Robert Fisk blasts U.S. Mideast policy

Fisk blasts U.S. Mideast policy
By: Tarek M. Baydoun / The Arab American News

Arab American News, MI
Dec 23 2006

Dearborn – Renowned British journalist Robert Fisk visited Dearborn
this week as part of a U.S. tour to promote his latest book. He
was hosted at the University of Michigan-Dearborn for a reception,
speaking engagement and book signing. Fisk, who is known for his
award winning coverage of the Middle East from his post in Beirut,
currently serves as Middle East correspondent for "The Independent,"
a prominent British daily.

Fisk’s visit to Dearborn was sponsored by the Armenian Research
Center, the Armenian National Committee of Michigan and U of M’s
Center for Arab American Studies. He was greeted by a crowd of over
400 attendees from the campus and the Arab and Armenian communities
of Southeast Michigan.

Fisk’s speech focused on the hypocrisy of U.S. and British foreign
policy in the Middle East from an historical perspective. According
to him, the current policy in the Middle East is similar to previous
failed imperialist agendas. He ridiculed the claims that President
Bush and others make about a purported desire to bring democracy to the
Middle East. Fisk said that the people in the Middle East want freedom
more than democracy, primarily freedom from the unjust influences of
American foreign policy and military presence in their region.

On the Iraq war, Fisk blasted the Bush administration and so-called
experts from the Washington-based think tanks for deception and
conspiracy in invading Iraq to occupy the country. He also blasted
American media sources for relying solely on the Washington power
establishment for information when reporting the lead up to the war
and during the ensuing occupation. "We were complacent, we journalists,
in the lead up to the invasion of Iraq,"Fisk said.

On Iran, Fisk blasted the U.S. for hypocrisy on the issue of nuclear
weapons, recalling that when the Shah of Iran announced in the 70s that
Iran would be pursuing nuclear technology including nuclear weapons,
the U.S. was "supportive." When the Islamic Revolution occurred in
Iran, U.S. policy was one of isolation and disaster, arming Saddam
Hussein’s regime in Iraq and providing political support which allowed
Saddam to ravage both countries in an eight-year offensive including
the deployment of biological weapons by Saddam against Iran.

On Palestine, which Fisk said was the central conflict in
the Middle East, U.S. policy has been hypocritical at best he
claimed. As an example, he pointed to the West’s isolation of the
democratically-elected Hamas government. The U.S., he said, has shown
that it will only accept democracy when it is suitable for its own
policy objectives. He challenged the idea that the U.S. can again be
seen as an honest peace broker, because of its unwavering support of
Israel’s policies. Despite this, Fisk rejected the idea that Israel’s
power in Washington is as strong as many claim it is.

Fisk has drawn criticism from Western media figures for his balanced
coverage of events in the Middle East. He has been an eye witness to
many of the conflicts and political events in the region since 1976,
when he began his work in the region.

Fisk has authored several books about the region, the latest of which,
"The Great War for Civilization: The Conquest of the Middle East,"
was available for sale and signing. His books have garnered him
a world-wide following and has helped Fisk establish himself as an
influential and respected scholar on contemporary Middle East politics
and history.

To many in the local community and in the Arab world, Fisk’s coverage
of events in the region is considered a rare case in objectivity and
factual accuracy. Western media coverage of Middle East politics is
more often than not considered biased propaganda by Arabs and Muslims
around the world, but Fisk is widely respected for his objectivity
in covering political developments in the region.

We owe the Armenians

FOREIGN EXCHANGE: We owe the Armenians
-Kalpana Sahni

Daily Times, Pakistan
Dec 23 2006

The Ain-i-Akbari mentions numerous Armenians who had been invited by
Akbar to settle down in Agra. Mariam Zamani Begum, one of Akbar’s
wives was allegedly an Armenian, as were the Chief Justice, Abdul
Hai, the Lady Doctor, Juliana, and several others

Ashot Hindilyan graciously offered to show us around the Armenian
Quarter of old Jerusalem.

"Is your name linked to India?" I asked.

"Naturally, -hindi- Hindilyan. At some point of time my family traded
with India. So much so I am told that I even look like an Indian. Do
I?"

"Y-e-e-s, I guess so. Your nose is definitely not an Armenian
nose…"

A professor at Birzeit University, Dr Hindilyan took us to every nook
and corner of old Jerusalem’s Armenian quarter with its narrow
cobbled streets lined with stone houses, the library, the cemetery.

We witnessed the ancient church service in the 11th century Armenian
Church of St James. As special guests, we were shown some church
treasures. These were cotton block-printed altar curtains depicting
the life of the Holy Family – all made in Madras! One of the most
treasured ones was an enormous block-printed curtain with images of
plants. Below each image was its name in Armenian script. Hindilyan
read out – imli and looked up as if to ask if it made any sense.

"Of course, that’s an imli tree!"

We tried to identify the other plants too. Why anybody would make a
veritable encyclopaedia of South Indian plants for an Armenian
church’s altar curtain is anybody’s guess. Perhaps some Armenian with
a passion for botany had guided the block printers while writing down
the names in Armenian script for them to copy. This particular
altarpiece was made in the 18th century.

Well, this episode spurred my curiosity. I remembered a Mr
Khachaturian who, long long ago, had been my cousin’s landlord in
Bombay. So I started foraging for more information.

We are ignorant about our Armenian links that go back to the second
century. Armenians had once traded in many parts of India and their
settlements were scattered along the coastline: Bombay, Surat,
Madras, Calcutta, and later in Agra, Lucknow, Delhi, Lahore, Gwalior.

Persia’s Shah Abbas encouraged Armenians from Persia in the 17th
century to trade with India. Their numbers swelled and soon they set
up schools in Madras and Calcutta. The first Armenian language
periodical was printed in Madras in 1794 and not in Armenia. It was
the British who gradually forced them out, feeling threatened by
their commercial expertise.

The Ain-i-Akbari mentions numerous Armenians who had been invited by
Akbar to settle down in Agra. Mariam Zamani Begum, one of Akbar’s
wives, was allegedly an Armenian, as were the Chief Justice, Abdul
Hai (in Armenian ‘hai’ means Armenian), the Lady Doctor, Juliana, and
several others.

Some claim that Sarmad, an outstanding Sufi poet of the 17th century,
was an Armenian Jew, while others that he was Armenian Christian. He
arrived in India in 1654 from Kashan in Persia, became a bhikshu, and
later turned to Sufism. Better known as the Naked Sufi, he attracted
followers from all faiths and classes. He wrote in one of his Persian
quatrains, "I obey the Koran. I am a Hindu priest and a monk; I am a
Rabbi Jew, I am an infidel and I am Muslim."

Among his disciples was Dara Shikoh, the prince philosopher and
humanist. Aurangzeb killed both Dara Shikoh and Sarmad. To this day
people lay floral tributes on the grave of Sarmad located near
Delhi’s Jama Masjid.

The Zamzama canon outside the Lahore museum was made in 1761 by an
Armenian gun-maker, Shah Nazar Khan, for Ahmed Shah Durrani, the
Afghan invader of the Punjab. The Sikhs later captured it.

What a lot we owe the Armenians! An Armenian lady doctor opened the
first nursing home in Calcutta; an Armenian conducted the first
archaeological digs. There are so many unsung Armenian heroes in our
history who fought the British alongside us. Colonel Jacob Petrus
commanded Scindia of Gwalior’s Army for 70 years (1780-1850) against
the British. Mesrovb Jacob Seth writes:

"His reputation was so high and he was so respected that the entire
city of Gwalior mourned his death in 1850. Thousands including the
nobility and military attended his funeral, and guns were fired
ninety-five times from the ramparts of the historic Gwalior Fort, to
mark his age."

Then there was the legendary Gorgin Khan, Commander-in-Chief of Mir
Qasim, the Nawab of Bengal’s army, and Movses Manook, a Colonel in
the Nizam of Hyderabad’s Army. The list of Armenian military officers
is long. There were historians too. Tovmas Khojamalyan wrote a
history of India in 1768. It included the period of British rule,
which could provide a very important source of alternative
information, especially in the chapters about the infamous ‘black
hole’ tragedy.

Was this a one-way traffic? Not at all! The 4th century Syrian
historian Zenob Glak mentions that from the 2nd to the 4th century AD
there existed in the Armenian area of Taron, an Indian settlement of
some 15,000 Indians, which prospered for over two hundred years and
consisted of 20 Indian villages. They were wiped out with the coming
of Christianity to Armenia. A Toran village by the name of Hindkastan
existed until the early 20th century as well as other names –
Hindukhanum, Hindubek and Hindumelik.

Dr Kalpana Sahni has been a professor at the Jawaharlal Nehru
University, New Delhi. A doctorate in Russian literature, she has
published extensively on literature and cross-cultural issues. She
can be reached at [email protected]

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Nina Shea Testifies Before Congress on Behalf of Iraq’s Assyrians an

AINA, CA
Assyrian Int’l News Agency
Dec 23 2006

Nina Shea Testifies Before Congress on Behalf of Iraq’s Assyrians and
Other Minorities

(AINA) — The following testimony of Nina Shea, Director Center For
Religious Freedom, was delivered on December 21 Before The US
Congressional Committee On International Relations, Subcommittee On
Africa, Global Human Rights, And International Operations.

Thank you, Mr. Chairman and Members of the Committee, for allowing me
to testify today on behalf of the Center for Religious Freedom.

Chairman Chris Smith has been a dedicated and passionate leader on
human rights for many years, and I wish to commend him for all the
important hearings held under his chairmanship in this subcommittee.

They have held governments around the world accountable, including
our own, and given hope and relief to millions of the world’s
oppressed. This hearing today is no exception.

Egregious religious persecution occurs in North Korea, Saudi Arabia,
China, Vietnam, Eritrea, Iran, Sudan and several other countries
officially designated by the State Department as "Countries of
Particular Concern," and is being addressed by the other witnesses
today. There is an additional country where religious groups of
various faiths face some of the bloodiest persecution in the world
today, a country that is not listed among the CPC’s. It is Iraq, and
it is on this country, and particularly on the persecution faced by
Iraq’s smallest, most vulnerable minorities, that I will direct my
testimony.

We should view Iraq’s smallest religious minorities — the
Christians, Yizidis, Mandeans, Baha’is, Kaka’i and Jews — as we once
did Soviet Jews. The persecution these small minorities face stands
out against even the horrific violence now wracking the rest of the
population. This is demonstrated by the stark statistic that an
estimated half of the members of the small minorities have been
driven from their homes in the past two or three years, either to
other parts of the country or abroad. Their very survival as
communities within Iraq is now threatened by what amounts to ethnic,
or rather cultural, cleansing. The State Department’s Religious
Freedom Reports accurately depicts a defenseless non-Muslim
population that is being pounded by all other factions. Al Qaeda
terrorists, Sunni insurgents, Shiite militias, Kurdish militants, and
criminal gangs all persecute and prey on these small religious
minorities.

Their situation is unique: Their religion and culture identifies them
with the "infidel occupiers" in the minds of the extremists, and
lacking the militias, tribal structures and foreign champions of
Iraq’s other groups, they are singularly defenseless against the
mayhem that has followed the occupation. Because they do not govern
any department, they are at the tender mercies of those dominant
groups who aim to take their property, businesses and villages. The
United States has a great moral responsibility to address their
plight, and specific policy actions are required to help them. These
policies will differ from the efforts we once took on behalf of
Soviet Jews. Most of these small minority people do not wish to leave
Iraq. We must expeditiously take actions that will maximize their
security within Iraq, and will draw back some of those who have taken
temporary shelter in other surrounding countries. For the most
desperate among them, we must begin to resettle them here, where
many, if not most, already have relatives who are well established.

While Shiites and Sunnis, who comprise Iraq’s religious majority,
also face appalling levels of extremist violence, sectarian strife,
and official discrimination on account of their religions, it is the
plight of Iraq’s small religious minorities on which I will focus
today both because the situation confronting these peoples threatens
their very survival, and because their situation is not being
sufficiently addressed by U.S. policy and was all but ignored in the
recent Iraq Study Group Report. The very fact of their
defenselessness — they are persecuted and killed, but do not
themselves persecute and kill — contributes to the inverse
relationship between their suffering and the world apathy at their
situation.

Iraq’s small religious groups — Christians (Chaldean, who are
Eastern rite Catholics Assyrian, including the Church of the East,
Syriac, who are Eastern Orthodox, Armenians, both Roman Catholic and
Orthodox, and Protestants, who are Anglican, Presbyterian, Baptist,
evangelical and others), Mandeans (followers of John the Baptist),
Yizidis (an ancient angel religion), Bahais, Kaka’i (a syncretic
group around Kirkuk) and Jews, together number an estimated one
million of Iraq’s population of 26 million at the fall of Saddam
Hussein’s regime. The largest group of these is Christian, the next
largest is the Yizidis with about 70,000-500,000 and the Mandeans
with about 6,000-10,000, and the smallest, the Jewish community,
whose numbers had dwindled to the double-digits by 2003. Under
escalating persecution and violence, these groups are fleeing their
homeland en masse. Though they constitute some 3 or 4 per cent of
Iraq’s population, according to the UNHCR, they represent about 40
per cent of the refugee population. This disproportionate exodus
attests to the intolerable treatment and conditions they face inside
Iraq. We have also received reports that an estimated half of the
Christians who remain in Iraq are internally displaced, with those
from the south moving to the north of the country for relative
security.

The UNHCR has determined that they are being targeted for their
religion by militants determined to establish an extreme sharia ruled
state. Because they speak Western languages and have cultural ties to
the West, they have also been targeted for perceived or real
cooperation with the US embassy and the Coalition.

In 2004 a dozen churches were attacked in coordinated bombings and
other similar incidents have followed. Since July 2006 alone, seven
clergymen have been kidnapped and two of them, both from Mosul,
murdered. As the State Department notes, these religious groups can
no longer gather in safety and many have stopped holding worship
services altogether. My friend, the Chaldean Archbishop of Basra, who
says his prayers in the language of Jesus, Aramaic, as is the
Chaldean tradition, has been transferred apparently for security
reasons to the diocese of Australia and New Zealand, and his Basra
diocese now has only a couple of hundred families remaining. These
churches are not just lying low, they are being eradicated.

Christian, Mandean and other women in some areas are being violently
pressured to conform to supposed Islamic conduct and dress, with some
killed or maimed, while men who operate liquor stores and cinemas
have also been violently attacked by extremists. Flyers were posted
at Mosul University this month declaring: "in cases where non-Muslims
do not conform to wearing the Hijab (woman’s head cover) and are not
conservative with their attire in accordance with the Islamic way,
the violators will have the Sharia and the Islamic law applied to
them." It was in Mosul that some female students were murdered for
wearing Western clothes and having a picnic with men in 2005 and
where Orthodox priest Fr. Paulis Iskander was beheaded and
dismembered on October 11.

Some of the death threats against non-Muslim minorities have been
personal and some of these have been collected and translated, such
as the samples that follow that were provided to the Center for
Religious Freedom by the Chaldean Federation of America.:

"To the traitor, apostate Amir XX, after we warned you more than once
to quit working with the American occupiers, but you did not learn
from what happened to others, and you continued, you and your infidel
wife XXX by opening a women hair cutting place and this is among the
forbidden things for us, and therefore we are telling you and your
wife to quit these deeds and to pay the amount of (20,000) thousand
dollars in protective tax for your violation and within only one week
or we will kill you and your family, member by member, and those who
have warned are excused. Al-Mujahideen Battalions."

"You traitor, Amjad,
We can behead the traitor and we are ready for that.

We can chase the infidels and renegades and everybody who deals with
them and with the occupiers and punish them according to Islam law,
‘The unjust have no supporters’ Allah is the most honest,
The Islamic Army in Iraq."

"This is the last warning~E to the American nasty crusader agent
(James). Our battalion will execute you by cutting your head and
blowing up your house. Allah willing. Our battalions will pursue the
snakehead your brother (Talia). We will arrest him wherever he is —
God willing.

Copy to the battalion Commander the Mudjahed
Abu Sayyaf and the Commander Abu Therr"

There are many other such examples — and many cases of targeted
killings backing them up. Grisly reports of kidnapped Christian
children being crucified and mutilated after ransoms were not paid
have emerged this fall from the ChaldoAssyrian community. Numerous
cases are also reported by the Assyrian International News Agency on
its website,

This week, I received a letter from the Sabean Mandean Association in
Australia that detailed the cases of Mandeans kidnapped and
assassinated for their religion this past year. Some of the
kidnap-for-ransom victims were reportedly circumcised before being
released, a detail that indicates religion played a role in the
crime.

Listed among the cases was the murder on December 2 of the Rev. Taleb
Salman Araby, the deacon who assisted His Holiness Ganzevra Sattar
Jabbar Hilo al-Zahrony, the worldwide head of the Mandean Community.

He was easily recognizable because he wore the white rasta robes of
the Mandean clergy. His family was prevented from holding a funeral
service for him by extremists who threatened to blow up their house
and the bereaved family was forced to bury him without any religious
ceremony.

Furthermore, such violence against Christians and members of the
smallest minorities is conducted with impunity. In northern Iraq and
in the Nineveh Plains region where up to a third of the small
minorities live, there have been no local police forces established
unlike other areas in Iraq, and the few forces that are provided to
Christian and minority areas from elsewhere have been known to harass
and prey on these small minorities. There are reports that the
judiciary discriminates against Christians and other small
minorities. The Washington-based Iraq Sustainable Democracy Project,
for example, reports that courts in the Kurdish area discriminate
against Assyrians who contest land and property confiscated by
Kurdish militants.

The Project also reports that in the Kurdish areas, Christian and
other small minority towns have not benefited equally from U.S.

reconstruction and development aid; their villages have been excluded
by provincial-level officials from benefiting from water and
electrical systems and denied their fair share of other utilities and
services, such as schools and medical facilities, provided by U.S.

aid. Apparently the US has no safeguards or checks in place to
prevent this. As an Assyrian mayor of one of these towns, Telhaif,
told me in November, such discrimination and marginalization is
making minority towns and neighborhoods uninhabitable and forcing
their residents out. According to detailed reports, once abandoned,
Christian, Yizidi and Mandean properties have been seized by Kurdish
authorities. Such treatment has given rise to charges that Kurdish
authorities are carrying out ethnic cleansing against Christians and
smaller minorities, including other ethnic minorities, such as the
Shabaks and Turkomen.

Government leaders in Iraq have been largely indifferent to the
victimization of the small minorities. The Speaker of the Iraqi
Parliament, Mahmoud al-Mashhadani, was quoted earlier this year
urging kidnappers to target Christian women instead of Muslims. After
addressing the kidnapping of his own sister, Thayseer, the Speaker of
the Iraqi National Assembly was broadcast by al-Iraqiya Satellite
Television as stating: "Why kidnap this Muslim woman; instead of
Thayseer, why not kidnap Margaret or Jean?" The latter are Christian
names, thus implying that it would have been better for a Christian
woman to have been kidnapped, raped and killed.

The United States Government urgently needs to take effective
measures to help the most vulnerable of Iraq’s religious groups. The
US owes a special obligation to these peoples because their
non-Muslim status associates them with the American occupation in the
minds of Islamist extremists. Furthermore, they alone are
defenseless, lacking militias, social structures and governing
authority. Such measures should include actions that would help these
peoples, who have maintained a presence in Iraq for thousands of
years, to survive inside Iraq, as well as actions that would help the
most desperate among them find sanctuary abroad. All such measures
should be expeditiously implemented. They are:

Appoint a Special Aid Coordinator for Iraq as recommended by the Iraq
Study Group. This post could prove to be very helpful in sustaining
Christian and small minority communities, particularly those in
northern Iraq that are being now marginalized.

Provide emergency relief for Internally Displaced Persons inside
Iraq. Ensure that this aid reaches the needy Christians, and other
small minorities now amassing in northern areas of Iraq.

Ensure that US reconstruction aid and development assistance is
equitably distributed to Christian, Yizidi, Mandean and other small
minority communities, including the ethnic minorities, the Shabaks
and Turkomen, particularly in northern Kurdish areas where many are
now fleeing from other parts of Iraq and where the US carries much
influence. Legitimate, independent, local leadership of these
minority communities should be consulted about the reconstruction
priorities of their communities. Kurdish authorities must not be
allowed to use US aid to ethnically cleanse northern Iraq.

Support the establishment of a new autonomous district that would be
jointly governed by ChaldoAssyrian Christians, Shabaks (an ethnic
minority with Shiite roots), Yizidis and other small minorities in
the Nineveh Plains, an initiative provided for under article 125 of
Iraq’s Constitution.

Support the formation of police forces drawn from the local minority
populations for Christian and small minority areas in the Nineveh
Plains, as consistent with a decision of the Iraqi National Assembly
and implemented elsewhere in Iraq.

Use more effective diplomacy with Iraqi leaders, particularly Kurdish
leaders, to insist on the protection and equitable treatment of small
religious minorities.

Resettle in the United States the most vulnerable members of the
Christian and other smallest minorities. This group includes those
orphaned, widowed, and maimed by targeted violence. There are over
thousands of such refugees who seek to join relatives already in the
US. Last year the US admitted a mere 198 refugees from Iraq, and is
already authorized to admit up to 20,000. The US must provide funding
to the UNHCR for the processing of such people and admit greater
numbers.

Many other steps could be taken as well. While no group is spared
suffering in Iraq, the smallest minorities are defenseless and the
most vulnerable. In addition, they are viewed as collaborators of
American occupiers by extremists. Today these Iraqi Christian
ChaldoAssyrians, Yizidis, Mandeans, and others are comparable to
yesteryear’s Soviet Jews. They need our help to survive egregious and
pervasive religious persecution and discrimination. The State
Department’s Religious Freedom Reports describes much of their
suffering, but U.S. policy in their regard has been lacking.

Thank you, Mr. Chairman. This concludes my testimony.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

www.aina.org.

How can the Arab Christians survive?

The Daily Star – Lebanon
Dec 23 2006

How can the Arab Christians survive?

By Rami G. Khouri
Daily Star staff
Saturday, December 23, 2006

"A commandment of love" was the theme that the Latin patriarch of
Jerusalem, Michel Sabbah, stressed when I asked him last week about
what Arab Christians should be doing to address the many challenges
and threats in the Middle East today. I was especially interested in
the role of Arab Christians because their plight is highlighted this
Christmas week, even as a delegation of United Kingdom church leaders
makes a timely Holy Land pilgrimage.

Christians experience the same pressures and challenges as the
majority Muslim population living under Israeli occupation, the
assault of Western armies, or the incompetent, autocratic
mismanagement of their own Arab political leaders. A strangled
Bethlehem, though, is likely to catch the attention of Western
citizens and church leaders more than a stressed Alexandria, Aleppo
or Casablanca. The four British pilgrims are the archbishop of
Canterbury, Rowan Williams; the archbishop of Westminster, Cardinal
Cormac Murphy-O’Connor; the moderator of the Free Churches, the
Reverend David Coffey; and the primate of the Armenian Church of
Great Britain, Bishop Nathan Hovhannisian.

The focal point of their four-day visit is a pilgrimage to the Church
of the Nativity in Bethlehem. Their trip and witness will help
Christians and other people of good faith around the world better
appreciate the impact of the Israeli occupation on all Palestinians,
including Christian communities.

Sabbah welcomed the pilgrimage and noted that, "at a time when our
communities in the two Holy cities of Jerusalem and Bethlehem are
separated by a wall and checkpoints, the visit of the churches’
ecumenical delegation is a reminder to us, to the Israelis and the
Palestinians, and to the world, that the pilgrims’ path of hope and
love must remain open."

Hope and love stand in sharp contrast to the Israeli colonization and
control policies in and around Bethlehem that have shattered the
physical, spiritual and economic integrity of the community, by
cutting off the built-up areas from thousands of hectares of
agricultural land and water resources. The main culprits are Israel’s
separation wall to fence in the Palestinians, and an associated
system of smaller cement walls, 27 Israeli settlements, and a network
of electric fences and apartheid-like "Jewish settlers-only" roads
and checkpoints, almost all built on land confiscated from
Bethlehem’s private owners. The result is a prison-like environment
for the people of Bethlehem, 70 percent of whom now live below the
poverty line. After Israel’s attacks and reoccupation of Bethlehem in
2001 and 2002, some 3,000 Christians emigrated, representing 10
percent of the local Christian population.

Leila Sansour, the Palestinian chief executive of the Open Bethlehem
project that works to preserve the city’s physical, spiritual,
demographic and economic integrity, wrote last week: "A UN report
into Christianity in Bethlehem predicts that our community will not
survive another two generations. We live from pilgrimages, and our
city is closed. We have traditionally stored our wealth in land, and
our land behind the wall has been seized. Our lives are intimately
bound up, economically and socially, with the Christian community in
Jerusalem, yet we are forbidden to enter that city, which lies only
20 minutes away."

When I met with Sabbah in Larnaca, Cyprus, last week, I asked him if
he saw a particular role that Arab Christians could and should play.
His reply was clear, and challenging: "My vision is that we
Christians, whatever are our numbers, are Christians in and for our
society, which is a Muslim Arab society. Christians have something
specific to give as Christians, because of their belief in Jesus
Christ and all the values that Jesus Christ taught us. This is an
obligation. Our commandment is a commandment of love, and it is shows
the way to build a society. Christian love is about accepting the
other or not accepting him. It is about building with the other or
refusing to build with him. All the Christian Arabs can bring to Arab
society this love as a power of cohesion within the society … to
love themselves and show how to live together with the Muslims who
are the majority in these societies."

He went on to say: "There must be a broad project, a social,
economic, political project so that people together can see how they
can prepare a country and homeland, and enrich every citizen so that
he or she feels at home, content and secure, without any fear of the
other. All citizens must have the same place and opportunities in
terms of their social and political rights."

In replying to a question of mine about whether Arab Christians could
play a role as bridges to the West, he answered: "We Christians can
be a true bridge through all the churches that are present in the
world. All of us together can have an impact. We have an obligation
to understand Islam for what it is, therefore we have the obligation
even to have alliances with Muslims, in order to build a new type of
society, and bring this as a model of coexistence to the West."

Love, indeed, seems worth a try. In that spirit, I say Merry
Christmas to all, and early Eid al-Adha and Happy Hanukkah wishes to
my Muslim and Jewish brothers and sisters, hoping that all of us
together will respond to Michel Sabbah’s call for an ideology of love
to replace this time of war.

Rami G. Khouri writes a regular commentary for THE DAILY STAR.

http://www.dailystar.com.lb

Bethlehem stands as a reminder of religious turmoil

The Record (Kitchener-Waterloo, Ontario)Canada
December 23, 2006 Saturday
Final Edition

Bethlehem stands as a reminder of religious turmoil

by WILLIAM CHRISTIAN

It’s only about six miles from the centre of Jerusalem to Bethlehem,
a much shorter distance than I thought.

I had an Israeli driver for this trip, since the route took us south
through the leafy, prosperous Jewish suburbs of the city, where a
driver with Palestinian plates would have been made distinctly
unwelcome by the authorities.

For my trip to East Jerusalem, the hotel was careful to order a car
with a Palestinian driver, since anyone with Israeli plates claimed
to feel unwelcome in those areas.

Most of West Jerusalem was built after 1949 and looks much like any
North American city. Before we went to Bethlehem my driver wanted to
show me his house, part of a series of row houses that overlooked the
Church of the Nativity. In April 2002 Palestinian insurrectionists
seized the church and held it for 38 days.

He pointed to the bullet holes on the front of the building and told
me of the evening when a bullet from the church came close to killing
him as he parked his car on his way home from work. Since he was
unwilling to take tourists into Bethlehem, a town controlled by the
Palestinian authority, he had a system arranged with a colleague, a
Maronite Christian. He phoned him on his cellphone and we met at a
pre-set point, where I switched cars.

Bethlehem is a very uninviting city. Its population is about 60,000
and it has the feel of some of the small cities in the rust belt
around Detroit. Once prosperous, it has fallen on hard times.

It has an educated, skilled, motivated workforce with nothing to do,
and nowhere to sell their goods, if they produced them.

There were some quite nice shops on the main street, with an
especially appealing one dealing in textiles by Palestinian women. I
liked the textiles and I was even happier that the proceeds were
going where they were very much needed.

There are only two serious reasons for going to see the Church of the
Nativity. First, if you genuinely believe, as some people do, that
this is literally the spot where the Christ Child was born. For you
this would be a genuinely holy place.

If you are among the somewhat smaller number of people interested in
early Christian church architecture, this edifice, which was started
after 529, is the place for you. (But you already knew that.)

Otherwise, you’re going to be disappointed by how run down the church
is, and how unprepossessing the setting is.

The church is in the care of the Armenian, Roman Catholic and Greek
Orthodox churches. When I was in the Grotto of the Nativity, an
Armenian bishop was conducting a choral mass. The chanting resonated
in its narrow confines. The experience was very moving — which is
what my guide said I should be doing, rather than dawdling around
buying textiles and listening to lengthy masses when he was being
paid by the job.

So I went to the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, first built in 330 by
the mother of the Emperor Constantine to mark the tomb of Christ’s
burial.

In the fine tradition of peace and understanding that has governed
the Middle East since time immemorial, the Persians destroyed it in
614.

It was promptly rebuilt, but the Egyptians hacked it down to bedrock
in 1009. Christian crusaders rebuilt it, and it remains largely a
crusader church.

Control over the church has historically been the source of
considerable dissension. In 1852, Turkish authorities had to
intervene and impose order on the disputatious Christian sects,
giving primary control to Orthodox, Armenian Apostolic, and Roman
Catholic overseers.

Later, the Coptic, Ethiopian, and Syrian Orthodox churches were also
conceded parts of the church, but since all the good parts had been
taken, the Coptic and Ethiopian Orthodox churches have so far not
sorted out rights over the Chapel of the Ethiopians, which is
basically the roof over one of the interior chapels.

So, if visitors wonder what people are doing up on the roof, they’re
protecting their turf. In fact, in 2002, on one hot summer day, when
a Coptic monk moved his chair into the shade, the Ethiopians
interpreted this as aggression. The ensuing battle to remove him put
11 in hospital.

Christians, Muslims, Jews. We worship the same God, but we’re
human-all-too-human.

It’s at this time of the year that Christians especially need to take
a few moments to reflect that a child born in occupied Bethlehem has
made the world, if not perfect, at least better than it otherwise
would have been.

William Christian is a professor of political science at the
University of Guelph.

Skinheads may be behind blast aimed at Armenians in Moscow

SKINHEADS MAY BE BEHIND BLAST AIMED AGAINST ARMENIANS IN MOSCOW

Ekho Moskvy radio, Moscow
Dec 23 2006

[Presenter] An explosion in a block of flats in Lyublinskaya Street
in Moscow which occurred yesterday [22 December] may have been
carried out by skinheads. Anyway, this is a preliminary theory of
investigators. Our correspondent Tikhon Zyatko has the details.

[Correspondent] A blast at 157 Lyublinskaya Street in Moscow went off
at about 1900 [1600 gmt]. As a result, four policemen and a sniffer
dog were hurt. A prosecutor’s office brought criminal proceedings
into the incident under the clause [of the Russian Criminal Code]
dealing with hooliganism committed in a socially dangerous way.

However, this case may be reclassified.

According to the investigators’ preliminary theory, this incident is
a fresh attack against foreigners staged by skinheads, the newspaper
Komsomolskaya Pravda said. An improvised explosive device was fixed
outside the flat of Armine Babadzhanyan who found the bomb. When she
came home with her son Tigran, she saw swastika drawn on the wall.

Next to it, on a radiator, she saw a sheet with an insulting text
written on it. The woman wanted to remove the sheet but noticed wires
connecting it to a glass jar filled with white powder. Swastika was
also drawn on the jar. After that, she called police.

[Presenter] The same group of investigators who deal with the
explosion at the Cherkizovskiy market [in Moscow] organized by
nationalists, is investigating the blast in the block of flats in
Lyublinskaya Street.

Armenians hand over captive Azeri soldier

ARMENIANS HAND OVER CAPTIVE AZERI SOLDIER – AGENCY

Mediamax News Agency, Armenia
Dec 23 2006

Yerevan, 23 December: The authorities of the Nagornyy Karabakh
republic handed a private of the Azerbaijani army, Vusal Qaracayev,
18, over to Azerbaijan at 1255 [0855 gmt] today.

Representatives of the International Committee of the Red Cross
participated in the handover, which took place near the village of
Bas Qarvand in Agdam District, Nagornyy Karabakh’s state commission
on POWs, hostages and missing persons told Mediamax.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

BAKU: Democratic polls essential for progress on Karabakh – Azeri ex

DEMOCRATIC POLLS ESSENTIAL FOR PROGRESS ON KARABAKH – AZERI EXPERT

Day.az, Azerbaijan
Dec 18 2006

Azerbaijani expert Eldar Namazov has said that the best way to settle
the Nagornyy Karabakh conflict lies through democratic elections in
Azerbaijan and Armenia. In his exclusive interview with the Azerbaijani
website Day.az, he said that democratic elections are essential
because their end result will be a government that will be able freely
to manoeuvre politically for a settlement of the Nagornyy Karabakh
conflict and will be free from outside pressures. The following is the
text of M. Arzu’s report by Azerbaijani website Day.az on 18 December
headlined "Eldar Namazov: The Armenian president’s statement implies
the beginning of a two-year delay in the Karabakh settlement":

Azerbaijani political expert Eldar Namazov has granted an exclusive
interview with Day.az.

[Correspondent] Armenian President Robert Kocharyan has recently
said that he has decided to slow down negotiations over a Karabakh
settlement until after parliamentary elections in May 2007 because
he does not want the process to become a hostage to the election
campaign. What do you think is really behind this decision?

Kocharyan’s statement not surprising

[Namazov] In actual fact, this announcement should not really surprise
anybody since it has been known for some time that the election
campaign is a major influence on the negotiating process.

The practice of putting a freeze on the negotiations in this respect
is not a new one, and therefore, it is no coincidence that the OSCE
Minsk Group has insisted that a breakthrough be made when there are
no elections taking place in either Armenia or Azerbaijan. So it
is natural that the negotiating process should be on hold during an
election campaign. It is another thing that the leadership of Armenia
and Azerbaijan have not spoken openly about this to their people – it
was more of a gentlemen’s agreement between the two sides. Now it is
just that Kocharyan is the first to say this openly. In other words,
everything is proceeding as one might have predicted, and there is
nothing surprising in the president’s announcement.

Change of regime to facilitate conflict settlement

[Correspondent] Accordingly, one will have to wait for the next moves
in the Karabakh settlement until after 2008 when the presidential
elections in Azerbaijan and Armenia are over?

[Namazov] Yes, and international observers had warned of exactly that,
calling on the parties to show the political will for a breakthrough,
to take advantage of a realistic window for a breakthrough in 2006
and not to put off a decision for such a length of time. Furthermore,
any realistic moves towards a resolution of the conflict will be
possible only if in Azerbaijan and Armenia there are honest and open
elections, the result of which will be the formation of a government
whose actions really will have the support of its people.

At present, the existing governments of the two countries are simply
going through the motions of a negotiation process.

[Correspondent] In other words, a change of regime in Azerbaijan and
Armenia is a necessary condition for the conflict to be resolved?

[Namazov] I would say that it would make negotiations a little
easier. Although it is clear form history that even the most
authoritarian regimes can come to some agreement and fulfil its
conditions. A major factor in all of this is the following: how much
is the international community interested in putting pressure on the
parties to the conflict in order to make them come to a compromise?

Therefore, when I say that democratic elections are essential I mean
that the end result will not just be the election of a government
with the backing of a popular majority, but a government that will be
able freely to manoeuvre politically for a settlement of the Nagornyy
Karabakh conflict and will be free from outside pressures. It is well
known that in the case of a falsified election there is an element of
pressure and certain forces start saying that they will turn a blind
eye to electoral violations, but in return demanding something back
on certain issues. That is why the best way to settle the conflict,
in my opinion, lies through democratic elections.

Autonomy for Karabakh

[Correspondent] How expedient would it be for us to allow another
two years for the separatist regime in Nagornyy Karabakh to exist,
which has in any case been the unrecognized but de facto regime for
more than fifteen years?

[Namazov] In this instance, we are choosing between the lesser of two
evils, for the alternative to negotiations would be military means
which, in my view, is not at present the best way to resolve the
problem. It is possible that with time we will be forced to revisit
the military option, but for now there is a chance to use peaceful
means, and we should take it.

[Correspondent] Some observers consider Baku to be at fault in talking
about its readiness to allow the Armenians of Nagornyy Karabakh as
much autonomy as possible, but not doing anything concrete towards
this idea. What is your opinion?

[Namazov] The level of autonomy of which the president of Azerbaijan
has been talking is predicated on the population of Nagornyy Karabakh
actually being given great freedoms in a wide variety of areas,
including culture, education, welfare and so on. Of course, there are
far-reaching principles concerning our sovereignty that one cannot
ignore. In particular, one thinks of foreign and defence policy,
and law. In other areas the population of Nagornyy Karabakh must be
given freedoms as understood in democratic Europe.

Kocharyan has no room for manoeuvre

[Correspondent] Where do you stand regarding the view that it is
in principle impossible to reach a just resolution of the conflict
with Kocharyan because he took part in the occupation of Azerbaijani
territory?

[Namazov] In answering that, I would like to take as an example two
Armenian politicians: Kocharyan himself and his predecessor Levon
Ter-Petrosyan. Both are considered initiators of moves to split off
part of Azerbaijani territory – one in Karabakh, the other in Armenia –
who came to power because of events in Karabakh.

This notwithstanding, Ter-Petrosyan was ready to find a compromise
and that was exactly why he lost power, making way for Kocharyan. It
is true that the current president has taken a hard line on the issue,
which is understandable coming from someone who overthrew Ter-Petrosyan
on the issue of not agreeing to a staged resolution to the conflict –
he has boxed himself into a hardline position.

Even if Kocharyan himself admits the need for a staged resolution as
do the OSCE, the international community and even a pragmatic section
of Armenian public opinion, it would be difficult for him to bring it
about from a political and psychological point of view. Such a change
of stance would threaten him with a public backlash as Armenians would
ask, why have we been groping around in the dark all this time when
we could have had a solution eight years ago?

In short, Kocharyan has left himself with no room for manoeuvre
and will maintain his position until 2008, the end of his term and
president. So I agree with the view that a compromise is impossible
while Kocharyan is in power.

[Correspondent] Could the situation improve if Defence Minister
Serzh Sarkisyan, considered the most likely successor to Kocharyan,
came to power?

I don’t believe that we need to think about the next elections for the
time being. The elections are a matter for the Armenian people, who
in 2008 will not just have to choose a candidate but also a position
on the Karabakh question. The future of Armenia depends on whether
it will live in peace with its neighbours or continue to teeter on
the edge of war with them as before. On this depends the path of the
country and of the region as a whole.

Armenian aide condemns "aggressive" statement by Aliyev

ARMENIAN AIDE CONDEMNS "AGGRESSIVE" STATEMENT BY AZERI PRESIDENT

Mediamax News Agency, Armenia
Dec 22 2006

Yerevan, 22 December: The press secretary of the Armenian president,
Viktor Sogomonyan, said in Yerevan today that aggressive statements
by Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev are "a specific way of
self-assertion and compensation for his lack of confidence".

The Armenian president’s press secretary said this while commenting at
the request of Mediamax on yesterday’s speech made by Ilham Aliyev
in which he described as "provocative" [Armenian President] Robert
Kocharyan’s statement that the negotiations on the settlement of the
Karabakh conflict will not be active until the parliamentary elections
in Armenia end.

"We are used to the fact that public speeches by the Azerbaijani
president regarding the settlement of the Karabakh conflict are
noted for their aggressiveness. Most likely, it is a specific way of
self-assertion and compensation of his lack of confidence.

"The statements made by Mr. Aliyev in Naxcivan were also tactless. We
regret that the Azerbaijani president, who inherited his post from
his father, did not inherit his wisdom. It is not the presidents’
business to bandy words with each other," Viktor Sogomonyan said in
an interview with Mediamax.

BAKU: Azeri president talks tough on Russia gas, Nagorno Karabakh

AZERI PRESIDENT TALKS TOUGH ON RUSSIAN GAS, NAGORNYY KARABAKH

Ekho Moskvy radio, Moscow
Dec 23 2006

Azeri President Ilham Aliyev has said Azerbaijan may reduce or cut
gas imports from Russia completely in response to increased prices
and vowed not to give in to "commercial blackmail". In an interview
with Russian Ekho Moskvy radio on 23 December, Aliyev also said
Azerbaijan intended to strengthen its economy and its army to counter
Armenia over Nagornyy Karabakh, played down the significance of the
CIS and voiced opposition to the imposition of sanctions against Iran
over its nuclear programme.

Right to refuse gas price

Aliyev said Gazprom’s insistence on a higher price for gas delivered
to Azerbaijan ran counter to the spirit of relations between the two
countries.

He said an Azeri delegation had come to Moscow for talks at Gazprom’s
invitation.

"Talks have already been taking place for quite a long time, but,
unfortunately, without success, since the positive level and baggage
of mutually-advantageous cooperation between Gazprom and the [State]
Oil Company of Azerbaijan is melting away through no fault of our
own."

"When suddenly the price goes up to 230 and at the last moment to 235
[dollars per thousand cubic metres of gas], one of course feels a
complete dissonance between such an approach and the spirit, nature
and essence of Russian-Azeri relations. And this is a matter of
regret because our relations are shaping up very positively and very
constructively, and embrace far broader spheres than merely energy.

"As far as energy is concerned, and particularly gas, it would
undoubtedly be more logical and reasonable in the future to seek
points of contact for joint activities, for joint projects, instead
of trying unilaterally to increase the price and in some measure to
force Azerbaijan into something. That is impossible. Azerbaijan is no
longer the kind of state that can be forced into anything."

Aliyev said it was Gazprom’s right to set its price, "just as it is
our right to refuse". "We are now considering our options: either to
reduce it or to do without it altogether."

Wider use of fuel oil

Aliyev said a greater reliance on fuel oil would be one way out for
Azerbaijan in response to the Gazprom price hike.

"This year our oil output was 30m tonnes, while our domestic
requirement is 6m. So there is no problem there. Gas output was
something like 4.5-5 [billion cu.m.], against a domestic requirement
for 10. So we have a shortage. And it is not nice to take advantage
of this shortage. We would never behave like that. Where are we going
to get it? We have nowhere to get it from. So we need to change our
energy equation and switch from fuel oil plus gas to fuel oil alone.

It is clear what it will lead to: we shall be compelled to reduce the
transportation of Azeri oil to the port of Novorossiysk. We have no
other way out. Our power stations need to be fuelled by something. If
it’s not gas, it has to be fuel oil. And where to get the fuel oil
from? Only by processing oil. And where can we get it from? From the
Baku-Novorossiysk pipe."

Aliyev said he could not allow Azerbaijan to be subjected to what he
described as "commercial blackmail".

"I have decided to find a way out of the situation with minimum
losses for Azerbaijan, and at the same time with dignity. I cannot
allow Azerbaijan to be turned into a country subject to elements of
commercial blackmail. I cannot allow that to happen."

No gas deliveries to Georgia

The Azeri leader denied Azerbaijan was delivering gas to Georgia.

"We do not supply gas to Georgia. We buy gas. This year we bought
4.5bn cubic metres. And, according to information and statements from
the most senior Russian leaders, we were the only country with which
Russia had no debt problems."

He said he could not rule out a political dimension to the gas price
issue.

"So, overall, I would not politicize the issue, although it is of
course impossible to rule out a political subtext. But it would also
be wrong to reduce the significance of the existence of the CIS to
cheap gas."

Little benefit from CIS

Asked what membership of the CIS meant for Azerbaijan, Aliyev denied
there was any benefit from membership other than providing a forum
for bilateral talks.

"We construct our relations with CIS members on a bilateral basis. In
the energy context, the projects that we implement with our
neighbours are outside the framework of the CIS. In terms of
political contacts, we also have good relations with practically all
CIS countries within the framework of bilateral relations. So from
the practical point of view, it gives us nothing. It is a good format
for meetings, for holding talks."

He went on: "So it [CIS] should not be demonized, nor should one
expect too much from it."

GUAM and Nagornyy Karabakh

Aliyev said the GUAM regional alliance of Georgia, Ukraine,
Azerbaijan and Moldova provided a "fairly productive" format and
noted that Armenia was the only country with which Azerbaijan had
difficulties.

"I believe the organization should not be against anything. By the
way, I think Azerbaijan’s membership of the organization is a
positive factor. Basically, we do not take part in any campaigns
against someone. We have a problem with Armenia, a country that has
occupied our territories. We are combating them and shall continue to
combat them using all ways and means along a broad front: economic,
political, military, humanitarian, propaganda, and in every other
way. But we have no problems with other countries. "

The Azeri president said GUAM had provided a platform for dealing
with separatist conflicts in a single format.

"We managed in the context of GUAM to unite all the separatist
conflicts into one format for the first time. It was not so before.

Previously, for some reason, and particularly in the West, it was
believed that Abkhazia, [South] Ossetia and the Dniester region had
separatism, while in Nagornyy Karabakh it was some sort of liberation
movement, even though the essence is the same: aggressive
separatism."

Aliyev said a thriving economy and a strong army were essential to
counter Armenia over Nagornyy Karabakh, which he predicted would
never be recognized as independent.

"We must be strong, we must strengthen the economy, we must
strengthen the army, we must be more active on the diplomatic front.

We must become a much more important country than Armenia, and are
already becoming one. With our importance, with our potential and
with our projects we must outweigh the Armenian lobby."

"No-one will ever recognize Nagornyy Karabakh as an independent
state. No-one needs a country with a population of 60,000. And,
without, primarily, the will of Azerbaijan this is impossible. And we
shall never agree to it. The main thing the Armenian leadership
should realize is that this will never happen. Beyond this, within
the framework of territorial integrity, of course solutions can be
reached."

Military spending

Aliyev recalled that two years ago he had set the task of bringing
Azeri military spending up to the level of the entire Armenian
budget.

"I am accustomed to keeping my word. And I have kept it, bringing the
army budget into line with the budget of Armenia. And that is not the
limit. It will be surpassed."

Asked about whether Azerbaijan would buy arms from the USA, Aliyev
replied: "I don’t think they will sell us any."

NATO membership

Aliyev played down a possible Azeri bid for NATO membership: "Entry
into any organization is a two-way process. Does the organization
want you to join or not? To bang on the door, to seek entry, to ask
and to plead are not in my nature. And the same applies to the EU. "

Sanctions against Iran

Asked how Azerbaijan would vote on Iran sanctions if it were a member
of the UN Security Council, he said Azerbaijan "would be
unequivocally against any sanctions".

"The development of nuclear technologies is not prohibited. Isn’t
that so? All countries have the right. There is the International
Atomic Energy Agency, there is international control. Is there
evidence today that Iran is preparing a nuclear bomb? We have no such
evidence. Do international experts have such evidence? It is all
based on assumptions. But we have recently seen what such assumptions
lead to – mistakes. So to punish a country because it wants to
develop nuclear technology – why are others allowed to and they are
not? A principle is being breached. Perhaps there are some people who
do not like it. That’s for sure. Perhaps some people feel concern or
danger. All right, then the issue has to be discussed, work needs to
be done, cooperation carried out. But to say they can’t go ahead or
there will be sanctions will lead to nothing. Believe me. "

Caspian

Aliyev also talked about ethnic Azeris and Azeri migrants in Russia
and regretted that "certain circles are trying to earn political
capital from nationalism". He gave an assurance that ethnic
minorities were treated well in Azerbaijan.

Aliyev expressed condolences over the death of President Saparmyrat
Nyyazow of Turkmenistan. He noted that "fairly intensive"
negotiations with Iran on the demarcation of the Caspian were under
way, while the border with Russia and Kazakhstan had already been
determined. But he noted that with Turkmenistan there were
differences of view on Caspian delimitation.

[The interviewers in the studio were Aleksey Venediktov and Nargiz
Asadova, and the interview lasted 53 minutes.]