Armenian Independence Day in Boston

Boston ARF Sardarabad celebration of the 105th anniversary of the First Republic of Armenia, May 19, 2023, Watertown, MA

WATERTOWN, Mass.—The Armenian community of Greater Boston came together on Friday, May 19, 2023, to mark the anniversary of an important chapter in our nation’s history: the 105th anniversary of Armenia’s independence, declared on May 28, 1918. 

More than 200 community members attended the event organized by the Armenian Revolutionary Federation’s (ARF) Sardarabad Gomideh of Boston. The event began with the presentation of the colors by the Homenetmen scouts and the singing of the Armenian and American national anthems by the newly-formed Armenian Children’s Choir of Boston, led by choirmaster Artur Veranian. Mistress of ceremonies Nanor Kojanian Nerkizian delivered the opening remarks on behalf of the Boston ARF and invited ARF Bureau representative Hagop Der Khatchadurian to the stage for a conversation. Der Khatchadurian emphasized that victory on May 28 was achieved through the patriotism, realism and sacrifice of the sons and daughters of Armenia, who had lived for six centuries under oppression, having suffered near extermination. He said that thanks to the long-lasting struggle of the devoted leaders of the Armenian republic and the prudent and decisive attitude of the Armenian army, the Armenian people gained their independence. “What happened was not a miracle but the indestructible will of the Armenian people to survive and to live freely,” Der Khatchadurian said. The Armenian people had their republic and statehood amidst poverty, persecution, hunger, disease and ruins. However, tangible social, cultural, economic and political improvements occurred. In a very short time, Armenia was strengthened to boldly stand on its own feet.

Mistress of ceremonies Nanor Kojanian Nerkizian in conversation with ARF Bureau representative Hagop Der Khatchadurian

Der Khachaturian stressed that the First Armenian Republic is the cornerstone of modern Armenian statehood, having survived Soviet Armenia and on to post-Soviet independence. He added that we should acknowledge and appreciate this seemingly impossible and unprecedented national achievement with pride. Yet, this joyous occasion did not last long. During two-and-a-half years of independence, the tricolors waved over the entire territory of the motherland as a symbol of Armenian statehood. The Armenian people became the masters of their national, political, economic, cultural, social, and military destiny. The Armenian people were free. Der Khatchadurian concluded that we should heed the message of the founders of the First Republic, the establishment of a free, independent Armenia to keep alive the spirit of unity, to preserve the independence and statehood of the motherland, to improve the social life of the motherland, and to strengthen the Armenian army.

He emphasized that after the fall of the independent Republic of Armenia and the establishment of Soviet rule, the Diaspora welcomed many of the founders of independent Armenia with an open heart and foresight. With full faith and conviction, the Diaspora embraced the sacred principles of these exiled leaders and founders, believing that the return to the homeland would be achieved, justice would be served, and the tricolor would fly over our homeland again. And so it happened.

ARF Bureau representative Hagop Der Khatchadurian (center) visiting the Armenian Museum of America in Watertown, MA.

Der Khatchadurian’s remarks were followed by a lively hour-long question-and-answer session. He implored all to not be discouraged, to not leave Armenia, to not abandon the Armenian cause, and to stand by our homeland firmly.

The Armenian Children’s Choir of Boston concluded the event by performing four popular pieces: Sardarabad, Zeytountsiner, Yerevan-Erebouni and Gakavik, as their inaugural performance under the capable leadership of Maestro Veranian.

ARF Bureau representative Hagop Der Khatchadurian (center) at St. Stephen’s Armenian Day School in Watertown, MA.

During his trip to the Greater Boston area, Der Khatchadurian visited several Armenian institutions in town, including St. Stephen’s Armenian Elementary School, where he met Principal Houry Boyamian; Dr. Garine Palandjian, Boyamian’s successor; and Artemis Megerdichian, the school’s Armenian language teacher. He spoke with the students about the significance of May 28 and our need for vigilance at all times. He also visited the Armenian Cultural Foundation at Arlington, where he was given a tour of the the foundation’s literary treasures by its director Ara Ghazarians. National Association for Armenian Studies and Research (NAASR) executive director Silva Sedrakian and library curator Ani Babaian welcomed Der Khatchadurian to NAASR’s new state-of-the-art facilities in Belmont, showcasing the voluminous collection of the institution. The next stop was the Armenian Museum of America in Watertown, where executive director Jason Sohigian and director of finance and building operation Berj Chekijian offered a great tour of the museum and its remarkable displays. Dr. Alisa Dumikyan, a visiting scholar at the museum, accompanied the staff and offered thoughtful remarks on the museum’s collections.

The final stop was the Tekeyan Cultural Center, where Der Khatchadurian was interviewed by editor of the Armenian Mirror-Spectator Aram Arkun. He also visited the Hairenik Association, meeting with the editors of the Hairenik and Armenian Weekly and visiting the ARF Central Committee of Eastern United States and the administrative offices of the Armenian Relief Society.

Author’s postscript: May 28, 1918 and Artsakh today

It is noteworthy that May 28 holds profound significance, reminding us not only of the resilience of the Armenian nation but also of the power of unity and determination in the face of adversity. In the spring of 1918, amid the turmoil of World War I, our ancestors faced a dire existential threat. The battles of Sardarabad, Karakilisa and Bash Abaran were not just military confrontations; they were decisive tests of our collective will, tenacity and unwavering love for our homeland.

We honor the heroic men and women who, at Sardarabad, turned back the Ottoman army, preventing the complete destruction of the Armenian nation. We remember the defenders of Karakilisia who, despite being outnumbered, fought with exceptional bravery and tenacity, embodying the spirit of sacrifice for our motherland. And we pay tribute to the fighters of Bash Abaran who held the line, demonstrating that the Armenian will could not be defeated.

These battles were a testament to the indomitable spirit of our people, and it was the Armenian Revolutionary Federation that played a pivotal role in mobilizing these efforts, organizing the defense and ultimately leading us toward independence. They rallied our people, instilled hope amidst despair and spearheaded our fight for freedom. Today, we stand on the shoulders of these giants. Their courage echoes through time, reminding us of our duty to preserve and protect the hard-won independence of our homeland.

As we remember our history, we cannot ignore the parallels with the current struggle of our brothers and sisters in Artsakh. The echoes of Sardarabad, Karakilisa and Bash Abaran resonate in the hills and plains of Artsakh today. Their struggle, like ours more than a century ago, is for the right to self-determination, to live in peace on the land that has been theirs from time immemorial.

Armenia’s past, marked by the resilience of its people and their struggle for independence, is mirrored in the present as the people of Artsakh strive for recognition and security. The spirit of 1918 must be kept alive in the hearts of every Armenian.  

The Armenian nation has been complacent, the ARF has made mistakes, and the Armenian authorities have not lived up to the standards they must be held to. A significant portion of the Armenians in Armenia have opted to reconcile with the path of least resistance, a path promoted by the current authorities, even if this path robs their children of a secure and thriving future in their ancestral homeland. The Armenians in the Diaspora have also reconciled themselves to a distant and not fully engaged relationship, all traumatized and beset by the harshness of the events of the past two and a half years.

The situation in Artsakh remains deeply troubling, as the region is continually plagued by unchecked Azeri aggression. The Armenian government, which must act as the guarantor of Artsakh’s security, appears to have abdicated its responsibility to safeguard the rights and security of the Artsakh population. Compounding this crisis is the unfortunate reality of international geopolitics: the US and European nations have shown a reluctance to challenge Azerbaijan’s aggression, seemingly swayed by considerations of oil access and broader strategic objectives, which include weakening regional powers such as Russia and Iran. The plight of the Armenians of Artsakh seems, regrettably, to have been overshadowed by these wider geopolitical games.

Yet, amidst this dire backdrop, the resilience and steadfastness of the Artsakh people shine as a beacon of inspiration. They remain defiant, asserting their right to independence and deep-rooted connection to their ancestral homeland, a testament to their enduring spirit and an unequivocal affirmation of their right to self-determination.

Their courage in the face of adversity is commendable and encouraging, illuminating the path toward hope and justice. Yet, the Armenian nation must reciprocate this courage. The ARF must be steadfast, go back to its roots, take the mantle to inspire, engage and lead the Armenian nation, and hold the Armenian authorities to task to right the nation’s ship.

Anatole France, a Nobel laureate, said: “Armenia is dying, but it will survive. The little blood that it still has left is precious blood that will give birth to a heroic generation. A nation that does not want to die, does not die.” These words ring as true today as they did originally in 1916. It is incumbent upon us all to make sure that this little blood continues to flow.

With that in mind, as we celebrate Armenia’s 108th year of independence, let us remember the sacrifices made, the battles fought and the victories won. Let us stand in solidarity with our kin in Artsakh and Armenia and pledge to support their right to self-determination, security and prosperity. For the same spirit that fueled the victories of Sardarabad, Karakilisa and Bash Abaran courses through our veins today.

Ara Nazarian is an associate professor of Orthopaedic Surgery at Harvard Medical School. He graduated from Tennessee Technological University with a degree in mechanical engineering, followed by graduate degrees from Boston University, Swiss Federal Institute of Technology and Harvard University. He has been involved in the Armenian community for over a decade, having served in a variety of capacities at the Hamazkayin Armenian Educational and Cultural Society, the Armenian Cultural and Educational Center, Armenian National Committee of America, St. Stephen’s Armenian Elementary School and the Armenian Revolutionary Federation.


Camp Haiastan Under the Trees & Cabin Circle Projects Completed

New meets old: the new circular benches with under-seat lighting (visible at night) and the new version of the eternity symbol that was part of the old Under the Trees

Franklin, Mass.— Just days before the start of Teen Session at AYF Camp Haiastan on June 25, 2023, construction of the upgrades to the Under the Trees and Cabin Circle areas was completed!

The projects have been under the watchful eyes of camp caretaker John Miller, volunteer-in-chief John Mangassarian, the camp’s landscape architect Kyle Zick and board member Michael Bahtiarian.  The last details to be completed were the finest points of the upgraded areas, including new custom circular benches, irrigation system and new lighting at both areas. This is all part of the design work done by Kyle Zick Landscape Architecture (KZLA) of Boston with construction by Haven Contracting Corporation of Westwood, MA.  

New and improved Cabin Circle with beautiful green grass and new circular benches. A newly-installed irrigation system has been installed to keep the grass green during camping season.

As previously reported, the Camp Board of Directors earmarked the Under-the-Trees project to be in memory of one of its longest serving board members, Mark Alashaian of New Jersey. The existing Under-the-Trees was built and dedicated in 1982 in memory of another New Jersey Armenian community member, Vaghinag Koroghlian.  The present updated project will be in memory of both Koroghlian and Alashaian.  The Cabin-Circle project will be dedicated in memory of Regina Najarian of Wellesley, MA, who passed away last June after a courageous battle with cancer. All three community members will be remembered at a ribbon-cutting ceremony at Camp Haiastan on Sunday July 23 at 3:00 p.m.  Also on July 23, the Providence ARF Kristapor Gomideh will host a traditional picnic for all, the one and only picnic for this camping season.

Camp staff enjoy the new benches before Teen Session

Both projects have been generously supported by the camp’s alumni and naming donors. The Camp Board is continuing to seek funds. Donations in support of these projects can be made by check and mailed to Camp Haiastan, P.O. Box C, Franklin, MA 02038, Attn: Under the Trees, or online at the Camp’s donor portal.

Located in Franklin, Massachusetts, AYF Camp Haiastan, was founded in 1951 and is the oldest Armenian camp in the United States. The Camp prides itself on providing a healthy and safe experience to Armenian-American youth to help them foster their Armenian identity and establish lifelong friendships.


AW: AYF leads Washington March for Artsakh

The AYF Washington DC “Ani” Chapter hung a banner on the Azerbaijani embassy on day 1 of their 7 days of action.

WASHINGTON, DC—The Armenian Youth Federation – Youth Organization of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation (AYF-YOARF) Washington DC “Ani” chapter completed a week of pro-Artsakh initiatives yesterday, culminating in a Greater Washington DC community-wide protest and march – from the Azerbaijani Embassy to the Armenian Embassy – rallying against the surrender of democratic Artsakh to genocidal Azerbaijan.

On day 2 of the chapter’s 7 days of action initiative, they hung a banner blocking the Armenian Embassy door.

The week of activism started with the hanging of a large banner outside the Azerbaijani Embassy in Washington, DC, condemning Azerbaijan’s aggression. They also placed signs that identified major Azerbaijani war criminals, such as Ilham Aliyev. The second day featured a sign outside the Embassy of Armenia, affirming that “The one who surrenders land we will bury.” (We hand over the Land to the Land Giver.)

On the third day, the AYF published an open letter demanding local businesses and government officials boycott Turkish and Azerbaijani products, as the countries continue to contribute to anti-Armenian aggression.

On day 3, the chapter laid out 120 candles in front of the Armenian Embassy in the shape of the Artsakh flag, to show their solidarity with the 120,000 civilians in Artsakh.

The fourth day saw AYFers arranging 120 candles in the shape of the Artsakh flag on the doorstep of the Armenian Embassy to symbolize 120,000 civilians the Pashinyan government has left behind as a result of its willingness to surrender Artsakh to Azerbaijan.

On the fifth day of action, a banner was dropped over busy Washington, DC overpasses during rush hour to spread awareness about the innocent Artsakh Armenians being blockaded by Azerbaijan.

On day 5 of the protest, chapter members hung a banner on overpasses in DC during rush hour.

In response to the arrival of Armenian foreign minister Ararat Mirzoyan in Washington, DC for “peace talks” with Azerbaijan, on the sixth day of action the AYF left blood-stained model hands at the doorstep of the Armenian Embassy – emphasizing Pashinyan’s responsibility for the surrender of Artsakh and the loss of Armenian lives.

The seventh day, coinciding with the US State Department-mediated talks between Armenian and Azerbaijani officials, saw AYF members gather with a cross-section of the local community for a pro-Artsakh protest march from the Azerbaijani Embassy to the Armenian Embassy – echoing the Artsakh Parliament’s stand that peace talks should be suspended until Azerbaijan ceases its aggression.

Chapter members laid out bloody model hands in front of the Armenian Embassy in protest of their concessions to Azerbaijan.

Beginning at the Azerbaijani Embassy, the youth-led march rallied with chants, and a speech was given by AYF DC “Ani” Chapter chair Nayiri Shahnazarian. She described how Azerbaijan had blocked off the Berdzor (Lachin) corridor for 200 days, “effectively creating one of the largest open-air prisons in the world.” She exclaimed that “today’s Azerbaijani attack which took the lives of four Artsakh Armenians – in the midst of so-called ‘peace talks’ proved, once again, that Aliyev and Erdogan have no intention of honoring any peace deal.”

Her message to Armenians around the world was that “when these dictatorships attempt to drown out our voices, we shout louder. When they try to crush our willpower, we push harder. When they try to eradicate our hope, we keep believing.” She emphasized that “we will continue to show up and stand up for Artsakh, for Syunik, and for the Armenian people all over the globe because there is nothing stronger than our love for our culture, our language, our people and our homeland.”

She urged government officials to recognize that “any peace discussion must respect the Artsakh people’s right to self-determination and include Artsakh leaders in the negotiations.” She concluded her speech by proclaiming that the Biden administration must stop “greenlighting a second genocide against the Armenian people.”

AYF Washington DC “Ani” Chapter Chair, Nayiri Shahnazarian, delivering her remarks to the crowd in front of the Azerbaijani Embassy.

Shahnazarian’s remarks were broadcast live on the AYF DC Ani Chapter’s Facebook and Twitter channels and are available on YouTube.

Protesters continued chanting as they began marching to the Armenian Embassy, making their voices ring throughout the streets of Washington’s embassy row.

After arriving at the Embassy of Armenia, ARF Sebouh Gomideh member Sosy Bouroujian made a powerful impact on the crowd by calling out the reckless and irresponsible actions of the Pashinyan regime and described how they continued to give “concessions to the butchers in Baku, by handing over our nation to those who seek to eliminate Artsakh and Armenia.”

ARF Sebouh Gomideh member Sosy Boroujian speaking to the crowd in front of the Armenian Embassy.

She continued by pointing out that the Pashinyan government seeks “normalization with the terrorists in Turkey, who continue their attempted displacement and extermination of the Armenian people, over 100 years after the Genocide.”

Bouroujian explained that if we “listen to his own words,” “read his own writings” and “look at his own actions,” that “the facts bear out this painful truth: Pashinyan never wanted Artsakh” and that “Nikol Pashinyan does not deserve to walk on the lands that so many gave their lives to defend.” She expressed that we need to “stand strong and true – shoulder to shoulder with Armenians across the world – and double down on our struggle for justice and recognition” so that “the legacy of Artsakh and Armenia will not be one of cowardice, subjugation or defeatism. It will be one of courage, freedom and victory.”

Bouroujian ended with the most important message of all. “We will not bow to the demands of the genocidal dictators of Erdogan and Aliyev. We will not bend to satisfy requests of normalization with forces who are intent on annihilating the Armenian nation. And we most certainly will not break our unwavering commitment to advancing Hai Tahd. Let the world know. Armenia always exists and remains.”

Bouroujian’s remarks were broadcast live on the AYF Ani Chapter’s Facebook and Twitter channels and are available on YouTube.

Sune Hamparian is a junior member of the AYF DC “Sevan” Chapter. She’s been a member of the AYF for over six years and was recently elected to serve as chair. Sune is in the eleventh grade and spends her summers in Armenia with her family. She enjoys volunteering at the ANCA and learning about the world of politics.


RFE/RL Armenian Service – 06/28/2023

                                        Wednesday, 
Karabakh Leaders Urge Armenia To Halt Talks With Azerbaijan
        • Artak Khulian
Nagorno-Karabakh -- The parliament building in Stepanakert, September 7, 2018.
Nagorno-Karabakh’s leadership and main political factions urged Armenia to stop 
ongoing peace talks with Azerbaijan on Wednesday after four Karabakh Armenian 
soldiers were killed overnight in what Stepanakert described as an Azerbaijani 
ceasefire violation.
In a statement unanimously adopted by its members, the Karabakh parliament 
linked the bloodshed to a new round of U.S.-mediated negotiations which the 
Armenian and Azerbaijani foreign ministers began outside Washington on Tuesday.
It said that Yerevan must refuse to negotiate until Baku ends truce violations 
along the Karabakh “line of contact” and the Armenian-Azerbaijani border and 
provides “documentary guarantees” of its commitment to the ceasefire regime.
“Otherwise, the continuation of the negotiations would mean the encouragement of 
the Azerbaijani side’s aggressive behavior and a privilege [granted] at the 
international level,” it warned.
The statement also called for international sanctions against Baku and said 
Russian peacekeepers stationed in Karabakh should take “tougher measures to 
counter Azerbaijan’s inhuman, genocidal actions.”
The Armenian government did not immediately respond to the appeal. Prime 
Minister Nikol Pashinian tweeted instead that the international community should 
take “practical steps to ensure rights and security of the Nagorno-Karabakh 
people.”
Pashinian pointed to the deaths of the four Karabakh soldiers and the continuing 
Azerbaijani blockade of the Lachin corridor. “High risk of destabilization in 
the South Caucasus,” he added.
The Azerbaijani Foreign Ministry responded by accusing Pashinian of misleading 
the international community. The ministry spokesman, Aykhan Hajizada, claimed 
that the Azerbaijani army took “retaliatory measures” after one of its soldiers 
was wounded by “illegal” Armenian forces.
“Armenia, instead of interfering in Azerbaijan’s internal affairs, must … 
respect Azerbaijan’s sovereignty and territorial integrity in both words and 
deeds,” he wrote.
Meanwhile, Russia expressed serious concern at the overnight incident but 
stopped short of publicly blaming the Azerbaijani side for it. The Russian 
Foreign Ministry spokeswoman, Maria Zakharova, also renewed Moscow’s calls for 
Baku to fully unblock traffic through the only road connecting Karabakh to 
Armenia.
“We believe that taking quick measures to fully unblock the Lachin corridor and 
creating conditions for the normal life of the civilian population would 
contribute to a de-escalation of the situation,” Zakharova told reporters.
Pashinian drew strong condemnation from the Karabakh leaders and the Armenian 
opposition after he pledged in May to recognize Azerbaijani sovereignty over 
Karabakh through an Armenian-Azerbaijani peace treaty. His critics say the 
far-reaching move only emboldened Baku to step up the pressure on the Karabakh 
Armenians.
The peace treaty is the main focus of the ongoing meeting of the Armenian and 
Azerbaijani foreign ministers which began in the presence of U.S. Secretary of 
State Antony Blinken. The latter also held separate talks with the two ministers.
“We support Armenia and Azerbaijan working together toward a durable and 
dignified agreement,” Blinken tweeted late on Tuesday.
Four Karabakh Soldiers Killed In ‘Azeri Shelling’
Nagorno-Karabakh - A road sign at the entrance to the town of Martakert.
Nagorno-Karabakh’s military said on Wednesday morning that four Karabakh 
Armenian soldiers were killed when Azerbaijani forces shelled its positions 
overnight.
It said that the positions located in Karabakh’s Martakert and Martuni districts 
were struck by artillery systems as well as combat drones. The situation in 
these and other sections of the “line of contact” was “relatively stable” as of 
7 a.m. local time, according to the Karabakh Defense Army.
On Tuesday evening, Azerbaijan’s Defense Ministry accused Karabakh Armenian 
forces of wounding an Azerbaijani soldier and said it is taking retaliatory 
measures. The authorities in Stepanakert were quick to deny that. They said Baku 
used the “false” claims as an “information basis” for the overnight shelling, 
which was one of the deadliest ceasefire violations reported from Karabakh since 
the 2020 Armenian-Azerbaijani war.
Tensions along the Karabakh “line of contact” and the Armenian-Azerbaijani 
border have increased significantly over the past month, with the conflicting 
sides accusing each other of violating the ceasefire on a virtually daily basis. 
The Armenian government said earlier this month that Baku may be gearing up for 
another attack on Karabakh.
Azerbaijani Defense Minister Zakir Hasanov threatened the Karabakh Armenians 
with fresh military action in televised remarks aired on Monday. Azerbaijani 
President Ilham Aliyev said in late May that they must dissolve their government 
bodies and unconditionally accept Azerbaijani rule.
Erdogan, Pashinian Discuss Normalization Efforts
Czech Republic- Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian and Turkish President 
Recep Tayyip Erdogan meet in Prague, October 6, 2022.
Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan and Armenian Prime Minister Nikol 
Pashinian discussed efforts to normalize relations between their countries in a 
phone call on Wednesday.
Pashinian was reported to congratulate Erdogan on the Eid al-Adha Muslim 
holiday. His press office said the two leaders discussed the implementation of 
an agreement to open the Turkish-Armenian border to citizens of third countries. 
It did not elaborate.
Ankara and Yerevan reached the agreement last July after several rounds of 
negotiations held by their special envoys. They have still not said when it will 
be put into practice.
According to a Turkish readout of the phone call cited by the Anatolia news 
agency, Erdogan told Pashinian that the two neighboring states should continue 
to take “confidence-building measures.” No other details were reported.
Erdogan also spoke with Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev by phone. The Turkish 
leader visited Baku earlier this month. Following that trip, he praised 
Pashinian for attending his recent inauguration ceremony in Ankara.
Armenian opposition leaders condemned Pashinian’s presence at the ceremony held 
after Erdogan’s reelection. They argue that Ankara continues to fully support 
Azerbaijan in the Nagorno-Karabakh conflict and make the normalization of 
Turkish-Armenian relations conditional on Yerevan meeting Baku’s key demands.
Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan visited Turkey and met with his then Turkish 
counterpart Mevlut Cavusoglu in February in the wake of a powerful earthquake in 
the country’s southeast. Mirzoyan said afterwards that Yerevan and Ankara agreed 
speed up the normalization efforts.
Ankara banned Armenian airlines from flying over Turkey to third countries after 
municipal authorities in Yerevan unveiled in late April a monument dedicated to 
Armenians who had assassinated masterminds and perpetrators of the 1915 Armenian 
genocide in the Ottoman Empire. It threatened “new measures” against Armenia if 
the monument is not removed soon. Pashinian described the erection of the 
monument as a “wrong decision” when he spoke to RFE/RL’s Armenian Service in May.
Reposted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2023 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
 

[Press] From U.S. Embassy – Visit of Sanctions Coordinator Ambassador James C. O’Brien to Armenia

NEWS RELEASE:
Special Coordinator for Sanctions James O'Brien's visit to Armenia
c. Yerevan, June 29, 2023 - US Embassy in Armenia on June 29-30 
Armenia hosted Ambassador James O'Brien, who is currently in the USA 
holds a special position in the State Department's Sanctions Coordination Office 
the position of coordinator. During his visit to Armenia, Ambassador O'Brien will meet the RA high-ranking officials 
with officials, including the prime minister, to discuss the US sanctions 
issues of cooperation and to express his appreciation for securing US sanctions 
regarding Armenia's commitment. Նա նաև կայցելի Հայոց ցեղասպանության զոհերի 
հուշահամալիր։ ###
Visit of Sanctions Coordinator Ambassador James C. O’Brien to Armenia
Yerevan, Armenia –  – U.S. Embassy Yerevan welcomes Ambassador 
James C. O’Brien to Armenia June 29-30. Ambassador O’Brien currently serves as 
the Special Coordinator for Sanctions in the Office of Sanctions Coordination, 
at the U.S. Department of State. During his visit to Armenia, Ambassador O’Brien will meet with Armenian 
government officials, including the Prime Minister, to discuss cooperation on 
U.S. sanctions and express appreciation for Armenia’s continued commitment to 
upholding U.S. sanctions. He will also visit the Armenian Genocide Memorial in 
Yerevan.



Press Release.doc

_______________________________________________
Press mailing list
[email protected]

RFE/RL Armenian Service – 06/29/2023

                                        Thursday, 
More Progress Reported In Armenia-Azerbaijan Peace Talks
U.S. - U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken meets Armenian Foreign Minister 
Ararat Mirzoyan and Azerbaijani Foreign Minoster Jeyhun Bayramov, Washington, 
June 27, 2023.
The Armenian and Azerbaijani foreign ministers made further progress towards a 
bilateral peace treaty but still disagree on some of its key terms, official 
Yerevan said on Thursday night after they concluded a new round of U.S.-mediated 
negotiations.
Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan and his Azerbaijani counterpart Jeyhun Bayramov 
met outside Washington for three consecutive days. They also held trilateral 
meetings with U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken and National Security 
Adviser Jake Sullivan.
“The Ministers and their teams continued progress on the draft bilateral 
‘Agreement on Peace and Establishment of Interstate Relations,’” read a 
statement released by the Armenian Foreign Ministry.
“They reached an agreement on additional articles and advanced mutual 
understanding of the draft agreement, meanwhile acknowledging that the positions 
on some key issues require further work,” it said, adding that Mirzoyan and 
Bayramov pledged to “continue their negotiations.”
The statement did not disclose those articles or the remaining sticking points. 
It reflected Blinken’s comments made during the final session of the three-day 
talks.
The top U.S. diplomat also said that “there remains hard work to be done to try 
to reach a final agreement.”
“I think there is also a clear understanding on everyone’s part that the closer 
you get to reaching agreement, in some cases the harder it gets by definition. 
The most difficult issues are left for the end,” added Blinken.
The two sides were understood to disagree before the latest talks on practical 
modalities of delimiting the Armenian-Azerbaijani border and a dialogue between 
Baku and Nagorno-Karabakh’s leadership as well as international safeguards 
against non-compliance with the treaty.
Yerevan has been pressing for an “international mechanism” for such a dialogue, 
saying that it is essential for protecting “the rights and security” of 
Karabakh’s ethnic Armenian population. Bayramov made clear late last week that 
Baku will not agree to any special security arrangements for the Karabakh 
Armenians.
Minister Confident About Grape Purchases By Armenian Brandy Giant
        • Robert Zargarian
Armenia -- A truckload of grapes is transported to a storage facility in Ararat 
region run by the Yerevan Brandy Company, 14Sep2010
Economy Minister Vahan Kerobian said on Thursday that Armenia’s leading brandy 
producer will not cut back on purchases of grapes from domestic farmers this 
year despite the uncertain future of its vital exports to Russia.
The French group Pernod Ricard, which owns the Yerevan Brandy Company (YBC), 
announced in May that all of its subsidiaries around the world will stop 
exporting alcoholic beverages to Russia.
The move linked to Western sanctions against Moscow raised serious concerns in 
Armenia about the YBC’s continued operations. The bulk of its brandy, famous 
across the former Soviet Union, is sold in Russia. More importantly, the company 
has long been Armenia’s largest wholesale buyer of grapes grown by tens of 
thousands of farmers.
“[YBC] will not reduce the volume of its purchases compared with the previous 
years,” Kerobian told journalists. “This was our main concern and it has been 
dispelled.”
The YBC management has made no statements to that effect, however. It also 
remains reluctant to officially comment on the future of its exports to Russia. 
Russian and Armenian media outlets quoted unnamed company sources as saying 
after the Pernod Ricard announcement that the YBC is continuing brandy shipments 
to the Russian market.
Armenia - A vineyard in Armavir province, October 10, 2022.
Other Armenian brandy makers look set to buy fewer grapes this year. They 
already cut their purchases in 2022, sparking protests by hundreds of angry 
winegrowers unable to sell their main crop.
“The situation is already uncertain,” Arsen Simonian, a farmer from the 
wine-growing Ararat province, told RFE/RL’s Armenian Service.
Simonian, who owns a large vineyard in the village of Verin Artashat and heads a 
provincial association of winegrowers, said that about one-fifth of the local 
farmers have already decided to cut down their vineyards and possibly switch to 
other crops.
“We do not expect that the entire [2023] grape harvest will be bought,” Kerobian 
acknowledged earlier this month. “We are now trying to figure out methods for 
making the two ends meet.”
The minister said on Thursday that the Armenian government will impose stricter 
quality controls and other regulations on local brandy firms.
“Control of the quality of brandy will definitely lead to a large volume of 
[grape] purchases,” he said.
Simonian agreed that such oversight could greatly benefit grape farmers. But he 
questioned the government’s ability to enforce it properly.
U.S. Sanctions Official Visits Armenia
Armenia - Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian meets James O'Brien, head of the U.S. 
Department of State's Sanctions Coordination Office, Yerevan, .
A senior U.S. official met with Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian on Thursday for 
talks that were expected to focus on Armenia’s compliance with Western sanctions 
imposed on Russia over its invasion of Ukraine.
The U.S. Embassy in Armenia said earlier in the day that James O’Brien, the 
sanctions coordinator at the State Department, has arrived in Yerevan to discuss 
with Pashinian and other Armenian officials “cooperation on U.S. sanctions” and 
“express appreciation for Armenia’s continued commitment to upholding U.S. 
sanctions.”
An Armenian government statement on Pashinian’s talks with O’Brien did not 
mention the issue. It said the two men spoke about the Nagorno-Karabakh 
conflict, Turkish-Armenian relations and “various issues of mutual interest.”
O’Brien arrived in the Armenian capital from Tbilisi where he held similar talks 
with Georgian leaders earlier this week.
U.S. officials pressed the Armenian government to prevent Russia from evading 
the sanctions through Armenian companies during a series of meetings held this 
spring. Pashinian said on May 22 that despite its “strategic” relations with 
Russia Armenia “cannot afford to be placed under Western sanctions.”
A few days later, Pashinian’s government announced that Armenian exporters will 
now need government permission to deliver microchips, transformers, video 
cameras, antennas and other electronic equipment to Russia. The Armenian 
Ministry of Economy, which proposed the measure, cited the need to prevent the 
use of such items by foreign defense industries.
The Armenian Central Bank essentially confirmed on June 7 reports that local 
commercial banks have frequently blocked payments for such supplies wired by 
Russian buyers in the past few weeks.
According to government data, Armenia’s exports to Russia almost tripled in 2022 
and nearly quadrupled in January-April 2023. Goods manufactured in third 
countries and re-exported by Armenian firms are believed to have accounted for 
most of that gain. They include consumer electronics and other hi-tech goods and 
components which the Western powers believe could be used by the Russian defense 
industry.
The increased trade with and other cash flows from Russia are the main reason 
why the Armenian economy grew by 12 percent in 2022.
Yerevan To Continue Talks With Baku After Deadly ‘Provocation’
        • Ruzanna Stepanian
U.S. - U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken, Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat 
Mirzoyan and Azerbaijani Foreign Minister Jeyhun Bayramov start a new round of 
talks in Arlington, Virginia, June 27, 2023.
Prime Minister Nikol Pashinian on Thursday effectively dismissed 
Nagorno-Karabakh leaders’ call to halt Armenian-Azerbaijani peace talks made 
after four Karabakh soldiers were killed by Azerbaijani forces early on 
Wednesday.
In a statement adopted later on Wednesday, the Karabakh parliament said Yerevan 
must refuse to negotiate until Baku ends truce violations along the Karabakh 
“line of contact” and the Armenian-Azerbaijani border. It warned that failure to 
do so “would mean the encouragement of the Azerbaijani side’s aggressive 
behavior.”
Pashinian said that the soldiers’ deaths were the result of Baku’s pre-planned 
“military provocation” aimed at undermining his administration’s “efforts to 
establish peace between Armenia and Azerbaijan and address the issue of the 
Nagorno-Karabakh people’s rights and security.” He noted in this regard that the 
Armenian and Azerbaijani foreign ministers are continuing their latest round of 
U.S.-mediated negotiations that began outside Washington on Tuesday.
“There is no alternative to peace in our region, and our government, faced with 
all difficulties and complications, will continue the political path of peace,” 
Pashinian added at the start of a weekly cabinet meeting in Yerevan.
A U.S. State Department spokesman, Vedant Patel, said late on Wednesday that 
there is “no change in the schedule” of the Washington talks that are due to be 
wrapped up on Thursday evening.
“We are deeply disturbed by the loss of life in Nagorno-Karabakh, and we offer 
our condolences to the families of all of those who were killed,” Patel told 
reporters. “These latest incidents underscore the need to refrain from 
hostilities and for a durable and dignified peace.”
Earlier on Wednesday, Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan and his Azerbaijani 
counterpart Jeyhun Bayramov held a trilateral meeting with Jake Sullivan, the 
U.S. national security adviser, at the White House. Sullivan said he urged Baku 
and Yerevan to “continue making progress toward peace, as well as to avoid 
provocations and de-escalate tensions in order to build confidence.”
According to the Armenian Foreign Ministry, Mirzoyan told Sullivan that 
Azerbaijani artillery and drone attacks that left the four Karabakh soldiers 
dead are part of continuing Azerbaijani efforts to “subject Nagorno-Karabakh to 
ethnic cleansing.” Pashinian likewise accused Baku of pursuing a “consistent 
policy” of depopulating the Armenian-populated region.
Pashinian drew strong condemnation from the Karabakh leaders and the Armenian 
opposition after he pledged in May to recognize Azerbaijani sovereignty over 
Karabakh through an Armenian-Azerbaijani peace treaty discussed during the 
ongoing peace talks. His critics maintain that the Karabakh Armenians cannot 
live safely under Azerbaijani rule and would inevitably leave their homeland in 
that case.
Reposted on ANN/Armenian News with permission from RFE/RL
Copyright (c) 2023 Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty, Inc.
1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.
 

​Is Armenia’s Move to Join the ICC a Strategic Necessity or Geopolitical Suicide?

Is Armenia’s Move to Join the ICC a Strategic Necessity or Geopolitical Suicide?


ANNA OHANYAN

JUNE 28, 2023
COMMENTARY

The government’s initiative to ratify the Rome Statute has become a major test of Armenia’s relations with Russia and Russia’s sway over its peripheries.

Russian President Vladimir Putin’s war of conquest against Ukraine was intended to restore Moscow’s hold on a key part of its old empire. It has failed. With no end in sight to the war, Russian influence is gradually eroding in its claimed “privileged sphere of influence” on its periphery. Nowhere is this more evident than in Russia’s evolving relationship with Armenia, as Yerevan is flirting with ratifying the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court.

Russia is historically Armenia’s oldest and most vulnerable partner, bound to it by bilateral and multilateral security agreements signed in the wake of the Soviet breakup. Having succeeded in stopping the war between Armenia and Azerbaijan over Nagorno-Karabakh in 2020, Russia introduced its peacekeepers into the region, but it has been unable or unwilling to implement the very agreement it brokered. Peacekeepers have done little to stop Azerbaijani violations inside Nagorno-Karabakh; nor have they been able to maintain control over the Lachin corridor connecting Nagorno-Karabakh with Armenia, as it was stipulated they would in the agreement that the Kremlin brokered to end the war. Russia also ignored its bilateral security obligations to Armenia as well as its multilateral security commitments under the Collective Security Treaty Organization (CSTO) when Azerbaijan launched attacks at Armenia proper and established a military presence inside Armenia. Russia’s failure to intervene on Armenia’s behalf has rendered Yerevan’s security architecture with Moscow all but defunct.

Anna Ohanyan is a nonresident senior scholar in the Russia and Eurasia Program.

Armenia has responded by expanding its outreach to other countries. In addition to Armenia’s continued engagement with the United States in the areas of judicial and rule of law reforms, it has launched cooperation on civil nuclear energy. A series of high-level visits from Washington culminated in the September visit of a U.S. congressional delegation led by then Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi. In addition, Armenia signed a defense cooperation agreement with India in 2022, in another sign of diversifying security partnerships.

Public attitudes toward Russia are also in decline. Although 50 percent of Armenians still consider Russia one of their country’s most important political partners, it now trails behind France, Iran, and the United States.

The most recent move by Armenia’s government, certain to affect its relations with Russia, was the government’s December request for the Constitutional Court to examine whether the Rome Statute on the International Criminal Court (ICC) is compatible with its constitution. The request was motivated primarily by the government’s desire to gain leverage against Azerbaijan, which has not signed the Rome Statute. By becoming a party to the ICC, Armenia would gain an additional forum to mobilize the international public and legal opinion against Azerbaijan for its attacks on Armenian territory. Strengthening its deterrence capabilities against Baku is the primary driver for Yerevan’s move towards the ICC.

Armenia signed the Rome Statute in 1999 but has not ratified it. In 2004, the Constitutional Court ruled that portions of the Rome Statute violated the country’s constitution, but since then, the constitution has changed. On March 24, a few days after the ICC issued an arrest warrant for Putin for alleged war crimes against Ukraine, the Constitutional Court concluded its monthslong deliberations and—citing constitutional changes since 2004—removed the legal obstacle to Armenia’s ratification of the Rome Statute and membership in the ICC. This moves the issue into the political arena, putting the responsibility for the momentous step on the Armenian National Assembly.

The ICC arrest warrant for Putin made Armenia’s parliamentary ratification even more challenging. Its ICC membership would obligate the government to arrest the leader of its traditional ally, should he decide to visit Armenia.

The Kremlin’s reaction was swift. The official Russian news agency TASS, citing unnamed sources from the Foreign Ministry, declared that Armenia’s decision was “absolutely unacceptable” and warned of “serious consequences.” For its opening salvo, Moscow appears to have dusted off its Georgia playbook from 2006, when it banned wine imports from Georgia for perceived transgressions by its former colony. This time around, the Kremlin banned dairy imports from Armenia, ostensibly for some newly discovered health and safety concerns. Armenia’s 2022 dairy exports to Russia totaled around $30 million—a small amount even in the context of Armenia’s $19.5 billion 2022 GDP, but an important income source for rural Armenians.

The reaction to this development in Armenia has ranged from “strategic necessity” to “strategic suicide.”

Advocates of ratification cite geostrategic, security, and moral arguments. They maintain that the failure of Armenia’s policy of relying on Russia as its security guarantor has made the country more vulnerable to external attacks. Russia’s turning a blind eye to Azerbaijani incursions into Armenian territory in 2021 and 2022 means the end of its role as a security provider to Armenia, a precarious security condition further compounded by the growing partnership between Russia and the Azerbaijan-Türkiye axis directed against Armenia.

By ratifying the Rome Statute, Armenia would gain leverage and exercise some degree of accountability versus Baku. Membership in the ICC would give Armenia new legal tools to utilize in its efforts to constrain Azerbaijan. Advocates of ratification cite the extrajudicial execution of at least seven Armenian soldiers taken prisoner by Azerbaijani troops—an alleged war crime—during the September incursion into Armenia. Membership in the ICC would offer Armenia at least some prospect of holding Azerbaijan accountable.

Existential necessity is another argument. In an interview for this piece, one prominent Armenian legal scholar noted that “Armenians as a nation have experienced a genocide. We owe it to our next generations to ratify the Rome Statute.” He added that the ratification would improve Armenia’s security by enhancing its ability to hold Baku accountable, considering its territorial advances inside Armenia. The ratification also would extend the ICC jurisdiction over Armenia, allowing the ICC to regulate Armenia’s behavior if the ongoing precarious diplomacy with Azerbaijan breaks down and hybrid war tactics by Baku escalate into active warfare in the territory of either state. Armenia’s willingness to submit to the jurisdiction of the ICC would remove potential obstacles to weapons purchases from advanced industrialized democracies. In return, those countries would be reassured that the weapons would be used for defensive purposes only and in line with international laws governing the conduct of states at times of war.

Most, but not all, opponents of ratification come from the Republican Party, which ruled Armenia for many years before the 2018 Velvet Revolution, and the political elites aligned with its previous presidents Serzh Sargsyan and Robert Kocharyan. They have argued that ratification will cause “unpredictable consequences for the country.” Describing it as “political myopia,” they reflect the view of many who remain skeptical of the effectiveness of international organizations as deterrents against Azerbaijan. Provoking the wounded Russian bear is fraught with existential danger for Armenia, they say.

The political positions on the ratification transcend the “velvet divide,” the split in Armenian politics between those who backed the 2018 revolution and those who opposed it. The executive branch has reportedly debated the wisdom of proceeding with ratification and the security benefits that could be derived from it.

One lingering question is whether the Armenian government would arrest the Russian president if he traveled to the country. Armenia would be the third post-Soviet country outside the EU to ratify the Rome Convention, after Georgia and Tajikistan. Putin has visited Tajikistan several times without fear of being arrested. The established consensus dictates that the requirements of the Rome Statute supersede the principle of diplomatic immunity, but the track record on this is mixed at best. If Armenia ratified the statute, it would be obligated to arrest Putin if he traveled there, but the chances of that happening are virtually zero. Other ICC member countries have refused to arrest political leaders for whom arrest warrants have been issued. The risk to Armenia from refusing to arrest Putin would almost certainly be only reputational.

Discussions about ICC ratification have taken place alongside Armenia’s downgrading of its relations with CSTO. Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan’s government canceled a CSTO military exercise planned for the fall of 2022 and refused to fill the post of CSTO deputy secretary-general. It also rejected an offer from CSTO to deploy a monitoring mission on the Armenian-Azerbaijani border. The concern then was that the CSTO mission would do little to stop Azerbaijani incursions under the guise of impartiality—let alone help Armenia, even though it is a CSTO member and Azerbaijan is not. Pashinyan has even raised the possibility of freezing or terminating Armenia’s membership in the CSTO.

The Pashinyan government’s initiative to ratify the Rome Statute has become a major test of Armenia’s relations with Russia and Russia’s sway over its former dominions. Intended primarily to strengthen Armenia’s position against Azerbaijan, ICC ratification has landed squarely in the middle of Armenia’s reevaluation of its long-standing relationship with Russia. Uncontroversial and most likely quite popular had it been confined to the context of relations with Azerbaijan, the ICC decision has emerged as a major controversy in Armenian politics because of its likely impact on relations with Russia. The ICC debate has also exposed the limits of Russian statecraft since its invasion of Ukraine: that its longtime ally would consider breaking loose from its strategic embrace is a sign of Russia’s diminished soft and hard power in the region. The ratification vote in the Armenian parliament is bound to be a momentous event for the country, as well as for the entire South Caucasus region.

Carnegie does not take institutional positions on public policy issues; the views represented herein are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of Carnegie, its staff, or its trustees.

Foreign Ministers of Armenia, Azerbaijan meet with US Secretary of State in Washington

TASNIM News Agency, Iran
  • June, 28, 2023 – 11:52 
  • Other Media news 

“Meeting between Minister of Foreign Affairs of Armenia (Ararat Mirzoyan), the US Secretary of State (Antony Blinken) took place in Washington DC Issues of regional security & stability, normalization process between Armenia and Azerbaijan were discussed,” the ministry wrote on Twitter, TASS reported.

According to the ministry, the delimitation process between Armenia and Azerbaijan based on Alma-Ata Declaration and 1975 map, as well as “withdrawal of troops from border”, and “appropriately addressing rights and security issues of people of Nagorno Karabakh” were highlighted as important factors for “lasting peace in the region.”

Armenia PM wishes Turkey’s Erdogan happy Eid as Azerbaijan targets Nagorno-Karabakh

Diplomatic sources say the call comes amid an ongoing effort aimed at getting Turkey to rein in an increasingly aggressive Azerbaijan.

Amberin Zaman

Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan called Turkey’s President Recep Tayyip Erdogan on Wednesday amid spiraling tensions between his nation and Ankara’s close regional ally Azerbaijan, part of what regional diplomatic sources say is an ongoing effort aimed at getting Ankara to rein in an increasingly aggressive Baku. The Turkish presidency said in a statement that Pashinyan had congratulated the Turkish people on the occasion of the Muslim Feast of Sacrifice or Eid al-Adha, an unusual move for the leader of a majority Christian nation.

According to the readout of the conversation, the two leaders also touched upon ongoing normalization talks aimed at restoring full diplomatic relations and reopening the land border between the two countries. Regional officials speaking not for attribution to Al-Monitor said that Pashinyan continues to believe that detente with Ankara is the best guarantee of fending off another full-scale attack by Azerbaijan and is courting Erdogan to that end. Armenian officials hope that former Turkish spy chief Hakan Fidan’s appointment as foreign minister will bring new impetus to the talks.

Pashinyan was among the first leaders to congratulate Erdogan over his May victory in twin polls that saw his right-wing alliance win a majority in parliament as well.

Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan called Turkey’s President Recep Tayyip Erdogan on Wednesday amid spiraling tensions between his nation and Ankara’s close regional ally Azerbaijan, part of what regional diplomatic sources say is an ongoing effort aimed at getting Ankara to rein in an increasingly aggressive Baku. The Turkish presidency said in a statement that Pashinyan had congratulated the Turkish people on the occasion of the Muslim Feast of Sacrifice or Eid al-Adha, an unusual move for the leader of a majority Christian nation.

According to the readout of the conversation, the two leaders also touched upon ongoing normalization talks aimed at restoring full diplomatic relations and reopening the land border between the two countries. Regional officials speaking not for attribution to Al-Monitor said that Pashinyan continues to believe that detente with Ankara is the best guarantee of fending off another full-scale attack by Azerbaijan and is courting Erdogan to that end. Armenian officials hope that former Turkish spy chief Hakan Fidan’s appointment as foreign minister will bring new impetus to the talks.

Pashinyan was among the first leaders to congratulate Erdogan over his May victory in twin polls that saw his right-wing alliance win a majority in parliament as well.

According to protocol, Armenia’s president, Vahagn Khatchaturyan, should have attended Erdogan’s extravagant inauguration bash. However, Pashinyan elbowed him aside and showed up instead.

Wednesday’s phone call, initiated by Pashinyan, came amid reports that four Armenian servicemen had been killed after Azerbaijan carried out strikes early Wednesday along the contact line in Nagorno-Karabakh. The day prior, Azerbaijan claimed one of its own men had been killed in the zone by Armenian forces. The spike coincided with US-mediated talks in Washington aimed at securing a lasting peace deal between Armenia and Azerbaijan. The two countries last went to war in 2020 over the disputed enclave that is internationally recognized as part of Azerbaijan but has an ethnic Armenian majority.

Azerbaijan emerged victorious with Turkey’s and Israel’s help, wresting back all of its territories occupied by Armenia in a previous war over Nagorno-Karabakh in the early 1990s.

Olessya Vartanyan, the International Crisis Group’s senior analyst in the South Caucasus who recently traveled to Yerevan, noted that Armenia has a pretty low bar. “I didn’t get the sense that there are hopes that Ankara can pressure Baku,” Vartanyan said. “Rather, they are maintaining the strategy of engaging Ankara in order to avoid its full-scale participation (on the side of Azerbaijan) in case of a new war.”

Fears of conflict have been brewing since last year when Azerbaijan imposed a blockade on the sole route connecting Nagorno-Karabakh to Armenia proper, starving civilians of vital supplies and escalating attacks on Armenian forces inside Armenian territory.

Russian peacekeepers deployed to the region in keeping with a truce brokered by the Kremlin in November 2020 have failed to halt the violence. “Moscow is absolutely useless, no matter whether it attempts to resolve the crisis or not,” Vartanyan observed.  

The International Crisis Group reckons that at least 1,200 military personnel have either died or been wounded since then. The bulk of those killed along the front lines are Armenians. Azerbaijanis constitute the majority injured or killed by landmines.

Turkey-Armenia normalization talks that kicked off in Moscow in January 2022 have yielded little so far, even after Pashinyan formally conceded that Nagorno-Karabakh belongs to Azerbaijan.

A first, minuscule reward came a full year later when Turkey lifted its ban on direct cargo flights with Armenia. The sides are still working on the details of allowing third-country nationals and bearers of diplomatic passports to use the land border that was sealed by Ankara in solidarity with Baku in 1993 at the height of the first conflict, which was won by Armenia.

“Erdogan’s position is very clear: ‘Satisfy (Azerbaijani President Ilham) Aliyev’s desires and you will have something tangible on Turkish-Armenian relations,’” noted Benyamin Poghosyan, a Yerevan-based political analyst. As for Pashinyan, “I believe he simply wants to create a positive image of himself in the United States and the EU that, despite Erdogan’s position, he is a constructive guy.”

The United States and the EU have urged Azerbaijan to lift the blockade, but Azerbaijan’s strongman Aliyev has grown ever more intransigent due to growing European dependence on his country’s vast natural gas supplies that are piped to the continent via Turkey. The invasion of Ukraine has further eroded the Kremlin’s influence over former Soviet states, allowing Aliyev to grow ever more aggressive and for Turkey to expand its footprint in Russia’s backyard.

“Baku continues escalating despite (the US-brokered) talks,” Vartanyan said. “The region is left hoping that only US and EU involvement can prevent another war.”



Armenian soldiers killed by Azerbaijani forces in Nagorno-Karabakh, separatists say

Four Armenian soldiers were killed on Wednesday by Azerbaijani fire in Nagorno-Karabakh, said separatist authorities in the breakaway region, which has been at the centre of a decades-long territorial dispute between the Caucasus enemies.

See who else is reporting on this story and which side of the political spectrum they lean.

SEE MEDIA MISS BY THE RIGHT

23 other sources covering this story

Total News Sources

23

Leaning Left

2

Center

5

Leaning Right

8

Last Updated

16 hours ago

Left 13%

Center 33%

Right 53%

CLICKTO SEE HEADLINES

FAR LEFT

LEFT

LEAN LEFT

CENTER

LEAN RIGHT

RIGHT

FAR RIGHT

Bias Distribution Powered by Ground NewsTM