Arrested After Antifa Clashes With Armenian Parents at California School Board Meeting

The Daily Signal
June 7 2023

EDUCATIONNEWS

Several fights broke out between Antifa and parental rights activists Tuesday night outside the Glendale Unified School District’s administration building in Glendale, California, during a school board meeting discussing LGBTQ+ curriculum.

Law enforcement arrested three individuals amid the mayhem after the protest “exceeded the bounds of peaceful assembly,” the Glendale Police Department announced Tuesday night.

Following the Glendale school board’s decision to incorporate LGBTQ+ “Pride” festivals and celebrations into June school days, dozens of parents pulled students from classrooms—with some elementary schools seeing only 40% of students show up for class on June 2.

Additional documents revealed that Glendale staff have attempted to incorporate LGBTQ+ materials and ideology into other curriculum. One assistant principal even told staff to teach children that every person is, by default, “queer” and “socialist.”

Parents from the traditionally conservative Armenian and Hispanic communities in Glendale planned to protest the board’s decisions at an upcoming school board meeting. Antifa Southern California called for activists to counter protest against these parents, whom they labeled “hate groups.”

Several parents told Glendale’s board that they were concerned with Glendale’s transgender policies, such as allowing students of the opposite sex to use the same bathrooms and locker rooms, putting their children at risk.

One father told the board:

I graduated from Glendale in ‘96, and I have two daughters. My daughter is afraid to change in the locker room because she knows another guy could come into the room. When I asked the principal, he told me there were no cross-gender bathroom policies.

Other parents previously told The Daily Signal that their children changed in locker rooms with students of the opposite sex multiple times, and that this is standard practice in Glendale.

The father finished by telling the Glendale board: “All of these fake people [pointing to several masked crowd members] are going to go away, and we’re going to vote every one of you [pointing to the school board] out.”

About 42 minutes into the meeting, Board President Nayiri Nahabedian stopped the public comment session as law enforcement locked down the building due to disturbances outside. The board meeting went into recess for almost 20 minutes while police attempted to manage the situation. 

According to footage from Los Angeles news networks and on-site independent journalists, masked progressive protesters in pink bandanas and progress flags traded blows with Armenian and Hispanic parents.

Glendale police then announced over loudspeakers that the assembly was now considered “unlawful” and ordered the crowds of protesters to disperse. They then arrested at least three members of the crowd on “various charges.” The department did not specify either the affiliations of the suspects or the charges involved.

Many of the speakers claim it is essential to teach children about LGBTQ+ topics, even though critics claim some of the materials are sexually explicit, even pornographic.

“Schools should teach kids to grow up in a diverse world, with different colors, religions, and sexualities,” one woman shouted at the board. Most of the pro-LGBTQ+ speakers shouted into the microphone, causing it to short out momentarily.

Several of the speakers turned their attention towards the parents protesting Glendale’s LGBTQ+ policies.

A man in a skirt, high-heel boots, and a women’s leather jacket who claimed to have three daughters told the board: “Their ideology is the same as the Proud Boys. Hiding their hate behind their kids just as Proud Boys hide behind their masks.”

A speaker claiming to be a representative from the “Revolutionary Communists” told the board that all socialists had a duty to protect LGBTQ+ students from “Christofascism.”

One Glendale teacher used her time to lecture white and Armenian Americans:

[I volunteer] extensively in South LA and work with the children’s hospital of Los Angeles with queer/trans youth in large groups, and so I deal with a lot of their trauma related to the hetero-normative, Judeo-Christian, patriarchal, imperialist, capitalist system that oppresses them. 

And so, I’m not just here in support of our LGBTQ youths, it’s all connected. I’m here in support of Critical Race Theory and Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion training because white people participate, for example, in the largest social welfare program in the history of the United States, and yet—now they put their hands up in the air and look at our housing crisis.

Armenians talk about the genocide that they received SSI, but they don’t want to talk about the indigenous genocide in 1850, and the lack of reparations for indigenous and black people in this country.

They don’t want to talk about—how dare you talk about how marginalized people come here…and you don’t want to talk about the oppressed trans youth who… you know those kids aren’t even learning to learn in this.

[At this point a bell sounded as her time speaking was up]

One in two will commit—attempt suicide and 95% know that they are “trans” when they are three, four, and five.

While the teacher didn’t explain what genocide occurred in 1850, what “SSI” was, or from what social welfare program “white” people supposedly benefit, progressive members of the crowd cheered as she sat down.

As of 9 p.m. Pacific Daylight Time, crowds outside had not yet dispersed, though Glendale police were ordering all to leave or face arrest for unlawful assembly. 

The Glendale Unified School District did not respond to The Daily Signal’s request for comment on the events of June 6 or the district’s LGBTQ+ policies.

Have an opinion about this article? To sound off, please email [email protected] and we’ll consider publishing your edited remarks in our regular “We Hear You” feature. Remember to include the url or headline of the article plus your name and town and/or state.


https://www.dailysignal.com/2023/06/06/antifa-armenian-parents-clash-california-school-board-meeting-required-lgbtq-activities/

Armenian, Hispanic Parents Clash With Antifa, School Board Over LGBTQ Agenda

Daily Wire
June 7 2023
By  Hank Berrien

Tensions boiled over Tuesday night outside a California school board meeting where officials were discussing efforts to celebrate Pride month, with parents and activists squaring off against masked Antifa members.

The clash came outside the Glendale Unified School District’s headquarters, where parents, many from the Los Angeles County city’s Armenian and Hispanic communities, were blasting board members for promoting a pro-LGBTQ agenda to young children. Other speakers, including a man in a skirt and high heels, showed up in support of the district’s pro-Pride agenda, according to reports.

“All of these fake people [pointing to several masked crowd members] are going to go away, and we’re going to vote every one of you [pointing to the school board] out,” one father warned, according to The Daily Signal.

The issue has roiled the district in recent days, with many parents, including those from ethnic communities, pulling their children out of school in protest.  Some elementary schools only had a 40% attendance rate on June 2, The Daily Signal reported.

Outside the meeting Tuesday, three people were arrested as parents confronted members of Antifa clad in masks and pink bandanas. It was not known who was arrested, but Glendale Police said the suspects “exceeded the bounds of peaceful assembly.”

Armenian parents have not been the only ethnic community protesting the LGBTQ+ agenda.

Parents told board members inside and media covering the confrontation outside that they opposed pushing the pro-LGBTQ agenda on children.“Bringing in curriculum for K-6 on gender ideology, that is what we’re against,” Any Torosyan, a parent from Glendale, told KTLA.

“I graduated from Glendale in ‘96, and I have two daughters,” one father told the board. “My daughter is afraid to change in the locker room because she knows another guy could come into the room. When I asked the principal, he told me there were no cross-gender bathroom policies.”

One teacher who works in the district told the board that children know they are transgender by as early as 3 years old, and that they are being persecuted.

“I am also a community member who volunteers extensively in South LA and work with the Children’s Hospital of Los Angeles with queer/trans youth in large groups, and so I deal with a lot of their trauma related to the hetero-normative, Judeo-Christian, patriarchal, imperialist, capitalist system that oppresses them.”

“Recently, intentional and harmful disinformation has been circulating about what is being taught in our district and the ways we serve our students,” Glendale Unified School District said in a statement. “This includes disinformation about LGBTQIA+ curriculum, sex education, and supporting transgender and gender non-conforming youth.”

“The option to opt out pertains only to certain curriculum, including development/maturation and sex education. Parents/guardians may not opt their child out of any lesson referencing LGBTQ+ individuals and history, as dictated by the FAIR Act,” the statement adds.

The California FAIR Education Act was passed in 2011. It requires instruction in history/ social science to include lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender Americans in the teaching of California and United States history.

The California Department of Education’s California Healthy Youth Act, which took effect Jan. 1, 2016, mandates that K-12 curriculum incorporate the LGBTQ agenda.

“Instruction shall affirmatively recognize that people have different sexual orientations and, when discussing or providing examples of relationships and couples, must be inclusive of same-sex relationships,” it states. “It must also teach students about gender, gender _expression_, gender identity, and explore the harm of negative gender stereotypes.”

Azerbaijan, Armenia on threshold of peace: Bayramov

MEHR News Agency
iran – June 7 2023

TEHRAN, Jun 07 (MNA) – After the end of the conflict, which lasted for about thirty years, for the first time Azerbaijan and Armenia stand on the threshold of peace, with the obligation of mutual respect, Azerbaijani Foreign Minister said Tuesday.

Speaking at a special meeting of the OSCE Permanent Council on Tuesday, Jeyhun Bayramov said after the two countries gained independence, for the first time they stand on the threshold of peace with the obligation of mutual respect for each other’s sovereignty, territorial integrity and inviolability of borders.

He added that within the framework of the Azerbaijani-Armenian normalization process, negotiations are underway on the text of a bilateral peace agreement, Trend reported. 

He noted that the talks held over the past few weeks in Washington, Brussels, Moscow and Chisinau made it possible to better understand the positions of the parties. 

Bayramov stressed that Azerbaijan expects mutual political will from the Armenian side to overcome differences in three specific areas that form the agenda of bilateral discussions.

Azerbaijan is actively working to ensure lasting peace with Armenia, he said, adding that there are opportunities and real prospects for establishing peace, strengthening stability, ensuring peaceful coexistence, advancing the peace agenda, and investing in economic development and cooperation. 

The decades-long conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan over Karabakh flared up in September 2020, marking the worst escalation since the 1990s.

Hostilities ended with a Russia-brokered trilateral ceasefire declaration signed in November 2020. The two former Soviet states agreed to the deployment of Russian peacekeepers in the region. Since then, there have been occasional clashes along the border.

SKH/FNA14020317000500

Armenia-Azerbaijan conflict: EU Special Representative for the South Caucasus visits Yerevan

June 7 2023

EU Special Representative for the South Caucasus and the crisis in Georgia Toivo Klaar visited Armenia on 6 June. 

In Yerevan, he met Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan, Deputy Prime Minister Mher Grigoryan, and Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan. 

His meetings follow recent high-level EU meetings with the leaders of Armenia and Azerbaijan, notably in Brussels on 14 May, and in Chisinau on 1 June, on the margins of the European Political Community summit.

The next trilateral meeting between the two countries and the EU is planned for 21 July. 

After his visit to Yerevan, Toivo Klaar will travel to Baku for similar consultations with the Azerbaijani leadership.

Find out more

Press release

https://euneighbourseast.eu/news/latest-news/armenia-azerbaijan-conflict-eu-special-representative-for-the-south-caucasus-visits-yerevan/

Armenia: socio-cultural initiative opens in Gyumri with EU support

June 7 2023

On 6 June, the Oda cultural room opened its doors in Gyumri, Armenia. The opening ceremony was accompanied by a live music performance of national instruments followed by a shadow theatre performance. 

The Oda cultural room, located at 11 Tigran Mets avenue, is a socio-cultural initiative that will host cultural events dedicated to music, art, and poetry. It aims to revive old traditions and contribute to the development of cultural tourism in Gyumri.

“The support to the Oda cultural room once again proves the EU commitment to promote cultural exchange and the preservation of the diverse heritage of countries, supporting the development of cultural tourism. I hope that the Oda will become a place for inspiration and a place where tradition and innovation coexist in harmony,” Frank Hess, Head of Cooperation at the European Union Delegation to Armenia, said at the opening ceremony.

The creation of the Oda cultural room was made possible through the support of the EU4Business ‘Innovative Tourism and Technology Development for Armenia’ project, co-funded by the European Union and the Federal Republic of Germany and implemented by GIZ (the German development agency).

Find out more

Press release

Construction Underway for Armenian-American Steel Plant in Yeraskh

June 7 2023
In a recent Facebook post, Armenian Economy Minister Vahan Kerobyan shared exciting news about the construction of a substantial Armenian-American steel
Armenian Steel PlantImage Source – Eurasianet
Strategic Research Institute

In a recent Facebook post, Armenian Economy Minister Vahan Kerobyan shared exciting news about the construction of a substantial Armenian-American steel plant in the village of Yeraskh, located in the Ararat region. This ambitious project is set to bring significant economic and industrial growth to the region.

With an estimated investment of around $70 million, the steel plant is being built from the ground up. The production workshop stands at an impressive height of 30 meters, covering an expansive area of 16,500 square meters. Once fully operational, the plant is projected to manufacture 180,000 metric tons of steel products annually.

The construction of this steel plant is a testament to the commitment to fostering industrial development and creating job opportunities in Armenia. The project has already provided employment to 200 individuals, and it plans to expand its workforce further, aiming to hire an additional 800 employees once the plant is commissioned.

The establishment of the Armenian-American steel plant in Yeraskh represents a significant milestone in the country’s efforts to bolster its industrial capabilities. This venture is expected to contribute to the overall economic growth and enhance Armenia’s position in the steel production sector.

https://www.steelguru.com/steel/construction-underway-for-armenian-american-steel-plant-in-yeraskh

These economies benefited from Russia’s isolation — but they now risk Western retaliation

    CNBC
June 7 2023
PUBLISHED WED, JUN 7 20231:09 AM EDT
Karen Gilchrist
KEY POINTS
  • Caucasus countries Georgia and Armenia, whose economies unexpectedly boomed in the wake of the war in Ukraine, are now facing the prospect of Western retaliation following a spike in trade with Russia.
  • Russia has emerged as Georgia’s second-largest trading partner by imports and its third-largest trading partner by exports in 2023. The isolated state is Armenia’s largest trading partner in terms of imports and exports.
  • The IMF said the spike represents an “opportunity, but also a risk” for the Caucasus and Central Asia region as the EU and G7 allies consider new sanctions targeting sanctions circumvention.

Caucasus countries Georgia and Armenia, whose economies unexpectedly boomed in the wake of the war in Ukraine, are now facing the prospect of Western retaliation following a spike in trade with Russia.

The two former Soviet states near Russia’s southern border surged to double-digit growth last year as an uptick in Russian workers, wealth and trade supercharged their wider post-Covid recoveries.

Georgia’s economy grew 10.1% in 2022, while Armenia’s jumped 12.6%, according to International Monetary Fund data. In 2023, their growth is set to slow to around 4% and 5.5%, respectively, reflecting a general moderation across the wider Caucasus and Central Asia region, the U.N. agency said.

Still, analysts say the fundamental growth drivers “haven’t disappeared,” and could put those countries under the international spotlight.

“The reason we haven’t decelerated as much as we could have is that we took advantage of Russia being sidelined by the rest of the world,” Mikheil Kukava, head of economic and social policy at Georgian think tank the Institute for Development of Freedom of Information, told CNBC via zoom.

Western leaders have raised alarm bells this year that certain traders are using countries such as Armenia, Georgia, Kazakhstan and Turkey to evade sanctions on Russia.

In its latest economic outlook, the European Bank for Reconstruction and Development noted that such countries were becoming so-called intermediated trade partners for the isolated state.

“Exports from the European Union, United Kingdom and United States to Central Asia and the Caucasus [have] increased dramatically, hinting at the rise of ‘intermediated trade,’ whereby goods are being exported to Central Asian economies and are then sold onwards to Russia,” the EBRD said.

Changing trade patterns in the region are an opportunity, but also a risk.
Subir Lall
DEPUTY DIRECTOR AT THE IMF

This year, Russia has emerged as Georgia’s second-largest trading partner by imports and its third-largest trading partner by exports, according to preliminary data from Georgia’s National Statistics Office, Geostat. Through 2022, Russian imports into the country rose 79%, while exports to Russia were up 7%.

Meantime, Russia is Armenia’s largest trading partner in terms of both imports and exports. Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan and Azerbaijan, as well as other countries in the region, have also recorded a surge in trade with Russia over the past year, IMF data shows.

“Changing trade patterns in the region are an opportunity, but also a risk,” Subir Lall, the IMF’s deputy director of the Middle East and Central Asia, said during a briefing earlier this month.

Spokespersons for the Georgian and Armenian governments did not immediately respond to CNBC’s request for comment on the uptick, nor did they provide a breakdown of the specific goods traded with Russia.

However, Geostat data showed that cars, petrol and unspecified “other commodities” accounted for the vast majority of Georgia’s trade on a general basis. Of particular note, the number of vehicles, aircraft and vessels exported to Russia quadrupled in 2022 and is currently around double 2021 levels.

“I can’t remember a time when Russia was Georgia’s leading trading partner — both in import and export. Some items saw a 1,000% increase or 500% increase. That’s suspicious, right?” Kukava said.

“Even though there’s nothing illegal here — they’re not sanctioned goods — we suspect that it’s dual use items, like washing machines, that can be put to so many uses,” he added, who noted that the parts from such items could be repurposed in military and microchip products.

The burgeoning trade flows have prompted calls from the European Union and allied nations to either get such countries on board with sanctions, or slap those countries themselves with secondary sanctions.

A spokesperson for the European Commission, the EU’s executive arm, told CNBC that it is currently working to “spot the redirection of trade flows from certain third countries acting as possible gateways to Russia.”

That follows comments earlier this month from European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen, who said the group’s 11th package of sanctions against Russia would focus on “cracking down on circumvention” in coordination with Group of Seven nations.

For Armenia, being compliant with the sanctions is an absolute priority.
Armen Nurbekyan
DEPUTY GOVERNOR OF THE CENTRAL BANK OF ARMENIA

The EBRD now estimates that such “intermediated trade” accounts for around 4-6% of annualized gross domestic product in Armenia and Kyrgyzstan. That, in turn, is boosting the countries’ “burgeoning logistics industries,” and underpinning the appreciation of local currencies, it said.

However, Armenia’s central bank Deputy Governor Armen Nurbekyan insisted that authorities are observing the country’s trade patterns on a weekly basis to ensure businesses are not falling foul of the embargoes.

“For Armenia, being compliant with the sanctions is an absolute priority,” Nurbekyan told CNBC. “We are in a region which is very turbulent, so we know what it means to be around countries which are under sanctions, and I think we have been quite successful in steering our economy in a way that we stay away from the problematic cases.”

Nurbekyan noted that trade increases had been seen “across the board” — including in food processing, agricultural goods, and cars — as domestic businesses have taken advantage of increased demand following the exodus of Western businesses from Russia.

He acknowledged that the percentage increase in demand for advanced technology parts, in particular, had been “quite big,” but said that was because levels had started from a low base.

“No one is so naive to assume that given the size of the sanctions, given the size of the flows, that anybody can avoid any risks. That is never the case. But our modus operandi is always that … we ensure that compliance in our financial institutions and more generally is of a higher standard [to other countries]. We not going to be opportunistic, in short,” he added.

Western allies have not yet specified what their next round of sanctions will look like, nor when they might come into effect. However, some analysts say that the prospect of them could push affected countries to rethink their allegiances.

“We need to wean ourselves off this dependence on the Russian economy,” Kukava said.

“This is a pariah country and economic dependence on them means we won’t be able to trade with the EU and the U.S. and the Western countries. The growth needs to come from trade with them, rather than with Russia,” he added.

That’s especially true for nations that aspire to EU and NATO membership.

We are adding fuel to the fire by intensifying this trade relationship with Russia.
Mikheil Kukava
HEAD OF ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL POLICY AT THE INSTITUTE FOR DEVELOPMENT OF FREEDOM OF INFORMATION

Georgia applied for EU membership in March 2022, one week after Russia’s full-blown invasion of Ukraine, and is working toward candidate status. The country, alongside Ukraine, has declared its aspirations to NATO membership.

Georgian public support for EU membership has resurged over recent months, with four-fifths (81%) of the population currently in favor joining the bloc, according to a recent poll from U.S.-founded non-profit the National Democratic Institute. Three-quarters (73%) continue to support NATO membership.

Armenia, meanwhile, has never submitted an application for either membership, and other Central Asian countries would not be eligible to join the EU.

“We are adding fuel to the fire by intensifying this trade relationship with Russia. The geopolitical context with which we [Georgia] are now thought of is with other Central Asia countries. But they don’t have EU membership as a target — we do,” Kukava said.

https://www.cnbc.com/2023/06/07/georgia-armenia-economies-at-risk-over-russia-trade-sanctions.html



Video from Baku with interviews of Armenian prisoners

June 7 2023
  • JAMnews
  • Yerevan

A video with interviews of Armenian prisoners has been published in Azerbaijan, who talk about the conditions in the Baku prison, what they do during the day, and about the opportunity to communicate with their families. In the video the prisoners smile, communicate with each other and even read books in Armenian.

Siranush Sahakyan, a specialist in international law and a representative of the interests of the Armenian prisoners in the European Court of Human Rights, believes that they were filmed under duress. She calls the video “window dressing” and considers it obvious that “there is no sincerity in the words of the prisoners, the video was filmed for propaganda purposes.”


  • Pashinyan-Aliyev-Michel meeting in extended format: Macron and Scholz did not help?
  • “A difficult conversation awaits Aliyev in Chisinau.” Commentary from Yerevan
  • “A difficult conversation awaits Aliyev in Chisinau.” Commentary from Yerevan

The Armenian prisoners on the video are presented as saboteurs. The program ends with the words: “Karabakh is Azerbaijan.” The prisoners themselves tell an Azerbaijani journalist in an interview that they “followed the order”, “installed a barbed wire fence and buried mines.” In the 14-minute video, 5 prisoners appear. Three are reservists taken prisoner in Khtsaberd (in Azerbaijan this village is called Chaylaggala) after the 2020 war, two were captured in 2021.

The prisoners say that they are being treated well:

“I am kept in normal conditions. I have no reason to complain. During the day I find myself different activities, but mostly I read books. I also watch TV, listen to music, news.”

“For example, when we were taken to court, there was an Azerbaijani man, our hands were tied, and he made a sandwich with his own hands and gave it to us. If I had been told this, I probably would not have believed it. But now I’m here and I’ve seen it. I learned that an Azerbaijani is the same as me. Before, I didn’t have such an idea about Azerbaijan.”

“Once a month representatives of the Red Cross come, they bring letters, we talk with family. Food, drink or hygiene products are provided.”

Yerevan is discussing the visit of the Armenian Prime Minister to Moscow, in particular, the moment when the Armenian Prime Minister interrupted the Russian President to react to Aliyev’s speech

The Armenian authorities have repeatedly made similar statements. The other day, Secretary of the Security Council Armen Grigoryan talked about this again:

“Last April, during a meeting in Brussels, President Aliyev promised [European Council President Charles] Michel to release 10 prisoners. More than a year has passed, and the prisoners have not been released. Naturally, the Armenian side constantly raises this issue.”

He stressed that Armenia is consistent in the implementation of all agreements and considers this “a matter of honor”:

“Our international partners should be very attentive to this issue, because in this way they show how international mechanisms work and how the international community fulfills its obligations.”

Briefly – what exactly the President of Azerbaijan said, the reaction to his statements from Armenia and Nagorno-Karabakh, as well as expert opinion

The head of the European Council, Charles Michel, raised the issue of “detainees” after the Pashinyan-Aliyev meeting held on May 14 in Brussels. He stated that “the detainees will be released in the coming weeks”:

“I emphasized the need for understanding regarding the military personnel who simply got lost and switched sides, and that they will continue to be released on an expedited basis.”

However, no information about the release of prisoners during this time has been received.

About two weeks after Michel’s statement, two Armenian soldiers disappeared in the border area. The Armenian Defense Ministry reported that Azerbaijan abducted them, and in Baku they were declared saboteurs. Armenian experts call this incident “a special operation organized by Azerbaijan in order to exchange the Armenian military for Azerbaijanis who entered the territory of Armenia in early April.” One of the Azerbaijani military is accused of killing a local resident.

Lately, there has been a lot of talk from Baku about the captured Armenians held in Azerbaijan, including two soldiers recently taken prisoner. Azerbaijani sources published information that they were visited by human rights advocate Sabina Aliyeva and members of the Ombudsman’s National Preventive Group for the Prevention of Torture. According to these reports, the Armenian servicemen “did not complain about the conditions of detention and treatment, expressed gratitude to the Azerbaijani state for the conditions created.”

The Armenian authorities say that the same issues are being discussed on all platforms, but experts say that the approaches and emphasis on them are different. Commentary by political scientist Stepan Grigoryan

Siranush Sahakyan says that she “was not surprised by the propaganda video published by Baku, it was not the first.” She believes that the prisoners were removed under pressure and the threat of torture.

“Azerbaijan is presented in the video as a philanthropic country, and Armenia as a country that plants deadly mines. In the footage showing two servicemen taken prisoner in Gegharkunik, the journalist says that the servicemen who planted mines and thus endangered the lives of Azerbaijanis want peace for their children.”

Sahakyan believes that with this video Baku wants to change the attitude of international institutions, including the Strasbourg Court, but the “extremely neat prison conditions” shown are simply hurtful.

The lawyer recalls that the reports of the Committee for the Prevention of Torture, acting under the auspices of the Council of Europe, present the real conditions of detention in prisons in Azerbaijan, which are “extremely far from this.”


https://jam-news.net/video-from-baku-with-interviews-of-armenian-prisoners/

EU mission expands to contain Baku’s provocations – Armenian political scientist

June 7 2023
  • JAMnews
  • Yerevan

New operation centers for the EU mission

The head of the EU monitoring mission in Armenia announced that in the coming months it is planned to open three additional operational centers for monitoring the border with Azerbaijan. Markus Ritter said that they will be located in Kapan, Ijevan and Yeghegnadzor.

Political scientist Gurgen Simonyan explains that the EU mission intends to place its observers in the direction where “the armed forces of Azerbaijan are illegally present.” He believes that monitoring these sections of the Armenian border “will help neutralize Baku’s destructive and destabilizing steps.”


  • Russian and Western platforms for Baku-Yerevan negotiations: Similarities and differences
  • “The territorial integrity of Azerbaijan includes Nagorno-Karabakh,” and other statements by Pashinyan
  • Withdrawal from CSTO not on the agenda of Yerevan: What is the danger?

The head of the mission of civilian observers monitoring the Armenian border said that more than 300 patrols have been carried out since February 20. The total length of patrol routes was 3,800 kilometers.

The EU monitors arrived in Armenia in February of this year on a long-term two-year mission. It consists of 100 people: 50 observers and 50 administrative staff. The purpose of the mission is to promote stability in the border areas of Armenia, build confidence on the ground and create favorable conditions for the normalization of relations between Armenia and Azerbaijan.

Markus Ritter recalled that the mission in Armenia materialized urgently, “with unprecedented haste.” He said that at the moment operational centers exist in the cities of Goris, Jermuk and Martuni.

“Our goal is to help stabilize the security situation in the border areas. According to various Armenian officials, our work contributed to a certain stabilization. However, in general, the situation is still unstable.”

The head of the mission of EU observers monitoring the Armenian-Azerbaijani border said that they inform the Azerbaijani authorities in advance when and where exactly they will be

According to political scientist Gurgen Simonyan, in order to understand what caused the need for additional operational centers in the directions indicated by the head of the mission, one should simply look at the map.

“The additional accumulation of forces and the activation of Azerbaijan near Yeghegnadzor are aimed at cutting off the Tigranashen-Yeghegnadzor connection, having control over this small area and tearing off Syunik [the southern region of Armenia bordering Azerbaijan]. The EU mission is expanding to contain Baku’s provocations,” he told JAMnews.

According to the political scientist, international actors are trying to prevent this, but the increase in the combat capability of the Armenian armed forces also plays a significant role.

According to him, the EU monitoring mission “does not give Baku the opportunity to create moral grounds for military aggression.” Such a basis could be the factual justification by Azerbaijan that Armenia was the first to start hostilities. However, this is not possible in the presence of EU observers. Simonyan explains that this presence is not limited to patrolling and monitoring the border:

“The mission headquarters takes into account, studies the factual data provided by the Armenian side, then presents them in the form of reports to the EU, EU member states and other interested parties.”

The political scientist says that recordings from cameras installed along the border by the Armenian Ministry of Defense are also taken into account. He gives an example of military clashes near the village of Tegh in April:

“Azerbaijan could not present its own provocation in this area as aggression from the Armenian side, because it was recorded by cameras, there was factual material.”

The expert also commented on the statement of the head of the EU mission, which he made in April. Markus Ritter said that the observers inform Azerbaijan when and where the monitoring will be carried out.

“This is done so that Azerbaijan does not resort to provocations. This is not about the fact that Azerbaijanis are warned in advance: “We will be out of place, do nothing against Armenia.” They are warned: “Please note that we will be on this site.” All their movements take place on the Armenian-Azerbaijani border, or in the contact zone, so Azerbaijan is informed that their armed forces should not open fire on observers,” Simonyan says.

He positively assesses the activities of the EU mission and believes that the observers are fulfilling their task. He says that after their deployment on the border, “we have not observed cases of large-scale military aggression.”

He emphasizes that the activities of the mission, as well as the ongoing Armenian-Azerbaijani negotiation process on the European platform, should be considered within the framework of the policy pursued by the West:

“And the collective West under the leadership of the United States is not interested in any military conflict or escalation in the region.”

https://jam-news.net/new-operation-centers-for-the-eu-mission/

Armenia-Azerbaijan peace is within grasp: don’t blow it up

June 7 2023

There is a constructive role for the US, UN, and Europe to play, but Russia has to be on board with what is to come, too.

The history of internationally brokered negotiations between Armenia and Azerbaijan over the disputed territory of Nagorno-Karabakh has not been a happy one. So far, the most that has been achieved are ceasefires after military victories by one side or the other: Armenian victory in the war of 1992-94, Azerbaijani victory in the war of 2020.

However, a radical change of stance by the government of Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan now appears to offer a new opportunity for peace — but only if the rights and physical security of the Karabakh Armenians can be guaranteed. This presents a challenge and an opportunity for the United States, the European Union, and the United Nations.

Pashinyan, who came to power following the 2018 “Velvet Revolution,” effected a major shift in Armenia’s position on a final settlement by offering to recognize the territorial boundaries of Azerbaijan, including Nagorno-Karabakh  — something his predecessors had always sought to avoid.

While speaking to reporters on May 22 in Yerevan, Armenia’s capital, Pashinyan noted that he is seeking an “international mechanism” for dialogue between Baku and the Karabakh Armenians to ensure the latter’s rights and security if and when an agreement is signed.

Recent weeks have indeed seen a flurry of separate high-level talks between Armenia and Azerbaijan, brokered by the United States, the European Union, and Russia — none of which has yet produced the much-sought-after comprehensive peace deal. The ultimate success of any agreement is also a domestic issue for the United States and France, given the large and politically powerful Armenian diasporas in both countries.

Tens of thousands of indigenous Armenians remain in Nagorno-Karabakh, despite the second war over the disputed region when Azerbaijan, backed by Turkey, conquered some territory in the enclave itself, as well as the surrounding regions that Armenian forces had captured during the first war. This was then consummated in a Russian-brokered ceasefire in November 2020 which guaranteed further territorial gains for Azerbaijan in and around the enclave. Since then, the remainder of Armenian-controlled Nagorno-Karabakh has been protected, albeit inadequately, by Russian peacekeepers under the oft-violated ceasefire. 

Getting to a final peace accord on Pashinyan’s terms won’t be easy. Since last December, Azerbaijan, first through state–backed “eco-activists” and more recently with the construction of a checkpoint, has been effectively blockading the only road connecting Nagorno-Karabakh to Armenia and the outside world. This action, widely condemned (including by the International Court of Justice), has resulted in an already-threatened population suffering severe shortages of energy, medicine, and food. The International Committee of the Red Cross, which was still able to enter Nagorno-Karabakh before Azerbaijan installed the checkpoint, is now reporting difficulties in entering the enclave and delivering essential aid, although medical evacuations appear to be resuming. 

Washington should now consider how it can facilitate the delivery of humanitarian aid to the Karabakh Armenians, whether via an airlift or other means.

It is crucial that the United States and the EU — having already chosen to reinvigorate the diplomatic process between the two nations — press for an agreement that will secure the appropriate protection of the indigenous population through internationally-backed dialogue between Karabakh Armenians’ leaders and Azerbaijani authorities. If the re-incorporation of Nagorno-Karabakh into Azerbaijan were to lead to the ethnic cleansing of its Armenian population, Armenians both in the Republic of Armenia itself and in the diaspora would never accept the result. Armenia would most likely do what Azerbaijan did between 1994 and 2020 — re-arm in order to resume the war at some favorable moment in the future.

The consequences (not least for the U.S.) of an agreement that fails to at least include guarantees that Pashinyan is seeking for the Karabakh Armenians will almost certainly result in further bloodshed that could eventually draw in other regional powers, including Iran, Turkey, Israel, and, of course, Russia, which is not keen to see its presence in the South Caucasus diminished.

Already, and despite the obvious current reality of Azerbaijani military superiority and Russia’s apparent inability to strictly enforce the 2020 ceasefire terms, Pashinyan is taking a colossal political risk by his shift in Armenian policy. Given that previous governments in Yerevan pursued a policy akin to strategic ambiguity – never officially recognizing the de facto state in Nagorno-Karabakh that Armenians call the Republic of Artsakh, while also acting as its main patron and guarantor – Pashinyan’s new proposal has come as a most unwelcome surprise to his population.

According to a recent poll by the International Republican Institute, almost seven in ten Armenians disapprove of their government’s policy towards Nagorno-Karabakh. In another poll taken last November, virtually no one supported the incorporation of Nagorno-Karabakh into Azerbaijan. For its part, the de facto government in Nagorno-Karabakh has voiced its strong opposition to Pashinyan’s policy.

It will be the responsibility of Pashinyan and his government to explain to Armenians why the current reality is not in their country’s favor and how to reconcile this situation with their previous policy declarations. But Washington, along with the EU and the UN, should test the viability of Pashinyan’s initiative by pressing Azerbaijan for the guarantees he seeks regarding the rights and security of Karabakh Armenians so as to push forward the overall negotiations and the anticipated agreement’s approval by Armenia’s state structures if and when one is reached.

According to Benyamin Poghosyan, Chairman of the Center for Political and Economic Strategic Studies and Senior Research Fellow at APRI, a Yerevan-based think tank, the only way to achieve stability is by convincing Azerbaijan to accept an “international presence” in Nagorno-Karabakh. Indeed, Anders Fogh Rasmussen, former Secretary General of NATO from 2009 to 2014, during a recent visit to Armenia stated that “we will need to have a kind of an international mechanism to monitor, control and guarantee those rights and security for the people of Nagorno-Karabakh.”

While Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev insists that Karabakh Armenians will be given the same rights as all Azerbaijani citizens – not the most enticing assurance given his regime’s notoriously repressive human rights record – he has opposed an international presence on the grounds that any discussion regarding Nagorno-Karabakh constitutes interference in Baku’s internal affairs. Aliyev’s recent comments on the subject epitomize his maximalist position.

However, the U.S. possesses diplomatic and economic leverage – such as the ability to revoke the Section 907 waiver, suspend Department of Defense military sales and support to Azerbaijan, and impose visa bans  – over Aliyev and his cronies that could be utilized as a stick behind closed doors to encourage Baku’s cooperation.

Given the increased attention to the conflict by the EU, which recently sent a two-year civilian monitoring mission to the Armenian side of the border with Azerbaijan, Brussels has an opportunity to assume more responsibility in the region, with U.S. backing. Given the increase in tensions between Moscow and the West, Russia is highly likely to oppose any Western-dominated peacekeeping operation. Thus, the Biden administration should consider advocating for the deployment of a long-term UN peacekeeping force recruited of neutral states to act as guarantors of a final peace accord and the rights and security of Karabakh Armenians.

A neutral UN presence is necessitated by Russia’s position. Having inserted its peacekeeping forces into Nagorno-Karabakh with a five-year mandate, as stipulated by the ceasefire agreement, Russia’s leadership accuses the West of pushing for an agreement between the two parties designed to remove Russia’s presence and influence from the South Caucasus while it is distracted by its war in Ukraine. In subsequent deliberations, the West should make clear that this is not its intention given that facilitating a final settlement between Armenia and Azerbaijan is challenging enough as it is.