Boston Globe – Holocust & Genecoide deniers

Getting at the truth
By Charles Fried

December 13, 2006
The Boston Globe CHARLES FRIED

MAHMOUD AHMADINEJAD, the egregious president of Iran, is hosting a
conference this week on whether the Holocaust really happened. There
are serious questions that someone with Ahmadinejad’s hostile attitude
toward the state of Israel might ask about the Holocaust — did it
justify the settlement of its survivors in Palestine in the first
place and has Israel misused the Holocaust to justify the Israeli
settlements in the occupied territories — but whether the Holocaust
ever happened is not one of them. To even somewhat sensible, mildly
educated people, Ahmadinejad’s conference is like having a conference
about whether the world might be flat after all.

Although Iran surely intends this as an affront to Israel and
Jewish people everywhere — my family and I fled Czechoslovakia
in 1939, leaving my grandparents and many relatives behind to die
in Theresienstad and Auschwitz — the real victims of this minor
latter-day outrage are the Iranian people and rational discourse
everywhere.

What Ahmadinejad’s conference proclaims is that truth has no place
in the world of politics; that if your ends are just, you can say
anything, no matter how far-fetched. Ahmadinejad tells us that his
pursuit of advanced nuclear capabilities is for peaceful purposes only:
power generation, medical applications, and not as part of a weapons
program. Why would a rational person put faith in any assurance from
a man so contemptuous of truth or even think there is any point in
negotiating with him?

But Ahmadinejad’s tortured logic seems almost broad-minded compared
with Turkey’s stringent criminal prohibition on any suggestion that
such a thing as its genocide of the Armenian people ever happened.
Many brave Turkish writers and journalists have suffered persecution
in recent times for proclaiming what no reasonable person would deny.
Yet the Armenian genocide is as certain a historic fact as Hitler’s
European Holocaust, for which Ataturk’s may well have served as a model
and feasability study. (A recent brief, horrifying and thoroughly
documented account can be found in Niall Ferguson’s "War of the
World.") Turkey and Iran turn truth into either a crime or charade.

And then there is the converse: What about countries like Canada
and many in Europe that make it an offense to offer propositions
derogatory of races or religions, or to deny the Holocaust, or
proposed legislation in France that would make it a crime to deny the
Armenian genocide. Here, too, the truth and how we come to know it
suffers. States that forbid such palpable lies degrade the currency
of truth as much as those who proclaim a lie as their national policy.

For in the end, the only way to bite the nickel to make sure it’s
genuine is in discussion, debate, assertion, and counter-assertion.
That is the process in which extremists in Iran and Turkey are shown
to be what they are — charlatans and liars. But states that shut down
that process, even to inane propositions like Holocaust or Armenian
genocide denial, debase the currency of truth every bit as much
as their opposites, For in their zeal, they assign to themselves,
to politics, and to official power (with its attendant machinery
of prosecutors, judges, juries, and jailors) an authority that can
reside only in the forum of individual judgment and conviction.

There is such a thing as truth; that is why Holocaust deniers are
fools or liars. But that is exactly why there can be no such thing as
official truth — truth endorsed, policed, and enforced by the power
of the state. Truth is above politics, and judges politics, which
is why politics has no authority to proclaim it. Official truth is a
contradiction in terms. In one respect the Turks seem worse than the
Iranians: They make it a crime to tell the truth, while Ahmadinejad
claims to doubt what only a fool or scoundrel would deny. Because
there is a truth about the Holocaust and Armenian Genocide, this
doubt is foolish, but that judgment is not a judgment of politics
but of the free mind that judges politics.

Charles Fried is a professor at Harvard Law School. His most recent
book is "Modern Liberty and The Limits of Government."

e/editorial_opinion/oped/articles/2006/12/13/
gett ing_at_the_truth/

http://www.boston.com/news/glob

Higher Educational Institutions Of Armenia Gradually To Pass To Euro

HIGHER EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS OF ARMENIA GRADUALLY TO PASS TO
EUROPEAN CREDIT SYSTEM

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 22, NOYAN TAPAN. The gradual introduction of the
European Credit system to the higher educational institutions’ sphere
is the logical continuation of the educational reforms implemented
in Armenia. RA Minister of Education and Science Levon Mkrtchian
informed journalists about this at the December 22 conference held at
the Yerevan State University, in which the rectors of the Armenian
higher educational institutions took part. In the Minister’s words,
the introduction of the credit system to the higher educational
institutions should be implemented stage by stage, as the abrupt
passage would certainly bring to mess and lowering of the education
quality. As the Minister said, this process is in different stages
in 40 countries which have joined to the educational agreement of
Bologna. In Armenia it is still in the initial stage. The test
of the credit system has been implemented in the country’s four
universities (Yerevan Engineering, Yerevan State, Yerevan Economic
and Agrarian Universities) for several years. In the L.Mkrtchian’s
words, the above mentioned universities should pass their experience
to others. "To announce at once that we pass to the credit system is
wrong, especially when the process of Bologna itself doesn’t bind any
term or immediate passage. All these steps should not be abrupt and
the educational peculiarities of the given country should certainly
be taken into consideration," mentioned L. Mkrtchian. The credit
system first was introduced to the Engineering University of Armenia
in the educational program of study for master’s degree on the line
of two professions (computing systems and informatics and engineering
management) since 2002. Later, it was tested in the educational sector
of study for bachelor’s degree among foreign students. At present
800 students are included in the credit system. Beginning September
this year, the university’s whole educational sector of study for
bachelor’s degree will pass to teaching by the credit system. The
introduction of that system to the other three universities was
implemented only on the line of a few professions of departments of
study for master’s degree. Corresponding structures have been created
in all the universities, which will be engaged in implementation of
educational-methodical plans and organization works.

Not Shells and Bombs Are Called To Determine The Situation In Our Re

NOT SHELLS AND BOMBS ARE CALLED TO DETERMINE THE SITUATION IN OUR REGION

ArmInfo News Agency
23 Dec 06

Interview of ex-speaker of RA Parliament, leader of "Orinats Yerkir" party,
Artur Baghdasaryan, to ArmInfo News Agency

Mr. Baghdasaryan, how do you appreciate the current processes in
our region and what the behavioral line of Armenia must be as not
to be an outsider of the common way of South Caucasus development,
if this way actually exists?

I may assure that the current geopolitical processes and their
development tendencies bode nothing well to Armenia in view of an
extremely initiative-free foreign political policy, which is carried
out in our country. We have to understand that the world political
centers do not intend to bother themselves with our cares, they are
waiting for initiatives and activity from us, by means of which we
could talk to the foreign world. Actually, not shells and bombs but a
political will and new competitive ideas are called today to determine
the situation in our region as a determinant. It means that we should
not give the priority in our policy to confrontation, but to trend
towards fulfillment of a healthy competitive struggle. And so, we have
to sooner realize that our neighbors are our rivals but not enemies. It
is important in so far as the overwhelming majority of the countries
of the region, we are in, has a clearly expressed task of integration
into the European structures, into a civilized family. They do go in
this direction. Meanwhile, we isolate ourselves instead of seeking
for the new approaches with respect to the two important players,
Turkey and Azerbaijan. We have to understand that if Turkey strives
today after the European Union, we, showing a flexibility, have to
sit at the Table of negotiations with Turks and try to find mutually
acceptable decisions. And what is of most importance, and we see
it well, the Turkish train has already started and keeps on moving
towards Europe. The train moves heavily, with artificial barriers on
the way, but it moves. That’s why we should not prevent each other from
developing by putting spokes in the wheels of the European locomotive
but, on the contrary, should try to do out best to put our locomotive
on this track.

Do you think it will be welcomed in Europe with an orchestra?

I think Armenia is able to play a key role in this integration
process. Why? Because, being a country, which has extremely strained
relations with the two of its four neighbors, Armenia is able to show
to the world its competitiveness based on the values of democratic
society, having displayed a foresight and diplomatic tolerance. We have
no oil, we are not a country with 60 million population. That’s why
we should use the chance we have – the chance to appear in the world
as a freely developing and truly democratic state. As regards the
sore subject if our relations with neighbors, healthy compromise is
certainly more important and useful that stubborn head-on enmity. We
should understand that the key geopolitical processes developing in
the region are incompatible with our current policy.

After all, the major document, a so-called , is signed with the
European Union within the frames of a new neighborhood policy.

Yes, on a paper, but we have to do the best, in a real life as not to
become an outsider, since Armenia remains aside of the major regional
economic programs. Those separating lines, which are created today
in the region, are not advantageous to our country. It’s only a
one purely political argument to be hardly argued since the facts
are on hand. There are other arguments here as well if consider,
for example, the situation and the processes developing around Iran
and in Iraq, if take into account the possibility of forming the new
states in this region. Armenia, as a state, can certainly play here
a definite role, including the institutional one, being invited to
discuss these issues. However, to be evaluated as a useful partner,
we have to refuse of building a close society based on a fear, to
refuse of the democracy imitation and to seriously start forming a
true democracy in the country based upon the key rights and freedoms
of citizens. This is already a domestic argument to the aforesaid.

Let’s go back to the . Once someone said: . You urge not to be late
but, having jumped on a loop step, we actually refuse of that of
no small importance what is received to call a guaranteed security
system. If discount a stillborn divorce CIS, then, probably, one
should not discount Russia as a partner and the CSTO it has created?

Nothing should be discounted, especially Russia as a partner and a
friendly country for us, as well as the CSTO as a security system,
until regulation of our relations with neighbors. I am far from
such ideas, however, I am sure and I have openly told about it to
my Russian counterpart- politicians who, by the way, understand me,
that the democracy is best security factor in XXI century. The matter
concerns security achievement by the society democratization. I do
not accept a marginal approach and object to oppose the CSTO and NATO.
It is, at least, incompetent to consider the North-Atlantic alliance
as a military unit only. The NATO has two constituents, a military
and political. My position is to maximum bring together the relations
of Armenia with the NATO’s political component, that will strengthen
both our Army and our political and civil Institutes.

It is difficult today to tell about the policy change since there is
no policy, we have not yet found where we are and where we go. We
have to clarify ourselves whether we join the "Russia- Belarus"
union or we’ll be the members of
the western European club, maintaining at that the best and kindest
relations with both Russia and Belarus. We will be able to build
neither the security
system nor the economic system until we understand what we
want. Everything
happens here per situation, abruptly, fragmentarily. One thing is
necessary – we are doing this one today, another one – tomorrow.

Is it a hint at a so-called complementarism in the country’s foreign
policy?

Complementarism is mainly a derivation from suspense of the Karabakh
problem. This foreign political thesis has proved itself, it played a
definite favorable role, however, it started to become outdated and
no one in the world perceives it seriously today. The critical mass
of complementarism is exhausted, he said and added it is necessary
to seek for the new ideas concordant with the situation and the
time. Compromises in the Karabakh issues must be searched as well, the
ex-speaker said. "The extreme ideas are unacceptable, since the future
is always more important despite the hard way, passed by our people.
For the same reason, the recognition of Genocide should not be a
cornerstone of the foreign policy as well. Well, let’s suppose some
countries more recognize the Genocide. What is next? We bow to the
memory of the Genocide victims, this fact is unofficially recognized
by the whole world community. But what we receive, carrying it as a
standard over the head? A moral satisfaction? And where is the real
policy then? The Genocide issue can be only a component of the foreign
policy to be elaborated. We have to build our foreign policy counting
on the future, for the sake of our children. Look, the Germans had
forced the whole Europe to its knees some 60 years ago, killed the
millions of people, destroyed London by bombing, razed Warsaw to the
ground. But now the Great Britain, France and Germany are building the
European Union and Poland has also joined them. This is an example
of a real policy based on democracy. Today, Turkey makes its way
towards Europe and we also have to go there and talk to it.

I would like to especially note that it is normal when
nationalistic ideas exist in our society, it is normal for a healthy
society. However, these ideas should not dominate since they start
to prevail, the society falls into an atmosphere of extremism, with
elements and properties, typical for such a society.

Georgia straightly aims at NATO. But along with it, participating
in all the regional energy and transport projects, it will soon
assure itself a maximum possible discretion from Russia. However,
all these projects pass over Armenia and if a railway plan of
Kars- Akhalkalaki-Tbilisi is implemented, the circle will close in
fact. Whether you are anxious about such a prospect?

Very much. Implementation of this project will seriously affect the
regional situation. The forecasts may be very unfavorable is consider
such a factor as Javakhk. However, Georgia today already receives
great means from oil transit by Baku-Jeihan pipeline. Azerbaijan
increases the economic power, attracts great investments, and only
in the oil-gas sector, while our newspaper editors in Armenia go on
a forced leave through a shortage of printing paper. A paradox, when
the country depends on conditions in the only Ukrainian harborage.
We should understand that without worthy throwing off the burden of
serious problems with neighbors, the only regional economic market will
be actually inaccessible for us. The whole civilized world community
considers the South Caucasus as a single whole. If we can become its
constituent part, be sure, there will be no question of building
a new economically ineffective railway communication passing over
Armenia. There our state interest lies in and the country’s future
must be built on its basis.

What’s the role of statements concerning the country’s foreign policy
in your resignation?

I would like to remind once more that we had disagreements on three
key directions of both the foreign and home policy. We have already
talked of the first one. It is impossible to long sit on several
swinging chairs simultaneously. The sooner we clarify our foreign
political priorities, the faster and more we’ll win. The second
principal disagreement concerned the ways of corruption- fight. One
should be naive to think there are places in the world where this
phenomenon is absent, however, the corruption has become a system in
our small country. This system crisis eats up all the healthy sprouts
in our political and economic field. We have always talked of these
phenomena. For example, what is the purpose of privatization? It is
an achievement of efficient management based on a thesis that an owner
is the a better manager than the state. We should solve the problem of
efficient management and economic reproduction though privatization. We
are not solving these problems now since privatization has become a
means of personal enrichment only.

Moreover, a means of short-term enrichment.

Quite right. If the task is incorrectly set, quite another result
is received as a consequence. The initial target setting is that the
privatization process, as a result, comes to enabling the monopolistic
structures and persons to receive super-profits.

The third disagreement concerned the issue of the country’s
democratization and construction of an open society. Imitation of
democratic processes and the democratic processes themselves are
quite different things. We follow an ostrich policy, having buried
our heads in a sand, and we think no one see us and notice our
"pranks". However, the democratic countries, our partners, see the
imitation of democratic processes in our country. Well, perhaps, we are
in a better condition than, for example, Azerbaijan, from the viewpoint
of democracy development, but we forget that Armenia and Azerbaijan
are considered in different planes. Azerbaijan is often overlooked
and not due to the oil factor, due to the political and economic
role of this country in the region, as well as taking into account
the factors of Iran, Turkey and GUAM, which since becomes not so
great but still a factor. Armenia does not have such "privileges". We
cannot compare us with Azerbaijan in all this. We have no other way
under these conditions but to create an open society. Legitimacy of
authorities plays a topping role here, the human rights and freedom
of speech play a no less role. Under conditions when the judgments,
passed in the country, are known in many cases in advance, when there
are no free electronic Mass Media, when the economy market is not
free and monopolized, one does not have to seek for odd trumps.

One thing more. If someone thinks it is easy to refuse of the
Parliament speaker’s post, he is mistaken. However, I’ve done it
and the "Orinats Yerkir" party supported me for the sake of future
reforms since, being at a power, we, the party members, made more
and more sure that we deal with deep system processes and not with
a transient period waste. We tried to perceive the power as a chance
to reform the public institutes, a necessity to change the people’s
life. That’s why, we received many strikes when leaving the power:
we faced treachery and loss of friends and experienced different
kinds of pressure. However, having overcome this trial, we underwent
a self-purification process, we strengthened and have become one of
the most capable and organized political forces. We shall fight for
our ideas and their realization. We are ready to do it openly and
not on the quiet like some others.

Informal relations and informal public institutes are formed and
root in Armenia. That is, we start to live rather by concepts than
by Law. Some allegedly connect it with our mentality, our genetic
inability of building a open civil society.

Mentality is of high importance, however it is stupid to
impute everything to it since the power is, first of all,
a responsibility. The power has a unique chance to create and
form definite rough rules of play in the society and control their
observance. The state should oblige the same oligarches to work under
conditions of open market and not on the contrary. We have informal
institutes – oligarches, for whom there are no Laws, they live by
their own concepts and laws. The state gives kopecks to the Police
and says: . The state official, having definite power controls,
takes bribes to assure a better life for himself. And what will he
do if the Chief-Minister looses millions in the
Moscow "Crystal" casino? That is the hidden motive of everything
what we so
comfortably "shake off" to the national mentality. We have to stop. We
need a
political will to eliminate all this. If a foreign company blames
today the
Government member for bribe-taking at the rate of $3 mln, such a
scandal in any other civilized country would become a reason for
a serious open trial and would possibly cause a resignation of the
whole Government. The examples are not so far: scandals in Hungry,
Poland, Sweden, Italy, while we said and forgot: .

Your estimation of the oppositional field from the viewpoint of
ideological basis.

There is no competition of ideas, a worthy rivalry in Armenia. There
is a competition of interests – a private, personal, group. I think
the opposition has a potential for unification and this process will
take place irrespective of the fact if it happens before or after
the Parliamentary elections. A problem of consolidation of parties
is available in Armenia. Existence of 70 parties in the country
with 2.5 mln population is an abnormal phenomenon. In my opinion,
this points to deideologization of the political field. The matter
concerns both a power camp and the oppositional environment. It is
the time to recomprehend the political processes in the country. I am
sure that Armenia will pass a qualitatively new development stage. We
are neither Turkmenia nor Belarus. The Turkman has a choice between
several hundreds of dollars per month, free gas, oil and obscurity. He
chooses the first one. The Belarusian also chooses the first one,
especially as the election spots of Lukashenko were built on a
contrast of the life level in Belarus, and how do you think where?
That’s right, in Armenia! Just remember the slogan: choose or you
will loose! The people of Armenia, though with another mentality,
has even no election choice today.

What’s the place of "Orinats Yerkir" in the alignment of oppositional
political forces in the country?

We are a moderate oppositional force. The extremism is not acceptable
for us in no sphere, neither an extreme liberalism in economy and
an extreme-nationalism in policy. We are the carriers of a classic
right-centrist ideology today. Several thousand new members join us
every month. We total 83,000 people. Our party is liberal-democratic
and it sees the country’s development in a priority of achieving an
economic competitiveness and in active regulation of the economic
field by the state. You see, I am talking not of management but only
of an efficient regulation by means of state institutes.

What are your forecasts concerning the coming elections and the
new Parliament’s staff? Whether the new financially-strong forces,
which are actively gathering the electorate today, will not create
a disbalance in the new Parliament, having the active ?

I have several possible scenarios on this account. The first
scenario: the power will show a political will and will organize
normal fir elections. The political players understand the importance
of this scenario. The matter here concerns the normal and not ideal
elections. The fulfillment of this scenario will lead the country by a
quite another way. However, we do not see a political will available
today for implementation of this version since the opposition is
deprived of an opportunity to talk to the society because of the
developed oligarchic system and a full control of the electronic
Mass Media.

According to the second scenario, there can be great falsifications,
which will inevitably cause social conflicts inside the society. You
see, everyone understands that the President is leaving, having
completed its term, and there is an opportunity to form a new
power. If there are great falsifications, great collisions will be
inevitable. Very different versions of the events development are
possible, which will cause an extremely strained situation in the
public- political life, the result of which is sad.

The third version: due to great money and administrative controls,
an attempt will be made to imitate the democratic elections. This
scenario also proves itself. Denis Corboy, a good friend of mine,
a British political analyst, a Head of supervisory missions in many
countries, had to tell me: . After Georgia, we are the only in CIS
counties, except the Asian ones, the state of affairs in which will be
controlled by the West with special responsibility. The Europe will
not keep mum and not because it is so anxious about us, but based on
its political interests. The imitation will not work. If there are no
social collisions, the country will face serious reputation problems
and the inner political and social tension will grow.

There is the fourth, optimistic scenario. The authorities will show
a political will and will come to an agreement with the key players
in the political field for conducting normal elections.

But you said we are already behind this scenario?

But this possibility still remains in some aspect. The first condition
is to accept the Electoral Code by a political consensus. The
second condition is a normal administration by the election process
before elections, during and after them. The third condition is an
efficient carrying-out of the election process for the people to
see that the political forces are enabled to talk to the society,
to bring their ideas and programs to the society. It is naive to
think that the oligarches will not make falsifications. However,
having this scenario, the authorities will not assume a liability for
that. It warns that any violation will be severely punished. If you
are an <Ñ~E> oligarch and you have stolen the ballot-box, you will
be tried. In short, the power take the steps which are positively
perceived by the society and it goes to the elections. They may be
non-ideal but mainly fair. This scenario can be real since there is
no other way out and there is still a time to change the situation.

If the power refuses of this version, mass protest actions, meetings
may happen in the country before and after elections. Arrests
are not ruled out either. However, one should remember that a new
election Presidential race will start in a couple of months after the
Parliamentary elections. There have been no such a situation in Armenia
yet to be fraught with such a great public energy. The society will
not stand such a permanent pressure if it is not deferred to and a
destructive effect of spring may work both inside the country and
outside it.

Interview by Emmanuil Lazarian

December 18, 2006

"SHEN CONCERN" CJSC STARTS ISSUING THE FIRST CORPORATE BONDS OF
NON-FINANCIAL SECTOR IN ARMENIA

Yerevan, December 21. ArmInfo. In December 2006, the Armenian "Shen
Concern" CJSC, the leader in construction materials production in
Armenia, issued nominal, undocumentary, discount bonds. This is
for the first time an Armenian manufacturing venture enters the open
securities market with corporate bonds. The Armenian Central Bank has
recently decided to register the issue prospectus of these securities,
after which the public bond placement will start.

The "Shen Concern" company told ArmInfo that the total nominal value of
the bonds will make up 160 mln AMD. The bonds will be placed in four
equal tranches worth 40 mln AMD. Each tranche consists of 4 thousand
bonds worth 10 thousand AMD per bond. The annual bond yield of the
first tranche is fixed at 9%. According to a preliminary estimation,
the proceeds from the sale of the first tranche will make up 36 697
248 AMD. This sum will be directed at refinancing of the company’s
debt. The underwriter of the issue will be the "E-Capital Asset
Management" CJSC. The bond turnover is 365 days starting from the
last day of placement.

At the moment, the "Shen Concern" CJSC produces construction materials,
paints, putty, it is also engaged in construction and trade of
construction materials. The company is also planning to establish
new types of production.

By September 30, 2006, the company’s proceeds from the sale made up
1 462.0 mln AMD, and in 2005 – 1 243.2 mln AMD as against 1 073.1 mln
AMD in 2004. The net profit totalled 272.3 mln AMD as against 36.1 mln
AMD in 2005 and 201.9 mln AMD in 2004. According to the specialists of
the company, in Jan-Sept 2006 the volume of sales increased by 17,6%,
while the net profit grew by 653,5%. The high rates of profit growth
are explained by the decrease of the cost price.

The specialists of the "Shen Concern" CJSC inform the future
bond-holders about the potential risks, such as possible lack of
well-organized liquid market of bonds in Armenia, the possible
fluctuation of interest rates on the financial market. The company
also admits that some changes may take place on the construction
market of Armenia, though over the past few years this sector of
economy has been steadily developing. Some risks may be connected
with failures in supply of raw material for the production.

To remind, at the end of 2004, the holder of 24% of "Shen Concern’s"
shares worth 850 thsd EUR became the European Bank for Reconstruction
and Development, which bought 12% more shares of the enterprise
in July, 2005. These are the first investments of the EBRD in an
Armenian private industrial enterprise. The rest of the shares belong
to the company’s top- managers. To note, the Armenian Central Bank,
which has been awarding ratings to various non-commercial enterprises
of the country since last year, gave "B" high rating to the "Shen
Concern" CJSC. The CB specialists estimated the company’s financial
activity by 3.86 points, the quality of the activity – 4.5 points,
the average mark is 4.18 points. In this connection, the CB is ready
to accept the bonds issued by the company as security while concluding
REPO-agreements with commercial banks. This considerably contributes to
the increase of the bonds’ liquidity and gives investors an opportunity
to enter the market of alternative financial instruments.

NEW AGENCY AMRATING IN GLOBAL RATING GROUP

London, December 19. ArmInfo. A new agency AmRating (Armenia) has
occurred in the Global Rating Group. The agency has prepared its
first analytical product "Review of Armenia’s Banking System."

Global Rating press-service reports the product gives an analysis of
the state of Armenia’s banking system, as well as of the risks and
problems in its development. The product also presents the leading
banks in the country and their investment attractiveness.

A positive factor of the Armenian banking market is its low
politicization due to the insignificant level of penetration of
political interests into the market. The development level of the
banking system leaves behind the general economic level. Thus, the
market of banking services is attractive for foreign investors. Healthy
and strong competition between the Armenian banks allows avoiding
monopolies in the banking market of Armenia. The strategic development
of big banks considerably influences the general development trend
in the banking sector.

Mr. Richard Hainsworth, Global Rating Group President, says the Review
of Armenia’s Banking System symbolizes the successful start in the
activity of AmRating and the fulfillment of the strategic plan of
Global Rating Group to open rating agencies in CIS.

Each country has not only a unique culture, mentality and language,
but also financial market. The agency will rely only on local
personnel. This is the fundamental decision of the group, which will
bring benefit to banks, clients, partners and potential investors in
the CIS, Richard Hainsworth says.

Mr. Emmanuil Lazarian, the head of the agency in Armenia, believes
that the establishment of the national rating agency will ensure an
unbiased stand on the development of the growing banking system in
Armenia, and on other segments of the financial market, which are
on the way to fundamental reforms. He says the goals and the tasks
of the agency are in harmony with the policy of Armenian Central
Bank regarding the planned transition of the country’s commercial
banks to Basel II principles connected also with introduction of
the systems of internal ratings and market analyses. "When preparing
the review, our analysts enjoyed the readiness of the Central Bank
and the commercial banks of the country to assist us in our work,
which is a good start," Mr. Lazarian said.

The first successful project of Richard Hainsworth in the establishment
of national rating agencies was RusRating agency. The agency has
been operating in the Russian market for over 5 years. Its rating
list comprises 45 banks and a leasing company. KzRating agency,
another project of Richard Hainsworth in Kazakhstan, launched its
activity in March 2006. All the national agencies established by
Richard Hainsworth are united in the Global Rating Group.

–Boundary_(ID_/6lUaf4KUgoIGyAbGQh0PA)–

Taking 12: The Year in Review

Taking 12: The Year in Review
By Aram Kouyoumdjian

Critics’ Forum
12.23.06
Theater

Last year, as I looked back on the theater scene of the preceding
twelve months, I counted on the fingers of one hand the number of
productions by or about Armenians. This year, both the number and
quality of productions were up; organizations buzzed with activity;
and one troupe even acquired a theater space. Below, as I review the
year in 12 steps, I begin with "Little Armenia," the play I know
best, since I had the fortune of co-writing it with Lory Bedikian and
Shahe Mankerian.

1. Commissioned and produced by the award-winning Fountain
Theatre, "Little Armenia" was inspired by countless interviews that
we writers conducted in the predominantly immigrant and working-class
section of East Hollywood that bears the name. The result was a work
with three intersecting storylines that cut across generations and
dealt with the struggles of an ethnic community to maintain its
identity, language, and faith amidst financial hardship and the pull
of assimilation. The Los Angeles Times called the play "seminal,"
and thanks to overwhelming community turnout, the production was sold
out from its very first preview. As shows were added to accommodate
demand, "Little Armenia" chalked up 21 performances over its five-
week run.

2. After expending a great deal of effort and suffering
disappointment by some unexpected setbacks, the Armenian Theater
Company leased a space of its own, morphing into the Luna Playhouse.
Energized by its committed core of artists, the company inaugurated
the new space with Lilly Thomassian’s "Thirst," a war drama infused
with mythical elements and fashioned after Greek tragedy. The space
has been bustling ever since, and Luna has already delivered on its
promise to include Armenian-language plays in its repertoire. The
company had earlier proven its ability to handle serious Armenian
drama with its production of "Zhangark" (Twilight). Aghasi
Ayvazyan’s gripping tale, set during the immediate aftermath of
Armenia’s independence when the country was being suffocated by an
economic blockade, was well served by a capable cast and Aramazd
Stepanian’s assured direction.

3. The Armenian Dramatic Arts Alliance (ADAA) added to its list of
impressive accomplishments as it increased its level of activity on
the West Coast to catch up with its record on the East. Aside from
announcing the establishment of a $10,000 annual prize for an
Armenian-themed script, the ADAA organized a series of high-profile
readings, including a private presentation of Oscar-nominated
screenwriter Jose Rivera’s adaptation of the Micheline Aharonian
Marcom novel, "Three Apples Fell from Heaven." Readings at the
Fountain Theatre featured works by a trio of woman playwrights,
including Bianca Bagatourian ("The Scent of Jasmine"), Lisa Kirazian
("The Blackstone Sessions"), and Kristen Lazarian ("Push").

4. The Theater Excursions program of the Armenian Center for the
Arts completed its second full year. The program involves monthly
theater outings for a group of aficionados, usually ranging in number
from 40 to 100. Highlights among this year’s selections included
star turns by Annette Bening in "The Cherry Orchard" at the Mark
Taper Forum and by Laurence Fishburne and Angela Bassett in "Fences"
at the Pasadena Playhouse. Exclusive talk-backs with directors and
casts followed four of the outings, including "Love’s Labor’s Lost."

5. In an earlier review, I celebrated "Love’s Labor’s Lost" as a
triumphant production, as directed by Simon Abkarian for the Actors’
Gang (at the Ivy Substation). Abkarian, I wrote, made Shakespeare’s
text "bloom into a masterwork of imagination, awash in surreal images
and gorgeous stylized movement, all bathed in luminous light." In
fact, he elevated one of the Bard’s "lesser" comedies "to an
emotionally complex and sexually charged piece of theater."

6. If "Love’s Labor’s Lost" set the standard for the best of
theater, it was matched only by "A Number," Caryl Churchill’s
intriguing take on cloning, at the American Conservatory Theater in
San Francisco. Flawlessly staged by director Anna Shapiro, the
production boasted not only intelligent designs of its sets,
costumes, and sound, but also a vital portrayal by Josh Charles of
three brothers who are as distinct in personality as they are
identical in genetic make-up.
Among the top tier of the year’s productions, director
Randall Arney injected Arthur Miller’s morality play "All My Sons"
(at the Geffen Playhouse) with vibrancy and contemporary relevance.
Laurie Metcalf’s coiled performance as Kate Keller was revelatory and
on par with a luminous Cate Blanchett’s edgy "Hedda Gabler" at the
Brooklyn Academy of Music. Standouts among actors included Laurence
Fishburne, rivetingly intense in "Fences" (Los Angeles); Norbert Leo
Butz, riotously manic in "Dirty Rotten Scoundrels" (New York); and
Rufus Sewell, perfectly nuanced in "Rock ‘n’ Roll" (London).

7. Audiences in Los Angeles were treated to a rare revival of
William Saroyan’s "The Time of Your Life" ~V a lovely mood piece set
against the backdrop of the 1930s. The play had found new life on
regional stages thanks to a stellar production in 2002 by Chicago’s
famed Steppenwolf Theatre Company ~V a production that later traveled
to Seattle and San Francisco. The staging by the Open Fist Theater
Company lacked the technical polish of director Tina Landau’s version
(and her gift for choreographing movement) but nonetheless captured
the essence of Saroyan’s funny, heartbreaking, and redemptive
narrative about the search for a better, decent life during a time
fraught with financial anxiety and fear of war.

8. Eric Bogosian was represented on the boards at least twice this
year. The Hollywood Fight Club’s production of "subUrbia" had little
to recommend it, except for a game group of actors. Far more
accomplished was the Gangbusters Theatre Company’s "Talk Radio,"
which channeled the frenetic energy of Bogosian’s writing into a
captivating performance by Christian Levatino as fictional shock jock
Barry Champlain.

9. Solo performances displayed wide range and included "Black
Angel: The Double Life of Arshile Gorky," in which writer Nouritza
Matossian portrayed the women who were key figures in the artist’s
life. At the opposite end of the spectrum, "Pomegranate Whiskey," a
cabaret by Lory Tatoulian, offered uproarious musical numbers and
monologues, including an inspired bit about a fatigued Statue of
Liberty yearning to return to France. This talented and fearless
performer certainly did not spare the follies of the Armenian
community from her satirical bite, and her medley of children’s songs
set to sultry jazz music was the stuff of comedic gold.

10. Young Armenians claimed the stage in "Verchin Verabroghuh" (The
Last Survivor), an original theatrical presentation on the subject of
the Genocide. This pastiche of vignettes was sometimes sentimental,
often moving, and always treated with due reverence by a well-
rehearsed cast comprised mostly of teenagers.

11. The worst of theater came from an unlikely source at an unlikely
venue, but the only redeeming quality of Sam Shepard’s "The God of
Hell" at the Geffen was its short running time. Neither funny nor
piercing, this political "satire" about a Wisconsin couple visited by
a mysterious salesman (read: government operative) who preaches
patriotism and inflicts torture with equal glee managed to be vapid
and dull, entirely superficial, and altogether exasperating within
the span of a mere 85 minutes.

12. Next year starts with great promise, as award-winning actress
Karen Kondazian reprises her role as Maria Callas in Terrence
McNally’s "Master Class." Kondazian takes the stage at the Lobero
Theater in Santa Barbara on January 4, kick-starting what we can only
hope will be an even more fruitful year for Armenian theater.

All Rights Reserved: Critics’ Forum, 2006

Aram Kouyoumdjian is the winner of Elly Awards for both playwriting
("The Farewells") and directing ("Three Hotels"). His collaborative
script for "Little Armenia" had its world premiere at the Fountain
Theatre in Los Angeles earlier this year.

You can reach him or any of the other contributors to Critics’ Forum
at [email protected]. This and all other articles published
in this series are available online at To sign
up for a weekly electronic version of new articles, go to
Critics’ Forum is a group created to
discuss issues relating to Armenian art and culture in the Diaspora.

www.criticsforum.org.
www.criticsforum.org/join.

Archbishop Goriun Babian visits Abu Dhabi

Archbishop Goriun Babian visits Abu Dhabi

Azad-Hye, Dubai
23 December 2006

On 7th November 2006 Archbishop Goriun Babian, Catholicosal Representative
of the Diocese of Kuwait and the Arabian Gulf countries (based in Kuwait
City) arrived in Abu Dhabi on a special mission.

Accompanied by Der Aram Deyirmenjian, pastor of the United Arab Emirates
(UAE) Armenian community and members of the representative and executive
bodies of the Abu Dhabi Armenian community, His Eminence paid an official
visit to "Qasr Al Bahr" Palace, where he met with the Director of the
Presidential Affairs His Excellency Ali Salem Obaid Al Kaabi. The purpose of
this visit was to express gratitude for the recently issued decree by the
Crown Prince of Abu Dhabi granting 2.500 square meters land to the Armenian
community in the vicinity of Abu Dhabi to build a church and community
complex.

Archbishop Goriun evoked the memory of the late President of the UAE, Sheikh
Zayed bin Sultan Al Nahyan. Two Catholicoses of Cilicia (Karekin II and Aram
I) had the opportunity to meet with the late President in 1995 and 1998
respectively. During both meetings a request for providing a piece of land
for the Armenian Church was put forward. It is worth mentioning that Sheikh
Zayed granted US$ 100.000 in 1998 to the Armenian community, as part of his
support to the foreign communities in the Emirate of Abu Dhabi.

Archbishop Goriun thanked the Government of Abu Dhabi for bringing the long
time dream of the Armenian community closer to reality and said, "with your
noble act, you inspired us hope that in the near future the members of our
Church will have their own place of worship and community center". His
Eminence briefed Al Kaabi on the activities of the Catholicosate of Cilicia
and the structure and mission of the Diocese of Kuwait and the Arabian Gulf
countries, highlighting the fact that throughout history the Armenians have
lived in brotherly and peaceful terms with the Arabs. He reminded the noble
Arab stance towards the Armenian refugees who escaped the Genocide and found
in the Arab societies the perfect environment for revival and full-fledged
involvement and contribution into the economic progress of their new
habitants.

Referring to the limited financial resources of the small Abu Dhabi Armenian
community, Archbishop Babian expressed hope that the Government of Abu Dhabi
would provide economic and moral support for the success of the
aforementioned project, in the same way it did in the past. He took the
opportunity also to elaborate on the special role of the Catholicosate of
Cilicia, under the leadership of His Holiness Aram I, in creating channels
of dialogue with all religions and especially between Islam and
Christianity. In this context Archbishop Babian expressed his willingness to
repeat what has been already achieved in Kuwait during the visit of His
Holiness Aram I, in the from of press conference and other academically
attributed activities with the participation of scholars and official
representatives.

Al Kaabi highly appreciated the visit and announced that "through such
encounters we come to know the Armenian community far better and our
relationship moves smoothly forward". He congratulated the Armenian
community for receiving the church plot and expressed hope that the
Government of Abu Dhabi will be able to provide further support for the
overall success of the project. Referring to the Christian communities in
the United Arab Emirates Al Kaabi noted that "the UAE Government does not
practice any sort of discrimination between Muslims and Christians. We all
live here in an atmosphere of mutual friendship and respect. Our State is
against any kind of religious extremism. I have known Lebanon through my
frequent visits. Particularly in these days it is very important to create
an ambiance of cooperation between the two religions and their followers by
utilizing the spirit of dialogue. We need the advice of spiritual leaders of
your caliber in order to facilitate this dialogue and to reach to positive
results. The Americans and the West do not know us in the proper sense and
they have misconception about what Islam and the Arabs represent. We need to
work together to correct this ideas".

Al Kaabi promised to undertake all measures necessary to arrange a meeting
for the Armenian side with the Crown Prince and the President of the UAE in
the future.

Visit to the Embassy of the Republic of Armenia (09 November 2006)

As in all previous visits to Abu Dhabi, His Eminence Archbishop Goriun
Babian paid a visit to the Embassy of Armenia. H.E. Ambassador Vahagn
Melikian, who has been appointed to this position since May 2006 (following
a five year tenure by Ambassador Arshag Poladian), showed a warm welcome.
Archbishop Babian briefed the Ambassador on the present day status of the
Armenian communities in the Gulf countries and gave a synopsis of the
accomplished achievements and other projects under process. In his turn, the
Ambassador gave an account on the future projects related to the Embassy.
His Eminence expressed interest to visit the construction site of the new
Embassy in order to observe the ongoing construction works on the piece of
land granted by the UAE authorities. The visit was materialized on 11
November 2006, accompanied by Vahe Toukhmanian, Chairman of the Council of
the Abu Dhabi Armenian Community. After witnessing the serious work that has
been done so far, Archbishop Babian thanked the chief architects Berj
Aprahamian and Salah Hariri for their volunteer designing work and
supervision of the project. The two architects informed him that the
construction of the two main buildings will be over in six months time.

Visit to the weekly school

In the afternoon of the same day (11 November 2006), Archbishop Babian
visited the weekly Armenian school of Abu Dhabi, which has recently
celebrated its 25th anniversary. Veteran Head of School Tamar Der Ohanesian
welcomed the Catholicosal Representative and informed him that the number of
the students who are following Armenian language, religion and history
lessons in the school was 50, covering all stages from Kindergarten to the
eight grade.

Meeting with the members of legislative and executive bodies in Abu Dhabi

On the same evening Archbishop Babian held a consultative meeting with the
members of the legislative and executive bodies in Abu Dhabi, during which
the following two subjects were discussed:

1- Bearing in mind that the four-year period of the Representative Council
(Temagan Joghov) in Kuwait and the other Arabian Gulf countries will come to
its end in December 2006, it is necessary to form an Election Committee
which will supervise the election process of the new Council. Following a
brief exchange of views, two probable dates were set forward but the final
one would be decided upon consultation with the Councils of Kuwait and the
Northern Emirates (Sharjah – Dubai).

2- The construction of the church in the newly granted piece of land was
discussed. It was decided to do some preliminary research at the present and
leave the concluding decisions to the discretion of the new Council’s
(post-election) meeting. Archbishop Goriun visited also the site of the
future church and explored the possibilities of constructing adjacent
buildings. Holy Mass was performed in the Greek Orthodox Saint Nicolaos
Church on 10th November 2006 during which Archbishop Babian reminded the Abu
Dhabi Armenians that they are witnessing important developments in the
history of the community, stressing that the decades long dream of having
own church is coming true with the collective efforts of all the members of
the community.

Source: Excerpts from the report prepared by the office of the Diocese of
Kuwait and the Arabian Gulf Country, 22 November 2006. English translation
by Azad-Hye.
________________________________________
Photos:
1- Archbishop Babian with His Excellency Ali Salem Obaid Al Kaabi, Director
of the Presidential Affairs in Abu Dhabi.
2- Al Kaabi with the other members of the Armenian delegation.
3- In the construction site of the new building of the Embassy of Armenia.
4- Group photo with the students and educational staff of the Abu Dhabi
Armenian community weekly school.
5- With the student (Abu Dhabi).
6- With the educational staff (Abu Dhabi).

See Armenian text and photos at:
Id=112dad92

http://www.azad-hye.net/news/viewnews.asp?news

Archbishop Goriun Babian visits Sharjah – Dubai

Archbishop Goriun Babian visits Sharjah – Dubai

Azad-Hye, Dubai
23 December 2006

On the second part of his visit to the United Arab Emirates, His Eminence
Archbishop Goriun Babian, the Catholicosal Representative of the Diocese of
Kuwait and the Arabian Gulf countries transferred to Sharjah, where he held
a meeting on the 13th November 2006 with the members of legislative and
executive bodies in Sharjah – Dubai. The meeting took place in the assembly
hall of the Saint Krikor the Illuminator Armenian Church in Sharjah. The
following two subjects were discussed:

1- The Council of the Armenian Community in Northern Emirates suggested
conducting the Temagan elections on 9th February 2007, considering that the
period from 17th January to 2nd February 2007 coincides with the school
year’s mid-term vacations.

2- Establishment of daily Armenian school:
Several weeks ago a decision was reached to hold a consultative meeting on
19th November 2006 with the participation of Archbishop Babian, members of
both legislative and executive bodies and Harout Ohanesian, the benefactor
of the Armenian weekly school of Sharjah. Unfortunately, due to
circumstances beyond personal will, the benefactor and several other members
will not be able to attain the meeting. It was therefore considered right to
postpone it to December (Archbishop Goriun will be visiting Sharjah again on
December to attend the 25th anniversary celebrations of the school).
Nevertheless, all the members insisted on conducting this meeting as soon as
possible in order to clarify several pending issues.

Holy Mass in Sharjah on the occasion of the 8th anniversary of the
inauguration and official blessing ceremony of the Saint Krikor the
Illuminator Armenian Church of Sharjah (1998-2006)

Until recently it was a tradition in Sharjah to celebrate the Name Day of
the Sharjah Church on the commemoration day of Saint Krikor’s entry to the
deep dungeon (moodn i virab). The sacrificial offerings (madagh) were
prepared on the same occasion. Considering that the above commemoration day
often coincides with the period of Greater Lent (Medz Bahk), and
specifically with the week that goes before the Palm Sunday (Dzaghgazart) –
during which the consumption of meat was a serious cause of contempt by the
believers – it was deemed therefore appropriate to detach the Name Day
celebration of the Saint Krikor Church from the sacrificial offerings day.
This first time experience proved to be very successful.

In the evening of 16th November 2006 special ceremony took place followed by
the blessing of the meat and salt. Soon afterwards the whole night
preparation of the madagh took place with the collective effort of 50
persons.

In the morning of the following day (17 November 2006) Archbishop Babian
performed the Holy Mass ritual with the presence of several hundreds of
Armenians from Sharjah – Dubai and nearby locations. It is worth mentioning
that thanks to the efforts of Der Aram Deyirmenjian a four-part mixed choir
was formed in Sharjah, which on this occasion performed composer Yegmalian’s
famous Divine Liturgy.

Archbishop Babian delivered a sermon on the subject of pilgrims and
pilgrimages in general and the offering of sacrificial meat and its meaning.
He referred to the centuries-long history of the Armenian Church which
reflected the history of the Armenian nation.

Following the Holy Mass a procession (consisted of the clergy and the
laymen) entered the community hall, where cauldrons were holding the
well-cooked madagh. Following the blessing of the madagh the believers sang
the semi-official anthem of Cilician Catholicosate "When the doors of hope
open" (Yerpor patsvin trnern huso).

Visit to the Ohanesian weekly school

During the visit to the Ohanesian weekly School Archbishop Babian expressed
his appreciation for the great job the Head of School Lorig Katerjian and
the rest of the education staff have been doing. He noted that the school is
experiencing increase in the number of students (160 this school year
compared to 125 in the previous year 2005-2006), covering all stages from
Kindergarten up to the eight grade.

Source: Excerpts from the report prepared by the office of the Diocese of
Kuwait and the Arabian Gulf Country, 22 November 2006. English translation
by Azad-Hye.

_______________________________________ _
Photos:
1- Preparation of the sacrificial offerings (madagh).
2- Blessing of meat and salt.
3- Sermon delivered by Archbishop Babian.
4- Believers follow the Holy Mass.
5- The procession moving towards the community hall.
6- Requiem service and blessing of the herisa (a special recipe prepared
from the madagh sheep or chicken roaster)
7- The ordained choristers.

See Armenian text and photos at:
Id=371daf93

http://www.azad-hye.net/news/viewnews.asp?news

CIS is useless organisation–Aliyev

CIS is useless organisation–Aliyev

ITAR-TASS, Russia
Dec 23 2006

MOSCOW, December 23 (Itar-Tass) — Azerbaijani President Ilkham
Aliyev has said that CIS is a "useless organisation, which dies not
give anything to Azerbaijan from a practical point of view."

Speaking in an interview with the Echo of Moscow radio broadcasting
station, Aliyev said that CIS was a good opportunity for the leaders
to meet and talk. "One should not set too high requirements to CIS,
describe it as a demon-like institution, or expect too much from it,"
the Azerbaijani President stressed.

In his opinion, no organisation of that kind — neither U.N., nor CIS
– settled any global problems. "Who is working on the settlement of
conflicts in Nagorno-Karabakh, Moldova and Georgia? Is it CIS? No,"
Aliyev said.

At the same time, he described GUAM as a "rather efficient’
organisation. He reminded that the U.N. had adopted a resolution
on frozen conflicts on the initiative of GUAM. "All the separatist
conflicts were brought together in a single format within the GUAM
framework. Previously the West believed that Abkhazia, Ossetia and the
Dniester Region have separatism, and Nagorno-Karabakh has a national
liberation movement," Aliyev said.

Two Opposition MPs’ Proposals Included In Legislative Package On Mak

TWO OPPOSITION MPs’ PROPOSALS INCLUDED IN LEGISLATIVE PACKAGE ON
MAKING AMENDMENTS AND ADDITIONS TO ELECTORAL CODE ADOPTED BY RA NA

YEREVAN, DECEMBER 22, NOYAN TAPAN. At the December 22 sitting, RA
NA with 78 votes in favor and 2 abstentions adopted the legislative
package on making amendments and additions to RA Electoral Code,
RA Criminal Code and law "On Local Self-Government." According to the
draft of RPA, ARFD, ULP factions, Business and People’s Deputy MP group
representatives, amendments and additions are made to more than 100
articles of the Electoral Code. Because of disagreements of principle,
Ardarutiun (Justice) faction members present at the sitting did not
take part in voting, with the exception of Aram Sargsian, Chairman
of the Democratic Party of Armenia who voted in favor. Hovhannes
Margarian, Orinats Yerkir (Country of Law) faction member, who withdrew
his signature the other day, also voted in favor. The above mentioned
MPs’ position was conditioned by inclusion of their proposals into
the draft. In particular, according to A.Sargsian’s proposal, passage
threshold of 5% and 7% working for parties and blocs, respectively,
at the parliamentary elections, was kept. The draft’s main variant
envisaged to use a differentiated threshold for blocs: 7% for blocs
composed of 2 parties, 10% for blocs composed of 3 and more parties.
On the basis of H.Margarian’s proposals, in particular, the right
of electoral commission member to vote as "abstained" was retored,
requirements on fixing additional electoral rolls at electoral
districts, stamps in identification cards of servicemen having
participated in voting for controlling elections amomg servicemen
were stipulated.

ANKARA: Ates On Azerbaijani – Armenian Dispute

Ates On Azerbaijani – Armenian Dispute

Anatolian Times, Turkey
Dec 23 2006

BAKU – Armenian problem is on the agenda of the Political Committee
(of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe-PACE),"
said Abdulkadir Ates, a MP from the Republican People`s Party (CHP)
and the head of the PACE Political Affairs Committee. Making a
keynote speech in the PACE Political Affairs Committee meeting in
Azerbaijani capital of Baku, Ates expressed concern that the Upper
Karabakh problem has not been solved yet.

He recalled that the PACE adopted a resolution (#1416) regarding
solution of the Upper Karabakh problem, and said, "requirements of
this resolution should be fulfilled."

Also, he stated, a sub-committee has been set up under the Political
Affairs Committee regarding this question. Ates said that members of
this committee will hold talks with Azerbaijani and Armenian MPs soon.

Pointing out that the Committee has submitted a memorandum to the PACE
regarding stability in South Caucasus, Ates underlined importance of
this document for a political compromise in the region.

On the other hand, Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev received Ates
and Murat Mercan, the MP of Justice & Development Party (AKP) who is
also the head of Turkish delegation in the PACE.

UK church leaders pledge to be ‘voice of the voiceless of Bethlehem’

UK church leaders pledge to be ‘voice of the voiceless of Bethlehem’

Independent Catholic News, UK
Dec 23 2006

Leaving Bethlehem this morning after a three-day pilgrimage, the UK’s
church leaders pledged themselves to continue to be a "voice for the
voiceless" on behalf of the beleaguered people of the town.

The Rt Revd David Coffey, president of the Churches Together in
England, was speaking on behalf of the Archbishops of Canterbury and
Westminster, and the Armenian Patriarch of Great Britain, after they
received symbolic Bethlehem passports.

The passports are an initiative of Open Bethlehem, a campaign which
began in 2005 to draw the world,s attention to the plight of the
town, which is in economic meltdown following the construction of a
30-foot-high wall by the Israeli army. The Israeli measures imposed
since 2000 have led to a catastrophic decline in the number of
pilgrimages to the town, on which its economy depends.

According to a 2004 UN report unemployment and poverty have caused
more than 400 Christian families to leave Bethlehem in search of
livelihoods abroad.

Shortly after walking through the checkpoint on Thursday, a visibly
shocked Archbishop of Canterbury said the wall symbolized "all that
is wrong in the human heart".

"Your visit reassures us that we are not forgotten," Leila Sansour,
Open Bethlehem,s chief executive, told the four pilgrims.

She said the passports signalled "our hope that you will continue to
be ambassadors for Bethlehem after you return home. She asked that
"whenever you travel you will speak about Bethlehem and remember us,
a people who long to travel in dignity and freedom."

There has so far been only one passport given: Pope Benedict XVI
received the Bethlehem passport in December 2005 from the Palestinian
president, Mahmoud Abbas.

"We are fortunate to have such distinguished ambassadors to speak
for us," Sansour said.

The passport asks the bearer to "remain a true friend to Bethlehem
through its imprisonment and that he or she will "strive to keep the
ideals of Bethlehem alive as long as the wall stands."

Mr Coffey in turn presented Leila Sansour with a Christmas card signed
by hundreds of people in Durham, in north-east England. The card shows
Mary and Joseph approaching Bethlehem but finding the town imprisoned
behind a wall.

‘We support your struggle for peace with justice’ – were the words
on the inside of the card.

The Open Bethlehem delegation included a representative of the Governor
of Bethlehem, as well as the coordinator of a network of Christian
organizations in Bethlehem and a representative of the World Council
of Churches.

The church leaders spent yesterday visiting Christian and humanitarian
projects in Bethlehem, including Bethlehem University (where 70 per
cent of the students are Muslim), the Holy Family hospital and the
Arab Rehabilitation Society, a hospital for the disabled.

At the university, the church leaders received from the students a
piece of a demolished house belonging to the family of one of the
students, as well as a candle and a handpainted tile.

Rather than hand over the stone from the demolished house to his
advisers, Dr Williams kept hold of it throughout his visit to the
university.

The students spoke of life under occupation, the sense of imprisonment,
and their anxieties about their future.

Text of Leila Sansour’s address:

"Your Grace, Your Eminence, Your Beatitude, Reverend Coffey:

As you end your pilgrimage to our city, my friends and I from
Bethlehem,s civil institutions wish to send you on your way with our
most heartfelt regards. Your visit was timely, not only because it is
Christmas, the time when we celebrate the birth of Jesus Christ. But
also because our city today is very isolated. Your visit reassures
us that we are not forgotten.

On Thursday the Mayor of Bethlehem awarded you the freedom of our
city. Today, on behalf of the Governor of Bethlehem, I would like to
present you with a Bethlehem passport to signal our hope that you will
continue to be ambassadors for Bethlehem after you return home, and
that whenever you travel you will speak about Bethlehem and remember
us, a people who also long to travel in dignity and freedom.

This passport has so far only been given to one, very distinguished
person His Holiness Pope Benedict XVI, who received it from our
president, Mahmoud Abbas. We are fortunate indeed to have such
distinguished ambassadors to speak for us.

The passport is an initiative of Open Bethlehem, a campaign to keep
Bethlehem free and open. The presence of the four of you here has
brought these aims closer. From the bottom of our hearts we thank you
for your time, dedication and prayers. We thank you for the warm bonds
with the people of Britain which it will help to forge; and we thank
you for bringing closer the peace and justice for which we all long."

Text of response by Rt Revd David Coffey:

"I know I speak for all the pilgrims when I say your words were
very moving. Each day we have been given treasures, and this is a
very special treasure that we take away with us. We bring something
very modest in return but nonetheless very meaningful to us. There
are many towns and communities who have pledged their support for
Bethlehem. This says: ‘Christmas greetings from the people of Durham
to the people of Bethlehem’. It says we support your struggle for
peace with justice; it carries the names and addresses of people who
have signed it.

What we have found here in Bethlehem is a people with identity, a
people with a story. And although we don,t know the stories of all
these people, they are real people, and they say they support you.

As we return, we do pledge to continue to be a voice for the voiceless
and we will continue with stand you in prayer at the end of our
pilgrimage."

Source: Open Bethlehem/ACN