Foreign Ministry Comments on Atkinson Report

PRESS RELEASE
Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Republic of Armenia
Contact: Information Desk
Tel: (374-1) 52-35-31
Email: [email protected]
Web:
Question by Armenpress:
Yesterday the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe heard the
³Atkinson Report² on the Nagorno Karabakh conflict, and passed a resolution.
What is your assessment?

Answer by Ministry of Foreign Affairs Spokesman Hamlet Gasparian:
At the outset, it must be said that we value highly the Council of Europe¹s
efforts aimed at the South Caucasus, and in particular, at establishing
stability and long-term peace in the region. At the same time,
notwithstanding its positive points, the Atkinson Report was, in our view,
generally faulty, since it focused on the consequences of the conflict,
without delving into its causes. Further, we believe that the process of
amending the report was not an objective one. One of our amendments, which
even had the support of the Rapporteur himself, did not pass because of the
Turkish chairman of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe
Political Affairs Committee.

Nevertheless, we welcome the various principles which are reaffirmed in the
document by PACE. Specifically, that Resolution reaffirms that independence
and secession of a regional territory ³may only be achieved through a lawful
and peaceful process based on democratic support by the inhabitants of such
territory² as well as that ³the problem cannot be resolved by use of
military force, that the status and future of a population must be
determined by that population.²

We also consider important the amendment (which was our proposal) where PACE
recalled the obligation which Armenia assumed upon Council of Europe
membership – to use its influence with the Armenians of Nagorno Karabakh in
order to achieve a resolution to the conflict. This effectively reinforces
the understanding that the conflict is between Azerbaijan and Nagorno
Karabakh.

Still, this document is not a binding document. It is of an advisory and
declarative nature. The negotiations will continue within the Minsk Group
framework, and we believe that the positive and negative aspects of the
Resolution cannot have a specific affect on the actual negotiations.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

MFA: H.Gasparian, Foreign Ministry Spokesman, comments PACE res.

MINISTRY OF FOREIGN AFFAIRS OF THE REPUBLIC OF ARMENIA
PRESS AND INFORMATION DEPARTMENT
375010 Telephone: +3741. 544041 ext 202
Fax: +3741. .562543
Email: [email protected]:
PRESS RELEASE
January 27, 2005
Hamlet Gasparian, Foreign Ministry Spokesman, answers question by Armenpress
News Agency
Question: Yesterday the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe
heard the “Atkinson Report” on the Nagorno Karabakh conflict, and passed a
resolution. What is your assessment?
Answer: At the outset, it must be said that we value highly the Council of
Europe’s efforts aimed at the South Caucasus, and in particular, at
establishing stability and long-term peace in the region. At the same time,
notwithstanding its positive points, the Atkinson Report was, in our view,
generally faulty, since it focused on the consequences of the conflict,
without delving into its causes. Further, we believe that the process of
amending the report was not an objective one. One of our amendments, which
even had the support of the Rapporteur himself, did not pass because of the
Turkish chairman of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe
Political Affairs Committee.
Nevertheless, we welcome the various principles which are reaffirmed in the
document by PACE. Specifically, that Resolution reaffirms that independence
and secession of a regional territory “may only be achieved through a lawful
and peaceful process based on democratic support by the inhabitants of such
territory” as well as that “the problem cannot be resolved by use of
military force, that the status and future of a population must be
determined by that population.”
We also consider important the amendment which had (which was our proposal):
the PACE reminder of the obligation which Armenia assumed upon Council of
Europe membership – to use its influence with the Armenians of Nagorno
Karabakh in order to achieve a resolution to the conflict. This effectively
reinforces the understanding that the conflict is between Azerbaijan and
Nagorno Karabakh.
Still, this document is not a binding document. It is of an advisory and
declarative nature. The negotiations will continue within the Minsk Group
framework, and we believe that the positive and negative aspects of the
Resolution cannot have a specific affect on the actual negotiations.

www.armeniaforeignministry.am

Post-Holocaust World Promised ‘Never Again’ — But Genocide Persists

Radio Free Europe, Czech Republic
Jan 26 2005
World: Post-Holocaust World Promised ‘Never Again’ — But Genocide Persists
By Daisy Sindelar

British Prime Minister Winston Churchill called it a “crime that has
no name” — the Nazis’ deliberate and systematic extermination of as
many as 6 million European Jews. But a name was soon found —
genocide, literally the killing of a people or nation. The Genocide
Convention adopted by the United Nations in 1948 was meant as a
pledge to ensure the horrors of the Holocaust would never be
repeated. But since then, the world community has consistently failed
to prevent the occurrence of genocide in places like Cambodia,
Rwanda, Bosnia, and northern Iraq. Why has the promise of “never
again” proven so difficult to honor?
Prague, 26 January 2005 (RFE/RL) — The term “genocide” saw its first
legal application during the Nuremburg trials (1945-46) of Nazi war
criminals.
The top surviving officials of Adolph Hitler’s regime were indicted
on crimes including the extermination of racial, national, and
religious groups.
In a televised trial 15 years later in Israel, Adolph Eichmann — the
man responsible for the implementation of the Nazi plan to eliminate
Europe’s Jews — faced inarguable evidence that he, too, had
contributed to genocide on a massive scale.Mass murder of national,
ethnic, and tribal groups has continued with depressing frequency —
most recently in Sudan, where pro-government Arab janjawid militias
have been blamed for the deaths of tens of thousands of black
Sudanese in the western region of Darfur.
“The accused, together with others, during the period 1939 to 1945,
caused the killing of millions of Jews in his capacity as the person
responsible for the execution of the Nazi plan for the physical
extermination of the Jews known as the Final Solution of the Jewish
problem,” a news anchor reported at the time.
Eichmann was hanged on 31 May 1962.
The Nazi trials and the 1948 Genocide Convention reflected a
determination in the world community to prevent a recurrence of the
Jewish Holocaust. But it was not enough.
Mass murder of national, ethnic, and tribal groups has continued with
depressing frequency — most recently in Sudan, where pro-government
Arab janjawid militias have been blamed for the deaths of tens of
thousands of black Sudanese in the western region of Darfur.
The United States has said the killings in Darfur constitute
genocide, providing a basis for action under international law. But
there has virtually been no intervention to date.
Why has the international community failed to keep genocide from
happening?
Bernard Hamilton is the president of the Leo Kuper Foundation, a
nongovernmental organization working for the eradication of genocide.
Speaking from London, he said the international community has been
slow to follow on the promise of the Genocide Convention.
“I think because of the gravity of the crime [of genocide], there was
a certain fear about either being accused of that, or accusing people
of that act,” Hamilton said. “So the international community was
somewhat cautious in setting up implementation mechanisms for the
Genocide Convention. It moved very early, but it moved very
cautiously, in the sense that it didn’t set up an International
Criminal Court [ICC], it didn’t set up a monitoring mechanism to
alert the UN of the advent of genocide.”
Hamilton said the recent establishment of the ICC is a major stride
toward putting the convention to work. So, too, is the new UN office
of special adviser on the prevention of genocide. Argentinian rights
lawyer Juan Mendez was named to the post in 2004. His first major
project — a summation of the situation in Darfur — was presented to
Secretary-General Kofi Annan on 25 January.
But other hurdles remain.
Rene Lemarchand is a professor emeritus at the University of Florida
and an expert on comparative genocide. He said a consistent part of
the problem has been the Western notion that victims of mass murder
are most often “far-away people about whom we know nothing.”
“Another reason is our abysmal ignorance of the events leading to
genocide and our inability or unwillingess to take appropriate steps
to prevent the worst from happening,” Lemarchand said. “Just consider
some of the countries where the worst killings have happened since
the Holocaust — Bosnia, Cambodia, Rwanda, Burundi. I don’t think
there is one American out of a thousand who could have identified
these countries on a map of the world before these countries were the
site of mass murder, of genocide.”
But while a public might learn of such a tragedy only as it is
happening, politicians and other officials are often able to see a
brewing catastrophe before it escalates.
As early as 1915, U.S. diplomats were urging Washington to intervene
in the mass killing of an estimated 1 million Armenians by Turkey.
Ankara has long denied charges of genocide.
Western officials also warned about the potential for genocide in
Bosnia and Rwanda. But it was not enough to prevent the murder of
more than 7,000 Muslim men and boys in Srebrenica in 1995, or the
Hutu killings of up to 750,000 minority Tutsi in the Rwandan genocide
the previous year.
Lemarchand said Western countries are often reluctant to dedicate
military and logistical power to situations that do not directly
threaten their national interests. They are also cautious about
leveling accusations they themselves could face.
The United States ratified the Genocide Convention only in 1986, and
after numerous amendments aimed at preventing the government from
ever facing genocide charges itself. It has also declined to join the
International Criminal Court.
Another problem is the term “genocide” itself. The convention’s
definition is used as a guideline for genocide cases in the UN’s war
crimes tribunals for Yugoslavia and Rwanda. But Lemarchand said the
rules are vague and indistinct — making it easy for countries to
remain on the sidelines as bloody conflicts unfold.
For example, the convention defines genocide as an act to destroy a
national, ethnic, or religious group “in whole or in part” and says
genocidal crimes include “killing members of the group.” Such a
definition, Lemarchand said, leaves genocide open to interpretation.
“And this raises the question — how many people should be killed
before you call the killings a genocide? Is the killing of 20 people
a genocide? Should it be 200? Should it be 2,000? I think, quite
frankly, the problem with affixing the label of genocide to these
terribly violent situations anywhere in the world is that a lot of
time is lost on trying to agree on whether this is or this is not
genocide. And as more and more people are being killed, nothing is
being done,” Lemarchand said.
This week’s commemorations to mark the 60th anniversary of the
liberation of the Nazi death camp at Auschwitz are once again —
however briefly — focusing the world’s attention on the persistence
of genocide.
It remains to be seen whether the international community can summon
the political will and public support to prevent future killings,
like the 1970s slaughter of 1.7 million Cambodians under Pol Pot’s
Khmer Rouge, or Saddam Hussein’s killing of some 5,000 Kurds in
Halabjah in 1988.

Armenia: Country’s Jews Alarmed Over Nascent Anti-Semitism

Radio Free Europe, Czech Republic
Jan 26 2005
Armenia: Country’s Jews Alarmed Over Nascent Anti-Semitism
By Emil Danielyan

Armenia’s tiny Jewish community is growing concerned by what it says
is mounting anti-Semitism in the South Caucasus country. Virtually
nonexistent in the past, the issue has emerged over the past year
amid a rise in anti-Jewish propaganda and the desecration of a
Holocaust memorial in Yerevan. The government has so far done little
to address the Jewish community’s concerns.
Yerevan, 26 January 2005 (RFE/RL) — Rimma Varzhapetian says she
always felt proud of Armenia when she met fellow Jews from other
parts of the former Soviet Union.
`We always declare everywhere that there has never been anti-Semitism
in Armenia, that Armenia is a good place for Jews to live and, more
importantly, that Armenia is quite a stable country in political and
social respects,’ Varzhapetian says.
That is why the secular leader of Armenia’s Jewish community has had
trouble coming to terms with what she says is a recent rise in
anti-Semitic propaganda.
It began in 2004, when ALM, a private pro-government television
channel, began broadcasting a phone-in talk show hosted by the
station’s owner, Tigran Karapetian. For months, Karapetian used the
platform to air views that portrayed Jews as an unsavory race bent on
dominating Armenia and the wider world.
Varzhapetian says her office in Yerevan received threatening phone
calls after the first series of ALM broadcasts.
Karapetian’s rhetoric appeared to embolden Armen Avetisian, the
openly anti-Semitic leader of the Armenian Aryan Union, a small
ultranationalist party. Avetisian in a recent newspaper interview
alleged that there are as many as 50,000 “disguised” Jews in Armenia,
and promised he would work to have them expelled from the country. He
was arrested on 24 January on charges of inciting ethnic hatred.
A Holocaust memorial in a public park in the center of Yerevan also
came under attack in September, when vandals desecrated the memorial
on the final day of Jewish New Year celebrations.
Yet what shocked the Jewish community most was an interview with
Hranush Kharatian, a prominent ethnologist who heads the Armenian
government’s department on religious and minority affairs. Speaking
to the `Golos Armenii’ (Voice of Armenia) Russian-language newspaper
a month after the memorial’s desecration, Kharatian accused Jewish
leaders of preaching extreme intolerance toward all non-Jews.
In a recent interview with RFE/RL, Kharatian cited what she called
the “aggressive ideology” contained in the Talmud, the book of Jewish
religious laws. `I see in the Talmud numerous points which clearly
state that non-Jews, or infidels that are not Jews, are not human
beings and are animals,’ she said.
Varzhapetian and other community leaders, including Chief Rabbi Gersh
Meir Burshtein, met last month with Armenian Foreign Minister Vartan
Oskanian to ask for help in addressing the problem. A ministry
spokesperson, however, said last week the issue is not sufficiently
serious to warrant government attention.
Mikael Danielian heads the Armenian Helsinki Association, a human
rights group that closely monitors anti-Semitic activity in the
country. He criticized the government’s failure to address the issue.
`I am surprised at the serenity of our state officials,” he told
RFE/RL. “It could have very serious consequences for Armenia.”
Armenia’s Jewish community is estimated to number less than 1,000
people. It is largely formed of scientists and other professionals
who moved to Armenia in the 1960s and ’70s to escape persecution in
Russia and Ukraine. Most integrated quickly into society, marrying
ethnic Armenians and adopting Armenian surnames.
Until recently, anti-Semitic sentiment in Armenia was limited to
occasional allegations by nationalist scholars that Jews had aided
the 1915 genocide of Armenians in Ottoman Turkey. The theory — which
is not supported by historical evidence — was first aired during the
presentation of an anti-Semitic book at a 2003 meeting of the
Armenian Writers Union. No one in the audience condemned the text.
A global report on anti-Semitism issued this month by the U.S. State
Department dedicates just three paragraphs to Armenia. But that was
sufficient to unleash a fresh wave of anti-Jewish criticism. ALM’s
Karapetian, who was cited by name in the U.S. study, responded with a
two-hour televised monologue lambasting the United States and the
contents of the report.
Several days later, Karapetian received an unexpected phone call
during an ALM broadcast. An Armenian woman living in Israel
criticized his sweeping bias against Jews, but was quickly cut off by
the broadcaster.
“If someone has offended you personally, or if you have problems with
your business, it doesn’t mean you should hold an entire nation
responsible,” the woman said in Russian. `Stop asking hysterical
questions on air,” Karpetian replied. “Shut up and listen to me. You
say it’s inadmissible to say `Jewish tricks.’ But is it permissible
to spit at a priest?’
Karapetian was referring to two recent incidents in Jerusalem in
which Jewish religious students spat at Armenian priests in a show of
their contempt for their Christian faith. The Armenian Apostolic
Church has had a presence in Jersualem’s Old City for centuries.
The incidents have been cited repeatedly in Armenia as supporting
claims of anti-Semitism. But Varzhapetian said Armenia’s Jews are
still hoping not only the government but also civil society will take
steps to stem the rising hatred.
`We are still awaiting a statement [of protest] from prominent
Armenians. Armenians themselves must express indignation. First of
all, because there are very few of us [in Armenia]. Secondly,
protecting ourselves is not quite appropriate,’ Varzhapetian said.
Varzhapetian and other community leaders sent an open letter to
President Robert Kocharian urging an end to the government’s
“conspicuous failure to see those inciting anti-Semitism.” But the
only response to date has been a statement by a cabinet minister
saying ethnic and religious discrimination does not exist in Armenia.

ENI: Israeli chief rabbi’s visit to Patriarchate

Ecumenical News International
News Highlights
26 January 2005

Israeli chief rabbi’s visit to Patriarchate seen as bid to
improve relations

Jerusalem (ENI). Israel’s Ashkenazi chief rabbi has paid an
unprecedented official visit to the headquarters of the Armenian
Patriarch in Jerusalem in what is seen as a drive by Israeli
officials to improve Jewish-Christian relations in the Holy Land.
Rabbi Yona Metzger, one of two chief rabbis, made the visit as
part of a series of meetings with Christian leaders to mend
relations after a Jewish seminary student attacked an Armenian
archbishop last year. “The rabbi condemned attacks against
religious clerics and called for mutual respect between all
faiths to be upheld in Israel and across the world,” Metzger’s
office said. [400 words, ENI-05-0050]

ENI News Highlights contain summaries of ENI articles published
today.

ENI Online –

Ecumenical News International
PO Box 2100
CH – 1211 Geneva 2
Switzerland

Tel: (41-22) 791 6088/6111
Fax: (41-22) 788 7244
Email: [email protected]

www.eni.ch

First checks distributed from Armenian genocide insurance settlement

Associated Press
Jan 26 2005
First checks distributed from Armenian genocide insurance settlement

By KAREN MATTHEWS
Associated Press Writer
NEW YORK AP) _ Five New York-area Armenian charities received checks
for $333,333 each on Wednesday as part of a settlement between an
insurance company and descendants of Armenians killed 90 years ago in
the Ottoman Empire.
The checks are part of a $20 million settlement between New York Life
Insurance Co. and descendants of a community that suffered what
Armenians characterize as the first genocide of the 20th century.

“It’s a happy day,” said New York Life spokesman William Werfelman.
“This is the day that’s the culmination of a lot of hard work by a
lot of the parties to bring an amicable solution and resolution to
this matter.”
Armenians contend that 1.5 million people were executed between 1915
and 1919 by Turkish authorities who accused them of helping the
invading Russian army during World War I.
Turkey rejects the genocide claim and says Armenians were killed in
civil unrest during the collapse of the Ottoman Empire. France and
Russia are among countries that have declared the killings a
genocide, but the United States has not made such a declaration.
The settlement approved last year by U.S. District Court Judge
Christina A. Snyder in Los Angeles is believed to be the first ever
in connection with the events of the era.
Under the settlement, $3 million was earmarked for charities and at
least $11 million was set aside for the heirs of New York Life policy
holders, with $2 million used for administrative costs and anything
not spent on expenses going to additional charities.
The remainder of the $3 million will be handed out to four additional
Armenian charities in a ceremony in Los Angeles.
Brian Kabateck, one of the lawyers for the plaintiffs in the
class-action lawsuit, said there were 2,300 policies issued to
Armenians in Turkey before 1915 that were never paid. People who
believe they may be descended from the policy holders have until
March 16 to file claims.
Under a formula taking inflation and interest into account, the
amount of the original policies will be multiplied by 15.5.
“We are here today urging people to make claims and urging people not
to forget the genocide,” said Kaboteck, who was joined by members of
Armenian religious and social organizations at a news conference at
the midtown offices of the Armenian General Benevolent Union, one of
the groups that received a check.
From: Emil Lazarian | Ararat NewsPress

Diversity group focuses attention on Caucasus for 2005

International Journalist’s Network
Jan 26 2005
Diversity group focuses attention on Caucasus for 2005
A group that encourages conflict resolution and minority rights is
planning several events this spring for journalists in Armenia,
Azerbaijan and Georgia.
In February, the London-based Media Diversity Institute (MDI) will
monitor 15 leading newspapers in the three countries. The institute
will examine the media’s coverage of topics such as refugees, the
disabled, and religious, sexual and ethnic minorities. MDI will
release a cross-regional comparison of the results after the study is
completed.
MDI also is organizing several team reporting projects for
journalists in the region. The first is scheduled for February 8 to
18 for eight Armenian and Georgian newspaper reporters. They will
travel throughout the two countries for two weeks, investigating a
diversity-related topic. One international and one local editor will
coordinate the team.
Similar team projects are scheduled for March 14 to 25 for
Azerbaijani and Georgian journalists; April 14 to 24 for Armenia,
Georgian and Azerbaijani journalists; and May 10 to 20 for Armenian
and Georgian journalists.
Journalists and NGO representatives can participate in one of several
media-relations workshops planned for the first half of 2005. Each
workshop will teach journalists the value of NGOs and how best to use
information provided by these groups. NGO participants will learn how
to gauge news value, and how to prepare news releases and news
conferences.
Media relations workshops are scheduled for February 25 to 27 in
Nagorno-Karabakh; March 1 to 3 for Armenians in Yerevan; April 5 to 7
for Azerbaijanis in Baku; April 5 to 7 for Georgians in Tbilisi; and
April 9 to 11 for Azerbaijanis in Ganja.
Three media management workshops – one each in Armenia, Azerbaijan
and Georgia – are planned for March. This two-day program teaches
editors and managers of minority media outlets about research,
targeting content to consumers, marketing, distribution, revenue and
budgeting. MDI says the goal is to help minority media be more
financially viable while maintaining professional journalism
standards.
The workshops are scheduled for March 1 to 3 in Yerevan, Armenia;
March 3 to 4 in Baku, Azerbaijan; and March 7 to 8 in Tbilisi,
Georgia.
MDI also plans to release a new version of its `Reporting Diversity’
handbook this February in Armenian, Azeri and Georgian languages. The
manual includes sections on ethnicity, religion, gender, the
disabled, elderly people, refugees, sexual orientation and political
dissidents. Each section offers reporting tips and detailed analysis
of actual articles taken from newspapers from the Caucasus, Western
Europe and the United States.
For information on any of these upcoming events, visit
or contact
MDI at [email protected], telephone +44 20 73800 200, or fax
+44 20 73800 050.

Children In Former Soviet Union Know Little About Holocaust

Radio Free Europe, Czech Republic
Jan 26 2005
East: Children In Former Soviet Union Know Little About Holocaust
By Jeremy Bransten

A personal memorial at the Birkenau death camp

World leaders gather this week to commemorate the 60th anniversary of
the Red Army’s liberation of the Auschwitz concentration camp in
Poland. Although the Nazis operated many deaths camps throughout
Europe, Auschwitz was the largest and it has come to symbolize the
horror of the regime’s atrocities in its purest form. Six millions
Jews were murdered by the Nazis in World War II — more than one
million of them in Auschwitz alone. Millions of non-Jews perished
alongside them — there and in other death camps — as part of a
systematic liquidation campaign unequalled, in planning and scale, in
recorded history. This is known as the Holocaust. If another
Holocaust is to be avoided, historians warn, the lesson of what
happened at Auschwitz and other death camps must be taught to future
generations. But what do today’s schoolchildren know about the events
of 60 years ago?
Prague, 26 January 2005 (RFE/RL) — Ask children on the streets of
Minsk what they know about Auschwitz and the Holocaust and you are
liable to get some disturbing answers.
One 13-year-old girl has this to say: “I think Auschwitz is a type of
hoofed animal.”
Her friend does somewhat better — but her answer is far from
complete: “It was some sort of camp during the Great Patriotic War.
They burned Jews there.””I have no idea what the Holocaust is. I have
never heard anything about something like the Holocaust.”
A third girl answers: “We could tell you more if they taught us
something about it in school.”
Belarus may be a disturbing example, especially considering the
country’s history of Jewish settlement prior to World War II and the
country’s devastation during the conflict. But it is hardly unique.
In 1944, the word “genocide” was coined to describe the Nazis’
attempt to liquidate the Jews, Roma, and other groups in their
entirety. Four years later, the word was officially adopted in the
United Nations Convention Against Genocide.
Yet for decades, in the former Soviet Union, all war dead were only
identified as Soviet citizens. The Holocaust was mentioned only in
passing, if it all. Today, several former Soviet countries are trying
to remedy the situation, making the teaching of the Holocaust an
obligatory subject in school.
But progress so far depends more on the initiative of individual
teachers. Textbooks are lacking, and so is general interest among
students. Kazakh history teacher Amina Tortayeva describes the
situation at her school in Almaty: “We do not have a special course
on that. There are many courses on the war period and we give some
kind of information on that ourselves. But in our textbooks there is
nothing written about the Holocaust. So I cannot say we have full
knowledge on that issue.”
Her students do not perform much better than their counterparts in
Minsk.
RFE/RL correspondent: “Have you heard about the Holocaust?”
Student: “No, not at all. Holocaust? I have no idea what the
Holocaust is. I have never heard anything about something like the
Holocaust.”
Irina Belareva, a high-school teacher in Moscow, says it falls to the
teacher to decide whether the Holocaust is taught or not as a
specific subject in Russia. “If you take the school curriculum,
specific discussion of the Holocaust is not required,” she said. “I
talk about it, but to a large extent, it depends, of course, on the
teacher.”
Even in Armenia, whose people suffered their own genocide a quarter
of a century before the Jews, knowledge among young people of the
extent, methods, and reasons for the Nazi Holocaust is shallow at
best.
Our correspondent in Yerevan quizzed several young people about what
they know about those events. The most comprehensive — if factually
incorrect — answer came from a 19-year-old boy: “The Holocaust was
perpetrated by Hitler. One-and-a half million people died. Hitler
sought the extermination of the Jews because I think Jews in Germany
had very high positions. That’s why he exterminated them and
expropriated their property.”
For years after World War II, discussion of the Holocaust in schools
in Western Europe was also minimal. Events were too raw. Survivors
wanted to forget their trauma. And the issue of collaboration with
the Nazis by parts of the population in many countries cast a shadow
over a fuller discussion of the war.
It was not until relatively recently that schools in Western Europe
began to teach the Holocaust in a comprehensive way. Germany,
understandably, has one of the best programs. Students learn about
the Holocaust and other aspects of the war in history classes, civics
lessons, and postwar literature studies. Visits to former
concentration camps as well as talks with survivors are also
frequently used.
Chana Moshenska, who runs educational programs at the Centre for
German-Jewish Studies at Britain’s University of Sussex, says
discussions with survivors are one of the most effective ways to get
children interested in learning about the period. “One way that does
work — but having said that, it’s only going to work for a short
time — is survivor testimony,” she said. “I think survivor testimony
is the most powerful way that young people can relate to what
actually happened in the Holocaust. Now, obviously, that’s
time-limited because survivors are getting older. They haven’t got
the energy to speak and soon they won’t be able to speak in public.
But when they come and speak, what young people see is someone who
looks like grandma or grandpa. And that has an enormous impact. And
then, quite often, these are people who experienced the Holocaust
when they were teenagers. And they’re able to say, ‘When I was 15,
this is what I was doing,’ or ‘This is what happened to my little
brother, this is what happened to my mother.’ And that has an
enormous impact on young people.”
RFE/RL analyst Michael Shafir is an expert on the period and served
on the International Commission for the Study of the Holocaust in
Romania, chaired by Nobel Prize winner Elie Wiesel.
He notes that Eastern Europe bears the twin burden of the Nazi and
Communist eras, making open discussion about past crimes, ethics and
responsibility — especially with children — doubly difficult,
although he believes, doubly necessary.
“Unlike Western Europe, East-Central Europe must not overcome one
difficult past, but two difficult pasts,” he said. “That, of course,
of whatever happened during World War II and its communist past. Now,
in both these cases there is a tendency to transform not only
villains but mainly collaborators or even stand-by witnesses into
martyrs and heroes.”
Students — be they in Russia or Britain — can be easily interested
in investigating the past, if a personal connection is made.
Fifteen-year-old Tatyana tells our Moscow correspondent she knows
about the Holocaust and she related it to the experience of her
grandfather in the Soviet gulag. “It concerns me a lot because my
grandfather, under Stalin, was sent to the [Soviet gulag] camps,” she
said. “When I was 10 years old, I read his diary. He left a diary
about it all and it had a strong impact on me.”
Shafir says the sooner the East comes to grips with the truth of its
past, the better. “Genocide” was coined to describe the Nazi
Holocaust, but it is a word that has unfortunately had to be used
since, to describe more recent events in Cambodia and Rwanda. Shafir
says genocide is likely to be repeated until the lessons of the
Holocaust are learned by children today: “It is important to convey
to anyone that the Holocaust was not something that Germans did unto
Jews. It is important to convey that this is something that anyone
can do unto anyone else. That is the tragedy of the Holocaust.”
People’s willingness to forget crimes of the past was a lesson not
lost on Hitler himself. Sending his troops into Poland in 1939, he
ordered them to be merciless, saying: Who today remembers the
extermination of the Armenians?”
(RFE/RL’s Armenian, Belarus, Kazakh, and Russian services contributed
to this report.)

Armenian ex-minister critical of Council of Europe’s Karabakh

Armenian ex-minister critical of Council of Europe’s Karabakh resolution
Arminfo
26 Jan 05
YEREVAN
The resolution of the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe
[PACE] on Nagornyy Karabakh is distinguished by its special
subjectivity, and drawing up such documents is unbecoming of
authoritative international organizations such as PACE, the head of
the faction of the Armenian Revolutionary Federation – Dashnaktsutyun
[ARFD] and Armenian ex-foreign minister, Levon Lazarian, said in an
interview with our Arminfo correspondent while commenting on the PACE
resolution on Nagornyy Karabakh adopted yesterday.
He stressed that the PACE resolution contains provisions that were not
earlier included in other international documents. The subjectivity of
the document is proved by the fact that the opinion of Nagornyy
Karabakh representatives was not taken into account when this document
was drawn up and discussed, the MP said. Meanwhile, he pointed out,
when the Chechen and Abkhaz issues were discussed, the opinion of
representatives of these peoples was heard by PACE. “Although such
documents cannot have a real impact on the process of settling the
Karabakh conflict within the framework of the OSCE Minsk Group, there
is a danger that they can form the wrong public opinion, which will
reflect on the activities of the OSCE Minsk Group in the end. The OSCE
Minsk Group is composed of members of international organizations,”
Levon Lazarian said.
Commenting on the current situation, I can say that thanks to
Azerbaijan’s efforts to transfer the Karabakh issue from the format of
the OSCE Minsk Group to the format of international organizations, a
new stage has started in the process of settling the Karabakh
conflict, he stressed.
Having realized that propaganda is of great importance in the Karabakh
issue, Azerbaijan changed its strategy, raising this issue with
international organizations. “We have to say that it will be
impossible to avoid discussing the Karabakh issue in international
organizations. In this connection, Armenia should place emphasis on
increasing the level of parliamentary diplomacy and speeding up
lobbying activities,” the MP stated.

BAKU: US envoy says Azerbaijan, Armenia must resolve NK themselves

US envoy says Azerbaijan, Armenia must resolve Karabakh themselves
MPA news agency
26 Jan 05
BAKU
“The OSCE Minsk Group did a lot last year,” US Ambassador to
Azerbaijan Reno Harnish has said.
The ambassador has told MPA that last year saw meetings of the
Azerbaijani and Armenian foreign ministers. He also pointed to
Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev’s statement at a Security Council
meeting in early January that certain changes for the better had been
observed in the process of negotiations. An OSCE factfinding mission
is expected to arrive in Baku soon to investigate claims that Armenia
is settling the occupied Azerbaijani territories.
All this, Harnish said, attests to the OSCE’s and the Minsk Group’s
interest in securing a fair and lasting peace. As far as the USA is
concerned, the diplomat said, its position remains unchanged. The USA
does not recognize the so-called Nagornyy Karabakh republic and
respects Azerbaijan’s territorial integrity. The diplomat said the US
policy serves peace and stability in the entire region.
The Karabakh conflict will be on the agenda of the February meeting
between US President George Bush and Russian President Vladimir
Putin. Harnish said Russia is playing an important role in regional
conflicts. In some cases this role is positive, while in others
negative. However, Harnish added that the solution to the problem
depends not only on Moscow and Washington. It is the leaders of
Azerbaijan and Armenia who must come to agreement first.
“Therefore, we are urging Russia to step up its positive role, and
Baku and Yerevan to display more constructive positions,” Harnish
said.
Asked by journalists about US-Iranian relations, the US diplomat said
Tehran had to meet three demands. First, the international community
is interested in Tehran giving up the development of weapons of mass
destruction. Second, Iran has to stop supporting international
terrorism; and third, Iran has to stop impeding the Middle East peace
process.