Istanbul governor says 3 arrested in connection with Dink murder

International Herald Tribune, France
Jan 20 2007

Istanbul governor says 3 arrested in connection with murder of
journalist Hrant Dink
The Associated PressPublished: January 19, 2007

ISTANBUL, Turkey: Istanbul governor Muammer Guler said three people
were arrested in connection with the murder of journalist Hrant Dink
earlier on Friday, CNN-Turk television reported.

No further information was provided on the arrests. Earlier in the
day, two people were arrested, only to be released when officials
decided they had no connection to the crime. Dink was one of the most
prominent voices of Turkey’s Armenian community, and a frequent
target of nationalist anger.

AI: Amnesty International Condemns Murder of Hrant Dink

Amnesty International USA
Jan 20 2007

AMNESTY INTERNATIONAL USA
PRESS RELEASE

January 19, 2007

Amnesty International Condemns Murder of Hrant Dink

(Washington, DC) — Amnesty International deplores the murder today
of the prominent Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink. The
organization believes that he was targeted because of his work as a
journalist who championed freedom of expression.

"This horrifying assassination silences one of Turkey’s bravest human
rights defenders," said Maureen Greenwood-Basken, Amnesty
International USA (AIUSA) Advocacy Director for Europe and Central
Asia. "Writers put their lives on the line when they cover human
rights violations, as the cases of Russian journalist Anna
Politkovskaya, and now Hrant Dink, brutally illustrate.

"But legitimate debate about ideas must be protected. The Turkish
government must redouble its efforts to protect human rights
defenders and open its political climate to a range of views. Recent
legal reforms have brought many areas of Turkish law in line with
international human rights standards, but existing limitations on
free speech such as Article 301 must be repealed.

"The U.S. government, as one of Turkey’s closest allies, should push
for a full and transparent investigation into Dink’s murder."

AIUSA is a longstanding advocate of freedom of speech in Turkey and
around the world. In an online action in October 2006, AIUSA
activists sent thousands of messages urging repeal of Article 301.

Dink, editor of the newspaper Agos and contributor to the influential
daily Zaman, was reportedly shot three times today in Istanbul
outside the Agos offices. He was 53. Dink was a passionate promoter
of the universality of human rights who appeared on different
platforms with human rights activists, journalists and intellectuals
across the political spectrum. Best known for his willingness to
debate openly and critically issues of Armenian identity and official
versions of history in Turkey relating to the massacres of Armenians
in 1915, Dink also wrote widely on issues of democratization and
human rights.

"In Turkey there are still a number of harsh laws which endorse the
suppression of freedom of speech," said Nicola Duckworth, Europe and
Central Asia Programme Director at Amnesty International. "These
laws, coupled with the persisting official statements by senior
government, state and military officials condemning critical debate
and dissenting opinion, create an atmosphere in which violent attacks
can take place."

Last year, Dink was prosecuted for the third time on charges of
"denigrating Turkishness" under Article 301 of the Turkish Penal
Code. Amnesty International called for the repeal of that law and
condemned his prosecution as part of a pattern of judicial harassment
against him for peacefully expressing his dissenting opinion. Dink
had already been given a six-month suspended prison sentence in July
2006 following an October 2005 conviction on charges of "denigrating
Turkishness."

Amnesty International calls on the Turkish authorities to condemn all
forms of intolerance, to uphold the rights of all citizens of the
Turkish Republic and to investigate Dink?s murder thoroughly and
impartially, to make the findings of the investigation public and to
bring suspected perpetrators to justice in accordance with
international fair trial standards.

For further information about Amnesty International’s concerns
regarding Article 301 please see Turkey: Article 301: How the law on
"denigrating Turkishness" is an insult to free expression.

NCC condemns murder of Turkish-Armenian editor, calls for justice

Worldwide Faith News (press release), NY
Jan 20 2007

NCC condemns murder of Turkish-Armenian editor, calls for justice

>From "Daniel Webster" <[email protected]>
Date Fri, 19 Jan 2007 15:26:01 -0500

NCC condemns murder of Turkish-Armenian editor, calls for justice

New York City, January 19, 2007–The murder this morning of Hrant
Dink in Istanbul, Turkey "is a devastating development," said
Archbishop Vicken Aykazian, diocesan legate and ecumenical officer,
Diocese of the Armenian Orthodox Church of America. "The Armenian
people around the world are mourning his death," said Archbishop
Aykazian, who is also president-elect of the National Council of
Churches of Christ in the USA (NCC).

Dink, 53, was owner/editor of Agos, the largest weekly
Turkish-Armenian newspaper in Istanbul. Dink and Archbishop Aykazian,
a Turkish-born Armenian, were lifelong friends having attended the
same seminary school together.

"He’s the latest victim of the Turkish genocide of the Armenian
people that began in 1915," said Archbishop Aykazian. "He died
because he had the courage to say there was a genocide" by the
Ottoman Turks against Armenians, he said.

Dink had been convicted of insulting Turkish identity for publicly
writing about the Armenian genocide and was given a suspended
sentence. New laws in Turkey forbid negative public statements
criticizing the country.

"The NCC calls on the U.S. State Department to use whatever influence
possible to make sure this political assassination is fully
investigated with courage and clarity," said the Rev. Bob Edgar, the
NCC’s general secretary. "The Turkish government must show it will
defend the rights and the lives of religious and ethnic minorities,"
Edgar said. The archbishop said Pope Benedict called for protection
of religious minorities during his November visit to Turkey.

Archbishop Aykazian recalled a recent trip to Los Angeles with Dink
where they spoke to members of the Armenian community.

"Hrant said he was not afraid for himself," said the archbishop, "but
he was afraid for his children."

News reports said Dink had spoken of the possibility of leaving
Turkey because he felt he was no longer welcome in his own country.

"I am praying for my friend and colleague, Archbishop Vicken," said
the Rev. Michael Livingston, president of the NCC and executive
director of the International Council of Community Churches. "This is
a time for us to hold in prayer all of the Armenian people."

Last September Archbishop Aykazian and the Rev. Edgar led a mission
trip to Armenia with Habitat for Humanity.

"We learned a lot about the Armenian people during our ten days
there," said Edgar. "They are proud to be recognized as the first
Christian country and they are determined to stand firm against
genocide because they know firsthand its effects," he said.

The Turkish prime minister went on national television condemning the
murder and announced two suspects were in custody, according to news
reports.

Archbishop Aykazian will automatically become president of the NCC in
January 2008. The NCC is America’s ecumenical voice of 35 Orthodox,
Protestant, Anglican, historic African American and traditional peace
denominations. Together those churches represent 45 million members
in 100,000 congregations.

——

NCC News contact: Dan Webster, 212.870.2252, [email protected].
Latest NCC News at

www.councilofchurches.org.

ANKARA: Erdogan: No Bloody Provocation Will Prevent Turkey From…

Anatolian Times, Turkey
Jan 20 2007

Erdogan: No Bloody Provocation Will Prevent Turkey From Advancing On
Its Path Towards Freedom And Prosperity

ANKARA – "No bloody provocation will prevent Turkey from advancing on
its path towards freedom and prosperity," Turkish Prime Minister
Recep Tayyip Erdogan said on Friday.
Erdogan attended a ceremony to decorate Guenter Verheugen, Vice
President of the European Commission, with Turkish Industrialists’ &
Businessmen’s Association (TUSIAD) Foreign Policy Award in Ankara.

In regard to killing of Hrant Dink, editor-in-chief of bilingual
Turkish-Armenian weekly Agos, Erdogan said that everyone was shocked
by the assassination.

"A bullet was fired to free thought and our democratic life with the
bloody attack against Dink. Two ministers and all security units are
continuing their investigation," Erdogan noted.

"I believe that our nation will give the best response to this
traitorous homicide in unity," he stressed.

He added that they would keep fulfilling democratic reforms.

ANKARA: Mesrob II: A Disgraceful Assassination Targeting Turkey

Anatolian Times, Turkey
Jan 20 2007

Mesrob II: It Is A Disgraceful Assassination Targeting International
Relations And Tranquility Atmosphere In Our Country
Published: 1/19/2007

ISTANBUL – Mesrob II, the Patriarch of the Armenians in Turkey, said
regarding killing of Hrant Dink, editor-in-chief of bilingual
Turkish-Armenian weekly Agos that it was a disgraceful assassination
targeting international relations and tranquility atmosphere in
Turkey.
At a news conference, Mesrob II noted that he condemned and damned
person or persons who staged this attack.

Stating that Turkish PM Recep Tayyip Erdogan and he had a phone
conversation, Mesrob II noted that Erdogan offered his condolences to
him on the phone.

Mesrob II indicated that he fully believed that Turkish state would
capture those who staged the attack.

ANKARA: Buyukanit: We Condemn Hateful Attack Against Journalist Dink

Anatolian Times, Turkey
Jan 20 2007

Buyukanit: We Condemn Hateful Attack Against Journalist Dink

ANKARA – "We strongly condemn hateful attack against Hrant Dink
(editor-in-chief of bilingual Turkish-Armenian weekly Agos)," Chief
of General Staff Gen. Yasar Buyukanit said.
Gen. Buyukanit released a statement noting that they hoped that those
who staged the attack would be found as soon as possible.

He added that bullets fired at Dink were also fired at Turkey.

Dink was shot in front of his office building in Sisli district of
Istanbul today, and died instantly at the scene.

ANKARA: Protests To Condemn Killing Of Dink In Istanbul And Ankara

Anatolian Times, Turkey
Jan 20 2007

Protests To Condemn Killing Of Dink In Istanbul And Ankara

ISTANBUL/ANKARA – A group of people who held a sit-in protest to
condemn assassination of Hrant Dink, editor-in-chief of bilingual
Turkish-Armenian weekly Agos, in Taksim district marched towards
Sisli district in Istanbul.
Protestors chanted slogans and carried banners reading "All We Are
Hrant Dink" and "We Condemn Those Who Murdered Hrant Dink".

On the other hand, nearly 700 people from several nongovernmental
organizations held a demonstration to protest killing of Dink in
Kizilay Square in Ankara.

Ismail Hakki Tombul, chairman of the Confederation of Public Sector
Labor Unions (KESK), said that Dink was murdered in a disgraceful
attack, noting that the bullet fired at Dink was also fired at those
who wanted to live free in Turkey.

Meanwhile, a group of people gathered in front of Human Rights
Monument in Yuksel Street in Ankara and chanted slogans denouncing
assassination of Dink.

Iran: Turkish Armenian writer shot dead

Tehran Times, Iran
Jan 20 2007

Turkish Armenian writer shot dead

ANKARA (BBC) — A well-known Turkish Armenian editor convicted of
insulting Turkish identity has been shot dead in Istanbul.

Hrant Dink, editor of newspaper Agos, was shot three times by an
unknown gunman outside his offices.

Dink was given a six-month suspended sentence in October 2005 after
writing about the Armenian "genocide" of 1915.

Turkey’s NTV television said police were searching for a teenager
wearing a white hat and a denim jacket in connection with the murder.

The channel showed pictures of a white sheet covering the
journalist’s body in front of the newspaper building’s entrance.

Dink, 53, had received threats from nationalists who viewed him as a
traitor, the Associated Press news agency reported.

He was one of Turkey’s most prominent Armenian voices.

He once gave an interview with the Associated Press in which he cried
while describing the hatred some Turks had for him, saying he could
not stay in a country where he was unwanted.

Hundreds of thousands of Armenians died in 1915, in what many
Armenians say was a systematic massacre at the hands of the Ottoman
Turks.

Turkey denies any genocide, saying the deaths were a part of World
War I.

Turkey and neighboring Armenia still have no official relations.

Kuwait: Leading Turkish journalist shot dead

Kuwait News Agency, Kuwait
Jan 20 2007

Leading Turkish journalist shot dead

MIL-TURKEY-JOURNALIST
Leading Turkish journalist shot dead

ISTANBUL, Jan 19 (KUNA) — An unknown gunman killed on Friday the
editor-in-chief of the Turkish-Armenian weekly Agos, Hrant Dink.

According to Turkey’s NTV, the gunmen shot Dink in front of the
paper’s office in Istanbul, and then fled the scene.

Police forces encircled the area to arrest the murderer whose age
ranged between 18-19 years. Two suspects were arrested and are
currently being questioned.

Hrant suffered fatal wounds and was pronounced dead upon arriving at
hospital.

In 2006, a Turkish Court of Appeals upheld a six month suspended
sentence against Dink on the charge of "insulting Turkish identity."
The charge resulted from an article he wrote urging Turkish-Armenians
to symbolically reject their Turkish identity. He also touched upon
the massacres against Armenians by Ottomans during 1915-1917.

Dink denied any wrongdoing in the article.

Turkish President Ahmet Necdet Sezer said this act was disgraceful,
adding that the criminals will never reach their goal.

On his part, Turkish Premier Recep Tayyip Erdogan condemned the
crime, noting that Dink was a victim of an atrocious act that carried
a number of implications.

While denouncing the crime, Turkey’s Foreign Ministry hoped the
perpetrators would be caught as soon as possible.(end) ta.

TURKEY: Religious freedom via Strasbourg, not Ankara or Brussels?

Journal Chrétien, France
Jan 20 2007

TURKEY : Religious freedom via Strasbourg, not Ankara or Brussels ?

By Dr. Otmar Oehring, head of the human rights office of Missio

There are now two major questions in the struggle for full religious
freedom in Turkey, Otmar Oehring of the German Catholic charity
Mission
en-kulturen/themen/menschenrechte
notes. Firstly, will the controversial Foundations Law be adopted,
and if so in what form ? Secondly, will the Turkish authorities move
towards full religious freedom after a recent momentous ruling by the
European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) in Strasbourg ? The ECHR did
not accept the Turkish state’s argumentation over the seizure of
non-Muslim minorities’ property, and even the Turkish judge at the
Court had no objections to the ruling. In this personal commentary
for Forum 18 News Service , Dr Oehring suggests
that, as Turkish accession negotiations with the European Union have
gone quiet, the ECHR may now be the best route for Turkey’s religious
minorities to assert their rights.

Two issues remain at the forefront of attention for Turkey’s
non-Muslim religious minorities :
whether the controversial Foundations Law will be adopted (and if so
in what form) ;
and whether the authorities will take any steps towards religious
freedom and towards recognising the legal status of religious
communities in the wake of a momentous 9 January ruling by the
European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) in Strasbourg.

In case No. 34478/97, the ECHR ruled in favour of a Greek Orthodox
community foundation running a High School in Istanbul’s Fener area
(Fener Rum Erkek Lisesi Vakfi) that acquired a building in Istanbul’s
Beyoglu area in 1952 by donation. The building was confiscated by the
state as a result of a court case launched by the Turkish authorities
in 1992 based on a ruling of the Court of Cassation of 1974 referring
to the so-called 1936 declaration on the registration of community
foundations. The ECHR held that the Foundation’s rights to its
property had been violated and ordered the property legally returned
to the Foundation or, if the authorities failed to do so, to award
compensation of 890,000 Euros. It also awarded costs of 20,000 Euros
to the Foundation.

The ECHR decision is positive – even if it is quite narrow in its
scope. It shows that the Court does not accept the Turkish state’s
argumentation over the seizure of non-Muslim minorities’ property.
Significantly, even the Turkish judge at the Court had no objections
to the ruling.

The Foundation has been seeking to protect its rights through the
Turkish courts since 1992. In the wake of the rejection of this
attempt in 1996, the Foundation lodged the case at the ECHR as far
back as 1998 – an unusually long time to reach a ruling even by the
Strasbourg court’s standards. The Turkish government showed close
interest in the case, with eight representatives involved at the
court. Most probably the number of submissions from the Turkish
government prolonged the case.

Although the Turkish press speculated excitedly about changes to the
legal rights of foundations in the aftermath of the ECHR ruling, I
doubt that changes will be far-reaching : the ruling itself will
probably have an impact only on the community foundations that are
allowed to some of Turkey’s religious minorities. Even so, under the
Lausanne Treaty there is no reason why other non-Muslim minorities
should not have such community foundations. The impact on religious
freedom more broadly is likely to be minimal.

Yet far more significantly, the ruling will provide a boost to
religious minorities who will be encouraged to see the ECHR as a
route to seeking the vindication of their rights. The Ecumenical
Patriarchate has already lodged a number of cases in Strasbourg over
property and the Armenian Patriarchate is likely to follow.

In one of its cases already at Strasbourg, the Ecumenical
Patriarchate is challenging the confiscation of its orphanage in
Büyükada, Princes Islands, arguing, in accordance with the title in
the land deed – Owner : Greek Orthodox Patriarchate – that the
orphanage is the property of the Patriarchate, a right Turkey says
does not exist. The authorities do not recognise the legal existence
of the Patriarchate – whether under the name the Greek Patriarchate
(Rum patrikhanesi), as the Turkish authorities prefer, or under the
name the Ecumenical Patriarchate, to which the Turkish authorities
virulently object – and therefore claim that it cannot own property.

Experts say that it does not matter either whether the Court rules
that the Patriarchate exists (therefore it can own property), or
whether the Court rules that the orphanage belongs to the
Patriarchate (therefore the Patriarchate must exist in law). Either
way the Court will recognise the Patriarchate’s right to a legal
existence.

Moreover, presuming that the ECHR will rule in favour of the
Patriarchate, this would provide a precedent that should force the
Turkish authorities to treat other religious-owned properties and
their owners in the same way.

The Vincentians, a Catholic Congregation, are also considering
lodging a case over a confiscated orphanage in Istanbul, originally
run by nuns, which it argues was church property. The Vincentians
explain that the orphanage was originally registered as the property
of one of its priests, as foreigners could not then generally buy
property. After his death, the Turkish authorities sought the seizure
of all property registered in his name and in 1991 the nuns were
"shamefully" expelled as the Directorate General for Foundations
(which should never have been involved as this property was not owned
by a community foundation) had sublet the property to a private
company.

But even more crucially, potential new cases from religious
minorities are likely to tackle head-on the religious freedom itself
of Turkey’s religious minorities, not just their ownership of
properties either through their foundations or directly as for
example in the case of property of Catholic religious orders.

Progress elsewhere has been slow. During Pope Benedict’s visit to
Turkey at the end of last year, according to information given by
media outside Turkey, Vatican representatives and government
officials discussed the possibility of establishing a mixed working
group to resolve the Catholic Church’s problems in Turkey, especially
over property and work permits for clergy and nuns. Catholics in the
country heard nothing about any progress on the working group during
the visit, and on 7 January the Vatican’s Secretary of State Cardinal
Tarcisio Bertone renewed the Church’s urging to the government to
initiate the working group. The Turkish government has still not
reacted at all to the Vatican proposal – at least in public – even
though prime minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan himself proposed setting
up a number of joint working groups when he met members of the
Turkish Bishops’ Conference back in 2004.

The long-running saga of the Foundations Law – which might have
resolved property problems for the foundations allowed to some
non-Muslim ethnic/religious communities – reached a new twist on 2
December, when President Ahmet Necdet Sezer, a committed secularist,
vetoed the Law which had been approved by the Turkish Parliament on 9
November (see F18News 22 November 2006
?article_id=875).

The Foundations Law (No.5555) – which was intended to replace the
Foundations Law No.3027 of 1935 – was due to regulate the rights of
all foundations, whether Muslim or non-Muslim, though much of the
attention focused on the way it would have affected non-Muslim
foundations. Muslim foundations would have found their lives little
changed – the Law would merely have codified existing law.

Contrary to expectations, the Parliament’s version of the Law did not
offer what the non-Muslim minorities had expected over defunct
foundations, or over the property confiscated from foundations by the
state in the wake of a 1974 High Court ruling and then sold on to
third parties.

Before Parliament approved the Law, non-Muslim circles were abuzz
with discussion over whether they should hope for this law’s adoption
or not. Many argued that any law adopted would be in a very negative
version that could not then be amended for another ten or twenty
years.

When Parliament adopted the law, reaction among Christian and Jewish
communities was mixed. Some were happy that at least a few of the
points put forward by minorities had been considered, such as the
demand for return of or compensation for properties confiscated by
the state as a result of the 1974 High Court ruling and still in
state hands.

On the negative side, reciprocity – a principle that has been
deployed especially to restrict the rights of the Ecumenical
Patriarchate, with its treatment tied to the Greek government’s
treatment of its Turkish Muslim minority – was enshrined in law for
the first time. Although Greece does unfairly restrict the rights of
its Muslim minority, such restrictions are not as extensive as those
imposed by the Turkish government on its Greek Orthodox minority. Yet
it is quite clear that the formal inclusion of the reciprocity
principle in Turkey’s Foundations Law was done deliberately as an
excuse to restrict Greek Orthodox rights.

President Sezer’s veto of the Foundations Law was harshly criticised
even in the Turkish liberal media. Most of the President’s
justification was based on points he disliked which affected
non-Muslim minorities. He argued that some of these provisions went
too far in their favour and went too far against the Turkish
interpretation of its obligation to its ethnic/religious minorities
under the 1923 Lausanne Treaty. On one point the President insisted
that it is impossible to recognise a foundation and its ownership of
properties for which there is no certificate as a foundation.

One leading journalist from the Istanbul-based Radikal newspaper
argued that this was strange as when such properties were accumulated
no community foundations existed – such properties were simply social
and educational institutions. Permits to own them were issued in a
different way, as in the Ottoman Empire even in the late 19th century
ownership regulations comparable to those valid today did just not
exist.

Although the President vetoed the Foundations Law it has not returned
to parliament. Deputy Prime Minister Mehmet Ali Sahin declared in the
wake of the ECHR ruling on the Greek Orthodox college Foundation that
some parts of the Law would have to be redrafted. Any changes ought
to cover foundations’ properties seized by the state and then sold on
to third parties, an issue not even mentioned – let alone resolved –
in Parliament’s version of the Law. Yet it will be difficult to
overcome many deputies’ view that compensating religious minorities
for such seized property will be too expensive and that the issue
should therefore be dropped (see F18News 22 November 2006
?article_id=875).

Implementation of the Law – had it been adopted – would also have run
into problems as some provisions contradict other legal provisions,
especially those found in the Civil Code.

But such contradictions already abound. Even though Article 110 of
the Civil Code bans the formation of foundations with religious
purposes, at least three such foundations – two Protestant and one
Syrian Catholic – have been founded during the last few years.
Whether this means that the related congregations as such have got
legal personality as foundations or whether these foundations are
foundations of congregations which as such still are not recognised
legally still has to be discussed as more and more cases will go to
the ECHR not just on the principle but on establishing foundations.

Alevis – a Muslim group the government does not recognise as a
distinct religious minority – could also demand religious foundations
– so far their places of worship are recognised only as cultural
associations (see F18News 22 November 2006
?article_id=875).

Property ownership for minority communities has been and remains
beset with problems. Places of worship of minority communities which
are allowed to maintain legally-recognised community foundations –
such as the Greek Orthodox, the Armenians, the Syrian Orthodox and
the Jews – are owned by these foundations.

But for Catholics and Protestants, who have not historically been
allowed such foundations, title deeds indicate that the congregations
or church communities themselves own the buildings. Yet the state
often refuses to recognise this. For example, it argued in ECHR case
No. 26308/95 that the Assumptionist Fathers, a Catholic Order, are
unknown in Turkey, so cannot own property. Places of worship which
belong to communities which do not have foundations are in a worse
legal situation than those owned by foundations.

In several extreme cases in the recent past, the state has argued
that some Christian churches owned by foundations are in fact the
property of individual saints (they are after all named after them).
The state has gone on to argue from this that the saints concerned
cannot be located – nor their heirs – so these places of worship
cannot be returned to the community foundations that claim ownership
and should therefore be seized by the state. Nowadays, the state is
more willing to accept that minority communities’ foundations own
such places of worship.

But the problems for communities without foundations do not end with
insecure legal ownership of their places of worship. Such communities
cannot run bank accounts. A priest, bishop, individual or group of
individuals has to set up a personal bank account on behalf of the
community. The same even holds for communities with foundations, such
as the Orthodox or Jews : their community foundations themselves are
recognised but not the churches or Jewish congregations behind them.
Such a restriction could be challenged at the ECHR – it is part of
the whole issue of the lack of recognition of religious minority
communities.

Publication of books and magazines is also more complicated – they
have to be published in the name of an individual, who therefore has
to take personal responsibility for their content. This has created
problems in the past, though less so today.

Religious communities’ charitable bodies also have no legal status.
Caritas Turkey, for example, functions under the control of the
Turkish Catholic Bishops’ Conference (which also legally does not
exist) and even works with government agencies, but has no legal
status.

Religious leaders’ status is not recognised in law. The one exception
is with the leaders of Protestant associations that have recently
been allowed to register (see F18News 22 November 2006
?article_id=875), though even then
they are recognised as leaders of an association, not of the
religious community per se.

As to the vetoed Foundations Law, the government can send it to
parliament again for further discussion – as President Sezer
indicated in his veto – although if it is again approved the
president cannot veto it a second time. His only option if he still
disagrees with provisions in it is to refer it to the Constitutional
Court. The government’s other alternative is to abandon it – or wait
until the next presidential elections expected in May, which many
predict Erdogan will win.

Although Sezer did not spell it out bluntly, his comments on the
vetoed Foundations Law make clear that he does not want any of the
properties confiscated from foundations over the years to be given
back. He sticks to the understanding of the Kemalists, the followers
of Mustafa Kemal Ataturk, of how Turkey should be governed. Erdogan,
on the other hand, is no more in favour of religious minorities’
foundations, but takes a different view of the state’s role.

Yet sadly, neither of the two big parties, the governing Justice and
Development Party (AKP) or the opposition Republican People’s Party
(CHP), is willing to accept the principle that all people have
rights, regardless of what was determined at Sevres back in 1920 and
Lausanne back in 1923. Neither party gives any sign that it has read
or understood Article 9 of the European Convention on Human Rights,
which spells out individuals’ rights to religious freedom, still less
that it is ready to implement it.

Now that negotiations with the European Union over Turkey’s potential
accession have gone quiet – and the Turkish government feels less
constrained to make concessions over religious freedom – the European
Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg appears to have taken over as the
best route for Turkey’s religious minorities to assert their rights.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

http://www.missio-aachen.de/mensch
http://www.forum18.org
http://www.forum18.org/Archive.php
http://www.forum18.org/Archive.php
http://www.forum18.org/Archive.php
http://www.forum18.org/Archive.php
http://www.spcm.org/Journal/spip.php?article5763