Just a technical problem

Aravot, Armenia
Feb 1 2007

Commentary
Just a technical problem

by Aram Abraamyan

Many people were sceptical when [former National Security Minister]
David Shakhnazaryan said that an election is not expected in Armenia.
[The parliamentary election is to be held on 12 May.] But he may be
right. How can a process whose result is 100-per-cent predictable be
considered an election? If the political and public atmosphere for
holding an election is lacking, it does not matter how the
authorities attain their goal – through vote buying, falsification of
the results, or in some other way.

Perhaps the only intrigue in the forthcoming parliamentary election
would be a possible confrontation between the RPA [Republican Party
of Armenia] and PAP [Prosperous Armenia Party] as a result of
economic rivalry among the power clans, but this is hardly likely. It
is almost certain that the clans will be modest and will manage to
divide up parliament (the economic levers), avoiding conflicts over
the first-past-the-post seats and sharing the proportional
percentages "fairly".

With just five or ten representatives, the other three or four
parties, regardless of whether they are in opposition or
pro-government, will not have any influence in parliament.

Thus the only problem left for the authorities to resolve before the
"election" is consolidation of the economic elite around the RPA-PAP
axis. At present, believing that the National Unity Party and the Law
Governed Country Party are serious competitors, the authorities have
concentrated their attention on them.

But propaganda is useless when there is a subject – a citizen, a
voter – who can decide which party will suggest more attractive
programmes in future – the Marxist party or, let us say, the
Trotskyites. Unfortunately, there is no such subject in Armenia.

Much the same can be said about training the police to beat people.
This suggests that the authorities are expecting an attempt at a
"colour revolution". But there will be no such attempt in Armenia in
the next two or three years. The main reason for this is that the
people do not want such a revolution.

Authorities to force sale of gold mine to Russians

168 Zham, Armenia
Feb 1 2007

AUTHORITIES TO FORCE SALE OF GOLD MINE TO RUSSIANS

According to our information, the Armenian authorities are forcing
Vedanta Resources to sell the Ararat Gold-Mining Plant [AGMP] to the
Russians. Several days ago, the Armenian and Russian presidents,
Robert Kocharyan and Vladimir Putin, said in Sochi that Russia is
going to make investments in the mining sphere.

This information has been circulating at the AGMP for a month
already. The leaders of the company are even advising their workers
to find new jobs. The children of the Indian managers at the plant
have told their teachers at the Ashtarak school that they will stop
attending lessons as their families are going to leave Armenia.

The director of AGMP, Vardan Vardanyan, told us that he does not have
any information about this. But the intentions of the Armenian
authorities are already being outlined. Let us recall that the
Ecology Ministry last year audited the AGMP and twice found large
stocks of [unreported] gold. The plant appealed against those acts,
and at present the plant and Ecology Ministry are engaged in
litigation.

Let us also recall that there is a lot of gold at the Sodk deposit:
eight grams per tonne. And the Indian owners were to mine about 50
tonnes of gold over the next 12 years. Gold prices are rising on the
world market.

Poll shows Armenians view president as "most corrupt" person

Haykakan Zhamanak, Armenia
Feb 1 2007

POLL SAID TO SHOW ARMENIANS VIEW PRESIDENT AS "MOST CORRUPT" PERSON
IN COUNTRY

Yesterday, the Transparency International-Armenia public organization
published a book Corruption Perception in Armenia, which presents the
results of a public opinion poll held in Armenia. According to the
poll, President Robert Kocharyan is the most corrupt person in
Armenia. Putting it mildly, the results of the poll are damaging for
all the branches of the Armenian authorities. Incidentally, the
participants in the poll mentioned holding a free and fair election
as a way to correct the current situation. This public opinion poll
in fact disproves all the other "false polls" carried out recently,
according to which the majority of voters connect their hopes with
the RPA [Republican Party of Armenia] and PAP [Prosperous Armenia
Party]. Corruption is an evil. For this reason, those who think that
the Armenian president, prime minister and all the other officials
are responsible cannot connect their future hopes with such people.

Armenia denies NATO membership

Itar-Tass, Russia
Feb 1 2007

ARMENIA DENIES NATO MEMBERSHIP PLANS

Yerevan, 1 February: The Armenian Defence Ministry has confirmed that
the republic does not intend to join NATO. A statement by the
ministry press service says this. "NATO membership is not on the
agenda of Armenia’s foreign policy," the statement said.

The George C. Marshall European Centre for Security Studies will hold
a seminar in Armenia on 5-7 February. Some media outlets reported,
quoting the centre, that the details of Armenia’s accession to NATO
would be discussed at the meeting.

"That is wide of the mark and does not proceed from the sprit of
Armenia’s Individual Partnership Action Plan with NATO and from the
interests of the republic’s cooperation with the George C. Marshall
centre," the Defence Ministry said.

Sarian: : L’Armenie en couleurs

La Tribune
2 février 2007

SARIAN, L’ARMÉNIE EN COULEURS

Dans le cadre de l’année de l’Arménie en France, le musée de la Carte
à jouer d’Issy-les-Moulineaux présente une rétropective Martiros
Sarian (1880-1972), le père de la peinture moderne arménienne.
Paysages, natures mortes, portraits, décors de thétre et
illustrations de contes et récits traditionnels… témoignent de sa
grande maîtrise de la construction et de la couleur.

Jusqu’au 31 mars. Tél.: 01.41.23.82.67. Site :

www.issy.com

ANKARA: Turkish minister comments on war on terror, US visit

Anatolia News Agency, Turkey
Feb 1 2007

Turkish minister comments on war on terror, US visit, Cyprus on way
to Albania

by Duygu Bayar:

"Foreign minister Gul in Albania"

Tirana, 1 February: Foreign Minister and Deputy Prime Minister
Abdullah Gul said that it would be wrong to assign the responsibility
of fighting terrorism solely to special representatives. He added:
"The representatives are doing what is incumbent on them. Our
expectations from them are well known."

Gul answered reporters’ questions on his flight to Albania where he
went for an official visit.

Answering a question on the recent Ankara visit of US Special
Representative on Combating Terrorism Gen (retd) Joseph Ralston, Gul
said that Turkey expects much from the United States in the war
against terrorism and that everyone in the United States, from
President George Bush down to the lowest levels, are aware of this.

Gul said that the United States must fight the terrorist organization
PKK as it fights other terrorists organizations and that, from that
perspective, Turkey’s expectations are even higher.

When asked how long it will take for any results to be achieved in
the battle against terrorism, Gul replied that "what he said earlier
was not a haphazard comment" and added that it would not be right for
him to say more about this issue in view of its nature.

When asked to comment on whether the special representative mechanism
is working, Gul said: "The representatives are doing what is
incumbent on them. Our expectations from them are well known." Noting
that it would be wrong to assign the responsibility of fighting
terrorism solely to special representatives, Gul said that this issue
is the highest-priority problem of the prime minister, the ministers,
and commanders.

Answering a question on his upcoming visit to the United States, Gul
said that the details of the visit have not yet been finalized but
that he expects to convey during this visit Turkey’s views on
developments in Iraq and the so-called Armenian genocide bill that
has been introduced in the US House of Representatives. He added that
this will be an important visit from many perspectives.

When reminded about efforts to organize international meetings on
Iraq, Gul said that he does not believe very large meetings are very
useful and that a meeting on Iraq between the five permanent members
of the UN Security Council and regional countries is a possibility.

‘Was it appropriate for Lebanon?’

When asked whether it was "appropriate for Lebanon" to sign an
agreement with the Greek Cypriot administration at a time when Turkey
has sent soldiers and aid to that country, Gul replied: "Of course,
it was not appropriate."

Gul said that he thinks this situation was the result of the power
vacuum and climate of chaos in Lebanon and that even the Lebanese
prime minister was not aware of the agreement. He added that the
necessary representations have been made, that Lebanon has
commitments on this issue, and that Turkey issued the necessary
warnings earlier.

When asked by a reporter whether the withdrawal of troops from
Lebanon is possible as a reprisal, Gul replied "no."

Gul was then reminded that a law enacted in the Greek Cypriot sector
allows oil exploration and extraction in the eastern Mediterranean
and that the first contract will be awarded on 15 February. Asked
whether this contract will actually be awarded, Gul replied that this
is unlikely. He added: "That cannot happen. If it happens, then
whatever is necessary will be done."

Gul begins contacts

Gul has begun in his talks in Albania where he arrived on a two-day
official visit.

Gul first met with Foreign Minister Besnik Mustafaj. The two
ministers are expected to hold a press conference after the end of
their meeting.

Tomorrow morning Gul will first attend the meeting of the
Turkish-Albanian Business Council together with Mustafaj. Then he
will be received by the prime minister, the speaker of the
parliament, and the president, in that order.

Gul is expected to return to Turkey tomorrow afternoon after
completing his contacts.

Is Gabala Radar working for Armenia?

Agency WPS
DEFENSE and SECURITY (Russia)
February 2, 2007 Friday

IS GABALA RADAR WORKING FOR ARMENIA?

by: Grigori Alexandrjan

SPECULATIONS THAT THE GABALA RADAR IS WORKING FOR ARMENIA ARE
ELEMENTS OF THE CAMPAIGN LAUNCHED TO CLOSE THE INSTALLATION; Official
Baku has reasons to want the Russians out.

The matter concerns the Darjal-type radar in the environs of Gabala
leased to Russia, the installation of the missile attack early
warning system. Speculations on how it is allegedly working for
Armenia began in Azerbaijan, clearly fomented by Baku’s intention to
exact revenge and up the rent in Moscow is paying off.

Here is a quote from theoretizations by Arif Yunusov, the head of the
Department of Conflict Studies of the Institute of Peace and
Democracy in Baku, "Suppose the hostilities between Azerbaijan and
Armenia break out again. It goes without saying that the Gabala radar
will keep track of everything. Where are the guarantees that
information, say, on movements of Azerbaijani military hardware, is
not imparted to the Armenians? Have we given shelter to a spy working
for our enemies? Members of the CIS Collective Security Treaty,
Russia and Armenia are supposed to share military information with
each other." Yunusov is convinced in other words that the Gabala
installation does not promote the interests of Azerbaijan in the
least. It is only working for Russia and, partially, for Armenia. The
political scientist therefore maintains that Azerbaijan should rid
itself of the radar data which may already be in the hands of the
Armenians.

The Gabala radar was originally built to detect ICBMs launched in the
Southern Hemisphere (launches by USSNs in the Indian Ocean included)
and to keep an eye on the southern hemisphere of outer space. It can
and does monitors airspace above the territories of Iran, Turkey,
India, Iraq, Pakistan, part of China, and some African countries.

Being an undeniably strategic tool, what kind of information can the
radar provide Armenia with? Yunusov fears that the matter concerns
movement of Azerbaijani military hardware. Isn’t that amusing? As
though it takes such a powerful radar to guess the destination of
such equipment.

There must be something else then, something Yunusov deliberately
omits. Azerbaijan with its pro-Western orientation is supposed to
tell the Americans sooner or later if it intends to allow them to
install their own military bases on its territory. And if it does
(which this correspondent, at least, has no doubts of), then the
campaign to close the Gabala radar will only gain momentum. The
principal agreement to sign documents on deploying a mobile American
contingent in Azerbaijan was reached during US Defense Secretary
Donald Rumsfeld’s visit to Baku in 2004.

AF General Charles Wald, US Commander in Europe, had spared neither
time nor effort to brainwash the Azerbaijani leadership before the
visit of his superior to Baku. American specialists examined
Azerbaijani airfields in Kjurdamir, Nasosny, and Gala. Kjurdamir
runways were repaired and the cantonment nearby was upgraded to NATO
standards. The Americans even planned to set up mobile TRML-3D radars
with the range of 200 kilometers near the settlement of Sanchagaly on
the coast. It goes without saying that the Gabala radar run by the
Russians is the last thing these objects needs close by. It means
that Armenia does not really have to do anything with Baku’s true
motives of wanting the Russians out.

Source: Novoye Vremya (Yerevan), January 30, 2007, EV

Translated by A. Ignatkin

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Manchester: Help! My business is going down the drain

Manchester Evening News, UK
February 2, 2007 Friday

Help! My business is going down the drain

by: MIKE KEEGAN

BUSINESSMAN Masis Kalanyan contacted Get It Sorted! in desperation as
he is on the verge of being forced to close down his popular
Manchester city centre restaurant.

Masis, 53, has been running the basement Armenian Taverna on Princess
Street for over 30 years.

In that time he has served up tasty Eurasian cuisine to thousands and
the restaurant has become something of a city institution.

But when contractors began work at the back of the premises in
November it began to cause major problems.

"We’ve had sewage water coming through from the work they were doing"
said Masis.

"It was coming into the toilets but it wasn’t far off getting into
the kitchen – we had to put flattened cardboard boxes down to stop if
from spreading."

He contacted his landlord, United Utilities and Manchester council,
but was on the brink of having to close for health and safety reasons
when he called us.

United Utilities assured us that workmen were on their way to tackle
the problem straight away and promptly sent a team who pumped out the
water from the restaurant on Wednesday.

But on Thursday morning, when Masis returned to the restaurant, the
water was back.

"I’ve been told two different things" he said.

"One is that there is grease in the drains which is causing a
blockage and the other is that it is an old Victorian drainage system
and part of the wall has collapsed.

"I just need whatever problem it is to be sorted because we’re not
far away from closing down."

We went back to United Utilities who said that a permanent fix would
be worked on next week.

In the meantime they are sending teams to pump water out and allow
Masis to carry on trading.

We will keep an eye on the situation.

GRAPHIC: THE HOLE PROBLEM Roadworks near the Armenian Taverna which
is suffering from flooding

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

NATO moves in on Armenia

Agency WPS
What the Papers Say Part B (Russia)
February 2, 2007 Friday

NATO MOVES IN ON ARMENIA

by Yuri Simonian

Armenia remains Russia’s ally in the southern Caucasus; A seminar on
Armenian Defense Ministry reforms, scheduled to take place in Yerevan
on February 5-7, will also discuss the prospects of NATO membership
for Armenia. This announcement implies that Russia is about to lose
its primary – if not its only – ally in the Caucasus.

BODY:

A seminar on Armenian Defense Ministry reforms, scheduled to take
place in Yerevan on February 5-7, will also discuss the prospects of
NATO membership for Armenia. This announcement from the George
Marshall European Center for Security Studies implies that Russia is
about to lose its primary – if not its only – ally in the Caucasus.

Official Yerevan responded to the news with a categorical denial. "It
doesn’t bear any resemblance to reality. Armenia’s foreign policy
agenda doesn’t include the issue of NATO membership," Defense
Ministry Press Secretary Colonel Sejran Shahsuvarian said. According
to Shahsuvarian, the seminar organized by the Marshall Center will
take place in Yerevan indeed. Those present will discuss the planned
amendments to the law "On defense" and employment of civilians by the
Defense Ministry. Moreover, NATO at the seminar is going to be
represented only by several Bulgarian, Estonian, and Latvian experts.
"We sent a note to the Marshall Center on Thursday morning demanding
an explanation of what is clearly a false information. We haven’t
received any answer so far," Shahsuvarian said. Chief of the Defense
Ministry PR Department Vrej Israelian hopes that the explanations
will be exhaustive. "No, I don’t know who might have needed this
false report made," he said.

However, there certainly must be something here because Russia’s
strategic partner in the southern part of the Caucasus has
intensified its dialogue with NATO. A NATO evaluation commission is
in Yerevan at present, inspecting compliance with Armenia’s IPAP
commitments. The fifth team of Armenian peacekeepers was dispatched
to Iraq in late January. At about the same time the government of
Armenia told the Defense Ministry to go ahead and discuss
organization of Joint Effort 2007, an international military exercise
on the territory of Armenia, with the US Defense Department and US
Army European Command. Last but not least, Armenia will join the
Ukrainian-American Sea Breeze 2007 exercise as an observer on March
13-15.

Nora Gevorkian, an expert in NATO activities in the southern part of
the Caucasus, ascribes the interests in reports on Armenia-NATO
contacts to their virtual absence until recently. "NATO was
associated with Turkey, Alliance member since 1952. Turkey’s policy
of the blockade was regarded as the policy of NATO itself," Gevorkian
wrote in her report. Everything changed in 2000 when Armenia found an
ally in NATO (Greece) which helped it form a battalion of
peacekeepers for UN operations. "NATO membership is not on the
agenda. Pragmatic as it is in evaluation of the regional security and
its shape, Armenia is advancing its relations with NATO step by step.
By and large, the republic is pursuing the policy of integration into
European structures. NATO is regarded as the leader in European
security," she said. Defense Minister Serj Sarkisian was quoted as
saying recently, "Relations with NATO will advance until appearance
of a collision between our commitments within the framework of the
CIS Collective Security Treaty Organization and NATO."

The canard the Marshall Center launched may be viewed as a message to
the Armenian authorities from the Western community, according to
Stepan Safarian, Director of the Center of National and Strategic
Studies. "With the elections coming up, the West a clear answer from
the Armenian authorities: does Yerevan aspire to NATO membership or
does it not? I don’t think that Yerevan will answer with a yes."
Parliament Speaker Arthur Bagdasarian’s statement in public that the
future of Armenia was inseparable from NATO cost him his job.
President Robert Kocharian is pro-Russian," Safarian said. On the
other hand, the Armenian authorities’ proclamation of the willingness
to join the European Union put Armenia in a tight corner in its
relations with NATO. The IPAP is something Yerevan was compelled to
launch. However, Georgia’s determination to join NATO (and its
potential entry in 2009) will certainly change things at the regional
level. "And yet, believing that Yerevan will necessarily turn in the
direction of Brussels in this eventuality is naive," Safarian added.

Source: Nezavisimaya Gazeta, February 2, 2007, pp. 1, 6

Translated by A. Ignatkin

UK e-petitions get one millionth signature

VNU Business Publications
vnunet.com
2 February 2007 Friday

UK e-petitions get one millionth signature

by Iain Thomson

Downing Street claims landmark in e-government

The UK government’s electronic petition system has received its one
millionth signatory.

The system has attracted over 2,000 petitions since going live in
October, covering a wide range of topics. The most popular is against
road pricing, which has pulled in over 600,000 signatures.

"We welcome this landmark in our electronic petitions service, which
is proving to be a popular way for people to get their views heard,"
said a Downing Street spokesman.

"We look forward to further developing the service in the coming
months to help citizens engage with the work of government."

Although the petitions website is regularly monitored for bogus
topics, a number have crept through. These include:

1. Replacing the national anthem with Spandau Ballet’s Gold (2,067
signatures)

2. Recommending the Queen to confer a knighthood on [Queen guitarist]
Brian May (404)

3. Removing an alleged Armenian Genocide portion of the Imperial War
Museum Holocaust exhibition (242)

4. Acknowledging fetishism and sadomasochism as sane sexual practices
(81)

5. Getting Tony Blair to read these petitions (13)

6. Campaigning to stop John Humphreys interrupting people (six)