Category: 2023

Four ex-leaders of Azerbaijan's formerly ethnic Armenian-controlled region of Nagorno-Karabakh have been detained by Azerbaijan's State Security Service and taken to the capital Baku, the state-run Azerbaijani Press Agency (APA) reported on Tuesday.

However, three other former leaders of Karabakh have arrived safely in Armenia, the Armenian state news agency Armenpress quoted one of the three as saying.

Azerbaijan took control of Nagorno-Karabakh after three decades in a lightning military operation on Sept. 20, and vowed to prosecute the "criminal" separatist leadership, who it said had poisoned the minds of the population.

Almost all the 120,000 or so inhabitants of Karabakh have since fled to Armenia, fearing for their safety. But Azerbaijan has arrested Ruben Vardanyan, a former head of Karabakh's government, and Levon Mnatsakanyan, former commander of Nagorno-Karabakh's separatist army, at border checkpoints.

On Tuesday, APA said three former self-styled presidents of Nagorno-Karabakh, Arkady Gukasyan, Bako Sahakyan and Araik Arutyunyan, as well as ex-parliamentary speaker David Ishkhanyan, had been arrested.

However, former state minister Artur Arutyunyan, ex-interior minister Karen Sarkisyan and the former head of Karabakh's security service, Ararat Melkunyan, all entered Armenia on Tuesday, Artur Arutyunyan said, according to Armenpress.

Karabakh is viewed internationally as part of Azerbaijan but had been run as a breakaway ethnic Armenian statelet since the 1990s following the collapse of the Soviet Union.

What is happening now, at an astonishing rate, in Nagorno-Karabakh is effectively ethnic cleansing on a mass scale.

A formerly autonomous province of Azerbaijan, populated overwhelmingly by people of Armenian ancestry, Nagorno-Karabakh has simply emptied itself out, after a short clash between the rival Caucasian states. It has created another humanitarian crisis and another wave of refugees in a world with no shortage of either.

Karabakh has led a precarious existence since the end of the Soviet Union, which once encompassed Armenia and Azerbaijan and mostly smothered such tensions. With the Russians gone, the area has been the subject of a succession of bloody struggles for supremacy over the succeeding decades. Before the latest outbreak of hostilities, about 120,000 of Karabakh’s residents remained, from around 200,000 at the end of the Soviet era in 1991.

By September, the population had dwindled to 65,000. Now it is thought that somewhere between only 50 and 1,000 ethnic Armenians remain. It is an exodus of historic proportions. It has not been achieved, quite, at the end of a gun or by gangs clearing families from their homesteads; but folk memories of past persecutions have forced the people to flee for their lives, carrying as much of their belongings as their cars will hold.

The proximate cause of the mass movement was the proclamation by the Azeri government that the province will no longer enjoy its “autonomous” status – a fatal breach of trust. As a self-governing oblast in Soviet times and after, its status as an Orthodox Armenian region within Azerbaijan at least gave it some minimal legal protractions against fear of domination by the Turkic and Muslim population that surrounded it.

As an exclave, it was always vulnerable to menace, and such fears sometimes turned to reality, but the people could cling to the hope that the international community, and the powers that interfered in the region so freely, Russia and Turkey, might honour it. Now it has gone.

Nagorno-Karabakh has been anything but stable for many years, and often close to disaster. Now, for all the tragically wrong reasons, the central cause of the volatility – the people of the province – has literally melted away across the borders on the move to Armenia. Western nations often complain about the scale of irregular migration and the numbers of refugees seeking asylum; well, here are about 100,000 hopeless souls arriving over a matter of days in a country, Armenia, which is poor and ill-equipped to accommodate them.

For a whole variety of reasons, the West has a vested interest in providing sufficient humanitarian aid to prevent the present crisis provoking further trouble. There are also geopolitical reasons to offer Armenia friendly assistance. Traditionally, Russia was the ally and protector of Armenia and its minority population within Azerbaijan. Azerbaijani governments looked to Ankara for support.

To an extent, and like other proxy wars such as the Yemeni conflict played out between Iran and Saudi Arabia, the fortunes of Armenia and Azerbaijan mirrored those of their regional superpower mentors. Yet since a soft revolution in Yerevan a few years ago, Armenia has tilted towards the West.

Vladimir Putin has grown more impatient towards his former loyal junior partner, and basically acquiesced in Azeri aggressions, despite having brokered a peace accord a few years ago. Now President Putin finds himself having to deal with more pressing issues than Armenia.

This does represent for the West a rare opportunity to acquire influence in the region, protect Armenia and its people from further abuses, and, in partnership with Turkey, ensure that the war in Ukraine doesn’t somehow spill over into the Caucasus, and potentially drag Georgia and Turkey itself into a wider conflict.

One immediate priority, which would also help ease delivery of aid, is the opening of the border between Armenia and Turkey.

In the words of one Armenian crossing the border into a safer but uncertain future, for the people of Nagorno-Karabakh, “it’s over, and everything is lost”. It is now too late for the West to save their original homeland, and Nagorno-Karabakh no longer exists in the meaningful sense it once did. It is not too late to save its hungry and homeless former inhabitants.

https://au.news.yahoo.com/voices-abandoned-soviet-peacekeepers-armenia-192007846.html

French Foreign Minister Catherine Colonna said on a visit to Armenia on Tuesday that Paris agreed to deliver military equipment to the small South Caucasus nation.

Colonna travelled to Armenia after Azerbaijani forces last month swept through the breakaway region of Nagorno-Karabakh and secured the surrender of Armenian separatist forces that had controlled the mountainous region for decades.

Over 100,000 ethnically Armenian people have fled from their homes in the Republic of Artsakh within the last two weeks as Artsakh leader Samvel Shahramanyan announced that the state will cease to exist as of January 1, 2024. Azerbaijani forces took over the region, also known by the Russian name Nagorno-Karabakh, in a deadly military offensive that commenced on September 19, following a nine-month blockade imposed on the only road channel connecting the territory to mainland Armenia.

Azerbaijani forces are also actively expunging any records of Armenian identity and history through the destruction of cultural landmarks and artifacts across the regions of Azerbaijan, including the newly conquered Artsakh region, putting one of the territory’s most symbolic monuments at risk of demolition. Among the many landmarks at risk is “We Are Our Mountains” (1967), referred to colloquially as “Tatik-Papik” (“Grandmother-Grandfather” in Eastern Armenian), an enormous mountainside sculpture just outside of Stepanakert, the capital city of the Republic of Artsakh.

Designed and built during the Soviet period from red volcanic tufa stone by Armenian sculptor Sargis Baghdasaryan and architect Yuri Hakobyan, the monument depicts an old man and woman emerging from the earth, symbolizing the intrinsic connection between the people of Artsakh and the mountainous terrain they inhabit. Prior to the Second Nagorno-Karabakh War in 2020, “We Are Our Mountains” was a popular tourism destination and a point of pride for Artsakhi Armenians who would visit casually or host important milestone events such as weddings at the site.

A photo of an Azerbaijani soldier standing in front of “We Are Our Mountains” with the Azerbaijani flag pinned to the monument began circulating last Friday, September 29 — one day after Samvel Shahramanyan’s announcement on the dissolution of the government of Artsakh — sparking outrage and upset among mainland and diasporic Armenians.

With the grim prospects surrounding the revered and symbolic monument’s future, an international humanitarian organization called All For Armenia has launched a petition to field global support for its preservation and protection.

“As a result of the complete exodus of Armenians from the region, less than a day’s notice of the need to evacuate, and the inability to bring anything but the clothes on peoples’ backs and some personal items, this statue has been left behind along with the history of the Armenian people in the region,” the petition reads, noting that the organization is looking into a way of enforcing a no-touch rule on the site for its protection. “Immediate action is necessary, as we are unaware of how long this statue is going to stay secure.”

The monument is especially at risk considering Azerbaijan’s well-documented history of demolishing Armenian cultural and spiritual sites across the country, being accused by scholars of committing “cultural genocide.” Since the 2005 demolition of an Armenian necropolis in the city of Julfa, Azerbaijan has effectively obliterated 98% of Armenian cultural sites from its southwestern enclave Nakhchivan, which had a large Armenian population well into the Soviet period that was later expelled by Azerbaijani forces in the 1990s during the first war in Artsakh/Karabakh. The Caucasus Heritage Watch’s satellite imagery continuously documents Azerbaijani-inflicted destruction and damages to a variety of sites in Artsakh and in various parts of Azerbaijan including towns, cemeteries, and ancient monasteries of the Armenian Apostolic Church since the 2020 ceasefire agreement following the Second Nagorno-Karabakh War.

Nearly all of Artsakh’s civilians have departed the region in fear of violent repercussions by Azerbaijani troops while Armenian Prime Minister Nikol Pashinyan characterized the events as “a direct act of ethnic cleansing,” an assessment agreed to by the Lemkin Institute and other human rights observers. Regarding the situation in Artsakh, the first prosecutor of the International Criminal Court (ICC), Luis Moreno Ocampo, told Reuters that “it’s obviously a genocide.” Hikmet Hajiyev, diplomatic advisor to authoritarian Azerbaijani president Ilham Aliyev, denied allegations of “ethnic cleansing” in an interview with Agence Free-Presse last month.

Rhea Nayyar (she/her) is a New York-based teaching artist who is passionate about elevating minority perspectives within the academic and editorial spheres of the art world. 

Deep in the mountains of the Karabakh range, worn thin by its grinding offensive in Ukraine, Russia's armed forces last month found themselves caught in another war.

With no tanks, trenches or warplanes, and largely hidden from international view, a contingent of roughly 2,000 of Moscow's troops played a key role in deciding the explosive end to a lesser-known conflict. 

Nagorno-Karabakh — a self-governed enclave carved from a southern corner of Azerbaijan that is home to mostly ethnic Armenians — has long been trapped in the eye of a swirling geopolitical storm of duelling world powers.

The area is known for its intermittent outbreaks of heavy fighting in recent decades.

Monika and her husband Georgi fled Nagorno-Karabakh during an outbreak of war with Azerbaijan in 2020, but returned on promises made by a Russian-brokered peace agreement.

The deal established Russian peacekeepers to enforce a fragile ceasefire between the two former Soviet republics and guard the only road left linking the enclave with Armenia, the so-called Lachin corridor.

However, last week, the couple found themselves retracing the same escape route through the mountains they took three years earlier — this time once and for all.

Armenia and Azerbaijan hold competing claims to Nagorno-Karabakh, which was kept relatively under control during the Soviet Union's rule, but spilled over into conflict once it collapsed and the enclave declared independence.

This became known as the First Karabakh War, which resulted in roughly 30,000 causalities, before Russia brokered a ceasefire agreement in 1994, leaving the enclave as de-facto independent.

There have been intermittent clashes between both sides in the intervening years, with Moscow's peacekeepers often used to enforce peace in the area.

The region erupted into heavy fighting again in 2020, descending into what became known as the Second Karabakh War, after a summer of cross-border attacks.

Azerbaijan reclaimed parts of the territory it lost to Armenia decades prior and the fighting escalated before a ceasefire was brokered again by Russia after six weeks.

Since then, a fragile peace has existed between both sides.

But on September 19, Azerbaijani forces, claiming a counter-terror operation, launched a large-scale blitz on the enclave, seizing it and killing hundreds of people, including civilians.

"Russians were there on paper, but in reality they didn't protect us," said Monika, who drove for nearly two days from her village in the enclave to the Armenian border.

The separatist government's surrender a day later triggered a mass exodus of more than 100,000 ethnic Armenians over the border to Armenia, fearing for their future.

Once they had reached safety, Georgi pulled over for a final glimpse at the jagged peaks on the horizon where he had spent his childhood, later working as a welder and raising a family.

"I have no words," he said, shaking his head and turning away to hide his tears.

Azerbaijan has said it wants Armenians to stay in Nagorno-Karabakh, and that it would integrate and protect those who decide to remain there. But few believe the government's claims.

Some fleeing barely had time to return home to gather their belongings before they joined a snaking queue of cars and trucks through the single road leading to neighbouring Armenia.

"Why did the world look away?" said Anahit, 78, a Nagorno-Karabakh resident who hitched a ride to the border after she was separated from her husband.

Days earlier, her brother-in-law had been killed instantly when an Azerbaijani shell detonated on his home as he tried to evacuate.

The family searched desperately for his remains but could only find one leg, blown apart from the rest of his body, which they buried near their home.

"Everywhere is covered in blood," she said.

As Azerbaijani forces bore down on Nagorno-Karabakh, Russian peacekeepers sworn to protect its residents instead appeared to stand back.

"Russian peacekeepers failed," said Kirill Krivosheev, a journalist at Russia's Kommersant newspaper.

Moscow has military bases in Armenia and the country is deeply dependent on Russia for its economy and defence.

The two have for decades developed close cultural ties – many Armenians speak Russian as a second language.

But the perceived failure of its troops to intervene in Nagorno-Karabakh has worn thin residents' patience with Russian leader Vladimir Putin.

"We trusted the Russians too much," said Anush Navasardyan, a school teacher from Nagorno-Karabakh, who had fled to an apartment in Goris, an Armenian town just over the border.

Ms Navasardyan heard shots ring out as Azerbaijani soldiers encircled her village, frantically opening the door to the stable where her four cows were kept so they might have a chance to escape too.

Mr Putin has batted away criticism that his troops in Nagorno-Karabakh allowed Azerbaijani forces to swoop in unimpeded, but analysts say their failure to protect ethnic Armenians shows the Kremlin's crumbling influence in the region.

Azerbaijan has also rejected Moscow's role in the mass exodus of Armenians from the enclave, as well as accusations of ethnic cleansing.

"It's not Russia's business to interfere," said Esmira Jafarova, a former advisor to Azerbaijan's government on international issues.

"These people [Armenian refugees] are leaving because they are not sure about the future. It's not the result of any kind of harassment or forceful action on the part of Azerbaijan."

But the accounts of people fleeing the territory tell a vastly different story, said Anoush Baghdassarian, a human rights lawyer working for the Center for Truth and Justice, an Armenian organisation based in the capital Yerevan.

"This is ethnic cleansing. It's important to demonstrate the forced displacement of these people," she said.

For days, Ms Baghdassarian stood in the centre of Goris' main square, interviewing some of the thousands of refugees pouring over the border from Nagorno-Karabakh.

Her recorded testimonies might one day be used in an international tribunal, she added.

The Azerbaijani seizure of Nagorno-Karabakh has shaken residents of Armenian towns and villages like Goris, who fear it could embolden Azerbaijan to push further into the country.

"Goris is totally under the watch of the enemy," said Aram Musakhanyan, a school teacher, who with others in the town formed a security committee partly to help prepare residents for possible invasion.

"Goris in particular and the region in general is located in such a position that with modern weapons, we could be cut off from the rest of Armenia within hours."

Azerbaijan's authoritarian president Ilham Aliyev has touted the idea of creating a land corridor linking Azerbaijan to its landlocked Nakhchivan enclave, on the other side of Armenia.

Peace talks between Azerbaijan and Armenia are scheduled on Thursday in Spain as leaders of the two countries meet on neutral ground in the hopes of hashing out another peace agreement.

"Everyone is tired of war," said Ms Jafarova.

"So we're looking forward to seeing that Armenia will be on the same page as Azerbaijan and finally we can move forward."

The same is too late for the separatist leaders in Nagorno-Karabakh, whose enclave has been dissolved and most of its people driven from their homes.

Its president, Samvel Shakhramanyan, announced last week he had ordered the dismantling of the breakaway state's institutions by the end of the year.

Its de-facto capital, Stepanakert, is like a scene from a zombie apocalypse – its streets deserted and cars and buildings suddenly abandoned.

Former residents say the events of the past few weeks have taught them a bitter lesson.

"We need the time to digest what has happened."