BAKU: Discussion of Lennmarker’s report in OSCE PA inexpedient

Azeri Press Agency, Azerbaijan
Jan 26 2007

Bahar Muradova: Discussion of Lennmarker’s report in OSCE PA will be
considered inexpedient

[ 26 Jan. 2007 15:42 ]

`Armenian’s unconstructive position impedes the influence of any
effort on the settlement of Nagorno Karabakh conflict,’ head of the
Azerbaijani delegation to OSCE Parliamentary Assembly, vice-speaker
Bahar Muradova said, APA reports.

Bahar Muradova said that Azerbaijan and Armenia have their own
positions concerning the report of OSCE PA chairman, co-rapporteur on
Nagorno Karabakh Goran Lennmarker and it was impossible to bring
these positions close.
`All decisions in OSCE are adopted by consensus. Therefore it was
inexpedient to raise the report with so many contrasted positions to
discussion. There is no change in these positions. I think that in
case there are no changes, serious achievement or positive result in
the process of negotiations, OSCE officials will again consider it
inexpedient to raise this report to discussion,’ she said. /APA/

Making Their Voices Heard: Screamers

Washington Post, DC
Jan 26 2007

Making Their Voices Heard
Friday, January 26, 2007; Page WE34

Rife with rotting corpses, severed heads and massacred children,
"Screamers" is one of the most horrifying movies I’ve ever seen.
Sadly, it’s a documentary, not a slasher flick. A strident reckoning
on a century of genocide, the film exhumes a Turkish campaign to
exterminate Armenians in 1915, then casts a baleful eye on
preventable slaughters up to the current ethnic cleansing in Darfur.
But sadly, too, its call to action is somewhat undermined by unsubtle
artistry.

"Screamers" isn’t easy to watch, and not entirely because of its
content. There is much ear-hammering heavy metal music and
full-throated screaming, courtesy of the band System of a Down, whose
members are Armenian American. The film is mainly their story — part
history lesson, part political broadside, part concert travelogue —
with unwieldy results. Oral accounts from now-frail Armenian
survivors and witnesses don’t quite mix with strobe lights,
headbanging fans and tour-bus antics.

Teamed with filmmaker Carla Garapedian (also Armenian American), the
band is out to make the Turkish government own up to a "wild orgy of
blood" (as one witness wrote to President Woodrow Wilson) after
decades of denial. Most engaging in its second half, the documentary
also indicts U.S. and British political leadership for failing to
officially use the word "genocide" in connection with the deaths of
as many as 1.5 million Armenians. Persistent vows of "never again"
ring shamefully hollow in the abattoirs of Rwanda, Bosnia and Darfur.

The film paraphrases a quote from Hitler before he invaded Poland in
1939 (a quote still in hot dispute): "Who still speaks nowadays of
the extermination of the Armenians?"

This documentary does. Whatever its flaws, that alone makes it worth
seeing.

— Richard Leiby

Screamers R, 91 minutes Contains graphic gore, disturbing images and
profanity. At AMC Hoffman Center.

Turkish authorities charge 6th suspect in Dink killing

International Herald Tribune, France
Jan 26 2007

Turkish authorities charge 6th suspect in ethnic Armenian
journalist’s killing
The Associated PressPublished: January 26, 2007

ISTANBUL, Turkey: Turkish authorities charged a sixth suspect Friday
in the slaying of prominent ethnic Armenian journalist Hrant Dink,
police said.

Dink, who spoke out about the mass killings of Armenians in the early
20th century, was gunned down outside his newspaper a week ago in a
killing that raised fears that Turkey may continue to be a dangerous
place for intellectuals who openly express their ideas.

University student Erhan Tuncel was formally arrested Friday on
charges of instigating the killing, at the end of the legal four-day
detention period, police said. A seventh suspect, detained along with
Tuncel, was released without being charged.

Five other suspects, including alleged gunman Ogun Samast and Yasin
Hayal, a nationalist militant who served time in prison for a 2004
attack and who police say confessed to inciting the slaying and to
providing a gun and money to Samast, were charged Wednesday.

Also Friday, the government sacked the governor and the police chief
of the Black Sea city of Trabzon, where all the suspects were based.
Both men had come under criticism after Dink’s killing for allegedly
not closely surveilling Hayal despite his conviction for bombing a
McDonald’s restaurant in 2004.

It was in their city last year that Rev. Andrea Santoro, a
60-year-old Italian Catholic priest, was shot dead by an apparently
Islamist youth angered by the publication in Europe of cartoons of
the Prophet Muhammad.

Authorities, meanwhile, launched a separate investigation into Hayal
for what appeared to be a threat against Nobel Prize-winning novelist
Orhan Pamuk – who like Dink has been vocal about the killings of
Armenians, police said.

Hayal shouted: "Orhan Pamuk, be smart! Be smart!" as he was being
brought to an Istanbul courtroom with his hands cuffed behind his
back Wednesday. The investigation could lead to Hayal’s prosecution
if it concludes that his words amounted to a threat against the
novelist.

Dink, the 52-year-old editor of the bilingual Ago newspaper, had been
brought to trial numerous times for allegedly "insulting
Turkishness," a crime under Turkey’s penal code.

Pamuk, who won the Nobel Prize in literature last year, also had
faced trial in Turkey for his comments on the Armenian killings and
had been accused of treason for doing so. His case was thrown out on
a technicality.

Dink’s murder inspired a massive outpouring of support for liberal
values, including freedom of expression, tolerance and reconciliation
between Armenians and Turks,

But the killing also pointed to Turkey’s continuing problems with
extreme nationalism. Most Turks suspect the killing might be linked
to ultra-nationalist groups.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

BAKU: Armenians hold Tofig Hajibabayev in capture for 15 years

Azeri Press Agency, Azerbaijan
Jan 26 2007

Armenians hold Tofig Hajibabayev in capture for 15 years

[ 26 Jan. 2007 15:11 ]

It was defined that the soldier of Azerbaijani Army Tofig Hajibabayev
who was missing during Dashalti operation in 1992 is in Yerevan for
15 years, soldier’s relative Gulnara Ahmadova said.

She noted that they considered him to be dead, but recently they knew
that he is being kept in Yerevan for 15 years.
`The chief of social unity for of `Hasrat Yolu’ Esmira Orujova said
that Tofig is in Yerevan. Up to now any of international
organizations did not take measures to find him,’ she said. /APA/

TBILISI: Khadjimba says no ethnic tensions in run up to elections

The Messenger, Georgia
Jan 26 2007

Khadjimba says no ethnic tensions in run up to separatist elections
By Ekaterina Basilaia

The vice-president of breakaway Abkhazia, Raul Khadjimba, has
rebuffed speculation from Georgian expert Mamuka Areshidze that there
might be ethnic tensions between the Armenian and Abkhaz communities
in breakaway Abkhazia in the run up to the forthcoming de facto
parliamentary elections, Apsnypress reported on January 24.

"The confrontations between Abkhazians and Armenians, desirable and
provoked by outside forces, will not occur," Khadjimba argued in his
interview with Apsnyrpress.

"This has been specially concocted to deteriorate the situation in
Abkhazia on the eve of the upcoming elections," Khadjimba maintained.

In an interview posted by Georgian newspaper Svobodnaya Gruzia
Areshidze stated that "soon the Armenian community, which makes up
the greatest part of the population of Abkhazia, might become a
headache for the Abkhaz authorities, as far as they are trying to
strengthen their position in the region."

According to Areshidze, local Armenians who are twice as numerous as
ethnic Abkhaz, control substantial economic levers in the region,
thanks to the positive attitude of de facto Abkhaz president Sergei
Bagapsh towards them.

There is a long-drawn rivalry between Bagapsh and Kajimba, who
currently share power in the breakaway region.

According to speculations in Georgian media, the reason for Khadjimba
defeat in 2004 ‘presidential elections’ in the breakaway region was
his "obvious aversion" towards local Armenians. "Consequently,
Armenians, dissatisfied with Khadjimba, supported Sergei Bagapsh in
the presidential race," Georgian media reported.

Areshidze says another factor increasing tension between Armenians
and the Abkhaz population has to do with "the Armenian community’s
desire to increase its current informal quota in parliament from
three seats in the 35-member Parliament to five in the upcoming
elections."

The main political movements competing in the elections slated for
March 4 will be United Abkhazia, Aitara (Revival) and Amtsakhara
(Signal Light), which are supportive of current de facto president
Bagapsh. They will run against candidates from the "Forum for
National Unity," an opposition movement where followers of
vice-president Khadjimba are united. The Abkhaz Communist Party,
which is teaming up with the Russian Communist Party, will also take
part in parliamentary elections.

Currently Armenians make up the largest minority group in Abkhazia.

Murders spark soul-searching in sleepy Black Sea town

Reuters, UK
Jan 26 2007

Murders spark soul-searching in sleepy Black Sea town
Fri Jan 26, 2007 10:57 AM GMT

By Gareth Jones

TRABZON, Turkey (Reuters) – Mustafa Coskun fears his once sleepy
Black Sea town has become a byword in Turkey for nationalist violence
after a string of nasty incidents culminating in the murder of a
Turkish-Armenian editor.

"We are all brothers, we have always liked foreigners here. But now,
when I go to other places in Turkey, they point and say ‘Oh, he’s
from Trabzon, they are all crazy there’," said Coskun, 48, sipping
tea at his market stall near the sea.

Trabzon seems an unlikely place for controversy of any kind.

Nearby, fishermen mend their nets. Seagulls skim the water,
snow-capped hills loom up above the town. There is a smell of fish
and pungent Russian tobacco — a reminder that Russia and Georgia are
just a few hundred km (miles) east and northeast.

But this town of 300,000 people — the fabled Trebizond which once
captivated Silk Road explorers such as Marco Polo — is now asking
how it could have raised youngsters capable of murders that have
shocked the world.

An unemployed youth from Trabzon, Ogun Samast, 17, has been charged
with killing Hrant Dink, an ethnic Armenian writer, in Istanbul last
Friday. Dink’s views on Ottoman Turkish massacres of Armenians in
1915 had angered Turkish nationalists.

The murder has reignited debate about hardline nationalism in Turkey,
which wants to join the European Union.

A man who has confessed to inciting Samast, Yasin Hayal, is also from
Trabzon. In 2004 he was behind the bombing of a restaurant in the
town.

Last year, a 16-year-old boy was jailed for shooting dead an Italian
Catholic priest as he prayed in his church in Trabzon. Turkish media
say the boy had fallen under the influence of Islamist,
anti-Christian and ultra-nationalist ideas.

ECONOMIC WOES

Zeynep Erdugrul knows how dangerous it can be in Trabzon to challenge
Turkey’s status quo.

She and four friends were almost lynched two years ago by a
2,000-strong crowd before police intervened. Handing out leaflets
about leftists jailed in Turkey, they were mistaken for supporters of
Kurdish rebel fighters.

"But I do not think Trabzon is more nationalistic than other towns in
Turkey. The problems are economic. There’s no industry, agriculture
is dying, young people turn to drugs," she said.

Asked if she saw any connection between the spate of violent
incidents, she said: "I think the state is responsible. It suits the
state to have clashes, be they between Turks and Kurds or between
secularists and Islamists."

Police have dismissed such suggestions.

Many in Trabzon say those who shot the priest and Dink were tools of
outside forces, possibly with links to the "deep state" — shorthand
in Turkey for shadowy, fiercely nationalistic elements in the
security forces and bureaucracy.

"They can’t have carried out these murders alone. They were
manipulated, brainwashed," Israfil Babaoglu, 18, said in an Internet
cafe similar to those used by the teenage gunmen. Like others, he
would not speculate who the "brainwashers" were.

For Trabzon’s governor, Huseyin Yavuzdemir, the killings are a
symptom of deeper social problems linked to fast urbanisation. People
have been migrating from the country to the town over the past decade
and both parents work to make ends meet, he said.

"Parents leave their kids in Internet cafes while they go shopping.
This is wrong. We have 250 such cafes here," he said.

Yavuzdemir played down economic factors, saying Trabzon is more
prosperous than many eastern provincial towns and its unemployment
level of nine percent is near the national average.

GUNS AND GREEKS

But he cited factors specific to Trabzon that could have contributed
to the violence, including a strong gun culture and the fiery
character of the people, known in Turkey for a quickness to take
offence.

Yavuzdemir also mentioned the view of sociologists that Trabzon
people try to assert their national identity more than many other
Turks because their region traditionally contained large ethnic Greek
and Armenian communities.

Sociologist Adem Solak, of the Black Sea Technical University, said a
big influx of criminals and prostitutes from Russia, Ukraine and
Georgia after the Soviet Union’s demise in 1991 had shocked the
conservative local culture.

"The struggle of values continues now, with the ‘clash of
civilisations’, the Iraq war, the crisis over the cartoons (in
published in Denmark depicting the Prophet Mohammad). All these have
a negative effect on our young people," said Solak.

"And the decline in the fortunes of (once successful local soccer
team) Trabzonspor is also traumatic for the morale of young people in
a soccer-mad city like this," he said.

Turkey’s Suicide: Our old ally’s bent on self-destruction

New York Post, NY
Jan 26 2007

TURKEY’S SUICIDE

OUR OLD ALLY’S BENT ON SELF-DESTRUCTION

by Peter Ralph

January 26, 2007 — IT’S hard to watch an old pal hit the skids,
making one disastrous decision after another, throwing away a
brilliant future. That’s the position we’re in with Turkey – a former
ally bent on self-destruction.

A NATO member ideally positioned to serve as a bridge between the
West and the Middle East, Turkey’s secular constitution and economic
progress should have made it an example for other regional states to
emulate. Instead, Turkey has been aping the blighted regimes of the
Arab world:

* Exploiting the population’s disgust with government corruption,
Islamists gained power through the ballot box – and immediately
started dismantling the secular legacy of Kemal Ataturk.

* On the eve of Operation Iraqi Freedom, Turkey stabbed the United
States – its only dependable ally – in the back, denying passage to
our troops in the fateful illusion that Ankara could save Saddam.

* Turkey strangled its (always faint) chance of membership in the
European Union with internal repression, ludicrous prosecutions,
farcical legislative efforts to Talibanize society and its stubborn
denial of the Armenian genocide.

* Instead of winning Europe’s approval, the government-sponsored
anti-American hate speech poisoning Turkey’s media only strengthens
European convictions that Turks "aren’t our kind."

* Impatient to send Turkish troops into Iraq to attack the PKK (a
radical Kurdish group with a terrorist past), Ankara might face a
startling military embarrassment, further alienate Washington – and
finish off its last prayer of EU membership. (The Europeans just want
excuses to keep Turkey out – and Turkey has a genius for providing
them.)

* Despite the potential for a mutually beneficial relationship with
Iraqi Kurdistan – where Turkish businessmen make substantial profits
– the Ankara government obsesses about preventing the emergence of a
Kurdish state. Betting on Iraq’s Sunni Arabs (who despise the Turks
but use them), Turkey has set itself up to lose big if Iraq
dissolves.

* With its mischief-making in Iraq, cloak-and-dagger monkey business
with Syria and failure to appreciate Iranian deviousness, Turkish
foreign policy is in a self-destructive shambles unrivaled since the
foundation of the modern Turkish state.

All of this leaves me in sorrow, since I spent decades arguing that
Turkey’s strategic importance required us to be patient as this land
of enormous potential found its way to the future.

For an enthusiastic visitor to Turkey for three decades, it’s been
heartbreaking to watch its society and economy come to life – only to
fall prey to Islamist vampires.

With Salafism – the Saudi brand of radical Islam – biting into the
Turkish political jugular, the joke is that the despised Bedouins of
Arabia have finally conquered the "Ottoman Empire." The most
primitive and backward form of Islam is increasingly at home in the
heartlands that had formed the core of the most powerful Muslim state
for five centuries.

Now the question isn’t whether our old ally can overcome its internal
difficulties, but which of its troubles will overwhelm it first. Will
the Islamist destruction of Turkish culture continue, or will a
rumored military coup plunge the country back into another period of
internal violence and political stasis?

For Washington, it’s all bad news. The march of punitive Islam
(punitive, above all, to Muslims) continues to feed on wild-eyed
anti-Americanism – but a military coup could lead to a misadventure
in northern Iraq similar to Argentina’s Falklands debacle.

Last week’s murder of the Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink (in
which Islamo-nationalists cynically employed a 17-year-old assassin
who could only be charged as a juvenile) laid bare the divide in
Turkish society: 100,000 Turks turned out to protest the barbarous
killing, but the government barely shrugged, since the demagogues now
command far greater numbers.

Turkey’s educated elite is in much the same position as Germany’s
elite during Hitler’s rise to power. Imagining that the Islamists
would sputter out, progressive Turks failed to act. Now Turkish
civilization – so great for so many centuries – is unraveling the way
Germany’s did in the 1930s. Turkish intellectuals made the classic
error of underestimating the common man’s capacity for hatred and
lust for blind revenge.

As for the spectacularly virulent and dishonest anti-Americanism in
the Turkish media – we need never have a "Who lost Turkey?" debate:
The Turks lost it for themselves. Instead of maturing into the
Western culture of responsibility, Turks succumbed to the Arab
world’s culture of blame.

Having looked down on Arabs for centuries, Turks are now becoming
functional Arabs, reclining into fantasies of greatness as surreal as
a Sufi mystic’s hashish dreams. Ataturk’s revolutionary vision for a
modern Turkish state – betrayed by his own corrupt successors – is
fading into the reality of yet another retarded Muslim satrapy.

An even more accurate parallel case than 1930s Germany is today’s
Pakistan. Turkey is on the way to becoming another extremist-poisoned
garrison state held together solely by its military.

On my last visit, I got a madman’s lecture from a Turkish customs
officer on the resurrection of the Ottoman Empire. But instead of
returning to that empire’s undeniable glories, 21st- century Turkey
appears determined to replay the miserable Ottoman twilight.

I wish we could save Turkey. But we can’t. That’s up to the Turks.

Ralph Peters’ latest book is "Never Quit The Fight."

/postopinion/opedcolumnists/turkeys_suicide_opedco lumnists_ralph_peters.htm

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

http://www.nypost.com/seven/01262007

BAKU: Van der Linden: PACE can’t make parties agree to a certain key

Azeri Press Agency
Jan 26 2007

Rene van der Linden: PACE can not make any party agree to a certain
key to the NK conflict

[ 26 Jan. 2007 13:31 ]

President of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe René
van der Linden interviewed by the APA European bureau

– How do you appreciate the cooperation between the PACE and
Azerbaijan?
– Azerbaijan is the member of the Council of Europe for 6 years. I
congratulate the Republic of Azerbaijan and its people. The
delegation of your country to the PACE is very active. I consider
that they should be mediators between the Azerbaijani parliament and
the Council of Europe, taking into account important issues discussed
here, as well as the importance of Azerbaijan’s fulfilment of all
commitments. The report on Azerbaijan will be heard in PACE session
in April. The state of political prisoners, press, political
opposition in Azerbaijan are among the issues of our concern.
Achievement in these issues is very important for Azerbaijan’s
development.
– When is Azerbaijan expected to be included in the list of
post-monitoring countries?
– I think that the countries under monitoring should be pleased with
it. This is a sort of help. If any country has strict commitments and
the CE helps to solve them, these countries should be satisfied that
they will soon fulfil their commitments.
– The members of Azerbaijani delegation asked to include them in the
list of speakers, but they did not make any speech. What is the
reason?
– I feel regret. You know that we come together only four times in a
year and we have less time to make speeches. This session was
dedicated to the rights of children, that is why the discussions were
held on this topic. Besides, the discussions on Kosovo problem took
much time. If the members of Azerbaijani delegation consider that we
made changes to the list, then they should appeal to me in written
form. This is very important issue; all countries should be treated
in the same level. I can not take a stance to happenings yet, I can
only say this kind of fact was not recorded during my chairmanship.
– Though Armenia continues to keep Azerbaijani lands under
occupation, your organization does exert pressure on them. But PACE
has special resolution…
– We continue to put pressure. We especially direct these pressures
on Armenia, but Azerbaijan is also being exerted. The reason is to
achieve the settlement of the conflict is very important. This is
political issue and we need political will in this issue. I think
that the meetings of the presidents were positive enough,
unfortunately, the negotiations on the settlement of the conflict
remains ineffective. I hope that by the assistance of international
organizations the settlement of the conflict will be achieved. /APA/

Ottawa: Ethnic groups unite in push to deport Nazi suspects

Globe and Mail, Canada
Jan 26 2007

Ethnic groups unite in push to deport Nazi suspects

Communities ‘feel it in their bones,’ says Jewish group leader
GLORIA GALLOWAY

OTTAWA — Four ethnic communities that have suffered persecution in
their homelands will join Jewish groups in demanding that Immigration
Minister Diane Finley deport six men accused of aiding the Nazis in
the Holocaust.

Representatives of the Armenian National Committee of Canada, the
Darfur Association of Canada, PAGE-Rwanda and the Roma Community
Centre will take part in a news conference on Tuesday to press for
the action that has been urged by Jews in this country for many
years.

"If any community can understand the moral imperative, it’s
communities that have themselves been part of the murderous aspect of
genocide," Bernie Farber, the chief executive officer of the Canadian
Jewish Congress, said yesterday.

"They feel it viscerally. They feel it in their bones. They
understand that they, by the grace of God, escaped. They came to this
country to live in freedom. And the last thing they would have
expected is that the country . . .would deem it appropriate . . . to
allow war criminals to live here."

The Canadian Jewish Congress and other groups like the Friends of
the Simon Wiesenthal Center for Holocaust Studies have asked
successive governments to expel six men found by the courts to have
misrepresented their wartime activities to gain entry to Canada.

They are Helmut Oberlander, whose citizenship was ordered revoked for
his activities as a member of an elite killing unit; Vladimir
Katriuk, who was accused of Nazi collaboration; Wasyl Odynsky, who is
alleged to have served as a guard at two SS forced-labour camps;
Jacob Fast, who is alleged to have collaborated with the Nazis; Jura
Skomatchuk, who is alleged to have been a guard at an SS camp; and
Josef Furman, who is also alleged to have been an SS guard.

The Jewish groups had hoped that Prime Minister Stephen Harper would
announce some movement on the deportations when he attended a B’nai
Brith dinner in Toronto last year. That didn’t happen, and Ms. Finley
did not return phone calls yesterday.

But Mr. Farber said he and other members of the Jewish community
still hope something will be done.

"This gathering on Tuesday will focus that hope and make it clear
this is not just a Jewish issue, that this is an issue about
multicultural Canada," he said.

"We cannot even start to deal with the present and understand the
impact in the future in relation to war criminals being in our
country until we at least start dealing with the past."

ANKARA: Strength in diversity

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
Jan 26 2007

Strength in diversity

Nicole Pope

The solidarity and unity displayed during Hrant Dink’s funeral
inspired some hope that his senseless murder would mark a turning
point and be the forerunner of change in Turkey.

Abdullah Gül’s acknowledgement that Article 301 needs to be amended
was welcome, as was the overture made by the Armenian Deputy Foreign
Minister Arman Kirakosyan, who offered an unconditional resumption of
diplomatic contacts.

There are of course just as many reasons to keep a tight rein on our
expectations. Tens of thousands of people attended the funeral, but
neither the president nor the prime minister was among the
participants, although Recep Tayyip Erdogan did pay a private visit
to Dink’s family later. Wednesday also marked the anniversary of
journalist Uğur Mumcu’s murder, which had led to similar display
of popular support 14 years ago but still remains to be fully
explained.
Turkish society is criss-crossed by numerous fault lines —
Kurd-Turk, Alevi-Sunni, secular-religious, Christian-Muslim — that
must be bridged to prevent the kind of polarization that killed Hrant
Dink and others before him. The hard-hitting and soul-searching
editorials published in the Turkish press in the past few days are
undoubtedly contributing to a more open debate. Airing ideas in the
public arena prevents radical views from festering and developing
like mushrooms in the darkness of Internet chat rooms, where
radicalism finds an easy platform.
But the official reflex is still to keep the lid shut on these
differences. This lack of flexibility has always led the Turkish
state to have an uneasy relationship with intellectuals and writers
who have promoted a diversity of opinions.
I remember attending a prize-giving ceremony for Yasar Kemal at the
Frankfurt book fair 10 years ago. Feted by the international literary
world, Yasar Kemal had been dragged through the courts in Turkey for
one of his articles on the Kurdish issue, yet the Turkish culture
minister was giving a reception in his honor at the fair. It seemed
bizarre that Turkey could at the same time proudly celebrate the
success of one of its citizens and charge him for his views. Orhan
Pamuk’s Nobel prize last year was greeted with a similar ambivalence
in official circles.
Only a few days ago, the rector of Istanbul University declared in an
interview published in Sabah newspaper that he would not invite Orhan
Pamuk or Yasar Kemal to teach at his university because of their
opinions. Such a narrow-minded approach to learning deprives students
of a chance to be exposed to a variety of opinions, which are
necessary for them to develop critical thinking and to gain an
understanding of the world beyond the borders of the country.
Critical thought is one of the building blocks of a democratic
society, but the notion that criticism can be constructive and useful
is still not well understood by the Turkish authorities. Deviating
from the received opinion is too often perceived as an insult or a
form of betrayal, largely because diversity — of views, of ethnic
roots, of religions — is still seen as the country’s Achille’s heel.
In fact, diversity is one of Turkey’s best assets. Together with
growing openness to the world, individualism and creativity, it is
among the elements fuelling Turkey’s rapid social and economic
transformation, but its value has yet to be recognized by Turkish
officialdom.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress