Portantino-Chaired Committee Examines Trade, Technology and Travel Relations between California and Armenia

Senator Anthony Portantino chairs a special meeting of the Select Committee on Armenia and Artsakh on June 12


SACRAMENTO – The Select Senate Committee on California, Armenia and Artsakh Mutual Trade, Art and Cultural Exchange chaired by Senator Anthony Portantino (D–Burbank) held an informational hearing on Monday titled California and Armenia: Trade, Technology and Travel Exchange. Topics of discussion included the need for direct flights and increased air cargo capacity between Los Angeles and Armenia, the California-Armenia Trade and Services Desk, and technology incubators in the City of Glendale.
 
“We had an important conversation on how to improve trade and technology exchanges between California and Armenia,” stated Senator Portantino. “We also discussed the need for establishing direct flights between Yerevan and Los Angeles due to the large and vibrant Armenian community in my district. I am thankful to all the participants who provided testimony and critical insight on how California can strengthen our economic relations with Armenia.”
 
The hearing began with an update on the California Trade and Services Desk in Armenia. In 2019, Governor Newsom and Armenia’s Foreign Minister Zohrab Mnatsakanyan signed a Memorandum of Understanding at the Armenian Mission to the United Nations in New York City formally establishing the California Trade and Services Desk in Armenia. As the facilitator of the trade desk agreement, Senator Portantino was in New York for the historic event. In 2021, the Senator also represented California for the placement of the California State Seal at Impact Hub in Yerevan. The Select Committee’s hearing provided an opportunity for representatives from Impact Hub, the official host of the California Trade and Services Desk, to give the State Senate an update on the economic developments and opportunities that have been generated from the agreement.
 
Additionally, the hearing included a report from the City of Glendale on its efforts to create a tech hub in Southern California. Glendale was represented by Mayor Dan Brotman who detailed the local tech scene and Glendale’s Tech Week.
 
“I would like to thank Senator Portantino for holding an informational hearing on how we can deepen our economic ties with Armenia and Artsakh,” stated Glendale City Mayor Dan Brotman. “I would also like to thank him for entrusting Glendale with a $1,000,000 grant to launch two technology accelerators, including Hero House. By combining the great work of Hero House with our Tech Week, Tech on Tap and other programs to support and connect entrepreneurs from around the world, we hope to build a technology ecosystem in Glendale that will strengthen the entire economy of Los Angeles County and Southern California.”
 
The hearing provided the Select Committee with the opportunity to hear directly from Hero House, a tech incubator who was the recipient of a $500,000 state grant, about how it expended the state resources and the positive outcomes it generated. Armine Galstyan, Managing Director of Hero House, gave an impressive and detailed summary of the economic activity stimulated by the grant.
 
“In 2020, SmartGateVC received a $500K grant from the Governor’s Office of Business & Economic Development to establish a startup accelerator in Glendale, California. SmartGateVC is an early-stage AI fund focused on investing and launching promising companies in California. The accelerator program in Glendale supported 33 companies from 10 countries, serving as a launch pad for their entry into the US market. These companies have already raised over $6M in funding, enabling them to establish operations in Glendale and some even relocated their headquarters to Hero House Glendale. The program garnered recognition for Hero House and supported companies in prestigious publications such as Time Magazine, Forbes, and others. Through strategic partnerships with local universities, research labs, tech players, and corporate entities, SmartGateVC continues to foster a collaborative environment for exploring technology and innovation,” stated Armine Galstyan, Principal at SmartGateVC.

The final topic of discussion centered around the need for a direct flight from Los Angeles to Yerevan. The 25th State Senate District is home to the largest concentration of Armenian Americans in LA County, while California is home to the most Armenian Americans in the country.  Armenia is popular destination for both travel and exchange of goods. Currently, a number of airlines offer flights from California to Armenia through transfers in other cities. 
 
“Access to a global pool of amazing talent is key to the success of any tech hub like Los Angeles. That’s why connecting LA to Yerevan with a direct flight makes complete sense and is long overdue. Over the past year, dot818 has been working with major US airlines, legislators, as well as LA-based tech companies with offices in Armenia, such as Plat.AI, to make LAX-EVN a reality within the next two years,” stated David Tonoyan, CEO of Dot818, a technology-building company.
 
At the request of Senator Portantino, the California State Senate Rules Committee first established the historic Senate Select Committee on California, Armenia, and Artsakh Mutual Trade, Art, and Cultural Exchange in 2017 to expand business opportunities through trade, economic development, cultural awareness, and education between California, Armenia, and Artsakh.
 
Members of the Senate Select Committee on California, Armenia, and Artsakh Mutual Trade, Art, and Cultural Exchange include Senator Bob Archuleta (D-Pico Rivera), Senator María Elena Durazo (D-Los Angeles), Senator Melissa Hurtado (D-Sanger), Senator Brian W. Jones (R-Santee), Senator Susan Rubio (D-Baldwin Park), Senator Henry I. Stern (D-Los Angeles), Senator Scott Wiener (D-San Francisco), Senator Caroline Menjivar (D- San Fernando Valley), and Senator Scott Wilk (R-Santa Clarita).

EU Leader Calls Azerbaijani Checkpoint at Lachin Corridor Counterproductive

The EU’s foreign affairs chief speaks at the European Parliament on June 13


The European Union’s foreign affairs chief, Josep Borrell, said Azerbaijan’s checkpoint installed at the Lachin Corridor runs counter to efforts to build trust between Armenia and Azerbaijan.

“Azerbaijan’s unilateral decision to install this checkpoint completely contradicts efforts to build trust between the parties,” said Borrell, who was asked on Tuesday by a European Parliament Member Francois Xavier Bellamy about the EU inability to condemn Baku for its action, Armenpress reported.

“The Court of Justice has condemned the blockade by Azerbaijan, but this state terrorism has not led to any sanctions by the Council, and the Commission seems unable to properly condemn this very serious violation of the fundamental rights of the people of Nagorno-Karabakh,” Bellamy said during a discussion in the European Parliament entitled “Relations between Armenia and Azerbaijan and the situation in Nagorno-Karabakh and the Lachin Corridor.”

“There are territories, border areas with Armenia, from where it can be seen what is happening in the Lachin Corridor, but the corridor itself is outside the jurisdiction of the mission and their area of responsibility. Now we are trying to find a solution for this specific problem,” Borrell said.

According to Borrell, the current situation in the Lachin Corridor certainly raises the concern of the international community, but the EU does not have access to the checkpoint located in the corridor, therefore it is deprived of the opportunity to carry out a full observation.

“The EU is interested in the establishment of peace in the South Caucasus, and for this purpose it implements initiatives of a humanitarian nature, as well as contributes directly to the negotiations aimed at peace. We are also involved in finding missing persons during the conflict and keeping the conflicting parties away from new clashes,” Borrell said.

In response to Bellamy’s question, Borrell said that efforts are underway to resolve the Armenian-Azerbaijani conflict and the parties have also expressed readiness to continue negotiations.

Borrell emphasized that a very important meeting between the French President, the German Chancellor, the President of the European Council and leaders of Armenia and Azerbaijan took place in Moldova recently.

The meeting mentioned by Borrell did not result in a condemnation by EU leaders of Azerbaijan for its illegal breach of agreements and threats to the lives of Armenians in Artsakh.

Yet the EU’s foreign policy chief invoked statements made following recent meetings between Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan and President Ilham Aliyev of Azerbaijan as signs of progress.

Borrell referred to announcement by Pashinyan and Aliyev to recognize each other’s territorial integrity, as well as Pashinyan’s later remarks where he said that Armenia has accepted Artsakh as a constituent part of Azerbaijan as a signal to Azerbaijan to pay more attention to the rights and security issues of the people of Karabakh.

“We hope that the message of the Armenian side will be an incentive, pushing the negotiation process to a positive direction,” Borrell said.

The EU’s top diplomat also said that the EU mission in Armenia is part of the peace process between Armenia and Azerbaijan, but it cannot completely replace the process. The only solution, he said, is within the diplomatic sphere.

“The conflicting parties have expressed their desire to continue the negotiations, and the next meeting will be held in Brussels, from which the EU has high expectations,” Borrell said.

He noted that the socio-economic situation in Nagorno-Karabakh is quite serious, which is why the EU has implemented various initiatives in the last two years to provide humanitarian support to the local residents, explaining that 70 million euros have already been allocated for this purpose.

Borrell said that the humanitarian support was aimed at solving health problems, including providing medical equipment and providing social support to people affected by the conflict. Borrell emphasized that there is still a lot to be done in that area.

Asbarez: Azerbaijani Forces Bar Armenians from Entering Artsakh

An illegal checkpoint, installed by Azerbaijan, on the Lachin Corridor

Azerbaijanis manning the illegal checkpoint at the Lachin Corridor barred two women and a child from entering Artsakh, the country’s Human Rights Defender said in a social media post, explaining that the three Armenian citizens had resided in Artsakh and were in Armenia to receive treatment.

“These individuals went to the Republic of Armenia to receive treatment during the blockade, and now, after resolving their health issues, they cannot return to their homes,” the Artsakh Human Rights Defender’s office said in the post. “It is worth noting that the Azerbaijani side allowed their exit from Artsakh, arbitrarily and illegally prohibiting their entry.”

“As a result of the harassment by Azerbaijan, the rights of these individuals were violated not only to move freely, but also to reunite with their families,” the rights defender’s office said in an statement.

The Human Rights Defender emphasized that the checkpoint illegally installed by Azerbaijan on the Hakari bridge in Lachin Corridor from April 23 and other measures hindering the free movement of people, vehicles and goods on that road violate not only well-known international norms of human rights, “but also the provisions of the tripartite declaration of November 9, 2020, in particular, point 6, which envisages the safe and uninterrupted movement of people, vehicles and cargo through the Lachin Corridor.”

“Azerbaijan is trying to mislead the international community with various propaganda videos, showing that the corridor is not blocked and the free movement of people is ensured,” the statement said.

“The existence of such a checkpoint, the use of passport, cargo and other types of control measures by Azerbaijan already mean obstacles to uninterrupted movement, causing significant risks not only of security, but also bearing the risk for other arbitrary disruptive measures at any given time,” the human rights defender emphasized, adding that this latest breach is yet another sign of Azerbaijan’s efforts to ethnically cleanse Artsakh of its Armenian population.

RFE/RL Armenian Report – 06/13/2023

                                        Tuesday, 
Armenian Police Accused Of Beating Up Another Lawyer
        • Naira Bulghadarian
Armenia - Lawyer Karen Alaverdian speaks at a news conference in Yerevan, June 
13, 2023.
Another Armenian lawyer on Tuesday claimed to have been beaten up by police 
officers while representing a criminal suspect.
The lawyer, Karen Alaverdian, said he was subjected to “undue physical force,” 
handcuffed and detained after trying to stop several officers kicking and 
punching his client at a police station in Yerevan last week.
The Armenian police launched an internal inquiry into the incident. 
Nevertheless, Alaverdian was charged with “hooliganism” and obstruction of 
legitimate police actions.
The lawyer said that he simply refused to leave the police station after 
intervening to stop the alleged torture of his client who is currently standing 
trial on unspecified criminal charges.
The chairman of Armenia’s Chamber of Advocates, the national bar association, 
voiced support for Alaverdian and said the police had no right to evict him from 
the police station during the suspect’s interrogation. “The lawyer did his job,” 
Simon Babayan told a joint news conference with Alaverdian.
Two other lawyers claimed to have been ill-treated at another Yerevan police 
station in February. They said the violence occurred after their teenage client 
stood by his allegations that he was beaten up in police custody.
The Chamber of Advocates demanded at the time that law-enforcement authorities 
investigate the allegations and prosecute “all guilty persons.” No police 
officer is known to have been charged, fired or subjected to disciplinary action 
over that incident.
Human rights activists say police torture in Armenia remains widespread despite 
police reforms declared by the Armenian government.
A government bill enacted as part of those reforms three years ago called for 
surveillance cameras to be installed inside all police stations -- and their 
interrogation rooms in particular -- by 2023. Only ten police stations were 
equipped with such cameras. They were switched off in last July on then national 
police chief Vahe Ghazarian s orders.
The police said the cameras are no longer needed because under another law 
enacted last year, suspects detained by police officers must be interrogated by 
another law-enforcement body, the Investigative Committee.
Dashnaktsutyun Vows Protests Against ‘Karabakh’s Surrender’
        • Ruzanna Stepanian
Armenia - Dashnaktsutyun party leader Ishkhan Saghatelian speaks during a news 
conference in Yerevan, .
The Armenian Revolutionary Federation (Dashnaktsutyun) said on Tuesday that it 
will join forces with other opposition groups to stage protests against Prime 
Minister Nikol Pashinian’s plans to sign a peace deal upholding Azerbaijani 
sovereignty over Nagorno-Karabakh.
“What Pashinian announced is not a peace treaty, it’s a new capitulation,” said 
Ishkhan Saghatelian, Dashnaktsutyun’s top leader in Armenia. “If it’s signed, it 
will have disastrous and tragic consequences for the Armenian people. The only 
way to prevent it is to organize a popular revolt and resistance front.”
“Nikol Pashinian has no mandate to hand over Artsakh to Azerbaijan,” he told a 
news conference.
Saghatelian said that his party will try to initiate such a popular movement 
together with other opposition groups, including those not represented in the 
Armenian parliament. The opposition demonstrations will start this summer, he 
said without giving concrete dates.
Saghatelian spoke on behalf of Dashnaktsutyun, rather than the main opposition 
Hayastan alliance, of which his party is a key member. Other Hayastan leaders 
have also condemned Pashinian for effectively recognizing Karabakh as part of 
Azerbaijan. But the alliance headed by former President Robert Kocharian has not 
yet announced plans for renewed antigovernment protests sought by Dashnaktsutyun.
Hayastan and Pativ Unem, the other opposition bloc represented in the 
parliament, jointly staged daily protests in Yerevan in May and June last year 
after Pashinian signaled readiness to “lower the bar” on Karabakh’s status 
acceptable to his government. They claim to have delayed a “capitulation 
agreement” with Baku despite failing to topple Pashinian.
Saghatelian admitted on Tuesday that the Armenian opposition’s 2022 bid for 
regime change did not attract sufficient popular support. But he expressed 
confidence that the opposition will pull larger crowds this time around.
“Last year, many people did not quite understand what’s going on and accused us 
of fighting for power,” said Saghatelian. “But now, I think, it’s clear to 
everyone that the guy [Pashinian] … is going down the path of making Artsakh a 
part of Azerbaijan.”
Armenia Also Fears Another Escalation In Karabakh
Russian military vehicles roll along a road towards Nagorno-Karabakh, November 
13, 2020.
The Azerbaijani military may be gearing up for another attack on 
Nagorno-Karabakh, the Armenian government claimed on Tuesday.
Tensions along the Armenian-Azerbaijani border and “the line of contact” around 
Karabakh have been steadily rising despite major progress reportedly made in 
peace talks between Baku and Yerevan. The conflicting sides accuse each other of 
violating the ceasefire on a virtually daily basis.
Baku regularly claims that Azerbaijani troops opened fire to stop Karabakh 
Armenian forces from fortifying their positions. The authorities in Stepanakert 
dismiss this as a smokescreen for justifying systematic Azerbaijani gunfire at 
Karabakh farmers and their tractors engaged in agricultural work. A senior 
Karabakh official said late last week that Baku may thus be plotting another 
upsurge in violence.
On Saturday, Azerbaijan’s Defense Minister Zakir Hasanov ordered his troops 
stationed in and around Karabakh to be prepared to “thwart provocations at any 
moment.” Hasanov’s ministry issued on Tuesday a statement saying that they stand 
ready to do that.
The Armenian Foreign Ministry pointed, meanwhile, to the “fake news” about 
Armenian ceasefire violations spread by Baku. It said it has “extremely serious 
concerns that Azerbaijan’s military-political leadership … is preparing the 
ground for carrying out fresh aggressive actions and ethnic cleansing in 
Nagorno-Karabakh.”
“We call on the Russian peacekeeping forces to strictly monitor compliance with 
the ceasefire regime and investigate all incidents claimed by Azerbaijan, 
publicly presenting the actual state of affairs,” the ministry added in a 
statement.
It also renewed Yerevan’s calls for the dispatch of an international 
fact-finding mission to Karabakh and the launch of an internationally mediated 
dialogue between Baku and Stepanakert.
The Azerbaijani Foreign Ministry dismissed the Armenian claims and accused 
Armenia of meddling in Azerbaijan’s internal affairs.
“Instead of hindering peace efforts and making false statements, Armenia should 
respect the sovereignty and territorial integrity of Azerbaijan, of which the 
Karabakh region is a part,” it said.
Baku also demanded Yerevan “immediately withdraw Armenian army units from 
Azerbaijan’s territory.” Armenia has repeatedly denied any military presence in 
Karabakh.
The rising tensions contrast with a recent series of peace talks during which 
Armenia and Azerbaijan narrowed their differences on a bilateral peace treaty 
discussed by them.
The foreign ministers of the two states were due to meet in Washington on June 
12 for further U.S.-mediated discussions on the treaty. The Foreign Ministry in 
Yerevan said last week that the meeting was postponed “at the request of the 
Azerbaijani side.”
Armenian parliament speaker Alen Simonian on Tuesday linked the delay to Turkish 
President Recep Tayyip Erdogan’s latest visit to Baku.
Reposted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2023 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
 

RFE/RL Armenian Report – 06/12/2023

                                        Monday, 
Armenian Ruling Party Member Not Prosecuted For Death Threats
        • Susan Badalian
        • Satenik Kaghzvantsian
Armenia - Civil Contract party member Suren Torosian.
A local government official affiliated with Armenia’s ruling Civil Contract 
party is prosecuted for assaulting a fellow villager but is not yet facing 
charges stemming from his recent threats to “shoot” Prime Minister Nikol 
Pashinian’s detractors.
Suren Torosian, who is in charge of utility services in Aragatsavan, a large 
village 80 kilometers northwest of Yerevan, sparked an angry demonstration there 
on June 7 after allegedly spraying a local man with tear gas and repeatedly 
hitting him with a stick during an argument. Armen Sahakian, the 24-year-old 
man, suffered a head injury and received urgent treatment in hospital.
Dozens of other Aragatsavan residents blocked a highway leading to Yerevan to 
demand Torosian’s arrest and prosecution. They were especially furious with the 
fact that Sahakian was assaulted despite suffering from serious chronic diseases.
“Is this the rule of law created by Civil Contract?” one of the protesters told 
RFE/RL’s Armenian Service.
Torosian was promptly detained and charged with assault only to be set free 
hours later. Armenia’s Investigative Committee said the assault charge leveled 
against him is not serious enough to warrant his pre-trial arrest.
Armenia -- Aragatsavan resident Armen Sahakian, June 8, 2023.
The incident drew media attention to the content of Torosian’s Facebook page 
and, in particular, an angry video message posted by the official there this 
month. In that message, the ruling party member lashes out at Pashinian’s vocal 
critics, saying that he “will have their ears cut off” and “kick them in the 
face.”
“If we force a couple of such types to lie down and drag them along the ground, 
everything will get fixed … I will shoot them in the forehead,” he says.
Torosian, who got his current job after the 2018 “velvet revolution” that 
brought Pashinian to power, goes on to urge the heads of regional divisions of 
Armenia’s police and National Security Service to “drag” the prime minister’s 
detractors out of their homes.
A spokesman for the Investigative Committee said on Monday the law-enforcement 
agency has not opened a criminal case in connection with the death threats 
because it has not received a formal “crime report.”
For its part, the Office of the Prosecutor-General told RFE/RL’s Armenian 
Service that it will comment on legal consequences of the threats only in 
response to a written inquiry.
Armenia - Suren Torosian airs a video message on Facebook.
Civil Contract has still not reacted to its member’s public calls for violence.
The governor of Aragatsotn province encompassing Aragatsavan, who is also 
affiliated with Pashinian’s party, on Monday criticized those calls and pledged 
to initiate a “discussion” of Torosian’s conduct. “His words weren’t normal, in 
my view,” said Sergei Movsisian.
Torosian also revealed in the same scandalous video that he recently gave a ride 
to an 8-year-old boy who turned out to be a refugee from Nagorno-Karabakh. He 
said he stopped his car on a highway outside Aragatsavan and ordered the boy to 
“get out” after the latter said that his family fled Karabakh because “traitor 
Nikol gave away our lands.”
Torosian then pledged to “deal with” the boy’s parents working in the public 
sector of another rural community. “We will throw such people out of the 
sector,” he said.
Armenian Church Again Warns Against ‘Humiliating’ Peace Deal
Armenia - Members of the Armenian Apostolic Church's Supreme Spiritual Council 
pose for a photo after a meeting in Echmiadzin, June 8, 2023.
The Armenian Apostolic Church has again denounced Prime Minister Nikol 
Pashinian’s policy on the conflict with Azerbaijan and said Armenia must again 
champion Nagorno-Karabakh’s right to self-determination.
The church expressed serious concern over the “difficult situation created in 
the country's life” in a weekend statement on a regular session of its Supreme 
Spiritual Council (SSC) chaired by Catholicos Garegin II.
“It was emphasized [during the meeting] that the authorities of Armenia should 
renounce actions that violate the dignity of the nation and oppose the 
humiliating ambitions and demands of foreign enemies with realistic and 
exclusively pro-Armenian positions, resolutely defending the non-negotiable 
right of the people of Artsakh to self-determination,” it said.
“The SSC expressed its support to the people and authorities of Artsakh, noting 
also that the just right of the people of Artsakh to live freely and 
independently will find protection in all national frameworks,” added the 
statement.
The SSC held another, emergency meeting late last month. It joined Karabakh’s 
leadership and the Armenian opposition in condemning Pashinian for his readiness 
to sign a peace deal recognizing Karabakh as part of Azerbaijan. It said that 
the restoration of Azerbaijan rule would leave the Karabakh Armenians facing a 
“new genocide and loss of the homeland.”
The church also openly criticized the Armenian government’s Karabakh policy last 
fall. Garegin authorized an Armenian archbishop to address an opposition rally 
in Yerevan that warned Pashinian against recognizing Azerbaijani sovereignty 
over Karabakh.
Tensions between the ancient church and Pashinian have deepened further since 
then. Last month, the prime minister accused the church of meddling in politics, 
prompting a scathing response from Garegin’s office.
Baku, Yerevan Make Conflicting Statements On Transport Links
        • Ruzanna Stepanian
Armenia - Russian border guards stationed in Syunik province are inspected by 
Russian Ambassador Sergei Kopyrkin, May 24, 2022.
Despite major progress reported during their most recent talks, senior Armenian 
and Azerbaijani officials made over the weekend conflicting statements on the 
practical modalities of planned transport links between their countries.
Azerbaijan’s Deputy Prime Minister Shahin Mustafayev said that in line with the 
Russian-brokered agreement that stopped the 2020 war in Nagorno-Karabakh Russian 
border guards will oversee “unfettered” commercial traffic between Azerbaijan 
and its Nakhichevan exclave through Armenia’s Syunik province. He told report.az 
that Baku, Yerevan and Moscow are now working out “technical details” of this 
arrangement.
The office of Armenian Deputy Prime Minister Mher Grigorian countered, however, 
that he and Mustafayev reached no such agreement during their negotiations, 
including a June 2 meeting in Moscow. Citing Article 9 of the ceasefire 
agreement, it said that the planned road and rail links will be under full 
Armenian control.
The clause in question stipulates that the Russian border guards stationed in 
Armenia will “control” the transit of people, vehicles and goods between 
Nakhichevan and the rest of Azerbaijan.
The Sputnik news agency quoted Russia’s Deputy Prime Minister Alexei Overchuk as 
saying in this regard on Friday that Moscow and Baku are not questioning 
Armenian sovereignty over those transit routes. Asked about the possible role of 
the Russian border guards, he said that it depends on the Armenian side.
The issue topped the agenda of Russian President Vladimir Putin’s trilateral 
meeting with Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian and Azerbaijani President 
Ilham Aliyev held in Moscow on May 25.
Mustafayev, Grigorian and Overchuk met in the Russian capital on June 2 to try 
to settle what Putin called “purely technical” issues hampering the opening of 
the Armenian-Azerbaijani border to commercial traffic. According to an Armenian 
government statement, they made “substantial progress” on the functioning of the 
railway leading to Nakhichevan.
Reposted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2023 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.