​Alexander Arkhangelsky: “Russia’s position causes resentment in Armenia”

Armenia – June 13 2023

Alexander Arkhangelsky: “Russia’s position causes resentment in Armenia”

Interview of writer Alexander Arkhangelsky with Mediamax

 

In spring you announced about launching a new project with Tatyana Sorokina and about raising funds “for a future film about a Sardinian who became a Russian hieromonk and an expert in the ancient Armenian church, and about where one’s Homeland in the world of the new nomad is.”

 

It is Father Giovanni (John) Guaita. He is an expert in the ancient Armenian church, and he interviewed Catholicos Karekin I. I really hope this book will be republished, because it is an amazing book.

 

Of course, it will not be a tourist film. We will get on a plane with him, travel here, and look at Armenia through his eyes as a country that has learned to maintain the sense of Homeland across all borders, dropping out of history, returning to history.

 

There are times when emigration is useless and times when it is useful. What does useless mean? It is when people simply save themselves and do not integrate into the cultures of the surrounding countries: either they dissolve in them completely, or begin to preserve everything completely, as it was in their Homeland.

 

Russia has entered a dramatic period – this is a new wave of emigration, and mass emigration in one stratum. If you count on 140 million inhabitants of Russia – it is still bearable, but it is emigration in one stratum, in one circle, in several major cities, and of course, these losses will be very tangible.

 

Those Russians who have come to Armenia over the past 1.5 years, in a good way, level out the problems that exist today in relations between Armenia and Russia, the problems that have become obvious after the 2020 war. To simplify, has something deteriorated in relations between Armenia and Russia?

 

Which Armenia and which Russia are we talking about? About political Armenia and political Russia?

 

First of all, yes.

 

A lot has changed. And dramatic changes are still taking place today.

 

It is obvious that Armenia is discussing a tragic option for itself. Perhaps what we see – a negotiated option – is politically necessary, I do not know, I am not a politician. But from a cultural and historical point of view, this is a tragic option for Armenia. What the negotiators propose to Armenia – the choice of reconciliation after what happened, is a tragedy.

 

It is not for me to give advice on what is right or wrong. I am just compassionate. This is the only possible position from the outside. Russia, of course, played and would still like to play a big role. It tried to play some positive role, but then it simply had no time for Armenia. Armenia was left to the mercy of fate, alone with the war.

 

But as soon as Western players appeared, able to take that negotiating position, Russia immediately began to return.

 

I felt resentment in people, it felt like a betrayal. I often visit Armenia, talk to people a lot, and I do not know if there is such love for Russia and Russians anywhere else. Now I am not speaking about politicians, but about people, about communities.

 

The Russian position is first dictating its interests too harshly, then stepping aside, not wanting to consider interests of Armenia. People outside the political field have felt this. Human destinies are the third aspect. Armenia has opened its doors to a huge number of Russians. It would be unfair if the Russians who have found refuge in Armenia will not respond to this with not just love, but solidarity and all they can respond with by being here and now, testifying before the world about the troubles Armenia is facing.

 

I do not think there has ever been anything like this before – extremely hard political divergence and extremely close convergence of human destinies: two processes on which we are now swinging like on a seesaw.

 

Since you often come here, do you have an understanding: does Armenia know what it wants?

 

I know that Armenia knows what it does not want. It does not want more war, it is tired. There is still heroism, and we know examples of this incredible heroism, but I have a feeling that the country is tired of the state of war. What it is ready to do to make sure there is no war, I do not know, I will have to accept the choice that Armenia will make.

 

But Russian politicians must firmly say where their interest lies. They must decide for a long term, not immediately, regardless of what elections are coming up, what elections have taken place, whether “environmentalists” appeared in the Lachin direction, or disappeared.

 

After February 24, 2022, Russia simply “gave up” on this process – forgive me for not a very nice word, but it is true. Was Russia engaged in the Armenian “plot” after February 24, 2022? I have a feeling that it was not, but then, feeling that the West came as a new negotiator, it decided to return quickly, to interfere with the West, but whether to help Armenia – I do not know.

 

In 2009, you wrote: “What should we prefer: habitual but proud stagnation in the very important but strategically unpromising myths of the 20th century or a change of cultural fate? A change of fate, or a conversion of centuries of history into modern realities? Closure in a provincial identity or playing ahead of history – without losing memory and identity? In this sense Russia and Armenia, for all their differences in scale and reality, are in the same phase. It is a dramatic phase. And a key one. Here and there, we are caught between our homebrew and our aspirations for a future that cannot be realized outside the space of world civilization, where we all want and need to go, where we seem to be enticed, but where they do not really wait for us.

 

Unless we know that you wrote this 14 years ago, it may seem that it has been written these days. Do you see any opportunities for a new rapprochement between Armenia and Russia in the political sense?

 

– I can look at the situation through the eyes of Russian politicians: “we would rather deal with the knot that we have tied and cannot untie, we are in a state of half-decay, we risk losing the unity of our country, well, what role can we play?”

 

Of course, Russia wants to keep control of this part of the earth – I am now calling things by their proper names. But we cannot put military, economic, or political resources into it. Armenia is a small country, it needs to understand with who it interacts, who is a strong supporter and who is a weak supporter, and who pretends to be a supporter. Of course, Armenia will maneuver, and this maneuvering will cause even more irritation and rejection among Russian elites.

 

I do not believe in rapprochement, except in the field of culture. In the field of science, humanitarian projects – I do, in political – I do not.

 

Is it realistic to expect that in conditions where there is no normal interaction between political elites, contacts between people can maintain some level of relations? Relatively speaking, if Russia, the Russian leadership decides to turn its back on Armenia, it seems to me that no cultural contacts will be able to influence this decision.

 

If I believed that political processes and political elites are eternal, I would totally agree with you. But they change. And that’s what I am hoping for. Cultural, human contacts by themselves will not solve anything, and have never solved anything during history. But they can save the ground for a future reversal. And this elite will be gone. Everything will change. The question is whether these contacts will remain, whether these knots will remain. I am a cautious optimist as far as the grassroots are concerned, and a total pessimist as far as the top is concerned.

 

Ara Tadevosyan spoke with Alexander Arkhangelsky

 

This interview was prepared as part of a joint project with the Tufenkian Foundation

Turkey Ready To Open General Consulate In Nagorno-Karabakh – Erdogan

June 13 2023

 

Turkey is ready to open a general consulate in the city of Shusha in the disputed Nagorno-Karabakh region, which could be a message to the whole world and Armenia, in particular, Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan said on Tuesday

ANKARA (UrduPoint News / Sputnik – 13th June, 2023) Turkey is ready to open a general consulate in the city of Shusha in the disputed Nagorno-Karabakh region, which could be a message to the whole world and Armenia, in particular, Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan said on Tuesday.

“We are ready to open our general consulate in Shusha at any time. (Turkish Foreign Minister) Mr. Hakan (Fidan) will work on the matter without any delay. If our general consulate is opened in Shusha, it will send a message to the whole world and especially to Armenia,” Erdogan was quoted as saying by Turkish newspaper Star.

The Turkish consulate in Shusha could be the country’s third in Azerbaijan, with the two others located in the second-largest city, Ganja, as well as in Nakhchivan.

The decades-long conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan over Nagorno-Karabakh flared up again in September 2020, marking the worst escalation since the 1990s. During the fighting, Azerbaijani forces seized control of Shusha and several other areas in the region. Hostilities ended with a Russia-brokered trilateral ceasefire declaration signed in November 2020. The two former Soviet countries agreed to the deployment of Russian peacekeepers in the region. Since then, there have been occasional clashes along the border.

https://www.urdupoint.com/en/world/turkey-ready-to-open-general-consulate-in-nag-1707965.html

Yerevan says Armenian positions shelled by Azerbaijani troops

 TASS 
Russia – June 13 2023
According to the press service of the Armenian defense ministry, the Azerbaijani army units opened fire from firearms of various caliber at the Armenian positions located near Sotka

YEREVAN, June 12. /TASS/. Azerbaijani troops opened mortar fire at Armenia’s positions near the village of Sotka in the Gegharkunik region, the press service of the Armenian defense ministry said on Monday.

“At 2:15 p.m. (1:15 p.m. Moscow time) on June 12, Azerbaijani army units opened fire from firearms of various caliber at the Armenian positions located near Sotka. They also used a mortar,” it said, adding that no one was hurt.

Artsakh: Numerous companies strive to avoid final closure amid blockade

Panorama
Armenia – June 13 2023

Azerbaijan’s 6+ month blockade of Artsakh (Nagorno-Karabakh) has paralyzed the country’s economy.

11,000 jobs have been cut in Artsakh under the blockade, but it doesn’t provide the full picture.

According to the Artsakh Public TV, numerous businesses are making last-ditch efforts to avoid the final shutdown which would further increase the number of those who have lost their jobs and income.

Azerbaijan has blocked the Lachin Corridor, the sole road in or out of Artsakh, since 12 December 2022.

Azeri forces fire at Armenian border positions, use mortars

Panorama
Armenia – June 13 2023

Azerbaijani troops opened fire on the Armenian army positions near the border villages of Sotk and Tretuk on Tuesday, the Armenia Defense Ministry reported.

“On June 13, from 11:30-11:45 a.m., the units of the Azerbaijani armed forces opened fire from different caliber small arms, also using mortars against the Armenian combat positions in the vicinity of Tretuk and Sotk. The Azerbaijani military also used mortars in the direction of Sotk,” the ministry said in a statement.

No casualties were reported among the Armenian military personnel.

Deputy Yerevan mayor gifted luxury car in 2022

Panorama
Armenia – June 13 2023

Deputy Mayor of Yerevan Tigran Avinyan has submitted an annual declaration of income and assets for 2022 to the Corruption Prevention Commission.

According to the document seen by Hayastan.News, Avinyan received a garage as a gift in 2014, in 2021 he purchased a 2014 Honda car, which he sold for $11,000 in the reporting year.

Avinyan owns a mansion in Yerevan’s Arabkir administrative district. In 2022 he was gifted a Volkswagen car worth 19,000,300 drams (approx. $50,000) by his father, Armen Avinyan.

According to Hayastan.News, Avinyan was gifted a white Volkswagen ID.4 SUV.

The deputy mayor declared 1,890,000 drams on bank accounts, as well as electronic accounts and cryptocurrencies.

He declared $3,000 dollars in cash. At the beginning of the year he had 26,300,000 drams, which reduced to 12,500,000 drams at the end of 2022.

His father also gifted Avinyan property worth 11,000,000 drams.

Tigran Avinyan has a loan of 13,000,000 drams from ARMBUSINESSBANK. He was paid a salary of 5,212,000 drams by the Zangezur Copper Molybdenum Combine (ZCMC) and 3,700,000 drams by the Yerevan Municipality for the period from 23 September 2022 until the end of the year.

Avinyan’s spouse Mariam Pahlavuni owns a mansion and drives a 2017 Range Rover, which she bought in 2020. She has zero drams on her bank account and has declared 1,300,000 drams in cash.

Ara Zohrabyan slams use of force by police against lawyer

Panorama
Armenia – June 13 2023

Ara Zohrabyan, a former chairman of Armenia’s Chamber of Advocates, has denounced the use of force by police officers against a lawyer.

“This is a very dangerous incident. This is the second time something like this has happened,” he told a news conference in Yerevan on Tuesday.

Zohrabyan recalled that they demanded the dismissal of the officers who beat up two lawyers in a police custody in February this year, stressing the need for tougher measures to prevent such incidents in the future.

“This is a terrible act. It’s too much for us to swallow,” Zohrabyan said.

Armenia voices ‘serious concerns’ that Azerbaijan could be preparing new aggression against Nagorno Karabakh

 13:15, 13 June 2023

YEREVAN, JUNE 13, ARMENPRESS. Armenia has serious concerns that Azerbaijan could be preparing the ground for new aggressive actions and ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh, the Foreign Ministry of Armenia said in a statement on June 13.

Below is the full statement released by the foreign ministry.

“For a long time, the Ministry of Defense of Azerbaijan has been spreading daily fake news about ceasefire violations by the Defense Army of Nagorno-Karabakh in the zone of responsibility of Russian peacekeepers in Nagorno-Karabakh.

It is noteworthy that in the information materials published by the Russian peacekeepers, ceasefire violations only by Azerbaijan were recorded.

Taking into account the already well established experience of Azerbaijan to provide “informational support” before carrying out the next acts of use of force and to artificially ascribe responsibility for future actions to the other party from the outset, the Republic of Armenia has serious concerns that the military-political leadership of Azerbaijan, despite all its own obligations, is preparing the ground for another aggressive actions and ethnic cleansing in Nagorno-Karabakh.

We call on the peacekeeping forces of the Russian Federation to strictly follow the observance of the ceasefire regime and investigate all the incidents voiced by Azerbaijan, publicly presenting the entire situation on the ground. 

At the same time, the Republic of Armenia reiterates its position on the necessity to send an international fact-finding mission to Nagorno-Karabakh, which can also provide reliable and unbiased information both about the situation in the line of contact between the sides and about the humanitarian crisis in Nagorno-Karabakh, the latter resulting from Azerbaijan’s disruption of the functioning of the Lachin corridor through setting up an illegal checkpoint in violation of the regime established under November 9, 2020 Statement, blocking natural gas and electricity supplies to Nagorno-Karabakh as well as targeting by the Azerbaijani servicemen of citizens carrying out agricultural works and their machinery.

The Republic of Armenia is convinced that addressing the issues of rights and security of the people of Nagorno-Karabakh within the framework of an international mechanism through the Baku-Stepanakert dialogue is urgent and should not be delayed, and calls on the international community to support this process.”

Sports: Wales opening doors to diverse communities ahead of Armenia fixture

Shropshire Star, Wales
June 14 2023

The Dragons host Armenia in a sold out Euro 2024 qualifier on Friday.

Female football supporters from Wales’ South Asian communities will watch the national team play for the first time on Friday through a new initiative designed to create a more diverse fan base.

The sold-out signs are set to go up for Wales’ Euro 2024 qualifier with Armenia at the Cardiff City Stadium with Rob Page’s side hoping to take another step towards next summer’s finals in Germany.

Among the 33,000-plus capacity crowd will be women benefiting from a partnership between Her Game Too Cymru, Amar Cymru – the group launched in 2020 to give the South Asian community a voice in the national team – and the Football Association of Wales.

Thirty tickets were made available to women from South Asian communities to attend the game. With the offer oversubscribed, fans that missed out have been invited to a Cardiff restaurant on Monday to watch Wales’ Euro qualifier in Turkey.

Roopa Vyas is a director of Her Game Too, the campaign group run by fans to raise awareness of sexism in sport, and has followed the Wales national team at home and abroad.

“We want to show the Red Wall is the friendliest fan base around,” said Caerphilly-born Vyas, who has a Ugandan father and an Indian mother.

“I have gone to games off my own back but I know the barriers that exist and it not easy for people from Muslim, Hindu, Bengali, Somali and other communities to do that.

“Amar Cymru is a progressive group that want to get female fans to games and they came to me as they knew I went to games and could shine a light on it.

I have gone to games off my own back, but I know the barriers that exist and it not easy for some people to do that.

“Hopefully we can go back to the FAW after the game and show them it was successful.”

Shazia Zahoor, born in Cardiff of Pakistani heritage, once played for Dinas Powys Ladies alongside current Wales captain Sophie Ingle and will be among fans experiencing her first international action on Friday.

“I’ve been a football fanatic since I was 13 and wanted to play but the culture did not encourage it,” said Zahoor, who will be joined at the Wales game by her sons Ibrahim, 11, and Zakariya, five.

“Even now I would feel uncomfortable talking to my father about playing football.

“I’m thrilled to be going to a Wales game and taking my two boys. It will be lovely to see other Asian women there because it really is breaking down barriers.”

The FAW want to create a more diverse fan base and has had mascots with South Asian heritage at home games and discussed establishing prayer rooms for fans at the Cardiff City Stadium.

Members of Amar Cymru – which translates to ‘My Wales’ and resonates with the South Indian, Bangladeshi and Punjabi communities – attended a Wales match for the first time in September 2021.

Jalal Goni, the organisation’s founder, says the landscape of Welsh football has changed even in that short time.

“When Amar Cymru started in lockdown it was pre-dominantly made up of males, but Wales being at the World Cup changed things,” said Goni.

“Females were saying how we can watch it and we had an event for the USA game at the World Cup that included arts and crafts and other things for the family as well as the football.

“The World Cup opened up the stadium experience for females. We know the older generation in our communities would not support females going to a male dominated event but we are breaking that stigma down.”

Goni, who will be part of a 10-strong Amar Cymru delegation in Turkey as the group attends a stand-alone Wales away fixture for the first time, added: “There is a lot riding on it.

“Female fans will be dressed differently in head scarves and cultural dresses and we hope there will be no negative comments.

“It is a massive step but the FAW have done a tremendous job in reshaping Welsh football, certainly since Euro 2016.

“Attending Wales games has become more of a family experience and we feel we are ready for this.”

Sports: Cymru [Wales] and Armenia set to clash at Cardiff City Stadium

   June 14 2023
Luke Sinclair

CYMRU and Armenia are set to lock horns at the Cardiff City Stadium on Friday, June 16. Both teams will be eager to secure a vital victory and boost their chances of qualifying for the prestigious tournament.

Cymru, led by manager Robert Page, started their campaign with a hard-fought 1-0 win over Latvia on March 28. The victory ended their nine-game winless streak, providing a much-needed morale boost for the team. Prior to their win, Cymru had suffered six defeats and three draws, including a 1-1 stalemate against Croatia in their Group D opener.

With four points from two matches, Wales currently sit at the top of the standings, level on points with second-placed Croatia. The Welsh team will be aiming to maintain their winning momentum and consolidate their position at the summit of the group.

Speaking about the upcoming clash, Robert Page expressed his optimism and emphasized the importance of building on their previous victory. He said, “The win against Latvia was a significant step for us. It gave us the belief that we can compete at this level. Now, we need to carry that momentum forward and secure another three points against Armenia. They are a tough team, but we are prepared and ready for the challenge.”

On the other hand, Armenia, managed by Oleksandr Petrakov, are still searching for their first win in the qualifiers. Having played just one match so far, they suffered a narrow 2-1 defeat against Turkey in March. However, Armenia showed resilience in their subsequent friendly against Cyprus, battling to a 2-2 draw.

Armenia’s winless streak extends to nine games, with seven defeats since their 1-0 victory over Ireland in June 2022. Despite the recent struggles, Petrakov remains optimistic and believes his team has the potential to turn things around. He stated, “We have faced some tough challenges lately, but our spirit remains unbroken. The players are determined to give their all and secure a positive result against Wales. It won’t be easy, but we are ready to fight.”