“Sixty telephone conversations with Putin” – Pashinyan on ending the 2020 war

  • JAMnews
  • Yerevan

Pashinyan on the circumstances of the Karabakh war

The Prime Minister of Armenia participated in a meeting of the parliamentary commission investigating the circumstances of the Karabakh war in 2020 and made a detailed report. In his speech, which lasted more than three hours, Nikol Pashinyan touched not only on the course of the war and the circumstances of the signing of the November statement on the cessation of hostilities, but also on the history of the negotiation process in the Karabakh conflict.

The meeting of the commission will continue on June 27, and its members will have the opportunity to get answers to their questions from the prime minister himself. Pashinyan promised to answer all questions live, except for those that would contain state secrets. The deputies will receive all the information during closed hearings.


  • “The document on unblocking roads is almost completely agreed” – Overchuk
  • “Regional players are not interested in a large-scale escalation.” Opinion from Yerevan
  • “Azerbaijan is better seen and heard in Brussels” – Armenian political scientist

Pashinyan has never said before that in order to end the 44-day war in Karabakh, Russia offered to deploy peacekeepers in the Armenian city of Meghri and around it. They were supposed to provide a connection between the western regions of Azerbaijan and Nakhichevan.

“I did not agree to this. I did not agree to the creation of a layer not controlled by the Republic of Armenia, that is, the creation of a corridor through the territory of Armenia. My position has not changed: roads should be open, but they should remain under the sovereignty and jurisdiction of Armenia,” Pashinyan said.

The prime minister recalled the document on the exchange of territories between Armenia and Azerbaijan, which, in the context of the settlement of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict, could have been signed during the 1999 Istanbul summit. He announced that Armenian Parliament Speaker Karen Demirchyan and Prime Minister Vazgen Sargsyan “prevented” the implementation of this project at the cost of their lives.

Pashinyan is referring to the terrorist attack on October 27, 1999, when an armed group entered the parliament building and shot deputies and members of the government. He talks about one of the unofficial versions of the causes of the attack. Many believed that it was organized by the secret services of countries that have their own interests in the region — Russia and the United States.

The theory was based on the fact that in November 1999 an OSCE summit was to be held in Istanbul, where the heads of Armenia and Azerbaijan could sign some document. It was about the mediators’ proposal for a territorial exchange: Azerbaijan ceded to Armenia the Lachin corridor connecting it with Nagorno-Karabakh, and in return received part of the territory of the Meghri region, that is, the same corridor to Nakhichevan. This option was considered unacceptable by many Armenian politicians, including Vazgen Sargsyan and Karen Demirchyan. After the terrorist act in the Armenian parliament, the documents were not signed.

“This document actually records the death of the fundamental ideas of the Armenian side about the settlement of the Nagorno-Karabakh problem,” he said.

Pashinyan said that although the document has not gotten legal force, proposals of such content continue to appear at the negotiating table.

The prime minister believes that the document on the exchange of Meghri for Nagorno-Karabakh had nothing to do with the right to self-determination and violated the principle of the territorial integrity of both Armenia and Azerbaijan:

“This is nothing but an act of recognizing Karabakh as part of Azerbaijan. Otherwise it is impossible to formulate. If you give away part of your territory in order to get Karabakh from Azerbaijan, then this means that you recognize Karabakh as part of Azerbaijan, and you put your own territory up for auction.”

How Yerevan evaluates the installation of the Azerbaijani flag on the Hakari bridge and the ban on movement along the Lachin corridor. Comments of the Prime Minister, Minister of Defense, MPs and Ombudsman of Armenia

In 2018, Pashinyan announced that he would start negotiations on the settlement of the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict anew, from scratch. He now explained that as of May 2018, he had two options to avoid it:

  1. “Azerbaijan should have actually recognized the interim status of Nagorno-Karabakh according to the logic of the Kazan document. It couldn’t be. Why did Azerbaijan have to accept what it rejected 7 years ago, and for the sake of which it started the April four-day war [2016]?”
  2. “I had to not only recognize Nagorno-Karabakh as part of Azerbaijan, but also agree to the status quo established around Nagorno-Karabakh and Armenia, and also to dismantle the existing status quo within Nagorno-Karabakh itself. It is impossible to imagine, even if we evaluate the situation from today’s point of view.

The prime minister assumes that for Armenia, the statement of the OSCE chairman made back in December 1996 may be news: “The legal status of Nagorno-Karabakh should be determined on the basis of the right to self-determination, which will give it a high status of autonomy within Azerbaijan.”

Pashinyan recalls that hostilities ceased on November 9, and the fall of Shushi played a pivotal role. He said that he has in mind the strategic role of the city, and not the symbolic one:

“After the loss of Shushi, Stepanakert, in fact, would be under attack, pressure on Martuni would inevitably increase, and most importantly, 25,000 of our soldiers would be under the threat of encirclement.”

According to the prime minister, the November announcement was the fifth attempt to stop the war.

He presented to the parliamentary commission details of the attempts and details from conversations with Vladimir Putin. Initially, the Azerbaijani side presented the following preconditions for a ceasefire:

  • “Surrender of Fuzuli without a fight,
  • the retreat of the Armenian forces along the Araks to the Khodaferi reservoir so that the reservoir would be under the control of Azerbaijan,
  • return of Azerbaijanis Guliyev and Askerov, who are serving sentences for murders and kidnappings in Karabakh, with the possibility of returning captured Armenians.”

These conditions were unacceptable for the Armenian side. In addition, according to Pashinyan, Baku did not link the fulfillment of these requirements with the cessation of hostilities, but only promised “a humanitarian truce to organize the funeral of the dead.”

Several attempts at a truce were unsuccessful. Baku not only did not support the ceasefire, but also intensified “its offensive actions, inflicting missile strikes on Stepanakert, Martakert, attacking Hadrut.”

Pashinyan says that along with attempts to prevent attacks, Armenia also made diplomatic efforts:

“The issue of deploying Russian military observers on both sides of the line of contact was considered, who would monitor the situation and record violations of the ceasefire. However, Azerbaijan constantly shied away from such a decision and conducted more intense hostilities.”

Russian media, citing a “diplomatic source”, reported that Washington is forcing representatives of Nagorno-Karabakh to agree to a meeting with the Azerbaijani side.

According to Pashinyan, 20 out of 60 telephone conversations with Putin during this period took place on November 8 and 9, when the text of the tripartite statement was discussed. He agreed to start these negotiations on the condition that the document does not contain provisions regarding Shushi and the corridor through the territory of Armenia. For his part, he offered to return the Aghdam region instead of the Hadrut region.

Pashinyan said that he signed the statement on the morning of November 9, but Azerbaijan refused to sign this version of the document and put forward new demands.

“The culmination of the process was the evening of November 9, when it became clear that Azerbaijan was making new additions to the agreed document. This meant that the text I had signed in the morning was no longer valid.”

According to him, Azerbaijan did not accept the proposal of Aghdam instead of Hadrut, there was no mention of Shushi and the creation of a corridor through the territory of Armenia in the text. It was only about the cessation of hostilities, the return of 7 regions around NK, the creation of the Lachin corridor and the deployment of Russian peacekeepers here and in Nagorno-Karabakh.

“But at the moment when the President of the Russian Federation said that Azerbaijan was proposing to add a clause on the return of enclaves in the Tavush region to the text, I stated that I ruled out the possibility of signing such a document,” Pashinyan said.

After some time, the parties managed to agree on removing the clause on enclaves from the document. It was signed, according to the Armenian prime minister, after “difficult, lengthy” discussions, in parallel with reports “about the intensification of hostilities and the accumulation of a large number of drones in the sky over Stepanakert.”

The Ombudsman of Nagorno-Karabakh published an extraordinary report on the consequences of the blockade and included personal stories of people in it. Details of the report, as well as assessment of the situation by the Armenian Foreign Ministry

What needs to be done to reach a truce and stop the war? For the first time, Pashinyan addressed this issue with the President of Russia on October 13. Putin said that “one can try to talk about ending the war in exchange for the return of 5 regions” around NK, which were under the control of Armenia after the first Karabakh war. A few days later, on October 19, in a telephone conversation, the Russian president confirmed that the war could be stopped according to the Russian plan developed many years ago.

“And the condition is as follows: 7 regions are returned in the 5 + 2 format, the issue of NK-Armenia communication through the Lachin corridor is being resolved, Russian peacekeepers are deployed in Karabakh, the status issue remains unresolved, it is postponed for an indefinite future,” Pashinyan said.

The Prime Minister of Armenia agreed, but the Azerbaijani side stated that it expected to receive all 7 regions at once.

According to an official statement from the Armenian Foreign Ministry, the Armenian-Azerbaijani talks scheduled for June 12 in Washington were postponed “at the request of the Azerbaijani side.”

The Prime Minister says that on October 19 he learned from the President of Russia about another condition from Baku. It was about guarantees for the return of Azerbaijani refugees to Shushi, who “accounted for 90 percent of the population of Shushi without any restriction on further increase.”

Baku also proposed the construction of a new road for the unhindered movement of Azerbaijanis:

“According to the proposal, all Azerbaijanis should have direct and unhindered access to Shushi, and not just those living in Shushi. For example, 50,000 Azerbaijanis could come to those living in Shushi, there could not be any restrictions. And they could stay.”

Pashinyan did not accept the offer. He says he was worried that the Lachin corridor would not operate, Azerbaijan could close it at any moment, because Shushi would not enter the Lachin corridor, and it would pass a few meters from Shushi. He believes that “recent events”, that is, the blocking of the Lachin corridor, proved him right.

As for the “fall of Shushi”, Pashinyan expects that the circumstances of the loss of the city should be clarified in the framework of the initiated criminal cases. He emphasizes that all his instructions concerned the strengthening of Shushi and the organization of the defense of the city. And he received assurances that he would stand. Contradictory information came from the President of Nagorno-Karabakh and from the General Staff of the Armed Forces.

“Before signing the tripartite statement, I was also informed that a part of Shushi was under the control of the NK Defense Army,” he said.

Siranush Sahakyan, a specialist in international law and a representative of the interests of Armenian prisoners in the ECtHR, believes that the videos were made under duress

Pashinyan also touched upon the former leaders of Armenia. He mentioned the article of the first President Levon Ter-Petrosyan “War or Peace? Time to think”, which talked about the need for compromises:

“To briefly formulate what Ter-Petrosyan said, it will turn out: it is impossible to maintain the status quo for a long time, let’s not engage in self-deception and cherish vain hopes, we have no allies on the issue of the independence of Karabakh.”

He stressed that Ter-Petrosyan does not give a clear and literal answer to the question of what status Nagorno-Karabakh will eventually have, whether it will be independent, whether it will be part of Armenia or Azerbaijan. According to him, this article has become “another factor aggravating the confusion in the Karabakh issue.”

According to the prime minister, the second president, Robert Kocharyan, deprived Nagorno-Karabakh of “any independence”, excluding Karabakh from the negotiations:

“Moreover, he deprived Nagorno-Karabakh of the only internationally recognized status, which made it possible to sit at the same table with representatives of Russia, the United States, France, Azerbaijan and Armenia. This, in fact, was the end of the international subjectivity of Nagorno-Karabakh.”

He also criticized third President Serzh Sargsyan, recalling his team’s “dubious slogan” that “bad negotiations are better than the best war”:

“The worst negotiations gave Azerbaijan time to prepare for the best war for it. With this slogan, they tied Armenia hand and foot, so that Armenia and Karabakh at some point X would be in a hopeless situation.”


https://jam-news.net/pashinyan-on-the-circumstances-of-the-karabakh-war/

Iran Denies Radioactive Pollution Of Aras River By Armenia


Author: Maryam Sinaee


Media reports about possible radioactive contamination of Aras River in Iran’s northwestern borders by Armenia’s nuclear power plant has led to widespread concerns.

However, Iran’s Nuclear Safety Center has refuted the reports. In a statement on Tuesday, the center which is an affiliate of Atomic Energy Organization of Iran (AEOI) said the river Aras is monitored at least once a year for radioactive pollution and that the last survey in March this year did not indicate any radioactive pollution as claimed by Payam-e Ma newspaper on Monday. 

Quoting a paper published earlier by the Border Studies Research Journal of the Iranian police, Payam-e Ma on Monday suggested that the extremely high occurrence of various types of cancers and liver diseases in Ardabil Province bordering the Republic of Azerbaijan, could be attributed to radioactive pollution of the Aras River emanating from Armenia’s nuclear power plant situated in Metsamor hundreds of kilometers to the west. 

Payam-e Ma’s article followed a warning on June 12 by Mahmoud Abbaszadeh-Meshkini, a member of the Iranian Parliament’s National Security and Foreign Policy Committee who claimed that effluent from the power plant which was polluting the river could be the cause of the high occurrence of cancer in Iran’s Ardabil. 

However, the cause of the high rate of cancer in the area is hard to establish. It is not clear whether the phenomenon is related to the environment or has other underlying reasons. But concerns linger on as many do not trust the Iranian government on the issue of radioactive contamination.

A deputy health minister, Dr. Reza Malekzadeh, told the media in October 2020 that a longitudinal study carried out over a period of 20 years about the occurrence of stomach cancer in Ardabil Province has shown a rate of 50 per 100,000 of the province’s population. This is the highest rate in the country. 

However, the Nuclear Safety Center’s statement said the Armenian power plant is too far from the Aras for its effluent to reach the river and pollute it as claimed. 

The Aras River which rises in Turkey forms part of Iran’s border with its northwestern neighbors, Armenia and Azerbaijan, before flowing into the Kura River in Azerbaijan. 

“The Aras River is being continually monitored for radioactivity and other required substances,” the statement said and added that the center will establish an online water monitoring station in the said area very soon to carry out tests. 

In the past ten years, Iranian officials have repeatedly denied radioactive pollution of the Aras River by the Armenian nuclear plant. 

Metsamor Nuclear Power Plant which is the only nuclear power plant in the South Caucasus was built in the 1970s. The two units of the plant provide a total of 815 MW of electricity and supplied approximately 40 percent of Armenia’s electricity in 2015. 

The plant has been a source of environmental concern since the Spitak Earthquake in 1988 which led to its closure until 1995. The plant has been classified by the EU as the oldest and least reliable of all the 66 reactors built by the former Soviet Union. 

The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), however, said in 2011 that the plant posed an “acceptable” level of risk to the environment and could “in principle” operate beyond its design life span. 

The media have also warned that heavy metals in the effluent of other industries in Armenia, Turkey and Iran have been polluting the river for many years. Most of the pollution, however, is apparently caused by Armenian copper mines and plants in the area. 

Firuz Ghasemzadeh, spokesman of the Iranian Water Industry, told the Iranian Labour News Agency (ILNA) on May 10 that the Iranian ministry of energy and both Iran’s and Armenia’s departments of environment had been investigating the pollution caused by the Armenian mines. 

According to Ghasemzadeh, sources of pollution were eliminated by installation of water treatment facilities, but occasional pollution was still possible. He also stressed that Armenia has given assurances that it would control the sources of pollution. 

Azerbaijan says Armenian forces shell border area

June 21 (Reuters) – Armenia’s armed forces shelled the positions of the Azerbaijani army in the border area of the Sadarak district, Azerbaijan’s defence ministry said late on Tuesday.

“Units of the Armenian armed forces fired at the positions of the Azerbaijani army from various small arms,” the defence ministry said in a statement posted on its website.

Armenian armed formations also fired at the Azeri army positions near Susha in the Nagorno-Karabakh region, the ministry said.

Reuters could not independently verify the reports. There was no immediate comment from Armenia.

Armenia and Azerbaijan, which have been locked in conflict over the Nagorno-Karabakh region for three decades, regularly exchange fire across their shared border.

(Reporting by Lidia Kelly in Melbourne;)

https://finance.yahoo.com/news/azerbaijan-says-armenian-forces-shell-020911981.html

Armenia: sheep shearing festival takes place in Syunik marz with EU support


The sixth ‘Sheep Shearing’ festival organised with the support of the EU was held on 10 June in Khot village of Syunik marz. 

The festival has been held in Armenia since 2014 and aims to raise awareness of the local products, traditions and culture of the Syunik region of Armenia, as well as to promote tourism in the region, boost cultural life and provide an opportunity for people involved in tourism and hospitality to generate additional income.

The five communities of Syunik marz – Goris, Tegh, Kapan, Sisian and Tatev – presented agro-food products, handicrafts, and other products.

Three beneficiaries supported by the UNDP through the EU-GAIA project also presented their products at the festival. These were the Maki Genetic Breeding Sheep Centre, and the Gyumri Leather.

The Green Agriculture Initiative in Armenia (EU-GAIA) project is funded by the European Union and co-financed by the Austrian Development Agency, and is jointly implemented by the agency and UNDP in Armenia.

Find our more

Press release

https://euneighbourseast.eu/news/latest-news/armenia-sheep-shearing-festival-takes-place-in-syunik-marz-with-eu-support/

The SEDE Delegation joined EUMA for a patrol near Lachin corridor for better understanding of the security situation

 21.06.2023
Goris, 21.06.2023 – Today, the delegates of the Subcommittee on Security and Defence (SEDE) of the European Parliament visited the operational hub of European Mission in Armenia (EUMA) in Goris to get better understanding of the security situation in border areas between Armenia and Azerbaijan on the ground. Following the briefing by Head of EU Mission in Armenia Markus Ritter, the delegation led by Ms Nathalie Loiseau and the Ambassador to EU Delegation in Armenia Andrea Wiktorin joined EUMA for a patrol near Hakari bridge on the Armenian side, leading to Lachin corridor.

Markus Ritter: EUMA acts in a way as a spotlight of the international community

As part of the welcome speech, Markus Ritter highlighted that EU Mission in Armenia “acts in a way as a spotlight of the international community on incidents and ceasefire violations in Armenian-Azerbaijani border areas.” At the end of the visit, Nathalie Loiseau expressed support for EUMA as well as “for the peace aspiration in the region,” and thanked all the involved parties for organising the visit.

Nathalie Loiseau: European Parliament supports EUMA as well as the peace aspiration in the region.

Besides the operations of newly launched EU Mission in Armenia, the purpose of the three-day long visit of the SEDE delegation was to assess the security situation in Armenia as well as the normalization process between Armenia and Azerbaijan.

What is SEDE?

The Subcommittee on Security and Defence (SEDE) is a subcommittee of the Committee on Foreign Affairs of the European Parliament. It is responsible for the European security and defence policy (ESDP), including institutions, capabilities and operations, as well as developing relations with strategic partners and third countries. During the Ninth European Parliament (2019–2024), the committee has 30 members and is chaired by Nathalie Loiseau from France. More information on activities of the subcommittee can be found here.

What is EU Mission in Armenia?

EUMA is a non-armed, civilian and non-executive mission with the aim to observe and report to the EU on the security situation on the ground. The mission is deployed on the Armenian side of the international border between Armenia and Azerbaijan, with Headquarters in Yeghegnadzor, planned six operational hubs (also called Forward Operating Bases) and a small Support and Liaison office in Yerevan.

Contact information

Press and Public Information Office

[email protected]

https://www.eeas.europa.eu/euma/sede-delegation-joined-euma-patrol-near-lachin-corridor-better-understanding-security_en

Safeguarding the People of Nagorno-Karabakh

   
Date: 
Wednesday, – 2:15pm
Location: 
2360 Rayburn House Office Building

Please join the Tom Lantos Human Rights Commission for a hearing on safeguarding the people of Nagorno-Karabakh as risks of renewed violence in and around the enclave increase.

Two and a half years after a bloody six-week war pushed Armenian forces out of Nagorno-Karabakh and the surrounding regions of Azerbaijan, tensions are again escalating. A blockade of the Lachin corridor to Nagorno-Karabakh by Azerbaijani-backed activists has entered its 7th month, and on April 23 Azerbaijan opened a military checkpoint on the corridor that is widely viewed as inconsistent with the provisions of the 2020 ceasefire agreement that ended the last war.  A number of international efforts are underway to mitigate the risk of a new full-blown war, including by officials at the U.S. State Department. One major issue is what is required to adequately protect the rights and safety of ethnic Armenians in Nagorno-Karabakh, where Azerbaijan seeks to assert control.

This hearing will examine the measures required to adequately safeguard, during this period of blockade and negotiation, a vulnerable ethnic population, and offer recommendations for U.S. policy.

This hearing will be open to Members of Congress, congressional staff, the interested public, and the media. The hearing will be livestreamed via the Commission website and will also be available for viewing on channel 53 of the House Digital Channel service. For any questions, please contact Mark Milosch (for Co-Chair Smith) or Kimberly Stanton (for Co-Chair McGovern). 

Christopher H. Smith
Member of Congress
Co-Chair, TLHRC
James P. McGovern
Member of Congress
Co-Chair, TLHRC

Panel I          

  • Ambassador Sam Brownback
  • Michael Rubin, Senior Fellow, American Enterprise Institute
  • David Phillips, Director, Peace-Building and Human Rights Program, Institute for the Study of Human Rights, Columbia University
  • John M. Evans, Former U.S. Ambassador to Armenia, Department of State

Witnesses may be added.

118th Congress
Watch the video at 

Questionable Secret Land Lease Deal Threatens Historic Armenian Community Land and Property in Old City


June 12 2023

Feature Story


A questionable land lease deal that the Armenian Patriarchate was pressured into making imperils land and property amounting to one-quarter of the area of the entire Armenian Quarter—approximately 3.2 hectares (almost 8 acres)—or 14 percent of Jerusalem’s Old City.1 The deal, made first with the Jerusalem Municipality and then with Israeli Australian businessman Dany Rubinstein, would reportedly sign away the property for 99 years.

Such a lease could be detrimental to the presence of the Armenian community in the Holy Land as well as to the character of the Old City overall.

While details are still hazy, the deal reportedly includes a parking area used by the community called “Goveroun Bardes,” Armenian for “Cows’ Garden”, as well as five residential homes belonging to Armenian families alongside it.2 According to local sources, the parking lot alone can accommodate from 150 to 180 cars.3

The Armenian community, outraged by the secretive deal, has been protesting continually since details were first leaked last fall and then solidified in April with a visit from Israeli land surveyors and a new sign on the parking lot in Hebrew and English announcing it as the property of XANA Capital.

Rubinstein reportedly aims to build a low-rise luxury hotel on the property.

Blog PostNewly Renovated, the Armenian Museum in Jerusalem’s Old City Reopens

A newly renovated museum in Jerusalem’s Old City explores 3,000 years of Armenian art, culture, and history.

A sign in English and Hebrew, erected by XANA Capital at the entrance to the Cows’ Garden parking lot in the Armenian Quarter of the Old City. The wooden cross was placed by unidentified workmen on June 13, 2023, then removed by Israeli police the following day.

Credit: 

Amos Chapple RFE/RL

Community Outrage

Hagop Djernazian, 22, a young Armenian activist, has been working diligently to raise awareness on the dangers of losing this land. He uses 18th- and 19th-century maps of the Old City of Jerusalem and its quarters to help explain the implications of the proposed deal: “I invite people who are unaware of the importance of Goveroun Bardez [which is the main part of the land lease] to look at the map of the Old City . . . and consider the historic and strategic importance of that parcel of land.”4

Entrance to the Armenian convent in the Armenian Quarter of Jerusalem’s Old City, captured sometime between 1898 and 1914 by photographers from the American Colony, Jerusalem

Credit: 

Library of Congress, Prints and Photographs Division [LC-DIG-matpc 06551]

Hagop Djernazian points out to the Armenian property, namely, the Seminary, included in the controversial land lease deal, May 19, 2023. Left: the Armenian parking spot—Cows’ Garden

Credit: 

Muath Khatib for Jerusalem Story

At the third protest against the land lease, held on May 19, 2023, Jerusalemite Armenian historian George Hintlian addressed the crowd: “There is no such thing as only the Armenian Quarter. The four quarters are one—it’s one Jerusalem, and they are all connected. Whatever happens in other quarters happens in the Armenian Quarter.”

George Hintlian

Hintlian, an expert on the Armenian Genocide, said that Israeli attempts to acquire Armenian properties do not surprise him; he has witnessed massive pressure, sometimes to the point of assassination attempts, over several decades. “The Armenian Quarter is a targeted quarter,” he noted. “We are one of the communities under constant pressure.”

Hintlian described the various fraudulent Israeli methods, including settler attacks and involving high-level governmental officials, to take over Armenian properties. “There is forgery, manipulation, and bribery in this deal,” he asserted. What makes this deal especially problematic is that it was done without securing approval from the Armenian Synod. (In fact, the priests had opposed it.) The Armenian community is working with international lawyers to revoke it.

Rally held on May 12, 2023, inside the Armenian monastery to protest the land lease deal

Credit: 

Arda Aghazarian for Jerusalem Story

In May 2023, the Armenian Patriarchate defrocked the priest Baret Yeretzian, director of the Real Estate Department of the Patriarchate, for deceptions related to the lease; he has since fled to Southern California. Meanwhile, on May 11, the Palestinian Authority and Jordan suspended recognition of the Armenian Patriarch Nourhan Manougian, who has served for a decade in what is normally a lifelong position.5

Three Armenian groups, which together represent the entire Armenian community, released a joint statement on May 20, asserting that the impact of the “illegal lease would be immeasurably detrimental to the presence and the national ethos of the Armenian presence in the Holy Land.”6

Setrag Balian, an active member of the Armenian community in Jerusalem, addresses the protesters against the land lease deal on May 12, 2023, at the Armenian monastery in the Old City of Jerusalem.

Credit: 

Arda Aghazarian for Jerusalem Story

The Broader Implications for Christians in Jerusalem

The Armenian land lease case is not disconnected from the broader Israeli practices against the non-Jewish residents of Jerusalem, which have accelerated in recent years.

For Jerusalemites, the fate of the Armenian property calls to mind the recent Ateret Cohanim settler takeover in March 2022 of parts of the Petra Hotel, owned by the Greek Orthodox Patriarchate. In a joint statement dated April 4, 2022, the heads of local churches in Jerusalem described the hotel’s lease as “a threat to the continued existence of a Christian Quarter in Jerusalem.”7

On August 7, 2022, the Armenian Patriarch of Jerusalem, together with the Greek Orthodox Patriarch of Jerusalem and the Franciscan Custodian of the Holy Land, vehemently opposed the Israel Nature and Parks Authority’s plan to expand the Israeli national park to parts of the Mount of Olives. The plan would entail confiscating and nationalizing some of the holiest Christian sites, an attack on Christians in Jerusalem.8 Although the authority said it would withdraw the plan, it is likely that the Israeli authorities will proceed when public attention shifts elsewhere.9

George Hintlian, Armenian historian and local resident

The Israeli government plan to convert the country into an exclusively Jewish state, which has accelerated in recent years, poses a major threat for all Christians and their heritage in Jerusalem.10 

In a recent report by the US Department of State on religious freedom in Israel, the West Bank, and Gaza, the Office of International Religious Freedom noted the grave public concerns over the Christian presence in the country. Some of the reported issues stated in the report include “violence and harassment against clergy and worshipers by Israeli extremists; vandalism and desecration of church properties; attempts by settler organizations to obtain strategic property in and around the Christian quarter of the Old City and the Mount of Olives; and restrictions on residency permits for Palestinians as part of Israel’s Citizenship and Entry Law.”11

Blog PostAnti-Christian Attacks in Jerusalem on the Rise in Recent Months

Anti-Christian vigilantism by extremist Jews has spiked since the new Israeli government assumed power.

The report also mentions other restrictions that infringe on religious freedom and worship, such as greatly restricting attendance for Christians wishing to attend the Holy Fire ceremony at the Church of the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem and the audacious threats by settlers and extremist Israelis toward Christians.

The racist chants of extremist Israeli settlers are not disconnected from state policy. Most recently, some of the Orthodox and ultra-Orthodox members of the Knesset (Israel’s parliament) have been aggressively pushing to pass religious-based legislations: One of the bills currently on the table is to imprison any person (e.g. evangelical Christians) who promotes Christianity to Jews.12 Recently, even a deputy mayor of Jerusalem was filmed at a protest again Christian missionaries in the Old City, chanting “Missionaries go home!” He stated, “As far as I’m concerned, let every [Christian] missionary know they are not welcome in the Land of Israel.”13

In this context, the uproar of the Armenian community at the reported land lease deal is not occurring in a vacuum: It stems from a deep-rooted understanding and dread that the deal, if implemented, represents a very real threat to the centuries of Armenian presence, identity, heritage, and culture in Jerusalem, one of many small steps toward the larger goal of transforming historic Palestine into an aggressively Jewish exclusivist state.

At the moment, the active Armenian community of Jerusalem is raising awareness on the importance of this issue, and concentrating all efforts to revoke the lease. “This quarter is everything to me. It’s the only place we have for Armenians to gather in the Holy Land,” said community leader Djernazian. “We have to fight for it.”14

1

“Armenian Quarter Land Sale Threatens Christian Presence in Jerusalem,” Jordan News, May 14, 2023.

2

Amos Chapple, “Jerusalem Armenians Fear Shadowy Land Deal Marks ‘Beginning of the End,’” Radio Free Europe | Radio Liberty, June 16, 2023.

3

Appo Jabarian, “Jerusalem Armenian Quarter’s ‘Goveroun Bardez’ (‘Cows’ Garden’), Valued at $27-$39 Billion, Illegally Leased under a Veil of Darkness,” Armenian Life, October 13, 2021.

4

Interview with the Jerusalem Story Team, May 2023.

5

“Jordan, Palestine No Longer Recognize Armenian Patriarch Nourhan Manougian,” Asbarez, June 13, 2023.

6

Kegham Balian, “Goveroun Bardez: Saving the Oldest Armenian Diaspora in the World,” Armenian Weekly, May 24, 2023.

7

“Statement by Patriarch Theophilos III on the Illegal Seizure of the Little Petra Hotel by the Radical Extremist Group Ateret Cohanim,” Protecting Holy Land Christians, March 29, 2022.

8

Jacob Magid, “Parks Authority Says It’s Shelving Mount of Olives Plan That Angered Church Leaders,” Times of Israel, February 21, 2022.

9

US Department of State, “2022 Report on International Religious Freedom: Israel, West Bank and Gaza,” Office of Palestinian Affairs, May 17, 2023.

10

Z. S. Andrew Demirdjian, “The Risk of Leasing Out Armenian Patriarchate of Jerusalem Land,” Keghart, September 9, 2021.

11

US Department of State, “2022 Report on International Religious Freedom.”

12

“Two Knesset Members Propose Law Banning Spread of Christianity in Israel,” Jordan News, March 22, 2023.

13

Canaan Lidor, “‘Missionaries Go Home’: Hundreds Protest Christian Worship Near Western Wall,” Times of Israel, May 28, 2023.

14

Isabel Debre, “In Jerusalem’s Contested Old City, Shrinking Armenian Community Fears Displacement after Land Deal,” AP News, June 7, 2023.


https://www.jerusalemstory.com/en/article/questionable-secret-land-lease-deal-threatens-historic-armenian-community-land-and-property 

Music: Alexander Chaushian: Armenian Cello Concertos


Reviews

Armenian artists champion the music of their homeland

The Strad Issue: July 2023

 Armenian artists champion the music of their homeland

Musicians: Alexander Chaushian (cello) Armenian National Philharmonic Orchestra/Eduard Topchjan

Works: Babajanian: Cello Concerto. Khachaturian: Concerto in E minor. Petrossian: 8.4 Cello Concerto Catalogue number: BIS BIS-2648

 

 

Alexander Chaushian and Eduard Topchjan share a fervent mission to secure the widest possible dissemination of Armenian music as part of their national heritage. This enterprising and beautifully recorded disc serves their purpose admirably by bringing together three cello concertos that span almost 80 years, all inspired by various aspects of Armenian music, from liturgical chants in Petrossian’s 2021 work 8.4, to folk melodies in Khachaturian’s concerto (1946). Petrossian’s language is perhaps the most inventive, with careful depiction of varying sound worlds to characterise the underlying themes. For example, the first movement ‘Massis’ (referring to Mount Ararat) uses brass, oboes and cellos, whereas the second ‘Sis’ opts for more percussive tones to underline its more stringent rhythmic character. Chaushian also finds a wide range of colours and timbres in the cello writing to reflect this aspect in a perceptive performance.

Khachaturian is the best-known figure here, famed for his passionate style, not least in his ballet Spartacus. The Cello Concerto only offers glimpses of this strong vein of melodiousness and, despite a committed performance from Chaushian, the piece seems discursive and structurally ill-defined.

Read: Cellist Alexander Chaushian joins The Yehudi Menuhin School

Review: Weinberg: Cello Sonatas nos.1 & 2, Sonata for solo cello

Review: Khachaturian: Concerto–Rhapsody*. Zakarian: Monograph*. Sharafyan: Suite*. Komitas Crane (arr. Sharafyan)†

The performers’ zeal really ignites in Babajanian’s concerto (1962), particularly in the exquisite sound world of the Andante, and the rhythmic bustle of the concluding Allegro. Here the finely honed ensemble under Topchjan is in perfect accord with an impressively virtuosic interpretation from Chaushian.

JOANNE TALBOT

Where did the Armenian orphans of Georgetown’s Cedarvale Farm go?

Canada –
With a ceremony honouring the orphans’ arrival 100 years ago set for this weekend, HaltonHillsToday is sharing the life stories of some Georgetown Boys
Georgetown Boy Sarkis Sarkissian (right) with friend Fred Aitchison.

Georgetown’s Cedarvale Farm was never meant to be a permanent home for the 109 Armenian boys who lived there a century ago – nor for the 39 girls who joined them. It was merely a school for them to become good citizens. 

But after their time there, it’s hard to know where a lot of them ended up as the trail went cold… mostly. 

Thanks to the work of Armenian-Canadian author Hrad Poladian, it’s possible to follow some of their journeys. His book The Georgetown Boys Stories by their Sons and Daughters gives voice to 11 alumni of Cedarvale Farm – now known as Cedarvale Park.

“It (the Georgetown Boys’ experience) is a historic fact. It should be recognized and known to all other Canadians,” Poladian emphasized.

The tales of three of them are at times tragic, colourful and hopeful. Here are their stories.

Krikor “Greg” Kasparian

At 452 Richmond St. in Toronto, one will find the Turco Persian Rug Company. This store has been selling and cleaning rugs for 117 years. One of the owners was a Georgetown Boy named Krikor Kasparian, who was married to Kohar Bedrossian, a Georgetown Girl.

After the owner of the rug company, Socrates Utudjian, died, there was a question of who would get the business.

“There was him and another [potential heir]. There was a coin flip for who would get the company and he won,” said Jessica Kasparian, Krikor’s granddaughter and current owner of the rug shop.

Georgetown Boys reunion in the 1960s. Wellington County Museum and Archives ph20017

The United Church of Canada brought Kasparian in the early 1920s to be a Georgetown Boy. It’s not known how old he was – his date of birth is an estimate – but he was likely 17 when he arrived in Toronto. His application was initially rejected because he was too old. But after the church listed him as a teacher, he was accepted.

Details are scarce about his life before coming to Canada – what’s known are simple snippets. He was conscripted by the Ottoman army and was injured. Somehow, he was reunited with his mother while still wounded. He lost a brother and both parents. His sisters survived and one of them moved to the United States. 

Kasparian suspects that trauma may be why her grandfather didn’t talk about his experiences much.

“He saw some pretty awful things,” she told HaltonHillsToday. 

“There were some occasions where he talked to my dad, and I know at some point my dad recorded it,” she recalled.

Much of what was on those tapes, however, have been lost as they were inadvertently recorded over.

Greg Kasparian died in 1989.

Sarkis Sarkissian

Sarkis Sarkissian was 10 years old when he arrived in Georgetown. His memories before that were only fragments. The Armenian Genocide started in 1915 when he was a mere two years old. 

His parents were Krikor and Miram. In an interview in the 1980s with his son, he said he doesn’t remember anything about his parents. He also admitted that Sarkissian may not be his real last name. He had memories of living in the Turkish city of Adana, where many anti-Armenian pogroms happened. 

He was sent to live with his paternal grandmother. While he wasn’t sure why, at some point she had him sent away to a nearby orphanage.

“She was getting old and I guess she couldn’t look after me anymore,” he told his son in the ’80s.

He often ran away from the orphanage to go be with his grandmother, but an uncle would inevitably take him back.

He was then shipped off to Cyprus and then Corfu in Greece, his final home before arriving in Canada.

After leaving Cedarvale, he worked on a farm near Guelph. Despite all the boys receiving training as farmers, Sarkissian is probably the only one who chose farming as a career.

He briefly journeyed to Portage La Prairie, Manitoba, to find work with a buddy named Fred Aitchison. It was here that he met his wife, Anne Popiel, the daughter of Ukrainian immigrants.

He spent the rest of his life on an Orangeville farm. He died in 1997. 

Harry Hatch

Born Haroutioun Khatchadourian, he was not supposed to be a Georgetown Boy. His older brother, who was caring for their mother at the time, put him in an orphanage. 

A different boy had originally been chosen to come to Canada. But when he was discovered to have head lice, Hatch was picked instead. 

He arrived in Georgetown at the age of 12, making him one of the older boys. After his time there was over, he worked many farms. 

Harry Hatch with wife Roxanne later in life. Susanne Felkner photohttps://www.haltonhillstoday.ca/local-news/where-did-the-armenian-orphans-of-georgetowns-cedarvale-farm-go-7100185

He often struggled to find work. A friend suggested that he should change his name. Thus, Harry Hatch was born.

He served in the Canadian Army and fought in the Second World War. He was almost part of the ill-fated raid on Dieppe, but a sergeant stopped him from being part of the attack.

“Where do you think you are going, Hatch? You are one of the only drivers we have and we need you here to drive,” the sergeant apparently told him. He worked as a driver during the war years. 

He and his wife, Roxanne, moved to the Mountain in Hamilton. There, he first worked as a cleaner at a jail, while his wife operated a bread and milk shop they opened together. He started working at the shop when the behaviour of the local youth made her uncomfortable. Eventually this shop was turned into a restaurant.

Harry Hatch died in 1974 from a brain tumor. 

July 1 will mark the 100th anniversary of the arrival of the Georgetown Boys. The Sara Corning Centre for Genocide Education will commemorate the occasion with a ceremony at Cedarvale Park on Saturday (June 24). The gathering will begin at 2 p.m. and various government and local dignitaries, including descendants of the Georgetown Boys, will be present.

Parliament war commission to summon Nagorno Karabakh president

 14:56,

YEREVAN, JUNE 20, ARMENPRESS. The parliament select committee probing the 2020 Second Nagorno Karabakh War will summon Nagorno Karabakh President Arayik Harutyunyan for a testimony, the chair of the committee Andranik Kocharyan has said.

He said that other high-ranking officials will be invited after Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan as well.

“We plan to invite the President of the Artsakh Republic. We postponed the invitation to the Defense Army Commander, I’d like Jalal Harutyunyan to come a bit later,” he said.