Is ban on export of dairy products from Armenia to Russian Federation a political decision?

  • Gayane Sargsyan
  • Yerevan

Export of dairy products to Russia

For more than a month there has been a ban on the export of dairy products from Armenia to Russia. In Russia, this decision was justified by “the use of Iranian raw materials in Armenian products, the import of which into the Russian Federation is prohibited.”

Although Rosselkhoznadzor checks revealed this problem only in the products of two Armenian producers, the import of dairy products of all exporters is prohibited, and for an indefinite period.


  • Stagnant economic ties in the South Caucasus: Three stories
  • “Armenian economy shows resilience” – PM Nikol Pashinyan
  • Unintended economic hit: how Armenia will suffer because of war in Ukraine

The Igit company does not use Iranian raw materials in its production, but as a result of the ban, it lost the opportunity to export to the Russian Federation. According to the manager of the company Aram Kroyan, mainly cheese was exported to Russia, 30-40 tons per month.

Due to the ban, which has lasted more than a month, the company has had to look for additional premises to store finished products. In addition, the company has reduced the volume of purchases of dairy products from farmers.

The company’s only hope is that the ban will be lifted in the near future and it will be possible to export products to Russia again.

“If the export ban is not lifted as soon as possible, the farmers will suffer first of all. The fact is that with the beginning of the spring season the volume of milk produced has increased and companies are forced to reduce the volume of purchases. If the ban drags on, manufacturing companies will have to look for new sales markets, as well as think about layoffs, and possibly closing production facilities,” Kroyan says.

The problem is being discussed at the state level and negotiations are underway between the Food Safety Inspectorate of Armenia and Rosselkhoznadzor. After a bilateral meeting on April 17, the Armenian side said: “Both sides have demonstrated a constructive approach and agreed to resolve the issue in stages.”

A Russian statement said: “Flaws in the supervision system have allowed Armenian companies to export products made from raw materials from Iranian enterprises that are not allowed to trade with Russia. As a result, in 2022 Armenia increased oil supplies by ten times. Such schemes disrupt the competitive environment not only in the Russian market, but also introduce an imbalance in the economic activity of the EAEU.”

The Eurasian Economic Union operates under the leadership of Russia and includes Armenia, Belarus, Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan. The organization provides its members with freedom of movement of labor, goods, services and capital. Armenia joined the EAEU in 2015.

Russian IT specialists are convinced that their relocation can contribute to real economic growth. Stories of Russians who moved their business to Yerevan

The difference in the content of these two messages reinforced the opinion of experts that it was not about economic or food security, but about politics.

“As a rule, the parties agree in advance with each other that the transmitted messages have the same content. Various statements testify to a serious conflict in relations between the Republic of Armenia and the Russian Federation,” economist Nairi Sargsyan says.

In her opinion, the ban is due to tense relations between Armenia and Russia due to the change in Armenia’s foreign policy vector towards the West:

“States use different tools to restore, correct or maintain relations. We can consider the ban as one of such tools.

Russia, having sufficient stocks of dairy products, allows imports solely for the purpose of strengthening political and other influence on Armenia. In order to maintain superiority in the countries of its sphere of influence, including Armenia, the Russian Federation distributes some kind of carrot. In this case, the carrot is a permit for the export of dairy products from Armenia to Russia.”

Armenia to use the Black Sea as an alternative to the Upper Lars checkpoint, as the only land road connecting Armenia with Russia is often closed due to poor weather conditions or landslides

Food law specialist David Pipoyan does not find the decision of Rosselkhoznadzor to ban the export of Armenian dairy products surprising. He considers the problem from a professional point of view and taking into account the many problems in the manufacturing sector:

“If we look at the trends in the development of the sphere, we will notice a regression in almost all aspects of food safety. Prior to the Rosselkhoznadzor, the Investigative Journalists Club of Armenia carried out sectoral expertise of Armenian dairy products. The Food Safety Inspectorate has followed the trail of violations identified by journalists and found various violations in many manufacturers. But no conclusions were made after these alarming signals, let alone action.”

Pipoyan emphasizes that the supervision of food production needs radical changes, but “there is no political will to solve the problems of the sphere.”

Compared to recent years, the volume of exports, in particular of butter, has increased significantly. According to the Ministry of Economy, if in 2021 only 170 tons were exported to Russia, and in 2022 more than 3,000.

“I think in Russia they noticed that there was a sharp change in volumes, which is an important indicator for assessing risks. They realized that the volume of production in Armenia could not increase so dramatically. For this reason, they had doubts about the use of raw materials imported from third countries. Therefore, we decided to check whether proper control is carried out. The message of the Rosselkhoznadzor contains a clear message about the lack of confidence of the Russian Federation in the work of the inspection body of Armenia.”

“Armenia has a great potential for success in the field of information technology” – Orion technology summit in Armenia gathers local unicorns

Pipoyan does not exclude a political background to Russia’s decision.

“There may be a political context, but if your production does not meet the quality criteria, no one is obliged to turn a blind eye to this,.”

Economist Narek Sargsyan believes that Russia is not announcing a specific date for lifting the ban, as it awaits an answer to the question of whether Armenia remains in its sphere of influence. The decision of the Russian Federation, in his opinion, is directly related to which foreign policy vector Armenia will choose:

“If Russia hears what it wants, the ban will be lifted very soon. And if not, then I think other areas may also be subject to sanctions, in particular the manufacturing industry.”

Economy Minister Vahan Kerobyan maintains any such activity was an isolated incident

According to experts, if the ban drags on for three to six months, Armenian producers will face serious problems.

“For the domestic market, the number of active dairy producers is actually too large. They didn’t open to satisfy the local market. And since Armenia has not diversified export markets, including for dairy products, we face a very serious danger. It is possible that in the long term it will be possible to organize itself, review production volumes, and diversify markets. But in the short term, I think the country will have serious problems,” economist Narek Sargsyan says.

Food law specialist David Pipoyan hopes that the problem will be resolved in the near future.

Regardless of the development of events, experts consider it abnormal that 45 percent of exports from Armenia go to Russia. They argue that it is necessary to think about the diversification of markets, otherwise Armenia will continue to depend on the Russian Federation.

“You can never be completely dependent on any country, either in terms of exports or imports. But we are well aware that there are many obstacles to entering other markets, starting with the prices of local products. It is very important for Armenia to enter the market with high purchasing power,” Pipoyan says.

In any case, Pipoyan considers compliance with food safety standards to be paramount:

“First of all, it is necessary to respect the rights of citizens and consumers of our country, as well as the countries where we export our products, and not to ignore safety issues.”

In response to a request from JAMnews, the Food Safety Inspectorate of Armenia reported that inspections are currently underway at nine enterprises producing dairy products. In the near future, the results will be sent to Rosselkhoznadzor to review the export permit.

Tatoyan: Azerbaijan will not limit itself to Artsakh and has no intention of peace regardless of the Artsakh issue

NEWS.am
Armenia –

Azerbaijan will not limit itself to Artsakh and has no intention of peace regardless of the Artsakh issue.  The former Ombudsman of Armenia, President of the Tatoyan Foundation Arman Tatoyan wrote about this on his Facebook page.

“Azerbaijan will not limit itself to Artsakh and has no intention of peace regardless of the Artsakh issue.

The goal of the Azerbaijani government is to numb our vigilance and advance aggression under the veil of false peace, and the destruction of Armenian identity.

Now, one of the fundamental goals of their state policy is to deepen the division and tension in our society, to make us all hostile to the Armenian Diaspora.

We would like to thank international lawyers Garo Ghazarian and Karnig Kerkonian for their invaluable support in the preparation and analysis of evidence.

All of this is proven with uncontroverted evidence”, – he wrote. 

CSUN’s Armenian organizations educate students about culture and history

DAILY SUNDIAL
CSUN, California

Gallery|6 Photos
Brandon Balayan, Reporter

Throughout the last week of April, CSUN celebrated Armenian Heritage Week – an initiative by various Armenian organizations on campus to commemorate the Armenian genocide.

Campus organizations included the fraternity Alpha Epsilon Omega, the sorority Alpha Gamma Alpha, the Hidden Road Initiative and the Armenian Students Association.

The week began with the “Stain of Denial,” a protest against the denial of the Armenian genocide, and a vigil in remembrance of those whose lives were lost.

On April 26, an Armenian barbecue, or khorovats, was held at Matador Square with a dance performance by Patille Dance Studio.

The last event of the week included a tribute to Artsakh Awareness Day with a screening of the Armenian film “Neutral Zone” at the University Student Union.

Gallery|5 Photos

Brandon Balayan
Members of the CSUN Armenian Students Association hold flags and signs during their “Stain of Denial” protest on April 25, 2023. The protest, that commemorated the Armenian genocide of 1915, was held in front of the CSUN University Library in Northridge, Calif.

https://sundial.csun.edu/174492/news/csuns-armenian-organizations-educate-students-about-culture-and-history/

Charles Michel says meeting with Armenian and Azerbaijani leaders brings clear progress in normalising relations

 

On 14 May, European Council President Charles Michel hosted Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev and Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan for a fifth meeting in Brussels.

The leaders focused on progress on the path towards Armenia-Azerbaijan normalisation, and shared a common willingness for a South Caucasus at peace.

On border issues, the sides reviewed progress and the next steps regarding the delimitation of the border. They agreed on the resumption of the bilateral meetings on border issues, confirming their unequivocal commitment to the 1991 Almaty Declaration and the respective territorial integrity of Armenia (29,800 km2) and Azerbaijan (86,600 km2). The ultimate delimitation of the border will be agreed through negotiations.

According to Charles Michel, the sides made “clear progress” in their discussions aimed at unblocking transport and economic links in the region. “Positions on this topic have now come very close to each other in particular on the reopening of the railway connections to and via Nakhchivan,” explained Michel in his press remarks after the meeting. The respective teams were tasked with finalising an agreement in principle on the conditions for opening the railway connection and the necessary construction work, together with a concrete timetable.

On humanitarian issues, the sides agreed at the meeting that further detainees would be released in the coming weeks. Charles Michel also stressed the need to safeguard the mutual understanding that soldiers who have simply got lost and crossed to the other side would continue to be released through a speedy procedure. 

Michel also called on Azerbaijan to guarantee the rights and security of Armenians living in the former Nagorno Karabakh Autonomous Oblast, in close cooperation with the international community.

Leaders will meet again in the beginning of June on the margins of the 2nd European Political Community Summit (EPC) in Chișinău and in July in Brussels. Michel also invited the leaders for another such meeting on the margins of the third EPC summit in Granada in October.

Find out more

Press release

https://euneighbourseast.eu/news/latest-news/charles-michel-says-meeting-with-armenian-and-azerbaijani-leaders-brings-clear-progress-in-normalising-relations/

Armenia returns to negotiating table after refusing talks with Azerbaijan in December

 eureporter 


The President of Azerbaijan and the Prime Minister of Armenia have held talks in Brussels facilitated by the President of the European Council Charles Michel. This positive development saw progress on border and transportation issues after earlier talks with President Michel stalled when Armenia refused to participate in a meeting last December, writes Political Editor Nick Powell.

Charles Michel’s efforts to help Azerbaijan and Armenia agree to a lasting peace were put on hold at the end of last year when Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan refused to attend a further meeting in Brussels with Azerbaijan’s President Ilham Aliyev. But patience by the European Union -and by Azerbaijan- has been rewarded with a meeting that went ahead on 14 March.

It seems that some progress was made in Brussels in the dispute between the two countries. It is primarily over the Karabakh region, which lies within Azerbaijan’s internationally recognised boundaries but has brought devastation to a much larger area during two major wars, causing widespread human misery and economic disruption. After the meeting, the Azerbaijan Ministry of Defence reported that its military positions in the Kalbajar region had come under mortar fire from Armenia’s armed forces.

Nevertheless, the leaders confirmed that they would meet again next month, together with President Macron of France and Chancellor Scholz of Germany, during the European Political Community summit in Chisinau, Moldova. The two sides didn’t offer a detailed readout of their talks in Brussels but President Michel provided some commentary.

“Our exchanges were frank, open and results-oriented”, he said. “Following the recent positive talks in the United States on the peace treaty, the momentum should be maintained to take decisive steps towards the signing of a comprehensive peace agreement between Armenia and Azerbaijan”.

“On border issues, we reviewed progress and the next steps regarding the delimitation of the border”, he added. Charles Michel also reported good progress on unblocking transport and economic links “in particular on the reopening of the railway connections to and from Nakhchivan”.

In an interview with EU Reporter last month, Elchin Amirbayov, who is Assistant to the First Vice-President of Azerbaijan, spoke of his expectation that President Michel would soon resume his role as a facilitator of peace talks. Mr Amirbayov saw the reconstruction of the railway through Armenia linking Azerbaijan with its exclave of Nakhchivan as an important confidence-building measure.

It could form part of the Middle Corridor between Asia and Europe, he argued, enabling Armenia to benefit from this increasingly important trade route once a sustainable peace reopened its borders with both Azerbaijan and Türkiye. He said his country was offering Armenia a ‘win-win’ strategy, not a victor’s peace.

“With it, Armenia will benefit even more because it will be open to investment, for example, from the countries around it”, explained Mr Amirbayov. “It would be considered as a relatively stable place which is not actually risking any new confrontation with its neighbours”.

The Azerbaijan Ministry of Foreign Affairs later confirmed that the Brussels talks had included the delimitation of borders and the restoration of communications. It stressed the extreme importance of the acceptance by Armenia of the internationally recognised territorial integrity of Azerbaijan.

It said that the meeting also provided an opportunity to discuss humanitarian issues, especially included the importance of clarifying the fate of missing persons and of speeding up the process of clearing minefields. Azerbaijan remained ready to continue dialogue and interaction with international partners to achieve normal relations with Armenia.

https://www.eureporter.co/world/azerbaijan-world/2023/05/14/armenia-returns-to-negotiating-table-after-refusing-talks-with-azerbaijan-in-december/

Armenian premier, EC president discuss regional situation — Armenian government

 TASS 
Russia –
The sides also discussed the upcoming tripartite meeting of Nikol Pashinyan, Charles Michel and Azerbaijani President Ilkham Aliyev

YEREVAN, May 14. /TASS/. Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan held an informal meeting with European Council President Charles Michel in Brussels on Saturday to discuss situation in the region, the Armenian government’s press service said.

“In the course of the informal meeting, the sides exchanged opinions about the current military, political and humanitarian situation in the region,” the press service said. “Prime Minister Pashinyan touched upon the situation that emerged as a result of provocative and aggressive actions taken by the Azerbaijani armed forces against the sovereign territory of Armenia over the past days and aimed at disrupting the efforts to continue peace talks.”

“Issues related to the humanitarian crisis that emerged in Nagorno Karabakh as a result of Azerbaijan’s illegal blockade of the Lachin corridor were also discussed,” it said. “The sides have also touched upon questions related to reconciliation of Armenia and Azerbaijan.”

The sides also discussed the upcoming tripartite meeting of Pashinyan, Michel and Azerbaijani President Ilkham Aliyev, and the importance of holding a meeting with the participation of French President Emmanuel Macron and German Chancellor Olaf Scholz in Chisinau on June 1.

https://tass.com/world/1617131

Russia thinks that there is no alternative to trilateral agreements on Karabakh — Kremlin

 TASS 
Russia –
Russian presidential press secretary Dmitry Peskov pledged that relations between Moscow and Erevan rest on the basis of “advanced partnership”

MOSCOW, May 14. /TASS/. Moscow believes that the trilateral agreements are the only basis for a lasting settlement between Baku and Yerevan, Russian presidential press secretary Dmitry Peskov said on Sunday.

“Naturally, certain sensitive aspects do exist. Russia, you know, is committed to the trilateral documents that were signed two years ago. We insist that there are no alternatives to them as a basis for the settlement. And in order to reach settlement, it is necessary to follow the path of implementing the agreements that were reached by the three parties,” he said in an interview with the Moscow.Kremlin.Putin program on the Rossiya-1 television channel.

He pledged that relations between Russia and Armenia rest on the basis of “advanced partnership.” “Special relations, which have deep historical roots. We are convinced that they have a bright future,” Peskov said.

The conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan over the highland region of Nagorno-Karabakh, a disputed territory that had been part of Azerbaijan before the Soviet Union’s break-up, but primarily populated by ethnic Armenians, broke out in February 1988 after the Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Region announced its withdrawal from the Azerbaijan Soviet Socialist Republic. In 1992-1994, tensions boiled over and exploded into large-scale military action for control over the enclave and seven adjacent territories after Azerbaijan lost control of them. Talks on the Nagorno-Karabakh settlement have been ongoing since 1992 under the OSCE Minsk Group, led by its three co-chairs – Russia, France and the United States.

Renewed clashes between Azerbaijan and Armenia erupted on September 27, 2020, with intense battles raging in the disputed region of Nagorno-Karabakh. On November 9, 2020, Russian President Vladimir Putin, Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev and Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan signed a joint statement on a complete ceasefire in Nagorno-Karabakh. Under the agreement, the Azerbaijani and Armenian sides stopped at the positions that they had held and Russian peacekeepers were deployed along the engagement line in Nagorno-Karabakh and along the Lachin corridor that connects Armenia with the enclave to exercise control of the ceasefire observance. Apart from that, a number of districts came over to Baku’s control.

Later, the three leaders adopted several more joint statements on the situation in the region. Last year, Azerbaijan and Armenia began to discuss a peace treaty.

Leaders Will Discuss Anti-Armenian Flyers at Town Hall

Glendale News Press, CA
May 2 2023

The Truth And Accountability League, in partnership with the L.A. County Commission on Human Relations’ L.A. vs. Hate, will hold an in-person town hall “Stand TAAL to Hate” on Thursday, May 4, from 6-8 p.m.
This free event with RSVP is open to the public and is being held at the Glendale Central Library, 222 E. Harvard St. in Glendale.
The town hall will feature an open panel discussion with city officials, experts and community leaders, including the L.A. County Commission on Human Relations Executive Director Robin Toma, Glendale Mayor Daniel Brotman, Police Chief Manuel Cid, Chief of Staff Joseph Iniguez from the L.A. County district attorney’s office, State Commissioner Sam Kbushyan and West Hollywood Mayor Sepi Shyne.
Moderated by TAAL’s founder and chair Vic Gerami, the goal of the meeting is to bring awareness, educate the public and discuss solutions to the rising anti-Armenian racism, Armenophobia and propaganda through questions and discussion with participants.
“The recent anti-Armenian flyers posted around L.A. County — home to hundreds of thousands of Armenian Americans — remind us that we must be vigilant about racism, hate acts and propaganda. It’s unfathomable that on the heels of the Armenian Genocide anniversary, Armenians are terrorized by flyers around schools and churches that call for the extermination of Armenians,” Gerami said.
“But we mustn’t allow the hate of a few to create division, pin us against each other and get us stuck in the problem. The Truth And Accountability League is focused on the solution. We want to bring together, not only members of the Armenian community, but everyone to create awareness, educate and find answers. Our panel of leaders and experts will discuss ways to handle malice that aims to victimize, dehumanize and diminish us. Hate acts affect everyone, regardless of ethnic background, race, religion, sexual orientation or gender identity. TAAL’s town hall is a forum to empower everyone.”
The two-hour event is a part of TAAL’s comprehensive and integrated Community Outreach Campaign to address the rise in anti-Armenian hate crimes the last three years, including the anti-Armenian flyers posted in Glendale on March 31 and similar ones in Beverly Hills in January that called for the massacre of Armenians.
“The Armenian American community is such an essential part of our L.A. County community, but the amount of discrimination and negative stereotyping they’ve experienced is too often understated because it is underreported,” Toma said. “I look forward to sharing the data we collect on acts of hate in our county, and most importantly, what we are doing with L.A. vs Hate to increase reporting and eradicate hate in all our cities and neighborhoods.”
“Stand TAAL to Hate” is a town hall to benefit every group that has experienced racism, been subject to hate crimes and defamation, along with L.A.’s Armenian community, which has been a target of such acts more frequently in recent years. With its nearly 40% Armenian community, Glendale is the perfect crossroad for such an event.
“I am proud to be the mayor of Glendale, a city rich with diversity, including one of the largest Armenian diaspora communities in the world,” Brotman said. “The Jewel City has zero tolerance for racism, hate acts and defamation. I strongly condemn the recent anti-Armenian flyers and work with Glendale Police and community leaders to find the perpetrator.
“I’m honored to be a panelist for the Truth And Accountability League’s town hall. I applaud Vic Gerami and his team for launching a community outreach campaign to create awareness, educate and empower not only the residents of Glendale but all of L.A. County.”
“As district attorney of Los Angeles County, home to more than 200,000 Armenians, I’m immensely proud to represent the largest Armenian population in the United States and the greatest number outside of Armenia itself,” District Attorney George Gascón said. “Our Armenian community makes tremendous academic, artistic, altruistic and many other contributions to our region.
“These hate-filled flyers that incite violence are abhorrent and must be condemned. My office takes hate crimes very seriously, filing 86% of the hate crime cases referred to us, far above the statewide average of 54%. I commend TAAL for becoming an antidote for the poison that is racism and holding this important town hall to promote equality and protect human rights.”
Cid said he looks forward to participating in the upcoming town hall.
“Coming together to discuss hate, accountability and transparency is a powerful act of solidarity and progress. This will be a great opportunity to educate our community on the efforts law enforcement is making to address these challenges, as well as to learn, share, and work together towards a more equitable future,” Cid said.
Kbushyan, an Armenian American, believes in tackling the problem head-on. The state commissioner has been a longtime community organizer and member of Mayor Karen Bass’ transition team.
“It’s been shocking to see anti-Armenian flyers advocating genocide against Armenians in Glendale and across L.A. County,” Kbushyan said. “We must all condemn this bigotry in the strongest terms. While our families and loved ones in Armenia and Artsakh are under assault by Azerbaijan, L.A. County’s Armenian community is being terrorized by hate, defamation and propaganda.
“Vic Gerami and his team at the Truth And Accountability League have taken a proactive step in organizing a town hall in Glendale to create a safe place for the community to address this ongoing matter. I look forward to being on the panel and serving the greater L.A. community.”
The audience will have a chance to submit questions in writing before the start of the town hall. Guests must RSVP through Eventbrite: TAALTownHall.Eventbrite.com.
Elected officials who would like to attend and have special requests and members of the media interested in interviews should contact Gerami at (310) 880-8563 or [email protected].
For additional information, visit TruthAndAccountabilityLeague.org.

First published in the April 29 print issue of the Glendale News-Press.

Glendale town hall seeks solutions to rising Southern California hate incidents

PASADENA STAR NEWS
May 1 2023



A town hall to bring awareness to anti-Armenian racism and other hate is set for Thursday, May 4, in Glendale.

The event, organized by the L.A. County Commission on Human Relations and the Truth And Accountability League (TAAL), seeks to foster a discussion on solutions to rising anti-Armenian incidents, along with other forms or hate against other minority groups in the county.

Moderated by TAAL’s founder & Chair, Vic Gerami, and live-streamed on various platforms, the event’s panel of elected officials and experts include the L.A. County Commission on Human Relations Executive Robin S. Toma, Esq., Glendale Mayor Daniel Brotman, Police Chief Manuel Cid, Chief of Staff Joseph F. Iniguez from the L.A. County District Attorney’s Office, State Commissioner Sam Kbushyan, and West Hollywood Mayor Sepi Shyne.

Rep. Judy Chu, D-Pasadena, will likely be the last panelist, organizers said Monday. Other elected officials, dignitaries, community leaders, and stakeholders are confirmed to attend.

The discussion follows a recent spate of incendiary incidents that have troubled local resident and leaders.

Last month, Glendale police began investigating as a possible hate crime fliers containing anti-Armenian sentiments. They were found posted on poles near St. Mary’s Armenian Apostolic Church in the city, sparking condemnation from city officials.

The fliers reportedly contained messages denying the Armenian genocide, while claiming that Israel “fully supports” its completion. According to reports, The fliers also referenced the ongoing blockade of the Nagorno-Karabakh region by Azerbaijan, which has become a humanitarian crisis.

The region is populated primarily by ethnic Armenians but lies within Azerbaijan. Last year, Azerbaijanis claiming to be environmental activists began blocking a winding road known as the Lachin Corridor that forms the only land connection between Armenia and Nagorno-Karabakh.

The blockade threatens food supplies to Nagorno-Karabakh’s 120,000 people. Armenia argues the protests are orchestrated by Azerbaijan and says the country also has repeatedly halted supplies of gas to the region — a claim Azerbaijan also rejected.

That spate of hate coincides with the finding late last year of plastic bags containing fliers with antisemitic messages that were left on driveways and in front of homes in San Marino and Pasadena at the start of the Jewish holiday Yom Kippur.

The incidents come amid a general rise in hate crimes in L.A. County.

Reported hate crimes in the rose to their highest level in 19 years in 2021, jumping 23% from the previous year, according to a report released in December by the county Commission on Human Relations.

According to the report, there were 786 reported hate crimes in the county last year, up from 641 the prior year. The number is the highest it has been since 2002.

The number of hate crimes targeting Asian residents rose to 77, the highest number in at least 20 years, according to the report. In roughly one-fourth of the crimes targeting Asians, the victims were blamed for the COVID-19 pandemic.

The report noted that 46% of racially based hate crimes targeted Black residents, although they only make up 9% of the overall population, and religion-based hate crimes jumped by 29%, with 74% of the offenses targeting Jews. Crimes based on sexual orientation jumped by 15% year over year, with 85% of those crimes targeting gay men.

The event is from 6 to 8 p.m. Thursday, May 4, at Glendale Central Library, 222 East Harvard St., Glendale.

The Associated Press and City News Service contributed to this article.

https://www.pasadenastarnews.com/2023/05/01/glendale-town-hall-seeks-solutions-to-rising-southern-california-hate-incidents/

ALSO PRINTED IN
https://www.presstelegram.com/2023/05/01/glendale-town-hall-seeks-solutions-to-rising-southern-california-hate-incidents/

TAAL Brings Elected Officials, Experts & Community Leaders Together to Discuss Anti-Armenian Racist Flyers in Beverly Hills and Glendale

 Gagrule.net
April 20 2023

‘It’s unfathomable that on the heels of the Armenian Genocide anniversary on April 24, Armenians are terrorized by flyers around schools and churches that call for the extermination of Armenians’ — Vic Gerami, Founder, TAAL

Los Angeles — Truth And Accountability League (TAAL), in partnership with the LA County Commission on Human Relations’ LA vs. Hate, will hold an in-person Town Hall, ‘Stand Hall to Hate,’ on Thursday, May 4, from 6:00 p.m. to 8:00 p.m. This free event with RSVP is open to the public and is being held at the Glendale Central Library, 222 East Harvard Street, Glendale, 91205. It will feature an open panel discussion with city officials, experts, and community leaders, including the Executive Director, L.A. County Commission on Human Relations Robin S. Toma, Esq., Glendale Mayor Daniel Brotman, Police Chief Manuel Cid, Chief of Staff Joseph F. Iniguez from the LA County District Attorney’s Office, and State Commissioner Sam Kbushyan. 

Moderated by TAAL’s founder & Chair, Vic Gerami, the goal of the meeting is to bring awareness, educate the public, and discuss solutions to the rising anti-Armenian racism, Armenophobia, and propaganda through questions and discussion with participants.

‘The recent anti-Armenian flyers posted around LA County, home to hundreds of thousands of Armenian-Americans, remind us that we must be vigilant about racism, hate acts, and propaganda. It’s unfathomable that on the heels of the Armenian Genocide anniversary, Armenians are terrorized by flyers around schools and churches that call for the extermination of Armenians,’ said Vic Gerami, founder of TAAL.  

He added, ‘But we mustn’t allow the hate of a few to create division, pin us against each other, and get us stuck in the problem. The Truth And Accountability League is focused on the solution. We want to bring together, not only members of the Armenian community, but everyone to create awareness, educate, and find answers. Our panel of leaders and experts will discuss ways to handle malice that aims to victimize, dehumanize, and diminish us. Hate acts affect everyone, regardless of ethnic background, race, religion, sexual orientation, or gender identity. TAAL’s Town Hall is a forum to empower everyone.’ 

The two-hour event is a part of TAAL’s comprehensive and integrated Community Outreach Campaign to address the rise in anti-Armenian hate crimes the last three years, including the anti-Armenian flyers posted in Glendale on March 31 and similar ones in Beverly Hills in January and that called for the massacre of Armenians. 

‘The Armenian American community is such an essential part of our L.A. County community, but the amount of discrimination and negative stereotyping they’ve experienced is too often understated because it is underreported,’ said Robin S. Toma, Executive Director of the L.A. County Commission on Human Relations. ‘I look forward to sharing the data we collect on acts of hate in our county, and most importantly, what we are doing with LA vs Hate to increase reporting and eradicate hate in all our cities and neighborhoods.’ 

‘Stand TAAL to Hate’ is a Town Hall to benefit every group that has experienced racism, been subject to hate crimes, and defamation, along with LA’s Armenian community, which has been a target of such acts more frequently in recent years. With its nearly 40% Armenian community, Glendale is the perfect crossroad for such an event.

Glendale Mayor Daniel Brotman said, ‘I am proud to be the Mayor of Glendale, a city rich with diversity, including one of the largest Armenian diaspora communities in the world. The Jewel City has zero tolerance for racism, hate acts, and defamation. I strongly condemn the recent anti-Armenian flyers and work with Glendale Police and community leaders to find the perpetrator.’

He continued, ‘I’m honored to be a panelist for the Truth And Accountability League’s Town Hall. I applaud Vic Gerami and his team for launching a community outreach campaign to create awareness, educate, and empower not only the residents of Glendale but all of LA County.’

We’ve also witnessed the former president of the LA City Council, Nury Martinez, make a racist statement about a colleague that was caught on tape. The prevalence of the problem led the Burbank Board of Education to revise its anti-racism statement and update the board policy to stand in solidarity with Armenians. 

‘I look forward to participating in the Truth and Accountability League Town Hall in May. Coming together to discuss hate, accountability, and transparency is a powerful act of solidarity and progress. This will be a great opportunity to educate our community on the efforts law enforcement is making to address these challenges, as well as to learn, share, and work together towards a more equitable future,’ said Manuel Cid, Chief of Police, Glendale Police Department.

The audience will have a chance to submit questions in writing before the start of the town hall. RSVP is required and can be sent through Eventbrite: TAALTownHall.Eventbrite.com

‘As district attorney of Los Angeles County, home to more than 200,000 Armenians, I’m immensely proud to represent the largest Armenian population in the United States and the greatest number outside of Armenia itself,’ District Attorney George Gascón said. “Our Armenian community makes tremendous academic, artistic, altruistic, and many other contributions to our region.’ 

He continued, ‘These hate-filled flyers that incite violence are abhorrent and must be condemned. My office takes hate crimes very seriously, filing 86 percent of the hate crime cases referred to us, far above the statewide average of 54 percent. I commend TAAL for becoming an antidote for the poison that is racism and holding this important Town Hall to promote equality and protect human rights.’

CA State Commissioner Sam Kbushyan, an Armenian-American, believes in tackling the problem head-on. He’s been a long-time community organizer and member of Mayor Karen Bass’ Transition Team.

‘It’s been shocking to see anti-Armenian flyers advocating Genocide against Armenians in Glendale and across LA County. We must all condemn this bigotry in the strongest terms. While our families and loved ones in Armenia and Artsakh are under assault by Azerbaijan, LA County’s Armenian community is being terrorized by hate, defamation, and propaganda,’ said State Commissioner Sam Kbushyan.

He added, ‘Vic Gerami and his team at the Truth And Accountability League have taken a proactive step in organizing a Town Hall in Glendale to create a safe place for the community to address this ongoing matter. I look forward to being on the panel and serving the greater LA community.’

Elected officials who would like to attend and have special requests and members of the media interested in interviews should contact Vic Gerami at 310.880.8563 (or) [email protected]. For additional information, visit TAAL’s website, TruthAndAccountabilityLeague.org.

Please click here for photos and see the attached invitation. 

About TAAL

TAAL is a 501©3 non-profit advocacy organization founded in 2020 due to a significant increase in anti-Armenian racism, defamation, hate crimes, and Armenophobia. We monitor and confront bias, disinformation, propaganda, and slander of the Armenian people and culture at the media level, including social media, academics, intelligentsia, and public policy.

Our Mission

To protect human rights, promote equality, combat racism where it appears and exists, stop the defamation and threats of violence against people of Armenian ethnicity, educate the community about racism, bias, and discrimination, achieve worldwide recognition of the Armenian Genocide, and end the crime of Genocide for all people across the world.

About the LA County Commission on Human Relations

The Los Angeles County Commission on Human Relations is dedicated to promoting positive human relations in our richly diverse, multicultural county. The Commission works to develop programs that proactively address racism, homophobia, religious prejudice, linguistic bias, anti-immigrant sentiment, and other divisive attitudes that can lead to intercultural tension, hate crimes, and related violence. Partnering with law enforcement, schools, cities, community-based organizations, youth, academics, policy makers, businesses, and other leaders, the Commission brings key players together to resolve immediate intercultural conflicts and to work toward the longer term aim of eradicating bias and prejudice.

LA County’s Human Relations Commission has a legacy that dates back more than 75 years to shortly after the so-called “Zoot Suit Riots” displayed serious, long-standing human relations concerns. This incident, during which large numbers of mostly White young men in the military clashed with local young men of color for three days in the streets of LA, served as a wake-up call to county residents. In January, 1944, the County Board of Supervisors established a Committee for Interracial Progress. Two years later it was renamed the Committee for Human Relations. Following national recognition for its effective work to improve intergroup relations, the Committee became an official agency of County government in 1958 and was renamed the Los Angeles County Commission on Human Relations. The Commission is among the oldest and largest of its kind in the U.S.

Each County Supervisor appoints three Commissioners who serve multi-year terms. The 15-member Commission meets each month. A staff of professional and support personnel in the County’s Department of Workforce Development, Aging, and Community Services executes the Commission’s programmatic work. The Commission’s signature projects include the annual Hate Crime Report and the annual John Anson Ford Human Relations Awards which recognize exemplary practices and exceptional leadership in human relations work.

About Vic Gerami

Vic Gerami is an award-winning journalist and the editor + publisher of The Blunt Post. Gerami is also the host and co-producer of the national headline news + politics program, THE BLUNT POST with VIC on KPFK 90.7 FM (Pacifica Network). 

Most recently, Gerami wrote, directed, and produce the journalistic documentary feature film, ‘Motherland,’ about Azerbaijan’s, Turkey’s unprovoked genocidal attack on Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) in 2020 and the massacre of 5,000+ people, and the two nations’ ongoing campaign of hate, violence, and disinformation against the indigenous Armenians. Here is a sneak peek at the film’s 5-minute sizzle.

Today reaching national and international audiences, Gerami first built a foundation of knowledge and skills by learning the media industry during his years at Frontiers Magazine, followed by positions at LA Weekly and Voice Media Group. 

Gerami’s radio program, TBPV, covers national, regional, and local headline news, politics, and current events, and Gerami offers analysis and commentary. He also interviews a high-profile member of Congress or other high-profile public figures on each show. His recent guests include Congressman Adam Schiff, Senator Bob Menendez, Congresswoman Jackie Speier, Governor Howard Dean, Congresswoman Katie Porter, Congressman Brad Sherman, Congressman Mike Levin, Congresswoman Maxine Waters, Congresswoman Judy Chu, LA District Attorney George Gascon, among many others. You can listen to all the interviews here. 

Gerami is also a contributor to some of the most prominent publications in the nation, including Windy City Times, Bay Area Reporter, Armenian Mirror-Spectator, The Advocate, The Immigrant Magazine, GoWeHo, Destination Luxury, OUT Traveler, The Fight, and among others.

The Wall Street Journal featured Gerami as a “leading gay activist” in its landmark 2008 coverage of opposition to Proposition 8, the ballot measure that for years denied same-sex couples in California the freedom to marry. In addition to his years of volunteer work as a leading advocate for marriage equality, Gerami served as a Planning Committee member for the historic Resist March in 2017. 

In 2015, Gerami was referenced in the landmark Supreme Court civil rights case, Obergefell v. Hodges, in which the Court held in a 5–4 decision that the fundamental right to marry is guaranteed to same-sex couples by both the Due Process and the Equal Protection Clauses of the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution.

https://gagrule.net/truth-and-accountability-league-taal-brings-elected-officials-experts-and-community-leaders-together-to-discuss-anti-armenian-racist-flyers-in-beverly-hills-and-glendale/