streets are patrolled by troops from Yerevan.

But 12 years after the official end of fighting, Azeri leaders remain
bitter over the scars left by the Soviet collapse and the ensuing war.

Television commercials and billboards appeal in English to the BP
workers in Baku, reminding them of Azeris displaced from their home
villages in the exodus that accompanied the war.

The presidential bookstore in Baku carries such titles as "The Myth
of a Great Armenia" and "Blood Politics, Or the Philosophy of Revenge:
Armenia in Azerbaijan."

And under the Soviet-era television tower, perched on a promontory
overlooking the skyscraper-studded city, is Martyrs’ Alley, row
after row of graves – most bearing photographs – of Azeris who died
in Nagorno-Karabakh.

The conflict’s roots are found in the earliest days of the Soviet
Union, when Lenin in 1923 created the Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous
District within the Soviet Socialist Republic of Azerbaijan, rather
than Armenia, in an effort to win Turkish sympathies.

But with Baku’s perestroika-era leader Heidar Aliyev – the current
president’s late father – encouraging his countrymen to settle in
the 95-per-cent Armenian region in the late 1980s, calls for an
independent Nagorno-Karabakh found resonance in Moscow.

A peaceful nationalist movement quickly turned violent. During and
after the Soviet collapse, Yerevan and Baku vied for Russian support
in equipping their armies as a full-scale war broke out.

For six years the upper hand in the conflict was determined by the
amount of weaponry Moscow supplied, Russian defence analyst Pavel
Felgenhauer said.

"Armenia had the advantage, then Azerbaijan, then Armenia again,"
Felgenhauer said, adding that Armenia was able to decisively gain
control of the region in 1993 after diplomatic relations between
Moscow and Baku took a turn for the worse.

With Armenian forces occupying nearly one-seventh of Azerbaijan in
1994, peace talks began.

For 12 years negotiations went nowhere, and the Nagorno-Karabakh
question became the trump card in the politics of both countries.

Armenian President Kocharyan was a leader in the breakaway region,
and Azerbaijan’s Ilham Aliyev rode to power on the coattails of his
father, who promised to reclaim the lost territory.

But although Armenian Foreign Minister Vardan Oskanyan earlier this
year spoke of "a real possibility of a rapprochement" with the Azeri
side, Baku now may prefer to hold out.

Since neither side would want to resume the debilitating fighting,
Azerbaijan’s rising clout as a supplier of oil and gas in the Caucasus
gives it the option of waiting until it would be guaranteed control
over Nagorno-Karabakh.

"Negotiations haven’t led to anything, and they won’t lead to
anything," Felgenhauer says.

Yearender: Frozen Conflicts Ring Black Sea Region

YEARENDER: FROZEN CONFLICTS RING BLACK SEA REGION
by Leon Mangasarian, dpa

Deutsche Presse-Agentur
December 20, 2006 Wednesday 5:00 AM EST

The Black Sea region’s frozen conflicts are unresolved wars or disputes
which involve Russia.

They include Transnistria, Abkhazia, South Ossetia and
Nagorno-Karabakh.

All four of these territories are diplomatically unrecognized
mini-"states" which have split off from other countries which were
parts of the former Soviet Union.

Abkhazia and South Ossetia have both left Georgia, Nagorno- Karabakh is
legally part of Azerbaijan but has split off with Armenian assistance,
and Transnistria has seceded from Moldova.

With the European Union due to extend its borders to the Black Sea
after the planned admission of Bulgaria and Romania on January 1,
2007, the frozen conflicts are poised to gain greater attention in
Europe’s capitals.

Romanian President Traian Basescu warns that the frozen conflicts are
a threat to the EU not least as breeding grounds for organized crime,
human-trafficking and drug-smuggling.

A German Marshall Fund study terms the conflicts "an unresolved
legacy of the Soviet empire" and warns they "threaten the periphery
of a continent composed of secure democracies."

Swedish Foreign Minister Carl Bildt says in his blog that "all of
them have the potential to destabilize a wider region if they flare
up again."

Although Russia’s role can be seen to varying degrees in all the
frozen conflicts, Russian President Vladimir Putin vigorously denies
any role in stirring up problems in the region.

"They have nothing to do with Russian machinations," said Putin at
a summit with European Union leaders in Finland last October, adding,

"Don’t try to blame us for what we can’t do because in the post-
Soviet space we have quite a few frozen conflicts."

Moscow backs breakaway Transnistria both economically and with troops
from its 14th Army which are stationed in the territory guarding a
huge munitions supply.

"With Russian support, the Transnistrian leader, Igor Smirnov, has
little incentive to compromise in his drive towards independence,"
a report by the Brussels-based International Crisis Group says.

Smirnov, who has run Transnistria since 1991, won a fourth term in
elections earlier this month.

Russia has also supported the breakaway Georgian regions of South
Ossetia and Abkhazia. Georgia accuses Russian peacekeeping troops of
siding with the separatists in both provinces.

The Russian state backs Armenia without which Nagorno-Karabakh could
not survive either militarily or economically.

"Over half its army are believed to be Armenian citizens," the
International Crisis Group says.

Despite ongoing attempts to mediate a diplomatic deal, voters in
Nagorno-Karabakh this month overwhelmingly backed a draft constitution
which describes the territory as a sovereign state.

Over 500,000 Azeris have been displaced from the region since 1994
when it came under the control of Armenian and ethnic Armenian forces

during a war. Since then an uneasy truce has been in place.

Armenia and Azerbaijan are debating the possibility of allowing a
referendum to determine the future status of Nargorno-Karabakh.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

ANKARA: Turkey To Continue Striving For Full EU Membership – Ministe

TURKEY TO CONTINUE STRIVING FOR FULL EU MEMBERSHIP – MINISTER

Anatolia News Agency, Turkey
Dec 21 2006

Ankara, 21 December: "The target of negotiations (between Turkey and
the EU) is full membership," said Turkish Foreign Minister Abdullah
Gul, reaffirming that Turkey will never take a backward step from
this aspiration.

Taking the floor at the parliamentary session at which the new budget
of the Turkish Foreign Ministry was discussed, Gul responded to the
criticisms about Turkey’s relations with the EU and noted, "If the
EU really wants to become an actor in the world, it should be aware
of the contributions Turkey will make."

Gul said these decisions indicate EU’s lack of vision when commenting
on the decision of the union to suspend negotiations with Turkey on
eight chapters.

"We will become a member sooner or later. What is important is that
Turkey should be ready when this day comes," he emphasized.

Gul said, "As the government, we know that the EU is using Cyprus
and Customs Union as pretexts", and noted that Turkey has not made
any concessions of Cyprus.

Fight against terrorism

On the other hand, Gul stated that Turkey attaches importance
to territorial integrity and political unity of Iraq, and drew
attention that deterioration of Iraq’s territorial integrity is an
issue concerning not only Iraq but also the region and the world.

Gul stressed that Turkey is exerting great efforts to eliminate the
terrorist organization PKK [Kurdistan Workers’ Party] in north of Iraq.

"We have not handled fight against terrorism to any other country. We
have the strength to fight till the end and we will do so. If those
countries are our allies, they have to help us. We are doing our best
to prevent a Sunni-Shi’i division," he pointed out.

Armenian allegations

Noting that the Foreign Ministry is working on the Armenian issue
carefully, Gul said, "We will try everything, including judicial and
arbitration methods. We will share all these views with political
parties soon."