RFE/RL Armenian Report – 05/16/2023

                                        Tuesday, 
Karabakh Leaders Slam EU
Nagorno-Karabakh - Karabakh Armenians rally in Stepanakert against the 
Azerbaijani blockade of the Lachin corridor, May 9, 2023.
Nagorno-Karabakh’s leadership accused the European Union late on Monday of 
turning a blind eye to Azerbaijan’s blockade of the Lachin corridor when it 
reacted to European Council President Charles Michel’s remarks made after the 
latest Armenian-Azerbaijani summit in Brussels.
Michel, who hosted the talks between Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian and 
Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev, made no mention of the five-month blockade 
that has caused serious shortages of food and medicine as well as an energy 
crisis in Karabakh.
Instead, he urged Baku to embark on a dialogue with “Armenians living in the 
former Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast” for the purpose of “guaranteeing the 
rights and security of this population.”
“This fact shows that the president of the European Council not only does not 
hinder but actually encourages Azerbaijan to use the sufferings of the people of 
Artsakh as a political tool,” the Karabakh foreign ministry charged in a 
statement.
It said Michel’s remarks also demonstrate that “the EU leadership continues to 
ignore the legal rights and interests of the people of Artsakh and is guided 
only by its own geopolitical and short-term interests in the region to the 
detriment of the values of democracy and human rights proclaimed by the EU.”
The statement added that only international recognition of the Karabakh 
Armenians’ right to self-determination can be “the basis for a sustainable 
settlement of the conflict.”
The Armenian government stopped championing that right a year ago. Pashinian 
subsequently declared that it recognizes Azerbaijan’s territorial integrity.
Michel implied after Sunday’s summit that Yerevan is now also ready to recognize 
Azerbaijani sovereignty over Karabakh. The Armenian opposition expressed serious 
concern over this declaration, renewing its allegations that Pashinian is 
forcing the Karabakh Armenians to live under Azerbaijani rule.
By contrast, the strongly-worded Karabakh statement contained no criticism of 
Pashinian.
Yerevan Still Reluctant To Clarify Stance On Karabakh’s Status
        • Astghik Bedevian
Armenia - Deputy Foreign Minister Mnatsakan Safarian speaks to reporters, 
Yerevan, .
Two days after the leaders of Armenia and Azerbaijan reportedly made progress 
during talks in Brussels, the Armenian government again declined to clarify on 
Tuesday whether it recognizes Azerbaijani sovereignty over Nagorno-Karabakh.
Charles Michel, the European Union chief who hosted the talks, said Armenian 
Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian and Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev “confirmed 
their unequivocal commitment to … respective territorial integrity of Armenia 
(29,800 square kilometers) and Azerbaijan (86,600 square kilometers).”
The total Soviet-era area of Azerbaijan cited by Michel includes Karabakh.
“Negotiations are ongoing on the provision of international guarantees for 
ensuring Nagorno-Karabakh’s rights and security,” Deputy Foreign Minister 
Mnatsakan Safarian repeatedly told reporters as they pressed him on the 
implications of Michel’s statement.
Safarian said Armenia always recognized Azerbaijan’s territorial integrity. “So 
there is nothing new here,” he said.
The diplomat did not clarify whether Yerevan will explicitly recognize Karabakh 
as a part of Azerbaijan in a peace treaty currently discussed by the conflicting 
sides.
The Armenian and Azerbaijani foreign ministers are scheduled to meet in Moscow 
later this week for further talks on the treaty.
Meanwhile, Armenian opposition leaders continued to portray Michel’s remarks as 
further proof of Pashinian’s readiness to help Baku regain control over Karabakh.
“86,600 square kilometers means Karabakh is a part of Azerbaijan,” said Armen 
Rustamian of the opposition Hayastan alliance.
Pashinian has not yet made any public statements on the Brussels summit held on 
Sunday. In recent months, he has publicly encouraged Karabakh’s leaders to 
negotiate with Azerbaijan while accusing Baku of planning to commit “genocide” 
in the Armenian-populated region.
The authorities in Stepanakert have repeatedly denounced Pashinian’s comments on 
the conflict with Azerbaijan. In a joint statement issued on April 19, the five 
political groups represented in the Karabakh parliament again accused him of 
undermining the Karabakh Armenians’ right to self-determination which was for 
decades supported by international mediators.
CSTO Exit ‘Not On Armenia’s Agenda Yet’
        • Astghik Bedevian
ARMENIA - The leaders of Russia, Armenia and other CSTO member states pose for a 
photograph during a summit in Yerevan, November 23, 2022.
Armenia is not considering leaving the Collective Security Treaty Organization 
(CSTO) despite its unprecedented tensions with other CSTO member states, a 
senior Armenian official said on Tuesday.
Earlier this year, the Armenian government cancelled a CSTO military exercise 
planned in Armenia and refused to appoint a deputy secretary-general of the 
Russian-led military alliance over what it sees as a lack of CSTO support in the 
conflict with Azerbaijan. It also rejected a CSTO offer to deploy a monitoring 
mission to the Armenian-Azerbaijani border.
The tensions have called into question Armenia’s continued membership in the 
organization. In a newspaper interview published over the weekend, the secretary 
of the country’s Security Council, Armen Grigorian, said Yerevan discussed the 
possibility of leaving the alliance. He gave no details.
Deputy Foreign Minister Mnatsakan Safarian suggested that the discussions took 
place shortly after Azerbaijan launched offensive military operations along the 
Armenian border last September.
An exit from the CSTO is “not on Armenia’s agenda now,” Safarian said, adding 
that Pashinian’s government may revisit the issue in the future.
“Yes, the situation is complicated, but being a CSTO member state and also 
having [membership] obligations, we continue to hope that our efforts will 
produce some results,” Safarian told reporters.
Armenia - CSTO Secretary General Imangali Tasmagambetov at a meeting with 
Armenian Defense Minister Suren Papikian, Yerevan, March 16, 2023.
Grigorian complained last month that “the security mechanisms that were supposed 
to protect us are not working now.” “Armenia is trying to find new security 
guarantees,” he told Armenian Public Television.
Safarian would not say whether the authorities in Yerevan see any realistic 
alternative to Armenia’s membership in the CSTO and bilateral military ties with 
Russia.
Armen Rustamian, a leading member of the main opposition Hayastan alliance, 
believes that in the absence of such an alternative Armenia’s estrangement from 
the alliance of six ex-Soviet states carries serious national security risks.
“Without having a new security system they are trying to wreck the existing 
one,” Rustamian charged.
“Leave the CSTO and explain why you did that, or stay in the CSTO and use all, 
even minimal chances of getting the CSTO to address our security problems,” he 
said, appealing to Pashinian’s administration. “We are becoming an unreliable 
partner, and that is adding to threats and dangers facing increasingly facing 
our country.”
Pashinian claimed in March that it is the CSTO that could “leave Armenia.” The 
Russian Foreign Ministry spokeswoman, Maria Zakharova, laughed off that remark, 
saying that she has trouble understanding its meaning. A senior Russian diplomat 
afterwards called for an end to the “harmful” spat.
Italian Police Seize $880 Million Of Cocaine ‘Bound For Armenia’
Italy - A screenshot from an official video of Italian police finding 2.7 tons 
of cocaine allegedly bound for Armenia, .
Police in Italy said on Tuesday that they have seized 2.7 tons of “extremely 
pure” cocaine destined for Armenia.
In a statement, Italy’s Guardia di Finanza police force said the consignment of 
drugs worth more than 800 million euros ($880 million) was found in refrigerated 
banana containers shipped to the Calabrian port of Gioia Tauro from Ecuador.
Armenia was the final destination of the shipment, via Georgia’s Black Sea port 
of Batumi, said the statement.
Calabria is home to the Ndrangheta crime syndicate, which is now widely regarded 
as Italy's most powerful mafia organization playing a central role in the drugs 
trade.
Earlier this month, the Italian police also found in Gioia Tauro 600 kilograms 
of cocaine which they said was bound for other parts of Italy as well as 
Croatia, Greece and Georgia.
Armenian law-enforcement authorities did not immediately react to their latest 
major drug bust. It was not clear whether the authorities will try to 
investigate the alleged cocaine shipment to Armenia foiled in Italy.
Armenia - Opposition deputy Agnessa Khamoyan speaks during a news conference in 
Yerevan, November 19, 2021.
Agnessa Khamoyan, an Armenian opposition parliamentarian, expressed serious 
concern over the development. She suggested that senior Armenian officials or 
“persons very close to the government” were involved in the botched drug 
trafficking operation.
The number of drug trafficking cases recorded by the Armenian police nearly 
doubled last year, highlighting a growing problem in a country not accustomed to 
widespread drug abuse. The sharp rise in such cases is widely blamed on 
increasingly accessible synthetic drugs mainly sold through the internet.
Khamoyan mentioned this “awful statistics” in a Facebook post on the Italian 
police statement. “This is a serious threat to national security, and I am sorry 
to say that the state is not taking any serious steps to tackle it,” she wrote.
Some pro-government lawmakers likewise criticized the Armenian police over the 
alarming trend when they met with Interior Minister Vahe Ghazarian in February. 
Ghazarian assured them that the police are stepping up their fight against 
drug-related crimes.
Reposted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2023 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
 

Ucom’s LEAD Leadership Program for middle managers has produced its first graduates

Save

Share

 13:10, 10 May 2023

YEREVAN, MAY 10, ARMENPRESS. The LEAD multi-module leadership program for middle managers at Ucom, launched in 2022, has produced its first graduates. It was specifically designed for Ucom mid-management in collaboration with Grow Edutainment. 

The program aimed to provide continuous development opportunities for mid-managers and leadership skills, create uniform management approaches, prepare participants for the smooth implementation of various processes introduced in Ucom, and strengthen inter-functional cooperation and communication channels between employees.

“The LEAD program is tailored to the needs of our company, and has inspired our emerging middle leaders to embark on the path of continuous education and development. It has taught them that leading people is first and foremost a great responsibility,” said Ralph Yirikian, Director General at Ucom.

The program was long-term, consisting of both courses and practical tasks. It also provided post-course individual counseling and mentoring by invited specialists.

IBA Men’s World Boxing Championships: Armenia’s Bachkov secures at least bronze after quarter-final win

Save

Share

 14:25, 10 May 2023

YEREVAN, MAY 10, ARMENPRESS.  Armenia’s Hovhannes Bachkov secured at least bronze and entered the semi-finals in the light welterweight division at the IBA Men’s World Boxing Championships 2023 in Tashkent after his 5:0 quarter-final win over Colombia’s Jose Manuel Viafara Fori.

Aside from a highly successful amateur career (three-time bronze medalist of the World Boxing Championships, three-time champion of Europe and a bronze medalist of the 32nd Summer Olympics), Bachkov went pro in 2020 and is so far undefeated with 5 wins, 4 of which by way of knock-out. He is fighting in the super lightweight division as a professional.

BREAKING: Azerbaijan bars Red Cross patient transfers from Nagorno Karabakh

Save

Share

 15:09, 10 May 2023

YEREVAN, MAY 10, ARMENPRESS. Azerbaijan has been obstructing the activities of the Red Cross in transferring patients from Artsakh/Nagorno Karabakh to Armenia ever since it illegally set up a checkpoint on the Lachin Corridor, the Human Rights Defender of Artsakh Gegham Stepanyan said on May 10.

“After setting up a checkpoint, Azerbaijan obstructs the activities of the Red Cross in Artsakh in every possible way. For 11 days now, the ICRC has been unable to transport patients in critical health conditions to medical facilities in Armenia,” Stepanyan tweeted.

Russia intends to withdraw from Treaty on Conventional Armed Forces in Europe

Save

Share

 15:24, 10 May 2023

YEREVAN, MAY 10, ARMENPRESS. Russia has indicated its intention to formally withdraw from the Treaty on Conventional Armed Forces in Europe (CFE), a military transparency agreement that is currently suspended, RT reported citing announcements published by the Kremlin.

Deputy Foreign Minister Sergey Ryabkov has been selected by President Vladimir Putin to supervise the procedure in the Russian parliament.

The appointment was revealed on Wednesday as part of regular Kremlin announcements. Ryabkov will represent the government in both chambers of parliament regarding the proposed withdrawal, the document said.

Leonid Slutsky, the leader of the nationalist LDPR party, told RIA Novosti that a draft law on Russia’s withdrawal from the treaty could be introduced as early as this week.

The CFE treaty was one of the cornerstones of the attempted de-escalation of tensions between the Warsaw Pact bloc and NATO during the final days of the USSR. Signed in 1990, the agreement set limits for deployment of conventional forces on the European continent and established various transparency mechanisms, such as on-site verification inspections.

Armenia, Azerbaijan to hold foreign ministerial talks in Moscow next week

Save

Share

 15:28, 10 May 2023

YEREVAN, MAY 10, ARMENPRESS. Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan will have a meeting with his Azerbaijani counterpart Jeyhun Bayramov on May 19 in Moscow, Armenian foreign ministry spokesperson Ani Badalyan told ARMENPRESS.

“A foreign ministerial level meeting between Armenia and Azerbaijan is planned for May 19 in Moscow, hosted by the Russian side,” she said.

ICRC ‘hopes’ to restore patient transfers from Nagorno Karabakh – spox

Save

Share

 16:22, 10 May 2023

YEREVAN, MAY 10, ARMENPRESS. The International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) has not facilitated transfer of patients from Nagorno Karabakh to Armenia since April 29 and is now discussing details pertaining to the format of its work with decision-makers from the parties involved, the ICRC told ARMENPRESS on May 10.

“In regards to developments, the International Committee of the Red Cross is discussing with all decision-makers from the parties the details pertaining to the format of our work,” ICRC Armenia Communications and Prevention Manager Zara Amatuni said when asked to comment on Nagorno Karabakh ombudsman Gegham Stepanyan’s tweet that Azerbaijan has been obstructing the ICRC’s work ever since it illegally installed a checkpoint on Lachin Corridor.

Amatuni explained that the process is confidential since it is proceeding in a format of a dialogue. She did not elaborate further on the discussions.

“It’s about the continuity of our humanitarian work. We hope it will be restored. However, there’s some need for clarification, and now this process is taking place. During this period we are factually not implementing transfers because we must have clarity regarding several details with all parties involved,” Amatuni said.

Pashinyan, Charles Michel attach importance to forthcoming joint meeting with French, German and Azeri leaders

Save

Share

 01:43,

YEREVAN, MAY 14, ARMENPRESS. Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and President of the European Council Charles Michel discussed the “military-political and humanitarian situation in the region” during an informal meeting in Brussels Saturday evening.

PM Pashinyan spoke about the situation resulting from the latest “provocative and aggressive” actions of the Azerbaijani military against Armenia’s sovereign territory, which “are aimed at disrupting the efforts for resuming the peace talks,” the Prime Minister’s Office said in a readout.

Pashinyan and Michel also discussed issues related to the humanitarian crisis in Nagorno Karabakh resulting from the illegal blockade of Lachin Corridor by Azerbaijan, as well as the normalization process between Armenia and Azerbaijan.

The Armenian Prime Minister and the European Council President also discussed the upcoming May 14 trilateral meeting with participation of the Azerbaijani President and attached importance to holding a five-sided meeting together with French President Emmanuel Macron and German Chancellor Olaf Scholz in Chisinau on June 1, within the framework of the European Political Community Summit.

Eurovision 2023: Sweden’s Loreen wins for second time

Save

Share

 03:08,

YEREVAN, MAY 14, ARMENPRESS. Sweden’s Loreen won Eurovision 2023 with the song “Tattoo” in Liverpool on Saturday, becoming the first woman to win twice in the contest.

Loreen is the only person after Ireland’s Johnny Logan to win the Eurovision song contest twice. 

Finland’s Käärijä came second with “Cha Cha Cha”, but he was still behind Loreen’s points after the results from juries from participating countries were announced.

Noa Kirel of Israel came third.

“I am seriously overwhelmed,” Loreen told reporters.

Armenia’s Brunette finished 14th with “Future Lover”. She received 5 points from Italy, 1 point from Latvia, 1 point from Austria, 1 point from Poland, 2 points from Moldova, 6 points from Ireland, 7 points from France, 3 from Estonia, 3 from Spain, 3 from the UK, 4 from Cyprus, 5 from Switzerland, 10 from Georgia, 10 from Albania and 8 from Czech Republic. With another 69 points from the jury, Brunette ranked 14th with 122 points.

Armenia gave to Israel.

Azerbaijan: The veneer of democracy is peeling off Baku’s authoritarian political structure

May 11 2023
May 11, 2023

Seven of the 125 seats in Azerbaijan’s parliament are now vacant and no one seems in a hurry to do anything about it. The prolonged vacancies are an indicator that President Ilham Aliyev’s administration is not worrying about maintaining a democratic veneer on the country’s authoritarian system.

Azerbaijan has a strong presidential system that includes what is widely viewed as a rubber-stamp legislature. Parliament is packed with pro-presidential MPs, most of them members of Aliyev’s New Azerbaijan Party, along with a smattering of independents. The democracy watchdog group Freedom House in its 2023 Freedom of the World report ranked Azerbaijan’s political system as “not free,” adding that Baku ranked among the “worst of the worst” states in the areas of political rights and civil liberties.

Parliamentary elections in Azerbaijan have routinely been marred by irregularities, according to monitoring groups. The last legislative elections in 2020 produced an expected, overwhelming pro-presidential majority, but it also yielded a minor surprise: the Central Election Committee invalidated the results in four electoral districts, citing complaints of fraud. The invalidations came after Aliyev spoke publicly about a need to clean up Azerbaijan’s reputation for dirty elections. “We don’t want any violations,” Aliyev said. “Those who committed violations should receive their punishment so that such situations do not happen in the future.” 

One way to address electoral fraud is to not hold a vote at all. And this is what has happened with the four invalidated results. No re-run elections have been scheduled in the un-represented districts. Three additional parliamentary vacancies have also opened up over the years: one MP died, another was arrested and expelled, and the third was promoted to a post in the executive branch. No moves have been made to fill those vacancies either.

Azerbaijani legislation seems to require expeditious action to fill parliamentary vacancies. The law on Elections for Parliament calls for re-run elections to be held within three months in cases where original results are nullified.

Back in 2021, CEC chief Mazahir Panahov told journalists that special elections for the vacant seats would be held “in the near future.” But since then there hasn’t been a peep about the matter from administration officials, who seem more focused on external issues, including as Azerbaijan’s prickly relations with Iran and the still smoldering conflict with Armenia over Nagorno Karabakh. Earlier this year, MP Zahid Oruj said that no special elections are currently planned. The next general legislative elections should be held no later than 2025.

Najmin Kamilsoy, a political analyst in Baku, said widespread apathy with electoral politics is enabling the government’s ability to put off special elections. Campaign season is a time when “political activity comes to life,” he noted. And given that elections have often engendered “international criticisms targeting election fraud, the government doesn’t feel an urge to call for new or repeated elections,” continued Kamilsoy, co-founder and analyst at Baku-based Agora Analytical Collective. “There isn’t much domestic demand.”

A lone vocal voice in calling for special elections is Ilgar Mammadov, chair of semi-opposition Republican Alternative Party (ReAl). He invoked a time-tested rationale for filling the vacant seats: taxation without representation is tyranny. “As parliamentarism is directly related to the tax policy of the state, it is the right of citizens to participate in the disposal of collected taxes by the Milli Majlis [Azerbaijani parliament] through their representatives,” he wrote in a public statement in 2022. 

Mammadov’s rallying cry hasn’t resonated much with voters, however. There’s been no groundswell of grass-roots support for special elections. Even some sitting members of parliament seem to question the point of filling the seats, acknowledging the existence of electoral fraud and the legislature’s subservient role in relation to the executive branch.

MP Erkin Gadirli from ReAl, often described as the only opposition voice in parliament, was vilified by pro-government MPs in January after he questioned the validity of the entire electoral process. The parliamentary rebuke followed Gadirli’s interview with blogger Mehman Huseynov, during which he said he could not be sure if his own mandate was legitimate. “There are no democratic elections” in Azerbaijan, he said. Another MP, independent Vahid Ahmadov, received an official reprimand from parliament’s Disciplinary Committee for taking a similar swipe at the legitimacy of the legislature. Ahmadov also called attention to the impropriety of some MPs operating business ventures while being involved in creating legislative frameworks concerning commerce.