Turkey and the EU: a foot in the door?

The News International
Jan 21 2005
Turkey and the EU: a foot in the door?
Dr Maqsudul Hasan Nuri
The 25-member European Union’s decision this past December to start
talks with Turkey in October 2005 are a step towards Turkey gaining
full European Union membership. Accorded associate membership in
1962, its almost forty-year long wait to enter the EU club has much
to do with its history, culture, geography and economy.
Geographically, Turkey straddles the continents of Europe and Asia
with 97 percent of landmass within Asia and only three percent in
Europe. Although an extension of Asia and the Middle East, it has had
a European countenance since the Byzantine Empire.
The EU’s 35 sovereign states have a common denominator in the
Christian heritage of Roman and Greek civilisations. Turkey is “not
an inheritor of cultural contributor of ancient Greece and Rome, has
not experienced Reformation and Renaissance,” remarked Valery Giscard
d’Estaing, the former French President and President of European
Commission, expressing apprehensions that its entry may contribute to
Muslim fundamentalism in Europe. Many Europeans share these views.
Despite President Chirac’s approval, nearly 67 percent of French
oppose Turkish entry into the EU. Germany, which since World War II
has had a large Turkish population, is as sceptical.
Turkey’s human rights record may be a factor in this situation.
Amnesty International (2004) has reported its discriminatory policies
towards opposition, women, and ethnic and religious minorities, and
the treatment meted out to the Kurd minority. Atrocities perpetrated
under the Ottoman rulers are also brought up, like the Armenian
genocide of 1915-17. Turkish military role, despite its secular
traditions, also raises eyebrows.
France, Denmark and Austria thus suggest only a “privileged
partnership” status instead of full membership. But Turkey has many
assets. With a population of 78.8 million, it is the largest
contributor to NATO forces and a willing peacekeeper in many theatres
of global conflict — Herzegovina in 1995, Kosovo in 1999 and ISAF in
Afghanistan since 2001. During the four decades of Cold War, it acted
as a reliable and redoubtable shield against the Communist threat.
The Kemalist tradition has enabled it to follow a secular,
constitutional, parliamentary democracy. With proximity and cultural
interconnectedness, it has worked hard to be part of Europe – as a
member of Council of Europe since 1949, NATO since 1952 and part of
the European Custom Union since January 1996.
The Islamic government of Justice and Development Party (AKP) under
Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan has repackaged itself as “Muslim
Democrats” a la European Christian Democrats. Raised in a poor
Istanbul neighbourhood, the charismatic firebrand Erdogan once
thundered: “The mosques are our barracks, the domes our helmets, the
minarets our bayonets, and the faithful are our warriors.” Yet in the
last two years his government has rewritten two-fifth of the
Constitution, repealed the death penalty, brought the army decisively
under political control, granted language rights to the Kurds,
promoted free speech and liberalised the economy.
Situated on the cusp of Asia and Europe, Turkey can act as a
bridgehead between Islamic and Western civilisations. With an
increased role in an expanding NATO and greater scope for economic
interaction, it will bring vitality to the EU. It is also seen as a
useful player in the global war against terrorism. (Napoleon
Bonaparte once observed that if there was a Pan-European state
Istanbul will be its capital.)
The Ottoman Empire’s record of dealing with minorities was generally
benign (it was the Christians who persecuted the Jews and hounded
them out of their homes). It is said that Turks have “tolerance in
their bones.” Present day Turkey, like Indonesia, represents moderate
Islam and bears least sympathy for al-Qaeda. The government’s agenda
is to root out corruption and Western style immorality.
Europe’s GDP is about $11 trillion like the US. Presently a “soft
power”, with induction it is getting larger. New members in 2007,
Romania, Bulgaria and Croatia, have a lower capita income than
Turkey. The next candidate may well be Ukraine. Turkish entry would
mean an increase in Europe’s population, resources and military clout
that may somewhat offset US hegemony. The EU has no ambition to
either become a superpower or turn hostile towards the US, but the
latter has to understand that this “lure of membership” is a
testament to EU’s increasing magnetic pull.
Yet Turkey’s road to full membership is fraught with pitfalls and
will be long and bumpy. The “yes” for accession talks has to be
followed up by Turkey’s recognition of Greek Cyprus, as well as
speeded up economic, political, social and economic reforms within
the coming decade.

The writer is Senior Research Fellow, Islamabad Policy Research
Institute (IPRI). Email: [email protected]

Motion made to free Las Vegas sisters

Motion made to free sisters
Legal team tries to win release for Armenian family
Las Vegas Sun
January 21, 2005
By Timothy Pratt ([email protected])
The legal team representing the Sarkisians, an Armenian family whose
teenage daughters are threatened with being deported to their
birthplace, has filed an emergency motion to release the girls from a
Los Angeles immigration detention cell.
“What’s the point of detaining them? They’re young girls who should be
with their family,” said attorney Jeremiah Wolf Stuchiner this morning.
“They’re not a flight risk and detaining them is just costing taxpayers
money,” he said.
The case involves Emma Sarkisian, 18, and her sister, Mariam Sarkisian,
17. They are threatened with deportation because their immigration
status was never straightened out although they have lived here 14
years, during which time their father, Rouben, has become a U.S.
resident, the step below citizenship — according to the family and
their attorney.
The Sarkisian family also includes three younger girls who were born on
U.S. soil and therefore are citizens.
The family has been broken up since last week after immigration
authorities arrested the daughters last Friday and sent them to Los
Angeles, where flights to Russia leave once daily.
Stuchiner was able to obtain a stay from the federal magistrate in Las
Vegas, arguing that immigration authorities should wait four months
while Rouben prepares himself to become a citizen.
Once Rouben is a citizen, he can petition for his daughters, and they
can become residents, Stuchiner said.
The attorney said the federal magistrate can decide on the emergency
motion at any time.
Meanwhile, family friend Marina Protopopova said members of the
Sarkisian family are driving today to Los Angeles to seek support from
the Armenian community there.
As of this morning there was also no court date to decide on the larger
issue of whether the daughters should be allowed to stay in the United
States until their father becomes a citizen, Stuchiner said.
“I’m arguing that it is the federal court’s discretion and humanitarian
interest to let them stay,” Stuchiner said.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Church service in memory of Armenians killed in Baku

PanArmenian News
Jan 21 2005
CHURCH SERVICE IN MEMORY OF ARMENIANS KILLED IN BAKU
21.01.2005 16:56
/PanARMENIAN.Net/ January 23 Catholicos of All Armenians Garegin II
will serve in St. Echmiadzin a special ritual in the memory of
Armenians killed in the course of the pogroms in Baku in January
1990. The commemoration of the victims will be served by all Armenian
churches throughout the globe. The liturgies will be offered Sunday.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Armenian servicemen sent to Iraq

Agency WPS
DEFENSE and SECURITY (Russia)
January 21, 2005, Friday
ARMENIAN SERVICEMEN SENT TO IRAQ
SOURCE: Nezavisimaya Gazeta, January 19, 2005, p. 5
by: Viktoria Panfilova
THE DECISION TO SEND A MILITARY CONTINGENT TO IRAQ IS AN ATTEMPT ON
OFFICIAL YEREVAN TO INDICATE THE INTENTION TO INTRODUCE SERIOUS
CHANGES IN ITS FOREIGN POLICY
Armenian servicemen were seen off to Iraq, yesterday. The ceremony
took place in Evartnots airport, Yerevan. Forty-six servicemen will
become a part of the Polish contingent. The parliament of Armenia
ratified the Memorandum on Understanding concerning participation in
Iraq, the other day. The decision to send Armenian servicemen to Iraq
was made during President Robert Kocharjan’s visit to Poland. It was
agreed as well that a limited Armenian contingent (up to 50
servicemen) would serve in Iraq under the Polish flag.
To quote Aram Sarkisjan, leader of the oppositionist Democratic Party
that is an element of Justice coalition, “A great deal of Armenians
have lived in the Middle East for the last 100 years. Because of the
genocide, you know. The authorities of Arab countries accepted them
and permitted them to develop their originality. That is why we think
it wrong to meddle in the affairs of Arab countries. What information
we possess at this point indicates anti-Armenian moods in Arab
countries, particularly in Iraq, Lebanon, Syria, and the United Arab
Emirates. Worse than that, we do not rule out the possibility of
dramatic consequences of this decision for our country.”
Debates in Armenia over involvement in Iraq lasted over two months.
They were fierce both in society and in the parliament. The National
Assembly ratified the accord after an eight-hour meeting last Monday
but never reached a consensus on the matter.
Lawmakers who voted “nay” claim that the presence of a contingent in
Iraq will collide with national interests of the country, interests
of state security. Moreover, it will generate a threat to the
existence itself of the Armenian community in Iraq numbering 25,000
people and Armenian communities in Moslem countries.
Sarkisjan told this correspondent that the decision to send
servicemen to Iraq is an attempt on the part of official Yerevan to
indicate the intention to introduce serious changes in its foreign
policy.
It should be taken into account meanwhile that Russia is Armenia’s
geo strategic ally and that this fact cannot help having an effect on
the bilateral relations between Moscow and Yerevan. In fact, Moscow
already used its influence with Armenia more than once to prevent its
strategic ally in the Caucasus from becoming too independent. Neither
did Armenian leaders consult with countries of the Organization of
the CIS Collective Security Treaty. “Hence the criticism of the
authorities’ stand on the matter,” Sarkisjan said.
Translated by A. Ignatkin

Sydney: All in the family for the Sarkisians

AAP NEWSFEED
January 21, 2005, Friday 2:24 AM Eastern Time
Spo: All in the family for the Sarkisians
By Billy Freeman
SYDNEY, Jan 21
Dinner table discussion at the Sarkisian household often focuses on
goals and how to achieve them.
Father Yuri and son David know exactly what they want, but the
problem is only one of them can achieve it.
Both Yuri and David want to win weightlifting gold at next year’s
Commonwealth Games in Melbourne in the men’s 69kg class and are
realistic about facing off against each other.
Yuri, 44, won three gold medals at the 2002 Commonwealth Games in
Manchester in the 62kg class, but has moved up a class in order to
compete against his son.
“We want the father and son to fight for the gold medal, which has
never happened before (in the) last 100 years,” said the senior
Sarkisian, who was born in Armenia and began representing Australia a
decade ago.
He said he would show his son no mercy if they both make the final in
Melbourne, saying his competitiveness would take over.
“This is the sport, it doesn’t matter,” he said.
“I know (we are) father and son, but you should fight until the
last.”
As you would expect from an 18-year old, David concedes nothing to
his father.
He wants to be the one standing atop the dais in Melbourne, teasing
his dad that it might be time to step aside.
“I’m not going to give him a chance to win anyway – he needs to
retire,” he said.
“In a couple of months I should be a lot stronger so I don’t think
he’ll have a chance anyway.”
David is currently competing at the Australian Youth Olympic Festival
(AYOF) in Sydney.
At the last AYOF in 2003 he won gold, adding to an already successful
career at such a young age.
He said he sometimes had to pinch himself that he was getting to
follow in his father’s footsteps.
“He’s like an idol, I used to always see him go off to competitions
and he would come back with medals,” he said.
“One day I just started to go down and train with him and now I’m
competing in international competitions.”

Armenian troops join coalition force in Iraq

Associated Press Worldstream
January 21, 2005 Friday 12:52 PM Eastern Time
Armenian troops join coalition force in Iraq
WARSAW, Poland
A contingent of 46 Armenian non-combat troops joined the Polish-led
coalition force in Iraq on Friday, a military spokesman said.
Gen. Andrzej Ekiert, the commander of the 6,000-strong Polish-led
international force, shook hands with the Armenian soldiers and spoke
a few words of welcome to them at the force’s headquarters in
Diwaniyah, south of Baghdad, said Lt. Col. Artur Domanski, a Polish
military spokesman.
The 46 soldiers – 10 bomb-disposal experts, 30 drivers, three medics
and three officers – will be given a week “to get acclimated to the
climate, get equipment and rest” before starting work, Domanski said.
The troops will be based at Camp Charlie in the city of Hillah.
Armenia’s parliament voted in December to send the contingent, a move
that was backed by President Robert Kocharian but drew sharp
criticism from many Armenians, opposition groups, and even the
30,000-strong Armenian community in Iraq, which fears being targeted
for attacks.

U.S. official’s statement angers Armenians

Associated Press Worldstream
January 20, 2005 Thursday
U.S. official’s statement angers Armenians
by AVET DEMOURIAN; Associated Press Writer
YEREVAN, Armenia
A statement by a U.S. State Department official about unrecognized
regimes in the former Soviet Union has sparked an uproar in Armenia,
with groups ranging from students to scientists taking offense over a
comment involving the disputed Nagorno-Karabakh region.
Armenians picked up on comments that Elizabeth Jones, assistant
secretary of state for Europe and Eurasia, made last week in a video
link with journalists in Moscow, Bratislava and Rome ahead of a
meeting next month with Russian President Vladimir Putin in Slovakia.
Jones said it is in Russia’s interests for the self-proclaimed
republics of South Ossetia and Abkhazia in Georgia, Trans-Dniester in
Moldova, and Nagorno-Karabakh in Azerbaijan “to be stable, for
corruption to end there, for criminal secessionists who rule there to
be removed,” according to the English-language Moscow Times
newspaper.
Nagorno-Karabakh is a mostly ethnic Armenian enclave that has been
under ethnic Armenian control since a deadly six-year war against
Azerbaijani forces that ended in 1994 with a cease-fire, but without
a political settlement. Its self-proclaimed government is backed by
Armenia but is not internationally recognized.
Armenian media lashed out at Jones, and leaders of the small Caucasus
Mountain nation’s Academy of Sciences discussed it Wednesday, with
one scholar, Nikolai Oganesian, calling it “prevocational” and
another, Konstantin Karagezian, calling it “amoral.”
On Tuesday, several hundred students marched to the U.S. Embassy in
Yerevan, the capital, and handed over a declaration saying it was
“unacceptable.” Neither Armenia’s government nor the leadership of
Nagorno-Karabakh has reacted publicly, however.
The U.S. Embassy issued a statement Tuesday reiterating that the
United States “does not recognize Nagorno-Karabakh as an independent
country,” does not recognize its leadership, and supports the
territorial integrity of Azerbaijan.
It said the United States “holds that the future status of
Nagorno-Karabakh is a matter of negotiation between the parties in
the Minsk Group process,” in which mediators led by the United
States, France and Russia are working with Azerbaijan and Armenia to
foster a peaceful settlement. Nagorno-Karabakh’s leadership is not
involved.
The statement said Jones’ comment “was directed at the need for the
U.S. and Russia to work together to resolve the conflicts and advance
transparency and rule of law in the conflict areas. We recognize that
the circumstances of each conflict are unique.”

ARKA News Agency – 01/21/2005

ARKA News Agency, Armenia
Jan 21 2005
New UNICEF representative takes over in Armenia
Flu illnesses cases not registered in Armenia in Jan 2005
2005 to be a year of resistance to external challenges for Armenia –
RA NA Deputy
S.Chzmachian: 2004 was unexampled successful for RA banking system
*********************************************************************
NEW UNICEF REPRESENTATIVE TAKES OVER IN ARMENIA
YEREVAN, January 21. /ARKA/. Mr. Sheldon Yett, a U.S. citizen is
appointed new UNICEF Representative in Armenia, according to the
UNICEF Office in Armenia. The new UNICEF Representative has a 12-year
experience in the field of international development and has been
working iwith UNICEF headquarters in New York as a coordinator of
humanitarian issues and has also served in Somalia, Burundi and
Kosovo, as well as in other field duty stations.
The new UNICEF representative in Armenia has already met with the RA
Foreign Minister Vardan Oskanian, and looks forward to working with
the Government of Armenia and other counterparts. L.V.-0–
*********************************************************************
FLU ILLNESSES CASES NOT REGISTERED IN ARMENIA IN JAN 2005
YEREVAN, January 21. /ARKA/. Flu illnesses cases were not registered
in Armenia in Jan 2005, Chief Doctor of Infection Clinics `Nork’ Ara
Asoyan stated today. According to him, at the moment 32 people are at
the hospital with respiratory diseases, however none of them has flu.
He added that there were no registered cases of botulism in 2005.
L.D. -0 –
*********************************************************************
2005 TO BE A YEAR OF RESISTANCE TO EXTERNAL CHALLENGES FOR ARMENIA –
RA NA DEPUTY
YEREVAN, January 21. /ARKA/. 2005 will be a year of resistance to
numerous external challenges for Armenia, as stated historian Hamlet
Harutunyan, the RA NA deputy in the National Press Club today.
According to him, the political forces of the country should
consolidate around the national problems, in particular, the Karabakh
issue. The statement of the US Assistant Secretary of State Elizabeth
Jones, he considers in the context of USA testing the interpolitical
stability in the country. Such checkups, according to him, can be
expected on the part of Russia as well. `They cannot thrust the
unfavorable settlement of the Karabakh conflict on us, if we come out
as one’, noted the deputy. At that, Harutunyan added that the problem
of change of power will not be pressing this year, as the opposition
has missed the opportunity which could be carried out in 2004. L.V.
-0 –
*********************************************************************
S.CHZMACHIAN: 2004 WAS UNEXAMPLED SUCCESSFUL FOR RA BANKING SYSTEM
Exclusive Interview of Samvel CHZMACHIAN, the Chairman Armenian Banks
Union to ARKA News Agency
ARKA – What was 2004 for RA banking system?
S.Chzmachian – 2004 was unexampled successful for RA banking system.
Thus, the assets of the system grew by 27.1% and achieved 365 billion
AMD and it is very good indicator. The credits grew by 39.6% and made
more than 130 billion AMD, total authorized capital grew by 6.7% and
stood at 39.2 billion AMD. Total capital of the banks grew by 26.5%
and achieved more than 63 billion AMD. Profit of the banks exceeded
10 billion AMD, having increased by 58.6%. Unfortunately not all the
banks can independentely overcome normative level on total capital in
$5 million by July 1, 2005. They now conduct negotiations with
investors and in favourable result they will be able to attract new
shareholders and remain in banking field.
ARKA – How do you estimate CB decision to increase the normative on
total capital for newly creating banks from $5 million to $10
million? What do you think, will the given normative change for
acting banks?
S.Chzmachian – Using the opportunity, I ask CB not to change the
demand to the capital for acting banks in near 5 years. According to
the information I poses, neither one country in Europe and Asia and
even in America, besides Kazakhstan, has the demands on capital more
than $5 million. I think, in this issue we should try to present
ourselves as bigger Catholics than Rome Pope, because it can lead to
losing of investors’ interest to banking activity in our country. The
banks themselves understand that it is necessary to increase the
capital and competition will lead to it without pressure by CB. CB
has made much for the banking system in the whole, however I think
that negative conditions that occurred in banking system in last 2-3
years, namely bankrupt Ardshinbank and Credit-Yerevan Bank, should
frighten our main bank, so much that it made such a decisions.
Armenian Banks Union asks CBA not to make decision when either the
sum of the capital is decreasing, or minimal demands to it are
growing.
ARKA – What risks expect banking system in 2005?
S.Chzmachian – We must be maximally careful in the issue of
crediting, must correspond to new demands on foreign exchange
position. The banks must be very attentive in fulfillment of demands
of new law on fight against money laundry and financing of terrorism,
because even one mistake committed by one bank can have significantly
negative influence on the whole banking system of Armenia. The banks
must be careful in hiring people. I would like to mention that
corporate management implemented by CB should not envisage full
depersonalization of people. L.D. -0 –

Armenian-Azeri friendship interpreted by Tolyshpress

PanArmenian News, Armenia
Jan 21 2005
ARMENIAN-AZERI FRIENDSHIP INTERPRETED BY TOLYSHPRESS
21.01.2005 16:09
/PanARMENIAN.Net/ January 20 Tolyshpress information agency published
curious material, which says that “according to an investigation held
by Azadlyg, Azeri companies, which send cargo to Armenia, are under
the protection of top persons of the country. Thus, head of Azpetrol,
which supplies fuel to Armenia, is brother of Minister of Economic
Development Farhad Aliyev. Monopolist in that sphere – ABU Holding –
is owned by brother of Chairman of the State Committee for Securities
Heydar Babayev. The protector of the supplies of tea, vegetable oil,
fish to Armenia is head of the customs Kemaleddin Heydarov, while
that of corn supplies is head of the President Administration Ramiz
Mehtiyev.

Rustavi 2 prepares telecast on Javakhk

PanArmenian News, Armenia
Jan 21 2005
RUSTAVI 2 PREPARES TELECAST ON JAVAKHK
21.01.2005 15:42
/PanARMENIAN.Net/ Journalists of Rustavi 2 Georgian TV Company are
preparing a telecast, devoted to the problems of relations between
Tbilisi with the Javakhk region. In the opinion of TV Company
journalist Nata Koberidze, the ethnic factor adds to these in
Javakhetia. Koberidze considers that if people here demand
self-determination, some real grounds for that should be present. “In
my personal opinion, Akhalkalak residents have such a right to some
degree. It is natural that as a proud people it cannot bear violence.
If the state cannot solve their problems, they have to rely on their
own,” she says. In the opinion of the TV journalist, the situation in
Javakhk is harder than that in Georgian regions inhabited by Azeris,
A-Info news agency reported.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress