Nagorno-Karabakh blockade: ‘In a couple of weeks there will be a mass famine’

The Observers
Aug 22 2023

The only road connecting Armenia to the enclave of Nagorno-Karabakh – a breakaway region disputed for decades between Armenia and Azerbaijan – has been completely blocked by Azerbaijan since July. A resident describes the challenges the population faces in obtaining food and water, adding that some people have died from the effects of the blockade.

Text by:Sorana Horsia

Since December 2022, the only route connecting Nagorno-Karabakh to Armenia – the Lachin corridor – has been gradually blockaded by Azerbaijan.

The region of Nagorno-Karabakh, predominantly inhabited by ethnic Armenians, has been at the centre of a conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan since the fall of the Soviet Union, leading to two wars from 1991 to 1994 and then at the end of 2020. In the latest war, Azerbaijan managed to gain control over the majority of the region. According to a ceasefire established with the assistance of Russia, free movement through the Lachin corridor would be guaranteed.

© The Observers

In December 2022, Azerbaijani environmental protesters blocked the Lachin corridor, demonstrating against the alleged exploitation of natural resources in the region by Armenia. Yerevan accused them of being backed by Azerbaijan. The tensions at the border culminated with a clash between Azerbaijani and Armenian troops in March and April. Azerbaijan set up a checkpoint on the Lachin corridor on April 23, claiming that its purpose is "to prevent the illegal transportation of manpower, weapons, mines” from Armenia to Nagorno-Karabakh. Initially, Red Cross humanitarian vehicles were let through.

After months of restricted movement through this corridor, Azerbaijan announced on July 11 the suspension of all traffic. The flow of humanitarian aid from Armenia was subsequently completely halted on July 26. Since then, trucks carrying 400 tons of food and essential goods have been waiting at the checkpoint set up by Azerbaijan.

As a result of this blockade, the humanitarian situation in Nagorno-Karabakh is critical. Stores are empty, people wait for hours in over 35 degrees Celsius to buy bread, and water resources are running low. Electricity and gas are also limited, as the supply usually comes through Azerbaijan.

Mary Asatryan works as an assistant to the Human Rights Defender (Ombudsman) of Nagorno-Karabakh in Stepanakert. For months, she has been documenting her daily life on Instagram, where she posts photos and videos of the queues in front of bakeries, the 20-kilometre journey she makes to fetch water bottles, and the locals helping each other.

The entire day consists of struggling with all the deprivations and the consequences of the blockade. So every day we have to check the schedule of the electricity blackouts, which are published either in the morning of that day or in the late evening of the previous day. Then we have to adapt to that schedule because the blackouts don't happen at the same time at my home, at my workplace, or at the shops. So you have to know where electricity is going to be working and manage your time accordingly.

Also, at the moment, you cannot buy anything at the stores anymore. The shops are completely empty. What we have left is a limited amount of bread, which is baked and sold at the bakeries. Why? Because there is no fuel left in the country to deliver the bread to the stores. So people have to walk by foot to the bakeries directly and queue there.

The bread queues can reach five or six hours, and most of the time people queue at night because during the day it's so hot that people can't stand. But there are, of course, people who queue during the day, but as I work at the office, I cannot afford that.

But I, for example, I'm getting exhausted physically standing in the queue sometimes. So some days I just even give up on bread. Last time I was standing in the queue, there were 500 people registered. So it's really endless.

There are some rare farmers coming from the nearby villages and selling their locally produced seasonal vegetables and fruits. So basically they sell what they have harvested in their yard. But to do this, imagine that some people have to walk tens of kilometres to sell something. So if you are lucky enough to catch a farmer on the street or, you know, find someone who sells locally produced fruit, then you have a meal for the day. But most of the time, it's the bread that people rely on. 

So a couple of weeks more and there is going to be a mass famine.

On August 15, the office of the Human Rights Ombudsman of Nagorno-Karabakh stated that a 40-year-old man had died due to hunger. However, Asatryan says that he is not the only case, and if the blockade does not stop, there will certainly be more deaths due to famine and lack of medication.

There was a very tragic story of two kids who died one month ago. So what happened is that their mother left their home in the village [of Aghabekalanj] and she walked tens of kilometres to reach the nearby city, Martakert, to find something to eat. The kids were sleeping at that time. Then they woke up. They didn't find their mother. They decided to walk to find her. They walked for a while and then they got tired because they were, of course, hungry and exhausted. So they found a car, they entered and they fell asleep. But it was so hot that they basically, unfortunately, died because of the heat and exhaustion. They died because of the whole situation. And this was one of the most shocking stories of the whole blockade.

Photos of the two children who died in Nagorno-Karabakh at the beginning of July.

The numbers of miscarriages among pregnant women are rising. Women are under a lot of stress. They have to walk all the time. It's very hot. They don't get nutritious, vitamin- rich food. So they lose their unborn children. 

There was a story, for example, of a woman from the village Haterk who started to bleed and there was no car to take her to the hospital. So she was brought to hospital too late and she had already lost her child. I think the most challenging consequences are in the healthcare system, because we have a lot of patients who are not receiving enough medication, they're not undergoing their planned surgeries now. And in the long term, of course, there will be more deaths.

On August 16, the United Nations Security Council held an emergency meeting at the request of Armenia to discuss the situation in Nagorno-Karabakh. Many countries called on Azerbaijan to reopen the Lachin corridor.


Militia entered Nagorno-Karabakh parliament to ‘back President Harutyunyan’

OC MEDIA
Aug 22 2023
 

A state-controlled volunteer militia last week entered the Nagorno-Karabakh parliament, reportedly to shore up support for President Arayik Harutyunyan.

On Sunday, news emerged that men in military fatigues had entered the region’s parliament on 16 August. Opposition MPs said that the militia members had one question: ‘who’s demanding Harutyunyan’s resignation?’

Both opposition parties that hold seats in parliament have denied that they were seeking the president’s resignation.

Marcel Petrosyan from the United Motherland faction told RFE/RL on Monday that there was ‘no demand for resignation’. He added that rumours of such demands were being deliberately circulated with ‘far-reaching goals’. 

Russian-Armenian billionaire Ruben Vardanyan — who served as State Minister for four months in late 2022 and early 2023 — demanded that Harutyunyan step down on Sunday.

In a live broadcast on Facebook, Vardanyan claimed that Harutyunyan had promised to do so ‘at the beginning of the week’, and that it was not the first time he had made such a promise. 

‘Some of the eight people present at that meeting did not believe your word. Another part said: “maybe he is telling the truth this time” ’, he said. 

He also accused Harutyunyan of ‘destroying’ state institutions, criticising him for allowing the government militia to enter parliament.

The militia was established by parliament in October 2020 during the Second Nagorno-Karabakh War. Composed of civilian volunteers, it falls under the control of the Defence Ministry and is tasked with defending Nagorno-Karabakh alongside the Defence Army. Little has been seen of the militia since the war.

The militia’s head, Karen Matevosyan, took to Facebook on Monday to express support for Harutyunyan in a live broadcast.

He said the militia was founded to save the Armenian population of Nagorno-Karabakh from ‘elimination’, and that the militia did not directly intervene in the region’s domestic politics. 

Harutyunyan met with representatives of the militia on 17 August, a day after they entered parliament. Details about the contents of the meeting were not disclosed. 

The head of Nagorno-Karabakh’s Parliament, Davit Ishkhanyan, issued a statement on Tuesday calling for unity and ‘restraint’. 

Ishkhanyan also warned that some other public calls for unity were ‘aimed at destroying the foundations of our statehood’, calling them ‘unacceptable’.

The president’s office and the ruling Free Homeland party denied on Sunday that Harutyunyan was planning to resign. 

However, the president has spoken about the possibility of stepping down several times since the end of the Second Nagorno-Karabakh War in 2020. 

Following the 9 November agreement between Russia, Azerbaijan and Armenia, that brought an end to the war, Harutyunyan promised to resign at the first possibility — once the situation normalised. 

Harutyunyan has faced previous challenges to his authority in the post-war period.

In the spring of 2021, large protests broke out over his close relations with the Armenian authorities, after Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan suggested he may recognise Nagorno-Karabakh as being part of Azerbaijan. Harutyunyan has since distanced himself from Pashinyan’s government.

Opposition parties within Nagorno-Karabakh have largely refrained from calling for snap elections, claiming this could be seen as an opening by Azerbaijan to conduct a military intervention.

Due to his profile and wealth, Ruben Vardanyan’s appointment as State Minister under Harutyunyan in late 2022 led to speculation he could challenge or succeed the president. The State Minister is the most senior post in the government under the president, and the position’s mandate was expanded with Vardanyan’s appointment, giving him control over most state institutions.

Critics warned he lacked a connection to the region or a deep understanding of its domestic affairs. 

His appointment also led to questions in Armenia over his possible links to Russia and the Russian Government, having made his fortune in Russia following the dissolution of the Soviet Union. Azerbaijani officials repeatedly railed against his appointment, claiming he was working directly for Russia.

Harutyunyan and Vardanyan had several public disagreements during Vardanyan’s tenure, and just four months after appointing him, Harutyunyan fired Vardanyan.

 For ease of reading, we choose not to use qualifiers such as ‘de facto’, ‘unrecognised’, or ‘partially recognised’ when discussing institutions or political positions within Abkhazia, Nagorno-Karabakh, and South Ossetia. This does not imply a position on their status.



Armenian coins and their link to Byzantium

Aug 22 2023
by LIANNA AGASYAN
000

The oldest Armenian coins found in Armenia date back to the 6th-5th centuries BC. As this was a century of cultural renaissance for Armenia, the earliest coins issued by Armenian rulers were struck for Kings of Sophene the 3th century BCE. The ruler's name and titles were inscribed in Greek letters. The coins of Armenia, both ancient and medieval, were fascinating and very diverse.

Armenian Kings usually inscribed the sign of the cross in various forms on their coins. Originally, references to Divine authority were found on most coins.

The unique status of ancient Armenia was recognised on Ancient Rome coins.

Ancient Armenia also played a notable role in Roman politics as a semi-independent buffer state between Ancient Rome and Parthian Empire.

Several Byzantine emperors minted coins that mentioned or depicted Armenia.

-The first picture shows a coin of the Kingdom of Sophene, King Arsames, third quarter of the 3rd century BC, a copper coin.

-The second picture shows a coin of the Armenian Kingdom of Tashir-Dzoraget and a Gold coin of King Yervand I (Orontes I Sakavakyats) of the Yervanduni dynasty (Кing of the Orontid Dynasty), 357–352 BC. These coins are similar to Byzantine copper coins but engraved with the name of the King. These are some of the first coins with Armenian inscriptions.

– The third picture shows: The first inscriptions in the Armenian language were found on this coin. It was the only medieval coin with an Armenian inscription minted in Greater Armenia. This type is directly based on the anonymous Byzantine Folles of John Tzimisces and Basil II, commonly circulated in Armenia at the time.

– The fourth picture shows the gold coin of King Levon I of the Kingdom of Armenia and Cilicia, enthroned facing, holding a cross in right hand and branch in left / Patriarchal cross flanked by two lions, heads reverted.

King Levon I of the Kingdom of Cilicia in Armenia was so ambitious that he struck twelve types of coins with Latin and Armenian inscriptions and a large copper coin known as a tank.

Signs of possible easing of Karabakh blockade

EurasiaNet
Aug 22 2023
Aug 22, 2023

Azerbaijan has reportedly allowed several dozen residents of Armenian-populated Nagorno-Karabakh to go to Armenia after having tightly blockaded the region for over two months.

The development has led to speculation about possible agreements between Karabakhi and Azerbaijani officials. 

On August 21, Azerbaijani public television reported the movement of "up to 60 Armenian residents of Nagorno-Karabakh with Russian passports" to Armenia via the Azerbaijani customs checkpoint at the Lachin road – which is the only road connecting the region to Armenia and the outside world. 

"These people supported separatism in Azerbaijan," Public TV's reporter said from the checkpoint. "Yet, the Azerbaijani side provides them an opportunity to go to any destination of their choice without barriers, totally safely." 

The Lachin road has been blocked since December 2022, when Azerbaijani government-linked self-identified eco-activists staged a sit-in on the Lachin road, accusing the de facto Nagorno-Karabakh government of committing "ecocide" in the region. The demonstrations ended in April after Azerbaijan set up a customs checkpoint on the other end of the Lachin road, near the Armenian border. While most Karabakhis refused to use the checkpoint, as they saw it as an acknowledgment of Azerbaijani sovereignty over the region, there was some movement

Later, on June 15, Azerbaijan shut down all kinds of movement on the road, greatly exacerbating shortages of foodstuffs and supplies in Nagorno-Karabakh. On August 15, the first report of a death from malnutrition emerged from the region. 

On August 17, the UN Security Council convened to discuss the situation at the Lachin road and Karabakh at the request of Armenia. While France, the UK, and the U.S. all urged Azerbaijan to abide by a February ruling from the International Court of Justice ordering the country to provide free movement at the Lachin road, the council failed to issue any statement or resolution. 

Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev has continuously denied that Nagorno-Karabakh was under blockade, as did the country's ambassador to the UN Yashar Aliyev. At the Security Council meeting, Yashar Aliyev cited the recent Azerbaijani proposal to provide humanitarian aid to Karabakh via the Azerbaijani city of Aghdam – which was backed by the EU Council President and Russia but rejected by Karabakhis, as they saw it as a legitimization of Azerbaijani rule over the region. 

"If Armenia were genuinely concerned about the ordinary residents of the region, it would never have objected to the usage of the Aghdam-Khankendi road for the delivery of goods to the Karabakh region," Azerbaijan's UN envoy said, citing the significantly shorter distance between Nagorno-Karabakh's de facto capital (Stepanakert in Armenian and Khankendi in Azerbaijani) and Aghdam vs the distance between it and the Armenian border. 

In this context, the news of a partial lifting of the blockade came as a surprise.

Azerbaijani pro-government media emphasized that those who left Karabakh were Russian citizens. 

In an editorial titled "The 'Russian world' plan didn't succeed in Azerbaijan," news agency Report.az presented the August 21 movement of Armenians as an end to a Russian conspiracy. "The game Russia played in Georgia and Ukraine did not happen in Karabakh. It is known that the Kremlin distributed Russian passports to its loyal tribes in those territories and later created so-called republics in the territory of these countries," the piece read. 

"This can be called a component of the hybrid war waged by Russia against Azerbaijan," it continued, repeating Baku's demand that the Karabakh Armenians "accept Azerbaijani citizenship and our laws."

(Russia deployed a peacekeeping contingent to the region after it brokered a ceasefire between Armenia and Azerbaijan to end the Second Karabakh War in 2020. The contingent is scheduled to leave the region in 2025, and its presence can be extended only with the consent of both sides. For a while after the Armenian side's defeat in the second war there was talk of Karabakh Armenians becoming Russian citizens and the region becoming some sort of Russian protectorate.)

Movement at the checkpoint continued on August 22. 

On August 21, the Armenian opposition media outlet Pastinfo.am reported that the Karabakh authorities agreed with Azerbaijani government to use the Aghdam road for aid delivery, and that representatives of the two sides would meet in the coming days in the Azerbaijani city of Barda, near Karabakh. 

Azerbaijani media interpreted this report as indicating an agreement was in the works for a lifting of the blockade of the Lachin road.

On August 22, David Babayan, advisor to the de facto Karabakh president, spoke to Pastinfo.am. 

He did not directly confirm or deny reports of a possible meeting of Karabakhi and Azerbaijani representatives in Barda, saying only that Karabakh was willing to discuss humanitarian issues but not "so-called integration or the dismantling of Artsakh's [Nagorno-Karabakh's] statehood" with Baku. 

He also said that any opening of the road connecting Aghdam to Karabakh would have to be linked to the opening of the Lachin road connecting Karabakh with Armenia. 



Exploring Armenian Flavors

FORBES
Aug 22 2023

There’s a restaurant in Chicago called Sayat Nova, which is named for the Armenian 18th century poet Arutin Sayadyan whose pen name means “King of Songs.” The food is so good I used to fly it back to San Francisco and got into fights with the TSA about whether the yogurt-laden dishes were technically considered liquid or not.

I had the pleasure of meeting Armenian chef and TV personality Ara Zada when I was down in Los Angeles a few weeks ago. We had a great chat about what is so unique about this cuisine. All answers have been edited and condensed for clarity.

There’s a restaurant in Chicago called Sayat Nova, which is named for the Armenian 18th century poet Arutin Sayadyan whose pen name means “King of Songs.” The food is so good I used to fly it back to San Francisco and got into fights with the TSA about whether the yogurt-laden dishes were technically considered liquid or not.

I had the pleasure of meeting Armenian chef and TV personality Ara Zada when I was down in Los Angeles a few weeks ago. We had a great chat about what is so unique about this cuisine. All answers have been edited and condensed for clarity.

L.B.Z.: Where is your family from and how often do you go back?

A.Z.: My mom and grandparents are Armenian but both were born in Egypt. The first time I went to Armenia in 2016 and I was going back about every six months until the Covid pandemic hit.

L.B.Z.: Where did you study culinary arts?

A.Z.: I did my culinary studies at Le Cordon Bleu.

L.B.Z.: When did you first experience Armenia wines and how have they evolved?

A.Z.: The first time I had Armenian wine was my first trip to Armenia. Since then, there has been a massive wine revolution. Tons of wine makers from around the world have come to buy vineyards. They have evolved the wine making processes and techniques. I’ve been told by several wine makers in Armenia that their best vintage is next one to come, since the winemaking process is in constant evolution.

L.B.Z.: What have some of the biggest challenges been for the Armenia wine industry?

A.Z.: For wineries just getting their name out has been tough. Armenia has long history of wine making that dates back 6000 years. However, during Soviet domination Armenian winemakers were encouraged to make brandy instead. Also, most people at that point were making their own wine in their backyard and it wasn’t that good.

L.B.Z.: Do you think the fact that many of these grapes are hard to pronounce have been an issue for them?

A.Z.: The indigenous grapes of Armenia can be pretty difficult to pronounce but it’s just a matter of people saying it a few times. What is also notable is that the indigenous grapes of Armenia don’t suffer from phylloxera and are grown on their own rootstock, which is very unusual in the wine world today.

L.B.Z.: What are some of the most traditional Armenian dishes?

A.Z.: Some of the most recognizable would be Khorovats which is Armenian BBQ, skewered up chunks of meat cooked on an open flame; Lavash-wrapped Trout; Harissa, wheat Porridge; and my favorite Khash, cow foot soup. The cuisine features lots of traditional Lavash bread, cheese and an abundance of herbs.


L.B.Z.: How has the Armenian wine scene been evolving in Yerevan?

A.Z.: The wine scene is incredible in Armenia. There is a whole street dedicated to cool wine bars and restaurants in Yerevan, the capitol.

L.B.Z.: You are involved in creating modern Armenian food. What does that involve?

A.Z.: I love creating modern Armenian food by taking classic cooking methods and making them easier for more people to enjoy or mixing ingredients from different cultures to bring new life to classic dishes.

L.B.Z.: Does fine-tuning the food allow younger people to understand it better?

A.Z.: Absolutely! Your people tend to be afraid of old Armenian dishes because they saw their mothers and grandmas slaving for hours in the kitchen. When I show people an easier way to prepare them, it inspires people to get in the kitchen and get creative.

L.B.Z.: You said you did a Mexican-Armenian pop up? What was that like?


A.Z.: I have been fusing Armenian and Mexican dishes for some time. We take Armenian dishes and add Mexican spices or vice versa and it’s been blowing up on social media. We call it Arm-Mex Fusion. We did a few kitchen/comedy pop-ups and the feedback has been incredible. Each event has had the tickets sell out in the first few hours.

L.B.Z.: How did you combine the flavors of the two cuisines?

A.Z.: Most of the time we come up with video ideas on the spot and they turn into magic on the camera. We took lahmajun—meat flatbread—and cut it up into chips, baked them and made nachos out of them. We made tacos using lavash, khorovats-spiced pork and a pepper sauce.

https://www.forbes.com/sites/lizazimmerman/2023/08/22/exploring-armenian-flavors/?sh=6a60c7b96f28





















Opinion: Claims of Genocide Push Nagorno-Karabakh Further From Peace

JURIST
Aug 22 2023

Edited by: JURIST Staff

Earlier this month, a former prosecutor of the International Criminal Court (ICC), Luis Moreno Ocampo, released a legal opinion claiming that genocide is under way against ethnic Armenians in the Azerbaijani region of Nagorno-Karabakh. Such serious allegations should not be made lightly and require careful scrutiny. In light of this opinion, the Government of Azerbaijan appointed me to review the allegations and produce an independent expert legal assessment. It was released yesterday.

For the Ocampo opinion’s potentially wide-reaching consequences, no evidence is identified to support the central claim that a genocide is presently unfolding in Nagorno-Karabakh. Yet its provocative assertions threaten to undermine a peace process between Azerbaijan and Armenia over their nearly three-decade dispute concerning Karabakh. A peace settlement is closer than ever before under EU and US mediation: the Armenian government has broken with precedent and stated it is ready to recognise that Nagorno-Karabakh is part of Azerbaijan – as has been the position of the international community in accordance with international law. Armenia invaded the territory in the 1990s and expelled the hundreds of thousands of Azerbaijanis that lived there. It has since financially and militarily supported the breakaway territory.

The Ocampo opinion was written on behalf of those who have everything to lose in a peace deal: the self-proclaimed government of the illegal entity. Its release coincides with rising prospects for a settlement and the region’s imminent reintegration into Azerbaijan. Unfortunately, it risks stirring tensions on the ground. Moreover, its allegations could limit Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan’s freedom to pursue a peace deal if taken at face value. After close examination of the opinion’s assertions, they have been found to be strikingly unsubstantiated.

It claims Azerbaijan has imposed a blockade on Nagorno-Karabakh which is causing mass starvation, and thus conditions of life calculated to bring about the physical destruction of the inhabitants. In 2020 a short conflict broke out which saw Azerbaijan reclaim some of its internationally recognised territory. That included a region through which a road – the Lachin corridor – passes, linking Armenia to the territory of the separatist entity. Azerbaijan has established a checkpoint on this road near the border, which is said was necessary “to stop the illegal flow of weapons, military equipment, and soldiers into [its] sovereign territory”. The road remained open to humanitarian aid supplied by the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC). The ICRC confirmed in a statement that its emblem has been misused for smuggling. It has also most recently confirmed that it has provided extensive medical, food and other supplies since December 2022 (when Ocampo claims the blockade commenced), and continues to evacuate persons in need of medical care and provide safe passage to reunite separated families.

The opinion does not grapple with these factual matters. Significantly, it fails to mention that Azerbaijan suggested an alternative route (the ‘Aghdam-Khankandi route’) through which the ICRC and government could supply the ethnic Armenian inhabitants of Nagorno-Karabakh. This option has been acknowledged by the EU. But these offers have been rejected by the de facto authorities in Karabakh. These are plainly relevant circumstances to take into account particularly when claiming that Azerbaijan is deliberately inflicting conditions of life designed to physically destroy those living there.

Information that clearly undermines the opinion’s conclusions is simply left out. The very serious allegation of genocide, from an individual of standing in international law, carries certain responsibilities, in particular meeting the exacting burden of proof and weighing all available evidence. It is therefore unjustifiable that these pertinent considerations have seemingly been passed over. It falls far short of the rigorous hallmarks of a fair minded and balanced expert opinion. Moreover, genocide has a high threshold in international law – the specific intent to physically destroy the group in whole or in part. The stringent requirement of this intent can only be inferred with very considerable caution and when it is unequivocally established, as has been stressed by various international courts. The opinion ignores the well-established international law position. Given that the opinion claims genocide is already underway, it is also curious that there is no mention of the material impact on the local population.

Last week, a UN Security Council meeting was held at the request of the Armenia on the situation in Nagorno-Karabakh. Whilst many speakers noted the issue of humanitarian aid had been politicised, no speaker – bar the Armenian ambassador – mentioned the phrase genocide or ethnic cleansing. However, Edem Wosornu, the Director of Operations and Advocacy at the UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs said humanitarian relief should be allowed to resume through any available routes. No statement was issued by the Council at the end of the session. The unsupported claims of the opinion have not provided any basis for international action.

It is essential that the unverified conclusions of the Ocampo opinion should not be allowed to obstruct the peace process between Armenia and Azerbaijan. Instead, its publication should galvanise the international community in doubling down on mediation efforts to bring a durable peace.

 

Rodney Dixon KC is a leading counsel and expert in international law. He has both prosecuted and defended before all international criminal courts, going back to the International Criminal Tribunals for the former Yugoslavia and Rwanda (ICTY / ICTR). He has particular expertise in cases involving alleged genocide and crimes against humanity, having acted in cases before the ICTY, ICTR and the International Criminal Court (ICC), for example, in the Sudan Situation concerning the alleged genocide case against President Bashir; in Syria for the mass crimes committed against the civilian population; and, for the East Turkestan Government in Exile regarding the alleged genocide of the Uyghurs. Rodney also represents the widow of Jamal Khashoggi. He is co-author with the current chief prosecutor of the ICC Karim Khan KC of the leading textbook on international criminal courts, Archbold International: Practice, Procedure and Evidence. He practices from Temple Garden Chambers, London, and The Hague.

 

Opinions expressed in JURIST Commentary are the sole responsibility of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of JURIST's editors, staff, donors or the University of Pittsburgh.

Under siege: Nagorno-Karabakh accuses Azerbaijan of throttling supply lines

POLITICO
Aug 22 2023

KORNIDZOR, Armenia — Maria Musayelyan gave birth to twin girls on Sunday — now she’s worried about being able to keep them alive.

With Azerbaijan accused of blocking all supplies to the ethnic Armenian enclave of Nagorno-Karabakh, fears are growing over the fate of the 100,000 people living there.

“There were days during my pregnancy when I know I didn’t get enough food. And now it’s not just about food,” the 25-year-old lawyer said in a telephone interview from the region’s capital, Stepanakert. “There’s no toilet paper, no toothpaste, no baby formula, no clothes for the children.”

Nagorno-Karabakh’s Armenians fought a war against Azerbaijan in the early 1990s; hundreds of thousands of Azerbaijanis were killed or forced to flee their homes as the Armenians took control and declared the independence of their unrecognized breakaway state — inside Azerbaijan’s internationally-recognized borders but cut off from the rest of the country by trenches and fortifications.

Azerbaijan turned the tables in 2020 with a lightning offensive that reconquered key parts of the enclave. The war was halted by a Russian-brokered ceasefire, but in recent months Azerbaijan has tightened the noose on the Lachin Corridor, a mountainous road that is the only link between Nagorno-Karabakh and Armenia.

In Kornidzor, an Armenian village on the border with Azerbaijan, a line of white aid trucks — laden with hundreds of tons of flour, cooking oil and other supplies from the Armenian government — has been stuck at an army checkpoint for the last month. Azerbaijan is refusing to let it pass. Nearby, half a dozen boys chase a football up and down a dusty field, every now and then letting out a cheer as it bounces off the burned-out armored vehicle rusting behind the goal.

Aid organizations, including the International Committee of the Red Cross, are also warning that they are unable to get food and fuel into the breakaway region and that a humanitarian crisis looms.

“The situation is close to catastrophe,” said Sergey Ghazaryan, the foreign minister of Nagorno-Karabakh’s unrecognized government. “There’s no sphere of life that isn’t suffering.”

Azerbaijan insists there is a solution — it’s just not one that’s palatable for Karabakh Armenians hoping to preserve some semblance of independence.

Hikmet Hajiyev, Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev’s foreign policy adviser, insisted to POLITICO that “the Lachin road is open” — while refusing to explain why the Red Cross and other international organizations are unable to use it.

He said his government wants aid to be delivered, just not via the Lachin Corridor from Armenia but from the Azerbaijani city of Aghdam, because it “historically links Karabakh to mainland Azerbaijan” and is “less costly and more convenient.” Russia tentatively backs the idea, while the EU and the U.S. say it’s not an alternative to Lachin.

Baku’s motive for the shift is clear. While the Lachin Corridor offers Nagorno-Karabakh a contiguous lifeline to Armenia, deliveries through Aghdam — which lies to the east of the enclave — would require long, looping transit through Azerbaijan.

Karen Minasyan/AFP via Getty Images

“Why are the Armenians refusing to use the Aghdam road?” Hajiyev asked. “Because they don’t seek reintegration — they simply seek separatism and they seek irredentism and would like to preserve their illegal puppet regime on the territory of Azerbaijan.”

Ghazaryan warned that Azerbaijan’s offer to bring in aid via Aghdam is an effort to force the Karabakh Armenians to give up their independence and accept being part of Azerbaijan. ““If we accept the opening of the Aghdam road and supply from the Azerbaijani side, we legitimize the crime they are committing,” he said.

“In case of the reopening of the Lachin Corridor we will reestablish our self-sufficiency and there will be no need to receive cargo from Aghdam,” he added.

For now, the Armenians are hanging on, but the humanitarian cost is rising.

In July, one Karabakh Armenian doctor said miscarriages had tripled as a result of malnutrition and a lack of medical care, while local media reported a woman lost her baby after she was unable to get to hospital due to a shortage of fuel for the ambulance.

Agricultural work has all but ground to a halt without fuel to power farm machinery or get food from the countryside to the Karabakh Armenian capital, local officials said. They also claim Azerbaijani forces have fired on farmers in their fields, making it almost impossible to sow crops and harvest hay for their animals.

Nagorno-Karabakh’s leadership is calling on the EU, U.S. and others to impose sanctions on Azerbaijan and to push for a return to the status quo ante to prevent a catastrophe.

At a meeting of the U.N. Security Council last week, nations including the U.S., U.K., France and Russia acknowledged the ongoing blockade and called for aid to be allowed in.

But the debate underlined how far apart the two sides are.

Yashar Aliyev, the country’s permanent representative to the U.N., responded to Armenian allegations by holding up printouts of Instagram posts purportedly showing Karabakh Armenians eating food and living life as normal. “People are happy,” he said. “They are dancing at their wedding party. This is a celebration. Very tasty cookies!”

Pressure is growing on Azerbaijan to relent.

Luis Moreno Ocampo, the former chief prosecutor of the International Criminal Court, published a report earlier this month calling the situation “an ongoing genocide.”

Russia’s failure to guarantee safe passage in and out of the region, which it vowed to do under the terms of the 2020 ceasefire, means the Karabakh Armenians are looking West for security assurances.

“We’ve been seeing two major trends since the start of the war in Ukraine,” said Tigran Grigoryan, head of the Regional Center for Democracy and Security think tank in the Armenian capital of Yerevan. “Russia’s interest in the region is decreasing and its priorities are shifting. Militarily, diplomatically, politically, they don’t have the leverage they used to have.”

Azerbaijan is seeking to reassure the international community that warnings of an ongoing ethnic cleansing campaign are overblown. It has hired London lawyer Rodney Dixon to write a rejection of the Moreno Ocampo report.

“If you’re going to make an allegation as serious as genocide, you have to look at all the factors,” Dixon said. “There might be many other issues between the parties, but there’s no evidence that’s been identified a genocide is underway.”

He said Azerbaijan’s offer to redirect aid via Aghdam shows it is not intent on driving out Nagorno-Karabakh’s Armenian population.

But there are doubts as to the Azerbaijani government’s long-term intentions.

“No plan, white paper or document setting out a positive vision for the future of Karabakh Armenians has ever been made public by the Azerbaijani authorities,” said Laurence Broers, an expert on the conflict and associate fellow at Chatham House.

According to him, assurances that locals will receive equal treatment under the constitution of Azerbaijan fail to acknowledge that they “are not just any population but one that has been in protracted conflict with the Azerbaijani state for decades.”

“The Aghdam offer would be more credible if it was linked to deescalation — rhetorically and militarily — and to a vision for an ongoing transformation of the troubled relationship between Azerbaijani state and Karabakh Armenian population,” Broers said.

Meanwhile, in Stepanakert, Musayelyan and her neighbors struggle to survive.

“We are eating whatever can be grown here, mostly vegetables — there’s some potatoes, some pears, some plums,” she said.

https://www.politico.eu/article/azerbaijan-armenia-nagorno-karabakh-lanchin-corridor-humanitarian-aid/

Israel can prevent a new Armenian genocide

YNet, Israel
Aug 22 2023
Dr. Sergei Melkonian
As things stand, Israel is indirectly complicit in what Luis Moreno Ocampo, the first chief prosecutor of the International Criminal Court, in recent days called a genocide against Armenians. But it is also in a unique position to put an end to the atrocity.

I refer to the eight-month blockade of the Nagorno-Karabakh enclave by Azerbaijan, one of Israel’s leading strategic allies. For the past two months not even Red Cross humanitarian missions have been allowed through, and last week the first resident died of starvation. Food and medicine are running out, and Ocampo has warned that many more deaths will follow unless Azerbaijan stops blocking the Lachin Corridor, the enclave’s vital access road. 
As many readers will know, Nagorno-Karabakh is a territory populated by ethnic Armenians that ended up on the Azeri side of the border because of Soviet machinations. Since the USSR collapse, it has operated as a self-governing entity, but in 2020 Azerbaijan attacked and seized much of the region in a war in which thousands of Armenians were killed. Israeli drones supplied to Azerbaijan played a big role in that victory.
Now comes the blockade against what remains of Nagorno-Karabakh and the 120,000 Armenians living there, clearly aimed at compelling their flight due to the threat of starvation. Indeed, Azerbaijani President Ilham Aliyev has been quite transparent, stating that the residents should either accept Azerbaijani citizenship or seek another home.
There are 30,000 children, 9,000 disabled people, and 20,000 elderly people among those who are besieged in Nagorno-Karabakh. "Without immediate dramatic change, this group of Armenians will be destroyed in a few weeks," Ocampo wrote in recent days in a pro bono report (read it here), entitled "Genocide against Armenians in 2023." He noted that Article II(c) of the Genocide Convention determined that "deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction" constituted genocide.
"You will find no crematoria in Nagorno-Karabakh, nor machetes, but genocide by starvation is no less devastating for being silent," Ocampo said. "It was the same deadly method used against Armenians in 1915, against Poles and Jews in 1939, and against the people of Srebrenica in 1993.”
Ocampo argued that state actors must intervene to force Azerbaijan to end the blockade, and the issue is now being debated at the United Nations Security Council.
Most observers might have expected the state actors in question to perhaps be the European Union or the United States, which are promoting sham “peace talks” between Armenia and Azerbaijan in which the people of Nagorno-Karabakh effectively have no voice. Or maybe even Russia, which has toothless peacekeepers in the area and which has a strategic alliance with Azerbaijan.
But perhaps they should be thinking of Israel.
The Jewish state, which was established after Jews suffered the greatest genocide in history, is indecorously close to the odious regime of President Ilham Aliyev in Baku.
Israel sells this regime weapons, to be used against Armenia, which is a fellow democracy and one of the world’s oldest Christian civilizations. Israel buys huge amounts of oil from this regime. Israel does a growing amount of business with this regime. And Israel also receives a forward base against its nemesis Iran from the regime.
This is a classic case of realpolitik in action.
That’s because in return for these things, Israel is in bed with a family-run kleptocracy that has, according to the Pandora Papers, siphoned away hundreds of millions of dollars of their country’s oil and natural gas wealth, and which allows its people to wallow in poverty and denies them basic freedoms. It also agitates wildly against Armenians and Armenia itself, commits atrocities against them, and carries out systematic desecrations of Armenian heritage sites. Now comes what is being described by one of the world’s leading jurists as an attempt at a second Armenian genocide.
Jews, of all people, should not look the other way. If sympathy for Armenia, a fellow scrappy democracy in a mostly non-democratic part of the world, is not enough, surely the genocide discussion should focus Israeli minds. Jews cannot be complicit in this.
Exactly 50 km away from the disaster zone, Israel is implementing large-scale investment programs. Israel is among Azerbaijan's top 10 trading partners, with trade between the two countries reaching $1.7 billion last year. About 90 Israeli companies are actively working in Azerbaijan. Three months ago, President Yitzhak Herzog visited Azerbaijan and discussed more new projects.
The growing influence of Israel on Azerbaijan and the wide presence of Israeli companies in the country can provide leverage.
During the blockade of Nagorno-Karabakh, Israel continued to supply weapons to Azerbaijan. Since 2016, there have been 92 flights with Israeli arms supplies. The last delivery was this week: IL-76TD of Azerbaijan's Silk Way Airlines arrived at Uvda airbase to receive weapons and transport them to Baku.
A temporary moratorium on the supply of weapons to a country that is committing deadly outrages against civilians could be a serious signal for Azerbaijan to reconsider its policy.
We know there are righteous people in Israel who agree. Just last week, a large group of Israeli scientists, journalists, public figures, and rabbis addressed an open letter to President Herzog concerning the humanitarian catastrophe.
Israelis protest in 2020, against arms sales to Azerbaijan fearing genocide in Nagorno-Karabakh
(Photo: Moti Kimchi)
Rabbi Avidan Freedman clearly drew the line between political gain and a morally correct choice: "As an Israeli and a Zionist, I burst with pride when Israelis are first on the scene to provide support for humanitarian crises around the world … When Israel thinks that it serves its interests by providing weapons to countries that … commit grave violations of human rights – it is a heartbreaking violation of our mission."
The Armenian people who survived the first genocide of the 20th century could not stay indifferent during the Holocaust. That is why 24 Armenians have been officially recognized as Righteous among the Nations at Yad Vashem.
Israel now has a chance to do the righteous thing itself and to provide a lesson in morality to an often indifferent world.

Dr. Sergei Melkonian is a research fellow at the Yerevan-based think tank APRI.
 

Armenia, selective abortion remains a concern Areas Armeniaita eng

Aug 22 2023
  • Areas
  •  

  •  Armenia

ita eng

22/08/2023 -  Armine Avetisyan Yerevan

Selective abortion has been an issue in Armenia in recent years. As a result of efforts by the government and the private sector, it seemed that many families had given up on the idea of having only a male child, but after the war of 2020 the issue has become relevant again. There are still families in Armenia who choose selective abortion.

“My brother died in 2020. It was a war. I missed my brother, I was looking for his replacement everywhere…”, Gayane (the name is changed), 38, who is pregnant and expecting a boy, begins her story.

The woman, who has a 6-year-old daughter, lives in the Kotayk region, which is near the capital city of Yerevan. She always dreamed of a boy, but it became an obsession when her brother died, an obsession shared by her husband.

“I planned that, no matter what, I would have a boy who would bear my brother's name, who would help me and my parents overcome the grief of losing my brother. I got pregnant 2 years ago. It was planned. It turned out to be a girl. I took pills, had an abortion. It was a difficult phase. I don't want to talk about it now. I committed a sin, but I needed a boy…”, Gayane says.

The woman developed health problems after the intervention. Fortunately, the treatment was successful, the couple planned another pregnancy, and this time the echo showed a “boy”.

“I live for my unborn son. He helps me, gives me strength. You know, I'm not the only one, there are many women who dream and aspire to have a boy”, she says.

According to the Statistical Committee of the Republic of Armenia, the highest index of gender disparity in Armenia was recorded in 2000, when the number of boys born per month far exceeded the number of girls. In ten years, however, the balance changed in favour of girls.

In 2021, the best balance was reached – 108 boys against 100 girls – but it went back to 112 against 100 in 2022. This is despite the fact that the standard ratio of newborns in the world is considered to be 104-106 boys/ 100 girls.

What caused the increase in the gender disparity index in 2022, experts find it difficult to say. However, there is a thesis that war is to blame.

“At this stage, it is still difficult to talk about the main reasons, but war has left its mark”, sociologist Sona Hovakimyan notes. According to Hovakimyan, selective abortion has always been a problem in Armenia, which is aggravated from time to time.

“Sex selection increases when a family is expecting a second child”, says Zaruhi Tonoyan, Coordinator of the UN Population Fund's Combating Gender Discrimination Program.

In 2022, the research “Prevalence and Causes of Gender-Biased Sex Selection in the Republic of Armenia” was carried out with the support of the European Union and the United Nations Population Fund. The study  showed that the preference for boys in Armenia has increased:

“We should highlight that girls matter. Women should be valued in society, we need to talk a lot about this, so that we can prevent selective abortion. We are taking a step back. We had a positive index, which we need to achieve again”, Tonoyan notes.

The research showed that selective abortion is especially widespread in regions, particularly in rural areas. If respondents in Yerevan are neutral about gender preference, preferences are stronger in regions, especially for a male child. A similar study was conducted in Armenia in 2017 as well. It is clear that the problem has worsened again, especially in the regions.

“Prevalence and Causes of Gender-Biased Sex Selection in the Republic of Armenia” research

Looking at results by regions, we can see that boys are most preferred in the Gegharkunik region. 33% of the respondents stated that they prefer boys.

“The first child should be a boy”, says Lilit, 19, from the Gegharkunik region, who has just gotten married but is already planning a child. “We always say in our family that we should have a boy, we will name him after my father-in-law, that is not up for discussion”, Lilit says. When asked what she will do if the first child is a girl, she remains silent, then shortly answers: “As God wills”.

Lilit is still a student. She says that one of her colleagues got married earlier than her and is already a mother. “She gave birth to a girl. Poor woman. They tried to force her to have an abortion. The husband’s family wanted a boy, but her parents stood by her and the girl was born. However, her husband didn’t go to the hospital. She lived at her parents' for about three months. Then, thank God, her husband came to his senses, now they live together, they are a happy family. Well, when I think deeply, I realise that the important thing is to have a healthy child. May I be healthy, I will have many children, both girls and boys”.

The Center for Truth and Justice Highlights its Groundbreaking Achievements and Features the Extraordinary Garo Paylan.

GAGRULE
Aug 22 2023

Documenting Atrocities and Saluting Heroes,

By Vic Gerami,

If you think that no one is keeping a record of Azerbaijan’s crimes against humanity, violations of international law, and war crimes, then you are in for a surprise.

The Center for Truth and Justice was established in November 2020 in response to the invasion of Artsakh (formerly Nagorno-Karabakh) to do just that. They are a group of lawyers overseeing the collection of firsthand testimonial evidence from war survivors via in-depth, recorded interviews. The attorneys run two law clinics, one in Armenia and one in Artsakh, which are the first of their kind. Through their clinics, they train Armenian law students and young lawyers to interview survivors of the war and record their testimonies. They have conducted hundreds of interviews and trained nearly one-hundred current or future lawyers. By being a permanent home for the testimonials, CFTJ is a resource for academic and legal practitioners who seek to use the evidence for education and/or legal action.

On October 13, 2023, the Center for Truth and Justice (CFTJ) will hold its third annual gala titled ‘Raise Their Voices: Break the Blockade’ in Los Angeles, with guest of honor Garo Paylan. In no uncertain terms, the CFTJ and Paylan do God’s work, making this union and the event much more significant.

The recognition of the Armenian Genocide of 1915 was possible due to the overwhelming evidence collected by experts, including testimonies, photographs, interviews, and other sources. Given Azerbaijan’s track record of practicing revisionist history, disinformation, and propaganda, the evidence that the CFTJ collects is invaluable.

The mission of the CFTJ is to be a living memorial to crimes against humanity. By being a permanent home for testimonials, the Center makes eyewitness accounts available for study, education, and legal action to foster education, empathy, justice, and change. They preserve evidence and make it accessible for current or future proceedings in Armenia or abroad.

Garo Paylan, An Armenian born in Turkey, was among the few Armenians elected to the Grand National Assembly of Turkey and served for two consecutive terms in 2015-2018 and 2018-2023, representing Istanbul and Diyarbakir. Though a politician, Paylan is also a leading democracy activist in Turkey. He is a founding member of the Peoples’ Democratic Party (HDP) and, since 2016, was the first Armenian in the history of the Republic of Turkey to publicly discuss the Armenian genocide of 1915 from the podium of the Turkish parliament. Paylan is recognized for his activism on human rights and minority rights in Turkey. He has received several awards, including the Grand Vermeil Medal, and has twice been nominated for the Nobel peace prize.

Artsakh is finally getting some attention after nearly three years of deafening silence from the international community and the media, following the report by the founding prosecutor of the International Criminal Court, Luis Moreno Ocampo, who classified the situation in Artsakh as Genocide. Meanwhile, Armenia requested an emergency meeting of the United Nations Security Council to address the ‘deterioration of the humanitarian situation’ in Artsakh due to Azerbaijan’s illegal blockade of the Lachin Corridor, the only road connecting the Republic of Artsakh to Armenia and the rest of the world.

The attendance of Paylan at the CFTJ’s event is significant and a rare occurrence for a public servant who isn’t about self-promotion and rarely travels to the United States. In addition to Paylan’s speech and the Center presenting their last year’s achievements, their new initiatives will be announced at the gala. The event aims to collect funds for the CFTJ’s initiatives of collecting evidence of war crimes, preparing public reports and confidential filings, and offering the facts that international law experts need to hold Azerbaijan accountable.

To learn more about the gala and the CFTJ and to purchase tickets, please visit cftjustice.org

BIO: Vic Gerami

Vic Gerami is an award-winning journalist and the editor + publisher of The Blunt Post. Gerami is also the host and co-producer of the national headline news + politics program, THE BLUNT POST with VIC on KPFK 90.7 FM (Pacifica Network).