ANKARA: US congresswoman Foxx supports Turk stand on Armenian issue

Journal of Turkish Weekly, Turkey
Feb 24 2007

US congresswoman Foxx supports Turkish stand on Armenian issue

Saturday , 24 February 2007

Turkish-American relations would be negatively affected if the
Armenian genocide resolution gets approval from the House of
Representatives, said Virginia Foxx, a Republican member of the US
Congress.

As US President George W. Bush puts special importance on national
security and counter-terrorism, the US administration is concerned
that approval of the resolution would have a negative impact on the
American fight against terror and its relations with Turkey.

Foxx’s statements came after a luncheon meeting with the
Turkish-American Chamber of Commerce and Industry held in her honor
at a Turkish restaurant in New York. Fox joined the Turkish-American
Friendship Group in the US Congress, after she was elected the North
Carolina representative, in an effort to help improve relations
between Turkey and America.
Putting her personal stance on the resolution in words that expressed
opposition to the bill because, she believed, there was no sound
reason behind it, Foxx further said that most representatives who
signed the resolution do not actually know much about it and have not
thought about it deeply. Foxx added that the recent shift of power in
the House of Representatives from the Republicans to the Democrats
was adding to the concerns of the US administration. Historically, US
Democrats have been more supportive of the Armenian claims than
Republicans.

House Speaker and Democrat Nancy Pelosi has expressed support for the
resolution. The Armenian genocide resolution was introduced on
January 30th and currently has about 170 co-sponsors.

Mustafa Merc, the president of the Chamber, told the Anatolia news
agency that they were maintaining a series of one-to-one connections
with US congressmen in order to convey a truthful picture of problems
facing Turkey, to improve the American image of Turkey and to prevent
the passage of the Armenian resolution.

EuroVision Song Contest: Armenia: results of the second semi final

esctoday.com, Netherlands
Feb 24 2007

Armenia: results of the second semi final

Tomorrow, the Armenian national final will be held. After the first
semi final yesterday, the second heat was held today. Another ten
songs were performed and three were chosen to move forward to the
final, one of them by SMS voting and the further two by a jury who
will eventually decide the winner tomorrow. A ‘wildcard’ was given to
Meri Voskanyan who had two songs in the selection.
The following songs made it to the final:

Hayko – Antime you need (Jury)
Emmi – You’ve done it (Jury)
Karine Asiryan – Your heart is hot (SMS)
Meri Voskanian – Carry me in (Wildcard)

Since Hayko was not only chosen by the jury but also won the SMS
voting, Karine Asiryan who was second qualified. Meri Voskanyan got a
‘wildcard’ because she ‘is popular in Germany and has no relatives in
Armenia’. Actually, The singer has competed in German Idol last year
where she reached the top14. In 2006, she was already announced as
Armenian representative by tabloid BILD, something which turned out
to be untrue.

You can find videos of the songs that qualified yesterday on
eurovision.am here. The other videos will surely be added soon. On
the page, you can also find the lyrics of the finalist entries.

The complete line-up for tomorrow:

Hayko – Antime you need (Jury)
Emmi – You’ve done it (Jury)
Karine Asiryan – Your heart is hot (SMS)
Meri Voskanian – Carry me in (Wildcard)
Arina Hovhannisyan – Colour of my tears (SMS winner)
Asta – My story
Sergey Grigoryan – I am yours (Quonn emm)

Turkish net forced to bail on hit tale

Variety Magazine
Feb 24 2007

Turkish net forced to bail on hit tale

13,000 complaints sent following premiere

By ALI JAAFAR Hit Turkish skein "Valley of the Wolves: Terror" has
been yanked only one episode into its new run following complaints
the show could incite sectarian violence.
Turkish satcaster Show TV, which aired the series, was reportedly
warned by regulator RTUK it would lose its license if it didn’t pull
the show, after 13,000 complaints were received following the season
preem.

Execs at both RTUK and Show TV have been quick to point the finger at
each other for the decision to nix the show, which garnered auds of
30 million and a 48% market share.

Execs from Pana Film, the shingle behind the franchise, were clear on
whom they blamed however.

"We have been given no official explanation, and the RTUK now deny
they ordered the show to be cancelled, but we know that they told
Show TV they would cancel their license if they continued to show
it," says Pana spokesman Tugba Mutaf.

"Valley of the Wolves: Terror" depicted Kurdish separatist violence
over the past two decades. Even though Pana officials claimed the
show "portrayed Turks and Kurds as brothers," sensitivity in Turkey
over the representation of rival nationalist aspirations has been
particularly high ever since the assassination of Turkish-Armenian
editor Hrant Dink in January by an ultra-nationalist Turkish
teenager.

This isn’t the first controversy to hit the "Valley of the Wolves"
producers. Last year, a bigscreen spinoff of wildly popular series
"Valley of the Wolves: Iraq" took the Turkish box office by storm,
attracting some 6 million admissions to become the country’s
highest-ever grosser.

Pic — which showed Turkish troops sent to the avenge atrocities by
Americans and their allies, including Israel — was pulled from
German theaters following accusations of anti-Semitism.

It’s unclear what will happen to the rest of "Valley of the Wolves:
Terror" series. Producers had already wrapped the second episode. A
further 13 were planned.

"We want to show this to our people. We’re looking at releasing it on
DVD, on the internet or maybe turning it onto a film," says Mutaf.
"Maybe some people are afraid of showing who’s behind this terror."

ANKARA: Yazicioglu: BBP to resist intl plot surrounding Dink murder

The New Anatolian, Turkey
Feb 24 2007

Yazicioglu: BBP will resist intl plot surrounding Dink murder

The New Anatolian / Ankara
24 February 2007

Grand Unity Party (BBP) leader Muhsin Yazicioglu said on Friday that
he isn’t trying to put up a defense but is digging deep to reveal the
truth behind last month’s killing of journalist Hrant Dink, at a
press conference to make public a report prepared by his party over
allegations it has links with the perpetrators.

Dink, an Armenian-origin Turkish journalist, was gunned down by a
teenager last month. The murder increased tension and turned the
spotlights on Trabzon, a northern city that is home to both the
gunman and alleged inciters. The police and Gendarmerie engaged in a
fight over a lack of communication and intelligence, while the
country, including politicians, has been slit over the controversy.

"We’re employing a transparent approach to shed light on to the
issue, otherwise, we don’t have to release our report," Yazicioglu
said, claiming that the killing was part of a greater plan to drive
Turkey into chaos.

"We’re clever enough to notice games played against Turkey. We’re
knowledgeable enough to prevent such games, and we’re determined
enough to resist these games as the last stronghold of the nation,"
he added.

"Turkey is being driven inside an international operation, in the
guise of being engineered by amateurs," he said, claiming that the
killing is the part of the Greater Middle East Initiative employed by
the U.S. to split the region through stirring up the people with
promises of further democracy and freedom.

"There is speculation that Trabzon is seen as a base for certain
religious groups, missionaries to resurrect the old Trabzon Pontus
Empire. Even though we accept them as just talk, the talk itself
causes reaction. Firearms given to the Iraqis by the U.S. are found
in Trabzon and with an extreme leftist organization. The Solidarity
Association of Prisoners’ Families (TAYAD), although it has no
supporters in Trabzon, held several demonstrations there," Yazicioglu
went on to say and concluded that these are parts of an operation to
wear down the Gendarmerie and ignite a debate within the state.

Yazicioglu also told reporters that photos of him with one of the
suspects, Erhan Tuncel, should not arouse questions as he is a
politician and such photos are normal for men traveling around the
country.

Two photos of Tuncel, said to be a former police informant and who
was arrested on charges of inciting the murder, with Yazicioglu were
published in dailies following the killing. Yazicioglu, in an
immediate comment, said that this was a plot against him.

After the speech by his leader, BBP deputy leader Ertugrul Ogan gave
details about the report prepared by him, deputy leader Omer Kose and
party official Metin Gundogdu.

The report brushed aside claims that Tuncel was a member of BBP or
its youth branch, Alperen Ocagi.

It also said that Yasin Hayal, the alleged second man behind the
murder, has registered to the party in 2000 along with his uncle, but
was dismissed last November.

In related news, Veysel Toprak, yet another suspect, was arrested,
raising the total number of arrested people to nine.

The police said that Toprak has close links with Yasin Hayal.

Armenia has very good relations with Russia – Kocharian

ITAR-TASS, Russia
Feb 24 2007

Armenia has very good relations with Russia – Kocharian

23.02.2007, 22.14

PARIS, February 23 (Itar-Tass) — Armenia has very good relations
with Russia in many spheres, President Robert Kocharian said in an
interview with the France 24 television channel.

`We have no problems with Russia, probably, because we do not create
any artificial obstacles for political considerations,’ he said.

`I do not think it would be wise to restrict the access of Russian
capitals to Armenia. On the contrary, we welcome all types of
investments. No one has ever said that only Russian companies can get
an access to a particular sphere: our economy is open to all,’ he
said.

Glendale: Schiff meets with students

Burbank Leader
Feb 24 2007

Schiff meets with students

Series of meetings is meant to encourage participation and diversity
in service, congressman says.
By Anthony Kim

Glendale Community College board member Vahe Perooman, right, joins
Rep. Adam Schiff at a Glendale Community College breakfast on Friday
and tells his story of coming to America from Iran.

GLENDALE – An elite group of student leaders talked politics over
breakfast with Rep. Adam Schiff Friday morning at Glendale Community
College’s culinary arts department.

Schiff invited about 25 Armenian-American students from high schools
in his district to promote diversity in public service, Schiff said.
The congressman met with Asian-American student leaders in San
Gabriel on Thursday, and hosted meetings with African-American and
Latino students in October.

"We wanted to encourage more participation in public service," said
Schiff, whose congressional district includes Glendale and Burbank.

City officials, commissioners, local clergy members and community
college trustees also had their morning meal with the students.
Students from Glendale, Crescenta Valley, Burbank, John Marshall
Fundamental and John Muir high schools were there to discuss public
service.

After brief introductions from college board President Armine
Hacopian and college President Audre Levy, Schiff stood at the front
of the room listening as every student shared his or her aspirations
and background.

– POLITICAL LANDSCAPE:
Scott introduces map for college
– Schiff meets with students
– BURBANK CITY COUNCIL MEETING WRAP-UP
– Search for market site is on

Sona Karakashian, 17, a senior at Clark Magnet High School, said she
loved campaigning for Assemblyman Paul Krekorian during the last
election cycle and that getting into politics is her dream.

"Maybe I can become a politician and serve the community of Glendale
someday," Sona said.

Romina Keshishyan, 18, said being president of Glendale High School’s
Junior State of America chapter – a nationwide political organization
for high schools – got her deeply interested in government and
politics. advertisement

But she still is not quite sure about what career to pursue.

"All of us here are undecided in what we want to do," Romina said.
"We just have a mutual interest in politics. I just want to know what
motivated [Schiff] to become congressman."

Many of the students had medical school on their minds rather than
politics.

Glendale High School student body Vice President Nare Kupelian, 17,
said she was interested in politics until TV show Grey’s Anatomy
sparked an interest in medicine.

"Now I’m debating on med school and politics," she said.

The community leaders shared their own experiences with the students
and the paths they took to achieve their positions.

Father Vazken Atmajian, from St. Mary’s Armenian Apostolic Church in
Glendale, was one of the many Armenian leaders at the breakfast
offering inspiration to the students.

"The opportunities are out there and you have to be ready to take the
opportunity…. Get educated as much as you can," he said. "Get
physical nourishment and spiritual nourishment."

New Testament Manuscripts: Discovery and Classification

American Thinker, AZ
Feb 24 2007

New Testament Manuscripts: Discovery and Classification

By James Arlandson

This article is the third in a four-part series on New Testament
textual criticism. It provides basic facts on how some of the New
Testament manuscripts were discovered and how they are classified. It
answers such questions as these:

What does Oxyrhynchus mean? What do Beatty or Bodmer mean? What are
the totals of the New Testament manuscripts? Were some of them
destroyed during the persecution of the early church? Why wouldn’t
God protect his Word from such complications? Should I trust the New
Testament?

These questions and more are explored in a basic Question and Answer
format, for ease of understanding. As noted in Part One, NT stands
for New Testament, MS stands for manuscript (singular), and MSS for
manuscripts (plural).

As noted in the previous two parts, this article assumes the basics
of the Christian doctrine of inspiration. The original authors were
inspired, but we do not have their very originals. (Incidentally, no
original manuscript of any book coming out of the Greco-Roman world
exists today.) The original New Testament documents were transmitted
by scribes, who were not inspired. But does this cast doubt on the
New Testament? Not if we are reasonable. New Testament textual
criticism attempts to purge out or decide on the best of these
variants that evolved over the tedious process of copying.

They can be classified in this way:

I. Spelling differences and nonsense errors

This is by far the majority. For example, the name John in Greek can
be spelled with two n’s or one n. Nonsense errors can come from the
fatigue of the scribe, such as spelling and (kai in Greek) for Lord
(kyrios in Greek).

II. Differences that do not affect translation or that involve
synonyms

This is also a sizeable chunk of the scribal variants. Two examples:
Greek can use or not the definite article for proper nouns, such as
Mary or the Mary. Such is the nature of Greek back then.

III. Meaningful variants that are not viable

This category represents the third smallest number of variants, but
it amounts to only a tiny fraction. For example, 1 Thessalonians 2:9
could read "the gospel of God" (found in most manuscripts) or "the
gospel of Christ" (found in one late thirteenth century manuscript).

IV. Meaningful and viable

This represents only one percent of all variants. For example, the
ending of the Gospel of Mark 16 is classified thus. Any reputable
modern translation will mention that the best manuscripts do not
support the longer ending. The reader should look at the New
International Version, for example. Please go to Bible Gateway and
type in Mark 16 and then John 7, and scroll down to the end of the
page.

So what do these four categories of variants have in common? No
variant overturns Christian doctrine, such as the deity of Christ,
which is often supported by other verses. Hyper-skeptics appearing in
the national media mislead the public about this. Also, the majority
of variants are a concern for scholars, but not for average Bible
readers, who need to know that our Bible is completely trustworthy.
For us non-specialists, this means that only one percent of these
variants are in play and are often noted in our translations. On the
positive side, 99% of the Bible is established. Or if we combine the
third and fourth categories, then only about 5% are relevant for us
indirectly. This means that around 95% of the Bible is established.
No text in the ancient Greco-Roman world comes close to this outcome,
but a very far distant second.

As I wrote in the previous article in this series, the Bible is a
highly reliable, accurate, and faithful record of the words and ideas
of the original authors, as inspired by God.

Source: Komoszewski, Sawyer, and Wallace, pp. 54-63.

2. What is the original language of the New Testament?

Since the question and answer is so fundamental, I have repeated them
in the other parts in this series. It was written in common Greek of
the first century, in a vocabulary and sentence structure that most
people could understand. This is especially true of the four Gospels.
Christianity is a missionary religion, so it had to use the language
that everyone knew in the cities in the first century. And that
language was Greek. Not much later, as Christianity expanded farther,
scribes translated the Greek New Testament into other languages.

3. Who physically wrote down the original New Testament books and
epistles?

It is likely that the original authors wrote their own books and
epistles. But it is equally likely that at least some employed
scribes to do this, as the authors dictated their words. For example,
the scribe or amanuensis of Paul’s long Epistle to the Romans reveals
himself: "I, Tertius, who wrote down this letter, greet you in the
Lord" (Rom. 16:22; see Gal. 6:11 and 1 Pe. 5:12).

4. Was copying hard work for the scribe?

We do not have enough information about the originals, but later
scribes sometimes would include in their manuscript a complaint, such
as the following:

He who does not know how to write supposes it to be no labor; but
though only three fingers write, the whole body labors.

A traditional formula reads:

Writing bows one’s back, thrusts the ribs into one’s stomach, and
fosters a general debility of the body.

Still another scribe wrote:

As travelers rejoice to see their home country, so also is the end of
a book to those who toil [in writing].

An Armenian copyist says in a Gospel that "a heavy snow storm was
raging and that the scribe’s ink froze, his hand became numb, and the
pen fell from his fingers!"

Finally, manuscripts may end with gratitude:

"The end of the book; thanks be to God!" (Source: Metzger and Ehrman,
p. 29)

5. Did scribes use contractions?

Yes, but it is unknown whether the originals had contractions or
abbreviations. A short time after the originals, scribes used them
mostly for sacred names (nomina sacra). Here are some examples, in
transliterated English.

God = Theos → THS (Th in Greek is one letter)

Christ = Christos → CHS or CHR (Ch or Kh in Greek is one letter
and is spoken as a hard c, as in cool)

Lord = Kurios → KS

Spirit = Pneuma → PNA

Jesus = Iēsous → IS or IĒ

After the scribe abbreviated or contracted the sacred names, he would
draw a bar or line over the letters to signal a contraction.

One textual critic says of the sacred names: "Scribes wrote these
names with special regard, and readers (lectors) uttered these names
with special attention in church meetings as they read the Scriptures
aloud" (Comfort, Encountering, p. 253)

See real-life abbreviations in a papyrus of a part of Paul’s
epistles.

6. What does "P" stand for (usually in Gothic or Old English font
style), and what about the raised number, as in P75?

This is used only by modern scholars.

The "P" stands for papyrus, and the number indicates the individual
papyrus that has been catalogued. Metzger and Ehrman say that a total
of 116 papyri have been examined and catalogued (p. 48). All of the
papyri, among many other manuscripts, have been used to produce the
most highly accurate and reliable New Testament possible.

7. What do recto and verso mean?

In being made (see this slide show on how), the reed plant produced
horizontal and vertical lines, as the strips of the plant were laid
horizontally and vertically, in two layers. Recto stands for the
"front" of the papyrus sheet or page, with the horizontal lines. The
verso is the "back" side of the same sheet or page, and its lines
were vertical, so it was more difficult to write on that side.

8. The name Oxyrhynchus appears often. What does it mean?

It is a city in Egypt, on the west side of the Nile, about 125 miles
south of Cairo. In 1897, Bernard Grenfell and Arthur Hunt, two
archaeologists, traveled to this city because they knew that a
Christian community had flourished in the early centuries of
Christianity. Egypt was naturally dry, so papyrus manuscripts could
survive there, buried. They searched in cemeteries, tombs, churches,
and monasteries, but they found a trash or rubbish heap, and
carefully excavated it. They struck "papyrus gold," so to speak.
Philip W. Comfort, another prominent textual critic, describes the
value of trash heaps, specifically for Grenfell and Hunt and the New
Testament:

Manuscripts found in rubbish heaps are not "rubbish" per se or
defective copies. When a manuscript became old and worn, it was
customary to replace it with a fresh copy and discard the old one.
Since the Egyptians are known to have disposed of such copies by
putting them in rubbish heaps, excavators looking for ancient
Egyptian papyri would search for ancient rubbish heaps in deserted
sites on ground higher than the Nile River. Grenfell and Hunt’s
choice of ancient rubbish heap at Oxyrhynchus was fortuitous, for it
yielded that largest cache of papyri ever discovered. (Comfort, In
Quest, p. 62)

Then Comfort tells us how long the excavations lasted.

Grenfell and Hunt excavated at Oxyrhynchus until 1907; the Italian
exploration society (under G. Vitelli) continued the work there
during the years 1910-14 and 1927-34 (Comfort, In Quest, p. 64).

Clearly the First World War (1914-1918) stopped the second dig, the
first for the Italians.

The Oxyrhynchus papyri are different from the ones discovered at Nag
Hammadi.

See this Website for more information on Oxyrhynchus papyri. Or do a
Google search with "Oxyrhynchus."

9. How many manuscripts were found at Oxyrhynchus?

High-quality classical works were found, such as those of Homer and
Pindar. But what about the New Testament?

In total, forty-six papyrus manuscripts containing portions of the
New Testament have been discovered at Oxyrhynchus. (Comfort,
Encountering, p. 64)

Oxyrhynchus is sometimes abbreviated as Oxy. or Ox.

10. Who was Chester Beatty, and why is his name mentioned so often in
the context of papyri?

Chester Beatty was an American living in Britain. He purchased papyri
of the Bible, both Old and New Testaments, found in Egypt in the
early 1930s. The precise location of the discovery is a mystery
because the Egyptian diggers and dealers would not reveal it. This
find must not be confused with the Oxyrhynchus papyri or Nag Hammadi
papyri. The University of Michigan also purchased some leaves of this
sensational discovery.

11. What manuscripts were discovered and then placed in his
collection?

Eight manuscripts of portions of the Greek Old Testament were found
in codices (plural of codex), which is the forerunner of our book.
All dates, in AD, refer to the time that the manuscripts were copied,
not originally written.

Two manuscripts of Genesis (one from the third century, another from
the fourth)
One of Numbers and Deuteronomy (second century)
One of Ezekiel and Esther (third century)
One of Isaiah (third century)
One of Jeremiah (late second century)
One of Daniel (third century)
One of Ecclesiastes (fourth century)
Greek New Testament

One codex of the four Gospels and Acts, P45 (late second or early
third century)
One Codex of the Pauline Epistles, P46, (late first or early second
century, or early third); Pauline is the adjective form of Paul, who
was a major apostle.
One Codex of Revelation, P47, the last Book in the New Testament
(third century)
This collection is housed in Dublin, Ireland, as the Chester Beatty
Library.

12. Who was Martin Bodmer, and why is his name mentioned so often in
the context of papyri?

He was a Swiss bibliophile and humanist who founded the Bodmer
Library of World Literature, at Cologny, a suburb of Geneva (Metzger
and Ehrman, p. 56).

He purchased papyri in 1952, discovered in Jabal Abu Manna, north of
the Dishna plain, in Egypt. They are different from the Oxyrhynchus
and Nag Hammadi papyri.

13. What manuscripts were discovered, now in the Bodmer collection?

All dates, in AD, refer to the century that the manuscripts were
copied, not originally written.

One containing most of the Gospel of John, P66, (ca. 150-200)
One having all of 1 and 2 Peter and Jude, P72 (third century)
One having the Gospel of Matthew, P73 (seventh century)
One having the Book of Acts and the general epistles, P74, e.g.
James, Jude, and other non-Pauline epistles (seventh century)
One having the Gospels of Luke and John, P75, (ca. 175-225)
14. What other discoveries of manuscripts are there?

The most famous discovery was done by Constantin von Tischendorf, a
German who traveled to Egypt and then to the Sinai Peninsula in 1843,
at the foot of Mt. Sinai, St. Catherine’s Monastery. He describes his
discovery. Apparently, some parchments were thrown in the fire, until
he rescued the remaining ones.

It was at the foot of Mount Sinai, in the Convent of St. Catherine,
that I discovered the pearl of all my researches. In visiting the
library of the monastery, in the month of May, 1844, I perceived in
the middle of the great hall a large and wide basket full of old
parchments; and the librarian, who was a man of information, told me
that two heaps of papers like these, mouldered by time, had been
already committed to the flames. What was my surprise to find amid
this heap of papers a considerable number of sheets of a copy of the
Old Testament in Greek, which seemed to me to be one of the most
ancient that I had ever seen. The authorities of the convent allowed
me to possess myself of a third of these parchments, or about
forty-three sheets, all the more readily as they were destined for
the fire. But I could not get them to yield up possession of the
remainder. The too lively satisfaction which I had displayed had
aroused their suspicions as to the value of this manuscript. I
transcribed a page of the text of Isaiah and Jeremiah, and enjoined
on the monks to take religious care of all such remains which might
fall in their way.

Then in 1853, Tischendorf returned to St. Catherine’s Monastery for
more manuscripts. He concealed his joy, so as not arouse the
suspicions of the steward of the monastery, who jealously guarded his
ancient manuscripts.

And so saying, he [the Steward] took down from the corner of the room
a bulky kind of volume, wrapped up in a red cloth, and laid it before
me. I unrolled the cover, and discovered, to my great surprise, not
only those very fragments which, fifteen years before, I had taken
out of the basket, but also other parts of the Old Testament, the New
Testament complete, and, in addition, the Epistle of Barnabas and a
part of the Pastor of Hermas. Full of joy, which this time I had the
self-command to conceal from the steward and the rest of the
community, I asked, as if in a careless way, for permission to take
the manuscript into my sleeping chamber to look over it more at
leisure. There by myself I could give way to the transport of joy
which I [felt]. I knew that I held in my hand the most precious
Biblical treasure in existence-a document whose age and importance
exceeded that of all the manuscripts which I had ever examined during
twenty years’ study of the subject. I cannot now, I confess, recall
all the emotions which I felt in that exciting moment with such a
diamond in my possession . . .

(Source)

He named the manuscript he discovered Codex Sinaiticus (or Aleph, the
first letter in the Hebrew alphabet). See this quick write-up.

15. How are manuscripts classified?

Manuscript (singular) is abbreviated as MS and manuscripts (plural)
as MSS. NT stands for New Testament. There are five main
classifications, plus quotations from the church fathers.

I. Papyri

Papyrus comes from a reed plant (see this slide show on how it is
made). Scribes used majuscules and minuscules handwriting on this
material. It is quite possible that the autograph (original)
manuscripts of the New Testament were written on it, or perhaps on
parchment, or both, but scholarship is unclear on this point. But
papyrus was not very durable, so we do not have the originals now.

This Webpage on papyri, written by Dr. Peter M. Head, a prominent
textual critic, lists the papyri and provides further links.

Here is a complete list of papyri. The page also has links to images.

II. Uncials

This word performs a double duty. It means a handwriting style, but
it "ordinarily designates [manuscripts] on parchment" (Greenlee, p.
27). It dominates from the fourth through the tenth centuries.

Generally speaking, the uncial MSS, especially the earlier ones, are
the most dependable group of witnesses to the NT text. (Greenlee p.
28)

This page on uncials, also written up by Dr. Head, lists the major
uncials, and has further links.

This page provides links to uncials on parchments, including links to
photos.

Here is a study of Codex B (03) or Codex Vaticanus.

This page has facsimile photos of Codex Alexandrinus (02).

III. Minuscules

"By far the largest group of Greek NT MSS [is] those written in
minuscule handwriting, thus dating from the ninth century and later.
Most are on parchment" . . . (Greenlee, p. 33)

Generally, this group of witnesses may not be as reliable as the
earlier ones, but this is not always true. A later manuscript may
have a more reliable exemplar (now unknown) than an earlier
manuscript.

Dr. Head also provides a list of the major minuscules.

IV. Lectionaries

This word comes from the Latin for reading.

These are MSS in which the Scriptures are written, not in ordinary
sequence, but in sections arranged in units for reading in church
services. In very ancient times certain scripture passages were
designated as the reading for each day of the year and for special
services and days. The lectionary MSS were then written to follow the
sequence of readings, with the day and the week generally indicated
at the beginning of each lection. (Greenlee, p. 35)

Finally, Dr. Head lists the major lectionaries.

V. Versions

Christianity is a missionary religion, so it needed to translate the
NT in other languages from the original Greek. Here are some common
ones, as Christianity spread out:

Latin (Itala), Syriac, Coptic (Egyptian), Armenian, Georgian,
Ethiopic, Gothic, Arabic, Persian, Slavonic, Frankish, Gothic, and
Anglo-Saxon.

These versions are helpful in NT textual criticism because they can
decide key words and phrases and clauses, provided they are easy to
translate back into Greek. A Syriac version, for example, some of
which are earlier than Greek MSS, help textual critics decide on
variants.

VI. Quotations from the church fathers

The quotations of the NT in the writings of the church fathers have
been studied in detail, but not all of them. Though this fertile area
is undergoing more study, Metzger and Ehrman estimate that the
quotations are extensive (though this quotation is found in the third
edition before Ehrman joined Metzger for the fourth edition):

Indeed, so extensive are these citations that if all other sources
for our knowledge of the text of the New Testament were destroyed,
they would be sufficient alone for the reconstruction of practically
the entire New Testament. (p. 126)

This is significant in attesting to the reliability of the NT that we
have in our possession. Also, the number of citations exceed a
million. Metzger is right to say that the citations are "so
extensive."

16. What are the totals for these classes of manuscripts?

The official listing (as of 2006) of the several important categories
of Greek New Testament manuscripts can be summarized as follows:

Papyri…118

Majuscule MSS…317

Miniscule MSS…2877

Lectionary MSS…2433

Total…5745

Source Papyri

The summary gives us a clear idea of how many manuscripts scholars
have to sort through.

Hat tip: Komoszewski, Sawyer, and Wallace p. 77.

17. Were manuscripts ever destroyed during the persecutions of early
Christians?

The totals gathered by Metzger (and Ehrman), cited in the previous
Question, seem like a lot (and they are), but we could have benefited
from many more manuscripts. Diocletian, a Roman Emperor who reigned
from AD 284 to 305, ordered the destruction of church buildings and
the Christian Scriptures in 303-304, but the persecution occurred
before and continued after that date.

Kurt Aland and Barbara Aland, two prominent leaders in textual
criticism of any generation, explain the devastation this decree
wreaked on the NT MSS.

The persecution of Diocletian left a deep scar not only in church
history but also in the history of the New Testament text.
Innumerable manuscripts were destroyed during the persecution and had
to be replaced. Even more were needed to supply the flood of new
churches which sprang up in the Age of Constantine [an Emperor who
reigned immediately after Diocletian]. (Aland and Aland, p. 70)

This was a time of crisis. A "snitch" society developed.
Non-Christians exposed the Christians and the whereabouts of their
Scriptures. Some devout believers paid with their lives, protecting
God’s Word. They deserve our admiration. We should honor them by
honoring God’s Word in our lives. Honoring means reading and studying
it.

18. All of the discoveries and recovery process seem so complicated.
Why wouldn’t God protect his Word?

I have asked and answered this question in the other parts in this
series. Christians believe that God works through history and humans.
C. S. Lewis’ preliminary study on miracles is relevant. Once the
inspired original manuscripts get assimilated into history, they
undergo the effects of time:

The moment [the newcomer, e.g. miracle] enters [Nature’s] realm, it
obeys her laws. Miraculous wine will intoxicate, miraculous
conception will lead to pregnancy, inspired books will suffer all the
ordinary processes of textual corruption, miraculous bread will be
digested. (Miracles: A Preliminary Study, p. 81)

However, these errors have been purged out (and continue to be), with
very few remainders. Why can’t devout believers today conclude that
God is in fact working through humans in the purging process? Isn’t
this a kind of divine protection that is worked out over time and
history?

19. So what’s the bottom line on all of this? Should I lose my
confidence in the NT?

I have also asked and answered this question in the other three
articles in this four-part series on New Testament manuscripts, but
it is repeated here since it is critical both for seekers and the
devout. The persecution of the church may have devastated the number
of manuscripts, but enough have survived to help us put together the
original, as much as this can be done, by cross-checking and
comparing the thousands we have.

Sir Frederick Kenyon (d. 1952), a premier NT textual critic of the
first half of the twentieth century, is optimistic about the general
result of all of the hard work done by many scholars.

It is reassuring at the end to find that the general result of all
these discoveries and all this study is to strengthen the proof of
the authenticity of the Scriptures, and our conviction that we have
in our hands, in substantial integrity, the veritable Word of God
(qtd. in Wegner, p. 25).

Kenyon worked in an earlier generation, and other MSS have been found
since his time. However, nothing has cropped up that challenges in a
substantive way the meaning and content of the NT. "Still there are
relatively few significant variants in the Bible, and among these
variants there is very little difference in meaning and content"
(Wegner, p. 25).

Christians should have gratitude, if I may intrude with my own
opinion, for scholars putting in so much time and energy and for
clarifying the NT. Somebody has to do this thankless yeoman’s work,
done often behind the scenes, with no glamour.

Therefore, far from losing one’s confidence, it should grow.

References

Aland, Kurt and Barbara Aland. The Text of the New Testament: An
Introduction to the Critical Editions and to the Theory and Practice
of Modern Textual Criticism. 2nd ed. Trans. Erroll F. Rhodes.
Eerdmans, 1989.

Comfort, Philip Wesley. The Quest for the Original Text of the New
Testament. Wipf and Stock (originally at Baker), 1992.

—. Encountering the Manuscripts: An Introduction to New Testament
Paleography and Textual Criticism. Broadman and Holman, 2005.

Elliott, Keith and Ian Moir. Manuscripts and the Text of the New
Testament: An Introduction for English Readers. T & T Clark, 1995.

Finegan, Jack. Encountering New Testament Manuscripts: A Working
Introduction to Textual Criticism. Eerdmans, 1974.

Greenlee, J. Harold. Introduction to New Testament Textual Criticism.
Rev. ed. Hendrickson, 1995.

Komoszewski, J. Ed, M. James Sawyer and Daniel B. Wallace.
Reinventing Jesus: How Contemporary Skeptics Miss the Real Jesus and
Mislead Popular Culture. Kregel, 2006. See Chapters 4-8.

Metzger, Bruce M. and Bart D. Ehrman. The Text of the New Testament:
Its Transmission, Corruption, and Restoration. 4th ed. Oxford UP,
2005.

Roberts, Colin H. Manuscript, Society and Belief in Early Christian
Egypt. Published for the British Academy by the Oxford UP, 1979.

— and T. C. Skeat, The Birth of the Codex, published for the
British Academy by the Oxford UP, 1983.

Wegner, Paul D. A Student’s Guide to Textual Criticism of the Bible:
Its History, Methods, and Results. InterVarsity, 2006.

testament_manuscripts_disc.html

http://www.americanthinker.com/2007/02/new_

ANKARA: Armenian historian comes in spite of Diaspora

Sabah, Turkey
Feb 24 2007

Armenian historian comes in spite of Diaspora

Diaspora responded to the suggestion of the Armenian historian
Sarafyan with a threat. Halaçoðlu stated that he will invite Sarafyan
to Turkey.

The extreme nationalist Armenians reacted harshly to the suggestion
of Sarafyan to conduct a collaborative research in Harput. Sarafyan
stated that he received criticisms such as "you are not a real
Armenian, Turks will foul you, you are making a mistake." Sarafyan
stated that he will not quit in spite of the criticisms.

The director of Gomidas institute, Ara Sarafyan said that he will
meet with Professor Halaçoðlu although the extreme nationalist
Armenians said: "you are not a real Armenian, Turks will foul you".

The extreme nationalist Armenians reacted harshly to the suggestion
of Sarafyan to conduct a collaborative research with the chairman of
the Turkish Historical Society, Professor Yusuf Halaçoðlu in Harput
about the events regarding Armenians. Sarafyan stated that he
received criticisms such as "you are not a real Armenian, Turks will
foul you, and you are making a mistake." Sarafyan stated that he will
not quit in spite of the criticisms.

ANKARA: Passage of Armenian resolution would hurt projects

Today’s Zaman, Turkey
Feb 24 2007

`Passage of Armenian resolution would hurt projects worth billions’

A Turkish studies expert based in Washington has said if it was
passed in the House, the Armenian genocide resolution would sever the
bilateral ties between Washington and Ankara.
In an article at Washington Times titled "Armenian genocide folly,"
Soner Çaðaptay, director of the Turkish research program at The
Washington Institute for Near East Policy, wrote:
"At this critical juncture of spiraling instability in Iraq and a
resurgent Taliban in Afghanistan, the United States cannot afford to
lose Turkey, a major, if underappreciated, partner for U.S.
operations in Iraq and Afghanistan alike."
Recalling that America’s favorability rating in Turkish opinion polls
is at an all-time low of 7 percent, Çaðaptay noted, "By passing the
resolution, the Congress would be passing judgment on Turkish
history, which the Turks would see as the ultimate insult."
A majority of Turks say that the 1915 deportation of Armenians from
Anatolia to Syria in the Ottoman Empire does not constitute genocide,
yet the House resolution will declares the events of 1915 to be
considered a genocide.
Çaðaptay argues that the House resolution would cause a massive
public outpouring of Turkish resentment against the United States and
this would inevitably cripple US-Turkish military cooperation.
"Three-quarters of all air cargo bound for Iraq transits through
Ýncirlik [air base in southern Turkey], and Turkey provides blanket
clearance for military over flights supporting Operation Iraqi
Freedom and Operation Enduring Freedom in Afghanistan. With its
proximity to Iraq, Ýncirlik also helps defray the cost of American
operations there. Six U.S. C-17 cargo aircraft based at Incirlik do
the job of nine or 10 military aircraft based in Germany, saving the
United States $160 million per year."
According to Çaðaptay, the passage of the Armenian resolution would
also hurt US businesses and consumers since Ankara is engaged in
several major defense cooperation projects with the United States,
including the Joint Strike Fighter in which Turkey has $175 million
invested and an expected purchase of 100 jets, and the upgrading of
200-plus Turkish F-16 fighters at a cost of $1.6 billion.
"The Armenian resolution would jeopardize such cooperative projects,
as well as kill a number of pending Turkish defense purchases from
the United States, including the Patriot PAC III Air Defense System
for $1.3 billion, 52 Sikorsky Black Hawks helicopters at a value of
$800 million, 10 heavy-lift Boeing and Sikorsky helicopters worth
$500 million and between 30 and 50 Boeing Apache or Bell Cobra
helicopters worth between $1.5 and $2 billion," Çaðaptay noted.

BAKU: Safarov’s father: I was sure of the result of legal procedure

Today, Azerbaijan
Feb 24 2007

Ramil Safarov’s father: "I was sure of the result of legal procedure"

24 February 2007 [07:15] – Today.Az

Coordination Council on Defense of Azerbaijani Army officer Ramil
Safarov’s Rights held a meeting.

The member of the council Azay Guliyev said that it was expected that
Appeals Court will keep the decision of the court of first instance
on life sentence to Ramil Safarov in force.

But we hoped that the decision will be amended after submitting
definite arguments to the Appeals Court. But the court was bias
again. The court did not take into account medical examiners’
judgment, the lawyers’ solicitations were not allowed, he said.

Guliyev said that the Coordination Council will file an appeal to
Hungarian Supreme Court against the decision of Budapest Appeals
Court.

Ramil Safarov’s father Sahib Safarov said that he expected this
decision.

We always raise a clamor before making something, and Armenians take
advantage of these arguments. Hungarian journalists were brought to
Azerbaijan, but they did not meet with Ramil Safarov’s family. As
Azerbaijan does not approach the case seriously the result was
expected. Defense Ministry have not called the lawyers or concerned
itself with the problem. They only offered financial aid to the
lawyers a day before they left for Budapest, he said, APA reports.

URL:

http://www.today.az/news/society/36973.html