Vartkes Yeghiayan at the Glendale Public Library

Vartkes Yeghiayan
The Case of Misak Torlakian

Wednesday, January 17, 7 pm

Glendale Public Library
222 East Harvard Street
Glendale, CA 91205

FREE event cosponsored by the Friends of the Glendale Public Library, the
Glendale Bar Assn and the Armenian Bar Assn.

Refreshments.

³The defendant is acquitted at the expense of the state treasury. In
accordance with the decision of the jury, the defendant is not guilty of the
punishable act with which he has been charged.²

The charge was murder. The defendent, Misak Torlakian, shot Bibhub Khan
Javanshir outside the Per Palace Hotel in Constantinople (Istanbul) on July
18, 1921, yet he was found not guilty. The Case of Misak Torlakian, a new
book by Attorney Vartkes Yeghiayan and Ara Arabyan, reveals the trial
transcript concerning the Armenian Ottoman subject who was tried and
aquitted by a British Military Court on the charge of murdering the
Ex-Minister of the Interior of Azerbaijan.

The book provides an examination of the legal process of a British Military
Court after the Armenian genocide. History, theology, philosophy,
physiology, psychology and politics were used by the attorneys during the
trial. As a result, the landmark legal case became not just a murder trial,
but also a study of the political, social and economic strategies in the
Middle East and a discussion of the rivalries between Armenians, Azeris,
Turks, the British and Bolsheviks for control of oil.

The author, Glendale attorney Vartkes Yeghiayan, recently reached a $20
million settlement between new York Life Insurance and the heirs of Armenian
genocide victims and Armenian charitable organizations.

Why Turks are growing disillusioned with Europe

Why Turks are growing disillusioned with Europe

The Financial Times
By Vincent Boland
Published: January 3 2007 22:52 | Last updated: January 3 2007 22:52

In 1933 Mustafa Kemal Atatürk, the father of modern Turkey, threw down a
tantalising challenge to his countrymen on the 10th anniversary of the
founding of the republic: `We shall raise our country to the level of the
most prosperous and civilised countries … we shall raise our national
culture above the level of contemporary civilisation,’ he said.

Atatürk, who died in 1938, bequeathed many exhortations to the Turks. Some
are pithy, some are apocryphal and one or two are even wise. They can be
found today in school textbooks and engraved on the walls of official
buildings. But the reference to `contemporary civilisation’ is more
ambiguous than most. It is generally assumed by Turks that he meant that
Turkey, once the heart of the Ottoman Empire, should become European. He
admired French republicanism and the British parliamentary system and under
his leadership Turkey adopted the weekend, western dress and an army on the
French model, beginning a journey westward that continues more than 80 years
later.
But the ambiguity of the remark, long overlooked, seems prophetic today.
Inside Turkey, the debate about `contemporary civilisation’ is as pertinent
now as it was in Atatürk’s time and this year will be critical in shaping
its outcome. Last year Turkey’s long-held ambition to join the European
Union suffered a head-on clash with reality. The negotiating process is now
partly frozen because of a dispute with Brussels over Cyprus.

Hostility in some EU countries to Turkey’s membership is increasing, while
support for membership among Turks is falling. This year, two events will
have a decisive impact on Turkey’s European ambition. Turkey’s parliament is
due to elect a new president in May in a process that could change the
country’s political dynamic, especially if Recep Tayyip Erdogan, the prime
minister, seeks the presidency (he has not ruled out such a move). Also,
parliamentary elections slated for November could usher in a coalition
government that lacks the singlemindedness with which Mr Erdogan’s ruling
neo-Islamist Justice and Development party has pursued EU membership.

By the end of 2007, Turkey’s relationship with Europe will not be decided
but it may be clarified. The elections will take place against a background
of a profound change in public consensus on the EU. When Turkey began its
accession process to join the EU in 2004, support for membership stood above
two-thirds. per cent, according to a recent opinion poll in Milliyet,
a Now it is about 35 daily newspaper. The decline is matched by rising
suspicion of the west more generally. The German Marshall Fund of the United
States, in its 2006 Transatlantic Trends survey, showed that Turkey’s
attitude towards the US, on a 100-point scale, declined from 28 in 2004 to
20 in 2006, and towards the EU from 52 to 45.

This about-turn in perceptions is shaking the faith of even the truest
believers in the country’s European destiny. Umit Boyner, a businesswoman
who heads a corporate initiative to promote Turkey in the EU, says: `Most of
us wanted to believe that the EU meant democracy and minority rights and
women’s rights and fighting corruption. Now we see this phobia about Turkey,
this feeling that we are not wanted by other Europeans, and we are asking
ourselves: `Is this really the Europe we believed in, or were we kidding
ourselves?”

The EU’s failure to honour a commitment to end the isolation of Turkish
Cypriots in northern Cyprus is the most obvious cause of this change in
sentiment. The recent vote in the lower house of the French parliament to
make it a crime to deny that the massacre of Armenians in 1915-16 was
genocide created much bitterness. It also led to a backlash against France,
perceived as the most formidable opponent of Turkey’s EU membership.

The EU’s constant focus on minority rights and the role of the armed forces,
mixed with the perception among large numbers of Turks of rising
Islamophobia in Europe, has added to the feeling that the EU is casting
around for an excuse to say a final No to Turkey’s membership. EU officials
insist, however, that the human and political rights of prospective members
are always closely scrutinised and that the door to Turkey remains open.

Cengiz Aktar, a professor and staunch pro-European at Bahcesehir University
in Istanbul, says the tone of the debate in some EU countries suggests that
Turkey is being made to address a question that no other member state has
had to address: whether it is a European country. `Nobody questions the
`Europeanness’ even of Cyprus, which is closer to the Middle East than
Ankara, but Turkey’s Europeanness is under question,’ he says.

Turkey is different from other aspiring EU member states in crucial
respects. Most of the formerly communist countries that have joined the EU
since the end of the cold war saw their destiny in Europe or were seduced by
Europe’s famed `soft power’ – its ability to persuade countries to transform
themselves, with the promise of membership, into stable democracies. This is
not the case with Turkey, a country with an embedded sense of identity based
on a distinctly hard nationalism inherited from Atatürk and the founders of
the republic through an ideology known as Kemalism.

Among its tenets are an unwavering belief in the soundness of Turkey’s
constitutional arrangements – which dictate a delicate balance between the
state and the citizen and parliament and the military – and fidelity to the
founding myths of the republic. These tenets are perceived, in some cases,
to be antithetical to European norms as set out in the Copenhagen Criteria –
a set of political objectives that aspiring EU members must achieve to get
in.

One of the most serious ideological clashes between Turkey and the EU
concerns the role of the military. Since 1923, Turkey’s armed forces have
seen themselves as the guardians of the republic and have staged four coups
d’état since the second world war (the fourth, in 1997, was a `post-modern
coup’ without actual tanks in the streets) as if to prove the point.

Turkey’s armed forces, a popular and monumentally self-important
institution, have agreed to greater civilian control of military affairs,
including budget supervision, as part of the EU process. But whether Turkey
is institutionally ready to accept a complete subordination of the military
to civilian authority, as the EU would require, is one of the central
ambiguities of the country’s European ambition. There are occasional signs
that the ostensibly pro-EU general staff is unconvinced that its vision of a
strong, centralised, sovereign Turkey is consistent with the country’s EU
membership.
If the military is undecided, so is the broad spectrum of public opinion.
For Turkey, joining the EU is a choice rather than a destiny. Because they
view it as a choice and see the decks increasingly stacked against them,
many are starting to rediscover their inner Kemalist. Turks are openly
questioning whether European norms or values are in any way superior to
those they already hold.
Kemalism may merely be a grander name for hard Turkish nationalism, suffused
with a strong sense of republicanism, sovereignty and self-reliance. But
whatever it is called, it is posing a direct challenge to the EU’s soft
power.

Sedat Laciner, director of the International Strategic Research
Organisation, a think-tank in Ankara, says Turkey’s experience of its EU
accession process is of a piece with its experience of other
western-inspired developments in Turkey’s neighbourhood in the past five
years – especially the invasion of Iraq, which remains hugely unpopular
among Turks, and the plight of the Palestinians. `All of these have changed
Turkish attitudes to the EU, with the result that the EU is losing the most
important tool in its arsenal, which is its ability to persuade Turkey to do
as it asks,’ Mr Laciner says.

Suat Kiniklioglu, director of the Ankara office of the German Marshall Fund
of the United States, sees a direct historical parallel between Turkey’s
most recent bout of suspicion of Europe and a similar attitude provoked in
the late 19th century by the agitation of foreign powers for minority rights
in the Ottoman Empire – which in practice would have given European citizens
living there almost colonial-style privileges.

The dynamic of Turkey’s relationship with the EU, where every aspect of its
modern identity and history appears to be a legitimate target for European
scrutiny and criticism, `is almost a replay of a time that invokes Turkey’s
worst fears about disintegration, about our unity being broken, about an
undue emphasis on minorities and people of non-Turkish stock,’ Mr
Kiniklioglu says. By `hitting Turkey on its most sensitive issues,’ he adds,
`the EU has overplayed its hand as far as the impact of its soft power is
concerned.’

The EU accession process has stimulated important reforms in Turkey – such
as changes to the country’s penal code and abolition of the death penalty.
But some commentators say the accession agreement between Turkey and the EU
contains the seeds of its own failure, because it does not offer Turks a
guarantee of membership. It is the first time such a pledge has been
withheld from a candidate country. Ahmet Evin, director of the Istanbul
Policy Centre at Sabanci University, says this fact compromises the EU’s
ability to use moral suasion to encourage Turkey to reform in the way that
would satisfy European public opinion. `The ability of the EU to Europeanise
Turkey is fatally undermined by this lack of commitment,’ he says.

A dialogue of the deaf would therefore appear to be preordained between
Turkey and Europe. A curious side-effect has been the manner in which
Turkish people are now turning on the EU with the message that `without
Turkey, the EU Erdogan has transformed his argument for Turkey’s membership
from is doomed’. Mr one of civil rights, economic stability and
greater democracy to one couched in religious and `civilisational’ terms.

Businesspeople are also increasingly likely to lecture the EU – as they did
at a recent World Economic Forum conference in Istanbul – about how Europe
needs Turkey’s young workforce, which is mainly unskilled, and its market,
which is large but relatively poor. Some observers say this argument is
indicative of the sometimes overblown notions Turks harbour about their
country’s strategic importance and urge a little modesty. `We have to
remember that we are the ones who want to join the club,’ Ms Boyner says.

Others say the basis of Turkey’s engagement with and understanding of the EU
needs to adapt to today’s realities. `The pro-EU argument in Turkey is
overstated by its supporters,’ says Ercan Uygur, professor of economics at
Ankara University. He says it was shaped initially by a lack of information
about the EU and now by a misunderstanding of what the EU might mean for
Turkey.

The EU is a choice for Turkey that should not be based on a
misunderstanding. `When it comes to a choice – an informed choice – most
Turks would still choose the European Union,’ Prof Uygur says.

aa70-0000779e2340.html

http://www.ft.com/cms/s/cec617aa-9b7b-11db-

Turkish PM warns sectarian tensions in Lebanon will affect region

Turkish prime minister warns sectarian tensions in Lebanon will affect
region

International Herald Tribune
The Associated Press
Wednesday, January 3, 2007

BEIRUT, Lebanon

Turkey’s prime minister warned that growing sectarian tensions in Lebanon
will affect the entire Middle East if left unchecked and offered to mediate
in the political crisis if asked by rival factions.
Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan arrived here on a one-day visit
for talks with feuding Lebanese leaders on the country’s deepening political
crisis.

Shortly after his arrival, Erdogan met with Lebanese premier Fuad Saniora
whose Western-backed government is facing increasing pressure in the form of
street protests led by Hezbollah and other opposition groups.

"I told Saniora that sectarian differences will leave repercussions on the
region," Erdogan told reporters.

"I also told him that all parties in Lebanon and all states in the region
must act to solve this problem," Erdogan said, stressing that a solution to
the Lebanese crisis should be reached through dialogue.

Erdogan’s visit came as the growing political and sectarian tensions among
Lebanese factions threaten to tear the country apart. It also came more than
a week after Arab League chief Amr Moussa said that his efforts have failed
to reach a solution to the crisis.

Tensions between pro- and anti-Syrian groups erupted when six pro-Hezbollah
Cabinet ministers resigned in November after Saniora rejected their demand
for a new national unity government that would give Hezbollah and its allies
a veto power on key Cabinet decisions.

Erdogan met Saniora who has been living at his office complex in central
Beirut amid a tight security cordon near the thousands of Hezbollah
supporters and allies camping nearby.

Erdogan, speaking in Turkish, said Turkey was not mediating in the Lebanese
crisis but was ready to do so if asked to help by feuding parties.

Saniora said because of its close ties with the Arab world, Turkey can play
"an important role" in promoting a solution to the Lebanese crisis.

"We stressed on stability in Lebanon and its impact on the region," he said.

Before meeting with Lebanon’s president and Parliament Speaker Nabih Berri,
a Hezbollah ally, Erdogan flew by a Turkish military helicopter to southern
Lebanon where he inspected Turkish troops serving with the U.N. peacekeeping
force known as UNIFIL. He reviewed an honor guard, thanked troops for their
service and had lunch with military officers.

Some 260 Turkish troops, deployed near the southern port city of Tyre, are
helping rebuild bridges and roads damaged in last summer’s war between
Hezbollah and Israel. Turkish officials said that the total number of
Turkish personnel in Lebanon would ultimately reach 681, including sailors
and engineers.

Erdogan also said he will meet later Wednesday with legislator Mohammed
Raad, head of Hezbollah’s 11-member parliamentary bloc.

While Erdogan was meeting Saniora, thousands of Armenians, raising Lebanese
and Armenian flags, gathered in the streets north of Beirut shouting slogans
against the Turkish premier’s visit, witnesses said. All shops in the
Armenian neighborhood of Bourj Hammoud north of Beirut closed for a couple
of hours.

"Turkey, Israel’s strategic ally, cannot keep peace in Lebanon," read a
placard by the protesters. The protesters dispersed peacefully but the
demonstration caused a traffic jam on Beirut’s northern highway.

Ahead of Erdogan’s arrival, about 100 Armenian citizens, waving Lebanese
flags, also gathered outside the Beirut airport to protest his visit.

In October, thousands from Lebanon’s 80,000-100,000 strong Armenian
community rallied in downtown Beirut to protest Turkish participation in the
U.N. peacekeeping force because they blame Turkey’s Ottoman rulers for the
mass killing of Armenians in the early 20th century.
Turkey, a U.S. ally and NATO’s only predominantly Muslim member, has close
ties to both Israel and Arab states.

hd-aj
/01/03/africa/ME_GEN_Lebanon_Turkey.php

http://www.iht.com/articles/ap/2007

Armenia eyes B2B opportunities with Canada

Foreign Affairs and International Trade, Canada
Dec 27 2006

Armenia eyes B2B opportunities with Canada

Toronto, January 18-20, 2007 > Armenia may be off the radar for many
Canadian exporters, but that just may change with Expo 2007, a
business-to-business exposition that is expected to attract hundreds
of Armenian exporters.

Today, the former Soviet republic boasts one of the fastest growing
markets in the Caucasus region, due in part to major economic
reforms.

`Armenia has one of the most liberal trade regimes in the world,’
says Vahram Pirjanian, President of the Canada Armenia Business
Council (CABC). This status is especially noteworthy given the
country’s hardships as a result of the collapse of the Soviet Union
in 1991. After the collapse, the economy was hit hard and its gross
domestic product per capita fell by 75%.

But 1994 marked a turning point, when Armenia’s government revamped
its fiscal and monetary policies which put the country on the road to
economic recovery.

And Canada has started to reap the benefits of this reform.
Information technology is one of Canada’s leading exports to Armenia
and Armenian exports to Canada are mainly comprised of finished
products and services such as jewellery, apparel, beverages and other
manufactured goods.

But Pirjanian believes more can be done to deepen Canada-Armenia
trade relations.

`In the past, questions always revolved around Armenia’s political
environment. Now, we are asked how and where to make investments in
Armenia. It is possible to invest in and trade with Armenian
businesses and make a profit, create jobs and increase exports. The
participation of so many businesses and representatives at Expo 2007
is a clear indication that greater trade opportunities exist.’

For more information, contact:
Vahram Pirjanian
CABC
Tel.: (416) 574-6704

rt/view.aspx?isRedirect=True&id=384713&lan guage=E

http://w01.international.gc.ca/canadexpo

Message of His Holiness Karekin II on the Holy Nativity

PRESS RELEASE
Mother See of Holy Etchmiadzin, Information Services
Address: Vagharshapat, Republic of Armenia
Contact: Rev. Fr. Ktrij Devejian
Tel: (374 10) 517 163
Fax: (374 10) 517 301
E-Mail: [email protected]
January 6, 2007

THE MESSAGE OF HIS HOLINESS KAREKIN II
SUPREME PATRIARCH AND CATHOLICOS OF ALL ARMENIANS
ON THE OCCASION OF THE FEAST OF
THE HOLY NATIVITY AND THEOPHANY OF JESUS CHRIST
Mother See of Holy Etchmiadzin, 06 January 2007

In the Name of the Father and the Son and the Holy Spirit. Amen.

"IF ANY ONE IS IN CHRIST, HE IS A NEW CREATION"
II Corinthians 5:17

Dearly Pious Faithful,

Today is the Feast of the Holy Nativity, the Feast of the Theophany of our
Lord and Savior Jesus Christ. The sacred mystery is great and wondrous,
which today we live once more. A new king is born in Bethlehem, for the
sake of renewed mankind and a new world, because "if any one is in Christ,
he is a new creation".

>From the Bethlehem of the Armenians – the altar of light Holy Etchmiadzin,
with soul-renewing emotions and joy, we extend to you the great tiding which
the angels gave to the shepherds more than two thousand years ago, "For to
you is born this day in the city of David a Savior, who is Christ the Lord."
(Luke 2:11).

The shepherds, with simple and pure hearts, recognized and worshipped the
Newborn Savior in the manger in Bethlehem; the wise magi presented gifts on
bended knee before His Divinity, Kingship and Priesthood. The arrival of
the Savior, previously testified to by the prophets, was proclaimed to all;
but it was not in all hearts that the birth of the Savior of the world – the
New King – was accepted with joy. With the intent of assassinating the
Newborn Jesus, Herod massacred the infants of Bethlehem. Yes, beloved, even
the incarnation and birth of the Son of God was accompanied by worship and
murder, the realities of peace and war, which beginning with Abel and Cain,
have taken parallel paths throughout the course of human history. The Child
born in the manger in Bethlehem came to change that course in the world with
the establishment of the New Covenant and the shedding of His blood. Christ
said, "This is my blood of the covenant, which is poured out for the many."
(Mark 14:24). The Savior came to free man from the snares of evil, from the
bonds of sin and death, and with His Divine strength, to restore him to
blessed heavenly glory. Christ brought new life to the world – a life of
the reborn, restored soul, through which man was to proceed toward God.
"And put on the new nature" – the apostle said, "the new nature created
after the likeness of God in true righteousness and holiness." (Ephesians
4:24).

The call to man to restore and improve, however, did not completely put an
end to the old man, nor the existence of old understandings, and evil did
not disappear from the earth. Today as well, underneath the nature of new
man often works the old man. Along with the pious worship of Christ by the
shepherds and magi, the evil acts of Herod also remain. The modern world,
characterized by the developing conditions, possibilities and abilities of
life, is yet not healed of miseries, calamities and wars; it is not free of
falsehood, jealousy and hate. Man ascended to the universe, but how far has
he risen in his inner spiritual world? The progress of science has
benefited the welfare of life, but how much also have the weapons of war
advanced? Indeed, modern scientific and technological accomplishments,
democracy, the rights and freedom of individuals and nations, – ideologies
proclaimed as supreme values – have remained inadequate to provide answers
to the issues and challenges facing mankind. They will continue to remain
inadequate if God does not live within us, if God does not work in our
lives, if importance is not placed on faith, holiness or the spiritual; and
on the contrary, when it is mocked instead. Efforts aimed at peace, justice
and philanthropy will be in vain, if we do not first appeal for God’s
beneficent Will and saving grace; if we do not fulfill the divine
commandment to love one another.

The apostle says, "Love never ends; as for prophecies, they will pass away;
as for tongues, they will cease; as for knowledge, it will pass away. For
our knowledge is imperfect and our prophecy is imperfect." (I Corinthians
13:8-9). All of mankind’s knowledge is incomplete, and has changed
throughout time and will continue to change; but it is love which never
ends. Love is always constant – it is perfect, "it is not irritable or
resentful, it does not rejoice at wrong, but rejoices in the right". All of
us, nations and peoples, have one holy and life-giving inheritance – the
love of God for us, His creation. God loves us all, regardless of race,
nationality, creed, sex or age. The testimony of this perfect love is the
revelation of the Savior on earth. Only by being led with that same spirit
of love shall mankind be new, and renew the world in the process. We
Christians have the promise and belief that "if any one is in Christ, he is
a new creation".

Dearly beloved Armenians, let us receive with gladness and gratitude our
gift of salvation – the Incarnate Son of God. Relying on Him, with fairness
and brotherhood, and as new men, let us build the new life of Armenia and
Artsakh; and keep our national life in the Dispersion strong, hopeful and
filled with the breath of the homeland. With the Savior, we shall not fear
difficulties nor obstacles, and our efforts will not be in vain, rather they
shall bring sweet successes to our homeland and Diaspora in renaissance.
With pan-national unity and the liberating love of our Lord, we shall defend
the just right of our people in Artsakh to live free; and with renewing
faith, we shall manifest and call to life all our aspirations and hopes for
the future. Therefore, let us keep the apostolic holy faith of our
forefathers untainted, and by their example, let us create that which is
permanent and enduring.

On the soul-renewing feast of the Holy Nativity of our Lord and Savior, with
Christ-bequeathed love, we extend our fraternal greetings to the spiritual
heads of our Sister Churches; to the incumbents of the hierarchal sees of
our Apostolic Holy Church, His Holiness Aram I, Catholicos of the Great
House of Cilicia; His Beatitude Archbishop Torkom Manoogian, Armenian
Patriarch of Jerusalem; and His Beatitude Archbishop Mesrob Mutafian,
Armenian Patriarch of Constantinople. We express our Pontifical blessings
and love to the devoted ranks of clergy of our Church and all our people
dispersed throughout the world.

With the glad tiding of the Holy Nativity, we greet the President of the
Republic of Armenia, Mr. Robert Kocharian; President of the Republic of
Nagorno Karabagh, Mr. Arkady Ghukasian; all state officials of the
Armenians; and leaders and representatives of diplomatic missions accredited
to Armenia.

Dearly pious faithful, let us pray before the cradle of the Newborn Savior,
that the souls of men be renewed by His limitless graces, and that the lives
of people be directed along the paths of mercy, peace, justice and true
brotherhood.

Let us appeal for our Lord and Savior to protect our people reinforced with
faith, and bless our labors and efforts for the glory of His Holy Name, for
the love and welfare of our homeland and nation dispersed throughout the
world, and for the vibrancy of our Holy Church. Amen.

Christ is Born and Revealed.
Great Tidings to You and Us.

Azerbaijan’s President Turns Down Gazprom’s `Blackmail’ Price

Eurasia Daily Monitor

January 5, 2007 — Volume 4, Issue 4

AZERBAIJAN’S PRESIDENT TURNS DOWN GAZPROM’S `BLACKMAIL’ PRICE

by Vladimir Socor

Azerbaijan has ceased importing gas from Russia as of January 1.
Despite the anticipated shortage of gas in the country — compounded by an
unanticipated production delay at the international Shah Deniz gas
project — Azerbaijan has refused to pay $235 per 1,000 cubic meters of
Gazprom-delivered gas in 2007. President Ilham Aliyev turned down such
`commercial blackmail,’ telling the Russian media, `I cannot allow that to
happen. Azerbaijan is no longer the kind of state that can be forced into
anything’ (Ekho Moskvy, December 23).

Gazprom’s final proposal to Azerbaijan in late December increased the
volume offer from 1.5 billion cubic meters of gas to 2.5 billion cubic
meters for 2007, though still far below last year’s 4.5 billion cubic
meters. And it raised the asking price to $235 per 1,000 cubic meters for
2007, compared with the $110 price charged to Azerbaijan, Armenia, and
Georgia in 2006. Moscow left the price unchanged for Armenia in 2007 in
return for property takeovers in that country; but it more than doubled the
price to Azerbaijan and also to Georgia, which ruled out property transfers
to Russia.

President Aliyev, Industry and Energy Minister Natig Aliyev, and State
Oil Company president Rovnag Abdullayev all declared publicly in the closing
days of the year that Azerbaijan would not accept arbitrary overpricing or a
politically motivated price. Indeed, geopolitics largely motivates Moscow’s
decisions to raise the price and slash the volume of gas deliveries to
Azerbaijan. The goal is to prevent the latter from helping Georgia to resist
Moscow’s twin threats of supply cuts and extortionate pricing.

Azerbaijan currently extracts some 5 billion cubic meters of gas
annually and the international oil-producing consortium extracts some 2
billion cubic meters of associated gas. The country’s annual requirement is
10 to 11 billion cubic meters. Azerbaijan will use some internally produced
gas, as well as fuel oil, instead of Russian-delivered gas, to generate
electricity. Almost all of Azerbaijan’s electricity-generating capacities
operate on gas, but a large part can also operate on the more expensive fuel
oil.

To obtain that fuel oil, Azerbaijan must redirect some volume of crude
oil from export to refining in the country. It will definitely not redirect
any volume from the Baku-Tbilisi-Ceyhan pipeline, but rather from the line
that runs to Russia’s Novorossiysk Black Sea port. That pipeline handled
some 4 to 4.5 million tons of oil from Azerbaijan per year in 2005 and 2006,
some of it from the international consortium and some from Azerbaijan’s
state company. The international consortium’s share in using that pipeline
has grown in late 2006 due to technical problems on the BP-operated
Baku-Supsa (Georgia) pipeline — a situation that seems to persist.
Azerbaijan can shift some of that volume into the pipeline to Ceyhan and
another portion for in-country refining, producing fuel oil to generate
electricity.

Technical problems are also causing a further delay of the start of
commercial production at the BP-operated Shah Deniz giant gas field, the
source of the Baku-Tbilisi-Erzurum (Turkey) pipeline. Planned for mid-2006
and postponed into December, that production start has again been postponed
for `some weeks’ due to a leak at the first well, deep under water. Three
other wells are due on stream shortly. The delay has complicated the gas
supply situation for 2007 in Azerbaijan and especially in Georgia. The first
gas deliveries from Shah Deniz had been scheduled to reach Georgia in
September 2006, then rescheduled for December 20. The postponement has been
a factor in forcing Georgia at the end of December to sign a contract with
Gazprom, buying gas at the extortionate price of $235 per 1,000 cubic
meters, as a stop-gap solution to survive the winter.

Both Azerbaijan and Georgia have considered the possibility of
emergency imports of Iranian gas in small volume to tide them over the
winter. In Azerbaijan’s case, Iran was willing at the end of December to
supply 1.8 billion cubic meters of gas in 2007, but the talks on the price
were inconclusive. In January-February 2006, Azerbaijan transited small but
critical volumes of Iranian gas to Georgia through the Astara-Gazi
Mahomed-Gazakh pipeline during the Russian energy blockade of Georgia.
Recalling that situation recently, U.S. Deputy Assistant Secretary of State
Matt Bryza declared in Tbilisi that no one can `tell Georgia to refuse
buying Iranian gas and freeze in winter.’

The winter of 2006-2007 is almost certainly the final opportunity for
Russia to exert leverage on Azerbaijan and Georgia through manipulation of
energy supplies. Clearly, this form of leverage has lost its effectiveness
thanks to the direct availability of Caspian supplies to Azerbaijan and
Georgia. By next winter, both countries should have become completely immune
to Moscow’s use of the energy trade as a pressure tool.

(ANS, APA, Turan, Interfax, December 23-30, January 3; see EDM,
December 8)

–Vladimir Socor

ANKARA: Diyarbakir district goes bilingual

New Anatolian, Turkey
Jan 5 2007

Diyarbakir district goes bilingual

The New Anatolian / Ankara
05 January 2007

A municipal council decision to offer municipal services in both
Turkish and Kurdish has been approved by the Sur district
Municipality of the southeastern city of Diyarbakir, reports said
yesterday.

The decision is likely to fuel tension in the region, as it is
clearly in violation of the Constitution, according to several
political commentators.

Sur Mayor Abdullah Demirbas last year faced prosecution for defending
multilingual municipal services at an international conference in
Vienna. Charges against him were dropped on the grounds of freedom of
expression, but the Interior Ministry severely criticized the move by
Demirbas.

It is said that the Sur Municipality as well as the Diyarbakir
Greater Municipality started multilingual services last year without
an official decision to ease transactions by Kurdish people in the
city.

Speaking at a press conference organized by the Sur Municipality,
Demirbas touted the news while arguing that Turkey, in practice, is
not monolingual but multilingual.

He also underlined that the decision was taken by a majority vote.
"We don’t have only one identity but multiple identities, we have to
live considering this fact," he explained. "We’ll give services
taking all studies and scientific data into account as we aim to
contribute to democracy in the region and the country."

Demirbas also said that they took the decision based on the belief
that municipalities and local administrations are also "schools for
further democracy."

Kurdish politicians in the region, spearheaded by Diyarbakir Mayor
Osman Baydemir, fiercely advocate further rights for local
administrations, which sporadically find support from the government.
The ruling Justice and Development (AK) Party had a long-term project
to invest further rights to local authorities, reducing the power and
authority of the central administration, but it has failed to
implement necessary phases of this project during its four years in
office.

"I hope this decision will be an example for Parliament," Demirbas
said. "I believe that Parliament will regard the multilingual and
multicultural structure of Turkey and take a decision that will
contribute to peace and democracy in the country. We think that
democracy will improve on a local basis."

The mayor added that through their decision, which is a first in
Turkey, municipal services will reach the public easier. "Both
Turkish and Kurdish have been used in the municipality before. In
order to give a better service we’ll give Kurdish, Turkish, English,
Armenian and Assyrian courses to personnel," Demirbas said.

Sociologist Aslan Ozdemir stated that they conducted a survey upon
the request of the Sur Municipality. According to the survey results,
24 percent of the residents speak Turkish, while 72 percent speak
Kurdish. "Therefore, the municipal services should be given in
various languages apart from Turkish," Ozdemir said.

Dunwoody Symposium focuses on Genocide

Duluth Weekly, GA
Jan 5 2007

Dunwoody Symposium focuses on Genocide

DUNWOODY, GA (January 4, 2007) – Incidents of genocide from more than
90 years of 20th century history will be explored during `Never
Again,’ Georgia Perimeter College’s annual Dunwoody Symposium to be
held from Tuesday, Jan. 23 to Thursday, Jan. 25 on the Dunwoody
campus. All symposium events are open to the public and will be held
in room 1100 of the C building.

A collection of more than 20 speakers, moderators and panelists,
including Emory University’s Dr. Deborah Lipstadt, author of `Beyond
Belief: The American Press and the Coming of the Holocaust,’ and the
Atlanta Journal Constitution’s Mark Bixler, author of `The Lost Boys
of Sudan,’ will examine the episodes, significance and the psychology
of genocide during the three-day symposium.

`We’ll talk about Armenia in World War I, look at genocide in
World War II and other events in the 20th century,’ said Dr. Thomas
Graham, GPC history professor and an organizer of the symposium.
`We’ll look at everything from 1915 up to three or four years ago.’

Along with speakers, presentations and panels discussions, Graham
said `Never Again’ will also show a collection of films including one
that inspired this year’s symposium.

`The theme for this year’s symposium is something I came up with
last summer in the middle of the night while I was watching `Judgment
at Nuremburg,’ Graham said. `The film came out 40 years ago. The
Nuremburg Trials took place 60 years ago. Our focus is to reflect on
the 60th anniversary of the trials in Nuremberg and Tokyo and how the
promise of `never again’ was not fulfilled. I thought this would be a
good idea for this year’s symposium. We just have to get students out
of their apathy. We can’t let this happen again.’

Speakers, panelists, and films were selected to help participants
`question broad themes of historical and philosophical significance,’
said Dr. Randy Finley, who serves as a symposium organizer.

`For example,’ Finley adds, `why do genocides occur in the modern
and postmodern world? What are the economic, political, and social
causes of genocide? Are they inevitable? Are there signs that might
indicate an oncoming genocide? Are there international organizations
that can successfully combat genocide?’

Finley said selected panelists include representatives of history,
science, business, law, music, cinematography, art, psychology and
political science.

`All will bring their academic fields’ interests in the subject
for student thought and reflection,’ he said.

The Dunwoody Symposium which began in 1980 is an annual event that
has featured such prominent speakers as former President Jimmy
Carter, Ted Turner, historian Arthur Schlesinger, Jr., entrepreneur
Truett Cathy, novelist Peter Taylor, and poet James Dickey.

`We’re excited about beginning the spring 2007 semester with the
symposium,’ Finley said. `Questions discussed here in January should
reverberate through many disciplines throughout the academic year.’

Headbangers Against Genocide: System of a Down

Foreign Policy In Focus
Jan 5 2007

Headbangers Against Genocide
John Feffer, IRC | January 4, 2007

Editor: Chuck Hosking, IRC

John Dolmayan, Daron Malakian, Shavo Odadjian, and Serj Tankian of
System of a Down

Thousands of young people with long hair and studded tongues pay good
money several dozen times a year to listen to lectures about
genocide. Well, `lecture’ is perhaps not the best way to describe
Serj Tankian’s delivery. The tall lanky Tankian, who has cascades of
curly hair and looks like the long-lost offspring of Frank Zappa and
Cher, is a natural on stage. But when he grabs the microphone, he is
more likely to shout than to talk.

Serj Tankian is the lead singer of System of a Down, a popular rock
group on the cusp of heavy metal. SOAD, as its fans like to call it,
is part of a new generation of politically engaged rock groups. Like
Rage Against the Machine or Green Day, SOAD produces some rousing
antiwar songs (like `BYOB’ with its chorus of `Why don’t presidents
fight the war? Why do they always send the poor?’). But the group
also has a very specific political goal: to educate the world about
the Armenian genocide.

A new documentary, Screamers, tells the story of the 1915 genocide
through the words, music, and activism of the four Armenian-American
members of System of a Down. The film comes at a particularly
important time. Despite repeated public avowals of `never again’ by
many government leaders – after Bosnia, after Rwanda – genocide is again
in the headlines because of Darfur. And Turkey continues to evade
responsibility for the Armenian genocide even as it attempts to join
the European Union and cement its alliances with the United States.

Screamers, as genocide expert Samantha Powers explains in the film,
are people who react viscerally to the horror of atrocity and won’t
stop screaming until something is done about it. The raw energy of
System of a Down clearly resonates with its audience. But will such
musical activism make waves outside the concert halls as well?

Political Metal
Heavy metal, according to convention, is all about Satan, death, and
doom. It is a musical form about as far removed from politics and
foreign policy as a lullaby or a mazurka.

Dig a little deeper, though, and even heavy metal turns out to be
more complicated than that. Ozzy Osbourne’s Black Sabbath, for
instance, would seem to be the epitome of reactionary, white-boy
rock. Long before his reality show resurrection, however, Ozzy took
aim at the Vietnam War in the song `War Pigs’ and blasted the
insanity of Cold War deterrence in the song `Children of the Grave.’
Today, heavy metal bands wear their politics even more prominently on
the sleeves of their black T-shirts. Bands like Lamb of God write
songs castigating U.S. foreign policy, while Cattle Decapitation
takes on the protein industrial complex.

It’s one thing to rile up an audience of recruitment-age young people
with songs about the idiocy of the Iraq War. System of a Down,
however, aims at the more difficult goal of activating young people
around an event that occurred nearly a century ago. In 2005, during a
concert tour devoted to the 90th anniversary of the Armenian
genocide, the band put photographs of the atrocities on the big
screen in the concert hall and ran TV footage of Peter Jennings
discussing the meaning and contemporary significance of the term
`genocide.’

`Today, more people learn about the Armenian genocide from System of
a Down than through all the other efforts combined,’ says Aram
Hamparian of the Armenian National Committee.

And it’s not just Armenians or the descendants of other genocide
victims (Jews, Cambodians) who groove to SOAD’s message. Although the
band refuses to play in Turkey, Serj Tankian reports, `We have a lot
of fans there. We’ve gotten into the heads of some of the younger
generation, and hopefully something will happen one day with that.’

For SOAD, the crusade is deeply personal. In Screamers, the band
members each relate stories passed down from their grandparents and
great grandparents about who survived, who didn’t, and the
unspeakable things that were witnessed. Scholars estimate that 1.5
million Armenians died during the genocide. `A whole race, Genocide.
Taken away, all our pride,’ SOAD sings in `PLUCK.’

There’s Something About Turkey
The stakes reach well beyond settling personal scores or even setting
the historical record straight. System of a Down is very clear about
the geopolitics of its work. Throughout the Cold War, Turkey fended
off all outside pressure to alter its policies – regarding Cyprus, its
mistreatment of Kurds, or its interpretation of its national
history – by emphasizing its anticommunist credentials. With the Cold
War over and membership in the European Union beckoning, Turkey has
been willing to make some concessions, such as abolishing the death
penalty and providing more rights to the Kurdish community. But
diplomatic recognition of Cyprus is still off the table, and the
Armenian genocide remains a forbidden topic.

Several prominent Turkish writers, including Nobel Prize-winner Orhan
Pamuk, have run afoul of the authorities for merely mentioning the
genocide. One of the first Turkish historians to grapple honestly
with the issue has published a new book on the genocide – from his
exile in Minnesota. In A Shameful Act: The Armenian Genocide and the
Question of Turkish Responsibility, Taner Akcam argues that
acknowledging the true nature of what happened in 1915 would require
accepting that the architects of modern Turkey were war criminals. In
her New Yorker review, Elizabeth Kolbert calls Akcam’s psychological
explanation `a view of Turkish ethnic pride that gets dangerously
close to a national stereotype.’ Given that most U.S. citizens are
similarly unwilling to associate the establishment of the United
States with the attempted eradication of Native Americans – and that
related complexes flourish in Australia, Israel, and many other
countries – Akcam has not so much fallen back on an ethnic stereotype
as he has articulated a more general psychological trait: the
universal impulse to deny the horrors that lie beneath all
nation-building.

Turkish efforts to stifle discussion on the Armenian genocide extend
far beyond the country’s borders. Peter Balakian describes in his
landmark book Black Dog of Fate how the Turkish Embassy intervened in
a textbook project convened by the New York State Department of
Education. Embassy officials told the organizers of the textbook
project on 20th century genocides that inclusion of a chapter on the
Armenian genocide would jeopardize U.S.-Turkey relations. `I traveled
to Albany several times … and sat in overheated offices imploring
state bureaucrats, who were horrified by the Turkish assault, to hold
firm on the chapter,’ writes Balakian, a professor of English at
Colgate University. `The Turkish contingent was threatening to call
President Reagan. Letters went back and forth. The Education
Department grew increasingly befuddled. Before it was over, the
Turkish government had succeeded in forcing changes to the textbook.’

At a much higher level of politics, as Screamers documents, the
Turkish government has lobbied the U.S. Congress to prevent the
passage of a resolution on the Armenian genocide. Although the House
International Relations Committee passed two resolutions in 2005
identifying the atrocities as genocide, the Republican-controlled
leadership blocked passage in the House as a whole. With Nancy Pelosi
and the Democrats now in charge, however, there is a good chance that
the resolutions will be brought to the floor and passed.

The Politics of Screaming
Unlike many largely forgotten atrocities, the Armenian genocide is
well documented. The accounts of survivors and contemporary
observers, the photographic evidence, and even documentation from the
Ottoman leadership itself make it impossible to dispute the attempt
to wipe out an entire race of people. Historians are still filling in
the gaps and piecing together motivations. Books like Black Dog of
Fate or Atom Egoyan’s exquisite film Ararat about the Armenian artist
Arshile Gorky explore the impact of the genocide on subsequent
generations.

However, these historical investigations take place in academe. The
books and movies are powerful but are ultimately, like most high
culture, understated and nuanced.

System of a Down is not interested in nuance or understatement. The
band members are passionate and angry, and they scream out shocking
lyrics often full of expletives. When Serj Tankian visits Congress to
lobby legislators, he seems, without a microphone and an opportunity
to raise his voice, like a fish out of water. But with Turkey still
playing the geopolitical card by threatening to stop buying U.S. arms
and hosting the U.S. military, a little screaming might be in
order – not just in concert halls but in the halls of power as well.

Links to songs about genocide:
System of a Down: PLUCK ()

Blowback: For Whom the Bells Toll
( .blowback.org/songs/songs_forwhomthebellstoll.html )

REM: The Flowers of Guatemala
( owers+of+guatemala_20115263.html)

Rage Against the Machine: Sleep Now in the Fire
( t-The-Machine/Sleep-Now-In-The-Fire.html)

Indigo Girls: This Train Revised
( ngUnid/42003E9E487244B0482568D8000EF51D)

RX Bandits: In All Rwanda’s Glory
( rwandasglory.html)

Kronos Quartet and Steve Reich: Different Trains
( rte_seesko.html)

Also see Adam Jones, `Ten Great Songs About Genocide’

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/P.L.U.C.K.
http://www.blowback.org/site.html?http://www
http://www.lyricsfreak.com/r/rem/the+fl
http://www.seeklyrics.com/lyrics/Rage-Agains
http://www.sing365.com/music/lyric.nsf/So
http://www.lyricscafe.com/r/rxbandits/inall
http://www.uni-oldenburg.de/musik/video/ga
http://www.fpif.org/fpiftxt/3869

TBILISI: Ethnic Armenians demand 5 member quota in de facto parl.

Daily Georgian Times, Georgia
Jan 5 2007

Ethnic Armenians demand 5 member quota in de facto parliament

Ethnic Armenians are seriously preparing for the upcoming elections
of the de facto Abkhazian parliament scheduled for 4 March. At
present the Abkhazian parliament of 35 MPs has only one Armenian MP,
Galust Trapizonyan.

Armenian Diaspora in Abkhazia has filed a requiest in Abkhazian
government in which he demands five member quota in Abkhazian
parliament, which will be represented by Armenians.

Experts tie the strengthening of Armenian Diaspora in Abkhazia to the
weakened positions of de facto president Baghapsh, who has a serious
rival in the election race, vice-president Raul Khajimba. Khajimba is
Moscow’s favourite and in fact governs the unrecognized republic.
Baghapsh, predicting possible defeat in the upcoming elections, has
no other way but to rely on the support of ethnic Armenians, who
represent the majority of the breakaway region’s population.