Humiliating EU deal offers little to Turkey

Media Monitors, USA
Jan 14 2005
Humiliating EU deal offers little to Turkey
by M A Shaikh
“…while the French and the Austrians, as well as others, are
virtually certain to block Turkish membership, they are not at all
hostile to the prospect of, say, Romania or Bulgaria joining,
although, as Ankara points out, these countries are even poorer than
Turkey. Their accession talks are in full swing, and they are not
subject to humiliating or obstructive objections or conditions.”
The deal recently negotiated by Recep Tayyip Erdogan, the Turkish
prime minister, in Brussels on his country’s longstanding quest for
membership of the European Union is, by general agreement, unfair and
humiliating, and by no means indicates – let alone guaranteeing –
that Turkey will eventually be allowed to become a member of the EU.
All it secures for Turkey is accession talks beginning on October 3,
which could last for a decade or more- with even more humiliating
conditions attached – and still fail to lead to admission into the
EU. Yet Erdogan, whose government is often described in the West as
`Islamic-leaning’, is determined to sell this compromising and
controversial arrangement to his own sceptical people -even to the
extent of arguing publicly that they should do much more than they
have already done to prove that their country is fit to be admitted
to the EU. But despite the fact that a large number of Turks are keen
to see their country join the Union and will support his conciliatory
– some would say submissive – style, the prime minister will find it
difficult to take the majority on board.
So much has been written and broadcast on the deal struck in Brussels
on December 17 that its provisions are familiar to all Turks and most
Muslims elsewhere, and need not be repeated here in detail.
Basically, an agreement was reached to commence accession talks on
October 3, with the understanding that talks will only start once
Turkey has signed an association agreement with all EU members,
including Greek Cyprus. A much stronger demand, calling for the
diplomatic recognition of the island, was rejected by Erdogan, who
threatened to walk out of the summit. This demand was based on the
contention that Ankara could not be invited to accession talks when
it did not recognise members of the organisation it wants to join.
Greek Cyprus was admitted to the EU on May 1 last year, despite the
fact that a UN project for reuniting the Greek and Turkish parts of
the divided island was on the table at the time.
The Turkish Cypriots had accepted the UN plan; the Greek Cypriots had
rejected it. By admitting the Greek part, the EU sabotaged the UN
project; while dropping its attempt to force Ankara to recognise
Greek Cyprus directly, it seems to have succeeded in forcing it to do
so indirectly. A direct recognition would have turned the Turkish
army’s presence in Northern Cyprus into that of an occupier. It was
not, therefore, surprising that Erdogan – and the chief of the
Turkish armed forces – objected strongly to it.
But the mere acceptance of the condition that accession talks will
not begin until Ankara signs a trade-agreement with the Greek
Cypriots means that the basis of an eventual recognition has been
laid. Moreover, the fact that the EU can make the start of accession
talks conditional on such a demand, and get away with it, means that
it can make further demands – such as Ankara’s agreement that the
killing of Armenians by the Ottomans amounted to `genocide’. On
December 19, for instance, Tassos Papadopoulos, the ruler of Greek
Cyprus, repeated his warning that Turkey’s EU accession is not
guaranteed, and that Cyprus would not support it unless Ankara
recognised his government. The prospect of Turkey joining the EU was
also treated with caution by much of the European media, and
opponents – led by Nicolas Sarkozy, head of the governing UMP party
in France – continue to express reservations.
Sarkozy told French television: `Europe already has difficulty
functioning with 25 members. The more members Europe has, the less we
will be integrated, the less we will share common values and the more
fragile we will be.’ Sarkozy is said to be more hostile to admitting
Turkey than Jacques Chirac, the French president, who is on record as
having said that he is in favour of Turkey’s membership.
Interestingly, it was Chirac who began to lay down the most effective
basis for rejection of membership when he announced that he would put
French acceptance to a referendum. He must know full well that most
French voters will reject it without any hesitation, given the
opportunity. Austria, another EU member – whose population is as
hostile to Turkish membership as the French – has announced that any
decision to admit Turkey will be submitted to a referendum. According
to EU rules, every member-state has the right to veto the acceptance
of new members by referendum.
But while the French and the Austrians, as well as others, are
virtually certain to block Turkish membership, they are not at all
hostile to the prospect of, say, Romania or Bulgaria joining,
although, as Ankara points out, these countries are even poorer than
Turkey. Their accession talks are in full swing, and they are not
subject to humiliating or obstructive objections or conditions.
So it is not at all surprising that a cross-section of Turkish
society, including highly secular people and groups, have objected
strongly to the deal agreed by Erdogan, demanding, when he returned
to Ankara from Brussels, that he abandon it. The opposition parties
and Islamic groups were the most vocal in their criticism. Denis
Baykal, leader of the main opposition group, the Republican People’s
party, said that `this is not the EU we want’, perhaps hinting, like
other objectors, that he is willing to join a union that respects
Turkish culture, religion and dignity. Certainly there are many Turks
from ethnic and religious minorities, such as the Kurds and the Roman
Catholic Christians, who believe that joining a friendly EU as an
equal member can advance their interests.
Most Turks who want to join the EU, however, `want to be a part of
Europe, but with our honour and values intact,’ as a factory-worker
was quoted on December 18 in a London paper as saying. The mayor of a
Turkish town, described by the same paper as `an undiluted EU
enthusiast’, says that he is `hurt’ by the attitudes of Europeans
towards his country.
Erdogan should heed his people’s views and feelings, and stop
demeaning them and destroying their bargaining position. By siding
with them, he is likely to gain more than from ignoring them for the
sake of a process that is extremely unlikely to culminate in the end
he desires.

Tbilisi ready to welcome NATO special envoy

Interfax
Jan 14 2005
Tbilisi ready to welcome NATO special envoy
Tbilisi. (Interfax-AVN) – A group of NATO experts has arrived in
Tbilisi to prepare the official opening of an office of the NATO
Special Representative for the South Caucasus and Central Asia,
Nikolai Laliashvili, chief of the defense policy and European
integration department in the Georgian Defense Ministry, told
Interfax- Military News Agency Friday.
According to him, the office will open in Tbilisi in February.
“It will be in Tbilisi, but will deal with Azerbaijan and Armenia,
rather than Georgia only,” he added.
He emphasized that the NATO special representative’s appointment is
an extremely important event for his country in terms of stepping up
the interaction with the Alliance, especially in light of the
organization’s approving of the program of cooperation with Georgia
in 2004.
The decision to send liaison officers and a special representative of
NATO to Transcaucasia and Central Asia was made at the NATO 2004
summit in Istanbul.
U.S. citizen Robert Simmons, NATO Deputy Secretary General, was
appointed the Alliance’s Special Representative for the South
Caucasus and Central Asia, who is expected to visit the countries in
the region from time to time. NATO Secretary General Jaap de Hoop
Scheffer introduced Simmons to leaders of the countries in question
during his November visit to the South Caucasus.
The Tbilisi office will also include Romualds Razhuks, the 49-year
old advisor to the Latvian defense minister and the former vice
speaker of the Latvian Seimas, who will be the liaison officer
coordinating the activities with Simmons.
Georgia voiced its intent to join NATO during the Prague summit in
2002.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

BAKU: Armenia becoming more interested in talks – Deputy FM

Assa-Irada, Azerbaijan
Jan 14 2005
Armenia becoming more interested in talks – Deputy FM

2004 can be described as a more active year in terms of the
negotiating process on the Armenia-Azerbaijan conflict over Upper
Garabagh, Azerbaijani Deputy Foreign Minister Araz Azimov told
journalists on Thursday. He said that during the three meetings of
the Azerbaijani and Armenian Presidents Ilham Aliyev and Robert
Kocharian and the four meetings of Foreign Ministers Elmar
Mammadyarov and Vardan Oskanian held in 2004, `views were exchanged,
which resulted in commonalities currently being discussed’.
Azimov said, however, that the approaches of the two sides are very
different and the situation is complex. At the same time, the parties
are interested in continuing the talks and consider them important
and useful, he said.
Azimov stated that `the meetings held are very important, but
`sensitive’, therefore, the sides agreed to provide the media `not
with the details but general information about them’.
Azimov emphasized that there are still a lot of differences, but said
he is confident that `the discussions will yield concrete results’.
He said that Armenia is becoming more interested in the talks.
`We hope the other side indeed has an intention to resolve the
conflict’, he said.
The Deputy Foreign Minister also pointed out that that the conflict
can be settled only within the principles of international law and
Azerbaijan’s territorial integrity.*

BAKU: OSCE fact-finding mission to visit occupied territories

Assa-Irada, Azerbaijan
Jan 14 2005
OSCE fact-finding mission to visit occupied territories

The OSCE Minsk Group (MG) co-chairs from Russia, United States and
France are due to arrive in Baku on January 28, Deputy Foreign
Minister Araz Azimov told a press conference on Thursday.
The MG co-chairs will visit the country as part of the OSCE
fact-finding mission which will look into the illegal settlement of
Armenians in the occupied
Azerbaijani lands. The mission will also include OSCE MG co-chairs
from
Germany, Italy, Switzerland and Finland.
Azimov said that the mission members will hold a number of meetings
with Azeri officials, after which they will tour the region. He said
that as part of preparations for the visit, the co-chairs will meet
with the other mission members in Vienna on January 21 to discuss
technical issues.
The Deputy Foreign Minister continued that `the mission should not
give any political assessments but prepare a report on the facts it
witnesses and confirms’.
The mission will visit five Azerbaijani regions – Kalbajar, Lachin,
Jabrayil, Gubadly and Zangilan, where Armenians were purposefully
settled, Azimov said.
`With regard to the two other regions, Aghdam and Fuzuli, I am not
aware of such facts’, he added.*

BAKU: NGO Forum appeals to CE rapporteur

Assa-Irada, Azerbaijan
Jan 14 2005
NGO Forum appeals to CE rapporteur

The Non-governmental Organizations (NGO) Forum has proposed to make
changes to the report prepared by the Council of Europe rapporteur on
Upper Garabagh David Atkinson to be presented to the PACE winter
session on January 25.
The Forum chairman Azai Guliyev told a recent roundtable that
although Atkinson’s report is unbiased, it does not reflect a number
of important issues. He welcomed the fact that the document confirms
Armenia as an aggressor, which perpetrated ethnic cleansing against
Azerbaijanis in Upper Garabagh and adjacent regions, and is trying to
establish a mono-ethnic state in the area, while Upper Garabagh is
controlled by separatist forces.
The appeal, signed by over 100 NGOs, was forwarded to rapporteur
Atkinson, relevant Council of Europe entities and embassies of CE
member-states in Baku.
The document suggests that the CE rapporteur’s report include
liberation of Upper Garabagh and seven neighboring regions,
immediately starting the process of returning refugees to their
homes, Armenia’s guaranteeing their security, evaluating and
compensating the financial and moral damages inflicted to Azeris who
became refugees as a result of occupation and deportation. The NGOs
also called for indicating the atrocities committed by Armenian
forces against civilians in Khojali in 1992 and legally assessing
this at the European Court and demanded Armenia to clarify the fate
of 4,852 Azerbaijanis that became captives, hostages and missing
persons in 1990-1994.*

BAKU: Stagnation predicted in Armenia

Assa-Irada, Azerbaijan
Jan 14 2005
Stagnation predicted in Armenia

Considering Armenia’s geo-political position and problems related to
its economic growth, the country’s future remains questionable for
Armenians. Therefore,
Armenian NGOs started implementation of the `Armenia-2020′ project in
2002.
The results of the project will be published in a book in Armenian,
Russian and English languages shortly.
The project coordinator Ardashesh Kazagetsyan told local media that
according to the project, only an insignificant part of people
involved in the project believe in economic progress in Armenia in 20
years.
`The majority of participants believe the situation in Armenia will
be the same or even deteriorate in 20 years, which is scary.’
Kazabetsyan stated that the project was participated in by 1,000
representatives of Armenia and 500 from the Armenian Diaspora in
foreign countries. The participants were from different regions and
with various occupations, he said.
Kazabetsyan continued that the project was valued at $2 million,
which was funded by wealthy Armenians living abroad. One part of the
project was prepared in Armenia and the other three parts in the
United States.*

BAKU: Companies dispatching cargo to Armenia determined

Assa-Irada, Azerbaijan
Jan 14 2005
Companies dispatching cargo to Armenia determined

Azerbaijani businessmen and 5 Georgian companies involved in
transporting cargo to Georgia and then to Armenia through Azerbaijan
have been determined.
A criminal case has been started over the activity of these
companies, the names of which are not disclosed, the Georgian Customs
Department reports.
According to initial investigation, the Azerbaijani companies have
transferred goods, which were purchased from Kazakhstan and
Turkmenistan, to Armenia.
Azerbaijani ambassador to Georgia Ramiz Hasanov told local ATV
channel that he was not authorized to name these companies.
Under the agreement reached with the Georgian Ministry of Finance,
the Azerbaijani government is regularly informed about the further
destination of the transit consignments.*

BAKU: Carriages en route to Georgia detained again

Assa-Irada, Azerbaijan
Jan 14 2005
Carriages en route to Georgia detained again

Freight carriages en route to Georgia through Azerbaijan were
detained two days ago to ascertain whether or not they were further
bound for Armenia. The number of such carriages withheld at Boyuk
Kasik and neighboring railway stations has reached 709, the State
Railway Office said.
336 of the carriages are loaded with grain, 278 with diesel, 36 gas
and 31 stove fuel, and the rest with other products.
In December, the Azerbaijani authorities detained numerous carriages
at Boyuk Kasik and other railway stations being transported through
the country’s territory to find out whether they were en route to
Armenia. After an investigation, the State Customs Committee chairman
Kamaladdin Heydarov said the companies engaged in transporting
consignments to Armenia were determined but did not disclose their
names.
According to the existing agreement, the cargo going through
Azerbaijan is not to be transported to Armenia through Georgia.
A working group is working at the Azeri embassy in Georgia to
ascertain the destination of the consignments.*

Burbank: Trial ordered in stalking by use of GPS

Los Angeles Daily News
Jan 14 2005
Trial ordered in stalking by use of GPS
Ex-boyfriend, 32, charged
By Naush Boghossian, Staff Writer
BURBANK — A 32-year-old man was ordered on Thursday to stand trial
on charges that he used a high-tech tracking device to stalk his
ex-girlfriend, the first case of its kind in Los Angeles County.
Following a daylong preliminary hearing, Ara Gabrielyan, who managed
a video store, was ordered tried on charges of stalking and making
criminal threats. He is accused of attaching a cell phone equipped
with Global Positioning System technology to the car of Gayane
Indzheyan, 35, and using it to keep track of her whereabouts.
Indzheyan testified during the hearing that Gabrielyan refused to
accept that she was ending their two-year relationship, and would
call her as many as 100 times a day.
“He said, ‘It’s going to be me or no one else in your life for the
rest of your life,”‘ she said.
“This was a relationship I wanted to be out of. I was dealing with
someone who was capable of doing anything … someone who’s pretty
dangerous,” she said. “I was dealing with it so it would end one day
and it would not end tragically for me or him.”
The Glendale businesswoman also testified that Gabrielyan was
violent, breaking her car windshield with his fist and crashing into
her parked car at work.
She said she became suspicious he was following her when he began to
show up at unexpected places, including Los Angeles International
Airport and even her brother’s grave site.
“I started thinking, How come he knows where I was all the time?” she
said.
Before she tried to end the relationship, Indzheyan said, she put up
her house and $20,000 in cash to bail him out of jail after he was
arrested in January 2004 on charges of credit card fraud.
Gabrielyan’s attorney argued that Indzheyan never really ended the
relationship and continued to call and have sex with him in order to
ensure that he would appear in court and she wouldn’t lose her
property.
“She used a fragile man as a puppet. Rather than ending the
relationship, she used herself as bait,” said defense attorney Andrew
Flier.
Outside court, Flier said he hopes to resolve the case before it goes
to trial later this month, with Gabrielyan being deported to Armenia,
where his family lives.
Prosecutors maintain that Gabrielyan was extremely manipulative,
making Indzheyan stay with him and comply with his desires.
“It wasn’t that she was stringing him along. She didn’t need to,”
prosecutor Keri Modder said. “He’s obsessed with her and wouldn’t
leave her alone. It’s a classic case of stalking.”

Oskanyan plans to visit Equatorial Guinea

United Press Interntional/Washington Times, DC
Jan 14 2005
Oskanyan plans to visit Equatorial Guinea
Armenian Foreign Minister Vardan Oskanyan plans to visit Equatorial
Guinea in mid-February, seeking the release of six Armenian pilots
convicted on Nov. 26, 2004, on charges of taking part in a failed
coup attempt and espionage. A court in the capital Malabu sentenced
the chief pilot to 24 years in prison and the rest to 14 years each.
Oskanyan said recently that the Equatorial Guinean authorities are
willing to meet with him, and details of the visit are being worked
out. Beginning in Jan. 2004 the pilots flew an AN-12 transporter
registered in Armenia but operating out of Equatorial Guinea under a
contract with a German company. On March 7, the pilots were arrested
in Malabu following the failure of the alleged coup. They denied all
charges, saying they had only begun working in Malabu two months
earlier. South African Nicholas de Toit, accused of masterminding the
coup attempt, received a sentence of 63 years in jail, while three
compatriots received sentences of 50-60 years. Equatorial Guinea
citizens convicted on the same charges received a one-year sentence.
The lawyer for the Armenian pilots has appealed their sentence in the
Supreme Court of Equatorial Guinea.