The Enduring Cost of War

June 6 2023
 

The Russian aggression against Ukraine shows once more that we have not learned the lessons of history and are paying a high price for it. Future generations will also pay a significant price for our generation’s sins: fractured and destroyed families; poor social and health services; and a polluted environment. Children with mental and developmental problems are the clearest examples of the intergenerational effects of war.

The tremendous stress of war increases the chances of interpersonal violence, particularly against women. When the victims of violence are pregnant women, the intergenerational effect manifests as the increase of still births and premature births among them. Mothers who were the children of Holocaust survivors were shown to have higher levels of psychological stress and less positive parenting skills. During the siege of Sarajevo, perinatal mortality and morbidity almost doubled, and there was a significant increase in the number of children born with malformations.

By analyzing the number of people killed indirectly by the “War on Terror” in Afghanistan, Iraq, Libya, Pakistan, Somalia, Syria, and Yemen, a report by the Costs of War Project at Brown University’s Watson Institute for International and Public Affairs estimates that the war in those countries resulted in 3.6 – 3.7 million indirect deaths, while the total death toll in those same countries could reach at least 4.5 – 4.6 million, and counting.

Stephanie Savell, the Costs of War’s Co-Director and author of the report states, “wars often kill far more people indirectly than in direct combat, particularly young children.” Almost all the victims, says Savell, are from the most impoverished and marginalized populations. Most indirect war deaths are due to malnutrition, pregnancy and birth-related problems, and infectious and chronic diseases.

According to the report, more than 7.6 million children under five in post-9/11 war zones are suffering from acute malnutrition. Malnutrition has serious long-time effects on children’s health. Among those effects are increased vulnerability to diseases, developmental delays, stunted growth, and even blindness, reports UNICEF. Those children affected with malnutrition are also prevented from achieving success in school or having meaningful work as adults.

Although using doctors, patients and civilians as a human shield is a war crime, they are frequent targets of uncontrolled violence. Now in Sudan, Médecins Sans Frontières (MSF) reports that their staff in multiple locations, have been repeatedly confronted by fighters entering health facilities, and stealing medicines, supplies, and vehicles. It is estimated that 70 percent of health facilities in areas in conflict are out of service, and 30 among them are targets of attacks.

In U.N.-sponsored health missions, I was able to see the consequences of war in countries such as Mozambique, Malawi, Angola, El Salvador and Nicaragua, a sobering experience that left painful memories. The sadness and feeling of helplessness I saw in the eyes of women and children still haunt me.

Repeated violence has numbed us to its consequences, our senses overwhelmed by cruelty. Faced with the tragic complexity of life, we are unable to savor its sweet moments of care and tenderness. Eager to escape brutal reality we watch the latest TV news and then mindlessly change the channel to a baking show.

But does war only produce negative effects? What we see now in Ukraine is that the Russian aggression against people of all ages -both soldiers and civilians- has produced millions of displaced people, but it has also given rise to the solidarity of Ukraine’s neighbors, who at high personal and social cost have provided refuge to tens of thousands of families fleeing the war.

Ukrainian women of all ages have also taken up arms to defend their country from Russian aggression. Currently, more than 60,000 Ukrainian women serve in the military, while tens of thousands more are helping their country as journalists, paramedics, teachers, and politicians. At the same time they continue being the center of support for their families. Because men are on the front lines, women must keep hospitals, schools and even villages themselves in operation, often without basic supplies. Although these actions are an example of the best of the human spirit, they do not erase the harrowing cruelty of war.

In his poem “The Dance,” the poet Atom Yarcharian, better known as Siamanto, who was killed by the Ottoman military during the Armenian genocide, expresses the horror of war,

                        The Dance

In a field of cinders where Armenians

were still dying,

a German woman, trying not to cry

told me the horror she witnessed:

“This incomprehensible thing I’m telling you about,

I saw with my own eyes.

From my window of hell

I clenched my teeth

and watched with my pitiless eyes:

the town of Bardoz turned

into a heap of ashes.

Corpses piled high as trees.

From the waters, from the springs,

from the streams and the road,

the stubborn murmur of your blood

still revenges my ear.

Don’t be afraid. I must tell you what I saw,

so people will understand

the crimes men do to men.

For two days, by the road to the graveyard . . .

Let the hearts of the whole world understand.

It was Sunday morning,

the first useless Sunday dawning on the corpses.

From dusk to dawn in my room,

with a stabbed woman,

my tears wetting her death.

Suddenly I heard from afar

a dark crowd standing in a vineyard

lashing twenty brides

and singing dirty songs.

Leaving the half-dead girl on the straw mattress,

I went to the balcony on my window

and the crowd seemed to thicken like a forest.

An animal of a man shouted, ‘you must dance,

dance when our drum beats.’

With fury whips cracked

on the flesh of these women.

Hand in hand the brides began their circle dance.

Now, I envied my wounded neighbor

because with a calm snore

she cursed the universe

and gave her soul up to the stars . . .

In vain I shook my fists at the crowd.

‘Dance,’ they raved,

‘dance till you die, infidel beauties.

With your flapping tits, dance!

Smile and don’t complain.

You’re abandoned now, you’re naked slaves,

so dance like a bunch of fuckin’ sluts.

We’re hot for you all.’

Twenty graceful brides collapsed.

‘Get up,’ the crowd roared,

brandishing their swords.

Then someone brought a jug of kerosene.

Human justice, I spit in your face.

The brides were anointed.

‘Dance,’ they thundered–

here’s a fragrance you can’t get in Arabia.’

Then with a torch, they set

the naked brides on fire.

And the charred corpses rolled

and tumbled to their deaths . . .

Like a storm I slammed the shutters

of my windows,

and went over to the dead girl

and asked: ‘How can I dig out my eyes,

how can I dig, tell me?’ “

Armenian; trans. Peter Balakian and Nevart Yaghlian

Dr. Cesar Chelala is a co-winner of the 1979 Overseas Press Club of America award for the article “Missing or Disappeared in Argentina: The Desperate Search for Thousands of Abducted Victims.”

Estonian experts join European Union civilian missions in Armenia and Moldova

EUROPEAN INTEREST
June 6 2023

–

Käsper Kivisoo will become the Strategic Adviser on Hybrid threats and/or Cyber Security in the European Union’s new civilian mission in Moldova (EUPM Moldova), and Enn Kooskora will join the European Union’s new civilian mission in Armenia (EUMA Armenia) as an observer.

EUMA Armenia will monitor the security situation on the border between Armenia and Azerbaijan to contribute to the stability of Armenia’s border regions. Estonian expert Enn Kooskora has worked on numerous missions, including the OSCE mission OSCE SMM in Ukraine.

The focus of EUPM Moldova will be on strategic expertise and operational support to reinforce Moldova’s internal security. Käsper Kivisoo, who will work as a short-term expert, previously worked as an adviser at the Government Office.

Estonia is posting experts to international civilian missions to help prevent and manage international conflicts. Estonian experts are posted to European Union missions in Ukraine, Moldova, Georgia, Iraq and Somalia, and the UN mission in Kosovo. Eight experts posted by Estonia are currently working with various international civilian missions. The civilian missions are coordinated by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs.

Armenpress: Armenian FM calls for maximum possible certainty in delimitation process with Azerbaijan

 10:14, 7 June 2023

YEREVAN, JUNE 7, ARMENPRESS. Minister of Foreign Affairs of Armenia Ararat Mirzoyan has talked over the phone with US acting Assistant Secretary of State for European and Eurasian Affairs Derek Hogan.

FM Mirzoyan and Hogan discussed issues of regional security and stability, the foreign ministry said in a readout.

Ahead of the discussions which are planned in Washington in a few days, the key issues of the process of normalization of relations between Armenia and Azerbaijan were touched upon, including border delimitation and security, proper addressing of the rights and security issues of the people of Nagorno Karabakh. Minister Mirzoyan emphasized the importance of ensuring the maximum possible certainty in the delimitation process, particularly the commitment regarding the map of 1975.  

FM Ararat Mirzoyan once again drew the attention of the American side to the aggressive rhetoric expressed by the top leadership of Azerbaijan in parallel with the negotiation process, stressing the need to exclude the threat of use of force and mutual respect for territorial integrity.




Armenia congratulates five newly elected non-permanent members of UN Security Council

 10:31, 7 June 2023

YEREVAN, JUNE 7, ARMENPRESS. The Armenian Ministry of Foreign Affairs has congratulated the five newly elected non-permanent members of the UN Security Council.

“Congratulations to the newly elected members of UN Security Council. Wishes of every success in their responsible mission to maintain international peace & security,” the Armenian Foreign Ministry tweeted.

Algeria, Guyana, Republic of Korea, Sierra Leone and Slovenia will join the premier body for maintaining international peace and security, starting in January, serving for a two-year period. 

The UN Security Council is composed of 15 countries, five of which – China, France, Russia, the United Kingdom and the United States – are permanent members, granting them the right to veto any resolution or decision. 

The 10 non-permanent members are elected by the General Assembly, which comprises all 193 UN Member States, and in line with geographical distribution by region.  

Voting is conducted by secret ballot and candidates must receive a two-thirds majority, or 128 votes, even if they run uncontested. 

Overall, 192 countries voted to fill three Council seats allocated to the Africa and Asia-Pacific Groups, and one each for Eastern Europe and Latin America and the Caribbean. 

Slovenia beat Belarus in the race for Eastern Europe, receiving 153 votes versus 38, while Algeria, Guyana, Sierra Leone and the Republic of Korea ran unopposed. 

The five newly elected countries will join Ecuador, Japan, Malta, Mozambique and Switzerland as non-permanent members of the Council. 

They will take up seats currently occupied by Albania, Brazil, Gabon, Ghana and the United Arab Emirates when their two-year terms end on 31 December.

Canada’s Trudeau meets Catholicos Aram I, expresses support for enduring peace in Nagorno Karabakh

 10:41, 7 June 2023

YEREVAN, JUNE 7, ARMENPRESS. Prime Minister of Canada Justin Trudeau has met with Catholicos Aram I of the Great House of Cilicia.

“The Armenian Canadian community is strong and vibrant – and when His Holiness Catholicos Aram I and I met today, we spoke about that. We also spoke about the atrocities committed during the Armenian genocide, and our support for enduring peace in Nagorno-Karabakh,” PM Trudeau tweeted on June 7.

Armenia-Czech Republic military-technical cooperation agreement discussed in defense and security committee

 11:34, 7 June 2023

YEREVAN, JUNE 7, ARMENPRESS. The Parliamentary Committee on Defense and Security Affairs is debating the agreement between Armenia and the Czech Republic on military-technical cooperation submitted by the government for approval and ratification.

Deputy Minister of Defense Arman Sargsyan presented the agreement to lawmakers on June 7.

He said that the agreement will define the direction of cooperation in the military-technical area, including the production of military-grade products, imports and exports procedures, licensing and quality control, as well as training of specialists and maintenance staff. The agreement also covers support for defense industry companies and relations concerning information exchange and storage.

The authorized bodies for implementing the agreement are the defense ministries of the two countries, as well as a working group that will be set up for military-technical cooperation as part of the Armenian-Czech Intergovernmental Commission for Economic Cooperation.

Sargsyan said that the Constitutional Court has approved the agreement.

It was signed in April 2019 and will take effect after passing national procedures in both countries. The Czech Republic notified Armenia on completing its national procedures of approval back in May 2019.

The agreement will be introduced for ratification in parliament after being debated in the committee.

Armenian gymnasts all geared up for World Challenge Cup in Croatia

 11:46, 7 June 2023

YEREVAN, JUNE 7, ARMENPRESS. Armenian national gymnastics team athletes are set for the World Challenge Cup in Croatia after their successful performances in the tournament’s Bulgaria edition.

Team Armenia’s Artur Davtyan, Artur Avetisyan, Artur Tovmasyan and Gagik Khachikyan will compete in the men’s division while Mane Poghosyan will participate in the women’s division.

Armenia head coach Hakob Serobyan will be among the judges.

Hayk Nazaryan and Knarik Brsoyan will be the coaching staff of the Armenian team at the event which will kick off June 8 in Osijek, Croatia.

In the previous World Challenge Cup held in Varna, Olympic bronze medalist Artur Davtyan took gold in vault and bronze medals in the pommel horse and the rings, while Artur Avetisyan won gold in the rings.

Armenia-Azerbaijan border situation ‘relatively stable’, says deputy minister of defense

 11:51, 7 June 2023

YEREVAN, JUNE 7, ARMENPRESS. Deputy Minister of Defense Arman Sargsyan said Wednesday that the situation on the Armenian-Azerbaijani border is relatively stable.

“The situation is relatively stable, there were shootings yesterday that were reported. We immediately respond in case of intensive shootings by the adversary,” Sargsyan told reporters.

Yerevan’s iconic giant corncob-like Youth Palace building to be rebuilt

 12:13, 7 June 2023

YEREVAN, JUNE 7, ARMENPRESS. The Youth Palace building in downtown Yerevan which was once one of the most iconic landmarks of the Armenian capital ever since it was built in the 1970s until its demolishment in 2006 will be brought back to life.

A project by Aprelu Yerkir Party and Artur Tarkhanyan Center called Public Initiative for Development of Yerevan, supported by Ruben Vardanyan Foundation, seeks to rebuild the Youth Palace building resembling a giant corncob (hence its nickname Kukuruznik in Russian) in the very same location overlooking Teryan Street, with the same design, but with modern solutions.

Aprelu Yerkir President Mane Tandilyan said that their project will also feature many other major programs. She attached importance to giving back the iconic building back to the city. 

Architect Anahit Tarkhanyan, whose father was one of the architects of the original Youth Palace building – said that the private company who had acquired the building and subsequently demolished it committed multiple violations of the law. The company had signed a contract assuming an obligation to invest five million dollars within three years, something it failed to do. Moreover, the building was demolished based on falsified documents, Tarkhanyan said, expressing hope that law enforcement agencies will eventually prosecute those guilty.

The project is still in a preliminary phase and experts are now working on the future concept of the building.

In a best case scenario the building will be completed in two years, and another two years will be needed for interior works.

Photos by Tatev Duryan