Editor’s murder a blow to democracy

The Age, Australia
Jan 20 2007

Editor’s murder a blow to democracy

Nicholas Birch, Istanbul
January 21, 2007

A JOURNALIST who was a prominent member of Turkey’s Armenian
community has been murdered in Istanbul in an attack the Prime
Minister described as an attempt to destabilise the country.

Hrant Dink, 53, a Turkish citizen of Armenian descent, was shot from
behind at the entrance of Agos, the bilingual Turkish-Armenian weekly
newspaper he edited.

A large crowd gathered as police cordoned off the area on Friday.
Workers at the newspaper, including Mr Dink’s brother, were weeping.
Three suspects were later detained.

"A bullet was fired at freedom of thought and democratic life," said
Prime Minister Tayyip Erdogan. Mr Dink had gone on trial several
times for speaking out about the mass killings of Armenians by Turks.
He had received threats from nationalists who saw him as a traitor.
He was a public figure in Turkey and, as the editor of Agos, one of
its most prominent Armenian voices.

In his last newspaper column, Mr Dink said that he had become famous
as an enemy of Turks and that he had received threats against him.

He said he had received no protection from authorities despite his
complaints. "My computer’s memory is loaded with sentences full of
hatred and threats," he wrote.

Established in 1996, Agos was the fruit of his belief that only
dialogue could resolve the bitter memories left by the mass murder of
Ottoman Armenians during the First World War.

An outspoken critic of Turkey’s continuing denial that the events of
1915 amounted to genocide, Mr Dink was equally opposed to
international attempts to politicise the issue.

Armenia Furious over Dink’s Murder

Sofia News Agency, Bulgaria
Jan 20 2007

Armenia Furious over Dink’s Murder

Politics: 20 January 2007, Saturday.

The Armenian government has condemned the murder in Istanbul of a
prominent Turkish journalist of Armenian descent.

The speaker of Armenia’s parliament Tigran Torosyan said the murder
showed that Turkey should not even dream about joining the European
Union.

Hrant Dink’s murder on Friday sparked a protest by thousands of
people where he was shot near his newspaper’s offices.

He had written extensively about the massacre of Armenians during the
final days of the Ottoman Empire in 1915.

Journalists and politicians in Turkey have expressed outrage at the
killing, which many described as a political assassination, while the
US, EU, France, and several human rights groups also voiced shock and
condemnation.

Police said Hrant Dink was shot twice. Late on Friday, Turkish media
quoted Istanbul’s governor as saying three people were in custody
over the killing.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

A Visa Problem in Canada, and an Excursion to Spain

New York Times
January 16, 2007

Music Review | Isabel Bayrakdarian

A Visa Problem in Canada, and an Excursion to Spain
By ALLAN KOZINN

Isabel Bayrakdarian, the soprano, and Russell Braun, the baritone, were to
have shared a recital on Sunday afternoon at the Morgan Library & Museum.
Both singers are Canadian, as are the pianists they work with, and at the
last minute, visa problems prevented Mr. Braun from traveling to New York.
So Ms. Bayrakdarian and her pianist, Serouj Kradjian (they are also
married), added two groups of songs and a solo piano work to the Schubert
and Pauline Viardot groups they had planned, and had the recital all to
themselves.

The amended program was a tour of national styles filtered through 19th- and
early-20th-century sensibilities, and Ms. Bayrakdarian was at her most vivid
when the music drew most overtly on folk music and dance roots. She gave a
florid account of `L’Invito,’ the bolero from Rossini’s `Soirées Musicales,’
for example, and her reading of the `Tarantella Napoletana’ from the same
set was brisk, fiery and suffused with an undercurrent of sensuality.

Ernesto Lecuona’s `Malagueña’ was enlivened with a similarly vital
performance. Here, and in its companion works in her Spanish set – `Del
cabello más sutil’ and `Chiquitita la novia’ by Fernando Obradors – Ms.
Bayrakdarian caught the essence of the music in her subtly shifting tempos
and flamenco-tinged vocalise passages.

Spain seemed to exert an unusual pull on Ms. Bayrakdarian and Mr. Kradjian.
Two of the Viardot songs, `Madrid’ and `Havanaise,’ emphasized the
composer’s Spanish roots and drew on flamenco figuration as fully as the
Obradors songs. On the other hand, in his pastel-hued performance of
Granados’s `Quejas o la maja y el ruiseñor,’ from `Goyescas,’ Mr. Kradjian
highlighted the stylistic connections between Granados and his French
contemporary Ravel.

Ms. Bayrakdarian put Viardot’s Gallic side in the spotlight as well, by way
of gracefully turned performances of `Sylvie,’ the gently macabre `Enfant et
la mère’ and the swirling `Aime-moi,’ a reworking of a Chopin mazurka.

The recital, part of the series that the George London Foundation has
presented at the Morgan since 1995, began with a group of Schubert songs in
which Ms. Bayrakdarian acclimated herself to the small, acoustically bright
new hall. At first she seemed to overestimate the power she needed, but by
the third song, she had taken the room’s measure, giving a beautifully
serene performance of `Nacht und Träume’ that showed her interpretive
flexibility and expressive sound to fine effect.

sic/16morg.html

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/01/16/arts/mu

Armenian Journalist Killed by Gunman

Christian Broadcasting Network, VA
Jan 19 2007

Armenian Journalist Killed by Gunman
By Benjamin Harvey
Associated Press Writer
January 19, 2007

CBNNews.com – ISTANBUL, Turkey – A journalist who faced constant
threats and protests as one of the most prominent voices of Turkey’s
shrinking Armenian community was shot to death Friday at the entrance
to his newspaper’s offices, police said.

Hrant Dink, a 53-year-old Turkish citizen of Armenian descent, had
gone on trial numerous times for speaking out about the mass killings
of Armenians by Turks at the beginning of the 20th century. He had
also received threats from nationalists, who viewed him as a traitor.

In October 2005, he was convicted of trying to influence the
judiciary after the bilingual Turkish-Armenian newspaper he edited,
Agos, ran stories criticizing a law making it a crime to insult
Turkey, the Turkish government or the Turkish national character.

He was given a six-month suspended sentence.

The conviction was rare even in a country where trials of
journalists, academics and writers have become common. Most of the
cases, including that of the Nobel Prize-winning novelist Orhan
Pamuk, were either dropped on a technicality or led to acquittals.

Dink cried during an interview with The Associated Press last year as
he talked about some of his countrymen’s hatred for him, saying he
could not stay in a country where he was unwanted.

"I’m living together with Turks in this country," Dink told the AP.
"I don’t think I could live with an identity of having insulted them
in this country. if I am unable to come up with a positive result, it
will be honorable for me to leave this country."

Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan condemned Dink’s death as an
attack against Turkey’s unity and promised to catch those
responsible.

Erdogan said two suspects had been arrested, but offered no details.

"Once again, dark hands have chosen our country and spilled blood in
Istanbul to achieve their dark goals," Erdogan said at a news
conference.

The prime minister said he had assigned top officials from the
Justice Ministry to the case and that they were on their way to
Istanbul from the capital, Ankara.

Raiders coaching candidate Sarkisian rejects offer

ESPN.com: NFL

Friday, January 19, 2007
Raiders coaching candidate Sarkisian rejects offer
By Len Pasquarelli
ESPN.com

In a strange twist that left the Oakland Raiders jilted by their first
choice to succeed Art Shell, Southern California quarterbacks coach
Steve Sarkisian on Friday evening rejected the team’s offer to become
its next head coach.

League sources who confirmed the move by Sarkisian gave no reason for
his decision. The Raiders had offered a contract longer than the
two-year deal Shell signed but further details were not available.

In a statement late Friday, the Raiders denied Sarkisian had been
offered the job, and said he removed his name from consideration. The
statement, in part, read: "The Oakland Raiders were not ready to offer
the position and wanted to wait until after the weekend as the
organization is still doing its due diligence."

In a separate statement, released by the university, Sarkisian said he
wanted to stay at USC.

"I thank them for their interest in me," Sarkisian said. "While the
job was never offered to me, at this time in my career, I’ve told them
I want to stay at USC. I strongly believe that the Raiders’ job is a
great opportunity for whomever their next head coach is going to be."

The presumptive front-runner for the Oakland vacancy for much of this
week, Sarkisian interviewed on Wednesday with team officials for the
second time in two weeks. He then flew back to Los Angeles, but
returned to the Bay Area on Thursday for another round of interviews.

In fact, the Raiders even interviewed Southern California offensive
coordinator Lane Kiffin, who was Sarkisian’s choice to be his No. 1
offensive assistant, on Thursday. That prompted speculation that the
club was close to finalizing a deal with Sarkisian.

In their statement, the Raiders said that Kiffin had made "no
commitment" to join the staff if Sarkisian landed the job.

Sarkisian, 32, served as the Oakland quarterbacks coach in 2004 and,
while he has not been a coordinator or head coach, he fit the mold of
the kind of coach owner Al Davis has traditionally sought. Davis
typically looks for candidates whose expertise is on the offensive
side of the ball, and who are young and innovative.

A former Brigham Young quarterback who played three seasons in the CFL
(1997-99), Sarkisian has a limited coaching resume. Beyond his two
stints at Southern California (2001-2003 and 2005), Sarkisian was on
the staff at El Camino (Calf.) Junior College in 2000.

In a related matter, San Diego Chargers wide receivers coach and Hall
of Fame member James Lofton, who met earlier this week with Oakland
officials, withdrew his name from consideration for the job.

Beyond Sarkisian and Loton, the Raiders have interviewed current
Oakland defensive coordinator Rob Ryan and former New York Giants
coach Jim Fassel. ESPN.com reported Tuesday that former Arizona
Cardinals coach Dennis Green rebuffed overtures from Oakland officials
to arrange an interview.

It is not known if Oakland will expand its search now or simply work
from the pool of current candidates.

Senior writer Len Pasquarelli covers the NFL for ESPN.com. The
Associated Press contributed to this report.

Turkey reeling from death of Armenian journalist

CTV.ca, Canada
Jan 20 2007

Turkey reeling from death of Armenian journalist
Updated Sat. Jan. 20 2007 7:51 AM ET

Associated Press

ISTANBUL, Turkey — Turkey’s prime minister on Saturday conveyed his
nation’s sense of shock a day after a journalist and Armenian
community leader was assassinated at the entrance to his bilingual
Turkish-Armenian newspaper.

Officials released a photo of the young man they suspect killed Hrant
Dink, who received numerous death threats for his views that Turks
carried out a genocide against the minority Armenians early in the
20th century.

"The bullets aimed at Hrant Dink were shot into all of us," Prime
Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan said. Within hours of Dink’s murder, he
had sent his interior minister and justice minister to Istanbul to
lead the investigation.

Dink, who had faced trials for the genocide claims, was shot and
killed Friday in broad daylight. No suspects are in custody.

He wrote in his last newspaper column that he was so worried about
attacks that his head swiveled like a pigeon’s as he moved around
Istanbul.

Most Turks assumed the shooting was a reaction to Dink’s public
statements that the mass killings of Armenians around the time of
World War I constituted genocide. Nationalists see such statements as
insults to the honor of Turks and as threats to national unity.

Whatever the motivation, the killing made it clear that Turkey
remains a place where people speak freely at their own peril, despite
generations of Western-looking liberal reforms and the nation’s
commitment to joining the European Union.

The New York-based Committee to Protect Journalists said Turkey was
the eighth deadliest country in the world for journalist, with 18
killed in the past 15 years for their work. Turkey’s Zaman newspaper
said 62 journalists have been assassinated in the nation’s 84-year
history.

Dink, 52, was often subjected to more subtle attempts to silence him.
He was one of dozens of journalists, writers and academics who have
gone on trial for expressing their opinions here, most under the
infamous article 301 of the penal code, which makes it a crime to
insult Turkey, its government or the national character.

In the most famous case, Nobel Prize-winning novelist Orhan Pamuk
faced jail time last year for insulting Turkey by saying Turks had
killed a million Armenians. His case was dropped on a technicality.

Dink clearly sensed his life was in danger.

"My computer’s memory is loaded with sentences full of anger and
threats," he wrote on Jan. 10 in his last newspaper column. "I am
just like a pigeon. … I look around to my left and right, in front
and behind me as much as it does. My head is just as active."

In the past few years, Turks had come to know Dink well, mostly
because of the high-profile cases opened against him. In late 2005,
Turks saw him lose his composure, crying on television as he
discussed his latest court case and what it was like to live amid
people who hated him.

A Turkish citizen, Dink said he would stay here, however, in the
hopes that cases he opened at the European Court of Human Rights
would be resolved in his favor, and do something to improve his
country.

Turkey’s relationship with its Armenian community has long been
fraught with tension, controversy and painful memories of a brutal
past.

Much of Turkey’s once-sizeable Armenian population was killed or
driven out beginning around 1915 in what an increasing number of
countries are recognizing as the first genocide of the 20th century.

Turks vehemently deny that their ancestors committed genocide,
however, and saying so is tantamount to treason. In the 1970s and
1980s, tensions were further inflamed as dozens of Turkish diplomats
were killed by Armenian assassins seeking revenge.

Turkey, which is 99 percent Muslim, and Armenia, which claims to be
the first country to officially adopt Christianity, share a border.
But the border is closed, and the two countries have no formal
diplomatic relations.

Socialists outraged at murder of journalist

ABHaber, Belgium
Turkey-EU news network
Jan 19 2007

AP Sosyalist Grubu Dink ile ilgili Erdoðan’ýn açýklamasýný
memnunlukla karþýlýyoruz (orjinal metin)

SOCIALISTS OUTRAGED AT MURDER OF JOURNALIST

Leading members of the European Parliament today voiced outrage at
the murder of Armenian-Turkish journalist Hrant Dink, 52, outside his
Agos newspaper office in Istanbul.

Socialist Group vice-president Jan Marinus Wiersma said: "The
assassination of this journalist is an attack on the free media in
Turkey. We are outraged by the cold-blooded way in which Mr Dink was
gunned down.

"We offer our sympathy to Mr Dink’s family and colleagues. We urge
journalists in Turkey to maintain their courage and to show that they
reject such attempts at intimidation.

"We welcome the commitment of Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan to
catch those responsible and bring them to justice."

Turkey’s Trouble With Minorities

Washington Post, DC
Jan 20 2007

Turkey’s Trouble With Minorities

Ali Ettefagh – The murder of Hrant Dink in Istanbul by right-wing
extremists may well shatter Turkey’s chances of joining the European
Union.

The killing of the 53-year-old Armenian journalist and the publisher
of a newspaper for the Armenian community merely intended to open
honest discussion about what Winston Churchill called the first
Holocaust of the 20th Century. In late 1970s, the civil war that
ended in a coup was triggered by a very similar murder of a respected
leftist journalist, Abdi Ipekci, by the rightwing "Gray Wolves"
nationalists. Back in 2000, a highly visible Jewish industrialist and
philanthropist was murdered in Istanbul but the matter was stifled as
economic crises overshadowed the matter.

Hran Dink (and 12 other Turkish journalists currently in prison) was
convicted of insulting the ethnic fabric and the "Turkishness" of the
nation, a criminal offence under section 301 of the Turkish Criminal
Code. This is a highly subjective law in Turkey and a topic at the
core of objections by the European Union which insists on fair
treatment of ethnic minorities. The French parliament has demanded
Turkey face its past conduct in respect to the systematic killings of
Armenians back in 1915.

Turkey is certainly in a tough fix: Its EU negotiations are frozen in
their tracks. It has a number of prickly issues and disagreements to
overcome with the EU including the issues of human rights,
recognition of ethnic minorities and the resolution of its no-win
position in Cyprus. Concurrently, it worries about the future of an
Iraqi Kurdistan and its own Kurdish population, some one-third of its
citizens. It has a young population base and close to 100% of its GDP
in national debt. Its private sector continues to bet on a one-way
road of entry into EU as it incurs higher levels of debt. With a
civil war on its border, the Turkish government openly supports and
arms the Turkomen minorities in Kirkuk. And it has other interests in
Bosnia and hostile postures towards Armenia and Serbia.

The sum of such components can further complicate issues in a region
that is revisiting its religious and ethnic roots, dating back to the
times of the Ottoman Empire and the pre-revolutionary Russia. Turkey
must deal with these ghosts in a frank and transparent manner just as
all other secular countries in Europe have done.

Q&A: Armenian "genocide"

BBC News, UK
Jan 20 2007

Q&A: Armenian "genocide"

French MPs have passed a bill making it a crime to deny that the
Ottoman Turkish empire committed genocide against Armenians in 1915.
The decision has delighted Armenians and infuriated Turks.

Why put "genocide" in inverted commas?

Whether or not the deaths of hundreds of thousands of Armenians
during World War I amounted to genocide is a matter for heated
debate. Some countries have declared that a genocide took place, but
others have resisted calls to do so.

What happened?

During World War I, as the Ottoman Turkish empire fought Russian
forces, some of the Armenian minority in eastern Anatolia sided with
the Russians.

Turkey took reprisals. On 24 April 1915 it rounded up and killed
hundreds of Armenian community leaders.

In May 1915, the Armenian minority, two or three million strong, was
forcefully deported and marched from the Anatolian borders towards
Syria and Mesopotamia (now Iraq). Many died en route.

What does Armenia say?

Armenia says 1.5 million Armenians were killed in this period, either
through systematic massacres or through starvation.

It alleges that a deliberate genocide was carried out by the Ottoman
Turkish empire.

What does Turkey say?

It says there was no genocide.

It acknowledges that many Armenians died, but says Turks died too,
and that massacres were committed on both sides as a result of
inter-ethnic violence and the wider World War.

What is genocide?

Article Two of the UN Convention on Genocide of December 1948
describes genocide as carrying out acts intended "to destroy, in
whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group".

What do others say?

France, Russia, Canada and Uruguay are among those countries which
have formally recognised genocide against the Armenians.

The UK, US and Israel are among those that use different terminology.

Why does the row continue?

Armenians are one of the world’s most dispersed peoples. While in
Armenia, Genocide Memorial Day is commemorated across the country, it
is the diaspora that has lobbied for recognition from the outside
world. The killings are regarded as the seminal event of modern
Armenian history, and one that binds the diaspora together.

In Turkey, the penal code makes calling "for the recognition of the
Armenian genocide" illegal. Writers and translators have been
prosecuted for attempting to stimulate debate on the subject.

Turkey has condemned countries that recognise the Armenian genocide,
and was furious when the French parliament passed a bill outlawing
denial of it.

The European Union has said that accepting the Armenian genocide is
not a condition for Turkey’s entry into the bloc. But some, including
French President Jacques Chirac, have said it should be.