Book Review: Of missionary zeal and its consequences

International Herald Tribune, France
Jan 26 2007

Of missionary zeal and its consequences

By Max Rodenbeck Published: January 26, 2007

Power, Faith, and Fantasy America in the Middle East, 1776 to the
Present. By Michael B. Oren. 778 pages. $35; £22. W.W. Norton.

Around the time of the War of Independence, America’s main contact
with the Middle East consisted in trading Caribbean rum for Turkish
opium. It’s hard not to wish, reading the epic story of this 230-year
relationship, now usefully condensed into a single well-researched
volume, that things could have remained as simple as the swapping of
your recreational poison for mine.

But things never were quite so simple.

Even then the potential for friction loomed as large as the
possibility of mutual gain. Before the end of the Napoleonic wars,
Christian sailors risked capture and enslavement by Muslim pirates
from the Barbary ports of Algiers, Tunis and Tripoli.

Governments could either front protection money, cough up ransom or
threaten force.

America tried all three approaches, and its erratic policy echoes
with sad familiarity in the 21st century. We find the same wrangling
in Washington between those who counsel appeasement (the cheaper,
saner option) and those who demand armed action (the more glorious);
bickering among Western capitals over whether to act singly or in
concert (Thomas Jefferson tried to corral a coalition, but Congress
balked); and daring strikes carried out with near-fatal clumsiness
(an attempt to blockade Tripoli led to the capture, in 1803, of the
frigate Philadelphia and its 308-man crew, and a subsequent,
heroically farcical attempt to free them by effecting regime change).

Michael Oren, an American-born Israeli scholar and the author of a
well- received study of the 1967 Arab-Israeli war, recounts such
exploits with admirable detachment. "Power, Faith, and Fantasy" is
hugely ambitious, drawing on hundreds of original sources to create a
finely balanced overview of this enormously complex subject. Out of
understandable necessity, the later chapters, dealing with more
recent times and America’s role as a superpower, preoccupied with a
multilayered and often contradictory agenda in the Middle East, grow
sketchier and less conclusive.

Yet it is a diverting tale over all, full of forgotten twists and
memorable characters. Who remembers now, for instance, that the
Statue of Liberty was initially conceived by her French sculptor as
an Egyptian peasant girl, intended to adorn the entrance to the Suez
Canal? Or that the first Zionists to settle in Palestine were in fact
American Protestants, who planted successive, ill-fated colonies
aimed at "restoring" the Holy Land to Jews, so that their subsequent
conversion to Christianity would speed the Second Coming? Or that
Civil War veterans officered Egyptian campaigns in Sudan and
Abyssinia? Or that before landing in North Africa during World War
II, the United States Army dropped leaflets advertising the arrival
of "Holy Warriors to fight the great jihad of freedom"? Some of these
episodes may sound trivial or obscure, but Oren cleverly weaves them
into the overarching themes of his title.

Consider America’s missionary effort. The printing of native-language
Bibles, and the founding of schools, clinics and three universities,
in Cairo, Beirut and Istanbul, that remain among the best in the
region, failed to win more than a trickle of converts. Yet a hundred
years of American mission work produced some unexpected change.

It was, in part, the missionary doctors’ reputation for altruism that
persuaded the Saudi king to offer his oil patch not to British, but
to American prospectors. And while the proto-Zionist restorationist
movement faded to the fringes of Protestant preaching – at least,
until its revival by some modern evangelicals – a sentimental
attachment to the ancient Hebrews infused the religious upbringing of
Harry Truman and Lyndon Johnson, the two presidents who did most to
cement American ties with Israel.

Such underlying trends have seldom been so well explored, but Oren
occasionally overstates their importance. Truman’s own words reveal
that "faith" was perhaps a secondary motive behind his crucial
decision to back the creation of Israel.

"I have to answer to hundreds of thousands who are anxious for the
success of Zionism," Oren quotes Truman as explaining. "I do not have
hundreds of thousands of Arabs in my constituents." Important context
is occasionally missing. Oren artfully touches on Middle Eastern
influence on American popular culture, from the hootchy- kootchy
dance to Camel cigarettes, but tends to dissociate this from the
wider Western tradition of Orientalism. There is much gory detail
about the Armenian genocide, but scant mention of the fact that
Ottoman Turkey faced repeated invasion by a Russia whose czars,
disastrously for the Ottomans’ Armenian subjects, claimed leadership
of all Orthodox Christians. At several junctures, Oren paints Europe
as stubbornly resistant to American policy, without adequately
substantiating the charge or explaining European motives. We hear
nothing of how America’s fateful, post- World War I decision to
restrict immigration helped push desperate Jewish refugees toward
Palestine.

While correctly noting the peculiar mix of cultural disdain and
romantic fascination that has marked American attitudes to Muslim
Middle Easterners, Oren curiously declines to distance himself from
some unflattering views. We hear, for instance, of an 18th-century
diplomat whose "experience had taught him that in the Middle East
power alone was respected," as if this were a quality unique to the
region. And a hint of distaste sometimes infuses his language. The
landmass of the Middle East curves "scimitar-like through Arabia."
Elsewhere, Oren speaks blithely of "nameless Middle Eastern thugs"
and "the ubiquity of Arab terror." Such shopworn phrases tend to
compound preconceived notions of the Middle East as a kind of
unfathomable Badland.

Commendably, in a work of such scope, there are very few errors of
fact or omission. Yet, as a reserve major in the Israeli Army, Oren
ought to know that Israel’s 1982 invasion of Lebanon was not provoked
by the PLO. "regularly striking" at Galilee. Yasser Arafat’s group
was certainly an elemental threat to the Jewish state, but had
actually been observing a long, American- brokered cease-fire before
Ariel Sharon’s drive to Beirut.

It is also odd that the author hardly touches upon the influence of
the pro- Israel lobby, or on the issue of United States financial and
military aid to Israel, factors undeniably crucial to any
understanding of America’s involvement with today’s Middle East.

Oren mostly avoids the temptation to seek historical parallels to
modern events. The occasions when he succumbs reveal the peril for
historians of this habit. Toward the book’s conclusion, for instance,
he avers that "by protecting themselves from Middle Eastern threats
while simultaneously trying to assist native people, U.S. forces in
Iraq were, in effect, revisiting the earliest American involvement in
the region." Surely, as we now know, the threat to America posed by
Saddam Hussein’s Iraq was more fantastical than real, until, that is,
American forces hit the ground there.

Such subtle reinforcement of America’s self-image as an innocent
among Middle Eastern sharks mars an otherwise exemplary work. This is
a pity, since, as Oren amply illustrates, it is America’s failure to
be clear and honest about its own motives, as much as its serial
failure to interpret the Middle East, that has so often befuddled
relations with the region.

Max Rodenbeck is the Middle East correspondent for The Economist.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

BAKU: Aliyev met with Swiss president

AzerTag, Azerbaijan
Jan 26 2007

PRESIDENT ILHAM ALIYEV MET WITH SWISS PRESIDENT
[January 26, 2007, 16:28:43]

President Ilham Aliyev of Azerbaijan has meet with the President of
the Swiss Confederation Micheline Calmy-Rey in Davos, 26 Jan.

Development of bilateral relations and expansion of cooperation
between Azerbaijan and the Swiss companies were focused. Also was
expressed a wish that the Swiss businessmen have invested in economy
of Azerbaijan.

The Swiss President took interest in settlement of the
Armenia-Azerbaijan, Nagorno Karabakh conflict. President Aliyev
updated on the conflict and negotiations carried out for its
settlement.

President of the Swiss Confederation Micheline Calmy-Rey emphasized
the important role of Azerbaijan in energy security of Europe. This
has turned Azerbaijan to a leading country in the world, she said.

President Ilham Aliyev spoke of the processes ongoing in Azerbaijan,
noting reliable investment environment in the non-oil sector in the
Republic.

The Presidents had comprehensive exchange of views on a number of
issues of mutual interest.

Armenian Catholics in Iraq get new archbishop after 5-year vacancy

Catholic News Service
Jan 26 2007

Armenian Catholics in Iraq get new archbishop after five-year vacancy

By Cindy Wooden
Catholic News Service

VATICAN CITY (CNS) — For the first time in more than five years, the
tiny Armenian Catholic community in Iraq has its own archbishop.

The Vatican announced Jan. 26 that Pope Benedict XVI had given his
assent to the Armenian Catholic bishops’ election of Father Emmanuel
Dabbaghian, 73, as the Armenian Catholic archbishop of Baghdad.

The post had been vacant since the October 2001 retirement of
Archbishop Paul Coussa at the age of 84.

The Armenian Catholic Archdiocese of Baghdad covers all of Iraq, and
since 2001 Vatican statistics have given the Armenian Catholic
population of the country as 2,000 faithful.

But Deacon Michel Jeangey, head of the Armenian program at Vatican
Radio, told Catholic News Service Jan. 26 that "probably more than
half" the Armenian Catholics have moved, at least temporarily, to
Armenia or Syria.

"They will return if there is peace," he said.

Still, Deacon Jeangey said, one Armenian Catholic priest and a group
of Armenian Catholic nuns continue ministering at the church’s
parishes in Baghdad, Mosul and Kirkuk as well as running a social
center and two schools in Baghdad.

Archbishop-elect Dabbaghian was born Dec. 26, 1933, in Aleppo, Syria.
After studying philosophy and theology at Rome’s Pontifical Gregorian
University, he was ordained to the priesthood in 1967.

He has served as director of an orphanage in Lebanon, as a seminary
rector and as pastor of Armenian parishes in Lebanon and in Georgia.

At the time of his election, he was pastor of the Armenian Catholic
parish in Tbilisi, Georgia, and director of the seminary there.

Taming Turkish nationalism a challenge in accused killer’s hometown

EurasiaNet, NY
Jan 26 2007

TAMING TURKISH NATIONALISM A CHALLENGE IN ACCUSED KILLER’S HOMETOWN
Nicholas Birch 1/26/07

The murder last week of Turkish-Armenian editor Hrant Dink continues
to make waves in Turkey, with the country’s powerful Turkish
Industrialists’ and Businessmen’s Association joining in national and
international calls for the immediate scrapping of a law that makes
it a crime "to belittle Turkishness." But the increasingly aggressive
nationalism that characterizes Trabzon, the port city that is home to
Dink’s suspected killer, suggests that the campaign to overturn the
law could face an uphill struggle.

Article 301, as the law is called, "laid the groundwork for the
assassination," said Mustafa Koç, a member of the Turkish
Industrialists’ and Businessmen’s Association (TUSIAD) and the
chairman of the board of Koç Holding, Turkey’s largest and most
influential business group. Those who support the law, he added,
speaking at the January 25 annual meeting of the TUSIAD high council,
"are trying to block transition . . . resist renewal . . . surrender
themselves to the current authoritarian atmosphere."

Taken to court by the same ultra-nationalists who targeted Nobel
Prize winner Orhan Pamuk, Dink, the editor-in-chief of Agos
newspaper, received a six-month suspended prison sentence under the
law in October 2005. In the last article he ever published, the
editor described the trial as a turning point in his life, writing
that the law had prompted "a significant segment of the population .
. . [to] view [me] as someone `insulting Turkishness.’"

Police have now detained five people in connection with Dink’s
January 19 murder, including 17-year-old suspected gunman Ogun
Samast, and an ultra-nationalist university student thought to be the
mastermind behind the attack. [For details, see the Eurasia Insight
archive].

All five detainees are from Trabzon, a fact that has convinced many
inhabitants that this port town, seen as the unofficial capital of
Turkey’s eastern Black Sea coastal region, is part of a sinister
plot.

For those locals less inclined to conspiracy theories, it is the
continuation of a nightmare that began in May 2005, when four young
left-wing students narrowly avoided being beaten to death in central
Trabzon by a lynch mob.

Like two smaller lynching attempts that followed it, that incident
hit Turkish headlines. Then, in February 2006, Trabzon gained
international notoriety after a 16-year old local boy shot and killed
the Italian priest who ran the local Catholic church.

"What has happened to Trabzon?" asked the headline in the Turkish
daily Radikal on January 22, a day after police, tipped off by
relatives, arrested gunman Ogun Samast on a bus that would have taken
him to Georgia.

Turkey was a nationalist country long before groups opposed to its
European Union accession process began pumping up xenophobia. Radical
nationalism of the sort that appears to have influenced Dink’s
murderers has traditionally been strongest in the towns south of the
3,500-meter peaks dividing Trabzon from the bleak Anatolian interior.
But it’s only recently that Trabzon has become a center for such
thinking, and locals say the phenomenon is spiraling out of control.

"What you have here is a headless monster, a nursery for potential
assassins," said Omer Faruk Altuntas, a lawyer and the local head of
the small, left-leaning Freedom and Democracy Party.

"You may not like its policies, but at least the MHP [Milliyetçi
Hareket Partisi – Nationalist Movement Party] controls its
followers," agreed town councilor Mehmet Akcelep, referring to
Turkey’s biggest extremist nationalist party. "But Samast and
hundreds of others like him aren’t party people. They’re free
operators. In part, Trabzon’s problems are Turkey’s problems. In the
space of little more than a decade, the port city’s population has
swollen from 150,000 to around 400,000 as farmers flee the economic
deprivation of the countryside. In Pelitli, the Trabzon suburb which
was home to Ogun Samast, youth unemployment is high, with only two
Internet cafes in which idle youngsters can wile the time away."

Local media also play a role. When General Hilmi Ozkok, then
commander-in-chief of Turkey’s armed forces, termed two Kurdish
teenagers arrested for trying to burn the Turkish flag "so-called
citizens," the town’s media outlets readily took up the accusation.
When leftist students began distributing leaflets about prison
conditions, two television stations told viewers they were
separatists. Within minutes, hundreds of shopkeepers were on the
street. The result was the May 2005 attempted lynching.

"Three or four times, [the local media has] pretty much invited
people to take out their guns and start shooting", said Gultekin
Yucesan, head of Trabzon’s Human Rights Association (IHD).

In most Anatolian towns, where people often only read local
newspapers for the used car advertisements, that wouldn’t matter. But
Trabzon’s ten papers and television stations are influential, for the
simple reason that this is a city built around soccer.

Trabzonspor is the only non-Istanbul club ever to have won the
Turkish League. Its blue and purple colors drape the city. And while
everybody here supports it, some say its influence on the city is
increasingly negative.

"Trabzon football has become a semi-official conduit for
nationalism," said retired teacher Nuri Topal.

Locals say it’s no surprise that Ogun Samast and Yasin Hayal, the man
believed to have given the teenager the gun that killed Dink, played
amateur soccer for Pelitlispor.

Rumors have long circulated about the club’s links with a local mafia
that got rich controlling this crucial staging post in Black Sea
human trafficking networks. Just last year, the club’s best player
was banned for conniving with match-fixing mafiosi.

IHD head Gultekin Yucesan describes an incident he saw at a
Trabzonspor match two days after Dink’s murder.

After a couple of bad decisions by the referee, he said, one
supporter shouted "Do that again and I’ll put a white hat on and blow
your head off." Samast was wearing a white hat when he shot Hrant
Dink.

"Trabzon must learn its lesson," proclaimed a headline in one local
paper on January 22. Though for now, it is far from clear that it
has.

Mehmet Samast, a distant relative of the teenager suspected of
killing Dink, tells a reporter how much he regrets what has happened,
how ashamed he feels. He appears to be sincere. But then, echoing the
rhetoric of several nationalist parties, he goes on to say that Ogun
Samast was the victim of an international plot.

"Trabzon is vital strategically," he explained. "This murder was the
work of the Americans, or the Armenian Diaspora. They didn’t like
[Dink] either, you know."

Writing on January 22 in the local newspaper Ilkhaber, columnist
Temel Korkmaz was blunter. Since Europeans insist on calling the
Kurdish separatists who kill Turkish soldiers "guerrillas," he wrote,
"I’ll call the man who killed Dink a guerrilla, too."

In her January 26 column, Ece Temelkuran, a liberal columnist who
writes for the national daily Milliyet, was pessimistic about
Turkey’s future. Readers were evenly divided in their reactions to
her earlier comments on Hrant Dink’s death, she wrote, with 50
percent supportive, 50 percent warning her to watch what she said.

But people who want to see a more open, more democratic Turkey "are
not 50 percent of this country," Temelkuran wrote. "We are in a tiny
minority. . . More than 200,000 people marched for Hrant Dink’s
funeral. That’s good. But don’t forget that number is barely 1
percent of Istanbul’s population."

Editor’s Note: Nicholas Birch specializes in Turkey, Iran and the
Middle East.

If It’s Tuesday This Must Be Timbuktu

Slate
Jan 26 2007

If It’s Tuesday This Must Be Timbuktu

Today’s university alumni are citizens of the world. They cannot be
wooed, as potential alumni donors once were, with charter flights to
Paris in the company of some retired professor of art history. The
California Alumni Association’s in-house travel agency, Bear Treks,
has learned to change with the times. In December it mailed a 20-page
brochure to members offering alumni association members and their
families "an epic journey by private jet" to gawk at indigenous
peoples on three continents before they die out. Available for a
limited time only! "The powerful and widespread effects of
globalization threaten the future of these colorful cultures," the
brochure explains.

Up to 88 reservations are now being accepted, according to sample
pages of the brochure below and on the following nine pages, to
participate in this exclusive travel package. The three-week journey
features "the ultimate in convenience, security & service," including
an expedition chef who uses "only the freshest ingredients" and a
staff physician "knowledgeable in travel medicine." Further, "a world
class team of scholars will … illuminate the history of empires"
throughout the expedition. The cost of your Birkenstocks is not
included in the package.

The itinerary begins in Finland where "like-minded" U.C. grads will
discover Sami nomads "the oldest surviving inhabitants of the
Scandinavian Peninsula" on the Island of Inari for an "intimate" Sami
family gathering and "yodel-like singing of poems." The group then
jets south to study proud Armenians, "people of the world’s first
Christian nation," where U.C. alums are hosted by the Hayer people
who "believe they are descended from … the great grandson of Biblical
Noah."

http://www.slate.com/id/2158257/entry/0/

New documentary featuring SYSTEM OF A DOWN opens today in N.Y.

93X.COM, MN
Jan 26 2007

New documentary featuring SYSTEM OF A DOWN opens today in N.Y.

"Screamers", a new documentary about the history of genocide
throughout the 20th century featuring SYSTEM OF A DOWN, opens today
(Friday, January 26) in New York and Alexandria, Va. The members of
SYSTEM OF A DOWN are all descended from survivors of the Armenian
genocide, during which the Turkish government slaughtered 1.5 million
Armenians. SYSTEM frontman Serj Tankian told Launch that the film
features an interview with his grandfather, who is one of the few
remaining eyewitnesses to the genocide. "My grandfather is a
survivor," he said. "He’s 96 years old and it’s a genocide that
occurred 90-some years ago, so there’s very few survivors. He lost
his brother, his father, his uncles, he was left in different
orphanages, he’s lost his sight from malnutrition and, you know, the
fact that he survived is an absolute miracle."

Last week "Screamers" was shown at the Library of Congress to a
standing-room only crowd of over 200 people. Attendees included seven
members of Congress and numerous young staffers.

Source: Blabbermouth.net

ANKARA: Turkish governor, police chief shifted after Dink murder

NTV MSNBC, Turkey
Jan 26 2007

Turkish governor, police chief shifted after Dink murder

Authorities are looking into whether there was any failing on the
part of local administrators.

Güncelleme: 17:05 TSİ 26 Ocak 2007 CumaANKARA/TRABZON – Two
senior officials have been shifted from Trabzon after the murder of
prominent Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink by a youth from the
Black Sea city.

Provincial governor Huseyin Yavuzdemir and Police Chief Resat Altay
were removed from their posts and assigned duties in Ankara on the
order of the Interior Ministry, it was announced Friday.

The Ministry also announced that it had appointed two senior
inspectors to investigate whether there was any failure or negligence
on the part of local administrators and the provincial security
department in connection with the killing of Dink in Istanbul on
January 19. Most of those charged with his murder, including the
alleged gunman, were from Trabzon.

It is not the first time that Trabzon has been linked to a high
profile killing that had international implications. Last year,
Andrea Santaro, the Roman-Catholic priest of Trabzon’s Santa Maria
Church, was shot dead by a teenager while at prayer in his church.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

BAKU: Azerbaijani and Armenian MPs to visit Nagorno Karabakh

Azeri Press Agency, Azerbaijan
Jan 26 2007

Azerbaijani and Armenian MPs to visit Nagorno Karabakh

[ 26 Jan. 2007 18:24 ]

Azerbaijani and Armanian delegations to PACE made a decision at the
meeting held within plenary session of the Parliamentary Assembly of
the Council of Europe to begin direct dialogues on the Nagorno
Karabakh conflict, APA reports.

The delegations reached an agreement to pay a joint visit to Nagorno
Karabakh territory. The delegations will meet with the displaced
people. They also agreed to prepare both societies to the possible
settlement variants of the conflict. Heads of the delegations Samad
Seyidov (Azerbaijan) and Tigran Torosian (Armenia) stated that OSCE
Minsk Group Co-chairs play the essential role in the settlement of
Nagorno Karabakh conflict. Nevertheless, the Council of Europe may
contribute to the improvement of the situation. The sides also agreed
to hold regular meetings for the implementation of OSCE Resolution
1416. /APA/

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Trabzon governor, police chief removed from office due to murder

People’s Daily Online, China
Jan 26 2007

Trabzon governor, police chief removed from office due to
journalist’s killing

Governor Huseyin Yavuzdemir and police chief Resat Altay of the
Trabzon province in northern Turkey were removed from office due to
recent incidents in the region, the semi-official Anatolia news
agency reported on Friday.

Ministry of Interior Affairs charged two chief inspectors to
investigate whether there was any failure or negligence of the local
administration and the provincial security department, according to
the report.

Last year, Andrea Santaro, Italian Roman-Catholic priest of the Santa
Maria Church, was shot dead by a teenager in Trabzon where he was the
parish priest for a small Christian community.

The key suspects of the killing of journalist Hrant Dink were also
from the province.

Hrant Dink, a 53-year-old outspoken Turkish journalist of Armenian
descent, was shot dead in front of his office building in Istanbul
last Friday. The killing has ignited a national public outcry since
then.

Last Saturday, Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan announced
that Ogun Samast, the suspected killer, was arrested in the northern
province of Samsun earlier in the day.

Before his killing, Dink had been convicted by the Article 301 of the
Penal Code of insulting Turkey’s identity over his comments on the
alleged Armenian genocide by Ottoman Turks during World War I and
received a six-month suspended sentence.

He had also received threat from nationalists who considered him as a
traitor, local media reported.

Turkey has denied that up to 1.5 million Armenians died as a result
of systematic genocide during the Turkish Ottoman period between 1915
and 1923.

Source: Xinhua

ANKARA: Nothing new in Armenian comments: Turkish Foreign Ministry

NTV MSNBC, Turkey
Jan 26 2007

Nothing new in Armenian comments: Turkish Foreign Ministry

The Foreign Ministry said that it was to be hoped that the tragic
killing of Hrant Dink would contribute to creating a new atmosphere
in Turkish-Armenian relations.

Güncelleme: 15:48 TSİ 26 Ocak 2007 CumaANKARA – There is nothing
new to be found in comments by Armenia’s Deputy Foreign Minister
saying that his country is ready to establish relations with Turkey
without any preconditions, a statement issued by the Turkish Foreign
Ministry late Thursday said.

The Armenian government had made similar comments on several
occasions in the past, the statement said.

Armenian Deputy FM Arman Kirakosian, made while he was in Istanbul to
attend the funeral of murdered Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant
Dink, were not a sign of a new step, the statement said.

Turkey wants to improve its relations with all its neighbours within
the framework of mutual confidence and respect, said that Foreign
Ministry.

However, enhancing bilateral and regional relations and co-operation
cannot only be achieved by the steps to be taken by Turkey but can be
possible with the will and steps of the other parties, the statement
said.

Turkey had taken a number of concrete steps in the past to further
improve dialogue with Armenia, including Ankara’s proposal to set up
a joint history commission to look into allegations that the Ottoman
Empire had committed an act of genocide against its Armenian citizens
during the First World War.

The statement also said that it was to be hoped that the slaying of
Dink would `contribute to the creation of a new atmosphere in
Turkish-Armenian relations, and Armenia will respond to our
good-willed efforts to overcome the stagnation in our relations with
Armenia’.

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress