Murder of Turkish-Armenian Journalist

Focus News Agency, Bulgaria
Jan 20 2007

Murder of Turkish-Armenian Journalist /REVIEW/

20 January 2007 | 19:02 | FOCUS News Agency

Istanbul. The murder of Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink
shocked the world. He was killed on Friday night. Dink, 52, was a
Christian of Armenian descent. He was frequently criticized by
Turkish nationalists, including politicians and prosecutors, for
saying the mass killing of Armenians by Ottoman Turks during World
War One was genocide. He received threats by nationalists who
considered him a betrayer. According to the information, the
journalist was killed in central Istanbul on his way to the office of
the weekly Turkish-Armenian newspaper Agos. The suspected murderer is
a young man aged about 18 or 19 who fired point-blank three or four
bullets.
The police arrested eight people. The analyses of the fired
cartridges from the site of the murder revealed that the patrons’
calibre was 7,65 mm and the weapon had not been used in other crimes.
At the order of Turkish Prime Minister Erdogan, the Interior Minister
ant the Justice Minister went to Istanbul.

The murder stirred violent reactions.
Turkey’s President Ahmet Necdet Sezer described it as an `inhuman
act’ stressing that such activities would never reach their goal.
Turkey’s Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan said the murder was `an
attack against the peace and stability’ of the country and promised
that the perpetrators would be arrested. Erdogan called on the people
and especially the Turkish citizens of Armenian descent for calm.
Turkey’s Parliament Speaker Bulent Arinc stated that the crime
wouldn’t break Turkey’s unity and calm no matter who and with what
purpose committed it.

The spokesman of the US Department of State Tom Casey said the murder
of Hrant Dink was a `tragic incident’ and described it as
`concerning’. He reminded that Dink had received threats for his
writing.
"Certainly we never want to see a situation in which individuals are
intimidated or in fact suffer retribution of any kind simply for
freely expressing their views," Casey said.

The EU Enlargement Commissioner Olli Rehn said he was `shocked’ by
the murder. "I am shocked and saddened by this brutal act of
violence.", a statement by Rehn on the assassination of the
journalist reads. `Hrant Dink was a respected intellectual who
defended his views with conviction and contributed to an open public
debate. He was a campaigner for freedom of expression in Turkey.’

Nuncio to Ankara: Assassination of Hrant Dink, an affront to Turkey

AsiaNews, Italy
Jan 20 2007

Nuncio to Ankara: "The assassination of Hrant Dink, an affront to
Turkey"

by Mavi Zambak

After assassination of the journalist of Armenian origin in Istanbul,
spontaneous demonstrations on the streets of many cities demand
`truth and freedom’. Suspicion falls on groups of nationalist
fanatics, who roam the country; but still nothing official.

Ankara (AsiaNews) – Yesterday 10 thousand gathered in Taksim,
Istanbul’s most famous square, were they remain all night to show
their sorrow at the death of the journalist of Armenian origin Hrant
Dink shot dead in the afternoon, as he left the offices of the Agos
weekly magazine, of which he was founding editor. A long procession
left the doorstep decorated with flowers and candles in suffrage of
the victim.

Armenians and exponents of the left remained in disconcerted silence
as they led a torchlight procession with banners and photographs of
their friend and intellectual. The recurrent slogan: `We are all
Hrant Dink, we are all Armenians, searching for the truth and freedom
‘, pronounced even by those who were not Armenian but defended and
supported the same ideals of the Turkish Journalist of Armenian
origin. Similar scenes in the principal squares of Ankara, Bursa and
Smirne, where over 150 thousand people gathered spontaneously, mainly
students and supporters of the Left.

The common opinion is that this murder was a provocation and had a
destabilising political motivation, carried out by one of the many
extreme right groups, nationalist fanatics, who roam the country
freely undisturbed. However no-one has yet come forward with an
hypothesis or name. As with the murder of Don Andrea the police
immediately began the hunt for a young man, as fate would have it
also a minor, possibly identified thanks to a video camera positioned
outside a shop beside the Agos office. So far 8 people have been
detained on suspicion.

The unanimous chorus from the daily newspapers and television
channels states that it is not only a man that has been put to death,
but Turkish society , that society which seeks fraternity, peaceful
democracy and freedom of thought. The Nuncio in Ankara is of the
same opinion, msgr. Antonio Lucibello: `It is a low blow for all
Turkey, one body has not been hit but the entire fabric of Turkish
society, at a point of time when it is consolidating democracy and
searching for a common course for the various components that make up
the country. During the week of prayer for Christian Unity – adds
the prelate – we cannot but unite ourselves to the sorrow of our
brothers, showing them our solidarity and closeness. We hope in the
deepest of our hearts that this will not alter the pacific climate
that was created by the Pope’s visit, between the faithful and the
leaders of the different religions and Christian confessions present
on Turkish soil’.

Before this `barbarous, disloyal and vile assassination ‘,
theArmenian Patriarch Mesrob II has announced 15 days of mourning for
the over 80 thousand Armenians in Turkey as well as those living
abroad.

Bullet ‘fired at freedom of thought’

Globe and Mail, Canada
Jan 20 2007

Bullet ‘fired at freedom of thought’
ESTANISLAO OZIEWIC and NICHOLAS BIRCH

Globe and Mail Update

TORONTO and ISTANBUL – One of the most prominent members of Turkey’s
dwindling Armenian community was shot dead outside his newspaper
office in central Istanbul yesterday in an attack the Turkish Prime
Minister said was aimed at destabilizing the country.

"A bullet was fired at freedom of thought and democratic life," Prime
Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan said, shortly after Hrant Dink was shot
several times from behind outside Agos, the bilingual
Armenian-Turkish newspaper he edited.

The slaying brought into brutal relief Turkey’s roiling relationship
with its ethnic Armenian citizens over painful and wildly divergent
memories of a brutal past.

The controversy over whether mass killings of Armenians by Ottoman
Turks in 1915 constituted genocide has spilled far beyond Turkey and
Europe, which is considering Turkey’s entry into its union.

In Canada, Prime Minister Stephen Harper’s government has both
formally recognized that a genocide occurred and, in a seeming
contradiction, supported Istanbul’s proposal for a fresh study of
those events.

Taro Alepian, chairman of the Congress of Canadian Armenians, said in
a statement that Mr. Dink’s assassination "should now be transformed
into an opportunity for reconciliation between the people of Turkey
and Armenians around the world."

Mr. Alepian said extremists who killed Mr. Dink should not be allowed
to have the final word.

"This was an organized attempt by those who want to destroy Turkey’s
European Union aspirations and cast Turkey into darkness," said Akin
Birdal, former head of Turkey’s Human Rights Association, himself
shot and severely wounded in 1998 by suspected nationalists.

Turkey has long maintained that the deaths nearly a century ago were
caused by civil strife, diseases and famine during the collapse of
the Ottoman Empire. And it has prosecuted Mr. Dink and others for
daring to question the official state denial that the genocide
occurred.

In October, 2005, Mr. Dink was convicted of trying to influence the
judiciary after Agos ran stories criticizing a law making it a crime
to denigrate Turkey, the Turkish government or the Turkish national
character. He was given a six-month suspended sentence.

They were the same charges that had been levelled at Nobel
prize-winning novelist Orhan Pamuk.

Amnesty International said yesterday that official attitudes in
Turkey and laws suppressing freedom of speech give rise to violence.

"These laws, coupled with the persisting official statements by
senior government, state and military officials condemning critical
debate and dissenting opinion, create an atmosphere in which violent
attacks can take place," said Amnesty’s Nicola Duckworth.

Mr. Dink, a frequent target of Turkish nationalist anger over his
defence of freedom of speech, had been complaining of death threats
for weeks. "My computer’s memory is loaded with sentences full of
hatred and threats," he wrote in his Agos column on Jan. 10.

One e-mail threatening his children worried him particularly, he
wrote, adding that police had taken no action after he complained.

Set up in 1996, the weekly Agos was the fruit of his belief that only
dialogue could resolve the bitter memories of the 1915 events.

In fact, Mr. Dink was vehemently opposed to a proposed French law
that would imprison anyone who publicly denies that the massacre of
Armenians was a genocide.

"I have been tried in Turkey for saying the Armenian genocide exists,
and I have talked about how wrong this is," Mr. Dink said in an
interview with CNN-Turk last year. "But if this bill becomes law, I
will be one of the first to head to France and break the law. Then we
can watch Turkey and the French government race to see which will
throw me in jail first."

His slaying comes at a crucial time for Turkey, which is preparing
itself for presidential and parliamentary elections later this year.

It also coincides with growing EU pressure on Turkey to resolve
continuing problems with its minorities. Last week, the European
Court of Human Rights ordered Turkey to pay 900,000 in damages to a
Turkish Greek religious foundation whose Istanbul property had been
confiscated by the state.

A law that would have helped Greek, Armenian and Jewish minorities
win back confiscated properties was vetoed last year by Turkish
President Ahmet Necdet Sezer.

Over the past week, Turkish newspapers have been full of reports that
the new Democrat-weighted U.S. Congress may recognize the Armenian
genocide.

Murat Celikkan, a friend of Mr. Dink’s, said he was one of the few
who dared speak out.

"The fact that he spoke for peace and brotherhood makes no difference
to the people who did this. Because this is a country where hate
speech is not stamped out, but promoted."

A crowd gather in front of Mr. Dink’s office and chanted, "Shoulder
to shoulder against fascism," and "We are all Hrant, we are all
Armenians."

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

"The Pigeon-like Unease of My Inner Spirit" by Hrant Dink AGOS

Nouvelles d’Arménie, France
Jan 20 2007

"The Pigeon-like Unease of My Inner Spirit" by Hrant Dink AGOS
Newspaper 10 January 2007 (translated by F.M. Gocek)

samedi 20 janvier 2007, Stéphane/armenews

I did not at first feel troubled about the investigation that was
filed against me by the Sisli public prosecutor’s office with the
accusation of `insulting Turkishness.’

This was not the first time. I had been familiar to the accusation
because of a similar lawsuit I had filed against me in Urfa . I was
being tried in Urfa with the accusation of `denigrating Turkishness’
over the past three years for having stated in a talk I gave at a
conference there in 2002 that `I was not a Turk…but from Turkey and
an Armenian.’

And I was even unaware about how the lawsuit was proceeding. I was
not at all interested. My lawyer friends in Urfa were attending the
hearings in my absence.

I was even quite nonchalant when I went and gave my deposition to the
ªiºli public prosecutor. I ultimately had complete trust in what my
intentions had been and what I had written. Once the prosecutor [had
the chance] to evaluated not that single sentence from my editorial
alone which made no sense by itself but the text as a whole, he would
understand with great ease that I had no intention to `denigrate
Turkishness’ and this comedy would come to an end.

I was certain that a lawsuit would not be filed at the end of the
investigation. I was sure of myself. But surprise ! A lawsuit was
filed.

But I still did not lose my optimism.

So much so that at a television show that I joined live, I even told
the lawyer [Kemal] Kerincsiz who was accusing me `that he should not
get his hopes too high, that I was not going to be smacked with any
sentence from this lawsuit, and that I would leave this country if I
received a sentence.’ I was sure of myself because I truly had not
had in my article any premeditation or intention – not even a single
iota – to denigrate Turkishness. Those who read the entirety of my
collection of articles would understand this very clearly.

As a matter of fact, the report prepared by the three faculty members
from Istanbul University who had been appointed by the court as
experts stated exactly that. There was no reason for me to get
troubled, there would certainly be a return from the wrongful path
[of the lawsuit] at one stage of the proceedings or the other.

So I kept asking for patience…

But there was no such return.

The prosecutor asked for a sentence in spite of the expert report.
The judge then sentenced me to six months in prison.

When I first heard about my sentence, I found myself under the bitter
pressure of the hopes I had nurtured all along the process of the
lawsuit. I was bewildered… My disappointment and rebellion were at
their pinnacle.

I had resisted for days and months saying `just you wait for this
decision to come out and once I am acquitted, then you will all be so
repentant about all that you have said and written.’

In covering every hearing of the lawsuit, the newspapers items,
editorials and television programs all referred to how I had said
that `the blood of the Turk is poisonous.’ Each and every time, they
were adding to my fame as `the enemy of the Turk.’ At the halls of
the court, the fascists physically attacked me with racist curses.

They bombarded me with insults on their placards. The threats
reaching hundreds that kept hailing for months through phones, e-mail
and letters kept increasing each time.

And I persevered through all this with patience awaiting the decision
for acquittal. Once the legal decision was announced, the truth was
going to prevail and all these people would be ashamed of what they
had done.

My only weapon was my sincerity. But here the decision was out and
all my hopes were crushed. From then on, I was in the most distressed
situation that a person could possibly be in.

The judge had made a decision in the name of the `Turkish nation’ and
had it legally registered that I had `denigrated Turkishness.’ I
could have persevered through anything except this.

According to my understanding, racism was the denigration by anyone
of a person they lived alongside with on the basis of any difference,
ethnic or religious and there was not any way in which this could
ever be forgiven.

Well it was in this psychological state that I made the following
declaration to the members of the media and friends who were at my
doorstep trying to confirm `as to whether I would leave this country
as I had indicated earlier :’

`I shall consult with my lawyers. I will appeal at the supreme court
of appeal and will even go to the European Court of Human Rights if
necessary. If I am not cleared through any one of these processes,
then I shall leave my country. Because according to my opinion,
someone who has been sentenced with such a crime does not have the
right to live alongside the citizens whom he has denigrated.’

As I voiced this opinion, I was emotional as always. My only weapon
was my sincerity.

Dark Humor

But it so happens that the deep force that was trying to single me
out and make me an open target in the eyes of the people of Turkey
found something wrong with this press release of mine as well and
this time filed a lawsuit against me for attempting to influence the
court. The entire Turkish media had given my declaration but what got
their attention was what was writ in AGOS alone. And it so transpired
that the legally responsible parties in the AGOS newspaper and I
started to be tried this time around for attempting to influence the
court. This must be what people call `dark humor.’

As I am the accused, who has the right more than the accused to try
to influence the judiciary ? But look at this humorous situation that
the accused is this time tried for trying to influence the judiciary.

`In the Name of the Turkish State ‘

I have to confess that I had more than lost my trust in the concept
of `Law’ and the `System of Justice’ in Turkey .

How could I have not ? Had these prosecutors, these judges not been
educated in the university, graduated from faculties of law ? Weren’t
they supposed to have the capacity to comprehend [and interpret] what
they read ?

But it so transpires that the judiciary in this country, as also
expressed without compunction by many a statesman and politician, is
not independent.

The judiciary does not protect the rights of the citizen, but instead
the State.

The judiciary is not there for the citizen, but under the control of
the State.

As a matter of fact I was absolutely sure that even though it was
stated that the decision in my case was reached `in the name of the
Turkish nation,’ it was a decision clearly not made `on behalf of the
Turkish nation’ but rather `on behalf of the Turkish state.’ As a
consequence, my lawyers were going to appeal the Supreme Court of
Appeals, but what could guarantee that the deep forces that had
decided to put me in my place would not be influential there either ?

And was it the case that the Supreme Court of Appeals always reached
right decisions ? Wasn’t it the same Supreme Court of Appeal that had
signed onto the unjust decision that stripped minority foundations of
their properties ? [And had done so] in spite of the attempts of the
Chief Public Prosecutor. And we did appeal and what did it get us ?
Just like the report of the experts, the Chief Public Prosecutor of
the Supreme Court of Appeals stated that there was no evidence of
crime and asked for my acquittal but the Supreme Court of Appeals
still found me guilty. The Chief Public Prosecutor of the Supreme
Court of Appeals was just as certain about what he had read and
understood as I had been about what I had written, so he objected to
the decision and took the lawsuit to the General Council.

But what can I say, that great force which had decided once and for
all to put me in my place and had made itself felt at every stage of
my lawsuit through processes I would not even know about was there
present once again behind the scenes. And as a consequence, it was
declared by majority vote at General Council as well that I had
denigrated Turkishness.

Like a Pigeon

This much is crystal clear that those who tried to single me out,
render me weak and defenseless succeeded by their own measures. With
the wrongful and polluted knowledge they oozed into society, they
managed to form a significant segment of the population whose numbers
cannot be easily dismissed who view Hrant Dink as someone
`denigrating Turkishness.’

The diary and memory of my computer are filled with angry,
threatening lines sent by citizens from this particular sector. (Let
me note here at this juncture that even though one of these letters
was sent from [the neighboring city of] Bursa and that I had found it
rather disturbing because of the proximity of the danger it
represented and [therefore] turned the threatening letter over to the
ªiºli prosecutor’s office, I have not been able to get a result until
this day.)

How real or unreal are these threats ? To be honest, it is of course
impossible for me to know for sure. What it truly threatening and
unbearable for me is the psychological torture I personally place
myself in. `Now what are these people thinking about me ?’ is the
question that really bugs me. It is unfortunate that I am now better
known than I once was and I feel much more the people throwing me
that glance of `Oh, look, isn’t he that Armenian guy ?’

And I reflexively start torturing myself. One aspect of this torture
is curiosity, the other unease. One aspect is attention, the other
apprehension.

I am just like a pigeon…..

Obsessed just as much what goes on my left, right, front, back.

My head is just as mobile… and just as fast enough to turn right
away.

And Here is the Cost for You

What did the Foreign Minister Abdullah Gül state ? The Justice
Minister Cemil Çiçek ? `Come on, there is nothing to exaggerate about
[legal code 301]. Is there anyone who has actually been tried and
imprisoned from it ?’ As if the only cost one paid was
imprisonment… Here is a cost for you… Here is a cost… Do you
know, oh ministers, what kind of a cost it is to imprison a human
being into the apprehensiveness of a pigeon ?… Do you know ?….
You, don’t you ever watch a pigeon ?

What They Call `Life-or-Death’ What I have lived through has not been
an easy process… And what we have lived through as a family…
There were moments when I seriously thought about leaving the country
and moving far away. And especially when the threats started to
involve those close to me… At that point I always remained
helpless. That must be what they call `Life-or-Death.’ I could have
resisted out of my own will, but I did not have the right to put into
danger the life of anyone who was close to me. I could have been my
own hero, but I did not have the right to be brave by placing, let
along someone close to me, any other person in danger. During such
helpless times, I gathered my family, my children together and sought
refuge in them and received the greatest support from them. They
trusted in me.

Wherever I would be, they would be there as well. If I said `let’s
go’ they would go, if I said `let’s stay’ they would come.

To Stay and Resist Okay, but if we went, where would we go ? To the
Armenian Republic ? How long someone like me who could not stand
injustices put up with the injustices there ? Would not I get into
even deeper trouble there ?

To go and live in the European countries was not at all the thing for
me. After all, I am such a person that if I travel to the West for
three days, I miss my country on the fourth and start writhing in
boredom saying `let this be over so I can go back,’ so what would I
end up doing there ? The comfort there would have gotten to me !
Leaving `boiling hells’ for `ready-made heavens’ was not at all right
for my personality make up. We were people who volunteered to
transform the hells they lived into heavens. To stay and live in
Turkey was necessary because we truly desired it and [had to do so]
out of respect to the thousands of friends in Turkey who gave a
struggle for democracy and who supported us. We were going to stay
and we were going to resist. If we were forced to leave one day
however… We were going to set out just as in 1915…Like our
ancestors… Without knowing where we were going… Walking the roads
they walked through… Feeling the ordeal, experiencing the pain….
With such a reproach we were going to leave our homeland. And we
would go where our feet took us, but not our hearts.

Apprehensive and Free

I wish that we would never ever have to experience such a departure.
We have way too many reasons and hope not to experience it anyhow.

Now I am applying to the European Court of Human Rights. How long
this lawsuit will last, I do not know. The fact that I do know and
that somewhat puts me at ease is that I will be living in Turkey at
least until the lawsuit is finalized. If the court decides in my
favor, I will undoubtedly become very happy and it would mean that I
would never have to leave my country. From my own vantage point, 2007
will probably be even a more difficult year. The trials will
continue, new ones will commence. Who knows what kinds of additional
injustices I would have to confront ? While all these occur, I will
consider this one truth my only security. Yes, I may perceive myself
in the spiritual unease of a pigeon, but I do know that in this
country people do not touch pigeons. Pigeons live their lives all the
way deep into the city, even amidst the human throngs. Yes, somewhat
apprehensive but just as much free.

icle=28540

http://www.armenews.com/article.php3?id_art

Dink suspect’s picture released

BBC New, UK
Jan 20 2007

Dink suspect’s picture released

Police believe the man is tucking a gun into his trousers
The Turkish authorities have released CCTV images of a man suspected
of involvement in the death of a prominent journalist of Armenian
descent.
In one image the young man can be seen running while tucking what
officials believe is a gun into his belt.

Hrant Dink was shot dead near his newspaper’s Istanbul offices on
Friday, sparking angry protests.

He had written extensively about the massacre of Armenians during the
final days of the Ottoman Empire in 1915.

The photographs released by Istanbul’s governor Muammer Guler came
from a security camera on the street where Mr Dink died after being
shot twice.

Because he didn’t request protection, he didn’t get close
protection. Only general security precautions were taken

Muammer Guler, Istanbul governor

Obituary: Hrant Dink
Turkish press outrage

The images have been enhanced by investigators in order to help with
identification, officials said, and the police have set up a phone
line for members of the public to pass on information.

The suspect appears to be in his late teens or early 20s. Of slim
build, he is casually dressed in jeans, a denim jacket and white
knitted hat and has a thin moustache.

In one image he is seen walking normally, in another he is running,
with his hands near his waist – officials believe he is hiding a gun.

Threats

Many in Turkey think that Dink was targeted for his controversial
writing on the killings of hundreds of thousands of Armenians by the
Ottoman Turks nine decades ago.

The issue is a sensitive subject in both Armenia and Turkey. Many
Armenians have campaigned for the killings to be recognised
internationally as genocide.

Turkey denies any genocide, saying the deaths were a part of World
War I.

Hrant Dink was one of Turkey’s most prominent Armenian voices
Dink was found guilty in October 2005 of insulting Turkish identity
after he wrote an article which addressed the mass killings.

Dink was one of Turkey’s most prominent Armenian voices and despite
threats on his life, he refused to stay silent.

Even with the known tensions surrounding Dink’s work he was not
provided with a bodyguard, sparking criticism that not enough had
been done by the authorities to protect him.

But Mr Guler says that this was because Dink had not asked for any
extra security effort.

"Because he didn’t request protection, he didn’t get close
protection," Mr Guler said. "Only general security precautions were
taken."

Journalists and politicians in Turkey have expressed outrage at the
killing, which many described as a political assassination, while the
US, EU, France, and several human rights groups also voiced shock and
condemnation.

EU question

The Armenian government has condemned the murder with President
Robert Kocharian saying: "The killing of this well-known Armenian
journalist in Turkey raises numerous questions and deserves the
strongest condemnation.

"We hope that the Turkish authorities will do everything possible to
find and punish the culprit strictly in accordance with the law".

The speaker of Armenia’s parliament, Tigran Torosyan went even
further.

"Following the murder, Turkey should not even dream about joining the
European Union," the Armenian news agency Arminfo quoted him as
saying.

The two countries still have no official relations since Armenia
gained independence after the break up of the Soviet Union in 1991.

Turkish press outrage over shooting

BBC New, UK
Jan 20 2007

Turkish press outrage over shooting

Mr Dink said he had received numerous death threats
Turkish newspapers express deep shock and anger at the murder in
Istanbul of one of the country’s most prominent Armenian voices, the
journalist Hrant Dink.

Several commentators predict the killing could spark a political
crisis; many also express concern about its potential international
repercussions.

HEADLINES IN MILLIYET

Hrant Dink Murdered: The Murderer Is a Traitor … It Was Turkey That
Was Shot Dead.

HEADLINE ON COLUMN BY HADI ULUENGIN IN HURRIYET

Ahparik, Ahparik! [Armenian for "brother"]

CAN DUNAR IN MILLIYET

Tsidesutyun Paregamis! [Farewell My Friend!] … You at least
achieved in death what you were striving for in life. Look, last
night all walked in front of the paper chanting ‘we all are Hrant, we
all are Armenians,’ something you spent a lifetime to see.

GUNGOR URAS IN MILLIYET

[Dink’s] murder will make the solution of the Turkish-Armenian
problem more intractable both at home and abroad. Our laws and
justice system have cornered one of our Armenian citizens who could
have contributed to the solution of the Armenian problem. He was
murdered by dark forces.

ILNUR CEVIK IN THE NEW ANATOLIAN

For some time we were hearing gossip that some people who have
angered the ultra-conservatives may be the targets of a new campaign
of violence. We were told that, unlike in the past, the death squads
are acting independently and are not linked or controlled by state
bodies. We hope the security forces and intelligence network does a
swift job to catch the culprit or culprits who are trying to push
Turkey into a spiral of violence. If this is done, the credibility of
the government and the image of Turkey can be saved.

YUSUF KANLI IN TURKISH DAILY NEWS

Whatever the motive behind the attack was and whoever the killer is,
Turkey and Armenia have both lost a very important son today, someone
who was trying to contribute to building bridges of peace and
understanding between his homeland Turkey and Armenia.

SAHIN ALPAY IN ZAMAN

[Dink’s murder was] a major blow to Turkey, Turkishness and humanity
… No greater insult could have been made against Turkey and the
Turkish identity. No greater blow could have been dealt to Turkish
democracy and Turkey’s international prestige. This murder, which was
committed by the true enemies of Turkishness, will unfortunately cost
Turkey very dearly.

NUH GONULTAS IN BUGUN

A section in Turkey that has run of out ammunition ahead of the
presidential election has taken steps to plunge Turkey into a crisis.

TAHA AKYOL IN MILLIYET

[Dink’s murder was] barbaric, cruel, and monstrous; politically an
act of lumpen nationalistic hatred.

MEHMET ALI BIRAND IN TURKISH DAILY NEWS

Hrant Dink symbolised tolerance. Those who shot at him have no idea
that they also shot at Turkey. Just wait and see how this will
resonate outside. The United States, France and other European
countries will send proposals on the Armenians’ genocide and will
just rush them through. Turkey will be blamed for everything.
Newspapers will write about how Turkish people could not tolerate a
liberal journalist of Armenian origin. Can there be any greater harm
to our country? Shame on them. Hrant Dink will continue to live in
our hearts.

CENGIZ CANDAR IN REFERANS

The people running this country should emerge from this affair by
paying a big price and by making not so much the trigger man but
those behind him pay the price. Whatever happens this fact is not
going to change: Turkey without Hrant has become an orphan. Hrant
Dink was murdered. Turkey was shot.

ANKARA: Dink’s Death: Things to do upon both Turkey and the EU

Journal of Turkish Weekly
Jan 20 2007

Dink’s Death: Things to do upon both Turkey and the EU Fatma Yilmaz

Saturday , 20 January 2007

Hrant Dink, the Turkish-Armenian journalist, was killed yesterday on
19 January. There is no clarity yet who is responsible for the murder
and why such a tragic event took place. However, what clear is that
the murder of journalist Dink in Turkey has sparked a wave of protest
both inside and outside the country. Not only the Armenian and
European people have shown their reactions and sorrows on such tragic
death but, possibly more than these people, Turkish people has
particularly expressed their sorrows and condemnation as a reaction
to the murder.

Beside to the demonstrations showing the reactions to the murder, the
politicians have officially expressed their opinions criticizing such
provocation. In this sense, Mr. Erdogan, the Turkish prime minister,
stated that the attack on Dink was an attack on Turkey and on Turkish
unity and stability. He also added that the "dark hands" behind the
killing would be brought to justice.

On the European side, the German Presidency of the EU stated that the
Turkish authorities will solve this case as quickly as possible and
has no doubt that Turkey will steadfastly continue along the path
towards fully realizing freedom of expression.

It seems so that two sides including the European and Turkish
officials share the same opinions officially, affirming their sorrow
about the murder and there is no way to accuse to the whole Turkish
society because of a betrayer who was probably planning to create
provocation in order to strain the relations.

The Turkey’s EU membership has already been under discussion due to
the reasons emanating from both some internal and external problems.
This murder has most likely targeted to damage the relations in a
more negative way. It is trying to make the parties take expeditious
and therefore wrong steps in favor of the people who will make profit
from such situation. This reminds me the previous cartoon crisis
aiming at producing a sense of anger so as to strain the relations
between the different religions. However, at this time, the tool
which was used for an atrocious aim became more brutal one, a murder.
Previously, the artificial cartoon crisis could not reach its target,
just like creation of `clash of religions’ in the long run. It came
and then went such a flash in the pan. Hopefully, the attack on Dink
would not let the people to be fooled by such provocation. What to be
expected from the people of all sides is to respond this tragic and
provocative event in terms of presence of mind. Therefore, the aim
should be finding the real criminals behind the murder, not to bring
the responsibility on whole Turkish society. Hence, there are things
to do for Turkey and the European authorities in support of showing
their real sincerity.

20 January 2007
Fatma Yilmaz
Center for European Union Studies

ANKARA: For Hrant

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
Jan 20 2007

For Hrant

by YAVUZ BAYDAR News

My grief is very, very deep. I have lost a wonderful friend and a
courageous colleague.
Could we see it coming?
I remember an evening, months ago, in a restaurant. The infamous
Pamuk trial had ended in tumult, with Orhan Pamuk leaving the Þiþli
Courthouse followed by an angry mob.
That evening we were all together in a display of solidarity for
Pamuk, authors, intellectuals, artists and journalists.
One moment we were by ourselves: Orhan, Hrant and I.
Deeply worried, I told Orhan that he really should watch himself. `In
Turkey, we have a dark record of mistreating intellectuals,’ I said.
`Just remember Sabahattin Ali, Uður Mumcu, Ahmet Taner Kýþlalý, Musa
Anter, Çetin Emeç, Ýpekçi… Be careful.’
Orhan was affected: he seemed to share my concern. But Hrant swiftly
retorted `We shouldn’t worry, they wouldn’t dare’. And when Orhan
moved away from us, he whispered in my ear: `Whatever happens,
happens. I know where we live.’
He had a great heart, Hrant. He never concealed his emotions, even in
the most heated debates. I remember cautioning him on this. But at
the same time, those who know Hrant will tell you how much he loved
to tell the truth, how he loved to be bold and how much he loved his
native Turkey and his brothers in Armenia. Because he sought
reconciliation through truth, he was hated by hardliners both sides.
He was a target.
I may have lost a friend, but we all know the process of tolerance,
peace and understanding has lost one of its staunchest defenders. His
dream was a Turkey at peace with its past, and a Turkey with free
speech.
May his great soul rest in peace.

no=100535

http://www.todayszaman.com/tz-web/yazar.do?haber

ANKARA: Journalist and author Hrant Dink killed

Atýlým, Turkey
Jan 20 2007

Journalist and author Hrant Dink killed

ÝSTANBUL (20.01.2007)- Hrant Dink, journalist and chief editor of
the newspaper Agos was killed following an armed assassination
attempt yesterday at the entrance to the newspaper office.

A new link joined the chain of political assassinations in Turkey.
Hrant Dink who had become the target of racist fascists because of
his statements concerning Armenian and Kurdish question was killed
today. He had been charged and sentenced rdue to Article 301 of the
Turkish Penal Code a short time ago because of his commentaries. The
killing of Dink attracts a lot of attention happening after the
conference of intellectuals in Ankara who had emphasized their demand
for democratical solution in the Kurdish question.

According to the first information provided by the office of the
director of public prosecutions, Dink lost his life because of two
bullets in his head at the entrance to the newspaper office. It was
also said that the murderer must be 18 or 19 years old and that he
left taking a vehicle on Halaskargazi Street.

He was threatened before

Aydin Engin, Hrant Dink’s colleague and journalist, declared that
Dink had been threatened by different people, amog them officials,
too. Engin said that some time ago Dink received a phone call by one
of the governor assisstants of Istanbul and remembered:

"When Hrant Dink went there, nobody cared. There were two people with
the governor assistant whom he introduced as ‘My relatives’. Then one
of the two, a man, hold a long speech saying. There are lots of
people on the streets and something might happen to you’. Hrant Dink
had told about this incident when he applied to the European Court of
Human Rights. ‘

ANKARA: Five thousand gather in sit-down protest of Hrant Dink

Hürriyet, Turkey
Jan 20 2007

Five thousand gather in sit-down protest of Hrant Dink assassination

Five thousand people gathered yesterday evening in Taksim Square in a
sit-down protest against the assassination of Hrant Dink, the
Editor-in-chief of the Armenian Community’s newspaper, Agos, which
took place earlier in the day. The protestors proceeded to march
towards the newspaper’s office carrying photographs of Mr. Dink,
candles, torches, and flowers.

The crowd, which had doubled in number by the time they had reached
the Agos building, sang and clapped hands in protest as well as
shouting such slogans as, `We are all Hrant Dink. We are all
Armenians’, and `Hrant Dink’s murderer is this country’s betrayer’.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress