Crossfire War – German FM to Three Capital Trip – South Caucasus

NewsBlaze, CA
Feb 17 2007

Crossfire War – German FM to Embark on Three Capital Trip – South
Caucasus

By Willard Payne

Crossfire War – Berlin – Washington – Moscow Watch – South Caucasus –
Central Asia Theatre: German FM Embarks Sunday on a Three Capital
Trip to South Caucasus – Baku – Tbilisi – Yerevan – Energy Security
Concerns

Night Watch: BERLIN – As part of the concerted effort of
Berlin-Washington-Moscow, and the industrial concerns that unite
them, German Foreign Minister Frank-Walter Steinmeier is scheduled to
embark Sunday on a three day, three capital trip to the South
Caucasus, on the eve of (f)allout fighting in this region the
deciding front: Baku-Tbilisi/Yerevan.

That may be the order in which he visits them. The visits in
Azerbaijan and Georgia may be more of a confrontation since both
governments have military support from Turkey-Iran with the intention
of causing another defeat for Russia in the region as in the first
Caucasus war from 1994-96, when due to so much corruption in the
Kremlin, Russian troops were not being paid as they are now under
President Vladimir Putin, Berlin’s protege. [IRNA]

Yerevan however is an extremely strategic base the Allies can use to
counter Tehran-Ankara. Armenia defeated Azerbaijan in their war over
Nagorno-Karabakh, 1988-94 and relations between Yerevan/Baku are
still extremely hostile with occasional exchanges of fire, but with
Allied support Yerevan will have no difficulty when fighting erupts
again and Armenia can even be used as a secure base for Allied
forces. And therefore help Moscow secure the Caucasus-Caspian and its
enormous energy resources for the industrialized world.

Steinmeier is representing the banking-industrial concerns that have
been financing Moscow’s domestic and foreign policy. An extension of
the centuries old economic connection between the West-Russia as the
West established Russia for the primary purpose of guaranteeing
access to Central Asian raw materials. This current war has increased
and solidified Germany and Russia economically to the extent where
right after the war’s conclusion the world may see a brand new
international hard currency ruble directed linked to a new deutsche
mark. Parts of Germany have never used the euro. The war will make
official what had been long known privately.

During and after Steinmeier’s visit to Yerevan watch for Allied
support of Armenia to increase.

Berlin star power eclipses click pics

Variety
Feb 17 2007

Berlin star power eclipses click pics
Memorable perfs but few breakouts

By ADAM DAWTREY, ELIZABETH GUIDER

The 57th Berlinale turned out to be one of the more disconnected in
the event’s long history: The sales bazaar trundled along at various
locations around the periphery of the Potzdamer Platz, while the
festival unspooled in the middle. And rarely the twain did meet.
In both of these parallel universes, excitement was in short supply.
The fest did serve up more stars than ever, generating an exponential
increase in German media coverage (important for politicians and
sponsors who bankroll the event), but neither the market nor the
competition stirred the blood of the critics or business crowd with
any hot-button issues or must-have movies.

Berlin was full of celebs tub-thumping their pictures — Clint
Eastwood, Robert De Niro, Matt Damon, Steven Soderbergh, Cate
Blanchett (in for two movies), Judi Dench, Jeff Goldblum, Richard
Gere, Jennifer Lopez.

Kosslick called it "the most star-driven festival in Berlinale
history."

Stone came not only to support her widely panned competition pic
"When a Man Falls in the Forest," but also to strut in front of a
well-heeled crowd to raise money for the Cinema for Peace initiative.
(Her rather wacky exhibition became an instant classic in
cyberspace).

Lopez flew in for competition pic "Bordertown," Gregory Nava’s film
about the systematic murder of women in the Texas-Mexico border town
of Cuidad Juarez, stopping to pick up an award from Amnesty Intl. for
raising awareness of this problem.

The three Yank titles in competition — the inevitable duo of "The
Good German" and "The Good Shepherd" as well as Zack Snyder’s "300"
— were received respectfully by the fest crowd, but hardly
rapturously.

Closest the market and festival came to a buzz film was the footage
from Morgan Spurlock’s top-secret comic doc "The Hunt for Osama Bin
Laden," screened by Wild Bunch. But with buyers forced to sign
draconian confidentiality agreements about the movie’s content, there
wasn’t much chance for it to stir debate.

In similar territory, First Look launched sales of its untitled Larry
Charles/Bill Maher doc taking a satirical look at religion. But with
just one provocative pitch sheet by Charles to show buyers, there
wasn’t enough material to stir controversy.

A number of titles in the competition traversed difficult terrain —
including the Holocaust, the Armenian genocide and AIDS. While
English-language critics were tough on most of the pics, applause in
the auditorium suggested that Europeans may respond differently.

A handful of sales agents such as Summit, Focus, Fortissimo and Wild
Bunch did report intense dealmaking and long lists of sales, but
overall, business seemed slow and difficult.

Still, there was a modicum of heat among several projects still in
the works, and curiosity about others that are just a glint in the
eye of producers.

The Spurlock doc was a hot seller, picked off by the Weinstein Co.
for North America.

John Woo’s upcoming epic "Red Cliff," the most expensive
Asian-financed film ever, will start lensing in China next month, and
sold to most major territories.

Other titles that surfaced included Volker Schlondorff’s
Afghanistan-set "Uzlan," Michael Hoffman’s Tolstoy biopic (with
Anthony Hopkins and Meryl Streep) and the Arthur Cohn-produced remake
of Shochiku’s "The Yellow Handkerchief," which will lense in New
Orleans in May.

Only scandale on the market side was the decision by
ever-cantankerous French sales company Wild Bunch to set up shop
outside the market headquarters at the Martin Gropius Bau to protest
fest topper Kosslick’s "disrespect."

Kosslick had declined to invite one of Wild Bunch’s films for the
competition and, to add insult to injury, allegedly didn’t relay his
decision personally. Kosslick dismissed the spat as little more than
a bid (admittedly successful) by Wild Bunch topper Vincent Maravel
for free publicity.

That’s what passed for excitement at this year’s event.

On the competition front, there was little to provoke protest let
alone outrage.

On paper, several pics looked to be involving or even controversial,
but so faltered on the artistic front that they just didn’t rouse
enough emotion.

In the ho-hum category were "The Other," "Desert Dream" and "In
Memory of Myself," and in the thumbs-down group were the Taviani
brothers "The Lark Farm." Even auteurs like Bille August ("Goodbye
Bafana") and Jacques Rivette ("Don’t Touch the Axe") failed to
ignite.

What did arouse some enthusiasm among festgoers were several
reasonably well-made and moving movies, with commercial prospects
across Europe and perhaps beyond.

France’s "La Vie en rose," a conventionally plotted but still
engrossing biopic about French chanteuse Edith Piaf, boasted a
glowing performance by Marion Cotillard. Pic was picked up by
Picturehouse in the U.S. many months ago and will open later this
year.

"The Counterfeiters," an unrelentingly bleak German production about
concentration camp inmates forced to forge currency to prop up the
Nazis, received loud applause at the premiere. By its very nature,
the Teutonic pic will probably attract only a limited audience.
Nonetheless distrib Beta has sold it to a host of territories. A deal
with the U.S. is pending.

Kosslick defended what he termed "the balance between big splashy
movies and tiny indie pics in the competition," saying that as long
as he is fest director, that mix will prevail.

But if this Berlinale is to be remembered for anything, it will be
for performances rather than directorial revelations.

Thesps ruled the roost, from the U.K.’s Marianne Faithfull ("Irina
Palm") and Judi Dench ("Notes on a Scandal"), through Germany’s Nina
Hoss ("Yella"), Karl Markovic and Devid Striesow (both in "The
Counterfeiters") to China’s Yu Nan ("Tuya’s Marriage").

Rumblings also resurfaced. Some Americans and Asians seem
increasingly dissatisfied with the venue and timing, though the
Europeans seem pleased with the rendezvous in their backyard.

European Film Market head Beki Probst says her org hired consultants
to help come up with suggestions for managing the Berlin market’s
growth.

She also says there might be new regulations ordering companies to
screen only new product, not movies already screened in Cannes.

Derek Elley contributed to this report.

ANKARA; The Dink assassination and neo-nationalism (ulusalcilik)

The New Anatolian, Turkey
Feb 17 2007

The Hrant Dink assassination and neo-nationalism (ulusalcilik) in
Turkey

Onder Aytac & Emre Uslu
17 February 2007
Font Size: default medium large

Nationalism has been a powerful force in Turkish politics since the
founding of the republic. Lately, however, nationalist activists have
become unusually strident in their rhetoric, and they have coalesced
around various radical political platforms to seek the ousting of the
Justice and Development (AK) Party regime, either through the ballot
box, or by violent means.

As nationalist themes gain more prominence in Turkish political
discourse, a radical new nationalist movement has emerged: the
ulusalcilar, or neo-nationalists, whose influence appears to be
spreading to the highest levels of state and society. This movement
is not an organized group with an established doctrine. Its various
components have their philosophical differences. Nevertheless, we can
distinguish three fundamental elements in ulusalci thought: the
externalization of Islam from Turkish nationalism, uncompromising
anti-Westernism and ethnic exclusionism.

Although the nationalism adopted by the founders of the Turkish
Republic had a distinctly secular tone, it internalized Islam as
psychological glue to ensure that ethnically different populations
within the boundaries of the new Turkey remained united. Ulusalcilar
however, prioritize symbols of Turkish nationalism and the Turkish
race, and accord secondary importance to Kemalism and secularism.
They oppose leftist ideologies, broad applications of democracy, and
minority rights whenever the homogeneity of Turkish nationalism might
be threatened.

If orthodox nationalists have adopted anti-European and anti-American
positions on foreign policy issues, Turkey’s neo-nationalists
absolutely reject Westernization as an operating principle.

Achieving "honorable and equal" status in the "world society of
nations" requires shunning all formal association — political,
military, or economic — with the Western world, not merely the EU
and the "strategic partnership" with the U.S. A review of ulusalci
manifestos and policy statements reveals a common "Turkey for the
Turks" theme. Turkish natural resources must belong to the citizens
of Turkey, not to foreign capitalists. "Globalization" is a
particularly ugly word in the neo-nationalist vocabulary. For
neo-nationalists, the Kurds, whether in Turkey or Iraq, are agents of
American imperialism. Therefore, the usual formulae offered to
"solve" the Kurdish problem are without foundation.

Inevitably, the Bush administration’s unstinting support for Israel
has led fringe media commentators, including and some ulusalci
outlets, to charge that the U.S. government is "in the hands of the
Jews," and therefore, they suggest, Erdogan, as a handmaiden of U.S.
policy in the Middle East, is at the same time an agent of Zionism.

Why has ulusalcilik blossomed into such a potent political force
today?

The fundamental causes were, first, the overwhelming victory of the
Justice and Development (AK) Party in the 2002 general elections,
which enabled the AK Party to establish a single-party government;
and second, the AK Party government’s implementation of the fast
forward reformation process toward membership in the European Union.

Turkey’s state elites — the civil service, judiciary and military —
are rigidly secular. They have never trusted Erdogan, and believe
that he and the AK Party have a "secret agenda" to introduce elements
of Sharia into Turkey’s legal and constitutional system. Elitist
discontent lies more in Erdogan’s appointment of individuals loyal to
the AK Party to senior bureaucratic posts, occupied throughout
previous republican history by the secular establishment. Also, to
meet the EU’s Copenhagen criteria, AK Party legislation has reduced
the military’s influence in the National Security Council (MGK) and
eliminated military membership in the security courts and the Board
of Higher Education (YOK). Hence the disempowered civilian secular
elite view the military as allies in the struggle against Erdogan and
his presumed Islamist program.

In addition, the AK Party’s liberal economic policies have created a
thriving private sector and stimulated increased foreign investment.
Nationalists accuse the AK Party (as they did earlier governments led
by Turgut Ozal) of reviving the "capitulations" the West imposed on
the Ottoman Empire and violating Ataturk’s principle of etatism.

Furthermore, Turkish nationalists came late to an understanding that
the EU accession process involved the sacrifice of much of their
status and ideology. For the country to qualify for EU membership,
the AK Party regime, taking advantage of their overwhelming majority
in Parliament, swiftly passed a broad series of major reform
measures. Many of these enhanced individual freedoms, and thus
implicitly threatened the authority of the powerful state
bureaucracy, which had for so long served as the power base of
secular nationalism. That the reform legislation was being promoted
by a political party with an agenda far different from their own was
further cause for alarm.

Who are the ulusalcilar?

As stated, the neo-nationalists have no political party or
overarching command structure, but there are a number of activist
organizations that can be identified as ulusalci, based on their
members’ shared acceptance of the movement’s principles.

Activist neo-nationalist organizations include the purposefully named
Kuvaiye Milliye Hareketi (Nationalist Forces Movement) and the
Vatansever Kuvvetler Guc Birligi Hareketi (Patriotic Forces United
Movement, VKGB). The VKGB, led by senior retired military officers,
claims more than 100 branches in 46 cities and towns. The Kemalist
Thought Association (ADD), led by former Gendarmerie Commander Sener
Eruygur, has sought preeminence in the movement on doctrinal and
ideological matters. Its roster of founders includes an impressive
number of professors and PhD’s, and it claims a nationwide membership
of 4,852. Better known is the Buyuk Hukukcular Birligi (the Great
Union of Jurists) and its leader, Kemal Kerincsiz. It is Kerincsiz
and his organization that have been responsible for the numerous
lawsuits brought under the notorious Article 301 against Turkish
intellectuals and writers — most famously Nobel Prize-winner Orhan
Pamuk and Armenian-origin journalist Hrant Dink for "insulting
Turkishness."

The neo-nationalists boast an impressive array of media outlets. They
control one daily newspaper, Yeni Cag; several periodicals, among
them the bi-weekly Turk Solu and its youth magazine, Ileri; Yeni
Hayat; Turkeli, a publication of the VKGB, and the weekly Aydinlik,
the mouthpiece of the Turk Isci Partisi (Turkish Labor Party) and its
venerable Marxist leader Dogu Perincek, who has lately reinvented
himself as a staunch Kemalist. There are two neo-nationalist TV
channels: KanalTurk and Mesaj TV.

Additionally, Istanbul daily Cumhuriyet, favored by the older
Kemalist intelligentsia, frequently voices ulusalci themes.
Cumhuriyet was once the most respected newspaper in the country, but
through its venomous attacks against AK Party leaders and their
policies it has lost any claim to objectivity. Additionally, several
mainstream newspapers carry the columns of ulusalci pundits alongside
more orthodox commentators — among them Emin Colasan (Hurriyet) and
Melih Asik (Milliyet). (Yeni Cag’s lead columnist is the popular
hard-lining nationalist and former president of the TRNC, Rauf
Denktas.)

Turkish neo-nationalists have their own underground network,
involving both active and retired military officers, significant
elements of which were exposed in a series of startling revelations
in the middle of last year. Police investigations into last May’s
murder of a Court of Appeals judge revealed that the murderer had
been under the control of a neo-nationalist group of retired military
personnel and that the shooting was probably a "black" operation
intended to look like the work of religious reactionaries. Another
series of arrests revealed the existence of the Atabeyler Gang,
composed largely of low-ranking active Special Forces officers, who
possessed diagrams apparently intended to support assassination
attempts against Erdogan and his chief foreign policy advisor, Cuneyt
Zapsu. More worrisome still, a third clandestine outfit neutralized
by the police, the Sauna Gang, which specialized in blackmail and
extortion, included both ulusalci military and ex-military personnel
and members of the Turkish mafia.

The Hrant Dink assassination

Ulusalcilik provided the ideological context for last month’s
assassination of Armenian newspaper editor Hrant Dink; and the
lawsuit against Dink, brought under Article 301 by Kemal Kerincsiz,
head of the neo-nationalist Istanbul Lawyers Union, made him a likely
target of extremist violence. It appears the 17-year-old assassin,
Ogun Samast, was merely a member of a small gang of adolescents who
had gathered around a braggart with vague but strongly expressed
extremist and xenophobic views. Some believe this small, apparently
independent gang is representative of a new and nasty phenomenon.
They call themselves, nationalist, ulusalci or anti-imperialist, find
their like-minded friends through the Internet, and select their
targets. These people are horizontally organized, loosely connected
and more secretive than the traditional terror groups. Dink received
death threats from notorious neo-nationalist bullies, like retired
Col. Veli Kucuk, who allegedly is the leader of these ulusalci
mafia-rings, but there is no evidence that links these unsavory
elements to his murder.

Nationalist and ulusalci commentators have engaged in a shameless
campaign to gain propaganda capital from this heinous crime. Various
columnists have hinted darkly at the involvement of Western
intelligence services. Several saw the motivation for the
assassination in the likelihood that it would smooth the passage of
the Armenian "genocide" resolution through the U.S. Congress, and
Tercuman newspaper actually claimed that Samast was an ethnic
Armenian! Inevitably, some, including senior spokesmen of the
Nationalist Movement Party (MHP), explicitly blamed the CIA, Mossad,
or both. Meanwhile, a neo-nationalist columnist with an established
reputation for uncovering elaborate conspiracies on the basis of
minimal evidence linked the location of Samast’s gang in his native
Trabzon to a certain "U.S. Black Sea project." This project, the
author alleged, is intended to project American influence in areas
east of Turkey and involves, as a key element, securing Trabzon as an
American base. Of the leading ulusalcilar, only the man most
responsible for this dreadful affair, Kerincsiz, showed any
contrition, condemning, in a public statement shortly after the
crime, the use of violence to achieve political ends. Ulusalci
bellwether Turk Solu, however, in its editorial written by Gokce
Firat, placed the conspiracy closer to home, describing Dink’s
assassination as a propaganda ploy by Turkey’s "Kurdish-Islamist
fascist dictatorship" to maintain themselves in power. Firat,
demonstrating the ability to harbor two contradictory opinions at the
same time, is also cheered by the assassination. "Turkey has lost an
enemy!" he advised his readers, with evident happiness.

ANKARA: Gross injustice

The New Anatolian, Turkey
Feb 17 2007

Gross injustice

Gunduz Aktan
17 February 2007

Following last month’s assassination of Hrant Dink, some U.S. State
Department officials and Armenia’s foreign minister urged Turkey to
use this opportunity to normalize relations with Armenia by opening
the border and "face our history" by abolishing Article 301.

The Americans say that if Turkey "helps itself" by taking such steps,
the administration will be able to defend Turkey more easily in
Congress. One cannot help wondering whether the "opportunity" that
arose as a result of Dink’s murder is for Turkey to use in order to
serve the interests of the U.S. and Armenia.

Even though Turkey hasn’t established diplomatic relations with
Armenia, it recognizes the country. The Turkish-Armenian border is
closed, but goods are transported annually by 4,000 TIR trucks to
Armenia via Georgia. In this way, Turkey is the second-biggest
trading partner for Armenia. There are 60,000-70,000 Armenians
illegally working in Turkey. Flights are operating to Istanbul and
Antalya, etc.

Despite these facts, an additional demand to open the border and set
up diplomatic relations would mean abandoning Azerbaijan in the face
of the continuing Armenian occupation of Karabakh and other parts of
this country. Moreover we have to keep in mind that the Turkish
Republic of Northern Cyprus (TRNC) does everything for a solution
while the international embargo against it continues.

There is not a single Ottoman monument left in Armenia. Not a single
Turk or Azeri lives there. You could think that the Ottoman Empire’s
Revan province never existed. However, we invited the Armenian
diaspora to restore the Akhdamar Church. Since there was no reply,
Turkey did the restoration as a gesture. In return, the infamous bill
was introduced to the French Parliament and a resolution introduced
at the U.S. Congress.

Meanwhile, pressure on us to repeal Article 301 is continuing. Thus,
we are expected to "face our history" and recognize that the 1915
events amounted to genocide. Actually, if we accepted the genocide,
nobody would want us to face our past.

Today, Armenia is a Tashnak dictatorship. But it dares to urge us to
expand freedom of expression. Not a single book that denies the
genocide claims is sold in Armenia. Let alone those written by the
Turks or foreigners, even the report (rather the testament) submitted
to the Tashnak Assembly of 1923 at Bucharest by the first prime
minister of the independent Armenia and the most important Tashnak
leader of the era, Hovhannes Katchaznouni, is still banned. They do
not read documents by even those who played a leading role in their
history so that they can keep intact their belief in a genocide.

Considering that it is almost impossible to have serious cooperation
with such a country, the U.S. should be expected to put pressure on
Armenia with a view to accelerating the democratization of its
regime. The U.S. not only does not do this, it does not even try to
prevent the unilateral genocide propaganda in its schools. But it
gives priority to influencing our attitude.

Under these conditions, there is no alternative other than seeking a
solution to the problem by adjudication or arbitration. Mr. Gul
expressed this view in December during the budget debates. In
response, not a word was heard from the U.S. administration, EU
countries or institutions, Armenia or the Armenian diaspora. It’s as
if all of a sudden everyone became deaf and mute.

In Turkey too, none of those who consider themselves intellectuals
said, "All right, let’s solve the problem by adjudication or
arbitration." They murmur, "It cannot be done through adjudication.
We should face our history and use empathy with the Armenians," just
as Armenia and the Armenian diaspora demand. I hope that they do not
render these services without remuneration.

Can adjudication be done without facing history? All the archives
will be opened and population statistics, forensic research, hospital
records and all incidents that happened during the relocation will be
thoroughly examined. Nothing better can be done to face history.

No, they urge only us to face history. They wish to ignore Armenian
insurrections, massacres, collaboration with the enemy, and betrayal.
As a result we would appear as perpetrators and they as victims.

The attempts to portray Turks as being responsible for genocide are
the basic reason for the current psychological regression and the
harsh nationalist reaction in our society. Nobody should entertain
any illusion that Turkey will eventually yield to these unilateral
allegations. We will take Armenia and its supporters to court and
will make them face history together with us. And we will make them
respect our dead as well.

There is no way out for anyone anymore.

ANKARA: Buyukanit bullish on US’ anti-PKK efforts

The New Anatolian, Turkey
Feb 17 2007

Buyukanit bullish on US’ anti-PKK efforts

The New Anatolian / Washington

17 February 2007

Turkish Chief of General Staff Gen. Yasar Buyukanit expressed his
hope late Thursday about better U.S. cooperation against the
terrorist Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK), saying, "I got the
impression from the U.S. a more effective fight against PKK (may be
coming). But we’ll have to see the result."

After meeting with U.S. Joint Chiefs of Staff Chairman Gen. Peter
Pace and U.S. Undersecretary of Defense for Policy and former U.S.
Ambassador to Turkey Eric Edelman, Gen. Buyukanit told reporters,
"You can’t give any exact timetable in the fight against terrorism.
We’ve been countering it since 1984."

Asked about Iran’s Shahab missiles, he said that he hadn’t discussed
this matter with U.S. officials. "As soldiers, we know that how far
the missiles can be sent and what they are," he added.

However, Buyukanit did express Turkey’s uneasiness about the
missiles.

"Such things may make any country and all regional countries uneasy.
Such a capability is dangerous, especially if it is out of control,"
he added.

Buyukanit also stated late Wednesday that the U.S administration is
resolutely against the so-called Armenian genocide resolution, adding
that he finds this a quite positive attitude. Buyukanit met with U.S.
Vice President Dick Cheney and President George W. Bush’s National
Security Advisor Stephen Hadley on Wednesday. He met with U.S. House
of Representatives Foreign Affairs Committee Chairman Tom Lantos on
Friday.

Buyukanit is also expected to participate in a meeting at the
National Defense University and attend a dinner to be hosted in his
honor by Gen. Pace.

Identity and Violence

L’express.mu, Mauritius
Feb 17 2007

Identity and Violence

by Surendra BISSOONDOYAL

An individual does not have only one identity, but a multiplicity of
identities. Soap box orators and other rabble rousers harp on one
particular identity to bring out the worst in people, and this is
what leads to violence. Amartya Sen, the Economics Nobel Laureate,
has, in a masterly exposé in his book «Identity and violence», shown
how «the imposition of an allegedly unique identity is often a
crucial component of the `martial art’ of fomenting sectarian
confrontation».

We are, up to now, fortunate that we have not had to go through the
sort of violence that has in the past engulfed many peoples in
senseless sectarian killings, and which has not spared innocent
tourists and bystanders. But the danger has not been totally averted
and we will come back to this again. In the meantime we are daily
watching powerlessly the butchery between Sunnis and Shias in
Baghdad, the centre of a great old civilization. What makes us
despair is that both groups swear by Islam just as the Irish were
slaughtering one another in the name of Catholicism or Anglicanism,
ignoring their common Christianity.

`Religious’ appartenance has not been the only motive behind the
explosion of violent behaviour. Racial and tribal differences, as
between Tutsis and Hutus in Rwanda recently, have been responsible
for the genocide of millions of innocent people. Opinion leaders
throughout the world – political, social, religious – need to
understand that others can have different identities which should be
respected.

Top footballers playing for a particular team may have different
racial, religious or national identities but it is their identity as
players for a particular team, however temporary, that predominates.
However blind belief in the superiority of a particular identity can
be the source of violence, even in football, as we have seen in Italy
recently. And some people want to go back to the days when
`communalism’ infected the game in Mauritius! It is preferable to
have stadiums which remain empty rather than full of corpses.

What can we do to make people aware of the danger lying in wait for
us? The French Parliament passed a law at the end of 2006 making it a
crime to deny that Turks committed genocide against Armenians in
1915. Of course it is a heinous crime to commit genocide against
people whose perceived identity may not be to the liking of those who
massacre them. But such laws are only palliatives. Furthermore it can
be argued that the law passed by the French Parliament is politically
motivated to prevent Turkey from joining the European Union.
Massacres that have taken place throughout history call for a deeper
analysis of buman behaviour. Amartya Sen delves into the past to show
how ideas, discoveries and inventions have migrated from one place to
another and then in the opposite direction later.

George Sarton, the historian of science, was amazed when he
discovered that the decimal system and the symbol for zero had been
brought to Europe by the Arabs from India in the seventeenth century
but it took the Europeans one thousand years to adopt them and
discard the clumsy Roman numerals. And he exclaims: «Rivers and
mountains are easier to cross than the barriers in the mind of man.»

It is precisely in the minds of young children that we need to sow
the seeds of peace and understanding to fight the kind of intolerance
and violence that we see around us in everyday life. We condemn, as
we should, the acts of terrorism associated mainly with those who
swear by `their’ perception of Islam. But do not the U.S.A. and
Israel have a share of responsibility in such a reaction to what
Palestinians have suffered and continue to suffer since the creation
of the State of Israel?

We talk about the clash of civilizations. Should we not rather talk
about the clash of obstinate and obsessive identities which prevent
some people from seeing the positive side of others’ identities?
Akbar, the great Mughal Emperor of India, who was a Muslim, insisted,
as Amartya Sen recalls, «on the need for open dialogue and free
choice and also arranged recurrent discussions involving not only
mainstream Hindu and Muslim thinkers, but also Christians, Jews,
Parsees, Jains and even atheists». And that was in the 1590’s!

We should ourselves not forget the irruption of violence that
threatened our future before independence and more recently when Kaya
died in prison. Unesco has rightly pointed out that `learning to live
together’ should be one of the pillars of education today. But what
do we see instead? A cut throat competition which makes children
aware that some of them are more equal than others. Are we not sowing
the seeds of confrontation and violence from an early age?

id=80960

http://www.lexpress.mu/display_article.php?news_

Elif Shafak talks about her novel and the real trial of imaginary

Village Voice, NY
Feb 17 2007

Under Siege
Elif Shafak talks about her novel and the real trial of imaginary
characters

by Lenora Todaro
February 16th, 2007 6:43 PM

"When I am writing fiction I am a different person with many
personalities – and I am very daring," says Turkish novelist Elif
Shafak during a conversation at the Warwick Hotel. "Then in my daily
life I return to being a person with anxieties and fears."
Shafak is registered under an alias. She cancelled a six-city book
tour (reading only in New York) after ultranationalist Turks declared
her an "enemy of the state" for passages in her novel The Bastard of
Istanbul referring to the "genocide" of Armenians "at the hands of
Turkish butchers." Another such "enemy" was assassinated on January
19: the Turkish-Armenian newspaper editor Hrant Dink, a dear friend
of Shafak’s. The Nobel laureate Orhan Pamuk cut short his tour of
Germany after learning the news. Now Shafak is shadowed by a
bodyguard, complete with earpiece and jerky, roving eye.

Of the 60 or so intellectuals taken to court by the same
ultranationalists for "public denigration of Turkishness" – a crime
punishable by three years in prison – only Shafak was called out for
the words of her characters. Shafak believes the lawsuits are
intended to derail Turkey’s bid to enter the European Union by making
the nation appear "insular and xenophobic."

A bestseller in Turkey, The Bastard of Istanbul follows two families:
one a Turkish clan living in Istanbul, the other Armenians living in
California and Arizona (where Shafak teaches part of the year).
Through their stories, Shafak explores a political taboo known in
Turkey as "the Armenian question," which asks whether in 1915 the
deportation and death of more than one million Armenians at the hands
of the Turks was "genocide" or (as the Turkish government contends)
part of World War I.

Shafak describes herself as a nomad and a free spirit – a girl raised
by her divorced mother, a diplomat with whom she lived in Spain,
Jordan, and Germany. "I am someone who is always writing either on my
way to Turkey, or away from it," she says. "When I feel suffocated I
leave." The 35-year-old writer in front of me doesn’t exactly exude
free spiritedness, cocooned in a black turtleneck, blouse, and long
black skirt. Living under threat makes her careful to stay on message
in public. No displays of righteous anger, no emotional
leakage – except one watery-eyed moment, while talking about the birth
of her daughter in Istanbul during her trial in September 2006. (She
was acquitted.) While nursing the newborn in a hospital bed, she
watched on TV as protesters burned posters with her picture. "An
amazing dialectic was happening within our room," she says. "On the
TV was darkness and violence, and you’re in a room where babies are
born every minute and there’s hope and light."

The Bastard of Istanbul, too, opens dramatically with the birth of a
child into difficult circumstances. Zeliha Kazanci’splans to abort
her fetus goes awry. Asya, the daughter born to her, becomes the
linchpin between the two families. Shafak’s Turkish women are writ
large: Zeliha runs a tattoo parlor and has three sisters: a
clairvoyant, a Turkish history teacher, and a schizophrenic. The
mother of the clan "might have been Ivan the Terrible in another
life." The story’s focus moves swiftly to Asya, a Dostoyevskian
19-year-old Johnny Cash fanatic and the "bastard" of the book. The
American-Armenian family, also replete with a brainy daughter
Armanoush, functions as a mouthpiece for Armenians’ anger toward
Turks. For 100 pages, Shafak skillfully sets up the collision of the
two plot lines, when future BFFs Asya and Armanoush will discover the
cross-pollination of their family secrets. Along the way, Shafak’s
steady glide is punctuated by her characters’ amusing existential
freak-outs and winking nods at the raucous finale.

Throughout the novel Shafak attends to the details of women’s daily
lives, especially the foods they eat. "It always amazes me how common
cuisines transcend nationalistic boundaries," says Shafak. At the
table, the taste of pilaf stirs Armanoush and Asya to realize their
families share a history. The Turkish dessert ashure anchors the
book’s structure with its ingredients shaping chapters and plays a
role in the tidy conclusion.

While food elicits memories, Alzheimer’s wipes them away. Some of the
most beautiful writing in the book comes in the depiction of
96-year-old grandmother, Petit-Ma, who has the disease: "The words of
the prayer she had to utter had all of a sudden fastened together
into an elongated chain of letters and walked away in tandem, like a
black hairy caterpillar with too many feet to count." Alzheimer’s
raises the question of how one remembers – the same quandary behind the
Armenian question. "If the past is sad," Shafak asks, "would you like
to know about it?" Her characters would and would not. Auntie Banu,
seeking answers about the Armenian question, says, "Either grant me
the bliss of the ignorant or give the strength to bear the knowledge
. . . but please don’t make me powerless and knowledgeable at the
same time."

Shafak says she’s reading Don Quixote right now. Given her
circumstances, it provides an apt comparison. Quixote and Bastard
share a penchant for satirizing nationalism and exploring the ethics
of deception. While Quixote moves between farce and philosophy,
between real adventures and imagined ones, Shafak, against her
wishes, is doing the same – moving from a real-life trial of imaginary
characters to an imaginative meditation upon mortality and new life.

ANKARA: Buyukanit: US to `wage a better battle’against PKK

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
Feb 17 2007

Chief of General Staff Büyükanýt: US to `wage a better battle’
against PKK

Turkey’s top military commander said he had the impression that the
US administration would "wage a better battle" in Turkey’s fight
against terrorist activities carried out by the outlawed Kurdistan
Workers’ Party (PKK).

"It is of course not possible to say anything definite about the
struggle against the PKK before we have definite results. However, I
have the impression that the US administration will have a better way
of fighting the PKK. We will take the end result as a reference point
for our evaluations, though," said Turkish Chief of General Staff
Gen.Yaþar Büyükanýt.
Büyükanýt’s statements came following a meeting at the Pentagon with
Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff Gen. Peter Pace and US
Undersecretary of Defense for Policy Eric Edelman.
When asked if he could set a deadline for the fight against PKK,
Büyükanýt said that it is not possible to set a deadline for an
anti-terrorism struggle, noting, "Turkey has been fighting against
terrorism since 1984."
Also, when asked to comment on whether Turkey sees the Shahab
missiles Iran possesses as a threat or not, Büyükanýt said that this
issue wasn’t a topic of discussion during his talks with US
officials, but added that "the Turkish military has extensive
technical information about such weapons."
Upon being asked if Turkey is worried about Iran’s possession of such
weapons, Büyükanýt responded by saying, "Of course, Turkey is
worried. Developments of this nature are bound to trigger fear among
countries within a particular region. It is most dangerous when there
is a likelihood of uncontrolled usage of such weapons."
Büyükanýt’s visit to the US capital follows Turkish Foreign Minister
Abdullah Gül’s meeting that focused on the Armenian genocide
resolution introduced to the US House of Representatives.
As part of Turkish efforts to lobby the US Congress to prevent the
resolution’s passage, Büyükanýt is scheduled to meet with Tom Lantos,
head of US House of Representatives Foreign Relations Committee.
Lantos had supported Turkey’s position on the Armenian genocide issue
in the past, but following the Turkish Parliament’s March 1, 2003
decision that did not allow for the deployment of 62,000 US troops
through Turkey for war with Iraq, Lantos said he would shift his
stance on the resolution.
Turkey rejects the genocide label, stating that 300,000 Armenians and
at least as many Turks died in civil strife when Armenians took up
arms for independence in eastern Anatolia and sided with Russian
troops that were invading the Ottoman Empire during World War I.

BAKU: Released Azerbaijani soldier transferred to Bayil ward #1

Today, Azerbaijan
Feb 17 2007

Released Azerbaijani soldier transferred to Bayil isolation ward #1

17 February 2007 [09:10] – Today.Az

Azerbaijani soldier Vusal Garajayev who was released form Armenian
capture was transferred to Bayil isolation ward #1.

Up to now Garajayev has been treated in Medical Institution for
tuberculosis patients # 3, sources in Justice Ministry Penitentiary
Service told the APA.

A criminal case was launched against Vusal Garajayev on Article 274
(high treasury) and 338.1 (violation of service rules) of the
Criminal case. The investigation is under way.

Garajayev Vusal Mammad born in 1988 was drafted from Balaken Military
registration Department and captured by Armenians on December 7 in
Aghdam territory. He was handed over to Azerbaijani side under
auspices of International Committee of Red Cross.

URL:

http://www.today.az/news/politics/36619.html

Nationalism Has Turkey’s Intellectuals on Edge

NPR.Org
Feb 17 2007

Nationalism Has Turkey’s Intellectuals on Edge
by Ivan Watson

All Things Considered, February 16, 2007 · A climate of fear has
settled over leading dissident intellectuals in Turkey, in the wake
of the assassination last month of a prominent Turkish-Armenian
writer. Ultra-nationalists have stoned churches, attempted hijackings
of ferryboats, and chanted the name of the writer’s killer at soccer
games.

Increasingly, writers and academics who have long challenged the
Turkish Republic’s taboos are seeking protection from the Turkish
state.

Worn down after enduring years of trials and attacks in the
nationalist media, Nobel-prize winning author Orhan Pamuk recently
fled the country. He was escorted to the airport by bodyguards. It’s
a far cry from the spirit of optimism and reform that prevailed just
a few years ago, when Turkey began negotiations to join the European
Union.

Analysts predict the tensions will only get worse, as mainstream
political parties compete to court the nationalist vote ahead of
presidential elections.

ry.php?storyId=7455092

From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

http://www.npr.org/templates/story/sto