Germany, US Correct Earlier Report About Armenia Steps towards NATO

GERMAN AND US EMBASSIES APPEAR WITH CORRECTION OF EARLIER REPORT ABOUT
ARMENIA’S STEPS TOWARDS NATO MEMBERSHIP

Yerevan, February 1. ArmInfo. We regret the error in a press statement
issued by the Marshal Center on Jan 31 as it does not reflect either
US or NATO policy, says the correction by the US Embassy concerning
the Jan 31 report about Feb 5-7 seminar in Armenia, which mentioned
Armenia’s steps towards NATO membership.

The source says: "We are very pleased with Armenia’s engagement with
NATO via its IPAP. Mr. Frank Boland from NATO International Staff is
in Yerevan this week to evaluate this progress in a more technical
nature.

Each Partner country makes its own decision on how closely it will
intregrate with the Alliance. Armenia has made clear that it does not
seek membership in the Alliance and NATO acknowledges this decision
while at the some time welcoming this substantive engagement."

AAA: Sen. Biden Introduces Resolution Condemning H Dink’s Murder

Armenian Assembly of America
1140 19th Street, NW, Suite 600
Washington, DC 20036
Phone: 202-393-3434
Fax: 202-638-4904
Email: [email protected]
Web:

PRESS RELEASE
February 1, 2007
CONTACT: Christine Kojoian
E-mail: [email protected]

SENATOR BIDEN INTRODUCES RESOLUTION CONDEMNING HRANT DINK’S MURDER &
HONORING HIS LEGACY

Washington, DC – Today, Senate Foreign Relations Committee Chairman
Joseph R. Biden, Jr. (D-DE) introduced legislation condemning the
assassination of Hrant Dink and honoring his legacy of tolerance and
peaceful change.

"We commend Senator Biden for spearheading this important legislation,"
said Executive Director Bryan Ardouny. "The atmosphere that led to this
killing must be changed, starting with the repeal of Article 301 of the
Turkish Penal Code. As a moral leader, America must ensure that minority
populations in Turkey are afforded every protection."

Dink, who worked hard to foster dialogue and understanding between
Armenians and Turks, was gunned down outside his newspaper office on
January 19 in Istanbul, Turkey. An outspoken advocate for democratic
reform, Dink stood trial several times for his public comments on the
genocide and was convicted in October 2005 for "insulting Turkishness"
under Article 301 of the Turkish Penal Code. He received a six-month
suspended sentence and was set to appear in court again in March 2007
for affirming the Armenian Genocide.

"Hrant Dink was a leading voice in Turkey’s Armenian community and an
eloquent advocate for human rights, press freedom, and democracy,"
Senator Biden told the Assembly. "His assassination was an outrage and
a tragedy. Hrant’s legacy deserves the Senate’s respect. His murder
demands our action."

The Senate bill is similar to H. Res. 102, which was introduced by
Congressman Joseph Crowley (D-NY) on January 29 with the support of the
Armenian Assembly. The Biden resolution condemns Dink’s assassination
and supports Turkey’s pledge to conduct an exhaustive investigation into
his killing. Furthermore, the legislation urges Turkey to take
appropriate action to protect freedom of speech in Turkey by repealing
Article 301 of the Turkish Penal Code, which criminalizes public
discussion on the Armenian Genocide. The resolution also calls on
Turkey to reestablish full diplomatic, political and economic relations
with Armenia.

For more information on Hrant Dink, including Assembly statements, media
coverage, photographs, and video from the memorial service at St. Mary’s
Armenian Apostolic Church, please visit the Hrant Dink Resource Page on
the Assembly’s Web site at

Th e Armenian Assembly of America is the largest Washington-based
nationwide organization promoting public understanding and awareness of
Armenian issues. It is a 501 (c) (3) tax-exempt membership organization.

###

NR#2007-022

Editor’s Note: Below is the full text of the Biden Resolution, which was
introduced today in the United States Senate.

110TH CONGRESS
S. RES.

RESOLUTION

Condemning the murder of Turkish-Armenian journalist and human rights
advocate Hrant Dink and urging the people of Turkey to honor his legacy
of tolerance.

Whereas Hrant Dink was a respected, eloquent advocate for press freedom,
human rights, and reconciliation;

Whereas, in 1996, Mr. Dink founded the weekly bilingual newspaper Agos
and, as the paper’s editor in chief, used the paper to provide a voice
for Turkey’s Armenian community;

Whereas Mr. Dink was a strong proponent of rapprochement between Turks
and Armenians and worked diligently to improve relations between those
communities;

Whereas Mr. Dink’s commitment to democratic values, nonviolence, and
freedom in the media earned him widespread recognition and numerous
international awards;

Whereas Mr. Dink was prosecuted under Article 301 of the Turkish Penal
Code for speaking about the Armenian Genocide;

Whereas, notwithstanding hundreds of threats to Mr. Dink’s life and
safety, he remained a steadfast proponent of pluralism and tolerance;

Whereas Mr. Dink was assassinated outside the offices of Agos in
Istanbul, Turkey, on January 19, 2007;

Whereas tens of thousands of people in Turkey of many ethnicities
protested Mr. Dink’s killing and took to the streets throughout the
country to honor his memory;

Whereas the Government of Turkey has pledged to undertake a full
investigation into the murder of Mr. Dink;

Whereas the Prime Minister of Turkey, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, has stated
that when Mr. Dink was shot, "a bullet was fired at freedom of thought
and democratic life in Turkey";

Whereas the Foreign Minister of Armenia, Vartan Oskanian, stated that
Mr. Dink "lived his life in the belief that there can be understanding,
dialogue and peace amongst peoples"; and

Whereas Mr. Dink’s tragic death affirmed the importance of promoting the
values that he championed in life: Now, therefore, be it

1 Resolved, That the Senate –

(1) condemns the murder of Hrant Dink as a shameful act of cowardice
perpetrated with contempt for law, justice, and decency;

(2) supports the pledge of the Government of Turkey to conduct an
exhaustive investigation into the assassination of Mr. Dink and to
prosecute those responsible;

(3) urges the Government of Turkey to repeal Article 301 of the Turkish
Penal Code and work diligently to foster a more open intellectual
environment in the country that is conducive to the free exchange of
ideas;

(4) recognizes the decision of the Government of Turkey to invite senior
Armenian religious and political figures to participate in memorial
services for Mr. Dink;

(5) calls on the Government of Turkey to act in the interest of regional
security and prosperity and reestablish full diplomatic, political, and
economic relations with the Government of Armenia; and

(6) urges the people of Turkey to honor Mr. Dink’s legacy of tolerance.

http://www.aaainc.org/httpdocs/hrantdink.htm.
www.armenianassembly.org

Armenian IT Sector’s Output Amounts to 100 Million Dollars in 2006

ARMENIAN INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY SECTOR’S OUTPUT AMOUNTS TO 100 MILLION
DOLLARS IN 2006

YEREVAN, FEBRUARY 1, NOYAN TAPAN. Output of about 100 million USD was
produced in Armenia’s information technology sector in 2006. The RA
Deputy Minister of Trade and Economic Development Tigran Davtian said
this. According to him, in recent years the IT sector growth rates
made 15-20%, which exceed the index of the country’s GDP growth
rates. It was noted that more than 120 companies operate in the IT
sector, with the total number of their employees making 5,000.

T. Davtian noted that in 2006, investments of over 10 mln USD were
made in the sector. In his words, this year the investment flow into
educational and scientific infrastructures of the country’s IT sector
will continue – in the form of establishing scientific and edicational
complexes. Particularly, Syposys will open its center in the area of
Viasphere Technopark. Epygy Labs AM company is also going to open a
new center.

Nobel winner cancels book tour over safety

Nobel winner cancels book tour over safety

Jess Smee in Berlin
Thursday February 1, 2007
The Guardian

Turkish Nobel laureate Orhan Pamuk has cancelled a publicity tour of
Germany amid fears for his safety following the murder of
Turkish-Armenian editor Hrant Dink.

Hanser Verlag, Pamuk’s German publisher, confirmed that the celebrated
author had called off a string of book readings in Hamburg, Cologne
and Stuttgart. He was also due to receive an honorary degree at
Berlin’s Free University.

Fears for Pamuk’s safety are running high. Last week, Yasin Hayal, the
man who police claim has confessed to orchestrating Dink’s murder,
issued what appeared to be a threat to Pamuk.

"Orhan Pamuk, be smart. Be smart," he called out to journalists as he
was being taken to an Istanbul courtroom by police. Police are
investigating whether his words constitute a threat to the novelist,
which could lead to Hayal’s prosecution. Both Pamuk and Dink have
been the focus of controversy in Turkey after talking openly about the
mass killings of Armenians in the early 20th century. They have been
accused of the crime of "insulting Turkishness".

Pamuk is famed for novels such as Snow and My Name is Red, and won the
Nobel literature prize in 2006. His publisher said that there were no
immediate plans to reschedule the trip to Germany, where Pamuk has a
large readership, partly because of the country’s sizeable Turkish
community.

Dink’s assassination earlier this month has prompted outrage at home
and abroad.

Within Turkey it has sparked fierce debate about excessive nationalism
as well as freedom of expression.

Genocide: rethinking the concept

Open Democracy, UK
Feb 1 2007

Genocide: rethinking the concept
Martin Shaw
1 – 2 – 2007

An understanding of the term "genocide" that draws afresh on the
experience of the last century is needed to ensure greater human
security in the next, says Martin Shaw.

A routine feature of public discussion of large-scale, anti-civilian
violence is that it is so important to protect the victims that time
should not be wasted on arguing about how the violence is described.
Indeed, this view is often voiced by aid workers, as well as
politicians and officials – amid the assaults perpetrated by the
Sudanese government and their janjaweed militia proxies, to take but
one example.

In such circumstances, calls to recognise these attacks as "genocide"
are often seen as quibbling about language while people die. The
hypocrisy of the powerful seems to reinforce this argument: after
all, in 2004 the then United States secretary of state Colin Powell
did recognise the sustained atrocities in Darfur as "genocide", but
promptly evaded the corresponding international duty (under the
United Nations genocide convention of 1948) to "prevent" the violence
and "punish" the perpetrators.

The right label, then, is not enough. At the same time, using the
"wrong" words offers a potent opportunity to perpetrators and
bystanders to confuse and defuse effective international responses.
For a long time, the preferred terminology for Darfur in UN circles
was "humanitarian crisis" – but this implied that humanitarian action
(such as providing food, shelter and medicines) would be enough to
save the victims of violence. It was not: however necessary such aid
was, it couldn’t stop them bombing and burning villages or killing
and raping civilians, and indeed the Sudanese government has
deliberately disrupted humanitarian efforts.

When the centrality of violence is recognised, the Darfur events is
often described as a "civil war". There certainly is civil war in
Darfur, and the policy of destroying the black "African" peoples of
the region has been part of Khartoum’s response to armed rebellions.

Yet the idea that this was "only" a civil war, in which civilians
unfortunately got in the way, has been the prime notion that the
regime (like many génocidaires before it) has used to obfuscate the
genocide. And international authorities like the UN’s international
commission on Darfur also bought into this idea (as the UN did in
Rwanda in 1994), because it enabled the UN to avoid the demanding and
controversial task of intervening to fully protect the victims.

A narrowing focus

The other term used by politicians, officials and journalists was
"ethnic cleansing". Certainly forced migration, for which "cleansing"
is a euphemism, was from the start the central policy of Khartoum’s
destructive campaign.

There were three problem with this usage. First, "ethnic cleansing"
implied that there was a crucial difference between what was
happening on the ground and genocide: if people were "only" being
"cleansed" (forced to leave their homes) rather than "exterminated"
as the Jews were by the Nazis, the harm was somehow not quite so
grave.

Second, "ethnic cleansing" was not legally defined and alleging its
existence carried no clear international obligation to act. Third,
the distinction between it and genocide was in any case spurious,
since killing, rape and other violence were used to expel the
targeted groups, and these were all means of "destroying" them as
peoples – which is how genocide has been understood since it was
first defined by Raphael Lemkin in 1944.

These flaws notwithstanding, the idea that "ethnic cleansing" is a
lesser form of anti-civilian violence than genocide has been
prevalent since the conflict in Bosnia-Herzegovina in the early
1990s. It followed, moreover, the longstanding trend f to narrow the
definition of genocide itself. Lemkin had originally argued that
genocide was comprehensive social destruction, attacking the
economic, political and cultural foundations of the life of
particular nations and groups as well as, often, their physical
existence.

In the adoption of the genocide convention, however, this idea was
narrowed to groups’ physical and biological destruction, and attacks
on social and cultural forms were only seen as genocidal when they
led to killing and physical harm. To reinstate a broader
understanding, lawyers have had to interpret the convention’s
terminology creatively, for example seeing a reference to "mental
harm" as outlawing expulsions.

Many academic commentators only accentuated the narrowing trend,
until for some genocide became simply and solely "mass killing".
Often this narrowing is exploited for political reasons – the idea
that genocide only occurs when there is an attempt to murder all the
members of a group both helps to make the Nazi holocaust "unique" (a
useful point for some Zionist advocates) and enables the dismissal of
"genocide" to describe other targeted anti-civilian destruction (a
favourite argument of all those who wish to defuse international
responses).

It is therefore very important to clarify the meaning of genocide for
our times. Lemkin was right to see that "social" and "physical" group
destruction were not different processes or phenomena, but two sides
of the same coin. His broad concept of genocide, rather than the UN
definition, is in this sense the essential starting-point.

Raphael Lemkin’s legacy

Yet Lemkin made two serious errors. First, he assumed that genocide
was practiced against straightforwardly defined types of groups
(nations, or ethnic groups); later scholars have pointed out both
that other types of group (class, political) are targeted, and that
in any case the point is not whether the attacked people fit into a
particular category (they sometimes don’t), but that a perpetrator
organisation defines them as a group to be destroyed.

Second, Lemkin rather mechanically presented physical attacks on
targeted populations as only one "element" of genocide. We can see
that the destruction of societies, groups and populations must
involve extensive violence against them, even if this takes many
forms, including wounding and rape as well as murder.

Thus genocide studies need theoretical clarification, as well as the
comparative historical analysis that currently dominates the field.
Indeed a clear general idea of genocide is the necessary basis for
evaluating and comparing cases – you can’t decide whether Darfur or
Bosnia constitutes genocide by comparing it to one other case, even
if that is the holocaust.

In addition, thinking about genocide has been hampered by rigid
interpretations of other ideas in the convention, such as the idea
that it must be the "intentional" action of perpetrators. This aspect
has been understood as meaning that the perpetrators have to have a
single, consistent, racist intention to commit extensive mass murder.
Yet studies like Michael Mann’s The Dark Side of Democracy:
Explaining Ethnic Cleansing have shown that perpetrators’ intentions
evolve in response to events: the most extreme policies are never
Plan A, or even usually Plan B, but Plan C that is adopted after
other policies have failed.

Moreover, understanding genocide only or mainly through the
perpetrators’ intentions leaves out the conflictual dynamics of
genocide. Genocide generally arises out of political and armed
conflicts, and of course genocidal attacks on populations inevitably
produce new conflict. Attacked groups always resist – not necessarily
with arms, because civilian populations cannot always improvise armed
resistance – but through individual and collective acts of civilian
resistance that do their best to frustrate the enemy.

Relationships between "victim" populations and armed groups are a
general feature of genocide. Victims both look to armed bodies, as
the Bosnians did to the Bosnian army, the Rwandan Tutsis to the
Rwandan Patriotic Front and the "African" peoples of Darfur do to the
Darfur rebel organisations, and also sometimes fear the effects that
their campaigns have in provoking genocidal attacks. Largely civilian
populations also look to international military intervention as a way
of evening up the power imbalance between themselves and their
usually highly armed enemies.

Sociology, not legalism

This suggests that we need to understand genocide not just as
one-sided violence, but as uneven conflict. I therefore argue for a
"structural" concept – genocide is a distinctive structure of armed
conflict that is also linked closely to other types of armed conflict
such as war.

This, of course, is a sociological rather than a legal approach to
the question. Political discussions of cases like Bosnia and Darfur
often get tangled up trying to interpret historical situations in
terms of a legal definition (which was itself the result of political
compromises in the 1940s). While the legal definition is still very
important, because it lays down obligations on states, a broader,
more coherent sociological approach to genocide can clarify the
public debate and cut through some of the problems that have arisen
from an excessive reliance on the law.

Thus the politics of genocide demand that we move away from the
obsessive legalism manifested in attempts to legislate how people
talk about historical events (e.g. the attempted French law against
Armenian genocide denial, the proposed European law on
holocaust-denial). Instead what we need is open debate that –
learning from evolving historical understanding – focuses on present
dangers, galvanising the public to demand action wherever civilians
are attacked because political leaders see particular groups as
"enemies". The idea of genocide cannot be confined within the bounds
of 1948: it must develop to help us meet the challenges of our times.

Martin Shaw is professor of international relations and politics at
the University of Sussex, where he teaches on the MA in war, violence
and security. He is the author of Dialectics of War (Pluto, 1988),
War and Genocide: Organised Killing in Modern Society (Polity, 2003),
The New Western Way of War: Risk-Transfer War and its Crisis in Iraq
(Polity, 2005), and What is Genocide? (Polity [forthcoming, December
2006] ). His personal website is at

lobalization-vision_reflections/genocide_4309.jsp

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

http://www.opendemocracy.net/g
www.martinshaw.org

Yerevan perspective: No sign of improved Turkish-Armenian relations

EurasiaNet, NY
Feb 1 2007

YEREVAN’S PERSPECTIVE: NO SIGNS OF IMPROVED TURKISH-ARMENIAN
RELATIONS
Emil Danielyan 2/01/07

Ankara appears to be sticking to long-standing preconditions for
normalizing Turkey’s historically strained relationship with Armenia,
despite domestic appeals that followed the assassination of a
renowned Turkish-Armenian journalist.

Senior Turkish and Armenian diplomats held rare talks in Istanbul in
late January amid hopes for a rapprochement between the two
neighboring states. [For background see the Eurasia Insight archive].
Armenian Deputy Foreign Minister Arman Kirakossian’s talks with
Turkish officials reportedly failed to make any progress, though.

"Differences in the parties’ positions on the discussed issues
remain," Vladimir Karapetian, a spokesman for the Armenian Foreign
Ministry, said in a January 26 statement about the meeting. He
indicated that Turkey continues to oppose an unconditional
establishment of diplomatic relations and the opening of its border
with Armenia.

Prior to the bilateral meeting, Kirakossian attended the high-profile
funeral of Hrant Dink, the ethnic Armenian editor of the bilingual
Agos weekly whose January 19 killing sparked outrage both inside
Turkey and far beyond its borders. [For background see the Eurasia
Insight archive].

Turkey closed its border with Armenia in 1993 as a gesture of support
for Azerbaijan, its closest Turkic ally, which remains locked in a
bitter dispute with Armenia over the breakaway region of
Nagorno-Karabakh. [For background see the Eurasia Insight archive].
Successive Turkish governments have conditioned the lifting of the
economic blockade on the withdrawal of Armenian forces from
Azerbaijani districts bordering Karabakh, and an end to the Armenian
campaign for international recognition of the events of 1915 as
genocide. [For background see the Eurasia Insight archive].

Turkish leaders haven’t changed their position despite pressure from
the United States and the European Union. Many officials in
Washington and Brussels believe that a Turkish-Armenian rapprochement
would significantly boost stability in the volatile South Caucasus.
In late January, Turkish Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul effectively
ruled out any policy shift, saying that Armenia should first "review
its negative feelings against us, and should not make unjust
demands."

The Armenian drive for genocide recognition, meanwhile, appears to be
gaining momentum. Influential Armenian lobby groups in the United
States are pressing for the US House of Representatives to adopt a
genocide recognition resolution. One of them, the Armenian National
Committee of America, characterized Dink’s January 19 shooting as a
"wake-up call to the United States and the entire international
community to unite together in ending forever the Turkish
government’s denial of the Armenian Genocide." A group of US
lawmakers introduced a new recognition bill on January 30.

On the grassroots level, Turkish-Armenian dialogue may be easier to
foster in the aftermath of Dink’s fatal shooting. The universal
condemnation of the crime provided a rare moment of emotional unity
between many Turks and Armenians. The latter were astounded by
television pictures of thousands of ordinary Turks marching in the
funeral procession for the slain editor and carrying banners that
read, "We are all Armenians!" The images defied the negative Armenian
stereotypes about Turks, prompting hopes to rise among many
Armenians, in Armenia proper and living abroad, that the images
reflected Turkey’s greater willingness to confront contentious
questions of the past.

Yektan Turkyilmaz, a US-based Turkish scholar, said Turkish society
will now be "at least slightly more sympathetic" to the Armenians,
but cautioned against excessive expectations. Some Turkey-watchers in
Armenia, meanwhile, remain skeptical, saying that the vast majority
of Turks continue to trust their leaders’ assertion that Ottoman
Armenians died in much smaller numbers and as a result of internal
strife, rather than from a premeditated government effort. "I don’t
think Turkish public opinion has changed since that murder," said
Ruben Safrastian, director of the Yerevan-based Institute of Oriental
Studies.

The final years of the Ottoman Empire, until recently a taboo
subject, are being increasingly discussed in Turkey, with a growing
number of local scholars and intellectuals openly questioning the
official version of events. Some of them, including Dink and Nobel
laureate Orhan Pamuk, have been prosecuted under a controversial
article of the Turkish criminal code that makes it a crime to "insult
Turkishness." [For background see the Eurasia Insight archive].

According to Turkyilmaz, other dissenters are increasingly worried
about becoming the next target of ultranationalist militants. "The
anxiety and horror that the killing of Mr. Dink has caused among
Turkish intellectuals is very deep," he said. "But the struggle will
continue as we want to see our country become freer, more democratic
and more peaceful. Turkey has a very deeply-rooted tradition of
opposition, and I believe that it will eventually prevail."

Editor’s Note: Emil Danielyan is a Yerevan-based journalist and
political analyst.

Journalist murder opens window of opp. for Turk-Armen rapprochement

EurasiaNet, NY
Feb 1 2007

JOURNALIST’S MURDER OPENS WINDOW OF OPPORTUNITY FOR TURKISH-ARMENIAN
RAPPROCHEMENT
Yigal Schleifer 2/01/07

In the days immediately following the shocking murder of outspoken
Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink, many observers expressed hope
that the tragedy could serve as a catalyst for reconciliation between
Turkey and Armenia. Initial signals, however, show that a
rapprochement still will not be easily achieved.

Dink was gunned down by a 17-year-old ultranationalist on January 19.
[For background see the Eurasia Insight archive]. The journalist’s
January 23 funeral in Istanbul drew over 100,000 mourners, including
– in what was seen as an encouraging sign -Armenia’s deputy foreign
minister, Arman Kirakossian. The occasion marked the first high-level
visit by an Armenian official to Turkey since relations between the
two countries were cut off in 1993. Joining Kirakossian were several
leaders of Armenian diaspora organizations – many making their
first-ever visit to Turkey – as well as the archbishop of the
Armenian Church of America, Khajag Barsamian.

Before leaving Turkey, Kirakossian reiterated his country’s desire to
renew relations with Turkey without "any preconditions."

"It looks as if we have a window of opportunity here because of the
sympathy that was created after [Dink’s] funeral, the new atmosphere
that was created in the country and the fact that the government was
quite resolute on the issue of investigating the murder," says Sami
Kohen, a columnist with the daily Milliyet newspaper and a veteran
observer of Turkish foreign policy.

Many in Turkey compared the aftermath of the murder of Dink, editor
of the bilingual Turkish-Armenian newspaper Agos, to the time
following a devastating earthquake in 1999, which saw historic rivals
Turkey and Greece enter a period of rapprochement — brought together
by the shared experience of the temblor’s destruction.

"We are hoping that a tragedy like Hrant’s loss will have the same
effect," says Noyan Soyak, an Istanbul businessman who is vice
chairman of the Turkish-Armenian Business Development Council. "The
will is there in both countries, but what the problem is nobody
knows."

The initial replies from Ankara to the Armenian gesture have not been
positive, though. Turkey’s Foreign Ministry said Kirakossian’s
statements contained "nothing new," while Prime Minister Recep Tayyip
Erdogan said Yerevan should first reply to his previous offer to set
up a joint commission to study the tragic events of 1915. [For
background see the Eurasia Insight archive]. Armenians contend that
the Ottoman Turks committed genocide, while the Turkish government
disputes the genocide assertion, saying that Armenians were largely
victims of a vicious partisan struggle that raged during and after
World War I. "They haven’t responded to my suggestion. These
statements don’t show good will. Therefore, I don’t find their manner
genuine," Erdogan told reporters in Ankara.

Egemen Bagis, a parliamentarian with the governing Justice and
Development Party (AKP), says a foundation exists for rebuilding
relations, but that Yerevan has rebuffed Turkey’s reconciliation
gestures. "Armenia has always played a very cold, non-cooperating
attitude with Turkey," Bagis says. "They should take advantage of
Turkey willingness for dialogue."

Some analysts in Turkey believe that, despite the tough talk, Ankara
may be compelled to make some progress on the Armenia front. The
murder of Dink, who was hauled into court numerous times under a
controversial article in the Turkish penal code which makes it a
crime to "insult" Turkish identity, has placed Turkey in the
international spotlight. [For background see the Eurasia Insight
archive]. An improvement in relations with Yerevan would help ease
some of the pressure Ankara is now facing on the freedom-of-speech
issue.

In addition, the Democrat-controlled US House of Representatives is
likely to vote in the near future on a resolution recognizing the
Armenian genocide. Any positive movement by Turkey regarding its
relations with Armenia would likely assist its lobbying efforts to
defeat the resolution. "Turkey can start a dialogue with Armenia this
time by slightly tuning its attitude. And it must," political analyst
Mehmet Ali Birand wrote in a recent column in the English-language
Turkish Daily News. "Talks should start. A dialogue should begin.
Prerequisites can be brought to the discussions later."

Milliyet’s Kohen suggests the Turkish-Greek model could serve as an
example for fostering a dialogue between Ankara and Yerevan. In the
Turkish-Greek case, thorny issues like territorial and historical
disputes were initially set aside in order to get talks started.
While Turkey and Greece have yet to resolve their territorial
dispute, commercial and cultural relations between the two countries
have taken off since 1999.

"You know that you have differences, but you enter into a dialogue,
you get to being on speaking terms," says Kohen. "The problem right
now is that the two countries aren’t even on speaking terms, and
there is a lot to talk about."

Turkish experts in Turkey believe that, ultimately, any move
regarding relations with Armenia will be determined by domestic
considerations. Turkey is heading towards parliamentary elections in
November and the government, facing a rising wave of nationalism at
home, will find it hard to make any dramatic moves on nationalist
hot-button issues touching on the issues of Armenia and Cyprus.

Soyak, representative of the Turkish-Armenian Business Development
Council, believes opening the border with Armenia, closed since 1993,
would be a step in the right direction, fostering goodwill and
bolstering Turkish trade at the same time. [For additional
information see the Eurasia Insight archive]. "The closed borders
haven’t helped anybody," he says. "They haven’t helped the Azeris
gain back territory. It hasn’t helped Turkey with fighting genocide
resolutions around the world. We should open the borders and see what
happens."

Editor’s Note: Yigal Schleifer is a freelance journalist based in
Istanbul.

Karabakh Debates Its Future

Institute for War and Peace Reporting, UK
Feb 1 2007

Karabakh Debates Its Future
Karabakh Armenians say they prefer the status quo to an uncertain
peace deal.

By Ashot Beglarian in Stepanakert

A series of broad public debates in Nagorny Karabakh suggest public
opinion amongst Karabakh Armenians is highly sceptical of the
compromises being proposed by international mediators on the future
of the disputed territory.

The Armenia-based organisation, the International Centre for Human
Development, organised a series of public meetings with the aim of
soliciting a wide range of views on the future of Karabakh. Now an
unrecognised territory with an overwhelmingly Armenian population,
Karabakh has been de facto separate from Azerbaijan for a decade and
a half. A ceasefire has maintained an uneasy peace between the two
parties since 1994.

The meetings were held on the eve of the visit to Karabakh on January
25 by the three international diplomats of the OSCE’s Minsk Group
responsible for negotiating a peaceful settlement of the conflict,
the American Matt Bryza, Russia’s Yury Merzlyakov and France’s
Bernard Fassier.

Tevan Poghosian, executive director of the International Centre for
Human Development and chief organiser of the initiative, said a key
aim of the debates was to bring the views of ordinary people to the
attention of the mediators, despite the fact that their talks were
held behind closed doors.

As well as a meeting in the Karabakhi capital, Stepanakert, two
debates were also held in the regional centres of Martuni and
Martakert.

The organisers said they gave the discussions an open format to
encourage the free exchange of ideas. Alisa Mkrtchian, a participant
in one of the debates, described it as a kind of `brainstorming’.

More than 217 ideas were voiced and written up on large screens for
everyone to consider and discuss.

Mkrtchian noted that there was wide support for the preservation of
the current status quo for Karabakh in which, despite being
unrecognised internationally, most local residents believe the
territory enjoys a measure of stability.

`Considering that there were representatives of different social
groups, political views, ages and so on, round the table, this level
of unanimity was quite telling and it reflects the attitude of
society to the Nagorny Karabakh problem and to ways of solving it,’
said Mkrtchian.

The Karabakh Armenians do not have a place at the table in the Minsk
Group negotiations, held between Armenia and Azerbaijan. Elements of
a peace deal under discussion include the return of the six
territories under Armenian control outside Karabakh and a referendum
on the future status of the entity.

Masis Mailian, deputy foreign minister of Karabakh, welcomed the
discussions because he said that the public in Karabakh had been left
`on the sidelines’ in the debate over their own future.

`I believe that the authorities should always rely on public opinion
and the position of society for its actions,’ said Mailian. `There
are a lot of interesting ideas, which the authorities should
definitely take into account in the course of its work.’

The participants debated five future scenarios: the status quo;
independence for Karabakh; Karabakh joining Armenia; Karabakh
becoming an international protectorate and giving up the surrounding
Azerbaijani territories; and Karabakh ceding the territories in
return for potential independence in the future (the closest option
to what is currently under negotiation). The option that Karabakh
should return to being part of Azerbaijan was not put forward and no
one even mentioned this as a possibility.

At the end of the debate, the majority of participants – 31 people in
all – voted for the option of independence, twelve said they wanted
to keep the status quo, with other options receiving much weaker
support.

There was widespread opposition to some of the ideas being discussed
during the current peace talks – the deployment of international
peacekeepers in the conflict zone, giving up of territories, return
of the pre-war Azerbaijani population and a referendum on the future
status of Karabakh.

One participant said, `Since the truce of 1994, the ceasefire regime
has been maintained thanks to the balance of forces that has formed.
This is a unique case. The introduction of a third force can disturb
this balance and lead to unpredictable consequences.’

A fairly typical view came from Eleonora Gazarian, who said, `One
thing became clear in the course of our discussions – we will not
make any kind of compromises under someone else’s diktat. I think
that we need a comprehensive solution with the definition of the
status of Nagorny Karabakh first and then mutual concessions.’

On a broader point almost everyone was agreed – that the Karabakh
Armenians should proceed at full speed with the project of building
up democratic and civic institutions in their unrecognised state,
whatever their international status.

Eduard Agabekian, the mayor of Stepanakert, said, `We must create the
state of which we dream – with a stable economy, socially just, where
there is no conception that some are allowed to do everything and
others are not even allowed to do what is permitted by law.’

Poghosian said he was pleased with the debates and planned to hold
similar initiatives in the future. `People had the chance to check
certain items of information and to give their own views of the
problem,’ he said. `Initiatives like this also have the aim of
inculcating young people with the ability to negotiate and solve
conflicts.’

Ashot Beglarian is a freelance journalist and IWPR contributor in
Nagorny Karabakh.

Armenians Complain of Labour Exploitation

Institute for War and Peace Reporting, UK
Feb 1 2007

Armenians Complain of Labour Exploitation
Employees consent to illegal working conditions for fear of losing
their jobs.

By Lilit Harutiunian in Yerevan

Zara, 20, a resident of Yerevan knows that she is being exploited by
her employers – but also says that there is nothing she can do about
it.

"I work from nine in the morning till nine in the evening,’ said Zara
(not her real name), a shop assistant. `We do not have an official
lunch break or chance to relax. We eat in the small room where we
change our clothes and we get ten minutes to do so. I get terribly
tired – but it’s still better than sitting at home without money."

A high unemployment rate in Armenia – officially less than ten per
cent but generally agreed to be much higher – means that unscrupulous
employers pay scant regard to labour regulations. The country’s
labour code stipulates an eight-hours day, but in practice most
people work much longer hours.

According to Article 139 of the code, a normal working week should
last no more than 40 hours; and employees should be given breaks to
eat and rest and be paid overtime if they work more than the set
number of hours.

The reality of Zara’s life is very different. She found it very
difficult to get a job, as there were few vacancies and she had no
work experience. She had wanted to go to university but her parents
were unable to pay for her studies.

Now Zara works in a cut-price shop on the outskirts of Yerevan that
sells clothes, food, and household goods. She earns 1,500 drams (4.50
US dollars) a day for her 12-hour shift; she has only one day off a
week; and has never had any holiday leave while she has worked there.

The director of the shop where Zara works refused to comment on the
working conditions of his employees and his failure to pay them any
overtime.

Boris Kharatian, deputy chairman of the Armenian Confederation of
Trade Unions, says that cases like this are extremely prevalent.

"Employers make up for deficits by taking the money from their
employees’ salaries but, of course, shop owners deny this,’ Kharatian
told IWPR. `In the meantime, citizens come to us for legal advice on
being forced to work longer hours, but no one wants to resolve their
problems with our help or in courts.

`They do not trust the courts or they do not want to waste time,
preferring to solve their problems with the help of their own
relatives and acquaintances or just find another job.’

Karine (also not her real name) is 19. She works for more than ten
hours a day in a Yerevan shop and is given only one day off a week.
She said she had no idea that she works more hours than are legal and
that she should have signed an employment contract setting out her
rights and obligations when she was hired.

The manager of the shop where Karine works denied the allegation that
his employees work long hours and insisted the working conditions
were in compliance with the law.

Karine herself is not complaining. "I earn 1,300 drams (four dollars)
a day and I do not want to lose this job,’ she told IWPR. `I do not
care much about the contract and the fact that I will not be
receiving a pension when I am old. My grandfather’s pension isn’t
enough to buy bread."

Karine said that she spent a long time unemployed and that many of
her friends are unable to find even a job like hers.

"In a situation of unemployment people agree to any conditions to
earn money,’ said Hermine Avetisian, a lawyer with the public
organisation Against Legal Abuse. `Many people do not care about
their own health, if they manage to find a job. They are content that
they can earn the money to satisfy at least their basic needs."

Donara Nazarian, 46, says she is distressed that her two daughters
spend all day working in a shop – but concedes that she can’t see any
alternative. She has been unemployed for many years, her husband
earns only 20,000 drams (55 dollars) a month and the money the two
young women bring in is vital for the family.

"For two years now, they have come back from work so tired that the
only thing they are able to do is to sleep," said Donara.

Officials targeting exploitation by employers concede that the
sanctions they have at their disposal at the moment are quite weak.

Satenik Dabaghian, spokesperson for Armenia’s state labour
inspectorate, said they had exposed 2,300 cases of illegal employment
practices last year and fined all the employees concerned.

"Unfortunately, punishment for this violation is not very strict, a
fine of only 100,000 drams (290 dollars)," said Gurgen Malkhasian,
deputy head of the inspectorate. `I think it is impossible to fully
eliminate this in the near future due to social and economic
problems. However, I think that the creation of the state labour
inspectorate is a major step towards resolving the problem.’

The state labour inspectorate was set up 18 months ago by the labour
ministry to protect workers’ rights and provide free consultation for
employees.

Gagik Bleian, head of the labour department in Armenia’s labour and
social affairs ministry, said that his department has recently
submitted a new draft law to the government proposing tougher fines
of 1,000 dollars for employers who break the law.

However, opposition parliamentary deputy and former prime minister
Vazgen Manukian believes legislation is not the answer.

"Our legislation is not bad but the problem is that it does not
work,’ he said. `People are afraid of losing jobs, as half of the
people who are able to work cannot find jobs; the courts are corrupt;
and trade unions are idle. That’s why people agree to work like this
and keep silent or else they emigrate.’

Lilit Harutiunian is a freelance journalist based in Yerevan.

Bot: Turkey Not Involved In Election Of D66 MP

NIS News Bulletin, Netherlands
Feb 1 2007

Bot: Turkey Not Involved In Election Of D66 MP

THE HAGUE, 02/02/07 – Foreign Minister Ben Bot is convinced that the
Turkish government was not involved in the distribution of an email
calling on Turks in the Netherlands to vote for centre-left D66 MP
Fatma Koser Kaya in the 22 November general elections.

TV programme NOVA reported in December that the Turkish government
called on Turks in the Netherlands via e-mail to vote for Koser Kaya,
who is of Turkish origin. According to NOVA, an e-mail bombardment
was sent one day before the elections to Turkish organisations in the
Netherlands from the Turkish general affairs ministry, by an advisor
of the Turkish Religious Affairs Minister.

The e-mail called on the electorate to vote for Koser Kaya because
D66 "is the only party that does not recognise the Armenian question
as genocide," NOVA reported. Apparently, the email was successful, as
Koser Kaya was the only one of the 150 MPs elected thanks to
preference votes.

Following the allegations, Bot requested clarification from Turkey.
Yesterday he wrote in reply to questions from conservative (VVD) MP
Hans van Baalen that the author of the email must have been a Turk
living in the Netherlands, who used an American internet forum. The
Turkish government has guaranteed that it was not responsible for the
email campaign, although it will investigate the matter further,
stated Bot.

http://www.nisnews.nl/public/020207_2.htm